EAST INDIANS IN BRITISH COLUMBIA, 1904-1914 :· AN HISTORICAL STUDY IN GROWTH AND INTEGRATION by BRIJ LAL, B.A., University of the South Pacific, Fiji, 1974 A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF lVfASTER OF ARTS in THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES ( Department of History) We accept this thesis as conforming to the required standard THE UNIVERSITY OF BRiitsH COLUMBIA February, 1976 In presenting this thesis in partial futfi lment of the requirements for an advanced degree at the University of British Columbia, I agree that the Library shalt make it freely available for reference and study. I further agree that pennission for extensive copying of this thesis for scholarly purposes may be granted by the Head of my Department or by his representatives. It is understood that copying or publication of this thesis for financial gain shalt not be allowed without my written permission. Department of ___H_1._·_s_t_o_ry_..____________ The University of British Columbia 2075 Wesbrook Place Vancouver, Canada V6T lWS Date 5 February, 1976, ABSTRACT The full history of the early East Indian community in British Columbia has yet to be written. Here~an attempt has been made to assemble the,:,information relating to some aspects of the community's origins and development between 1904 and 1914, the first decacie of :their presence in Canada. This thesis also attempts to examine the structural position of the East Indian community and its -lack of integration into and acceptance by the host society. Four major factors influencing the nature of development of the East Indian comm.unity were examined ·,in detail: the socio-economi:c background of the East Indian immigrants, the nature of institutional developments in the nascent community in British Columbia, the attitudes and perceptions oft:the host society, and the political respo~ns,es'J,>±' ·the Dominion and Imperial governments to Indian immigration. Intensive, as opposed to extensive examination of these factors dictated the adoption of a thematic rather than a chronological approach. The methodology employed was interdisciplinary in nature, utilising theoreti•cal material drawn from the disciplines of sociology and anthr0pology. It was found that the East Indian community was an alienated ethnic group which lived on the social fringes of the host society. ··Integration and acceptance of the East Indians did not take place as a result of vast differences in the cultures.and institutions of themr country of origin -ii- -iiiand the host society, but mere importantly, because the immigrants themselves did not want to integrate. The East Indians were sojourners who hoped to return to India in their old age to enjoy the wealth they had acquired abroad. TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ••••••••.••••••••••••••••••• ·; ••••••••• q 1 CHAPTER I. THE SOURCES OF EAST INDIAN .IMMIGRATION II. FORMAL ORGANISATIONS AND POLITICA~ ACTIVITIES IN THE EAST INDIAN COMMUNITY II;I:. THE 'HINDU' AND HIS CANADIAN IMAGE ••••••• ..a 98 IV. EAST INDIAN IMMIGRATION IN POLITICAL . PERSPECTIVE :•.'.•:,:·i ~:~,~ .-; :~:: .•. :;;:. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 13 0 CONCLUSION ........................................ 167 APPENDIX •••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• 171 . BIBLIOGRAPHY 13 . • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •• -iv- • • • • 6- • • • • • • • • • • • 178 LIST OF TABLES Table I. Page The Numbers of East Indian Entering Canada from 1904-1914 ••··••••·•··•·•··•••······•·• 15 II. Regional Origin of East Indian Immigrants.. 30 III. Price of Labour in Hoshiarpur •••••••••••••• 33 . . . . .. . . . . . . . . 37 Price of Labour in Jullundur v. Comparative Wage in the Lumber Industry -v- ••• 116 LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS Page Figure I. Map I Comparative Numbers of Chinese and East Indians Entering Canada Between 1903 and 1910............................ 19 . :·~~Map of Pllll.jab ............................ . 26 -vi- ACKNOWLEDGMENTS In the course of the training and research that went into this study, I acquired numerous debts to individuals and institutions; it is a pleasure to aclmowle~ge them here. My greatest debt of gratitude is to my advisor, Professor Peter Ward, for all manner of things technical an~ information~l, and even more for his example, his extreme generosity, and his liberality in allowing me scope and initiative to be myself. Professors Peter Harnetty and Edgar Wickberg provided the first systematic introduction to Asian and overseas Asian studies. Some ideas explored here were first generated in their graduate courses. Professor Harnetty, in addition, made some valuable suggestions on sources for this study, and I am grateful to him for that as well. Professor Fritz Lehmann showed sympathetic interest in my endeavours and provided the necessary encouragment all along. The staff of the Public Archives of Canada, in Ottawa, United Church Archives in Toronto, Provincial Archives in Victoria and the Special Collections of the University of British Columbia Library were extremely generous with theirtime and resources. I would like to record my sine.ere-: :th_S:nks to them as well. Finally, I hav.edbenefitted from advice, criticism and support of a number of my colleagues. My wife, who pursued graduate studies in the natural sciences on her own, provided me encouragement and support all along. Without her tangible and intangible assistance, the comple~ion of this study would.have been prolonged considerably. -vii- -viiiThe University of British Columbia Graduate and Summer Research Fellowships, John s;Ewart Memorial Travel Grant from the University of Manitoba, John and Annie Southcott Memorial and CF Air Travel scholarships, all contributed funds towards the completion of this study. In expressing my gratitude to them, I absolve these institutions and the above mentioned individuals from any errors of facts or interpretation. I alone assume that responsibility. Introduction The East Indian community in Canada forms a small but interesting part ·o f the !Larger mosaic of Indian settlement · throughout the world: G,u yana, Tri~idad, S~irtam, South. Africa, 1 Mauri.tius, Fiji and countries in Southeast -Asia. Indian emi.:. grat~_9n to and settlement in various . parts of · the world perhaps dated ·back to pre-historic time.a , the ·' pr~:cess taking piace ~· ,-· 2 in several waves. Merchants were followed by Brahminic and Buddhist scholars·, teachers and professionals who served as major instruments for the pr.opagation of . Indian culture. Con~ sequently, znost of the•, Southea~t Asian kingdoms founded . ·' during the first ~fourteen centuriesof the Christian era were ~stablished by ~he Indiahised ~ristocracy or emigrant elite 3 from . India~ La~ge scale emigration of Indians, however, took place in the • la.t ter part of the last century, and .in the first few decades of · the present century at ' a time when European colonial expansion and its attendant in:dustrial and commer. . . ·- cial ventures -crea~ed the need for large and cheap source of . labour. . But th~ Colonial governments and planters often deemed ,, . . .,, .. . . . . . ~ ' . ' ' it · uneconomical, · impolitic ·and -sometimes frankly impossible to draw upon · the native ·popu.lations. Consequently, with the progressive prohibition of the institutiori·of slavery, . India and China became the· major sources of labolir supply. Emigration f'.rom India took: place in three major ways. · - .. The largest of . the, three can '· be · characterised as· indentured -2- migration. Indian migration to Mauritius in 1853, Guyana in 1838, Trinidad in 1845, S9uth Africa in 1860, Surinam in 1873, and Fiji in 1879 fall in this category. The second, more 4 limited type of mi'gration assumed the form of Kangani system. Its operation was confined mostly to Malaya and Ceylon. The third type may be called non-indentured or passenger migration, and Indians who migrated to parts of South and East Africa in 1896 and to North America around the 1900's fall into this category. They went largely as merchants and traders to the former countries and as pioneer labouring class in the case of the latter. The numbers of East Indians emigrating to Canada, and North America generally, were modest in contrast not only· to their numbers in other parts of the British Empire but small also in comparison with those of other Orientals in Canada, namely the Japanese and Chinese. But neither this fact nor the fact of their legal status as British subjects in the Common5 wealth provided the Hindus (as the East Indians were and are still known in Canada) with immunity from constant abuse and vilification by the host society that was determined to remain white. The fear o~ Hindu invasion touched deep, sensitive chords in the social fabric of British Columbia, the Canadian province that had borne the brunt of Oriental immigration since the middle of the nineteenth century. - After 1900, attempts were made to curtail the political rights of East Indians already resident here, while at the same time the -3- ever vigilan~ ~ritish Columbi~ legis~ature pressed the ·nominioh· ~overnment 't o prohibit · altogether all ·East Indian . . .. immigration. Unwanted, ·uneducated ·ana · wi thout any· particular skills, · the East Indians remained on · the ·periphery of -Canadian :soo.t.e:ty"' · : ~ It is a cruel, twist . of fate that defeat, humiliation and other such ·. demonstrations · of human insignificance should consign a gr:oup to oblivion,· but the fact is :t. hat this happens all: to o.-;,oft.~n.The ·,E;:tst Indian community, unlike other immigran.t, ~r av.e n ·'Oriental groups, ha.s oc~upied only a marginal position in scholar1y• 1:Lterature On minorities in• Canada. · . • • . . • . \ , t . • . • 1 Professor Gary ·Hes s' description· of theI:11 in the context of 6 ·. ,Amerio~ society as "Forgo~ten Asian~~ - is apposite for the • . • I ·• . . I • ..·• .· . . ' ' . • . · Canadian' situation as well~ · Canadian accounts about the · \ Oriental diasp_o ra' in British Columbia• have· generally confined 7 themselves to remarks on the _Chineseand. the japanese~ . ",. . /, . . The "Komagata Maru Affair t ... as it . has come ',.•t o ' be' kriown' I is the only relatively well known chapter · in ., the history of . .. .. the East Indi~s i:ri c~~.a , but even that ·1s examined ,mostly . ~rom the _p erspective ·ot: either the host · society or the Indian 8 nationalist·· and ·the Ghadr m~vements. . Adrian Mayer' :s report : .• ·- .. '."... ·.i, . ,· ·,, ·• ' • ,... , • ·,. .., • I · on the · East ·Indian community of Vancouver confines itself to -~. . . .. . . .. . .. :. . . . ' 9 ·• a i•preliminary: d.e 11rteation i of the ·-community ... · .-R ajani Kant ~ . . ' . •' . .. .. ' __ .- . --- •· " . Da~-• book published ~n 1923, though ;till the most important s:i.ngle · work on , the'· Ea~t·_ . Ir.tdians; focuses its attention on the Hindustani settl·ement 'on the . Pacific Coast in a rather general -4- way, and in view of the fact that much new evidence has become available recently, his account is outdated. lO · . tlle other ha~sl, Indian scholars. have also discussed · On . . . .... :-· . . \.: . . the East••-;,.~,:A·India.p.· experi~nce on: the Pacific N· o rthw.es: t · in a ... ; : • • • • •• • • •• • • • ge;1:1:eral , way, · focussing especially on'. ·the · Indian -nationalist ' • • . , •• : _,,. > .,~ . ••• • • • • • , --,:~, : • • movement. · Almost·· invariably~ · the · story of · the East Indians . .. .. ',, ' .; · ;, ·,. . . .,... ., _ of Canada, forn:i,s _a : s·eco!ldary part of ·their accounts for it was . .the .East Indian -population of the United States that was . ... . .. . ~ ' . ' . ' politically the more involved with the Indian revolutionary 11 · mov~ments. · This paper focuses on the East Indians of British . ... ... -· ··.·, Cc;>lumbia, the Canadian province _,:. ', ··, . . . . _ in which most of them resi..... '",• ded, and_ ~tt~mpts ·to .· present ;. a systeIIJ.l:ltic ·description of various aspects of the East Indian comm.u:µity during a decade ..... -~-'-. : ,;:.=6°f:~:i"t:s~· · presenc~) in _Canada. The _'adoption . of this approach . was dictated by . the k~nd · and extent ,of data available and because of the; dearth of descriptive accounts • on the sul;>ject. Beyond mere systematic description, however, this paper is also an exercise in analytical understanding of the process of immigrant adjustment. One of the central concerns of ·this study is the examination of the stru·c tural position of the East Indian community and its lack of ?-ntegration / into and . 12 ·a~ceptance by the host society. To this . end, ·. the inclusion . " of some of the theoretical material, drawn from the,. di sci• 13 plines of soc~ology and·_ ant~ropology was deemed desirable. -5It helps to give this study the kind of thematic unity that might, given tne · nature of· this investigation; . otherwise be difficult to attain. Furthermore, · it ··is useful· ·to· be. aware of the va~ious theories involved·, · for .·such an awareness .e.. nables · one to . .read historical documents with an .-.. : . I eye 'for hist·p rical patterns; thus sharpening one• s historical ·understanding. Moreover,. it is th~ conviction of the writer that, for · those interested in immigratiOn history and . . ' ' . : . . related ·field's, the social sciences offer approaches which . .•.. ·: ..:,. . . · will · yield the most prof~ table results. - Sociological and .. , . .· l . . . . . . theo;r'etical eniph4.sis · notwithstanding·, . however, •it ·is to be insisted that . this . paper remains essentially an exercise in . . . . . social,_ ·history, and d'oes ·not pretend to · be anything else~ • ' • •· ' ' ~: I~ .Th~ acceptance . and integra.tio~ iiff irimiigrahts in:tb' the .. host ·. ~~'~i ~:ty· is ;'la~gefi a f~~tiQn ~-f th·e·· following factors: · . (if the· degree of ·attachme~t the immigrants fe~l to their . society' of origin . ( the inverse · of ·this should be correlated ... . ' , . .. ,... , .:.. . .-with mea~ures of acceptance in~o the host society}; (ii} the op,e riness of the host SQci~ty; (iii) and the similarity ,of cultures of the countryof emigration and the · country of .. 14 inimigrE,3,tion. Within these broad categori·e s, however, a . .., number of specific variables must he · considered. ·Thus the degree · of attachment of the . immigTaI?.t to the country of his .. .... • .. . .. . . .. .• • . . . I . origin must include a · discussion ' o'f the iminigrant•s motives .. . . .. . ·- -.. -· ·-. .. . "" ( . , for migration, his socio-cultural ·and economic background, -6- ·. and the social structure of the migration process itself. The nature of •initial crisis' as S~N·. Einsenstadt pµts it, · is one · of the most cruciaJ; variables in explaining·: the extent 15 of ~he ,;a~-s ~rpti~~ ~· p;~ces_s • Ais'o iinpbrta~~ ~in this regard .: ,::_,:. ,,: is the· nature·· of · insti tuti9nal development of · the · immigrant -!' .. ~ ·.' ,.:;-··· · . . '•· .. . . . community ·-in the new country, new ·'roles perfornred and values . ,, . accepted and the var~ous degrees ·to ·which 'the :commtjnity ' ·.::-···· - ·: participates in and identifies with the new setting. · . -~ - .. . .. The . openness of the ho_s t · society must include a discussion of two distinct ' variaples. One is the ·social . attitudes of the members of the host society and, their image of the immigrants in their midst. The esteem in which- the host . society holds the immigrants, the ·kinds of role-performance it expects of them, and the type of values it ascribes to them will have an important bearing on the process of immigrant . adjustment. The other variable ·is tha~ associated with the formal policy ·of the government of the host society : towards the immigrant group. To some extent, the policy of the government will reflect the attitude of the host society as a whole towards the immigrants. The laws gov~rning the conditions of entry, controls to whi.ch the immigrant group is subjected, privil·eg:e J of free movement within the country occupationally and !_itliiiT such possibly restrictive stipulat:i;ons will influence the process of immigrant adjustment to some degree. -Discussion of these · spe•c ific variables will also -7- illuminate the similarities and differences between the cultures, of the society of·origin-and: the society.of desti~ nation. The·erl,ent of.the similarities and differences. will throw further light·. on· the· process · of immigrant integration. All these :factors are examined· largely within the•_.'.-· 'per~od of the·_first ten years of ;E~~.t Indian presence in . . .. ',: . , . . \ I · Canada~ The ·te~inal. dates 1'904 arid' 1914 were chosen because · the former marked:t:he·beginning of East.Indian immigration ·to Ca.nada~hile.the ·latter ended, for \all ·practical J?urposes, one of· the ~ost .~aran(atlo· · ch?:pters in the· history of the East Indians in ,this' c·ountry.· I~ is no exaggeration to' suggest · that these first ten·years have been the moi:st crucial ones· . I , for the East '·Indian cominuni ty~ and' ·have in large measure . ·- . , . . ~ . determined the nature of·the East Indian-Canadian relations in· the· subsequent. years •. In a sense;. then, th~ period'··under' ' . . ' .. . :- . . . . . . . ' . consid~rat±oh -:is a·· discrete and isolable one for all indepth ·. historical study. Thfs · fact ·M.s had two ·major consequences for the ·structure of this paper. ·On the one hand .it: has· 1,e,d to an·intensive rather than ~-extensive·examination, of the· pro~l~;lll of East Indian integrati'on·and acceptance~ On the· other~ it has compell~d t.he adoption of a thematic as· opposed to a .chronologi9al ·app.roach. Each of the factors mentioned·. above are· examined separp;tely and·· in· detail,· keeping at· . . ..... .... .- ,. .,.. ' · minimum comp;ehensive and integrated anaiysis·in t:tie main . .. . .- . . -~ ,, . -- . . - . . ' ' . ' . . .. ., ' body of the essay. Thus Chapter I will draw attention to -8the socio-economic background of the East Indian immigrants and their motives for migration to Canada. Chapter II will discuss the institutional development of the community in British Columbia during the! first decade of their p:resence here. Chapter III will examine the attitude and response of the host society towards the East Indian immigrants, and Chapter IV will outline the political response and policy of the Dominion as well as the Imperial governments towards the East Indians. A clearer perception of the structural position of the East Indian community in British Columbia and its lack of integration into the host society will then emerge. Finally, a ·brief definition of some concepts used or implied in this pap.e r, is in order. The concept of integration is used in the broadest sense. As used here, it refers to all the transactional processes whereby members of an ethnic group acquire the cultural characteristics of, and gain entrance into the institutional systems of an ethnic group to which they do not belong. The process of integration is essentially a two-way phenomena in which members of each ethnic group seek to acquire . the cultural characteristics of the other. But, in practice, in an established and ethnically stratified society such a:s ;i,that of Canada, the cultural and social institutions of the dominant ethnic groups are the norms to!: whi"ch ethnic minorities have to conform if they are to be integrated. Acculturation, or -9- cultural integration, refers to the process of learning the values, ideas and bel).avioural patterns _of an ethnic group to which one does-not belong. In the Canadian context, once again,· acculturation means imbibing the values, culture, ideas and ·the like, of the dominant ethnic groups,presumably the whiJe Ang~o;_Saxons. Assimilation, or structural integra- . tion, refers ·to the ~oc.ess of penetration by ·members of· a · minority ethnic group,'·:of· the social institutions of the . . . '.. ! '.majority society, in: bdth ·private as well as public life • 16 FOOTNOTES~ INTRODUCTION . l . For a useful summary of the p·o si tion .of . East Indians in these countries, see Chandra Jayawardena, ''Migration and So·c .ial · Cha.Jige: A Survey·:'of- Indian Commu:hiti'es·. Qverseas ;'"· Geof·raphfca.1 Review . · 'LVIII..· · (July · 1968j ·.· 426-49 • Ari.irudh Ctup a,·--. ed., Indians . Abroad: Asia and Africa! Report of · an International, Seminar, Indiei.n· Council for 4 rica (New- · 1 Delhi: · Orient Lc>ngman•s·, · 1971.J · ·· .. ,; ,; • · · ........,1p1-~----------........----' .. . 2 ·.. . ·... .··' . . . ' ·.. , . . ' ' . . See Narendranath Ganguly, [ndians 1.n · the Empire Overseas; · a survet, Charles. Rreer Andrews··Memorial Volume {London: New ·Irtd~a Publishing· ·House~ :1947); c.KondapifIndian ·9Qtµ1.cil. of World Affai;rs,. 1951); F~cfui#an s~, Emi· ration· of Indian Labour ·.18 · '' ,· l · 00 (I>elhi: PeopleTs:· u 1:s :ing ··.• 0t1.se·, , .; · • 3 See . G~ Co~d~s, The Inliianised States of Southeast Asia:: (Honolulu·:. . '•The U:riiversity ot ·· H awaii .Press, 1968.-) , · . • 1 .. . . ·•.· - ,:, 4 · This ·was a system where;py ;gT.Qil:ps;1.of people mostly from · South· I ,P .dia · 1eft under.::ithe supe·rvision of the Kangany or · labourer recruiter to work on· -plantatidris · in IVIal'aya and· Ceylon. The kangany. was / the 'intermediary between:. the · : . labourers and. the plantation : management, The system ' · received its name.: because of· the : important role of. the kanganis. See ·Kernial -Singh -Sandhu, :Indians in Malaya, Some · As ects· of their . Immi ration and . Se.iLtiemen:t: ·.. ··· · · am ri ·ge :, · :rn:versr y · · · ress , . : · · ·9'' O• ~ ·:. ,· . , . ,, , , ' -· Rann . ra .K• . Jain~ ·- South Indians' on-- the · Plantation Frontier · in Malaya (New Haven and tondon:Yal'e ·University'·'Press; 1970), . 31.· ', .· . . . · 5 The Hindu is a person who professes the faith of Hinduism. The ·word does · not denote racial · or ethnic · category as most · North Amari cans · thought, and ,still ·· do. , · 6 ·. Gary R•.Hess,. HThe Forgotten : Asian Ameri·cans: The East Indian •co.~ i ty·• ii:;L the·· :U ni tea Sttjl.t.e ·s," Pacific Historical Review; ·XLIII {November', 1974-/1' ?76-596~ · · ·· 7 ·, .. See T:i.~n-Teng _Cheng, . .Oriental Immi~tion to Canada . · (Sharigai: TKe -Comme:r ci?l Pre:3!=3, . 19~10· W.Pete~ Ward, •~,White ·canada Foreverf ·British Col-$,bi' s ·Response to:·, · 0·~1ent·a 1s·,r-1858.:1914.; if, :unpublished PhD dissertation, · Queen~J.s · · .. Unive3.:si'ty, Kirigs:ton, C>htario, 1972, L :. ,. 1 0 -10- -11' -_ I . 8 · See Eric Wilton Morse, "Some Aspects of Komagata Maru ·A_f,f ai~;" Canadian Historical Association· Repor.t(l936), _ _ ,l00...;109; R.L~Rei:d ·, · "The Inf3i!ie St.ocy_of the 1l{omaga·t ·a Maru'," British Columbia Hist·o rical Quart:rly, V (January, 1941), 1-23. 9 A~ C.Mayer, "Re~ort :pn the East -I~d1an Community in Van~ollver,11 Institute of Social and Economic Research, Univers":f.ty · of British Co:l'l:Uilbia, 1959. ' IO Raj_a ni Kanta ·Das, Hindustani Workers _on the Pacific Coast, -(~erlin: W~de Gru.yter &_Company; 1923.) . . . . 11 See Chapter II ·f or details. 12 The word •community ·must be used in a precise sense here. $ It is used _gere in the s_enee Lawrence Crissman has defined it· as "an area -of common life based · on common ·iniberests which determine a6tivi ty" and which "has ethni:o ity.. as well st -as ···106ality as .i t.s basis. Thus, . the -e.t hni.c community is seen a~ having social, rather than strictly te:rritorial boundaries,. though in the case ' of the East Indians in _ Briti~h Columbia, the two coincided. See Lawrence Crissman, "Segmentary Structure of Overseas Chinese, n lVIan, II, 188. 13 These two dis-c iplines -have dominated immigration studies, an understandat>ike fact given the rec~nt development of the field. Hist_o rians have rtot begun to J,:ook systematically · at this field •. See Rµdolph J ;Ve·col_i , ·0 Eu,-r6pean Americans: From Immigration to Ethnics.,•~- Internati.o nal Migration -Review, · VI, (i972), 403.::.434;--· Robert D.Cress, tiHow Historians have looked [:: at ;Immigrant"s -to.' Uriited States,tt ibid;. -, VII (1972),.· 4;...13. Cross emphasises -interdisciplinary approach. , · 14 This view, .in essence represents ~ synthesis of many theories r.elating to immigrant adjust~ent, more specifically those of S.N .Eisens:tadt, The Absoqtion of Immigrants · - (London :ffilutl"edge . and· Kegan Paul ~9.~A.J ;-H. J .H~·eren:, · -,-_ · · . Transmigratic in Indonesia,f Mapp:);e:~---B-oom'tl967 9t _quoted ,~in Christopher Bayley, -"fmmigran~ _-_ip:i:~ pri ties -in the _-, · _· _ Netherlands;: Int egrEition- and :As~iyu1a~i.o n," T-he \.. Irtt erha tional Journal!· of Migration· 'Review, _-v ·(Spring, 1971)'; ·:_18-33; · · -·_ Hub.er~ _M. Blalock -~r.• ,.. _Toward ~ Theo~-.of Minor±jtGroup' _:• . ,, Relations ~- (New Yo~rk•; : . John Wi+ey; --- 6:7J.; E _- "Bo:aacrc~, "k :,The~ry of -~iddleman Mi-n ori:t i~s," American.Sociological - Re:view ,'·"38 · (October, :,~1973) ·58J.;.594:_ · ,. · :- -- · \.: ~a- 15 - -'-:s~e Eisenstadt, op.cit., ''Introduction." -12- 16 For a use ful analysis of these and other· sociological · concepts especiallf•'iif the Canadian · context, see David R. ·Hughes, Evelyn _Ka,ll_~n:, The Anatomy of Racism : Canadian Dimen~ions ;·(M~ntreal : Harvest House, 1974~ ) ., 1 CHAPTER I THE SOURCES OF EAST INDIAN IMMIGRATION The importance of the relationship between the background of the immigrant, his motives for migration and the nature of the community that he eventually establishes in 1 the country of his destination has long been re.~ ognised. The extent of the similarity of the cultures of the country of emigration and the host country will, for example, exercise a decisive influence over the process of immigrant . adjustment. Similarly, the motive behind migration w:j.11 also . determine in large part the extent to which the immigrant will be willing to participate in the inst±tutional systems of the new country. The degree. of attachment which the immigrant feels towards the country ' of his origin will also be determined, to some extent atleast, by his motive for migration. Clearly then, the motivational structure and background of the immigrant are crucial factors in the process of immigrant integration and acceptance. T~is chapter draws attention to the socio-economic bac~ground of the East Indian immigrants and ·e xamines·: thei'r motive for migration to Canada. Although some information was available on the structural conditions present in th;e areas from which the East Indian@immigrants came, very little material C was found that explained preisely the motive for migration. Consequently, motivation had to be inferred from two sources. One was the social, economic, political and demographic condi- -13- -14ti~ns present in the area of the immigrants• origin and t:fie ·,·other was the way ·in· which the immigrants' community in . . .. India perceived ·mfgration Ets a strategy and solution to their 2 1 p;obl~msj Finally, . the •process . 0£ ~mmigration has· been aha_: lysed within · the push..,;pltll ·frainework·.Motivation in this:··model is seen· in terms or pressure ' from tiie · piace ·6f · origin accompanied by a perce!)tion of opportunity · and prosperity i _n the 3 place of . destina.tion~ The · exact date when the first East Indians reached the shores of North America is · notcertain,but possibiy.they may hi:ive come as ·early · as · the middle ·of the nineteenth c~ntury. · ·~ i, In the United S~a.t'es, two · Ea.st Indians were registered in 4 . 1859, 'five in 1860 and another six in ia61. Those who came ·_at that time, according ·to one ,source, were seamen aboard Br~:tish.and Europ·ean'. ships.Further, · 0 they ·11.ked · the - country, its opportunities ·and its peoples, -~ d they · decided to adopt it as their homeland, settling in various· p~rts·of the coun. .. . . . , . 5 try ... Towards the clos.e ·of-- the . century, a · larger number -o f -~ ,. . . .. . East Indians began coming to North America, as· the ' result of the visit to the United s;tates of India's leading' theologian, Swami Vi vekana:nda, who travel~ed ·_ to the Columbian Exposition . . . . at 'C hicago in 1893 ~However, ·neither of these movements indu_c ed the , later mig~ation of East Indians.Those who came later were not seamen but mostly retired British· soldiers,not ' intellectuals but ·simplepeople of peasant origins from the rur~l areas of the Punjab province. -15Various sources place the first East Indian arrival in 6 Canada in l897 and 1899. On th:is occasion,it is reported, some of the group landed at Victoria and Vancouver and the remainder went to Seattle.Official statistics of East Indian 7 immigration, however, begin in·1904.(See Table I.) TABLE I • • • • • ' • • ' • • ' I t • • • > : THE NUMBERS OF EAST INDIANS filiT:E!RII,'{(l CANADA FROM 1904-1914. Fis6ai·•y~~f.s- ·Aa.ui.t .Maies' - iiiui t F~~!l:~s·-· Ch±ia.·f~~- i'i>t:ii I . •· ·. , .. ,· '\ ... 1904-1905 ·. ,. 36::·· 1905-1906' 377 8 2 387 1906:...1907 .:.2120 2 2 2124 1907-1908. 2620 3 2623 1908-19:09 5 1909-1910 9 1910-1911 4 1911-1912 2 1912-1913 1913-1914 78 - ,4'·, -- ,.,, · .,. i';]5··· · 45 6 . - 10 1 5· 3 1 2 3 5 2 8 88 During the next few years,the. numbers of East-Indians entering Canada increased rapidly~ Befor~ June 19'06, the numbers .· were limited in extent and appeared to demand only the normal attenti'on. of· the· immigration Department and medical authoriti-es, but the sudden increase to more·than two thousand bet- -16- ween July and November 11 caused considerable alarm as to the . effect which the influx of this• class . of · immigrants would· be likely t6 · exerciseupon the existing conditions throughout the . province ill 'the· :matter of general health of the · comrhun:ity and . . . . -· ~. •, . . '. ' the "industrial interests which would ·be affected by the coming 18 ·o f these ·pe~ple.) ·' · Since ,thes:e ·incr~ases took place at a time when antiOriental ' sentiment' in . B~i tish 'Oblumbia . was . especi~lly . rife' .. . they caused ' even greater alarm and ·apprehension iri the minds .· . .. :.: · -· . o'f· . the whites ~-f ,: the province a~d th e t>ominion government • 1 . .. .. -· _Willia.m Lyon Mackenzie~- King;tnen Deputy .Minister of La:bour, -· . . . .. who · had been appointed· to examine · the ·c auses· of the antiOriental riots -- of 1907 ·,was further asked '· to investigate · the '.. . ; causes of Oriental,particulariyindian immigration · to : canada. .- , ,, . . . . . ' King found the distribution of some misleading literature" by ... . ·\ . • . : : I . certain · individua.ls,the activities oflcertain steamship companies . . .. . .. ·.. . -·· ' .. . . . ·: . , . ~nd the exploitative ventures. of some East .Indian immigration agents in British Columbia to be the most important causes of 9 .~hdia_n · ·i ~igr~tion to .Canada. ·-:. · There are a .