Richmond. Anthony H. . . 1972 Ethnic Residential S ~regarion in Metropolitan Toronto, Toronto: York University, Institute for Behavioral Research. 1974 VERNE A. DUSENBERY Aspects of the Absorption and Adaptatior~ of Immigrants, A CaJJadian Immigration and Population Studv. Ottawa: Information Canada. Rosenberg, Stuart E. 1971 The Jeiu h Communitr in Canada. (two volumes). Toronto: tewart Canadian Ideology and Public Policy: The Impact on Vancouv r Sikh Ethnic and Religious Adaptation* kClelland and Rot tein, Abraham and Gary Lax . 1972 Independence: The Canadian Challenge, Toronto: Committee for an Independent Canada Sandberg. Nell C. 1974 Ethnic /dentir.1 and Assin11larion: The Polish American Community, , 'ew York: Praeger. Seelev. John R.. . le. :inder. im. and E. W Loosley 1956 Cre.\t"·ood Hei}.{ht ,. TH nto: Universit; of Toronto Press. ABSTRACT RESt; 1F Simmel. Georg 1955 Cm~flict. I ranslateJ bv Kurt H. \: 'olff, Glencoe: The free Press. Spada. 1969 The article seeh to a count for a relative!_' recent and eH:r-increasing proliferation and diver,;;ificat1on of institut10n, \ tthm Vancouver' Sikh community. FoLusing on the development of the dominant ethnic-political organi1at1ons. the paper argue that the emergence of these organizations mu t be understood in term of an apparently more ge 1eral differentiation of Vancouver Sikh ethnic and relig1ou 1dcnt1t1es, organizations. activn1es. and leader<, a differentiation not inherent in Punjabi Sikh culture but one com1'>tent with Canadian ideolog) and public policy . . V. The /w!ta 1 111 Cana la. ,1 ntreal: R1v1era Printer . Tepperman. Lome . 1975 Social .\lu/11/iri m C:..,,wda, roronto: McGraw-H1ll. Warner W. Uo\d ,rnd l eo :role 1945 The So-c :al Snrem.\ of American Dhnic Groups. l\'ew Haven: }'ale L'nivers1tr Press. Wemteld. M rton ., 1977 "Dete1rn1runts of Et nic ldrntihcation of Sla\s, Jews and Italians m 1 oronto. Cnpuoh hed Ph . D d1sscr .ition. Harvard Uni\crsity. J9 O "The .It: , Le but du present article est de mettre en valeur la recente et croissante proliferation de diver,;e" of Queb~... Perceived ,\nt1sem1tism. Segregation. and Emigration,'' Je1t·1.m Journal u/ ouoluK\' 'June. 1980) pp. 5 20. 19~1 "lntermamage. Agonv and Adaptation" in The Canadian Jewish Mowic cd · 1orton 'et feld. Wflharn Sh..1ffir. Irwin Cotler. Rexdale, Ontario. John Wile ' of Canada . · Wilev. ,'orbert F 1967 "The Ethnic Mobilny frap and Stratification Theory," Social Prohlems, v. 15, (Fall). pp. 147 159 Wirth, Louis 1928 The Gheuu, Chicago: University of Chicago Pre<;s. Yuzyk, Paul /967 L'J..rainian Canadit1t'\, Toronto: Ukrainian Canadian Business and Profe sion Federat~on. X ~ ;::- - ~~i~~~~. -~ u ) - ~ 1 ~ , ~ ~ \JY"' l i /~'1- sl 1 institutions au sein de la comrnunaute Sikh de Vancouver \1ettant !'accent sur le developpement des organisations dominantt:s politico-ethniques. !'auteur demontre 4ue la proliferation e ce organismes doit etre cons1deree comme faisant part,e d'une plus grande divers1te de l'ethnie Sikh de Vancouver. des relig1ons, des organisations, des activites et des chefs. dl\ersite qui n'e t pas inherente la culture Sikh du Pendjab mais qui est due l'ideologie et la pohtique du Canada. a a Vancouver's Sikh community is the oldest, most heterogeneous, and perhaps ·till the largest and most influential Sikh community in Canada. 1 For seventyfive years, despite periods of relative isolation from the Indian sub-continent and lternately hostile and indifferent treatment from the wider Canadian society, the community has persisted. Dunng the past ten years, the community has xperienced considerable growth and internal diversification brought on, in part, by a tremendous upsurge in Sikh and non-Sikh "East Indian" immigration from outh Asia, Britain, East Africa, East and S.E. Asia, Fiji, and the Caribbean; 2 t~e coming of age of a sizeable Canadian-born and rai ed generation of Punjabi Si h immigrant offspring; and the emergence of an organized and vocal group of gora (white) Canadian and American Sikh converts. Prior anthropological accounts (Smith, 1944; Mayar, 1959; Ame & Inglis, l973; Sr vastava, 1974; Chadney, 1976. 1977a, b) seem to support James adney's assessment that-at lea t through the time of Chadney's fieldwork in the early 1970s-that Vancouver Sikh community was underg•oing a process of C nadian Ethnic Studies, XIII. 3. 81 ,, a - - ... --·····,.,. ,..,.,..," .. ,...r, r-rr1ncc- r:ruv1n11FS All CANADA VANCOUVER SIKII ETHNIC AND REUGIOUS ADA PTA TIO ·ethnic adaptation," i.e .. "accommodating ~he. I rgcr Canadi n society y ome aspect. of traditional PunJab1 culture" {Chadn y, 1977a: · foregomg · d · d"d · 2-A). 1 evertheless, these account suggest th~t this _a _ap~atto_n 1 n_ot 591 ·mvo 1 'e wi·despread behavioral , structural ' or mant l as imtlatton . . mto. white . n societu. Rather. ta ing into account the often confl1ctmg octal and Cana d ia J d d. . t· th 1 se cultu al pressures emanating from the ~o ta~ sen 1?g ocie ie~, ese_ana_ Y stre. ed changes internal to a community which continued to differentiate itself rom the wider Canadian society. One area of adaptation little noticed in previous_ a~counts ha;. been tha\~f institutional adaptation. 3 For most of the commum~~ s seventy- 1\_e year~, · · al gurdlvara {temple) society fulfilled the traditional role of n t1tut ona ongm . I . l h center for the v rious activities of the Sikh c_om_mumty. nc1ea~b1~ ~ y. f owehver. new institutions have ari en to take on s1gm~~ant. respons1 i11ty ofr the~e Thus , today , one finds active Sikh part1c1pat1on ma number o · et me . ·c·es ac t 1v1 1 . . · b organizations with explicitly pol_itical, cul~ural, soc_1al, and soc1a 1 ~e_rv\~e . o jectives.4 Gurdwaras, in the meantime, flourish, but with more narro\\ lyre 1g10u!, concerns. Demographic and social changes, in and of themselve~, are not sufficie_nt to account for the new institutional makeup of the comm~mty. or ca? factional and interpersonal di putes within th~ co?1m_unity be entirely r~spons1ble _for _the proliferation and diversification of mstl_tuttons. Instea_d, I w1l! argue~ •~stitutional developments within the community-and especially a d1fferent1ation of ethnic and religious identities, institutions, activities, a~d l:aders-can best ~ understood as reflecting the increasing impact of Canadian ideology and pubhc polic .5 'Religion' nd 'Ethnicity' in Canadian Ideology and Public Policy As befits its New World ethos, religion in Canadian ideology is con~ive~ in terms of notions of pluralism (i.e., many religions and religious denommatton coexi t harmoniously), voluntarism (i.e., the individual i~ free to belo~g to and participate in the activities of the religious group ~f his or _h~r ch01ce), and freedom (i.e., the state neither endor es one part1cu~r. religion no_r allows limitations to be placed on the individual's legitimate rehg1ous expression; ~nd~ at the same time, the state bestows certain special statuses on all rec~gmze~ religious organizations). This Canadian ideology with respect to rehg~ n reflect din Canadian go¥Cmmental policies in the form of the legal protect~on of individuals' rights of religious affiliation and expre ion {e.g, as set forth m the Canadian Bill of Rights {1960), the Canadian Human Rights Act ( l 97~a), and the various provincial a d municipal human rights statut~). and m s~ch advantages as the tax-exempt status accorded the property of rehgious organizations when such property is used for religious purposes (e.g., see the B.C. Religious Institutions Act (1960) and the Vancouver Charter (Chpt. 55, Sec. 396(c)iv)). The Canadian ideology with respect to ethnicity is reflect~d- in th~ co~moi:ityaccepted image of Canadian society as a "mosaic"-a pluralistic s~1ety m..which, unlike the American "melting pot," th constituent elements ared1scret~ eth°:ocultural" groups which retain their unique ethnic identity ~°:d cultu~l mtegnty d _ pite social interaction. Tne most explicit statement of thi~ deolog.y m t~e ~rea public p licy is, of cour~ , ·n the federal policy of"mult1culturabsm wtthm a 0 CA AD/A ETH IC STUD/£ /ETUDES THNIQUE AU A ADA l03 bilingual framework," first enunciated by the Lib ul governn 11t i 1 7 I (Can da, 1971 ). Here, the government doe not simply guarantee certain human right t individuals of all races, color , ancestries, national origin , etc. (for these. see the Bill of Rights, the Human Rights Act, and the pro •incial and municipal human rights statutes), but takes pos"ti e tep to ensure the recognition and vit lity of ethno-cultural organizations · nd their tivitie .6 There is much to notice about the repre entation of religion and ethnicity in Canadi n ideology beyond their common pluralism While social cientific definif on of "ethnicity" commonly Ii t .. religion" a one of the ba e of ethnic identity and solidarity (see, e.g., Isajiw's {1974) review article), it appears that in Canadian ideology, religion and ethnicity are viewed as generally se a ble a d potentiall · cro s-cutting sourc s of social identity and so i· l solidarity and relatively distinct generator of ocial norms. Further ore, n t only can religious and ethnic identities. groups. and norms be distingui hed according to Canadian ideology, they can also be seen to contrast. Thus, ·herea religious idenf ty is vie ed as essentially voluntary and individuali. ti (member hip b in achie\able through the symbolic action of re-birth, confirmation, nd conversion), ethnic identity-like the even more extreme racial ident ity- is vie •ed as es entially communal and non-volitional {membership being ascri ed on the basis of common ties of origin and descent). 7 Furthermore. as a coro lary of the preceding, whereas religious norm. are seen as absolute and inviolable {generally involving faithful adherence to some .. code for conduct" enjoined on al believer and protected as .. religious rights"'), ethnic norms are seen as relatively loose and non-sp c1fic {generally involving the retention of only a few "cultural markers" sufficient to index one's membership in a particular ethnic category). 8 Finally, implici in the ideology and crucial to its public-policy implementation is a separation of sacred and secular domains such that religious institutions ( e.g., churches, temples, mosque , and other "houses of worship") which benefit from certain taxation and incorporation policies can be distinguished from t e ethnic institutions {e.g., ethnic-political, e hnic-cultural, ethnic-social, and ethnicsocial service organizations) which are the intended beneficiaries of multiculturalism programs and other forms of public funding. 9 T aditional Sikh Ideology and lnsftutio I Structures It would be a serious mistake to assume that traditional Sikh ideo' oc.1 y corresponds to Canadian ideology with respect to the differentiation of rel 4 , o >"\ and ethnicity. 10 Since Sikhism has heretofore been essenti Uy a regional faith, • Sikh and Punjabi identities of ·ts adherents have been large y conjoined. And even when s·khs have settled abroad, their insularity-reflected in norms of endogamy and non-proselytization-has meant that they have gone virtually unchallenged in defining as they· please the meaning of the term "Sikh." I is not surprising to find, therefore that it is commonly asserted of and by Punjabi Sikhs that the Sikhs constitute a distinct religious-cum-social-cum-political-cumcultural community and that it is either impossible, un arranted, or iil-advised to attempt to delineate components of this unique Sikh identity. Chadney pinpoints this traditional Sikh ide logy when he asserts: It is this constant blending of sacred and secular identitie , goals, structures, and functions, which, at the emic level, help explain the important continuance of Sikhism in Vancouver . . . . ◄ or it is VANCOUVER /KH ETH IC AND RELIGIOUS 1DAPTATJO • not simply a religious identity, it is an identity ofSikr. which i:s an identity incapable of being categor·call) isolated ·nto disparate and separate sacred and secular identities (Chadne ·, 1976: 195; emphasis in original). Rich symbolic support for this ideological unity of the sa red and secular domain is to be found in Punjabi Sikh culture in the miri/ piri and degh/ tegh/ Jateh concepts. According to traditional Sikh hagiography, the sixth Si ·h Guru (teacher), Hargobind, was invested wi h two swords at his installation as G ru, one representing spiritual power (piri: from the Persian word, pir, u ed to denote a religious teacher) and the other repre enting temporal power (miri: from another lslamically-introduced word, amir, meaning commander of the faithful). Besides encapsulating the long-standing i.·h no .. ion of world I_· involvement coexisting with spiritual enlightenment, the prriring of miri and piri reflects the ideal of Sikh religious and socio-political unity and o ereignty. A more recent symbolic development, first popuiarized at the time of the ninth and tenth Gurus (i.e., in the late I 7th century), was the pairing of the terms degh {cooking pot) and tegh (sword) to emphasize that .. the use of arms is an extension of the giving of alms .. (Cole & Sambhi, 1978: 30) and their conjunc ion with fateh (victory) in reference to the temporal and spiritual vie ory of God and God's Khalsa Panth (the orthodox Sikh community). Historically, one could enumerate numerous examples of the continued blending of what from the perspective of contemporary Western ideology would be distinguished as "religiou " and .. non-religious." Institutionally, one can observe this in the jointly political and religious aspirations of the Sikh communal party, the Akali Dal, which has periodicaly agitated for a separate Sikh homeland and against incorporation into a secular Indian state; in the political as well as religious activities of the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee (the organization legally empowered to run the affairs of the historical gurdwaras in the Punjab); and in the often parallel leadership of these most dominant of Punjabi Sikh organizations. However, the institutional framework wherein the difference in ideologies is best observed is in the scope and function of the Sikhgurdwaras, the central Sikh institution at the local level. It is conventional in English to translate gurdwara (literaHy, .. the Guru's door") as "temple." This is unfortunate, since, as virtually every Sikh scholar has pointed out, Sikh gurdwaras traditionally have beenand in most cases continue to be-more than simply "houses of worship/' as religious buildings in the West are commonly considered. If we wi h to apply our conventional Western understandings to an explanation of the traditional role of the gurdwaras in Sikh social life, it would be more appropriate to speak of them as religious, social, political, cultural, and social service center for the local community. 11 In titution I Developments Within the Vancouver Sikh Community: 1907-1947 Given this place of the gurdwara in Punjabi Sikh society, it is not surprising that a gurdwara was formed in Vancouver in 1908 following the arrival of som five thousand Sikh immigrants and that from the very beginning it served a multiplicity of apparently religious and non-religious purposes. In its early years, the Khalsa Diwan Society's gurdwara on West Second Avenue was truly a religious, social, political, cultural, and social service center for th entire South- CANADIAN ETHNIC STUDIES/ETUDES ETHN!QUES U CANADA 105 Asian immigrant population of the lower mainland. n this building, re ular readings from he iri Guru Granrh Sahib (the c Jlec ed s: h Scriptures regarded s the rei~ning Sikh Guru) ere conducted; he traditional langar (free kitchen) operated; nd shelter was provided for the h meless. In addition, the gurdwara was a pla"e where the overwhelmingly wor i,1°-class, male population came together to cialize. discu s i ues, air conflicts, nd r ach d ci ions affecting the community. 