3 5887 ; -·I•... ~•'-< . ~ e . NAME OF AUTHORI NOM DE C AUTEUR ___N_o_rma..;._ n_L_._B_u_c~h_i_,g,:__n_a_n_1_ · - -- Identity: ; CANADIAN THESES · ON MICROFICHE · - Biblioth~e nat i onale du Cana.da N~ti onal Li brarv' of Canada · . - THlSES CANAD/ENNES .l -SUR-MICROFICHE ---·- - - --'---- - - ·-'' ·- --,-- - -- - -- - - An Examination of Fiji~n East Indians in 1 British Columbia. UNIVERSITY / UNI VERSITE-~ - - -- . ' DEGREE FOR WHICH THESIS WAS fll'!ESENTED / , , ' GRADE POUR LEOUEL CETTE THESE FUT PRESENTEE~---=P....:h;:..;''-"D'-.'--- -- - -- - YEAR TH IS DEGREE CONFERRED / ANN EE D'OBTENTION DE .CE DfGRE_-"1=9~7~7~ - -- - - -- - --'-~ --- - ~ -- - - - - - - - -- - ~ - . - .,/' -- - - - -- - -- - -- NAME OF SUf'..ERVISOR / NOM DU DIRECTtUR DE TH£Sf_ _=P~r~-~M=i=c=h=a=e=l~K=e=n=n,.,.y,_-_ __ Permission is. hereby granted to . the NATIONAL LIBRARY OF L'autor;sation est, par la presente, 8'CCordee b la 8/BLIOTHl• . QUE NATIONAL£ DU CAIVADA ..de microfilmer cette tMse et CANADA to microfilm this thesis ano t o ~ or sell copies ~') . . . of the film. de preter ou de, vendrf). des exemplaires du film. _ The author reserves other publication rights, and neither the. L'auteur se reserve Jes autres droits de publication; ni, la thesis nor extensive extracts from it may be print.eel or other- tMse ni de longs extra its de ce/ltt-ci ne doivenr etre imprimes . Wis~ reprod~ced withol!t the author ' s wri:,, . . 'i . ~ ~ ou autrement ·reproduits sans J'autorisation ecrite de /'auteur. permiS:sion._ DATED I DATE_ _~M =ac=.y,__=2~4~•-=c l~9~7~7 _ _ _ SIGNED/SIGN{_~~~~~----------- - - - -- ------ PERMAN ENT ADDRESS / RESIDE NC£ Fl xi___ .. l ...3...1~9__..E...a....s.ut~3.,_7._t-h.._Au..x.v,...e..,n....u...,.e"-lt>------ - - -- - -- ~ -- - - - - - - - Vancouver B. C. J ,. I ♦ · National Library of Canada Bibliotheque nationale du Canada Cataloguing Branch ', Canadian Theses f?Ivision Direction du catalog age . ·. Division des theses canadiennes Ottawa. Canada K1A ON4 NOTICE AVIS The quality of this microfiche is heavily dependent upon the quality of the originat thesis .submiHed for rrnc rofil m.- . ing. Every effort has been made to ensure the highest quality of reproduction possible. - La gualite de cette microfiche depend grandement de la quatite de la these sou mise au microiHmage; Nous avon_s tout fait pour assurer ,.me qualite superieure de reproduction. ..,. 0 If pages are missing, contact the university which S'il manque des pages, veuillez communiquer avec granted the degree. ..., ~ .. =- = l'universite qui a confere le grade. -, 0 Some pages may have indistinct print especially if the original pages were typed with a poor typewriter ribbon or if the university ·sent us a poor photocopy. , La qua.lite d'impression de certarr7,es p·age$ peu_t laisser,a desirer, surtout .si tes,.pages originale? 9nt ete dactylographie_es a l_'aided'un ruban use ou si l'universite· . nous a fait parvenir une photocopie de mauvaiM qualite. Previously. copyrighted materials (journal articles, published tests . etc.) a:re not filmed. . , Les documents qui font deja·l'objet d'un droit d'au-. teu r (articles de revue. examens pub lies, etc.) ne sont pas .... microfilmes. . · . \, Reproduction in f~II or in part~ t.his f~lm is .g overned by the Canadian Copyright Act, ~.C. 1970. c. C-30. Please read the authorization forms which accompahy this thesis. La reproduction, meme parheHe, de ce microfilm est soumrse. a la Loi canadienne sur le droit d'auteur: SRC 1970, c. C-30. Veuillez prendre connaissance des formul,es d'autorisation qui accompagnent cette these. ~- THIS DISSERTATION HAS BEEN MICROFILMED EXACTLY AS RECEIVED LA THESE AJ~TE MICROFILMEE TELLE QUE NOUS L'AVONS REQUE L, C I • - ------------- --..; , IMMIGRATION, ADAPTATION, AND THE MANAGEMENT OF ETHNIC IDENTITY: . AN EXAMINATION OF FIJIAN EAST 'INDIANS IN BRIT1SH COLUMBIA .. 0 . . - - - ~~ - - ,, ·-•-•- - -~--- . Norman Leroy Bue hi gnani ' . . . M.A.,, ca·i:t.for.nia State University, Hayward, 1974 ' \, •.: -:_-- •~ccc'cccc7-:,l - z , , I.. •• , ;/ A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIA~ FULFILLMENT Of THE REQUIREMENTS FOR TH~-»EGREE OF. DOCTOR OF PH1LbSOPHY '1n the Department' · of Sociology and Anthropology -0 ~ , •. Nonnan Leroy_ Buchignani 1977 Simon Fraser University May 1977 ---~ - - ~ ----- ,: . Al.f ri-ghts_ ~~sell'ved. This'•thes_is may not- be · r e y r ~- -i--n-whe-le---e-r- m~,-by---photoco;py ··or; other means, without permi ss i on of the ~author. 4 0 c-. ' -- ,- --~----"- . .------ . -ii- ,.__ . -'~': -- - ---- - Appr6-¥-al Name: - Norman Leroy ~uchignani Degree: Doctor oaf Philosophy~-: · .· Title of Thesis: " .. l Irrm1g.ration, Adaptatibri and the Managemerit _ of, Ethnic Identity: - An E?(~mination .of Fijian East Indians in Britis~ Columbia ·•~/ . Examini11g Committee: f: t,~7 ( j \ ~ tl::F.-- _Cha frmin :'"·-; ,_.Roberr ~.11 i e· - . . .--. . . .. - ·; . ·- = = f .,,.- ~< '. Michael G. Ken - · Senior Supervi-:: Hamish Dickie-'Clark . Noef _Dyck Dr. Grace ~nderson o. •External Examiner Professor. of Sociology· and ·Anthropology Wil f r_ed Lauri Uni vers i tY· . · ·_ WaterJ ~o; Ontarfo' _ er .-.,,-. ~--- Date Approved: ,_ ,. . ,, . . . -··-··· ----~ ,. - . - PARTIAL COPYRIGHT 21CENSE -I hereby __grant to -Simon Fraser Unjversity the right to le:nd . . ~Y tneii~, project or extend~d essay (th~ title of which is shown below) "'." c, t.;Se""S of +he S•r--:0,1 f="rase;: Universi-ty Library, an:d to make partial or s:"g le copies only. for such ~sers or ij\,response to a r:equest from the o f any otner university, or othe r .educational instit_ution, on -' i ts own beha If o r . fo r :one of its user s . I further agree t _hat perm i s5 ion ! ib rar/ • purposes may ,be '" grarhed 0 '.'or r-iu!tiple CODyir,;fot 7~1is work for scholarly - - - - ·--· . ...-v- ..-:s - -· " ••• -· - -;- -..ll. ·-- ---~- ·- ... -- ' - . .., - - ----- ~ ------ -':-y me or the Dean c:: Graducte Stud ies. · It· is unders+ood that co·py i ng ; c~r :-uol i ca .t i o n of t h is ·..:or k tor. f i nanci a I gain ·.sh~·L I not be a I Io wed my 1~-r i tt~o perrr:i ion, ~ ,.; ; T-fl'.)U7 . •·..;.. ~ ~ 55 ,,. "'- Thesis1/ 0 roject/Extended Essay TiT~~ 6f ·, Irrmigratlon, Adaptation, and the Manag~t of Ethnic Identity: ... ~ (I An Exam:ination of Fijian E.ast Indians in British Columbia•. e,, _--_:.JT'"1,:;r: , -~~~-~~--'--------;,-...;.._- . ..., . Norman L. Buchignarri,._ - . May 24-, -19-7-7 . - ·------ -- - - -- - Q -iiiAbstract This thesis is an examinafi_ on -~of fFielimiTgration of Eas.,t Indian pe:opl e . - .., j . , ,. 'from Fiji to British ·Cofombfa (;1960-76). _;, As such, '"it_h.as 3 brdad objec ~· tives. The first" objective is t,o describe an~ explain the processes b_y_ . . ' -- . ·. . .- :. . ~ . ._. . - • ·_ _,.- - ., . . . . 'v- . . ' . .. . . ~ . . . ... ·-which over . 9,000 Fijian East Indians have co.me to Canada -0ve r the past' -15 -years. The second ob_jective is to des·c ribe the waysi in which these new - b Canadians h~ve · materia l ly;· socfally~ and ideologically adapted . fo life in . ~ the Lower Maim and- of· ifrHi•s11- cdi-□mb·i·cr. · Because this· .thests- f s · ·the ·Tfrst · · -·· --,---- "·--· ;det~i ~led study ;of a contemporary Ea_~ t Indian community carried out in this ~ - ~ provi nee, it concentrates upon those aspects of the inini grati oi_,, and seftl e--- ·-·-. _,, - -- ----- · ·.:•:. .. _: . .. ·--·-~ ~- - --_:_- - . ::::.-•.. ·::,,r"-·: --~ --- ment ' of Fiji~ns with which other Asian ilTiTiigran~s must ·also deal. These . . . ,· . . . . . . . areas ~_femphasis include analyses of initiaL Fijf~n ~stablishment in Can:. ada, their development of sources of fncome and their place i' n the prov-: .,. . . . ~ . incial economy, patterns of housing, geographical settlement, and expenditure, the structure of Fijian CaAadian household and colTITlunity, and the nature of social relations between- Fijians and -ot.her Canadians. The :tl'lird· - _ objective of this thesis is to contrast and co.mpa~e Fijian Ea~t Indian ~ &- " • • • irmtigrati-p-n ~with earlier Asian irrmigration to BriUsh Columbia; The the~ 'fs is based primarily upon_ parqcipant observation ·fieldwork, . carried out by the author in th~ Vancouver area between December, 1974 arid January, 1977. This anthropologically-derived data base was augmented by \ a·rch1vai' research on ~e history of A~ian ·ilTITiigration to Br_itish Columbia. It was found that like earlier- Asian ilTITligration and settlement, that of Fijian East Indians is highly dependent upon the extensive ·activation of.kinship networks. Fijian ilTITiigration is predominantly chain migration, and kin-based mutual aid assists individuals financially, infonnationally, and psychologically in making the initial .transition to Canadian life. . . .- . '."iv ... -- -· ~evert_l'lel_~ss_. j t__ Wah _fQufid thatlUian irrrnfgration was a~so s_ubjec:t to . . ... - - • ,· · ~trong sociological. ai;i-d personal corrsfratnts; particular}~ _important fac:,.:. · · \•. ·_ to'rs ·were the hbu:sehoHI tiead ~ place in .t he Fi,Jian economy, fhe develop1 . -mental stage of the family, pnd the perceived degree o(riJk incurre~ by . : . . ... . i~igrating· -tC>_ Canada.· It was also fourid that in Canadcf be{n-e fit·s of mutual • · ·· ~id were largely restric·ted t? the househoJd. , economy a,:idto Fij .i an Canaty -~---~; ~n s-oci al organ i za ti~~-~-~~r instance; _Fiji ans have h~~---g-~-e.~!:_? !ff i cul -----· ·-- .. ··. ~ -- . in securing jobs approp~iate to their qualifications, chiefly d~e tQ .· ?, ·.... • • • • • - .. ' • - . J ' ".various . difficulties in translating ' theirFijia·n· work experi~nce into . . . . . ·· tanadi an terms; Fifi an -soci aTfletworks 'have rial mitigfted :-'t tifs pri::rblent Despite the resulti-ng low individual in_cOIT!es, it was ·found that mutual -, as:s·istance, combined wjth the tendency to fonn large ho~sehold -U{lits, · _,>~ • .· _.,, . an owed Fijians particular advantages iQ the quick achieveme"tit of h"ome ownership. It was also dis.covered that . house -preferences _have led to a 7 very high Fijian geographica.1 concentration in East Vancouver ·. Fijian Canadians constitute a newly-coalesced conmunity which is experiencing ~apid assimilation to Canadian norms and practice~ whenever doing -so does not involve severe so·cial or economic costs; These adaptations result both from a Fijian flexibility in adjusting to new practices and beliefs and from the relative absence of the severe economic and social constraints under which earlier Asian irrrnigrants to Canada laboured. It is argued that ongoing assimHation is resulting in a continual tradeoff of the advantages of Fijiani-s Fast Ind-i an ettrriical1y;.;5asect sacral organization for increasing class-based i11formati~l, educatio.nat-,--and- occupational advantages . ' . .------ --------- --= ,-'-~----_:,___:_ -v- , (? --·· _, ~ Ackn·owl edgements - ... ..,;._\' / • 0 1 would fi ke to ,th.ank Dr. P.A. S. Sa ram for di rec ti nq me towards· thi- ·• • •-·•-- ••- •- · • --- ~ - • - -,, Dr • .Hamish Dickie-Clark and.. 'Dr. Noel Dyck qlJ helped in :their own way to make ·.this thesis a reality. -~ -_I would -llke• to a.-tkhow1ettge" the corrt,nuous-financtar' ittpport oT tfie __, Qepartment of Sociolo.~y and Anthropoldgy which I received during th1s research. A Simon Fraser. University Graduate Res·earch ·Stipend al low~d me to concentrate upon the final organization of the thesis.without inter, ruption . I am especially grateful for the considerate help and understanding of the Fijian Canadians with whom 1 worked, especially Mr. Alber·t Jayant. 0 ,.. t . ; Table of Contents r--- Title Pag~ i Approval Page ii Abstract iii Acknowledgemerrts "' V List of tables -- . List of Figures, Graphs, and Maps xiii Introduction Chapter One: Chapter Two: ·l The Setting Sojo~rners: the Chinese The Chinese in the Economy Setti[lg the Ca-ste line : .,. FormaJ Re·stri cti ons against the\Chi nese The Jk;ianese · · · Chinese and Japanese IITITiigration Cur!Ss The East Indians Protest against Restriction "Entrepreneurial Activity The End of the ~irst Era of Asian I1T111igration • Ethnic Relations in Earlj B~itish Columbia: a settler society A Resource-Based Economy Subordination Asian Reactions to Subordination Home Government Support Political Motivation Political Knowledge CoIT111unity Structure Economic Motivation Skills Social Organization and the E~onomy The Modern- Sett-ing: East IndianS--i-n British Columbia after Worl~ War II Tbe._Mrui_ern_Economy __ Notes Fiji, Fijians, and Fiji Indians Toward a S~ar Economy The Process of Indenture 5 5 7 9 12 13 18 20 33 34 35 38 40 42 45' 46 48 49 50 · 50, 51 52 52 _ _ _fil__ 64 77 83 84 C - .. . - _- _:_-_- Chapter Two:• (continued) Homogenization and Subordina'tion: th~ voyage ~· The Lines · Work The Early East Indian COITITIUnity Fiji in the 1920's and l930's: the COITlllUn i ti es . fijian~Indian Relations· Political Otganization• After__tha.. War:. .... Economic Takeoff Independent Fiji Fijian Indians Today: a S1.1111Tlary Notes Chapter Three: I . . ° Chapter Four: 87 87 89 90 94 l 01 104 1.05:- · ·- . - . · - ... · - 109 112 . 115 118 IIT111igration · 123 A Descriptive History of Fijian 123 ~:· ~ IITITJigration to C~nada . . Fijian lITITJigration tg Canada, 1962 to 1976 130 Ethnicity andCitizenship · 1°34 Age and Sex Distributions 135 Occupational Class i~d Education , · 138 . Typtca l Irrrn,igrants and their Conc;erns 144· Ill111igration Detenninants: the societal context 148 Immigration Determinants: the individual context 154 Initial Resources • J 54 Choice Considerations: younger irrmigrants 156 Choice Considerations: older iffllligrants 158 Irrmigration Determinants: women 162 The Ultimate Constraint: Canadian irrrnjgration regulations 163 The Processes and Mo.tivations Behind East Indian Irrrnigration, Past and Present 165 Chain Migration and its Consequences. 168 Fijian Indians in the Canadian Context 169 Notes ~· 171 Matuse· as . a Home · 258 259 · Expenditure and Models for It • ---zs-g~ --.. --· rlo'rrs-e furnfsmngs; P-ubi'ic a-ri'd Pr, vate Status, Confonnity Pressure, anti · Tradition· · · 262 264 Cars Food and Smaller Expenditures 265 -ix- .. Chapter Five: (Continued) Patterns of Expendi_ture: Hindu · Protestantism, or limited demand? · Functionality and Purchasing . ~tionality a·nd Purchasing · Cash am:1 Credit ... · · An Economy or-Needs . Assimil·ation .and the Economy of Needs · Notes · . . .~ ' I 267 270 2,71 272 274 275 276 ·-wttntn·-nres-e--:- Wa-1 ls-:·~- ·r iJfa-n-. cana:cti an · · Chapter Stx: 0 .. '. \ f · _ · · - 281. ~ - .re .. ; : . cot .·· ·.. ·-- · ~'. ..o: ·• . - ~. I .' _ , .' 'l • : : ... . 9 ----· · · -·-- --- ----··· ------- ···- - 284 287 288 :Primary Genera.tio,:i _Couples · , .A;s~endant_ Generation Couple·s 291 , · Sources \of Power . 293 . 293 Visitors Dependency .294 · -295 Depe~dent Chi,l dren · _ 297 · Potentially Independent Childr~n Married Children . 299 . 302 . Other ~ei'cendi ng G-e neratfon Cou~s Potentially Independent Adults · 303 Household Residential Structure in the Overview · 305 Female and Male Roles ·.306 Ideologies of Superiority and Inferiority: the view from the top 307' .3U8 .The View from Bel ow Male and Female Realities 309 Male and Female Conflict . 312 Chi 1dren: people ·of two worlds · 316 Television and Chilaren of .all Ages 318 . Childre~ and Adults . 320 Notes 324 --- - -------- ·-·-- --- ~- - --- - ---~ ·····- Chapter Seven: - Household tife Generalization and RealifY .. · The Extended Family Househald and It~ . · • -__ ,JnterriaL Re lat ions ~ . stc1J:us -" p.ower ~- ·{ · .. securf ty ~ and the COl.ijn-e. of ' au thori tY Signtffcant Competitors for Status a·nd Power:: · .. .,. ~ - - - - -- -- ···- CoJJITluni :ty: Fijian Sdeial Relations in the · Urban Context ·---------Kinship Networks: .the structural bas.is . . 328 of co111T1un i ty . Kinship Networks as Ethnic Networks: three Fijian COlllllunities 329 Kinship Networ~ as Class l{etworks 331 ..... ····-··- ··· -··-·-·--· . - - - -·- . __ . ..____ ----- --------·----- . .. - - 328 - - -- ----- - -------- . --~ - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - Chapter S~ven: • ( Conti nu~) The Structure of Soci&l Relatioosi ttfe "empirical pattern. Fiji a·nd Vancouver as One CoTIJTJunity Vancouver and Outlying ColTlllunities The Uses of Social Networks Religious COfJlllunities Fijians and Hinduism The Personnel ·· Ufe-Cycle Rituals \ -· - Marri:age - --- --- Death · ~ Hindu ~6usehold and Public Observances Annual Hindu· Cel\brati&ns Hinduism and Corrmunity t4oS4ffi-S ·~ Life-Cycle Ritugls · · Ho~sehold and Public Observances· ' .Moslem Fijians as a Corrmunity Fiji an Religious Corrmunitie5, EstabJ i sti· ment, and Direction s·ecular Associations and ~Corrlhun.ity Events Economic Bases for CoITJTiun~ty · · Fi Jtah C.orrmuni-ty and 'Its Puture: centrifugal and centri p·eta 1 t~hdenc·i es ,, , Notes · - 332 335 339 341 344 344 . 345 ·. 345 . . - 347 .. ~-~- --- -~~~----• 349 351 354 355 ·356- -·- - •---------· ------- ------357 358 361 362-. 363 364 36fi ' Q .Fijian Indians in Canadian Society: Social Constraints, Social: and Self Iden.ti ties, . -• , ·. . . {he- Social and Sel.f Identities of· Fijian . Iodians in. va·ncouver·. . · · 376 The Selective Corrmunication and. Distcirtiorf of. Social ,Icfentity ·. 37-9 1 ·InteractionalChannels ~ _,. 380 ,· I ntraethni c Channe 1 s ·. -·. 385 . · Media Channe is 385 · Reception and Integrp.tion 380 . , -Critique of Materjal Culture . -· ·. , 391· -~riti.q~es. of Social and Interaotiona.r _ Practice · · · . . · • .. · 391 / 'Interpretation and Ideological Defense · 391 "The Pre~entation of Self: - announcfog .. TfJ~ra:rr identiir- -~:~~- ~- , -~~ 395 11 11 ·East Indians·as Hindus : 'attempts at folk understanding . ~98 399 · Canadian Ideals and Ethnic Stigma Social Identity and Structur~ · 404 Chapter Eight: 375 · · _ · . -xi- .. - Chapter Eight: (Continued) I. tae Constraints Dtscrimination and _., of Ethnicity Cl ass Fijians, Caste, Notes. 405 409, 411 a{c! 1 ~ . 412 Con.cl us ion List-of References . 419. Appendix I: :,_434- A Bjblj_o.grapby of" East Indians ·in· Canada ... . \ C ., .,.., / f- • . -xii. · · · Li st. of Tables • Tabler .• Table III . . {. . Ch1J;~\ Workf_orce Pa~tici.patj~n, 1885! !' Provin_()al_ ' ~· . • ., -· ,_,_ __ _ __ - _.. • e . . ·.. ! • -~ . ·•. •. ·' .12 Eas·t'I.ndian IIIDligradon to Canada, Fiscal Years i 904: to 1908. · 21 East ·Indian Irrmigraticm, March.:n, 19-0~- to Mar.ch 31, 1920. "' · · · '-Jo . Table IV East Indian- InJ11igra~ion to Canada, 1956 to 1975. Table V ._Chine~e,.Wprkforce Co~position in ~-ictori_a',. . ._,. _ 59 0 1\,a4. · 66 ,67 Table VU P~ovincial Asian Workfofce Compositi6n, 1925 . . ·· ' . Provincial ~sian Workforce_ Composition, 1940. Tab'le VIII Asian InJTiigrat-ion to Canada, 1,886-'1919. 69 Table IX East Indian Workforce Participa~ion·, 1934-1946. 72 Tabl ~ VI 67 r Table X . OccupatiOAS of Indians in Fiji, ' 1911. . , , 92 - Table XI Fijian InJTiigration to Canada, to April, 1976. 130 Table XII · jntended Occupation of Fijian InJTiigrants, ·19727"1974. 139 Tab1e· XIII Intended Occupation of Fijian lnJTiigrants, 1975, by Spee.if i c Categories ._ ·- 140 Table XIV Fi)ian Indiarr Wage and .Salaried Labour, 1972, by Sector. 141 Table XV· Educational Achievement of Fijian IITITligrants, 1975. 143 Table XVI · ,·Folk Vie~s Contrasting Fiji and Ca(tada. 161 Table XVII 174 The Canadian lnJTiigrati.ori Point Syst~. Table XVIII Distribution of East Indian Entrepreneur.i.al 1fci¥ertising~--229 Table IX~ .Intended ' Destination of Fijian InJTiigrantsi J_97~, ·-xfi i - . :_ ·· . .· . List of Figur:es"'.Gr,aphs., and Maps ---------- -------- -- -- - - - - - - - - - - - · - - - - - -~ - - ~ ~ - • Page._ · Figure l. Fijian IJTJTiigratibn t6. Canada (numbers by years), · 'to April , 1976. (gJLaph) . Fig~re 2. .• The Age DistributjOn of the Population of Fiji~ (5 year segment$), 1974. _ · · (gJLaph) . Figure 3. ... 129 . . The Age Distribution of Fijian IJTJTiigra-nts\fc> Cana-da- ,~---. . Numbers b_y Age {5 year segm_ents). " __ · _ · (g11.aph) 136 l . 136 . Ftgure 4. Sex -Ratios of 19-74 and 1'975 Fijian Irrnnigrants to Canada~ by p.ge. (gJLaph) - 137 Figure 5. The Sequence of Fijian-Canadian Housing_. Figure 6. The Geographical Boundaries of Preferr~d Fijian House Types. (map) 245 'Fijian East Indian .Residential Distributions in the Lower Mcti nland. tma.p) 246 Sikh Residential Distributions in the Lower Ma i nl ~ nd , l 959 . (map) 247 Sikh Residential Distributions in the Lower Main l an_d, 1976. (map) 248. Figure 7. Figure 8. Figure 9. (,£..Uu,6:tfta.tion) 236 r :, - .1 - Introduction . ·- ·-·----·-· . ' Since-the l960 s, when the Canad·iari j_mmigration regul?-tions were 1 loosened to ailow non-Europeans to apply on equal tenils with those from t~aditional · source countries~· the variety of i111T1igrants to Canada has -· greatly increased . One consequence of this change f<1r British Columbi'a-- · · has been th'e ris·e of a set of new corrmunities~of Asian immigrants, comp- ·1ementing the Chinese, Japanese, and Sikhs who ·have been here for over seventy years. East Indian people fro~ Fiji are one of these new groups. This thesis is .an examination of the immigration of Fijian East .Indians to British Columbia and their adapta,fion to life in the Lower Maini'and ~-. from 1960 to 1977. _The objectives of this work have be~ largely determined by .need and method. The primary goal is to describe the structure of Fijian East Indian irrrnigra~ion to Canada and to explain why that structure has taken · the form which it has. The descripti.ve,, nature of this objective· has been _ shaped-by the paucfty of prior research -on Asians in Canada; Appendix I constitutes virtually the entire corpus of printed and academic material upof East Indians in Canada. With the exception of a brief investigation ~the Vancouver Sikh conmunity done by Adria·n Mayer (1959), the..;e have ---- -. been no comprehensive sociological s.tudies done on East Indians fo Brttish CJ 1 Columbia since the late 1920 s (Cheng 1931}. . B-ecaus.e of this. empirical vacuum~:~ I do no_t feel it justifiable. .t9 concentrate upon a narrow aspect of -Fijian East Indian i11111ig_r,a_tio_n i:_o ,. British Columbia. r . Neith~r have I chosen to develop a single theoretical theme or an overarching hypothesis. Nevertheless., tt}is thesis is not _an ethnography in the Rorina l sense of the- word, r '/ . certain areas of Fijian Canadian _lif~ to the ex~lusion ofpttiers. Both the immigration of Fijfans to Canada and their subs~quent . adap. . . e . tatiop to Canadian s~ciety are currently under, radical flux._. There were· · 0 virtually ,:;~Fij_i ans in Canada in 1960, and now the.r e are over· 9,000 of_ __ _ them. More tha,r half of those in the Lower Mainland ha;e .come since -1972: ·• 'It ·c Moreover,. they are a heterog·eneous populatidn to begin with, made even more so by the variety and depth _of their adaptations tp Canad'fan Jife . . Consequently, I have concentrated .upon those areas where relatj vely corrmon -- constraints abound. I have pl.aced il heavy emphasis upon the societal constraints under which these new Canadians mu~t 1ab6tir. My primary research methodology was participant observati'on, carried out between December, 1974 and Janu?ry, 1977. The decision to use this sor ~ ofmethodology was · based upon two related considerations. . . . . . First, • . . - historical research upon Asians in Canada has shown an almost total lack · of that sort of personal information which participant .observation pro- . , due es so ,Ii ; an. exhaustive reading of . the~ past 'li tera tu re on East Indians in Canada leaves me without ani feeling .for the facto~s of -individual values and choice which oriented these·people'~ ..lives. The historical record stands .mute to even such bas-ic things as East Indian house.hold organization and self identity. Secondly, becaus·e my primary goal wa!? a general outline of the immigration ·o_L£Jjian East Indians to . Canada,. I felt that participant observation held the most prom_ise for produc;r1_g_ a relatively holi~tic understanding of this process. ~· Accordingly, I have concentrated heavily upon how Fijians themselves ·see their situation, and Iv -3- upon what fac~ors they consider -when they ·attempt to irilnig!'ate, find a .j,ob, buy a house, and fonn _a co11111unity~ If there is a major ·theme iti this _, ~ work, -- it - is that' t:he illJTligratfon and -s·ettleinertt ol '. thes~. people in Canada - ca_r.inot be, understood wJthout tonsi'deration of both societal cons-t rair1ts a_nd the field of choice available to, Fij'ia1Js within· these constraints; . During my",data collection, I tried to gain an insight ,into the every.., . . . ~ s. ~ {; . ' . -~,,,- . . ~- day lives of the,se people by · participatirig as best a ~;tranger can in their _ '."~ o~'il l!f~; I vt,fited people, went shopping _with them~ saw them off and - -, • _. -~.. . I . on airplanes, and- the like. In this way, l was -able to es·tablish cont~cts with over one hundred households, and was. able to colle_c t det~il-ed, infor- ' mation on the unfolding of thi_s Jrranigration sequ-ence from a· number of- theni _ continuously. In gaining an insight into the place of women in these , households I was often assisted by Doreen Indra, of this Department. The ·use of any -methodology obviously results in/ ~ompromising the col- lection of certain sets of information in the hope of gaining ground in other areas. This methodology, and the study generated out of tt are no '\ exceptions to this rule. This inquiry does not attempt ~n extensive quantification of the data. It concentrates upon general problems, pro~ cesses, and personal considerations, rather than upon a statjstical analysis of a few specific themes. ' Beyond the description of this process of ilTITligration and settlement there is one other;- goal _of this thesis. This is to contrast and compare Fijian East India-rt irnnig-ration with earlier Asian i-H11rt~ratwA w ~iti--s-R- - Columbia. British Columbia is unique in Canada iri having a long history of Asian tlTITligration -- one which goes back to the Fraser River gold rush of 1858. This earl fer situation was one of ~~treme fOriflict betweenAian•-- ------- ~nd white labour, and·tesulted in the'eventual e~clusioa of further Asian = iITITiigrabon and in the sub.ordination of resident Asians in.to ''a set Df racfal cast.es. Throughout.the subsequ·ent parts of the thesis I return to th~ee questions: Wha~ par.alle-1s are there between earlier Asian iITITiigrants and today's Fijian on·es in -backgrounds, objectives, and skills; are there similarities in their respective places in British Columbian society;_ and what has been the response of other Britfsh Columbian-s to their,presence? The sequence of the chapter-s= reflect a 11 these corn:erns. 0 Chapter One develops an historical account of Asian immigration to Canada and ,· describes the-setting to which Fijian iITUTiigrants have come. Chapter Two deals with the bac~ground of these people, begi~ning with the introduction of their forefathers into Fiji as indentured labourers. - Chapter Three is concerned with des·cribing the process of immigration itself. It also f}J outlines the criteria which Fijians have used to decide whether to immi.,.,, grate, and the demographic nature of the resultant irrmigrant.populi;ition. Chapters .Four and Five, ..respective~y, deal with the place of Fij~ans ' in the provincial economy ~nd the patterns of expenditure which nave developed upon that economic basis. Chapters Six and Seven outline the changing structures.of Fijian Canadian households and coITITiunity social organization. Chapter Eight comes full cirtle to discuss ~he way in which Fijian East Indians view their place in Canad-fan society, how members of that society. vi-ew them, and how these two a&p&ts- _gf fi-j~n life in Canada reflect earlier patterns of Asian ilTITiigration to British Columbja. ·-s- . Chapter One~ The Setting Sojo~r~ers: 1 t~e Chines~ . (/ British Columbia has seen three Asian imm,igrant groups establish themti . • • • • ., • • • • selves in" the province before f920,: the Chinese-, Japa~ese,· ar1d -East Indiqns. Chin~se arriving fr6m California to.participate in the gold rush of 1858 ··were· the first of these thre,e, arjd the patterns which evolved . to 'dea-1' with them were to order much of the st:.1bsequent history of the other two groups. - Their number grew steadily, and by 1864 there were ·approximately . 2,500 Chines~ in the .province, many working for whites ~s labourers or as 2 cooks (Howay 1914:567-8). These immigrants had come to California mainly from eight -0istricts of the southern Chine~e ~rovince of Kwangtung (Cheng 1931 :~). which were to provide a majority of the Chinese inTTiigrants to Canada up until very recently (Cho 1970:16)~ The Chinese wer~~1most exclusively from peasant populations with a long heritage of overseas enterprise. Many had beeri landless labourers with limited prospects in China,· but few were from the absolute bottom stratum of Chinese society. · Although "coolie" origins were assumed by British Columbians for all three of these Asian minorities, most of those who came fell rather into the category of those rich enough to leave but poor enough to go. 3 · The early Chinese were primarily sojourners '(Siu 1952), "birds of · passage", coming to North America with no initial intention of permanent· residence. They were attracted to Canada and the Unit.ed" States by the promise of enormous economic rewards, for there existed a large di'fferential .., between wages in their home country and wages in British Columbia. Fo·r ,. - - 0 - ~--- - -- . ~xample, as. late as 1900 farm labour in Kwangtung Provir:ice earned no more · than 5¢ per dtem (Ctie'ng 193°1 :sr, while wages for qomestic service in Bri.tish Col~mbia we,re twenty times tha~ amount}(King l908a);~ It was be- ·. · . l ieved that funds carefully saved here were to be read1ly trarsl~,t~~ into a position of respectability and security upon return to China. IITITligration was viewed as a temporary condition, as a means to an end, 5 and this had many consequences for the place of Chinese fn British c·olumbia~ Because the motivation behind iITITligration was the accumulation of the maxi·mum funds - in the shortest possible time; ~chieving a _high rate of savings was an important consideration. Not surprisingly, Chinese communities in North America were almost exclusively male, which meant that the t_ypical irm,igrant's wage rate did not have to provide for the cost of reproduction of the labour force, save for the cost of support of the ilTITiigrant's f in . China.~ Chinese pe~sant parsimony, combined with the relative ficiency of male communal living (Cheng 1931 :196-213) also decreased expend Chinese were additionally loath to invest money in capital expenditur~s ·in Canada -which were unlikely to give a quick re.turn, and this further in-creased the rate of saving. A Puritan pattern of expenditure is only one-half of savings~- for . . income is equally ·important. · Bonacich (1972) argu·e s (perhaps too simplfs..: ti ca 11 y} that th-e sojourner terrds to assess jobs targel y ;-n ternrs of · 7 extrinsic financialfc:onsiderations. Historically, Chinese w~re found - willing to do what were by Canadian standards the most distasteful and repetitive of tasks, and acquiesced in working for long hours at high l r "'. -7- '. levels of exertion. The Chinese in the Economy This .sketch of 'the Chinese as a sojourner is admittedly a_very general one, but even within its broad o~tlines one can see that it was ·in~ evitable that the desirability of a Chinese presence in British Columbia would become an issue among white colonists from the beginning. With those first Chinese ml~ers from California came a number of .white fortune seekers who brought with them a measure of the considerable anti-Chinese sent~ment . wtiich had arisen in California. one. The complaint was primarily an economic As early as 1855, animosity had arisen in Shasta County (Califor- nia), where whites and Chinese competed as small-scale independent miners and as labourers (Ward 1973:7). The California Chinese gradually replaced whites at the secondary river claims -(Saxton 1971 :53), but lacked the 0 capital and the political res_ources necessary to colJ]pete with the rising large-scale mining ~oncerns. Complaints against Chinese labour consequently came first from the California working class and their sympathizers. 8 ;s ~ the Chinese occupational base in C~lifornia broadened in the 1860 s so did 1 the anti-Chinese feelings As early as March, 1859, the Victoria Gazette was making the claim that Chinese were degrading the wages and working cond-itforts· of wnite labour (~rd 1973:25). · If one includes its many variatipns, ·ttr;~ ·was to oe ~ _ 1 -- · most ·significant charge to be aimed at Asian iITlTligrants prior to World War I I. I - -- ·!. · - - , . .;, -8- I Hostility to the Chinese followed basically the same pattern of growth . 9 in early British Columbia as it dJd in_C~lifornia~ In the - 1~60 s and-early 1 1870 s many British Coltjmbians favoured Chinese inrnigration, arguing that 1 only through the use of Oriental labour could the vast potential of the ,, province be taµped; this was primarily a middle and upper class argument. Already the Brjtish Columbian economy was well along -in its historical development of a basis of primary extractive industry which was highly laboyr intensive. Mining and the forest industrie$, land clearing, trans- . portati on and,. 1ater, the fishing industry a 11 were two-cl ass structures reminiscent of the plantation. There were many workers and, separated _from them both economicaJly and socially, _few managers and owners. Like the · plantation, labour in these industries was a primary cost of pr..oduction, and it is understandable that those who e~ployed significant amounts of it 10 were in favour of Oriental labour. Th6se involved in the smaller stale sales and service indu·s tries looked to the Chinese as a potential market· (Ward 1973:34). 9 0 But the Chinese quickly lost their middle class support and were to violently polarize the working class ~gainst themselves. With its working class support, the elected political elite of the ~rovince soon became :, solidly against the further entry of Chinese to British Columbia: By the turn of the century, advocacy of Oriental immigration was so pol-itically damaging that provincial economic elites, even with their considerab1e political power, found iheir position on this issue untenable. One must keep in mind that even prior to this sequence there existed -9- . . the near universal assumption that the Chinese -were distinct from white Mankind. This .was taken as a given,. even ~Y supporters of the Chinese. They .were, first of all, seen to be another race; British Columbians wer~ typical of nineteenth century Europeans (Banton 1967: 1-30) fn vi ~wing race · as a relative-ly irrlilutable combination of biological, psychological, and 11 cultural characteristics. These ideas, when coupled to the perceived threat of Asian economic competition, were to result in the castelike (Berreman 1972) subordination of the Chinese, Japanese, and East Indians in British Columbia. Setting the Caste Line: occupational distribution Considerable local hostility arose in the mfning areas of the province as the number of Chinese increased. As early as 1864 resentment was high · in the Cariboo; it increased steadily through 1869 a·s the Chinese, having established both a material and informational foundation for life in the provi nee, branched out as "storekeepers, traders a·nd packers, fanners, I • gardeners, and domestic servants (Howay 1914.:569). 11 The Chinese "did not entirely acquiesce to a· caste line drawn so sharply that all whites were economically above them. Neither were employers of one opinion for, re- gardless of their perso_nal views of the Chinese, they were tempted by the prospects of cheaper Oriental labour and by the threat 1-t created to wh.ite e . labour's demands for higher pay and better working conditions. And Chinese labour was cheaper. · In the 1860 s the Central Pacific 1 Railway estimated that their overall costs for Chinese labour were two-thirds . I -lO-- that of its white labtiur and that the use of Chinese in the ·construction ,. of the transcontinental railway had saved the company $5,500,000 (Saxton 12 1971 ·:63). From the earlie st . days in both Br_itish~~~ia and California · 0 . <- ~ . there arose a s.,EJJ:t labour market (Bonacich 1972), where white workers were paid significantly higher for the same job as were Orientals. Wage dif13 ferentials were characteristically 30% to 40%. This was t~ persist overtly 14 until the l~0 s, and can be seen as a limited victory .for white labour. 1 Th-is dua 1 system of- wage rates was one of the first materi-.a-l- caste restric .,,. tions to be placed on Asians _i~ British Columbia. Throughout the 1860 s and 1~70 s the Chines~ in British Columbia 1 1 -attempted to ·break _out into OfCupations other th~n unskilled wage labour; · Entrepreneurial activities whic~ depended on a Chinese clientele were one 0 of the first areas sec.ured. _Merchants and s11ppliers of seryices to.the Chinese corrmunity not only provided those things which were riot readily available at Eur6pean stores, but offered irrmigra~lfchinese the option of. buying Western corrmodities in a psychologically .'safe' context which did pot require entry into the white community; the penalty was slightly higher • . ~ . .• ~ i; ~ ·. prices than were available in the larger whit~ stores (Cheng t-931:189). Merchants serving the Chinese corrmunity also branche.d out into the sale of Asian corrmodities to the general public and into direct -competition with white entrep·r eneurs. • The grocery business,. hand l-aundrY,-,---the r-es- · tauraµt trade and tailoring became economic strongholds for the Chinese by 1910. The Chinese defended these entrepreneurial outposts by offering the 5 . c heaper pr1ces1n . d 1anger open hours th an th e,r · compe, t · t ,on. · l wh1. t e pu bl 1c '(/ •. ..i .. ... -11- . European competitors' fought baclc with advertising pleas to ·'buy Can9-dian 1 , with boycott~a~d with polftical pre.ssure to restr-ict Asian licences, but none of these attempts were successful 1n _the face of the cheapness and . convenience <>f Chinese goods and ·ser-vi ces :. . These Chinese . entrepreneurial ac.tivi.ties were strictly limited!>-though, ______________ _ . ~ by _capital, labour, -and by cultur(al · constraints. ac~ivi,ty ·was hampered ~y the lack~f financing. . ' . 0 16 Large"'.'scale industrial Thus, the Chinese hand laundries were non-competitive with ~capital-intensive mechanized -.~: laundries which dominateKthe hotel and ,industrial trade. Part of the p-ri~e ·differential - between the Chinese and white store was · dependent upon the Chinese employing family rather than wage labour, and therefore expansion beyond th~ family's labour resources involved increased costs. ' ., , Those entre~eneurs who catered to the Chinese population itself were limited· in . their numbers and" growth potential by the size of the Chinese corrrnunity. Among entrepren_e urial _ {ilternatives, .the stri'ct social caste fine between whites and Chinese made the middleman option a very limited one. A; Access. to . " - - the profe.ssions_>was also barred. The one o where Chinese were able to move out -0f the unskilled . work force was in Used to · the severe land use requisites of China, . they finnly secured the niche of market gardening (Donley 1928) by 1900, which· they large_l.y have held into the present. . - . - r:... - - L - . Entrepreneurial .activity aside, the Chinese, as w1th the J~-panese and East Indians who came after them, were primarily blue collar workers located in primary industries. Cho (1970:22) summarizes the occupational distri- .. ----'--'- - - - - - - - - - -- - bution of the Chinese in 1885 as: Railway Construction 1'i'i ni ng -Farming Canning Mi 11 Work -Services 3,500 2,240 800 390 2-70 2,670 9,870 Total Table I. Provincial Chinese Workforce Participation, 1885 17 By 1902 (RCC~I 1~02), the Chi~se were heavily concentrated in market gardening~ coal mining~ the lumber and. shingle business., fish ca.nning, dom. estic•service, hand laundering, tailoring and sewing. shift materially until World War rr. This was not to 18 Formal Restrictions Against the Chinese: the head tax Having subordinated the Chinese -by lower wages, a second set of restric. . tions attempted -to limit the numbers of ~hinese 1n the province and to constrain thos_e here to a subordinate class in an ari~tocracy of labour. _. The first murmurs of legislative action aro~e in 1865 (Aridratki 1958:1; Ward 1973:32), but it was a decade before restrictive legislation was success- · fully enacted. A heao tax of $50.00 per individual per annum was proposed to the Legislature in February, 1872~ but th.is . was defeate_d (Cho 19}0:19). " Ih 1875, the Chinese were disenf~anc~ised in Brit{sh Columbia. 19 Through 1878; repeated attempts were made to int.roduce __the__p_i:.e_y_j_o_u_sJ_y_ .def.eated_b_ead_ ______ :__-;- tax, this time at ~J0.0Q p_er ~-n!J.um, but these..J','_e_rg_declared unconstitutional _________ _ • by the British Coh1mbi a-Supreme Court. . # In 1878, Chinese were banned from labouring on public works (;.i_ard 19'73: ·7 1). -13- At the Federal level, British Columbia's M.P.s were unable to find support for their exclusionist cause until 1885, for they were in essence fighting the Canadian. Pacific Railroad, which was aware of the savings made by the Central Pacific's use of~Chinese and wa~determin~d to do the · same. Thousands of Chinese migrated to Br{tish Columbia in the.period 1878-1884. In 1885, the railroad complrted, Parliament passed the first . of a series of irrrnigration curbs against Chinese. Unwilling to totally ba-n the Chinese, Parliament passed legislation which required that Chinese . pay an entry fee of $50.UO upon arrival -in Canada; the number of irranigrants carried by shipping was also limited to one Chinese immigrant for every 50 20 tons of shtpping. . This restriction resulted in a tempo.rary reduction of Chinese immi gr!tion to Canada, but its effect was mor~ than countered by the severe depression o; 1885-7 which threw thousands , Chinese and w~ tes a 1 i ke, out of work. 21 Anti~Chinese sentiment . reached the point o~ violence. Never- theless, as wages in British Columbia rose; inflated by the temporar.y slackening of Chinese immigration, it again became ec~nomically feasible to come to Canada, and the number of Chinese doubled between 1881 and 1891 to 8,910 (RCCJI 1902:7). This made Chinese Canadians one-.e leventh of the total British Columbian population. 22 The Japanese By ~ , the de-sti ny of the Chirrese wa-s to ire -ttnked .-closely to that · of British Columbia's second Asian irrrnigrant group, the Japanese, and from -14- this point they must be discussed simu1taneous1y• The first Japanese came to British Columbia before 1882, possibly as early as 1878 (Sumida 1935:25). Immigration was numerically insignificant before 1885, but letters sent to Japan by those first piorliJers brought a continuously increasing flow of new ilTllligrants in the next five years. The Japanese were irrmediately attracted to the growing salmon fishing ..., industry. By 1901 over two thousand of the 4,597 Japanese then reported ' to be in British Columbia were involved in fishing or in related activities 23 (RCCJI 1902:340). Japanese irrnnigrants to Canada were largely sojourners like the Chinese, but their backgrounds were considerably more vari~d. Again, the sources of immigration were fairly localized, Wakayama, . Shiga, Kagoshima, and Hiroshima prefectures supplying roughly one-half of the total number 24 (Sumida 1935:55). Like the Chinese, most were from rural backgrounds; ... 9bout_half were previously farmers, while common labourers and fishermen 25 made up-the second and third largest categ·ories. Until 1907, when the first s-ignificant number of women i1T111igrated, the Japanese were primarily motivated towards the betterment of the.ir sit.u26 ation at home. Following this pattern, larg~ numbers of immigrants ~ transited between Japan and Canada, staying in this country but a few years. Only one-third of the Japanese ilTllligrants arriving in Canada before 1901. ' were·actually here in that year. Sum1da (19J5:47J reports that most had irm1igrated in response to two factors: first, those who did so were in situations of very restricted economic mooility, and secondly, they were -15- young enough not to be tied directly to family responsibilities. Indeed, the average age of Japanese immigrants was less than 24 years . .As with . , the Chinese, the wage rate differentials betw~en Japan and Canada were very 1 Typical wages -large. for unskilled agri~ultural work in Japan averaged 15¢ per diem in 1897, whfle maximum rates for sk'illed labour seldom went above 30¢. 27 . j~'\ Reaction to the Japanes~.s q~ickly forthcoming. They were fi_rst mentioned in the British-Columbia Leg,slative Ass'embly in 1881 (Cho 1970: 14). By 1893, white salmon fishennen on the Fraser had organized the Fisherman's Benevolent and Protective Soc-:-iety in opposition to the growing . number of Japanese fishermen (Ward 1973:127; Phillips 1967:25). ~ The Japanese _wer·e provincially disenfranchised in 1896 (Ward 1973:151). In the economy, an attempt was made to restrict the Japanese,· like the Chinese before them, to a subordinate pbsition. Although successfol in the long term, this objectiv_e proved difficult to attain. First of all, '· Japanese tended to move. out of wage· labour in larger numbers than did the Chinese. The firmer economic base which resulted gave the Japanese a grea_ter ability to combat restrictions. Secondly, the Japanese government stood firmly behind t~eir citit~ns abroad. · This gave legislative restric·tions upon Japanese ilIDligrants the potential to become international issues . ., The strength of the Japanese government was also id~ologically important, for as perceived by Canadi~ns the stereotypes of Japanese were seen to be .in line with·anati011al Japanese image of a proud, independent, Westernizing country. Third, both politically and economically the Japanese·'tended to 1 •. -16.. coalesce for mutual support, reflecting in so doing their feelings of self worth and national pride. Finally, as the Japanese in Canada became the first Asian group with a significant number of irmnigrant families their stake in British Columbia increased and they became far more motivated towards defense of their collective po~ition . . Even •so, as a mirwrity, the jaQanese found their resource·s insufficient to prevent a significant limitation of their rights and privileges in British Columbia. Throughout their pre-internment history large numbers worked as wage labourers in much the same fashion as the Chinese (for occupational statistics, see note 18). Many went initially into the wage labour market, especially into the lumber, pulp, and pap.er industries, where Japanese participation was significa·nt up to World War II. In the work force the Japanese were also ;subject to the conditionl of th~ same 27 split labour market .as the Chinese. As late as 1934 (Sumida 1935:341), Japanese were paid consisteptly one-quarter to "one-third less than whit~ . ~ ih the lumber and pulp mi 11 s. qther Japanese worked at a va ri e.ty of blue collar jobs, prin.c ipi:illy at fish canning (where Japanese women worked in large numbers}, as ·domestics, cooks, gardeners~ and before 1910, as rail~ . way wor kers an d miners. 28 Much of the hostility which arose ag~int the -Japanese derived from their strong tendency to move into competi ion with independent whites, . particularly i~ the areas of fishing, far- i , and small business. · The Japanese were particular-ly ·successful in the fishing industry, where- they concentrated primarily upon salmon gi 11 netting. Japanese fi shennen brought -17- wfth them to Canada knowledge of alternative fishing techniques and insights into the Asian market,,which were to increase-significantly the value of the British Columbia catch. Nevertheless, they were met with strong op- position by both white and Indian fishermen. These irrmigrants originated the sa~t herring industry (28,000 tons were put up in 1910), an·d with it, the Asian trade. They a1so initiated the salt salmon indus.try, which i.n-· . - 1/ ' . 1 creased the value of Chum salmon, before considered the least valuable be~ cause of its poor canning qualities. They al so brought with them improve~ trolling techniques and were leaders· in motorizing the fishing industry. Pleas for the limitation of Japanese in the fishing industry began as ~ ear1y as 1893, but reached particular intens_ity by the turn of the century. The bitter sockeye strike of 1900, which saw the Japanese fishermen finally acceding to canning company demands, further increased the cry for excl'usion.29 In that year, the British Columbia Legislature passed the first of a series o.f 11 Natal Acts 11 , of both Japanese and Chinese. which were aimep at the immigration exclusion These acts prohibited irrmigration into the province of those who could not speak or ~ead English to a level deemed.· sufficient by irm,igration officials; implicit was the qualification that 30 Asians would not pass in any case. The Japanese Consul protested that this was a discriminatory measure aimed at a friendly power, and 'the legis- · lation was disallowed by th_e Federal Gov.ernment, as WgS__ ~_im_i_l~r_legi~l_gtipn in 1902, 1904,· and 1905 (Sumida 1935:29; Sugimoto 1966:38). _ - - -- - - - - - - ---- - - - --- - There was ··virtually no immigration from Japan in the period ·1900 to t -c. ,t,.. 1904, as prefecturi 4 1 governor,.,s fol.lowed the dictates of the Japanese govern- -_18-, . . . J . ment and 4cted the issuance lof _overseas pas.sports (Sugimoto 1966:23). This was in part d~ne : in consider~tion ~f the possibility of :futufe host{l- ' ities with Russia. · Protest in the fishing industry abated ·slight-ly, only · · to ri-se to even greater levels as Japanese irrmigration resumed in 1905. Chinese and Japanese Immigration Curbs During this same decade (1891-1901) two other factor~icombined to · .