- number of things that are unclear,or simply ne~lected in King's ' report .but ·which are quit~ important for the ·purposes of discussion in this chapte'r.For instance,the report neglects _to mention the fact that ·the first East Indian imm.i grants came to Canada from Canton,Shangai and· Hong Kong, and: not· ·from the Punjab.The question why East Indians came when they did and not earlier or later receives no attention in the -17in the report either.Furthermore,it mentions only the pull factors which stimulated immigration, neglecting the other ) side of the equation·; the push. factors .An examination of both these factors is· ,central to the· theme of this chapter. A number of reasons help to explain why the first East Indian immigrants came to Canada from southeastern parts of China and Hong'--Kong~Indians had gone there earlier in the employ of·the British as policemen and.soldiers and·as indi10 viduals in the pursuit of weal th. The· structure of the· community in these places had relatively few ties with India i and was_ only marginally integrated·irtto the associational and . -, institutional life of·the host societies.This made the community much more responsive to·the possiblity of migration. Also, the· fact that· the·· East · Indians· lived ·in a cosmopolitan environment that attract·ed people from·, all over the world, people with wham the East Indians could come in contact ·and I learn of oppo:rtunities abroad, was further conducive to this ' . . . . \ . . end~Hence the East Indians responded warmly when news of better. I , . . economic opportunities in Canada reached them,ihdirectly, from the Chinese who had been sending glowing reports home 11 from Canada· directly; from Sikh soldiers who, after ·a:c:d; participating.in the Queen Victoria Jubilee Celebration in 12 London,ha.d ·passed through Canada~ Once it.becomes clear why-Canada's first East Indian immigrants came from parts of China. and Hong Kong,another question arises:why d:i:d immigration take·p1ace when it.did -18and not later or earlier?,;Aiiy response to this must be ·speculative but it may b:e suggested ·that part of the answer ' . .. could be found in certain incidents reiating to the Chinese immigra"t.on which preceded the East Indians.!· arrival in Canada. Chinese, who had been coming to the country since ' 1858, found consistent opposition to their . immigration in late 1870's; after the 1880•s their immigration was discouraged by a system of entry tax. First imposed in 1884, the (fhead· tax was fifty dollars, It was increased to one 13 hundred dollars . in 1900 and five hundred dollars in 1904. .. This large increase in h·e ad tax temporarily curtailed the 14 number of Chinese entering Canada. Consequently, the l ,•. shipping companies began looking for prospective clients in the ·East Indian .community. Since the East Indians in parts of China and Hong Kong had already heard of opport,mi ti.es in Canaqa, they responded warmly to the overtures of the shippiBg cpmpanies. Thus immigration began from the middle. of 1904. :One factor, therefore, :in encouraging -~he migration of East· Indians at this time was the 15 timely availability of transportation.(See Figure I.) After the initial pattern of immigration was set, the response from India to the news of better economic opportunities in Canada was also -very enthusiastic. To some extent this wa~ due to the curtailment -of Indian immigration to Australia. Indians had been going to Australia since about 1837 · and :~-even though a committee in 1841 had rejecte_d the~-- __ contract -system because, in its view, it savoured too much the ~--19- iIGURE I COMPARATIVE NUMBERS OF CHI NESE AND EAST INDIANS ENTERI°NG CANADA BETWEEN 1903-10. ·' 5000 N + ' . ,. HEAD TAX OF $500. KEY E \ CHINESE IMMIGRANTS o o o EAST INDIAN IMMIGRANTS FISCAL YEAR 1903 = APRIL , 190 R ; 4000 I to MARCH 31 , 190 + ' u M B + + I I M ' M I 3000 G R A N T s 2000 ,- .......... .,,, ,.+ I 1000 I I I 0 j· -r 1903 --1- 1907 1908 FISCAL YEARS 1910 -20- 16 perpetuation of slavery, immigration had continued. The passage of the Immigration Act of 1901 and the fifty word dictation test eventually succeeded in stopping Indian immigration to Australia.The- news of the El Dorado in Canada tllu.s came · at · a time · whenother doors ·had just been closed. · This, together wi.t .h the encouraging participation of the shipping compan:i.es, helps to explain,in part atleast, why the immigration ·of the· East Indians· ,to Canada took place in ., the .first ·few ·years of 'the twentieth century.It is now appropriate to look closely at some ··of the factors that King out. . . . . lined as the · ca.uses·of East Indian -immigration to Canada. ' King had noted the importance of the distribution of "glowing accounts · of the opporturti t:i..es of fortune~making in the province of Bri ti$h Colwnbli·a " as one ·of the · baus.e s of · 17 · immigration. Most of these accounts came in the letters. of the relatives and friends who were already in Canada.~These 18 letters probably ·provided the . greatest inducemen:t to· migrate. . . .; . . . Seven · of the fifteen witnesses , brought before Kiri€;'s · commission said that letters · from friends and relatives had been respon··. _ 19 s!bl:~=~fo~ -j;hei·r coming tq ,·C_a nada. Th:eir accounts found .. . · . .· . - ·~. . .. 0 ,•• --: ----: · ,.. . . . . ,- ' . . .. .. . . ·further ~ri-fication in reports of Canadian immigration offi. .. .. .. . .. . . ~ cials.-For example, : immigration agents aboard the · Tarta· r · found . . . ', •·, . , ' that many immigrants' ·"have wrinkled letters, with scrawled· ,,. .. · -·. -- Urdu filling' both pages, tell~n_g of the rich land across the 'T , western water and they · c ling to these talismen one . Hindu .. .. . points his ··letter·. at' · all the Sahibs who visit the waterfront -21shed asking that he be given the job the writer told him 020 Letters were thus a potent source of . awaited him ~ere. information to East Indian migrants. King had al~p emphasised the importance of the "activity of certain steamship agents who werEL desirous of selling transportation in the interests of the companies" in· ind:ucing·East Indian immigration. A witness before the Commission produced a propaganda sheet tha:t the agents of Grand Trunk Pacific had distributed in rural Punjab, and stated that he, like many of his other countrymen, had come to Canada as the result of such propaganda. The sheet, when translated, read as follows: When you get off first at Vancouver, you will be examined by the doctor, and will have to pass the Canadian doctor's examination. When wouarrive at · Vancouver, if you are sick .or are suffering from any ailment, you will not . be allowed·to land, and will be· ··sent· back to· your country. To prevent · this trouble or inconvenience; the company has so·. ·: arranged that. all those who are coming, or'iwish to buy ticket·· in Calcutta, when they get their ticket,· . will be ·e.xamined by· a doctor without, expense. The doctor will· have a look at you, and if the doctor in ··Calcutta should forbid anybody got1.1g, his ticket money will be returned in full. · When men have made ·their arrangements for Hong Kong,· they will have to arrange for·catering and 1 food. 'Every person wh0° lands in Vancouver must have not··1ess than:$10, the equivalent_.of 50 · rupees; and he will.have· to satisfy .the inspector that he is not a beggar. The price of the;ticket is this: From Calcutta to·Hong Kong, oµtside the · fee·d:tng· ·expenses,· 45 rupees; 156 from Hong Kong ·to. Vancouver •. '.21 _ · · " 3 ;_:A similar notice was also distributed by Gillandar, Arbuthnot and Company who. were agents for the c·anadian -22- Pacific Railway. ·That the shippng companies played an important role in inducing the migration of the East Indians to :.C.a nada . there is ··n o doubt, ·but ·whether·· they played ··the dominant role · that King · d·e scribed is somewhat doubtful. · As a writer ~t that>tiIIle not.·~~-, "they ~c~·h e East · Ind~~~\ had all · rec:el:ved· letters from friends and ·relatives here, · and those, not the notices posted in Calcutta 'by the ·Steamship Companies . .. , was [ si~ the induc·ement to come~ There were articles in . P:unJab ·n~wspapers :about ·,British Columbia but these were of · · · 22 @neral character." ,- Finally,King had noted the activity of some East Indians in British Columti:La who were ndesirous of: exploiting their fellow subjects" and"certain industrial concerns which . with the · object of o·btaining a class of unskilled · 1abour at a price below th.e current rate, assisted by a number of natives to leave ·under actual or virtual agreements to work 023 for ·hire:. Wi tne~ses told King that · they had · come 't o Canada because one . Pandit Davichand had sent· them tickets 24 and promised ·. them work here. Davic;tiand allegedly ran an Employment Agency, ' and he claimed that he had been assured •· .. . by some British .Columbian lumber mill owners of employment for about two thgusand East Indians. Hence he openly stated ., that he was negotiating with parties in Indi~ with a view 5 of bringing "these sober and patient" Hindus to Canada.~ -23In 1907, when five East Indians were about to be deported, they testified to Commissioner King that another agent, Fran Singh had compelled one hundred of them to pay five dollars each and another one rupee as well so, that he ·could bribe the Canadian Immigration officials who would.then allow them ! to land. In the event of failure of this attempt, the money 26 was to be refunded. It is possible, as Davichand indicated, that some selfstyled East Indian immigrant agents in British Columbia operated through counterparts in India. There·most of the · immigration agents ·were money lenders. According· to some of the East Indians who had come to Canada, "there are several moneylenders in each of the large centres of India who-act as·immigrationagents for their·own profits. They are good advertisers and tell of the·wealth to be made in British Columbia where wages are high and work is plentiful. In · return for advancing $50 to·their victims, they demand and receive mortagages, ·not alone on·the little plots of their land o,©- the intending.immigrant, but also upon the land of numerous relatives, of friends of men· who have the wealth 1127 fever. These reports are perhaps distorted representatives of· actual cases but the '·fact that the moneylenders were . . taking advantage of the intending migrants is shown :in the testimonies of some of the' immigrants before King's Commi.;: ssion. One witness had borrowed two'hundred rupees at the· rate of fifteen percent per annum, and even mortagaged all his land to ·-_the moneylender. Another claimed that it had. cost him about two hundre_d·and eighty rupees to ·come to Canada; to raise· this amount, .he .had to sell horses, C'.OWS and other Thus -far, only pull factors in East Indian immigration . . . . to Canada:. have. been examined. But this in itself does not tell the whole story.-, For without the operation of 'certain push factors· in India, -these influences would have 1:?een largely ineffective ;There1ffore ·it· is necessary to examine social and.economic conditions present in the various dist.. . ,. . ricts in the Punjab from which most of the early-immigrants came. However, before this can be done, ·a br:1.ef view ofsome aspects of the,Punjabi society should be tak~n as this would p:ut into perspe.ct_ive later discussion of the push factors. Three aspects particularly, geo.;;.poli tic.al, socialstructural and religious,· deserve attention. · · '·The Punjab province :Lies at an angle between two • •· • s:-: .... mountain ranges that divide the Indian subcontinent from the rest of Asia; the :Himalayas on the·11orth and the Sulaimans on the northwest·(see Map I}.-Behind these mountains are the plains of Punjab, _stretching from the ·river Indus in the northern ,.-part to the· Jamuna in. the southwest. Between these I two·great rivers are the rivers Jhelum, Chenab, Beas, and· · Ravi and ' on the banks of these rivers live most of the,;.· · population of the province. Because of its physical location, the Punjab has-, f;i;:om the_ earli~st. days of Iridian- Itisto~yt .:h.Pi:d.. A NINETEENTH CENTURY MAP OF THE PUNJAB SHOWING THE AREAS OF ORIGIN OF THE EAST INDIAN IMMIGRANTS. NOTE: In common, present day English tendering Hosheearpoor (in the map) should be read as Hoshiarpur, Jalindhur as Jullundur, Loodiana as Ludhiana, Ferozpoor as Ferozpur and Amritsir as Amritsar. Source of the map: J.D. Cunningham, History of the Sikhs (London: John Murray, 1849), Map I. 07 69 68 :x: ·=r 30 TOORKISTAN Oozbeks a.nd Toorkmu.ns 34 ,,. AFGHANIS ~andahar SKETCH S/1.ewu'f:1 appro..wnatel_ y THE POLITICAL DIVISIONS I OF TElE PUNJAB &c. "'I O"I after the Treatie s of 31 1846 .Dadw-. 29 29 .&,lat D B E LOTCH 28 t Explanatio1t. oC. the Colouring British Dom.iniona 27 Lahar. a.nd. Jummoo Toomslan 6 0 Tanary- J:lcekaneer t.} Bl= l R ~'-:na.nd.,c...a Chine■e- 28 8 D f Yellow J a p 0 0 t a n a H o Jeyoebneer Ajuu,ero 28 ~ 66 67 T 69 70° 71 ' 72 13 74 75• _A,hlilhal b,.Y Jt>hrt .Jiu.rt~. Al.b«,iarlt> Sfrrid:.. Lmdon.. 11149 . 76 77 78 79 lt._...a~J.& C.Walk.r -27to beariP.the brunt of frontal challenges from people and cultures which came from the northwestern borders on the 30 plains of India. The consequence of these sporadic migrations on the Punjabi mentality has been well summarised by Kushwant Singh. He says that as a res:µlt of these incursions, "the Punjabi developed a frontier consciousness, · looking with apprehension to the mountain passes through.which every . few years came death and destruction. Despite -the richness of the soil and the abundance of the harvests, there was never any prolonged posperity nor even any promise of long life. Chronic turbuLence produced restive temperament." At the same time, "the Punjabi became conscious of being the most important defender 0f India. He developed a patriotism which was at once bitter towards the invader, . but benign, and often contemptuous to his own countrymen, whose fate and fortune depended so much on his courage and 31 fortituae." As a result of the physical :;!:.ocation of the province and historic movements of the people to India, the Punjabis developed a martial tradition, one that was ; recognised by the British as well, for the British Indian Army consisted in large part of Sikh soldiers~ Service in the army .entailed mobility and frequent movements to places out of India, a process that was highly conducive to migration. The social system of the Punjab did not prohibit migration to the extent thatr the soctal :~:syst-em of .1areas -28influenced by Brahminic tradition 4id. Crossing the "Kala .. ·, pan_in (black waters) was regarded · as · full of perii to · the Hind~ soul, . 9Ut that was hot a bi~{ hurdle to the Punjabi. The Brahminical system that · exerci·s ed ·such... an important influence · in other parts· ·of India did not find itself · entirely 9ompatible with the system of production and the social system of the culturally and ethnically diverse people· of the· Punjab. The countless numbers : .of verti· c al · jati grades and sub-grades :did not exi·st . in the · Punjabi society·. Their · consol_idation ·was prevented by- the changing 32 ~eo-political landscape of the ·p~ovin~e. . • . ,I The religi·on ot the Sikhs further prevented the deve- .•. . lopment of a highly . stratifii.'ed society, t;tnd encouraged social mobility and equality among its' believers. It · was, in the words · of Kushwant Singh', "an edifice built as it -· · . . . . . . . . - . ' . 3 were with Hindu bricks and Muslim mortar. ,_- ~_-Sikhism was ·· . " .., ,. ·· • .. •. ·c at once non-Vedic, non-Brahminical an.d protestant in ' . . .. . . •: spirit and behaviour. It was, at the same time, critical of the · rites of Brafuninical Hinduism. Its language of communication was ··not Sanskrit but ,Gurumukhi, a language which th' e co~on . mari 3 4 could qµde~stand and comprehend. ' . - ···;• ' Furthermore, the very formalistic ' structure of Sikhism, especially in contrast to the amorphous nature of Hinduism, reinforced the military tradition of the Sikhs, and further 35 sanctioned the process of social mobility. In short, · in -29terms of their tradition, society and religion, the Sikhs were distinctively dif°fe;rent from other people of India ' who were heavily influenced by Brahminical Hinduism. Moreover, these three factors also sanctioned social mobility among the Sikhs, which was further conducive to Sikh migration abroad. Canada's first East Indian immigrants came from the districts of Hoshiarpur, Jullundur, Ferozpur; Amritsar, Ludhiana and t.o a lesser extent, from 0th.er areas in India. More specifically, most of the first immigrants seem to have . ' 36 come from Hoshiarpur and Jullundur. (See Table II) In this . context it may be_ mentioned that most of England's and Australia's East Indian immigrants in this period ·also came · 37 from these two distric•ts. Since most·of the East Indian immigrants came from Hoshiarpur, this discussion must start with the ' examination of the· socio-economic conditions - in that· district. Excess population was one·of· the most pressing problems in Hoshiarpur in the last few decades of.the nineteenth century. Because about one ·quarter·of the district was hilly,-: supporting a very low population density, most of the population lived i:n_;the lower parts of the district which some•times supported as many as six hundred people per square mile of cul ti vait·ed land.· The census reports of ,.1881 noted that the· "district is populated to nearly the verge·· ·of its -30TABLE II REGIONAL ORIGIN OF EAST INDIAN IMlVIIGRANTS DISTRICTS NUMBERS . 5. PERCENTAGE :Amritsar 10 3.8 Bombay 4.4 .7 Bakanar 2 Balgang 2 .4 ,,' ,;: 4 ·2 ;.4 Ambala· Calcutta 1.9 0 ••" •,'..80 · .14,.4 Faridkot ·6' l.Q Gurdaspur 2 .4 Gullundar 2 .4 Hoshiarpur 190 34.4 ·Jullundur 167 30.4, 1 .2 2 •4 ' Jindiala · · 2 .4 Katla 4 .8 Kanjre 4 .8 Kapurthala 2 .4 Lahore·. 3 .5 Lailpur (Lyallpur?) 7 1.3 Ludhiana 40 7.2 Nabha 2 '• 4 Total 548 .. •Ferozpur Jawhal Jullbenar -31capabilities, and in some areas, beyond its supporting 38 powers." In the same period, the population density of ·the·entire Punjab province was only one hundred and.fifty 39 two •• .By 1904, Hoshiarpur h~d eight hundred' and sixty. seven persons per square mile of cultivated. land.·· It was ·the second most densely populated·district in the Punjab. The same decade (-;il.8'91,;,..1901) saw an· increase in population ·density of· the pro~ince as a whole from one hundred and sixty.eight 40 to one 'hundred and seventy eight·persons per square mile. It is ·evident that Hoshiarpur was a densely populated dis~rict and demographically supportive of immigration. But over- · population-in itself, however important though it is, may ·not _be a _cause.for immigration. Its importan6e must be seen in the context of other factors outlined beiow·. The pressure of population was aggravated by the destruction of large tracts of land in Hoshiarpur clue to the 41 effect . of the choh. · Its; effect(tiwas particularly acute in the case of·this district.since a·large·partof it lay in the hills. The·way in which the choh affected the district is vividly described by the Punjab Gazetteer for the Hoshiarpur district. The ~ . :rises up far. in the hills below the water sheds, leaves them by -~ comparatively narrow Qµtlets and 'rapidly widens .as it makes its way through the · plains villages until it.breaks into a number of branches. For several years before the .£h.2a reaches the vil+age, the land is enriched by ·. deposit of extraordinary fertility, composed partly of q],ayey particles washed down from the hills, but mainly -32the deposits of good land destroyed in villages higher up in the course of the torrents- the action·is wholly detrimental, and-- unless the ,. course · of·· th.e choh .is changed highe:r: .up,~, it maybe taken· 'as ah acc·epted ·fact that · the land will never entirely ,;:r-e·Q over ·its . origirml f ertili.ty.: .' 42 · Between ·+:852 and · ·1 882 the number of acres of land destroyed 43 by ·choh in th,e t ·e hsils ·of Hoshiarpur,Garshankar and Dasuah " " , •h• - • ~ . . v ... ; •• ••- •~• •• • I ,••, 0 , ••-• 4 rose ;· from ·48, 206 •to 80, 057-, an ·increase of sixty six percent~ '• · l\fore land was · laid unproductive as time went on.In 1904, it , · ' ' ' . was ca}culated .that 'from about 1900 ·, to 1903, no l ·ess than 28,420 acres were· reduced ·to sand by the ehoh.Although some v• •• • • •••• land was reclaimed fr,om the uncultivable pOrtions of the - - ..ct1strict; the · choh decimated area still exceeded the reclaim.. . 45 ed ~rea. ., The general )., ~tate of the economy was seriously affected by the effects of ·'the choh as well as the --excess population~ Between 1880 and 1900, the pri·ce of all · the stapler:foods in tl}e a:l.;strict- .wh~~], gram, maize and bajra- rose by more than 4 ;if~; percent -E? : ;h~le the price of labour rose by only 47 thirty onepercent.(See Table· III.) For the province as a whole, cost of ·food staples rose by thirty to ._tilirty five percent and the price of labour rose by twenty tive to thirty 48 pe;cent. Hoshiarpur,· "there · was a large body of people .rri having no land and receiving very little pay for menial work[whfil;_ are __unable to ·support themselves with the amount of food necessary - for the subsistence of themselves and their 49 families." Periodic visits of famines and epidemics -33TABLE rrr · PRICE OF LABOUR IN HOSHIARPUR SKILLED Year ,. UNSKILLED - .. Highest ·· Rs.An.P~ 1880-81 0(,I ·, 6 0 0 3· 0 cf '3 0 0 1 6 · 1885-86 0 8 0 0 3 0 0 --t-5 , ,.Q 0 2 0 1~90-91 0 6 0 0 4 3 0 3 9 0 2 3 1895 ...·96 0 8 0 0 5 0 0 4 0 0 2 6 19qo-01 0 8 0 0 5 0 0 5 o · 0 2 6 . · .· ,, . ·. Lowest Rs.An.P,. ·- ·,. '. •'" ·~ ·.•. .• /· Highest " Rs.An.P. . ·Lowest Rs.An.P • ,;, \" ~-- a. Rs. - rupees; An. - Anna; P.- Baisa. · compounded the problem of the Hoshiarpur peasant. These affected Hoshiarpur intermittently, and. in varying degrees 1 throughout the nineteenth c entu.ry~ Intra-district as well as interdistrict migrat:i.on was an 'i mportant part of the social structure of the •ii:i'..strict. . . ~ Apart from movement· of· people from. the Ji;1;strict due 1;io marriage ·and other traditional ·engagement.a, miich of the migration was of 'a ·pe::nnanent or semi-permanent · nature. The motive behind these types of migration was to relieve pressure. on the . subsistence economy .. of the diStrict. , In .the late 1890' s and the _early ·1900' s twice as many people emi50 grated from Hoshiarpur as those who had immigrated into it. -34Movement of people was, however, not restricted to new settlement are·a s, such as the Canal Colonies which had been I started by the govlrnment in the ·l890's to relieve the press~ 51 ure of population . in some of the districts. A number had -~... also ·moved ·-out of India to · Europe · and ' the Faf East. Statistics regarding the movement of people outside the Province and·outside India are incomplete; but the fact. that people had gone abroad from the ·district is substantiated by the number - of ...people who ·were returningfrom Europe.and the Far . .. .. . 2 East to ·t _h e O.istrict. 5 · ., Migration .out of India was a favoured course of action for many people in the District. In the Garshankar teh:sil of Hoshiarpur, it .was agreed · by most of the residents that migration was most desirable. The emigrant almost always returned with money and as one of the villagers put it, 1153 "instead of 20 p·e,r sons starving 20 had bread. An old peasant who had spent fifteen years in America, told Malcolm Darling that he had encouraged his son to go t~ere. According to him · there was no "annoyance:~• · in America and a man could do as he liked; moreover there was plenty of land and plenty of money in America. But, he said, in the Punjab, land was · insufficient and money was scarce. If you were poor, you could not borrow as no one would loan you money. Another peasant ·said:"only give our village passport to Australia 1154 and America and we will gladly give .up our land here. -35When, as an alternative, e~igration to Canal Colonies was suggested, the ~eaction was negative, the main objection being that much capital was required to buy land there while the security of the crops was not assured and the returns were much poorer. On · the other hand, one emigrant from Australia had returned with about Rs 56,000 and another was credited with bringing back as much as o n e ~ (£7,500). 55 Apart from ~c;q_uirin-g more:_mon~y, the emigrants· also le_a rned new :and modern methods of farming, and on retw:m.ii:tg ~-o the -d-i s,t m·ct theu often sp~nt large sums ·of ·money -in ·c onsolidating holdings and in improving the methods of cultivation~' The emigrant then, was ·not only richer and more sophisticated in social · ways than those who had not gone- abroad, but also ·introduced new agricultura1 · tecliniques that were greatly admired. It seems reasonable to conclude, therefore, that structural conditions present ir:i. Hoshiarpur ·· were ·conducive to •migration. Pressure of population' aggravated by the choh, a subsistence economy not -adequately supportive of the ·large population, and a ' favourable perception· of emigration, seen together in perspective, _all lead to this con·c 1usi6n~ Moreover, it should be eV,ident that the motive behind migra. 't ion w.~s'';,. purely economic, the emigrants hoping to return · to the district after earning enough money to enj0y the fruits .... , of their arduous labours abroad. -36Jullundur, like Hoshiarpur was also a major source of Canada's East Indians,: Internal as well as external migration was a most important part of the social and economic structure of the district. Population pressure on scarce resources was an important factor in the economy and society of , Jullundur as well. The district was a densely populated one. The density of population per total area had increased from five hundred and ninety seven to six hundred and forty _· persons per square mile between 1883 and 1908. The density per cultivated area rose from seven hundred and sixty two per square mile in the early 1880 s to eight hundred and 56 forty two per square mile in 1908. The population density 1 of the district was much higher -than that of the province 57 at large. It must be noted, however, that the increase in population was not uninterrupted. Periodic visits of epidemic diseases such as cholera, plague and fever throughout the second half of the nineteenth century, affected populati,o n 58 growth. But these did not alleviate the existing -population problems of the district as much as they added to its ·, difficulties. · Economically, Jullundur was better off than Hoshiarpur. Famines did not greatly affect the district because of irrigation. The chohs were absent. Jullundur•s merchant-cultivators were, according to Kessinger, "so accustomed to adequate crops even in the worst years, that they sold everythimg not needed for immediat·e consumption. dur.ing famines- to tak.e 1159 advaritage of afflicted areas. This may well have applied -3'!J.to well-to-do merchants and cultivators who were fewer in numbers; for many became victims of difficult conditions in the district~ Thus the Punjab Gazetteer of 1908 no-t ed that . a . . "there is,_considerable portion of the population living from hand to -mouth on daily wages or small dues recieved at each harvest, the poor residents in towns and village menials who are seriously affected by a rise in prices to which their 60 The price of labour scanty income had not been adjusted." in the district was low throughout the nineteenth century. Although there was gradual rise in wages, the increase was 61 not significant.(See .Table Iv.) TABLE IV PRICE OF LABOUR IN JULLUNDUR _- :1:Ths:R:il'led Skilled Year - Highest Rs.An.P. ·Lowest Rs.An.P. Highest -Lowest RsoAn.P • . Rs.An.P. 1870-71 0 6 0 0 4 0 0 2 6· 0 2 0 1875-76 0 6 O 0 5 0 0 3: 0 0 2 0 1880-81 0 5 0 0 2 0 0 2 0 0 1 0 1885-86 O 6 O 0 5 0 0 2 6 0 2 0 1890-91 0 8 0 0 6 0 0 4 0 0 3 0 1895-96 O 8 O 0 6 0 0 4 0 0 3 0 1900-01 0 0 0 5 0 0 3 0 0 2 6 8 ·-38Migration was a strategy that the people of Jullundur, like those of Hoshiarpur,utilised to cope •with the problem of excess pressure on the economic resources of the district. Apart from semi~permaneht and permanent migration to neighbouring districts, a considerable number of people also migrated to ·c ountries outside India.The official documents are . incomplete on .the number o·f · emigrants leaving the district for overseas ·countties, but the . Di'strict Gazetteer of · l883-84 . . ·. _ . . . .. . . . . . . .. noted that 1187 of the emigrants who .had gone to Europe returned to ·the ' district, thereby illustrating the fact that . .. . . · . . . people had gone abroad. .62 As was the case in•· Hoshiarpur,men from · Jullundur also migrated o_ ;n a semi-permanent :b asis · to 63 the C~:nal Colonies· in · the western Punjab. Others .left for -· .. ·... " Australia, returning with .:"substantial · proof · that money 11 64 coul•d ·be made ·there. Family and kinship r6lations were supportive of migration. However, only those property groups (all ·of .which were kinship based) with· sufficient manpower in the village· to operate . ;family holdings·, and assure the continui.ty of the family in ·case the emigrants failed to · return, sent their members abroad. In the rural Punjabi value system, material ·behefits acquired overseas were never sufficient to jeopardize · the continuity of the family in the village.Kessinger found that in Vilyatpur, . a village in Jullundur, the -"motive of the group who send a member overse~s /[families with rapid growth rates], was to .augment the portion of the property group by acquiring land -39st65 in Vilyatpur through resources from abroad. Further, Kessinger discovered that those families that•:s,had engaged in overseas migration ' owned more land throughout the period . •.. ... .. - .. . 1848-i968~~- ·ver,y .often,for the individual, emigration meant numerous sacrifices..;. · separation from · the family,the · community and even the impossibility of producing legitimate heirsbut his major return was· achievement •for hi's family.In· short, . migration in Viiyatpur in the late .nineteenth and early twentieth centuries was a lucrative alternative for increasing family wealth and adjusting the supply of family labour to its · resources. ·. How did people in the district at large view migration? filost of the people ·:We;i:-e : . :favourably: .dis:iro·se-d to :the. ide.a.- · It was reported than less than . five percent of ' the emigrants failed to return, and about · six to seven percent returned empty handed, · but the rest of the returned created<· favourable impression.In the words of one of · the peasants of Jullundur: ... -.<:He [the emigrant:) tells us not .to spend so much · ·. · · o-n marriage, and. is less extravagant himself .He is well behaved and. 