12 Gurdwaras sub equ ntly b ilt in oth r area of Sikh s.Jtlement in Bntish Columbia became legally affiliated branches of the ancouver Khalsa Di"' n Society. Thus, during this period, the Vancouver Khalsa Diwan Society could legitimately claim to speak on behalf of all the Sikhs-and thus the verwhelming majorit_ of a l Sout -A ian immigrants- in British Columbia. It wa not incon istent with Sikh ideolo y for a .. temple" organiZ t" on such as the Khalsa Diwan So iety (hereafter, K DS) to engage in political activities, and the KD quickl · took the ead in fighting against the exclu ionary Can dian immigration polici s and for the exte sion of ~h1c~ .::vc.c..e.<2t:tee( •~ CA, ADIA.\' f.T!I ,csn [)fF.S I EH Df.S ETll\!Ql'ESAUCA\'AD.4 107 term . 19 With the community pro pering, suffering litte 0\ ert hostility and anti ipatmg more open immigrati ,n. the Welfare s ociation had become les. politically active. t 1canwhile the gurd1\·ara . as the ocial center for the Sikh communit). "ere now more than e\er fu ctioning like Western- tyle '"houses o "orsh1p." opening their doors primarily for weddings. funeral , and Sunday er ·ices. Ho\.\-ever, certain events had been .·et in motion or were about to e. et m motion, whi h in the cot.rse of the past decade have significantly changed the community makeup and altered both the organizational structures and I adership pattern .. ln~f t •ional Denlopments Within th V ncouver Si h Community: 1970 1980 Hr t of all. changes in Canadian immigration policies in 1962 and especiall:-, i 1 until modified in 1973 and 1974) ignificantl) liberali?ed regulations affecting the immigration of South Asian . Increased immigration and increases restdting from a significant exce · of birth over deaths within the Sikh communit) help r.: ,· plain the perhap four-fold increas in the . 1kh popul uon o f the lower mainland to cun ent estimates of upwards of ort) thousanc per un . t the same time, the makeup of the • East-Indian"' pl)[)Ulation as a whole ;(no\.\ including I mailis. Pakistanis. Fijians. and other~ of South-A 1an ancestry) h ... s gone trom overnhelmingl_ . ikh to a point \\ here Sikhs rlpre nt only one-half to t\\O-th1rd of all "East Indians·· in the lower mainland. Furt ermore. rapid gro\\th and increa ing dive sity within the Si h communi y it elf(resulting from Sikh immigration not only from India but from Britain, Ea t Africa , Fiji, a. d other Commonwealth countries) has meant!-. me attenua ion of the influence of the old family and village ties which had en t.d to integrate new 1mm1grant - into the community. and which had served as po\.\er bases for certain community leader . While uch tie continue to be important generators of olidaritv within the community, no one person's ties are by themselves sufficient to ensure power and position within the Sikh community . At the same time that diversification and internal growth in the ikh community has worked against the continued dominance of the old Sikh leaders, similar factors conspire to challenge any as umption of continued Sikh dominance either locally or nationally - within the collective "East I nd1an" ethnic category. 20 I. 67 (and la tin The past decade has also seen the introduction of the federal multiculturalis : programs and the passage of human rights legislation at the federal. an provincial le\els. One effect of these policies has been to make clear that in the Canadian context "East Indians" are seen as constituting a di tinct ethnocultural group and that the Canadian government would prefer to deal with pan"East-lndian" ethnic organizations. At the same time, while Canadians generally remain insensitive to confessional and conventional difference among South Asians and persist m lumping all those of South-Asian ancestry in a single category, the term "Hindu" which was once applied indiscriminantly-and largely inaccurately-to those of South-Asian ancestry in Canada ha for the most part been replaced by "East Indian" as the common ethnic label. While other Canadians may assume thc1t "East Indians" share common ethnocultural traits and common socio-political interest , Canadians of South-Asian ancestry are themselves aware of the increa~ipo rlivt-•Ttv 0-f b ,a.~,-cu v-.~, "\.n.Y \ e r ~ - -t-:s rV\ Gr ' \ T' ""\ C,.., ,e.. Co" S t e (" 4 I 11:.,0 ~ r ' 6 ' 0-. l"I '"> ...> 'S", l 't l '"' -\' <;..N-(='<" I ,, , +\r-.~t S VAJ 'COU VER SIA.H ETHNIC AND RELIGIOUS ADAPTATION ohn Wood ( 1978) make clear, .. East-Indian" participati~n in the process leading to the new Immigration Act of 1976 was marked by d1spa~ate_and ~ften . · ntati·ons By the m1d-l 970s, there was no organization. either con fl ictmg prese · . · f . al "ht'ch could accurately be said to represent the interests o a . . local or na t ion , " · d "E t-Indi'an" community. In Vancouver, the Welfare Association was unite as · · lR · f . d'callv active and had been stricken from the Provmc1a egtster o on l \ ~por.i i . . . . l l f -. · the KD. was increasingly immob1hzed by mterna strugg es or S c:O~;~t of the executive and the Akali ~ingh Sikh S_ociety continued its genera~ly · · · s The onlv organizauon pre urning to represent the entire quiet1st1c way . u · community \\as the soon-discredited ~ast Indi~n DCefence C_ompmitteef, aC·v1 · odist (now affiliated with the Albaman-leanmg ommumst art o ana a~:~~ist-Leninist (CPC-ML)) which ha? organized vigilante actions to d~fen~ ""Ea •t Indians" in Vancouver from physical and verbal harassment by whites. To fill this void m ethnic-political organizational solidarity expo ed _by ~he immigration policy review. an all-Canada "Ea t-Indian" umbrella organization was tormed in 19.,5- 76. Drawing its leadership an~ support_ largely from the Indo-Canadian elite (i.e .. the Western-educated. Enghsh-speakmg profes 10n~ls. bureaucrats and business people) and. at the local level. from those v. 1th prior experience in dealing with Canadian governmental ~ureaucracy (e g .. th1rough private or government employment and or leadership of the K DS o~ 'welfare Association durmg their activi t phases), the orgamzatton called itself the . ational A sociation of Canadians of Origins in India ( 1 TACOI) and set as its aims and obJect1ves: l. T O encourage Canadian of origins in l ndia to fuily participate in Canadian Societ\ "' r o provide a nat10~al voice to Can~dians _of origins in india. 3. To provide a forum for exchange of ideas, issues and common cone rns . . 4. To facilitate communication within and with other organizations. 5. To a sist in the onentation and adaptation of Canadians of origins in India to the Canadian milieu and bring about a better understanding of Canada and other Canadians. . . 7. To formulate guidelines for improving the collective image of Canadians of origins in India. . 8. o assure due recognition of the contribution of Canadian of origins in India to Canada (N ACOI, 1977) r C-~ \'4DIA \' f.Tll\'I(' .\TU[)/ES!f:"Tl'[)ES ETII '/QUES -H ' CANAIH 109 Citi1en ' Welfare <\ssociation, and the fledgling Fraser Valley East Indian Canadian Welfare A ·sociation) as wcli a . the .. left1:t'' alternatives (e.g .. the aforementioned East Indian Defence Committee. the rival Indian Peoples· . o iation of • -orth America and the recently-founded East Indian Vorkers' Association) suggests a significant acceptance of the po . it ion that to compete for funds and recognition in the wider Canadian societv it mav be necessarv to organize into ;hat are at leaJt in theory pan-•·Ea t-India~" ethnic-poli~ical organizations. 22 <\s suggested earlier, the rise in ethnic-political organizations has gone handin-hand with a proliferation of ethnic institut1ons ofvariou<; sorts Thus. •ith the e~tabli hment of group· such as the Punjabi Cultural .. cc1at10n. the Pun1abi Literary Association. and of independent Punjabi scho ls. one find . that cth-niccultural activitie: are no longer the exclu. ive pro\·ince of the Kurdwara.