CANADIAN IDEOLOGY AND FUBLIC POLICY: THE IMPACT ON VANCOUVER SIKH 'ETHN 1c;- AND 'REt.I GJOUS • ADAPTATION 1 Ver~~ A. Dus~nbc~y Pepart.mi::nt Qf A thr ~·po lo3y University of Ch! n~c !'rJp<:r f o,ir pr9; ._ ~ntatio~ 1J\ ~hu C nadn:rn Et,hn!c St~di'f £ .\SS()CiBtf -»i, M f:i J ~8 " 1979, V.:m~.cuver , 1LC .. Cci: . b,~r ll--l4., 1974 11 Funily 0r~1.~iz.ati,_,• .1.J1d Chntn 110~~ th-., Ovfllrsu.15 I"dia.:u with Spitci~l 3.~f~rocc to hdh.r. Ii1Jnirr11~t F.t'1'lilin"' 0f Britil'h Columbi1., C.1.u .da." i!\ G ort• .J(urin ( r,,d.), Th~ ["iirr.ilY ir I di : A. ]. ~ l':"ioo 1 Vic:w (The t: 1tua: 1-:outn'f\), pp. 369-391. - --1 1978 India.wlY H ti C;:lt ~da. 1 r. 1"r1,1 I rnmi r ntio· 1 nlic y 11 i r Ca.)'t il d i,.Y: }'ublic P 0 li c J" , Vo 1. IJl., ! . o • pp • 5~-7-56 7 o 11 ~1.:t i , 26 e_.,\'\~ Pl-,\) A. C\Jc..'0 U V...s £1 P.,E.~Y, ca.~,,:k-{L I fl~ a.~+M ~ ~"'- · ~ ~, ~ lL~ ~ rt ~ f l '11 Ll -~. 4, lJ.vit~d, d.u:v.50, r ~ ""1.n"'--e,c,,"'--0.... ::s-"-~ IA/4. ... Q l '\ ~ - . J'lA"'- l"f i I o.c, · vw ""/ ~ v- i f'e... (t:' 11 "2-A.\,, ~ o , lte..) W Lu, ts J ~ IJ'l. s ,,- cl.._ o I\.\J.., c:'¼.e__ G\,\/vl..1>\ 1k_ To..~(,,_ (ov- JC... ofll\.. ~ · , T \A_h ~ ~--\<,,r-u., l\., \} t 'l.• -{."'-\ l k.1,. :-, . .,. ""'- l,I. IA f-, ~ ~ J:~ w:'.. <_, h>.. 1 f/,,lcda. i5' L,\_ <;: ~"- -Y-L I q~ , "'- 1 Ivv1k . Ct o 1M,-"· fA .,J_ \!IA"' S _ 1 '61-~ i11on~ other thin~s, he has suggested that one significant contrast between South .Asfan and modern ~-Jestern jdeoloeies is in the latter's differentiation of social action and idet1tity into a multitude Inden & Nicholas (1977) of separate and distinct "domains." eve.n_ go so far as to suggest that the convontional distinction made in the modern West between the sacred and secular domains may not be present in South Asian cultures. 4 It would, therefore, be a serious mistake to assume ~ priori that tradit.ional Sikh ideology corresponds to that of Canadian ideology wjth respect to the differentiability of 'religion• and 'ethnicity'. Since Sikhism has heretofore b Pen essentially a regional faith, the Sikh _and Punjabi identities of its adherents has been largely conjoined. And even wh,en Sikhs have settled abroad, their insularity -- reflected in such things as endogamy and non-proslytization--has meant that they have gone virtually unchallenged in defining as· they plea~i'ed the mea·ning ·of the te·rm "Sikh." It is not surprising to find, therefore, that it is commonly asserted of and by Punjabi Sikhs U illt the Sikhs constitute a distinct religious-cum-political-cumsocial-cum-cultural community and that it is either impossible, unwarranted, or ill-advised to attempt to deli neate out components of this unique Sikh identity. Chadney reflects this traditional Sikh ideology when he asserts: It is this constant blending of sacred and secular identities, goals, structures, and functions, which, at the emic level, helps explain the important continuance of Sikhism in Vancouver •••• For it is not simply a religious identity, it is an identity of Sikh which is an identity incapable of being categorically isolated into disparate and sep~rato sacred and secular identities (Chadney 1976:195; emphasis in original). Rich symbolic support for this ideological unity of the sacred and secular domains is to be found in Sikh culture in the miri/piri and deeh/teeh/fateh concepts. ( According to Sikh traditions, the sixth Sikh guru(teacher), Hargobind, was invested with two swords at his instal1ation as guru, one represenbng sp·ritual power (piri: from the Persian word, pir, used to denote a religious teacher) and the other representing temporal power (miri: from another Islarnica11y-introduced word, nP1jr, moaning commander of t}rn faithful). Besides encapsulating the long-standing Sikh notibn of worldly involvement coexisting with spir1tual enljghtenment, the pairing of miri and piri reflocts the ideal of Sikh relie;ious and soc:i o-pol _. U cal unity and sovereignty. A more recent symbolic development, first popularized at the time of the ninth and tenth gurus, was the pairing of the terms degh (cooking pct) and tegh (sword) to emphasize that "the use of arms is an extension of the givine of rl.l.,.,,~" (Cole & Sambhi 1978) and their conjunction with f ~teh (victory) which refer s to the temporal and spiritual victory of Gcxi and God's Khalsa Panth (the orthodox Sikh comnrunity). 