'dislikes quarrels but is frequently · ·. forced · into · it by others.He ·often cultivates accord·ing to new meth<;>ds, and · last year, . so it was said, ·· one got Rs.l,500tJout of · 25 . ,acres· which ·he farmed with only the he·l p of a boy. Finally. he · was.ts educa-,, tion ·for girls· as well as boys~ · In atleast three·:cases emigrants_have brought back Australian wives. One marriag~ _ei:'3:ded in separation after a prolonged and bitter -$'t~ife;another in the couple finally • · settling in ·Australia;and the third in the wife .. embracing th~/:.r ,el±.g ion of her husband, who was a Mohammedan, and adopting Indian dr~ss.She was greatly respected, and on her husband• s :dea.t h, her son inherited most of the property. ' 67 Thus, in Jullundur too, social and economic conditions were condu.ci ve to ·migration. The inoti v~i-;:. behind migration of people overseas:z~was purely economic.The money acquired in · the process of sojourning abroad was _to be used:t'orthe expansion and conso·l idation of land· holdings in· the district. It is not necessary to examine in detail socio-economic conditions in Amritsar and Ferozpur from whic~ some of · Canada's East · Indian immigrants came ,;as conditions there were not -· .radically different from those in Hoshiarpur and Jullundur.On the whole, economic conditions in Amritsar and Ferozpur were better than in the first two districts discussed and this may, to some extent, account for the relatively fewer emigrants 68 from these two districts. Notwithstanding this, however, these districts-, too, had suffered from · population pressures and periodic epidemic diseases.Migrationfrom ' these two districts to areas outside the Province and to places · outside 69 India on .a · semi-permanent or permanent pasis was al·so common. Thus far, the process of East Indian immigration to Canada has been analysed in terms of the push-pull framework. It has . been seeri that IJ].ost of the immigrants came from a rur~l, peasant background.Furthermore, it has also beennoted that the motive behind : their migration was economic.The immigrants wanted to earn enough money abroad so that · when they returned to their villages, they could buy · more ,land and consolidate their holdings, and at the same time improve the social and -41economic status 0f their families.It has also become evident that the East Indians came·to Canada as free migrants,·and not · · under any form of c·ontract· or indenture. It is · appropriate to ask at . this point how the abov·e discussion bears on the wider concern of this paper which is the integration of East Indian . immigrants ·i nto ··: ·_: · Canadian society .The role which the various factors played in·determining the process of integra~ tion may become clearer if they are · examined separately. The significanee::m:f the . peasant background may become evident once the conc.e pt of . peasantry· is understo<;>d •.· _A~ L~ Kroeber has defined the peasantry .as "part societies" · and ~ ., ' 7 "part cultures•.·n Rccording to -Robert Redfield;peasants are the bear~rs . of folk traditions' ~l whil:e' a more recent view of E~ic Wolf is that pea$ant ·societies are units integrated 72 into the larger_ state structure. Despite different emphas:e s, all the three ·scholars · pbint to the relative isolation, exploitation and ignorance of the peasantry within the wider structure of human society.The peasants, whose world view is circumscribed by the limits of local "little traditions" pre~ fer the security of these traditions as .a means of avoiding wider society.They adhere ·especially closely to these values if they come into sudden contact with another more urban society where personal ·and particularistic values,characteristic of rural, . peasant ·societies, are generally subordinated 73 to more generalised~bureaucratic ideas. If the behaviour -42and outlooks of the East Indian immigrants are viewed in the light of their peasant background, an important reason would be found as to why the East Indian community remained·an alienated minority and whY,_ it eventually failed to integrate into the host society. In their motivations, most of the East· Indian immigrants 74 were sojourne·rs. As such,· th:ey had no de·sire to participate in the social life of the new country, for that would have involved time, resources• and numerous other sacrifices.--which they could not afford.Moreover.,to them, a symbiotic relationship with;rather ·than social life ..in,the new society was more desirable.In other words, they liked to s~e themselves more as people who performed a function than as people with social· status. In view of this,.fit seems that to a large extent, isolation from the host society must have have been· s:elf imposed. Thus a further reason for the lack of East Indian integration is prpvided. Fihally,not only the peasant background and the sojourner mentality·but the nature of the•m:igration process itself discouraged integration.Unlike the indentured immigrants who had generally volunteere'.¢ as individual'is, and who were treated as such on the voyage, on the plantations and in the supervi- sion of their duties, Canada's passenger migrants had come asa '-~i•):,, 6 ;,,i::,I _,;;._' ;--• ::'. ,;,<_, '.<.· ':, ,.:-,. ,• .· 3 For a g.etailed theo~eti~a~ 'disc~ssion see a useful .. collecti:on of essays . in J .A. Jack~on, ed", Migration . (Cambridge University Press,1969) ·. ·. -· <·. · •· · .,, . : ,_ .. ; ·.. 4 J. C.Misrow, t East Indian I~i ation on the Paci.f ie , Coasti :; (Califo·~ ia.; -' 91 ,, { Repri:p ·e ~ by· R =& -~ Researc?Associates, 1971), 2. · · : · . · · . ., t ...., . 1 5 Kalyan Kumar Banerji, Indian Freedom Movement Revolutionaries in America (Calcutta : J!jnasa, 1969) ,.· 7. ·6· . . . . i-- . . - •'• . . .· :; . . . . .. . See Misrow, op.cit. ;S~-~nandirashekar, "Indian IDlllligration ·in· America, n -Far Eastern Survey, 13 (1944), 138-14e; Gurdial Singh,. -~Ea.st .f.ndia.ns ·in the United States," . S'Ociolo~ and --Soc:i'al Research·; 30 (Sept-em1?erJ 1945 August, ·, , 946-l, 209~216~ ·. -~ · . · · · · · ..· · . .. ·. -.,.·-, ' . ,. 7 Frank Oliver, Minister of Interior, to Governor General, f9 October, 1907, Immigration Branch, Vol. 384 part 2,PAC. 8·r ~-Ibid • .. .:...· lO See Eric Wilton Morse,"Immigration and Status of British East Indians· in Canada: 'A Problem in Imperial Relations," µnp~blished M. A.Thesis, . Que.e n's ·University, Ontario~- 1936, -· Chapter -I~ · 11 Kushwant Singh et, al, , Ghadr ; _I ndia' s First Arme:d -44- -45Revolution · 12 (New Delhi : R. ,& K Publishers, 1966) 1. , Adrian May~r, Report on East Indians, op.cit •• 2 13 Canada Year Book, 40. 14 Karin St-raa ton:; 1 11 The Political ,System of the Vancouver Chinese Co:mmunity: Associations and Leadership in the Earlyl960's," unpublished M.A.thesis, University of British Columbia,-1974 ·, · 30 ff. . . 15 . The number of Chinese entering Canada in these years was derived from Canada Year Book, 1919, 222. The number for < · i East Indians was drawn from Table I, 15. 16 Nar.endranath Ganguly, . Indians in the Empire Overseas (London : The New India Publishing House Ltd., . l947J, 68 • . by 17 King, IDVIethods which .Oriental Laby~er.s have been induced to come to Canada," ·op.cit. · 18 According to rec·ent ·research, ·it seems that :t'relationsinfluence • is the m6st important factor, i'n some cases .an independent factor, ·1n the decision tb •migrate·~· See G. · · · Beija; N.H.Fri.jda, B.P.Hofstead and R;.Wenth.o lt,' Charecteris.: tics·: of Overseas· migrants ( Th·e :Hague, · ··19~:r). ·': · •••= I,'. I .- • • . I •:, . .) •~ •, • , .·; , : l •• ·w. 19 .· i,~'wra~ke~~ie···K iri~-, ··~\Notes and Memoranda, 1887-1921 ~ l tl King Papers, · MG 26;J4 Vol~ ·c38-40JPAC. . - . ·~ : ': ' ''· : .,• '• 20 Vic~oria Daiiy Times, 16 November, 1906. See also the. . Times· of .14 .-Nov.em£,er_;_' J906. ,. 21 W. L._Mackenz·li!.:e King, op.cit. · 22 Victoria :Oa.ja~y: Times, 22 November, 1906. 0M~~~-~ . nabeFra _: Aus ral:ran'::Na. ·i:ona.1···u:n:i:versity:7Press, ,; ·, · ... · '!9,74),--··12. ·, ... • .. · •, ·• · _, ..::, .. , · ,· ... ·,;J-;;,,.·,:'-,;<·-' \::--.<• · · · .. · ; . .... ; ~ 38 Cens1.tS Refort,.1881, quoted in District Gazetteer of H_oshiarpur 1 Lahore : Government Printer, 1883..;.1884)-, .8~ ,·• ..:• .. ,:: ,,. ..:'-~,~~•· .....~{-,,.:.,:. \ .:· . ·•: ,.· ... • ..-.~ ·. ,.•:·,. _, • ;,;!~ .. '• ··•"- . _·•_•,'·•••·,, -\·•···· l•, .,: .•. .• 3g· Tom G.-Kessing~r, Vil . . : Social and · Economi · · . .· Berkely"-:,: . · _ n;vers_ __ _. .. , . ress;r>. · _ ·. . • :See· alsq Punjab ·Gazetteer, Hoshiaz;pur ··D is:7.~·ct; ·1904:.l.~\(·;6'8-. _· 4o Kessinger, .:i_bt_, 29. This book;· though it contains . much useful infom.ation, ·falls ·outside the· period of this ·study.• · It is the··assumption. of the· present writer that .· impressions·, once created., p~r.ticularly in a relatively unchanging peasant so ci:ety do not change rapid:J.y over long 'period ,of time and f0r:ithis reason t_he book probably serves as· an indication ·o·f o'pinion· people held -of the . · returned ·emigrant ·in· the· period under dis·cussion. 54 Ibid. 55 Ibid.181. 566 see .. Pun~ab Gazetteers, Jullundur District, 1883-1884, dhc3.pter 11:; ·ibi& •. , 19¢8, 47.~Th,e pres·sur,e::;in Hoshiarpur was· reli.eved tQ"' some·· extent ·becau.se·-·of· extensive .grazing grounds 'in the· District 'but in Jullundur,· -the~e was n0 such·grazing land. · 57 See Kessinger, Vilyat~ur, op.cit., 86. There is some · discrepency between Kes.singer• s 'figures and those giyen in the District Gazetteers, -'out the ·d:it,fferences are not c' significant. · 8 8 58·.· For . detailsd•see Kessinger, ibid., 5- 9. 59 · Ibid. ,87. ' 60 ·~jab Gazetteers, Jullundur District, 1908, 226. 61 Puntab Gazetteers, Jullundur District, 1904, Part B, Statis ical Table IX.The importance ,of.these low figures become: apparent.: in )·the light . of·. extremely high wages ·which Sikhs ·abroad . were earning. · ' :. -4962 Puniab Gazetteers, Ju.llundur Distr~tt, 1883-84, ··· Statis ical T.ables; 'Migration.• 6 3. Kessinger, Vilyatpur, 91. 64. Ib.l. d • , g· 11) '7"! . . ~. ,!, • . 65 Ibid., 171 66 . Ibid, 172, Table 30. 67 Malcolm .Darling, Rusticus Loguitur, 181. 68 For' detaiis, .s ee the· District Gazetteers of Amritsar · and ·Ferozpur , from 1883.:..84 _to 1911.- . • .. ·.·---• ., ••.•, . \' .. ~. -,:.: ·.· ·- ,.... . . .. . ... :. ' . . - ·- ... . 69 · Th:~:::'. '. pr_o tests against-: 'tederal immigration measures both .,.were to occupy the thoughts and actions of ·canadian East Indians. Leadership '-in · such matters -was to be pro-~ ded . by educated persons. The example of Das had opened -the way for others to follow. Furthermore, the suspicions of sedition:·, and betrayal by the East Indian community··_were:.p:i~nt.e d· ~deepiy • • I• • in the minds of not only the Canadian officials -but the Canadian people also, and -this was -a potent source of -hostility against the community. Subsequent activities of other East Indians only confirmed the Canadians ·in their suspicisions .; and t'fi±· g --: in consequence retarded East Indian acceptance .. ,. into the host society. · Through his de,dication and eloquence,Das had managed to create in Vancouver an active fol-l owing. -one of the most prominent of Das• foLlowers was Guru Datt Kumar, popularly 38 known as G.D.Kumar~ He hadc:arrived in Vancouver on 31 October,1907 and was indicted three times for 'defrauding 39 his countrymen• but for . want of evidence, he was released each time. In the absence of Teja Singh and Taraknath Das, he assumed the leadership of the community. Kumar made periodic visits to Seattle to confer with Das while he was there, indicating a close. work.ing relationship between the two leaders. After a number of these visits which culminated in · a three month stay in Seattle, Kumar returned to Vancouver in November, 1909 and opened the Swadesh Sevak Home at 1632,2nd -63Avenue West, Fairview. The function of the Rome was mostly social and charitable, but politics inevitably crept in also. From the 2nd Avenue home, Kumar also published a monthly paper called the Swadesh Sevak (Servant of the 40 Country.) It was published in Gurumukhi, and hence was primarily ad.d:liTessed to the Sikh community. At first the paper confined its attention to·the grievances of the Sikhs arising out of immigration restrictions, but later it also included critical commentaries on British rule in India. But the Swadesh Sevak ceased publiuation not long after its inception,· owing·primarily to the lack of interest of the community and lack of financial support. It stopped 41 publication in 1911.Kumar, however, was nottto be daunted by the failure of his first endeavour. Taraknath Das, who had left New York for Berkeleyin September, 1910, arrived in Vancouver towards the end of the same year. Both collaborated to establish the India House, modelled on the India House of Loridon. The aim of Das and Kumar was· tQ make the House the base for their political and agitational work and at the same time to · supplement the work of the Gurudwaras by providing shelter to the poor and unemployed segments of the East Inaian community. The venture, however, did not secure the support of Teja Singh, perhaps because it posed threats to his own leadership of the Sikh community. Lacking in support and a 42 regular source of funds, the project collapsed. -64On 4 January, 1910, a noted East Indian activist, Hussain Rahim alias Chagan Khiraj Varma arrived in Vancouver 43 · from Honolulu. He had gone there from Japan. Soon after · his . arrival in Vancouver, Rahim formed the Canada India Supply Company and engaged his politica~·expe~ience gained " in Japan to re-activate radical _politics in the East Indian community. But once again the secret service, · of the Immigration Department was active and in October, 1910, .Rahim 44 was arrested for deportation for being in Canada illegally. After searching through his personai effects, it was found that Rahim had in his possession"note ·books containing information on how to make bombs and numerous addresses of . . ' . . 45 prominent agitators in England, Natal and Paris, .. Later it was also found by the Canadian Immigration authorities that Rahim was in contact with people like Krishnavarma and 46 Madam Cama of G.eneva and that he was rec.e i ving banned 1 newspapers like The Indian Sociologist, Bande Matram and Amrit Bazar Patrika. Rahim, it seems, was one of the most important links between the East Indian community in Vancouver and Indian revofilutionaries in other parts of the world. The protect:i.nn of Rah~m against possible deportation by the Immigration Department was thus in the best interests of the powerful radical group in the East Indian community in British Columbia. Hence the Hindustani Association was formed to -65-. halt the deportation of Rahim. The initial objectives of .· the Association were 1. To defend and help any Hindu who might be so unfortunate as · to fall under the displeasure of the Government or be threatened with deportation. 2. To continue an agitation: against the Canadian Immigration Act as affecting the Hindus and if possible to get the restrictions removed. 3. To purchase a piece of ft.and and erect a building to ,,.. be the headquarters of the Association where: a. a school for the teaching of English to the Hindus should be established. b. that a set of rooms be set aside for the ind:bgent and the sick of the CQmmunity to be housed and attended to by one of their own members. 4. That one of their members be sent to the United States to collect funds for the Association. It was also agreed to appoint G.D.Kumar the secretary and treasure of the Association and Harnam Singh the delegate: 47 to the United States. Soon after its formation, ~he Association sent a letter to Lord Minto, Lord Morley and Sir Wilfred Laurier protesting against ·the ·pending deportation of Rahim. In the letter, the Association claimed that "as British subjects, we demand our inalienable rights to reside more freely in the British Empire {Jin<[] request immediate redress against high-handed, impolitic and Empire- 0 048 breaking _actions _of local authorities. Further investigation occasioned because of. this protest resulted .. . in the Immigration Department's inability to produce enough evidence agra.iri.st Rahim •., Consequently, suits against him were dropped and he was allowed t :o stay in Vancouver. The success of the Association in stopping the ·: deportation of Rahim prompted itsmembers and ·founders to give the organisation a more formal structure and a ·wider,, more permanent base. Passage of restrictive federal immigration measures and the failure of previous East Indian organisations also contributed to this end. In early 1910, the Hindustan Association was formally 49 ~stablished in Vancouver. (See Appendix I for the .:{ ,consti tu:tion of the Associat;i.on). The primary objective of the Association was to nestablish Liberty, Equality and Fraternity of the Hindustani Nation in relations with the rest of the nations of the world." For its· members in Vancouver, .the Association pledged to. provide social services and economic aid. The range of the Association's interests is indicated in the number of Departments that it organised, including Immigration and Emigration; Sanitary Training Bureau; Social Advancement Service; Educational Services Department; Political Relations Department; Trades· _and Commercial Development Service; Justice Department; and the Publications Bureau. The -66aAssociation, in short, had unmistakeable marks of organisational comprehensiveness and sophistication. For a few months after its inception, the Hindustan Association performed valuable intermediary services for the East Indian community, ·s eeking liberalisation of immigration restrictions. In one such petition to the Governor General, the Association noted that even though the East Indians were "not paupers and have independent , means ·. of subsistence," they found themselves . discriminated against,· while the Association p~inted out, the Chi~~se and the Japanese were not. Further, the petition noted that "the present Dominion Immigration Laws are quite ' inconsistent with the Imperial policy · because they discriminate against the people of India," and remarked that nwe strongly protest against it, and demand our rights as British subjects with all the emphasis we can 115 command. For sometime at least, it seemed that the ° Hindustan Association had tti.l:-l y •" imposed some unity on the rapidly diversifying East Indian community, and that it was representing the interests of all the segments of the community. However, in the following year, 1911, that sense of apparent unity fast disappeared. The Sikhs made separate and distinct attempts to reinforce their own group solidarity. On December 15, 1911, the Khalsa Diwan Society was . re-organised and strengthened- to - promote the specific -6751 interests of the Sikh community. The Sikh Temple Committee issued a separate newspaper, Pardeshi Khalsa. It made a separate representation to the Governor General-In~Council regarding the various disabilities under which these 52 "unoffending and harshly treated people" were labouring. Apart from building a new Temple for the Sikh community in Vancouver the Sikhs raised abo~t $10,000 to build three 53 high schools in Doaba, Manjha and Malwa in Punjab. The Sansar noted that two Sikhs had ,c eliected about $23,000 in cash and promisesL for the establi~hment o,f Khalsa High 54 School in Jullundur. While these generous contributions were made towards the promotion of Sikh interests in British Columbia and in India, charitable organisations such as Swadesh Sevak Home and the India House failed due.~ t .o:itiack 55 of financial support from the Eas.t Indian community ._· This seems to indicate that communal interests superseaea · wider concerns for the social and economic betterment of the , entire East Indian community. In the same year, 1911, Hussain Rahim formed the United Lnd:ga,:, League. The League was an "organisation pledged to carry on activities with constitutional means,n and purpowted to be an °instrument,;; ,of social and political 56 regeneration of the Hindustanees." In its declaration of principles, the League emphatically stated that it stood for democratic self government for India, and that it did not believe in any caste, creed or colour that impeded the -68realisation of its ideals.A few days after its inception, the League sent a lengthy petition to the Dominion government drawing its attention to the various restrictions on East Indians in Canada and urging their immediate repeal. The petition noted the "fidelity and heroic loyali ty" -.;,,of the Sikhs to the cause of the British Empire, and reiterated that the official status of the East Indians in Canada was wholly differentiated from that of other Oriental 1157 immigrant~. Therefore, the League argued, the East 0 Indians were justified in demanding preferential treatment. The Minister of Interior in reply wrote that "there is• a very strong feeling amoµg classes wielding considerable political influence in Canada against any relaxation of the restric:t;ions'' and ,that for this reason, "it is not possible 58 to for-see the -ultimate result of your representation." ·T he prol'iferation ·o f a number of East Indian organisations with essentially the same social and political aims betrays a lack of unity, cohesiveness and able leadership in the community. The united front that the community had shown in 1907-08 now seemed to be an illusion. Instead of one acknowledged head of the community, · there were now .several leaders, each wanting to lead the community in his 59 own way. An attempt was made to form a committee consisting of the various East Indian leaders, but the failure to agree on who was to head the committee resulted in an 60 early demise of the venture. As a result of this and -69previous disagreements among the various leaders of the community, many East Indians lost faith in the educated men and in their integrity and ability to lead them. This lack of, confidence __ · in .the mass of illiterate East Indians may, in part, also account for the failure · ~.f yar.=i:,ous organisations and papers. Some of the members of the community charged .that there were < ~ietj:, leaders who were, in fact, supported financially from· contributions made by the people. These leaders were not, it was pointed out, self-sacrificing individuals genuinely interested in the social and economic welfare of the East Indian community. The case of Teja Singh ,. was reportedly the most spectacu1~i. It was rumoured that as far bac~ as 1907, when Teja Singh had first appeared in Vancouver, about sixty or seventy East Indians had given a written undertaking that they would take care of .Teja Singh's financial needs in return for his leadership. By 1912, ~> ·.,-, however, these· East Indians were no longer willing to carry out the conditions of the guarantee. When faced with this . situation, Teja Singh threat·ened to take the matter to the 6 Chief Khalsa Diwan in Amritsar, . India. ill But shortly afterwards, he left Vancouver instead. It should be evident by now that the problem of strong leadership and organisational unity within .the community r~ma~n-~d: unsolved by the beginning,:1 of the second decade of the present century. In the next three years, however, -70various leaders, with differfung political and ideological convictions made attempts to overcome this problem. As a result of these efforts, three factions developed in the community: radicals, moderates, and 'loyalists.• The potential for factionalism had always existed in -the East Indian community. An· intelligence report on Vancouver Ea.'st Indians had earlier estimated that about ten percent of the Ea~t .· Indians were loya.1.-~;to the government, thiry percent act_ively 62 sedi ti.ous and sixty prece.n t were waverers. There had . - ~ . always existed an uneasy and tenous relationship between these factiorir but this was no longer possible. The gradual polarisation of .the relations·:::--:.:~ between the East Indian community and the host society due to the passage of a series of restrictions upon immigration, the search for strong leadership in the community and the arrival of some East Indian revolutionaries · on the .Pacific coast account for thi's. Of the three factions, however, only the radical and the modrerate East Indians had organisational structures · to implement their objectives; the loyalists worked under cover as secret agents of the Immigration Department. Consequently, only the former two shall be discussed here. A fuller discussion of the loyalists will be found in a later chapter. The moderate element, which preferred a more peaceful and constitutional approach to the. solutinn of East Indian -71problems in Canada, was led principally by one man, Dr Sundar Singh. Singh during his early years in Canada had -begun his poli ti·c al career in the radical camp. He was 7 for instance, the founding secretary of the Hindustan Association in 1910. But his enthusiasm for such involvement in radical / politics underwent a sharp change after 1910. This. mayyhave been due to his desire to., provide leadership to the uncommfflied and politically detached segment of the East Indian community, thereby carving out a place for himself. But despite his zeal and enthusiasm, Singh failed in his . endeavours in British Columbia.His newspaper, '~he _:A:cyan :was founded in 1911 and aimed at nmaking the Indians, especially the Sikhs aware of in°g1istices done to their kinsmen in ' ' 6 ' 3 0 Canada; it failed publication a year after it was sta:...ted. Financial support from the community was not forth·,~,ii. coming. The following year, Singh started publishing the Sansar which was directly addre~sed to th·e,_Sikhs but once again, owing to the lack of interest and financial support of the East Indian community, it ceased ·· -- :- '-_ publication 64 soon after its inception. In these newspapers, Singh had attempted to promote the moral, religious, social and political education of the East Indians. At the same time, he had also criticised the activities of the radical members of the community. For this, The Hindustanee,a potent organ of the radical faction, labelled the Sansar •maya·1 • a great -7265 illusion and cheeky beggar. In 1914, it remarked caustically that "our Sansar friends of Victoria were eagerly sought out by our wise and benevolent government of Canada, and along with the reappearance of the Sansar, the Canadian politicians and their flunky press have:hastened to label Dr Sundar Singh as the leader, though he is in fact leading 066 just himself, by himself •••• But both East Indians and whites in British Columbia proved unreceptive to Sundar Singh's ideas. This was the result of the well entrenched position of the radical faction and the pervasiveness of west coast racialism. Singh therefore decided to move to eastern Canada. His choice of eastern Canada was predictable. Much to the dismay and disappointment of British Columbians, eastern Canadiansha.d always shown a somewhat more liberal and tolerant attitude towards the Orientals, and this relatively liberal atmosphere was certainly conducive to the purpose of Sundar Singh. Moreover, the ground was also familiar as Singh had in 1912, addressed the Empire Club of Toronto, putting before it the East Indian case. In his address at that time, he had stressed the virtues of the Sikh 'race' and extolled the uniqueness of their religion, their strictly monogamous matrimonial habits and their impeccable services to the British Empire. Furthermore, he had also appealed to the "good sense and the humanityn .of the -73Canadians, "being firmiy persuaded that if the question is prope:t"ly brought befo·r e right-minded Canadians, 0 0 justice 67 and fair play" wou{d be . given. Shortly after his arrival in Torontoq Sumia;r Singh 68 The membership of the formed the · C~nada . India League. League at,.·the time of its inception was about eighty five, practically all of it drawn from T_oronto ~ A membership fee of one dollar was levied while other revenue came from voluntary subscriptions. Singh's procedure in disseminating his ideas to the Canadian people was "to lecture in public halls and other public .gatherings, thereby interesting the 069 citizens in his . propaganda. Pamphlets were printed and circulated to supplement the . pr9paganda delivered at the meetings. Among its other activities, the League attempted to send Ernest W.Jackson to India to· put before the Indian public t_he plight of their compatriots in Canada. Jackson was, however, · refused a landing permit by the British authorities and was subsequently deported from Hong Kong. At about the same time, James E.Dobb was also sent by the League to Demarara to solicit ·the support and sympathy of the East Indians there for the cause of East Indians in Canada, but that trip,too,was aborted by British interven:.. tion. Apart from this, the League did not do much else. Its effectiveness as a spokesman for the East Indians in -74Canada was limited. As W.D.Scott,the Superintendent of Immigration, remarked, "we know:..of no rights which the League possesses to speak f.pr the East Indian population of either Can~9-a or Ind:i,a.. Located as they are in Toronto, they are geographically little fitted to speak of the conditions of·Easttindians in Canada, practically all of 7 whom reside in British Columbia." 0 The Canada India Committee grew out of the Canada India League.The Committee had two primary aims: a.To promote a wider appreciation of Canada's relation to India. 