\. Likewise. groups like the India Club of Vancouver." the International Punjabi Society. the India Mahilla (Women's) A.ssociation. and \ano..is .::porting clubs funcrion as ethno-social organizations independent of the gurc/H'ilra,. Final!\. ethn1c-s Kial services. once almost exc1u i\ el~ the in t1tut1onal pro\ mce of the gwdirnras. have now largely been ta ·e n over by governm .nta l agencies or semigovernmental organi1at1ons like the Immigrant Sen ice<; Centre or the lo al Teighborhood Houses which increasingly employ · Ea t Indian." to deli\er services to largely "East-Indian" clients. 23 (Jne might uspect that this proliferation of ethnic organizations taking over what were once the multiple re ·ponsibilitie of the Ktmlwaras might lea\e the gurdwara,;; themselves deserted and lifeless. This has not been the case. Gurdwaras continue to enjoy high attendance and tremendou material upport fr m the ikh community. Several new gurdwaras have been built, are being built, or are being planned in the lower mainland. Indeed, the past ten years have ecn something of a religiou revival within the Vancouver Sikh communitv. Calls for greater religious orthopraxy have resulted in increa. ing ritual elabor~tion in the established services as well as the reintroduction of Sikh ceremonies and gurdwara protocol which had nearly died out in Vancou ·er. The elect10n for the 1979 term and subsequent re-election of an .. orthodox"-dominated executive committee of the KOS ha been seen by many as a consolidation of "orthodox" control over gurdwara affairs and a repudiation of lapses in religious orthqpraxy perpetrated over the years in the interests of ocial accommodation. 24 The present leadership of both the KOS and the Akali Singh Sikh Society appear to view their mandates primarily in terms of promoting a return to religious orthopraxy and not as necessitating political activism. Thus, they have ~ hile at the local level. N ACO I's British Columbia Chapter has been concentrated their energies on maintaining the gurdwarar, as a context for the dominated by the Vancouver Sikh elite (and suffers, says i~s detractors, _fr 0 ?1 10 practice of what they regard as appropriate Sikh religious activities and have elitism), it would be unwarranted to assume that the Sikh com~u~ity_ involved the Societies only indirectly in ethnic-political activities. 2 5 For the oldVancouver has been united in accepting the wisdom or necessity of part1cipat~on guard KDS leadership, the loss of power in a gurdwara which was built under in a pan-••East-Indian" ethnic-political organization. Given the traditional Sikh their leadership and which practices a brand of Sikhism with 'which they felt ideology of religious-cum-ethnic distinctiveness, it is not surp_rising that ther~ comfortable has been a blow. 26 On the other hand, as they have withdrawn from should be residual support for the position, most vocally enunciated by the loca ?1'rdwara society affairs, many of these people have become incr~ingl} Shiromani Akali Dal of Canada, that Sikhs are a ••separate people" who should involved in the ethnic organizations, finding them to be a more rewarding forum be known not as "East Indian " or ·•Canadian of origins in India" but as for their interests and expertise. In light of these changes in orientation and .. Canadian Sikhs" and whose political interests should be looked after _by th e leadership _o~ the c_om~un~ty's institutions, it is not surprising t~ fipd that m;:1nv ~rdwara societies or other repre entatives of the Sikh Panth (comn:iumt~): In of_H,e q- ua t,ne.s · r1' :_'~:., -,d-~· (lli1lt . IS>/ ,Jt.,f>) h CJ Q.,[Af", !)r 1cier'\1, ~1[-__ [AS e 1.wa.l -f general, however. local Sikh participation in the ... establi-hment" ethnic-political 11 u-.llPL- ~,• ·· --1. ~r~a,-,,;-z..~ ~,- l\~ (e~ f\:jft'C,.O . f\ ,e_v-2v.-va.d ~.... fr: (1·.~o.'t,- , ci f:o.sk l"'ol.a"' C0-..'\dd1,-tcl\ K.D~ t L\.;\-€(5h,p [-rq ,p,ofe~ on I __.-----.-----------~- . .... . VANCOUVER SIKH ETH I AND RELIGIOV ADAPTAT/01' .. d ·tyfl an b"lingualism) a now im ortant or leadership of the .. na d . mo erm . d · · f · 1·t·ca1 organiza ions but of lesser importance to ay a cntena or .:t h me- o 1 1 . d , · · e ecti n to the executive omm1ttee of the gur \~ara societies. Sikh Sup ort for the Differentiation of 'Religion' and 'Ethnicity' The prolifera•ion and diversification of ~eligious an~ et_hnicf instfitl~ftioTn , activiti and leaders with·n the Vancouv ~ Sikh ~ommumty_ 1 a act o 1 e. o what extent it represents a fundamen~!• 1rrevers1bl~, _consc1o~s accep ance of c adian ideology with respect to rehgion and ethnicity remams to be seen. I d be noted however that support for the differentiation of 'religion' and ~ct~~icity' can b~ found ar:iUt vocal and visible group of non-"East-lndian Canadia~ and A~encan Sikh converts. While the two groups tend to define themselves m va t~y differe~t ways with re pect to the Vancouver Sikh communit~ ~s a_whole, their ~-ery existence pea •s to the separabi it~· of religion and et .mc1ty m the Canadian context. :n What is striking about the second- and third-generation Canadians_ of Punjabi- ikh ancestry is their strong ethnic identity. Second- _and thirdgeneration Canadians of Punjabi-Sikh anc~ try have largely ~voided tra~sgressing the imp[cit norms (e.g., by marrying ou'- or conv~rti_ng out) ~hich govern inclu ion in "our commun~ty." Pressures both f~om ~ithm an? w1th~ut have reinforced the norm of Sikh endogamy, so t.1at mtermarnage with Canadians of other ethnic backgrounds-and thus any question of conflicting ethnic allegiances-is still uncommon. Moreover, duri~g t~e past dec~~e? the ethnic consciousness of many of these people has been igmficantly pohtic1zed. The increase in overt a ti-"East-lndian" hostility on the part of other Canadians, though largely directed at the new immigrants, has been sufficiently general_i~ed so as to affect the second and third generation as well. nd these people, sens1tn,e to an injustice being done to all "East Indians," have regarded the ethnic-political organizations as the appropriate institutions for mounting a response.27 On the other hand, many of these same people express estrangement from the recent Sikh religious revi alism, regarding it as an unfortunate return to aspect of life in "village India" with little relevant to, or positive im_Plications f~r,_ the community's situation in Canada. To such peopl , the issue of r h~ious orthoprax should rightfully be an individual one, di tinct from and subordm~te to the community's efforts to better their po ition as "East Indians" i~ Cana_d_1an ·ociety. Thus, for many of the e people, the orientation of the ethmc-poht1~l institutions and the challenge they provide in bridging the gap between the ~t~~ic community and the wider Canadian society is more compelling than the activitie of religious orga izations from which they feel largely estranged. It is from the~e people that one gets the clearest statement that it may be . P?ssible ~o ~ •ethnically' Sikh (or Punjabi or .. .1.fast Indian") without being 'rehg1ously' Sikh.