44912 I♦ National Libr~r;y of Ca,:iada ..-~ CANADIAN THESES ON MICROFICHE . ' Biblioth~e nationale ~··ciJ Canada THtSES CANAD/ENNES SUI IIICIOFICHE , Ibreen Marie Indra NAME OF AUTH0fVN0M DE L' A U T W R - - - - - - - , , - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - TITLE OF THESIS/ TITRE DE LA THfSE_ _ _ _ _E_tlni-' ___c_i_t.._y-',_Soc_ia_l_S_tr_a_t_if_i_ca_t_i_on_,_and __Op-'-inion--------'- Fonnation : _ An Analysis of Ethnic Portrayal in the Vancouver Newspaper Press, 1905-1976. au. __ver __s_i_t_y_·__________________ uN 1VERSITY 1uNtVERS1Ti_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _S_imn ___Fraser ____ DEGREE F~ WHICH THESIS WAS P{IESENTED/ • Ph D GRADE POUR LEOUEL CETTE THESE FUT PRISENTEE _ _ _ _ ._._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _, _ VEAR TH IS DEGREE CONFERRED/ANNfE D'OBTENTION DE CE (,RADE _ _-1_9_7_9 _____________________ .... _.,.Y_____________________ NAME. OF SUPERVISOVNOM OU DIRECTEUR DE THE,$E _ _ _Dr_._Mi...,.._chae __l_G~·,,--Kenn .... / ,r Permission is hereby granted to the NATIOOAL LIBRARY OF L'autorisation est. par la pr~sente. accord~tf A la 8/BLIOTHl- CANADA to m•icrofilm this thesis and to lend or sell copies OUE NATIONAL£ DU CANADA de microfilmer cette tMse el 6f the film. de prlter ou de vendre des exemplaires du film. The' author reserves other publication rights, and neither the L'autell( se rlserve thesis" na extensive extracts from it may De printed or other- thlse ni de longs extraits de celle-c i ne doivent etre imprim~s w'ise reproduced without the author's written permission. ou autrement reproduits sans /'11utorisatiori""dcrite de /"auteur. Jes autres droits de publication: ni la ' If 7? SIGNEDISIGNl---..------------------ 6..,7..th..,.A,.ve._____________________-,-_..,, PERMANENT ADORESS/~""''---1..,06_s..,.J... - .. Mmtooa Nbezta I ♦ Nallc)ltal L.trcwy of Qnlda Collect ion1 Developt• ,t Branch Canadian Theta on Microfiche Service Biblio4hQJe nalionale cl.I Qnlda Oirectiof1 du developpemet,t des collections Servica des tMles CS\adiennes SUf' microfiche AVIS NOTICE • La qualite de cette microfiche c:Wpend grandement de · The quality of this microfiche it heavily dependent upon the quality of the original thesis submitted for microfilming. Every effort has been made to ensure the highest quality of reproduction possible. la qualite de la these soumise au microfilmage. Nous '"•. avons tout 1. fait pour assure!' une qualite superieure de reproduction. If pages are missing, contact the university which granted the degree. S'il manque des pages, veuillez avec l'universite qw a confere le grade. Some pages may have indistinct print especially if the original pages were typed with a poor typewriter ribbon or if the university sent us a poor photocopy. Previously copyrighted materials (journal articles, published-tests. etc.) are not filmed. islE- ., communiquer La qualite d'impression de certaines pages peut a laisser desirer, surtout si les pages originales ont ete dactylographiees a l'aide d'un ruban use ou si l'universite nous a fait parvenir une photocopie de mauvai,e qualite. Les documents qui font ·-deja l'objet d'un droit d'auteur (articles de revue, examens publies, etc.) ne sont pas microf ii mes. Reprodu_~on in full or in part of this film emed by the Canadian Copyright Act, R.S.C. 1 70, c. C-30. P1eale read the authorization- forms ich La reproduction, -mime partielle, de ce microfilm est soumi"se i la Loi canadienne sur le droit d'auteur, SRC 1970, c. C-30. Veuillez prendre ~naiuance des accompany this thesis. formules d'autorisation qui accompagnent ~tte.these. THIS DISSERTATION HAS BEEN MICROFILMED . EXACTLY AS RECEIVED LA THESE A ETE MICROFILMEE TELLE QUE NOUS L'A.VONS RECUE Ottawa.C.... K1A ON4 NL-339 ,,...,_ 8/801 \ ' \ E'.THNICITY, SOCIAL STRATIFICATION, AND OPINION FORMATION: AN ANALYSIS. OF ETHNIC ~ORTRAYAL . IN THE VANCOUVER NEWSPAPER PRESS, 1905-1976 . by • Dore-en Marie Indra · M.A., California State University, Hayward, 1974 ' .,, . '' . A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in the Department of Sociology and Anthropology Doreen Mari,: Indra 1979 SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY May 1979 All rights reserved. This thesis may not be reproduced in '!"bole or in pa.rt, by photocopy or other means, without perntlssion of the author: .. . .... · .• .., . PARTIAL COPYRIGHT LI CENS£. , ,.,.' \ hereby grant fo Simon Fraser University the right to lend my thesis, project orexten~ed ~ssa,y_ (the title of which is shown below) to users ot" the Simon Fraser Uni vers I ty L iprar.y ; .and to make par:-t i a I or single,copi~s only for such u~e/s 'or in response'to ~ request from the ~ I ibrary of any otl)er ·university, C!>r other educational . its own beha If 'or for one of· its ·users. lns.tifution, ·on I· further a·gree that ·perm Issi on: for multiplecopying'ot.this work for sc~o,l_a1i'v.larposes may be 9ra,:ited by me cir , the Dea·n. of Gradua1'e Studfes. It is understood that copying or publ i;atiO!li of this wor-.k for financf~1 ·gafn· sha1 ·, not be q.l~ed witho~t my written per~ission. , _,, ,,..._... ~Title of Thesi~/Project/Extended Essay Etmicity, Social _Stratificaticn, and Opinim F01J1Bticn: . An lmalysi.s of Etmic PmLtayal in the V8DCIOU'.ler NeWBpSper Preas, 1905-1976. Authpr: v/ .,..r- (signature) " ~ Mllrie Indra .r •• 1;..• APP R·O v ·A L Nine: lm'een Ha:ti.e Indra I Degree: ·' D:>ctor •of Philo8ophy Tftle of 'lhes~ Ettm.city. Socia] Stratification, and Opinim Formation: . In Analysis of_ Etmic ,Pot.t~ay,µ in the Vancouver NaftJPll)et' freas. 1905-1976. · · 1 Exan:ining_ Camd.ttee': I OlErl.rperscn: ~ W. Wyllie ~-G.--;?J;. Senior~ Hemish ·D:l.cld.e-cJ..m:k ti)el Dyck .. Herl:J>ert ~ p· ~ -= Jdn Porter Estemel E:nmner Professor Depul:Wlt of Sociology Carl.etcn lhiversiCy , - iii - Abstract . Ethnicity and the mass media have been important influences on Canadian society, yet many aspects of relationship between th.e two have no~ previously been explored. In particular, very little systematic attention has been paid to how the media cover issues and events involving ethnicity. This thesis examines in detail how the daily newspaper press of Vancouve·r. British Columbia, has portrayed ethnicity between 1905 and 1976. The primary data base for this study was generated througli a computerized content analysis of the press during the decades 1905 -1914, 19281937, and 1967-1976; the Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World were considered in the first of these eras, the Vancouver Province and the ' Vancouver fu!!!. were dealt with in the second, and the Vancouver Sun in the third. One out of every thirteen issues printed was sampled, or approxi- mately twelve hundred issues in all. This sample generated approximately four-thousand items., specifically dealing with ethnicity, which were then coded in terms of twenty-eight content and format variables. This data was subsequently analyzed to generate time specific, quantified assessments of how these newspapers dealt with each of the many ethnic and national groups which received substantial press attention. A social and economic context for each of these g~oups was provided in order to illus'trate the relationship be!Ween press portrayal and the place of that group in Canadian society. In order to develop a further understanding of the societal effects of the press portrayal of ethnicity in the pre sent day, the impact of stigmatic I - lV - press coverage on Vancouver Sikhs between·1975 and 1977 was subsidiarily considered; the data bases for this aspect of the- study were a daily content analysis of South Asiah news items in the Vancouver Sun during the first half of 197 5, participant observation during the same period, and a formal survey of one hundred male Sikhs' attitudes to the media carried out in 1977. It was found that throughout the twentieth century the press has generated relatively coherent stereotypes of both aomestic and foreign groups. Moreover, these press stereotypes have tended to be highly evaluative, with• the consequence that some ethnicities have been given far better coverage t than others. Although these press images have changed through time the British, Americans, and Western Europeans have consistently been portrayed -• • more favorably than those who have been perceived to be culturally or physi~ cally different from them. Historical evidence and Sikh responses to the media both confirm that the unequal fashion in which the Vancouver news• papers portray ethnicity has served as an important legitimation for the socio-economic privileges of majority group individuals at the expense of others. . r I /J - V - Up till now it has be~n thought that the growth of the Christian t:nyths during the Roman Empire was possible only because printing was not yet invented. Precisely the contrary. The daily press and the telegraph, which in a moment spread inventions over the whole earth, fal:>ricate more myths in one day than could have formerly been done in a century. Karl Marx (Cohen and Young 197 3:iv) One of the truly depressing aspects of our inquiry was the ingenuous. view of so many media owners that they are mere spectators. They' re .!!21. spectators. They control the presentation of the news and thereff Domestic Inunigrant News Items: Vancouver Sun (1%7-1976) 460 Most Common Themes in Domes~c Immigrant News Items: Vancouver Sun (1967-1976) 460 The Primary Group Mentioned in News Items Dealing with Sub-Saharan Africa from the Vancouver~ (ler s of a stigmatized minority likely to view the role of the preas in Canadian society? The methods employed in this study derive from the goals set forth above and a detailed outline of these methods makes up the bulk of this chapter. Basically, the methodology and attendant data bases employed - 8 - were dual. The primary data base for the analysis of the press itself was archivally derived, while that concerned with the effects of the press on an ethnic group was based on field work. A detailed computer based content analysis of the cove.rage of ethnicity in the Vancouver press was my major source of data. As outlined subse- quently, it covered three ten-year periods which span the twentieth century: 1905 through mid-1914, 1928 through 193 7, and 1967 th:ough 1976. In- tensive analysis of these periods enabled me to develop a detailed picture of ethnicity in the press for three distinct eras of British Columbia society. At the same time it provided the basis for temporal c;:omparison of press coverage across three-quarters of a century. In all, 4, 134 individual stories ' were analyzed in terms of 23 variables relating to format and content. The question of what direct effects news coverage has upon people whose ethnicity is involved can only be approached through one or.another sort of interaction with ethnic individuals during times when such coverage occurs. To do this in such a way as to gain an insight into the responses of '"--even a handful of ethnic groups would be an unrealistic objective, even if it were the major goal of this thesis, which it was not. Consequently, as a specific insta,!lce of the interaction of press and ethnic public I chose to investigate the re.action of Vancouver Sikhs to a period of a particularly active press coverage which occurred during the fir st half of 1975. As out- lined in Appendix III, between January and June 1975 the frequency of South Asian news items in the Vancouver Sun and the Vancouver Province increased V ., - 9 - 1 dramatically after a period of relative quiescence. In conjunction with a daily content analysis of news items bearing on South Asians during this period, I sought to gauge the effect of these printed news stories on individuals through informal interviews with people actually involved in the events portrayed in the news stories as well as with people representing a range of , community organizations who responded to this presentation. Several British Columbia politicians who also had reacted to this coverage wer~ 4 interviewed. In addition, I attempted to keep in daily contact with members of the South Asian community during this period. Through this sort of limited participant observation an attempt was made to understand the short term effects of news coverage upon South Asian individuals. In order to discover the place of the media in the lives of ethnic group members, a questionnaire was subsequently administered in mid-1977 to 100 adult male Sikhs living in the British Columbia Lower Mainland. This study was undertaken one and a half years later than the participant observatio~ was carried out, and corresponded to a period of relatively low coverage of South Asians by the local press. It was assumed that ad- ministering the questionnaire during such a relat~vely quiet period would allow the individuals questioned to have a more objective and detached perspective on news coverage than they otherwise might have had. 1n this, the Sikh community was singled out for several reasons. For one, Sikhs represent the largest South Asian group in the Lower Mainland. Also, the image of the Sikhs has become largely synonymous with the . - 10 - covering term "East Indian" for most of the British Columbia population and for the press as well, as will be demonstrated later. Males were chosen as respondents for the questionnaire in order to simplify analysis of the results. The Press and the Public At this point I should like to make clear the perspective taken in this study as to the general role Qf the press in society. The press is viewed here as one of the important mechanisms through which the individual is integrated into social contexts- larger than his or her own experience (Porter 1974:460). Moreover, by focussing attention on particular events, the press helps to define the issue of the day. In both respects, much of our knowledge about the world comes from the mass media. As Bernar.d Cohen (1963:13) notes in a study of the press and foreign policy, the press "is significantly more than a purveyor of information and opinion. It may not be successful much of the time in telling people what to think, ·but it is stunningly successful in telling readers what to think about." In choosing and publishing certain news stories rather than others, ediitors and other newspaper pers~el who shape the content of newspapers play a role in • structuring readers' perceptions in terms of what are to be considered the important issues of the day. This has been termed the agenda setting function of the media (Siegel 1974:3). Paul Hartmann, Charles Husband and Jean Clark, whose work (1974) will be discussed later, have clearly demonstrated this relationship in their studies of race and the British press. They note that race-related press • - 11 - coverage in Britain shapes the general picture within which attitudes towards racial groups develop, while the prevalence of prejudice depends in large part upon local community conditions (Hartmann et al 1974:82-86). I believe the media to be important in this way in defining is sues and in . providing the terms of discussion in which opinions on issues are worked \.., out among individuals in a face-to-face communication. It is with this view of the role of newspapers in society that the method of analysis stems. Indeed, what kinds of images of which ethnic groups have been provided by the Vancouver press to the Canadian public? In the context of what kinds of situations have ethnic group individuals been defined? What are the press topics and themes associated with ethnic groups a~ different times in Canadian history? By looking at how several newspapers deal with ethnic presentation through time, this study develops a temporal picture of each ethnic group in Canada, pictures which are quantified and which can be contrasted with each other and compared through time • .Ihi: Three Periods Three ten-year ·periods were chosen for intensive analysis and I think it appropriate that the major reasons for why these periods were chosen should be briefly outlined here, even though an elaboration of these reasons has been incorporated into later chapters. Each period will be discussed in turn. The fir st period, 1905 through mid-1914, was chosen because it was a time of rapid economic and demographic growth for Canada and for British - - 12 / Columbia iri particular. ·, Under the leadership of Wilfred Laurier, the Liberal party was then actively developing Western Ca~da, building new railways and transportation systems (Lower 1970: 144). Emigration from Europe, the United States, and Asia was extensive, and immigration from the former two was formally encouraged by the government. ~ Under, Clifford Sifton' s program to bring people to settle and develop the "empty" -prairies, irrunigrants came from Britain, Germany, Scandinavia, the Balkans, the Ukraine, Russia, and the United States. It is estimated that from 1896 to 1914 approximately three million people arrived in Canada (Palmer 1975 :7). The development of the Canadian prairies resulted in growth of industry throughout Canada. In British Columbia, the fishing and mining industry expanded rapidly, as did the lumber industry, supplying as it did the construction materials for the homes and buildings of these new prairie l settlers (Lower 1975). j i i{ Far from Atlantic Canada, British Columbia faced Asia, and while t European immigration to the province during this era was extensive, it was Asian immigration that was to become one of the major issues occupying the minds of the British Columbians of that day. While Asian immigration had become an issue in British Columbia well before this period, it was during this decade that the conflict reached its peak (Buchignani 1977: 1-76). This sort of ethnic conflict was not confined to British Columbia but • rather was a world phenomenon which particularly characterized this period of history. Thus, at the same time that immigration and ethnicity became C .. - 13 - · important questions in Canada, et~ic group~ in many other parts of the i world also made the newspapers. massive i~lux of immigrants. War I. The United States experienced it's own In Europe, the Balkan War preluded World,, China was s_lowly emerging frSm colonial rule, while Japan was· trying to colonize it once again. colonization of Afr.ica. :uropean powers wero conso~✓ ,7 These and the many other conflicts then ongoing around the world makes this era a particularly interesti'ng one to look at in ~ . terms of how the aspect of ethnicity is presented in the press. . The period was concluded with the .beginning of World War I (August, 1914). ,.,,/ . .._ The years 1928 th~oughJ'jJ.'.7 were largely depression years, and this - . was especially so in British Columbia, where the economy had never been developed above the level of primary industry (Re snick 1974:6). With a high rate of unemployment in the province, British Columbiana also h_ad to deal with. an influx of people to their province seeking work from other parts :, of Canada. /? ~ight. Competition for jobs and other scal\ce resources was a,t its Thu~~ era was ideal for investigating the relationship between press portrayal, ethnicity and economic hard times. The pe_riod was· one of relative demographic stability, at least in terms of 'traditional' immigrant gro_ups. Asian immigration had been virtually terminated by 1928, while European inunigration was si.Inilarly restric,ted in 1932. Outside of Canada a great struggle was on among the industrialized nations to gain markets , while at the. same time protecting their own; thi_a resulted in continual .. ' international conflict (Glazebrook 1966). The s~e was being set for Worl-d - 14 - War Il. The third period, 1967 through 1976, brings the s ~ into the pre sent. -....____· At least for the fir st'h.atf of the decade the Canadian economy was undergoing significant expansion; in this, there was considerable similarity with the first period. Once again, Canada was accepting .large numbers of im- . migrants. 1967, the year beginning this period, was an historic one in the ever-changing saga of Canadian immigration. In that year, a new set of i I immigration regulations were enacted that removed preferential treatment of inunigrants from white, Western and Northern European source countries. Canada's position in world affairs has changed conside'fl-ably in the postwar era, and with the independence of f!Ulny colonial territorie•s, differential l racial tteatment of the world's population in terms of immigration became 1 an embarrassment to the Canadian government (Hawkins 1972 :99-118). The new legislation had the consequence of radically changing the pattern of Canadian immigration. Asian and Carribean immigration in particular in- creased dramatically. This period also saw the rise of increased French Canadian nationalism. Anglophone-francophone issues became highlighted as never before in this century. In British Columbia, the first few years of this decade were ones of economic good times while the risihg cost of living became a major concern , during tat last five years. Im.migration and the changing ethnic and racial ~ture of;~ population -------- then bec~e i••~•• and often figured in folk ex~ pJaoations fot the economic crisis that was taking.place. J l l j j l - 15 - The Newspapers The selection of which Vancouver newspapers to choose for analysis was not a difficult one, for it was largely determined by the nature of the newspapers available. Five newspapers were available in Vancouver during the fir st period, that is from 1905 through mid-1914 (McGregor 1946). The Vancouver Province, the Vancouver Daily World, and the News-Advex-tiser were the only ones which were dailies and which published consistently through this period. Both the Province and the World appeared in the after- noon and published daily with the exceptic;m of Sunday. (a daily morning paper) did not appear on Monday. The News-Advertiser Of the other two, the Saturday Sunset began as a weekly paper in 1 9 ~ l e the Vancouver Sun, a daily, did not appear until 1912; neither of these papers published consistently through the period and for that reason were eliminated as possible candidates for this study. This left the Province, the ·World and the News-Advertiser. There were several censiderations which eventually led to the selection of the Province and the World. Among these was the rela~ve cir- culations of these papers; in this regard the Pr~ce· held the lead over the , World, while the News-Advertiser ran a poor third {McGregor 1946: 111). • 1 -,., The political stanc~s of these papers also were of consequence in their selection. The World was Liberal in political affiliation and 1Vas usually a strong supporter of the Laurier government. The Province. on the other hand, leaned towards a Conservative political orientation (McGregor 1946: 113). - 16 - Each paper was thus aimed at a slightly different readership. 