--~ increase the call for the exc.lusion of both Chinese and Japar1€se. First of all, the number of Chinese in the province (who, it must be remember~d, still entered under the $50 head tax of 1885)' increased by 50% to 14,885 (ROAP 1927:3). This alone put the Federa} govern~ent under pressure to further restritt Chin~se irrrnigration. Secondly, both Japanese and Chinese were at this time moving. strongly into · farming and small-scale business, thereby in_creasing the strength of the white middle class and farme'r opposition to the i r presence. Only those members of the national and prov- incial economic elites who were dependent upon Asian labour or who feared economic retaliation from the source countries (principally from Japan) . argued for continued iim,iigration, and this they could no longer do overtly .' \ \·- While the Laurier. government had previously argued that Asian manpower was . . . ,:, necessary to the expanding provincial economy, this position was rapidly · eroding, and with it, the Libera_ls' election potential in -B_r_i~ish C;cilumb~a. Because treaty and trade considerations ·were not as dependent upon . Canada's treatment of Chinese nationals as they were upon that of the Japanese, the Government moved first to curb Chinese irrrnigration. Despite -. -19-- _.-. ....- -- . v· . . : -pressure from the CPR, whi~h claimed (1899.) . that an focrease in the head . . . . . "": .. , .,...~; . tax would ha-ve ·a disas'trous effect on the revenues of Canadian Pacfric 31 Shiplines, the Chinese h;ad tax was raised to $100 in 1900. The arguments put forward by the Royal Conmission of Chinese and Japanese Irm1i-, g ~•ti on . ( 1902) . r::s u1ted in •~.urther )." :re~ ?f th,e • tax ,to $500 i.n 1?p4, •.·. ' 32 e_ffecti~ ~ly curta illn~- Chinese :"'1rrmi gration f_rom'.~;1905 ,to 'cJ ~Q9. Thls',, tax !,· ~ - . '---, :::-,. :-was;- beyond t _he resourc:es of- most inmiqrants, an·d was a 1so too -hi qn for . . labour c6ntfactors to advance. Chinese immJgration was to inc~ease again only w_herr the severe rise in wages provoked by shortages of Asian 1abour allowed irrrnigrants to remit savings to others in China, thereby allowir,f new irrrnigrants to pay the tax. Jaranese exclusion was not so easily accomplished. Uo through 1905 there had been enormous pressure upon the Government by Canadian business to be included in the Anglo-Japanese trade agieement of 1894-5, which had been · shown to be so profitable -to the British. The progress of negotiations on this treaty, which were concluded January 31, 1906, would have be-en seriously disturbed by any move made during this time to restrict Japanese iTTITligration. The treaty itself, like many trade agreements of the day, granted ocal irnnigration and res1dence rights to both parties, making quent Canadian restrictions on inmigration contrary to the treaty (Su( The only diplomatic recourse available to Canada was to attempt an agreement between the two governments above and beyond the treaty itself wherein Japan would agree to restrict the flow of its own 33 nationals. This goal was not achieved until late in 1907, when a Gentle- _; .-. . - -20. '·., ··--------. ,:, . .• - . ----- ~ - .... - man Is Agreement was signed in Tokyo restricting the number of passports issued to male labo~rers coming to Canada to 468 per annum (Sumida 1935~34). -... · : ·. - - 34' - ' , . .· The [q.st ;1.ndians _- -. , ) t .was durin·g 'th i's turbule~ ~ peri'oc:i _at''.the :1:urn: ~f ·the century that ;:·- the third of British Columbia's Asian iJTITiigrant groups made its appearance ·. The first East Indians to come to the province probably did so intermittently betweerr 1898 and 1902, coming from the Chinese and Japanese treaty ports in the capacity of merchant seamen. Long term settlement began about · 1902, when it became evident that consistent work was to be had in the - ·Port Moody sawmi 11 s. As with the Japanese, the word spread back via 1etter anct word of mouth _to those same Asial"t port cities, principally to Hong Kong, Shanghai, and the Malay States, prompting an increasing number of East Indians to come to Canada. By 1904, the number of East Inoians in Vancouver 35 fluctuated at around 100 to 15o. The great majority of -these first pion• eers were Sikhs, who had gone to China and South East Asia in the British 0. Army and who, when mustered out, chose to remain in the Fa~ East. Many of these ex-soldiers had been employed as policemen, watchmen, and as dockya~d workers. The non-Sikh complement, who never comprised .more than 15% of the East Indians fn pre-War British Columbia, came from all over India; Gujerat, Oudh, and Bengal were significant sources (Das 1923:3). From 1904 the number of East Indians in British Columbia in~reased dramatically: ·.. . . - -· • Year 1904-5 .. l-905.:.6 : .. 1906-7 , · · 1907-8 Table II. . - - - - - - · - · - --·--- ------ - . .. · Nu~ber tntering . , . 45 - 387 . 2J24 2,623 East Indian Immigration to 35 anad·a , Fi seal Years l 9'04 · to 1908. · _ · · •· ·The reasons for this increase are threefold. Perhaps · the most important initiating causes were letters sen,t from the' initial inmigrants ·to their villages, e~laining the prospects of inmigration . . Secondarily, the · steamship companies~ particularly the Canadian Pacific Steamship Company, . . ~ advertised similar claims in circulars which wefe ·widely distributed in . ' the Punjab . . This was an overt attempt to mitigate the losses in ·Pacific traffic caused by the $500 Chinese head t~;{!of 1904. 37 _· Transi~ from the_ . Punjab was from Calcutta to Canada via Hong Kong and Singapore, and any increases in the India traffic directly built up that of the China to Canada run. Of least importanc~ were the solicitations of East Indian .,, labour contractors. While these were the initiating causes, the wider constraints of inmigration depended upon factors similar to those of Chinese and Japanese ilTllligration and, not surprisingly, the structure of ilTllligration was very close to that of the two previous groups. Again, the geographic area from which the majority of East Indian irrmigrants came was extremely bounded, in this case to an area not much more than fifty mi1es across. Punjabi irrmigration of this first era came chiefly from the districts.of Jullundur, . , Ludhianna, Hoshiarpur, and Ferozepore, with smaller numbers from Amritsar, ----- \ ( -22- Pat'ia'la and La ho.re districts. '\/, . ' ..::_. _·c. The po~ul acec pf thes~ 'dfsfri cts h,lq a long - • ~,. ·tradHion of movement and accorirrnodatioff behind therrf· prior to irranigration to North America. After their strong support of the British forces during - . the Mutiny of 1857, the Sikh community of the Punjab enjoyed a favoured position iri Brftish policy for over fifty years. Already developed into. a mil it.ant people by rep~ated in\'.asions from the North West and by resistance to Moslem rule, the Sikhs were to provide enlistments to the British _·,-...---~ sep6y regiments out of all proportion to their numbers. i I Through army · - ~ service in places as ~iverse as China and the Sudan, as well as through short term immigration to Aust_ralia (Kessinger 1974), Uganda (Patel 1973; .; Morris 1968), and South East Asia they gained a con·siderable knowledge of the outside world. In the 1880's and l890's, the Sikhs alsq began migra- ting in considerable numbers to other,.areas of India (Aurora 1967) as well as westward in the Punjab to"the deveTbping Canal Colonies. These Si_kh i1T111igrants were almost uniformly of the dominant Jat ·caste 38 of the Punjab. Most were from the landed peasantry, and a good_ number possessed family land in excess of 30 acres (Das 1923:l). · By all Indian standards of the day, these i1T111igrants wer.e rather well off. Very few had been wage labourers in India. Various economic and geographical r~asons have been advanced as to why .-· these particular areas were such dominant sources of East Indian ilTllligratiori _ _ to North America and Britain. All concede that the primary motivational consideration was once again the hope of earn,ng enough money overseas to finance the purchase of additional land or to set up in a traqe or as a "' I -2-J- _moneylender (Darlings 1928:22). Wage differentials were very large, but 39 La..l (l976:7J and Aurorq tftis was true with respect to a'i1 Of_India. (1967:3-15) both lo~k to the high population d~nsity bj ~ull~ndur .and - Hoshiarpur, combineef with a rising cost of living, Lal adding the factor • of rapid land erosion in Hoshiarpur. But it.seems more reasonable~ as suggested by Darlings (19211:22-40) a"nd Kessinger (1974:87-92), that immi- gration from these two districts, rather than being a result of deteriorating internal conditions, was the result of its -opposite. Darlings notes that Hoshiarpur and Jullundur had the lowest agricultural debt in / the Punjab, with Jats in these same areas being below .the average .. This low agric.ultural debt was paralleled by that in Rawalpj,ndi and Jhelum · (Darlings 1928:84), which also -were ·s ignificant sources of emigres,. _ Kessinger's study of Punjabi historical records through one hundred jears illustrates th~ extreme fertility of the area by ~the absince of food shortages in Jullundur since 1880 (1974:87). In short, immigration seems to have been made possible by conditions which favoured capital ~cc4mulation and stability. IIITlligration in turn allowed the families of those who had inmigrated to concentrate capita-1 still further, building up~financial reserves which allowed continued immigration of family members. Representative of _this dense interconnection between fam,ly an.d inmigrant; over one-half of those Sikhs polled by· the 1908 Royal Commission (King 1908a) who had arrived in that year had relatives ·here already. It was their unfortunate lot that these first of Canada s East Indian 1 inmigrants came onto the scene at what must have been the worst possible ~ -24· - - - --- -----·---- - ------ - •time. - Hostility:.:to both Chinese ; _n·a JJp'ahese - immigration· ,had -been rising . . -: . · .. :- . . ' ~ ,,_ . . steadily since Hf95, and considerable momentum had gathered towards a · successful ban upon all further Asian immigratipn. who supported exclusion were substantial. By this time the forces · The white working class, inclu:.. - ding organi'zed labotir, was united in this demand. By ttre--·turn of the· century so also were large segments of the small-scale entrepreneurial and farming cJasses; with -them moved most of the· ideology-producing el..: . . · 40 ements of the society·: from the newspapers to the clergy. ~ Elected provincial politicians were so -uniformly anti-Asian that one's stand on this i·ssue diminished as primary election material, and the issue ' shifted to whfch party or politician would more expediently accomplish the goal of exclusion. Only the Federal Government's vested right to determine po1-icy dealing with aliens (BNA Act, Sec: 9l, No. 25), coupled ·with its power Of disallowal of new provincial legislation (BNA Act, Sec. 90), impeded exclusion, and Federal reluctance · to exclude Asians was fast becoming a political l _iability . . Weakening of the Federal stance was indicated by the 1900 and 1904 increases in the Chinese head tax, the second obviously meant to be exclusionary. In their initial few years,East Indians were also to be severely disadvantaged economically. British Columbia's attempi to restrict access on-\· the part of thi Japanese· and Chinese to all but a narrow spectrum of oc~ij. pations had bee~ for the most part successful. For East Indians this meant that their initial entree into the British Columbian economy had to be made in direct competition with two minority racial castes, each with " ,,. _,.,....,.. ...25- I its own developed ecological niches and with its own corrmunity· resource base. The largest East Indian flows of immigrants in the years prior to World War I (fiscal ye,ars. 1907 -and 1908) were to come in the midst of a severe depression. Wall Streef prices fell sharply March 14, 1907 as did those on the t~icago Exchange in August.· With British Columbia's economy so h1gh ly' deP,endent on resource industries, the effects of the general slowdown were greatly magnified in- the prov'ince. The 1umber industry, which had bee_n booming with the rise in prairie demand~ expecte_d .only 35% of the previous year's logging (Sugimoto 1966: 64). · By the end of the year there were 5,000 unemployed whites in Vanctiuver, 500 in Victoria, 1,000 in Nanaimo, and another 1,200 in the Kootenays (Ph_illips 1967:47). Asian labour was also affected. By September of 1908, tne Chinese Board of Trade estimated that there were at that time l ,500 Chinese out of work; of the approximately 3,000 East Indians then in the pro vi nee, . perhaps as many as l ,000 were also unemployed (Harkiri 1909:6). In early,1906 ther~ had been full employment, and employers were complaining about the·effects of the $500 head tax on Chinese irrmigration (Wynne 1964:406). sulTTiler months·. East Indians continued to find work, at least for the In lieu of Chinese, -150 recently arrived East Inqians were brought to the Cari boo rni nes {Lock l e_y· 1907: 52; Muthanna_-1971_:_SJ~whi le others fo_und work in-Port Moody and New WestrrlinstE=r sciwmills._ Ne_vertheless, the first·cries for East Indian exclusion were being raised by 'mid-1906. In July, both the Victoria and Vancouver trades and Labour· ('- -26- LI Co1,mcils P.assed petitions opposing an East Indian pres-ence f'n British Columbia (Ward 1973:189; Lal, 1976:132), followed soon after by Vancouver's city cquncil ~ In .October, Mayor Buscome of Vancouver went so far as to , order city police to bar newly arri~ing East Indians from leaving the CPR docky~rd detention sheds. The winter of 19D6-7 hit these new irrrnigrants severely.- · Without the . . ., - .- .. presence of an established corm,unity they were dependent upon the larger _white society for the· purchase of goods and services and for all employment. They soon founq that no one would rent to them at any price (Nihal Singh 1907). . - - Food and fuel were often refused as well. 41 L They ·found themselves iJl prepared for winter weather, especially in the inte~ior of the pro vi nee; those _who had "gone to the Cari boo i.n the su1TJTier wa1 ked back in November, having been without Sufficient clothing and bedding to ~~in- tain themselves there. . By mid-wi1'ter there were pgrhaps -1 ,500 unemployed ~ast Indians in Vancouv-er. f(?t surprisingly, the classic British Columbian stereotype of the - East Indian began to arise as early as this. 42 Forced to live in large • numbers in scarce and inferior housing, ~ritish Columbia derived out of this suffering a folk image of the "Hindu" (as all East _Indians were calle.l, regardless of their ethnic origins). He was perceived to be dirty and _ unsanitary, with an ''intrinsic' Oriental tendency towards overcrowding and consequent irrmora 1i ty. Cornpl a i nts about strange food and strang·er dress · 43 Their lack of shelter and insufficient clothing arose jfllTlediately. heloed to nurture the nearly universal belief of this period i_n climatic I -27- racial determinism; people from tropical climates were, after all, adapted to their climate, a·nd ought to stay there. This same _folk theory, when reversed, · made an excellent rationale for the designation of temperate I · colonial areas, such as British Columbia, as 'white man's country'. 44 As British Columbia moved 'into its sJ,Jmmer period of economic activity · fast Indians were able to secure jobs, even in the depressed conditions of 1907. _Besides the sawmills, they worked in the _cement plants, cutting wood, and clearing lan~J Wages ranged fro~$1.25 to $1.50 a day. Condi- tions stabilized to the point that the Sikh conmunity was able to form their f1rst organization, the Khalsa Diwan Society of Vancouver (Lal 1976:54) . . But already the Federal Government had decided to attempt a complete · termination of Indian irrmigration. Laurier, writing to Colonel Fafk Warren in January, affirmed the Government's intent to ask the Hong Kong and India Governments to distribute information to potential irrmigrants warning 45 of hard conditions in British Columbi.a. · By October; the India Government had implemented this pl~n, and was circulating suth warnings in the Punjab (London Times, October 12, 1907:Se). It should be stressed that Laurier,· as evinced in a letter to Lord Grey i'n September, saw East Indian irrmi grati on as more than simply~ther 46 prob 1em of Asian 1abour. Rather, ·Indian irrrnigration had Imperial conse .. quences. Paradoxically, either- exclusion or continued inmigra,,ttoo ~s · seen as a threat agafost British rule in India. Banning Indian i'rrmigration overtly would further weaken the fiction of full Indian participation in -28- the Empire, while a resident Indian conmunity in British Columbia might, like those in London, Paris and San Francisco, become a-centre of sedition itself. So seriously did the British view this situation that William - Hopkinson of the Calcutta Police was sent to Vancouver in ]908 to inves- _ ~ -_ ti gate. sedit_ious _activities on °the Pacific Coast. f1e was- to be continu- ously involved with this• question until he was shot in Vancouver by Mewa Singh, an Indian nationalist, in 1914 (F~rguson 1975). Provincially, the British Columbia Legislat~re di~enfranchised East 47 As ;he Indians in March, 1907, even though they were British s~bjects. depression deepened~ racial tensions in the province increased, especially ,-: ~ , --• as Japanese a_nd Indian iITTTiigration conti-nued unabated. This hosfi l i ty flared into action when 600 lumberjacks forcibly evicted 200 East Indian mill workers from Bellingham, Washington, on September 5th (Ward 1973:200). I Most of these EasJ Indfans crossed the border into British Columbia, despite offers by their previous employers of wages equal to white ~orkers (Dodd 1907:1158). Two days later, Vancouver experienced its most serious anti-Oriental riot to date, when an angry crowd, variously estimated at . from 6,000 to 18,000, collected to hear speakers of British Columbia's newly famed Asiatic Exclusion League. - In the riot which issued, Chinese property was extensively damaged. The Japanese stood their 'ground in the -. 48 streets and blocked advances by the crbwd into their neighbourhood. William L. Mackenzie King, then · D~puty Minister of Labour, was sent to Vancouver to investigate the riot, and his report resulted ~n extensive reparations being paid to both the Chinese and Japanese by the Canadian ··---- -·--- . . . Government. ' . This international incident provoked the Federal Government into activity on the overall question of Asian irm,igration. · In spite of the \ _fears voiced by Canad fan manufacturers that the trade treaty with Japan · ""uld be ab~ogated, the Government, represented by Rodo,ieux, ~oncluded the previously referred to limitation on Japanese immigration. Once its administrative machinery was · in operation this· agreementeffec- 49 ttvely ended the large-scale il11llfgration of Japanese work_ers to Canada. King ' was also delegated to inquire into ihe caases of Japanese and East Indian immigration to Canada (1908a). His investigative visit to'British Columbia was followed by one to England, where he sou.ght to come to some agreement with the British and India Governments on a pblJcy of East Indian exclusion (1908b). These negotiations resulted in the January 8, 1908 Order in Council, ' which required that all inmigrants entering Canada via British Columbia ports who were not specifically covered by separate treaties must cbme on a continuous journey from their country of origin. route from India . And there was no such By this Order, Canada had effectively banned subsequent East Indian inmi grati on wi th'out the embarrassment of speci fi ca lly men ti oni ng India. · -_ / · It was less than two months b.efore this Order iri Council.was ~ o a · l legal test. In Mqrch~ the- British Columbia S\,lpre_m_e Cojf't ruled that this . Order was te~hnically defective in that it illegally delegated powers of the Governor General in Council to the Miniiter of the Interior (re: j -30-' ' Beh_a ri, Lal · (1908), 13 BCR 415). The East Indian defendants, three of whom were residehts of ~iji'although born in India, were arguing entr:v on the grqunds ttiat as British Subjects they had rights of access througho · . · 50 out the Empire. This legal impediment was eliminated by the Government on March 26th (Andracki 1958:53) ~ with a rewording which was strict enough to have banned Bri~j sh ilTBlligration to Canada from Australia, should it have been rigor, ously applied (Lal 1976:138). On May 2Z,t h, a subsequent Order in CouncJl . ·> required_ that_ in addit1on to coming ·to Canada on a continuous journey from . ~~ their pl~ce of origin, East)ndians were to be in possession of $200 upon entry. ~lthough ·the continuous journey clause was to be attacked again and aga_in in the c_o urts, being declared ultra vires in 1910 (Andracki 1958: 111) and again in 1913 (in re: Nara,in Sinqh et al, ·rn BCR, 406), it was to . •. remain in effect until 1947~ The limitations pl aced on East _Indians by this ·r egulation effected a near total ban upon further il11Tligration of East Indians to Canada before the Second World War.. From 2,623 arrivals in fiscal year 1907-8, il11Tli- gra,t i on flow went to: · , Year Number Year Number 1908-9 1909-10 1910-11 1911-12 1912-13 1913-14 ~1 20 31 7' 7 1914-15. 1915-16 1916-17 1917-18 19-18-191919-20 0 l ,_Table II I. ' 5 88 0 0 ·e--· 0 East Indian Irmni?ration, March 31 , 1908 to March 31, 1920.5 - - --· . - -31- Prior to 1920, East Indians in British Columbia formed a communi(y of. males, ·in this following the pattern of Chinese- immigration. women are listed as irrmigrating priorto 1920. Only 18 The early prohibition of East Inaian irrmigration made the establishment of a normal family lffe in British Columbia an impossibility; indeed, the legislation had that goal very much in mind. In the long run, most of these East Indian pioneers left British Columbia, either to return to India or Honq Kong or to travel on to California, where Sikhs were to enjoy early success in agricultural 52 pursuits. Immigration figures show that 5,366 East Indians entered CJnada before the end of 1921, and yet census figures list only 2,342 East In?ians /fl.. Canada in 1911 and but l ,016 in 1921 (Cheng 1931 :1~5). Deifp.ite all adversities, this small East Indian population formed itself into a tightly ordered, self-contained community. Jhe Sik~ religion; .with its organization developetl a'round democratic and participatory principles and with its dogma oriented towards defense in adversity, was · 53 eminently suited to become the structural core of the community. By 1908, $10,000 had been subscribed for the establishment of a permanent {Sikh temple in Vancouver, and_b~ 1912 there were temples in New Westminster, r Port Moody, Fraser Mills, Barnett, and Victoria (Aryan, November, 1911 :~..., There is a Sikh_proverb that five-Sik~s·form God", and it was through 11 rel i gi-Ous organi za t, on, cross-cut with networks of famili-a l, village, and political ·relations, that the Sikh cormrunity estae-li-sl'lee itself iR- &i-tish Columbia. As has been mentioned, Sikh iITJTiigration came from extremely localized sources. One of the consequences of this localization of origins was the importation of a whole set of pr~-formed social relations to Canada. Jrelations were not limited to those between East Indians here. These Because of •,c:. the dense communication networks between British Columbia and the Punjab, social relations connected Sikhs with village organization and familial expectations; As _,with F;'jian immigration 50 years afterwards, the Sikh · community of British Columbia ope.rated under the' dual constraints of both . 54 their new.home and their old one. · Ampng these early immigrants the.re developed a pattern of communal domestic organization which strengthened internal solidarity whfle at thesame time allowing the rapid accumulation .{)f funds. Typically, from five to twenty males would live together, the number depending upon their work situation and locality. Money for food and other household expenses would be pooled, and domestic duties such as cooking rotated among the group's ? members. If resources were sufficient, one of the group might be paid to cook excluiively for the rest of the group (Das 1923). ' The residential group also formed a. basis for mutual support, and loans, favours, and obligations flowed freely between its members. The usefulness of this arrangement from an economic ooint of view is readily evident. As noted by Cheng (1931 :203), East Indian Canadians were able to accumulate savingsdat a considerably higher rate than either.the Japan~se or the Chinese. The community collectively also evinced the benefits of ·mutual assistance. r ' As mentioned, they were able to collect $10,000 by 1908 towards a Vancouver Sikh temple. In that same year, the Guru Nanak Mining and Trust Company was started with a claimed capita, . h -33- 55 -worth of $50,000. By 1914 the colTlllunity had considerable financial r 56 resources. Beyond pure accumulation, East Indians were able to donate thousands of dollars io charitable ind political causei, and successiu)ly 'provided welfare and legal services to their own colllTl,unity continuously through World War I I. -~ , )';;c C. -,.,if'. . Protest against Restriction This social cohe~io~ can also be seen in early political organization. From 1908 on, the East Indian community fought .loudly against the restrictions put upon them. Unlike the Japanese, they' had no home government support whatsoever, and yet _they campaigned relentlessly against subor9inati-0n. From the first they made the maximal claim -- that, as Britlsh sub- jects, as "members of the Aryan Race", and as retired ·soldiers of the Queen, they should be accorded all of the rights -of other Canadians. Neither the Japanese nor the Chinese were so explicit in their protest. Their counter-attack against caste subordination and exclusion was not limited to the courts. Using their literate middle class as inter- mediaries, East Indians propagandized the Canadian public directly. English language periodicals such as the Aryan (1911-1912), Canada and India (1915-1916), the Hindustanee (1914-1915), and India and Canada (19291930) were aimed at least in part at the white corrmunity. The Canada India - - Corrmittee of .Toronto- also presented East Indian grievances to the rest of Canada in a series of pamphlets (1915a; 1915b; 1916). - Several early members of the colllTlunity, particularly Saint Nihal Singh {1~07; 1908a; I -34- 1908; 1909; 1912), Sunda Singh (1911a; 19llb; 1911c), and Nand Singh S4rha ' (1913a; 1913b) wrote extensively in popular journals about the conditions under which their compatriots lived. 57 1912 and to India in 1913. Deputations were sent to 0ttawaQin . Political mobilization was not to be,directed solely towards the amelioration of their own situation. Frustrated in the attempt to gain .. equality in British Columbia, many Sikhs vigorously supported a number of Indian independence organizations with time, money, and occasionally,~with their live~. As early as 1908,-,Taraknath Das was publishing the 'sedit- ious' journal Free Hindustan, first in Vancouver and then in Seattle. From this ,_point until the end of World War I, East Indians in British Columbia were closely affiliated with the significant independence movement centering in San Francisco which, under the initiating inspiration of Lala Har Dayal, was crystalized into the Hindustanee Ghadr Party. Ghadr was to be the most important overseas revolutionary movement to arise 58 prior to the thirties, and was the first which,was not overtly communal . East Indian workers in British Columbia also had sonsiderable sympathy with the International Workers of the World tt7aut l9lf:24). Entrepreneurial Activity In contrast to both the Chinese and Japanese, entrepreneurial acttvity among early East htdiattS in Canada was httt slightly iieveloped. The bltte collar nature of the East Indian workforce was maintained until after. World War II.. The only significant exceptions to this tendency were f~ w , -35- I,. the wood industrie~, which by the 1930 s were to employ over 90% of all . 59 · _East Indians involved in industrial wage labour. By 1923, East Indians 1 owned seven logging camps, two shingle factories, abo~t 5~ (mostly oneman) firewood businesses, and six lumber mills (Das 1923:27). Two of the latter, Mayo Lumber Company and Kapoor MHls~ were to become la·rge-scale employers in the late 1920 s (Canada and India 1(3):4), and even though 1 the Depression reduce_d East· Indiarl(Participation in the lumber industry,. East' Indian mills accounted for 5% of the total provincial production in 'Ill 1914 (Smith 1944). Farming, particularly dairying, was another entrepreneurial outlet, and a few farms had been established-as early as 1912 (Hindustanee, January, 1912:8). There were 25 farms noted by Das (1923:28) in 1923, and approximately this same number continued to exist into the post-War era, when the number began to incfease, (Button 1964)~ · Retail business, with the exception of a limited participation in transportation and firewood selling, was minimal. 1 The End of the First Era of Asian Immigration The onset of World War I marked the beginning of the end of an era in Asian irrrnigration to British Columbia. By 1913, Japanese irrrnigration had been severely reduced by treaty, and East Indian iITITligration had been stopped altogether. The famous Komagata Maru incident of May and June, 1914 failed to dent the continuous journey clause as it applied to East Indians (Ferguson 1975). In fact, the number of East Indians in British -36- --~olumbywent down sharply during the War as· many Sikhs returned to India '-...._J ~ C with revolutionary intents (Mathus 1970) or moved to the Unitea States. Chinese irrmigration was only th.en recovering from the li_mitations of the 6 1904 head tax: o ~disruption of shipping by the War, combined with an Order in Council (December 9, 1913) banning all labourers from irrmigrating to British Columbia, limited· further increase in Chinese irmiigration temporarily. ;,, At the 1918,;Jmperial War tonf~rence it was decided that, while it was >. the right of the D"ominions to regulate their. own irrnnigration, for humq,'nitarian reasons the wives of Blien residents in those Dominions ou9ht to ,- ,,.. be allowed to follow their-husoands. In response to this opinion, and after eleven years of forbidding it, the Canadian Government's March .26, 1919 Order in Council finally allowed the wtyes and dependent children of East Indian residents in Canada to enter the country. By 1940', 256 women and 423 children had done so, and the corrmunity was well on its way to61 wards a normal social life. Subsequent to the First World·War, Parliament banned totcqJly the ~ further irrmigration of Chinese warkers (DHC 1923, 503). legally irrmigrated to Canada from 1925 through 1952. Only seven Chinese Unlife East Indian exclusion, Chinese wives and children were not allowed entry under the new regulations, and the Chinese in British Columbia were destined to r-emain a primarily male society until after the Secund Wurlct war. The Japanese were the last to be successfully excluded from further '" irrrnigration to Canada. While the Lemieux Agreement limited the numbers > • -37- of Japanese immigrants sharply, it continued to average near to 600 a year over the twenty years from the enactment of the Agreement to 1928;· 11,745 . Japanese, 5,995 of them women, entered during this period. After the First World War and the suc!essful exclusion of the Chinese, hostility towards ,Asians centered on the Japanese (Roy 1973). In 1922, the Federal Government was pressured to restrict the number of fishing licences held . 62 · by the Japanese. Propagandists continued the cry of exclusion, based on . . - . . ' the dual thesis that th~ Japariese were both an economic and a -political latter because th~ Japanese were ~resumed to have totil win their home government and ~ight become a Japanese tool to· 63 over the Pacifi~ No>thwest. e of their early naturalization and their consequent high pro. . portion of the Japanese became liable to the other charge which their exclusion. · The Provin.c ial Government's Report on Oriental _ctivities within the Province (1927) estimated that the rate was four times that of the general population. Exclusionist developed this evidence along the lines· of a popular Empire thesis (Stodda 1920) which suggested that unless drastic measures were taken the breeding potential of the Asian peoples would make white countries 'go yellow'. In 1928, Japanese irrmigration was further limited by treaty to no more than 150 a year, thereby completing the- exclusion of Asians 64 from Canada. ,I ' -38----------- - ------- - - ~ Ethnic Relations in Early British Columbia:. a settler society Prior to· the Fir.st World War, British Columbia witnessed . the successive entree of three Asian minorities, and in each case the response of the white population was one of-hostility, subordination, and of attempted exclusion. Man/ of tt:1e answers to why this was so stand out clearly i_n_ . the historical record, even in the brief fashion in which it has been related here. Considerably more understanding comes from cisting this . ' . history in more gen~ral terms, par~icularly with reference to the sociological literature on comparative ethnic relations. British Columbia was, first and foremost, a settler society -- a society defined and established by a body_of colonizing European irrrnigrants who came with th~ intention of permanent res,idence. ~Other settler societies of British origin would include the early American Eolonies, New· Zealand, Australia, Kenya, Rhodesia,.and marginally, South Africa. In each of these iases, British Columbia included, this historical pattern of sett1ement was to have irrrnediate consequences for ethnic relations. The.move itself meant that one's life chances were intimately tied up with the new homeland; interests, affiliations, and most importantly, rights became more and more derivable from the settler society and less·from the 65 Group affiliation, at least in the narrow sense of country of origin. economic survival, was with-one's fel1ow emfgre~or it was-tfle·socfoeconmni,c pasittorr of this group in ttre cutuny upun whictr om:+-s- ~i1mmt depended. It is not surprising that in each of these British settler societies -39- · - - - · - - - - - - -- - - - - - - -- the new homeland was categorically d1.i ned as "white i:i_an 's'. couritry''. In · its nineteenth-century usage, tied up as it was with ;crimatic and racial .. determinism, this the.sis gave Europeans an~ priori rationalization that ·, I - th~y had rights of access and use to those areas of the globe which were climatically temperate and which were "empty", iQ the s~nse that the_y gJd _ · not contain '"highly developed indigenous societie$-...- Thus, climatically, Kenya was considered fit fqr white settlement while adjacent Uganda was not, British Co-lumbia rwas demograph,cally acceptable while India was not. 66 . . In British Columbia, detached as it was from Eastern Canada and facing the Pacific with its "·teeming millions", the ideology .of whi-te man's country included elements of Anglo-Saxon destiny and of the defense of , -. • the vanguards of West_e rn Civilization agains~ the "hordes of Asia". :-~ British Columbia was "empty": ,. ~ With fertile territory equal to France and Sp~in combined the population of British CoTumbia is little moref these liabilities are placed on Fijian i1T1T1igrants. \ A'sians · were rigorously segregated socially. C01T1T1unication between · whites ~nd Asians was orimarily of a functional nature, and rarely touched • • ~~ - - ~- - - ·' · --~ --- ~ • •. - · -✓~ - - • --•-~· ·'• r "'"" -.- ~- _> -, ., ·· _. t • , .. , •,-·-'!• .,, -~ ..;.,e , ·,_..,,._ _ ~ - --'-••·. _ ,. •·•· . -43- upon personal experience. Business transactions and employee-employer relations made up the majority of links between Asians and whites in early , British Columbia : Information flow in the sphere of ethnic identity was near non-existent, with th·e consequerrce thait..~tereotypes, of Asians had very ...,_ , ".:. ·-.., ,,_ little in the way of 'objective' content to them. .· Racist avoidance, coupled with Asian caste segregation in occupation and in geographical ' location, reinforced by the centripetal tendencies of the minorities themselves, bounded each of the three communities. 68 actions were performed by midd]emen. Most significant inter- 'Asians were systematically barred from a whole range of occupational possibil1ties and were thereby relegated l?rgely to the blue collar working class. Even o/ithin the working class Asians were subordinate. A split labour market was universal until the 1930 s, when minimum wage laws sought 1 to ensure preferential white participation in the work place by the legis69 lation of equality in white and .~sian rates of pay. The belief was that if both received equal pay, a 11 jobs -would therefore go to whites. Asians were also restricted in their possibilities for advancement, and tended to remain for long periods of time at the same job. Managerial positions, expecially when in the control of"white workers, were rarely secured by' Asians. Conversely, Asians were given few opportunities to compete for skilled manual jobs, and tended to be given the most repetitive and onerous 70 In the mills, a white might operate a saw and an East Indian would ones. stack lumber; whites would fell trees and Asians would -work on the green chain. L -44- There were many other restrictions on Asian employment. Asians were informally excluded fr-0m the great majority of white collar clerical and sales jobs, in many cases up until the late 1950 s. 1 together from the craft unions. They were barred al- _ Provincial decree restricted them from working on public works and on the felling of Crown timber. Federal regu- lations limited the number of Japanese fishing licences granted from 1922 onwards (Angus 1931 :8). Asians were informally restricted 'from employment in the Federal, Provincial, and Municipal Governments. In the professions, specific regulations of the licencing bodies in Pharmacy and Law {Angus " 1931 :6) reserved these occupations _tor whites only. Additionally, the Trade Licence Boards Act of 1928 (B.C.S. 1928, Chap. 49f provided the possibility of the severe regulat1on of Asian business licences should it ,.) be "in the public interest". f/ Social ·and political restrictions were equally severe. Asians legally could have been (and often were) banned from restaurants, theatres, 71 . h an d movie ouses. There was a great reluctance to sell housing to Asians, ·especially in middle class areas. participation whatsoever: Politically, Asians were allowed no They could not vote, either municipally, provin- cially, or f~derally, nor could theyrserve in the Legislative Assembly, or on municipal or school boards. Most Asian Canadians held the status of alien residents, and therefore were potentially subject to deportation or collective removal, should they individually violate Canadian law or should 72 the law be changed. . J -45- 0 Asian Reactions to·Subordination • There was much that the Chinese, Japanese and East Indian immigrants held in common, not the least of which were the preceeding restrictions under which they laboured. Each group came from a fairly localized source and from a rural background. In each case there was ~nsiderable ethnic and class uniformity, both of which were strengthened by a common Canad-ian 73 experience; The pattern of irrmigration and the motives for it were also similar. The initiating impetus was in all instances dependent upon a flow of information and personnel between North America and home. This propagation of knowledge about Canada built up an exponentially increasing number of people irrrnigrating which was limited only by G~ve7nmental barriers. Chinese, Japanese, and East Indians all were sojour~e~s, and the motive for immigration was irrmediate gain. There were consequently few women and many young, single men. Each group eventually accepted caste subordination (for they had no alternatives), but each hoped that in that subordinate position they would have the right to follow their own ethnic traditions; having been denied the preferred status of being separate but equal, they acquiesced to being separate, even if unequal._ Within the\erimeters of each group there developed a.complex set of "parallel institutions" (van den Berqhe 1967:34), which helped to define reality in an image of home and which provided for a wide range of needs, from religion to recreation to social welfare and education. Early British Columbia was a hybrid sort of society where, much -41 r -46- like blacks in present-day South Africa, Asians were subordinately integrated in the provincial economy and rigorously segregated elsewhere.· Industrial wages fueled a whole diversity. of traditional institutions, WA'.H:h were c·rysta 1i zed ,through caste subordination and entrenched by the . t 74 lack of new il'11Tligrant personnel. The·remarkable parallels between Chinese; Japanese, and East Indian immigration should not blind one to the variations upon the general pattern wrought by each group. In retrosoect, the political and economic resources available to each group differed considerably, with the result that their contests with ·the forces of exclusion and segregation were each played out ~ distinctively. These reservoirs of potential power can be separated ana- lytically, and the differences in res9urces thereby made more evident. \.. Among the political resources which were relevant to the situation of immigrant Asians were the degree of home government support, political motivation, political knowledge, and the internal structure of the community. I Economic resources are also separable, and include economic motivation, skills, and again, internal corrmunity organization. Each is discussed in turn. Home Government Support In each case, one of the most significant factors in the determina:.. tion of the place of Asian immigrants in Bri~ish· Columbia was the degree to ·- -- which the Canadian Government and its citizens believed that discrimination . against il111ligrants \lr'Ould be met by sanctions from the country of origin. ... _47:.. Home governments could also directly affect the course of immigration itself. This ' factor could and did work either positively o'f negatively. The . Japanes·e were the only group whi .ch received significant support from their government and the i nternati ona l interests of Canada were such that ·restri cti ons on Japanese immigration were made only through treaty and were effected solely by the Japanese Government. The Japanese Government also supported _i~s c\tizens in Canada through diplomatic and media ~hannels. · Japan ? national image as a militarily powerful, rapidly modernizing, 1 independent country directly affected both irrmigrant Japanese nationalism and self worth and the white stereotype of individual Japanese built up after that image. Japanese immigrants earned a grudging respect among whites for standing their ground, for innovation and Westernization. the three Asian groups, they were seen as the dangerous 1 1 Of ones -- a measure of respect in adversity. The Chinese had no support whatsoever from their home government, · and consequently the course of Canadian i1'1111igration policy which -dealt with them was decided unilaterally and was based upon nitional interests . . The national image of China as a helpless giant, governed by a decadent aristocracy and prey to any foreign nation bold enough to subjugate her, reflected negatively upon the Chinese •iITJT1igrant. They, too, were seen as childlike, in need of strong control and direction, as amoral, as patient and hardworking, but incapable of innovation and only s-iow1y a:dap·ta.-ble"to modern ways. They were domirrate-d in accorda~ with the stereotype-.- I twas . only for the East Indians that the home government worked directly against their interests. Because India was a British colony, its · policy was subject to control by Britain, and it was not in either the British or the Canadian Government's interest to allow Indian immigration to North America. It was accordingly stopped quickly : totally, and with- out dissent on the part of any of the concerned governments. East Indians derived no political resources at all from India, save for the minimal leverage which they were able to develop by publicizing their plight in Indian journals. Political Motivation Once in British Columbia, the degree to which Asians mobilized their counter-attacks was dependent upon several interconnected factors, motivation being a vital aspect. MotivqJ:ion for oolitical acti.on (including defence of self and of personal honour) depended largely in turn on the reasons for immigration _and on the irrrnigrants' collective view of their self worth. All groups came initially as sojourners, and this itself severely limited political motivation, for political activity was action directed . away from the ilTITlediate concern of accumulation. The decision to stay more or less pennanently, made first in significant numbers by the Japanese, •resulted in an increase in concern for their future in British Columbia, and t~reby increased the motivation for pol iti cal action. TM s was so al so for th'iEast Indian colTITlunity, which was able to apply enough pressure to bear that entry to Canada was allowed for their wives and children. .. 9. '·.. . . -49- ,~-·•0,.- Political .motivation was also dependent upon immigrant ideas of sel,f and corrmun,ty identity, and upon the degree to which they were willing to accept the British Colulian 'premise of inequality' between whites and Asians. Within the constraints under which they liv~d, the Japanese . fiercely defended their status, honour and property. East Indians, who had come to believe that as British Subjects they possessed definite rights in the Empire, also reacted strongly against subordination; S-ikh ethnic pride augmented this feeling considerably. Although by far the smallest of the three groups, East Indians politically made up. for their n.umbers by con- · certed motivation. Political Knowledge If one takes political knowledge loosely to include that information which allows the exercise of political options in a given context, this factor too varied considerably. Of the three, the East Indians, as parti.- cipants in the British Empire, had internalized the methods of the_European lega_l system to the greatest degree \ and it was in this sphere that they . stood out. From 1908 on, East India~ constantly challenged the irrmigration ., laws in the courts. Chinese and Japanese were far less active in the courts, especially in the light of theit larger numbers and longer residence in British Columbia. Because of their understanding of British government organization and of Western media, East Indians were also the most effective ·- .. in propagandizing their vi~ws. f J J -50- Community Structure Political motivation also depended largely uoon the degree to which total community resources could be mustered, and this was in turn dependent upon community s t r ~ Community solidarity varied among the groups, with the numerically smallest, the East Indians, exhibiting cohesion to the greatest degree. Size, length of residence, and community heterogeneity all varied together, and it was evident that among the Chinese there existed a wide range of personnel, with the effect that concerted community action was extremely difficult. Elite members of these three groups, who were the most likely vehicles for political action, were differentially tied to collective concerns, with East Indian and Japanese elites -being by far 75 more representative of the coll1Tlunity than the Chinese . Economic resources varied~ but not in such a marked degree as political resources ·. Neither did they result in as divergent an outcome between Chinese, Japanese, and East Indians. ,,,-- , This is readily understandable in the light of the fact that most formal and informal limitations up.on Asian~ concerned econOfflicissues, and most of these restrictions pressed upon each group equally. Economic Motivation As has been discussed, the motivation for initial immigration was an important determinant of the ill1Tligrant's orientation towards life in Canada. As most came initially as sojourners, regardless of group, there was little to differentiate initial economic motivations. Members of all -51- --~ _____ ......... . ----- -- ----- -·------ ---- - - - - - · - 0 three groups, desirous of ecQnomic positions which would give consi~tent and quick income, were forced into the lowest ranks -of the working class. But as the Chinese and Japanese communities developed, entrepreneurial op~ions became increasingly a.vailable. Because entreoreneurial activity was usually capital intensive, .moving out of the working class ·was often synonymous with the decision to remain in Canada . . Both the Chinese and the Japanese developed small entrepreneurial· classes, while the East Indians did not. Coming to the scene at a later d~t~, East Indian entre- pren_eurs could neither rely on their o~n small community for ·support nor could they compete successfully against the established Chinese and Japanese entrepreneurs for a portion of the white business. The East Indian community was to remain essentially a working cl ass one unti 1 very recently. . / Skil 1s ,) It would be a grave error to suggest that inmigrants from Asia came without ski 11 s. Cl early they did not. Both -the Chi ne~e and the Japanese moved significantly into agricultural pursuits, following their backgrounds. The Japanese concentration in the fishing industry was also deoendent in part on.prior experience. While East Indians,also possessed agricultural expertise, utilization of those skills in Can~da__ ~~_ffere~i___f_!'Qll] j:~_e lack _of____ ~ -available East Indian manpower and from the necessity of competing with the - - - - ·- - - - ~ -- - - -- -···- dominant position of the Chinese and Japanese in vegetable and fruit farming. It is not surprising that what East Indian agricultural endeavour -52- there wa:s concentrated primarily upon dairying. Although the.Sikhs pas~ sessed acknowledged military and policing skills, ·these were not utilizable in British Columbia because of racial restrittjons. Social Organization and the Economy Again, there was much alike in the three groups' internal social organization, especially as it affected economic pursuits. The demographi- cally larger size of the Chinese and Japanese communities allowed the rise ,:z,,. of an entrepreneurial class employing conmunity members, as mentioned. . • ,. And Chinese, Japanese, and East Indian corrmunity structures obviously facilitated successful .competition with white wage 1abour. But commurii ty structure could do little to affect the primary source of economic input -- wage labour, the structure of which was determined outside of the coIT111uni ty. The Modern Setting: East Indians in British Columbi~ after World War II After the effective termination of Asian irrrnigration in the 1920 s, . 