71 b.To secure its equitable adjustment. It claimed that its motives were based on the fundamental Rights of Man and the principles of Chri'stianity "without 72 regard to political, sectarian or personal· aims." In two important resolutions, the Committee accepted, as involving a high moral obligation, Queen Victoria's pledge to treat British East Indians as equal subjects in the British Empire, and secondly ·it ·registered its oppsi tion to discrimination against "East Indians in C~nada. However, it also insisted that due regard be paid to the economic needs and aspira73 tions of Canadians. The 0ommittee voiced its liberal opinions through a a number of pamphlets. Canada and India- A Journal of Information and Conciliation included articles that were moderate -75in tone and general in approach. The problems of the East Indians in Canada were placed in the context of the problems of the East Indians in the Empire •. In the Hindu Case, the Committee prepared a full and accurate account of ·the East 74 Indian problem in Canada. In 1916, the Committee issued yet another pamphlet, India's Appeal to Canada, in which calls were made to view the problem of East Indians more 75 sympathet:Loally. The general tone of all these publications was much ·more conciliatory than·that of the more radical .. papers such as The Hindustani; The Free Hindustan and the Ghadr, andHas such neither the Committee nor the moderates generally posed serious threat to peace and political stabili ty.:2.ei ther in Canada or India. For this reason and because of its small numbers, the.moderate element was an inconsequential variable in the political calcuiations of the federal government. It was the radicals who posed a problem for Ottawa. In British Columbia,while the moderates organised in Toronto, the radical faction was active and flourishing. A number of events which took place in the community account for this.One of the first of these was the adri\ission of wives of Sikhs in British Columbia. On 21 June,1912, two Sikhs, Bhai Bhag Singh and Priest Balwant Singh returned to Vancouver with their j,v±yes ;.;:·Bhag Singh who had been in Vancouver for more thaµ four years had gone to visit in -76India in 1910, while Balwant Singh had gone there in 1909. Both ~he Sikhs were allowed entry into Canada but their spGuses were not. on the grounds that they did not have previous Canadian residence, they did not come directly from India as the Immigration Act required, and did not have in their possession the stipulated amount of two 76 hundred dollars. Strict observation of the law on the part _of the Immigration Department was strengthened by by the belief that the work of bringing the wives to Canada was the doing of professional agitators who were 77 always trying to embarrass the government. This issue created wide interest in the East Indian community as well as in British Columbia at large. Many·white people also 78 took up cudgels on behalf of the East Indians. The Sikhs, Hindus proper and the ·Muslims all stood united on the matter and petitioned the imperial and dominion governments for the admission of the East Indian wives. After six months of angry ·debate and heated discussion, it was ·_ decided that the two women be allowed to· remain in Canada. The Immigration Department, however, emph°sised· that this was done as an act of· grace and that the action was "-not to be taken as a precedent for any subsequent cases that 1179 may arise. For the radical faction, the admission of the two Sikh wives represented a clear victory. Given one concession, they asked for more. A spate of letters ·'by the East Indians -77asking for further relaxation of immigration restrictions 80 appeared in the Canadian press. A delegation of three East Indians was sent to England to plead for a more liberal and equitable Canadian immigration policy. This was .done because, in the eyes of the East Indian community, Premier Borden · had failed to:::- keep his promise to remedy the 81 prevailing conditions. If 4owever the delegates failed in their mission to England, they were to proceed to India where they would seek the .influence of the Indian National Congress, the Sikh Educational Conference and the ·Indian Muslim League to bring the matter to a satisfactory con. . c 1 usion. 82 In addition to these efforts, an open letter to the British public was sent by the East Indians of North America. They demanded that the rights of East Indians in British Columbia be the same as those enjoyed by other ethnic minorities such as the Germans, Ita.lians, Austriansr; and the Japanese. Furthermore, they demanded that pressure be brought to bear upon the Canad±an government to allow the entry into Canada of the wives and children of the East Indians already resident there, and asking that thos-e.-,i orders -in1i!eouncil discriminating against East Indian immigration 83 be repealed at once. rn British Columbia,warnings were issued regarding the misrepresentation and misunderstanding of the East Indian problem in Canada. G.D.Kumar, -78addressing a joint meeting of the United India League and the -Khalsa Diwan Society remarked that "the Japanese misrepresentation of the Russians had resulted in bloodshed of thousands and the loss of millions of dollars. I draw the same parallel here, where some misguided fools represent the Hindus as immoral,backward and as having no p;power at 84 - all." :Many East Indians of the radical faction also join- ed the Canadian Labour Party and the Industrial Workers of the World. It was feared by some Canadian officials that there were branches of the two organisations in -the East 85 Indian community itself. There is no doubt that the motive behind East Indian involvement in these organisations was not deep ideological committment but a desire to promote group interests. - 4e'tiv.itiesJ of the radd!cal faction in British Columbia were part of the ,wider network of revolutionary movements on the Pacific coast, working simultaneously to overthrow the British in India. Vancouver had initially be.en the centre of th·e revolutionary movement during the first dee- -ade of this· cent~ry. But vigilaht wat·ch and' intervention by the British and Canadian authorities had proved a constant source of irritation and frustration to ::th·e a-c :ti vists ." A.-s a result, · the move,ent had shifted .its base to San Francisco around 1911. The United States offe.r ed a more congenial psychological and political environment in which the Indian -7986 revolutionaries could work. After 1911, one·man, Lala Hardayal, was largely responsible for arousing and sustaining the interests of the East Indians. of North America 87 in revolutionary politics. Like Taraknath Das before him, Hardayal was a political suspect in India, and like Das he, too, took refuge in America. Hardayal .was a native of Delhi. Born in a Brahmin family, he received his early education at St.Stephens College, Delhi and in Lahore where he earned his M-.-.1.A. degree. Thereupon he proceeded to England on a $tate schola:r;sb.p;p-_ior:.. thnee. y,ear,s.,., He ,joined Oxford's St. John College .but after sometime surrendered his· scholarship because "he 088 disapproved of the English system of education in India. He came back to India briefly in 1908 and preached passive resistance in Lahore.A year later, in September 1909, however, he left for Paris at the insistence of Shyamji Krishnavarma to edit Bande Matram, the monthly organ of the Indian Independence ·League. Soon after his arrival in Paris, Hardayal discovered his views to be inc9mpatible with those of Shyamji. "Failing to persuade the latter to adopt viol:ent .me:thods in the furtherance of political ends, .. Hardayal left Paris, "determined to :transfer the centre of 089 his activities in America. In 1911, Hardayal arrived in California and in the same year, he was appointed a lecturer in Sanskrit and Indian Philosophy at Stanford. However, -80after a year's teaching at the university, Hardayal was dismissed from his position for •overplaying' his relationship to Stanford. go Relieved from his contractual commit·ment to the university, Hardayal began epousi~g his radical views in public. But to have his ideas given wider appeal, and to increase his effectiveness, it.was necessary for him to have organisational backing. This·?was provide.d by reviving the dormant structure of the Hindustani Association which· had lapsed since 191:L' This organisation liad been formed largely because of the efforts of G.D.Kumar who had moved to Seattle from Van91 couver towards the end of 1911. Sohan Singh Bhakna was elected president, G.D.Kumar·secretary and Pandit Kanshi Ram 92 treasurer. The aims of-the Association were "receipt of vernacular papers :from India, the importation of- youth from India to America f.or education with a view to devoting their lives :to national .life in India and ~he, holding 01] weekly 1193 meetiggs to discussl,politics. A weekly,The India, was published by the Association through whi_clf.-:notices of political meetings and other.discussions were sent out. But soon lethargy set in, . enthusiasm •. :waned and the organisation .! was on the brink of collapse..Hardayal:)is: timely arrival 94 saved the Association by providing it a philisophical base. At meeting _on 21 April, 1913, Hardayal moved a resolution to reorganise the tottering Association. 'He proposed ,,, -81that it should be called the Hindustani Association of the Pacific Coast, in short the Hindi Pacific Association.The primary objective of the Associati:on was "to end British rule in. India through armed revolution and to sett:,up a ,., republican form -of gover:runent based on liberty and ,·.equality." From.its headquarters in San Francisco, the Associa:tion was to issue a weekly call.ed Ghadr, published in Urdu and Punj_abi. H~rdaya.l emphasised :r:-ight from the beginning that "there will be no place for religious discussion in the party." Moreover, membership in the Association was to be open to all Hindustanis; it was not intended to be a party of the 95 educated elite. The first issue of the Ghadr was published in November 96 Revolutionary mottos.of the Ghadr Party (named for 1£313. paper) were graphically portrayed in the various publications. Many articles arid poems ti.om the Ghadr were reprinted in bo:oklets, five of which became very popular,namely: Ghadr di Gunj (Echoes of Mutiny), Ilan-i-Jang (Declaration of War), Naya Zamana (New Age), ,The Balance Sheet of British Rule in India, and A Few Facts About· ·British Rule in Iridia • . The Ghadr paper and· the party played· a very important · · role in the political and nationalistic education of overseas Indians.Together, th~y "instilled a revolutionary spirit and ·zeal in Indians abroad· and prepared them for ·armed riat6- -· 097 ionalcrevolution for achieving Indian independence. In -8lathe gurudwaras in the United States, Canada, Shangai, Hong Kong and Singapore, "it became customa·ry to recite poems from Ghadr and hold political discussions after evening prayers." .The party managed to change Sikhs from "loyal 98 British subjects to a:r:-de~t revolutionaries." For the politi:eally sensitive East Indian community of British Columbia, the Ghadr party provided much inspiration. The appeal of the party fell on a particularly fertQe soil as it coincided with the Komagata Maru incident. It influenced the party's .· activities and reinforced Indian anti-British sentiment in 99 Canada,the United States, the Punjab and in India as a whole. ' ' ' Despite planning,enthusiasm and zeal, the political movement of the East Indians in British Columbia and . the Pacific coast failed.The feder.al government was ~dam,a.nt about restrictive immigratio~ and British rule in India was well entrenched. In view of this, any movement against both the 0 federal and the Imperial governments was bound to fail. Notwithstanding these difficulties, however, part of the reason for the poor execution of revolutionary plans lay with the radicals themselves. In the first place,they did not have a coherent plan~, of action. On the one hand,East Indians in British Columbia fought legal battles in the ,n courts in Canada, as shall be seen detail later, and on the other tried to aid their compatriots in the United States to drive the British out off India. Fighting two battles on -82two fronts without a well defined programme of action· ledto the eventual defeat of the East Indians. Ideological, social and cultural cleavages within the community further contributed to the eventual defeat of all political move~ ments.Informers within the ~community were always- ready to report to federal authorities any plan of action that the radical faction embarked upon. Cultural distrust was imported from India and penetrated the · inner layers of the East Indian community.For example, in the Ghadr party of the west coast, the Sikhs of Doaba and Malwa regions disso100 ciated from those who came from the Majha ·region. The '.p rominent Indian nationalist leader, Lala Lajpat Rai found hi•s experiences w1 th the East Indian in North America generally 'disappointing,' for he discovered deep-seated cultural prejudices between Bengalis, Marathis, Punjabis and the South 101 Indians. The problem of leadership was a difficult one as well. In Cana_g.a, it was not so acute in the early years, but as the community diversified and factions developad within it, lack of strong leadership became an important problem. People such as Taraknath Das, ·Teja Singh and G.D.Kumar left Vancouver while Sundar:~.Singh defected to eastern Canada, leaving the -.bont.r.ol to Hussain Rahim and a few others of the Sikh Temple. On the wider political front, Hardayal, who had provided the East Indian community with inspiring :> ·_ . Z; leadership, was arrested in California ' on 16 -March,1914 because of his anarchist views and ordered deported •. R~leased on bail, he absconded to Switzerland and did not retuwn to 102 the United States. Towards the .end of his life he 103 became a pacifist. Those foliowing Hardayal lacked his appeal, and in fact perpetuated the · existing social and cult- . 1 ural cleavages in the community. 04 The East Indian community in Canada and the United States was not abl:e to maintain absolute secrecy about its :activities. The role of informers has already been noted. Under pressure from officials in Canada and India, many 105 important lead:e rs informed on their colleagues • Confess- ions and defections apart, however,the secret agents of Canada, the United States and Great Britain were also active. Canada alone had agents in Boston, New York, Kansas City 106 and Seattle. Robert Morss Lovett,the University of Chicago professor wrote in his ·. autobiography ,All Our Years, that he was more .deeply moved "by. the treatment of East Indians in the United States by British agents,acting through our authorities,than any other instance of foreign inter~ 1 ference in our affairs." P7 Finally, rna warm response from India to activities of East Indians on the Pacific coast was not always forthcoming. The appearance of Mahatma Gandhi and his philosophy of nonviolence in South Africa and subsequentt y in India swung -84the mood of many Indians from radical to moderate and constitutional politics. Leaders such as Bal Gangadhar Tilak 108 ,publicly disavowed their previous radical tactics. Lala Lajpat Rai from the Punjab wrote that "we do not want armed resistance ••• We do not want passive resist:ence ~ •• We want to get away from murder and assasination, conflagaration and 0109 terrorism ••• rn. these words he captured the moods of many of his countrymen. At the same time, many Sikhs in British Columbia were also disillusioned by the lack of support from prominent Sild1 .leaders in the Punjab.As Dr Sundar Singh wrote in the Sansar, "though hearing our cries and knowing our troubles,not a single brother from India has come to enquire · about our conditions or to befriend us or to share our troubles; nor do we ever hear of such a person. There is no one here to advocate our cause, and relieve us 11110 of our troubles by .self sacrifice and enlightenment. On the contrary, a powerful body of -p eople in the Punjab were decidedly opposed to the .. political plans of their emigrant compatriots, and in fact aided the government to 111 break up Ghadr revolutionary bands. For a variety of reasons, then, political movements in the East Indian community were frustrat.ed and eventually defeated. However, even though they failed,, they had an important impact upon lhe process of integration ?f the East Indian community into the host society. It is appropriate -85therefore to examine briefly what some of these ef.f'-~.t ;s , were, The political movements increased the group cohesive-· ness of the East Indian community to a considerab~e d~gree. This process was enhanced by the relatively homogeneous background -of the immigrants in terms of th: e ir place , of . . •· origin, religion and social system. The community had a number of institutions that were geared to catering to the needs of its members and which, in doing so, perpetuated its alienation from the Canadian environment. The Khalsa Diwan Society and the various gurudwaras established very early in · the community catered for the spiritual needs. of the majority 0£ the East Indians, the Sikhs. The existence of a number of vernacular newspapers such as the Pardeshi Khalsa, Swadesh Sevak, and Sansar, short lived as they were, also reinforced ethnocentric ··values, while meeting the needs of the majority of the non-English speaking .East Indians. Such ethnic institutions indirectly circumscribed the intellectual horizon the immigrants and discouraged their participationi mn the activities of the host society. The contributions of the various political organisations towards the alienation of the East· Indians from the host society can hardly be over-emphasised. Those moderate organisations _which preferred a more conciliatory approach to the solution of East Indian problems, and which aimed -86to facilitate the process of East Indian integration into the host society were,for reasons outlined above,ineffective. The radical organisations, intensely nationalistic in their outlook ··, took to agi tational politics and called upon the East Indians to sacrifice with "body, mind and soul." A large part of the East Indian population was imbued with patriotic spirit, and responded warmly to the call for active participation in the revolutionary plans of the radicals.- Those who did not, · such as Sundar Singh and the moderates were treated by most of the community as traitors. Thus the nature and values. of the political organisations also encouraged group cohesiveness which in turn retarded the integration of the East Indian immigrants into the host society. Leaders of the various political organisations also played a very important role in retarding integration.They actively attemptedtto maintain and enlarge ·their cl_ientele in the East Indian community. Most of the leaders were prosperous and well educated, and some such as Hardayal, brilliant and dedicated. Almost invariably, theywere extremely nationalistic in their outlook:, and when the illiterate members of the community wavered, the leaders reminded them of their t. .duj;y" to their motherland and exhorted them to 1 work harder.,- A. large segment of the comm.unity was dependent upon the leaders for ., the various intermediary services they -87performed and it therefore followed them even more closely. It may indeed be no exaggeration to state that for a people coming from a tradi~ional, peasant background, the leaders played the most- important,role in the way the East Indians structured and defined their roles in the wider social h2.-? structure of the new country. Since the radical leaders, I who were in the majority, were antagonistic to the policies of Canada, they tended to encourage the alienation of the East Indians from the host society. In conclusion, then, this chapter has drawn attention to the relative institutional completeness of the East Indian community seen in the proliferation of various social, political and religious organisations, and ' articulate leadership. It has als0 attempted to show the importance of this factor to the process of East Indian acceptance and integration into the Canadian society. Important though it is, however, it must be emphasised that the institutional completeness did not create the alienation of the East Indian immigrants. Its importance must be seen in the context of other factors •. Together, this and the previous chapter have largely concentrated on those factors pertaining to the East Indians themselves. The next two chapters will focus on the attitudes and policies of the host society. FOOTNOTES~ CHAPTER II 1 Raymond Breton, "Institutional Completeness of Ethnic Communities and Personal Relations of Immigrants," American Journal of Sociology,70 "(September, 1974), 193. · ·· . . . - :' . ' . -~ . Thi's - term as B·r eton uses· must be seen in a relative sense and not in ·an absolute ene • . Ofcourse there are no ethnic · qolllII!,unities that could perform all of the services . required · by i .t s members, otherwis:e members ·would never make use -of · the ·· institutions of the:, ho.st society. .. . .. -~ ·, : . 3 Breton, op.cit., 196. 4 Adapted from· Breton, 198-200. 5· The terms radical anal moderate are used to emphasis the differen·o e in tacticrs which two segments of East -Indian •-" cpmmunity utilise<;l to, :·achi·e ve their aims. Both' the· moderate ·ae · .wel-I ~, as the_: radical · -E ast Indians wanted . independence· · f9_r Inq.i~ -and ·more equali tarian immigration policies ·:- in Canada, -:but . whereas · ~he - former pref'erred ,a :more •pea:ceful, consj;i tutional means 1;o attain ·their goals /~he latter took · · · .. · · to agitation.,- conspiracr,t a~d violence to achieve :their · objectives~ · ·' · I 6 . \ ' . The Lotus Dagger Society was formed in England in . 1891 by .. Auribindo Ghose, but it did not last long. See N ~N. Bhattacharya, ·"Indian R,evoluti9naries ·Abroad," Journal of · · ·Indian History; · 50 (1972·} , '416. , . . · 1 · .. _ . . . . . . . . . . . . ' . IbicL'shy~mji: °lcrishnavarma, a native of Kathiawar.near . Bombay was one 0·f the first Indian revol~tionaries. .I ~ · · · · t. r 8 _Ibid. .· 9 See Arun Coomer Bose," Indian Nationalist Agitation in · · th~ . United . States and --Oa.nada till the Arrival of :Hardayal," · d.oUrrtal Indian · History ', 43 -' ( 19~5}; ·229. . · ·· .. ' ~J • ' '• ' ·of ll Ibid., 15. 12 Ibid.For a detailed life history of some of the leaders, -88- -89- see Fauja Singh, Eminent Freedom Fighters of Punjab, (Patiala : The Punjab±- JJrµ. ve:r,-sity·, . ,·1972.~) : ,•· '•"'' " .-.,·,~, .. ._,<:-:-:.. ,:·. . .., ,. .. . .. :~- -~~~·:,... ~.·:· ,•~. •. ':; /;,. '" . . :'.:- ' "/-_ . ·, ( .,. •. ::• 13 Bose, "Indi~ Nationalist Agitation," 234. 14 For a history -~ heet o°f Teja Singh, see · 'Report on Hindus• in· G_ove.r_no_r. g_ -~fleral. ~ s -Numbered Files, ,Y.oln. 200t File 332, part 3 (b), ~bl~cc -Archives of Canada·, · Ottawa (PACJ. · · i • · . • • ' . I • 15 Ibid." '~~\i also, Gobind Behari\ Lal,' "Dr. T~raknath Das · ir1 F·r e·e . Indiat'" : Modern Revi'SW, 92 (1952}, 36-38. 16 Governor General's Number ed Files, Vol~ 201, File 332 part 5(b}. Singh ··was _a medical practitioner at Westminister . Hospital,- London. Later he · was ship's medical officE3io~ron · the Mail Line . whi·ch ran· from •Liverpo~l · to Brazil a.pd New York, . and with _.·t he Bri·tish-India S. N. Co. on its run from London to Bombay. . 1 1 I 17 'Memo. on HinduE:Ji! Governor General's Numbered Files, Vol. • ✓- ~' 200 . File 332 part ~ - (a}.. • . 1, .'' . ; . . . . ' ' i 18 : '.. goverriment 9fficial n~ted that the - Committee was •in fact · a,. »labour· _Union, using as a · redezvous,- a Sikh Temple, built ·2½. y_emirs• 'ago · at· ·Fairvi:ew, ·2nd ·A venue, Vancouver. It. w'as·i dec:p:led to pr,0vide :a~sistance· to indigent Hindus so as .- to ; ke'ep /them···off . the.-··~:tt~e~:~_,: to fopn a. labour . union." ibid • .. .... t ~ _· ; . :, -·~ .-- ~- - ·< -. ; ~--~_;: ·_- ; ~- ~~"-_/: ~ f- • ..,, •,'. '. ; , . _-:._ - >;. -~ . - :~:-=-~; .. . .,,. =.: ...... ,· \;. . • 'a, • · ...: • '.1 .; ,,.: . ·- . ~ >J,' • . / • .'i ' ••• 19 W~C:Hopki:nson to W~W.Cory, ·15 April, 1909. Gover,nor ·Gene·r al-ts,·Numbered'·Files·, Vol • . 201, File 332_ part B (a) PAC. ~-... •·.:..::, ., :.:--~---~.. ' ····-· -- · . . 20 .Ibid • . ' 21 .se~ Chapter IV for a detailed study. 22 ·. : ... ·:_ · · See footnote 17. . · 23 .·s~·e·+w:c:Hopkinson to J.B~Harkin, 4 January, 19I!>9. ·. ·· ·· · ... . . . · Gov:ernor': General'' s ·Numbered Fi-les,'-- Val • . 200, File 332 part · : 3 (a)~ ·':PAC. · -,- ··' · ·· · " ·· · · 24 'A Note on the Revolutionary Movement in Canada,' · Immigration · Branch; V6t~ ·386',part · ll PAC. The association was · formed ' in'..· late · 1906 ·.or -early ·l.907. -90'25 See Artm Coomer Bose, "Indian Nationalist Agitation ···· in the United-States, 0 -235~--26 - ·· - ._. · ... - . Evidence of this·was-'round in intelligence reports by :Hppkinsonand-his.ihformers.·see also,"Political Agitation Atno:rig ::the ·Hindus on ·the_ :l'acific Coast•- froin-. 1912 to ).:915, IH> · (19+4)/··~ove~or,- G~n~ra.1:• s·.NUJn1).e+9e9- •'Files, · Vol.· 205 ~ File 332-·part''.12 ('a;-); _..Note· ·c:ni"tn:·e Hiridu:Revolutionary Movement , :i,n •;·bservers contended that Indian · civilization had remained static (with the possible ® -104- exception in Indian Literature) for almost three thousand years. To a nineteenth century western mind with its fixa~:' tion on progress, such a phenomenon was .· extremely difficult to comprehend. Of all the aspects of Indian civilization, caste; religion and the status of women elicited -the most critical commentary. Caste, as an institution apparently sanctioned by religion, was repungnant ·and unacceptable to most wes·terners. · It stratified social life and its ... rigidity retarted abition for the individual who was thought to be unalterably. :fixed within his stratum. As .. . , one commentator noted, caste was a ·"complete inversion of all natural and moral laws" and it was held largely 19 responsible for the moribund state of India~ The ~nevitable result, surmised many westerners, was intellectual, cultural and physical deterioration of the Indian. · Unfavoura·- . -·· ble, deprecatory comments were also frequently made with · -respect to Hindu.ism and the status of Indian women. . . . . . 20 : Brief though these· notes hav.e been, -·-they nevertheless are indicative of the low regard in which the west held India and the Indians in the latter part · of· the nineteenth century. Furthermore·, British Columbians seem to' have · subscribed to these western perceptions. This, however, is not surprising. Most whites in British· Columb1a·derived their ancestory from England, and when they came to Canada, they brought along with them their ancestor~• baggage of cultural stereotypes. They were continually reinforced by -105continued contact with Great Britain. From across the American border, popular ideas expressed in school text books, newspapers and other forms of communication flowed much more easily, and undoubtedly the India:m.::1.stereotypes ,i '~ of the Americans also influenced Canadian attitudes. Thus, echoing the voice of the whites in the United. States and England, a Qanadian writer noted that India is a lamd under a curse, or rather under thre:e fold · curse, that of caste system,' of gaunt eyed faminiae, and a ·poison breathing plague. MillJons· ··of people perish in the prolo1+ged agonies of starvation during famines and they· have no power.to resist the ·· epidemics which sweep· over the land~ Of sanitation· · .they ·have no.t the faintest idea; in···cosequence the water supply is_ polluted; the very air is filled with infected dust .~ . . 21 · ~· 1 The Victoria Trades and Labour Council was a persistent 'critic of East Indian, and of Oriental immigration generally. In one of its "persistent and unequivocal" petitions to the provincial government on the matter of·the East Indian immigration, it·pointed out, 0 that the country from which they came has ~ong been recognised as a hot bed of the most virulent diseases, such as bubonic plague, small pox, Asiatic cholera and the worst forms of vene~l diseases, and however, strict the medical examinations at our ports maybe, there is a constant danger that these people being 1122 the transmissmon of diseases to our people. This was a ., , familiar theme in western accounts of India. Another theme constantly harped upon by many British Columbiatj.s was·f~!bhe excessive population and poverty of -106of India from which East Indian immigrants in Canada tried to ·escape. It is doubtfu.l·if ' those who talked about this issue ·had firsthand knowledge of the social and -economic c,ondi-: tions in ·India; · most likely they derived their knowledge from accounts in the English and the American press. But -whatever their source, ·they· believed that if once the. East Indians were allowed entry, there would be . no halt to · greater .numbers whe would flock in later. A British Columbia Senator refle·c ted the . thoughts of many when he told the Upper House that ·'We know there · is nothing to prevent two million . people a year coming in from that part of the country · where ,plague a.nd pestilence prevail, and w:er:eeable bodie.d men receive about ten cents a day when they get work, but- there is not always work for them to do. If they are not at once stopped from coming to our · shores, in time they will come ·i~ like a flock of locusts and destroy the country. · :23 Fred Lockley, in a widely publicised article, chose to express British Columbia's fear of "Hindu Invasion" in a more sensationa~ way: Have you ever watched a band of sheep in a rocky~ :-: and barren field, pastured till the grass has been eaten down to the roots? You will see the sheep gather near the fence and look longingly at the luxuriant bunch of grass in the· next field, while they march back and forth along the fence line in the hppe of finding a chance to get into the grassy pasture • • • • · · India, densely-populated, plague-smitten, famine stricken, is that overcrowde~ and over pastured field; British Columbia and · the -United States · are ·th~ green fields · toward whi-c h the ever hung:ry: hordes of India are eagerly looking. They ·have found· the gap and are pouring in. Will the ·rest follow their · leaders i .n an· overwhelming flood? Will India, with her 296,000,000 -population; of whom ,more - than -107- 100,000,00~ a~e al~ays on the verg~ of starvation, become an immigration mena:Qe? -•••• . 4 . · West coast• s fear.s of being floe.ded'lr.~py ·a "brown tide" and "Hindu invasion" were perhaps not as great as its fear of the nyellow peril," but even so, they were continually expressed during the period under discussion. Western and American fbmages of Indians as degenera,e, slavish people · were also echoed in Brittsh Columbia. The common belief here too was that it was hopeless to expect the Indian., , to adapt their habits and outlooks to 2 the Canadian environment;? for he was "totally opposed" ~ .