11 The World 11 purported to support the working man of British Columbia, while the Province aimed at middle class reader ship which affirmed ''order, 'progress; and good government. ,r As McGregor (1946:144) notes, this rivalry between • the publishers of the two papers involved not only different political orientatio~s but a clash of personalities as well, 'and this strengthened the differences between the two paper'S. The News-Advertiser was eliminated largely because its social impact was not as large as the other two dailies; while it was politically Conservative, it was a far less influential paper than the Province. By 1928, the year which began the next period of press analysis, the World had disappeared from the Vancouver scene and the Vancouver-~ and Vancouver Province were the only dailies continuing from the previous era . (Lamb 1942). , Two other dailies appeareyuring this period, but neither published continuously throughout the time span. The Vancouver §!!L opened in 1924 and closed in 1932. The News Herald was established in 1933 and ceased publication in 1957. As before, the Province continued in a Conservative political tradition while t h e ~ supported the Liberals (Lamb 1942). Competition between the Sun and the Province was extremely sharp (Kestertoa 1967:100), as it had been between the Province and the earlier· Vancouver Daily World. Both papers were picked for analysis_during this period. During the last era, 1967 through 1976, the Vancouver~ alone was - 17 - chosen. Although its rival, the Province, continues to publish, constraints of time and effort predominated in thi~ choice. As it was, the volume of material coded was overwhelming, and the volwne of material on ethnicity gleaned from t h e ~ during this _period approximated that of any two papers of earlier times . . The Vancouver Sun was chosen over the Vancouver I 2 ~ because of its much higher circulation. Content Analysis: The Foundation At the planning stage of thMtudy, the question arose as to what methodology to use. The aim of the study had been established to develop a general view of the world of e!:hnic groups as presented daily to the public by the Vancouver press. In choosing to do a formal content analysis of these many ethnic groups I was motivated by two considerations. The first was that no similar analysis to my knowledge had been done in Canada; in fact, in the detail that I wanted, nothing in the world literature even came close. Secondly. I wanted the subsequent analysis to be as objective and as flexible to a variety of questions as possible. Formal analysis seemed to be the only available route. Nevertheless, prior content analyses of ethnic portrayal in the media have often taken the narrow form of measuring attitudes {during a short tune span) in terms of negative, positive or neutral presentation. was avoided for several reasona. This method First of all, I was interested in the more complex question of how situations in which groups were portrayed might reflect upon the structural positions of these people in Canadian society. - 18 - Secondly, I wanted to do an analysis of a long time span in order to see how these portr'ayals change with time. To think merely in terms of negative, positive, or neutral portrayal would say little about the events and subjects surrounding the coverage of ethnic groups. In other worlds, I was not so much interested in measuring degrees of prejudice, discrimination or favorable or unfavorable images as I was in the attributes associated with ethnic groups arid the media contexts in which they were placed. The foundation of the content analysis format utilized in this study was ultimately derived from Race i l News: ~ Study i n ~ Handling o f ~ i n ~ British National Press fL2mjfil i2, .l21Q. by Paul Hartmann, Charles Husband, and Jean Clark (1974), although it was much altered and expanded ,for my purposes. In their study Hartmann~,!! undertook a content analysis of four national British dailies through 1963-1970. This study was primarily done to see "whaf kind of version of the daily worlci was laid before the public as a kind of suggested agenda fo~eir thought, discussion and action" (Hartmann, Husband, & Clark 1974:94). That is, they were interested in how race-related matters had been defined in the British national press and what kind of picture of race relations had been made available to the British public by the press • • Their content analysis had two aspects: British race-related stories and overseas stories. In the latter, they focused their analysis on Commonwealth countries and the United States. In choosing four national - 19 - dailies, Hartmann, Husband and Clark chose both 'quality' papers and 'popular' ones; that is, newspapers which had different political orientations . . and which ·represented a varied socio-economic readership. Their study was not one of prejudice and discrimination but rather was oriented to look at race-related news stories as cultural and sub-cultural phenomena, emphasizing "definitions of situations" (Hartmann .!tl, al 1974:146). By asking the question "What was the material about?", the structure of the content analysis emerged. and subject matter. Each news item was classified into main topics With a list of.!. priori topics in mind, they sampled news items for inclusiveness. Within a list of topics, Hartmann, Husband, and Clark found that it was possible to distinguish more specific types of subject matter. These more specific types, they called subtopics. For instance, under a general topic of 'Housing', a story could be on overcrowding, on housing shortages, or on government provided houses. They found that coding only topics and subtopics within a news story was not sufficient, for a news story often contained reference to other themes not directly found in the topic category. To cov~'r these, a list of themes was also drawn up, in many ways parallel to the subtOpplS«: . Each news item (in the British material only) was therefore classified under a topic and subtopic heading, while themes derived in the news item were coded separately. For instance, if a topic fell under 'Legislation', the story might also include reference to immigration, but immigration may not have been the main topic. It would therefore be coded as a particular theme under - 20 ' . 'Immigration' but under 'Legislation' ~s a topic. This they found to be an important means of discovering wheth_er certain themes occurred in reference to particular _topics. In d_oing the content analysis for this study, a similar method was used, but it was significantly expanded and modified for my purposes. Perhaps the _major difference between the Harhnann, Husband and Clark study and mine lies in the different orientation of the two· studies. • is not the Canadian one. The British context While 'race' has been one way in which people in Canada have defined each other and themselves, particularly in British Columbia-, the 'ethnic' label has had more general use. As a~ example of this 'ethnic' salience, in the Canadian census there has never been a category in which a person could label himself or herself as simply 'Canadian'; one must rather be 'British', 'German' or 'C.hinese', Since 'ethnic' background has been· such an important way of defining "'p·eople in Canada (Porter 1974:60-103), l have broadened my analysis to ~1: , · include virtually all ethnic groups found in the Canadian context. All rGanadian ethnic group~ that were large enough to be frequently used by people . in referring to each other and all those that have been fr~que-ntly used by the ~ . media vy-ere included. . On the o~her han~, Hartmann, Husband and Clark were centrally interested in 'race' and 'coloured people'. Indeed, they did not distinguish between various ethnic and national groups within, the category 1 coloured'. . This cont~nt analysis expanded the category of people looked at from one to include the 68 cat~gories listed in Table I. - 21 - Ethnic Group Colored 11 Other Colored Black 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 African Rhodesian, South African Black American West Indian Canadian Other Asian 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 Chinese Japanese East Indian, "Hindu" Sikh, Punjabi Ugandan Asian Other East Indian Other Asian Vietnamese Native People 40 41 42 43 North American Indian Inuit, Eskimo Other Arab ! Israeli 50 51 52 53 54 55 60 Arab, Muslim Israeli Jewish, Hebrew Other Palestinian No~ European 61 Other I !.._ 22 ~~ Code Ethnic Group 70 European 80 British 81 82 83 84 90 Canadian 91 92 ' English Scottish Irish Other 100 Anglo French Eastern European 1(D 1, 102 10 3 104 105 106 107 108 110 D-oukbobor Hungarian Communist European Polish Russian Ukrainian or Galician Yugoslavian Other Western! Northern European 111 112 113. 114 115 116 120 Dutch French German Scandinavian Other Nazi Southern European 121 122 123 Italian Greek Other - 23 - Code Ethnic Group 130 Hi spano-Po rtugue se 131 132 133 134 Spanish Portuguese Latin American Other 140 American 150 Immigrants, Unspecified 160 Australian & New Zealand 170 South African White or Rhodesian White Table I. -. The Ethnic Groups Coded in the Study - 24 - While Hartmann, Husband and Clark did a content analysis of the national press in Britain, I focused on one area in Canada, specifically metropolitan Vancouver. This study was restricted to British Columbia in order to obtain an in-depth picture of one area within Canada along a long time dimension rather than a broader area with a shorter time depth, as did the Hartmann !:_t & study. This content analysis also expanded the foreign news story category to include not only the U.S. A. and British Commonwealth, but all parts of the world where 'ethnicity' was a part of the news coverage. Thus news items were coded to take into account where in the world the story covered by the press occurred. The locality of all news items were broken down into the following areas: British Columbia, Canada, Europe, Africa, Asia, Latin and Central America, Australia and New Zealand, the Caribbean, and the United States. Because it was found that objectively defining a foreign news item to have an ethnic content was extremely difficult, two categories of foreign news items were initially created (in addition to a domestic one which included Canada and the United States): one in which ethnic_ity was specifically mentioned and the other in which it might reasonably be inferred • • In questionable cases a three-person panel judged which of these two categories would apply to a g_iven forei.gn news item based on the author's explanation of the item. For most purposes these two categ~ries of foreign story were treated together. While Hartmann, H~sband and Clark analyzed four newspapers, they - 25 were not centrally concerned with showing differences between papers. In contrast, I sharply distinguished between newspapers in this content analysis, and was concerned with the question of what degree of_ variability there was betw~en the various newspapers. Since Hartmann, Husband and Clark were mainly cpncerned with what kinds of images race-related news items contained, they did not find it important to distinguish the format that these items took. For instance, they did not distinguish between items contained in editorials, letters to the editor, etc., or whether such items also contained photographs. I was concerned with both the form and content of the material and consequently several format considerations were noted. Among these were included'the length~£ the story in column inches, the headline width in columns, and the source and ~ of the news item. The later was coded into the categories found in Table II. Source and Type of Coverage 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Table II. news, local source news, news service source news, Canadian source news, foreign source editorial political position letters to editor cartoon news, other Types of News Items and Their Sources In addition, I also nbted the presence or absence of a photograph, the .P!&!:,_ on which the news item was placed, and the ~ - Each item was - 26 - also coded as to the newspaper from which it was derived. Obviously, the topics and themes which surround and surrounded Canadian ethnicity are much different than those of interest to Hartmann et al. Modiiications and additions to their methods of coding topics and themes were quite extensive and ar_e detailed subsequently. Basically, news items \. were coded in terms of 18 possible topics, 185 subtopics, and in terms of up to 6 themes with the same 185 categories. These topics and subtopics are listed in Table ill. Sampling Each newspaper published approximately 3,000 daily issues during each decade and it was therefore necessary to derive a representative sample of the whole. This was accomplished by first selecting a random date at the beginning of each decade. For 2-:i:istance, at the beginning of 1905, Tuesday, January 3rd was the date selected to begin the content analysis. Thereafter, every 13th is sue was selected right on throughout the period. A short reflection on this technique will show that in this way the days of the week were constantly rotated and evenly represented. The next issue a_n a ~ lyzed would be Wednesday, the following wt>uld fall on a Thursday and so on. _ If an issue was unavailable on the 13th day, I went to the following day and then went back again to the 26th issue from the ~riginal day. 3 1,200 issues were surveyed in this study. ln all, about ,his extremely large sample was necessary in order to insure an adequate sample of items on specific' ethnic groups. 27 ~ Topics and Subtopics 100, Housing a.nd Settlement 1oi'. -.-.. are overcrowded 102. . .. cause high rents or house prices to ri~e 103. . .. _cause neighbor~ods to go ethnic 104. . .. housing is restricted or are denied housing 105. . .. provide their own housing 106. . .. cannot find housing 107. . .• do not keep up their houses 108. . .. cause overcrowding 10"9. Other 200. Education 201. • •• cause schools to be overcrowded 202. Canadian children held back by •.. children 203. Special educational provisions are required or have been established for ••. children 204. • .. children in educational system are costing too much money to the taxpayer 205. . .. children are educationally disadvantaged compared to the Canadian child 206. . .. children make bad adjustment to Canadian schools 207. . .• children make good adjustment to Canadian schools 208. . .. a re under-educated and lack we stern cultural knowledge (except regarding work) 209. Support of foreign student 210. Other 300. Health .!.!!£ Welfare 301. •.. are a hazard to health 302. . .. health is poor 303. . .. health is good 304. . . are a drain on social services 305. . .. are not a drain on social services 306. . .. are on welfare 307. . .. want health or welfare services 308. . .• do not pay their share of social services· 309. Other 310. . .. provide their own social services A J' - 28 - 400. Employment .!.!!,g, Economic Activitiie s 401. ... seek jobs 402. . •• calfie unemployment and take jobs 403. • •• c~se low:er standard of living for ·canadian wqrkers (re. work) 404. • •• ate needed for the labor supply 405. • •• w~ard or are good wprkers 406~ ••• are poor workers or lazy ones; do not work hard or do not follow orders 4:07. • .• are skilled workers 408. .•• are unskilled (re. work) 409. Other (mostly trade, soliciting, tariffs, and markets) 410: •.• are unemployed 411. •.• are employed .•. are or will be driving Canadian establishments out 412. of business ..• send their money out of the countty 413. 414. . .. are frugal and do not spend much • .. own or are buying up property or businesses 415. 416. . .• patronize only their own businesses . .. employ each other 417. . .. are a source of cheap labor (positive) 418. . .. are in economic distress due to natural disaster 419. 0 500. 600. Numbers 501. 502. 503. 504. ·505. 506. 509. ... are of a certain population size . .. are increasing in num)ters There are not enough •.. here •.. birth rates are higher than general population • •. cause overpopulation in Canada Too many ..• will lead to trouble Other Advocation of Ethnic Restriction 601. • •• should be barred from certain jobs and get less wages 602~ ••• should be denied social services 603. • •• should be denied rights of citizenship (votes, etc.) 60-l. • •• should not be allowed to use conveniencesb businesses, etc. ' 605. • •• should not be allowed to do things in ethnic ways 606. • •• should not be allowed to compete with other businesses 607. • ~. ahould be barred from immigrating 608. • •• abould not be allowed to speak foreign languages 609. Keep Canada White - - 29 - 700. Ethnics ~ Restricted 701. ••• are barred from certain jobs; get less wages 702. . •• are denied social services 703. • •• are denied rights of citizenship 704. . .• are .not allowed to use white conveniences 705. . .. are not allowed ethnic ways 706. . .• cannot immigrate 707. Lack of information or knowledge restricts .•• 709. Other 800. Ethnics Charge Restriction r'\. 801. ... claim that they are barred from jobs, housing, e ~ 802. . •• claim that they are barred from social services 803 • . •• claim that they are barred fro~nadian social \.,.,-"' institutions 804. ... claim that they are barred from rights of citizenship 805. • .. claim that they are not allowed ethnic ways 806. . •. claim that they cannot. immigrate 809. Other 900. Ethnic Relations 901. •.• organizations try to better ethnic relations ..• relations are be.ing mediated by an external force 902. • •• have good relations with the police 903. . .• have bad relations with the police 904. Relations between and the larger society are 905. ~etting better Relations between and the larger society al'e 906. getting worse Relations 'between larger society. and •.• are good 907. Relations between larger society and . :.. . ar-e bad 908. Other 909. . .. are assimilating 910. •.. have outside support " 911. 912. ... and another group united in action or concern 913. . .. try to impose thei:r ways on other parts of society 914. . .. do not get along and exploit each .other ... are ·a threat to the. Western Wo'rld 915. Pro-American Investment or Pro-United States 916 . involvement -917. Anti-American Investment or Anti-Uoited States involvement 918. • ·•. bilingualism advocated • - --I - 30 - ·1 000. .Immigration 1001. There is too much immigration from ••. currently 1002. • •• are coming to the country in large numbers 1003. • •• are entering illegally 1004. .•• arrive or will arrive 1005. • •. should be aided in immigration or are aided 1006. . .• br.ing over their relations or would like to 1007. A ••• is being deporter the Victoria constituency. Aided by the support of his own paper he won, and thus began a political career yvhich was to lead to the premiership of British Columbia and into federal politics. While de Cosmos 1 sold his interest in the Colonist in the mid-1860 s this did not end his involvement with the press. From 1867 to Confederation -de Cosmos was a member of the pro. vincial legislative council (Robin 1972:274). Thereafter, he was an important opposition leader during the short-lived McCreight ministry; so also was J. Robson--another early newspaper figure to whom I will turn shortly. McCreight' s government was an unpopular one, due in no small measure to vi_rulent attacks by de Cosmos in his new Victoria Standard, and de Cosmos became the second premier of British Cohunbia. He was simultaneously premier, legislative repr~sentative for Vict~ri~ and a federal member of Parliament. When joint provincial-fed~ral office holding was made illeg_al in 1873 de Cosmos chose to remain in federal politics and · gave the premiership over to G. A. Walkem. De Cosmos remained a • \ - 48 - " powerful political voice in British Columbia. He was a virulent anti- orientalist and gave heavy support to a railroad for British Columbi,:. The Standard, which la~ted about twenty years, kept closely to the same orientation as its founder. consistently good press, It continu~ to ghfle Walkemand de Cosmos anq never m_eptioned the frequent expos~s of de Cosmos I involvement in graft and questionable real estate speculations. De Cosmos' original creation, the Colonist, passed into the control of J. S. H. Matson in 1906, by which time the Colonist was a solidly Conservative newspaper. · De Cosmos was only the first in a long line of individuals who used the press as a stepping stone for political office. . Another early figure to follow • J in 1860. The Mai~land ,population was still tbl> ~parce this route to fame and fortune was John ~obso~( wb6 founded the Columbian . /.. J ~ New Westminater. to financially support s11ch a paper, but while it lasted the Columbian was an important platforrx:i 1 f!)t Robson's political opinions. Robson himself be- ''·.,. . '• came a very visible figure in the provincial legislature. He moved the Columbian to Victoria in the mid-1860's, where it was bought,out by the . Coloniat in 1869. Robson became the Colonist's editor. He was later Provincial Secretary and Minister of Finance under A. Davie (1887-9) and . . subsequentJy became premier, a position he held until his death in 1892. Both editorially and in hi• own personal politics Rob•on was sympathetic to business and antithetical to labor. The 1870' s were slow timeW for ~ r i t i a h Columbia e.conomy, and 1t - 49 - was likewise an era when.there were relatively few attempts to further develop the newspaper industry. In 1870-71 tkere were only about 10,000 Europeans in the whole of the province, and because of the extreme dependence of the economy on primary resources and agriculture, many of these individuals lived away from the tdwns and were therefore not potential consumers of newspapers. Whereas- even a town as isolated as Barkerville could support a newspaper in 1864 (The Cariboo Sentinel, see Goodchild 1951: 109), money was extremely tight in the 1870' s for the pr_oducers and consumers of newspapers alike. There were nevertheless several at\empts to establish a newspaper in New Westminster during the 1860's and early 1870's. Columbian has already been mentioned. Robson's T h e ~ Westminster Times was . started in the same year as the Columbian (186~, but 'twq year.a later' financial consideration forced it to move to Victoria,· where it bec:ame the Chronicle. Like the Columbian, it was bought out by the Colonist (1866). A more successful try was made by James K. Suter in 1869. worked at the Colonist until Robson was hired as editor. Suter had Convinced that his demise at thO Coloniot was the wo•k of Robson, both he and his'M,ainlimr Guardian were to maintain a vig~rous feud with Robson for ~any years. ' This intensified \11{fien Robson opened the Pacific Herald in New Westminster ~-._J· in 1882. Even when Robson became a cabinet minister he continued to own the paper and ran it through his brother ,Lamb 1945:129) •. ·Competition between the Guardian and the Herald was personal and intense . • , \ - 50 - Until 1880, New Westminster was the metropole for the Lower Mainland area, but this v,.:as clearly to change with the completion of_ the CPR.· Everyone knew that the terminus of the Canadian Pacific Railroad would provide the ixnpetus for the _growth of a substantial city. Real estate fever dominated the area, and businessmen rushed to secure a foothold where they believed the terminus would be located. the terminus would be at Port Moody. Early thinking was that The Moodyyille Tickler was appro- priately begun in 1878 by W. R. Colbeck. It did not live out the year. Like the more substantial~ Moody Gazette (1883-1887) financed by James S?ter, the Tickler is only of historical interest, for the terminus was to be Vancouver. Three papers were 81dablished in the new city in 1886, the Weekly Herald!!!