1 the three corrrnunHies stabilized socially and demographically. All three continued to make extensive adaptations towards Western culfurar norms, at least in those spheres where Asians and Canadians interacted. Dress shifted, 76 and English facility climbect. A growing number of Asian Canadian children "' had been born and raised in the province, and through their schoolin~ and social contacts came a·massive exposure to Canadian culture and social practice. Nevertheless, the legal and informal restrictions against .Asians \. -53- persisted through World War II, during which the Japanese in Brftish Co1um77 bia were uprooted from their homes and interned away from the coast. The East Indian co1T111unity, which 'yle will now follow to the;present, moved 0 I • •-·~ slowly towards a position of relative equality in the society while.main:... taining its social separation from it. Altrrough a high degr,,ee of-internal corrmunity strife -eerststed· throughout this p~od, animosity between--Ea-st~ 78 Indians and whites mitigated corisiderably. By the mid-1940's wage parity with whites had been achieved, at least in t~e larger industries, although 79 equal occupational opportunity had not. The East Indian corrmunity of British Columbia in the l940's remained -, almost entirely Jat Sikh, and was the.refore extremely homogeneous in background. Save for a small number of males who had irnnigrated illegally, an of the men in the 1=01T111unity had' come prior t6 l 9.l 3 or as the depend,ent r '--.., sons of those first Jrrmigrants. time sma 11.. The number of Canadian-born was at that- Women were either the wives or daughter;s o.f ilTllli grant men. No \ other relations, including the husbands of Canadian East Indian women, were 'allowed entry. Ov~r the "quiet years" the corrmunity socially turned in upon itself. -fo 1944, ·only three Sikh men are reported to have married· · . ' /I .. 80 Canadian women, while no Sikh women had married Canadian men (Smith 1944). W~rld~•.rr II saw t~e ,beginning of a new era for British Columbia's East Ind~unity. This change was the result of several factors. In British Columbia, East Indians renewed their fight foKlegal equality during .,. the ~ar, for the ~irst time with significant white political support. One of the primary goals was renewal of the privilege of i1T111igration, which was I ) j -54- then prohibited /or 11 irrrnigrants belonging to any race who are deemed un-. ~) suitable to assume thl duties and responsibilities of Canadian citizen~ 81 11 ship • Equall~nt was the destr~n of the numerous social : and economic limitatiqns created by the Legislature and by regulating boards whi~h were·dependent upon keeping one off th~ Provincial voters• ~ 1is t. -- - • - - - - - - ~ - ------ Followfng the pattern set up by 'the visits of Srinivasa Shastri in- 1922 and Rabindranath Tagore and Rev. (.F. Andrews in 1929, several Indian notables lobbied the Federal and Provincial Governments on the fr_anchis_e \ duri_ng the early 1940 s. 1 These included H.~.L. Polak~ ~ r y of the Indian Overs-eas Association and a compatriot of Gandhi in South Africa, the Hon. Pandit Kunzru, Kodanda Rao, a member of the influential Servants . . of India, and Dr. o:P. Pandia, wht> remained to carry the fight to its conclusion. In 1945, the CCF put the issue to a vote in the Leg,islature, where it was ·narrowly defeated. Subsequently, on April 2, 1947, the Legis- · ~ lat~re passed Bill ?5, which granted both East Indians and Chinese the right to vote i~British Columbia, subject to the same requirements as other residents. This' fonnally eliminated most legal restrictions ~on East Indtans in the province, and simultaneously gave them Dominion franchise. ·' Municipal franchise was achieved late in the same year. - This importan~ shift in the legal position of East Indians in British Cofom9ia was_not the si~le result of a minority fight for equal rights. ~~ath~~i international events subsequent to Wor;ld War II were irw,ortant·••influences, as they were for the equally moraen,tous'changes in Canadian i1T111igration policy which were to come. The War, like the '1reat·Har before -55- ...... ~ - it, shook the foundations of the world ·Qrder. One of the consequences was the decolonization of much of the Third World and the rise of the voice of these emergent nations on the world scene. -With the independence of India l and Pakistan, and with th_e growing strength and autonomy of China, Canadian domestic and international policy regarding·them could no longer be - - - - ------------- - --~-- -- made unilaterally, as it had been in the case of East Indian and Chinese -- ------~~ ' immigration restrictions of the past era. As an active participant in t_h_e creation of the Unitec:I Nations, Canada became open to the charge of hypocrisy if it were to continue to discriminate against its Asia~ minorities; when in 1946 the Canadian Government chose not to support a resolution in t~e United Nations <:,;m'ldemning_/ - the treatment., of Indians in South Africa, the move was met with an adverse home press reaction which suggested parallels b~een Indians in South / Africa and Indians ·; n Canada (Andracki 1958: 198). The end of the war saw Canadian industry expanding rapidly, f_illing the vacuum created by th·e mi 1itary destruction of the major European econ.;. omic structures. Several labour shortages were soon evident, especially in primary industries, which -have been 'historically prone to wild oscillations in their output. For the first time since 1931, irrmigration was' 82 looked to for a. ~ource of additional wage labour. On May 1 ,· 1947 (P.C. 1734), the Mackenzie Ki119 Goyey-11_111~n't:_~11ne>u_11_c_ed that thereafter,_~nd_iri_du_e_ __ regard for labour demands, irrmigrants from traditional source countries 11 I 11 . (i.e., from white, English-speaking ones) would be'allowed to inmigrate to Canada under extremely liberal conditions. Additionally, in deference to --- ···--·- ------- --- - • -----··- -· .. --- ---- - -----·-·- - - -- the U.N. Charter the Chinese Immigration Act was repealed, and the Chinese were given the · same rights to sponsor relatives as the East Indians had secured thirty y.ears before. Ttie onerous continuous journey clause of 1908, which had for all purposes ended East lndia·n immigration, was also .removed. Even so, Asians were to be maintained as a separate .cateqory for immigration purposes until 1967. By June, 1950, the previous liberalization · . of immigration regulations were seen to have been insufficient to meet Canad-ian labour demands, and they were therefore further loosened. From . ;llf: that point on, (white) Canadian residents would be able to sponsor relatives of any degree. Independent inmigration was to be allowed in agri- culture, entrepreneurial and professional occupations, andl."inthe case of workers sponsored by Canadian employers . .Asians were unaffected by the - . new regulations. In the same year, the class Qf admissible Asian irrmigrants was increased to include the husbands of Asian Canadian women and their dependent children; In · l951, a series of bilater.a l agreements allowed_ the inmigration of . 150, 100,' and 50 people per year from India, Pakistan,.and Ceylon, respectively, over the number admitted as sponsored relatives (Hawkins . 83 · 1972:92). Attempts by the Vantouver Khalsa Diwan Society in 1952 to have the range of sponsorable relative~ in_c~_ea~ed met _with failur~ __i_n _______________ _ .. India's quota was increased to 300 in 1957, --84 and the criteria for selection under the quota were slightly altered. Parliament (Corbett 1957:30). - . - - -- ---·- - , By the 1961 census, there were only 6,774 East Indians in Canada, 4,526 of - - - ;, 'i -57- which were resident in British Columbia (Jain 1971 :6). While this was up'-..,../ considerably from the 1951 figures of 2,148 f'd l ,937~ East Indians in British Columbia ha~ only just acbieveWnumbers the size they~had had in 1908. Becal.:e admissible class of East Indian iITITiigrants up to 1962, ~ were largely the close relatives of East Indians residing in Canada, a. S,.jkh majority continued to be preserved in British Columbia. Marriage and sponsorship both continued to reinforce the concentration of iITJOigrant source areas. Of those who were able to iITITiigrate independent of sponsor- ship many were of other 'ethf backgrounds, but.· their numbers were not significant. Moreover, betuse of the fierce competition for the few quota positions a large number of the early independent ilTBlligrants were profession·als or businessmen who tended to locate in the metropolitan centres of the East, especially in Ontario. British Columbian East Indian iIT111igration continued to be Sikh and to be working class. Adrian Mayer (1959:3) estimated that more than 9/lOths of the Vancouver area East Indian population was Sikh in 1959. Mgst continued to move into manual occupations, and perhaps 75% were still in one or another of the wood industries, with a heavy concentration in the mills. Through these·years, Canadian iITITiigration policy moved increasingly in the direction of economic ratfonali zatJon; requirements____conc.erned_wfth_ _ matching Canadian workforce demands with suitable iITITiigrants increased, and sdon were to take precedence over other considerations. , Under this demand the range of countries, of ethnic backgrounds, and finally, of J .J -58;- colours from which irrmigration was acceptable also increased. · This process of economic reorientation of immigration policy was acknowledged in the unification of manpower and irnnigration concerns under one department of Government in 1966 and in the continual restriction of sponsorship which was carried out from 1956 through 1967., In 1967 the regulations were issued under which irnnigration is currently conducted. Although I will have reason to qualify this assertion at a later point, they at least theoretically signified a complete rationalization of the system. From that point on, the Government formally disavowed a policy of racial or. , 85 national restriction of irnnigrants. A rationalized point system was 11 11 established.which gave weight to the factors of education, skills, occupational demand in Canada, knowledge of English ~r French, age, and prearranged employment. Sponsorst)ip was reduced to dependent relations. A new hybrid class of nominated immigrants was created which mixed these socioeconomic factors with consideration of support by one's nominating relatives. Theoretically, this system would be applied unifonnly throughout the world, and neither would previously preferred or previously banned ,, countries be differentially evaluated. It was tfiis policy change which radically altered the nature of the East Indian population of Br'itish Columbia. This shift had two aspects, both demographic, but with differ~nt consequeri~e~. _Firstof _all ,_the_numbers of East Indian people who irnnigrated to Canada increased enonnously: - - - - - - - - - - - { -59- Number Year 1956 1957 1958 1959 1960 1961 1962 1963 Table IV. Year ~umber 1964 2,077 332 334 1965 3,.491 4,094 1966 459 6,000+ ) 741 1967 · 691 57,500+ 1968-73 86 ~estimated 20,000+ 744 1974 830 1975 17,000+ ) 1,331 East Indian Immigration to Canada, 1956 to 1975. _In 1974 and 1975, for instance, people of East Indian origin comprised a minimum of 9% of the total immigrant flow to Canada -- a huge increase over the past -- but still only one-half the flow from Britain alone in those years. By my own estimates there are now roughly 45,000 East Indians resident in British Columbia, which represents more than a doubling of the population since the census of 1971, which gave the figure 87 With the qualification that it is only a rough estimate, as 18,795. othese·45,000 now constitute about one-quarter of the-approximately 0 145,000 East Indians in Canada. The second demographic consequence of the liberalization of the immigrat1on regulations has been a broadening of the sources of East Indian immigration, with the resultant increase in. the heterogeneity of the British Columbian East Indian population. Inmigrants ·from India are no longer only Punjabi Sikhs; there are now many India-bQrn Hindus and Moslems in British Columbia who come from all ove~r tne rnafansabconfinenc-~1he ex-- ·--~--- --~-~~-p-ulston of A-stans from Uganda tn l-9-lt--and--the Ca11adia11 Government's deci-s=-:-~ ---~~-- -ion to grant a large number ?f them refugee st~tus,.;{a~resulted in the . f creation of a collfllUnity of Ismaili Muslims in British Columbia, who now -60- 1 must number well over 6,000 (Morah 1974:2). Pakistani Moslems have also begun to arrive, as have immigrants from Sri lanka (Ceylon), Kenya, and others whose previous_ residence was in Britain. The Fijian East Indian community of Vancouver is. at least in part a result of this new immigration policy. / There is, therefore, no longer one East Indian community :in British Columbia properly speaking, but rather several, which are complexly interlinked by networks which follow ethnicity, nationality, relig,ion, class, k.inshi-p and ·occupation. N-one of these sub-communities, the Fijian one included, stand as isolated a~d autonomous elements, 'and yet the sum total, .. ',if I the "East Indian corrmuniti', no, long_er has much more than a definitional rea 1i ty. The exception to this generalization concerns East Indian-Cdnadian relations. As will be brought out in Chapter Eight, most white Canadians { in British Columbia have only the most vague notions about the very real differences which exist between one East Indian and another, and therefore tend to view all East Indians as members of a relatively homogeneous group. Because of this lumping piocess, stereotypes and interactional patterns built up after the Sikh pioneers of yesterday are used upon the East Indians of today. Thus, whatever the background and personal affiliations of any single East Indian resident of British Columbia, he must const~ntly interface witf) a larger so€ial cont-ext which he knows wtl-1 prejuctge-nim-in88 accord, w:i th a uni versa! -S-te--r--eo--ty.pg.. Internal-ly-,~~ creates more solidarity and interaction between members of the different East Indian subconmunities than might otherwise be~ -f -6F This increase in the representation of East Indians in British Columbia has not passed unnoticed by the rest of British Columbia, and there has been a considerable prejudice an~ hostility growing againstl"'\\ these new immigrants from the late 1960's on. j East Indian immigrants f have been coll~ctively held to be responsible for the high unemployment current in the provinc~, for the steep rise in the cost of living, especially of housing costs, for increased taxes (these for presumed East Indian welfare and educational costs)~ for the deterioration of neighbourhoods, and for the demise of Canadian civilization generally. Individually, they are seen much like they were 60 years ago, as argumentative, violent, litigious, unassimilatable, and intrinsically communal. Added to this has been the high birthrate charge which was applied to the Japanese in the and 1930's. These ideas are part of the context w1th which Indo= s must now come to terms, and while it may not be possible to generalize to all East Indians, these interactional constraints significantly modify Fijian patterns of behaviour. The Modern Economy A f~al.point should be made in this introduction to Brit\sh Columbia as a setting for Fijian irrmigrants, and this concerns the nature of the present day provincial economy. Back in 1929,-_primar}'--pr---0-duct-i-o-n---acc:-0unt-e-dfor more than 65% of thg total productjQn c:rL tbeQrQvince {_British Columbia 1935:4), with forestry alone contributing about 40% of primary production. Today, the economy shows this same dependence on extractive industry. -62- ' } Forest products accounted for 49% of factory shi~ments in 1972 (British Columbia 1972:56), and 95,000 people weie employed in forest industries in 1975 (British Columbia 1975:v). Mining and agriculture are still of great importance to the economy, and most secondary industry is geared to the processing of primary resources~ . Nevertheless, the economy has not remained within this basis alone. Small-scale secondary industry employing less than 50 workers has increased, while employme_n t in service industries has exploded, increasing 71% i,!1 the last ten years (British Columbia 1975:v). has gone up by 59% in the same period. Employment in trade industries Both of these increases reflect ·- . the rise of Vancouver as a West Coast centre for shipping and fi~ance. ( While the base of the economy has· wideee ultimate importance of the extractive industries still makes for wide, industry-selective swings in employment. · The economy has, since 1970~3, experienced a strong downturn, a-nd i::irimary industries have · been _particularly affected. provincial unemployment has risen since 1970~ Overall It is now at 9% and has not been under 6% sqnce 1970 (British Columbia 1975:10). While industrial emp_loyment has ihcreased about 14% over the last four years (1972-6), it has been level ove~the last two, and down slig~tly in forestry and manufacturing. Although personal inc~me has increased from . $4,121 to $6,074 · per capita over 1972-5, doubTe-digit fnflation Tn l>r1 ¢-es· ·-.,-as stab,nz-ed --re-al persona 1 income for the-- last two years.- -Sharp rtses in housing costs- _hthe average Vancouver house now sells for $65,000), _coupled with high ~terest rates have made house ownership prohibitive to mo~t pe-op 1-e without -63- • 89 large initial equities. Food prices have increased a ful1 50% since 1972 (British Columbia 1975:viii) . .There are few indications that British Columbians exp~ct these· conditions to ameliorate significantly in the i1T1T1ediate future, and for many this is a time of frustration, retrenchment, and of the 1imitation uf expectations. Simultaneously, for Fiji an Cana~ dians this is a time of establ1shment and pioneering, and of development of corrrnun i ty. Fijians, like all immigrants, come to Canada br{nging with them values and expectations which are largely formed by the cultural context which was their birthright. It is to this context, to Fiji, which we must now turn, in order to gain some insight into Fijian society and with it, · into its individuals, some of which have ventured to a new home in British Columbia. \ , -64--------------- Chapter One: Notes 1. As with the Japanese, no attempt will be made to provide an extensive history of the Chinese in British Columbia. For further detail, see the historical theses by Andracki (195?), Wynne (1964), and Ward (1973), the sociological study by Chenq (1931) or the geographical one by Cho (1970). See also the two Canadian Royal Commission reports (RCCI 1885; RCCJI 1902) on Asian irrmigration to Canada and the Provincial Report on Oriental Activities within the Province (ROAP 1927). 2. They also ,participated vigorously in small-scale gold mining. Howay (1941 :568) notes that by 1860, Chinese claims constituted a maJoritY in the mining records of Yale. They were a majority by 1863 in Lytton as well. · · 3..._ This classic equation holds for Fijian immigration as \'/ell. off do not come and the poor cannot.···· The well- 4. In the inflated wage market of the gold rush, the differential between here and _China was at least as ·marked. A.J. Langley, writing in 1861 (1862:13) claimed that domestics in Victoria could then expect £5 to £6 per month, while J. Pemberton, then surveyor general of Vancouver Island, (1860:130), estimated that unskilled labour was being paid at the rate of $150 per year.· 5. See Bonacich (1972) for a more abstract analysis of the place·of the sojourner. I am drawing an ideal type, not suggesting, as did the popular stereotypes of the day, that actual Chinese Consistently achieved this ideal. 6. As noted by Cho (1970:21); the population -estimates of the 1885 Royal Corrmission gave the nUJTiber of males in British Columbia as 9,870 out of a total of 10,550 Chinese. Cheng (1931 :203) claims the r~tin of males to females in his time to be 15 to 1. A balance was not ~chieved until the 1960 s (Cho 1970:69). Cheng (1931) makes the point that this absence of women was cruciql to saving, considering the low wage rates. While he estimated that a single Japanese male could save an average of $570 per year, Cheng maintained that Japanese with families could save nothing at all. • .,.--. 1 7. Perhaps this state, rather than the ideal type of the ascetic · Protestant, constitutes pure economic rationalization at the individual level. The Protestant•s ideological coimlitment~ wfiTcn-gavemeanin-~f to his work situation, constrained h-'is behaviour, often in. ways which were nut perfectly congruent wtttr economic -dictates. 1m: Chinese, alienated from their work, could view labour more instrumentally. See Buchign·anf (1976) for a discussion of the post-Weberian debate on the subject'of ideology and economic behaviour .. · ~~- I -65------------ - - - - - - - 8. As both Saxton (1971:2) and Ward(l97l:62) maintain, anti-Chinese feeling cannot, either in California or in .British Columbia be explained only on the basis of cheap labour. For instance, prejudice against the Chinese as a_{ace rather th_an as competitors-made jt· difficult for white labour unions in British Columbia to accept either Chinese (Cheng 1931 :212) or Japanese (Sumida 1935:142) affiliate organizations. The Canadian Trades and Labour Congress platform had an Oriental exclusion plank until the 57th conference in 1941 -- · twenty years after the effective excl~sion of fllrthex A_si_a_11J11111Jigr_at5nn (TLC Proceedings 1941 :2). · · · • 9. See Cross (1935) for a pro-labour view of the California Asian debate. One shoul-d--keep in mind the extremely close communication evident. be..: tween California and British Columbia in the days prior to the completion of the Canadian Pacific Railroad. - 10. Jbert Dunsmui-r, king of the Nanaimo coll eri es, was an ardent supporter -' 11. of Chinese labour. So was his son, James, who became Premier and later, Lt. Governor of British Columbia. The CPR powerfully supported Chinese ilTITligration in Parliament as both a source of labour and of passenger revenue. In the case of East Indian immigration, whi-ch began almost fifty years after the first Chinese arrived in British Columbia, I know of very few pieces in print in the pre-War years which assume otherwise. Even• in the light of their claim to Aryan origins and their acknowledged place in the British Empire, there was a very common assumotion that as a r"ace East Indians wer~ inferior to wh.ites. 11 12. 13. 11 Saxton also notes (1971:56) that while white ·mine labour demanded $3.00 per day in California--i.n 1866, when the Central Pacific was completed in 1869 its skilled Chinese miners were working for $1.50. By the account of Charles Crocker, one of the heads of that railway (RCCI 1885:xviii) Chinese miners tunneling in the Sierra were able to manfor-man outpace Cornish miners brought in from Virginia City at premium wages. • Cheng (1931 :168-181) gives estimates of Oriental fiages in the mid1920's which average between 60% and 75% of whites, depending both upon industry and ethnic group. The_ RQyc1l_ Cammi ssi O!!__Qn Chine~e' IIJ111i- _____ ·__ _ gration (1885:xTJ estimated that unskilled Chinese labour at that time could be had for $15 to $20 per month, as opposed to $40 for equivalent whtte "taboar. 14. • - - Bonacich is moreunqualified in thi~co tention, suggesting a model where employers seek to buy labour cheapest possible price~ with ethnicity being essentially irrelev nt; a split labour market bY,this theory arises in response to organized pressure by white labour. This -66--~--------- --· becomes problematic when one considers the history of Britis_h- -eolumbia. First of all, it assumes that employers actualiy viewe~LOrlental labour . as interchangeable with white labour. Often they-did.not, seeing · Asians as less hard working, weaker,.or less skilled than whites. Benjamin Rogers' (B.C. Sugar Refinerymanager) response (RCCJI 1902: 465) is typical. He refused to/ hire any Asian labour. Moreover, often split labour markets arosepfior to any demands on the part of whites. Finally, even a split labour market .is but limite~rotection if the number of whites in the work place is steadily di nished; in increasing wage demands.in a split labour market, white war e"rs risk pricing themselves out of a -job. 15. Cheng (1931 :183) estimated that 90% of the 200 Chinese grocery stores in the Vancouver area catered primarily to white~~ Their prices were about 5% to 10% cheaper than their competition, and most were open till 10:00 p.m. Tailors (Cheng 1931 :184) were also able to offer · clothes·at 10% to 15% price differentials, as were Chinese-owned · restaurants. 16. ,These constraints are markedly similar to those experienced by Fijian Canadian e.ntrepreneurs (Chapter Four). 17. The range of Chinese occupations in these early years is illustrated by the Royal Commission's (1885:363) estimates of their work force composition in Victoria: Merchants ~ 45 Girls 31 Married Ladies 41 · Doctors 12 Barbers 20 Boot makers 130 Saw mill hands 17 Cooks I servants 180 Brick makers· 60 Farm lapour 40 Carpenters · 25 Vegetable seller~ 20 16 Fish sellers Tinsmiths 2 Sailors 3 New Arrivals 380 Table V. 18. Store employees 179 Boys under 12 10 School Teachers · 4 Sewing workers 30 Cigar makers 28 Washermen 90 Vegetable gardeners -114 Bricklayers 25 Match makers 7 tharcoal bijrners 16 Printers 3 Butchers ~ 8 - ~10 Pedlars _f_ye 1_cutters __ ... 6.4___ ~ _ _ __ Br,rk strippers , 30 Prostitutes 34 . B'oys between T2'" & 77 ~-- 92 . Chinese Workforce Composition ~n Victoria, 1884 The provincial Report ory Oriental Activities within the Province (1927:22) gave Asian workforce distributions as: J -6T- - - Female Male _C_h,_·n_e_s_e__H_in_d_u_s__J_a.__pa_n_e_s_e _C_h1_·n_e_s_e__J_a.._p_an_e_s_e - 3,865 728 2,437 Lumber industries Other wood 99 83 23 manufacturing 83 l 554 Pulp and paper Manufacturing food 72 7 1,272 8 products 71 Coal-mining 542 54 73 Metal:..mining 49_ Smelting 260 l l Builders' materials 413 71 Coast shipping 53 93 13 Contracting 116 76 Chemicals, etc. 9 28 Garment-making . House furnishings l l Jew~l ry Laund y, cleaning, dye, rig - - _ ( 47. l 14 l Lea er and fur l 3 6 Metal trades l l Oil-refining 33 Printing &publishing l Street-railways, gas · 4 power, & telephones 24 788 · 3,460 7 Totals 6,974 Table VI. Provincial Asian Workforce Composition, 1925. 3 -l 111 2 z 5 2 131 • These figures do not include agricultural work, unskilled or independent labour. In 1940 the Department of Labour of British Columbia (1940) gave the following as the figures for-t:hose industries most corrmonly employing Asian labour: Chinese Japanese East Indian Building materials ,,,.. Coal Mining Coastal Shipping Explosives, Chemicals Food Manufacture _ _5_30 Lumber industries Meta 1 Mf nfngPulp & Paper Snip Buflaing Smelting Wood, other Table VII. Provincial Asian Workforce Composition, 1940. -68- for e participation in British Columbia at that time was . ~-1rt..-.-A8,000, of which 4,950 were Chinese, 4,728 were Japanese, East Indian. 19. 20. vote was determined by provincial voting roles, this effectively barred Chinese in British Columbia from the Federal vote .. (Andracki 1958:3). '· The inspirations for this formula were the exclusion acts, of the Australian colonies of Victoria (1855), New South Wales (1851), and South Australia (1857). Students and tourists (and merchants until - T8s7rwere-•excep£eO:· ~As-tne· RoyaT comifiss·i on est·rmate·cr·tT885:366t-•••- -_ -that the typical -Chinese irrmigrant was able to save only $46.00 per year, this head tax of $50.00 was a considerabl_e barrier. 21.. In Victoria, 2,000 marched in protest against the Chinese in 1885 (Ward T973:9o)-:-~TnS--ept'em1Je·r,-'--f885~- an anti~Chines-eriot at·Rucr-~----=- ,~-- ----- -- Springs, Wyoming resulted in the death of 28 Chinese (Andracki 1958: 61; Saxton 1971 :202). One year after its charter was granted (1887), crowds-in Vancouver forced Chinese who were clearing land for -the new town t~ return to Victoria (Ward 1973:104). As the depression mitigated in 1888 the level of Hostility subsided considerably. 22. ·Foran exhaustive socio-economic survey of the Japanese in British Columbia see Sumida (1935), and Young and Reid (1938). 23 ... In contrast to the Cpi nese_? 2,692 Japane~e h~d h:come na tura 1i zed by , 1901 (RCCJI 1902:356). - This was done primarily 1n order to secure - -fishing licences. 24. Sug-imotq (1966:21Lalso lists Saikaido and Sa.q,;-odo as significant sources. Sumida gives the .propo~·t,_·_ons of prior Japanese occupations in a sample of 305 as 152 farmers, 5 labourers, and 23 fishermen, with the other 75 spread through a wide range of backgrounds. · , The voyage itself "-OU~d c st in the neighbof;:ood of $60. Typically · at same amount wi im. This total was far the irrmigrant had abo bey~~---the c_apability o _ the typical farmin family and man_y mortgage_d' lan~ecured loans at high rates of intere t in order to pay the cost__s~ :Lat_er_~a~t__Jn -~~ . . . ·~~· .... ~.~ ~ ~513· ,.,.. 529 ~~ij 575 East· Indian Workf()('_ce Participation, 1934-1946. . i -73- After 1949, information on ethnic background was _not collected. ., 60. Paradoxically, the $500 head tax, devised to appease British Colu~bfan exclusionists, had by this time become a lar_ge source of provincial revenue. The tax brought in over $1,500,000 in 1912 alone (Andracki 1958:128)~ 61. If these figures appear low, this is because of comparison to the 6,100 ~ast Indians who immigrated to British Columbia at one time or another prior to 1941. Since therE! were about 600 wQrktng'rnale_s_j_11__ . . _ _____ _ the community of ·1 ,500 (1941), many of whom were in their fifties, the ratio of meD to women and children is, in fact, a reasonable one. 62. Japanese gill netting licences were reduced from 1,989 in 1922 to 912 in 1932 (Sumida 1935:239). Surprisingly, the nu_mber of white and Indian fishing licences di~ not increase by anything near the same amount. -; 63. The list of classic anti-Japanese tracts is very long. Representative would be John Nelson's (1921) Will Canada Go Yellow?, Tom Macinnes' (1927) Oriental Occupation of British Columbia, H.H. Stevens' (1911) The Oriental Problem, and A. Hurd's {l913)The Racial War on the \. °' Pacific. 64. · 1,359 Japanese actually irrmigrated between 1930 and 1941, an average of 113 per year. -05. This contrasted strongly with the situation where Europeans immigrated temporarily and in small .numbers to the colonies, as in the British Colonies of India, Burma, and Uganda. 66. · Race relations accordingly were more similar in British Columbia and Kenya, and in India and Uganda, respectively. I 67. AJthough perhaps risking heresay to liberal dogma, it seems difficult to see how British Columbia labour could have survived without immigration curbs. Business otherwise would have been able to reduce wages and working conditions in accord with the labour supply'; only with the establishment of permanent A~ian communities with vested interests in their future in British Columbia and with material expettations similar to white workers wo_lll<:l~si~rr_jmmigration cease to depress the wage-marKet. - ----- 6S. As 1a:te a-s 1926, Sumida notes that fewer than 26% of Japanese immigrants could understand simple spoken English (Sumida 1935:64). The c proportion of East Indians who could communicate in English in that year would not likely have been any greater (Dhami 1969). -74- 69. By setting a minimum wage rate close to the rates of pay ea~ned by whites, white labour sought to destroy the major concessions they had been forced to make in accepting a split labour market. N,e-vertheless, minimum wage legislation were not entirely succ~ul. _F.or instance, the 1934 (B.C.S. 1934, Chap.-,47) minimum wage 1 et the wage minimum for work in the mills at 35¢ per hour -- wi h he provisio~ that 25% of workers could _be paid at rates 25% less. These 25% were invariably Asian. ~ 70. This same pattern was followed by East Indian inmigration tg~B ~tain ~in the 1950' s ~Aurora l96-7). 71. The loss of clientel caused by the Great Depression mitigated many of these restrictions. I • 72. In 1908 the Canadian Go1Jernment had attempted to remove the East Indians en masse to British Honduras (Harkin 1909), where they were to supplement the flagging supply of indentured labour. Cries for the total removal of Asians from British Columbia were heard through World War II, and although they were not acted upon by the Government, these demands were disconcerting to the province's Asian resi- _ . -, dents. ~ 73. There were elites in each group, and they were important. But the corrmon life situation here broke down many ethnic and class barriers, at least in the earlier years. For instance, East Indian observers (N.S. Sirha 1913, Indian and Canada 1929) report a considerable reduction of caste prohibitions, and East Indian elites, who would have had nothing whatever to do with the Sikh peasijlltry·in the Punjab, openly espoused their cause here. - 74. In many cases more recent Asian irrmigrants have been far more 'modern-' than those who have lived here, frozen into ethnic castes, for forty years. A major split in the Sikh corrmunity in 1953 was based upon this very sort of conflict (Mayer 1959). 75. Chinese elites were oft~ merchants, and their interests were hardly coincident with those of the working class Chinese irrmigrant. From this period o~lites in the East Indian co1T111unity have also tended to drift away from the concerns of working class members. This has been especially evident with the renewal of Indian inmigration in the early J950 's~ which--brought-to Canada-a number of middle-clasS--------- East Indians who had hot shared in the experience of those already her_e. · ._ __ _________ __'________________ 76. For instance, a considerable minority of Sikhs dropped the wearing of turbans and ~beards. Chin-ese traditional dress was a rarity by the 1-940'.s. -75- 77. On the internment of the Japanese during World War II see La Violette (1948), Canadian Department of Labour (1945), Report on the Adminis~ tration of Japanese Affairs in Canada, 1942-1944, and the British Columbia Security Coornission Report (1942). 78. ( The level of intra-colTITiunity tension is perhaps best indicated in the preliminary (typescript) report of the 1938 Federal Board of Review on Illegal Immigration. Although this Board was established and traveled the province in resppnse to British Columbian char~es that there was then large-scale illegal ilTITiigration of Japanese (the Board found none), 58-Eas-t -lndians wer-.e -reported to the---e-0n111i--ss-i-0n-- --- as being in the c~untry illegally -- by other East Indians. 79. Nor has equal occupational opportunity be~n ae;hieve~ to date. I will return to this question in detail in Cha~ter Four. Punjabi blue collar workers are sti11 relegated to tbamor--.e- men-i aJ ta-s-k-s+ especially in the wood industries where they continue to be heavily represented. In 1944, the skilled trades were still restricted (Smith 1944). 80. Although personal experience suggests that these figures are low, this pattern of marriage exclusivity contrasts sharply with marriage practice among Sikhs in rural California, where there was heavy intermarriage between Sikhs and Me~ican American women prior to World War II (Dadabhay 1964; Wenzel 1968). 81. For an in-depth review of the fight for franchise among the Sikhs, see the Khalsa Diwan Society of Vi.ctoria's Report on Dominion, Provincial, and nici al Franchise for the Hindus in B.C. (1947). For internationa1 corrmentary on this question see Ho land (1943). . 82. 83. , \ . The standing QrdetJn Council of March 21, 1931 (P.C. 695) fQrbade all irrmigration save for British Subjects from the U.K., Irel~d, riewiound.l and, New Zealand, Australia, and South Africa, and Utlited . ·. States citizens; irrmigrants from these source countries were to· be \ .:able to show that they had sufficient means ro carry on in Canada. Agriculturalists with the resources to begin farming were also· allowed. This policy was enforced in an exclusionary manner through~ out the Depression and the Second World War. · · These treaties were more of a symbolic nature tban they were functional. J.W. Pickersgill, Minister of Citizenship and Irrmigraticm, wh.e n as k.e.d by a -House ....of__ comno.ns.-coom-i-ttee----to--J-u-s.t-i-fy.---the--emp-1--G;imen-t- - -----of 12 \IIOrkers in the Delhi irrmigration office re·sponded {Hawkins : l 972: 101 ) ; _ _ _ __ _ --~ ---' t As a matter of fact, you know as well as I do, that we do not have an office in ·India for the purpose of getting irrmigrants, for the sakP. of increasing the popul ~.tion of '! 1 . ( -76-- - - - - - - . - - ~ I 84. 85. . ~ ~ Canada. We agr~ •• ;~~ this quota as a gesture for ~he improvement of ~nwealth relations. And, having done so, we have to tr~at these applicants decently and have enough employees there ~o answer the letters and deal with the correspondence and the applications which are received. _ See Mayer (1959:34) for the range of sponsorship allowed in the preference quota of the 1957 Canada-India Inmigration Agreement . . Irrmigration still continues to come primarily froin -H,e traaltfr1na-r· ---------- - source countries of Mackenzie King s day, in spite of the point system. For the reasons for this one must look to -the question of . access to the i11111igration system, and to the direction of information flow about it. 11 11 1 86. In conjunction with their policy of non-dJscrimination figures for ethnic origin -of irm,igrants were not kept by the Departm.ent of Manpower and Irrmigration after 1966. This makes determination of the flow of . types of inmigrants a difficult and approximate business. This 1967 figure ' adds the irrmigration total of India, Pakistan, a,nd Fiji for that year, and is therefore too low. The 1968-73 figure sums Indian, Pakistani, Bangla Deshi, Fijian, Sri Lankan, Ugandan, and Tanzanian · figures for those years, as do the totals for 1974 and 1975. Many _ Kenyan and British residents who inrnigrated were also East Indian, and they are not included, nor, were those who came from the United States, Australia, and South Afri ta. Source.- Depa'rtment of Manpower and Irrmigration Annual Reports, 1967-75; Departmenr.anpower and Irrmigration (1974b). · · 87. These figures for the present !ast Indian populati n of British Columbia are detennined by adding the _1971 census fiqures to the percentage of East !ndian flow giving British Columbia as its intended destination for the subsequent yea~s. - 88. This statement about the reaction of East Indians to stereotypes is a bit simplistic, (see in Chapter Eight). Nevertheless, East Indians do have to deal with this sort of stereotyping, even if they seek to explain it in differing ways. 11 11 , '\ 89. J By current rule of thumb, with an average house price of $70,000 and a $15,ooo ·ctown ·payme-nt, a famfly must n~ve an income 1n excess of · - - - - -$20,000 a year to qualify for a mortga~. -77- Chapter Two:· Fiji ,.. Fiji ans and Fiji Indians The. independent nation of Fiji is located in the South Pacific, 2,000 1 n:iiles northeast of Sydney and 3,000 miles southwest of Honolulu. Its 361 . islands comprise a total land area of 7,022 square miles, of which the two prihciple islands, Vanua·Levu·and_Viti Levu, represent 6,148 square miles, or 87% of the tota 1 (Watters 1969: 2; France 1969: 1). Aside fr.om these two _ . ' mountainous islands upon which the great majority of the 570,000 people of Fiji live, 94 other islands are inhabited, although only two of them . exceed 100 square .miles in area. EveR though Fiji is firmly within the tropics, the wide variation in geography among the islands makes for a great deal of regional variation in ·temperature, rainfall, and consequently, in population distribution. Because J the prevailing winds and their elevated central topography, v·iti Levu and Vannua Levu hav~marked wet and dry coastal areas. The eastern, windward coast receives an annual rainfall in exc~ss of 100 inches, distributed over much of the year. The natural flora is dominated by tropical forest in the low lying areas. The leeward sides of both islands get less than one-half the rainfall of the windward toasts, ind this falls exclusively ~uring the time of peak rainfall in the East. Veg-e-tati on is thef;jore considerably different, with grasses, reeds, and broken tree cover being roost typical. --- go below 50qF. t or above TOO~. Temperat\Jres throughout Fiji rarely Mean al/erag·e temperatures· for -both wet and d-ry zon-es elttSte-r around r!4f-., -wtttr a daily range of but 10° (Ward 1964~4) ;~ Prior to the 19th Century, Fiji was inhabited by a large population with a well-developed Melano-Polynesian culture. It ts possible that native ,. -78- Fijians then numbered about 200,000. Subsist~nce was primarily based on vi 11 age-organized root and tree crop agrkulture', supplemented with ·fishing and the collections of wild plants. This economic basis generated signifi' cant social stratification and int_r-village social organization. Although the pattern varied across the Fijian islands, the tendency was for populations to be_dtvided into !}atrilineages (yavusa) which were seen as each sharing a single apical ancestor. Each yavusa was in turn divided into localized sub~lineages (matagali). Matagali tended to ~e village based, 2 and were further divided into ext~nded family households (tokatoka). Above the yavusa, alliances and associations were very fluid, al)d there was much warfare and continual geographical displacement. No social or political organizatio~ spanned either of the two main islands. . The first Western contact with Fiji came af the turn of the 19th Century through castaways from wrecked ships: When it becarne,known that large stands of valuable sandlewood existed on Vanua Levu, trade developed quickly. The continual warfare between chiefs was soon being manipulated to tbe ends of Western traders. Chiefs became involved in the sandlewood trade, and provided labour for its felling.and preparation. Missionaries began to arrive in 1835, and almost i1TT11ediately upset the precarious balance between chiefs and resident traders by attempting to dicredit the Fijian spiritual beliefs which iri part rationalized chiefly power. At the same time, missionaries consciously made use of the strati___ ----- ---'---- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ' ! 1 - - - - - - c fication system, and sought to convert tribal populations through the coercive power of converted chiefs (France 1969:30). Missionaries also brought with 1 ~ ~ J 1-- ;"i I -79- them English law, which they had sufficient power to begin enforcing in the 1840 s. 1 But the most serious consequences for native Fijian life were to flow from the establishment of white agricultur~l- pursuits; unlike previous newcomers, incoming planters by definition challenged. the land tenure of native Fijians and wi"th it., their very social or~der. Sheep farming was tried in the 1860 s (France 1969:37), but the most significant crop of this period 1 was cotton, which was in short supply because of the disruptions caused by the American Civil War. From 1860 to 1870, the white population of Fiji increased from about so· to over 2~000. European planters found it impossible to lure native Fijians. into agricultural wage labour because their traditional economy was still a~ailable to them and it offered alternative resources to employment. 0 Planters tried trans~orting native Fijians from other areas of the islands,· thereby separating them from their homes but this, too, proved ineffectual. In.. response to the labour demand, Europeans ~ent to the only means which could hold workers in an ecosystem with alternatives ·of--eq~l promise -. 3 . ~ indentured labour. As early as 1864, planters began to import labour from other South Sea islands on three year indentured contracts (Gillion 1962:2).,.. In the late 1860 s, planters attempted to secure Indian workers, fol1 lowing the patterns.of other British-dominated plantation economiei like______ Mauritius and the British West Indies, both of which had successfully switched from slave to indentured labour. The Fijian planting interests were ' rebuffed by the Government of India, which would not allow the estabUshment of Indian indentured labour under a native government. Native recruitment from the New Hebrides, Solomon, and Gilbert Islands was to continue until abuses ended the approval of it by the British Consul in 1869. During this same period, the Fijian chiefly hierarchy was formed by settler interests into a puppet native government. I,n 1865, a Confedera- J ti on of Chiefs was formed, which was to me.et annually to pass 1aws for all of Fiji. Cakobau was named as the first president (France 1969:73). In. 1867, Cakobau was named the ruler of the Kingdom of Bau, in 1:he_hoge~t~at his ascendancy would confer legitimacy to the alienation of large areas of Bau by white settlers. Both of these governmen~, were largely unsuccess- ful, and in 1871 another Cakobau administration was formed; it was totally controlled bY, settlers, and rapidly proceeded with the further separation of Fijians from their land. By 1874,, 854,000 acres, of which only 16,324 we.re under cultivation, were claimed by whites (Mayer 1963:10}." Meanwhile, cotton prices had crashed, following the reestablishment of the American plantations pnd the disruption in consumption creat~d by the Franco-Prrian War (Gillion 1962:3). The cotton economy of Fiji collapsed with the price, to the extent that by 1875 planters could not afford to pay for the return voyages of three thousand islanders whose labour contracts had expired. After twenty years ·of increasing social dis- ruption, the is.lands were formally ceded to Britain in 1874, without the ..,, \:' . - - ,,- ...... - --- threat or use of force. - - -- ----------- The Colonial administration of the first governor, Sir Arthur Gordon, was to determine the broad outlines of Fijian history for fifty years to come, I -81- .,,. Three aspects of this policy are of crucial importance. First, Gordon deeded back to the native Fijians all la~d not proven to be then"in legitimate freehold nor held by the Crown. This ·1and, constituting roughly 4,000,000 out ·of ~a total 4,503,438 acres, was to be held in pe.rpetuity by the matagali. Each matagali was deeded what was presumed to be its abor- igina.1 land. from thls- --po-fot--on, Fi-j-i-a-n - nat-"ive 1-and --was to· be--·perpetua-tty------- ___ . inalienable, either to individual Fijians, to other matagali, or to Euro- peans; the consequences of this policy fo~ Indian-Fijian relations will become eminently clear later. Secondly, Gordon adopted a unique mixture of indirect rule and a formal restructurjng of the indjgenous social organization... . This earlier or- ganization was fairly similar to that of other large Melanesian and Polynesian societies, and was based upon fluid, large-scale, polysegmental patrilineages. Gordon both used and changed .this structure. \ He allowed the ownership of land to revert to the residence groups which the Government believed t~aditionally possessed ~t; as it turned out, actual patterns of Fijian land tenure were in fact geographically variable, were developed along concepts of ownership and control which were considerably at vari0 ance with British co1T1110n law, and were continually being renegotfated by force and alliance. Gordon as it were 1 froze - -- 1 - the system, not only by associating matagali ~·-- · - - - -- - - -- - - - -- - --- - - pennanently .with certain pieces of property, but al so by formalizing . - -- -- - - -- - - -- . - - -- - - -- -~ - - -- - - -- the overall hierarchical structure which was built upon it. - - - -- Once tecorded on the books, the colonial government took vanua (.?olitica1 federations of -- ,_) -- . -- - . yavusa}. yavusa, and mataqall to be fixed, pennanent, politic.al and social ------'; '. ---- - - - --- - - --•-- g ------~----~- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - uni1s. As native administrators, the government also created a set of 4 hi er~~-'tral, appoj nteo, non-traditional chiefs. C ;. ,:---- - Thi rd, in an obviously protecti oni-st stance, Gordon· violently objected to the ·us·e of Fijian.Jabour in the Colony's plantation system. . ' It was ' . . G6r-don~ -who had previousl ifieeff-Governor of Mauritius and thei-efore hacr-•- ~--~- ----:-:•-·_.,. ~ .:ff; 1:: . ,. ."considerabl~ experience with indentured labour, who formally approachedf'\'ft~_,' ,· the India Government on tb~ part of Fiji in 1876. _Arra~gemenis were finalized in 1878, and the subsequeht year saw the first shipload of Indian indentured labourers reach Fiji. The major terms ·of engagement agreed to · by the-Colony, as demanded by the Government of India were (Billion l962tl6): a. workers would be indentured for a per-iod o.f five years· b. wages should be·ls. per day for workers· doing "normal labour c. the voyage to Fiji would be paid by the Fiji Government " d. there would be penalties of either jail or ffne for non~ ' .~' fulfillment,ot work . e. return passage would be guaranteed after ten years residence I in. Fiji f. workers co~remain as settlers in Fiji if.they so desired ,o Beyond the contract itself~ the agreement covered methods of recruitment, housing, and passage. It was, required that 40 immigrants would be:women ---- - ---- - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - for every l 00 men recruited. £ ~ The system organized under this coatract prevailed with but mi nor mod- · ifications from 1879 until 1916. By th~t time the combined influence~.of ' the First ·World War and rising Indian nationalism brought recruitment to a \ .., . - -83- .