·to the social and economic institutions of the western society. According to his critics in British Columbia, the East 26 Indian was "dirty, ignorant and most immora1n and although he was an "excellent creature in his own country," in Canada he would put _tci) ,_; .b lush vilest character of the 27 slums ... J.B.Williams, a reputed provincial journalist, 11 claimed that "the class of Hindus that have invaded British Columbia are commonly known as Sikhs; meaning the lower class, entirely dependent upon their physical capabilities • • I " • - those who have no set aim in life. They are the coolies 028 -of Calcu~ta. , ?lil{iams .l ike his . counterparts in America and Great Britain was extremely prejudiced against the Indians, and not _surpri_s ingly, his descriptions qf- them were gen·e·rally inaccurate. ·But this was no deter~.ent to ' ·- . the popular acceptance of his accounts in British Columbia. -108Thus far, one source of the negative stereotypes of the East Indians has been examined. An attempt has been' made to demonstrate the fact that Canadian perception of the East Indian immigrants and their country-of-origin was derived, in part, from prevailing western conceptions of India and Indians in the nineteenth century. This means that to some extent, an unfavourable image of the East Indian8immigrant was already fairly well entrenched in British Columbia even before he made his appearance. The second, and perhaps more potent sour.ce of the Canadian stereotypes waOs'~the:.:eoli.J:tact between the immigrants·and the host society. But this is not to say that the white images of the East Indian immigrants were based on accurate perceptions.,Far from it; in fact prominent stereotypes were kept alive more through contact with.prevailing ideas and images derived from western sources than with any real, personal contact with the immigrants and their community. ·~hose images based on fact were commonly selected and· exaggerated to conform to th¢se stereotypes. In the process 29 they neglected other factms of the East Indian character. What,then,was the content of the British Columbian stereotypes derived from •experience' and contact with the East Indians? What particular features of the immigrants and their community were singletl out for close attention. One popular belief was"that the East·Indian immigrants were unclean and uncouth. Wherever they were present, on -109- si.de wall{:s, streets and ferries, they had12::the very unpleasant habits of crowdin¢f talking very loudly, spitting clearing their noses and throats in public, and refusing to meve when women and children passed by. Instead, the 30 story went, they stared at them rather rudely. It was also :be:trueved that the Sikhs particularly were veJ'Y~-'fond · of alcohol, especially gin, which they fondly called •·kadwa pani' or bitter water. They often got hopelessly drunk and became objectionable sights on the streets. Such sights became even more unpleasant because of the type of dress that the East Indians wore. Often the Sikhs, to show that they had been loyal subjects of the British Empire, paraded themselves in dirty, old,ragged military dress, scarlet tunics of Sikh line regiments, braideiti>edecked 31 cavalary tunics and wr~nltled khaki dress. Most objectionable of all was Sikh headgear, the turban, often in gaudy folds of red, blue, green, yellow and other bright colours. To Sikh, it was his •rasma rivaz' or custom, but to the · whi tesi.-:, it was what "r~.d tag is .to · ~ 32 infuriated bull. n Further, many whites thought the use of turban to be extremely unhygenic and the fact that the Sikhs wo~e it . .. . ··- .... with pr.ide confirmed whites in their belief that East Indians were indeed most unclean. Caste was another ins·ti tution that' many· white British Columbians found 33 totally repugnant. But caste as such ms doctrinally unacceptable to the Sikhs, and if caste restrictions were -110- observed in British Columbia, they must have been confined to a very insignificant minority of the Hindus in the East Indian community. Perhaps the white observers mistook the practice of subtle discrimination in food habits of the Sikhs, especially in the consumption of meat, fort,:lbhe practice of caste, but such a misconception was no deterrent to the wide acceptance of the image. A belief associated with the previous one was that most East Indian immigrants thrived in overcrowded housing. East Indian housing was~described as Vancouver' s Black 34 Hole of Calcutta,'"1 Libby's prison, or Dante's Inferno. 11 ' In one case,•a newspaper reported, seventy five East Indians lived in a house which was suited for six people, "allowing the widest st::vetch of the law regarding the amount of cubic air space that.should be allowed for each / 35 individual ... In another, similar incident, a journalist noted that seventy East Indians were living in a house which at one tiiime occupied by a fami:J.y:1_ of two parents and twelve.children. "Here like sardines in a box these desti tudes are co·mped and· accasionally relieve their . monotony by sanguinary contests in which blood ~lows like 1136 water. Facts were blurred with rumour and fantasy. But the whites of British Columbia were quick to conclude that overcrowded conditions were further evidence of East Indian uncleanliness and frugality. What the whites saw had some basis in fact. The East Indians were generally -111- frugal in their habits for they wanted to earn as much money as possible in order that they could spend their last days in India in relative material comfort. But to · some exten1t, the East Indians lived in crowded houses out of no choice of their own. The white landlords refused to rent houses to them. In some cases the East Indians were forcibly 37 ejected from houses they had already rented. In one case · atleast, some s1;aunch white exclusionists, expressing their ·~'.·:· ·:_;;\unwill1.ngness to accept East. Indian presence in their midst, burned down a house where a few of the immigrants 38 were · living. Discriminations •. against the East Indian immigratns in matters of housing were not isolated incidents, but a general feature of life in British Colilmbia. Thus the image of overcrowded housing am~ng the East Indians must be seen in the light of their·motives as well as the respon~es ·of members of ··the host society. · _ Many white British Columbia.ns be~ieved firmly that the living conditions as well as the personal hygiene of the East Indians threatened the outbreak of many diseases. This belief was not confined to the East Indians alone, for many whites believed that Chinese .living conditions 39 However, the dang_e r' from also threatened pestilence. the East Indian quarter was graver. Vancouver's Sanitary Inspector Morrison noted that -: "From a sanitary point of view I consider them l]:ast Indian.ii worse than the lowest class of Chinamen. It is impossitble to conceive a more -112- filthy condition than the manner in which t ·hese men live.ff. 40 in any old dilapidated building they can manage to rent." In Victoria, Alderman Morseley declared he had been informed by · a promin!;Ult doctor of Vancouver that "a great deal of the trouble from spinal memingitis and infantile paralysis was due to insani tan [fil:,£] conditions prevailing 41 among the Hindus in that city.» Such statements were widely publicised in the press. The prevailing image of Indianas a hotbed of epidemic diseases offered fur:th·er supporting testimony. It is true that a small number of the first East Indian immigrants to Canada did suffer from some ·diseases such as trachoma, but most of them were 42 carefully screened at the port of entry~ It is also true that the first East Indians lived in areas that were not very sanitary, and in houses that were hastily improvised, but whether they threatened the health and welfare of the wide·r society to the extent the whites, ·alleged is diffi. cult to measure in view of dearth of relevant material. The limited evidence which exist '. :, seem to contradict _ prevailing beliefs. Dr. E.H.Lawson of British Columbia, ·the sur.gelbn in charge .on the Canadian Pacific Railway ships Monteagle lind Tartar ( aboard which a number of East Indians came to Canada), said: It was my daty to make a thourough physical examination of each immigrant at Hong Kong, and although at first I was -strongly prejudiced against them, I lost this prejudice, after _th_o~S8.!1:_<1-~ J~ad passed through my hands and I had -113compared them with white steerage passengers I had seen_on the Atlantic. I refer in particular ·to the Sikhs · and I am not exaggerating' in the least when I say that they were one hundre~ percent cleaner in their habits and freer from ,heose than the European steerage·passengers I had come in contact with, ·My recent· 'impressions as a surgeon in mining camp among thousands .of white men; where immorality is rife, has increased my · respect for· the Sikhs. 43 . . · A further assumption in British Columbia during the first two decades of this century was that most East Indian immigsants were be·ggars, or potential beggars. It was widely rumoured that on a number of occasions,: they begged from door to door asking for jobs such as carryiµg wood. and water. _Begging for milk and money was· reported· to be 44 very common as wel1. It was widely believed that when they failed to get what they wanted, the Sikhs attempted to . . . 45 molest white women. -In one case, it was reported, Sikhs ' .. . actually committed crimes which should "make the blood of 46 every citizen boil." Once· again,what the whites believed had some Basts in fact. Isolated incidents of begging by the East Indians did occur. Refused housing, and in some instances food and fuel, by part· of the~ white commiin±tyc, ·and . . ~ lacking in supportive mechanisms in their nascent community, East Indians had little alternative but to rely on help from the outside community. However, once fIBTUdwaras and other charitable societies were established in the community, 47 begging was effectively ended. Moreover, the need of charity also declined as later arrivals brought meney to -11448 see them throµgh for some months in Canada. But the image of the Eas.t Indian b~ggar often persisted despite evidence · to the contrary, As far as East .Indian aggression and violence was concerned, they , too were exaggerated. The Sikhs especially were very sensitive about rude remarks.whites -made about their religion · and social customs, and when such 49 incidents aros.e ; · they retaliated aggresively. But such occassions were rare. As to. the allegations that Sikhs mmlested or frightened white ~omen, -little .hard evidence was 50 ever presented. It was ·commonly accepted in British Columbia that the Orientals posed severe threats to white labourers.In the case of _· the East Indians, thre·e factors were singled out for attention. Most whites believed that, compared with the Chinese and the Japanese, East Indians were most selective in the type of occupation they chose. Whereas the former two were prepared to · do domestic, agricultural and labouring jobs, the East Indians, it was believed, generally shunned them. Alexender S.Monroe, Dominion Immigration Agent at Vanc0uver told the Superintendent of Immigration j;hat: nAs compet·i:tors.-: of white ·1abour they are' the most dangerous we have, as they practically engage in the same class of work as the white labourers do; viz: mill work and street work. They will not engage in domestic labour, gardening or agricultural work that whitemen leave untouched, but seek the same lines of employment usually followed by the -1151151 white laboureies. Another impression commonly held was that the East Indians, like all other Oriental groups, were ' ' extremeiliy frugal in· their· habits and sent all their savings to _India. Little, if any at all, was ever invested mn British Columbia. They were, in a sense, leeches· on the 52 pioneer industrial economy. of the province. A third view . was that the East Indians, like other Oriental groups, were driving the whites out of jobs · by working for much lower wages than the latter could ever accept. A provincial journalist in his investigation on the '11Hindu invasion' reported what he thought represented a working man's view: "British Columbia is a whiteman•s country. The coming of the hordes of Asiatic labourers will keep wages down and crowd the whitemen to the wall; since the whitemsn cannot, nor will come down to the Asiatic labourers low standard of living. Forty of fifty of them will live in a house ·that rents for $18 to $20 a month. · Fortu,;, ·or fifty white labourers mean a score of families, eaeh one living.in its own house and a score of the men to stay at barding houses or restaurants. These Hindus pay less than a dollar a month a piece for rent, and they board themselves, so you see a white man would starve at wages which- mean weal th to a . 053 Hindu. The Victoria Trades and Labour Council affirmed Lockley's findings, and stated that the employment of 054 Orientals and whites, "side by side was nu~ of.':qu.estion. Was there any substance to the fears of the white -116working men? How accurate were such fears? Unfortunately, the dearth of concrete economic evidence prevents a comprehensive analysis of how well founded the fears of whites were, but whatever evidence that does exist once again -points to the fact that white fears were quite exaggerated. The .impression that the East Indians were mo~e selective in their occupations than the Chinese or the Japanese was · perhaps tru.e, and it was also tru.e that, in certain industries, they were earning higher wages than the 55 Chinese and the Japanese. (See Table V.) But · i 't is premature TABLE V COMPARATIVE WAGE IN THE LUMBER INDUSTRY, 192li (In cents) CHINESE· LOCATION JAPANESE .· CANADIANS HINDUS··_·f.ANJ:S .. Number of employees on which calculations are based. · • . ' .. ' ' ~ ~ 90 . .. . : .. . - ·-· 31 59 90 Vancouver, B. C••••••••• . . ' . Coombs, B.C • . • • • • • • • • • • 20-22 20-,27 30-80 26-35 20-30 25-40 25-80 27½-50 Ladysmith, B.C. • • • • • • • 25-35 30-40 50-85 30-40 Duncan., B.C. • • • • • • • • • • 30-40 40- 6 01J( 40-lOO 40-75 · 20-60 30-100 · · 26-75 , ' ' ' . Variation ••••••••••••• i From the data suppiied by the Hindustani employers. .;.111- to proceed from this fact to the conclusion that the East Indian workers were undermining the economic position of the white workers, In the first place, many white employers such as lumber manufacturers preferred white workers over the East Indians even at higher prices. But, as one of the most successful lumber manufacturers on the Pacific coast 56 put it, ii"the whites are nhard t .o find." Consequently, the East Indians had to be hired. And secondly, the numt,er of East Indian8workers in British Columbia was hardly ever large enough to drive whites out of jobs and reduce their standard of living as many of them claimed. The belief~.· that the East Indians were a drain on the economy of the province was·' simi;J,;a~lyr-~xagg·e_rated. Of course ., ~ I :_.. . . • : • the · predominan:tly male population of the East Indian community lived frugally, saving as much as it could. The immigraftt.s @ad little desire for permanent residence in the country and in consequence they sent their surplus earnings to India. But the amoup.t sent could riot - have been substantial enough to warrant a crisis, as many whites believed, if the small population and relatively small wages received by the East Indians are borne in mind. One scholar has estimated that on the Pacific Coast in 1908, the average income of fifty three Hindustanis amounted to a meagre sum o·f $451. 00 for an average of 19.2 months in the year.By 1921, that 57 amount had increased to ·$900.00. It may have been substantial by East Indian standards, but the ..same cannot -118be said if it is viewed from the standards of the host society. In any case, the savings that East Indians sent to India hardly constituted a crisis of the proportion that many whites believed. Moreover, Europeans were also sending 58 substantial amounts of money -to .their mother countries. But only the Orientals w_e re singled out for attention, pointing onae again to the selective nature of white prejudice. , In early twentieth century British Columbia, many _ whites believed cthat · the East Indians were the (-l"ea.st ·_desirable 59 of all the Orientalt1groups. This sentiment was prevaill¢nt ·. 6 6 on the Pac~fic coast gen~r~lly~ , As late as 1920, a Canadian official noted, "I think it is the general consensus of · o~inion that lf>f three nationalities, the East Indians, although British subjects, are the least appreciated on the Pacific coast. To him is not granted the same regard as to the Chinese and Japanese. Just how far this may be attributed to his social and religious customs I cannot say but the fact remains that the East Indian seems less adaptable to our 061 · climate~ economic and social life. John, as the Chinese was pa:bernalistically labelled, apparently accepted his lowly position with little overt resentment, and was considered extremely faithful and honest. Furthermore, it was commonly accepted that British Columbia would "have difficulty getting without them." The Japanese it · -~ a:s.-- · cra:imed,- ·~dopted . ' western dress and customs much more readily and quickly than -119- both the Chinese and the East Indians. He.was, like the East Indian very competitive, but at the ' :'_ same time, honest 62 and fair. On the other hand, many Canadians thought that East Indians were the least amenable to social and cultural change. They were violent; and in business deceitful and 63 "looked upon wi.t:P.i:sils:pic;Lon by most people. n The Eas.t Indians, more than the Chinese and the Japanese, raised their own voices against retrictive immigrf.!tion policies and also ' ' managed to secure some white support as well. Furllermore, they ·made little . secret of their political and ideological convictions, and epoused their anti-British and antiCanadian views in public meetings, newspapers, almost any place where opinions were exchanged. This may have been a cause of some resentm~ti.t among the white people of British Columbia. It may also be pointed out that, unlike the : Chinese community, which was a more closed one in terms of its social 64 systems and spatial location, the East Indian community possessed a relatively open social structure, inviting '~ greater scrutiny from ~he host s0ciety. This, too, may have pronded some grounds for the less favourable attitudes the whites had of East Indians. ,_·Whatever the reasons,marty whites were deeply convinced in their minds that the East Indian immigrants were the least desirable of all the Asians in the province. Finally, one of the most pervasive myths, in a sense subsuming all the others, was that the East Indian could -120- never be assimilated into:the Canadian society. What the process of assimilation entailed and what conditions were to be met before it could take place was never fully understood by the whites of British Columbia, but the belief that it could not take place was deeply entrenched in their minds. Christian Sivertz, the staunchly anti-Oriental Secretary of the Victoria Trades and Labour Council put into words the thoughts of many whites when he wrote: The people of India in common with all Asiatic races, are reared and nurtured in and under the influence of civilization and environment that seem to be, .in principle, totally opposed to the civilization and environments under which we of ·the western civilization and environments are born and reared. IDn practice they certainly are found to be bothunwillingand incapable of assimilating with the people of western races who for very justifiable reasons, aspire to contro1·the future destiny of this broad and fair land, with the hope that civilization in the best and truest sense may advance and develop to a fuller degree than has yet been achieved. But with the invitation or admission of these people, the Hindus would threaten and eveg make impossible the realisation of such hopes. 5 Sivertz• views were sgared by some Christian leaders .. as well. The Western Methodist Recorder, commenting on the Komagata Maru incident, observed, the economic aspect of the Oriental question ±~ serious enough, because it means unequal competition - labour and some lines of bus~ness - by men of different standards and ideals; but the social and moral aspects are much more serious to contemplate. It is notl\UD.erely unreasoned prejudice that influences western feeling; it is not that Asiatics are inferior; it is that they are different, so different that -121- the two races are incompatible, and as such an attempt to fuse them as common people is useless and would inev!htably result in a lowered standard of civilization which would hardly look attractive even to the ardent advocate of Hindu rights to unrestricted immigration on the plea of the brotherhood of man and fellow British citizenship. Surely it is utter nonsense to argue from this ·basis when it is evident that each race is better off in its own natural environment, and when, too the unrestrained mixing o# the races on this ?oast would ~ead_to ~conomic disaster anq. _ethnical demoralization. · 0 · Negative views on the assimimability of the East Indians were not confined to British Columbia alone. They echoed with equal force on the entire Pacific ·c oast. United States Commissioner of Emigration, H.A.Mills believed that the assimilhative qualities of the East Indians were lower than 67 those of any other race in the west. To many whites, such views were self evident facts and the most formidable 68 arguments against East Indian immigration. Still there were ·others who, repeating the psuedo-scientific theories of race which simultaneously circulated in ·Europe and America, asserted that it was con:brary to natural laws for the Orientals and the ·whites to live together. Ernest MacGaffy, a reputed journalist oi British Columbia, claimed: "It is only neces·s ary to remind ourselves· of certain truths to bring home to everyone the conviction that the Oriental was never intended, either by· nature or art, to live with . . . 069 the whiteman. Such racial myths persis~ed, ~ . even .though . . they lacked a basis in fact, continued to feed the public imagination with the image of the unassimilable East Indian~~ -122- Seldom did the white public question the role its actions might have played in the formation of 'that image. British Columbia's contemptuous attitudes and negatively stereotyped images of the East Indians were not as widely nor as enthusiastically shared in Canada's other provinces. Much to the west coast's consternation, residents of the eastern provinces generally evinced a much more 7O tolerant response to the .Oriental problem. An indication of this was seen:rin·~th:e active ca.m.;,afgn··~pys soiner, prominent citizens of Toronto for a more equa.litarian immigration policy regarding East Indian immigra~ion. But the voices of eastern protest were neither vociferous nor sustained. Often they did not reach British Columbia, and when they -· did they were disregarded ·by the decidely· anti-East Indian population of the province. · Similarly isolated protes·ts · of ' .. East Indian sympathisers within the province were also drowned by the .exclusionists' concerted calls for a white 71 British Columbia. In the end, then, British Columbian's image of the East Indian immigrants as depraved, unclean, uncouth, clannish, poor, violent · and anassimilable prevailed. These stereotypes often contained a germ of truth, but usually they were ·grossly distorted. At best, the stereotypes were only selective perceptions which focused on certain aspects of the immigrants and their community. Almost without exception, British Colum.bians measured the East -123Indians with the yardstick of their culture and,invariably, the Indian fell far short of the mark. Only very rarely did whites attempt to see xhe ~East Indian in his own social and institutional setting. To some extent, at least, the proliferation of negative stereotypes of East Indians was a result of the nature of late nineteenth and early twentieth century west coast society. It was a ?tr.ttctu.;ra.lly plural society, whose • .r. . • - • dominant white segment wished a homogeneous white Canada. Consequently the non-whites were cast aim a deprecatory light. · Whatever the source of these ·stereotypes, however., their impact on the process of East Indian acceptance and integra. ~aon was significant. Assertion of ethnocentric values by the whites precluded the possibility of developing more open and amicable contacts between the two groups. Furthermore, when such values and stereotypes entered the economic and political life of the society, they furthered the process of East Indian alienation. ·Prevalence of negative stereotypes also encouraged the East Indians in their already negative disposition to adapt to the ways and valu·e·s of the Canadian society. Together these influences impeded the process of •resocialization' among the East Indians in their new environment and retarded the process of East Indian acceptance and integration. FOOTNOTES - CHAPTER III 1 See S.N.Eisenstadt, Immigrant Abso?ation, 'Introduction'; Chandra Jayawardena, "Migration and ocial Change," loc.cit. 2 Minako Kurikawa, ed., Minority Responses:Comparative Views of Reaction to-Subordination (New York: Random House, 1970), 3. 3 This idea is fully explored in W.P.Ward, "White Canada Forever; British Columbia's Response to Orientals, 18581914," unpublished Ph.D. ·dissertation, Queen's University, Kingston, Ontario, 1972. But my interpretation of Ward's ·arguments draws heavily on as yet unpublished paper entitled ''John Chinaman." 4 Ward, "John Chinaman," 18. 6 · Gordon W.Allport, The Nature of Prejudice (Boston: THe Beacon Press, 1954J, 191. 7 Ibid., 196. 8 See discussion o~ this in Bernard Stern, "Americt;m Views of India121and Indians, 1857-1900," unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, University of Pennsylvania, 1956; Harold Isaacs, Scratches on Our Minds: American Views-of China and India (New York: Capricorn Books,pl946); Henri Baudet, , Paradise. on Earth; Some Thou hts of Euro ean· ·Images o · Non.;. uropean en= ew aven: ale niversity Press, 1965) especially for philosophical interpretation; and Donald Lach, Asia in· the Making of·Euro e,Vol. 5, Books I and II (University ·of Chicago Press, ·1965. . . . 1 9 See Stern, op.cit., chapter one. lO Pott er' s School·· Geograph.y, (Philadelphia, 1891), 40. The other leading textbook was Hatper's School Geography.See ·Bernard Stern;· ~ i ,- 83·. · · -· · _· · ~ ~ •· 11 See Mrs. A.C.Chaplin's, Our Gold Mine, 66. Quoted in ·-Stern, ~ 12 William H~Stuart, "Calcutta, the City of Palaces, 11 -125- ~i!~ Harper's Magazine, 34 (1866), 229; see also Julian Ra~)ph, Sacred Ci t _y of Hindus," Harper• s MagazinE::,,_100 ( 1859), 13 Quoted in Stern, "American Views of India and Indians," 112. In thesnineteenth century hierarchy of races, the Europeans or the Caucasian was the very t9p. Mitchell's Geofraphy Text Book For High Schools (1840), for example, sta ed. that .. The European or the Caucasian is the most noble of the five races of men. It. excells all others in learning and the arts, and includes the most powerful nations of most ancient and modern times. The most valuable institutions of society, and the most useful inventions haveo:riginated wdlth the people of this race." Quoted in John A. N!i!:e tz, Old Text Books : S:pellings, Grammar, Reading, Arithmatic Geo a h · American .Risto· · Civil Government, h :n1.o o en.mans i · ·r · · u.sic ·- as au ;: 1.n ·· ommon chool Coft:on:i.:a ·:t a s i · .:·· ·.mversi ty 14 Attention here is to be focussed on what the "common man,"· thought 0€ India, and ne>t what scholarly works of Max Mueller, Sir William Jones and various Oriental Societies in India had to say about India. The appeal of these scholarly s~udies to the common man was limited for most of them derived milch~-.:of their information from school text books and journalistic tracts. 15 Harold Isaacs, Images of Asia, 274. 16 R.S.Mintown, From New York to Delhi, quoted in Stern, 83. 17 Ibid. 18 Drury.A.Luke, Geo~raphy for Schools upon a plan entirely ~ , (Providence, 162~), 35.Quoted in Ruth -Miller Elson, · Guardians of Tradition ·: · American School Books ·· of the -19th century (Lincoln, Nebraska: University of Nebraska Press, 1964); 161. Another · geography··text· book by David Page, · Advanced Textbook . of ·Physical Geographt (London : · William · Blackwood &Sons, 1880), claimed a simi ar view, asserting 0 that · Europe is ever active and progressi v.e ," 317. 19 William L. Stuart, "Calcutta, the City of Palaces," 302. 2 ° For details, relevsnt chapters in Bernard Stern,op.cit. 21 Fred Lockley, "The Hindu Invasion: A New Immigration Problem," Pacific Monthly, 17 (1907), 595. 22 Daily Colonist, 18 October, 1906. 23 Canada, Senate Debates, 1907-08, 480-4. 24 Fred Lockley, "The Hindu Invasion," 584. 25 Daily Colonist, 18 October, 1906. 26 Province, 11 December, 1906. 27 The Independent, 20 June, 1906. 28 J.B.Williams and S.N.Singh "Canada's New Immigrants," Canadian Magazine, 28 (February, 19©7), 383-391. 29 Professor Ward in hi~ unpublished paper, "John Chinman" finds a similar situat!bon with the Chinese image as well. 30 D.S.Burjor to w.c.Hopkinson, 30 January, 1914. Governor General's Numbered Files, Vol. 204, File 332 part lO(b), PAC. 31 Daily Colonist, 15 November, 1906. 32 Burjor to Hopkinson, op.cit.? 33 See Daily Colonist, 18 October, 1906; .15 "August-; , 2-5 September; Tein-Feng Chen, · 0riental .Immigration in Canada (Shangai : The -Commerc!Lal Press,· 1931}, 141. · 'Report on · · Hindus;• Governor General's Numbered Files, Vol; : 200, File 332· part 3(b), PAC. · · · · · · . . . 34 J.B.Williams,"Canada's New Immigrant," 385. 35 Ibid., J86. 36 The Report in American Review of Reviews, 35 (JanuaryJune, 1907), 367. The report depicts the situation in Vancouver. 37 Province, 23 November, 1906. See also a memorandum frem Minister of Interior to Governor General, 27 November, 1908. Immigration Branch, Vol. 384 part 1. 38 Province, 7 December, 190y'. a 39 Peter Ward,"John Chinaman," op.cit., 5. 40 Sanitary Inspector's Annual Report, 1911, Immigration Branch, Vol. 384 part 4, PAC. 41 A clipping of the V:ii.:otoria Daill C~lonist, .£!!:• 1911 in Immigration Branch, Vol. 384 part , AC. 42 Report of Superintendent of · Immigration, 1913-1914,76. See next chapter.· 4i Quoted in Kushwant Singh, Ghadr, 1966, 4. See also Isabella Broad, An Aipeal for Fair~lay for the Sikhs in Canada, n.p. 1913; Victoria•Daily • imes, 14 September, 1907 for Dr. Underhill's favourable impression of the Hindus. 44 Victoria Daily Colonist, 15 November, 1906~ See also J.W.Macintosh; Chief of ·P olice to J.C.Smith, Commissioner of Immigration, · 7 January; -1 908. Immigration Branch, Vol. 492 ,} Fi:Jie 763419. PAC. - 45 Victoria Daily Times, 22 December, 1906. 46 Colonist, 15 November, 1906. 47 Victoria Daily Times, 29 January, 1908. 48 Colonist, 15 November, 1906. See also Province, 29 IDctober, 1906. 49 Times, 5 December, 1907. ° 5 For example, see Colonist, 16 November, 1906. 51 From A~S.Monroe to W.D.Scott, (ca. 1911) Immigration Branch, Vol. 384 part 4, PAC. See aiso British Columbia Magazine, IX, no. 12 (December, 1913), 711-15. -12852 Alderman, H.M. Fullerton of Victoria, upon urgings by · · the white labour, moved :that· all city work should b·~ · · ·restrci ted to whi t ·es singe the· East Indians took all his ·savings to Iridia, and his motion was unanimously passed. From Victoria Daily Colonist,~• 1911, Immigration Branch, Vol. 364 part 4, PAC. 53 Fred Lockley, "The Hindu Invasion," 590; W.G~Donley, "The Oriental Agriculturalist in British Columbia," B.A. ·E assay, University of British Columbia, 1928, 15. 54 Christian Sivertz, Secretary, Victoria Trade and Labour Council,to R.L.Borden, 28 December, 1911, Borden Pap:E3rs, 144735-6. 55 Das, Hindustani Workers on the Pacific Coast, 59. The figures in the tab.l e fall outside the period of this study, but it can be assumed that they · are indicative of a trend. For more detailed treatment of th.e wages and income of the East Indian workers, see chapter VII of Das• book. 56 See Victoria Daily Times, 20 November, 1906.