SUN DAY, JU LY 29, 2007 THE PROVINCE I A21 Sikh name change supports hated caste system The report "Sikhs outraged at n ame changes" gives the false impression that the use of Singh and Kaur as a last name has been prohibited altogether. The Canadian High t ommission in New Delhi, in fact, sug\ gests that the u se of Singh _and Kaur as a las t nam e is no t s ufficient fo r t he purpo se o f ., immigration to Canada. Applicants have been advised by the New Delhi visa office to add a family name or surname to the existing name that ends with . Singh or Kaur. In India, as in the western world, there is no set pattern of use of the first, middle and last n ame. The family name, which is usu ally the surname of an individual, invariably p oints to a caste in Indian society. Sikhism, as a r eligi o n, has endeavoured to uproot the caste system by giving common names, like Singh and Kaur, to all its fol~ lowers. Adhering to the tenets of their religion, Sikhs with progressive outlooks normally don't use family names that point toward a caste. - Surely the intention of Canada's visa office in New Delhi is not to pe r petuate the hated caste system. Yet the requirement to add a surname linked to it will serve this very purpose. As no one has been aske d to drop Singh or Kaur from their given name, there is no question of Hardev Singh Chahal (left} and son Jatinder Singh Chahal lead Sikhs down Vancouver's Main Street in the annual hurting Sikh sentiments. celebration of Baisakhi. Controversy has arisen over the similarity of Sikh names. RIC ERNST - PROVINCE FILE PHOTO The real issue is the adding of a Public relations disaster Focus on a fair deal . test on someone is frightening. a caste-based surname and the I can u n d erstand how Sikhs propriety of forcing a p erson to I strongly support CUPE in its Whether tl).ese replacement workers, so-called "volunteers," _must fee l to b e requested to change his or her name in order bid to get a good contract, but I'm t o b e considere d eligible to change their names. But they surprised it criticizes those who were paid or riot to do other people's work is immaterial, because m ust u nderstan d that it can be volunteered to clean the beach. emigrate to Canada. Raghbir Singh Sirjana, Delta necessary for their own safety. Paid or not, this public act of Houston Landscapes was given a Pennie McNutt, Squamish kindness is a PR battle that the nice bit of front-page advertising. Potential for disaster union c an't win - s o why Kent Hous t on is either a I work in a very busy laboratory Government ignorance "socially responsible citizen'' or a bother? The union already has Vancouat a hospital in Squamish, which It seems the proposed policy "scab." I lean toward the latter. h as. a large East Indian populaover changing Sikh names ver Mayor Sam Sullivan on the But this is just a distraction. The tion. _ doesn't come from a concern over ropes. To alienate the public over fact remains that "Sam's Strike" Many of the names, including applicant mix-ups, but rather picking up trash is poor thinking, never should have happened. the first, middle and last, are the from a common political policy terrible PR and only gives The mayor and the city council of pure ignorance. have been lapdogs to the GVRD same and are gender-neutral. Sullivan more ammo to use labour-relations board, which has There are many reasonable against CUPE. I once called a person in for lab methods to address concerns slowed the whole process and tests and had three people stand Just watch - for the rest of the up, male and female. over mix-ups. I don't recall this fireworks, there will be even more asked for concessions no group Because they d on't use their attitude being directed toward of employees would agree to. volunteers picking up garbage. Union: Don't stick your other Smith, Jones, Brown and Wang. It is time for the city to deliver birth dates as identification and very few speak English we ll This is a very sad position to foot in your mouth. Go after Sam a fair deal and get this summer enough to give us a correct ID, take in today's world. and not these good samaritans. back on track for its citizens. Zheng Dao Wang, Vancouver the chances of doing the wrong Robert Randall, Richmond Ken Hamaguchi, Richmond Selfish union stance My God, how spiteful and selfish can this union be? Despite knowing that there is a garbage strike on, many of the fireworks attendees couldn't have cared less what kind of mess they left behind. Th ese volunteers came out on their own, early in the morning t o bo ot, and mad e this city a cleaner, safer, more beautiful place for the rest of us and for those tourists who add so much to our economy. I guess the union would rather everyone wallow in the garbage. What a pretty image that is! To the volunteers: Good on you and thank you very m uch. Sonja Veit, North Vancouver Shameful approach Shame on Mike Jackson of CUPE, Aaron Jasper of the West End Residents Association and letter writer Glen Hansman. . We're all citizens of Vancouver, union and non-union, and we all should be picking up garbage, not only during the Celebration of Light but during our daily lives. I<:eeping our city clean has nothing to do with the present labour dispute. If we want to be considered a world-class city, we all have to step up to the plate every day. Gentlemen, wake up and smell the roses that aren't under the pile of garbage - that would still be on the street, if people took your approach to keeping the city clean. Juri Raiska, Nor th Vancouver Impediment to society Sign me up! I never thought I would volunteer to pick up other people's garbage. But if CUPE local president Mike Jackson thinks it's wrong for citizens to pitch in and keep our beaches clean, then I would like to offer my services. Sadly, the real issue here is how the unions have become completely outdated vehicles that operate only as an impediment to a productive and functioning society. And the irony is that organized labour does not realize how ridiculous its endless complaining sounds to the rest of us. Beth Hardy, Vancouver