· One receives just the converse message from the gora (white) Sikh conver s." For them, solidarity with Vancouver's "East Indian" Sikhs is based not on shared Punjabi heritage but on common adherence to a univer al ,ikh dharma 'ariously translated as "religiont "way of 1 ife;• •• uty"). The convert make .. t It D clear ide logica 1 dis inction betwe~n r:ligi_o~s accommodation (e.g .. the giving up_ of beards. urbans, and other Sikh rehg10u · ymbols") which tl.ey conside neither nece ary n re cu able, and ethnic adaptation {e .. , an end to residual Punjabi "ca te consciou ness" and the "' ubjugation of women", ·hich they accept and would encour ge. 3 The con ·erts· ma·or contention i -a-vis the .. East-India ,., Sikh commun=ty in Van ouve is that in the proces of ~ ·ommoa~tion to Can dian no ms th · Canadians o Punjabi-Sikh ncest · who have v1_0 ted what he con •ert ta c to b inv· olable religious norms re patit (literally, "fallen;fl the converts• tran lation is ••apostate") and thus •·Ea tlnd·ans" (or "Punjabis") ut no 1 nger .. re l :'ikh _.. :;, 1 Since they d fine them elves in re'igious e ms. t e converts ave viewed the gurdwaras~their own as well as tho which are p, cdominantly unjabi Sikhas the appropriate instituti nsforth :r eti, · ·nvo! em nt ith·'East-Indian~ Si ·hs. In the gurdwaras, they have generally li~ned themselve with .. orthodoxtt elements, helped sponsor 'isits by ... ikh .. m1ssionarie "from India, performed gurbani Ki,:tan ("hymn of the Gurus") at ~ervices, and (at t e Akali Singh gurdwara) introduced "Sunday school .. cla. se~ for the children. Furthermore since the~ hol~ uc~ a~ unequivocal notion oft eir own identity as ·re igiously: but not ethnically 1kh, the converts are able to draw a sharp ct ·stinction between "religious" discrimination and discriminatio · based on "race ·• "ethnicity," or "national origin ." Thu the converts, as individual litigants as cocounsel_ thr_ough t~e Sikh Youth Federation of Canada, have b en particularly ag~essive !n seeking to secure and expar.d Sikh "religious r·ghts" in Canada. Ba mg their arguments on the principle that religious code for conduct are privileged and in iolable, they have enjoyed n teable succe s in appealing instances of perceived religious discrimination to the court , H ,man Right boa~ds _and other p~blic ?odies. They have ensured, for example, that "orthod~x Sikhs can retam their beard . turbans, swords and other religious symbols without fear of di crimination and with full understanding that such religious sy~bols a~e being retained on religiou principle and are not merely a perpetuation of bizarre "East-Indian•· ethnic customsJ! dr Conclusion . It is somewh~t ironic that whil~ the ethnic-political organizations serving the 1kh c?mmum:y. are ofte~ casttgated for their impotence in defining· and defe~dt~g- ethmc m~ere~t , 1t is once again an explicitly-religious organizatfon and individuals actmg m the name of religion who have brought about ome small-b~t, to many Sikhs, ignificant-changes in Canadian policies affecting them. This sho ld serve a a reminder not to overlook channels of power which may be open to ethnic groups aside from the expre sly political. However, this should not obscure the main point of this analysis, which has been to account for the proliferation and diversification of institutions within Vancouver's Sikh ~mmun_ity: In this ~e?ard, it seems appropriate to conclude that the de facto diffe~enttation of rehgious and ethnic-political institutions. ac ivities and leaders With_i~ the Vancouver Sikh community repr ents a significant departure from rad1ttonal Punjabi-Sikh ideology and social structure. This departure can also be ecn as constituting adaptation to Canadian ideology and publ'c policv. If o, what more general implications are there in these developments within the Sikh community? Are these developments peculiar to the S,kh ~,tn~t;r.n ;~ ' nad~, di..l"lV1V)' C-<,o:--.A ""~ \.)('11£1 J..Z.. '(\\ - ( ~ d\ () .., l O , - ~ - l.. <._ \.., I , ,n VA CO['VER SIKH ETH 'IC AND REUGIOLS ADAPTATION · d · t·tut·ional forms? Or are the developments noted here for the Jg1es an ms 1 . •. · c d· group· in 1couver S1.khs common to other .. ethno-rehc1ou ~ . .ana ian ·. . f xample to Canadian Doukhobors. , 1ennomtes. Huttentes, OrJCtet\- ore · · · c · thodo-.. Old Believer . Jt:w '? I \ ould ~ugge._t _that,.m respo~dt~g to anad1an ideology and public p· ticy each ..et.hno-rehg1ou~ gr_oup 1s l~kely ftCo havd~ a omewhat different experience retl ctmg ( l )_ the_ un~que mtersect10n o ana tan and the groui ·s traditional ideolorv and m. t1tut1ona l -tructure . ~nd (2) t~e nature and extent of intt:racti~n _bct':"een the grou~ a~d- th~ wider. SOCl~tr ~~t 1f, as has been uggested. a d1stmct10n between rehg10n and _e!lrn1c1ty i a \,ommonplace of Canadian ideol~gy. then it :-,houl~ not be s~rpnsmg t~ fir~d an increa ing differentiation of religious and ethmc identit~es .•?rgamzati?~s. and leadl.rs takin place ,Hthm these "'ethno-rehgious communities ac t .\,.tt·e~ i 1 • • . • • over time. And if r~)\itical pov,er 1 • a ~ecular rather than rel~g10us prerogative m Canadian ideology. one might aiso expect to observe ~".er time the emergenc~ of ethnic-political organizations lien mg t~ese com~~mt1es and a corre ponding de-politintion of the· r religiou:'.) inst1tut1?n~. If this~: s1. we nee~ to .~no\\ more about the institutional developments w1thm the~e ethno-rehg10us communities. for the outlines of a general theory await further substantiation b~ others. *A \er ion of this paper wa t rst pre..,e!lted at the R1ennial Canad.an Ethmc Stud1e Assoc1atio.1 \ketings in Yam:ou\er. B.C. October 12. !974 . The paner 1s based on arch1\al research and on fi tiwork conducted in 197 ..,9 with the Yancou,Pr Sikh commumty. The research builds on pre\ious research conduced in 1972 and 1974 with the Healthy. Happy. ~oly Organization (3HO) whose member are no- , knov,n m_o re w1delv as Can ad1an _and American 1 Sikh converts. Funding for the latter research was prn,ided by th~ .S . . at1onal Endowment for the Humanities (Youthgrant t:A Y-20553-74-398). I would like to thank Brenda Bee~. Norm Buchignani. El1rnbeth o\ille. Gary fowney. Rich Handler. and John Wood for their help-ul com~ents on earlier drafts of ~his paper. FOOTNOTES I use the term "Sikh comm unit\·- in a broad sense to include all those ll\mg m greater Yan• couver who consider themselv~s to be Sikhs. Cnfortunatel~. accurate statistical information on the Sikh population in Canada 1s hard to obtain. not least because "Sikh" is no~ a categor} of enumeration (either religious or ethnic) in Canadian census _data ~hile Toronto's and Ya ncouver's Sikh populations are by far the largest m Canada. it remains an open q1..1t1;t1on as to whether Toronto's has yet to surpas Vancouver's as the largest. 2. I ;)Ut quot,1tion marks around "East Indian" because while it is the conventional categorical label for all those of So ... th A'>ian ancestry in Canada. many persons so label:d find it misleading and derogatory and would prefer another general label (e.g., ln~oCanadian" or .. Canadian or origins in India") or a more specific one (e.g., "Canadian Sikh" or "fijian Canadian") or none at all. 3. "Institutional adaptation" should not be confused with "structural assimil~tion." While the latter refers to the "large-scale entrance of immigrant group members mto the chques, clubs, and institutions of the host society on a primary group level" (Gordon, 1964: 7!), the former refers to changes of institutional structures wllhin the irt:migra~t ~ommumty with respect to institutional forms :anctioned by the host and sending soc1et1es. 4. By .. ethnic-political organizations, I mean those i_nstitutions _whose pri1'.1a~ activities im olve lobby in for the inter sts of a particular ethmc community and med1a_t1_ng b~tw~en the ethnic community and the social institutions and particularly th_e P?ht1cal !nsut_ution. --of the wider socie y. By "'~thnic-cultural," I refer to orgamzat1ons. pnmanl,Y concerned with promoting the folk arts. histof) and language _o~ the e~hmc group= .. traditional cultur~." .. Ethnic-social" organizations are those providing soc1a! and re~re,, ational opportunities for members of the ethnic community ... Ethnic-social sen-ice L'l'YAIJtAi\ t:.,/lf,\I( ·1uUIES/ETUD£SETH. IQ ESAUCA:\'A[)A 113 organi1ation are tho e delivering social senic:es to the ethnic community. These are. in a ense. 1deal-t) pe in · titutiun Organi,atwnc; can be and often are involved in more than one type of actn ity .. ·e,ertheles . l feel justified in my characterization of variou organi,ation within Vancouver's • tk.h community on the a i of their dominant orientation. 