5 / Historically, one could ennumerate countlP,SS examples of the blending of · what from the perspectiv.e of contemporary Western ideology one mi_gnt want to distinguish as 'religious' and 'non-religious'. Institutionally, one can observe this in the political and religious aspirations of the Sikh communal party, the Akali Dal, which has peri~ically agitated for a separate Sikh hcmeland and agajnst incorporation into a secular India; in the poli~ical as well as religious activities of the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee (the committee legally empowered to run the affairs of the historical gurdwaras in ·the Punjab); and in the often parallel leadership of these most dominant of Punjabi Sikh organizations. However, the institutional framework wherein the differences in ideologies are best observed is in the scope and function of the Sikh gurdwaras, the central Sikh institutions at the Jocal level. It is conventional in English to translate gurdwara (literally, "the Guru's door") as ~•temple." This is unfortunate, sinco, as virtually every Sikh scholar has pointed out, Sikh gurdwaras have traditionally been--and in most cases continue to be--more than simply "houses of worship'1 as 'religious• buildings in the West are commonly considered. If we wish to apply our conventional Western understandings to an explanation of the traditional role of the gurdwaras in Sikh social life, it would be much more appropriate to speak of them as religious, social, political, Cultural, and social service centres for the local comrrrunity. I< Institutional Development wi thin the VancouvEr Sikh Co-mmuni ty Given this place of the gurdwara in trad i tional Sikh society, it is not surprising that a gurdwara was formed in Vancouve r jn 1908 coinc i dent with the arrival of fivo thousand Sikh laborers and that from the very beginning it served a rm1ltiplicjty of apparently 'religious' and 'non-religious' purposes. In its early years, the Khalsa Diwan Society's gurdwara on West Second Avenue was truly a religious, social, political, Cultural, and social service centre for the entire South Asian immi grant population of the lower mainland., In this hu;lding , re f;u]~r rAadi nr.;s from the Sikh Holy Scriptures, the Siri Guru Granth ~ ' we r e Gond~1cted~ the traditional free kitchen (langar) operated; shAltir was prov}ded for the homeless~ In addition, the gurdwara was the place where the overwhelmingly male population came together during non-work hours to socialize, where consensus was reached on decisions affecting the immigrant community, and where conflicts were aired. ! •j Since it was not inconsistent with Sikh ideology for a "temple" organization such as the Khalsa Diwan Society (hereafter, KDS) to engage in 'political' activities, the KDS took the lead in fighting against the exclusionary Canadian immigration policies and for the extension of ~ights to all South Asian immigrants in British Columbia. Having played a central role in the community's rejoction of a proposal that the community be relocated to British Honduras, the KDS found itself deeply involved in seeking a redresr. of the corrmrunity's grievances against the Canadian& B.C. governments. · · · Causes championed by the KDS in the pericxl from 1909 to 1947 included the following: sending delegations to Ottawa and London to argue fo!' the lifting of the exclusionary "orders-in-council"; supporting court challenges to the legality of Canadian immigration policies; offering material and legal support to the passengers of the ill-fated Komagata Maru; assisting individual immigrants facing deportation orders; "1orking for favorable de cisions from Canadia officials which (1) would allow South Asian immigrants to bring aver their wives and dependent children, and (2) would extend domiciliary r i~hts to illegal i rnm· grants who had been successfully established in the country for a certai.n period of time; and working for the federal, provincial, and municipal franchise for "Hindus" in B. C. which would allow South Asian-Canadfans/not only the right to vot,3 but also the right to enter certain professions (notably, 1, w and rne d i cj ne) ,..,.,..~ n · ,, -, ·~- clos ed to th rrn. 15 .· · During the comnunity's first decades, spor;, dic attempts to found what would have been S8p:trate ethnic-pol itical organjzations failed for lack of support from ,,., the largely working class community (see Lal 197 ). For most Sikhs, the gurdwara was deemed the appropriate n]~ce for determining a r e sponse to the Canadian experience. And thus, so long as the South Asian i TTlf"ligrant popnl;~ti nn r , ·111. incd small, overwhelmingly Sikh, and relatively united (if only in respect to the intransigence of Canadian authorities), the KOS was able to serve as the institutional 7 centre for meeting the community's varied needs. Things began to change following WW II. ,1 By 1947, the Sikh population in the lower mainland had shrunk to little over one thousand. However, with changes in Canadian immigration and c_itizenship policies, the community began to expand after decades of contraction ' and retrenchment. One effect of the changes was to stir up incipient factional conflict between the more "moderninst" and "traditionalist" segments of the community. In 1952, a disp1te arose over requirements for election to the KDS executive committee. The "traditionalists" argued unsuccessfully for the exclusion of clean-shaven and turbanless Sikhs from KDS leadership positions. I/~ And after their defeat, somH d..