£ North Pacific News, the Advertiser, and the News. All three were burnt out by the great fire of the same year and all three came back. Th~ Herald was begun by William ~rown, who had previously published the Walkerton Herald in Bruce County, Ontario (Lamb 1942:2). Put into financial straits by the d,.e, Brown nevertheless changed the Herald fro~. a weekly to a daily in 1887 but was forced to fold in the same year • . The Vancouver Daily Advertiser was a much more substantially financed proposition. Owned by John Hay and edited by William Macdougall, it was from the first designed to be a high volume, low cost daily paper (Lamb 1942:6; Lamb 1945:l~l). Originally an afternoon paper, it quickly switched to compete directly with its major competitor, the Vancouver News.· < - 51 - The News was owned by N. Harkin and J. Ross, and like the' Advertiser began as a fairly large scale endeavor. Nevertheless, having two papers (the Advertiser and the News) in such a small city was unrealistic, and both were soon heavily in debt. ''\ .' In 1887 they were both bought out by Francis Carter-Cotton and were amalgamated as the News-Advertiser. Carter-Cotton had sub~tantial • financial help from R. Gordon. He also had high political ambitions, and like Robson and de Cosmos before him used his newspaper to further them. British born and largely ignorant of Canada or its traditions, CarterCotton was an ardent Conservative whose influence was soon felt in Vancouver and Victoria (Lamb 1945:193). The News-Advertiser was quickly expanded .and Carter-Cotton did everything he could to establish the paper a-s a monopoly in Vancouver, down to securing exclusive acce.ss to . I telegraph news from the rest of Ca-nada in the Lower Mainland (Lamb 1942: . 23); this telegraphic monopoly hurt the World badly (Lamb 1945:196). ~ Carter-Cotton was well rewarded for hls support of Conservative causes , ~ and became 'Minister of Finance and Agriculture under C. A. Semlin (18981900), Chief Commissioner of Lands and Works ( 1899-1900). and the first Chancellor of the University of British Colwnbia. Later, he became President of the Board of Trade (1913~ and Chairman of the Harbor Commiasion (1913). Save for a very brief period, he was in the provincial legislature continuously fo~ twenty six years. . Ca_rter-Cotton was a power- ful man. so much so that he wa:s able to be instrwnental in laving Joseph . Martin {later premi~r) removed from· the Semlin Cabi~et • Although his paper was a powerful fore~ in local affairs, CarterCotton was unable to secure a press monopoly. In -1890 the News- / _Advertiser's c~nstant attacks led Mayor Oppenheime:r:. and others to begin ' the . unsuccesrul Daily-Telegraph. Two years before, J. C. McLagan ' opened the V/ancouver Daily World. Mc Lagan had ~arlier J fegun the Victoria Times (1884) as an overtly pro-Liberal palliative to the Conse·rvative stance i of ~e Col?nist. ✓- McLagan' s World was likewise a supporter of th~ Liberals. __ : i Between '• . :·- . . i' 888 and 1898 the News-Advertiser and the World ~ngaged,. in~-i . . . . coi:nplex /bterplay in their respective presentations of the news 'wht:li, closely ~aralleled the relationship between the Victoria Colonist a~d .' the Times. i The editorial writers of the World consistently attacked the Conservatives and Carter-Cotton personally,, while the editorials of the News-Advertiser reacted similarly,to the Liberals. In both instances, w}?:a.t . was news was sever·e ly managed in the light of the political sympathies of the owners. It should be noted that this competition did. not occur in a vacuum. As readers, the whole of Vancouver participated in it as well. In a city of only 13,683 people (1891), the News-Advertiser claimed a circulation of 2,000 while the World's was 3, 500 and the TelegJ"aph' s was 750; a production of 6,250 daily new•papers in all (Lamb 1945:192.). In 1898 the New•-Adverti•er and the World were joined by a third newspaper, the Vancouver Province. In actuality, the Province wa• begun in 1894 as a Victoria based weekly by Hewitt Bostock, an affluent, Britishborn lawyer with high political aspirations. Bostock was himself a Liberal, and used th~wide-ranging weekly Province to help get elected in the YaleCariboo riding in 1896. He was the only· Liberal elected outside of Victoria. Bostock was later appointed to the Sepate by Laurier and subsequently became Senate speaker (Robin 1972:272). Bostock eventually sold his interest in the Province to W. C. Nichol, who completely changed the character of the newspaper. Nichol was one of· the first owner-editors of a major British Columbian newspaper to have extensive expeTience in the newspaper business. Before coming to Vancouver, Nichol had worked for newspapers in Toronto, London, and Hamilton, and had been one of the founders of Saturday Night. Upon secur- ing the Province he played well the already traditional rQle of the British Columbia newspaper owner. He was vitriolic and absolutely unrestrained in his personal attacks against his enemies. One of the first and foremost of what would eventually be a long line of victims was McLagan (and the World). At that time it was widely known that McLagan entertained hopes, of receiving a senate seat from Laurier as a p~y-off for the World's support of Liberal causes in British Columbia. In fact, the position wen,t to William J Templeman, the editor of the Victoria Times. Thereafter, in his attacks on McLagan Nichol consistently addressed him as "Senator;" these were of course more than personal rivalries, for Nichol was at least as ardent a Con ■ erwative as McLagan was a Liberal. - Similarly, Nichol addressed the . ·, Victoria Colonist as the 'Daily Dunsmuir," and was so defamatory in attacks on Premier J. H. Turner that the latter instigated a libel suit against Nichol (McGregor 1946: 100). Nichol was also closely allied with big business. After the Province moved to Vancouver and became a daily (1898) Bostock became increasingly detached from concerns of the newspaper, thus opening the way for Nichol to buy him out. In 1901 Nichol arranged a deal with Thomas Shaughnessy of the Canadian Pacific Railway whereby the Royal Trust Company would advance funds to Nichol sufficient. for him to purchase the Province (McGregor 1946: 105). It was especially after Nichol became sole owner of the Province that his true colors really c,.ame out. Well financed, tech- nically innovative and aggressive, the Province soon became the number one .. ! paper in Vancouver. Part of this rise in popularity was the result of weaknesses\ the two competing papers. In 1901 McLagan of the World died, leaving-the~ap~r temporarily witho1;1t direction. . It was eventually put back on track by his widow, who ran the World until it was bought by L. D. Taylor in _1905; the World nevertheless lost groqnd to the Province in the intervening years. The News-A~vertiaer' • chief pr~blem was rather thz_!;.l'ilVse--that Carter- e Cotton refusJd to die. Carter-Cotton's continuing influ~nce made the New1-Advertiser an archaic paper, locked into a nineteenth century idea of what was new,. Patronage froni Conservatives in government was one ·of the principle thing• keeping the New1-Adverti.1er alive at the· turn- of the century \ 4 ,. 55 i,' and it was not to last. With the takeover of the World by· L. D. T~ylor the competitio.n be~ . ' tween the Province and the World escalated sharply, so much so tha.t the ' Worlg unsuccessfully sued the Province for libel in 1907. L. D. Taylor was a Liberal and, like so many other newspaper owners, he had a good deal of politic~l ambition. 1 In 1910 Taylor ran for the mayor of Vancouver, . despite. advice that "the man who controls a Vancouver newspaper of good circulation has ~ influence than any. may~r--even more than the pnmier" (McGregor 1946:llb). Taylor won, and was to serve on and of.£ as mayor of Vancouver for a total of eleven years. He continued to control the World until selling the paper to John Nelson in 1917. • The World continued to be too weak financially to compete well with the Province. In 1910 Carter-Cotton finally sold the News-Advertiser to J. S. H. ~tson, who already controlled the Victoria Colonist and the Nanaimo H~ald. The News-Advertiser thereafter quickly conformed to Matson' s Conservative tendehcie s. John Ne hon, . late of ·the Victoria Times, •as ;'\ appointed manager. . The News-Advertiser suffered badly from a ·.1oss of < patronage when the Conservatives were routed from office (1916). The provincial Coneervatives had earlier directed their adver~sing and printing . ' almost exclusively to Conservative papers, as in 1913-11114, when $81,898 out of $87, 191 in government printing funds went toJ;onserYative supporter• (LaJnb 1942.:12.5). Several new newspaJpe~s came on the acen.e at this time. •• In 1907, , ' - 56 - Joseph Martin attempted to reverse the standard progression from news' paper owner to politician but failed. Martin had been a force in provincial politics for some time (and an enemy of Carter-Cotton) and opened th~ Morning· Gl!tardian in the hopes of returning to the fray. years. It only lasted a few Far more significant was the rise of the new weekly British · Columbia Saturday Sunset. Owned and run by John McConnell, the Saturday Sunset was an unabashed western copy of Saturday Night (McGregor 1946:122). Mc~Conrlell was a staunch Liberal, who used the Saturday Sunset to campaign r . fir a "White Canada," and to attack Lt. Governor Dunsmuir and the McBride qovetnment. He frequently charged the Province with being a tool of the GPR. \ . _McConn~ll' s ev~al success as a newspaper owner was decided in · ~rt by .the political failures of others. In the 1911 federal election the Lib;era1s were ~irtually wiped out in British Columbia; the Conservatives 1;riwnphe.d everywhere. In reviewing the disaster, party minions concluded I lbat·their inability t6' hold onto British Columbia in large part lay with the'ir I - , . lack of sufficient newspaper ~port (McGregor 1946:-123). Consequently. · in 1912 when the Saturday Sun•et metamorphosed into the daily V&nfOUver ~ it did so with sub•tantial Liberal party fOiancial support. It was able to start out immediately a• a full blown competitor to 'the Province and the ailing New1-Aclvertifer . . Under the management of F. C. Wade, whc> had previou•ly been a Liberal member ol the lep•lature (Robin l 97Z: 157-164), the 22 vigorou•ly -. \_I ,1-" . \ - 57 - (_ attacked the incumbent Bowser government, and was figured to have been instrumental in installing Harlan Brewster and the Liberals in 1916 r (McGregJ...._ 1946:127). So energetic was the electioneering fight between · the various papers that W,.,de was in debt over $30,000 by its conclusion. He was subsequently rewarded by being given the post of agent-general for British,-Columbia in Lohden • . At that point the Sun passed over to R. J. Crombie. Crombie's takeover of the Sun was made possible by the financial backing of Colonel ' J. W. Stewart, a railway_ · contractor who had secured enormously profitable contracts for-work on the .Canadian National R~ilwa,y and the Pacific . . Great Ea,.tern Raiiway. Stewart's f~m (Foley, Welch, Ste\llfart, and ~ann) was a heavy suppot:ter of Premi~r Richard .,McBride, who compensated . . - .• them handsomely. - . - . . An att;mpt cm ~e part · of Mcl3ride to · secure a g_over~. . ~ . . · ment loan of fj.ve mil.lion dohar s to the _financially over-e~tenqed,.firm · contributed to ;the premier's dem.ile. ' Stew~_rt' s suppor-t of the Liber4'1 S~ · .< . was an adroiti political move,. consid_ering ·the ri~ of . · Colwnbia.n ·~litiqs. . the Liberals· in Bi:iti11h ' . Not surprisingly, Crombie' s bilsic editorial posi~~ diverged from _that of the feder·a1 Wberils in that a, "p_ro '-West}' theme fre7 . . . ·.... "' . . : . _. . quently predominated_-. Pr_o "". W~ at -(re(JU:8ntly tr~sia~d intd a paa fc,~ greater provincial political ancf social autonomy, especi~lly via.! ,?lL ·r·a~-l - . way building. . ·:--r -· § - : •; . . .;. ln 1917 Crombie was in such an econonucally successful poeition ' that be wa1 aDle to buy out the New1-Advertitel'. -- He promptly killed the paper ;f I - 58 - and transferred its subscription list over to the Sun. This move left Vancouver with three newspapers, the overtly Liberal Sun, the Conservative Province, and the World. While the Wet"ld' s editor John Nelson was to leave the World to flirt with the People's Prohibition ~fove°"nt and the Provincial party, the World for the most part remained symp~eti~ to the Liberals through the ensuing years. The lnterwar Years ln the period between the two World Wars the press very slowly changed its character. As their capitalization increased, the newspapers became more like corporate businesses and less obviously like devices for the individual ends of owners. In order to protect themselves from the vagarities of the political arena, the papers also tended to become less active in their editorial support of specifically political positions, and began to take on the guise of being apolitical--of being "neutral watchdogs of the public' 1 interests." \ The press' s actual political involvement nevertheless continued to be significant through the era. Corporate consolidation of the Vancouver press began quite soon after the First World War. In 1921, John Nelson sold the World to Charles ' Campbell, · who was later to become secretary of the prpvincial Liberal organizing committee. In a stinging attack of the takeover, the fu!!!. claimed that an earlier suspicious sale by Campbell of a warehouse to the provincial liquor ..control board had allowed Campbell to buy out the World; they were · . .probably not v_ery far wrong. .• .J .. In 192-4 Campbell sold the World to Crombie - 59 - of the Sun, who promptly shut it down. Campbell quickly returned to the newspaper business by starting the new Evening Star. Victor Odlum, a prominent Liberal. He soon sold out to The Star was to continue on until 1932, ,I when it died a victim of the Great Depression. ... In 1920 W. C. Nichol was appointtd_Lieutenant Governor of British Columbia. Three years later he sold out his inter-est in the Province to William Southam and Sons, Ltd. which was then an eastern corporate chain of five newspapers. · The Southam Corporation continues to own the Province today. In essence, there were two major newspapers in Vancouver during the late twenties and thirties - -the Province and the ~ - Both continued to be competitive with each other, and diverged editorially on a number of issues. During the Tolmie years (1928-193 3), the Province supported the Conservative premier. Still under the control of Crombie, the Sun often attacked both the Province and Tolmie venomously: What is wrong with the Province newspaper as everyone in British Columbia knows is that it has gagged on that delectable diet of politic&! tripe known as the Tolmie government. (June 27, 1932 in Ormsby 1958:447) Thomas Pattulo (Liberal 1933-1941) was correspondingly villified by the Provipce (Ormsby 1958:455-6). Pattulo was not one to take such attacks lying down and once retorted that " the Province exhibits a spleen and venom which a seU reflecting ,newspaper should avoid" (Robin 197 3: 19). . . - 60 - Even· the Sun's owner-editor and one time friend frequently gave Pattulo a difficult time. ( Pattulo replied once that: Its brief owner is given to fads and fancies and suffers from mental dispepsia. He takes a hop, step, and jump around the world, picks up a lot of neurotic ideas and exploits them through the media of his newspaper in terms of finality which are evidently designed to create an impression of great profundity. (Robin 1973:19) The Pattulo regime gave the Sun editors a diificult time. They loathed the Province, and hence tended towards the opposite side of any In an overall sense this tendency con- issue that the Province supported. formed to their Liberal sympathies. it impossible to support Pattulo. At the same time, the _fu!£ often found Hence, it was considerably less politi- cally consistent than the Province, whose support of the Conservatives coincided nicely with a decided lack of sympathy for Pattulo. During the 1930' s the CCF began a long climb to prominence in British Columbia. They did so virtually without the support of the major metropolitan newspapers. In Vancouver, the Province was vehemently against the CCF, and constantly associated it and its supporters with Communism, anarchy, and labor. The~ was more flexible, and often supported CCF candidates or CCF ideas on ~ t the paper saw as their individual merits._ - ' Still, it never supported the CCF party or philosophy. The ~ • s sensitivity to the 'big story' insured that as an opposition party the CCF was not able to easily use the newspaper as a vehicle to spread its - 61 ideas. From the 1930' s to the present, neither the Province nor t h e ~ have supported the CCF or the NDP in a provi1'.icial election. Both papers supported the formation of a coalition wartime government excluding the CCF. As mentioned, a combination of the depressed economic conditions of the 1930' s and the increasing capitalization required in the newspaper business were severe constraints on anyone wishing to establish another newspaper in Vancouver. The only attempt which was successful in the short run was the News Herald, which rose out of the ashes of the Star in 1935. The News Herald was establish~d as a joint stock company managed, edited, and partially owned by individuals who had previously worked for the Star. It never had the financial clout to become a full competitor with the Sun and the Province, Qut through careful manage,ment and economizing was able to survive as an independent paper until 1951. During the 1930' s there were many areas of a less specifically political nature in which the Province's and Sun's position or type of pre sen- \ tatioii were very close to the sa.me. In one respect, these similarities rose directly from the fact that the format and the placement and arrangement of news in the Vancouver papers stabilized in the interwar years. Both papers developed approximately the same departinental divisions, located about the same place in the paper. Both attempted to increase the impact of the paper and its attractiveness to potential buyers by making the presentation of news more dramatic. Headline size increased, as did the number of photographs - 62 - accompanying news items. The rise of specific sections of the paper to do with business, sports, and the like allowed. both papers to significantly increase the density of spectacular and confrontational stories in the first section of the paper. Simultaneously, both papers were able to get "pre- packaged" news items about events in other parts of Canada and the world through the news agencies more cheaply than ever before. To a marked extent this informational dependency began to destroy the uniqueness of the individual papers. Slowly the presentation of news and even the style in which it was presented became dependent on people and processes outside of the control of a local press. The two papers also came together on a range of local issues and 1;>erspectives . .Both maintained one important press tradition from the past-British Columbian boosterism. On many important social issues of the era before World War I the press had found itself on the other side of Ottawa, and in many respects this tended to develop in the press a specifically Western (or rather Pacific Western) outlook. Regardless of the graft and influence peddling surrounding the construction of the railroads at all levels of government, the federal government was mor_e restrained than most, and often looked askance at the various railroad building schemes in British Columbia. Virtually always, ea.rly papers supported the provincial cause. , Likewise, the early press tended to support provincial interests in the .fight to terminate Asian immigration. These issues subsided in the interwar years. The railways were built , C . 63 - '. .. J Nevertheless the PrJll•vin~e an<;l and Asian immigratiorihad virtually ceas~d. f the Sun tended to continue to sing the praises pf B,ritish .Columbia in the ---: 'bopes that doing so would attract capital and tourists to British Columbia. Both papers also maintained a (fairly r.ealistict st~nce that .Ottawa s,.;,w British Columbia as a satellite hinter1and. ' This strain of tho{ight had always been an integral part of the· Vancouver newspapers, but in the interwa:r years it w~s less affected by the political st_ripe of those in.power in the -. nation's capital. · In earlier days the local papers tended to express a much \ greater allegiance to federal politisal parties and they would often mute their cries of eastern domination accordingly _whenever a party of their f particular persuasion reigned in Ottawa. • In short, several convergent forces were moving the newspapers towards each other with the consequence that the newspaper press ex}µbited less and less of a diversity of views. A near mo~pqly of news in print was not far away. The Post-War~: _Consolidation 12, Business!.! U.syal In 1946 a long and bitt~r strike of the ~rapher' s union at ihe Province severely weakened the paper's competit}x_e position with respect to the ~ (Nichol 1970:205). The Province was in any case a morning news- paper, and as such was already beginning to feel the effects of a nationwide shift among readers towards evening papers. ~ has From the early 1950' s on the been the preeminent Vancouver newspaper. In 1951 the Sun " Publishing Co. was able to buy out the floundering News Herald, but quickly , - 64 - . (1952) sold the paper to the Thompson newspaper chain when it found that the paper could not easily be turned ·around. . The early 1950' s also s;w., more changes in the political orientations of the Province and the Sun. ' W. A. C. Bennett was de signaled premier in 1953, with the CCF becoming the official opposition. Conservative parties were badly mauled. reaction was more interesting. Both the Liberal and Of the two papers, the Province's Bennett and his 1953 cabinet members were political and geographical outsiders. ' They were not from the traditional metropolitan establishment, and philosophically they diverged sharply from past traditions. One would have expected a cold reception from both Va:g.couver newspapers, but this was not to be the case. Barring an occa- sional editorial attack on the Bennett government's political and financial indiscretions, the Province usually approved of Bennett as an advo·cate of small government, a balanced budget and business dev&topment. This quick t alignment with Bennett shows that in reality the Province had earlier ceased to be a Conservative paper in the traditional meaning of the world. Rather, it had become conservative in the small-c sense that has become typical across North America. Like Bennett's, the conservativism of the Province had become nGn-reflective and non-philosophical. The fu!!!