( halt. - -------- - - - ------------- / A little under 69,-000 Indians·registered for indentured labour ~n Fiji during this time. Toward a Suga.r Economy ...... .. . What made indentured Indian. labour a success from the poinf of view_of the Fijian plantocracy was. the developm~nt of the crop which wa~ to become. the mainstay of the Fijian economy to the present -- sugar. The switch - to - · sugar was made during the 1870ts; -,y was confirmed in 188() by the 1_oc'atf6n · / - - . . . •.• of a··sugar mi 11 at Nausori by the Col oni a1 Sugar Refining Company of Sy.ilney. Des_Vo.eux,Gordon's successor (1880-1885), refus.ed to allow·the C.S.R. > Compan,Yand.others to use Fijian labour (Gillion -1962:71), and the C.S.R. ' . . moved to secure worl&rs from oth~o uth Sea is 1and.. When 220 Out of 587 · isl·a~de~s indentured in 1881 d·ietl from dijease i~ the· cane fields by September of t~e following year,-~.R. decided t~ e.xci"usively use_ Indian . labour. . . 6-_ ( -, < · . · ,~ As with the other Colonies which recruited Indian indentured immigrants, the Fijian planters were required to pay the full cost of the intro-· duction otlaboure·r s, while the Fiji Governmen~_eid the costs of repatriation and the maintenance of the inmigration system (GilJion 1962:73). ·The high . r . initial costs ofind1an ~abour were to force the· continual conso·lidation of . ~ the sm~Tler Fijian plantati,orfs -tnroughcffft-tne--resT of~tne~T91:nCentury; on,y-those wittr international corporate backing were able'tcr survive----the fluctuations of the::.~ sugar pric::e. .. - . - ~ 'I -- , By 1885, less t,han 10 cane planta,t,ons w_ere using indentured 'indians, and five compan i-es emp-loye~tJO% of the ... -84- 4,000 Indian immigrants. In 1889~ there ,were only three mills in Fiji o~med by other than the C. S .R·. ,. and by the turn of .the century' the company produced about 82% _o f the total sugar exported from the-Colony {Gillion •. . - - . " . -,,c.. ·. • 'I . • . 1962:79). -~ltbough the ·number of employers ~ng indentured labour was to • Q • Q ,,, ; , - ·i ncreas-e -once --mo,re ,,. .; tile- C.S.R .- -was-,,,.,.to. -fie th.e dominant f actor---thr-ouglwu-t the ______ _: ~-~-~~--~- . ~ - period of indentured labour use in-,Fij;'. '. ,, ~he Proce~~ of ln~entu~e . . -· . . p .. . . . In contrast tb both Europ·ean and Asian immigrattbh to North America, irrrnigration from India for the purposes of ind~tured labour was often 7 viewed as a recourse of last resort. There was little of the chain migraI odentured_ inmi gra·nts tion typical of' r~orth. Amer1 can"' immigration -patterns-. ' . , -. ·- ' . . ~ere, more than anything, extr~cted _.f;om. their social milieu . . : Both in North ____ ~:. - ..· ,· ; and South India there ~as a reluctance to -emigrate overseas to areas ' w~iih - hai not bein 1 sec;ured 1 and proved out by kirfor by village rriates.' .Indent!,lred iITITii grants moved into con di ti ons of abject poverty and tota 1 subordination, · and were not likely to put forward glowing reports of their situation. Mor,eover, the concern wit_J, caste position, ;Which was p.fw4ys threatened by travel, was magnified by the unknown sitLlation which indenture presented; Hindu dogma even sugge?ted that one 1ost caste upon trav~l in,g across the · ·· ··---· --------···------ - ----~- _ _ _ ___ ------- , . ocean. Few irrrnigra_nts who went to ''FijLdid so only in consideration of · 5 the higher· wages ' i·n-- Fl j f._~ _Mos~ ;had . be~n,,. detachecf fron:i .thei·~ tra~ion_aT:____ .-r~-------r--½. roots by family Of vilJage conflicts, jnsohency, or wand~rlust (Gi -llH>n . • . 0 r:.-. Many of these initiating causes were at least in part ~conomi- · I cally depenaent, and t J succe~s of immigrant rec.,ruiters variea inversely with the success of the· Indian crops~- :::- Jn years of good_harvests immi- grati on. ,qu~tas often We_!lt unfiJ 1ed. • ~ Fiji secured its' irrrnigrants where ::'....,_/it cpuidJind them,~and the extreme . - - " heterogeneJty of the initial ~dian populatJon-of FJJ.L _i.s a_. ~_~r~c~~-~~~n..s_~=--- . ··--~---•--• r (} . quence of this•practlce . . Through its immigration,centres in Calcutta and -. • fa Madras, Fiji_ developed large-scale i~fgration, fr9m b~th· North .and ·south " . India. - - - . . - - Llttar Pradesfr "{tl1en~-~t1nfl:ed P-rbvlntes) - pfoviaeff-tne-ma.1-orn:y crf ' -~ -~ Fiji's Indian immigra~. to the 'irrrnigrant flow. 6 IJ1 the north, Bihar also contributed strongly In all, 45,833 indentured India_ns passed throu_gh tne Calcutta depot on their way to Fiji:~-i . • chose to In the north, primaril.i depressed • areas provi·ded·the bulk of immigrants. 0 I Neither Punjabis nor Bengalts_ . emigrate, and those few Punjabls who·did so proved_ to be '.resist~ -- (I- ant' to the .i'ndenture system -- to the point where they were only solicited . as a last resort. Madrasis were first indentured in-1902, whe~ the Fiji Government estab-, • • ; , - , _/ 1 i shed an> irrrni gration agency ·in Madras. • C In contrast to tt,e north, many Madras is had previous experience_ with short ·term irrrni grati on oversea_s ,- in this case.to Bul"ma,'Ceylon, and Malaya, and i11111igrants were more easily secured. - f1ost were recrui tea from the di stri cts;1Jf ~orth A·rcot, Madra~ Krishna, ,, Go§la va ri~, .V-i zaRnapa:t-n~am, 1anjore-;-rfa-la5ar-; -crno Cormna:cure---rm1110n · -. 15-, l·32 i-!"'~:ttmri-g°r-~-s- -w e-re-b-rott~through Madr ~s before,. - the termination of the process in,1916. " Indian irm1igrants to Fiji therefore posses---s-e-d a wide .range of cultural '-'i<' ----l,.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - background;. · Although about 85% of those: whO i mmi~nrica lcu;~~ were" Hindu and most nort.herners spoke or could understand Hindi, 14,% were', _;__ . Muslim, with the complement being made up' of .a spr'inkling of Christians . . . ;.... . ., . and· Sikhs. A- f41l range of castes, with r~presentati on !ai rly typicaff. : ~hat one w~uld find i_n an Indian vnt1g·e {Gi 11 ion .l 962: 52), immigrated·} . ~ ,whic:h Tamil and Telugu,have continued to be used·by a diminishing number. of .south Indian F{j.; ans to- the present. · There were understandably fewer Muslim immigrants from the south, and there was a larger proporti'br:i ot cultivator castes than was exhibited ,by northe'rn' i~igJ-tion.' . Female immigrants were.,even more varied. '3 ~ Q < - • ' The evils of the indenture , system of ,earlier times ,~oupled wi!Jl, the. des.ire to es.I;blis:h permanent . , colonies of Indian iTilTligrants overseas, had led ·the Gov r ' ent of India [j ' to demand that 40 women immigrate to Ffji for every 100 men who did so .. C, e. • ' .. ' The a·ctual proportion who arrived _i~ Fiji constituted a little over this . minimum limit. Very' few-families immigrated, and the ifnmigra-ti;n of s_ingle · . . . ' - ·vtomen from I_ndia' wa·s strongly against c·ustom.,. Cohsequently, there•was . • 0. great difficulty in securing. a sufficient number- of women for indenture, and the bounties -for producing·women i.fl1TI-igrants were very high. both fair _and-.foul (incluci\ng abduction~),'were·:usce,ct'to·meeLthe quota .. •• . ,. ~ a,, . < · • , • • W - . 0 •c,,l Most women who came,were widows without family support; runaway or dese'~ted . ' ~ .,• - -- - - - - - - ---------------------------- ~~ wives, or women estranged from their fami-lies·.. Their ~aste dlstribu,tion - - - - - --- - - -• ----- -- was rnughly that of male ill1Jligrants. ~ - - - ~ . . :·•-OT'.~ . . . . " the voyage Homogenization and Subordination: . ""'I •· '. . -. .. "' . 0 -· .. The whole prqcess of ·fecruttment, of p~ssage and of {ndentured_ 1i fe 0 combined_to bring togethe'r these d{sparate cultur ali backgrounds into a socia'l struct_ure which ~is .uniquely F.ijian. • . . . ,. • . • ' . .. . .. - .. Although immigrants were . . . . -_ . . ~ . • . _· . -- - ~ --- .... __·_.- •. :_ • __ - ·s: . :_ .: ~·-.. r_ecru"jfed from a 1l over th_ e ''rndfa.n subcontinent~,foe corrmonality ' of their " . , ... . ·· __ ·--·· ·· -~-•- -- ·-- --~- --- -- - --~- .:. . - -- -~ ·--·--- --~-:..~ - -- ·---:-· - --- .... ---- --•'·-· '·---.--· . ~---·-·-•----------~---.- --------~-----~ ---- ----,--~~ -:0 -··-·-· ·_ ~ -···-·· •~- - - - . . ...--• •· :subsequent experience leveled ·many~ of the differences between them which . . . . . , - 1 .. . .. ·. . . . . . . • . ·..· -y1ere incompatible wi.th the imposed con_s traints '-- of,recruitment 4nd i.nden·- , 11' -...\.. . - fure: ...... __ -_ :_ _·:_· : . . . - -- ---- -- ___ _:·_-- ----···-----· ... ·- .. ···---·- ---·-- ·· ----· ··-· -- - // Caste barriers were the most susceptible to this r,rocess, and ·a ,fun~da.'.. 1 -~ ·- ¢~ntal ambiguity arose ~t o~ce with re_spect to the dogmatic ·.: .· . -:,:::-·.:._~--;.;~ . ··; .. pres~ription I J against intercontinental travel. The realities of recruitment and trans- · port caused caste restrictions on _tood µ.reparation and on personal contact . . . to give way almost irrmediately (Ja,yawardena 1971)~ . ~ . . Although prcivisiorfwas . . - made for the use of Brahmin cooks ~nd low caste sweepers during· th~ . ~ ' . -. . . voyage, th~re, wa~ little which could mitigate against the c~apse of mos~ . cormiensal rules; . . . ~-- ,' A strkt ;5hfpboard routine, coupled · with the ·absence of . ' one's traditional support group, further 'weakened caste b~ providing alterna- ·· tive normative patterns \ ~ ci.~ beha~iou~ enforced b; authorit~, Hindi was ai- ,.. . ·ready -moving towards its present position a·s a Fijian Indian lingua franca. 0 _The Lines Upon la-ndtng tn-ftjf, -the in1nigra11t was-as-signed w ·-an employer, was quickly sent to begin ~is ~r her five year contract. on, employers were to dominate the irrmigrant's life. • and From this poin~ Government played f , -88- . - - ,_ ___ . .: _:.__ ·, -·- · . . .. ·. . ·. ,·,f :.. only a wea_k. r~gulative ~role~ ·: The situatipn orev~ryday life on the pl~nta"' · tions furthered th~ homogeniiation process begun during recruitment and . !o_ • • •..; _I-' . • • i. -_ .. . . -~ -- P.a Ssage. · Livi'ng units, although divided into .family i,mitts when appropriate, ··· -· . . -. . . -~. . . . . . ~ . . .. - - ' ' - - . . · ---:c. - . . . .' ·. ' : ' . ~ ..... :. . . -• . . . . .. . . . ~ . were Jarge ,· common 'b\,Ji 1dings ( the lines). Access to food ,an'd services, . , . . . _·.-r= . . . . . - :, . ~ . . which were paid for out of wages, were·relatively 'equal for .; all inmigrant_s. • . .•. 1, . • .. - ·-"·· ·commun-iey -forma-tton ~t;>y-people-4-rom- -the---same--area•-oi -lndi-a wa:s a-c:t4vely - . .. - -.-,·------ - ·•·~ ~ '{ .··• ·: discouraged by plan,tation owners ancfwas strµcturally limited by lif~ ori · l • . : c· i .. . . lhe coiTJTlonalities of _work aside, day to day ·livin'g conditions in the . . 1i nes were ones ·of poverty and of the near totc11, absence of oea 1th and . ...... . . ·sanitary facilities. .. . Death rates during inde_ntur;e _in Ffji occas~onall{ _ . . . . reached 50 pell' thou~and workers per Year, and "never went belo~ 22.1 . . (Gillion 1962:142) . . The rate . for non~indentured India~s in ~iji was about 9.8. Child mortality- reached88 per thousand in thel890 s . .. Earlierin . , ., . . ·, . the same decade, ot.r a quarter of the i1T10igrants were either dead or 1 . . . . . . . . . repatriated as incapable of further work before the end of their five ' 0 - . year c;ontracts .. The suicide rate in the lines betwe_en 1902 and 1912 was claimed tQ_be 926 per million, as oppos.ed to 147Jfor free Fiji Indians . /" ' . . and 63 in the North Indian source areas (Andrews and Pejr'SC)n 1916:13). ~ It was impossibl~ unHer these conditions to recreate any semblance of :::c::•~~::::lH::::•r:::; :r-:::~ia:~s:!~~~~ ~~~=t: s~~-;:~; : ;\~:~e 5 i was much intermarriage between all traditional Indian groups. 1ife, property, ~or marriage were sacrosanct. Neither Personnel flowed through ·_.·.,,ii ~ J ➔ •• • - -- - --- - ---- .------=-~ ___:~; "___.,__,:__... . - ' <7•.:.,-. -.- ._,----C'r ) ., .___ _ ._____..__ _____ --~· C_•_ • the system_at such -a. rate · as to mitigate against the Jormatio!J of. stable gro·ups. Work: . ~ork~wa-s -m:ghly-rathma-1i-ze In the days prior to 1911, the procurement of a native lease was a • complicated business, whic~ resulted in uncertainty of tenure for the - , - - ~ - ------ -------- - - - - - - - - - - --------------~- Indians and an uneconomic distr1bution of cane production for companies. - - - - - ----- The Government subsequently stepped in to regulate of native leases and the areas where Indian settlement would be en sugar -terms ----------- uraged. Settlement was on a substantial scale, for as early ~s 1912 Indi~ns were --- --- -- .. ' ·· ' -- ---- ----·. -•, ----- ---· farming over 22,000 acres under rice, cane, ~aize, bananas, beans, tobacco, Ond a n 'f'b•r o~ s~bs id i ~ry crops . l O Rice and can~ took up abo~t 75% of . the ~ g e (G1ll1on 1962:143). Although ex-indentured Indians did not go exclusively.into tenant ~ fanning, a great number did so. -Coulter (1942:25) gives the following dis~ -"6 ' . Agri cu 1ture , Co1T1T1ercial ( Inpustrial Domestlc -Sundry Occupations Not stated · . - _. •.· -< . .· -- - 10,357 5-30 ·. · 1,896 . -•. -·;,J::846 '-~ -_--- --·~-- ....... .. 126 1 ,49 □- · ;... . Total . Table~- . 18~245 A- J ••• •• Occupations of India~s ... in Fiji, 19_11 :a. • ' t°~"'I '" D . The totar population of Indians in Fiji was then 40,286, as contrasted with ., · 87,000 native Fijians, 4,000 Europe~ns, _an.cL9,000 othe'rs, who were principal-ly Pacific Islanders or par! Europeans (Fiji l976a:l). Faced with the irrminent termination of indenture, the C.S~R. in 1914 made the major decision to shift the bulk of their production out of · plantations and into Indian leaseholds. ijecruitment of indentured Indians was- formally ended in 1916, and al) remaining c ~ were ·terminate~ in 1920. ~ C.S.R. then broke_most of its holdings into 10 acre tenancies with te~ year, renewable leases. "°' Renewal wa-s normally automati~, given . . . . that contract~recfuireineifts Were· fulfillecL -:---syT9Jo-;-~T;ooo- acres ·or--c-:-s.R. __ ·_______ ~ tan ct was umter Ind~an 'tease- ·amt tn ~ -production, ~Iii le the compaV,- -- -- - plantations cultivated some 15,000 _acres . . An additional 32,000 acres were ~~ ~ fanned •by Indians holding pri!J)arily native Fijian leases (Mayer 1.963:49). r ' ;., . -931' .,__ As su-ggested by Coulter's 'figures, Indians developad se_v eral n_on. "· agricultural pur~its .. These were t-~ become s1gnif'icanf .in later: years, . . . . . . ;~ since 1912 the amount 6f prime farm larid has ~ot greatly increased, while both -India n and native Fijian populations· have. 0 From the earli-es t ..-·.. ..: 0 :, . .i~·- ~ ·- 0-·;~--~:-: ·r:::~~:___ ~ days_.o f i nqent1,ire, .f re_e lo_d;i~n_s _b_cgl_SIJRJ) l i.E:id their .compatriot~ .. tn:f ~ - lines with many of the goods · and ser:i c\s ne:c essa ry for""i i fe ~ _meagre· ·. .~ . · 0 · ., r · · • _ . . , .':- · ,_ --j__ • " ·- ), !_ho\Jgh ,t~y then-_w~r~. J,y 1887, whi~ho~keepers w~t e complai~ing a-bou; 4> , 0 :- · Indian corn~~tition (Gillion 1962:lfr). ,. · ... ""· -- ' ------ - - -- · The,, f,,ir.st decade of the . twentieth century saw the beginnings of independent irrmigration o'f Indians to' Fiji. ·· • ·. Un.like tho's e who cam~_ iTI a·s inden:tured labourers, these ~/,terprising inlmigran~ _came with hopes of either es~ablishjng an entrepreneurial position i n ~ or with the desire to wo·rk at a skilTed occupation. · Unlik~s~ i~dentured immi- -., . . . ' grants ,~new class of ilTiTii grants came from the two : tradi ti qna l Indian sources je/adventurers and traders -- the Punjab and ' Gujarat, respectiveJy. ' Punjabi Sikhs began arriving .in 19~4, and by 1935 1t was ~stimai~d ... that ther~\ were about 3,000 of them in Fiji (Coufter 1945:81). · These ' . Sikhs came froin the same areas as ·those who had come to Canada during the same period (Gillion 1962:133). Many Punjabis -became Pr?sperous inFiji as farmers, and secondarily, in trade_ and co11111unications. .. As the initial • lb'-' ·-· . ,_ ·- •. ·-·-· - --- --·--··· ···--··- - . ·-··· 0 - • -· • . • - .. . ---~ - -· ·, ----·· - - --- · - - ~ - - - --- . . flow was primarily male, many married into the ex-indentured population . . craftsmen. Most were Hindus. Although many were · forced to' adapt to a 1. ~ terna'tive occupati'ons . in Fiji, 'lhe Gujaratis were to become a signfficant . \, . -~. ~ .,L .. •, . ti ·· ~ ·-·-· --- · -·-·. -- . --·- ------- .- -. --·--····-_.>II-·-··. ~ .. ._· .- . - factor in the p~litics and e~enomi~s of Fiji, even though they numbered no 1 ·mar~ thaQ.-2~_soo · in 1935 (Coulter 1945:81). Fr;e immigratfoh was seve.rely limited by the Colonial g·o vernmeht in 1930, largely because of white. middle . class opposition. ~) ~ \ In addition to. Indian eny~g!'~n_e ur~, a signific:a~t numbet: __of _f~ine•s! ___~--~-·-' ~ shopkeepers entered the Fijian economy over this-period, and numbered abqut a thousand by . 1930 (McMill~n. 1929 _:398)_. Th~Y gave the Indians stiff - n-fthe -' 1n tfaf soclety; - ··· - _ ··-,;' - c ompeti _tion,~nd _e-~t;a6lished for the~selves "·a ~ /. Fiji in the 1920 's and 1930' s: -~ -· ·.. ·" ) lhe corrmun°i ti es Durin.g the two decades a_fter the Fi tst World· war the, basi C pattern o'f,' . · Fijian society as . it is presentl:Y constituted was·· to<~rystaHze, Becaus.e Fiji is and was a polyethnic society,. and because from this. point on the · ~ .. ' _ " ;, ..- -- vii' .interaction between native FiJian · and I_ndian colllTiunities is so ma·rked, both g ~ o ~ ,be djscussed s·imultaneously. . · Accordingly~ th: discussion must now return . to ~at, ve Frj i a:.n · life, which was 1 eft at .the time when· . 'I - - --;-- - Fiji was ceded .t6 Britain. It has often been said that in • Fijj native peop.J_e have suffered fr~ t ~ n ~ and.Indians this one contains om not enoogh~ . As · With m~ny ' such aphorisms, ·. · Govern~n·t weighed heavil·y_ on the i.n d i v i d u a ~ Gordon ncr aoITl5t'--was -a, remy respon5ltrte- ·tor-"'tlll: native population of Fiji ~ t g·oi-ng ~he way of the native Hawaiians, the penalties for group surv·ival were economic stagnation in a nee-traditional society. • How this was so I -95- ( - --------···-· -- - -- - - - · - - -' - ~ -- . ~ - -- --- I becomes apparent when one looks •at the rtructure 6f early native adminis- J t ration in Fiji . _ 1 ( ' • . Gordon and his predecessors were sensitive to the highly ·group-_ . ori1;nted aspects of native Fijian societl (in'cidentally "igr,oring ·1:·he , individualistic.side of it) and built their administration Jpon ihes~ fosi ghts. -Fiji was ·aivicferl into a number of provfoces, and in each --o-ne ___ _ . . · a · na'tive · administrative _chief (Roko) was appointed. sig]e dir,ectly to the Governor. -~-· .. ~ '1 1, The Roko was _respon- Each province 'fl.~S cii_videg_fu!'_ther into . ti ki nas, each with _an appoi nte,d Bul i. Each of the thousand-odd vi 11 ages was to hav·e an appointed headman~ . . ,Administr'ative jurisdi~,t _ions. were also divided up'-hierarchicall·y . .Tikitia n~tive courts ' heard disp~te.s retardin•g native c.u~tomary -law; ·appeals· and more serious offences went to the Europe·an Pro vi nci al Court ( Roth 1951 : C 3). Tiki na "administrators al so saw to it that vil hge headmen followed , . ! govern111ental regulations regardin~ village prqduction, co1lected taxes, and the lik.e. Each' tikina }'las given a council; P(es'1ded over by the B~li, "'!hich made recofllllendations· to "the Provir:tcial Councils; neittre·r of these ~ c~ncils - .,. j had any legislative powers.· The Provinc;ial _.:counc~ls, madi up br.imarily _by B~uli, each ·eleited two-of their number to·tne Council of .. -. . : _ ______,,,( ~ ~efs,{"whi~h advis~d- the Gover,nor directly. . .• , "' Whi.le it must be kept in 1 . .:, mi rtd that this fonna l hierarchy of ch_~~f? _di_<:1__ not necessarily parallel -the hierarchy of t r aditional chiefs, which still exists today; there was .. - a strong tendency for the mern_t>ers Qf the higher level" councils to be from 1mportant chiefly families. They therefore possessed both fonnal - and in- ~ .. .) , I --- -96- . ~ - _- ·- - - • - --- . I . . _,..__ __ - - 4 - - - - - - .,. formal power, and at the same time tended to.. bt somewhat dtvorced from th.e needs an<;! prob.lenis of the fijian villager. They were te be · a_ decidedly c,o.rise~vative forte in :_iji&affa•irs (Watters 1969:15): ·Along' with this highly° ~tructurecl polit"ica(administration came-a . , sy,stem of land tenure· and· labour·· regulatio'n .which was to be largely respon·. . ., . - sible for a majority- of nat"ive: Fijians rema-ining ·suosis-tence·t:ar~rs.·unti-1- - -- --- --'· after World War~II. .. \l It.has been mentioned ·that native: lani was totally un~li~nab-le, except,~o~he Crow~ .. , This_ rule has per'sistech\o the present,· s_ave -for minor exceptions arou,nd 1905-9 ·(Roth 195~1 :5). - , While this reg1,1- , lation no doubt protected Fiji-ans against the wholesale theft .of the land f ,:. . . . I which wa,s their very life,.regulations upon its use were very severe, and ag~in were based upon- the impression thp.t Fijians were a "collective" .., people. First of all, it was the· various matagali who· were deeded· the.rights , - to native land . . Use was reserVed for native Fijians who belonged to that matagali, much like Canadlan native r~serves; but unlike the· latter case, . ., no provision was made for _individual .use rights of matagalimembers. · ··fact;. in the ~~rly years particularly, eve~;thing pos-sible was In doJ to ensure· that ,the vi)lage· coll~tively was the m~or Fijian productive unit. At least by law, Fiji-ans were requiredto live in their villages_, unless : . . they could demonstrate that they either had land elsewhere or had employ--;- ment. ___ - ___ .~ _________________ ,._ - ,- - -- -Nayacakalou (1963) reports that even then-this was true of Fijian - mi grants ro ,urban Suva.. --- ------------- Each. male Fijian was required to fann a specified amount of \(variety of crops _in his ~village e_ach year • . He was also res- . . • :; . . . -97-. . . ponsible for labour on village maintenance under tfie ·Girection -of the · ·.. : . ·, headman. ~ Within -the - village~ any individual initiative ha·d to fight thrQ.ugh- ' both the admfnistrative formalities · which encumbered individual action and, . . . . . . . ., . tJ the" informal village and kill -customs which had arisen in .earlier days . . , 1 1 -ensu_re that .the ~roupwoul d. benefit f-rom individual success. ____ l"n~any _ . . 0 ~ . 0 cases this resulted_ in-resignation to the sta tus ,quo: In the twenties and thirties, tfiis was even-more marked;and its effects can be seen , in the slight deg~e to wnich Fijians had moved into. wage labour _o r - cash CfOpping by that time. AgricuJture continued to be the mainstay of nati~e Fijians, ~with Indians, but the n.atur~ of their . pa~ation - was strikingly diffefrent. While most Indian agr-fculturalists were cash cropping aJmost exclusively, if for nothing el_se but in order . to pay for their tenancies, most Fijian agriculturalists in the twenties I and thirties were subsistence farmers. • .• : • • • The most signific?lit exception was . . . in the case of c9pra production, which had been ..a n~tive Fijian preserve since the depression of the pri~e ih 1884 dro~e m~ny of the European planters out of the business (Mayer 1963:16). While it would. be difficu.l t to argue that the standard of living.of the typical Indian agrfculturalist • of the twenties and thirties was materially higher than . his Fijian counter. .• part, he was firmly_ ti.ed into the cash--.e.c.on'omy and-was...ec;onGJ!l.:i-c-al-ly-u-Q-- - .. . - ---------encumbered by· extensi v~ COIIJDU.n_aJ . ob] i gati.ons~ . In terms of non-agricultural occupations, there was a divergence between Fijian and Indian pursuits, but one which was not substantively on ✓ - _-98- - the side -of eith·er group up into the 195-0's. · Fijians were concentrated · in ~gricultura1 liboui; gold mini~g: construction lab6ui, an~ g6vernment , employment. The 1936 census al.so indicates that 556 Fi'jians had chosen to become independent farmers (Coulter 194~:63). it i__s iinporta~t · to note;_;, that working native Fijian~ were : mainly wage labourers. Participation i~ - .~ ..... -~-~ ~ntrepreneurial activity such as retail and wholeiale trade and the provlsion of services was negligibl~. This same period saw the India:n. population coalesce into ordered Indians distributed themselves over the countryside wherever corrmunities. . . - . usable lease land was available; forming scattered vill_age-_like co1T111u-nities which were loosely patterned after continental Indian models, but which were at the same time gre~a_tly modified by .the cash economy in which most participated. Each cane Jann was a relatively autonomous production . unit, dependirig far less on networks of obligation for the fulfiflment of services, than would a fann in rura 1 · India. Although- the empi ri ca 1 evi~ dence is slight, it seems that even before 1920 'corrmunities hap developed ~ . . "complex hous'eholdand ward groupings" (Mayer 1963:145) based on kinship, r~al background, religion, and increasingly, on class. Nevert;eless, economic success ~- in strong contras_.t..Jo the· situation of the native · Fijian~- was dependent upon a highly rationalized system of woi~based . . upon money and upon indhddual ist effor..t ". - -It should be noted that sugar contrast~ wlth_~_traditional native crops in that it is not a food crop, at least in the sense that it cannot of itself_supply much in the way of the foodrequiremen~s of those who .• 0 . t ' ..:99_ ·-- \ farm it. , __ . --·-···-·-·· __ · _______ _ -_. ·.-___ ._· ~ -- Cane fanners were, therefore, cash farmers, even though in most ·· material respects they were no better off than subs_istence farmers. • - t No.~ only,/id ~he !arme.r participate in ~ mo.~eta_ry ec~nomy b~cause of . cash croppjng\ but the system was further rationalized: because _of . the · . ' nature of s.LJgar cane farming itself. ' Several factors areQo! consequenc_e. First, cane itself has a long growing' ·seas·~n, · ; :~me .fifteen to ·eigh,teen months. Each farmer therefore sta_ggered pl anting of his land in . order to guarantee a relatively consistent annual production. ., Neve.rthe l e'Ss, tjle-. · . nature of the crop dictated that farmers would be lin_ked into a _comp.lex system of credit with stores and with providers -of foodstuffs. tredit i~ ,~ i2 d . ~ .· , rural Fjjian Indian society .was, of necessity, .a way of life. · . Secondly, except for times of planting and harvesting, which were ones of furious acti"'.itY, the crop · itself requi red1i ttl e tending. I This was to all ow fann members the ability to develop the 9·ptions of .temporary, non-farm i ., einp l,oyment. I < , ·/ · / · Equally important were_ the efffrts ~qf _t~e C.S.R. Company. Whether ·. the Indian cane farmer leased C.S.R. or hative land, the C.S.R. sug~r mill was t _he only outlet for his. product, ·anct he was tied to a highly complex . contract with it. . . C.S.R. lessees were held to very strict conditi-ons in- · deed, which included the manner of crop rotation, ·fertilization, wee.ding, > ,. , and the use of specific varieties of_:,_c.ane (Mayer 197.3..:.39) . .. Both. the. . · C. S. R. lessees and those -who contracted to supply the COfTIPany _with cane (apprqpriately called 'contractors') were tied to a ·collective price for . their cane, based on a complex fonnula wh.i ch included factors of lessee . -------~ . -100- . . . - ··-· ··- an.£! compan_r costs as well as . the world sugar price. - . . , ···-- - - Production. quo~a·s H~rvesti ng of carie in Fi J-; 'i-s : don~ •by local har-· were _a lso .included. l3 vestjng gangs, which cut and del.iver.alf the c;ane in a spec.ified area. . .. . . ti- ~ .. Th~ in.di vi dual cane farmer,- under the -Grower.' s Harvesting Agreement ' 7 • ..:... . . • . • e, ,,:;(M;y~'r ..1973:9fl), , was -required either to ·partic-ipate ·,i n this l'~bbu-r or~ ·· - . • ~ .• . • . • . . . • 0 ·• --~- ';,.,. pay a substitute-. " Wages and work .requirements were clos-e-ly sp·ecffied: -•· ·· The result of these' ~~ntr6ls wai an overall sugar ~roduction system which . . ' . . . was co~petit1ve with ~lantation systems elsewhere. · These factors ccintri buted to the marked i ndi vi dual it,Y of Indian ' •. , , farmers and to the- conseque~t we~kn'e ss of settlement-wide _social con_trc,ls. Vi 11 age panchayats were evidently\ommon very early, but they lacked . t~e . ·_• equivalent sanctions that comparative groups would.~ave had in India (Gillion 196~:145). The most significi~t early organizations among Fiji Indians were either politi'cal or religious, and sometimes were both; · ~hile the processes of economic rationalization contin~ed to level cultural differences between one Indian Fijian and another, the income pro_duced by participation in a cash economy allowed the introduction of mass/· ive inputs of social and religious 'orthodoxy' from India du~ing this same ·time. In a very real sense, Fijian Indians underwent a collective ? , l · <: process of "Sanskritizatjon" (Srinivas 1966:1-45) while at the same time undergoing rapid Westernization. It is not surprising that the Indian population was to form itself most · definitely into groups based on religion and ethnic background. A division between north and south . Indian Hindus and between both of them ...... p - ~ ~ ~---"- .. ---· ;, . -· -----~~ ~ :' ' r and the primarily northern Muslims w.ere the most signi~icant. Although 7 the ~~marka~le so_c~al to~era~.ce w~ich~.xisted betwe~~ these group' during the 1ndentured per1oa was to continue to the present, the 1920's iaw a coalgscence inl:b partially 5-eparate social · groups, and intermarrfag~, the 14 prime indicator of . ~ndfan social distance, became infrequent. ~~ ~ A large input of orthodoxy came' through-the ministratio~s of holf. 0 men, who came ana went from India and from other averse.as Indian...-sett\e' " men ts. · Finding most of . its converts arriong . the northern Hindus, the reforfni st• . Arya Samaj• was ' the first organization to start successful schools for . ' , . . . ' - - cg. 15 Indian cbildren · /~ Fiji (Gillion 1962:1, 8-9). The Sanatan Dharm Sabha C represented orthodox Hindus from both the north and south . · Muslim mosques were also founded early, and the Muslim League was soon established as .the 16 social and political focal point for this group. Political concerns brought forward a number of groups with widely . divergent backing. The .Indian Reform League, es~ablished in 1924, was a secular~ liberal _, organization which pushed for a general amelioration of ' Indian conditions (Mayer 196~:46). ' The Arya Samaj pressed both se·c ular and religious concerns, while the Then Ikya Sanmarga Sangam advocate( south Indian educational and language rights. Fijian-Indian Relations The structure of Fij-ian society before World War II was clearly such that conflicts betwee!l native and Indian Fijian concerns were inevitable. On one hand, the native Fijians owed their ~urvival to: the protection .,,, . \ -102-- ---------- ------ - -·- - - - - --- - - -- whic'h was af_forded them by the colonial agministration . .· The. se · 0 - whl~h their land tenure gave the native Fijians enabled the~ : to mai . . . I . C(?!_ltinuity •with their _o rigins · in .a modernizing world. · But, at the time, · protectionist policies h~d created a plural society in F1fi, the problems of which a~e far frbm solution today. w -~ ., The paradoxes of tne ·s ituation were many. Fijian natives owned most of the land, and yet the same, policy which secured it for them denied the native population many options in its u~e. Corrmuna,- obligations, reinfo. . . ~ reed by governmental dictate and cornniunally-_based economic development " programs (Watf~rs 1969) did not interfate well with the structure of the impersonal, rationalized .economy outside of the. village (Spate 1959; 1961). Increasing Westernizat~on created increased demands, both m~terially and socia1ly, and yet most native Fijians were w.i thout the economic means . to l ,realize these · goals . . ..__ . -...,__ The Indian population was almost at the opp6site pole. Deeply involved in . the cash economy, they had little control over land, which was, as it w~s for the native Fijians, their ultimate .basis for survival. Ind·ians, if anything, complaine·d of the lack of government involvement' in / theit sifuation . . Their weak position vis-·a-vis· the C.S.R.- Company was strengthened not bY governinenta 1 concern over the ., conditions o( its Indian citizenry, but by gra~s ro_ots" farmer: organi zati_?n. 17 , Indian _sE?t_tl em~r:1ts . had no local governmental structure until 1970 (Dyck 1975:91). Schoo]in·g and other social services were· only grudgingly offered to Indi·ans. -·, -Per~ . . . . -' , -. haps most ' importantly, Indians argued that while t-hey were dfrecll/ respon- ' . , . \. -. J -103,. . ··- - - - · - - - - ~ -- - -- - · · - · · - - -- Siple for the production of a majority of the colony's economic OL!tput, ·they were without effective political representation..._ . Native ar:id Indian Fijians b·oth saw their unsatisfactory Gondition as '. at least in part stell1Tling from the actions of the oth~r group; there was .much chauvinism on both sides . . Native~Fijians complai.ned vigorously--- that Indian lessees had control over all the best cane iand, and th'at this denied them access to cane farming. . . . I . They felt threatened by what was seen . . as an insatiable Indian thirst for more land, and in reaction raised the ' . ' conditions of the, Deed of Cession to inviolate status . . The perceived Indian threat drove Fijians and Europeans into an alliance which persists to today. / In day to day interaction, Fijians constantly met Indians in situ~ ations where Fijians felt dependence. likely as not- be Indian. Stores and transportation ~ould So also would be the buyer of produce and th money lender . . The Fijian stereotype of the Indian was of an effeminat , r crafty fellow who was not to be trusted. - Indi~n complaints about supposed Fijian faults were equally ethno-1! centric. In contrast to the intensive utilization of land on their own - farms, Indians prot~sted that the Fijian native did ·not : 'properly' u~e his land. Rather, · fo9ians argued that their industry ' was what allowed the native Fijian a stereotyped situation of indolence and ease. To ~ Indians, native Fijians were an agreeable , but lazy people who would work only when they had some particular goal in mind; they _cared nothing for accumulation of wealth, but rather were required by custom_to distribute - t . . -104~.: _ ---- ·- ___ ._ .. . . -• • . - - -------- - - anything they had to any of their kin or vi 11 age mates who wanted it. ·. · l Political Org"c3.nizafion The problems of land_use and of ethnic-based opportunity have been at the heart 6f politic~l efforts by both native and Indian Fijiansi Through. . out the coionial period, the British administration adhered to .a policy of ' . gradualism, increasing the representation of local F;'jian corrmunities in government, but. always playing the dominant role itself. . The original colonial administration of 1875 consisted of an ExeGutive Council and a . Legislative ·council, both sitting at the sufferance of the Governor (Meller and Ahthony 1968:4); both bodies represented only the Europeans . In 1904, t~e composition of the Legislative Council. was changed, and its membership then was to be made up of ten official representatives, six elected European settlers, and two. nominated. native. Fijians. The Euro- pean members would be elected by the European population only. Indians had no representation. ) In 1916, in the face of vigorous Indian agitation, the Legislative Council was expanded to incltide one nominated Indian among twelve official 18 representatives. The twenties saw Indians pressing for· further representation in government, arguing particularly that in the light of their numbers and the'ir importance . to the colonial economy the non-official members of the Legislative Council should be elected on the basis of a ' .{J corrmon role (Mayer 1963:51). In this they were supported by the Govern. 19 ment of India. In 1929, the Legis 1ative Council was again restruGtured, Sf a 3 ' p C I -105- inc~easing Indian representation to three: members, who were communally elected (Meller and James 1968:13). All three elected Indian represen- tatives resigned over t11e Government s refusal to allow a common role. 1 1937 saw the last changes in the Cbuncil which were to occur before 1963. For the twerity-::five intervening yea'rs, the Legislative CounciT was to be made up of thi_rty-one members, sixteen of whom were official representatives. Of the complement of fifteen, five were to be from each of the . 2 · commun, . · t ,· es. Communa 1 ro 1es were s t ,· 11 use d t o dec r. de .th e· t hree maJor . ° elected repres~ntatives. · After the War From the beginning of the 1940 s, Fijian society has expe~ienced a 1 yearly increasing rate of change which hqs affected all aspects of life . These three decades have seen Fiji become more and more integrated irtto world networks of traae, conmunications, and values. The Fiji of today, a 1though basically structured a,,s it was j n the 1930 s, is far removed 1 from the stagnating and isolated sugar colony that it once wis. In 1939, both Indians and native Fijians were -overwhelmingly agriculturalists. Indians continu·ed their dominance of sugar production, producing 97% of tbe cane in that year (~ayer 1963:121)J Of the total Indian population, perhaps 60% were dependent upon sugar farming, while about two-thirds of the rest were either farmers or fi shernien (Stanner 1953:179). The Depression, coupled with the related collapse in sugar consumption C. ~ ------···-· •• - . ; - l06- and sugar prices, had a severe effect on Indian attempts to achieve a .• < comfortable level of existence on the farm, and it drove many Indian 21 traders out of business. Rural Indians were suffering un~er ' high lev~ls • · 22 of debt, coupled with very low payments for their crops. Native- Fijians - felt the Depression less acutely, ~s they were able to shift back to subr- ,·· sistence agriculture. The 1940 s saw few mitigating changes in this 1 · pattern, save for the transient effect of money pumped into Fiji during the War, and for higher prices for sugar which resulted from the end of the Depression. /I During the War itself, several . factors did, however, contribute to a_ straining of relationships between Fijian natives and Indians. In respons~ to native concerns over the management of their lands and to Indian problems with security of leases, a Native- Lands T'rust Board was created in 1940. While the Board was empowere9 to act as an intennediary between tne matagali and the Indian leaseholder, regulating and universalizing the ' tenns of the lease, it also was directed to consolidate Fijian land for future use by the selective non-renewal of leases. 23 These lands · set - aside, which were termed reserves, were the source of much frustration on the part of Indians, who charged that they were being displaced from productive lands only to have their fields go )ack to bush. 24 ..c" ' During the War, native Fijians s-u-ppo/ted-the Brit-t sh -effort vigorously, with about 10% of the total pop-u-1 ation V-Ol~--e+i-ng- f'of'.' s-e~¥ice.T -- I--oo4a-A-s-,both for reasons of necessity and for lack of enthusiasm for Britjsh rule, did not participate, and were accordingly belittled by the _native Fijians. ... 01 A severe cane ijrowers strike in 1943 did little to increase native sym~ 1 pathy for Indian causes, even though to Indians_ it -repres~nted the be~ - . . ginnings of effective Indian political organization. ~ The ·end of the War saw both major communities very closely matched - in terms of non-farm economic access. In wage labour, Indians and Fijians ··· represented 50.8% and 39.5% of the workforce in 1946, the year when 25 Indians first became the la;gest of the Fijian communiti€s. These percentages correspond rou_ghly to Indian and Fijian population distributions. 26 A-b·out 80% of both native and Indian wage earners were unskilled labourers working forminima1 wages (Sta.nner 1953:219). The 1950 s saw Fiji weather . a period of slow growth, rising prices, 1 and of increasing population. severe underemployment. F6r the Indian· farmer it was·a time of Many cane farms were only an acre or two, and were insufficient in themselves to support a family (0. ~_o ughl~3:59)_. . 1 · 1 In ,1953, the average amount of cane harvested per grower was only six ) .. , . . 27 acres. This put increasing pressure .upon IQdia·ns to secure at ]east . . . . .. -~ part-time income from either wage labour or eri:trepreneurJal activities, both of which were then severely limited. The C.S . R. did .'not·allow its leaseholds to be divided among one s heirs, with the consequence: ~hat in 1 each generation there. were many young people who had to look ~lsewhere 28 for a•living. The high level of farm de~t persisted (Mayer :1~7_3 :53).' . ' During this decade, many Fijian ~a:tive~ also 'attempted_!? _~r~a_k away from agriculturai life, seeking in the urban centres both economic rewards and freedom from corrmunal obligations (R.G. Ward 1961 :257-9). •· · - -- ··--- -- -- --- .,, .-108-, --- • ----- - ---- - - Others remained in the rural areas·, b_ut formally broke away from.their_ villages in order to become indf;!per,ident farmers (galala). By 1960, per- haps one-third of all Fijian natives lived away from their vinages (R.G. Ward 1961:261 ). Increasing _l_abo ur pa rti c&p ti on by both Fiji ans and Indians _resu]tec!_ in the quick post-~ar developme?tt~trade and agricultural unions. While there were but two c~ growers' unions in 1943, there were eleven in 1957; there were perhaps a dozen· trade unions functioning at the same time (Mayer 1963:113). Unionism .effected a considerably positive change in working conditions and in agricultural contracts, while at the same time _ p.rviding a vehicle for the use of both nat~ve and Indian political leaders. Strikes against the C.S.R. in 1957 and 1960 led, in the subsequent year, to the Company fonni,ng a semi -autonomous Fiji an subsidiary, the South Pacific Sugar Mills; Ltd. · The 1950 s also saw governmental attempts at merging the administra1 tidns ·of native Fijians and Indians. This was o~ly partially successful, primarily because of the opposition of the touncil of Chiefs. The colonial government desired a single local government to deal with both colTITiunities (remember that at this time th~re was s.till1'no Indian local authority), and a joint schoQl system for both Fijians and Indians. Ne,ther l of these plans were effected, al though the schoo1 curricuTi.im was--standardized and English was made tITT: prtmary language of instruction above the 29 fifth grade in all schools. ' --------- -109- , Economic Takeoff. economy oega~ the It .was not unt-i l rapid expansion which cont· fueled th:is expansion. es to the .present. Several related facto~s i~ota~s a lar~er Fiji~an income from su~:, which was due _primarily to steeply-increased world prices and from -ihe national~zation of the S.P.S.M. ~ubseqCJent to ind~pendence. ActuaL pr...o.,.. duction over 1965 to T975 has actually decreased slightly, but the \4alue of-the crop has increased almos~ four ti~es (Fiji l976a:71). Growers in 1974 reallzed almost exactly three times the price paid for a ton: of cane. fo 1965 ($F20.9'4 as OQposed to $f'6.70). · As late as 1975, sugar was responsible for ·~l.7% of Fijf's exports (Fiji 1976:67), but other exports, such as bananas, coconut oil, timber, gold, and manufactured goods have . . h . . l .30 s hare d 1n t e rise 1n export va ues .. " .-- ... - A second factor has been the development of tourism from almost nothing to Fiji s· second most' important produ~er of exlernal income. The 1 rise of jet pass~nger service in-the Pacific, coupled with the establish• ment of Nandi as an international-calibre airport connecting Hawaii with Australia, has made this tourist industry a reality. -, Source countries of tourists are primarily Australia, the UnJted ~tates, New Zealand and ' . Canada,. i.n descending order. Tourism now pro vi des direct emp 1oyment for, over 4,000 people, up five times in the 1ast ten years. / . Along with the ever in~reasing interconn~ctions between~-;}ijian . ancf wo-rTd ec6nomfes has-- come a mass--fve Tnput of"Western ideas. While the lridian peasant ~griculturili~t of the 1950 s might have but rarely come 1 . ... . . · -110- ~ - -- ---- ->+ - ··--- -·- -- ~ Iface to face with the world of Europeans and European--v:1-ues-~:ayer~-973 : 153), today such- contacts are continual. . . Tourists and the . structure .· . created to serve them have -both been transmitters of.._ a lterna ti ve life styles; while the touri?t rarely has ~nything but service contacts with most of the Fiji population, European tourism provides both natives and Indtans-with a powerful,, albeit fuzzy picture of. the outside worla. · ·· As the economy expetiences continued rationalization, with more and more Fijians working within a modern economy, economic motivations and the techniques for their imple~entation are ~nde~ flux. Although the pro~ portion 9f Fijians working for wages or· salary is still small by comparison with Western . societies~ kin and companion links have spread information 31 gleaned t~rough it ' across the i;lands : . Work and labour are becoming much more,skilled, and consequently demand greater adjustment to Western ways . ·than they once, did. Perhaps the·most massive input of Western ideas comes through the . - schools, to ~hich both native and Indian Fijians are heavily ~ommitted. The percentage of children of primary school age who ar~ attending ·school ' is ahove 90% for both COf1111unities (Fiji 1973:49),and the schools; .based " · as they are ori Bri~istT models~ are fairly rigorous. ln 1972 ~ u t 28% of Fiji s total population· was in school . Over 80% of those[~ho , entered 1 first grade in 1964 were in school eight years later. This concentration upon education is both a cause and an effect of modernization. As an effect, parents now realize that the future lifie - ·chances of their children may depend heavily upon their educational quali- ---- -- -- ----- - -lll- fications. . As a cause, th>curficulum is now heavily ·o riented -towards ;European events, values, and techniques. English is the medium of in- struction, and the nalonal English literacy rate for lS to 19 yea_r olds is : 75%. By comparison, for those over 40 it is below 15% for Indians and f 32 be]ow 50% for Fijian natives (Fiji 1973:57). English is also the official national language: ( Beyond introducing new values into Fijian society, schooling is .also contributing to a growing inter-generational :vertence between ~arents and children. . . ,. As with any rapid~y chang~rrg . ~ ,.; social contex~, Fiji is losing some of the continuity with the past it . .f' once had. CoJTITiunications, , taken widely, have also expanded. Although there is ,. , no television service in Fiji (it is now in the planning stage), radio, the newspapers, and p.olitical pamphlets saturate Fiji . The Fijian nat- ' ional radio network serves not only as a vehicle for current is-land and international events, but also as a central message exchange for the 33 isl a:Rds. Su_ch· messages not only connect ·Fijians with each other, but If .; ,-- also give some idea of their action~ overseas. Fiji has two subs tan ti a 1 English 1anguage daily newspapers as w·e 11 as weeklies in Fijian (Nailalai) and Hindi (Shanti Out and Jai Fiji). The"" English language papers, the Fij"i Times and the Fiji Sun , are completely modern in fonnat and style, down t-0 -thesupe-rma-f'ketads a-nd---t-h-e--P~amits--:. . ~ cartoons. Save for con~ they woul d.b.e i ngi stiµgu .:i-s-habl e from a 34 typical larger-circulation British or North American small town paper. Movies, books, and other printed material from both English and Indian ' -112- sources have also made their i fl)pact. .( ) ' ( Inde~endent FiJJ ,;I " Ano!her modernizing force ha·s been the increasing political concern \ · arid participation bj'. all FiJjan communities since limited elected positions . were first allowe~ by th~ colonial administration in 1969 . - • , Because . the I politic~l. structure of independent Fiji is of some _consequenca. fn under~ standing why Fijians have ·come to Canada, the e~olution of nationhood must be briefly reviewed. In 1963, an election was held.to determine membersbip in the LegislatiV:e - Council; its makeup had oeen under cfttack by Indian politicians -for many years previously. _ For these ~ctions, the prior voting qualifications r' based on property and income were removed, and women were allowed to vote (Meller and Anthony 1968:3). Fijians were to vote in a colony~wi de election for the f.irst time. · The reconstituted,Jouncil would number thirtyseven members, with the "govecnment holding nineteen seats -- a majority of on€: The eighteen other -positions were - divided equally among native 35 Fijians, Europeans and Indians •. Four members of each ethnic delegation were elected on _separ.a t~ co111T1unal roles. This ~lection in many ways saw- polarization~ on issues which repli.. -· - . cated previous pol iti cal concerns, but the, stands were brought forward , more Joudly by t_ne campaign~ . , . For nat fve Fijians, the question o·f constT- - tutional reform was un·iversally qualified by the assertion th9-t Fijian rjghts outlined in tp.e Deed of Cession be maintained. I European candidates, ' :..113J whose constituencie~ were dependent upon maintanence of the ~tatus quo and who were fearful of an Indian domination of government, strongly supported .· this stand (Meller a~d Anthony J968:70). 