· 57 Das, · op.cit. , 61-~ 58 Figures are unavailabl·e , but that it was happening is beyond doubt. See D.S.Dady Burjor to w,c.Hopkinson, 30 · · January, 1914. Governor General's Numbered Files, Vol. 204, File 332 part lO(b), PAC. . 59 The possible exceptions were the labour groups who · viewed all Oriental in the same light. See Christian Sivertz to R.L.Borden, 28 December, 1911. Borden Papers, 144735-6,PAC. He wrote that "the working population of this city (Victoria) regard all the. native tribes of India in the -same light as any other Oriental nation." 60 Millis, H.A. 0 East Indian Immigration to British Columbia and the Pacific Coast States," American Economic Review, I · ( 1911), 75 ., 61 F~C~Blair, Secretary to the Department of Immigration and Colonization, to Saxton Ireland, 17 April, 1920 1 Immigration Brarich, File 536999 part 12, PAC. 62 W~D.Scott to J .H.Clark, United State·s Commissioner of Immigration, 15 September, 1913. Immigration Branch, Vol. 385 part 6, PAC. For evtdence of the fact that many people agreed with Scott's view see Tein-Feng Cheng, Oriental Immigration in Canada (1931), 140ff. 63 Ibid. 64 Spatially, the Chinese were mostly confined to the Chinatown. Socially, they had very little contact with the host society; certain voluntary associations such as the Chinese Benevolent .Association perform·e d intermediary function. Furthermore, numerous clan, community and surname associations controlled Chinese social life. Such associations were lacking in the East Indian community and compared to the Chinese, the East Indi~n individuals had more contact with the host so·ciety. See Karin Straato~, "The Political System of the· Vancouver Chinese Community: Associatiorts · and Leadership in the early 1960's," unpublished M.A.Thesis, University of British Columbia, 1974. 65 Christian Sivertz to Frank Oliver, 17 December, 1906, Immigration Branch, Ace 69/17 Box 219, File 536999, PAC. 66 Western Methodist Recorder, XV, no. I (July, 1914), 12. Quoted in-Ward, "White Canada Forever," 256. 67 H.A.Millis, · "East Indian Immigration to British Columbia 11 110 and the Pacific Coast, States, 75. 68 British Columbia Magazine, IX} ,no.:;12 (December, 1913), 11m~15. 69 Emxest MacGaffy, "British Columbia and the Yellow Man," .British Columbia Magazine, III, no. I (1912), 198. 70 W.G.Smith, B~ldin~ the Nation (Congregational Missionary Society, 1922), l 8. See also Isabella Broali, "An ·Appeal for Fairplay for the Sikhs in Canada, n-.p. ,1913 · 71 Various religious denominations were more reserved in their views about Oriental immigrants. But they too could n9t ~scape the prevailmng negative stereotypes of the · · Orientals. See Peter Ward, "The Oriental Immigrant and Canadi~· Protestant Clergy," BC, Studies, no. 22 (Summer, . · 1974},', 9-19. CHAPTER IV EAST INDIAN IMMIGRATION IN POLITICAL PERSPECTIVE "We must admit that Canada's attempts so far to regulate immtgratio~ haye been crude and freakish· _for· ·ourselves and ·pos~eri ty; but · tempered· by·'tn,.e.· fear of c~using the Imperial -government uhn,ecessary -emparra.s:ijmefttc·ana;, second, t,he "·perhaps too -hasty ena.qtment_. of immaturely consider~d restri•ct_i ve·.:·legislat~on ·at· the·- ·behest of ··.the: ·opportunist~-_. makeshift politicians - ",, ·rather than the·, result of· .·carefu.J:ly ·considered statesmanlike· policy·not marred by·poi:ttical expediency •."1 ,. · - · ··· .. · ·, · "If the Dominion government would come out flat footedly and<· say 'Jlwe wil-1 -_not admi:v· the Hindus. We· thimk that-~his color- outweighs __ the faqts of his:toyalty, his -goo·d character and his: /: . ·_ - appr.eci_atioil' of all··'things ·British,' my' people · would u:nde:rstand ·their posi tiori. But to be _ told that they :are Bri ti.sh. subj.ec1;fs ·and entitled to 'fre·edoin i.mder · the British flag; and to "be kept apart from thei:r families;- constitutes a· treatment which they cannot unde:rstand. It does not' s~vour justi~e a~d 'i t 2 is nei th,er -'straight 0 :(onrd nor human.J.. tarian. ·· The 'policies, practic·es· and_ programmes of government, - ... - employers, trade i.mions and certain voli.mtary associations ;,,,;-- of ~he host-. coi.mtry ··all constitute, important factors in ... \ immigrant accept~nce and_ integration.·· Most important, however,. is: the· policy of· -:t;he. .. ·government, sirtce it· commonly '.,,. ,,_. ·refle·cts and :·frequently reinforces the atti tud.e of· the host society towards the immigrant~ .. The relative ope:rm.ess or restrictiveness of the . government policy-, seen· in the laws governing conditions of·entry; leng:t;h,•of.stay permited, -· ' . •'· . ,.1 >" .,, . . .. . controls to which il'lllIU,grants· are subj.acted,·· readiness to • • • 0 • •• • " ,• • ' • • • > :•~ •• • • '< L grant permission to bring wives and other such possibly: -130- -131restrictive stipulations, will determine, in some measure, . . ' .the •nature, extent and direction of ·immigrant integration. • This · chapter examines the nature of Federal and Imperiaili polici·es concerning East Indian immigration to · Canada.; The policies of the ;Brovincial ·government receive o:nly brief attention because immigration was primarily a federal matter. At all three levels, the desirability of curtailing immigration was agreed Upon but the degree of concern differed among them. India's imperial status in the British Commonwealth complicated the problem of the East Indian immigration to Canada. No overtly discriminatory legislation could be ·passed without regard for the complex nature of imperiai reiat±onships in which India occupied • • I • ,, a critical and sensitive ·position .. Yet the ·interests of 0 labour groups and · the determ!bmation of the Dominions, including Canada, to have even .greater influence in determining their own immigration priorities, necessitated ' ' restrictive · immigration legislation. A gradual, but sure, change in . the nature of the imperial ·relationships between Canada, Great. Britain and India facilitated · this. At the same time~ · lhn. ·Canada, the determination and: rigid application of restrictive i~igration measures · widened the cleavage which divided East Indians froin the host society~ And ·in this atmosphere of · distrust and hostility, the . process of East Indian acceptance and~integration was retarded. -132Anti-Indian xenophoebia in British Columbia first . ·. ~. :. ., appeared in a substantial.form in late July and ·early ... .... . .. ' •' , . Augµ.st of 1906 when a ·1arge number of the immigrants arrived in Va.neauver ( see· Table ' I; . p. -15 . ,) ·· The ' .Trades .and Labour Ccmnci:1s in :·Victoria and · Vancouver were in the 3 . ~guar~ :~f t;~ -move~~~t·.• . The VancouverCity · 0Quneil and ..,.... . . . . some· provincial Members of Parliament also took up the ' ,. ·: , . cry. But a's . large numbers of East Indian -immigrants . , . '. ;_ •.-~ . ' . as th.e ir' plight deteriorated owing ·to lack . arrived·, ·and . .. . of supporti ;,e· organisations in theit-· -·community, more . - ·: ~- :• ~-,1 .• • , • • , •,; ~...,;~·.::·~:. ,,_ 1•-r,;' :.;;. ,. • , .. : .. , · •· vociferous calls· ·were · made'. ,to purtail . East :,Indian ~ . . ., ·.:. .'.::_~ •-·· .~ .. . ",;. .... immigration al together. ·In 0ctober,' 1906,- Mayor · Buscombe ..... ~ ,.,l ·, ~ . , .. ,. of Vancouver too)! .the , first - decisive ac-t ion:- against .the recently arrived · immigrants • . After · caliing ;a meeting,to . . .•.. . . ' . . _. ,. . ' discus's the qu,estion, · he ·u.r;ged __:th:e · danad±an Pacific · Ra:ll~ay· officials" to . deta.in ·all Ea.st Indian immigrants . . . . .... . : .••·•·· . who arrived on .. board the company's :ships· until the. Ci_ty Council was certain that they would not become ·p ublic • . . ~ ,l 4 c.h a~ges ... His · req~est· ·was l~ter carried out by ~Flt· officials who prevented a. shi:p 'load· of Indians from leaving the compa~•s immigration·sheds. Meanwhile, the decidedly anti-Oriental provincial press vilified the newly arrived 5 East Indians. At the same time as these protests were made, provincial . politicians also pepperedSir Wilfred Laurier . 6 with prot~sts. Laurier's response to the clamour from -133white exclutionists in British Columbia was a very cautious one. W, D. Sc_o tt, the Superintendent of Immigration was sent to investigate allegeq indigence .within the East Indian community. Scot.t reported ·that the climate, caste system and the physique of the East Indians made them unsuited to life in Canada. Therefore, he recommended restrictive 7 measures for controlling their immigration. A few months later, while the outcry against the East Indian immigrants continued unabated, E~Blake Robertson, Scott's assistant was sent to Vancouver to ascertain .the possibility of deporting some of the East Indian immigrants under the existing Immigration Act. During the course of his investigation, Robertson di_d not find a serious problem of indigence within the East Indian community and further discovered that only one ·East -Indian was eligible for deportation, and he was · ~oo ill to be moved. 8 Laµrier himself was quite aware of the complexity of the East· Indian problem in British Columbia, and h~ shared the prevailing belief that the East Indians were undesirable in Canada. More than once he noted that the East Indians . were loo.k ed upon with still more disfavour 9 than the Chinese or -the Japanese. Moreover, in his view, the East Indians were the least suited .t o withstand the ~old ·climate ~ef Canada. Curtailment . of immigration was· thus ·in the best interests · of the East Indians themselves. "Experience has shown," he argued, "that the -134immgirants of this class, having been accustomed to the conditions o~ a tropical climate, are wholly unsuited to ·this· country, and that their iriapili ty to ,.~ adapt themselves to surroundings s·o ·entirely different, inevitably ·brings upon them much suffering and privationt"lO But unlike the staunchly anti-Oriental British·Columbians, who preferred direct and forthright measures to curtail East Indian immigration, ·Laurier sought informal representations ·to end the problem. He told a correspondent in · early 1907, I may inform you that we have taken a _c tion to have the Government of India and the authoriti_es at Hong Kong keep us posted about the movement· of. emigration which is -taking • place from India to Canada. We have ta.ken steps -to have these authorities know that _ the Hind~i:t · co~ng · to Canada wil;l \ikely . meet 1 with ·very serious diffieulties'.1°'· ·· · . . .. ' . . Immigratm·on agents . in ·Vancouver also used indirect, . . administr~tive ·techniques to check to some extent ·East Indian immigration to Canada: Since prior to ··1908 there were .· no specifi'c . regulations governing East Indian . . , .. immigration.;; .Immigration ~offi_c. ;ail.s r_eli'.~Jil _on ··c.et:tain . -. · sections of ensting Immigratmon Act and applied· them · rigoiF.0usly .. when. the need · arose ·~ In this regar,d, Section 28 was particularly important ·:· · · •:;No immigrant who is a pauper, or destitute, a ·- professional beggar, · or vagrant, or who is likely to ·•become ' 8. public . charge and ·perE?on l~ded in ·Canada, · who within two years o:r · • thereafter, ·ha.a become ·a charge upon pµblic fun~s, -v.rhether·municipa.1, · provin·c ial or · federal·, or an · inmate of ·or ·a char£e upon any charitable institutions mayT;b:e'·._;~ ·e,ported -135and returned to the port or place whenc~ ~uch 1 an immigrant came or sailed .for Canada. ·· . . ' . ~ Medical examination at the port of entry was another technique used to check East Indian immigration. It was dis.c overed in early-· i906 that some East Indians suf:f'ered from trachoma, ·consequently the check for this · particular . . . . . - . .. ~ \ disease was stepped up, · and prospective immigrants .were rejected at the slightest signs of having·thisand other dmseases,; Thus between January and October ·J lsitf 1996, •.( ..,, , ' ... ~- " . ·, ,, one · hundred East Indians -were reje·e·ted on medical' grounds; seventy four for trachoma, others for partial blindness and conjunctivitis. By March, 1907, ·the number rejected orimedical ·grounds increased to one hundred and twenty;and by the next -fiscal year, the number had · leaped· to ·;two hundred . ·-· .. . . . 13 and eighteen. ·. . . ' Indirect and informal techniques adopted by Laurier and the Immigration _n.e,p~rtment· ~? not have satj,sfi;ed the exclu~ionists of the. British Columbia, but they were in line with the Imperial ·policy on Dominion immigration • .As early as 1a97, Joseph Chamberlain, in his opening address at the Colonial Conference, had recogmised the inevitability of constraints imposed by the white Dominions upon the immigration of people "alien in civilisatio~, alien in reli'gion, alien in custom, whose · influx, moreover~ would most certainly interfere with the legislative rights of the existing labour population.n However at the same t:i.me, he urged that respect be given to what he described as the -136'traditions' of the Empire which made no distinctions in 14 favour of, · or ~against·· creed or colour. He further proposed that statutes Should avoid reference to criteria . of race or colour, while .achieving the desired discriminato:;-y aims by means of administrative technique·s. As a clear indication of his thinking, in 1900 Chamberlain authoris.ed the Goveim~r · General of Australia· to assent to i an Immigration Restriction Bill despite << unequivocal statement , by. Aastralian: l ·e aders that the education test in any European language selected by an offi·c·er would be 15 applied only to nori-E~opean immigrants. Similarly, despite protests from a Japanese Shipping Company, Nippon · Yusen; and the Bengal Chamber · of co·mmerce, Chamberlain paid no heed· to the passage of the Commonwealth ·Posts ·and 16 Telegraph •·s Act of 1901. He · merely expressed "~egret that their feeling of obligation in this matter is not shared ' ·by 'the Parliament ·of t ·h e Commonwealth," and that it should have "conside:ried'it desirable·to ·dissociate themselves so 7 completely· from the obligation and policies · of the -~pire. nl ~~ - But beyond the formality of reg!bstering regret, nothing · . ' much was done. By the beginning ··of the twenteeth century, the Imperial Government had taken the position that exclusion ,was inevitable, if not desirable. Consequently in the ensuing years, it gave more l. attention to ·relief · from internal · restricti6ns ·than to exclusion. While these discriminatory immigration regulations -137were .being passed by the Dominions, the moderate Indian politicians were _petitioning the Imperial Government to p·rotest the disabilities of Indians within the British Empire. They noted that the position of overseas Indians was one · i~sue on .which "classes and masses and illiterates, . . .. 1 moderates · and revolutionaries we.re agreed·.11 ? If only.· to · · ,--- prevent unrest 'in Indi~i,l they argued, · overseas· Indians · should be given more -liberal consideration. The in.di~ ) National Cong~ess, led by moderates, passed successive ;Ges·o lutions · from 1895 to 1914 expressing .concern over discrimination in ·immigration legislation as affecting 1 ov:e~~e@'s - Indians, i:~_-; hut despite genuine concern and , sincere .. l·: . ·., ··. . , . .. . . . ·. .. . - . ... ·- eff oirit s, -· not much· was ·achieved. Apar~ :from· giving the.. . ·-· . . lnd±~n··i,oli ticians a sense· of satisfaction ·at having done the:ir duty, ·the · resoiution fel-1 on hard; · unreceptive ; ,. . -· gr9und's at: the colonial· conf~rences ·for, in the minds of po~iticians fro~ the white Empire, India was on a differ,e nt 2 category from their ·dominions. Q The British Government, in the meantime, was in the diffi9ult position of having to listen to complaints from one part of the Empire against another. To informal representations from Canad?, about .the · possibility of enacting legislation to prevent the immigration of non-indentured East Indians, :IJord Elgin,· the Secretary of State replfed . ·~ . - in the· negative ... The move," he said, ."must come · from Canada itself. We leave it to the Canadian Government to -138take such measures as may be necessary to restrain tmmigration into ·its own .terri1iories. Should that government .thimk it fi:t- ·to legislate so as to require certain qualification such as physical fitness to be determined by physical examination on landing and possession of certain amount of money, we will make every endeavour to make such legislation '' widely; known, but we trust that ·no express discrimination st21 will be used against British Indians. canada made the move at the beginning of 1908 as sh~ll presently be seen. In the meanwhile, in March JL,9 08, t twoLh~~rt3d . E.!ast Indians· arrived in ·Vancouver aboard .the Monteagle. Not all aboard, however,· were allowed to land. An --.Qrder~-In-Council . . . . had been passed: ·on~J:an~ry 8; giving the Minister of ·interior the power to· prohibit any ·immigrants from landing in Canada "•unless they came· from •·:t h'e ·66untry of their · birth or- citizenship by . a . continuous . journey; and on through ' ... tickets purchased ·b efore ·le.~ ving the country of ·.t h·e mr 22 birth or citizenship. ~• ·'This Order was applied immediately to the . East Indian ·immigrants 'a board the Monteagle. Seventy eight of ·the immigrants who had wai. ted theft•· tll.nr in Hong .·Kong to come -tcr Canada were debarred because they hali not ·c,oni.e directly from their country of origin or citizenship. Another one hundred and five who had come· directly from Calcutta were debarred for. lack of proof that they had 23 purchased their ~tickets in Calcutta. The success of the 4 Order in prohibiting the entry of East Indians prompted its -139inclusion in another order, PC662, passed on March 27, 1908, which required that the continuous passage be applied to all potential immigrants, not only to those that :t he · 24 Minister of Interior deemed necessary. · · The fact that the continuous passage regulation applied with special effect against ·the East Indians has prompted the belief that it was,-~s-,fiact, intended ·. 25 specifically to check East I~dian •immigration to Canada. But, as .I,.aurier pointed out, "These regulations were adopted in· order to have absolute control of steamship companies bringing immigrants ·to Canada ,so that we coula .. -- -- -- . compel them · to take them (;mmigrant] back to the co;µntry of their origin.•• Lauri er further emphasised the fact that th~ regulation applied witlie.qual force to Europeans and 26 other Asiatics as ·much as they did to the East Indians.: Japanese who 'Here. refused landing in California and Hawaii couid no longer come to Canada as· they· did .in the past. · Nor could the Europeans in the United States, Australia, New Zealand and other such places seek entry into Canada, temporarily atleast. In fact, at thi:.s time some 1,049 · • Europeans living in the United States were not allowed 27 . entry into Canada. However, the ·Chinese, Japanese · and • • • • I ' • • • Europeans could still come to Canada on a through ticket purchased in their home country whereas the · East Indian could not since there was no direct steamship · route ·· between Canada and India. The dominion government had -140succeeded in eliminating the problem without overtly naming the East Indians. While these developments took place in Canada, Mackenzie King, who had left for England on 4 March, 1908 to confer with Colonial . and Indian offices on their views regarding Indian 'immigration to Canada, met with the Secretary of Statec for Colonies, the Secretary of State;_ for India and the -British Foreign Secr.e·tary. Through · · discussions with these officials, King .· reached what he described as a "satisfactory understanding of the · . ·. :. · · 28 situa~ion. The view that Canada should restrict immi- 1 gration from India was reaffirmed. Furthermore, the concept of ·a white -Canada was considered desirable not only for economic and social reasons, but highly necessary on political and national grounds -as ·well. It was agreed that "Canada ·is ·the best judge of the course t9 be adopted, and that as a self gov.e·rning dominion, she cannot be expected . 1· to refrain from enacting such· measures in the way of restrictions as in the discretion of her people afe 49 deemed. " .The governemnt of India, through the 1ftidia . . ,. . ·-· ·-'· .... -: Office, willingly agreed to issue warnings to offset the "misleading.. :e ffects of the distribution of literature with regard to conditions in Canada, ·and to inform the migrants of' the risks involved. King also discovered ·' . that the ·Indian,~g:pation Act (XXI of 1883) prohibited the :emigration of .East Indi-a ns ..under an:)T. fonn of contract. Part of the proble_m of Indian immigration was thus solved. --141- For the purpose of curtailing non-indentured migration from India, King suggested that the amount of Jwenty five dollars required :hi ' the possession of the immigrant could be :raised to two hundred dollars. This King ·beli~ved would be a protective measure for the immigrants too. The amount 30 was raised as · suggested in June, 1908. It is to .be noted, however, that this order was not to apply to countries with which Canada had special arrangements such as Japan. Cp,inese immigration ·was covered ·by special statutory regulations, namely the system o~ head taxes, -and hence it, too, fell outside the provisions of the order. In reality, the order applied exclusively to the East Ind~ans. All three parties, Canada, Imperial governemnt and especially. India were satisfied by the arrangement. Lord Minto, -the Viceroy of India, in a letter to Laurier, expressed appreciation for .the manner in which the Dominion government had approached the problem. In Minto•s view, there was "practi31 cally no chance" of immigration from IDndia. With immigration from India reduced to a trickle, some Canadian officials began entertaining the thought that the East Indian resident in Canada might be sent to some other British colonies. After surveying British Pal1lama, the Phillippines and the Fiji Islands, Canadian officials chose British Honduras as the place most suitable for thetr;.,,p_lan. The governor of the colony was favourably dlbsposed to the proposal. Moreover, the propeot--of -142employment also seemed likely. The Province, chroni£iing the views of the whites of Bri tish't Columbia, claimed that the pr9po$a.1,.ought to be an a~tracti ve one :toi the Hindus themselves" as ·the climate of British rfo1ui'nb:i.a, was not • • . •- . • • •.••- ~~ •• - 4 • suited to them, and at the same , time, it ·"would have the· advantage of disposine; of the unfortunate·suggestion - that the · natives of India were not welcome in any part . . . . . . 32 of the Empire.•• J.B.Harkin, · private secretary to the .. . ' . Minister ·of · Interior, ·and the person who · played the dominant, ·role. in the ·proposal "later pointed .' out 'that the whole plan · was concei:ved on humanitarian ·grounds, but this . seems ·doubtfui.-33 ·, · Thedelegates, consisting of J.B.Harkin, William C. Hopkinson (a ·• tho.~-roughly distrusted person in the East Ind!La.n community) and ·two East Indians, Nagar Singh and · Shan Singh, left Vancouver for , the·,,•Bri tish ·Honduras · on 34 15 ·October, · 1908·. "After spending a month ·in the · Colony, · the ·. delegates ·returned to Vancouver. At a general meeting ·of the East Indt.an community at the Sikh Temple, . the British Honduras proposal was denounced ·bw.:, a majority. Charges were made by Nagar Singh, one of the East Indian delegates, that Hopkinson had offered him $3,000 to give a . favourable report ·about the colony. The story went that if Nagar Singh complied with Hopkinson' s ideas both he and his family in India would . rece':i.ve· added renumerations. On. ·the · other . hand,Harkin . and Hopkinson charged that certain .. . . . , . . . · East . Indian leaders, especially Teja S±ngh had pressured -14335 the delegates into the denunciation of the plan. There 36 is probably a grain of truth in both these ~llegations. But some of the Sikhs in Victoria had already petitioned the Governor General "against orders of being removed to 37 British Honduras," as early as 31 October, 1908 while the delegates were still in British Honduras. Both the India and Colonial Offices were non-committal right .from the ou:tset. They insisted that the problem of financing the venture was to:: be shouldered by the a:ominion /iJ;.'.f\i'I,~ goyernment, if it met initial approval of the maj0rity ,. of the community. Any formal arrangement such as indenture, 38 the India Office pointed out, was out of question. · The . eventual failure of the British Honduras plan signalled a failure in the dominion government's informal and somewhat indirect approach to solve the East Indian problem in Canada by encouraging emigr~tion while at the same time preventing further immigration. Henceforth, firmer and ,.·, ··. more forthright meassures were adopted indealing with the East Indian problem. The year 1908, then, was a most significant one as . . far as Canadian...- East Indian relation was<;c6ncerned~ · Indeed it made the previous four years of East ·Indian presence in Canada seem almost uneventful. For 1908 had · seen the pa~sage of the continuous journey order, it had seen King's mission to England, witnessed the failure of the British Honduras plan and the slow but sure -144growth of political awareness in the East Indian community. After 1908, however, circumstances began to change. · The three-cornered problem of t .h e ·East Indian immigration, I involving : - · -- ,::, Ili.he Imperial government, the Dominion governm~nt and the East Indian immigrants, essentially became ·a · I_>roblem. involving the latter ·two. To be ·sure, there were appeals by the Ea.st-Indians ·to the Imperial ·government, but-the focus of the conflict changed. It is therefore, appropriate to e~ne the ·changes -in the structure of 39 Imperial relationships between 19.0.8 and 1917 ·as · this will · shed light on •the discussion of Eas·I; Indian activities later. · .At the Colonial Conference in 1911, Lord Crewe declared that the Imperial government "fully accept ·the principle · that each of . the Dominions·, must· be allowed to decide for itself what elements it d.e sires to accept in . its population. clct11'1'\ The extreme"by ·some Indians that membership of the British Empire shall entitle any British subject to reside where he chooses, is disposed off'· by acknowl".edged polijr~·cal 4 facts ... °F~rthermore, the . I~p~rial government· also stated that the Dominions would negotiate directly with the Indi~?1"<1government which was apparently in touch with the Indian opinion. These negotiations wouid recognise '· the power of · each ·conununity under·- the crown to dE)termine the . '. structure and content -of its own population. AssUJI1ptions . ,;'. ,.. ::' ,. . . . ~ ... of cultural and racial superiority would graqually be· -145subsumed within wider concerns for the establishment of reciprocity :ari.d equality-between India and the Dominions. Princ_iples of exclusion enunciated at the 1907 Colonial Conference . ...were .rei tera. t ed. · In 1914, Lewis Harcourt ' , ·: . . . .:··::· ~ecr~t~ry for Colonies, sp~aking in the British ·Parliament _on the ·~outh · African ·deportation · problem; '--sta.ted unequivocally ·that ·British, ;citizenship was a, misnomer. It was too liberal a translation of Civis Roma.nus Sum,he said, and it did not in fact exist. What did exist, Harcourt pointed out, was British sujecthoodwhich entitled the possessor · of that- status to the protection of the sovereign. But he argued, "it gives the individual ' no right of ·entry to or-licence in any part of the Empire if he attempts to violate the laws which is within the 1141 .CQJ'.Ilp.:e ten.c.~ o·f the dominion . to pass and register. · · The next few years brought dramatic changes in India's official image in the Empire. Her services to the cause:of the Empire during the great war were admired by all. nshe [Indiif,. had ·bled herself white defending the Empire," said . . 42 Joseph Chamberlain. S~r Robert Borden, the Canadian Prime Minister, moved at the 1917 Colonial Conference that India be allowed to . attend Colonial Conference. as · ·.a matter 43 of right. But the enhancement of India's . official image, and the flattering words uttered on her behalf by the Prime Ministers of the white dominions, was not accompanied by modification in Canada's immigration ·restrictions -146- imposed upon the East Indians. In fact, Canada gained a legal ' entrenchment of her previous position regarding East J;ndian immigration. ·Rights of exclu·s ion were formally recognised. Temporary..Lyisits for the purpose of pleasure and qonvenien-ce, and temporary residence for education · were to be allowed. Legal wives and chil·dren of permrua~ntly resident East Indians in Canada were · to ·be allowed . residence 44 as well. In ·. ~~~, · the 191·7 .c onference :gave ·f ormal legal' . ' '-' sanction to the idea of dominion autonomy±~ immigration ·matters and the principle of exclusion, ·at the same time regognising the declinirtg influence of Imperial corisiderat±ons in Dominion immigration policies. TheJe changes were reflected in numerous measures passed by the Canadian government .concerning East · Indian immigration. Acco,rding to the ·Immigration Act of 1910; ·the Governor· G:en.e raL. in Council could'., ''prohibit the landing in Canada of ' passengers brought to Canada by the -t ransportatian i,'c:o mpanies which ·r efuse · or neglect to · comply with :the pr·o visions of ·this Act ••• .and might prohibit ·tor a .stated period or permanently in Canada of immigrants:,; ;·.b elonging ·· ····· ··-- . to any race -deemed unsuited to the climate .or requirements .. ' of Canada or of immigra:nts:0.of any specified class, occupation .. 1145 or · character. This' clause, though never applied to the East'•Indians, is illustrative of · the determination :of the Canadian government regarding its immigration policies. Pursuant to the Immigration' Act, both the continuous journey ..;.147- clause and the Jtrder-in,.:-c ouncil regarding the possession ' ' ,/ ' o.f $200 were put: in the form of fresh ,,orders:'in-council, 46 PC920_ ,,and -PC926 respe~tiYel.y. ,And; as has already been seen, a.further demonstration of the Canadian government's determination was provided in ·1912 on ,.