5 Like "adaptation." the term •'ideology" i_ theoretically load done which de erves careful definition. Follo"ing one common anthropological usage (see Nicholas, 197.3: 75 0: Geert1. 197'\ 193 233, Schneider. 1976: 220). l regard ideology as the natives· social theory. nden,10 din th1 \ ay. ideology is a non-e,aluative theoretical concept - that i , one expressing actors' ideas bout ideal for their scx.1cty. While ideolog1e_ build upon and draw their authoritativeness from pervasive and persuasive cultural symbol . the natives· ocial analy is (I) is "prey to the ame problems of coherence and authority as are other cultural systems" ('.'licholas. 1973: 76). and (2) "is not the same a~ the analvst', thec,reticallv c nstructed view of the native culture" (Schneider. 1976: 220) GI\ en th(,; dc1init1on of id~olocy. it becomes apparent that one can hold ··ethnocultural plurali·m1" to be the rrevailing Canadian ideology without thereby endor. ing it as one·~ own social, 1entific an.dysis of Canadian ,;ocit:ty and culture. Understanding this. 1t is possible tc agree" ith John P rte r's conclusiOn that "(i)f not its one distinctive value. that of the mo a1 1 C ,rnada's mo:,,t cheri<;hed- l 1965: 55 ) without disputing those who pre ent evidence of ethni~ hierarch~ M tluid e~h111c boundaries or a widespread adoption of common cultural premise aero-.:; ethnic oundaries. 6. The Canadian idt:olog:. with re-,pect to ethn1c1ty and the government's policv of multiculturalism ha\e been variou-,ly cnt1c1zed by social scientist for inaccurately portraying the -,tructur· I r a li 1es ol Canadian oc1ety (Porter. 1975). for confw,ing the analytic notions ol "ethni ... lt~ .. and "culture" (burnet. 1976). and for co opting the leg1t1mate human rights concern of imm1 rant eroups b\ tocusing on their "fo.lk" activities (Sehr )eter. 1978). or b1 creating "career eth'lic.-" with ,ested mtere,ts 11, perpetuatmg current multicultural! m programs ( f I tderes & Goldenberg, 1977 J. ~evertheless. reiteration of their commitment to the mL.Jt1culturah~m policy by recent Liberal and Con enat1ve go-.ernment and the <,uppon tht> p1)licy has received from all three ma3or political part1e-. suggests that the ideology persish and that the policy 1· likely to be continued 7. The Canadian tdeolog 1 v. 1th respect to "ethnicity" appears to share much in common wtth the ideology -w nh m,pcct to •·race ." The major difference appears to be the greater degree to which the ··tact<;" of racial 1dent1ty are taken to be mnate and encoded m one' · substance (e.g. 1n "blood" and "coior"). It may be most appropriate, therefore. to regard "East Indian" like "Ba k" and "'.\ati ·e Indian" as a racial-ethnic category label (though, in fact. many Canadians of PunJab1-S1kh ancestry could easily .. pass" as white Canadians if color wen: the onl:- index) . 8. This point dc _erves further elaboration Par,;ons ( 1975: 65), quoting David Schneider, pomts out that in . · orth America. "ethnic ~tat us 1s conspicuously devoid of social content" and "the markers of [ethnic] identity are in a \ery important sense 'empty symbols'." In other words. m ~orth America, so long as a few general "cultural markers" are retained, considerable "cultural adaptation" can take place without bringing into 4uest1on one's "ethnic identity" 9. While the separation of church and state is not as absolute in Canada as in the United· States (and thus, e.g., independent religious schools are eligible for public funds in British Columbia), multiculturalism funding is apparently not intended to support overtlyrelig1ous activities. Where religious institutions do receive public funds, it is usually specified as support for what are taken to be ancillary ethnic-cultural or ethnic-social service activities Thus. in the early 1970s the K DS was briefly given a grant by the city of Vancouver to run an .. mformation center" for new immigrants. The Vancouver gurdwaras have not sought further funds even though the KDS Punjabi School might be eligible for funding from the Secretary of State (Multiculturalism) for its Punjabi language classes. KOS leaders give as a reason for not seeking such funding the fear of loss of autonomy. Since the Punjabi language and, espec1ally, the Gurmukhi script are so intimately connected with the Sikh religion, it is hard to imagine the authorities being able to enforce the teaching of rehg1ously-neutral Punjabi language classes at the gurdwaras. IO. In his comparative study of South Asia and the modern West, the French anthropologist Louis Dumont ( 1970) has admoni hed us to fully recognize and respect the contrasting 0:N~.c-•-r - ~C~A=N - - - - - - - - - -, - - -- V- A_N _C _O ~ U:V:£:R~S~l~K~H;-:E~T=H~N:/C~A~N~D:--:R~E~L~/:G~/0:L:.:S~A~D:A:P~TA:T~! other things he has suggested that one significant . A · o f t h e t w o regions. mong ' 1deolog1eo; · · ·ism · t h e l : •ter ' s d'ff .,cologies . d modern Western i erenc.ontrast etween S?uth-Asi~dn anty i·nto a multitude of separate and distinct "domains." · I ct1on and I enu · · Id . · t . ·v) even o so far as to sugge t that the coment1ona istmc t~n ttat1on o f s_oc1a a Jndcn & Nicholas (1977. x1 . gthe sacred and secular domains may not be present m made in the modem West between South-Asian cultures. d. . I d·scussion of the multiplicity of functions of the tra 1tiona 11 Sec Mayar ( I 959: 8-9) f or one I ikh gurdwara. f t h early activities of t> Singh ( 1977. 174-175) and Das ( 1923: 88) for accounts o some o t Se 12. OS the Vancouver K • .. . f the KDS's efforts to achieve dom1cihary nghts for illegal outh13 Foradeta1ledaccounto . 1947 . Asian immigrants in British Columbia, see I'\,. , a . . ,· . f th KDS's efforts to achieve the federal. prov1nc1al and munH.:1pal e 14 For a detailed account o . franchise for all "Hindoos," see KOS, 1947b. d of earl · would-be ethnic-political leaders ( often 15. Lal (1976) contrasts t~ bac~~~:~:siderable\nor experience deali ng \\ith Wester~~rs) hi?hly-edu<:ated, non-Sik~~ w1 l . working-class Sikhs) . Many of these political ac~1v1sts . th those of the ~assehs arge ~unity's earl\.' years and found more receptive audiences left Vancouver dunng t e com . J elsewhere. ·d d · cuve in Vancouver at this time. I have not cons1 ere 16. The Ghad_r (Re~~lutton) _Par:tY wa\~e Vancouver Sikh community. however. because (I) ~tan ~thru~-p?ht1ca~ in~1:~:::a~~s the poht1cal s1t~at1on in India rather th~n t~e situation it~ pnmaI) one~ta~10Cn d d (") while active in Vancouver. its organint1onal center ot the community m ana a, an was in the United States. · · h \ I ffihates of the VancoU\er KOS have now I 7. All of the gu:~waras which or~~t etheeg~:stern Sikh. Samachar Society, publisher of ach ieved their independence. P · t be an umbrella organization for all the the monthly Sikh Samachar Journa 1. aspires o . B.C. gurdwara societies. • · d b. · f the East Indian Canadian Citizens· Welfare Assoc1at1on as set 18. 