36 _, ... ,.;j;, IY Indians avoided the subject, save for o~posing Fijian domination of government . . Access to land wa~ one · /' of the prime concerqs expressed by Indian politicians,, and the questi-on of ~ setting ~iide reserve lands for Fij,ans was an important consideration 37 Chauhan 1970. > ( ) Almost immediately after the election the home government entered into talks with t'.he new Legislative Council which portended eventual irfdependence. In '1964, an unofficial majority was allowed in the Executive Council, which was the chief colonial policy-making body. furee of these unofficial members, one from each ethnic group, were given ministerial positions. In 1965, the members of the Legislative Cqu_11cil were called to Land~ to participate in a Fiji Constitutional Conference. . . . The ~esult was a new Constitution, which was rat·ified · in December, 1965, over the lo~dprotestsl 38 of five of the six . Indian M.L.C.s (Meller and Anthony 1968:120). From that 'point on, the Legislative Council was to have an unofficial ,· j majority, to be ·e lected under a complicated system of both communal and . · ~ ~ , coITlllon role voting.· Fijian representation was proportionately increased, . ---Jg . while European paiticipation was decreased slightly. ·e:· The Governor was sti11 to maintain ulti_lT!Qte control over the government, and could appoint m\iiislers from the M.L.C.s when he deemed it appropriate. 1965 saw the cons'olidation of formal party organizations' across Fiji. ·· - .,. . -114- A. D. Patel's Federation Party, based securely" upon the cane unions out of J which it grew, dominated Indian politics, although the new Muslim Minority Party, fearful of Hindu pol itica_l control;' and the National Congress Party were significant splinter groups. The Fijian Association, under· Ratu K.K. T. M5ra, eensolidated support among the na_tive population. -~ Legjslative CoLJncil · majprity for,~ The e·l ecti ons of 1966 resulted in \a ;:,· I ~· the Alliance Party, a lo6se'coalition made up primarily by Fijian, E.uropean and anti-Federation Indian leaders. In Sept~ber, 1967, the Governor shifted the Executive Council to the status of a Council of Minister's, with (HMSO. 1967: 5). Ratu Kamisese Mara becoming'C on, the Alliance and Federat o ment and major-0pposition___ ' From this point· ntinuously been the govern- ties in Fiji. Another London Constitutional Conference was held during April and May, 1970, which resulted in independence for Fiji and a new Constitution. Fiji became a self-governing Dominion within the Corrmonwealth, with a legislative system much like Canad~'s, including an appointed Se_nate and a House of Representatives. , The actual structure of election and appointment to these two bodies is complicated, and still includes the use of coITJTiunal roles, thus assuring that the Indian majority in Fiji• cannot become the Gover·nment without mono- . .. -·· . ·---~----········ 40 ..-.. ~-· -~ -~·-· l_ithi_,c internal -organization and large-sca·le non-Indian support. More--:-.,.:,;' over, ~~ny issue dealing with Fijian lands mus_t be _passed ·by-the Senat-e, which has an assured Fijian majority. 41 The first general election to be held since independence took place . -115- - - - - - -- - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - I in April, 1~72, and resulted in the continuance of the Alliance Pa~ty in power with a, majority of 14 seats; Alliance won 33 seats. and the National I · .Federation Party, under the leadership of S.M. Kaya, won 19. 42 . The result has be·en a government dominated by Fiji an and European leadership. Ratu Kamisese Ma(a continues in the c~pacity of Priroe'Minister . .. Of fourt~en · r- ·,;,-"'·;· cabinet po;tf.olios, native Fijians presently hold nine,.: Europf;a'ns hold three, and Indians hold but two (Fiji 1976b:8); . Only six out of twentytwo Senators are Indian. Fijian Indfans Today: a summary ) It is a difficult mafter to adequately' categorize the Indian people • of Fiji without in some way doing violence to the wide variability which exists among them. If one were to take the easy route and define an average, normative adult Fijian Indian, he or she would be young, for the average age of the Indian population is about sixteen. Our average Indian would be living in a rural context, with a high likelihood of being involved directly in agriculture. Someone else in the family prot'ffibly works in the nearby town.\\, He or_she would be surviving adequately, but frugally, for it must be r~membered that Fiji is still a Third World country by material standards. Housing would be sufficient for Fiji s 1 mild climate, but would be small, perhaps made of wood with a thatched roof, in need of repair, and would be shared by family members beyond one's nuclear family. ---------- -- ----------- There would likely be no electricity, although a few of one s neighbours might have it, and therefore none of the normal el~ctrical 1 --------- -116. . .. - . . appliances, . except for ba,:ttery-powered rad_i_o s. -Lighting and 'cooking w9ul' d . - · ~-' be done with kerosene or ga~, and the presence or absence of running water would depend largely upon geographical location. ~ . -· -- - _ ,Depending.upon age and sex, this a~erage IndiaJwould most :likely • T .· know ~:.-a con~t derable'·~mo~ryt of Eng~\~sh, e·sJ)~ cialfy~f f 'he was yo"ung or ni~,l ~; it i~ 9lso .- likely ttia F his or hercJ)t1rents know very }ittle E~g~l-ish, and · hav·e -had onJy slight contact with Europeans. Despite the ability to use Eng) i Sh or, at ]east, to understand it, Hindi Would be .fs:lct in everyday conv~rsation unless necessity demanded the use of English/or Fiji an. But at the same time, iri some ways th~ variability between one Indian and another is great ~ and continues to increase, particularly in terms of ecocomic position . Ethhic divisions between northern Hindus~ southern Hindus and Muslims are still of consequence, at least when it comes to questions of marriage or.mutual obligation. The Christian Indian popu- lation, though small and not strongly separate from the Hindus, is important because most of its members ar~iterate ahd · well-to-do. ' Being a Gujarati or a recently expatriated 'continental Indian also implies a 43 considerably different background and staAdard of living. Thefoge of Westernization evident within the Indian ethnic subcoITJTiun+Jes is also highly variabJe. Small numbers of Indians l_ive today much as their grandfathers did in their time, and the grandfathers of' to- day are truly of another age. At the same time, a smaller number of , Indians live lives which are fundamentally no different than the European 44 population of Fiji, down to ustng English for domestic. ·conversation. ,:-,-L . -117- As· there always nave been there are also important class and status divisions within the Fijign Indian co~un1.,t~~ there are rich people an~ poor people, .people on the way up·and others pn the w~y.,ddwn~ :· Jhele ·are· ti' c .drunkards:., ·- 'proper.~ peop 1e arid rogue~:.. r~., igi·O.l:jS v.eg~tali ~11S and' at.be is . - -~- · · 0 i ..... ;:.- - ; ~ ~ p _ _ : · · ~~ ~- - " ' · " "~<>-..~ - ·s:.•: · _·,s,_ · "- Within thfs : vari~bili,ty, COQSfr:-ained bf ,Fijian 'sac·ie"ty as lt lS _-. \; ' "- - '~ ·• presently constituted and within indivi?ual situations determined by' unique personal histories, some of these people have decided to leave , Fiji and come.to Canada. Knowing 5omething bf the fuakeup and historical trends of both Fi.jian and British' Columbian society, we must now look to the process of the iinmi grati_on of Fi.j i ans to Canada to see how these two . . contexts interface with indi vi dua 1 decision-making to produce the demo·, graphic makeup of Canadian Fijian society . ./ .... , ·' , - -118- Chapter Two: -· Notes l. .. ( There are several excellent geographical-studies of Fiji,'particularly R.G. War,d(l9'65) andWatte'rs (196~)~ · .. -• . .. , . 2.. _ Native sociql organization was very·coniplex, and has not altogether .. , · ·been- sorted out, see Dyck (l 975) , Geddes ( 1959), Bel shaw ( 1964}, and ·,Sahlins·(l962). Groves' (1963) review article of S.ahlins (1962) out- . - ~ lines turrent opinion.on Fijian social organization, while Roth (1951) 1 I 11 outlines the official view of Fijian indirect.rule 11 • 3. - As noted soni~ seventy years ago by Herman_Nieboer (l~lO), slavery and _ indenture tend to atise only in those situations where labour has alternative and relatively equivalent economic resources available to wage labour. · ' · 4. Administrative chiefs sometimes corresponded to trad.itional ones_, but not of necessity.· · 5. Wages were about 4 to 5 times that of unski~ed labour in India, bu.t so wera many-costs (Gillion 1962:Al). Moreover, wages were_consjderably lower than those which the contract suggested were bein~paid. 6. Of 21,368 who immigrated from the Calcu,tta depot from 1879 to 1900, 10,258 were from the Northwest Provinces (48%), 5,885 were frbm Oudh (21.8%), and 3,734 came 1ro~ Bihar and Bengal {17.4%). 7. It is a certainty that many hid their high caste status, as recruiters were instructed to select members of the agricultural castes if at all possible (Tinker 1974:51). Gillion (1962:54) notes that the C.S.R. requested.that its agents not send Punjabis, literate Indian~ of any sort, or, discharged soldiers, as these types of immigrai:its were likely to cause trouble for the company. 8. Gillion (1962:190) gives- this figure by summing up labour Department records in Suva up to 1957. _But it is my personal experience that many people have made ase of the privtlege in order to have one-h~lf of a return trip to India paid for by the government, These people are included in the records, yet have returned to Fiji .. - 9. Gillion (1962:138) notes that only 515 Indians were in their second contract at the end of 1912. ------- 10. Tinker (1974:320) gives the figure as 46,000 acres being in Indian hands in 1912. 11. Watt~s (1969) ha·s studied economic development closely'in four villages. In each case there is a considerable, but variable, negative effect from collective duties and responsibilities. '\ • -- - 1 . :--e . ·. . -119'c,, -- ~ :,: - - & . 6 . . 12. " Fijian Indian ,facjli.ty with ·creqit sy,stems is ''of 4/~~c·t,c~~uerice.:' J.Jl their econom'i'c"arientation in Cana11~ . . In fhi:!~t, _c redit _-use had plunged much of the Indian rural populati_o n(of -tiji deep-l y into debt. = --• 13. ~ajar international sugai producers and· cons~mers have set up a · .system ofy1;arly production quotas for each country, with the hope of stabilizing sugar prices. 14. But intermarrfage, es.pecially between northern and southern H.i ndus, seems to b·e on the increase at present. Hindus and Muslims both celebrate the Hindu Hali festival and Hindus used to attenq~.Lim Moharram: Everybody celebrates Christmas. •1 .15: Indian schools were to be corrvnunity o-rganized and largely selffinanced until ve_ry recently. The colonial administration was reluctant to . spend money on I.ndi an edue;ati on, while. the missionaries, who had been so successful among the native Fijians, did not expect many Indian conve~ts and shied away from ~he construction of Indian -s chools. · ·_ ·· . . . . 16. The Muslim League split into two groups in 1933, when a leader of the non-orthodox Ahmadiya se~t arrived in Fiji. His adherents formed the Muslim Association of fiji . .~ 17. Cane fanners first struck the,"C.S.R . . in--1921 (Mayer 1963:39), following upon .a general ~trike by Indi~n labourers in 1920. The formation of the first two unions of cane fanners, the Kisan San_gJl_ (1937) and the Akhil Fiji Krishak Maha Sangh (1941) led to the severe strike· of 1943, and later, to considerably better conditions for cane fafmers. 0 18. · One additional Europea_n representative was also added . . 19. 20. It must be remembered that during this period 'the Fijians had an · additional . political avenue .. through the Council of Chiefs. ' Three of both the European and Indian blocks were to be elected. five Fijian representatives were nowinated. · All ~ - -r .• 21. O'Loughlin (1953:5) estimates .. that a.bout one-third of the 1,500licenced Indian traders were forced out of business. 22: C.S.R. lessees, on the average, were only paid £80 for their 1938 crop -1Stanner 1953:179,. 23. The Indian fanners secured the condition of 30 year leases, but without guarantee of renewal. I -120- 24. The charge might have been .well founded with respect to the use of particular parcels of land, but overall Fndtan farm lands have net .. shown an apprec,i able decrease. - 'In fact, over 1956-1966 Indian cane lands increased from 115,654 acres to ;l 53,000 (Anderson 1969 :32). No one denies, however, that by modern agricultural standards Fijian· lands are grossry under-utilized. ~ 25. Native Fijians suffered from a declining population until 1921, when the population stabilized. Indian birth and child mortality rates were very much better during the subsequent period, atcountfng for their numerical majority. Indian birth rates are now sharply down, and this, -coupl~d with out-migration, has kept the Indian ~opulation at 51% of the total Fijian population since.1966 (Fiji 1976:1). 26. In 1946, the Indian and native Fijian populations stood at 120,000 and 118,000 respectively. But of those working for wages, 55% of Fijiil'rl natives worked full-time, while only 38% of Indians did so; the participation rates are therefore rou~hly eqaal (Stanner 1953:240). 27. The J956 census revealed that 16,883 Indians wer..e-- involved in cane farming, and claimed that this was 6,000 above the requfrements 6f farming (Watters 1969:20). · 28. Watters (1969:8) estimated that' in 1961 the average Indian far~er owed about 64% of his average annual income ($533) in -outstanding debts. · 29. There were 75,000 students enrolled in school in 1959. Of the primary grades, this constituted about 75% of the children of school age. 30. This is slightly skewed by the monumental' but temporary rise irt th_t. price of sugar in late 1974, Nevertheless, sug~r conservatively I produces 75% of· Fiji s export fl ow. 31. In 1972 (Fiji 1972:59), only 55,61~ Fijians are listed as being employed at either white or blue collar work. This is, of ·course, a very l!:!Jlh. rate by Thi rd World standards. Of these, abo.ut 70% were above the level of unskilled labour (Fiji 1973:64). 32. The marked difference between Fij,ian native and Indian English literacy for older people reflects the successful efforts--of~mi-s-si-on-ar;-e~among the native population and the use of Hindi in earlier Indian sc-h-oo-1 s- • 33. For a fee, which varies with the time of day, Fijians can have births, deaths, and other messages broadcast on the radio. In a country with limited and expensive phone service this radio communications system is vital, and radio audiences are large. !..... . ·r C f 4 -121- 34. Circulations are high, about 15;000~aily for eac~. 35. This distribution reflected the enormous economic power of the Europeans, who numbered only a few thousand, and the traditional rights of the native Fijians, who consJituted about 42% of the population. 36. . . . ~ This allian~e betwee~ Fijians and Europeans had a considerable tradition behind it.· In 1962, native Fijians and Europeans had emphatically rejected the government s suggestion that Fiji move towardsa _member system of government,~fficial members contr9T cabinet depa rtmE;nts. _ . 1 37. Meller and Anthony (1968) have recreated candidates• stands for the· 1963 election through p-ublished s.tate-ments. It is my imp-ression through talking with people who were involved in this election that Indians were quite vociferous on the question of land tenure in their unrecorded speeches. · 38. · The four M.L:C.s of the Indian Federation Party, led oy A.O. Patel, were unanimous in their disapproval. 39. There would be thirty-six unofficial members, and rio more than four official ones. Nine native Fijians and nine Indians would be elected co11111unally, as would seven Europeans. Two Fijians .would be n·ominated by_ the Council .of Chiefs. Additionally, nine more positions were to be elected at large, but three would be reserved for each ethnic · group. Thus, the total composition would be: 14 Fijians 12 Indians 10 Europeans 4 Officials (Maximum) 40. The current system guarantees that of the 52 members of the House of Representatives, the total makeup would be: 22 Fijians 22 Indians 8 General Electors . . General ele·ctors consist of Europeans, Part Europeans (should they decide not to register on the Fijfari roTeJ, and- Cfffnese. - - 41. Of the twenty-two Senators, etgh~are crppotntect oy the Counc, l of Chiefs, seven by the Prime Minister, six by the Leader of the Opposition, and one by _the Council of Rotuma. 42. · S.M. Kaya replaced A.O. Patel as Opposition Leader upon the latter s death in 1969. Alliance has since lost three seats, two by members 1 ,I! -122- .. ·,_ shtfti~to independents and one as the result of a resignation and suoseq·uent -by-e 1ect ion defeat. The next genera 1 election must be · held by April, 1977, at the latest. 43. Indicative of this ,5or.t of split, marriages between Gujaratis and those who are descendants of i_ndentured labourers are still very rare. On the other side, many Fiji-born Indians are suspicious of the Gujaratis, especially in business and politics, and tend to · conside~ Indian expatriates (who are often professionals) as un-. warrantly elitist. 44. But r have not met a Fijian Indian, save those w~o were primarily brought up in Canada, who does not know · an Indian Janguage. Even the m'ost Westernized Fiji Indians are still heavily tied .by kin links to Indian ways.of dQing, even if they do not th~mselves practise many of them. " ' . - - - - - - •- · - - - - - - ~ -- I -123- F' / Chapter Three: Irrrnlgrati on·. This chapter out1ines the pattern of Fijian irrnnigration to,Canada. This is no easy task, for .in suc:h a .s;,,nmunjty immigration is of central . concern to everyday 1 i-fe. J . Irrrnfgration means separation from kin and , country; i1TJ11igration means finding a new way under strange conditions; -if1TTligratj,Qn of one's friends a~~ relatives helps to es7ablis in a newborn corrrnunity and•, binas that corrrnunity in a networ cation and concern to one'-s homeland. uni- For the F~jian commu ity, where' f t.fHy ooe--ha,lf of the total J161ttilation has come si-nce the end of 1973, the impo_rtance of irrrnigratio~ cannot be.overestimated. 1 Because irrrnigration co]ours (c,much of Fijian Canadian life,( it will be intimately tied in with every subsequent aspeot·of this inquiry. Here, the focus is more narrow, and cpncerns the development and understanding . ., of · the actua 1 process of coming to Ca.nada . . This chapter seeks to describe the nature of the irrrnigration flow itself and to offer some insights into why it exists and why it has taken the fonn- it has . .. A Descriptiv'e History of Fijian Irmligration to Canada Before attempting any explanation of the process of inrnigrati-0n · it is necessary to · .Know something about it, at least in broad outline. Thit/fl# particularly important be~ause, even though Fiji~n irrmigration to ~nada .has a very :hort his-tor:,,, ·i-ts ·~ r e has..shi rtea-•constd~Time·. 4with previous Asian i1m1igrants to British Columbia, Fijians~-a prior collective experience with inmigration; although Canada is currently , the most imp.o.rtant acc.ep.tor of Fijian emigr~es, it is not the fir-st by any .\ ( · -124------ - -------------------- - - - means. - - ~ - - - Like earlier Asian irrmigrants to Canada, Fijian Indians first de- veloped a pattern of sojourner i11111igration. after World War II. This began to be significant Although both Australi.a and New Zealand maintained " · racially restrictive iITITiigration policies until recently, work permits 1 which allowed three to six month stays were available in the early 1950 s. Q an~ many Indians made use of them (Mayer 197l:186}. the possibility. Many mofe learned of This form of short-te~ (male) immigration fncreased in 1 ·frequ,ency through the years, to the point that by the late 1960 s 'v'.isits to Australia and f{ew Zealand were a co111T10nplace, ev}n in the rural villages (Mayer 1973:212). 1 In the 1960 s, short-term work in the smaller islands, notably the - New Hebrides, was frequent for both Indian and native Fijians. The density of this flow of personnel is indicated by the very high present rates of departures from Fiji. In 1975, for instance, the total number of Fijian residents who left Fiji numbered 28,597, 53% of which were heading·for _Australia or New Zealand (Fiji 1976a:105). on holiday or business.excursions. This figure· includes Fijians 0 Most of thfs emigration from °Fiji was cyclic and, save for those who , left on holiday, much of it was finflly oriented towards the accumulation of sa.vin~~ a country where scarce·wage-paying jobs returned a,r<"aver\ -age of 21¢ an hour in 1965----{-fiji -t97fra-:-8~7,.-the--i-ncenti-ve-for--sojourner. iimiigr~ + ' V-fM'¥ 'l-a-r~T now a round 65¢ an hour, wages A-'lthough the average--Wa.ge---rates in Fidi are· fa/ ~ork overseas have risen .- accordi ng1y: The desire for overseas work continues among both native and lndian Fijians, -125----- d ·-· - --- - - - - - - - - - · - - - - -- ·- and is limited primaril_y by the labour requirements of the receiv'ing countries . . While sojourner irrmi grati on is a qua l_itati ve ly different endeavour than lea'JLd__ 11 ~ closely to the Canadian national averages for all irmnigrants. .,, ) -136- 35,00 • 30~00 25,0 20,00 15,000 ,,oo 0-4 5-9 -14 -19 -24 -29 ~34 -39-44 -49 -54 . -59 -64 -69 +70 Figure 2. The Age Distribution of the Population of Fiji (5 year segments)~ 1974 ..., 450 400 "'." ..... -........__ · 350 300 250 200 150 100 iQ 0-4 5-9 -14 -19 -24 -29 -34 -39 -44 -49 . -54 -59 -64 -69 +?O Figure 3. The Age Distribution of Fijian Iliaigrants to Canada, . 1974 and 1975 Immigrants, Nuabets by Age (5 year segments) .... -137·· ······ - - - - · · - - -- - - -- - - - - - -- A large part of the divergenc~ bet~en the Fijian Indian population distribution -and that of new inrnigrarits can be accounted for by the criteria . . . of the i•igratio.n process itself. which of course ~lects for . adult workers rather than non;ative population distributior\i, and which sets a prewiita on being in . the twenty-thirty year ol_d age bracket. I - Sex rcrt1os · of tn.119-ra-nts -a:tso -cr,~erge considerably Tfom -tne· norillal · -; - ---~ ~---- - .. r • - . even distribution exhibited by the Fijian Indian populat,on {Department ,., 7 o· of Manpower and Inra1gration Ann!,lal I11111igration Sta~i~tic~__ 1974; 1975)~ 2.001 1.75 -/ 4 1.so-f 1. 25 ratio: ;ales -i 1.0 females .875 • 750 .625 .500 0-4 5-9 -14 -19 -24 -29 -34 -39 -44 +49' Figure 4. Su htios of 1974 and 1975 Fijian Imigran~ to Canada,_ by.Ag~ __ __ ______ __ __ -138- l. · This ske~ing, with males significantly outnumbering females in the middle age brackets, rep.resents the combination of two factoris; fi.1t, · . the prelimina~y inm/4ration of male heads of households and the in¥itgration -,; . ., of single men, ·and secondly, the delayed immigration of their wives and daughters. . ' Occupational Class and Education 7 It is diffjcult to discuss the occupational background of iIT111igrant Fijians w'ithout simultaneous-ly considering at least several correlated variables, notably class and ~ducation. .., The degree -of urbanism, of westernizati-on, and of material success are also c1f>sely linked . . Many of these measures are most difficult to assess empirically in ( n ifTITligrant cofTITlunity, because one's only method of confirmation available .' 1s constant •cross-checking of background materi a 1 among a number of informants. According)y, I have assembled ,a composite of the background of F]jian· immigrants by bui,lding the foundations on statistical data, iven <) -though this ~ay riot necessarily be the most holistic appro~ch pos_sible. It i sfr~asonab 1e t"o beg in withfo~hc~paht~ on. Thretedsebtstohf ~cc~patti ~na 1 .. da t a are o consequence, on 1y one. o w ,c 1s co 11ec e y · e rnm,gra ,on · _ \ , process: / . prior occupation in Fiji,. ·inte.nded occupation'-tn Canada, and realized occupation in Canada. . -. . ~tis only the second of these for ~which -- ···-· ·- - - -·-··-·---- - --- -- ------------- --- - - - -- - - - -- -- there exists data covering a}l iJJJTiigrants. · Although there are numerous - · - - - -··--·-·-- - - - -- - - -- - - -- cases where the intended occupation of iJJJTiigrants is not the occupation in which they were engaQed irrmediately prior to iITJTiigration, neverthel~ss, , - - -- " " ~: -139- ----------- ------------ __,;/_ _ _:_ ______ __________ _ V in a very high number of these cases they had extensive prior experience in > these callings~· O~e can take figures for intended occupation to mat~h . actual prior occupation, with_ some variation, very closely. The following table surrmarizes the intended occupation of Fijian 12 immigrants for 1972, 73, and 74: 7 Number Occupation 44 Entrepreneurial - Managerial ·Profess ion al Cl eri ca] . , Commerce & Sales Service• Agricultural .Fabrication, Construction, - &Transportati6n Other Table XII. 16 53 270 105 81 42 517 70 Intended Occupation of Fijian Irrmigr,ants, 1972-1974 It is readily apparent that the inrnigration'selection mechanisms have generated a .population which is very much at ·variance with the Fifian Indian population as a whole. As mentioned, farming is still the primary occupation of some 65% of Fijian Indians, and yet.agriculturalists do not figure highly in those p,ursuits which have,gained Fijian inmigrants access to Canada. This should not imply that these irrmigrants are some sort of urban elit_e, det-ache~ from the concerns of 1he countryside, for they are not. A majority of adult Fijian Indian irrmigrants were.born on farms, ,· most gr~u~ on them, and a great rnany have contfrfuTng rnteresflrf-fffem, etther tf\rougll ow11ershtv ortlirough ,relatives who continue to live IDT~- fann. Nevertheless these are_ fairly special people by Ffjian standards. To , -140- see this more clearly, let us look at a job~specific list of occupations given by iITJTiigrants in 1975 (Heatn~l976): -. ·~.::~ ... ~ . .. ~ ~ - ,I Occupation · ~inber: motor vehicle.mechanics & repairmen 79 carpenters & related professions 60 general office clerks : 58 ategory unavailable 43 bo keepers & accounting cle 42 salesper corrrnodities, other . 38 typists & clerk-typists 29 welding & Kame cutting 20 electrical equipment repair & installation 1·9 Table XIII. .Number Occupation sales clerks, coimnodities service station attendants truck drivers sec re ta ri es & stenographers chefs & cooks construction electricians driver-salespersons cabinet &wood furniture makers draughtsmen tailors & dressmakers others (frequency <10) Total workers Intended Occupation of Fijian Immigrants, 1975, by Specific Categories; 18 18 15 14· 13 13 12 11 10 10 252 774 '· If one keeps in mind the fact that 252, or about one-third, of these i111Tiigrants are in a wide range of occupational categories (obviously, more than twenty-five additional ones}, one sees a distributi.on of occupations dominated by skilled white and blue collar jobs, only a handful of which do not require significant training and experience; When one considers the following distribution of Indians in the Fijian workforce, coupled with the very rough percentage of the Indian workforce each of these categories· represents, the s_pecial nature of the inmigrant _po_pulatton be_come_s _ apparent: -141- !~umber Occupational Sector Percentage of Working Indians .6 1 ,046 Agricul'ture, Forestry,&'. Fishing 370 .2 Mining . 3. 6 5,500 Manufacturing 450 .3 Electricity, Gas, and ~Jater 5,236 3.5 Construction 5,158 3.4 Trades and Tourism 2,551 1. 7 Transport, Storage, Communication Finance, Real Estate, and 940 .6 Business Services 7,599 Service Industries ~. Total - 28,850 18. 9% - · 13 Table XIV. Fijian Indian Wage & Salaried Labour, 1972, by Sector The highly selective nature of the occupational spectrum of Fijian ilTiTiigrants indicated by these charts m~y even underestimate the difference between it and the Fijian population. Figures for intended occupation are kept for inde~endent ~nd nominated i ~ $ , and not for their sponsored dependents. Thus, the occupational backsiround of women dependents, most fcorrnnonly wives and adolescent daughters, is largely ignored. In fact, not only do women irrmigrants represent a considerable percentage of the Fijian Canadian working population, but they also come with significant non-fann work histories. Conservatively, 30% of irrmigrant Fijian adult women have worked away from home while in Fiji. Educationally, the irrmigrant Fijian Indian population is very heterogeneous, reflecting the fact that the impact of schooling in Fiji has changed radically over the past twenty years. Especially p-rior to the 1%0-is, education w-as a scarce resource among trre fm:lian puputatiun;o:m:t this, coupled with traditional views of male leadership and male economic support, led to women getting very little schooling indeed. Many Fijian I • , · I . -142- Ihdian women · above the age of forty have had no ' education, and this holds 14 for irrmigrant women as well. Indeed, the average English literacy rate among Fiji Indians over fortyjears old was about 15% in 1966 (Fiji 1973: 57), and, is likely to be no greater than 30% now. In Fiji, Indian education is costly, and children ~nded to receive education in proportion to their family's ability to pay for it and to support the children while they were in schoo~. case for secondary school education. This still remains the There were traditional grades where one left school; before 1955, women often left after three grades, if they went at a11 , while there are significant lasses among both sexes presently-at the end of eight grades (which also mar~s the end of primary school) (Fiji 1973:51). Wastage in secondary school is very high at each level, and currently only 10% of Fiji's student population is finishing twelve years of education. While the general pattern once was one of very limited education, with even less for women, this is under rapid flux, and a· decade will likely see a very high rate of secondary school completion by both sexes. Al- ready, males and females are equally represented in the first year of Fijian secondary schools. In su111T1ary, then, one can generalize that all children of school age · were in fact in school prior to ilTITligrating, that for adults age inversely correlates with education, and that wives have had considerably- Tess- · schooling than their men. Surprisingly, even though both school-age children and uneducated women and older people will bring down the averages I I -143/ severely~jian immigrants to Canada show a very high level of primary and s.ecendary education (Heath 1976): Years of Education " Numbers 575 37 56 59 69 79 94 122 347 0 l 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 12 182 257 166 170 13 45 9 10 11 Table XV. , Years of Education _j Numbers 14 15 16 17 18 21 24 15 14 Total 2,323 8 3 l Educational Achievement of Fijian Immigrants, 1975. Although disguised in the averages, one must conclude that male family 15 heads will tend to have something above ten years of education. Another surprisfng thing is their high degree of English verbal ability. Department of Manpower and Irrrnigration figures, even though they are certain to be overestimates, claim that 99% of Fijian immigrants in 1975 knew some English (Heath 1975). A very high proportion is confirmed by my own expe- rience; Fijian Indians, used to a polyglot social context, rapidly develop 16 English fluency. As with o~upational and educational measures, this certainly implies once more that Fijian irrrnigrants are no cross-section of the Fijian population. In fact, this language capability is unusual among Canadian irrrnfgrants as a whole, 32% of whom in 1975 could speak neither » -144- English nor French, as measured by of criteria, (Department of Manpower and Immigration Quarterl1 Immigration Statistics 1975 IV:13). The figure for British Columbia follows the national average: Typical Immigrants and their Concerns is a notion of Something which cannot be derived simply from figures , what sort of person stands behind them. 4 , Without such a picture any argu- ments about the causes of immigration remain abstract ones. Accordingly, I have attempted to make up a set of typical immigrants, none of which exactly correspond to anyo~e, but which can certainly help to understand . . t. 17 th e process of 1mm1gra ,on. Males are unarguably the heads of Fijian households, if one is careful to mean this only in the narrow sense that their say is usually dominant in family decisions which involve its interaction with the external world. While it can be convincingly argued that in fact women form the central core of many Fijian Canadian households, especially those which are larger than nuclear families, males are the vehicle through which vital decisions are channeled. Accordingly, their place in the immigration procedure is overt, and important. . The place of women is equally vital, but a bit more delving is required to bring it forth. There are, broadly speaking, four types of males among Fijian Indian imni grants to Canada, young and o1d de.ipendents, and younger and older work i n-g males . Two of t~~ r i--es , t-ke- €ie-1}ettt:ieft-t -ooe-s- ,- -e-a-tt- be- --de-a-l-t with fairly quickly. Young;~tives of both sexes, which is to say the -145,- ,. ·sons, daughters, an·d occasionally, the nieces, nephews, and "cousins" of male immigrants, who -were in a dependent situation ' in _F iji rar~ly have much say in whether they will immigrat~. 18 Thus, males beiow the age of seventeen and females who have not yet married (up to about the age of twenty-two) normally immigrate to ca·nada as part of a family, if the immigration laws a]low them to do so. The family household forms the typica1 "quantum unit" of Fij~an im_m igration. 19 Older dependent men are relatively infrequent immigrants, as are older women, for several reasons. The first reason is primarily demo- graphfc; because immigrant !amilies are fairly young, and because Fijian Indians once married at a young age, parents, uncles, aunts, and older inlaws are still well within their productive lives,,. and are ty~ically i~ their forties. They, therefore, neither are dependents nor do they qualify as dependents by Canadian irrmigration regulations, which specify that old age dependents are to be over the ages of sixty-five for males and sixty for females. There are many parents who have come here, but they must come as nominated relatives, under the same criteria as other people in that category. Another factor which limits the number of elde~ly dependents is their reluctance to break with ways of doing, with friends and with relatives which have Stood the test of a lifetime. Old men and women have a func- tional and honoured place in Fijian households, and both their functionality and ~tatus is slighted in the Canadian context. Many old.er Fijian In_dians view Canada as a place for the young, and many who come find life here very ambiguous. .. -146- Most of tho-se who initiatt the process of immigration are workingmen, some with fami1ies, others not. One can divide this broad group in two by age -- actually by degree of establ ishmen_t in occupation a,nd family -- for this h-as a significant bearing on the motivations and goals of immigration. •' · The immigration of the younger variant, because of his age and the t 1 consequent freedom from familial ties which it represents, is far. more simple to explain than that of the more established immigrant. Descrip- tively, he could be from about seventeen to approximately twenty-five. He may be married, but if so, most of his children are probably below the age of eight. In Fiji, he and his family most likely did not live in a house~ hold where he was the dominant male; more commoniy, he would be living with his parents oi ~with an older patrilineal relative. ' Although from a family which was we 11 enough off to pro vi de him with some education, it is likely that he had extreme difficulty in utilizing \ his training, and was employed at a number of job~ throughout his short work history, these jobs being seP,arate<\by periods of unempioyment or of part-time employment. f· Culturally, he is \~lready fully of two worlds, for because of his age he knows little about Fiji as it ~as before 1955, nor was he rais9J altogether within the confines of family tradition. As an adolescent he likely as not was part of a peer group wh,ich aggressively sought the novel and the unusual in the changing and Westernizing Fiji. Perhaps a re-al-example wo4ld be illuminative: . -· - . - ---- ----~ Ram Chand (a pseudonym) is now twenty-six. He has been in Canada since 1973, when he was nominated by his immediately elder brother, who came in 1970. When he first arrived he ha, -been married for a little less than three years, and had ' I j -147- at that time one d~ter. Ram was born and raised on·a tenancy cane farm a o ten miles from Lautoka, which was run by his father. s the third of three sons. He spent his early adolesc~nce in school, in part because his father and elder brother were already underemployed on the fann, even though it gave them an adequate income. Hise first em~loyment for wages was with his paternal uncle, who bought produce from local farmers and trucked it to market. While this began as part-time work, he soon learned to drive the truck, and eventually was working with fair regularity. He continued to live at home, even after his marriage to the daughter of a moderately successful mixedcrop farmer who was the neighbour of one of his relatives: His elder brother ~ad become an accounting clerk in one of Lautoka's tourist hotels, and immigrated to Canada by virtue of being ·nominated by another paternal uncle. When fully established he was allowed to nominate his brother, who then came to Canada. I Our older male immigrant in fact is old more in tradition and estab-· lishment than in age. In fact, he may well be 1n_his mid-twenties, al- though those above thirty would be closer to the ideal type. , In all respects, he contrasts only jn degree with his younger counterpart, but the su11111ati on of these small _,,d--i:(ferences make him a considerably dif-....... ferent person. Hew-ill be married and have a family. I,) Very few males above twenty- five are not married, and those who are not are clearly considered aberrant by their relatives. Although he may have pre-school children, as likely as not most of his offspring are in primary or early secondary school. He sees himself overtly as the head of this household, with all the responsibilities attendant to it. His family resides in a house in which he- E -- the voice of authority; not infrequently fie will own fne house, ancf h-ewill coll111only also have a controlling or ownership interest in some incomeproducing property. -148~ ~ - - ------- ------- ---- • ---~-- ---------- 0 He is also well-rooted into a fairly stable social and ec9nomic context. It is likely that he will have been working at his present job f~)r a considerable length of time, not infrequently over ten years. He may well be as senior in position as he.is likelyzo -be during his working career. Within his family~ he is beginning to pl the part of a significant elder, helping to make marriages, to mitigate disputes, and to assist younger relafives in whatever ways his position makes available. He has been raised far more traditionally than his younger counterpart, and will tend to be more ambiguous about the prospect of a Weste~nJzed Fiji; wh~t is largely coherent change he will likely see ~s a loosening of constraints and as a descent into r~lative anarchy. Ahmed Syed (a pseudonym) is now forty, and was thirty-six when he came to Canada. He was.an independent irrmigrant, / even though many of his close relatives were already here ~ and c0uld have nomtoa.ted him. He was married, and had at that time one daughter of seventeen, another of eleven, and a seven year-old son. The younger two- were attending school when they came. Ahmed was a skilled woodworker, who had followed the traditional pattern of apprenticeship and certification. He had worked for the same employer for almost twenty years. The Syeds lived in Suva, and owned their own home. Ahmed was the_ only son arrbng five daughters, and had led the family since his father died when Ahmed was twenty-three. Ahmed and his wife were practicing and devout Muslims, although thei~ children were rather less so. Ahmed's job placed him in continual contact with Europeans and both parents were fluently bilingual. - ------ ---- Irrrnigration Determinants: the societal context Chapter Two outlined the history of Fiji a~Fijian Indians at a general --------'--------"'-'- r -149- level. Within that history we have seen that the situation of Indians in - -Fiji has always been tinged with uncertainty, first . in . the contusion of .., indenture and then in the teriuous positicin of subordinate tenant farmers. minds of many Fijian Indians, and That uncertainty persists today in the r . is a primary, though not necessarily a direct irnpetus toward immigrati-on-. wf\,c~ _the structure of Fijian < There are two related general areas in society as presently constituted provides a source of concern to Fijian ~ "' 1rldians: _ their place in theiconomy and their ability to use politics ..,,, towards their collective ends.\ Eac~s discussed in turn. Although Fijian Indians have been the largest ethnic group in Fiji . / since the 1940 s, and in spite of being a numerical majority for a decade, 1 vthey have been fighting unsuccessfully for proportional political representation since;.A:'he 1930 s. 1 The cry for a common role was in fact on.e for proportional representation. At independence, it was agreed.. that in the interests of a smoother transition the first post-independence election (1972) would be or~a~iong lines of electio_ns in.the 1960 s. 1 - It therefore included both communal and common role voting, with total ethnic - . . . melT)bership •for each group still being limited. . The result was _a strong victory for the Allianc's..J!apty and the perpetuation of an Indi~:dominated opposition party, the Nationa 1 Federation Party. ~ The consequences of .this arrangement are dua 1 , in the sense that both ------what the Government does and .what lt appears to do both affect the way in . .. . . . . . -- - - -- -- ~- - - -- - - r' ·which people see their own position. ' ' In both respects, the post-:-independence - Government has given ! ~_cause for coiective worry. The formal polari- ,I -~~ ----- -150-.. - ---- zation of the All1ance anq National Federation parties is neithe~ accidental, arbitrary, nor overly phil~sophical. Rather, this polarization is directly one of interests which are in head-to-head conflict·an'd it is based firmly upon ~ragmatic considerations.plliance versus Federation symbolizes the· duality which has·persisted in Fiji for decades: Fijian natives and Europeans versus Indians, and wHh_it, the primal division of views on land and economic policy. This split along ethnic i'ines\in a parliamentary syS-tem where tbe" ritinority (Federation) party has no dir'ect participation ·.in government is ~angerous one, as was noted even before independence (Fisk 1970:48). For Indians, it means _realistically that land poli(;es. cannot change '- greatly in thei_r favour;' the Alliance Party has the technical right, even though it would not likely be activated, to remo~e Indian leaseholders altogether. Moreover, the National Federation Party, because it has so long been identified with Indian interests, is unlikely to ~ick up enough native Fij"i an "or genera 1 elector support to_ b'ecome the government ' without a radical revision of its program. /' Politi'ccfr .scandals and charges of corrupti on/2a·ve weakened .th~ A11 i anc'e Party during the 1as t two years, while the F~tion Party has begun to actively solicit native support . . Nevertheless, it is hard to see how the Federation Par~ can achieve a governing majority ir1the_next election. __________ _ - - - - - - _;:..,.....- Being represe~ted bi a - minority party has symbolic consequences as - ----- _,r,:well. Why, ask Indians, do we have no say in government, when we are a numerical majority and we provide the basis for the economy? r , In state- ---------------- j -151- r \ _ __ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ . --- ----- ---~--- - --- - - - . . . . . , _ _ . \ ments 1 ike , these{ governmental opposition brj.t,gs out all th~ stereotypic . / ~ - - feeli~which Indians have for native Fijians. A strong 'Protestant' work . ethic-theme argues that Indians must do- all the work in the society, in order to provide the basis for native Fijian "indolence and laziness", only to have those same Fijians dominat~ in g£rnment. Indian views ahout the .nature nf native Fij.ian partici_patj_op tri .th_e_ ~------------ --, ' economy-are seriously in error, as a comparison of incomes and standards , I of living in.Chapter Two indicated. But this matters little to s ~ e whf is not in possessi~ of the facts. Indians see Fijians and Ejropeans do~inate the few high-status governmenta tand" economic jobs, and fear parallels at less exalted levels. V They are suspicious of the Fijian )mOrical domination of the military and the polic~. The structure of the economy of Fiji also ~rovi~es'general grounds for worry, in t9Js case for Fijian Indians and natiyes alike, even though the consequ~s whi cl:1 are seen 'a~e not the sa~ f_or both groups~ Objec-. tively, ·the Fijian economy is _likely to be very problematic in the future, • . ~ 0 espec~:l::t: s:n::::s~x-co;onies, thJ Fiji:n economy is dominated by a ve;y few major e~port p~od.u ctJJ ... ) • / 0 t✓sale of. 'which are necessary for\ the / •·, finance of government and a reasonable standard of living. - i ~ 'A ll of these . exports which a-re of any consequem:'e are raw materials or basic foodstuffs, - ; -____ . - - -- ·-·-- .. -\ . ----···-·--·- - - -- - - - -- - - - - - - -- · - -- - - - - - - - the pric~ of which cannot be significantly controlled or"'Cieveloped by Fiji . . the economy theref6re- is1argeTT-Teft' unprotected against the price fluctuations of a dozen or so corrrnodities on the world market.- -·l--52- At the same time, Fiji is a significant imp~ter of most manufactured · = · 21 goods, fuel, and, shamefully, oflmuch food. Fiji has had a net negative balance of trade every year since)ndependence (Fiji 1976a:61). Perhaps · more important than the balance o~ trade, these ~arge imports mean that / \ I the prices of many e"'.·eryday cormmdities in Fiji are set by the ability_of - -- - - ----- - ---- - - industrialized countries to pay for them. In many ways, Fiji suffers from Thi,rd 'world income~pled to First World prices. ( The job marktk in Fiji is currently expanding rapidly, paralleJing±he J economy s exp 1os i ve~owth over the PiiS t decade. Wage emp 1oyment has in 1 fact gone up by aboV5o% in th~ last ten years (Fiji 1976a:83).' In terms ✓ ...) ff percentages, native and Indian F-ijians have shared in this growth in /proportion to their numbers, for in 1972 native Fijians held 38.6% and Indians 49.4% of the .wage and salaried jobs (Fiji 1972:63). In terms of higher paying, higher status jobs Indians have done a bit better than - their numbers, especially in service industries and commerce. The top jobs are still almost exclusively· European. There are economic reasons why Fijian Indians might see immigration as a more viable option than native Fijians. First of all, jobs are hard to get, especially skilled ones, and despite the increasing number of people working,~here is an even more quickly increasing. number of peo!)le looking for them, native and Indian alike. 1 T_he_tot~J.JJptenti.al wo~king population is current]J_-~rowinJl_~.}~~~n_ 3_% and 4% per anlum {Fiji 1973:20). . ~ ~ # J One of.,-fhe prime.-.dtfferences between Indiens and native Fiji ans is I the_ir r~tion to land, which . is .important to even the most urbanized. ., For - -- - - - - - - - "- - / . -153- the ' Gtion, its maximum limits: ""1 the size of Indian holdings has essentially reached Indian land therefore can sustain additional popu- lation only in proportion to incr~ases in its cash productivity, and 1these increases recently have come only via increases in crop prices. Each fndian farmer must plan to place one or two of his children in wage labour ( Fisk 1970:42). • • matum. - . The Fijian farmer does not operate under this same ulti, If he is working matagali land,his children can count on the possi- bility of doing the same, should other options fail. Most matagali land is grossly under-utilized, and can stand considerable·p6pul?tion increase, . even if farming methods were to remain unchanged (Ward 1965:~o-A3). ,, Most urban Indians have the same lack of options for their children jr rural counterparts, compounded by the fact that unlike the cane , they cannot count on certain employment for~ of their offspring. all urban Indian children must find wag~ employment or go A similar situation obtains for urban nati,ve Fijians in terms of preference, but not in terms of necessity . . This means that a large number of the five to six thousand Indians who come 1nto adulthood annually must aim at the no more than three thousand new jobs which are created each year in the whole economy. ' Things are not ~ so drastic as they might ~eem from comparison of these two figures, for they do not include replacement of retiring ~~r~onnel_n_o_r-__increasir,_g__ underemployrnent 6n the farms, but they are serious enough, and are likely to get worse as the large pre-adult population matures. Shifts in prices,and incomes have also affected Indians more than -154- _ be . se they are more thoroughly involved in native Fijians, principalzy the cash economy. . The (u an-based) consumer price index has increased . . I ~ - 60% over 1968-74 and 40% from the beginning of 1974 to April, 1976 (Fiji 1976a:74). The t~~inciple items of the index, food (40% of expenditure) ' and housing (23%) hit Indians differentially, because they are by far and away more likely to be paying for housing and buying mos·t of their food rather than ~oducinglt. IITITiigration Determinants: the individual context. The foregoing figures give one considerable insight into why Fijian Indians might want to iITITiigrate or might at least look to non-traditional options, but it says very little about why certain people rather than others desi_re to leave Fiji nor why they have cho'sen to make the attempt. Fiji an iITITifgrants to Canada do not constitute a cross-section of the Fiji an Indian population, but rather are a group pre-selected first by the decision to irrnnigrate being made by certain type of people, and secondly by the mechanisms of the Canadian ilTllligration process itself. The . factors which are relevant to the fonner, to the choice of whether or not to irm1igrate must now be considered. Initial Resources ~ - In orde-r to ma-ke S-U-ci+ a ciloiGe, -000 -mY-S-t fh·s..t-AAGW--th-a-t- it is avail able, and this knowledge must be sufficiently concrete to motivate people to action. ~nowledge about Canadian iJ1111igration is far from universal in J; , -155- Fiji. News stories about Fiji ans ·-who have "made it appear with some fre11 quency, as do references to Canadian immigrants over the national radio station. But this sort of information is fairly ethereal. Almost without exception, ilTITligrants 'are in p~ession of more_ personal knowledge than thi!3 when they attempt to immigr~te, either th~ugh- communication with a relative in Can~da, through visiting Canada directly? or throug~ discussing immigration with a visiting immigrant in "Fiji or with his relatives. Only in the first years was anonymous information ~f very much consequence in initiating ilTllligration. Like previous Asian immigration to British Columbia, chain migration is the dominant theme, am:I its first link is an informational one. A prospective immigrant must also ·feel that the mechanical processes of applying /or immigrant status are not insurmountable, and guidance from pri or immigJ~nts, plus a familiarity with bureaucratic organization are valuable prior assets.