_ was leas kind to Bennett. From the earliest days of his administration the Sun sniped at Bennett's government but it pritnarily .attacked specific actions and activities rather than the government's performance as a whole. In 1956, the Sun continually mocked Bennett's "debt I • . - 65 reduction scheme" through which the premier purported to have eliminated ... ~~ . most of the province's outstanding d~bt. - Betw,-en- 1956 and -1958 the Sun continually broiled Highways Minister P. Gaglardi, and Minister of Lands, • Forests, and Mines, Robert Sommers for alleged graft. . '" Somer~ was moved ' J • to charge that the Sun's coverage of him was "the most dirty and. slanted in the history of British Cohunbia"(Robin 1973:199). Throughout the late 1950' s the positio~s of-the Sun and the Province remained much as they were. The Province supported the Socreds in the elections of 1956 and 1960, while t h e ~ still.attempted to advocate a Liberal government- -which was then a political impossibility (Robin 197 3: 219). Similarly, the Province was much tno'l"e supporti.ve of Bennett's in- famous~aling s with Axel Wenner-Gren than the~- The}e differ~nces were not so ;iubstantial as to keep the Sun and Province from ioi_tiating a joint business venture· which they continue today. When the Newe Herald finally folded in 1957 the printing· plant was bought by Pacific Press Ltd.,_ a ~mpany owned jointly by ~un Publi;hing Co. and_ Southam Press Ltd., controlling owners of the Pfgvince. ' . The~ and Province were subsequently printed at the same facility by Pacific_Press, even though their eclitor~d reporting staffs remained distinct. No lottger were their interests strictly ·se,parate. .- Throughout the 19_60' a the Province and t:Ae ~ cbntinued to hlic attacks on each other and upon those in governm.ent were also attacks against their polJ.ticaf competition-_-against those who either held or aspired to the same positions as they. There were nevertheless a great number of commonalities in the way that the various newspapers portrayed events. The formal constraints of 71 - producing the news were always ~ t } l e sam• for all. Moreover, the rule of thumb fo .r what was and was not· news also tended-to be , ~uc·h the same, at . least with respect to a partfcular era. The newspapers have 'always been sensitive to the unusual, and hence deviations fr · everyday 1~ rather \ than everyday life itself have always dominated the n '- ~ commonalities sprung from the context of British Columbia~ ) Almost by definition, people who have had the financial' and political power to own and operate newspapers have not been representative of British Columbian society at large. For the most part the British Columbia press has been dominated.by representatives of th~ upper-middle class. ' The ' daily press was never the preserve of the ")ll'orking population--at least not .at the levels where control is exercised. Moreover, without exception all of the owners and editors of Vancouver's newspapers up to. the l 9b0' s have been of Anglo origin; a great many e>f them were either British, Scottish, or Angl~Cana~ans from Central Canada • • The papers owned and edit,e d by these men primarily reflected the interests of business and the well-to-do. Through the history of British Columbia the newspapers have continually spoken out for increased incentives to busines·s. Eadier they cried out fo'r federal subsidies for more railroads; later th_ey entertained great hopes for a trade with the Orient. They were always suspicious of Ottawa. ~ ' The middle class orientation of the :qewspaper press was also evident • i\i its lack of support for labor. With the exception of such 'no win' issues as - 72 . __,,,- -· oriental immigration,-t1?-e press ra•relysupported the position of working · people. . Unions ,got very bad press in the crucia,l orgaq.izing years of 1.870-1920. Similarly, the interests and concerns of ~orking "eople were "' rarely rep!'esented by the newspapers until the yost World Warr II era, when f""" -\ ~ ~ the democratization of middle class values and pr~vile_ges allowed what was still a middle class perspective on the world.to :represent more people than ~ ,. it previously did. ' The post-..,... era has seen two corporately controlled newspapers establish a monopoly on the news in Vancouver. readership is now assured. r They are newspapers who~e Substantial profits are more or less guaranteed; o~ average, Canadian newspapers with circulations above 100,000 all averaged more than 16% after tax profits between 1965 and 1970 \Davey 1970: 5 6). Not only do the Province .and the Sun collaborate in printing their '1 'separate' newspapers; they have also developed an agreement whereby ~ business advertisers are forced to advertise in"both papers {Davey 1970:44}. Moreover, their market is largely independent of the price of their product. There is therefore no particular financial incentive for today's Vancouver newspapers to do more than go through the motions of presenting "- the news. Many businesses depend almost entirely on newspaper adver- tisin'g to reach the publ{c for they know that the great majority of households subscribe to them. Advertisers are unconcerned with the quality of news in the press and readership seems to continue at a high level no matter what passes for news in the papers. ;.. There_ is literally no profit in todays - 73 - newspapers being innovative, provocative, or the champions of anything. These things still happen on the odd occasion, but they are holdovers from. a past ideology of the p.ress which even historically was rarely put into practice: , ' Still, de spite the frequency that one hears that people do not read ~e newspapers anymore or that the newspapers do not reaiJ.y ha.ve any significant impact on today's society, this is just not so. No better instance of this has been documented than the Vancouver newspaper s'trike of 1970 and its effect on its abal'ldoned readership. The strike shut down the Province and the Sun from February 15, 1970 to May 15, 1970. The Sele ct Senate Committee contracted a study to gauge its effects, and they were substantial. Fir st of all, it was found that Vancouver people were addicted to their newspapers~ In a sample of 125 residents, only three did not subscribe to a newspaper. Ninety-two subscribed to one of the two major dailies, while another 26 subscribed to both. In addition·, there were 23 subscriptions to # papers other than the Province or the Sun; 141 newspaper subscriptions in a sample of 125 people (Davey 1970:139)~ There was no doubt that these readers missed their newspapers. I j Seventy-nine (63. 2%) "felt deprived of news and information during the shutdown," as compared with 33 (26. 4%) who did not. Moreover, it was !!,2! the lack of advertising that they most sorely missed, as has 'been so often suggested as the main reason people continue to subscribe to newspapers. - 74 I Seventy- six (52. 8o/o) re s~ndents listed the loss of front page news as a ... section of the.d)aper they missed a·s opposed to twenty-three (18. 4%) who listed advertising; the editorial page (n = 45) and the sports section (n = 41) were more frequently listed than advertising, which shared its pos\tioq with the comics and the theatre and entertainment section. ~ Relatively few of the respondents (n == 35) felt that radio and TV news filled the void left by ~·. the loss of their daily paper. / I t is not difficult to prov,ide more general support for th,e contention that the newspapers have been and continue to be important social institutions. It is true that to this very day the ~~odox position held by many " press spokespersons is that the newspapers do not substantially affect people's opinions and beliefs--they just priht "the facts. 11 Earlier pub- lishers were even more forthright, and sometimes claimed that in any case what the press did or did not do was no one else's affair. W. P. Hamilton of the Wall Street Journal has been reputed to have assert_~ d that: A newspaper is a private enterprise owing nothing whatever to the public, which grants it no franchise. It is therefore affected with no public interest. It is emphatically the property of the owner, who is selling a manufactured product at his own risk. (Peterson 1976:73) In short, newspapers are businesses, and let th~ buyer beware. Although they never reached this extreme, in the earlier days of the_British ' Columbia press one ·c an frequently see. evidence of a similar philosophy. In the postwar era newspaper publishers have in no way shied away • . - 75 ·.,; from the fact that they a:re businesses, n'rst and foremost. - Nev-erthelesfi, to an increasing extent they he,ve sousht:to-,propagate a somewhat contra_: .. . . dictory ideology '-Yhich is now current in all industries: that as good ·, corporate citizens newspape_rs have a social responsibili:ty•to serve their _. clientele; tq,ey .are an essential element of-s.Ociety; _and h'ence~'sh.~':11d ac~nowle_dgl: their social function and address it squarely • ..Parado::icically, the rise of this "social responsibility theory of the .( J',i. press" {Peter son 1976:73-103) seems to have le~ to the concomitant rise of ________,.--- ~ - conviction among press personnel that they do not have a substantial impact on the people they "se~ve"; they are professionals, whose job it is to capture in print the world as it is; they, should not be tied to anyone, publ_isher, owner, politician, businessman, or friend, and henc·e should not be the advocate of any special interest group; the newspapers are' only communications devices, facilitating the flow of information from one part 4 of society to another. This conviction that the press is a neutral mirror on the world that doesn'ttaffect anything seems a bit tenuous when one considers the histor- ical role of the Vancouver press .given here. It seems.c:., more unrealistic when one returns to the original pr,emise that newspapers are first and foremost manufacturing industries in business to make money. Like any other manufacturing company a newspaper makes money by selling more of its product or by increasing its profit margin by increasing prices or decreasing capital and labor costs. Publishers and other rrianagerial ' - 76 ~ ' ~ "--,, ' i. .. • pe__rsonnel c;9ritfoue · rn thei: job'9' by demonstrating that tI,ey h _a v~ successfully tackle~ these objectives. ' Succe-ss ~e.re me~ns the ·ability _t~ exert·. cqntrol pver p~oduction _a rid hence, ·o'ti'er "tha news. .... • The se goal~nd ,, 0 . ,strategJ~_,s_ do not in any respect parallel the avowed premises of the -social re sponsil;>ility of the press. ... .. • / _ In .t his light one must consider -that the "social re sponsipqity of the •· - .. "" press" is primarily an ideology used by those who control newspapers .to defend their privileged (and almost totally unregulated) position in the so-cial and economic world; it should be noted that as the ideology unfolds it is I clear that press responsibility i~ not cast/as a goal--it is claimed to be already achieved. The primary ~eason for this success is ·frequently - claimed to be th~ fact that press personnel is "free" (read uncontrolled) to ~ . act autonomously. Like any substantial social ideology, press ideas about its role in society has found considerable academic support, which the press has in turn used to give further credence to its own conviction. This is especi- ally the case for the premise that the press does not markedl_Y affect society or individual beliefs. In the 1950' s and 1960 s this stance was supported by 1 ,. a crop of exceedingly naive but very influential American social scientists. Addicted to narrowly conceived survey re search and to the investigation of immediate cause and effect, they produced research findings showing that the press could not influenc·e the public. (Klinebe rg 1974:37-55). It could not sway elections Neither could it make people change their opinions . - 77 .... • .,,. about important issues (Katz 1964). ) More rec,eqt _work has expose~ the weakne~ses of this kind 6£ work ' ,... _,. .... (Halloran 1974:9-36) . . . . :? •i .. , . F9r on.e - thing, earliet investigations looked for . .◄ ' · · •· ·~ffects of only on~ sort: imfuediat~, • surface level eha~ges in betief and behavior. in sample population.:3,"' They d\d, not -inv.est?igate what Ls in all f ~ . . probabili-ty the most important ,effect of the pre~s: . maintaining already . "' . • ..... consider the degree to which the newspapers effect,charige incrementally, . as individuals· integrate material from a number of items. Thirdly, they were.extremely literal in their analyses, and hence failed to investigate the . relationship between the assumptions built into new.s items and ana.11,gous assumptions iri the reading P':1blic (Rock 1973) . Fourthly, they refused to ask what seemed to be the most elementary question--where do beliefs . about things outside of one's immediate experience come from, if not from the media? Although this tradition dies 'hard (especially in the light of newspaper interests in its perpetuation), modern research has delivered it some telling blows. There is gathering .consensus that in many respects the newspapers are the most influential of all the mass media (Edinborough 1962: 15), To be sure, radio and television have given the newspapers a run for their money, but in certain respects the obser'~a.tion that the electronic media have broken the news monopoly of the newspapers is incorrect. Newspapers anjieir associated news service provide a ·; ,.. .,, , - 78 ' .. ' . substantial proportion of the ll)f·o:r:rnation used by .. r -a dio .· , . . .· ~nd °ieleviJi~n; 138) of the.broadcasti~g networks in the United Stat~_i;;. Electronic media o· , . · < ~iegel (1_97~:5-6} .£Qund this to be so of the CBC, as did Bagdikian ( 1~9_71: ' ~- outlets with fewer resources than ,the CBC would presumably be even more dependent upon riew-sp~per c,opy.. r . Moreover, the press i---l! not politically neutral, and hence makes a . very irnpqrtant contrib. }.ition to the Canadian political_. scene (Siegel 1974) ~ . -, . -.. JI, • -. e . . -~ o' \ . ...• ... To be sure, the kind of partisan p,olitks typical of B.ritish ~dlum_b ian .. - ~ newspapers at the turn of the century are no longer prevalent today, but the impact of the newspapers afe no less significant, despite the fact that_ their contribution is of a different sort than previously. · P"litics. Consider national ]few Canadians realize how small the- Ottawa press gallery. is, yet it is the source of parliamentary news for the nation. Their selection of coverage generally defines the presentation of national politics. More- over, the clublike, elitist atmosphere of the Ottawa press corp hardly encourages . a diversity of opinion. Their "business as usual," blow-by- blow coverage of the political scene constitutes a world view, a definitio I of the situation with direct political consequences. They set the agenda and in doing so provide pervasive limits to the realm of acceptabl ~ . discourse. As the following three chapters unfold it should become evident that the way in which the press constrains discussion of politics is only a specific instance of a more general pattern. The newspapers relentl.e ssly • • define a particular version.of the universe by complex processes of associ- • ation and inference. • They, detii'!t; ."normal society" ,in reia:tio11. to what· it· is . ... • ongoing dis!l'i.9Ution af·power andJ~rivilege in Canadian §o.ciety. Of the many way-s in which the newspapers do this the primary-question is what st constitutes news; ,ili !. ~ ethnicity I wj.11 have much to say about this " I • , ,.. , subsequently. Nevertheless~ 'it wq.uld not be overstating the case to claim • that one 'of the priTilary outcomes of the w~y that the newspapers select news ,J .. ~ ' ;"' 1' ''\ is to turn the universe into a gr.hldmorali:ty play where good and evil are locked in combat; like in morality plays the press focuses in on person- . y--- \' ali~~sychologie s, and there is little discussion of societal con- \-'. straints or whether the individuals involved might want to change the rules \... of combat. Like moralio/ pl,9-ys the moral schema of the newspapers is not a normative societal one. Rather it corresponds closely to the convictions of societal elite? (Clement 1975 :276-283). To the extent that ethnicity is news.it is submitted to these same processes. Newspaper publishers have been and are members of the Canadian 5 upper class. Most of them are of British Canadian origin outside of 6 Quebec, as are a substantial proportion of management personnel. One would reasonably expect this to be reflected in the newspapers they create. This expectation is easily confi.rmed when one turns to the portrayal of ethnicity in the Vancouver press in the decade before World War I. ..., • •. l . - 80 - Chapter Two: Notes ' . . Taylor was in .f act reguired to supp<4t the ~aurier government ·as an informal condition of his mortgage 61-th_JIJJ-~orld (McGregor 1946: . . . 11 3). . 2. This daim is ~le~,rly supported by the rr:ateria1 ·i.n "this -th!!sis dealing 11 with the categoi:ie s "Canadian, "Anglo Can.adi,ci.:n, II ~nd "French · Can'-dian." -~ . 3. 4. -~ . • Even advocation of the terminatign .pf Asian immigration could 'f>e argued to primarily refle t:t h;l.iddle class interests, such as those of farmers and small businesses. ,, Of course, this c.redd says nothing of the level of competem:e of press personnel. As John Porter (1965:485) has point,ed out, "there is, of course, nothing professional about the role of newspaper reporting. . As a group repoders have no disciplined acatlemic training in a,n y . particular sphere, although they seem prepared to write about almost 11 anything. . 5. Clement ( 1977:207; 1975: 3 30) suggests that something over 70% of the media elite are of upper class origins. 6. Indeed, a recent study (Pitman 1977:242-243) showed that the metropolitan Toronto press personnel involved with newsp.aper content are very likely to be of British origin down tp the lowest levels of decision making. To take the other extreme, only 2% were from visible minorities. Clement (1975:334-6) claims that 81. 9% of the national media elite are of British origin; 13. 3% were French and 4. 8% were of other backgrounds. • \ - 81 # Chapter Three: Ethnicity and the Vancouver Presa (1905-19\4) This chapter has two basic goals: to de scrib'e the portrayal of ethnicity in the Vancouver press of 1905-1914 on a group by group basi~ .and to provide a social and soci:_9logical context for that description. Causal . . explanation of why the press chose to present ethnicity in the way that i~ dtd . is now largely impossible; those who created the early newspapers are now . '.. . . ·,,• gone/ ?-nd' the hi,torical rec.ord is insufficient for ¢e purpose. • 11atives, .however, need not be limited to tlie descriptive. • The alter- " In this and · -A . following eras I have attempted to explain press portrayal from three . ~ interwoven points of view. First, I have tried to ~ompare the cov~rage given to any one ethnic group with that received by other groups. in this sense, I have created a press worldview· of ethnicity, a worldview which defined the lines of the ethnic moral community very tightly indeed. In the world of the pl"es~ are to be found examples of the sociaJly valued expression of ethnicity and examples of ethnic outcasts. Secondly, I have provided a social context for each of the groups which received a significant amount of press coverage, including factors such as their place in British Columbian society, economy, and polity, their group image in Canada, and British Columbians' views of their relationship to the home countries of these people. This social background serves two purposes, the first of which is to make understandable the specific types of news items found for each ethnic group. It has also been used to help explain the general shape and tenor of the image of each group ,I . . .,, • as presented by the press. . - 82 •. Thirdly. I ,have trie As 'prospective Canadian irri- migrants, the British have had a "special entry status'' until very recently and they have been as soc_iated· very closely with one of the two charter groupa--i..Q. Canada. Moreover, the British irn,migrant waf! rarely seen as a "foreigner." in this country nor' were the British often considered to be an ) "ethnic group". (Careless 1969:10). Especial-ly in this earlier era, the 8 British were oft:A seen as being a particular variety of Canadian. This association between Canadianness and British ethnicity was reflected in the ,, fact that for the most part the English, Scots or Welsh were not e~pected to adopt new cultural values or ways of doing subsequent' to coming to Canada / (Porter 1974:60-103). Rather, they were often used as ideal types a~d were T seen as the carriers of a cultural heritage to which Canadian people should aspire.. One sees this tendency for the British to be set up as models for - 113 - other Canadians very ~learly reflected in their moral community scores. In the Empire-oriented, Conservative Province, ScoJs, British and English were evaluated well above Canadians; while French Canadians scored lower than Russian inunigrants. Perhaps because the British were so often seen as equivalent to ideal models for Canadians, they have been rather consistently defined as Canadians by both the sociological and the folk literature of Canada (Careless 1969:10). The consequence is th~t much of the British irllmigrant experience which could have been viewed· in an ethnic relations paradigm has been defined simply as part of normative Canadian social and economic •organization. With this ease with which British _immigrants were subsumed under the label "Canadian" has also come the inaccurate conviction that the British in Canada constituted a homogenous group, albeit o.ne which _had class or ·status divisions despite being culturally homogeneous~ In fact, there were (and are) many types of British immigrants to Canada. Ethnically, Scots, English and Welsh all fell under this classification as British, yet "Considered themselves distinct; within each of these groups . in turn existed great regional and religious variability (Careless 1969:4). There were also enormous differences in the class backgrounds of these inunigrants. Among them were skilled and unskilled workers, agricultural laborers, businessmen, professionals, and elites. At times, the interests of these various types of individuals would coincide and at others not. instance, at the turn of the century many British immigrants in Canada ~ For - 114 - agreed that unskilled, poor British citizens were not desirable as immigrants. 6 Alternatively, skilled blue collar workers in British Columbia continually lobbied that only British domestic and agricultural workers be solicited as immigrants (Woodsworth ~909). Tradesmen, they claimed, were walking the streets in Canada (Province, July 11, 1913, page 1). This was paralleled by the concerns of many British Columbia economic elite, who wanted continued imrn.igration but did not want skilled workers froin Britain, who they saw as labor trouble makers (Parkin 1895:14). With this variability in mind, the overall impact of British immigration on the province was nevertheless great. Many Britisp Columbian notables were British born (Jackman 1969; Lamb 1942; McGregor 1946). The participation of skilled British workers in the creation of labor parties ' and the trades and labor unions was very great (Phillips 1967;,Robin 1972). ,• British immigrants we re highly represented in Vancouver and provincial ~ political offices and still others made their impact as captains of industry and . 