\~ 01r-oo\ is't~.': 1 1 - broke with the KDS and founded a second Vancouver gurdwara and a second society, the Akali Singh Sjkh Socjety. Thus, while the KDS continued to represent the majority viewpoint of the comnmnity, its credibility as the sole organization speaking to the wider Canadian society on behalf o.f all ''Bast Indians" was open to question. 1'3 cJr, , c, "'') 5.\,. "' (.' \ Out of this J.. emerged what could be regarded as an ethnic-political organi- zation -- the East Indian Canadian Citizen's Welfare Association. religious', being independent of any gurdwara. It was •non- And, though dominated by the sizeable Sikh population and sharing some leadership with the KDS, by setting its objectives as working for the benefit of the entire "East Indian" comnnmity throughout the country,. it implicitly accepted a Canadianized view of social reaHty--viz., that there exi~ts an "East Indian" ethno-cultura 1 gro 1p shad n~ certain unique interests 1 and activities. Thus it was at this juncture that the Welfare Association began to take over some of the more 'political' f unctions (e.g., pressing the governm nt for increased immigra tj on quotas for India) which had previously been undertaken # by the KDS. f7 As the community gradually grew in numbers during the 1950s and 1960s on the strength of sponsored relatives and quota imm:igrants, evidence pointed to a continuing "accomodation" to certain Canadian norms. 8 tlhile the inf1 ux of newcomers (and 1 especially the practice of seeking spouses from Indi a) served to counteract any assimilative tendencies, the new immigrants generally deferred to the established immigrants--often their relatives and fellow villagers--for direction in adapting to Canadian customs (Thus, · for example, on the basis of the job-getting advice of earlier immigrants, male Sikhs were often clean-shaven and turbanless by the time they reached Canada). As the 1960s drew to a close and the KDS prepared to move into its impressive new gurdwara overlooking the Fraser River, leadership of the KDS and the Welfare Association was in the hands of those "modernists" who counciled "accomodation" 'J.6 and who had themselves "succeeded" in Western terms. With the comnrunity prospering, suffering little overt hostility, and anticipating more open immigration, the Welfare Association had becorre less activist. And the gurdwaras, while still the social centres for the Sikh comnnmity, were now more than ever functioning like Western-style "houses of worship2- -opening their doors primarily to perform weddings and hold Sunday services. However, certain events had been set in motion or were. about to be set in motion which in the course of the past decade have significantly changed the community makeup and have altered both the organizational structures and leadership patterns. First of all, changes in Canadian immigrati on policy in 1962 and especially in 1967 (and lasting until modified in 1973 and 1974) significantly liberali~ed the regulations effecting Indian immigration. As a result, the Sikh population has experienced perhaps a four-fold increase to today's estimate of forty thousand in the lower mainland. At the same time, the makeup of the "E'l s t Indian" population as a whole (now including Ismailis, Pakistanis, Fijians, and others of South Asian ancestry) has gone from being overwhelmingly Sikh to the point where Sikhs represent perhaps a bit over half of all "E.Jt.st Indians" in greater VAncouver. Furthermore, rapid growth within the Sikh community ( resulting from Sikh imnrl gra tion from Britain, East Africa, Fiji, and other Commonwealth countri es) has meant s omo attenuation of the influence of the old family and villa ge ties which had served 9 in integrating new immigrants into the comrm.inity and whjch had created power bases for certain conmrunity leaders. While such ties continue to be important generators of solidarity within the conmrunity, no one person's ties are by themselves sufficient to ensure power and position within the Sikh community. And at the R•""' time that diversification and internal