~ Both of these assets concentrate in the urban areas. A final initial resource, and a crucial one, is adequate money to carry out the process, should the_..,..Canadian authorities assent. This is a complex co!"Miideration, but minimally, one must have the funds to complete the application process, pay for one s transportation to Canada, for one's 1 expenses prior to getting a job, and for the support of one s family in 1 - Fiji. -- -------·· . -- --------22" . . ------- --· ·--------------- This means something in the order of $1,000, minimum. _ Even this minimum can only be approached if one can count on lodging and other support by Canadian relatives during the initial stay before the i11111igration · of one's family. I11111igrating with one s family and without the support 1 -156- of relatives requires resources in the order of three to five thousand . dollar~. 23 Even the one thousand dollar figure would eliminate most pro- spective iITTTiigrants, for t~is is about half the gross yearly salary of a reasonably ski 11 ed worker. · The only option for those without sufficient savings are advances for plane fares by established Canadian_ relatives, which a re common and which further magnify the resource value- of Cana di an kin. Choice Considerations: younger illlTligrants I have likened immigration to a gamble where the stakes are the immigrant's position in Fiji, and where the payoff js uncertain because not all the cards are known. Many people either throw ·in their hand before the bidding has ended or choose not to gamble at all. ✓ What largely deter- mines if one wilJ play are an actor's own perceptions of the field of choice and his forecast for the future, having once made . the decision to i rllTii grate. For younger irrmigrants the gamble is often a small one, and the initia] phase, that of the iITITiigration of a male alone, is much like a magnified and slightly more complex version of the short-term labour migration which is so corrmon among this generation of Fijian Indians. If a younger male - - -···----·- . irrrnigrant is unmarried, hiS most pressTiig choice considerations ·:rnv-olve t4e- ~ree te which-ms temporary absence in Canada w9tf"tti atte~t his life __ _ I chances in Fiji, should he choose to return home. _For many young male inrnigrants the potential loss is slight, for a very high proportion have · -157- had a wor-k career comprised of a series of joVof short duration. This consideration is more ~erious for those involved in the civil service or in their own entrepreneurial activities, the former because of the high ' I demand for these jobs and the unlikelihood of regaini~g one once lost. Because Fijian .Indian entrepreneurship is typicalJy of small-scale, the poter-itial immigrant miJtit well ~ the business and this often makes· immigration impossible. Among younger intnigrants -0ne finds very few of either. For young married couples the liabilities are larger, but still not overwhelming. Again, tile preliminary i11111igration being carried out by a \_, single male cuts both tQe risks and the costs, and very often the younger couples are still resident with their in-laws in Fiji, which further reduces risks. Typically, these young families move from one context to another, from Fiji to Vancouver, by moving temporarily from one wing of tAe family to another. The main impetus for intnigration expressed by Y?unger imm_igrants involves the hope for a higl1er material standard of living, coupled with a measure of dissatisfaction with economic prospects in Fiji and the knowledge that the risks of making the attempt are not overwhelming. Most . have a fair idea of Canadian wage rates, a measure easily comparable with ~ those at home, and ~now that their friends in Canada_h9vesecured __(_l:>,Y_~_ Fijian standards) large houses, costly furnishings, and expensive cars. 1 They might likely have seen these things~directly in the many pictures which flow between Fiji and Vancouver. '\ They would also h.9$ some notion , -158- that success here was not necessarily dependent upon one's economic position in Fiji. Other things they would know less clearly. They would know that snows in Vancouver, but abstractly, without knowing its implications, notions about social services, about the nature of community, or for that . matter abou_t life in a large city would be very fuzzy. Over the past year or so there would be some concern over discrimination and racial violence in Canada, ~ this too would be.abs~ract. Even younger Fijian immigrants are extremely nostalgic about many . aspects of life in Fiji. Although it is difficult to say how much the . \ . ·/ loss of these things is actually considered before they are given up; intan~ gibles like the possible loss of a defined feeling of plaie and of a secure self identity must be factors in immigration choice. A minority"'but a goodly number of married women (especially older ones) do not want to leave Fiji for these very reasons -- because in Fiji they had built their life, and a large part of it was defined by dense relationships with both people and places. ---..___ \\ Choice\ Considerations: older irrunigrants I Fbr older immigrants· the risks are more substantial, and it seems that the kcision to leav -J ' is•therefo r-e---e-S-OA-S- ad-va-A-C-€4 fur ch more cl-oseiy-scrutintzed-,-------and--the- · - -----devel ope4-than those of-- their young~r counterparts. The risks for ill11ligrants with established families an9 occupations are formidable and sometimes generate problems long after immigration. -159, . \ ~ Most had ·reasonably well-paying and secure jobs by Fijian standards, but they were well-paying because of demand, and were jobs which were not likely to oe regained if given up. Of these, a number worked for them- ~ selves in some service capacity, such as in the building trades or in · ·transportation and related services, and they risked the loss of -whatever clientele they had through any absence. Having established families with children of school age powerfully affects the decision-making process. _IITIIligration creates a break w~th established school patterns, with one's Rlace in the co1T1I1unity and per. . -" haps with a significant place in one's family as well. . Moreover, it can not be a clean break, because concerns of proper:ty and kin will continue 24 after immigration. What reasons, then, do these people give for leaving? Standard of living rises again in prominence, but in a more sophisticated manner. Most of these people, I believe, saw themselves faced with the ·possibility of stable wages and positions in an economy of inflating prices. To support this, they note particularly the high costs of food, housing, schooling, health services, and property taxes. It is constantly stated that their primary motivation in illlTligrating was to further the life chances of their children, and I believe in fact intnigrants have sacrificed TT!lfch in terms- qf their- mm --cumfortto come to Canada. True, very few if any could boast of a higher material standard ' of living in Fiji, if measured by 11hat commodities one had the ·ability to . , ·r -160- buy. . - ------------ But in ma~_ other respects their standard of living must be judged to be inferior here. · They have sacrificed status, e·ase of the pace of life, the security of a supportive network of friends and relatives, favourite foods and favdurite spots. The lack of ability to advance one's children was seen in both an immediate and a long range sense. Immediately, the complaint was that the cost of schooling of their offspring was becoming a significant and worrisome.expense. B-y all indications the expense is considerable for most . Fijians, and it seems to account for most school wastage. Schooling in Fiji is not free 11 11 , in the sense that it is paid for exclusively out of general governmental revenues. Rather, parents pay school fees at rates dependent upon the number of c\ndren tbey have in school as well as the nature and level of the school. The Fijian educational system still shows its.origins, and is organized much like a set of private schools with an over-system of governmental control and assistance. Fees for 'r-- primary school now run about $50 a term, while secondary school costs ...,. .,.£_,< - ' can run as high as $120 per student per term, in addition to. the expense of supplies. ~ - Other social services of concern to an established family in Fiji, such as health care, also are paid for on the basis of use, assisted by governmental subsidies; the,v, too, ar_e__ ~! _l_i_niited access be_- ____ ~ _______ _ cause of cost. - - - -· - - - - - - In the long tenn, many of the adults in these established families express deep concern over the future of people like themselves in Fiji; in this regard, they consider their possibilities more theoretically 'than -I -161- their younger counterparts, and go beyond assertions that "things are bad" to causal sequences for why they believe that things are this way. A coITVTion complaint was of the lack of potential means of personal advancement. Many saw their future in Fiji as at best one of retrenchment and a slow deterioration of previously made gains. For their children, they saw increasing job competition, especially with native Fijians, who were rather consistently seen as usinQ their governmental power to open up jobs \ at the expense of Indians. Concern for the makeup_of the national govern- ment is also great. The decision to immigrate, rather than· being tha result of a strong wpull '( fro_m a materi a_l ly rich Canada (as Canadian folk themes so often suggest) is rather the result of a complex weighting of relative uncertainties. Potential ilTITligrants, save for those who have either visited Canada or lived extensively in an industrialized -country, factually know very little about conditions here, save for a series of stereotypic oppositional pairs with parallels in Fiji: · Canada Fiji _ low material standard of living high -. , high wages low prices high high education "free" expensive health care "free" expensive low mobility high -few traditional amenities normal ---------- --- -·weak, ·out grc>"Wfh9 ---- -normal community - - - ------ - Table *V1. fotk vtews -Cont r as t i 119 rijt-am:t nnractcr - -------------- Older irrmigrants know full well that there is more to a society' than· a few such indicators, and they also know~that they know very little abou:t -162- Canadian society, save for the p~allels which it mi-ght-have witJi urban .Fiji. They know, or at least believe, there is a good - likelihood that their standard of living will increase if they immigrate . They know also that there must be many unforeseen consequences which come with it, and this constitutes further uncertainty . So also does the fact that one plays for higher stakes when immigrating, with far fewer ideas as to the rules of the game than in the Fijian context. • The decision to begin the proces.s of(;mmi ~ration; something to which one cannot -have access, of necessity constitutes that actor's vote for where either the greater yield or least uncertainty lies. With many of these established Fijian Indians the vote is cast fo-r Canada. IITllligration Determinants: ti women Although the Canadian i1T111igration regulations are not overtly sexbiased, both the regulations' emph~ses upon skills and past Fijian Indian ideas about the place of women have combined to' limit the amount of inde. pendent deci si on-making_ Fiji an Indian women can carry out with regard to ilTllligration. ,-f 1 • • Women from Fiji could legally apply on their own volition to come to Canada as independent ilTITligrants, but their relative lack of , skills and the unusual independence this act implies limit the possibil- . Very few womeR come- as independent iffll1i-gran~--t~---s-ense--of-maHng---------- j - i ty. -the decision to do sn and carq1ili9- out the procebde-pe--Rdently . Of . ~ ·-~ those women who come under the technical category of independent immigrants·, most come as adult family members who could not gain entraace under !.:;,~ l~ i ~ ~ !'l I\l \cl --i 4al, -di J -163-------- • - - - - ~ ~ - - - - - - - - - \__. the nominated category. Most women who iT1111igrate do so in the context of family, either being sponsored by their husbands (a relatively automatic process) or being ~ nominated b,Y relatives, and even "in the latter case the ~~sion is. only in part independeflt. An unmarried s+ster might have been part of.-he-r- --~-- ----~----- married sister's or brother's household in Fiji, and he_r nomination subsequent to the irrmigration of the rest of the household, though categorized as a separate action, is in fact simply the formal expression of the collective process of family irrmigration. Similar fami'ly factors enter when women come to Canada to marry, as most such marriages are arranged. The Ultimate Constraint: 25 Canadian irrmigration regulations So far, I have reviewed in a descriptive manner the makeup of the c..✓- Fijian· Indian population in Canada, and have outlined how sociological factors and individual circumstance have interacted to produce decisions to immigrate. The output of this decision process, if it could be so 11 11 ,Ci pictured, is a body of people who·would like to come to.Canada. These ' people are not identical _-with those who actually irrmigrate, for in the . ....' end Cana di an irrmi gration regulations select the l ~tter ~up out of the former. I must therefore deal with this selection procedure briefly, as it, more than any other single factor, detennines tne demographic nature of Fijian Canadian irrmigration. Since 1967, the Canadian immtgration system has been very highly oriented towards the fulfillment of Canada's manpower needs. The point '~ JI r -164- system which now rates applicants for landed irrmigration status is almost totally rationalized. Education, age, and English and F~ch language ability are given a numerical weighting; each of these factors is consid26 ered to contribute to the immigrant's adaptation to the Canadian economy. • Occupational skills are important and their valuation is well regularized. There are curren-tl-y three ways in which Fijian irrmigrants --eome-tO--- ---~-'-'~-----Canada. As an independent irrmigrant, one must normally have (in addition. ~ ~o the educational and age requisites)~ either a job with a high demand factor and an ,as;u~eJ job, or a very htgh job demand factor. Virtually -~ no Fijian irrfiligrants have pre-arranged employment, and independent immi- J grants enter. largely because they possess skills highly in demand at 27 that point in time. Lack of occupational demand severely limits the possibility of many Fijian Indians il11Tligrating for, unlike the decade after the l4ar, job demand is now largely restr~d to skilled and semi./ 28 skilled workers, of which there are proportionally few in Fiji. Nominated i111T1igrants are given points for the support of their Canadian relatives in lieu of high occupational demand, but skills are still a factor. Most Fijian irrmigrants are nominated by relatives, and this mechanism, because it selects relatives preferentially out of the total class of applicants, increases the coherency of the il11Tligrant flow and the resultant co111T1unity. The weighting of ,-occupational demand for both nominated and sponsored irrmigrants is clearly responsible for the class distribution of current Fijian ilTllligrants, as the il11Tligration requirements for education and lit' . ·, ... _;.:.( . I - eracy skew this dist~ibution a~al~ from the Fijian averages. tions _of Sf3 :,so,red irrmi~ran.ts (wh~ are direct depe The applica- ents of ari independent 1 or nominated relative) are grant~d more ,or 1-es·s automatically, and do not . . materially affect the general demographic dist ibution of the immigrant population. - I ~, The Processes & Motivatio.ps Behind East· Indian lllTlligration; Past & Present) 0 ! There ex i s t s tri~-i ngpa ra 11 e1s ~et~een the Jctua 1 process_ of F j i an__ __ __ > ~ ( ~ _~ , IJ, Indian illlTli_grati on arid that of PunJbi Sikh~, past and present. The par.,. . alleli reflect the degree to which these groups of people enter a similar . .I ' •• . · set of externa r cons tra-i nts, have ana 1ogous motivations and possess ~i. , co1T1TIOn backgrounds and values. The first East Indian irrmi grant~C_anada were sojourners; at fir.st,~. 0 fehd any intention of r.emaining -ft- this country·. · It ha~ ·- been -no~ed( - · · · ·- that they were relativ~ly well off, but not so well off that temporary ' . . i11111igration lost its attdctive~ I"':igra~ts ~ witb goals which . ·.were limited, in a situation -of relatively low rjsk. Save for the very 0 first pioneers, each irrmigrant had a support group on either end of his journey -- his family at home and fellow irrmigrants in British Columbia. Only upon ~ -blishment here was there action ·taken to make the funda- (__ mental c ~ ~ n t of sending for one's .f amily. --- -- ,-- -- ---·--- - ---------·- - --·-- Ji 29 - -- - -- - Because of their 1 imited objectives, the early ~ Indian irrmigrants m~~imi .zed expend,iture ·here and made new social . context. tew ·attempts to a·~ -Qate into their This left them open tp the charge of lack of -coninit- • J .. --- - - . - r __ _ -166- ment, and rationalized racist structures of belief, particularly in rega~ to the• presumed intrinsic unassimilatability of Asians. . The same goal limitation made East Indians relatively manipulatible in the workforce, although they were less so than other Asian irrmigrants. ... · Today,· the 'sojourner' i-s gone . Both for Fij-ian 'and S-ikh inmi-gr_.ants-- - -- - - ----- the closest parallel could be termed 'the tester', best represented by the.younger, unmarried, male irrmigrant. The similarities between these two are very great, especially in regard·to the degree of ~k and to the j structµre of irrmigration. It also comes out in y~unger i111r1igrants pos- sessing a lesser degree of affiliatio/with Canadian s·ociety than have -o 1der .:JlllTil . . gran t s. 30 Ci But the primary motivation for i111r1i,grati on is cons i deraBly different than that of the sojourner in one.important regard; few young Fijian irmiigrants view· coming ~o Canada· as a temporary thing. I believe that this would hold also for most younger Sikh i111r1igrants as well. This change in motivation 1ygely stems fr~ the 1ack of viability ,of the sojourner option in a lorld where once disparate economic systems are leveling, at least in terms of prices. Where. once a .sojourner could successfully gain from the enormous differen ·a1 in value between the --r-' C Canadian and home economies, much as does he ethnic middleman when he ----------------- manipulates the difference between vi 11 age and world economies (Barth 19'66;, 1967}-, this option is-severely limit, \ no longer possible to return to Fiji with in the case of Fiji. It is "stake" which is large enough f to make for a significant1y higher standard of living ·in Fiji, especially l ., J -167- ' when one measures it against the alternative possibilities here. Moreover, ~ _ it takes far longer for one to develop savings here which are .significant ~'home' levels than it did in 1908; incorporation into the modern Canadian _economic structure requires heavy initial expenditur.e, as w~ shall see. By the time an intnigrant has amassed a large net worth he is very likely to be 'trapped' by th'1canadian standard of living, an~y the credit system which allows ii _ The mature East Indian illlfligranirmiigration from F1J1 for the period prior to.1963, and yet several Fijians irrmigrated to Canada via India in the post~War years, and a handful of others seem to have been resident here before . 1960. . 11 11 I -172........... 9. The imnigration of people over 50 now constitutes about 8% of the total fl~wfrom Fiji (1974 & 1975 figures), as contrasted with about 9.5% f,or 1 countries (Scarce: Department of Manpower & Irrmigration Annual R arts 1974; 1975). · - . . 10. Southern Hindus may be slightly under-represented in Canada, but I cannot substantiate this. 11. The national modal age of ilTllligrants, which is also the mean, is about 25-26. The l-ower- mean for Fi jianS- reflects their higher -numbe.r-of dependent children. The national average of ilTllligrants under 15 or over 59 is about 29%. Sources for the following figures are Fiji (1976a:l) and the Department of Manpower & IITllligration Annual IITllligration Statistics (1973; 1974). 12. The categories used by the Department of Manpower & IITllligration were under continual flux during this time period, and these figures are therefore only approximate. (Source: Department of Manpower & IITllligrati on Annua 1 Irrmi grati on Sta ti sti cs, 1972-4). 13. The figures for percentage of the wor.king Indian population were arrived at by dividing by the number of Indians between 15 and 59 (151,487) years old in that year. The percentages are therefore likely to be low. (Source: Fiji 1973:63, 18). 14. To say that these ~men are illiterate is not to imply that in any way_ they a re i ncapab 1et uni nte 11 i gent, or i n~xperi enced. By North · American standards 1rather the opposite would be true. · 15. Some, on the other 'tBnd, have very little education at all. As ITK>re Fijians pass through the school system to completion these figures will necessarily rise in _coming years. 16. Ma~Y, irrmigrants are initially limited in their English speaking abiMty, but tend to have no inhibitions whatever in usirfg what little they have. · In proportion to their interaction with Canadians, they advance remarkably in a short time. ) 17. The theoretical literature on migration is very large, and it is beyond the scope of this thesis to discuss it directly. For a concise . sumncu-·:1 of recent theoi-eti.caJ - arguments -i.n~Ws~tield---se-e~J--C-m::--\rt..----(1-H-U----~Kapf erer (1970:179-197), with thorn I am largely in agreement. ~verth~le~s.,, even. though they argue that network considerations, which are obviously variable, ought to be primal in explanation they give no means whereby this sort of variability may be expressed. 18. The combination of Indian i deijs of family and the shifting pattern of life in Fiji has made for much flexibility in residence patterns and -173- for the recognition of relatives of very wide degree. Irrdian Fijians have deve 1oped their own i nterna 1 "welfare program", which includes. mechanisms for relatives bringing up children who are without support. 19. The Canadian immigration laws have been made with Western ideas of what constitutes a family firmly incorporated within them. Thus, a head of household could not sponsor a dependent non-related child without demonstrating formal adoption; a nephew who was raised as one's child may have to be nominated, ~ther than sponsored, which is a more difficult and less_ successful procedure. 20. Although the National Federation Party has prodded the government to reorganize the procedure for ele'ttion to the House of Representatites, there has been no significant response, and the 1977 election is likely to. be based on the same methods of election as tbatof 1972._ 21. Indian farmers have shifted from mixed farming to exclusive cane fanning due to the high price of cane. This has left a large vacuum. Foodstuffs for the tourist trade are also often imported. In 1974, Fiji spent $41,000,000 on imported food -- more than it did on fossil fuels. _,, 22. A conservative breakdown would be: • transportation family support (variable) expenses of application Canadi~n initial expenses (minimum) 23. transportation (2 adults, 3 children application expenses initial expenses in Canada before income matched e~penditure (2 months) $ 6 . ,o.oo (3 months) 50.00 00.00 $1 , 130. 00 $2,000.00 50.00 600.00 $2,650.00, 24 . . Itm1igrants tend to sell Fijicl'lfl property or leaseholds only at that point where they have decided irrevocably to stay in Canada. Land and property a re so dear in Fiji, and constitute such a symbo 1 of sacuri ty that _it is_ kept ~Yen_when__itis_'!Jro_ssJy~economical __to ___________ _ continue doing so. Family responsibilities do not end upon irrmigration, and_a._r~ a. c:onstant concern. 25. Fijian Indian '.arranged marriages allow considerable freedom of choice. Honnally, family matchmakers arrange for initial contacts between prospective mates only after the male has expressed aninterest in marriage. Afterwards both parties have the option of 1 11 -174---- - - ----- - - - - - - - - - - declining the match, although sometimes the consequences of declini~g, as it reflects negatively on both families, puts on considerable pressure for acceptance. 26. The point system distributes points in the following manner for independent immigrants: maximum points education and training personal assessment of interviewer occupational demand occupational skill age arranged employment language: English French relatives in Canada area demand Table XVII. 20 15 15 10 10 10 5 5 5 5 100 The Canadian Irrmigration Point System 27. Demand factors shift from month to month. In 1975, only 3 of 2,323 Fijia!!,-'immigrants had pre-arranged ernployment (Heath 1976). 28. About 22% of immigrants from Fiji in 1975 were independent immigrants, while 58% were nominated and 20% were sponsored (Heath 1976). 29. This increased risks in two·ways. There was a large number of people to support at Canadian costs, while at the same time removal of one's family signified a decreased probability of a successful return, should things go badly in Canada. 30. This idea is a hard one to argue substantively, as younger people of whatever background, tend to be less integrated into the normative structure of thin~s simply because of their age. They have not yet been tied down by family and by job responsibility. Nevertheless, younger ma_k.._Fijian irrrnigrants tend to see their inmediate situation much more lrr- tenns of material gain and much less in regard to things like place in the society than do older immigrants. - This pat~rn seems to be weakening with regard to the large increase in Indiatrprofessionals who now irrmigrate, llKlny of whom do so inde1 pendently. A la~ge percentage of these people choose to go to the ------------East than to Btitisn Coiurnt:Ha. 31. 3-Z. B-e-cause uf the- tact- -of an ear 1 i er tr ad it i 011 of i11111 i gr at i 011 to Canada and because of the skill-oriented requisites of the irrmigration regulations, most Fijian irrrnigrants come from urban contexts, and a great majority come from Viti Levu. Sikh irrmigration is still quite localized, - altROugh it seems that becaus-e of the s-kill factors of- theirrmigration selection apparatus more recent Punjabi irrm1grants are coming from the cities than previously. -175Chapter Four: Making a Living Incorporation - Both individually and collectively Fijian Indian ilTllligrants are continually faced with the problem of initiftl incorporation into Canadian society: New ilTllligrants have to find their,way, rearn the basic rudi- ments of a~cceptable behaviour here, find housing, and find a job. Es-tab'"' lished community members must repeatedJy deal with relatives and friends who are in this state. As has been mentioned, the rate.of incoming irrmi- - grants per year is currently a significant percentage of the total number of resident Fijians, and so almost without exception every Fijian Indian , in Canada participates in t~is process frequently. Many do so more or In the light of the current folk ind governmental less continuously. . ' ~ concern over the adjustment of ilTITiigrants to Ca,nadian ways, it_i? useful to outline briefly how Fijian Indians solve this problem in its initial phase, and moreover how they succe_ssfully employ traditional methods to deal with this new phenomenon. It must be definitively stat~ that Fijian Indians in British Columbia incorporate new members in a remarkably efficient ~nd smooth manner. They do so primarily because of a heavy dependence upon familial support; underlying this are ideas of what family and individual action-constitute which are considerably at variance with more individualistic North . American patterns. 1 This first phase of life in Canada is extremely important, because within it many decisions are made which will affect life for many subsequent years. For Fijians, it is a rather more crucial time than for, . . -r -176- say, an American iITITii.grant, because while Fijians are excellent candidates for life here, they ar'e by no means culturally identical. to Canadians: Particularly, they lack explicit inforntation both of- the ways in which. / things are done here, and lack the knowledge of the methods · which our · society provides fqr dis"rrerr·sing information about such things . .ATI fact;:- -= _-•'- ••:- •· most of our information services are highly (!epe·ndent upon having some - . prior insight i nt9 gaining access to th~m, and- these _routes to access ~L.. ___, --- must be learned by Fijians if they are not to be severely restricted in 2 their life chances. The Trip and Initial Placement _~Fijian irrmig,rants to Canada now almost all come directly from Fiji, and do so by air. The trip itself is the first symbolic indicator of sep- aration and of new beginnings, and it is tiring and brutal. Irrmigrants ' -~ have usually been subject to a near continual round of ~isiting prior to embarking, in addition to a long drive by car to Nandi ·rnternational Airport. Counting stops in Hawaii and in the continental United States, the plane trip itself takes almost a full day. For many it is their first plane trip and for most it is an anxious process, as they move from plane to plane without very much in the way of social support. There are often - - - - - - - ten to fifteen irrmigrants on the same plane, but there is less corrmunication between them than one might expect. The end point is Vancouver International Airport, where they must face the anonymity and confusion of Canadian customs and irrmigratfon checks. ------ - - - af DI C . I As an almost unbroken rul~, family members are waiting for the new fOari'ivals at the airport -- a good thing, considering that otherwise e n t ~ to Canada could be extremely hard; initial immigrant aid more'-or-less 3 ;tops_ at the cost. oms checkout. , Already the decision has. bee~~. de as to · - wh er(;he new i mm1 grant (or vi s i tor , as the s i tu_a ti ons _a re _pa ra~_-il ities, even in th~se' cases w~~ th~fr sta-Y is onl}' Je~porary. ~ - ~ , . __ _ is not very much time normally available to be devoted solely _to the new inmigrant, for Fijians work long and odd hours, :nd often al l ~ t hou~ > hold members are employed, while..,most children SPJ)'ld their days in scho~ ' ~. .__~ ( The _consEi.Auence is ~hat new arrivals have a rather casual introdu-ction - to Canadian ljfe, but it is one which has'at the centre of it the security of kin and housetp>ld. This introduction starts from the home, arid moves outward from the relatively well known to the less familiar .. Around the home, initial familiarization with Canadian ·material culture begins . • -They start their ideological ad~at)~~n th~ough adjusting to the ways. i_n /,W.h1ch hou;ehol2 memb ers act di.f.ferentl.y than th~y did _in F i j i ~ 1 6 learning•of the exitfoits of other inmigra hrough television. t ., _. Fijians are by no means experts in i ing these new arrivals to the ~rl d outside of_ th~ h_ome_.__ Somet·imes their emphases seem odd, an_d_ _ _ _ _ __ <;>cc~sionallX one__!',_e~sident_~ijian explainin~_'t~irys Canadi an1 to ~nother 0 constitutes a case of the blind leading the blind. process is on the whole remarkably effective. ,r Nevertheless, the Much of one's initial ) I . ,.. -179- -l'- -···--'-•--·--····- ··• -- - ·- -··---- -----··-- - - - --- -~~ - exp~~e 'outstde\,cbm~s through a heavy ?-~hed_ule of ~sitin_g and tele-phoning other Fijians whom one knew prior to ilTJJlig{ation. ·" ) ... The impending · arrival "of an-irrmigrant sets in mofion a "network alert , which might 11 quickly encompass several hundred people in the case of an older adult, followed upon his or her arrival with continual visiting . 0 • . . 'fhe _ speed- wit-A wh-ich th-is- -sor-t of extra-famili-al acquai-n-tanee- wi-th---- Can~da builds depends in large part on sex. Women are mor~ likely _to be bound to the- househo 1d by 1ack of transpor~ati on and -by a tendency for • - .- :::=----===..=::-.__ _ - _--. -women to go ·visiting primarily in the_ company-of others. :-:==---= ,L............ - - The weaker English facility of many women also makes them reluctant to venture out alone in the first few months. } In,nigration .results in many c~anges in the material and social situ: fat; on of those who d~so, and. these changes _must a1so, be taken into con~ _ ... ____.).. . ... • ·l'.l.' • ·1 . sideratt°n in this_ initial period, as statuses readjust oetween· the ilTl11i- - - . grant, his kin, and acquaintances. In this case, both ~edge and 0 ·es,tablishment ·arevefwer, a nd for a while at least the ilil11igrant must ,. accept a position of . relative subordinati-0n in many matters concerning . . - his 1i fe, if for no reci'son other than the 1ack 'o f a lterna·t i ve sources of information.~ Establishment gives considerable authority to one's new ways. Pe~ts, smoking, different foo"d and dress, different modes of address, unorthodox marriage practices and other things both big and sman · ----- are concrete social.. facts in ' Canada, and 'are quickly _ accepted· by mo~t in. . . coming a rri va 1s. . Tho·se who·se Fiji an ·s ta tu·ses i n~_e rf ere with- a ·mi ni11J,.a·1 ·· ~ '(~uiescence to these new practices face possible ost.racjsm. . \_ . -1 ; . .i - u ,· ---180-·• - ----------~--------~~-~---- ~ One of the most important thir1gs which must be accompli"shed in short . order is finding a job, .especially for men. Working is both acceptable. ·and desired of women here, at least in ti!lle, but for new immigrants the employment of males takes precedence; Surprfsingl-y, the he~p of relatives is fa'irly;abs____tract. :t For reasons which.will be put forward shortly,.few. --- •-~------ , --- ---- - ~ - ------- ,• ' . •-- --- - • . ----- ,_ . - - - •• -~ - - -·· '.,.. ·~~--·-_;-····•-•-•·--;-•-·---- ~ ~--'- Ff ji an immigrants are in a p·osition to either employ other F{ji_ans_ or to·, directly secure employment for them. In. suggesting·possibilities for ~loyment, the help ro-rthcomtng from re-l-ativ-es--i-s v-ar'ia-b-le. • E~µec tedc=:= 0 ' .fl wage · scale's, example! of desired types of"'occupations and opinions as to 11 · - • the sort ot ~ork i nvo 1ved in a_ given occupati on;are f~rthcomi ng, as may be a few hints as to.where one might look. •F;jian social networis are very sensitive to job for new immigrants in this fashion. Fijians also~ cultivate emp.ldyers to the long term end of placing more family members in the lattl:!r's employ. Both informational and social links are\jt the basis of most job searches in Fiji, and here they feel more comforta~le following similar . •, patterns. I V But u1timately most first jobs are achieved through the Man- . power office and throt1gh, individual initiative .. Most inmigrant male~ . currently find work within about a month of arrival, although for the . particular, the shy~ and the despondent it may take several months.· • - ,, ::II .. • ' Thrnughout the- Ume -0f -job-se-ar:-ehi-ng -the-----i-nmi-9-ra-nt---.-r--e-~s----on-the-seG-lfF-i-t-y~·- - - - 1, of -tLis Canadian relati'les_' support. · I The length of time during which an inmigrant will stay with his or · her relatives depends ulti,mately on personal considerations,> but for male ... . . irrin~1g?aott witll·famnies it rarely extend~ :~eyo,nd a few months _ except -in . - . . . '. ~ . . . - . - . . ,,~ -: - . - . . - -- those circumstances ·wher:e space caiJ_be rented from one's relativE!s or " . ; . . . . . where the d:cision has been made to cfo~ a limi _t-ed Join#'house~lder people and unmarried women are . nonnally incorporated into the · household ·· , · · m6fe-·or=-l ~} ~_je~~~~ri-~~)' .______~·o~ - ~~! : _~r~l _f a_rrii] _ie:s~?_0f~~--d_e~i-~io_n__!,~);eems :t_Q_ _~lrno_sJ "~-lways . . The .. have precedenceqv~r tbet_r status, l'nd·.~xttinsic job factors-, particularly money, will in the end . . . . usually triumph over intrinsic ones. This near total ' economic rationalitatfon of F~n orientations to- wards work can be seen in numerous examples of both first job choice and of the reasons for changing jobs . . Th~ likelihood that _one.' sJi rst Canadi a·n 0 1 job is exactly in one- s prior line - ~ 'J, • ~ of w~k-- isvery low, I _woui·d think- no{ . • • i • - eve11 twenty percent. •· The reason for ,this 1 i es w~ th problems of certi fi_, '. ' • • I I... • c'ation, qu~lific,atoions and job avail-ability, in addition ,t o the need for : irrmediate income . . As. a resu.l,t . there exlsts ·a strjking unifQrn11ty among :': . ·. . . . .: . - . . .. . . ' ·I' . ~ . ,first Fijian jobs . . E"or many, •first jobs are ·i_n unskilled blue collar _· work in a;e:s of low pa_i,, 9ctct ·hour~ -and IJ;g_h tur~over .. Most o; th~al'e :: in hght secondary industries. I~itial pay i~.m-o st frequently $3 ..?0 to c < , $4.'50, with the- low~r f _igure _predominating. \it!!,le there is __some _pAfal~ ___ __ _ _ _ _ leling of. 'fJrst Cal]adian jobs and prior Fij"ian ones~ the/rule fn these . · - --- ~- . --· .. --....Loll --·· ·-- - .. · - ···. cases is that status and expressed skills will decrease while pay increases. A- mechanic .may become a gas· st_a tion attendant, a tailor a clothing worker, -183- or a carpenter -a.hardware store employee. _ j -_. Nonnally these jobs are highly routinized, which the immigrant soon°: ~ feefs. . .. But that routinization offers . a measure o·f protec'tion .and. breath-/ . . . .. . . . ··" ·- . hig s:pace whfch allo~s one to settle in. · Because··of the typically low ., •· · : wages, _there _Js _a ':gd6d li k~l t!!9()~_:th~J: m_crny {?_om_etim~s :.aJll,JtLone.:'. .s____ ~_:____ -- - ,________ _:_ workmat~s are also i111T1igrants, who often hel'p one in gaining a sense. ot _ '.. · a iong whil.e work will . constitute one of the most significant things :·, Fpr -~ ,, . . - . sources· of ideas aobut C«friaaa : that the -·new 111111li grant~has-. ~ ~ ✓ 0 .. - Certification, Qualifications and Informational A~cess: "Wtlat' _s your Canadian experience?" C • ·Even in the longer term, Fijian Indian inunigrants <:face almost insur- . ~ . . mountable _obstacJ es to re_tt1mi ng to work in their prior . occupati'Ons. ·, ·So ..t. . ·{ar, ·most have not achieve9 . this end/ and many have either never maqe ·the attempt or no longer try. It is clear that tnis situation ·has both· policy and ethica1 impl)cations, the form~r: because the overt charter of . -~ Canadian ilf!Tii~r:~tion policy_' presumes to matoh inmigrant .flow to , highly . . ·. 0- . • C spe,cific job demand, ,a.nd _the 1at'ter because on the face .of thing~ , thi's might· seem to constitute denial of access ·of op:p ortunity ·~o members -of q>n . 0 ethni½group. The causes of this .under-uti-1ization of ski ll-s-- a~-ver-y-ce,m»ex-;- and ~~---_:._ ____ · ~-~ comprise a set Q[ statts..tic_a.l barriers to accesc;~ · Some ·of t h e ~- ~- - _, rial, in the sense of being outside of the control of .the 111111igrant, while ./ others. are dependent in large part o~ his or her own unique p~rsonal ~ o a \ ✓ -184.i: ·-· 9ual ities. The prime extern~l constrai-nt ·~>one which ~t.e nds· to affect Fijjan ' jo6 seekers whatever their .backg-round: is th.at of the demand· for Canadian 0 ' 41· experience . . · Fijfons a\e ~e,t'wittt' thts . question all al,ong the· occupati:o nal ·. s:pectrum from professional _s to ·baby~sitters. Iriiti~lly theypossess · none . ' 1 . . .··.. . ' . .of this valuable substance, and beca1.fae_:·of this cla.ck are not li.kely to~: '. __,______,_ ·-- -- ... . · ··· ' -•--·• - - -~ '-·· . ·-···-·- . . ·- --- . - ~·· - easily get any of it;,pciradoxicaJly, in many cases jt is necessary t. But.for many, espec ially th_o.~ewho_se . e_qu;iv~lent job 1 ·;ncanooa ·is unionizeq, .fiJJ.an •certifica1>i~ do~s n6t -'•a·pp-l y. ·. The. 'conse- ·· . •. ~. ·. • • ~- • • • • • I • • • • • • • .' • . · · ,eiu.ehce is that twenty yea rs· of experience as·· a woadwork~r, inc 1udi ng a· fu\f ap:pre11ti ceship ,- by· no_' means :guarantee~ one access to-~the appropriat~ -··-- .--:-·-----. .. .. . .... · ..'. .. ___ ,. ___ ---· •·- .·.· ·· · ~~- ------ ···---:-·- ~~-- :--·:·-----~~----~-·- '· _, union, let alone a job. . . . This same problem hits'whit,e co·l lar worker·s and "\ professio·nals, althou_gh the latter fi .e lds do ~ave explicit means to de-. -"termine qtJalif-ie:a-t-t-oos and to strggest specific addfttotrar· t rafning if it i.s necessary; . ~e pro.b 1em of gaining ,access to certified jobs is one which has faced irrmi grants from a 11 source countries for almost a hundred .years. But the increasing rationalization of job criteria, increas_ing unionization, . and the higher levels of immigr~nt skills in the gost-War years have in- -' , , __. -.;Ml_ ., . .:-r.- ·. creased the number of pe9ple affected ~Y it. ::i . • • -. ~ • Up until five years ago, • . .;· 't. "I. many irrmigrants (Fijians included) who faced , this situation were able·~ to . . - ~ find wor.k in less skilled positions wh·ich are normally· ones which leed to . :·. :~ .. t ' ' certjfied jobs; unable to be qualified as a unio~ ~arpenter, an i~i- · 0 grant may have accepted the position of a unionizld carpenter's assistant. Or he might have switched to a telated building trade where certification .f and competition for jobs were weaker (Anderson 1974:73). Because of the·- nea-r--stagnant- state of the- pres-en~Brnts-h · Col□mtr;-a-n- - ~------- --:-- ... -:: econ.omy,. Fiji-an in:migrants of 1974 1977 a-fl rarely exercise this option. With a provincial unemployment rate of 9%, _e ~ s e lower status jobs . · are in high demand. The result ha$ been that irrmigrants foufld such work r r _ -187-_ -•-- ___ - __ ___)._ ____ ·_____ _ 1- ~-\J . . . ' ,~ in 1970 whtle current immigrants with 1dentic:al qualifications are being forc~d to look elsewhere. ... Fijians wllo are faced with these problems of qualifkatiol}s and certi- fi catfon are therefore often temporarily shut out of their line of work alto~·ether, and consequ,ent]y cannot exercjse the option_of "working their., . .. way_ :up-- to- the,r pre-vious level~- a-n-dye·t would li\e--fi,-wo-rk· ·,n the --b-ccu~p-a:. -~~ -- ---~- tion they know. _Their options at this point ifepend largely upon their acces'S tQ information_,_ ·and often this cl£C:essi s. e)(c:eedi ngly limited.' A.~ter~ making the rounds of ~spective employers, visitingithe appropriate union ahd regul~tive offices, the job seeker often is at a loss-as to· what' should be his or her next move. It is likely that he or she has oeeh given a set of fairly abstract suggestions ab~ut_ further training or edu~· cation. Few fake these suggestions seriously, and yet a smaller number findthe .me·ans to act upon them. Sometimes thi~, too, can be a bit ludicrous. A case in point is the photogtapher who, after twenty years of experience in his own business, now is using his pr~cious non-working time to take basic photograph~c courses at the British Columbia Institute of Technology. But more likely, the skilled worker lacks the means to obtain concret~ and feliable infor~ation on how he should proceed at this point, and ceases to persist in his endeavour. Lack of concrete information on this and other vital issues is often a principle\teterminant of FijiaD behaviour and choice in ---- Canada. ----- -- ~ ------ It is compounded by Fijian reluctance to aggressively search out such information or to demand one's r1ghts. Fijians are used to being 0 . I / l / .! ~ntroduced to jobs through th~ir social_contacts and often feel alone and · ./ ihre~tenea when facing · fmpersonal societal institution~. Social Constr~ints -One other factor. contributes to Fijians not returning. .to their former ·- job. · ·-- ,. ___ _- ~·-- ·-··· ---.•··· ' ·. . : ,-. achieve in Canada through manual labour, and has two a~pects. -~ . .. ·,. _.. ' ... .'. The first · -~ - . . . . - is o-ne of the necess Hy - e-f-work i-ng ;. - A.$ -the- irmii-grant--f-am-'i+y-- §frci-cnSc a&ee-S-s""' . . c =~ to ca·nadian material standards of living they also beconie locked into the t . ~ necessity of wo'rkiri.g to pay tor it. - . ~onseql,lently,_ any at\empt at re"'" . _, .. . . . . - . establishment in o~e•s prior occupafiori which seriously interferes with 'irrrnediate income is not likely to be. followed. This tricome consideration - precludes extended periods of additional training or educatio~ unless they can be managed withih_a full-time work schedule. SecondJy, these unskilled and semi-skilled jobs can support a Fijian family in Canada at material leyels wsich are far above those possible in Fiji. ,_.· . . This concerns the standard of life which Fijian.Indians typically ._- . ~ - - ·- At the same time, hopes for .one's children and toncerns about • social services are more-orfless automatical-ly fulfilled, at least in the short term. There is therefore less moti v.ati on to persist in return-ing - Discrimination and Jobs One possiblE: explanation for Fijian Indian lack. of acc;ess to sk_illed ,· , .,. . - -· ..--- -.:: - -- - - --- - - • ---· ....-- ------ . ··- -189:.. - . be racial dfstrimination, pure and simpie. jobs . . While job discrimi- nation 1~ best discussed in the context of ethnic relations (Chapter . . . Eight); it is approp~iat,e that it be· dea1t with here insofar as it is restricted'to the search for jobs. For- this-di-sc-uss4-on- H -- i-s---use-fu+- to make a ·dis-tinct+on between- ---- · -- --- -- - - -"-------· ethnocentric,' structural discrimination and rad ally:--based di scrimi r:,ati on: .·.. • • - . - . . - . j . . • - . • • -~- Eth~ocentric, structural discrimi~~tion ~xists when an indivi~ual or . group, is .d.enfed .-acresi ,to eesJ r-ed th-in.gs becaure - their,-rewur-t-esare incoITDTiensurate with the structure ·whic.h ; det~rmines that acces~.'.... . 0 Raciaily-based discriminat~s when an individual or group · is denied access to desired things, even though their resources are corrmensurate with the structure which determines that acces~. • on the ba~is of presumed group characteristics. ··· . . . ~ The second of these is synonymous with the term discrimination as it is usually employed, and the first is the result of reflection· on Rex's (1970:116-·23) point ·that the tenn-discrimination itself is often arialyti .:. · .cany meaningless because it is not often divorced from the question · of class-based selection and skills. Under t~ese definitions, Fijian Indians are ,most definitely the victims of ethnoc.entric qj,s"crimination in their ' ✓ job search, for they often possess the abi 1 ity to do the jobs. \ Yet it is J c011111on that the incorm,ensu,rate natureqJ their qualifications and the ... ethnocentric expectations of · them held by employ~_rs and certifiers denies them work. ·· · · -· ---· --·-------- ·--···-·--·-=> # -· __· -~ ·__: But it is something altogether different to ask whether these same -. individuals are being ·subjected to racially-based discrimination.· That this .~ s exist, I have no doubt. .• • Nevertheless, the· fact that racial :l,. · · discriminatton ~an be ~oncealed· under the prote~tion of the wide latitude ~ - - ', . . . --- - ... · - -- -- - - · ,·- - ------·- --- - · - '\., o! job qualifications makes the factor diffict/ltto 'sor~: Few .·F:jj_ian males seem to complain of this sort of distrimin~tion, .but hew inmigrant · vi cti.ms of di scr1mination are often th.e 1east 1i-kely to percei V:e_.i-t ·s. · -~· . ~~\ :'~ , . .. . .. -. existence, especially if that existence is a subtle .. one. . . _.. II- ·. . -- ..· •· ,-~- . t ~--- ~---···"·-- - ·-• ·-- - - - - ~- - - ---··• ~- - ~-- . 0 ....... _. _ __ -. •. ~ : •. • , •• • . • . ·. . . .· . . 1n a Mont;eal study; Ch~ndra (1973) ha s shown- that ~ nder ,efJ!pi_ t :: . -1~~1~:._:.~--·~~:~~ -'·i· .. - ·-·· -· , - .. .......' : .,.:_·:.-:-- _• .l. ~·- - ~ . . I •.• . _. _ , _. : ·1 ; ) . ctrntrolled ',s_<;tua:dons middle cl~ss Ea~hdian job-seekers with 'identfcar -\.. . ,qualifications to w~ite pa'rtic:ipan.ts suffered considerable discrfminatjon, . incial Human "Ri.ghts Bra~ch has. received more complaints from East Indian jot, see:ers than. from . any oth_er ethnic categor'y, chi ch .is indicative of . ~ '· g concrete discrimination, but an overall weighting 1s hard to come by. - I do not, howev~r~ have any evidence - that overt, racially-oriented di~crimination ~ j o r faator in the job search, as compared with the other constraints which have already been put forward. ~ - Work and Th~ Family ,- The achievement of full-time ·~ e n t allows the initjal financing . . . . . . of the heayy expenses incurred by iimligratioh of one's famfly. In.addition ...,_. . :. . to travel expenses and to the ·costs of tying up loose ends in Fiji, the . . ..... \I . . . -. • - Q • • ,• first few months here are ones o'f high expenditure.