7 f 1nance. Consider, too, that Canada was then firmly part of the British Empire. Still in part economically dependent on British capital, Canada was ideologically tied to Britain and the legitimations for the British role in Canada were very powerful. To make Canada British, P111>testant and White was a constant theme in the de~elopment of we-stern Canada (Ward 1973; Nelson 1921). These legitirnations also were developed on other fronts. For instance, - 115 - '-consider the still current belief in the British immigrant's influence on Canadian' s "deep respect for tradition, law and order." These and other "British" traits, have been argued to have had a sustained influence upqri · Canadian institutions and soc_ial order (Lipsett 1963:49-258; Underhill 1960: 12). Whether these presumed connections are valid is quite inelevant, for they were important in the realm of ideas. Lack of violence and con- servatism is often cited as major differe}lces between the United States and Canada (Grant 1958; Lower 1958; Lipsett 1963). Moreover, turn of the. century middle class British Columbians in particular were very Anglophile (Hobson 1906:32) and they tended to define themselves in contrast to ~se on the other side of the border who were in fact so culturally ·and economically similar. Clearly, this ideology served the interests of virtually all classes of British-born in the province. In addition, the early development of large scale industry in the province indirectly provided the pro-British tendencies of the middle class with ~ti.anal support and helped to generate the fundamental ethnic polarization ,r ' for which British Columbia of the turn of the century is noted. In response to the rise of industry many skilled British immigrants came to British Columbia to fill a variety of skilled and semi- skilled jobs. It is not sur- prising that when they perceived that they were being threatened by a flool - . of "cheap labor" from Asia and Europe they turned to their ethnic origins as a justification of their own privileged position. The high salience of immigration as a social and economic question in - 116 - British Columbia also made British ethnicity a political question, which was reflected in the philosophical stances of the Conservative and Liberal parties. The Conservative vision of the day was one, of a Canada that was firmly, safely, and forever within the British Empire (Berger 1970). If any.thing, Conservatives sought to strengtheJ\ Canadian cultural ties to Britain .through selective immigration and through trade preferences. They saw Canada as I primarily an Anglo-Saxon c-0uhtry with British institutions and culture, and they were intent upon developing its ~opulation on the basis of British immigrants--immigrants who were the "carriers" of this civilization. The Liberals would certainly have liked to have had a British-only immigration policy if immigrants could have been found in the United Kingdom who matched the manpower requirements for Canadian economic, development. Failing that, Liberals were not adverse to looking elsewhere for inunigrants. The Liberal version of nationalism differed as well. Ethnically, Canada would be a "melting pot, sumably had become. 11 as American society pre- Economically,_ Canada would seek international advantages in trade and industry wherever these benefits were to be found. Ideologically more in line with American thinking, Canada and Canadians would be molded into a :'new" North American Nation. In all respects, the Liberals could be said to have been more "internationalist" or "continentalist" in outlook than the Conservatives, who were willing to allow proBritish considerations a much more important role in Canadian economic development (Laxer and Laxer 1977: 19). - 11 7 - Detached as it was from a philosophical dependence on Britain, "British institutions" and the like, Liberal policy on who constituted a proper Canadian was much mo re economically oriented than the Conservatives and was consequently much more ethnically encompassing and less Anglophile than was their competition: Although in British Columbia this Liberal sentiment was considerably muted, the differences between Liberal and Conservative philosophy remained. Considering their numbers, and their importance in British Columbian . society, one would have expected that British ethnicity would have been a predominant element of news presentation in this era. In fact, it was not. The Province and the World devoted but 8. 9% and 8. 3% of their respective domestic ethnic coverage to the British, in direct contradiction to that thesis so often put forward by members of the press- -that it accurately reflects what is importa·nt in everyday life. Neither 1s the range of topics dealt with in British coverage representative of societal happenings, as Tables XXVil through XXIX indicate. - 118 - Topics and Subtopics Vancouver Province number % Vancouver Daily World number % 1 2. 1 1 2. 1 1 1 2. 1 2. 1 1 2. 1 1 1 1 1 2. 1 2. 1 2. 1 2. 1 2 3 3 4.2 6. 3 6. 3 Legislative & Legal discussion of limitation debate on immigration ~other 1 1 1 2. 1 2. 1 2. 1 /v~olence, Hostility Against victim oi iarime 2 4.2 Education Health &: Welfare are a drain on services Employment &: Economy seek jobs cause unemployment more needed for work are poor workers buy or own property are cheap labor 1 2. 1 1 2. 1 3 6. 3 1 1 2. 1 2. 1 Advocation of Restriction should deny ethnic ways should deny immigration 1 2. 1 Charge Restriction charge barred from services 1 2. 1 Ethnic Relations relations get better relations are good relations are bad try to impose ways Immigration too much many come arri·1e should be aided in are deported are solicited by Canada profit on immigration 3 1 6. 3 2. 1 2 1 4 5 1 1 1 1 4.2 2. 1 8. 3 10.4 2. 1 2. 1 2. 1 2. 1 .:: - l 19 ~ :::,, "' Violence, Hostility By accused of crime other Cultural Differences huinor home country loyalty Canadianness urged best cultural practices number % ,J 2. 1 2. 1 1 . 1 2. 1 1 2. 1 Celebrities entertainers social notables other 1 1 2. 1 2. 1 2. 1 Spurts participate in 1 2. 1 Ethnic Organizations ethnic festival organization takes role organize concertsother l' 2 4.2 1 3 2. 1 6. 3 number % 4 8. 3 1 3 1 2 2. 1 6. 3 2. 1 4.2 1 2. 1 1 4 2 2 1 2. 1 8. 3 4.2 4.2 2. 1 4.2 2. 1 100. 0% Normal News humanist victim of accident 4 2 4.2 2 1 Total 48 100.0% 46 Table XXVll. e. 3 British Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Yancouvsr Province and Vancouver Daily World (1905-1914) ;, - 120 - Vancouver Province number .:!L To:eic ::f Vancouver Daily Worlq number i 8 16. 8 10 21. 0 4.2 7 14. 7 6 12. 6 3 6. 3 Ethnic Relations 4 8. 4 4 3. 6 Violence, Hostility By 2 ....Ll. 4 --2.:...2. 36 79. 8% 36 75.6% Immigration 16 Ethnic Organizations 8 Cultural Difference 2 Employment & Economy Total Table XXVllI. The Most Frequent Topics of Domestic British News · Items: Vancoµver Province and Vancouver Daily World (1905-1914) Theme Ethnic Organizations Vancouver Province iumber Vancouver Daily World number 11 14 Immigration 16 6 Legal & Legislation 9 8 Cultural Differences 8 8 Employment and Economy 12 4 Ethnic Belations 4 4 Crime By Ethnics 2 4 Table XXIX. '--J Most Common Themes in Domestic British News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World (19051914) \\ - 121 - Moreover, coverage of British ethnicity was heavily concentrated into a few areas; the seven most frequently coded topics accounted for over✓ the news items dealing with British ethnicity in both papers. The immigration of British settlers and the consequences of that immigration we~e involved in a number of the news items in either paper, but this general subject was covered quite differently by the Conservativeleaning Pr-ovince and the Liberal World. In terms of percentages, the Province devoted 33. 4%-,of its British coverage specifically to immigration, which was double that of the World (16. 8%). Moreover, reference to Tables XXIII and XXIV will show the Province s evaluation of British eth1 nicity was very much higher than that of the World; the moral community scores for the British were +O. 62 (Province) and +0. 06 (World), re spectively. , Typical of these stories would be the report that ', SETTLERS POUR IN FROM BRITAIN Five Hundred Expect to Reach Vancouver by Monday Evening (Province, April 5, 1911, page 1) or that there was a RUSH OF SETTLERS TO CANADA Increasing Tide to Dominion Follows Industrial Troubles in British Isles. Canadian Chamber of Commerce will Adopt Energetic Policy of Publicity. (Province, April 13, 1912, page 28.) In general, the Province reflected its Conservative leaning~ in its positive coverage of British immigration. The constant theme was that British were the superior type of immigrant, and should be actively solicited - 122 - in order to develop British Columbia and provide the province with continuity with its British roots. The World did not oppose this view; rather it stood mute on the subject. 1 The World more frequently emphasized the individual attributes and the group characteristics of the British in Canada than it did the more abstract themes develop:d by the Province. For instance, 20. 9% (n = 10) of the World sample dealt with cultural festivals and other happenings associated with ethnically British organizations in British Columbia. Most of thi~ coverage in turn dealt with Scottish organizations, which may reflect the heavy personal involvement of the World's former owner J. C. McLagen (Lamb 1942:40) in this area. It is surprising that neither pa.per chose to represent British ethnicity as a significant factor in the ongoing provincial economy, save in rela,n to how British immigrants might help provide the stable manpower and initiative to build up British Columbia. / Throughout this era of boom and bu st, economic is sues were a fundamental aspect of newspaper concern, yet the British-born were rarely singled out on ethnic criteria as being relevant to economic conditions. In many respects the British-born were not defined by· the newspapers as foreign. For instance, in counting how many people had entered Canada, the Province (June 30, 1911, page 18) claimed that nearly two million immigrants had come in the last decade, of whom "750,000 were British, 700,000 from the United States and 650,000 were Foreign." ~ ~ c e s of - 123 - this tendency of considering that the British were not ethnic can be taken from the papers almost at will. Immigration and the British Columbia labor situation provide excellent examples of this process. For instance, the World editorialized (January 31, 1908, page 6) about ''Immigration Troubles in Canada, 11 criticizing the Salvation Army for bringing immigrants to Canada that were lazy and irresponsible, yet neglects to mention that these immigrants were exclusively British; immig.rants, rather than the British are the stigmatized 8 group. Labor news was handled in much the same manner. The two decades prior to World War I were perhaps the most turbulent in British Columbia's labor history (Phillips 1967). It was a time of increasing industrialization in the face of extreme employer-employee conflict. Strikes ~which were continually in the news) were countered by the solicitation of "cheap labor" from the United Kingdom, Asia and Europe and occasionally were broken by the militia (Morton 1970); the British-born were active agents on both sides of this battleline, yet their ethnicity was rarely reported in the pap-ers. For instance, when the Province (May 29, 1912, ~ 1) reported that in the aftermath of a strike that the "Law-Breakers are Foreigners" it neglects to mention that most of them were British. Likewise, the extensive coverage of the Nanaimo coal strike of August, 1913 in both papers failed to mention that a large number of the union leaders were British-born, as were many of the off ice rs of the militia which was brought in to break the strike - 124 - -- (Silverman 1970:157); if the Italian or Chinese component o.f either side had ~, .- . been equally signific~nt their ethnic presence would have been given p~ominent coverage. · Similarly, coverage of the British-born in the early press would lead one to the incorrect conclusion that they rarely broke the law- -i_n the world of newspapers, criminality was almost completely the preserve of Asians, Native Indians, Italians, and other "foreign" types (Vall~e and Schwartz 1961:565). Most reported instances of the British-born either participating . in or being the victims of crime did not include an ethnic reference. In ord,er for British ethnicity to be reported in crime stories that background had to be an iiitegral part of the story itself: "Bill Sykes" is Captured. Member of Respectable English Family Learned to Steal in Toronto. Couldn't find work and was too proud to beg. (World, June 2, 1909, page 5) Scotchmen Who Desert Their Wives Sir George Macrae Seeking Means of Tracing Them. Distinguished Britisb Statesman now on a Visit to Victoria. I (Province, October 12, 1912, page 11) When one dra~s back from the specific events presented in the press, '> . a definite image of the British emerges. The British-born were pc,~rayed as a homogenous group who were not differentiated from the general \ Vancouver population. If anything, they were to stand as models for other Canadians in their cultural practices and their love of order and good 125 government. ··As such, they were neither foreigners nor deviants. Rather, they we-r~ portrayed as staunch defenders of the British tradition in Canada . . • .agai~st the disrupting· ideas of foreigners and Americans. Asians In terms of the a'mount of coverage devoted to them, Asians figured more impo'rtantly than any other group during this era. 1 1 Of all the ethni- cally related domestic news items presented in the Province, Asi~ r~ceived 48. 3o/o of the total. In the World, Asians received 49. 6%, (c;i" . virtually one half of all the news items dealing with ethnicity during this decade. This intense coverage was certainly ,U2!. warranted by their numbers. In 1881 there were estimated to have been.only 4,350 Asians in all of British Columbia. While this figure increased rapidly in subsequent decades, reaching 19,524 in 1901 and 30,864 in 1911 (Glazebrook-1966:189), the growth of the Asian population of the province did Qt keep up with that of the g~neral population. a pane se together For instance, Chinese accounted for 26. 5% of the foreign-born population of V ncouver in 1901, but only 9. 3% of the foreign-born population in 1911 (MacDonald 1970:310)., ~ Asian immigrants to British Columbia came primarily.from three source countries: Chin&, Japan, and India. While individuals from these three countries moved into relatively siinilar social ,nd economic conditions in British Columbia, their ~sources and objectives were quite distinct, one fro01 the other. The Japanese, for instance, were able to - 1-26 - dra:w upon political support from their home government as well as psycho- . logical support from their conviction that Japan was then rising to world j prominence (Brown and Cook 1974). Indian immigrants poss_essed consider- able knowledge of how British political and legal institutiQ!}S ope rated· and were able to ~se this knowledge as a resource, despite receiving almost no home government support whatsoever ( ~ l 97;:47-48~. Wracked by internal strife and ravaged by colonializing p~wers, China was unable to • regulate or assist its i m ~ in any significant fashion (:6rown and Cook 1974:69; Jacob_s and .Landa\! 1971:124-15(. In addition, both the press and people of British Columbia drew sharp distinchons between the Chinese, Japanese and South Asian Indians. In due regard both for the different resources of these immigrants and for the fact that they were characterized by the press as being distinct, each of these groups are discussed separately. ~ Chinese The first Chinese immigrants to North America went to California. The responses developed in r~action to their presence in that state were to be carried over almost entirely into the British Columbian context (Howay 1,41:567-8; Wa~d 1973:7). The initial Chine·se pioneers to California came (as did many thousands of Europeans) in response to the word ·that gold had been found c'n 1848. As mining expanded and California developed an industrial base, Chinese increasingly moved into situations of wage labor, where through no fau)t of their own they soon came· into conflict with - 127 Europfran workers (Jacobs and Landau 1971:124-158). Employers exploited ~ the political weakness of the Chinese by using them to subvert the demands of white labor. The Chinese were used as strike breakers and as a means of depressing the wage demands of other workers. Lacking the political resources to move directly against employers, organized labor used its political influence to get a wide range of anti-Chinese laws passed restricting Chin-ese immigration, political representation, and labor rights. A parallel and related sequence developed in British Columbia. Once mo_re, the first Chinese arrived in response to a gold rush, this'. titri.e in 185 8. Again, anti-Chinese hostility di_d not become an important political ,,, factor until the 1870' s, when the industrial economy was beginning to develop _ (Howay 1942:567-8). From 1872 on, the British Colurh?ia legislature was to pass an unending stream of anti-Chinese legislation which attempted to limit the Chinese presence in the province and to subordinate those Chinese who were here socially, economically, and politically (Cho 1970: 19). A_s in California, British Columbia did not speak with one voice on the question of the Chinese. Whereas popular hostility against them was 1=1ufficient to guarantee that the provincial legislature would do everything in its power to limit the Chinese, the owners and managers of large scale industries in particular knew the advantages of Chinese labor and sought in their own ways to assure that it would ccmtinue to be present (Phillips 1967) • . For instance, despite British Columbian working class objections the Canadian Pacific Railway was able to make extensive use of Chinese labor; - 128 - the first restrictive immigration head tax of $50. 00 was placed on the Chinese in 1885 , only ~ the railway was completed. Prior to that, the federal government had disallowed ~very attempt by the !3 riti sh Columbia legislature to regulate Chinese immigration (Glazebrook 1966:184). As late as 1899, the CPR was still lobl:1ying against further curbs on <:;hinese im~ migration. . Despite such powerful economic interests, the head tax on the Chinese was raised to $100. 00 and then to $500. 00 in 1904. In the short term this latter tax severely limited furthef" Chinese immigration, ~ut it eventually resumed, only to be stopped by World War I (Carrothers 1938:6). In 1923, the Canadian government unilaterally banned the subsequent im- migration of virtually all types of Chinese immigrants. · Official figu.res show that only eight Chinese immigrants legally entered Canada between 1923 and 1947 (Straaton 1974:38). ' The hostile reaction to the Chinese shown by the working class was, not restricted to that class (Robin 1972:34). Small scale entrepreneurs, notably in retail sales, quickly felt the effects of Chinese competition and joined the drive towards exclusion. So did_farmers, especially those in vegetable farming. The collective 'Critique of the Chinese was relatively straightforward, for it was untempered by notions of ethnic or racial equality. Basically, there were two objections to the Chinese, one social and the other economic. Socially, it was taken as a given even by supporter.s of the Chinese that they could not assimilate to Western cultural practices or t h a 7 r--_ / .. - 129 - were theoretically possible the Chinese did not want to do so. The alter- native, specifically racist charge was that in any case no one wanted them to assimilate, for the Chinese were fundamentally different than people of European origins. Evidence of the inability of the Chinese to assimilate was also used to argue why they should not be allowed to develop a presence " in Canada. The Chinese were perceived to be immoral and dirty. "chose" to live in groups in vice and in unsanitary 'conditions. They They practiced strange and immoral customs, and did not have the sensitivity of Europeans to suffering (Pidgeon 1912; Ward 1973). Economically, there existed a basic premise that the Chinese in the work force could not join collectively with those of different ethnic backgrounds tp support common interests. They were perceived to be without initiative and to be passive in the face of employer exploitation, the_reby threat'ening the situation of other workers by accepting working conditions and wages that were seen as unfit fo~ whites (Phillips 1967;1-35). The image of the Chinese presented in the press was generally similar to this stereotype, but it emphasized some aspects of it and not others. Table XXX illustrates the range of topics and subtopics found in the domestic coverage of the Chinese in the World and the Province. Table XXXI lists the seven most frequent topics found in both papers. Two generalizations emerge from these tables. The first concerns the types of topics which the press considered to be newsworthy.in relation to the Chinese. While press coverage of the Chinese was very intensive, - 130 {' Topics and Subtopics Y i1,1;1, i; '2 l.l~sa: ~l.:S2YW!i.~ number % · Housing and Settlement provide their own housing cause overcrowding Education require special provision costs too much are uneducated Health & Welfare are a health hazard 2 3 number % 2 1 1.8 0.9 1 1 0.9 o. 9 1 0. 9 1 o. 9 1.9 2. 8 Employment & Economy cause unemployment are needed for work buy or own property are cheap labor 2 2 3 2 1.9 1.9 2. 8 1.9 Numbers are a certain nuµiber 1 1.9 Advocation of Restriction should bar from jobs should deny ethnic ways should bar immigration Yill!i.S2YY~ ;r Daily World A 1 2 0.9 o. 9 1.8 1 0.9 1 o. 9 1 0.9 l 1 0.9 '3 2. 8 Are ~trictee c. are barred from jobs are denied citizenship cannot immigrate other 1 1 2 o. 9 o. 9 1.9 Charge Restriction claim immigration bar Ethnic Relations try to better re}Jltions relations mediated by others have bad police relations relations get worse· relations are good relations are bad 1 2 1 1 0.9 2.8 o. 9 0.9 0.9 1 1 2 0.9 o. 9 1. 8 .,. l - 131 - Ethnic Relations (cont'd.) have outside support . unite with others . exploit each other a·re a threat to the West ·lmmigration too much come illegally arrive are refu~ed entry are a source of money Legislative & Legal act to limit or re strict discuss restriction of' discuss protection of are in the courts protest to government debate on immigration Violence, Hostility Against are assaulted or harassed are victims of crime are dealt with harshly are dealt with leniently o/o numl;>'er % 1 2 0.9 1. 9 2 3 2 1. 8 2.6 1. 8 2 1. 9 1 5 2 o. 9 4. 7 1.9 1 o. 9 7 4 1 3 6. 1 3. 5 o. 9 2.6 1 o. 9 4 2 11 3. 5 1. 8 9. 6 1 o. 9 1 5 o. 9 4.4 1 o. 9 number 6 1 1 5. 6 o. 9 o. 9 2 2 1 1.9 1.9 o. 9 .i Violence, Hostility By assault, harass people assault each other meet imposition with force are accused of crime cause crime to increase Cultural Differences eating customs religi.o us customs working practices sanitation & health are unassim.ilatable stick together humor other 1 5 1 16 l 1 2 1 o. 9 4. 7 o. 9 15. 0 o. 9 2 6 17 1 1.8 5. 3 0.9 14. 