growth in the Sikh community h'ln w<.H'K O d Ao-A-\nr.t the continued dominance of the old Sikh leaders, sirrri.lar factors or domoP"~aohio growth and internal diversification conspire to challenge any assumption of continued Sikh dominance within the collective "East Indian" 'ethnic' category. :✓. I The past decade has also seon the introduction of the federal Multiculturalism programs and the passage of ht1man rights legislation at the federal and provincial lev ls. One effect of these policies has been to make clear that in the Canadian context "East Indians" are seen as constituting a distinct "ethno-cultural" group and that the Canadian government would prefer to deal with pan-"East Indian" •ethnic' organizations. At the same time, however, it has become apparent that while Canadians persist in lumping all those of South Asian ancestry into an undiff0rentiated "East Indian" •ethnic' cate gory, they are capable of recognizing that various 'religions' may be represented within the 'ethnic' category. Thus, it may be noted, the term "Hindu" which was one applied indiscriminantly to those of South Asian ancestry in Canada is now recognized as a 'religious' label and has generally been replaced by "East Indian" as the most commonly usP.d 'ethnic' label. ~fuile other Canadians may assurno th a t "E,n.~c.: t I...," _d1·.ans" sha ro common "ethno-cul tural" d' ns themselves are aware of the traits and common 'poljtical' i"lterests, Id n 0- Canal d jnterests of those consjdered "E~st Indians." increasing diversity of backf,round s an Thus it is not surprising that, as John Wood (1978) makes clear, "EaS t 1nd jan" participation in the process leading to the new Imm.igra U on Act of 1976 was m.'lrked by disparate and conflicting presentations. B' the mid-1970s, there was no organi- zation, either nationa 11 y Or loc(~l1y, which could accurately be ~ajd to represent , ·t In Vanc cruv 0r, the Welfare Association the interests of a united "E, ,st Indian' cmnnrun-t Y• ,A was only sporadically active and had beon stricken from the Provjncial Register of Societies, the KDS was increasingly immobilized by internal struggles for control of the executive, and the Akali Singh Sikh Society continued its generally quietistic ways. About the only organization claiming to represent the entire community was the --- soon-discredited East ·I ndian Defence Committee, a Maoist group (now affiliated with the ~lbanian-leaning CPC-ML) which had organized vigilante actions to defend "East -- Indians" from physical and verbal harassment by whites. J ;_ To fill this void in •ethnic'-poli~ical organizational solicarity exposed by the irmnigration policy review, an all-Canada "East Indian" umbrella organization was formed in 1975-76. Drawing its leadership and support from the Inda-Canadian elite (i.e., the Western-educated, English-speaking professionals, bureaucrats, and businesspeople) and, at the local level, from those with prior experience in dealing I with Canadian governmental bureacracy (e.g., through private or government employment and/or through leadership of the KDS or Welfare Association during their activist phases), the organization called itself the National Association of Canadians of Origins in India (NACOI) and set as its aims and objectives: 1. 2. J. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. To encourage Canadians of origins in India to fully participate in Canadian Society. To provide a national voice to Canadians of origins in India. To provide a forum for exchange of jdeas, issues and common concernsTo facilitate communication within and with other organizations. To assure and protect the rights of Canadians of origins in Indiao To assist in the orientation and adaptation of Canadians of oiigins in Indja to the Canadian milieu and brine about a better understanding of Canada and other Canadians. To formulate guidelines for improvjng the collective image of Canadians of origins in India~ To assure due recognition of the contributions of Canadians of origins in India to Canada (NACOI 1977). While at the local level, NACOI's B.C. Chapter has been dominated by the Sikh elite, it would be unwarrented to assume that the Sikh comrmmity in Vancouver is united in accepting the wisdom or necessity of participati..on in· a pan-"East Indian" 'ethnic'-political organization. Gjven the traditional Sikh jdeology of religious- cum-ethnic distinctiveness, it is not surprising that there should be residual support for the position, most vocally enunciated by the local Shiromani Akali Dal 11 of Canada, that Sikhs are a "separate people" who , hn11ld be known as 1Canadian Sikhs" and whose 'political' interests should be looked after by th~ p;urdwara societies or other representatives of the Khalsa Panth (orthodox Sikh community). 