-t,he · issue· of ' admitting the wives ·of ·East- Indians resident in Canada,;::~~ -In the· meantime; agitation and protest· from the·. East Indian community persisted •. An interesting case in point arose·in January, .1911. About three hundred.East Indians in the United State·s petitioned the Earl of Crewe and the Dominion government, stating that although several of them owned property·in Canada, they_were not allowed entry and 47 cosequently wer.e suffering heavy losses. The Canadian government, as usual, confined its reply to the defence~; of its policy of restricti<;>n, pointing out that 'Kmerican authorities were very strict in matters of immigration, and that Canada would have a problem on its hands if America found East Indians undesirable and refused to take them back. This being the case, Canadian officials argued that they had no choice but; to apply restrictive provisions of Canad&an law. Further, the Dominion government reminded the Imperial government that·"it had always·been understood that the views of the people in a self governing part of I the Empire should be considered as the best evidence of what constituted imperial interests in that part of the 048 Empire. -148The Indian government was in no position to influence the decision of the Dominion government, but it politely noted that the claims by the East Indians were not unreas:u,R 'able and expressed an opinion that · greater facility for ·· the movement·ot;·the ·East Indians·across the borderw<:>uid be appreciated. A year ·passed before the Dominion government took any action, but not. because of pressure from either the Indian·or,the Imperial governments, for·there was very little of_ this. In .November , 1912 ,· an ·~frder-i'.n·.9ouncil was passed in ·which the Minister·· of Interior·· authorised permits to the East Indian-subject "who may visit·can:ada temporarily, coming 'direct· from India, or from the· United States, •. :i.t being understood, however, tl+at 1;nr:. the case of those coming from the United States, they would first be required to obtain from the United States Immigration Department the necess·ary authority to return to United States at ·the expiration of the permit, 'or at ··an earlier···dat'e , if the Canadian· government should so 1149 desire. Fearing the influx of East Indian immigrants, the Canadian gov.ernment did not proclaim the Order-InCouncil, and the matter of its application·· reste·d on the dis.cretion · of the· immigration officials at the border. Those immigrants seeking admis.si'on into Canada -temporarily for commercial purposes had to submit their requests ·to the 50 Immigration Department. The legality of Canadian immigration legislation -149regarding the East Indians came before the courts in 1913. And much to·· the consternation of the -Immigration Department ' ' and ··the · DonJi.nion government, 12'rders..,:1in-.council PC92O· and PC926 requiring the possession ._of two hundred dollars and the continuous journey to Canada respectiv,e ly ," · were held · u.ltra\.:ri;r.es 'PY Chief Justice Hunter of · the Brit·i sh Columbia Court.· "o f ·Appeals .~he _p:Qca.sibn ~ arose · on 17 October, 1913 . . - -·· . 1 . . .. when fifty six ·East Ind1a?1.~:, destined for various places in BritishColumbiaarrived ' in Vancouver aboard the Panama . . ' ~ . · Of the fifty six passengers, · ten were landed / · i:mmediately,havin~ satisfi~d the Immigration Department of previous domicile ·in -British Columbia ·and having met the various medical requirements. The following day, ,seven 51 others were landed on similar grounds. The rest could not · meet the . requirements of the existing regulations, and wer-e thus· refu~ed admission. The matter, however, did·- not rest there. The East Indians in Vancouver, on behalf of the thirty nine East Indians aboard the ship, appealed against the decis~on of the Immigration Department. The first attempt to obtain a writ of habeas corpus was dismissed by Judge Murphy who ruled that se'ction twenty three of the Immigration. Act of 1910 prohibited him from hearing their application. But in a new application before Chief Justice Hunter, the East Indians succeeded in obtaining the writ of habeas corpus. Hunter ruled that both PC92O and PC926 were invalid and ultra vires because -150- they failed to comply with the language of the Immigration 52 Act under which they were passed. As a result, the remaining thirty nine East Indians were also released and a~lowed entry into Canada. · Embarrassed, frustradi.ed and bitter, the Immigration Department sought to correct those flaws in the immigration regulations that had led to the entry of the East Indians aboard the Panama Maru.. Both PC 920 and PC 926 were 53 replaced by ~ew orders-in-councii. On 8 December, 1913, another order-in-council was passed, non-discriminatory in appearance, b.u t achieiied the desired purpose. By that order, no artisans, or labourers, skilled or unskilled were allowed to land at any po'rt in British Columbia because the labour market was overcrowded. The question of deciding who was an artisan and who was a labourer lay entirely in ' the hands of the Board of Inquiry whose decision could be 54 appealed to the Minister of Interior only. By the end of 1913, those flaws in the immigration legislation that had · led to the embarrassment of the Immigration Department in the matter of East Indian immigration were corrected. Both the Department and the Dominion governmentswwep,e fully prepared to withstand any challenges that might arise. In the following year, an incident occured that presented the first serious challenge to Canadian determination to keep the East Indians out of Canada. This was the ..famous -Komagata--Maru.--incident. The- •-ship · Komagata·-Maru,- wi-th--- -151three hundred and seventy six East Indians, all but thirty of whom were ·Sikhs, ·arrived in Burrard inlet on 23 May, 55 191~. The leader. of the whole enterprise was a colourful Sikh, Gurdit Singh, a wealthy native of Amritsar district, who had emigrated to the Malay States in the late nineteenth century. What led Gurdit Singh to venture upon the whole affair is not at all clear. However, two views have been put forward to explain Singh's possible motives. · The Komagata Maru Committee in 1915 argued that Gurdit Singh was "actuated by the ·desire to pose as a political hero 56 n Th . . t· h t h b •••• e unproven assump ion ere seems o ave een that since Singh had witnessed the dehumanising and brutalising aspects of British colonialism in Malaya .,a nd Singapore, he wanted to put an end to it. To some extent, public statements and private correspondenees of Gurdit Singh himself give credence to this theo.ry. For example, the day tth:Ef:i'shfilp arrived in Vancouver, he reportedly said : ••The me.in object of our coming is to let the British government know how they can maintain their rule in India as the Indian gove•r nment is in danger nowadays. We can absolutely state how the British governm~nt will last in 1157 India forever. 0~ the other hand, Ted· Ferguson has argued that Gurdit Singh's motive was primarily financial. In his previous occupations, Singh had been a building and railway contractor, a ·bookstore owner, a linen exporter and. a . pawnbroker - in all, a successful businessman. -152Consequently, "he had fallen under the spell of the comrilercial world's most seductive siren, the prospect of bigger profits," and decided to seek his fortune in the shipping -business which ended . in the ~omagata Maru fiasco! 8 The trut~. perhaps is somewhere in the middle. · Whatever the motivation behind the Komagata Maru enterprise, ·Canadian officials were uniformly against the venture. The bitter memory of less than· a year ago was · :fresh in their minds. Moreover, ~ost of them· and the whites in t:ne· provinceat large perceived the Komag-a.ta Maru enterprise as · a most flagrant attempt to evade our laws," 11 and therefore vehemently argued that · no. concession should 59 \be · granted.; .~-h e ;remier or! B·r .;_tis~· Columbia, Sir Richard ,,_,,. ... - . .. ., .. • " · --· .-. ... ,_. _ . 11/l~?Bride stated ·oa:tce gorically that · to admit o·r ientals in 11 large numbers would. mean ·• in the· end . the extinction of -:i./ ..:~, white peoples and we h!3,ve always in mind the necessity of 60 keeping tllis a white man's country.•• The .federal ·- · government ·, headed by Rob:e rt Borden also declared its . ' . .. intention to enforce with· vigour existing ·immigration 61 legislation ·0.11d the reeent},J:>'rders-in-council. In their ... determination to follow closely the letter of the law regarding East Indian immigration, the immigration officials, as well as the p·rovincial · and the· d;ominion governments.recieved overwhelming support from the majority 62 of people in British Columbia. In the meanwhile, prospective immigrants were examined -153carefully by the immigration officials. Twenty substantiated their claim of previous Canadian domicile and were landed. A further ninety were raj.ed medically unfit to enter 63 Canada. Other than these two ~i~sses of immigrants, the Board of Inquiry made no orders of deportation or admission. · In one case, that of Wazir Singh, however, hearing had 64 been made but no decision was given·. In this case, ·Edward Bird, the immigrants• f' lawyer, saw a possible chance of success, and the case came before the British Columbia Court of Appeal. A full bench of the Court upheld the legality of the orders and the Immigration Act itself 65 under which the East Indi~s were being refused entry. J But the ship did not leave ·Vancou.ver once those aboard had lost their battle in the courts. A number of obstacles arose, and these related to the unloading of .~ car~., the proposed loading of new · cargo for India, the p~y.ment of charter dues on the vessel, the· moni~s due on the cargo, and the supply of provisions and · water . .. _·: .. 66 for the men onr board the ship. ·. 0 While the ship was lying in Vancouver, its charter had been transferred to the East Indian Shore Committee 67 which had raised almost $54,000 for the purpose. This money A~d been raised by the collective · efforts in · the East .Indian community since the news of the Komagata Maru enterprise became known to them. After the Sea .Lion had met stubborn opposition ,..when. it tried to. .force ·.the . -154Komagata Maru out of Vancouver harbour, the Shore Committee .demands to the Immigration D.epartment · presented a number of . . .... .. _. which were to , 68 be ·met ·before the ship departed. The ·l ocal . . ·East Indians were "determined that the ship ·s hould not ' ' ' A • leave .Vancouver until the·government ·had·repaid to them, in one way or another, all money· advanced· by ·them, whether 1169 paid .to keep the·c~arter·alive ,or ot~erwise. The letter containi~g ·the . demands was :forwarded to · Ottawa. Prime Min:i.st~r Borden sent Agriculture ·Minister Martin Burrell . to Vancouver to -see if some agreement · could b:e ·reached. Fa:i.ling to agree to · Indian demands, Burrell nonetheless promised · that . an impartial Commissioner wou.id· be appointed who would ·.be urged· to . give full :and · s_y mpathetic considera. tion to the East IndiaruH demands. The iocal East Indians represented by the Shore Committee accepted Burrell's · offer after initial hesitation~ And on the morning of .23 July, the Komagata Maru, with H.M.S.Rainbow beside her, left Vancouver harbour, with disgrunti'~fi,disappointed East .. · Indians aboard. H.G.Clogstun, a retired civil servant from India, was appointed to investigate the question of whether payment should be made to the Shore Committee for the expenditures it had incur.r ed in the venture,;?©; After a lengthy investigation, he recommended that the government should not reimburse the Committee for any of the expenditures as the entire enterprise was a political one aimed at -155embarrassing the government. This meant that for the East Indian community at large, severe financial losses accompanied \ , stinging political defeat. The Komagata Maru affair represented a clear, though hard fought, victory for the · o:ominion ·government. It had withstood ·· successfully the challenge of the East Indians. Furthermore, its determined and assertive reaction had demonstrated· conclusively that she alone, and not India or for that matter the imperial government, had the right to determine the structure ·~nd content of its population. But what impact -(· had the incident, -arid federal government polici:e s upon :t hetEast Indian community? Two major effects can readily be·seen. Politicaileaders of the radical· faction realised by 1914 that if they; ',; were .. to succeed in their endeavours at all, they must take the offensive. As ·the Hindustanee claimed, appealing to Home authorities" · for · any ·help was "like · crying in -wi-J.de-r 71 ness. " Conspirat.& ~:i. -; ., and agi tational activities 0 reached their highest peak in 1914 • . The smuggling-of arms and ammuni ti.o n from the United States into Canada and 72 73 then eventually into India, and making of bombs to foment a revoluti·on driving the British out of India increased at this time~ These activities were in line wi·th the programs and · policies of the Ghadr Party which had been kept informed of the proceedings in the Komagata 74 Maru affair. -156In addition to such activities, retaliatory violence followed against those who were thought to · have conspired against the community. The most conspicuous enemies were Hopkinson; the· wily immigration inspector and ·secret agent, and members o'f the loyalist. faction led by· Bela Singh. _D issension and conflict had always existed :in the community, but this .became more marked particularly after 1910(1c,when political agitation · sharply increased in the · · .East -Indian community. ; To some· extent atleast, the ! ~- .' '' Immigration· Department fostered cl.eavages by informally encouraging the loyalist faction to · report on their compatriots~ It later became known that Bela Singh was 75 a paid ·a·gent of , the department. The · first viqtim in the violent conflict that. ensued between loyalists and radicals \., i _·was Harn.am Singh, a member of the, loyalis.t faction. He disappeared on 17 August and two weeks later, his body was found .in a reservation near the Sikh Temple, his throat slit b~ a razor. In the heat of emotion, it was concluded that the death of Harn.am Singh was a ,. murder, though most·: 76 probably thought he had ·kil-J:ed.-hinis_eif.. On 3 · September, 1914,- Arj~ Singh, another · of Bela Singh' s colleagues died accide,n tly, while showing off a newly bought · gun to Ram 77 Singh. Convinced that t4e two · deaths were murders, and also fearing his own life, Bela Singh struck first. On 5 September, 1914, ~e killed Bhai Bhag Singh and Battan Singh at the Sikh T.emple while attending obsequial -157ceremonies connected with the death of Arjan Singh who had been cremated earlier that evening. Six others were 78 injured., 0n 21. October, 1914, the day when Bela Singh' s trial was to begin, Hopkinson, who was to be the chief 79 witness was shot in the Court by Mewa Singh. He made a full confession, and was subsequently hanged on 11 January, 1915. Bela Singh was finally acquitted on 29 November, 1914, on the grounds that he acted in self defence. But retaliatory violence did 'not stop here. Between March and October, 1915, a number of assaults, a !!:tmlir.riler and bomb explosion rocked the community. The climax of all the violenc~, however, was reached in India in May, 1934, when ,, the revolutionary Babbar Akalis, many of them ex-Ghadrites, caught up with B~la Singh, chopped off his legs, hacked off his arms., one at a time, ''before · delivering the coup de grace: severing his head."BO With this, the long trail of violence, terror and assassinations among the East Indians came to an end. This chapter has attempted to examine the nature of political resposes of the imperial arid Canadian governments to East Indian immigration in Canada. The problem of the East Indians was a complex,one, but despite this, the direction and purpose of the aims of both the governments was clear enough. At both these levels, it was agreed that East Indian immigrants were~undesirable, and therefore to be excluded from Canada. Disagreement lay in the method \ -158used to achieve this end. Between 1908 and 1914, the area of disagreement narrowed as the ~ominion government moved from informal, indirect representations to a more determined and · assertive stand in its policies towards East Indian immigration. As has been seen, this was the .result of a .gradual change in the nature of imperial relationships in the matter of immigration involving Canada, Great Britain and the Indians. In . conclusion, it is necessary to return to the central theme of th±s study and ask how the actions of the ·dominion and imperial governments influenced the process of East . -!'( ' .• Indian integration into Canadian society. In the first place, the passage of restrictive· ·-and discriminatory measures designed to curtail Indian immigration confirmed the view of many O•f the immigrants that ·not only the whites of British Columbia but the Canadian government as well was basically hostile to · them. The failure of the imperia-1 government to respond to the;iI.prbtests and petitions of the East Indians further increased ·their suspicion. Consequently, they took matt·e rs in their own hands, and retaliated with violence. This, in turn, widened the cleavage between the immigrants and the host society .and intensified distrust and hostility between them. Secondly, the belief of the .dominion government that the East Indian immigrants were unassim:ij:J.a)iJ.,,¢ . ,· elements in the Canadian society, reinforced the prevailing anti-Indian stereotypes in -159British Columbia. Its determined approach, seen in the passage of restrictive immigration measures, gave institutional form to these ·prevailing ideas and stereotypes. Thus, both directly and indirectly, the reactions of the dominion and imperial governments contributed, in some measure: ,, to the lack: of East Indian integration and acceptance. FOOTNOTES - CHAPTER IV 1 Letter to the Editor, Vancouver Sun, clipping in Immi€iration. Branch, . 474, · file 72882.f, PAC. · 2 Statement by Sundar .Sin~; British Columbia Magazine, VIII (Sep_tember, 1912), 667. · · 3 Ward, "White Canada Forever," 189. The next few paragraphs · draw heavily on pp. 189-192. 4 Ibid., 190 5 See particularly the various issues of Daily Colonist, World, Daily News Advertiser from July to O'c tobe~, 1906. 6 World,19 September, 1906. 7 W.D.Scott, Memorandum re Immigration of Hindus to Canada, 2 November, 1906, ·Rodolphe Lemieux Papers, JL, 82-83. Cited in Ward, · op~cit., .191. 8 Scott to E.Blake Robertson, 5 December, 1906, Limieux Papers, I, 73. ' 9 Quoted in Eric Wilton Morse,"Immigration and Status of • British East Indians in· Canada: A Problem in Imperial Relation," unpublished M.A.Thesis, Queen's University ;; · Kingston, Ontario, -. 1936. : lO ttReport of the Committee of the Privy Council," 2 March, 1908 in W.i~:L.Mackenzie King, Report on . his Mission to En~land to Confer with the British Authorities . on the Su ~ect9f Immigrati9n ~o Cana~~ from the ·?rient and Immigration from India in Particula:t', Sessional Paperr;;· , · No. 36a,. · ottawa: 1908, 5. 11 Laurier to Officials in Hong Kong, Calcutta and London, cited in Wara., "White Canada Forever," 192. 12 Canada, Commons Debates, 1906-1907, 234. 13 Report of Superintendent of Immigration, 1913-1914, 76. -160- -161- 14 Proceedings of the Colonial Conference of 1897, quoted in A.T~Yardwood, Asian Immi- ration to Australia: The Background to Exe usion l 9 _.;.19 Mel ourne: Me ourne University ' Press, _ 1 964), -124·,•. ·_ 15 Ibid. 16 The Act stated that "No contract or agreem~nt for the carriage 'of mails shall be entered into' on behalf of the Commonwealth up.less it contains a provision that only white labour shall be ~mployed -in such a carriage." Yarwood, op~c~t., 19~ · 17 Ibid., 127. 19 Dharam Yash Dev, Our Countr of the. Pro bl ems of I-n...'""i_a_n_s__ ""'i-n--!!!l'_"o_r_e..,1,..gn--s:L!l' ' "'a_n___s_·'!-."".- - - - - - Al~aha bad:-: · J. B~Kirpalni; l9 40) , · Appendix C.- · 20 As the Pri,me Minister of Austral.i a stated at the 1907 conference : · "Let India:.(raise her standard of living, let her pay a fair wage. ·. Then ·arJ.,_d not until then could she ·· ·· invi t'e compar±son ·with all ·o ther white people of self 11 governing colonies. Hancock, op.cit.nl67. - . . .... 2~ Elgin. to Grey, 25 January, 1908; Immigration Branch, Vol. 384 · part II, PAC. . 22 _PC27, January 8, 1908. Cited in Eric Wilton Morse, \;I~-• . ' .•' . ,. .. . ~' -. ":P . · ..c.i· t --_-..... - - .:..35,.,. •• .-~~ ;: • • • ,_, • • •. v.l) ,. :.·. - · •• , • • -.,.~ • ,•" 23 ·· Times, 19 March, 1908. 24 PC 662, 27 March, 1908, ~ . , 36. 25 T°i1i;tappa~ent in most of the . works by East Indians. It seems more ·convi·ncing that the order was ini.t ially intended to· apply with equal force to all immigrants, not only to . ·East · Indians. Later it· was found to apply with special force against East Indians. See also Sir Robert Holland, "Indian Immigration into Canada: The Question of Franchise,"~ -162Asiatic Review, XXXIX, _137 (January, 1943), 167. 26 Canada, Commons Debates, 1908, III, 5490. 27 Statement of Frank Oliver, Panada·;_;' Commons Debates, 1909, 480. . · · . . · ', ·-··-·-; ,-·, ~-· 28 W.L.Mackenzie, Report on Mission to England; op.cit., 7 • . 29 Ibid. 30 PC 1255, June 3, 1980. Quoted in Eric Morse, "Immigration and Status of Br±tish East Indians in Canada," 34. 31 ill!!-, 41. 32 Province, 20 0'.c tober, 1908. 33 J.B.Harkin to W.W.Cory, 20 November, 1908. Memorandum accompanying the . Report ·· on East Indians in British Columbia: !_Report regardin 9 the ·proposal . to . provide work in British Honduras for the indigent .- unemployed amon9st them. Published under the authority of .Frank Oliver, Minister of · Imrt .ew.±0r.~.o&909. Immigration Branch A.ec.69/70, Box 304- File 86552 ~ See a1·s o Colonel E. J.E. Swayne, "Confidential Memorandum on Matters ··Affec't ing the East · Indian Community in British · Columbia;" 20 December, 1908. Governor General's Numbered Files, Vol. 200,File 332 pa~t· 3(ia), PAC. 34 -Ibid. 35 Province, 23 November, 1908; Canada House Records, Ref. 25 A2, 'Acc.120/11 Vol. 200, ~AC • . 36 The Role · of -Te-ja Singh and the Committee for the Management of Silctl Diwans was noted in Chapter II •. The bribery charge. _will . prqbably·never be adequately documented. '-·'·- 37 · Lord Crewe to Governor General of Canada, 31 October, 1908, Governor Gep.eral's Numb~red Files, Vol. 200 File -332 part 2(b), 1908, 'PAC~ · ... 38 c';e\'i t ·o Grey, 19 September, 1908, ibid. Colo11ial Office to the Minister .of Interior, 23 November, 1908, Canada House Records, Ref. A2;' Acc. 120/11, Vol. 200, PAQ. -16339 The year 1917 is here included because, for the purposes of this. study,- the la.s t major colonial : conference was held in ~hat year. And it marked· the culmination of various att _empts ·to arrive at a satisfactory solution to the East Indian problem in the British -Empire~ .' . . . ,· , . 40 . Sir Keith Hancock, · A Survey of British Commonweal th Affairs, _op.cit.,· 1,74 • .. 41 Quoted in Toronto World, 25 May, 1914. 42 Ha:0.cock, op. ~it~, 169·. Similar sentiments were expressed · by ·Lord Hardinge, the Viceroy of India, Canada and India, _ 1 ( 1916) ~ · . · . . • . :· , _··_• 43 Hancock, op.cit., 169 • 44 Reciprocity of Treatment between India and the Dominions, . · ·attached to the memoranda pr.e par.ed by Sir S .P. Sinha, Immigration Branch, Vol~ '386 part 11, file 536999. Those resolutions were not always carried out. The Khalsa Diwan · Society · petitioned the Imm±gration Department in 1919, · protesting its · failure to carry out -the resolutions. Khalsa. Diwan Society t ·o Minister of Immigration and Colonisation·, June, 1919; Inqnigration Branch, Vol. 386 part . 11, file 536999; PAC • . 45 Immigration Act, Chapter 7, Section 38, subsection (b) ·and ( c), Statutes of Canada, 1910. 46 PC920 and PC926 cited in Narain Singh et.al., 18 British Columbia ·Law Report, 1913 ~ ·· 47 Petition from the East Indians to Crewe, quoted in Morse, op.cit., 66. 48 PC704, 6 April; 1911, ibid. 49 PC 3211, 16 November, 1912, cited in Eric Morse, 0 I:mmigration ~d Status of British East Indians in Canada," 68~ 50 Minister of Immigration and Colonisation to Governor · Ceneral-in--Council; 13 December, 1918, Immigration Branch, Vol. 386 part 11,PAC. -16451 . Memorandum on 39 Hindus, 12 February, 1914, Immigration Branch, Vol. · 385, part · 8, PAC • . 52 Narain Singh et. 1-;.al. ,. 18 British Columbia Law Report,1913. 53 PC 23 and PC 24, ·replaced Pc · 920 and PC 926 on 7 January,•1914. Cited in D~puty Minister of Interior to Maclean•s Magazine, 22 Sept~qiber, 1952, Immigration Bran.eh, Vol_• . 602 , File 883624 pa:i:-t 8, PAC. · · 54 PC 2642, 8 December, 1913. It was renewed by PC897 on .· 31 March, ' 1914. Cited :i,.n Sir Robert Holland, "Indian Immigration into Canada: The Question of ·Franchise," 1~8. 'This · order never .applied to · Japanese , and to the Chinese · ;i.:t; :was not applied till much .later. See Canada, Commons · ·Debates, 1914, 1222. Europeans were exempt from this order as:01most ·of · them enter.ed ·thro:µgh eastern ports. Moreover~ :;.,__ in many cases, the restrictions :were waived.~Se~: L"!M.Rortter to A~S.Monroe, 1 Apri;l, 1908; Immigra_tion Branch, voi.481, File .745162 ·: (Private); ·Memorandum .from the Department ·of·· · · Inte_ri0r, 12 March, 1913, ibid.·, Vol.561, File .8 08722, 20 March, 1913, ibid~ V.o l. 480, File 745162 pa:rt 2; W.D.Scott to C.E.Willeox, 'Immigration ·agent-in""'.charge at Niagra Falls, 6 March, 1916, ·ibid., Vol. 481, File 745162part ll}i PAC • .· .· ,,· .· .·~ :~• [:· .. . ~ ,. .. ' ill.9- 55 Kushwant-. Singh, ·A History of the Sikhs, Vol.II, 1964·, (Princetoh : PrincetonUr.ii versi ty Fress, 1966 )-;-r78. • • ·:· • . • ·. . • • • • ·• ••. • ! 56 Gazette of I:ndi~(Extraordinaryj, Government of India, · Home Politi·cal, 14 ·J·a nuary, 1915, 9. The Gazette reported the findings of Sir .William Vincent, H.Walmsley, Sir Bijjoy Chand ·Mehtab, P.J~Fagan and Sardar Daljit Singh who w.e re appointed :to Il:0ok into "the ~ho_ot_ing at Budge Budge (Calcutta) of pas~engers ··a board the ·. Koinaga ta ·:wraru · when it returned to India. · 57 Vancouver Sun, 27 May, 1914; see also Ram Sharan Vidyarathi, Koma7 ata lVIaru Ki Samudri Yatra (The Sea Voyage · of Komagata Maru ·-(Mirjapur : Krantikari Publieation, 1970). · ·This account gives Gurdi·t Singh' s side · of the picture. For · corroborative evidence,see correspondence relating to · - · ·Gurdit Singh in Immigration Branch, Vol. 601, File 879545 part 3 arid 5, PAC. 1 58 Ted Ferguson, AV ·t Canadian Prejudice Man's Countr • An Exercise in o : Dou le a.;y; ·Canas.a Ltd., 1975), 12. -16559 M~lcolm R.J.Reid to W.D.Scott, 8 July, 1914, Immigration Branch, ibid. 60 The Times, 23 May, 1914. 61 Canada, Commons Debates, 1914, 2369 and 4214. 62 See Literary Dige.s t,49,(18 July, 1914), 95-97; 8 August, 1914f 226; Minutes ·of a Public Meeting held in Dominion Hall, Vancouver, British Columbia, 23 June, 1914, Immigration Branch, Vol. 601. File 879545 part III, and various editorial comments in Vancouver ne~vspapers on the subject. '• • I 63 E.Blake Robertson to Minister to Justice, 30 July, 1914, Immigration Branch, Vol. 602, File 879545 part 5, PAC. 64 R.L.Reid, 0 The Inside Sto-r y of the Komagata Maru Incident, 0 · British Columbia Historical Quarterly, V,(January, 1941), 11. : . . ' , •• , '.· • • .• I . ·. ·•,, • : . • , ., • ' 65 In re Munshi Singh, 20 Bri ti.sh Columbia Eaw Report, 243. 66 Reid, ■,.cit ; see als~ ~ric S.M~rse, •s~me Aspects of t~e Komaga a Maru Affair, 1914," Canada Historical A~~ociatiori' Report, · (1936), 100-0 • · - 67 w.c.Hopki;~on to W.W.Cocy, 1 June, 1914, Immigration Branch, ·_V ol. 601, File 879545 part .II; ibid,, Vol .• 602, File ·sq~545 · part 7; Province, I Oc~·o ber, 1915; Ted ., Ferguso!l, Whiit'e Man• s Country, 33.68 Reid, 2Iriside Story," op.cit., 18. 69 Ibid.19 • . ;- ~~=- 70 The Report of H.G.Cloguston on payment of East Indians in conn,ection with the Komagata Maru incident _was found in Immigration Branch, Vol. 602, File 879545 part 8, PAC. ·see also Sir Borden· Papers, Manuscript Group 26 H l(a} _ Vol. 40, File OC 196 part 6, 17338-17369,PAC. 71 The Hindustanee, I (March, 1914), 2. 72 Three East Indians who had attempted to smuggle arms · from the United -states into Canada were arrested by the Canadian poli·c·e . The aim of the smugglers was -to put the -166... arms into~·the _hands of the Komagata Maru passengers! SeeW;.C.Hopkinson to W~W.Cory, 13 August; 1914, Governor Genera1•·s Numbered Files, Vol·• . 205, File 332 part 12(b), PAC. 73 Credible evidence of bomb making was found in the house of one Gurdit Singh in Victoria. See W.C.Hopkinson to W.W;.Cory, l7· September, 1914t Immigration Branch, Vol. 388, File_536999 part I (British-- J. See also Malcolm _R.J.Reid to W.W.Cory;-- 5 December, 1918, GovernorGeneral~s - Numbered Files, Vol. 208, ·File 332p:;1rt 16(b') , PAC. '74 A Note on the Revolutionary Movement in Canada, Immigration Branch, · Vol. J86 part II, PAC. . . . . ' 75 Malcolm J.R.Reid to W~W.Cory, 11 January, 1915, G Governor General's Numbered Files, Vol. 206, File 332 part 13(b), PAC. 76 Ray Gardner, J,fWhen Vancouver Turned Back the Sikhs," - Maclean•s Magazine,(8 November, 1958), 68. 77 Ibid. Ram Singh was acquitted at the trial. 78 Ibid.; see also Kuswant Singh, Ghadr (1966), 29. 79 Singh, ibid. Complaints against the activitie~ of Hopkinson were made as early -as 1910. The Hindustani Association had complained to .the Minister of ·Interior about the double deeling of Hopkinson but no notice was taken; See Hindustani Association to · the Minister of Interior, 29 July, 1910, Immigration Branch, Vol. 561, File 908722 i part I; Immigration Agent, Vancouver to W.D. Scott, ·· 5 July, 191'0, ibid. The latter contained allegations made by G:n:icumar. 80 · Ted Ferguson, .W hite Man's Countrt' 172; see also Gardner-, op.cit. ,68. Bela Singh, -af' er serving a·_ · year,~s imprisonment . for. assaulting. Lachman Singh on 16 April, -1915, had left for India on the advice ·of the Immigration Department. CONCLUSION This paper set out to provide a syst~matic description of the East Indian community during its first deeade of presence in Canada, and to examine the structural position of the community and the reasons for its lack of integration into the host society. This ' was done by examining four factors, the socio-economic background and motivations of the East Indian immigrants, the nature of institutional developments in the nascent immigrant community in Canada, the attitudes and perceptions of the members of the host society, and the policy of the Dominion and Imperial governments toward East Indian immigration. The picture that emerges of the East Indian community in British Columbia is one of an alienated minority ethnic group living on the social fringes of a host society. It was a socially truncated, potentially volatile, and politically sensitive community composed predominantly of male peasant sojourners who hoped ultimately to return to India to enjoy the fruits of their labours abroad. Internally, the community s~ffered from deep structural cleavages which resulted in bitter fights, violence and assassinations and left permanent scars on the image of the community. White west coast sociaty distrusted and detested the East Indian immigrants with even greater intensity than they ·did the other .Oriental groups amidst them, namely the Chinese and Japanese. The myth of East Indian unassimilability prevailed in the end. Why did not acceptance and integration of the -167- East Indians take place?