9 o. 9 2 1 1.8 o. 9 l o. 9 1.9 0.9 ;. 1 1 o. 9 o. 9· 1 2 1 o. 9 1.8 0.9 - 132 - Celebrities politicians social notables Ethnic Or_ganizations ethnic festival organization takes role religious organizations help other Normal News human interest accident victims suicide other Total Table XXX. number % number % 1 4 0.9 3. 7 2 1 1.8 0.9 1 3 o. 9 1 o. 9 1 ,o. 9 1 o. 9 1.8 2.6 o. 9 0.9 100.0% 2.8 l o. 9 1 2 2 0.9 1. 9 1.9 1 o. 9 2 3 1 1 107 100. 0% 114 Chinese Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World (1905-1914) j - 133 - Vancouver Province Vancouver Daily World i number i 24 22.4 27 23. 8 Legislative &: Legal 9 8. 3 18 15. 8 Immigration 9 8. 3 15 13. 1 Ethnic Relations 11 10. 2 11 9. 8 Cultural Differences 5 4.6 9 8. 1 Normal News 6 5. 1 8 7. 1 Violence, Hostility Against 5 4.6 7 6. 2 Employment &: Economy 9 8. 3 1 o. 9 78 72. 2% 96 84. 8% m.unber Violence, Hostility By - Topic Total Table XXXI. The Most Frequent Topics of Domestic Chinese News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World (1905-1914) - 134 - accounting for 19. 8% of the Pro;ince's domestic coverage and 20. 5% of the World's, this did not lead to a concurrently wide range of press interests. Rather, both papers concentrated ~ i r coverage of the Chinese upon certain key areas, notably violence and crime perpetrated by Chinese, Chinese-white relations, the immigration of Chinese to Canada, the Chinese in the courts, and cultural differences. Clearly, the key characteristic of the Chinese as portrayed by the press was their presumed pros:livity for crime and violence. In this regard, the Province devoted 22. 4% of its domestic coverage of the Chinese to this type of story, which was closely paralleled by the World's 23. 8%. In turn, the most frequent subtopic under this heading for both papers was the Chinese bei?g accused of crime. Many of the criminal activities reported under this subtopic were concerned with. petty crimes associated with immorality and disorder- police raiding Chinese gambling establishments, "opium dens", or places of prostitution. Commonly the central "lesson" of these news items was • that the Chinese either did not or would n~t adjust to Canadian conventions of social'&.(der and morality. For instance, under the byline "Magistrate "'-=-- Rules Rat is Wild Animal" (Province, November 27, 1912, page l), the paper claimed that the " ••• counsel for Chinese charged with cruelty contended that it was vermin. 11 A health inspector ha~ b~ought the individual to court because he had nailed a rat to a board to scare away other rats. / ' . He was convicted of cruelty to animals. 9 • A similar story in the Province (October 16, 1909, page 12) rel)ted how a Chinese gardener was fined for driving a lame horse despite obJections from passersby. I?rugs, prostitution, and gambling were in turn linked to the new Sodom and Gomorrah-.:.Chinatown. In the newspaper press Chinatown epitomized evil and degeneration. There was a constant concern that the Chinese (in collusion with "irnm.igrant'' whites) would lure "white slave racket 11 11 girls 11 into the (Province, September 1, 1901, page 3); this concern was reflected in provincial legislation which prohibited the employment of .. white women by Chinese. It was the press' view that the Chinese were so dangerous to the safety of white women that those women who chose to help the Chinese in any way were both naive and stupid (Province, September 16, 1907, page 1). In general. the Chinese were seen as being morally pol- luting. This theme of Chinese vice was a clear reflection of the more encompassing paternalistic ideology of the relationship of Europeans to the-\ Chinese which was current at that time. The Chinese were characterized as sly but not too bright children, who needed a stern hand to keep them from going astray. As the World put it, they w.ere not so much immoral as ,. they were "unmoral" (April • .1908, page 6; March 3, 1914, page 7). This stereotype was further enforced by the extensive covei;age of the Chinese and legislation, citizenship, and l~_gal business. Under this broad category, Chinese in the courts was the most common subtopic by far, accounting for 5. 6o/o of the Province's total domestic coverage of t~e - 136 - Chinese and 9. 6% of the World's. Most of these news items related to the Chinese acting as. deviants in one or another way--either as criminals or attempting to evade the immigration regulations. Legislative coverage dealing with the Chinese was almost exclusively restricted to discussion of the threat that the Chinese posed to other British Columbians or to\'how that threat could be dealt with by the gov·e rnment. Illegal immigration was another concern of the press which got high priority. The Chinese of that era were a community of males (Corbett 195'?). They were segregated socially and residentially from other British • Columbians and were limited in their ability to. use English. ' Moreover, ' whatever interaction did occur between Chinese and others was highly institutionalized; whites used Chinese as domestics, bought from Chinese grocers, and had their clothes done at Chinese laundries. While a few whites went to Chinatown to gamble and a handiul of church groups attempted to convert the Chinese, by-in-large there was very little close interaction between whites and Chinese. ·'I'hi_s situation is reflected by the press' - ......______ ______________ coverage of Chinese-white relations. Ethnic rela.non-s-----news items were the fourth most common type dealing with the Chinese in both papers. While the frequency of subtopics found under this general topic was low, a general press orientation to interaction nevertheless emerges. defined their terms here: Both papers clearly Chinese-white relations were at best a question of adjusting both groups to each other's presence--absolutely no interest at all was evinced of the posaibility of the Chinese assimilating to European .. - l".37 - wa~cof doing. r ' This stands in sharp contrast to newspaper concerns over ! the place of Eastern Europeans in Canada, where the question of assimilation was central. Both papers came to the same general conclusion that relations between the Chinese and 9thers were not particularly good, and both found the source of the problem to be the Chinese- -a classic case orblaming the victim. There were, however, slight differences between the Province, and the World in their respective definitions of this situation. The i Province was on the whole far more concerned about the international im~ations of British Columbia's Chinese population and their treatment. In-particular, the Province was concerned that local Chinese might provoke homeland Chinese to boycott Canadian goods; several stories in 1905 linked a Chinese boycott of American goods to suppor_t by Vancouver Chinese protective associations. Nevertheless, the general tenor of the press portrayal of Chinese ethnic relations reflected China's image as a decadent, drifting country of effete mandarins and mindless, subordinate peasants. In a parallel fashion local Chinese were usually portrayed as docile and unable to defend their honor (Down 1972:142). For in~nce, the Japanese were. given far more covel"age than the Chinese in the aftermath reporting of the serious antiOriental riot of 1907. In the ensuing coverage the Chinese were only specifically mentioned once by each paper, while the' World followed with six news items on the Japanese and the Province with three. This was despite the fact that it was Chinese rather than Japanes~ property that was - 138 - most extensively damaged, and it can b~rgued that this was a reflection of the differing response which individuals of the-se two groups _showed to the rioters. The Chinese attempted to avoid the rioters, then followed the event with a general labo1: strike. In contrast, the Japanese chose to defend their. property in the streets and were successful in doing so (Sugimoto 1966:l.J20). Underlying virtually every news item dealing with the Chinese was an assumption of negatively evaluated cultural difference. ~ l e news item~ with main topics of cultural difference were .relatively few (.l 8% of the / . . . ~ c e ' ~ coverage and 8. 1% of the World's), themes dealing with cultural ~ n e e were the most frequently found of any. Table XXXII gives the most frequently found themes for each paper. Vancouver Province Themes Cultural Difference . Vancouver Daily World number nwnber 55 37 " Ethnic Relations 28 18 Employment and Economy 25 17 Violence by Chinese 21 28 Legal and Legislative 16 Ethnic Organizations 11 . . 17 ... ~ -'t H) ; ..... Table XXXll. · Most Common Themes in Dom~stic Chihese·· N..,..s Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World (1905-1914) For the most part, these expressions of cultural difference tended to serve as superficial explanations for the main event of a given news item. "II - 139 - For instance, of the 16 news items in the Province whose topic was . that a Chinese individual was accused of crime, 12 contained a theme • that the Chinese have different morals than othkr people--different morals that were presumed to lead to criminal deviance. It '!Vas only in the area of employment and economic activities that . there existed any substantive difference in the coverage of the Chinese be,..-- tween the. twef papers, _and _that difference would not be easily p~edictable from a superficial consideration of the political interests of the Province and the World. For the .Province, this area was one of principaf concern,• and about l lo/o of its domestic Chinese coverage was directly devoted to it. On the other ha:qd, the World stood almost mut~ , on this question; only one . . ~ . ne~s• item had employment and economy -as a. 'topic or subtopic. Even as· themes, these. issues ~ere more frequent in the Province (n = 25) than they were in the Worid (~ = 17). rn ·the light C?f the World's claim to be the standard bearer of the whit~ working class ~s selective silence seems to make no s~nse. J " H ~ t h e pattern becomes clearer when one considers the actual . · content of news, items dealin~ with the economy in the !ight .o f the contra• • • ' _4 • ·, dietary political ~demands which were b e i ~ t on the World in tlilat er~ • . ' ' ' ,. . . ~ . ... ' . :' The World was no·rm.ally a strong supporter of Liberal policy, which was .,./ . ~ / . ~ . . then exploring the thesis ·that C~dians could be made dut of a far wider range of ·people than ever before thought possible or desirable (Palmer 1975: 17). If nothing ilse, th1 ~olc:>nization of ·the Prairie provinces by. · r · - 140 - Eastern European immigrants demanded this sort of ideology. This ideo- logical and practical opening up of the ethnic criteria of immigration and citizenship on the part of the Liberals corresponded in most instances with the democratic feelings of the working class movement in British Columbia, which had overriden many ethnic differenc~s in the light of more pressing collective economic interests. The problem which the World faced was that th·e Chinese and other Asians in British Columbia were seen by the working class as the problem of the times, thus making it suicidal for the World to advocate greater Chinese participation in Canadian society. At the same time, to emphasize the supposed deleterious effects of the Chinese upon the I, conditions of the working class and upon the economy generally would argue ag.tinst the programs of the party which ,the World attempted to support. In the light of these contradictory demands, it is not surprising that the World chose to neglect the question of the Chinese in the economy, and instead concentrated on ways in which the Chinese violated the la~s ~nd regulations ' which were designed (by the Liberals) to keep more of them out of the com_1try and restrict those who were here. The Conservatively-oriented Province was not similarly co1;_strained. The Province tended to be much more overt in its critique of Chinese cultural differences than the World (see Tables XXX and XXXll), and was m~c-h more concerned with the place of 'the Chinese in the provincial economy. In the case of the economy, the Province was mor~ "societally- oriented" than the World; the Province would oft~n develop abstract argu- "' ---- - 141 - ments like.- the Chinese being needed as cheap labor. to build th"e provincial . / economy, while it was more common for the World to deal with the impact of the Chinese upon ~ndividuals.,,. In overview, the image of the Chinese as portrayed by the early Vancouver press stands in the sharpest contrast to t:i,e British. Whereas the British constituted the ideal by which others could be compared, the Chinese served the opposite function--to define the boundaries of the moral community by characterizing what it was not. The press stereotype of the Chinese emphasized disorder, immorality, and lack of structure in relationship to normal society's order and morality; the Chinese symoolized Nature in opposition to Culture. Moreover, the portrayal of the Chinese by the press frequently legitimated their subordination, and both papers actively supported it. The press almost never defended the Chinese against such subordination, and indeed rarely dealt with the Chinese as individuals at all. News 'items rarely gave the names of the Chinese individuals who were so portrayed-·I instead they were "Chinamen." They were shown as being anonymous and homogeneous, thereby depriving them of all evidence of personality, individuality, ambition, or emotion. - 142 - The Japanese The first Japanese to come to British Columbia in any number did so in the late 1880' s, well after the arrival of the first Chinese (Buchignani 1977:30). Like the Chinese, the Japanese also came from fairly localized ' areas in Japan, and many were initially motivated to come to Canada in order to better their long-term economic prospect~ at home. Consequently, the first Japanese Canadians were predominantly male, as were the Chinese before them. Although many Japanese entered int'o wage labor of the sort done by the Chinese, others moved into economic areas which had not been marked previously by a strong Chinese presence. Perhaps the most important of these was the fishing industry, in which the Japanese were to play a signi ... ficant role until World War I (Ward 1973:127; Phillips 1967:25). In addition to joining native people and the Chinese in the canneries, the Japanese participated in fishing itself, and soon established themselves as successful independent fishermen. Only legal residents of Canada could obtain fishing licences, which led to a ·growing number of Japanese establishing permanent residence in Canada; economic success in turn allowed many to bring their wives and children to Canada. Unlike the Chinese and South Asians, who were destined to remain predominantly male communities until the end of the Second World War, the Japanese quickly developed a community based upon families whose life chances were dependent on their successful adaptatidn to the Canadian context (Roy 1972:250). ·~ - 143 Objections on the part of others to Japanese immigrants were not long in coming, and were heard first from their economic competitors (RRCCJI 1902:340). As early as 1893, white and Native Indian salmon fishermen on the Fraser River had organized in opposition to the increasing presence of the Japanese. Later, criticism was to come from organized labor and from vegetable farmers (Roy 1972:250). Those British · Columbians who opposed continued Japa:dese immigration soon found that it would be far more difficult to "deal" with the Japanese than the Chinese, notably because the former were to have continual home government support (Sumida 1935:29; Sugimoto 1966:38). Several international political considerations made the Federal government extremely reluctant to act unilaterally against Japanese immigration. For one thing, Japan was the formal ally of Great Britain, and hence, of Canada (Glazebrook 1966:222). Moreover, the Liberal govern- ment of Laurier was extremely optimistic of developing a large trade with Japan, and was not about to have this plan interfered with by the actions of a few (Gowan 1970:63-84). Consequently, the question of restricting Japanese immigration was to become an extremely devisive one between the Federal government and its British Columbia counterpart (Glazebrook 1966: 221). For instance, the Federal government continually disallowed British Columbian legislation aimed at restricting the Japanese. It did so in 1900, when it disallowed a "Natal Act," which was aimed at restricting Japanese immigration through their inability to pass a written test in a European - 144 - language (Gowan 1970:65). Laurier' s position was very clear. In defense of disallowing this sort of legislation, Laurier clailned in a 1903 speech to Parliament that: We intend to have a trade between Japan and Canada. We intend to bring about a development of the relations which exist between that progressive people and our own people. We ..• ai:e trying to promote trade between Canada and Japan because, after all, we a re neighboring nations. (Gowan 1970:66) I l It was the conviction of the government that Canada could become an important provider of raw materials and food to Japan. There were even great hopes that the Japanese would switch their dietary preferences from rice to wheat, thereby providing a market for the newly arising output of the Prairies (Gowan 1970:65). Thus, despite increasing protests from British Columbia, the Federal Government was unwilling to move decisively against Japanese immigration for fear of prejudicing Canada's chances for increased trade with Japan. On January 31, 1906, the Canadian government became a party to the Anglo-Japanese trade agreement of 1894-95. Like many trade treaties of that era, this one granted reciprocal immigration and residence rights to individuals from both countries, thereby making a unilateral move on Canada's part to restrict Japanese immigration contrary to the treaty (Sugimoto 1966:42). The only recourse available to the Federal Govern- ment was to request that the Japanese agree to limit the flow of immigrants r - 145 - themselves. Such an ~agreement was signed in Tokyo in 1907, and limited the number o f ~ laborers {only) coming to Canada to 468 a year {Swnida 1935:34). The Japanese government's strong concern for the plight of its nationals in Canada strengthened the position of Japanese immigrants and made it easier for them to actively defend their situation than it was for the Chinese. In a time of extreme nationalism, the Japanese government con- sidered its overseas residenfs to be an extension of the state, and acted against any limitations which were placed upon them as if they were aimed at Japan itself. Throughout this era, the Japanese government sent a number of representatives to support the position of the Japanese in British Columbia. In addition, Canadian perceptions of Japan stood in sharp contrast to that of China, and as with the latter, the national image of Japan was.integrated into the local stereotype of the Japanese. At that time Japan was rising to prominence as a major world power. Their decisive defeat of the Russians in 1905 had drawn attention to the industrial revolution then ongoing in Japan, and to the military potential of this Asian nation (Jacobs and Landau 1971:114). Moreover, there was increasing concern that Japan would be able to dominate the Far East trade, especially with China (Lorence 1970:438). The Japanese in Canada were seen to reflect this national image. They were viewed as being far more dangerous to European interests than - 146 - . the Chinese, for they were perceived as being innovative, re•ourceful, and extremely nationalistic (Roy 1972:243-255); in particular, they could quickly develop an understanding of European economic practices without becoming European. The Japanese were seen to actively de{end their right~ and property, even by Laurier. In reference to the Japanese acti- vities in the anti-oriental riot of 1907 Laurier noted that: the Japs showed fight, turned upon their assailants, and routed them. This is at once cause for rejoicing and for anxiety; rejoicing because the rowdies got a well de served licking; anxiety because it may make the Japs very saucy, and render an adjustment of the trouble very difficult (Brown and Cook 1974:69). The general critique of the Japanese was therefore quite different than that of the Chinese, though both depended ultimately on invidious racial distinctions. It was clearly seen that the JatJanese were in no way lacking in most of the characteristics which Europeans thought constituted ideal virtues. They worked hard, supported their families, defended their honor, were resourceful, clean, and well ordered. Accordingly, the rationale for Japanese exclusion was more specifically racist than that dealing with the Chinese; the Japanese should be barred from coming to Canada because they were so successful, for they would never become aliiliated with Canada and would always be oriented to Japan (Roy 1972: 243-255). Their presence in British Columbia was equated with the pre- sence of the Japanese government, and fears were expressed that - 147 - Japanese immigrants were only a beachhead for a massive economic and social takeover of the Pacific Coast by Japanese. As with the Chinese, the Japanese in British Columbia received news . cove rage far out of proportion to their numbers. In 1901, for instance, there were only 1,010 Japanese ,ip Vancouver, who made up about 9, 5% of the foreign-born population of the city (MacDonald 1970:311); while the number of Japanese in Vancouver rose to 1, 841 over the subsequent decade, their percentage of the foreign-born shrank to 3. 3%, for the influx of others was far higher. Nevertheless, the Japanese accounted for 11. 6% of the domestic news items dealing with ethnicity in the Province and 12. 9% in the World during the decade, 1905-1914. As can be seen in Tables XXXIII, XXXIV, and XXXV, the press image of the Japanese diverged considerably from that of the Chinese even at the high level of abstraction represented by these tables. In broad over- view, the portrayal of the Japanese was, like the Chinese, highly stigmatic (the Japanese moral community score was -1. 38 in the Province and -1.01 in the World). At the same ti.me, that stigma was derived from quite different attributes of behavior. To begin with, neither paper gave Japanese cultural difference high suiency. Cultural difference was the topic of only three news items in the Province sample and one in the World. Even at the secondary level of themes, cultural difference did not play a predominent role. as is illustrated by Table XXXV. • - 148 - Topics and Subtopics Vancouver Daily World number °lo Education need special education undereducated 1 1 1.4 1. 4 Health & Welfare are a hAzard to health health is poor 2 1 2. 8 1.4 Employment & Economy cause unemployment lower standard of living other send money out of country buy property in economic distress Nwnbers are a certain nwnber Advocation of Restricta>n , should re strict jobs should deny rights should bar immigration should keep Canada white 'I Vancouver Province nwnber % 1 1 2 1. 6 1.6 3. 2 • 1 1.4 1.4 1.4 1.4 2 3. 2 1 1 1 2 3. 2 2 2.8 1 1 1.4 1. 4 1 1 5 7. 9 3 1 4.2 1. 