13 In general, however, local Sikh participation in NACOI and in the revived and revitalized East Indian Canadian Citizen's Welfare Association and .the fledgling Fraser Valley East Indian Canadian Welfare Association suggests a significant acceptance of the position that to compete for funds and recognition in the wider Canadian society it may be necessary to organize into what are at least in theory pan-"East Indian" 'ethnic'-political organizations. As suggested earlier, the rise of ethnic-political organizations has gone hand in hand with a proliferation of 'ethnic' institutions of various sort. Thus, with the establishment of groups like the Punjabi Cultural Assoc..1a h; the Punjabi Literary S6ctcfJ, and independent Punjabi schools, one finds that ethnic-Cultural (i.e., folk arts and language) activities are no longer the exclusive province of the gurdwaras. Likewise, groups like the India Club and the International Punjabi Society function as ethno-social organizations independent of the gurdwaras. Finally, ethnic-social services, once almost exclusively the province of the gurdwaras, have now largely been taken over by govern.mental agencies or semi-governmental organizations like ;._t..f the Immigrant Services Centre and the local Nei~hborhood Houses. One might suspect that this proliferation of •ethnic' organizations takin~ over what were once the multiple responsibilities of the r:urdwaras mjght leave tho gurdwaras as ifelesG institutJ ons. This has not been the caso. attendance Gurdwaras continue to enjoy high/ and treinendou:, material support from the S · kh community. deserted, 1 New eurdwaras have been built, are beinp; built, .::i.nrl arP- hei_ne planned ';.s in the greater Vanco1vcr ~roa. Indeed, the past ten year s ha~· seen something of a 'religious• revival within the Sikh comnrunity. orthopraxy have resulted in increasing Calls for greater 'religious' ritual elaboration in the estab] :ished services and in the reintroduction of Sikh ceremonies and gurdwara protocal which had nearly died out jn Vancouver. This year's election of an "orthod.ox"-dominated executive of the KDS was seen by many as a consolidation of "orthodox" control 12 over gurdwara affairs and a repudiation of lapses i n 'rel jgious' orthopraxy perpet'">fr, rated in the name of "accomoda tion." ... At present, the leadership of both the KDS and the Akali Singh Society seem content to view their mandates primarily in terms of promoting a return to 'religious' orthopra:xy--thus,concentrating their energies on maintaining the gurdwaras as a context for the practice of what they regard a~ appropriate Sikh 'religious' activities 1·t and involving themselves only indirectly in 'ethnic'-political activities. old-fJuard KDS leaders, the loss of power For the in "their" gurdwara (i.e., one which they 'J.f built and which represented their brand of Sikhism) is a blow. On the other hand, many of them have become increasingly involved in •ethnic' organizations as a more rewarding forum for their interests and expertise. It is not surprising, t herefore, to find that many of the qualities which Chadney had identified as crucial to KDS leadership (e.g., professional or business occupation, lengthy residence in Canada, "mcxlernity," and bilingualism) are now important for leadership of tho 'ethnic'political organizations but of lesser importance in suitability for election to the 'religious' societies• executive. Whether the proliferation and differentiation of 're ligious' and 'ethnic' institutions, activities, and leaders is merely a temporary state of affairs or reflects a more fundamental acceptance of Canadian ideology with respect to 'religion• and •ethnicity' remains to be seen. It should be noted, howeve r, that support from within the Sikh comrrrunity for the differ entiability of 'religion• and 'ethnicity' C. ') ~ /' f \ ' , cor1es from those two (' /\ ~ r ' l < t ,,.. f-' -,~ho, having been born and r fl1 y-Pd •n Canadian soci e ty. are most likely to interpret social action and social identity in terms of prevailjng Canadian ideology. These two groups are the now si zeable and maturing second and third generation of Canadians of Punjabi Sikh anc estry and the small but vocal and visible group of non-"Ertst Indian" Canadian and American Sikh "converts." While the two groups tend to define themselves in vastly differont ways with respect to the Vancouver Sikh community as a wh ole, their very exjstance speaks to the separability of 'religion' and •ethnic i ty' in the Canadj an context. l 3 With