1 he aims an o 1ect1ves o vos w;:t ~a~t ;0 i~o~~,::~h;~~~~~~u~ c°:n~~/~~~~~a~~e~d cultural advancement of the Canadian 1 citizens ot East Indian ongm m Canada . h b 0 f the Indian (b) To act as an effective medium of cooperation _between t e mem en, Commumtv in Canada and other Canadian c1t1zens. C d (c) To i~terpret India, the people. traditions and c~lture. t? the people o-~-/!'la ~utie I (d) To inculcate among the Canadian citizens of Indian ongin, the responsi iues. and rights of Canadian citizenship . d 1 dia by the (e) fo promote better understanding and friendship between Canada an n exchange of mutual information. . d other 1 (f) To establish centres for the purpose of cultural. recreational. socia an community activities. . · deal in or (g) To purchase, se\l, take on lease, hire, mortga_ge, or other~1se acquire or es of the foreclose property, land and buildings, or any interest therein, for the purpos Association. f h h poses of the (h) To erect buildings on such lands, or any of them, to urt er t e pur Association. . I or personal provide or mamtain al 1 necessary re_a ( i) To buy • sell ' deal· in ' hire ' make or · th b. ect' ves of the Assoc1at1on. . property or equipment for carrying out e O J 1 be deemed (j) To publish periodicals, books, pamphlets and such ht~rat_ure as may nd necessary to promote the above-mentioned aims a obJectives. tioned (k) To promote all other ancillary objects for the advan~e~ent of the above-men aims (East Indian Canadian Citizens' Welfare Assoc1ation, 1954). · I K DS leadc::rship at th e 19. See Chadney (1976: 154- 168) for an account of the factors crucia to time of his study. . NACOi . t d however on the nat10nal 20. Sikhs from Vancouver continue to be we 11 -represen e , , executive committee. A DI A V ET II 'IC STUD I ES/ ETL DES ET/I \IQ L ES A U CA \' A {)A 115 21. The East Indian Defence Committee re pre ents an intere tmg case study since it is a grocp which apparently would like to ta e advantage of both Canadian and traditional Sikh ideologies of reh 10n and ethnicity. Recognizing the importance of the gurdwaras to the Sikh community. the Defence Committee un:)uccessfully ~ought control of the Vancouver gurdwaras during the mid-1970 One of the arguments ra1 ed again t Defence Committee involvement in gurdwara aff a1rs was that as a .. political" organization and, as an affiliate of the Comm uni t Party of Canada ( Marxist-Leninist), n apparently "anti-religious" organization, its participation in the affairs of a religious organization ~o uld be mappropnate. Having been rebuffed in effort to secure a base in the gurdwaras. the Defence Committee sought to build a "Memonal Hall" wh ic h would serve as a meeting hall and community center commemorating the earl\ martyrs of the Vancou\'er "East-Indian" communitv, the Indian Freedom Fighter , and recent Indian ·ax.ihte activists The · found . however. that by installing a copy of the Sin Guru Granrh Sah,h and allowing the building to be used for weddings, they could call it the Desh Bhagat Temple and thu,; (I) take advantage of the fact that "house of worship" are considered non-thre· tening by m "1 t Canadians and are granted tax-exempt status under local statutes. and f 2) keep 01 n the channels of communication with those Sikhs who ha\e need of a place to perform functioru; and do not object to this particular blending of religion and politics 22. The Indian Peoples' Association of ·orth American (IPA. 'A) i,; affiliated wnh the Canadian Communist League-Marxist-Leninist (CC L-ML) . The conflicts between the Defence Committee and !PANA (and between the CPC-ML and the CCL-ML) deme from splits in the Communist Party oi India-Marxist (CPI-Ml during the 1%0'>. The Eaq Indian Workers' Assoc1at1on (EIWA) 1s modeled after the effectl\C Indian Worker Association (IW A) in Britain. 23. It i~ interesting to note that there are no ethnic s-ocial-serv1cc organizat ons a '>UCh operated from within the "East-Indian· communll_. Traditionally. 1khs have looked after their own either informally (e.g .. through family and village connections) or througn the gurdwaras. Only recently in Vancouver has the long-standing resistance to turning to out 1de agencies for counseli ng or assistance begun to dissolve. this being both cau e and effect of the breakdown of established patron client a°'i brokered relationship in a rapidly growing and diversifying Sikh population. 24. There 1s special irony m the election of the 1979 K D<; executive committee. fh1s wa the first K DS election contested under new election procedures ( membership fees, clo-.ed membership rolls, secret ballots) which had been pushed by "modernists" as necessary to ensure fair elections but had been opposed by .. traditionalists" as a deviation from established electoral traditions (a show of hands by those present at the gurc/}1 ara on election day) . The 1979 e-lect1on was a hard-fought affair with the incumbent K DS leadership (which had strongly pushed the new procedures} and the "orthodox" challengers ( many of whom had opposed the new procedures) seeking to enroll as many new members as possible and to ensure that their supporters mad e it to the polls. Pre-e ection arithmetic forecast a close election which would probably be won by the incumbent group. Instead, the .. orthodox" group emerged with a clear majority of seats - and all major positions-on the new executive. The new election procedures appear to have·backfired on the old-guard KDS leadership who, given the privacy of the voting booth. coulc}no longer ensure the loyality of those (e.g., family, members . village-mates, employees, clients) whom they had countt>d as their supporters. 25. The term .. orthodox" (with its specifically-religious overtones) seems more appropriate ir describing the present gurdwara leadership than the term .. traditionalist" (which speaks to a conservatism in a broad range of ethnic concerns). Whereas Sikh "traditionalists" (represented at the organizational level in Vancouver by the Shiromani Akali Dal of Canada) would insist on maintaining the gurdwara' traditional multi-functional role, the .. orthodox" leadership seems wary of mixing religion and politics . For instance, during recent provincial and federal elections, candidates who asked to address the sangat (congregation) at the KOS gurdwara (a traditional forum for courting the ikh vote) were allowed to do so only after considerable debate on the part of the executive as to its propriety, and were instructed to speak only to the highly-charged issue of whether Sikhs should be exempted from hard-hat safety regulations on grounds that hard-hat requirements conflict with the Sikhs' religious duty and thus religious right to wear their turban . iA. 'luui f:.I{ ,)! H t.lli . IC A ac.: of these people argue that in. t~is reltg1ou. ly-pluralist1c soc,et_y. '_'m~der_nist" a~d Jrthodox" branches of the Sikh reltg1?n should be allo ed to _co-exist inst1t~t1onally m the same wav that reformed consenat1v~ / ort~odox co_n grc~t,ons exist within Judaism th wa, d~nominat,onal difference exist within Christianity. These people argue that ~~er/are ~ther gurd1rnras in the Vancouver area that the .. orthodo. •· cowld attend without taking over the KOS. 27 . .. East-Indian" -.tudents at the local co~leges and ~ni~·ersitie ~ppear to he e~~raordinarily active not only in their own "East-Indian" organizat,o~s _b ut 111 campu. poht1~s g nerall y. And there seems to Ix ome carry-oHr betw:en this act1v1,m an~ ~ubsequ~n 1n~•ol\e":ent with the community's ethnic-political orgamzat;on · and the poltt1cal parties of the wider 28. D IA i IJ H ,\IC Sil D/f,~ / l:Jl IJl. E TIIN/Ql E5i AU C ·u REU(j/OUS ADAPTAT/O, oc1ety. Jong with marry111g a Jt(>ru. form · 1 conven,ion to Chri t1anity remains one of the sure t \.\avs-to find oneself cut off from one\ family and others m the PunJab1-Sikh communit~ . Fe~ of these people have taken such a drastic . tep Rather. man . re gard thcmsi; h-es · -. "non-religious" (one of the options available in reltg1ou .· h-p1ura li .;, t1c Canada) 29. . 1ost Canadian and Amen can Sikh convert are member'- 01 the If alt"1y. H a pn y. ! . oiy Organization (3HO). a group founded in 1969 m Lo. ngclcs b'> a .'i kh 1mrn1gra •1t. Harbhajan Singh Puri (a k, a \ ogi BhaJan. a k l a . .~iri Smgh Sah ib Bhat Sah ib Harbhajan Singh Khalsa Yogi). The group was original!:- m.:ru it ed u n the ba i f P un· Kundahni and Tantnc \ oga teach ings and had a basciall~ yog1 c 1d e nt1ty (s e U t!se nben. I 973). but 1t has evolved overt he cour~e of the past decade into a small but d edicated grou p of people who regard themsel e-. a~ upholders of Sikh orthopra , y in th1.: West <-,ce Du enberv. 