·-; -·What factors militated 4gainst this? On one 1he:3Z:el, lack.of .accomodation was the result of vast differences between the cultures and institutions of India, specifically ~he Punjab, and Canada. These racial, social and cultural differences in the behaviour and outlooks of the East Indian immigrants and the white Cana~ dians tended to produce mutual hostility and friction when the two cultures came in contact. Such being the case, the possibility of East Indian acceptance and integration was limited from the outset. Beyond this essentially deterministic explanation, however, a furth~r question must be asked: which of the ' two sets of factors, those pertaining to the host society or those relating to the East Indian immigrants play the dominant role in the eventual alienation of the East Indian community? This study seems to indicate that the latter . . · played the primary:·.: rc;,l',.e :. Evidence for this was provided in the discussion of the motives of the ·immigrants and the nature of the development of the community in British Columbia. It has been seen that early East Indians in Canada · were not true immigrants, intending to become permanent settlers in the new homel~d, but were sojourners, temporary residents in the country, planning to return to their homeland when their primary goal was ach$eved. Not all the East Indian immigrants succeeded in this ambition but the desire and intent to return to Indiariprohibi ted._them ___from -169participating in the institutional system of the host country. Integration, of necessity, involved time, resources and money, all of them unnecessary impediments in the way of accomplishing the primary task. Therefore it was to be avoided. Thus, isolation and alienation of the East Indians from the Canadian society was largely self imposed. The nature of institutional developments in the East Indian community .furmher discouraged the process of integration. _Intensely nationalistic leaders and political:l.Jrganisations which had taken a strong hold on the life of many immigrants, indulged actively in agitational and conspiratorical politics, fully .aware .o f the hostility and bitterness such activities created in the minds of most members of the host society. But these effects were recklessly neglected. The radical activities of the leaders and the organisations tended to circumscribe the interpersonal relationships of individual East Indians with the white society ·at large. Those who did attempt to establish amicable links with the · host society, were looked upon with a good deal of suspicion and contempt by the majority of the East Indians. A case in point was Sundar Singh•e:whcr.-was branded a traitor to the East Indian cause. Another was that of a Christian convert, Jagat 1 Singh, who was severely beaten on atleast three occasions. As a result of both direct and indirect coercive pressures, the process of transforming primary group and ethnocentric values, and acquiring and learning new roles were -impeded, -170and consequently, the process of acceptance and integration was effectively curtailed. What·, then, was the role played by the host society in determining the process of East Indian integration? The host reaction solidified and isolated the East Indian community. Due to the activities of the white excl~sionists of British Columbia-~1. voluntary segregation by the Indian immigrants gave .way to forced segregation. The hostility also nurtured the love of the homel~d, a sentiment reinforced by communal organisations through such institutions as language, ethnic newspapers and nationalist politics. In a very real sense, the host ·society, too, played an important role in ·the alienation of the East Indians. But it must be emphasised that the stereotypical perceptions, the discrimination and the restrictive legislation contributed to, rather than created, this condition. Important as they were, they nevertheless played a secondary role. The East Indians were conscious and deliberate creators of their alienat:e d:'J. minority ethnic status, and not simply victims of collective discrimination by the majority white society. This study has shown that East Indian acceptance and integration into the Canadian society was the result of the interplay of factors pertaining to the immigrant community and the host society, in which the former played the primary role while the latter played an important but secondary role. -170a- FOOTNOTES - CONCLUSION 1 "Hindus in Canada," n.p., n.d. (United Church Archives, Toronto. -171APPENDIX Rules and Regulations of the Hindustan Association, printed in Vancouver on 23 August, 1910. Name: This Association shall be called the Hindustan Association. Object: To establish Liberty, Equality and Fraternity of the Hindustani nation in their relation with the rest of the nations of the world. members: Every Hindustani by his birthright is eligible to become a member of this Association, and om the following conditions: 1 ·. That he must solemnly sign an application that · he will carry out the objects of the Association to the best of his ability. 2." That he will eliminate the prejudice ot caste, colour and creed from himself. Admission: An application for admission as a member signed by an enlisted member, shall be presented to the Secretary or a . member of the Committee. This done, his name will be placed -172on the roll of members. Absent Members: The headquarters of the Association shall, at the moment be at Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada, but may be transferred to some other country or place if approved by .a general meeting specially and duly convened for that purpose. Managing Committee: ' Managing Committee will be chosen by ballot or vote in a General Meeting. Officers: Managing Committee will then choose the President, Secretary, Treasure:r,from am0Bgt themselves, and to so act as to constitutionally ?arry out the objectsTol the Association. Meetings Ordinary: meetings will be h.e ld every week to discuss and promote the objects of the Association. General·Meeting: A general meeting will be held every year to elect the Managing Committee, the members of which will retire yearly by rotation but will be eligible for re-election. Special ·Meeting: The President or the Secretary may convene such a -173meetin@~whenever (1) some special bylaws are to be introduced, (2) extraordinary expenditure are to be sanctioned, (3) special reliefs is to be extended to the Hindustanis, (4) a requ:i.sition is to be sent · to the Association signed by. atleast a quarter of the members. Fees Any member paying $1000 will be designated a patron of the Association. I Life Member: Any member paying $100 will be made a Life Member of the Association. Ordinary Member: · Ordinary members will pay a monthly fee of 50 cents in Canada and one Rupee in India, Departmental Services: The following services may be opened as far as means of the Association allow: 1. Immigration, Emigration. 2. Sanitary and Physical Training Bureau. 3. Social Advancement Service. 4. Educational Services Department. 5. Political Relations Department. 6. Trades and Commercial Development Services. 7. Justice Department. 8. Publications Bureau. ~174A qeneral Office will be established to look after the above departments and general work of the Association. Pri vil~es of Members: · · 1. A member will have free access to the quarters of the Association. 2. He will be allowed to vote in the government of the Association. 3. He will be entitled to represent the grievances to the Association, which will grant him every possible redress within the practical powers of the Association. 4. Personal matters will not be attended to in pre preferences to general matters at hand. Duties of Officers President: To preside over all meetingsi·,:. keep them in order, and carry out the rules and regulations. He will sign all documents for authentification, and will have the casting vote in case of a tie. 3ecretary:The Secretary will keep the minutes, records, convene meetings, carry on correspondence and make reports. He will solidify organisation of the Association; and authenticate documents by signing as the Secretary. He will have custody of papers. Treasurer: The Treasurer will keep a set of Account books, properly written up to show assets and liabilities of the Association, recimve and imburse money as sanctioned and -175directed by the Committee. He will supply securities for gcfod faith if required by the Managing Committee. He 'Nill submit an Annual Budget, render an Annual Balance Sheet, allow inspection of books to the members at their request by appointing a reasonable time for the same: keep all vouchers and recl¢d.pts and documents for evidence of transaction; have ail audit made by the Auditor appointed by the Committee. Managing Committee; The Committee composed of the members, will study the Will of the members, suggest reforms, deliberate at their meetings, carry out their duties as the delegates of the Special wards of Members which they may happen to represent. Donations: Contributions will be received on the approval of the Mamaging Committee at the dis:cretion of the President or the Secretary without any obligation on the Association. Receipts must be issued from the Treasury. Trustees: Two or more Trustees shall be nominated by the Committee to hold the property of the Association in their names as Trustees, subject to the approval of three quarters(¾) of the membership. · Scope of the Administration: The Association shall not enter into any trade or commerce. -176Extra Powers: Grant-in-aid, relief funds, borrowing power, collection from Public, ete. must be fully deliberated upon and sanctioned by the majority of votes in the Committee. Resolution: In regulation of all the affairs of the Association, whether in a General Meeting or the meetings of the Managing Committee, the majority will prevail, and the resolution thus adopted will be binding on the whole of the Association. Change of Rules1 Suspension, repeal, modification or further introduction in the rules and regulations will be made only at the V General Meetings, which will be only corrected by a notice to this affect to the members. Privileges:J of Absent Members: Absent members will not be sent any such notice,~,nor will their votes be counted, but their suggestions will be welcome. The~ will pay but $11.~0 per year as fee of membership. An annual report of ,t he proceedings of the Association will be sent to them. Their enquiries will be replied a:s l f':t;1lay as possible. They will help promote the cause of the Association abroad. Quorum: The Managing Com.-ni ttee will make the rule for quorum -177for themselves. The quorum for the General Meeting shall be ½ of the members. Officers Protem: In the absence of the President, etc. such officers to act protem shall be chosen by the Committee from themselves. · Sundar Singh, Secretary. SELECTED aEF~RENCES Primacy Sourpes I . Published A Governm·e nt Doc,u ments l Canada a Dqminion Canada~ Canada Gaz·e tte. _ _ _ • Ca!l:~da YearBook(l910, 1919) • --- • Commons .Debates.· --- • Commons Journals. _ _ _ • Repor~ of W~L.Mackenzie King, C.M.G., · ·Commi•s sioner Appointed to Enquire into ··. the' Methods. ·by ·which '0rierr.ta1. ·.~Labour-ers have· ·beerr'·Induc·ed ::to Come.. to·,,.canada·~,,..• .·· 1 ot. t awa ·•,: .. Govertunent·. ·Printing Bu.reau r'l908. . . . ' . . . ' . ~ ' . ••. , . - ·- .• •... . ' . ' .. • . .; . ; i .-.. : . • ---- · ~ "W.L.Mackenzie King, · C.M.G., Deptity r 4~nister of Labour, '6n His Mission :to England- ': to Confer with the British Authorities on the Sul:>ject of . IID!lligrati9n . to Canada ·from the Orient, and .lrriilJltgr~t~ipil~'. ·from ·India in Particular~" · Sessionar ,, . . ·. · : Pa;per · ~6~;,. T~98~._~· ~• · · :ne •. _ _ _ .·Senate Debates. , _ _ _ • Sessional Papers • --b • Statutes. Provincial . British Colll.ijlbia. Journals of the Legislative Assembly. .. : . I ---- • Statutes. -178- -179India 2 Prov~ncial. a ____• Punjab Imperial Gazetteers. ____• Census ·Reports District. District Gazette.ers. b B Punjab Administration Reports. Books and Pamphlets, etc. Broad, ·Isabella ·Ross • . An Appeal for Fair Play for · ·. · · Sikhs in Canada~ n.·p. , i913. : -. . Canada India Committee~ Canada and India - A Journa1··of . Information and Conciliation. Toron~o, :·19r5 ~ . ' . . ·. _ _ _ • The Hindu· Case. Toronto, 1915 • ' ' ----~ • A' Call for Canadian Justice. Toronto, 1915. _ _ _.• India's Appeal to · Canada. Toronto, 1916. ... ,··· Chandra,~~Rain. ·Exclusion ·of Hindus · from America '. . .. ' Due·' t 'o British Influence. San Francisco, 23pp· .· '· .\ U 'd · :·.... ··.· · · · ..:.... · . . . .. . Ghadr Party. · · Ghadr-di-Gunj {Echo of Mutiny). ·· ' .- · . San ·Francisco, 1914. . • Ilan-i-Jang (Declarat~on of War). San - - - Fancisco, 1914. _ _ _.• Naya Zamana (New Era). San Francisco,1914 • • The ·Balance Sheet of British Rule in .-e __,;_-.. -;.;.... :_\-~..- . India. San Franeisc·o , 1915. ·• A Few Eacts About British Rule in India. - - - San Francisco, 1915. Harkin, J.B. The East Columbia ..: .. ,."A :R o·· pro · ·wo· d " · sin B~itish osal r · he1· -Hon. · Frank ·Olive.r; ·Minister · of ·:tiie : Interior, 1909. -180- .Misrow, J.C. East Indian Immigration on the Pacific Coast. Stanfor,d , California, -1915. Reprinted , by ·-R- &·· E Research· Associates, ·_San Francisco, · 1970-~· Smith, W.G. A Study .in Canadian Immi~ation. Toronto : Ryerson Press, ,19 _ ~ _ · .· .. .. -~ . . . \... .; ... Woodsworth, James s. Strangers Within Our Gates, or Cominf Canadians • .Toronto . : Methodis Mission 'Press, 1907. · - ·, · ·C Articles Bose, Subhindra. "Asian Immigration in the United States." Modern Review, XX!/ (May, 1919), 524-26. "Can:ada's Rejection of the Hindu.n The Literary · - ,,. -· Digest, · 49 ( 8 August, 1914), 226. Dayal, R . . .The Disabilities of Indian Abroad." · - _ Modern Review; 41 (1927), 161-168. Dodd, W~D~ · "Hindu in . the Northwest." World Today, -_ · · XIII (Nov·ember, 1907), 1157-60. _ Grace, Elizabeth Ross. "Eastindian Immigration." Westminister Hall Magazine, 3, no. I ~1914;.?); 10--12. , · - - - · · -Grant, ½K.J. ·"Among the Hindu of British Columbia." · •Missionary Messanger -( 1915?), 106-109. ' .....· ' - . - Kawakami, ·K. "White ·Canada · : Canada's Oriental Problem." CaRada Month, XLII (December, 1913), 193-9. ·._-Kumar, Guru Datt. -"Hindus in the United States." " Span :of Life, - 5~ rto. 3 (March, 1912), 7-11. .... .. - .. . .. Lockley, Fred. ·· "The Hindu Invasion : A New Immigration Problem.'' Pacific Monthly, 17 (March,_ 1907), 583..;.95. - - - . _ - ··• , ""':. ' ·:· ~ Principal. "Problems· ·of Immigration, VII. Mackay, .. Komagata Maru." _Westminister Hall Magazine and -Farthest West Review, V, · · no. 6 ·{July, 1914) ,- ·5-9.- ' -181McGaffey, Earnest. "British Columbia and the · YeTlovr Man. n British Columbia Magazine, · VII, ·no~ 1(1912)·, 198-200.; · , ____ • "Immigration.;. Its Advantages and Disadvantages. 0 British Columbia Magazine, 8, ho.10 (1912), '725~27. . .. . Millis, H.A. "East Indian Immigration to British · Columbia and the Pacific Coast States." American Economic Review, 1 (1911), 72-76. ,."East Indian Immigration to the Pacific - - - - Coast." Survey, 28 (1912), 3g,9_ 86. "Sikhs Besie~ing Canada." The Literary Digest, 49 {18 July, 1914), 95-96. Wallace, William Stuart. "Canadian Immigration Policy." Canada Month, XXX (February, 1908), 358-61. ', · Williams, J.Barclay and Singh, S.N. "Canada's · New Immigrants." Canadian Magazine, · 28 : .- - (February, 1907), 783-391. · ·. . . D Periodicals British Columbia Magazine. Canada ·and · India. Canadian Magazine. Queen•s -Quarterly. E Newspapers The Daily British Colonist (Victoria). The .' .Dai·l y · News-Advertiser ·(Vancouver) • . ·.. . . . Province (Vancouver}~ . . . : ' . World , (Vancouver) ·. -· Victoria Daily Times. ~,-.,. . ' .,_ · -182The Aryan. Desh ·Sevak. The Hindustanee. ·· Khalsa Herald. Sansar. · ·' F Law Reports The British Columbia Reports. G Miscellaneous Empire Club Speeches. II' Unpublished .. . A Government Documents Canada. Departme~t of the Secretary of State. Correspondence. (Public Archives of Canada3. --~ : . Immigration Branch Papers. (Public Ar·chiv'es of Canada) • .• Governor General's Numbered Files. ----(Public Archives of Canada). B Personal Papers Sir R.L.Borden Papers. (Public Archives of Canada) • . . .. . . ;' .. " ' .. ,· S-i-:n:. W:t-fu.£:r~d· Laurier Papers_.· (Public Archives . Canada). --, of W•.L.Mackenzie King Papers • (Public Archives of Canada). ·, · · · · · T. E. Eg~!ton · Shore Papers. -((~Un-it.ea :'Chtl.rch -Ar.chives, '.Eoiohtqt~_) · ·· _. . C -183C Miscellaneous ltHindus in Canada." (United Church Archives, · Toronto). · ·. ·"Report re Hindoos at Vancouver." (United Church Archives, Toronto) • · Secondary Sources I Books and Pamphlets, etc. Allport, Gorden W. The Nature of Prejudice. Boston: . The ·Beacon Press, ·1 954. · Banerji, ~~lyan Kumar. Indian Freedom Movement Revolutionaries in America. Calcutta: Jijnasa, 1969. ,, ,. .: . Barth, Frederick. Ethnic Group and Boundaries: · · The So·cial Or anisation of Cultural Difference. e . Brown 9. Baudet; Henri~ Paradise on ·Earth: Some Thou hts on · Euro!ean Images o on- uropean an. Transla ed l'., by E izabeth Wentholt. New Haven and London: Yale University Press; 1965~ Beija, G.; Hofstead, B.P.; Wentholt, R. Characteristics of Overseas Migrants. The Hague; · 196T. · · · · · · . i: ' · -·' · ·• Brown; Emily C. Hardayal, Hindu Revolutionary and · · Rationalist • .Tuscon : Arizona University . · · .,... · · Press, _1 97 4~ Cheng, Tein-Fang. ·oriental Immigration in Canada. Shangai ·: The ' Commercial-· Press, 1931. Coedes, G. The Indiariised States of Southeast Asia. -. Honolulu ·: The Uni v:ersi,t y of Hawaii: Pres~, 1965. . • ' • . • • i •• ~~- •• 1;,·.. , •i , ., . . - ··~ •, ,- , • .•· : Das, Rajani ··Kant. ·Hindustani Workers . on the · Pacific · Coast. · Berlin : W. de Gruyter .& Co., 1,92:3•.-: ··: _·: ., ·•, .... . . ' . Deol ,- Gurdev Singh. The· Role of the Ghadr Party · in the Indian National Movement. Jullundur: Sterling Publishers (Pvt.) Ltd~, 1969 . ./ . . . Dli-armvir. Lala -I{ardayal and Revolutionat'ii · · Movements -of His Time. New Delhi: ndia Book Company; 1970. , Eisenstadt, S.Nii- The Absoqtion of Immigrants:~\ London : Routledge & egan Paul Ltd., 1954. · Elson, Ruth Miller. Guardians of Tradition : . American School Books of the Nineteenth Centur~ •. L.inco~',-Nebrask~ · : Uni'\7'~r~i t.! of Nebras a Press, ·1964. · ·· ·· · .. ,, ·.· .; · Ferguson, Ted. A ·white Man's Country: An Exe · • Toronto : Dou . • . . . . ·•.! .... . Ganguly, · Nar~ndranath. · . Indians in the Emaire Overseas; a Survet~Charl.e s F~eer An rews · Memorial' Volume.) -~ondon : New India Publishing · House , ;-: 1947. : .· '~ Gupta, Anirudh, ed • .Indians Abroad: Asia and ·· · _ Africa; Report ·of an International Seminar. -~ New ·Delhi ;: ·. O:riient · Longman•:s·;:"' -l:9nl ~-- ··:)~:::t·:: ·::-: · -· ;,;-,• ;.'_,"': . , , I _·GuptaBo:;a;~!!iy~m~fui~!ti~~;;o~~. Mov~~-~-~~ :- . ' . . •, '. . . . ;_ . . ... ,. . . . . ,- . • ·• . .. . . . , . . -· , : \~''.· ,d; Hancock~ . Sir Keith.- A Survef . ef the British Commonweal th Affairs. ~~ol. , I•• London : Oxford Uni versi-ty:•Press, ' -1937~ ··: : · · ,· Hardwick, F.'C. ,;a:led. From Beyond- the We$tern ... Horizon : Canadians ·-from the · Indian Subcontinent. . Canadian Culture Serie-s · , no. 4. Vancouver : ·Tantalus Research Limited, 1973. Hughes, David R. and Kallen, Evelyn. The Anatomy · · · Racism : Canadian Dimensions. Montreal : · · · Harvest ·House·, :1974. · · Isaacs, Harold J. Scratches on Our -Minds: American Views of· China and India. New York: Capricon Books, ·1 948. -, -- ,., -,., -dlackson, J .A •., e.d . .. Migration. Cambridge University ·· Press, 1969. . · · -185- Jain,RavindraK. South Indians on the Plantation ·· · Frontier ·in ·Mala_;ya. New Haven and London : -•- · - Yal_e .University · Press, 1970. -· · -~ ·. · · ·.· · Joshi, Vijay Chandra, ed. L . · ·, · . ol. I'-................"""""'"~..,...,.................6..-~-............. : ;:· · . . lishers ··" . Kessinger, · Tom G. · Vilyatpur 1 1848~1968 : _Social · · and Economic Change in a North Indian Village. · -~ -· · Berkeley : ··University of CaJ:ifornia Press, - 1974; ., · ·· · · · . .. · · · .. . · .. ·. Kondapi, c. Indians Overseas. Madras: Indian Council of World Affairs, 1951. Kroeber, · A.L. Anthropology. New York: Harcourt Brace and Co., 1940 • . Kurikawa, Minako, ed. Minority Resposes: Comparative Views o~ ·Reaction to Subordination. New York : ·Random -Reuse, 1970. · Lach, Donald. Asia in the Makinf of Europe. Vols. 1 and 2. Chicago: Universi y of Chicago Press, 1965, 1970 • . Mackenzie, Norman, ed. Lefal Status of Aliens in · Pacific Countries .• · ondon : Oxford University ·. Pres·s , -1937. · . · ·. · · Majumdar, Bimanbihari. Militan Nationalism in India and its Socio d. _ 'en~ral ·· . . _ E3i's, :t '. . . ' "· :'' '. <· ·... .; ·" . Mathur, La~i Prasad~ IndianRevolutionari Move. · · . ment :in the United States. New Delhi :_ s.. . · cfu.,iia, 1976. · . _ ·· ·< . - Mayer, Adrian C. "Report on the East Indian Community in Vancouver." Insti tute.aof Social and · Economic Re!:Jearch, University of British Columbia, 1959. · Nietz, John A, Old Textbooks S Arithmatic Geo . - · Readin · · s, _Grammar, · n< ommon -186- Price, Charles A. The Feat White Walls are.Bu.iltA · ·. · orth America an · · erra .. : ·Aus a; iona .. niversi y •· ress, 974. · • ·· Rai, Lala Lajpat. Autob±offllhical Writings. Edited by Y. C. Joshi. New De . _: University Publishers, · 196'5 • ' ' . ' .' ..,. ' ' . : ' '. . .. .. . .• . , I .· . . . Ray, Niranjan. The .Sikh Gurus and the Si:kh Society. Pat~ala -: ·-·Punjabi University, 1970. ~~dfield:?, .Rob~rt ~ reas~t Societ;y: and Culture. · . Chic.ago :· Uru_:versi ty of Chicago Press, 1956 • ..... .·. . :· --· . . ·: ,{:. ., . :. . ' :..... ·. .. . .-' . - . , ..... - · .. - . Saha, Panchanan. · Emigration of Indian Labour, 1834-1900.• Delhi : People's Publishing House,-- 1970;, :·· . .. ., -- · ·· _ ·._· ' · Sahot.a, Sohan ·Singh. Th 7 Desti¥: of the Sikhs. _ . · Jullundur ·: Sterling Pub ishers (Pvt .• ) Ltd., ·'··· •197r. · · Sandhu . ' Kernial Singh. Indians in Malaya : . Some · ration and~ettlement : ·'Cambr:i; ge . Yn.1.:versi y _.:- ..- • •; • ·. _-1 .. . : . ... _• • . • : . : ·~: : · · _ . Singh, Fauja. Emi s.:., Patiala ·;_- • ·ab. • Singh, Kushwa.nt. The Sikhs. London: Allen and Unwin Limited, l953. . I Singh, Kushwant. A History of the Sikhs,.Vol. II, · _ -1839-1964. ·P rinceton : Princeton Uni'versi ty Press, 1966. k:: · , · · : et.al. Ghadr 1915 : India's First Armed Revolution; New Delhi: R & K Publishing House, 1966. Spencer, Robert F., ed. lVIifhntion and Anthropolo~. · Seattle: American E ologicai Society, 19 O. Vidyarthi, · Ram Sharan. Komagata Maru ki Samudri _· · · Yatra ( Sea Voyage of-Komagata I't'Iaru). Mi:rjapur ·: Krantd!kari Publications, 1970. ' ' ' . . . Wolf, Eric. Peasants.New Jersey : Englewood Cl·iffs, 1966~ I -187II Articles Ames·, Michael and Inglis, Joy, "Conflict and Chap.ge in British Columbia Sikh Family _.,· Life." BC. Studies, no. 20 { Winter, 19731974), 15-50~ · · Angus, .H. F. "East Indians in Canada. International Journal, II (1947),47-50. 11 · · - · - · · ,-. "Legal Discrimination on Racial Grounds ·1.n British Columbia." Pacific Affairs, XXII •, {1949), 276--277; _·_._ · •. · . · · .I. ~- "Asiatics in Canada." Pac!t.flbc Affairs, ·-:•.-_,.-------""'XI...,-X; · no. · 4 -(December, 1946), 402-406. . . ,. ' .. ·- . '·- •·• :, · ' ' •. ~:.:..:"·~~:.. _,, . - : ·.• . · "The'· Legal Status in Bri ti.s h Columbia ----o-f Residents of Oriental Race and The.i r · decendents," in The Legal Status of Aliens · in··Pacific . Countries; ed. Norman .M ackenzie •. , ·· Oxford Unive·r si ty·:Press, (1937), 77-89~ ·: ·. ' ' . -~ . . . ... _. !. ·- • Antonvsky, Aron and Katz, David. "Bureaucracy - and Immigrant Adjustment." International . Migration Review, VII {1973), 247-256. Bayley, Christopher·. "Immigrant Minorities in -Netherlands: Integration and Assimil~tion." · · · International Migration Review; · -V · (Spring, · 1971), 18-JJ. · · Bhattacharya, ff~·t~I. "Indian Revolutionaries Abr.oa:d." . Journal of Indian History, 50. {1972), 1 415--30. - ·, · - .Boggs, Theodore H. "Oriental Immigration." Annals of the American Acadef of Political Science, · 107.;(May 1923) 5().;..5· •. : '· , · • · ' · . " ' . .. ' . . . - - • . . . 1· - · · · · - • "Oriental Penetration and British · .. Co·l umbia. n International Forum Review, . I . no. 3 (Jaj.y, 1926), · 11"".'19. · _- .·:. · · · '(1·--:, ...-, · ,. 11 ]3onac.i ch, Edna. ·"A Theory of Middleman Minorities. - · American Sociological Review, 38 (October, . 1973), 583~594. -188Bose, Arun Coomer." Indian Nationalist Agitations · in the United States of ·America and Canada till ·the arrival of Hardayal in 1911." Journal of Indian History:, 43 (1965), 227-239 • . Bose, Subhindra~ "Asiari Immigration in the United _ f?tates." Modern ·Rev,iew, X:X:V (May, 1919), -,524-526 ·:;-~.'-,-: .-··- -•::~_:-:.·--. . . . Breton, Raymond, "Ins.ti tutional Completeness of . Ethnic CommW1ities and Personal Relations of Immigrants." American Journal of Sociology, 70 (Septemb'er, 1964), 193-205. · · . · Brown, Giles T. "The Hindu Conspiracy, 1914-1917." Pacific Historical Review, XVII (1948),289-3'1.0. Chandrashekar, ·s. "Indian Immigration in America." Far Eastern -Survey, 13 (1944), 138-143~ . Crissman, Li~:- !!.The·•. Segmentary Structure of Over. seas Chinese." Man, 2 (1967), 185-204. . . . ':-:--~ ~ . Cross,· Robert D. ttHow· Historians have looked at Immigrants to United States." International Migration Review, II {1973), · 4'."'"13 • . .· . I , Dadabhay, Y. -"Circuitous Assimilation Among Rural · ·Hindustanis in. California,." Social Forces, · XXXIII (1954), . 138-141. ' · · · , . · .· · · Daniels, Roger. "Westerners from the East: Oriental Immigrants Reap~raised." Pacific ·· .... · Historical Review? x:x:xv -{'1966), 373-385. ' ~ ·, ·..... Dignan, D.K. ·"Hindu Conspiracy in Anglo-:-lndian Relations." Pacific Historical Review, XL . (1971) ·, 57-7'7. ,' · · ·, · '. ·. - Eisenstadt, S.N: !ID.h~ Place of Elites and Primary Groups in the Absorptmon of New Immigrants in Israel." 'The American · Journal ··o·f : Sociology, LVII (July, 1951-May, l952), 222- 23:l. - Gardner, Ray. "When Vancouver Turned Back the · Sikhs." lVIaclean•s Magazine, 8 November, 1958. Hess, Gary R. "The Hindu in America: Immigration · and Naturalisation Policies and India, -1891917-1946." Pacific Historical Review, 59-79. XXXVIII (196~h "The Forgotten American Asians: The East Indian_ Commµnity in the United States." Pacific Historical Review, XLIII ·· (1974), · ,, • • ! · • 576.;;.596. ·- · Holland,; Sir Robert. "Indian Immigration .into Canada ·: The Question of Franchise." The ·-- Asia:tic · Review~ XXXIX: (January, 1943)";- -'167-172. ·- Jayawardena, Chandra. "Migration and Social · - · · C~ange : A ·Survey of Indian Communities ·• e,;; _-. - Oversea·s ." Geographical Review, LVII (July, . - .. l968); 426"'."49. · . . Jensen; Joan IYI. · "Aparthied : The Pacific Coast · ·Styl·e ." Pacific Historical Review, XXXVIII .... (1969), 335-340. - •· - - -· Johansen,· Dorothy O. · A Working Hypothesis for The Study · of Migrations." Pacific Historical Revi·ew, ·XX:X:VI (1967) 1-12. _- _ . 11 Lal , Go bind Bihari • "Dr. Tarakna th Das in Free . India." Modern Review·, 92 (1952), 36-58. . ·- . ., . . . Majumdar, R. c.~•rutbing:ra.na/th~,-and the Indian ·Revolutionaries in: U~S.A." Modern Review, ·113 (1'963), ,453.;;;;54. · · Morse, Eric Wilton. "Some Aspects of the Komagata Maru Affair." 'Canadian Historical -Association Report, (1936), lOO-08. •. Naidis, Mark. "Propaganda of the Ghadr Party." Pacific Historical Review, 20 (1951), 251-60. · · Reid, Robie L. "The Inside Story of the "Komagata Maru. •1:.~Bri tish Col · · tori cal uarterl , V, no • l anuary, 3• Raucher, Alan. "American Anti-Imperialist and the Pro-Indian Movement, 1900-1932." Pacific Historical Review, XLII (February, 1974), 83-111. · · · · . -190Singh, Gurdial. "East Indian in the United · Stat.e s." Sociolo~r and Social Research, · JO ·(September, -1 5-August:, 1946}, . 209.;..216 • . ;,-,· _ •'•:~ ~ ., ·• ~.) .... ..... .,::-~· 0 Siu, Paul C. "The Sojourner. The American Journal of Sociology, LVI:II: (July,- 1952-May, 1953), , 34-44. -• . ·;·,.. · .' . . ' ·•. \.. ·.· . . .· - . '. ·- ·. . . . ' . .. . Smillie, Emmaline E. "An Historical Survey of Indian Migration Within the Empire." · Canadian Historical Review, IV, . no • . 3 (1923_); ·217.;;.'57-. . ·. ·. .·. · · ·. , Smith, Marion w. and Boulter, Hilda w. Sikh Settlers in Canada. n Asia and the Americas, 44 (August, 1944), 359;..64·. ·· · · · · 0 Vecoli, Rudolph J. European · Americans: From Immigrants -to Ethlb.tes." International Migration- Review, VI, no. -4 (-19-72), ·40311 434.,·. '" ·' .•' Ward, William Peter. ThEt:::Oriental Im:rµgrant and Canada's Protestant Clergy·." BC. Studies, nb. 22 (Summer, 1974)·, 9-19. 0 Wenzel, Lawerence. "Rural Punjab:i..s of California: · · a Religico-Ethnic Group." Ph.ylon, XXIX · (1968), 245-56. IIII Thesis and Essays __ Dodd, Balbindar Singh. "Social Change in Two Overseas Sikh Communities." Unpublished B.A. ·E ssay, Universit~ of British Columbia, 1_9 72. Donley, -W.G.-"The Ori·ental Agriculturalist in . British Columbia." B.A.Essay, University · · · of· .B ritish Columbia, 1928 • . Lowes, G.H."The Sikhs of British Columbia." B.A • . Es·s ay ;· 'U!Ji versi ty of Bri tis_h Columbia, 1952. Morse, Eric Wilton~ "Immigration and · Status of British East Indians in Canada: A Problem · . · in ·/__ _·Imperial Relations." Unpublished M.A. · · Thesis, Queen's University, , Kingston, Ontario, . ·1 9J6.· _____, -191Piggot, Elenora. "Dominion Government Polilpy on Immigration and Colonization, 1867. · · 1938;" -M.A.Thesis, University of British · Columbia, · 1950. · · · Stern, Bernard. "American Views of India and Indians, 1857-1900." Unpublished Pn.D. ··· dissertation; :·•Uitiversity of Pennsylvania, 1956. . · Straaton, •Karin. "The Poli ti cal System of the ·. Vancouver · Chinese Community: Associations and ·Leadership in the Early 1960's. Unpubli~hed M.A. Thesfus, University of · British Columbia, 1974. Ward, William Peter. "White Canada Forever: British Columbia's Response to Orientals, st ·1858-1914. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Queen's University, Kingston, OOntario, 1972. Ward, William Peter, "John Chinaman." Unpublished · paper, 1975.