immigration once again restricted and w'th many recent Sikh immigrant families having sta~ted families, there is a good deal of concern over the future of S,k~, children growing up in this new and suspect Canadian society. Obviously, therefore, those second and . third generation Canadians of Punjabi Sikh ancestry who are now reaching maturity are being carefully looked at for some indication of what I I ' Sikhs in Canada may be like in the future. Some cccsnd and third generation people have becoim, from the perspective of the Sikh community, " invisible people" who, through their own volition or by transgressing the implicit norms governing inclusion in "our community," have been written off by the community and merely stand as ?] negative examples of the dangers of uncontrolled "accomodati..on." On the other hand, of those who have remained a pa rt of the community, many feel estr·anged from the recent 'religious' revivalism, regarding it as an unfortunate return to aspects of life in "village India" with little · relevance to or positive · implications for the community's situation in Canada. For such people, the issue of 'religious' orthopraxy should be an individual one, distinct from and subordina le. to the conm1uni ty' s efforts to better their position as "East Indians" in Canadian society. Thus, for many of these people, the orientation of the 'ethnic'-po1itical institutions and the challenge they provide in bridging the eap between the 'ethnic' community and the wider Canadian society is more compelling than what they see as the internal factionalism and obscurant activities of the 'religious' institutions. It is from these people that one gets the clearest st~tement that it may be possible to be ' ethnically ' Sikh (or Punjabi or "Ea st Indian" ) without be"ir1g 'religiously ' Sj.kh. :· ("' One gets just the opposit9 message from tho gora (wh."Lc) S'kh convert3~ For them, solidarity with Vancouve 's "East Indian" Sikhs is based not on a shared Punjabi Sikh heritage but on cormnon adherence to a UY"\iversal Sikh dharm1. (variously translated as "reli gion ," "way of life," "duty"). The converts' major contention vis-a-vis the "Ea s t Indian" Sikh community in Vancouver is that in the process of "accomodation" to Canadian norms many have violated what the converts consider to be the inviolable tenets of the Sikh 'religi on '. Behind the ccnverts' contentton that such people are patit (literally, "fall en"; the common translabon is "apostate") 14 and aro thus "East Indians" but no longer" real Sikhs" is the idea that Sikhism is a •religion• with a particular "ccxie for conduct" (in fact, the Sikhs do have what is called a "code of conduct": the - rehat marayada) which enjoins upon its followers certain absolute -'religious• norms not legitimately subject to modification in any social setting. Since they define themselves in 'religiou~• terms, the converts have viewed the gurdwaras as the appropriate institutions for their 'religious' involvement with "East Indian" Sikhs. In the gurdwaras, they have aligned themselves with "orthodox" elements, have helped sponsor visits by Sikh "'religious' missionaries" from India, and (at the Akali Singh gurdwara) have started usunday school" classes for the children. Furthermore, since they have such an unequivocal notion of Canadian ideology and of their own identity as •religious' Sikhs, it has been the converts through who, as individual litigants or as co-council/the Sikh Youth Federation of Canada, have been most aggressive in seeking to secure and expand Sikh 'religious' rights in Canada. Thus, basing their arguments on the principle that 'religious' ccxies for conduct are privileged and inviolable, they have taken cases to the courts and the Hmnan Rights Boards to ensure that "orthodox" Sikhs can wear their beards, sword 5 ,. turbans, and other 'religious' symbols with out fear of discrim:i.na tion in employment and with full unde rstanding that them are being retained on 'roli~-.ious ' principlo and not as mere 'ethnic' customs. ~1 Conclusion What, then, of the community's future? Admitedly, many questions rermin. Is the differentiation of 'religious' and 'ethnic'-po1itical institutions, activites, and leaders merely a temporary structural respons e to Canadian ideology and public policy or does it represent a more irrevocable institutional adaptation? Will the movement for orthopraxy involve a call for the re-centralizati on of 'ethnic' and 'religious' activities and leadership in the gurdwaras? Will those recent immigrants who have been largely responsible for the 'reli!:;jous ' re viva.1ism in Vancouver begin to loose their fervor and find it