1975) . At present. perhap a s man:, as three o live th ousand b u t now here nearthe250.000claim'~d - Sikh con crtsli\etn o er one hundred 1H O a ., hr11md .. , p intu : communes .. ) throughout · orth America and 10 several c itte, ab roa In \'ancouver. an ashram has c , i,ted ..,rnce 197~. The orientat io n lJf the 'a nco u\ er ashram is split between 1m olvement w 1th the local "Ea-;t-lnd1an" Sikh commun ity ar.d with the "alternat1\e-ltfe tvles" subculture . Relat1onsh1p-. bu we e n JH O an· ·or h Americans with Punjabi-S1ih ancestries have often been strained . b ut the dole.-i 01 o members of the Vancouver JHO ashram ha\e been in o h ed with Van cou\ ·r\ PunJa b i Sikhs bot~ through the ?urd11 aras and through the Sikh Yo uth f ede rati or. nf - an da ( a joint gora Sikh-Punjab, ~,kh venture insp ired and adw;ed by P u n ). 30 . The converts regard "caste consciousness" and the "<,ubJu gation oh~ o m e n'" a, mco n-, 1ste nt with Sikh religious teachings. f-or a fuller discussion of ~orth Ame rican and Punja h1 perspectives on Sikh egalttarianism. see Dw,enbery, 1980. 31 . ln support of this idea that Sikhism is a religion with certdin religious norms not legit imate!) subject to mod1ficat1on in any social setting, the comcrt s point to the reh at mararnda. which they term a SiJ...h •·code of conduct for living.tt Formulated h_y a selt:c t group of distinguished Sikh h1stonans and religious leader~ as part of a ger eral codification of Sikh religiou principles earlier 111 this centur _. the rehat ha s been circulate by the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee Wh ile the converts and some "orthodox" leader regard it as a definitive st.4 117 REFEREVCES Ames. Michael l\1 and Joy lngli 1973 "( -nn1 t and Change in Bnti h Columbia Sikh Family Life.- BC SruJ1c~ 20 15 49 . Buchignani. Norman L 1979 "South ..\sian Political Organirntion in C an,1da . I 06 1920." Pape r prese nted at t he Bie nn ia l Canadian Ethnic. tudies As oc1ation 1eet ings . Va ncol!\er. BC .. 0 t ober 12. 19 9 Burnet. Jean 1976 "Ethnic Relations and Ethnic Policie.., 10 Canadian oc,et ) :· pp 23 4 0 in Fra nc es Henry (iSd ). Ethnit Hy in rhe Americas The Hague· 1\1outo" . Canada 1960 An Act for the recogmt1on and Protection o f H u man I hts an d Fu nd ament.t! Freedo m s. in Statutes of Canada, Vol. I. Ch. 44 . Otta\,\.a : The Quet:n' , Pri n ter and Controller of Stationery. Canad ian Culture : Announ1..." m ent of l mplem cnt at1on of l'oh of ~1 u lt icu lturah"m \\-!thi n a Bilingual Framework . in H o u e (/ Commo m !)eh,ue (0 tobcr 8. 1971) 19 l 1978a Canadia n Human Rights ..\ct. in Canadian Ga:ette, Pan Ill. Vol 2. no ( procla 1med March I. 19..,8 . 19 h \1ult1culturalism : Announce :nent o f '\ e\, Pr{,l! ra m - IO llu u e ( 1\1arch 21. 1978) . ,re Olll!/ 1 {}fl\ . ch ,3 nehal€ C hadnc:- _ Jame '.'! Ga) lord 1976 "The Vancouver Sikhs . An Ethnic C o mmuntt ~ tn Ca nada ·· ( l ' np u blt-.h~d PhD dissertat ion. Department of -\nthropol o g y. M 1ch1gan Stat l nne .., ,t~) 197 a Abtract.TheVancouverSikhs . D u.1erra tinn 4h tr cr1 l nurnatw11a/3 (9) . -912 \ 1977 b ·· Demography, Identity . and Dec,s ion- ~,fakm g. fhe Case of the \ 'ancou\e r Sikh : · l/rhan Anthropologr Vl(1 )· 1L 7 204 . Co le. W . O\\Cn a nd Piara Singh Sambhi 197 The S1kh.1 : Their Re/1gwu\ Bt!hef, and Pract u e.1. I ond on: Rou ledge & Kegan Paul Das. Raj an1 Kauta 192 3 Hmdustam Workers on the Pac[fic Co ast . Berlin an d l e1pz1g: ~ a lte r d e C, ruy t r & Co . Dumont , Louis 1970 Homo Hierarchicus: The CaHe S rstem and It s lm11ilcat1om . ·h1cago: T he sity of Chicago Press . ni ,,; e r- Dusenbery, Verne A. 1973 "Why \, ould an} body j_oin . . ?: A Study of Recruitmen: and th e Healthy_ Happy . Holy Organization ." ( l ' npu bl1shed semor H o nors Essay. D e pt3:rment of Anthropolog}. ~tanford U niversit)) 1975 "Stra1ght-Freak-Yogi-S1kh: A 'Search for Meaning' in Contemporary American Culture." (Unpublished Master's Thesis. Department of Antnropology, University of Chicago) . 1980 "Hierarchy, Equality and the As ertion of Sikh Identity in . · orth America" Paper presented at the 56th Annual Central States Anthropolog1cal ssociation Meetings. Ann Arbor, Michigan. Apnl 9 - 12, 1980. Ea t Indian Canadian Citizens' Welfare Assoc1at1on 1954 Constitution and By-Laws (as adopted December 7 1954). Frideres, J. S. and Sheldon Goldenberg 1977 "Hyphenated Canadians: Comparative Analysis of Ethmc. Regional, and National Identification of Western Canadian University Students," Journal of Ethnic Studies 5(2): 99 - 1. VANCOUVER SIKH ETH IC AND RELIGIOUS ADAPTATION .:rtz. Clifford .. 193 - 23"., m T"L · , ,,e / nterpretat,on q f Cu I tures. 19 73 .. Ideology as a Cultural System, pp. New York: Basic Books. Gordon. Milton Myron 1964 Assimilation in American Life· The Rolt• of Race, Religion. and National Origins. . 'ew York: Oxford University Press Inden. Ronald B. and Ralph W. Nicholas . . . 197"' Kinship in Bengali Culture Chicago: The U01vers1ty of Chicago Press. Isajiw. Wsevolod W. 1974 .. Definitions of Ethnicity," Ethnicity I: 111 124. Khalsa Diwan Society 1947a A Report o_f Correspondence and Documents reiating to negotiat,ons between /939 and /947. culminating in domicilian· right ht>ing accorded to 210 members of the Indian Communir_, by the Dominion Government. Vancouver. B.C.: Khalsa Diwan Society. 1947b Report on Dominion. Pro\'mcial and Jluni ipal Franchise.for the Hindus in British Columbia. Victoria B.C · Khalsa Diwan Society. Lal. Brij 1976 .. East Indians in Bntish Colu mbia. 1904 -1914: An Historical Study of Growth and Integrat10n." (Lnpublished master's thesi . Department of History, Ln1versity of British Columbia). Mavar. Adrian C. 1959 A Report on the East Indian Community in Vancouver. (Working Papers, Institute of Social and Economic Research. U nt\ersity of British Columbia). National Association of Canadians of Origins m India 1977 Constitution and By-laws (a adopted at th~ Second Annual Conference, Vancouver, B C.. August 27 28, 1977) ~icholas, Ralph W 19"'3 "Social and Polit1cal Movements," in Bernard J Siegel (ed.), Annual Reviews in Anthropology. Vol. 2 Palo Alto· Annual Reviews Inc. Parsons, Talcott 19.,5 "'Some Theoretical Considerations on the ature and Trends of Change in Ethnicity" pp. 53 -83 m Nathan Glazer and Daniel P. Moynihan (eds). Ethnicity: Theor_i and Experience. Cambridge. , 1ass.: Harvard University Press. Porter. John 1965 The Vertical Mosaic: An Ana~i•sis of Social Class and Power in Canada. Toronto: The University of Toronto Press. 1975 "Ethnic Plurahsm in Canadian Perspective, ... pp. 267 304 in Nathan Glazer and Daniel P. Moynihan (eds.), Ethnicir_i : Theorr and Experience. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press. Schneider, David M. 1969 "Kinship, Nationality, and Religion in American Culture: Toward a Definition of Kinship, .. pp. 116- 125 in Robert F. Spencer (ed.). Forms of Symbolic Action. Seattle: The University of Washington Press (for lhe AES) 1976 "Notes Toward a Theory of Culture," pp. 195 221 m Keith Basso and Henry Selby (eds.), Meaning in Anthropology. Albuquerque: The University of New Mexico Press. Schroeter, Gerd 1978 "In Search of Ethnicity: Multiculturalism in Canada," Journal of Ethnic Studies 16(1): 98-107. Singh. Kushwant 1977 A History of the Sikhs. Volume 2: 1839- /974. Delhi: Oxford University Press. Smith. Marian W. (with Hilda W. Boulter) l944 Sikh Settlers in Canada . Asta and the Americans 44(8): 359 - 364. CANAD/Al\' ETH 'IC STl'f)fES FTl,'DES ETIINIQUF.S AU C 'AD4 119 Sri\astava, Ram P . 1974 "Farmly Organit..ation a?d Change _Among_ !he Overseas Indians with s~ ial ~eference to l?dian Immigrant F_am_1he in British Columbia, Canada." pp. 369 39 f in Ge'-)rge Kurian (ed .), The Famtly 111 lnd,a: A Regional View. The Hague: Mou·on. Wood. John IQ78 "East Indians and Canada's Ne~ lmmigrdtion Policy," Canadian Puh/ic p /icy IV(4 547 - 567