· --.The high .co,;;t of ·~ ~ . . ee ·br-ati{jh.t~ffter, a-n-d--there-fore--a-t+ hq_usetiol d goud-s-;---new cl othi.;.ri~g- a=n=dal----atcth=e- ~'L' .- - ~ ~ 'S -- • • • • inevitable car mu~t a·l l be · procured here .. Rent and rental deposits also are significant early exf:}enses as the family switches from one economic . · •· \, - system __to the other. __, -- - - • - Although these things are often procured on credit, paying for them puts heavy_ and increasing pressu,e on household members to work~ lOS i tion it· is nece,ary_ to delve into it a bit me seen diligently looking for the first non-ho~sehold job of their lives. 0 Fijians collectively are restricted in their possibilities of obtaining skilled employ'ment, and these constrain~s press farmore ,;,;,,:.,, -..,.. heavily upon women than men.- Although many iITBTii gtant _Fi j i an women posses? saleable job skills, a large number nevertheless have little but industry - to offer to a prospective Canadian employer, and find getting.a job most difficult. It is -not uncommon that older women may take the better part. of a year to secure empl o_yment, and a few mature wom~n have chos~n_ to leave the Vancouver area for more promising places where they have_r~}a_-- ________ tives, notably in Alberta. Many try to break through the Canadian experi- ence. barrier threugh a variety_of part-time jobs, notably as secretaries, -203- receptionists, janitorial workers, or baby-sitters ..:- •-a process which offers limited success in achieving full-time employment. Although tangential to analysis of the situation of work · itself and · ... better covered in Chapter Six, the importance of the income of women to the Fijian Indian family in Canada has simtrltaneously increased their · importance in the family. Whereas (reality aside) daughters traditionally have been consid~ed to be less economically valuable than sons to the Fi'j i an household, in Canada there is a tendency for the opposite to be I' the case. Rather than beihg seen as a burden lifted, the marriage or a• daughter in Canada may well mea~ the loss of her income to her parent's household, even if she and her husband then reside matrilocally . . The economic importance of women has also been reflected in an elevation of their household and c-oiTOTJunity statuses. Job bistributions: the working class One must begin a discussion of the acfual distribution of Fijian / Indians in the Lower Mainland workfo-~-£._e~with a major qualification, that because this is such a young colllTiunity many or the things which hold . . prese~tly ar. e not likely t~ do so ten yejrs from now . In particular, Inda~ Fijians have not yet developed strong fthnit speciality occupations'' nor have they created any large-scale sources of self-employment. Few Fijians , currently work for other Fijians, primarily because of the limitations and .. - the current directions of Fijian entrepreneurial activity. - - - -- --- -· ---- --- ··-- -- - --- - ~ The number who · work for East Indians -of ot,ethnic backgrounds cannot be over a few °.::J ~ :;.f -204- hundred. Most work foir Canadians, and virtually all work either for an . hourly wage or for a fi-xed salary, with the exception of some _ w ho have - moonlighting Jobs based upon commission. Many mal~s are in~olved in blue collar work. More spe~ifically, they tend -to concentrate in U1e small-scale secondary industries -wh,ere : unions are either weak or absent; un1onization is not so much a factor . . . . . ·- -.. ·- . . here =as is _the correlation between low status, relatively unrewarding, · blue collar jobs, and the lack of unionizati0n. But at the same time, unioniza~on of skilled _b}ue collar work gererally) resul'ts in more for~ • malized entry criteria -- which . Fijians have more diffi~;n surmount~~ ~J,~~ • ing. I - .0 Unlike the Pttnjabi Sikhs, -who ·have historicg.lly tended to concentrate - in the wood industries, the range of occupations and of employers of \ - Fijians is quite large. While there i? a .go-ad J~kelihood that where there i-s one Fijian employee one wil ·l find another, there tire only a few places where Fijians .predominate in a total workforce of more . than twenty._ A poultry processi,ng p)ant east of Vancouver, a furniture factory i'n Richmond, a large retai\ store in downtown Vancouver, and the jani.torial staff at the Vancouver International Airport are exceptions to _the rule. These exceptions tend td exist due to parallel sequenc~s, beginning with a, rather chance pj)acement of a Fijian in that job. Thereafter, their steadiness · in what was a highly transient job, combined with the,;. ~ . "-'. practice of notifying friends, relatives, and out of . work Fiji 9 ns of posstble job openings, resulted in a growing number of Fijian workers. - - - Fijians ha.ve this capacity to ·take "over those occupational niches which .. I - 1 .. .· ·. . .- . . . . . ' are not directly · defended by other workers or are not highly desired, be"' '. cause they are reasonably stea.dy · ~o~k~ who do not tend to be absent, . ' --.iA · ' ·who will stayat the job longer than others (thus requiring proportionally less training time), who will not likely organize, and who can quickly ' supply new workers. Althou~ this process bas reached a developed stage 0 in only a, few pla ces, on a mu~fler-scale it is corrrnon, and determines many of the cas~ere more than one ·Fijian works for the same employer. ~ther their work h~b:i ts nor this ·. sort of i n~orm~ti ona] gatronage_ can o~come the constraints on a chi evi ng a sk'i 11 ed job; moreover, _part ' ' ' of the Fijian workforce is not particularly skilled. Consequeftly, ~ . tu,an workforce is largely consigned to relativel~skilleef work ancrio work with little managerial responsibility. ~ In blue collar work there is ' £,~dnkn1fi\tion i~ _light manufacturing~ away from the Sikli-dominated wood . 16 · . ind~stry. Metal fabrication, furniture and clothing manufacture, and foqd processing are significant employers, esll"cially ·where there are swing shifts. ~ There has been some success.~·the btrii~g trades, espec- ially at the lower ends of the scale_wh~e there is more job mobility, •• • and in heavy machinery. ~ In blue collar. service industries. Fijian~ are well represented irr automotive maintenance, equfpment repafr and service, janito.r ial work ( very important), food services (j n_<;Jy_c;ti og <:p_p_ki og__and __ s_a_le__o_t:__p.r.ep_ared foods), warehouse work,- and store ~elp. '\. . - . . Of th~~e_,janitorial _\'!or_l Fijian services; there seems to be something of a reluctance on the part ' of Fijians to trust automotive work to moonlighters. P' . - 18 The Fijian Entrepreneur - Even if an entrepreneur is defined in the widest possible terms, as I'.:. . . a person who has effective control over a commercial undertaking from ~ which he or she gains benefit, one finds that very few fijians in Canada fit the definition. But even so, experience elsewhere suggests that the nature of entrepreneurship in ethnic corrmuhities can have an important f effect on the direction a corrmunity will develop : · In partjcular, to the degree to which it provides a set of "parallel services" to those available in the latger' so~iety the entrepreneurial structure can be~sed as a rough measure of intergroup separation and, correspondingly, of · assimi - ~ . • ·1g ""\ lat,on. _ .. 0 -209- Two Kinds of Ent~epreneur In any situatfon ·of a 'minority ethnic group one can define two sorts of entrepreneurs, wha! could be tenned value differential dependent (tra- · ditional, community-oriented) and value equivalent (rationalized, societally-oriented) entrepreneurs. As irnpl ied by~_ the parenthetical adjectives, , these i·deal types involve two variables which normally tend to co-vary with the degree to· which entre~reneurial act;µt_ity is dependent upon an ethnic Glientele and the degre~ to wh·ich sucti behaviour js economically rationalized. As Barth (1958) argues, the presence of an ethnic'boundary often implies ~hat a valu~ differential exists across it; jn a few or in many dim~ ensions worldview and perhaps the calcufus which ma~es sense ~ut of it are different. Economkally, this can be expressed in a demand for ethnically-preferred goods and services not available in the larger society, as well as in different measures and standards for the procurement . . . and production of thes-e things. -~ Entrep·reneu~ia·l activity is p~ssible at ·any juncture between community and societal value systems which admits of ~ the possibility of gain, hence the category 'value differential dependent entrepreneurship'. Such activity may or may not be highly rationalized, depending on ·the actual situation, ,but usually Is not, at least relativL to societal norms. ' - The other entrepreneurial route is to become a generalist, providing goods' or services ·to the- society at large, simultaneously opening one's self up to whatever levels 'of competiton societally exist in that endea- -- -- - - ·- -·--·- - ' _, -210- vour. This variety dqes not make use of extant value differentials between the ethnic community and the larger society (save in the reverse sense that his or her ethnic background [values] may be an aid in competing in a soci- . etal context), and does not depend upon that community for his livelihood. Hence the term 'value equivalent.entrepreneurship'. Of these two, presence: of the (value divergent) former is one indicator of parallel institution 20 building a~d the latter, of assimilation. Entrepr'eneurial activity among Fijian Indians in Canada is rather weakly developed, especially in the light of the strong p~erence for it which is often expressed. There are both individ~ally- and socially-de- rived reasons for this lack of development. Personal Constraints: capital and knowledge It is more or less the rule that Fijian Canadian workers are limited in their possibiTi_ties for job .advancement by the necessity to have a relatively continuous income; ilTllledi ate needs usually take precedence over · long term goals. preneurs. This holds wan even greater extent for potential entre- Few are able to break completely away from wage labour and de- vote full time to entrepreneurship. Jo household life. To do so would be extremely disruptive Not only does this consideration cut down the number of potential entrepreneurs, it limits the effectiveness of those who make I' - - - --- -- - - - - - - --- - - - - . the attempt, for often effort is put into new entrepreneurial attempts only in proportion to their success, wnfch is TikeTy to oe~TnTtfally small. Most Fijian entre·p-reneurs are workers first; factory workers who sell real· --• -••--•---- - L---- - - • - - - • ~ • estate ~r paint your house, gu~rds who iell-trips to Fiji, and the like. For all but the very privileged, capital problems are the doom of many FiJia·n enterprise•& , particularly those which involve the~ formal . e s• ~-. tablishment 9f a place of liusiness. re~ults ·'.in -business~s starting off shakj ly anct;7-elative to the competition, often ineffi c0 i ently, for they lack both a reasona.ble volume ·and the means to develop it; here the factor of a lack~ or rather, 0¥ diffefent knowledge also enters·, for too often such endeavours show a 11 the s i g'ls of being created upon models of small-sc·ale entrepreneurship in Fiji. / Many of these bus- inesses are doomed from the start, for they are economically unviable here, especially in the light of business costs and the availability of alternative sources for the things and services which they sell. Know)edge constraints also operate to restrict the potential range of entrepreneurs-hip which mater~alizes. Because of the "nature of the Fijian society, Indian business has tended to be of lower and middle range, where it did not compete with larger incorporafed estab_li~hments. Many of these entrepreneurial niches disappear or severely diminish when one faces the Canadian context, for instance running a small rural bus · company, a dr;-y goods store, or a one-man garage. This, coupled with an extremely limiting set of social constraints, results in a minimal number of types of Fijian Canadian bustnesses, i_Q_ea_ch_of J-tQJ_f_b_J..ber~ __ iLeither fierce competition or an overpowering monopoly. I ~ . Societal and Community Constraints As a new Canadia.n immigrant group, · Fijian Indians have not deve.loped C . .-· • · ~ ~ an llethnit hegemony" (Hannerz 1974:48) in.any entreprimeurfa) activity, a ·• ' . situation which parallels work patterns. ' '. . .· . . 0 Unlike the · Uga:nda~n, Ismail is / . . · .· .. ·. 2l entrepreneurial acitivity itself is not an ethnic speciality, · ... - .' •"\.· 0 More; over, Fijians are not associated in Canada with expertise in any particular area, as are Japanese with gardening; ,in fact, most Canadians are oblivious to their existence as a dtstinct ·group, and do not regard them at all. On the whole, Fljian entrepreneurs must therefore do what they can with their own individual resources. At the same time, because of the high degree of Westernization of Fijian Indians there are very few significant ~ifferentials which exist between their needs and the available range and quality of "goods and services provided by non-Fiji,rn entrepreneurs which are open to exploitation by differential-dependent entrepreneurs. It goes almost without ·1 saying that the presen t day lack of formal restrictions upon Asians in . . ·. \; British Columbia·, which· had earlier tended to compartmentalize their buying while it did the same to their social and .economic access, also diminishes this variety of entrepreneurship .. As wi 11 ut ined in Chapter Five, with respect to large purchases Fijians the direction of least cost, within their own limita----- - - -- . ·- - ----- -- - --- ·· - ·· re the lowest cost lies. ·---- ··--·- - · . Because of this, _t"he dif- ferential-dependerit Fijian entrepreneur is restricted to pr oviding a service not directly paralleled by his non-Fijian competitors. Because - -~------- ·-273- of high overhead costs (.part-time entrepreneurs·~xcepted), he cannot normally provide a service cheaper than his Canadia,:J competition, and .be:.. l cause of an over~all 1g,ek of centdpetaJ"•:forces·::·p:uslfi ng F.i Jia~s in °Llporic "'. ./ :_,,/' - ~ C one another,. he ,snot likely totl:ieableto sell the samefh)ngs at very much high~r prices, except by manipulating his customers' ignorance. Considerl.ng the wide variety of things offered for, sale in the Canadian market place, the above generalization would seem to give almost no opportuniky for differential-dependent entrepreneurship among . ' Fijian Indians. bleak. But while the options are indeed few, they are not this One must take into consideration that such a fellow must provide 'different' goods and services rather widely. If, for instance, I am the only seller of coconut graters or of Fijian Kava in all of British Columbia, I have a differential to manipulate, clearly. ute differenc~s can offer equalntential. But less absol: For· instance,, there are 0 . ~ hundreds of people in the Lower Miinland, many of them integrated into large corporations, who mak~ a living selling houses to the rest of the popul.7ion Presumably a very large proportion of them, because of their e erience and resources, can in fact offer services which are ma" terially better than those offered by any of the score of Fijian real estate salesmen. Nevertheless, many of these same Fijian businessmen do quite nicely selling houses to other Fijians. Part of their success is dependent upon the use of kin and ethnic network tiet, but at the same time they know the needs, the problems, and the resources of the Fijian family, and therefore can do a reasonably efficient job of matching house, -214~ · -~= people, and financing. ✓ , In a mor~ subjective,'l,;'ght,,hi\).t,~e prqy.'ide_s a • ,. , ' • / • , ' ·.r,,. %- ·-: < . • -~- . e,_ measure:.of psychologi~a 1· '\ satety'• .,Q· especially :i,n. the .·j n~i ti a·l ti~~t when • '. - /. . .• ' "< ' ,; • J-' . . '/ • c~- ' • ""- ' i _, • . . . • , ' • ' ' • . •', . ' . ' the~ Fijian confronts the compl Teated business of buying_ a first Canadian -·: .,. . ~ . '• T .. ~-...~•c-- • h·ousa.., L . · This safety factor is not an overwhelming one among Fijians, for they are a people used to interacti_ng with a wide variety of people and situations~ It nevertheless does interject a measure of temperance into- wt,at might ·otherwise appear to be a pattern of strict economic rationali-· zation. For instance, the lone Fijian barber's success must be attributed 'I! - largely to non-economic factors, parti cul a·rly to his establishment's . function as a meeting place for other Fijians. If there were two Fiji.an barbers, or. if the one Was to raisi his prices above hi~ Canadian competition, it ~s probable that economic factors would become activated. Value differentials are not utilized only as devices wnich protect e. the ethnic entrepreneur's hold over his ethnic community-clientele. Cana- dian or other East Indian entrepreneurs can and do manipulate similar differentials in order to gain a Fijian clientele, thus·the need for such a - wordy term as value differential-dependent entrepreneurship. It also serves as a caution against suggesting that it is simply ethnocentrism which sends Fijians to Fijian entrepreneurs. The relatively small number of Fijians in the Lower Mainla.od also limits entrepreneurial development, for they constitute a v~r_y~ma_lJ _ c ientele unless they are purchasing large things (house. cars, airline ti kets) or small ings many times (food, haircuts). The relative lack ,. -215- . ''' of;a .J.i j tan ethnic-based opportunity structure internal to the community . 4s the result df both numbers and their brief residence:in Canada. ' Competition, obviously a function ·of all the factors just mentioned, is ,often very severe because of the diminudve size of· t~~ Fijian population, the specialty areas availaqle, and the competition with established Canadian businesses .. In order to bring this out we mu~t move to i more detailed descrip~ion of the ecology of Fijian entrepreneurJa1 , activity. {' Value Differential-Dependent Entrepreneurs The most significant differential-dependent, full~time Fijian businesses are in food, car services, housing, real estate and travel. Fijian dietary customs have not changed radically with immigration, save for the ,, loss of some items through- expense or lack of avanability ► and although • C · they are not identical with _Continental Indian foods\ Fidian Indian ones are very similar.· It is ~nly natural, especially in that small food and dry goods stores are an Indian specialty in Fiji, that several people have att~mpted to get into this business in the Lower Mainland. One of these, or more accurately, one of these families has .been eminently successful at this endeavour, and currently runs the largest Indian food store in the area. Not surprisingly, they are Gujaratis, following their ethnic tradition in yet another context. Because this store is an established fact, its very existence decreases the possibility of someon~ els~ following the same sequence to . { \ -216- - near zero, even though attempts continue. Even a Fijfan Muslim st~re be·; gun in fairly respectable size, . located within the geographical c~htre of • . ✓~ i the Fiji an. "neighbourhood", and presumably with the abi 1ity to attrlft other than FijiaR Mus1ims recently failed after less tharr a year. Ma~y East tndians of other b~ckgroun~s patronize the successful store, cind so it does not provide an ideal type for a Fijian ethnic entrepreneurship, +,.:. but it does for 11 East Indians • 11 --~ -~ :- There are1 a considerable number of sma 11 er f>.unjabi -run, Punjabi-frequented· stcfres fri ·tne lower Mainland which also cut down the possfbilities for a 11ew Fijian entry into the food business. Th~ few other Fijian foo~ stores which are currently open limp on, but with the one exception seem to offer iittle h~pe of success. In this area, another entre,preneuriaL logical possibility exists, r that of the corner grocery stores, which are to be found scattered · throughout the lower Mainland, with partic;ular concentrations in-older areas. But in fact this niche is not available,·for it has long been the . . . domain of the Chinese, as noted in Chapter One. ·Although viability of these stores has decreased greatly with the rise of supennarket chains . ~~ (remember, they once could sel 1 things cheaper than their competi_:torsf:~ _---~ they persist, relying on famil1 labour ind the low overhe~which is the / / consequence of long establishment and little maintenance. Even though a number of Fijian Canadians have had experienc.e wjth_thJs sort _of star-.~ . -~-- ___ _ it is unlikely that many will attempt to open one hgr_e. Th_eQn~_which to my knowledge presently exists has opened across the street from a larger,· established, Chinese-run store. l They seem to do very little business. j -217- There are very few other types of dtffere11ti al ... dependent sto_res • which are run by Fijians~ . Most of the non-food ethnic specfality areas . have been flooded with Punjabi or Ugandan East Indian businessmen, especially the former, fpr the latter tend towa,rd ·value-equivaler.it endeavours. Clothing arid cloth, Indian curio and 'import' shops, stereo and. and further expansion tape stores and the like have been done to deq.th, ' . 22 . t hese areas wou l ·d be·econom,ca . 11 y su1c1 . :d a l . Th ey are essen t.1a1~ l y ,n closed niches . . AL!tomotive \cepair by Fijians, for other Fijians, is a well-estab1i shed practice. There are two sorts of repa i_rmen, those who work out of a garage and those who work at home, and the latter ar~ almost totally dependent upon Fijian customers, while the foY'{Der are so only in part. While this promises to become a very secure niche for some of ·those who can establish themselves in it, the niche-is definitely a bounded one for . three reasons. ·o First, _the number of incoming car m~intenance people (79 in 1975} far exceeds the reasonable needs of a corrrnunity of less than 7,000 and most have had to find work servicing the general population. Secondly, as with house repair and alterations,.Fijians w·ill tend to " select an automotive repairman on the basis of kin, all things bei.ng equal, and this limits the ability of these people to build up their· clientele. And finally,-in this area the value differential between - - - - Fijian and non-Fijian services is not great, and many Fijians will go to Canadian establishments for service, especially if they bought their _car through a dealership with a service department. Nevertheless, there are ' _--.218- - - several Lower Mainland service stations n'ow run by Fijians, who depend on both an assured Fijian clientele and a,stati,sticany probable Canadian one. Because housing ~nd the search for it are so important, and because the rapidiy jncreas i ng number of resident Fi Ji ans puts constant pres.sure ~ on this search, lt is not sur~rising that real estate is one of the more developed Fijiari entrepreneurial options. Most Fijians involved in the sale of real estate aie affiliated with a company, either as a partner - .- in a· small one or as an agent with one of the·large Canadian real~estate ~ales corporations. These latter institutions have for several years been very much aware of East Indian housing needs, advertise widely in East Indian periodicals, and are keen to employ competent East Indian sales p-eo!<)le. In the light of the prior discussion, it is understandable that Fijian agents are more often used to buying housing than to selling it; price is solely important in the sale, while buying involves a complex set of considerations involving family needs, ability to finance the fulfillment of that need, and the degree of knowledge the prospective buyer has of the overall sttuation. It is especially the family which is buying its first Canadian home which will tend to use a Fijian agent, par ti cul arly when it lacks. the help of a krmwl edg.eable _relatJye___Wi_tb ___the time to guide them through the process.___ ._ While at first sight it could be argued that the Fijian real estate agent constitutes an ideal type for the entrepreneur who preys on his own -219- ~ . community, upon closer inspection tbis assertjon would be hard to suppq,rt. To be sure, these people ·are about as unsc_rupulous as is normal in their no more, no less -- and there are many reports of d_isreputable trade ·a.d i vity on their part. But at the same time they have provided the means to the end of an ~ppropriate house for.many Fijians who w6uld not likely ... . . have found the means elsewhere. Such agerits know whit their cli~~~~l~ want, whilt th·ey wil1 put up with, and complementarily, what they do not They also know ~ow th~ Fijian family operates, and .have some idea want. of the ability of any one family to fund such a purchase. They know also · that this~ity to pay often exceeds the needs even when the rules which mortgage sellers use for judgi~g ability to pay show no chance df • success. They are brokers, cultural translators, and entrepreneurs, all ' · in one ·package, where success in the ,last is dependent upon .the former · two. Beyond these few nota~le areas, full-time differential~dependent entrepreneurship is for the most part restricted to what are often one/ person niches, as in the conspicuous case of the barber previously men. tioned. There are a considerable number of skilled .Part~time entrepre- . neurs bf this sort engaged in house repair . and the l.ike. • There are .also others wh.o gain fairly mar_ginal incomes from entrepreneurship; weddings and . other important social events.·provide a few such ·options, . as for those - ----~----- ---- ·-· - ----.- -·-- ----- --------.. . - .. - . - -- . - ---- ·-· - -- ·-- --· - who take wedding pictures or who provide the music at · th-e reception. ---- - -- - -- - ·--·· - - -- - ·- -- ---- - ~ --- - -- . . ·-- ·- ---- - - . - - - - - - . I V, -220-' Value-Equivalent.Entrepreneurship ,. ~ting out these- two ·categories empirically cannot be a_ clear-c~ : thing, for the possession of Fijian ethnicity itself is an expression Jf a value differential which will be utilized if nothing countervails;it; Fijians will tend to go to other Fijians, even when there is no evident - material gain to be had in doing-so. While ficient to offer very much protection tendency is not suftial-dependep: entre- pr~neurs" it does assure value-equiv_alent ones a s_mall measure of security. For insta!]ce, a Fijian travel agent is in no position to legally offer lower ~rices for Jtr fares than his competjtion. But at • j the same time, the fact that he can hope to bring in a portion of the ' Fijian business means that he is not alt_ogether at ~the mercy of his • . competition or the whims of-the general public . With the exception of the janitorial business, most value-equivafent Fijian entrepreneurs tend to be partially dependent upon a Fijian..,,c,. entele at least initially;· their intentions are to reach the largest,· ··1 possible market, rather than to obtain an overwhelming dominance over a small one. This seems to be a more viable option, and it is becoming the more coJIJ11on one. T~is option means, at least insofar as the entrepreneur interfaces with the public_~ that Cana_d_ian.._~o_rth Amer_tcan-We_st_ern_Eu.ropean ec_onomic___________ dictates must be_closely_followed, for success with a Canadian clientele 23 is dependent upon pl~ying the game ~ore-or-less by Canadian rules. Not only must his economic behaviour be highly rationalized, but it also must ·~ I ( -221- , .· address the question of selling_something to Canadians, and this ~equires considerable insight into Canadiah ways~ . In short, value-equ,valent entrepren~urship both depends upon and creates forces for assimilation. There is a near total lack of anything which coulq be called entrepreneurial activity in the. area of manufacturing,. This void is understandable, considerin~ that in Fiji mos\industrial businesses were run by Europeans and that Fijian immigrants lack sufficient capital to start anything of this sort here. Rather, most value-equivalent entrepreneurship is in the service industries, and is of small-scale. Family~run janitorial companies are . becoming corrmon, and there is a good likelihood that this trend will · continue to increase. The necessary experience is often gained through · employment by the larger janitorial companies. A Fijian family concern can e~sily offer a lower price for a given contract than the large, 0 / companies and still increase net family inc;ome over what it would be.__i-f ..:· the same job was done by the same people working as employees. In this occupation Fijians seem to have found themselves a n~. with much incorrmon to that o/theChinese laundry of earlier times; for .. -- : _ smaller jobs, · those manageable -by such a fainily company, they are l.ikely to prevail, while the large~-janitorial jobs, just like the early hotel laundry trade, will continue to go to the bigger Canadian companies. - - - - - --- ------- - - - short, their advantage is low overhead ~nd family labour, but it is a selective advantage, dependent upon scale. Fi j.i an~.,lTlake a heavy QgI_ capita use of trave 1 services, for both In .. immigration and visiting. Fijians are there, ready to provide such ser- vices: In this, they participate in another niche abounding with both p , other East Indian ·and other Canadian competitors. To the best of my know- ledge virtually all Fijians involved i.n this business presen.tly are work~ng . for non-Fijian owners under commission arrangements. Considering that the ~ijian trade ~lone constitutes a multi~million dol.lar yearly busfnes~, there is like'iy to be increasing attempts by Fijians to capture this 24 trade. Beyond these areas value-equivalent entrepreneurship is s,r{rely ., limited. There are a few small independent businessmen, for exampl~, iri printing and upholstery, and·a few professionals, notably lawyers and architects: Two small construction and excavation companies have also been created. Fijians in the Economy: another subordinate.caste? With some knowledge of the means by which Fijians in Cana·da make a living, having outlined the social and individual constrai.nts which -have detennined those means, I must return to some of the questions posed at the beginning of this chapter. _In very broad terms this is: to what ex- tent do Fijians have equal economic access as other Canadians? The answer is complex, although it migh{ not~eem so at first glance. -- "Fij1an economic access is most certainly ncYt"the-same·as oftief"Tanadians. They have far fewer, far te-s-s rewardtrrg ecurromft~os-si1>"ilities· than would•a cross-section of the British Columbian. population. -~~c ,::..__ ;._•, .,-_-. ,_, ,--; ,..,,_. __ , :·.:;.;:.•;.,-""'..;..~:,,r'"'-~-;, ~ ~ :,.~r', =1-~~~ ' -~ ~ &:s'~..?.;t, _~*~-~ ~ 'l,' '-"=--:,.,..,,_...-.•·- -•• Access to skilled and entrepreneurial occupations is \?everely limited. at manual, unskilled joBs. make $3.50. Most work Few make much aBove $~.00 an hour, and many In the work situation they hold the lower positions, and are rarely managers. ~ work odd hours; they are commonly night people, working swing and graveyard shifts. They are, in short, collectively. disadvantaged with respect to Canadian Jabour. There are many·parallels to be made between the economic situation of Fijian immigrants and those Asian sojourners who came before them. Be- cause of the industrial and extractive nature of the British Columbian ¥. economy, anlalso because of its settler society origins, -race relations, : ~i-rr;sritistl' Colum~ia have never had a paternalistic (van den Berghe 1967: 1 0 -.~ lBt...phase, where subordinate Asiaris had a 'natural' or traditionallydefined pl.ace. They were in direct initial competition for economic resources, ~and the resultant form of subordi.nation created a near ideal type "Herrenvol k democracy" with access to opportunity ·in the dominant I group being determined by mer.it and class, and access in the subordinate group being constrained by race. Asian groups constituted racial castes, kept in this position by overt, formal restrictions. There are no such formal restrictions _now, and yet Wians are economically at the lower end of the British Columbia opportunity spectrum. The reasons for this are clear. What were once primarily racial determi- nants have become cl ass -detenni nants. For Fijians it is not acc:ess -it-;;.-- s.el f which ha.& reen limtM, mre rather the-means to- access~--"fheir re=----- strictions are statistical ones; because of the nature of the incongruence / _. • ••·•• •••• • • • • • - - -" -'~ ••• - • • • -•••- '""••• · •· ••• • •• CL ,;_,_,,, : : - . . -224- between Fijian backgrounds and Canadian demands they hold lower economfc life. chan~es individual 11 . . Because they share this problem among them. selves they are ~elatively disadvantaged collectively. Informational ., gaps, the lack of skill-translation mechanisms and the absence of suitable experience are all-class, a~not ethnic restrictions, even though they are ethnically~based. Unlike thoie forma•:'.Ji' restrictions which limited Asian economic access . in earlier British Columbia, the ways in which Fijians are similarly restricted in . access stem (racialism aside) from their liabilities of ' background and from being immigrants. . ' . . ' . - ~'- Unlike the:ir predecessors, their . i; children face few such~anct~ps, e~ce.p t insofar as the same processes affect them, and1this is likelj\1:9 be sl.ig~t. The -ideal state ·of equalitj ·of immigrant economic access, given the stratified nature of Cahadian society, would be that of achieving identical life chances as any other e d the same skills and background. Canadian who possess_ . . . · larg~ly holds. For FiJians this 25 Moreover, Fijians themselves are not on the whole dissatisfied with their lot, even though they realize the nature of their position in the . economy. . \, . Used to working in a Fijian society which was highly stratified by race, cla,ss, age, and kin, their ....ideas about equality and. access are fairly congruent with the real ity of the r•d - i an 5 tr:tHic:t i on _system ~ Economt c Subordination, Statistics, and Irrrnigrant F1ow If there exist no racial restrictions which divide British Columbians ----- .. -225- into racial castes as once was so classically done, and yet if Fijia~ns (and I believe most other Asian immigrant groups as well) are still economically in similar structural places as their immigrant predecessors, how can such a situation be maintained? As has been alluded, in the next ten years it i~ almost certain that personnel will be flowing out of the category "Fijian Indian-Canadian" iri great numbers. There ar-.e-.no raci.al _ and few social barriers to keep' them in, and powerful assimilative forces are pushing them out, the children in particular. Whereas the previous formal racial barriers created situations of racial endogamy and cultural separation, neither can be maintained in the face of today's statistical J barriers. Such a situation would soon result in the collapse of ethnic stratification except for one contravening variable -- continued immigration. Immigration provides new personnel for these subordinate positions, replacing those who flow out of them through achievement of a greater degree .~ , of economic access. The restriction of Fijian immigration will lead t4"- the continued reduction of economic liabilities among the resident popu, la ti on. 1 Job 2 Familt, Place .and Things ../' ,:j To this point, I have addressed the ways in which Fijian Canadians . ···--- -· - ---- - --- - - - - - · - --- -· ·-··-----~ -- - ------- earn a living in some detail , albeit abstracted from the everyday context of which it is a part. ··-------·- -- ~~- We must now turn to that context, to material expenditure, social organization, worldview and inter-ethnic relations. • . -226- / /' Because of the· newness of this corrmunity, because it is a settling, rather than a settled, corrmunity, these factors are currently in rapid ., flux, as they are likely to be for the fores~eable future. In the hope of presenting something more than·a transient, historically-particularview of this process, I shall continue to focus on those core problems and their tentative solutions which are likely to have more universal applicability, beginning with the material problems of settlement and their consequences. - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - -227-- · I Chapter Four:·· Notes l. British and American immigration is vastly more individualistic, and is typified by the immigrant family rarely relying on the resources of anyone external to the family itself at any stage of the pro~ess. This implies an enormous duplication of services, high cost, c1nd· 1nitial separation from the rest of Canadian society; two thousand Fijians coming to Canada means the community grows by two thousand, while two thousand British arriving simply implies that many more independent families have come, each left to its own resources. 2.~ - This same·problem obtains within an indigenous population. I currently have no need for weffare services, nor have I any prior experience with them. · But I know how to begin inquiries which would makefch s€rvices available if they were necessary', while many people i _ ore desperate circumstances might not. . . 3. In many such meetings, the only times I !eve not seen immigrants ·met by relatives are cases where something had gone wrong.with plans. . , 4.~ . There are indeed a few 'loners' and families for which rentar,accommodation has been previously arranged, but both are rare. · ( - 5. Parents will tend to stay with their children"and vice-versa, and adult siblings with each other. Nephews, nieces and younger 'cousins' will most likely move jn with their elder collateral kin. Young males may more~likely move in with other males. 6. There is no television service in Fiji, and consequently Fijians have not built up the same defenses against it as have we. Television's effects will be discussed further in Chapter Six. 7. Some ludicrous situations arise in this way. One older woman comes to mind ~ho had run a series of small retail stores in Fiji over twenty years. She could not find work of any sort here for almost a year. 8. Architecture, draughting, accountancy, and skille~ blue collar work requiring New Zealand training usually results in achievement of a New Zealand c~rtification. Fijian teaching experience is convertibli into Canadian terms. 9. Personal communication. In the course• of investigating complaints the Human Rights Branch collects case histories,'many of which show ~nambiguous discrimination-. · ··-· · - -- - . -- --- -- ---~-------- lfr. ' In twenty suctr families, selected tn sactr a way that ttre--c-entrat-- pair had been here for over four years (coming before 1972), there were 64 people working, 35 of which were women. Tpe higher female participation reflects the can<;:ellation of a lowe~robability that , -228., --------------- -- women can secure employment by the higher number of young, unm~rried working daughters in these households. 11. This study will be abbreviated in reference to (CWV 1975). It was a national opinion survey of approximately 2,000 Canadians representing close to a cross-section of Canadian society. It makes no.pttempt, however, to relate collected attitudes to work to behaviour on the job. . 12. 57% of men and 40% of women listed work as the most important m~ans towards achievement of life goals (CWV 1975:18). 13. In the same vein, 67% of·t~e sample responded in disagreement to the statement that "If I could earn $7 an hour, I would take any job.II (CWV 1975:23). 14. I have no intention of generalizing from the situation of Fijian Indians in this regard to all Asian Can~dians~ or for that matter to all Inda-Canadians. However, inasmuch as there are definite parall~ls between Fiji an Ina i an and other East Indian cultures and familial o~ganizations, there ought to be parallels in work orientation. 15. This observation is based upon secondary information, received from Department of Manpower and Immigration employees who have long been i~ed with the Interior lumber industry and from a number of . In~r residents. 16. In PJince George. there are a number of Fijian Indians worki~g · in the woo/indusfry, but in the Lower Mainland this is not a large emplo,yer. 17. I will be discussing the constraints upon the type of housing selected by Fijians in the next chapter. At this point it suffices to say that Fijian houses tend to be large, old, and in need of repair. 18. Because there are very few Fijian entrepreneurs, certain parts of this discussion have been left purposely ambiguous in order to preserve a measure of anonymity. · · · 19. This idea of parallel services is linked to van den Berghe's (1967: I 12-21) use of the concept arallel institutions' to denote dupli-. cation of institutions aero s an ethnic boundary. ., 20. I have no great desire to b caught up in a flood of analytical definitions, few of wnicli ever seem to be subsequentT,Y utilized in tfi-elr defined form. By assimila ion, though, I do ~ot mean to imply inte- · gratton, which can obvicrqsly occur even tn ttrn~e extreme cases of - ethnic or racial separation, as with the Chinese in Malaya or for that matter, with India~s and native people in Fiji~ See Schermerhorn (1970:23-41) on this point. -229-------+- - - ~ ./ 21. According to knowledgeable bankers in Vancouv~r. the Ugandans in ~ Canada are vitally returning to their entrepr_eneuri al pursuits, and are investing heavily in moderate-scale businesses which are beyond the resources of most Fijians. · 22. I know of one olock (not street) alo~e in Vancouver upon which~ are three sari stores and an , East Indian cloth store, not to mention two other East Indian stores::'selling hi-fi and television sets. The following inventory of advertisements taken from three East Indianoriented-publications (The Inda-Canadian, April, 1976; Diwali Souvenir, 1975; Telephone Directory of the East Indian Community, ·1976) is indicative of the strong concentration of entrepreneurial activity in a very few areas: 21 i"'" ·food & spice stores real estate & mortgage 17 12 i travel 11 ' television & hi-fi sales furniture, appliances & ~ hardware 9 9 cloth & clothtng 6 building & renovation photography 4 entertainment 4 gifts 3 ·3 automotive repair printing 2 'jewelery others ( frequency =· l·) Table XVIII. Di~tribution of East Indian Entrepreneurial _ • Adverfi sing. lf i,, 23. 1 l am not suggesting s imp~y~t in this case demand shapes supply. I mean, rather,' that when a F, j fan businessman interfaces with a rationalized economy he necessa · y must internalize its structure, including the subtleties of social interaction and values. 24. The dollar volume of Fijtan tr~vel brings up an interesting parenthetical point. In the earlier history of British Columbia the steamship companies made lucrative profits on the Asian irrmigrant trade, and therefore were loath to see it stopped. Today the airlines, . particularly CP Air, obtain similar beneftts- from Pacific i11111igra-tion-; Air fare costs for Fijians going to and from Canada last year must ttave beert ift ~ess 1rf ~c,-000,O00, and th~ Hji-art traffic i-s-oot-tri~ compared to that from Hong Kong and India. 25. There is one exception, but it is more apparent than rear.- One could argue (indeed, I have) that in many cases the restrictions on access ""' r t - -230- to opportuni ty ~among Fi j i~ns is dependent upon \.criteria which are irrelevant to"'tJ'lei,r ca pa.city to do the-work. But the same argument holds ~-~-vis other Canadians. Such extraneous criteria are often used 6y occupational groups to restrict access to ·their number, even if they do not necessarily realize that they are doing sb. Along such ·11nes, unions have long used limited apprenticeship systems to indirectly · restrict their membership. The three-year longitudinal study (Thr~e Years in Canada) ·of 1969's immigrants carriea out by the Department of Manpower and ImmJgration (1976d) showed that almost 50% of economical lf-actiye immigrants not only {elt it necessary to return t~o educational or skill training, but actually had done so. 0 . ; . Interest group·s also affect the fl•ow of immigrants into their o~;cupational areas. As a blatant example of professional groups controlling access via immigration policy, even though one must wait months for a dental appointment in the Lower Mainland (it ranges to a year in the Interior of .British Columbia) the current (September, 1976) demand factor for immigrant dentists is zero. A prospective independent immigrant with a zero demand factor is not admitted, even if he or she gatns the normally requisite number of points. For doctors it is also zero. -~ ll I ( 0 l_ -231- --~---------- Chapter Five: A House, a Car, a Chair; Expenditure and Models for It. Objectives Fijians work in order to earn money; this chapter is concerned with how they spend it. Within this theme there are several. objectives, one of which is the description of Fijian patterns of ·buying with particular reference to housing and those other large-scale purchases inv~lved in their establishment in Canada. With such a short history of iITllligration, the manner in which Fijians deal ~1th material factors is of paramount ~importance to an understanding of their assimilation, corrvnunity organi ', . zation, and self identity. Because some of these irimigrants came ten years ago while others step off the plat weekly, one has unique access to a diachronfc sequence of Fijiarr hous(ng development as well ./7 to changes in oi~er areas of expenditure which will be illustrated h~re. As with many other aspects of Fijian Canadian life touched upon in athis work, this sphere has stood in an empirical vacuum until now. No other recent inquiries of Asian-Canadian material culture currently: 11 exist. 11 This void is not only one of scholastic impofta:nse, for major themes of British Columbian anti-East Indian racism involve supposed patterns orEast Indian housing, settlement·, and buyfog. The second objec- tive of this exploration is to bring to light the'fontrast between Fijian expenditure as re.al ity and- as it is perGei ved by other Canad-ian-s-,. for- - - ----- - - - the contrast is indeed great. As has been a consistent practice throughout this thesis, I am not interested in material development of the Fijian community for its own .. . . sake alone. , Again, the object of inquiry is argued to be the . result of . cul tu rally constrained _i ndi vidua 1 choice, _tempered by the constraints of Canadian society. Seeking the formative elements o'f these decis_ions in Fijian tradition and family necessity, the implications of material things for self identity must also be addressed. - -~ . ··----. --·-· - ~- ----·- · - ···- -- A third, inter~inked objectiNe is to follow the discussion of Fijian work ethics of the previous chapter with an inquiry . into Fijian methods · of paying for purchases -- into economic rationalization,_ cash, and credit_. Behind the way in which these elements . are structured stands a Fijian orientation to purchasing which, like its work counterpart, diverges from · ' - Canadian practice. Finally, the diachrohic structure of- Fijian purchasing, espetiilly when combined with the choice models which underlie it, has implications for aspects of Fijian social organization and for the fq_ t ure developmerit .. . - of this corrmunity as a whole, and both of these will be briefly explored. This inquiry begins by outl,ini~actor-5 which Fijians :onsider when ·looking for housing, and then moves to how _these factors are actually employed in the resultant purchas.e of houses. From this, it shifts to geo- graphical settlement patterns, which largely result from housing choice, and ends with a discussion of other patterns_ of purchasing ... Throughout, important foci are ic:i~~J goal~_, th~ financi_al constrai_nt_L_put_up9n them ,__ __,__ ___ _____ _ questions bf mutual aid, and ~he . structures of expenditure which result • ~ - -from their combination. -,. - --- -233- Housing~ from visitor to king As with anyone in Canadian society, for- Fijians housing is a basic . necessity, one which must be met almost by definitio_n. But Fijians \re unsure, sel!-conscious · irrmigrants .. They are also a people who place great importance upon the residential family unit, and are individuals who have grown up to the theme that ·1and equals security; the significa'1,ce of housing to- Fijians cannot be overemphasized: The purchase of a house is a central objective, ano once acquired, it. is at the core of thei.r every_,,. day lives. Accordingly, the means to its acquisition have been well de- _veloped, even in the short time during which Fijian irrmigration has been . of any consequence, and we must look at this· structure with some detail. As both ~n ideal pattern and a normatively-defined empirical one, there is a definite - sequence which Fijians follow towards home ownership. It has ~n noted that upon arrival Fijians will in.itially sfay with relatives while a job_ is secured. Unless a decision has been made for the newcomers to join the household of their host (or ~hat of another _family), the next step is to secure rental accommodation. Some pre-1972 ilTITiigrants · were- able to skip this step because of the greater ease of financially - securing a house ·, and a few newer irrmigrants move directly to houses because of cash reserves brought over from Fiji, but both are exceptions to the rule. - - - -- -- ------------ -- - ------- -- - -- - --~----- ~ - --------- • - - - In contra~_!_ to the folk-critique that _Asians are coming to British Columbia ,with enonnous savings and are using this money to buy up Lower Mainland property, Fijians earn the financial rights of access to a house --- _J -234-, in Canada, working in the same job market as othEN,: Canadians. The type of ., rental accorrmodation preferred by Fijian~ already shows something of the model of desirability whi_ch they apply to houses; · room space, is the most important criter'ion. Fijian house.h olds -are large.. Space, especial·ly bed- Save for young families, A nuclear family with an eldest c~ild of seventeen would typicaliy have____threeGo·r -more children;and ;"n--d~e ~co~-si-... eration _for Fijian personal privacy, two- bedrooms are usually deemed necessary for a mature _fa,mi ly. . Cost is -the prime lim-itation on the form -which rental housing wiTl taki, although it is not the only one. Because all but a few who have been blessed with extremely :low rents plan to eventually buy a house, there '. is a general reluctance to pay more for rental housing than is absolutely . necessary. The higher the rent, the longer it will take to accumulate the financial resources to buy a first house . And rents in the Lower Mainland -are very high, as ·refl~cts the inflated local prices of real estate and of mortgages. Two-bedroom apartments in the Vancouver area currently run . -- 1 , about $310 a month. The type of rental housing preferred by Fijian families is locally ... referred to as a basement and is an apartment constructed in the ,- suite, . . ...