necessary to "accomodate" to ma.ke a go of it in 15 • • • I Canadian society? What will he the criteria for being considered a "good Sikh" or a member of "our comnn.mity''? What are those inviolable 'religious' tenets to which one nrust adhere to be a "good ( ' religious' ) Sikh or the limits of "accomo- da tion" beyond which one must not·venture without ceasing to be accepted as of "our ( tthnic' ) communi ty7" The dynamism of the Vancouver Sikh cormnunity is such that one can hardly hope for dafinitive answers to these questions. I do hope, howe~er, that I have left you with a sense of the institutional adaptation that the comnrunity seems to have gone through as it as it increasingly reflects the prevailing Canadian ideology with respect to 'religion' and 'ethnicity.' l 6 END NOTES 1. This paper is based on archival research and fieldwork conducted in 1978-9 with the Vancouver Sikh comrrrunity. Amore detailed analysis of Vancouver Sikh social accomodation and cultural persistence will be found in the author's forthcoming Ph.D. dissertation (Department of AnthropologyJ University of Chicago). This research builds on previous research conducted in 1972 and 1974 with the Healthy, Happy, Holy Organization, whose members are now known more widely as Canad i an and American Sikh converts. Funding for the latter rPsearch was provided by the U.S. National Endowment for the Huma.nities (Youthgrant #AJ-20553-74-398). An earlier draft of this paper was read by John Wood, Brenda Beck, and Elizabeth Coville. I thank them for their helpful comments. The shortcomings of this paper, however, remain mine. 2. I use "community" in a broad sense which includes all those persons who either by their own account or in the judgement of others are thought to belong to a particular social category as that category is known in Vancouver. Obviously, as this paper brings out, there may exist differences of opinion as to what these categories represent and who belongs in what category. I put quotation marks around "East Indian" because while it is the conventional categorical label for all those of South Asian ancestry in Canada, many of the persons so labeled find 1t to be a misleading and derogatory label and would prefer another (e.g., "Inda-Canadian" or "Canadian of origins in India"). J. By "'ethn· ic'-political" organizations, I ri1ean those institutions whose primary activities involve lobbying for the interests of a particular ethnic community and mediating between the ethnic community and the social institutions of the wider society. Such organizations are thu s not usually pol i tical parties, but the relationship bet -:een such organizati ons and the e s t ab] 1.shed polj tical p;l rties would be an i nteresting area for further investi~atjon. 1 \ 4,. "Institutional adaptation" should net b~ c:onfuned wHh "$tructl)n:l asshdla ion,.•• While tnc latter r fcrs to the "large .. sca.le en {'at ~lCC ~f ~f'lrnigrmiL group embers into the cliques, chibs, and instttuUoRu. of th~ h.Gst soc iety on a primary group level" (Cordon 1964; ~1), the former rcfcrn. tQ changes ~f l~GtHuUon41 struct.uns within ln hmilgrant cc:mim,,.mity with rcspetCt: tn ln~titi.atioMl fo~t:U\s sanc:tioncd by the host and sending sochties. "Instit.uti ul .ad~pt:nU o ~" ln probably (f!Yltura) logically prior to "str,,u:t.\~rttl assimUatit>n" a&id may, ln fnct, be: a neccBsny prerequisite !or it. 5. ..E thn t c-poU tic.d," "cttm t ~-s~c lal," "c th:n! c~CYltuJ"a l ~" and 0'e ~h~ t c--sodA! serv 1cc" al'e, in a sense, id1tol type iust!tytions& Org.ani:lations can be hw ~l ·,1~d in mare than one _type of acttvit..y& However, io the cas~ of the Vancouver Sikh cor.-...'t'l~mlty, I feel justified ln my characterlzatio~ of arlous organizattcne on the b8Gi$ of their dominant orientation. 6. Like "ad4ptation," th~ Uno "ideology•• is a theoretic Uy 1~.aded on~ whtch de:.ervei; careful definition. Following one common snt~ropologtcal usage (6ce Nicholas 1973: 75~80, Geertz 1973:193 233, Schnelder 1976:220), I regard ideology as natives• 4 soc:lal theory. Undernto d tn t~is way, tde<.'logy Js a n-.)n . . ~valtMltive theoretical concept••that ta, one slrlppcd of its "connotatio~s of falsity and fanataclG~" (Nicholas 1973:76)--whlch ai111s at a representati on of th~ n.1liv4!3 1 ·tdcas about and ideals for their eoc:iety. (cf. Shil's definition of "tde@logy'' as "cmc varl nt form of those comprehensive p,atterna of cognitive and rporal beliefs about rMn,society, and the univc~se ln rtlatlon to man and soctcty, which flourish in numan ~o • e ,~~q., \ lcontinucd on n~~ t pA g~) ---= According to Geertz, ideologies, like other cultural pstt~rns, "provide _a template or blueprint for tbe orgunizatton of social and psychological proccasea" (1973: 216). Accordingly, the ideologlc41 formylattonu of a p&rtlcular society involve both the apeciflcation of the m~anjngful domains of social action in that society and the qellmitation of social organization and social !dentity -•ppropri te to those domains. Two societies ffl4Y thus recognize dlffcrent domains and organize them in different ways according to tbeir differing ideologJes. Where ideologie• contrast as significantly as h•s been suggested for South Asia and the modern West (see Dumont 1970), newcomers may be nqutred to adapt thei . institutions ~nd &ocial idenUUo.