4 Are Restricted are barred from jobs cannot immigrate 1 2 1. 6 3. 2 1 1. 4 Charge Restriction claim barred from jobs other 1 1 1 1. 6 1.6 1. 6 1 1 1.6 1. 6 1 1 1. 6 1.6 3 1 1 1 4. 2 1. 4 1. 4 1. 4 2. 8 4.2 Ethnic Relations try to better relations relations mediated by others relations are getting worse relations are bad have outside support unite together threaten western world other 1. 6 1. 6 2 3 1 1. 6 - 149 number % l. 6 6. 3 4.8 1. 6 2 2 l 2. 8 2. 8 1. 4 2 3. 2 1 2 1 1. 6 3. 2 l. 6 2 l 2 4 2.8 1. 4 2. 8 5. 6 l 2 1.6 3. 2 5 3 1 6. 9 4. 2 1.4 Violence, Hostility By assault, harass others assault, harass each other meet upposition with force are accused of crime other l l l 6 l l. 6 l. 6 l. 6 9. 6 l. 6 2 2 2. 8 2. 8 l l. 4 Cultural Difference working habits require special provisions speak English badly l l 1 1. 6 l. 6 1. 6 l 1.4 Inunigration many are corning are entering illegally arrive are solicited to come Legislative & Legal politicians urge restriction restrictive laws discussed are in the courts " immigration discussed other Violence, Hostility Against are assaulted property is destroyed are dealt with leniently . number % l 4 3 1 ' ,- /""-... r Celebrities politicians social notables Ethnic Organizations ethnic festivals organizations have a role organizations are sinister religious organizations aid other 2 1 1 3. 2 1.6 1. 6 1 2 1. 4 2.8 1 5 1 1.4 6. 9 1. 4 L - 150 - cNormal News acc;ident victims ethnic makes good suicide Total Table XXXlll. number % 1 l. 6 1 1. 6 63 100. Oo/o number- °lo 1 1 1. 4 1. 4 72 100.0o/o Japanese Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World (1905-1914) Topic Vancouver Province number % Vancouver Daily World number % Violence, Hostility By 10 15. 9 6 8.4 Immigration 9 14. 3 5 7.0 Advocation of Restriction 7 11. 1 6 8.4 Legislative & Legal 6 9. 6 9 12. 6 Employment & Economy 6 9. 6 4 5. 6 Are Restricted 6 9. 6 1 1. 4 Ethnic Relations 5 8. 0 10 14.0 Violence, Hostility Against 3 4. 8 9 12. 5 Ethnic Organizations C, 2 3. 2 7 9. 7 54 85. 7% 56 77.7% Total Table XXXIV. The Most Frequent Topics of Japanese Domestic News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World (1905-1914) . - 15 1 - , Vancouver Province · nwnber Theme Vancouver Daily World nwnber Hostility, Violence By 23 17 Employment and Economy 22 19 Ethnic Relations 20 22 Cultural Difference 18 16 Immigration 15 0 Advocation of Restriction 14 16 Legal and Legislative 13 31 Table XXXV. Most Common Themes in Domestic Japanese News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World (1905-14) The most common theme of cultural difference was that the Japanese were loyal to their home government, which was actually a political distinction rather than a cultural one. lO Even the extensive new.spaper coverage of alleged Japanese crinri.nal- ity and violence reilected the fact that culturcll difference was not principal to the image of the Japanese. It will be recalled that the portrayal of Chinese crime and violence c o ~ ; within it strong attributes of deviance ' :! and immorality. Not only were the Chinese charged with frequently violating the law, but aho they were seen aa violating the "rules of deviance ... Instead of " normal" arirninal activity like theft, Chinese criminality was aee:a. to be abnortnal- -involvement with drug a, prostitution, and the "white slave trade." Thia was not a principal theme in the coverage of Japanese - ·152 t,' criminal activity. Most instances of reported Japanese crune or violence was the type typically associated with Western life--assault, violation of liquor laws, and the like. The most frequent theme of this sort was that ·the Japanese were violent. This characteristic was but part of a larger stereotype that tied British Columbian Japanese to what were presumed to be Japan's national interests. The major threat that the Japanese posed was seen by both papers to be political and e:::onomic rather than cultural. Like the Chinese, the Japanese were charged by the Provin#ft)palrticular with degrading °!e conditions of the working man, causing unemployment, and buying up property, farms, and businesses. Even though the Japanese immigrants were , far fewer than the Chinese, the press was concerned that the organizational qualities of the Japanese might cause them to be stiff economic competition to both the working class and the businessman. The way in which this critique was develo~d dillered considerably between the two papers. In g_eneral,·the Province tended to stress what it saw as the direct detrimental effects of the Japanese upon British Columbia and overtly argued for further restriction, while ~ World generated a stereotype of the sinister and conspiratorial nature of the Japanese and let its readers make their own conclusions as to what should.be done about it. This dilierence was obvioualy a reflection of political consider- ations, and followed the same general pattern as Chinese coverage. With a Liberal government in Otuwa, the Province could maintain - 15 3 - its Conservative orientation by totally opposing a Japanese presence in British Columbia. The Province accordingly more frequently portrayed the· effects of the Japanese on the economy (9. 6% of the_sample) than the World (5. 6%). more often advocated their restriction (11. 2% as opposed to 8. 4'1o), and devoted twice the coverage to the immigration of the Japanese than the World ( 14. 3% as compared with 7. Oo/o); the World sample showed ' not one item with an inunigration theme. The Japanese image constrpcted by~e Province was also far more violent and criminal than that of the ¥ (Ii,'. s infesting Lonely Suburban Homes. Question handed over to the Parliamentary Committee. ~ (World, November 16, 1906, page 1) The story claimed that "after reading the press" women were "afraid to leave their homes." The Province's coverage of the same date, page, and subject was no less alarmist: WOMEN BEING ARMED FOR PROTECTION FROM HINDOOS Unless outrages cease, their perpetrators will be targets. Working men arousec1. Take steps in Defense of Helpless Women Subject to Attack. Other presumed South Asian tilltltu;al differences were given equally high saliency in the press. Overtly showing how the stereotype of local South Asians. was affected b ~ e image of South Asians in India, the World item of November 17. 1906 (page 1) is representative of how both papers viewed So?th Asian living conditions. In a full width headline it claimed that:· _SEVENTY HINDOOS SPEND NIGHT IN THREE,ROOM SHACK V ANCOUVERS "BLACK HOLE OF CALCUTTA'' - 169 - Even after immigra~_on had been stopped for three years, these· s~eteotype s remained current: DECLARES HINDOOS ARE FILTlilEST From Sanitary Point of View Worse 'than Lowest ~Chinese: Such is .statement of Sanitary Inspector in Annual Report. {Province, January 12, 1912, page 3) Despite the unambiguo~sly negative image of South Asians in the two newspapers, there were a few minor differences between the Province and the World in how this stigmatic image was constructed. For one thing, in overview the Province's portrayal of South Asians defined these people niore . definitively out of the moral community than did the World: while South . . C Asians received lower moral community scores in both papers than either '-.._ the Chinese or the Japanese, in the Province their score was lower than any other local ethnic group except for ItaHans. Their score was -2. 03 in the .Province and -1. 31 in the World. In addition, the Province tended to dwell upon two types of issues --~ which- the World dfcd not: the Imperial conse,quences of South Asian immi- ~ gration and the negative effects of South Asian immigration upon British Columbia. These two concerns were closely tied together by a more general ideological position which legitimated British rule over the Empire and Indii"'in particular. was that: -, \ For instance, an ongoing worry of the Province - 170 VANCOUVER lilNDOOS AID PLOTTERS IN INDIA Thousands 0£ Dollars Sent fro}ll British Columbia to Headquarters. MONEY TO BUY RIFLES. Evidence Gathered by Secret Service Man Demonstrates EJqent of Seditious Movement in the_ Province. . (Province, June 1, 1910, page 1) Paternalistically, the az:ticle further points out that Indians had "no gratitude for what Britain did for them" and that local Indians were "ignorant coolies who contribute money and unscrupulous leaders" to a vain independence movement. Similar concerns are shown in the Province's • more frequent interest in overseas Indians, primarily those in India; the Province overseas sample shows almost twice the number of ethnic news items dealing with South Asians as does that of the World (n = 22 as opposed to n = 12). In turn over a quarter of the Province's overseas coverage of Indians dealt with anti-British demonstrations. On the local front, the ProvilM:e concentrated upon similar questions, as can be seen particularly in the distribution of themes in Table XXXX. In particular, in contrast to the World the Province gave extensive coverage to them} s dealing with ethnic relations (n = 23 as opposed to n = 5), employmLt and the •~my (21, 5), and the restriction of South Asians_ (19, 2). Once more, an implicit paternalism makes its appearance; if left to their own devices, Indians 'intrinsically" tended towards squalor, immorality, and violence. They should therefore be ruled with a stern hand. Consistent with this view, the Province argued that Indians could not ,-, ,. • 7 •. 171 ·- e - ... . possibly be allowed to participate fully in British Columbian society, because if ~hey were to be given the freedom and independence which wa.s · centrav. to d~mocratic society, they would si~ to their "natural" level. The • -<:. ,.. press c l ~-d that even as subordinates, "Hindoos" were a threat, for like the Chinese their debased living style allowed 'them to undercut the wage demands of white a.. Moreover, t h e ~ backed up such arguments with reference to the presumed negative ~ t s of Indian im.n:1igratio..Il to_ . other places, such as South Africa. In overview, it is clear that both papers tended to de.velop an image of South~ian ethnicity which reflected then current id:eas about India and Indian/· Neither paper gave much credence to the Imperial fiction that non-w-\te British subjects had any rights whatever in Jhitish Columbia, yet both used the related argument that strong British control over India · might eventually lead to the uplifting of Indians to European standards. Both papers characterized immigrant South Asians as being the dregs of IHe well known place of Sikhs in . the Briti'sh India army and to the obvious sophistication and education of Indian society, in dir.ect contradiction to ~~ some local Indian leaders; both cast South Asians entirely out of the newspaper moral community. -----· ·• 172 ,,...... ,.,- ' In carrying out the ~lysis of• this era it imm.ediate'ly becam.e obvious that the Vancouver press sharply distinguished between several kinds , of Americans. • ' 0 . \ There were ~hat l:ould be termed "just plain Americans," --7 ' . - • as represented by a headline su-ch as: INVASION BY AMERICANS. 7 5 Thousand F amilie s entered Canadian West this Year (Province,., Oct~ber 1, 1909, page 1) ' ' ., ·" Another variety of Americans was the "Negro", who w_a s always so de sig- . nated by the pre s .s: NEGROES COMING TO SPY OUT THE LAND. Advalilce Guard of Black Army from Oklahoma Now Waiting at White Rock · (Province, April 15, 1911, page 1) Yet another type of American was the individual who was primarily characterized by his or her ethnic background, as for instance: ITALIAN CONVICTS INVADE NEW YORK ,No.Less than Five Thousand Said to be in City (Province, August 30, 1911, pageil) Almost never did the press classify the latter sort of individual as a "real" American, and the ethnic attributes surrounding his or her behavior were a-scribed primari!y to ethnic background rather than to being an American. Following this folk claaailication, various ethnic Americans have been - analy~ed under their reported ethnicitiea. Thia still le.a ves two Ina.in var- ieties of Ame-rican, who were dealt with in fundmentally different ways by • :, . - 173 - ·- . the press. While it has been frequently proposed that a theme of anti0 Americanism has·pe~sisted ,throughoilt the history of Ca~da (Baker, 197if: . r ~ • 11 " • " 4 426) and that the identity of Canadians still depends. upon a negative de~ ...... ✓ finition of Ametcans and ~e United States (~itvak an·d Mau_le 19:4:16), this has by .no me~ns been· dominant in the history of_ British Colum~ia, ... - ' ~ .. .. In ✓ fact, detached as it was from Eastern Canadian· concerns, there existed a general tendency to see Americans in such a favorable light that the economic and political integration of British Columbia with the United States found a ~mber of sympathizers within th~ province. - Part of this favorable image of Americans must be ascribed to how ; these individuals were seen within the spectrum of immigrants to Western Canada at the turn ot the century and thereafter. American immigrants were actively solicited to come to the Canadian Prairies by private immigration agencies and the Canadian government (Palmer 1975:40). These potential immigrants were ethnically acceptable and they were seen to bring with them far more capital than any other type of settler (Canadian Annual Review 1906:285). Many immig,rants came, both in :response to these solicitations and in reaction to their limited possibilities in the United States. It has been estimated that between 1901 and 1910, over a half million Americans became Canadian citizens (Wilson 1932:264, 179). This large influx of Americans did not happen without concern being raised as to how these new Canadians might affect the future course of . - . . Canadian society. In particulcf.r, thefr arrivat"provoked wor'ry ab()Ut the century-old threat of. the Ameri~ap. ,annexation o~ Cana6}a (:~aker l 97_0:426; · •• - ', -, • • ,- ~:' Mcinnis 1958:403). • If' - • • ~ e . • ; ~ <' V • • - . , Specifical~y, these arguments· centered on tlie equally , old que_stion of_~rade r~ciprocity, which ~eparated Conservc\tiv-e from <1,,_ 4 ~ . f . Liberal thought. Fearing the weakeriirtg of Empire ties, the Conservati~es ,, ,- ' we!e opposed to a liberalizati~p. of trade barriers between Canada and her c• southern neighbor, while we steTn Liberals in ·particular argued for~ freer ..... ~ 'J trade in the hope that it would lead to increased economic prosperity for the we stern provinces. While most American settlers in the Prairies were far~rs, the majority of those who came to British Columbia either were not or did not remain so after their arrival. Reflecting the general nature of the pro- vincial economy, Americans moved into industrial labor and to a range of occupations in urban areas. In Vancouver, the American-born population was the second largest of any immigrant group, but was always far smaller than that of the British-born for the period in question; they constituted about 17 to 18% of the Vancouver foreign- born population in contra st to the British, who made up almost three times as many (Macdonald 1970:311). Despite the nwnber of Americans in British Columbia and the ittrong economic and social ties between the province and the Pacific Coast states (Myers 1914:301) neither the World nor the Province gave much of its ethnic ~ coverage to Americans. Only 24 news items in the Province's domestic sample dealt with American ethnicity. The World gave this subject greater i. -.175,- • .... ;; .· exposur~, but the s,ample was still small (n ::! 35). These low ·frequencie.s, which would cortespond to but 4. 2% of th'e . Province's df;Jmestic coverage ·and 4.-8% of the World's, .should not lead op~ .. . . . . , to the conclusion thatthese pa?,ers did not deal ~ . ~ '- wi-* events. concerning:. .. - ~;, •Americans and the United States, for this was hardly the ...case. ' ~ ';"'· American "~ events' were an extremely important aspect of news coverage in ,the pre as. . Both the Province and the World depended he~vily upon ..f\me:r.-ica.n news . source's for their international news coverage (Warnock 1970:1~2-123). Nevertheless, the coverage of Americans in the United States was rarely presented with Ameritan ethnicity as a significantlactor. both papers had already succumbed to a definition of 11 In this respect, normal 11 news which did not diiferentiate happenings on the other ude· of the border from those in Canada; a report of a murder in Detroit was identically portrayed to one in Victoria, save fo1r the geographical locus of the crime.· This tendency contributed directly to the relative invisibility of Americans in the local press, for they were usually portrayed as non-ethnic individuals operating in normal society. Moreover, both papers tended to report the Americann~ss of individuals only when the individual ~o portrayed were outside of their homt: country. • It should be recalled that events conveying an ethnic element· which occurred in United States localities were ineluded in my domestic sample. .... ' ... While this might lead one to conclude that most news items dealing with American ethnicity would have occurred in the United States, it was not the case: •, - 176 -- . Locality- of News Ev-ent · British Columbia · Vancouver Pi;ovince Vancouver Daily World 9. 8 ' . 15 •"" United States 35 24 Table ~XXXI. " The Loc~!ity of Domestic News Items Dealing with Americans: Vancouver Province and Vancouv,er 'na°ily Wo:tld (1905 .- 1914) ~ Despite a lingering suspi_cion of Americ.an business in:t'ere'sts in British Columbia, b~th papers were extrem~ly sympathetic to'Americans !n their coverage of them. This followed similar press__;tepde,ncies on this subject ii:"cross the country (Baker 1970:429). Americans scored higher on the moral community measure than all other immigrant groups save for ~ Scots: British and Germans (-0. 25 in both papers). Tables XXXXII and XXXXlll prese~ the distribution of topics and subtopics found in news items which addressed American ethnicity. As can be seen, the key subject of American news items was immigration. Almost without exception,. both papers saw large scale American inunigration to the Canadian West as a good thing. A World editorial of April 3, 1906 (page 6) is characteris~ic: in discussing the possible "Americanization of the Northwest," it was the editor's position that in ·an overall sense American immigrants wer~ good for the country, noting in particular another important the~e associated with Americahs-•that they brought badly needed capital into Canada with them. Another World - 177 - Topics and Subtopics Vancouver Province ·mimber % .. Employ~ent & E conom_y -cause unemployment' ,; are unemployed . employ each other Vancouver Daily Wo.:rl~ ·_.' nwnber % -. 16. 7 2. 9 4.2 1 ;. "Numbers' increase in numbers 1 Are Restricted other 1 2. 9 1 1 1 2. 9 Ethnic Relations relations get better relations are bad anti-American investment Inunigration m~n,y are -~oming ':£'-enter illegally arrive . are 1e-ported are .fused entry should solicit more emigration to U.S. bring in money Legislative & Legal· laws limit behavior immigration law discussed Violence, Hostility By assault and harass each other are accused of crime J 2 8. 3 2 6 25. 0 5 20.8 1 4.2 1 1 9 1 1 1 2. 9 5.7 25.7 2.9 2. 9 2. 9 1 2. 9 1 2. 9 2 5.7 2. 9 4.2 4.2 1 1 2 2. 9 8. 3 3 2. 9 · 8. 6 0 '._..-. • Celebrities entertaine,r s politicians 1 1 2. 9 Sports participate in sports 1 2. 9 2.9 . ' - 178 - number o/o Ethnic Organizations ~- .E: . • - ~ s take role in community numbe-r 1 1 ,,.,1 Normal News b"-ing tgurists to B. C. 1 100.• 00/o 24 Total 35 100.0% ,{ .. Table , 4'XXXII. V '"\ . American Pomestic ·News <&:overage by Topics and . Subtopics-: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily Wotld (19Q5-1914) •~ \ . r! Topic V anc;ouver Province munber· % lmrn.igration Vancouver Daily World number % 13 54.2 14 45.9 5 20.9 1 2. 9· 2 8. 3 4 11. 5 ~ 8. 3 3 8. 7 1 .....i:.l. i. ~ 23 95. Cf'/o 27 77. 7% p Employment & E conorny Violence, Hostility By ' Ethnic Relations Legislative & -~egal Total · Table ):S:XXXlll: ,- The Most Frequent Topics of American Domestic News -Iterna: iancouve·r Provinc-e and Vancouver '· . _ Daily World (1905-1914) . . ' • . • 6 ' . ,, --.,.-.~ ' -~~:·~ . . • :.- ..,, editorial of August 2, 1909. ("The. American Invasion", page 5) ackn.owledged .' ~ . the basic !radeofi that the Liberals were willing to .m~ke; alth~u.gh increased immigration from the United States_might i~d to an Amer~canization- of . . western Cana-dian culture, Americans nonetheless made· g·o od citize.ns and contributed materially to the country. This should not .suggest that the World and the Province differed materially iti their coverage of American immigtatiOtl during this era, the former supportirig increased immigration, while the latter rejecting it in ,favor of British immigration. ~- . This was not the case. Both pap~rs ex- pressed some reservations about the cultural impact of Americans on Canada, but these concerns were in' each case clearly- subordinate to a general desir~ to see greater American immigration~ For instance, the Province'.s editorials .on this question (December 29, 1911, page 6; July 17, 1909, page 7) could easily have been editorials fbr the World; in ~e latter editorial ("Why American Farmers are Welcome in ~anad~") the editor ~f I the Province specifically refutes the observation of a writer from t11e' .. - . · London Daily Mail that the )United .States inva~ion" of Canada was a danger to the country. While the Province was ~itably more pro-British -than the World, this did not lead it t_o an anti-American stance. ~ven in terms of the eco:oomi.~ effects ~f America~s in Canada. the Province was generally favorable; while the Province occasionally claim~d ~ t Am~tic~ tended~ take jobs ~way from Canadians (see the letter to the ediJ, ·_ Province, J~y 2., 1908, ~ e 7), this worry was mitigated by the positive ... - 180 - ;.economic prospe~ts of large scale American inunigration. _r Neither did the Province nor the World characterize Americans as . ethnic.ally inferior to British stock, even though this theme was current in Conser-..:ative thought of the times (Baker 1970:426-449). Both papers perceived that Americans b~ought with them certain customs which con- ' of the British, notably a tendency to~ards trasted with the ideal ill}lge disorder, anarchy, an.d social familiarity, but both were hopeful that these tendencies would pass with time. In addition, like the British, Americans in the news were usually seen as part of normal society-. even when Americans did things which would be associated with the ethnicity of other groups. For instance, while both papers consistently used American reports of spectacular crimes as filler material, in the sample only two of these " items in the Province and four items in the World specifically associated ~ ., American ethnicity with crime. The assumed normalcy of American ethaj..city can no better be ~ummarized than in the following distribution of ,,, themes associated with it. In marked contrast to the foregoing Asian groups, Americans received almost no coverage associating them with difference, violence or immorality: "-., - -181 - ', -"'Vancouver Provinc.e ·number Theme Vancouver Daily World '--~, number Emplo;Y:_ment & Economy 14 6 Immigration 10 11 Ethnic Relations 6 6 Legislative & Legal 5 11 ' •4 4 5 1 Numbers Cultural Difference Violence, Ho~ty By Table XXXXIV. '.1 ~ I . 