~ , - basement level of a private house, where . it usually takes up all or most • of the.availablesquare footag_e. ____ Fijians are loath to rent iii apartment ' bui 1dings, except when families are sma 11 . These ba~ment suites usually .. -- . . . - have two or one bedrooms (the former predominating), a kitchen and eating area, a wash.room, and a living room, with all dimensions a bit reduced -- -1 · -235- from that of the'house abpve. T h ~ always a private entrance, usually at the back of the house, and tiften there is a connecting set of stairs ta the main floor above. Why Fijians prefer thes~ basement suites involves several factors. They are certainly a good value in terms of their cost rela~ive to space; a two .. bedroorrr·basefi1ent- suite typically rents in the range of $230 a- month~ and one-bedroom ones go for ...somewhat less, around $190. Utility\costs will depend upon whether the suite is a 'legal ' one ( ~ 24~ or _n W, in _ __ .... ji/1, the latter case they are usually zero, thereby further in~.reasing their value to prospective tenants. But cost aside, there are other ways in which these suites are advantageous. ) Fi rs t of a11, they are .very coll1110nly rented from other -East Indians, oft(n from other Fijians, who reside on the main floor. This pro- vides for ~ r freedom of use ~than would obtain in an apartment building. " An East Indian tenaht understands Fijian family organization and ,the social • demands p~t upon the f ami 1y by i 11Illi gra ti on ; he or she wou 1d find th_e large and variable number of resident family members acceptable, where an . . / . . /' apartment house manager, to f_ay nothing of the other tenants, might be • _ 2 quick to complain. The same goes for cooking traditional foods, to 3 the smell. of which apartment house tenants also object. Additionally, basement suites provide a measure 'of overa 11 autonomy and security. unparalleled in other rental accolJITIOdations, and may well have the additional 4 · · b~;e·f -it- o.f having kinfolk upstairs. As with the earlier stage in this progression \o home ownership, the } -236... -- time during which Fijians stay in rental accommodation is variable, depen.\ ding upon individual, ~ocial, and historical factors. Be'saiJse o'ltthe increase in rents and the cost of houses over the past four years, this time period is now longer than it was, and will likely tend to continue to increase significantly over the next few years, all t_hings being equal. Today, the time·"spent .in rental housing averages abqut a year, with-much _ ___· ---•--•------variability in individual cases. In the future it is likely.that for many Fijians renting wi~l become a long-term or a permanent condition, although it is not so now. The seq~ence js now co~plete only with the riext step~ the purchase of a house. As a normative Fijian Canadian culture pattern this sequence from visitor·to house owner is still developing, as reflects ongoing Fijian immigration. It has created within the rising · Fijia~ corrmunity a structure which interfaces with.that of chain migration: Financial Assistance other Fijians Landlord Own Stay Rental with Housing ..--! m -.-1 +.J i:: i:: ca Ill -.-1 ..-! +.J -r-; 0 -.-1 ! µ. H Relatives (mo!lths) Home OWnership __ ( 4 Although Fijians exhibit all the characteristics of English 11 house I -239- pride", in buying a house there is no overriding initial concern with lot sizes, shrubbery, paint colours, and the like, or with the neighbourhood locality, except in r~~rd to how the latter affe't'ts access to transportation. counts. It is what is ·inside the walls of a house which ultimately ~ <4' - t:•i·- The ideal hou~·must be relatively close to sources of employment, a It factor which has resulted in quite a number of Fijians moving closer to work after buying a first house further away. This is of particular im- portance when women household members work, for they often must rely upon public transportation (bus) to get to and from the job, and both distance and an·odd-hour work schedule can easily make travel most difficult. Consideration of the nearness of other Fijians is relatively weak, but is not altogether absent. Fijians follow the Sikh (Mayer 1959:4-6) pa~tern rather than the Chinese one (Cho 1970) in this, and select houses primarily for their own qualities and not so much in regard to the proximity of other Fijians. As will be de'e -only---forma-1-ly--,..-- - -~--, ' -·-~ -. . ·~-!J._ f'tje~ l --_-Jlo agency .of _g.overruhent normall,¥ enfo~c.es.-thls. asi;>ect of the-- zoning code. The 'illegality' of these suites is reflected solely in -244----------- - ---------- - - their invisibility.in mortgage qualifications (they are"not considered) . i and j.rJ the fact that they cannot possess independent uti l Hy servicing. Beyond this, they are~ facto legal; The only marked exception has been in th~ suburb of Richmond, where during the fall of 1976 there was a crackdown on illegal suites. Ninety percent of those charged (Vancouver Sun, Nov. 4:33) were East Indian. Buy a House, Form a ConTTiunity: Fijian settlement patterns in the Lower Mainland This compromise.house type is not just an abstract model. Fijians do buy the sort of homes which fit this model with relentless uniformity. 9 They never buy houses without basements, except in a few special cases. ·- More than one-half of Fijj-afl~~homes have functional basement suites, and their lack in the 0 ~ 1 - 1 believe to be mainly attributable to the short . . time during which the houses have been owned. 10 Because of cost consid- erations most first Fijian homes in Canada are relatively old, typically 11 in exces~· of twenty years, and often double this. Costs currently range from $50,000 to $60,000, again referring only to initial purchases. There are typically four or more bedrooms, and there are never less than 12 three. · ,/ ? Houses possessing all of these features are severely localized in I."" the Lower Mainland, especially those whifh.;:;~are low priced. - - - - - - -- - - As ind.:icated - - - - - - - - on the first following map (Figure 6), certain areas can be quickly eliminated. Kitsilano and Kerrisdale h ~ : type of house, but at pro hi bi ti ve prices. Sba,ugnessy and its envi rans, Point Gr:_ey, and the ,- -~---:~ ,.,,,-----~-....~""'~,./ -~~---=-------=---/ r; '"'"'" NOR.TH VANCOUVER ~ ,:, ,~ VANCOUVER '~!-':, .. -- ... --- · BURN.QY '" . ·( fl N .,r:. .... "Q BURNABY ......... ••§ i ..•-•o • :. 1 ..... IQ .!IA,_ • • • t![I·.. .• • • •.• •~•riit. Drive.• . ~ ~.·--=~ '-',._, __ ,,,,, . . ' • I • • / I J • RIQU1011D ( ) • // .. I 1- • _fE; • SURRE\'. I I I I. I I DELTA Figure 7. Fijian East Indian Residential Distributi6hs in the ~ewer Mainland "'' " .,. ,, ,I ' ~ ' V•oRTH VA•c.ouVEa . ,-, ••• • , . • • ... • • • • . • VAMCOUV!ll. , 1 • • r Il , • . ,... ~~. ... ...,,,. . .. . l· . • .4', . ·~, . .-- .•·.. • :'•Jo'. • • :. I ... I :,.. ..... ......... ' :, .... 0 ...:.), ............ .... ~- .... ., . . 4 • ,. • I ~URNABY Avenue : •• "' ... "" __ • --·4}..at ________ •,o:1~·-• ----·..L•., ... ' ~•. . ~1 •••• • • .. • • • ,/ ,J ,/ r •.!.Jtarin\ Drive, ,~ - l.. <~( ~ -V..•-!!--••·-----•- ~ ~ I N ...., ~ I ~ ,___ ~ l '"-.. '-.., ' \ • IUQIMOND I ' ",,l\ / ,,___,,,/ SUQEl " .DILTA Figure 8. Sikh Residential Distr'ibutions in th~ Lower Maifnland, 1959 " . I , \0 r--- • • • • O'I - 'D~ - - c •• • (CJ .......... • ••• • • • • ••• • C (CJ :::;;: •• ••••• . L _(]_)_ -~ 0 ...J Q) .£:. • • • • "'1 "'g; • 0 u ~ > - • • . • . +- I I (/) > . '• C • c ; 0 +::::, , I I • .0 L .. ~ 0 z • +-· (/) • • • •• 0 (CJ •• • • • +C Q) u • (/) Q) Ct'.: .£:. ..:.:: CJ) ( O'I Q) L ::::, 0) LL i i ' ~ I - ---- -249---- - ----- -- - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - whole North Snore are completely irrel~vant, for in none of them is anything availaole 6el_ow $70,000. Ricnmond possesses some promise, but.on the who 1e is too ,new and this is reflected in• prices-~ foca 1 point of the highest density of these houses is in older South Vancouver, or more ;; accurately in s-outh--ea-s-t Vaneouv-er. settlement are relatively sharp. The logical boundaries-b-f-F-fj-tan ----------- --------- Th~oundaries are sharpest along Main Street in the west, and in the east, and are weakest in the north. def Empiricai"boundaries are quite close to these logical ones, as . 14 ~ onstrated by the distribution of households in Figure 7. As _is strik- / ingly evident, the bulk of Fijians have chosen to live in.East Vancouver. There are small localizations in Richmond, Port Coquitlam, and Surrey, out these are diminutive in ct>mparison with that of East Vancouver. . , Be- yond these outposts, very few concentrations of Fijians exist in British Columbia, with the notable exception of Prince George. There are, for i nsta~ery few in either Victoria or K a ~ This strong concentration As reflected in the intended destination of 1975's Fijian immigrants, who almost unifonnly were going to places where other relatives already resided (Heath 1976): Vancouver Vic tori a Other B.C_. Edmonton Other Alberta Toronto r 160 ) 13 ) 222 Hamilton, _382 _) -~ ___ __ __Guelph~~ --~------l5---} ) Other Ontario 34} 126 - 41 } 185 Other_ Prov i rices 20 ) 20 . 18 ) ., Table !XX. Intended Destination of Fijian Irrmigrants, 1975. l ,505 ) 9 ) 1,896 Calgary - ---- -- - 7 ' Of those 382 who are placed in the 'other B.C. 1 category,· a great number will have headed for cities adjacent to Vancouver. House Choice or Corrmunity Choice? .This extreme localization of Fijian settlement is indeed primarily the result of two factors: Fijian demands for affor5a.ble housing of a particular type, and chain migration. It is difficult to separate the.se two, for they are but two aspects of the"' diachronic sequence of the establishment of these people in Canada. I believe that house choice pre- dominates in this localizatibn, for the reasons which. have just been outlined. Fijians are fundamentally a new corrmunity, and most are either in their first Canadian house or are aiming for this situation; they must buy where they can, and East Vancouver is the logical place. factors are also of consequence. I But other Perhaps the most important is that one's home be reasonably accessible to public transportation. This is vital to the development of the family's female workforce, and in any case Fijians are loath to spend long periods of time corrmuting to the jdb. Vancouver or close to it. 15 .. And most of the potential jobs are in Houses are cheaper in outlying areas for just· ~ this reason but everythi n~el se being~ ~qual~, Fijians wi 11 not opt for a 16 twenty-mile daily transit to the job. 0 Statistical and social factors which result from chain migration also reinforce this concentrated settlement pattern. Because new irrmigrants nonnally reside temporarily with their relatives, they are likely to { j -251--- - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~, - - - • search for rental accommodation and ultimately for a house in adjacent areas; the tendency for Fijians to rent to other Fijians reinforces this ~ trend. . A~ the same time~ community access is not afogether d,ropped from view, especially with more established residents. Th°qs, the latter often select houses in th-is same area when they move up to their second Canadian house. Part of this concentration results from informational constraints. To date, Fijians have been very reluctant to pioneer new geographical areas in Canada, and settlement outside of the Vancouver area is very spotty. Moreover, with the exception of those in Ontario, all other Canadian Fijian communities started with initial 1 colonization 1 from the Vancouver area and were built up by the secondary chain migration of relatives who 1- came chiefly from Vancouver. Thus, the communities in Edmonton and Calgary' are growing quickly at present, as the word spreads back that jobs are avail~le in Alberta, while to the best of my knowledge there could not be more an forty Fijians resident in the rest of Alberta. 17 Moreover, these communities would have been economically viable had they begun to grow five years ago, but the informational inputs were, then insufficent to promote migration. Fijian and Sikh Settlement Patterns Compared A1 indicated by the distribution in Figure 9, Sikh settlement in the & Vancouver area ,::u~rently parallels that of Fijians, but exhibits greater 18 dispersion from~e centre. As Mayer (1959:4-6)-has indicated, Sikh J ' I settlement in the late 1950 s was largely dependent;upon the same criteria 1 ~s that of the present day Fijians -- ability to ~fford a house and its distance from work. As illustrated by Mayer s (1959:35) map (Figure 8), 1 concentrations existed along False C~eek and in East Varicfuver, the former ~ \ resulting from an earlier day when lumber mills in that area were a significant source of employment. Also paralleling the Fijian situation, Mayer (1959:6) saw very little connection between this geographical localization ~ and links to kin and friends, for as with Fijians the car mitigated the distance between coITD11unity-members. As illustrated by these settlement patterns, while there is no 11 India town where East Indian residents predominate, there is a very high East 11 Indian presence in East Vancouver. As developed in the last two chapters, while this concentration facilitates the growth of coITDTiunity it also contributes to the growth of anti-East Indian racism. The Collective Advantage Many people in the Lower Mainland have -----""' sien',c-their house-buying potential evaporate in the last five years as price increases far outstrip those of wages. Without con~iderable collateral, the costs are for too high for many of- those of moderate (even median) income. Rents have increased 19 as well . Unless an unlike,'y change occurs inth~-f~ture, the next gener--- ati on of Vancouveritei will either inherit houses or rent. It may well be that' the day of the single family dwelling is largely over in the urban core of Vancouver. - 253:.. This high cost of hurt Fijians too; but it has done so ~elative to wages~ and it was not difficult for the enterprising Fijian family to buy a house; virtual ·ly all did_so, and some bought several. Recent increases in the price ocf houses have increased the value of these earlier ilTllligrants' investments greatly, often doubling them. This in turn allowed these same people to place very large down-payments on far superior houses a~d yet not have to deal with overly onerous payments; many of them have done this as well. The result is that eal"'l i er immi - grants possess unambiguou$1Y fancier homes, while recent immigrants have found the means to any sort of house whatever difficult to achieve. While changing conditions through time have differentiated Fijian housing, it has also been variable among the Fijian population at any one time, for families do not all possess equivalent resources. Those with .: low individual incomes · or where few family members work labour under a considerable liability, and either of these situations slows dowh the sequence to home ownership markedly. Nevertheless, Fijians will continue to buy houses, and will do so ( above their class and occupational station. Mutual aid, and ·a larger pro- ductive family workforce are the keys to this success-. Because they are wi lTi ng to 1 i ve in 1a rger domes ti c untt,1:han· manrC'1ter-1;canad iOns. th~-tr A-0-USi~ £-OS-t f)e-r f)e-r5-Gfl ~ oown sha r ply, --4¼ do the cost of services which are related to the household. Larger households also allow better utilization of time devoted to daily chores, with the result that Fijian _ ::s =r C s ' ) -254. · -·--- ·- ----------- --- - - - - ~~ hous~holds release consistently more personnel to the labour market. Even though Fijians on the whole do not earn large individual incomes, the total income of a household can nevertheless be impress iv~ if more than two family members work, as is so common. While it is relatively rare that-adult incomes are totally m_erged, agreements (sometimes form_~J _· ones) are normally worked out so that house payments can be met without constituting too much of a burden on those who nominallj own the house; ) t~se agreements can ran~e from formal and binding joint ownership of the 20 :··-l{ouse to what essentially constitute rental arrangements .. Because obtaining a house is more often dependent upon qualifying for a mortgage than it is upon- the Fijian family s ability to pay, mutual aid 1 systems have developed to deal with this problem. Quite a number of I Fijians are able to either obtain part of their down;-j)ayment as a loan , from Canadian relatives or to talk relatives into putting up their own property as collateral; the latter is more risky as it could potentially lead to the loss·of one's house, and is therefore rare. Beyond these financial benefits which •Fijians enjoy -because of their ,reliance upon kin are other advantages which stem from their orientation towards purchasing in general. Initially at least, Fijian- ilTITligrants are not heavily colTITli tted to patterns of high cons ump ti on; it is not so much --- - - - - - - - - - - ----·- --·------·----·---- -~ that they are intrinsically parsimonious, but rather that their material needs ·are rather limited in extent ancrtnaf tney have~~ yet been taught --by the North American media and by Canadian life patter~ed aft~r it that they shquld need more. The result is that for a while immigrants' expen- • , -255- diture on quickly consumable things is limited, and savings whicil can), / applied to a house accumulate. Moreover, Fijians do not have excessive expectations about what I would,constitute an idea~ house. They will accept old age and bad condi- tion in order to quickly secure a house. Because this limitation of expectation is reflected in lower cost it increas~s ihe Fijian likelihood of obtaining a house. Few Fijians will wait until they can afford a $67,000 house if they can affor-d a $57,000 one. Finally, Fijians are not so privatized that they are above having renters living in their house. Many of their Canadian neighbours are, or else they would have long ago followed suit and developed the latent potential of their basements. The~e basement suites are often the difference between just making it as~ house owner and a comfortable existence. Perhaps an example of these systems of mutual aid in operation would be in order: ,, I I .I dlli'illst_a_irs "\ up_s_t_a_j_r _S__ - - - - - - - - - - A Fijian-Canadian Household -256- The modest house in thich these people live was bought a year ago for $53,000. ~ - works in a-furniture»ctory where he makes about $10,000 a year, gross; His wife~ adds another $6,500 for her work in a clothin~act~, making~e couple's total incom~ $16,5~ Neither 3 , , nor 7 work at.present. ~ and 0 qualif~ed or a $40,000 mar gag~ and their montQlY pa~ts are approximately $420. Towards · ~ 11 this payment~ and_\V pay $190 a month as rent for their twobedroom11 basement suite, utilities inclnfy recently married, and have ·a yo~g so11, . Of this nuclear family only the husband now works. \ Recently, the married son and his wife have announced their intention to leave the household and to find rental acco1T1110dation. They cite ti-le lack of privacy and autonomy as the reasons; this house is not physically divided. If they in fact do so, as ·seems_ - ' t -258.JL ~rta in, the $500 payments wi_l l fa 11 ~on th¼1der couple and ~ , who can only work erratically.~ and are still in school. They have other monthly payments which are also very high, and ' fear they may lose their house. · The rate of nucleation of Fijian households is likely t6 increase, as assimilation to Canadian norms and values progresses . . Indeed, the eventual end point of the housi-ng sequence outlined earlier ·will eventually_be a household configuration no different than that of other Canadians, and this . r \ tendency is already becoming evide!Ji among earlier irrenigrants. While it is , . - 7' certain that because of the financial advantages they enjoyed in coming to Vancouver when house prices were still low they do not need to depend so heavily upon th~ income power of an extended family, at the same time their children, raised for a significant part of their lives in Canada . t owar ds 1.1v1ng . . . sma 11 er house ho1ds aft er marriage. · are t en d1ng 1n 21 The House as a Home As should be by now obvious, the house stands at the core of Fijian life. . This will become even more evidei1t in Chapter Six, where the social and co1T111unity aspects of Fijian establishment in Canada are outlined. For now, if suffices to say that house-buying _constitu!es a landmark in FiJian life. Fijians centr~ strongly upon the home and family, to the extent that the two......a.re inseparable. The house becomes a focus for identjty and -··--------------·-· - ---- - ,- a place of ease and security. 0-- ·:r..- ' ---- - - - - - - -- - In many respects its walls encapsu,ate • - ---- ··-·· - Fijian ways of doing which are not expressed in the public world. b-a.ng4age, values, and customs often shift at the portal of the front door. The home is also the pri~e focus of Fijian conmunity; it would be .... I -259· · - - - - - - - - - -- -~ - - - - - -- fair to say that Fijian community is as much a network of houses interconnected by lines of corrmunications as it .is a network of individuals. ·-,• ,.· Expenditure and Models For It It must b~ reiterated that buying reflects the buyer. -ce_rting ~ent, you, are what you buy. To a discon- Although the question of self I i den ti ty and buying must be deferred to Chapter E_ight, purchasing and expenditure have other implications -for the purchaser which directly affect Fijian establishment in Canada. Here the concern is with the pattern of expenditure itself and with the equation of thrift which stands. behind it. It would indeed be convenient if Fijian patterns of expenditure could benicely packaged into one of -those ready-made models of thrift and deferment of gratification which abound in the literature of economic development, but they cannot be. Empi ri cal Fiji an s true tu res of j.urchas i ng a re fairly coherent, but do not collectively fit into any such simple cate- _ gory. Rather, their consumption patterns and their orientations to them depend very largely upon what specifically is being bought, and so I will \ _ attempt a division of this sphere in order t~ustrate the themes which stand behind it. . ' I begin with ~hat constit~es a large initial capital outlay in Fijian establishment in- Ga-nada,- house- f-urn-i-s-h4-ngs, --:_ ____ ., -------------------- - House Furnishings, Public and Private Home furnishings can be divided into two spheres, the public and the -260- private, with respect to the likelihood that these things will be seen or . used by people outside of the family hous~hold. P~rha~ it might be more accurate to say tha.t there are areas c,f the home whic( ~re deemed to l-S-a-a!>S t-1.1e~r!-'-•,.--- - -- - - - - -- - -- - - - - -- i Pri va te .areas are to a far greater extent furnished in an economically rational marme-r:,, bas.ed at least in part on traditional expectations~ B.e.'.'." I -264- -- - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - cause these areas are by-and-large used.only by household members and ' visiting women they are far less directly a product of status consider. 27 ,. a t ,ans. An automobile is the other important purchase effected soon after iITJTiigration. Cars are relatively rare in Fiji, as reflects their very high cost. There, owning a tar was an important marker -of middle class / success, made even more so because it was not a necessary adjunct to life. Here cars are quickly realized to be a family necessity due to the --- long distances between"home, work, and shopping. Uncertain public trans- portation and the odd_ hours which many Fijians work make buying an autoIt is however an extremoly costly necessity. Monthly mobile unavoidable. car installments are aimed at repayment of the loan in a few years, and therefqre payments are very high; the payments and· insurance on a $5,000 car can occasionally match family rent, and in restricting available .,; monthly funds the purchase of a car can seriously reduce the family's ability to buy othe·r things and to save. Nevertheless, Fijians do accept 28 the in-evit_a_b_~~, and- vi-rt- u-a-lly a-- l- l- fam_ -ilie-s h-ave at least one cafThey are very hesitant to have two. j Severa 1 mrire.:or-1 ess rational fa~tors--increase the pr, ce of cars to t F1 J 1 ans. Perhaps because of their feral an Fam i 1 i ar i ty with aato,110bi 1es they prefer to buy one which is either new or nearly so; they are concerned / that if they do not they will bef p-lagtied with expenstve repairs. Because i - )t • - ... -265- fijian families are large, it is .the preferable course to buy a bigger ' car, which is correspondingly more costly. ,, While the status potential of cars is carried over from Fiji ;n some de'~ and results in a measure of con~picuous consumption, particularly among ybung males, this is not · neg-rly so marked as with home fu_rnishings, Fijian~_g lso pgy rnoce _fQ_L cars becaus~ .of their purchasing naivete, a point to h\ further discussed .s hortly. ',, ~ Food and Smaller Expenditures - ~ I have -already said something of Fijian eating practices and 'of the ", entrepreneurial possibilities open in this area because of the demand'·,, -~ for . -IgcJ\an s ~ foods. The expenditure patterns which surround this area must now be considered. Because Fijians eat customary foods in the customary manner their overall food costs are very much lower than for tho~ who follow North American dietary habits. -~ Indian food after all evolved in due regard for.efficiency in situatibns of want. The relatively better-off conditions of Fiji have considerably modified the Fijian Indian dieti~~pecially toward the inclusion of seafoods and greater use of meal' ahd_fowl, but none of these predominates. For Fijians basic foods are therefore far cheaper than for their high protein-consuming neighbours. - While Fijian dishes are often -labour-intensive thi~s in a way money saved, for few ffJfan foodstuffs are bought ,n any pre- • pared state. Fijians do not scrimp over food, but at the same time are not overlJ =-r & , -266. - extr?vagant, except at important functions. • • - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ They allow themselves a sig~i\ ficantly higher standard of everyday food than most had in Fiji, with the notable. excep~on of the wide range of traditional foods which are not available here, and w.ith the qualification that a few inTTiigrant Fijians were able to employ servants fh Fiji to do much of the attendant work. - For food, Fijians mix both rationalized and traditional sources. For most, the (Fijian) Gujarti-_run East rnlfn specialty store is the main source of Fijian specialty items and of basic dry goods like rice, oil, lentils, and sharps (coarsely-ground flour). Many of these items are either unobtainable at the larg.e supermarkets or are more expensive there, due to low turnover and small packaging. Nevertheless, there is an element of traditionalism in this relationship, for a Ugandan-run ' store but a half-a-dozen blocks away on the same street often has significantly lower prices and better specialty prodaG.e •. and yet few Fijians frequent the place. -- .... ,.,__~- - For meat, chicken, and fish items, there is very little ?hopping around done for competitive prices on single items, and not very much comparison ~s made of the overall price levels of different establishments. 1 Rather,/t is conTTion to develop personalized relationships with those who / ,,/ , ~ / i n the small butcher and fish shops which still persist in comp_e_-_ _ __ i titian with the chain stores; this sU~:tio~-~~~;llels many buying relationships in Fiji. For those other items which other Canadians use, especially produce, canned, and paper goods, Fijians head for the chajn stores, where these \ I . things do tend to be cheaper. They do not do much comparison shopping between stores, and tend to settle into a pattern of shopping at one or ·~another of these states in particular. In this, the hope of a chance meeting with other Fijians and the adjacent availability of other stores 29 are both important factors. Beyond home, furniture, food, and car, Fijian expenditure is severely 1imited, primarily because needs in other areas have not yet been created. Clothing costs are low, the cheaper-department stores are frequented almost exclusively, and there is still some home clothes-making going on. Only housa-modification costs are collectively high, but this could be considered to be an jRVestment rather than expenditure. / Fijian re~ional costs are very low as well, for visiting constitutes a primal-z ingredient ?f it, and one's cost output in attending to 30 visitors is lar~ly reciprocated. The significant exceptions are trips either to Fiji, which usually mix business and pleasure, or to California, where many have ~elatives; neith~r is an annual occurrence, by any means. With respect to i111lligration, some funds are remitted to Fiji, ~ mostly to one's family or towards the maintenance of property there, but this does not appear to be an important factor; also related to i111lligration, phone bills_cire 9ft~11 large; bu_tt-tii~_i?~_bJgl}Jy~ vaxjable. Be~ yond these things there is very little else. - - - - - - - - ~ ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - Patterns of Expenditure: Hindu Pro.testantism br \imited demand? -Fijians on the whole are far more controlled in their expenditure l,, I l r I -268. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -~ ·than is normal in the middle class North American society to which they aspire. It is reasonable to ask whether this parsimony is linked to an ·analogous ideology of the place of goods and services which might serve to limit and control the nature of expenditure. In short, does there exist among Fijian ilTllligrants anything to parallel the Protestan~ Ethic's orientation to material tbings? The answer must be made very tentatively, for I have access chiefly to beha\liour and to rationalizations for it, and jdeological commitments are difficult things to root out. So qua·1 ifi.ed, it has al ready been suggested in Chapter Four that Cana di an work ~thics have a number of parallels with th~t of the Protestant Ethic, and that Fijian work ethics diverge from these considerably. With respect to purchasing ethics, differences between Fijian and Canadian practice are far fewer, while both diverge markedly from the ideal type characterized by Weber. To illuminate this parallel one must return to the Prot- estant Ethic i~self. ( The ascetic Protestant view towards the acquisitron of goods supposedly was one of detachment, for extreme involvement with worldly goods threatened salvation. Although required to find salvation within the context of soctety, the Calvanistic Protes~antwas to be "in the world, but not of it". Expenditure was justified by utility and functionality, as defined ----------------- by how these tni ng-s ·contributed fo orderly life- in a ca 11 fog and not in regard to now tney eased or gave pleasure tJ THe. Tnae·ea-; the easy life was intrinsically dangerous to one's salvation. Fijian orientat;tons towards material things are not framed in such a l / r .\ -269- narrow calculus of bare functionality and guilt. Rather, at least as an ideal type, goods are intrinsically good, for they give pleasure to the owner. It would be nice to have anything one desired, and there would be no shame in it if such a thing should occur. But it will not, for in this world one is constrained by both individual and social limitations. Pleasure and useful things come from access to money, and conversely, money should be spent to get these things. Hard work, judiciously applied, begets money, whfah in turn allows access to desired goods. This is not an ideology very reminiscent of that of the Protestant -~ic. On the ot~er hand, neither is it very different from present-day high-consumption{North Am~rican ideologies of buying; this raises ~ral ) questions. this thesis: The' more :fundamental one is in truth outside the scope of why is it that in North America the Protestant Work Ethic has persisted, while the associated orientation to goods has not? . That such~ ihing has happened is certainly reasonable, for modern industrial . ' econo~1~s require two things of their populations -- that they work steadily and that they £onsume the products of their work, The existence of a Protestant-like parsimonious ideology of expenditure would be disastrous to the structure of Western economies as presently con?tituted. It- is not surprising that the whole weight of the media and of criteria for, . high soci-al st-at-us have been- lon-g- orient-ed--toward-s---h-tgh---consump-t-ton-;-----T~ sma-l-l-e-r"-~tion is mo-r--e- amenable -tG- investi~ation here: if Fijian ideologies of expenditure are fundamentally no different than those of other Canadians, what causes Fijians to exhibit lower levels of expendi- .. -270- ture, even taking into consideration the obvious factor of lower income? There are really only three logical options. R€lative to other Canadians, - Fijians might exhibit a higher efficiency in purchasing either (1) becau~e they are more careful to buy based upon criteria of functionality, or (2) \ because they are more careful to rationalize the process of buying as reThey migfft also -· gards p-riee, alternative possibiltties, and the like: exhibit lower levels of expenditure simply (3) because of a lack of developmen-t of need. The actual pat tern is a complex amalgam of a 11 three of these possibilities, but crudely put, one could claim that the general ,. _ pattern is that lack of need,. augmented by functional buying, has offset _deficiences i~ finding where the cheapest price (es. Functionality and Purchasing \ On the whole, Fij'ian expenditure is reasonably utilitarian, especi~ ~ ally in large purchases like housing. In the latter case,first house choice is very clearly ~ient~d towards the functional needs of the family. other instances, the degree o{ functionality is more variable. In Second house choice, for instance, is just as clearly motivated by the desire to - have a new house as it is by its higher use-value. We have s_een also that status criteria are important in public area house furnishings. But on the whole, Fijian expenditure in the areas of private household furnishings, ca rs, food and clothing a re very we 11 matched to need and very 1i tt le conspicuous consumption occurs. Fijians tend to concentrate their buying on basics and upon items which are not quickly consumable. Much of this -271- htgh functionality of Fijian expenditure does not come from any particular inhibitions in spending on frivolous things, but rather from lack of models for so doing, a point to be discussed shortly. The main other way in which the cost of Fijians' use of goods.and services is reduced is through collective use, and this natur~lly does not restrict itself to housing £ests a-lone, but transfers to all household items which are not of a strictly individual nature; for example, a family will require a refrigerator regardless of the number of individuals within the household. Wherever Fijians can make households which contain more than the number of people in other Canadian homes they have an edge in functional use whjc_h eventually comes out in lower famili,al maintenance costs. • Rationality and Purchasing - The achievement of a pattern of low expenditure is most seriously restricted in the area of finding desired goods and services at the cheapest price, with the significant exception of housing. There are several reasons for this. As with findi\g work in one's field, newer Fijian • iIT111igrants suffer from severe informational restrictions; .they quite simply do not know where to go to get the best prices, nor do they know much about alternative financial routes to the same end. - - - ---------- This initial infonnation vacuum is perpetuated by~ second consid- ---- --- --- - ---- - - - eration which mitigates against the most efficient patterns of purchase, that of the routinization of sources. ~• \ l . ·-~-\ -- .... ·•-- ~----- --·· . . -· . .-,· -• - .. - It is typical that a Fijian family --~ ------ -272·- · ·-· ·- · ----- - - -- - - -- - - -- -- --1 buys many of the things it needs f'.om a. very limited number of establishments, few of which offer any competition wit_h each other. It has been suggested that part of this routinization may stem from pat·terns of buying in Fiji, and from the security which comes from shopping in a place where one 11 knows the rules 11 , but these ay;e very tentative solutions. One aspect of Fijian buying pra-ettce most certainly i-s a factor here and consti--tutes - · another source of gross inefficiency in Fijian expenditure, and that is the constant use of credit. -- , Cash and Credit ( While it has long been a maxim that paying cash for purchases kept one living within one's means, few people t-0day do either, and Fijians are ~ ' no exception. Especially tor large purchases and for many smaller ones 31 credit buying predominates.. r One must .keep in mind that Fijians come 'from a background where credit was vital to even the most isolated cane . farmer, and their Third World status ought not cloud this fact. ~ Fijian . Indians have been firmly into a cash and credit economy for three-quarters of a century. Crops brought in cash, and credit from stores and money- lenders supported life between harvests. These patterns have been carried over into the cities. Ease of credit often detennines the source from which Fijians in Ca~ada will buy, which introduces a two-fpld i~efficiency. First of all, -'t these places are not necessarily those with the cheapest prices; unifonnly, :~ a car on a dealer's lot will cost more than the same car sold privately, j 4 I-I -273- but the former provides financing, while the latter seller usually requires cash. Fijians, often with very low cash reserves, . wiLl opt for the car on the dealer's lot. The same situation holds between businesses which are in competition. Ci:irs, fu-r-ni tu-re, houses. (natural ly}.T cl otl'li ng., gasoline,. and ca~ ser.vic'tng_ ~~ - ---~~ are very often bought on credit from those who offer it. That the same thing might be offered at a lower price elsewhere on a cash-and-carry basis does not override the perceived advantages of credit. Secondly, Fijians rarely consider ·the cost of the exorbitant interest ~~son their loans, some of which reach 25% per annum. Interest is al- most like a natural condition of life, not a factor to be ~anipulated among expenses. Rather, it is very coll1llon for purchasing costs to be ,- ~Judged chiefly upon one criterion alone: how much a month will it cost? It is almost as if one's standard of living was d_ependent upon the number of "so much a month's" one can obtain, these in t~rn being dependent upon monthly income. It is not rare that over 50% of Fijian Canadian fa~ily 32 Consumption is expenditure goes out in the form of monthly payments. often limited by Fijian lines of credit. Credit buying also has two other effects which depress the efficiency of Fijian expenditure. The use of credit allows one to purchase in the ... light of an irrmediately perceived need, thereby decreasing the potential for planning purchases and for seeking out the cheapest price. More import- antly, extensive credit buying severely decreases cash reserves, which can have the~effect of absolutely requiring a steady, uninterrupted income . • r( -274~ ' People with high monthly payments· are therefor:e often lo·l· ed to a particular job because it provides the necessary financial iewar s, and can be faced with disaster if family income is Jnterrupted or less ned even slightly. An Economy of Needs From where then does Fijian parsimony arise? It comes mainly from a get1ef'u4~lack of development of needs relati v~ to other Cana-d lans't a lack"·~~-which is not ~~?ed on ethical principles, but rather upon their limited assi~ilation of Canadian norms. In •short, they have not yet learned that they need electric blankets, dishwashers, or diaper services. Because it is only in the home that Fijian cultural patterns can be preserved to any significant degree, it is there that this economy of needs is most strongly evidentc Jhere are obviously some attempts made \ at reduplication of ele~ents of ;Fijiaw family life in Canada, and this ·- I . I / ~ - / endeavour does reduce costs. ,. ~ use materi a1 things were 1 imi ted in Fiji~ so were ,neeos, not in:::.i~t/ s-~nse that Fijia~s lack ambition or the ., · "\ ~ .. 1 quest for mar~, but rather because of the formation of ways of doing which were parsimonious reactions to economic limitations. In Canada, one sees this carried over in a concentration upoo basic purchases and upon nonconstmtab le -good-s-, and-tn -an .emphas-i s -on--goods-over-servtce~ '-Addittve pu re has i ng pr evails~ th er e "i--s-_,---for instance, 1ittl e money spent upon enterw tainment and recreation. Because Fijians have not ·yet reached the state where chf1dren are viewed as being unna.tura 1 or -bur-densome, they -a.-e-far ~ ) , . less of an economic liability than in other Canadian homes_.___ -.-Cnildren are . ' part of the family in more than a definitional sense, and need not be -; bought off with expensive toys or with their own high-sugar diet. As§imilation and the Economy of Needs Because Fi.j i an parsimony of ex~i ture ;k>es not· stem from any direct , ideological c,olTfllitment to be so, there is very littlawhich wilLin the · -.}eng run ~eep f ijiaft ·patterns from-'."qeie-ld-;-mergi·ng- wi~ nonrrattve Car1aclfatf'· -~•c•=-== 7 7 ones -under the influence of ass imi l ~-pressures. Unlike the- Sikhs, Fijians do not have a history of an aggre_ssively defensi~/minority united by religion and blood, with its strongly centripetal tendencies. all early Asian irrmigrants to British Columbia, they do not labour under the restrictions of a racial caste rest.rictions which affect buyin~~~ much as they do access to work and social esteem.lther, their ~nique heritage, with its heterogeneous Origins, its str g forces tow£: economic rationaljzation and its many Western iflfluences make .Jem-susceptible to rapid economic assimilation. Only the primal importance of the family, and of collective action based upon it -- that one facet of Fijian life which has survived undiminished into the initial phases of irrmigration -- will slow down this process. It is to the family and the social net-wo-rks--wh-i-eh -surrot.mds---it- to --whicrr-we must now-tur . • -~ - 0 ··~,. ·~c-~ r e ~~hapter Five: ~216le Notes "· l. This figure is an average of apartments advertised for rent in the weekend,Vancouver Sun editions of September, 1976. Many of these ads , a r e "come-ans" which are aimed at luring prospective renters to a ~cular~real estate agent, and t~e effective a~er~ge is likely to be even higher. . ~ ., 2. , Complaint's by. other tenants ar reported to be very common in apartment buildings, where tencint ,amilies are normally stable and numerica 11 y sma·11 . Fiji-ans ;n these'¼ i tua ti ans of t~o not· knovr ,thetr- · · · - - ~ -- -rights as tenants and do not sta~on them; thy are unused to situ. ations where non-relatives \!;{ -to dictate the r familial customs. 3., Ina few cases I have encounJred, Fijian families who live in apartment buildi~ -It-ave- .for- Ute mest part disperrsechwith eoold=ng=1irrcH-an =foods; I cannot say how much of this marked change can be attributed to modification of eating habits •due to :omplaJrits. · ===-~ -===·· · 4. Having k·in upstairs obviously can be either a benefit or a hindrance,· depending on personal factors. ·Regardress, it ~oes provide an on-" ~ go1ing information .to those downstairs over a wide range of areas. 5. Many. Sikhs _with whom I ha.ive ta l k~rgue that f'or them a house is an integral part of the fami_ly. Haus ._ in the PunJ.·ab. rarely go~out of. family possession, ?ut this is not o· in Fiji._ /_, ·. ···- 6. -This is a near universally quoted figure among..,both real estate sales-, men and local bank loan officers. · 7. Because of the present. cftff i cul ty expressed by.many people in qua 1i fyi ng for mortgages,~ price spiraling has11eurrently abated. Prices are not-~ike,ly .to decrease i_n ·the near future. 8. Credit unions are more liberal about interpr~fing sources of income and the like, but rarely allow more than 20% deviation from-these figures . • 9. These cases include side-by-side duplexes with li~ited basement areas and large ranch-style houses in Richmond built without basements because of the cost of dealing with su6-surface water. .10. It is not atypical be constructed within,. a year of ....u:ie.-.p.u.f'Cfl4.!:e-.u.+~.,fl.(;~~~i;..A{J~--Y-1'l@-.~----=-------------:---' ..) This i~ not to say that Fijia av who Haye been able to buy a secon modern ones. lo\ie of old _house?. Those. usually have selected p L - r . . -277-:.. -\ 12. In many tnstances, ,rooms have been modified or used to new purposes •in order to create more bedrooms. ;. 13. By logical b4!,i.ndaries I am referring to those detennined by the distribution of ·housing of t~e type and .c ost .range sought by Fijians. These were detennined by block-by-block touring of the area and wix'!:h the aid of two local reaLestate agents. -;-:i~rl.i - •" , , , ~ , . . . . ~ •'. • • . l .., :.:: . . ' - 14 . . This map results ·from 1-32 veri-ried -addresses ofr;.fJji aJl'1 houses ou~-·-of·~...:- ~. ----- · - · those which l collected during this study. Those resident south of Vancou·ver in Richmond and Surrey may be under..:repFese-i \te~, as were ·· · · those in Port Coquitlam.. .i !> 15. ~'i=.}ians .inJTiediately recognize -the need"ccfor a car ·irr-Camroa. · Men-are': not so quick to accept that wonien_migh_t a·1so , nee9 them, an9 many'·.-- ·_:· · women· are in this way significantly handicapped. · c.= ~-.. 16. ,. • ~ - • •·· , ,II' V - •. • • • • ~ • ... . - "' . ~ , • : • '. SJ • A\.ti\-01Jgh this .is a highly speculatiye assertion-, it seems t~at the . fowir proport-ion of Sikh women who work an·ow Sikhs more flexibility · in selecting houses. Many more Sikh$ do in fact live in out.lying . · areas, but sol)1e of this spread definitely ~s tlie resu_rt of historical settlement patterns (see Button 1964). · -· 0 ~-.. ~. • .... , 0 . rP 17 . . By all evidence, those-who move to Alberta presently cause they cannot . find · work here rather than beca tions or Alberta. ~ · ·· <; Figure 9 was con·s tructed by selec~·inall the addre,s ses of four Sikh n~mes _.. Bains; Dha.Tiwa·l, S~.dh~a . ·11 -: out of- ~lie Tel:ephone; o1ty (Singh Publ1cat1ons 197~) . . D1rectory ' Qf [the}-East.rn·d1an Co The Sidhu names~were. plotted by, Alan Mabin, Department of Geography, Simon Fraser University. ·. . 19. Rents have not risen as fast as house prices betause of the provincial restriction of annual rent increases to .10.6%. This has cooled speculation cb'hsiderably, as houses can . now· rarely be financed. and . paid for through -.rent. • 20. As these contracts are normal1y dependent upon the agreement of all pa rt i es Gorwerned-,--t-hey-are- ~oeeas ion ally- bro k-en-,- somet4mes·-wi-th--d-i-s---_:._ ___ .,c_~-~:__ _ astrous results; the nomina 1 owners are· occasionally .left with the · . total load o£ monthly payments after other parti-e-s. --ha=l.-'e'--1-l.= e .f_.t-.~------ - -- - ~ - < - - ' 21. This is not to say that Fijian household patterns are.currently under rad i ca 1 flux. It is still far too ear_ly to : predict the norrnati ve_~ . · structure of second-generat;iqn Fijian-Canadian_ sodiety. ' · -~- . ~-.. . . ... ·'1,.. ~ ....__ -278-- - - -- - - - - - - - 22. Th.e mar:ke,.d exception occurs in highly assimilated· households, particularly _tho~wh _ich ha?_ be~n under strong Anglo in-fl u-ence in Fiji~" . e.g. the upp mtddle class. - - - _ _ . ~. . 23. -The exc·eptioQ would be momentos of Fiji. • . . , ' • • • -_ • • t) • . , 1/iJ C .:· tl - 24. ·on t~·few occ~sions whe_n I have, seen Fijians visit Canadian· hou·s-es d~co a ted with _ex_~~!!.~ i_vg__p_eri od_ fur__ni !,ur__~_they _ti_a ve _been dist i_n~t l y___ nonpl ssed. -- · • ~ • 25. · ::~:~.:~i; ~~o: ;:;•~;. ;~; .::~:;;: .: a~h; :~;~; ------------~ A These Fijian markers are very ·important in regard to Fijian self 1 26. · ;~:;~erounroc·•,~~C . portions, especially in cases where the item involved was not coJT1T1on in Fiji. _Ste~os ·are 2 case in point.- Not only do they tend to / have the same gen~appearance, but also they are placed in a uni-· fonn manner. · - 27. This brings up an interesting point for which I have no ready answer._ .. 'When visiting it ·is corrmon that. women move to "the kitclaen while the men sit in.the living room, especiall_y" if the· vi-sitors are close ,, fr~ ends Jir' r~lati ve~. But t~i s:means that.while visiting,. ~o!l)en hav_e ·:a.ct.,_--ess,,;.to both public and private areas while men are rest.r,cted to the ·public one. Does this therefore ill)ply that public- status sfan.:. n to work, and often do not learn to drive. In part, this deficiency could be argued to stem·from practical considerations---; Fijians are reluc- · tant to buy old cars and newer ones cost money -- but this seems insufficient to explain the differential. Lack of access to cars )~everely restricts . some women's access to friends· and- relatives, and •' isolates them at home. 29. 0ne must keep in mi no ·tha t with so many peop l ~working, F{j ian·s haye· very. little time leftJor.shopping. For many families, Saturday is. the only cbnveriierit-t"ime-~--Going·tc>--large-shoppfog centres eases the ,--_---------_ ·~