& H "they are to participate. ~n 1ingfuUy in tttc wAder sodety. Finally, whil m~ltiple ideologies NY co~ ist wit !n any ~n socie.ty and draw oopport fr diffeTcJlt. ~egrncnt& of the soctely. what 1 ~all the "prcvaHhig folk ideology•• h ltkdy ·o predominate in mo t social slt~ tlt>ns .. It is l11pqft rat to "ecogniZe . ~at while J d<2ologl G buUd upon Eld duw the l r authorl tatlvenes from persuasive cultural symbols• the flati vest-aocial ,sn.at.ysis (1) is "prey to the sar1e.problema af coherence and ,author-lty aa.ar~ .oth r cultural systems"· (Nicholas 1973:76), and (2) "is not the s~m« as th an lyst•s theore~ tlcally constructed view of the native culture" (schnelder 1976:220). ·These points are important fo~ putting in perspective what ia often taken to be a tho~ny is~ue, viz., the problem of wh iher or not Canada is "really" an tmfically plwralhtie or, even more problemattc. a culturally phuallstlc: society. Ci en th12 definHinn of ideology presented her~, it becomes appnirnnt· thot on~ c n ta~. "ethno ... nu l tur 1 pluralism•• te be the pre val ling Canadian folk ideology without thier~by and~r & ng it as <»ne•s own "social schntiftc" analysts of Canadian society . nd cultl-'rc. Undt!rstandlng thia, it is possible to agre·;.if.ic~ Gcvnrl'.mu.t (VucouvtJr, B.C.: }.r,e:•l a L)iw r. ~ocj ""t;r). 19~7h R~port o• Domh'io», Frovi'cici 1 Hhdum j_"t, ii d ~:u ..-icip&l F'r111i. chiu for th!' Britiish ColuMbi, ( Vjctor·,, n.c.: Khl.-.n Diwu ~~ociety). La.l, Brij 1976 nia,:t I ·i 1di, :- i n Britiah Columbia, JlG/-i-19111.: /1 r,,_ Hi ■ tnrical ~)tUdJ" of Growth l"'f'd 1-.,t.e,--r1t.io•," u p 1 1bJi.,h~d m1.:-tc-r' tr,..f'iB, ', ,tpt. ., of Hi•tfiry, Th U.-,inrajt,:r of PrHi h Col1171bia. 1959 11 A R•111y,ort 0.- t.h.., i;., .t-, I ·f ldi,.~ C0mmu itJ ir• [fi l c0uv•r, 11 ;{,y-ckil',,l-',1p11r, lr,Jl!t.i. t ut~ of Soci; -P'i t:cor·or1ic ·?r.11orcr, ';r .n U iY~r i t ·r 0 f Bri ti~ h Ccl ·1mbi • 24 · 1977 11 Co•... t i t ·I , : ' . ,!" ::l D.:,r-1• vi ti a.t .:~ ~CO'Rd A.tJ.'1U1.l 1,o~f,.r11~c•, ( - Au~u,t 27-28, 1977, v~rccuv~r, ~.C.). Nichola.a, Ralpb W. 1973 "Soch.l nd Politica.l Movsrnnt.1 11 b Bttrurd J ,3ie~el (ed .), A~l!u.11 R,:view, in AnthroroloiQ:, Vol. ? ( F lo :Ut.n, C&.: ~~_;- rt 1 r."'·de-:· s be.). 1975 11 Tli~orc~t·ic;:il Co;.s id,r:u ti o~ , o.i t.h~ l\ •.tur«e .,. d Tr~ d,s of Cha.~g• a.thu. Gla zor nd Doid F. Hoy· ihn ( ed1.), ~t~iliici~y: ~heor} ud ti;xptiriucet (C.u!1brid,ar 111, }:u~.: H,rva.rd u~lVftrsity .Pn~I , pp . 53-83. :-;; o rf\11 of Ethi;icity 11 il• Port. r, J ohr 1965 Th,"" Vl!rt~ich }iou.ic: Am Aulysil! of Socia.l Ch ..,: llr.;d 1--'owu i11 C nuh . (Toron+.o: ·q, ,. l 1.,.._· v-~r,i t :r of 'i..,or 0rd .o Fr.,;?,) . 1975 " i;t.r. ldc Plur, lirr~ j ,, C r. ri. in Perspective'' il\ l'.& t. h 1 Gl.1.z"Jr r.d D r1iP-l F. 1-.oyl',iiho (~d~.), S1 h ~i c.Lt.-r : J.he'2T,~ .:f-~. :~•e~ri .r~~( C. ,:tL;rid_-: -l , E.l . :T . ; H1.rn rd U~i nr~i ty Pr'!' 1 ft pp. 267-304. 1 J, 1969 11 Khuhip, l\iatioaa.lit;r, ~ d Relirio• i- Americ.n Culture: Tow.trd a. D11fi:1itio• of Kiuhip" ill F.Qbert F. Srt1J,-,cu (ed.), Form, Cllf S.yra.bolic Acti " (Sut t. le: Th• Ull;i nrlity of 't/Bhi-ertc• Pre;; fGr the AES), pp. 116-125. 1976 11 1978 "b Surch of Et. h-cdcity: 1968 "LJ•olQt,r: Not.-,1 Tow,rri • Theory cf Cultur111' ir. Keith I-!. 8 1111c, ud Ht!"~ ry /...• Sdby (11d11.), •·~ uhr-; h 1\nthro ol~~ (Albu ,p1.-rqu•, ~~.l-i.: Th~ U:rii v~ni ty of 1 «-w t-;i,xic o Prus l 97-22C. :-:v.1t-i.cultur1li11rn ii' Cn•d, 11 b Th1 Jourul of ~th"ic Sludi••, V0l. 6, Fo . 1 (spri~r 197~,: 9?-107. The Co•cept. aYid fu~cti r; r of Id•rnloty'' i'ttt th• lr tie rut,ional .Encycloptdh, ~f thit Social s~i""HCM~, Vol. 7 (r,Cl\'f Y0rk: LcHil.lu 1rcd Fre~ ~rR,r.J, pp. 66-75. Sillr,h, Kuahw.-.•t fl h ist.or"' Clf th.- Sikhs, V0lurr.18 2: 1839-1974 (Dalhi: Oxford ll . Pren). 1977 S:nith, }:1.rin W. (with h ilda. ~tl . Boul:,ttr) 191..4 11 Sikh 3 et t 11" r ~ i 'll C" fil .i d a 11 i • /.. ~ i ._ pp. 359-364. i r. d th" h · ~ :i. c. .u , \fc 1. /~ I~ , r o o 8 ,