2 Most Common Themes in Domestic American News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World (1905-1914) Black Americans did not fare so well _in: the Vancou~r press. Their moral community scores were lower ti»n any Europeatoup except for the Italians (-0. 82 ~ t1fo Pro~ce and _-1. 61 in the Wo ). Although coverage of black ·Americans was not extensive in either paper. (n = 17 in the Province and n = 18 in the World), such cover·age as there was was extremely stigmatic. There were at that time very few black people in British Columbia, and even f~wer were actively attempting to come to Canada. What, then, accounted for their negative treatment in the press? It would seem that the press stereotype of black Americans was imported~ 12!2 from the United States via the American sources of news upon which both -papers heavily depended. Virtually all news items dealing with black Americans originated in the United States--the exact reverse of the 182 origin of most items dealing with other Americans: Vancouver Province Vancouver Daily World British Columbia 1 3 Canadian (other) 2 American 14 15 17 18 Source of News Item Total Table XXXXV. The Source of News Items dealing with black i Americans: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World (1905-1914) Virtually all of these news items also dealt with events which occurred. in the United States (82% of the Province items and 94% of the World items). Tables XXXXVI and XXXXVII outli1;1e the topics, subtopics, and tr&mes found in aasociation with news items on black Americans. Reflecting the lack of relevance of these news items to everyday British Co~bia concerns, a l ~ n e of them presented black people as individuals with names, personalities, motivations, and goals. Instead, virtually every story dealt in one way or another with the unusual,· particularly with events involving crime and violence. Considering the sample for both papers, only one news item dealt with what could be termed normal news. Neither paper provided a social or economic context for -ti these tales of conflict; there were no background articles ~n black Americans in either paper, no feature articles, editorials!, ,07 letters to the 12 editor. • - 183 - Topics and Subtopics Health & Welfare ,.., are a health hazard Vancouver Province number %· 1 5. 9 Advocation of Restriction advocate job restriction Are Restricted are denied rights 1 Charge Restriction claim their . rights bar red 1 Ethnic Relations · have outside heQp ~ Legal & Legislative laws limit laws protect are in court l 5. 6 1 5.6 5. 9 I 1 1 Vancouver Daily World number % 5. 9 5. 9 1 5. 6 5. 6 Immigration arrive 1 5. 9 1 Violence, Hostility Against are assaulted 1 5. 9 6 3 3 4 22.2 1 2 5. 6 1 17. 6 17. 6 5. 9 , 11. 1 1 1 5.9 5.9 1 5. 6 18 100.0% Violence, Hostility By • assault, harass U.S. riots are accused of crime Normal News are victims of accidents make good suicide other Total TM>le..:X:XXXVI. 1 5. 9 17 100.0% '. Black American News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World (19051914) 9 - 184 - Vancouver Province Vancouver Daily World number number Violence, Hostility By 7 16 Violence, Hostility Against 6 5 Ethnic Relations 5 3 Are Restricted 5 Cultural Difference 4 l Immigration 2 1 Legislation and Legal 2 1 Theme .\ Table XXXXVll. Most Conunon Themes in Domestic Black American News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World (1905-1914) - 185 Native People When Captain Cook first arrived on British Columbia's shores, the·re were an estimated 80,000 native people, living in the interior and the coastal areas of the region (Duff 1964:361). Subsequent contact through the next h~dred years br6ught disease, malnutrition, social disorganization, and alct>holism, whic};i severely reduced the local pop\1l.ation. By 1905, the native population of Briti~h Columbia was about 25,000 and was still falling (Canadian Annual Review 1906:484). It would not be until the 1930' s that the number of native people in the province would stabilize and eventually begin to increase (Robin 1972:31). While native people are at present largely outside of the mainstream of British Columbia economic life, this was not always the case. In earlier days, native people shaped and shared in the province's expansion and growth. In the fur trade they had been a necessary part of the economic order and it was only with the coming of industrialization that native people were increasingly relegated to inferior and part-time roles in the local economy. For instance, while native people are credited with discovering . • the important coal reserves near Nanaimo in the mid-1850' s and even were • the first to _mine it, they were soon supplanted by British miners (Griffin 1958:14). Nevertheless, native people played an important role in other aspects of the provincial economy before World War I. They were very active in the salmon fishing industry, both as fishermen and as cannery workers. ( - 186 In more isolated areas, their participation in the logging industry was extensive, and native people also adapted to fill the roie of migratory agricultural worker. In general, native people constituted an important source of reserve labor for a fluctuating and seasonal British Columbia economy (Robin 1972:31). .. As such, native people were not seen by others as serious competitors ' . ;_,- to the "white capitalist, landowner, or laborers" (Robin 1972:31). Al- though the claim of native people to aboriginal land rights occasionally was\ L cause for white concern, in general native people were neither feared nor totally despised. Rather, they were viewed somewhat like errant children, who were the heirs of a (romanticized) past in Nature in which they could no longer participate; neither had they "learned the ways of the modern world" sufficiently to be given a full role in it. As can be seen in Tables XXXXVIII and XXXXIX, the press coverage of native people during this era was quite extensive. 8. 9°lo of the Province's and 11. 7% of the World'_s coverage of domestic ethnicity concerned native_ people. This is a greater percentage than any European ethnic group, and is comparable in frequency with that devoted to South Asians. The negative societal image of native people in British Columbia 13 carried over to the press portrayal of Indians in both papers. By far, the most common topic found in these news items was Indians in one way or f another being violent or hostile to others or to themselves. In particular, the Province was keenly interested in this topic, devoting 39. 7% of its • - 187 - Topics and Subtopics Housing & Settlement do not keep up their houses Vancouver Province number % 1 1 2. 1 2. 1 Education other Health & Welfa·re health is poor Advocation of Restriction should deny conveniences should deny ethnic ways 2 2 4.2 Ethnic Relations orga~zations try to better relations relations mediated by others relations are good relations are bad have outside support impose their ways Legislative & Legal laws limit behavior laws protecting behavior discussed are in the courts protest to government other Violence, Hostility Against are assaulted victims of crime ' :r,.. 1 1.5 1 1.5 1 1.5 1 1.5 1 1.5 3 4.6 2 1 3. 1 2 1 3. 1 1. 5 1 1.5 1 2. 1 1 2. l 1 2. 1 1 2. 1 2 4.2 1 1 4.2 Are Restricted are barred from jobs Charge Restriction claim citizenship barred not allowed ethnic ways other Vancouver Daily World number % 6. 3 6 1.5 6. 2 1.5 9. 2 4.2 2 2 3. 1 3. 1 2. 1 4 1 3 2 1.5 - 188 number % number % Violence, Hostility By as~ault, harass others assault, harass each other U.S. A. riots, & demonstrations meet imposition with force are accused of crime cause crime to increase are violent given capital punishment 1 9 4 2. 1 18. 8. 8. 3 5 5 7. 7 7.7 2 4.2 1 4 1.5 6. 2 2 3. 1 Cultural Difference have different morals have different religion require special provisions have different idea of law other 1 1 2 1 1. 5 1 1.5 1 1.5 1 1 1.5 1.5 1 1.5 1 1 2 1 1.5 1.5 3. 1 1.5 1 Celebrities entertainers social notables historical notables Ethnic Organizations celebrate their festivals take role in community celebrate holidays 2 1 4.2 2. 1 2. 1 2. 1 4.2 2. 1 ".: 2 4. 2 . _s " Normal News hwnan interest are accident victims make good other Total Talile XXXXVlll. 3 6. 3 1 3 1 1 1.5 4:6 1.5 1.5 48 100. 0% 65 100.0o/o Native Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World (1905- lc,fl4) - 189 ' Ywic'gµver Province Topic Vancouver Daily World ,; I number % number % Violence, Hostility By 19 39. 7 18 27.7 Cultural Difference 5 U). 5 3 4.5 Legislative . & Legal 4 8.4 13 19. 9 Ethnic Relations 4 8.·4 6 9. 2 Normal News 3 6. 3 6 9. 1 Charge Restriction 2 4.2 4 6. 1 Ethnic Organizations 2 4.2 4 6. 1 Violence, Hostility Against 2 4.2 4 6. 1 41 85. 9% 58 88~ 7% Total '·, TABLE XXXXIX. The Most Frequent Topics of Native Domestic News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World (1905-1914) - 190 - ,domestic coverage of Indian ethnicity to it. Indians were very often seen to be prone towards interpersonal yiolen~ - -fighting and common assault were frequently found subtopics relating to Indians. It' should be noted that this ·association of native people's ethnicity with violence stands in contrast with coverage of both the British and Americans when they are reported to have done similar things; in the latte: ca~e ethnicity was rarely reported to have been a factor, while in the former it almost always was. Despite this common fascination with the perceived violence of Indians, the Province and the World differed quite significantly in their portrayal of other aspects of Indian life. On the whole, the World was far more sym- pathetic to the Indian situation than was the Province; this is reflected in the fact that the Province's moral community score was far lower (-1. 34) than the World's. (-0. 80). On the whole, the Province was much more sensitive to native cultural differences, and tended to use cultural difference as an off-hand explanation of the then present plight of Indians. This concern with cultural difference is especially obvious at the level of • themes. As indicated in Table L, 45 out of the 47 news items in the Province's domestic sa~e included a theme of cultural difference. This contrasts with the World~here only 23 out of 65 news items contained themes of this sort. - 191 - Vancouver Province number Vancouver Daily World number 45 23 19 24 Ethnic Relations 14 3 Legislative & Legal 5 21 Violence, Hostility Against 5· 4~ Theme Cultural Difference Violence, Hostility By Q- ~ 4 2 Employment & Economy 3 Ethnic Organizations Table L. Most Common Themes in Native: Domestic A}l1erican News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World (1905-1914) In turn, virtually all of these perceived cultural differences- were stigmatic. The Province referred time and ti.m e again to the fact that Indians stuck together, had different morals, ate different foods, had a different religion, and consequently required (or demanded) the ability to do things whic;h others either did not, 1Vould not, or could not. For its part, thf? World tended to pre sent a greater spectrum of Indian activities than the Province, as ,ie indicated by the range of subtopics found in Table XXXXVfil. The World was also more concerned with local Indian happenings; about 70o/o of the World's sample occurred in British Columbia, while only 500/o of the Province• s did. In terms of frequencies, the World therefore presented as much coverage on provincial Indian ethnicity as the Province did on Indians altogether. Moreover, the World occasionally actively s~pported Indian causes, especially in reaction to the appropriation of Indian land by the provincial government. For .instance, in an editorial of April 3, 1907 ("Indian Reserve Titles'.', page 7), the World argued that 1nt portrayed as being a particularly severe threat to white dnmjnance, neither were they ~een as contributing anything in particular to British Colwnbia. Viol~ and uncivilized, they would need many more years of contact with "white culture" be.fore they ., • , - 194 - could take a more substantial place'in the society. This portrayal of native people provided a perfect legitimation for white control over the province's destiny. It provided an explanation of the sorry state oi Indians (it was their own fault). Moreover, because it fitted so well with the then current ideas of British manifest destiny, this ideology created a. framework for ethnic relations, and made close political and legal control of natives look like it was in.native interests. As with the press' treatment of Asians, only in the most minimal ways did either paper support the cause of this disadvantaged and subordinated minority; rather than an advocate for minority rights, the press directly contributed to the perpetuation of subordinate native status by supporting the ideological rationales for keeping natives separate and i ~ r . Other Europeans I . By far, the foregoing gro,,ttps constituted the most salient ones in the press portrayal of ethnicity during the decad~ 1905 to 1914. In a way, .~ this selective silence on othez: Europeans in partic..ular reflects the ethnic makeup of Vancouver before World War I. It will be recalled that the British,. Americans, and Asians made up the great majority of the foreignborn. In comparison, the French, German, Austro-Hungarian, Scandinavian, Russian, Italian, and Greek populations of the city togethe.r constituted but 4. 3~ of the population at large ,(MacDonald 1970:341). Unlike Prairie and Eastern c i.,~ , Vancouver had not yet experienced a . large influx of continental European imnugrants. -- 195 - Coverage of the ethnicity of other European im~grants is broken down in Table LI: Ethnic Origin Vancouver Province Western & Northern European Dutch French German Scandinavian Other Southern European Italian Greek Other Eastern European Doukhobors Hunglrian Russian Ukranian Polish . VancouveJ<.,_Daily World 1 1 12 8 10 2 5 4 3 30 26 3 4 1 8 2 . 6 1 5 12 2 1 Hispano -Portuge se Latin American Spanish 1 Europeans (Unspecified) 6 1 2 8 ' 3 Australian/New Zealand 2 I South African/Rhodesian (white) 2 Table LI:- Frequency of Domestic Coverage of Other European Groups: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World (1905-1914) Western and Northern Europeans As can be seen, Western and Northern Europeans received very little coverage in either paper, with the exception of Germans. In retro- spect, it is noteworthy that the treatment of German ethnicity in this period prior to World War I was quite positive. Although the low frequency of German news items makes it difficult to develop the press image of these people in detail, in an overall sense, Germans were se~n to be good immigrant material. Although the press saw Germans as holding onto a loyalty to their homeland for long periods of time, both papers generally conceded that they worked hard, stayed out of trouble, and were in the long term assimilatable. As will be detailed in the subsequent chapter, this favorable stereotype was to distintegrate with the arrival of World War I. Altl)ough the French received relatively little coverage, even in so small a sa.inple one can see what later becomes a principal element of the press portrayal of French Canadians--crime. Fully one half of the- French sample from both the Province and the World dealt with the French as criminals. Eastern Europeans Coverage of Eastern Europeans was of Northern and Western Europeans, for unlike the latter, the former were ~-~ ~ in the middle of a political controversy between ~ d e r a l Liberals and ,_/ Conservatives. Laurier' s solicitation o~European immigrants was a hot .,.~) - 197 - political issue of the day (Palmer 1975:17), and the conservative Province had more than a pas sing interest in using Eastern European news items to embarrass the Liberals. The Province kept to a relatively consistent theme that Eastern Europeans were culturally different, negatively affected the economy, were violent and unassimilatable; as in the analogous case of the Japanese, the World's response was to remain silent on this issue, as is indicated by Tables Lil and Lill. Italians At first glance, the coverage of Italians by both the Province and the World seems anomalous. First of all, their coverage was relatively heavy--30 and 26 news items, respectively, despite the fact that there were only 1,922 Italians in Vancouver in 1911. Secondly, their coverage was extremely stigmatic; in both papers the Italian moral community score (' was lower than any other group (-2. 13 in the Province and -1. 81 in the World). Tables LIV and LV amply illustrate the activities and tendencies I which the press associated with Italians. Italians seem to have been stereotyped more severely by the press than any other group. Certainly no other group's portrayal is so concentrated into a few stigmatic qualities. The Italians in the press were, first of all, violent and triminally inclin~d; this reflect~.d general North American views of Italians (Vallee and Schwartz 1961:565). 77% of the Province's coverage of Italians dealt with this topic- -a figure identical to the World's. Approximately one out of four news items in either paper dealing with Italians concerned Italians 198 Topics and Subtopics Vancouver Province · .Vancouver Daily World number % number % Housing & Settlement are denied housing 1 4.2 Employment & Economy work hard 1 4.2 Nwnbers are increasing Ethnic Relations try better relations r·e'lations are mediated r-elations are bad impose their ways have outside help . . Immigration arrive are refused entry 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 7~ 1 1 7. 1 1 1 7. 1 7. 1 1 1 7. 1 7. 1 4.2 4.2 4.2 4.2 4.2 4.2 4.2 Legislative & Legal are in court make bad citizens laws limit 1 4.2 Violence, Hostility Against are assaulted 1 4.2 I 7. 1 3 12. 5 4. 2 2 1 14. 3 7. 1 1 7. 1 1 7. 1 Violence, Hostility By assault, hara•• others assault, haraas each other are accused of crime cause crime to increase meet imposition with force 1 2 1 Cultural Difference different religion humor 1 Celebrities 1 8. 3 4.2 4.2 4.2 0 I - . 199 - ,, ,..· \ . \ % number % 1 7. 1 •. l 7. 1 1 4.2 8. 3 4.2 24 100. 0% 14 100.0% numbe.-r Ethnic Organizations organize in community Normal News human interest accident victims make good Total Table LII. 2 Eastern European Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World (1905-1914) Theme ~ 1 Vancouver Province number Vancouver Daily World number Cultural Difference 15 9 Ethnic Relations 6 1 Employment and Economy 5 1 Violence, Hostility By 5 5 Immigration 2 2 Education 2 Health and Welfare 3 Table Lill. Most Common Themes in Domestic Eastern European News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World (1905-1914) I .,. 200 - Topics and Subtopics Vancouver Province number % Vancouver Daily World number % Ethnic;: Relatj.ons relations are mediated -1 3. 8 Legislative & Legal are in court reports on immigration 1 1 3. 8 3. 8 l 1 3. 8 3. 8 1 3. 8 1 2 10 2 1 1 1 3. 8 ,$. 7 "38. 5 7.7 1 3. 8 1 3. 8 2 7.7 1 3. 8 5 19. 2 1 3. 3 6. 7 3. 3 30 100.0% 26. 100.0o/o Immigration too much other 3. 3 -Violence, Hostility Against are assaulted Violence, Hostility By assault, harass others assault each other are accused of crime cause crime to increase are executed are violent other 4 13. 3 12 40.0 20.0 6 1 3. 3 Cultural Di.fference di£fereJ1t eating customs bad language use 1 3. 3 Celebrities politicians L ,v"" social notables 1 3. 3 Ethnic Organizations -1. have suspicious organizations Normal News human interest victims of accidents other Total Table LIV. 1 2 3. 8 3.8 3. 8 Italian Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World (1905-1914) . .. - 201 - Vancouver Province 'Vancouver Daily World nwnber nwnber Cultural Difference 24 2 Violence, Hostility By 18 20 ~nic· Relations 4 Themes . lm~gration . 3 Legal and Legislative 3 6 Haye Suspidous Organizations 3 6 Table LV. ,Most- Common. Themes in Domestic Italian News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World 14 1905 -1914) - 202 - assaulting each other. It would seem that two factors combined to generate such a stigmatic picture of Italians in the press. The first of these involved Canadian views of American immigration policy. Traditionally, American immigration. policy had tended to be somewhat more open than that of Canada in terms of the ethnic range of immigrants which the former found acceptable. At the turn of the century the United States had turned to Italy and to Eastern Europe in a search for more industrial labor. The decade 1905-1914 saw an enormous influx of Italians into the United States, which in turn provoked concern in Canada that the federal goverrunent might follow a similar course (Leacock 1911:316-327; Lower 1965:382). These reservations about large scale Italian immigration were clearly present in British Columbia, where several thousand Italians had arrived between 1900 and 1911. Italians were beginning to be characterized as white Chinese (Royal Commission on Italian Immigration 1905). ~though there were less than two thousand Italians in the Vancouver area at that time, fears were already being raised about the generation of a Vancouver "Little Italy", Italians taking awa~s from Canadians, and the social implications of Italian immigration. Secondly, the large influx of Ita.lians into the United States was duly noted by the American press, and these stories were in turn picked up by 1 the Province and the World. 33o/o of th~ Prov ince ·:1 -~ sample and 54o/o of the World's sample pre•ented events which occurred in the United States. .. The 203 - following item is typical: ITALIAN CONVICTS INVADE NEW YORK No Less thart Five Thousand Said to be in City (Province, August 30, 1911, page 1) Italians are an important indicator of how finely discriminating the ethnic c"~tegorization of the press was. Sociological and historical com- mentary upon this era has tended to characterize ethnic relations in British Columbic:1; as being Asian-white relations, with the former subordinate to the later. In so doing, one of the most basic facts of the actual structure of ethnicity in this context have been obscured--that neither were all whites nor all Asians seen as being the same. Both the press and the people made relatively clear distinctions between different varieties of Europeans; Italians are clearly on the cut line of the moral community, individuals who were acknowledge~ as racially white, yet treated by the press as culturally colored. Immigrants Immigrants do not constit1'ite an ethnic group in any normal sense. Nevertheles·s, "immigrants" as a category provided one means for the<· newspapers to express opinion on the general question of immigration and its effects on Canadian life. Particularly in later eras, "immigrants"· also provided a way of the press expressing disapproval of specific types of immigrants without incurring a charge of•racism (see Appener of news items which cast"~thnic relations into ~~') an oppositional mold of: s~, Asians versus Canadians. This did not occur. Moreover, "Canadians" were very rarely reported as the secondary figures in ethnically relevant news items. In the total combined sample of domestic and foreign coverage, only 1. 9% (n = 13) items in the Province noted Canadians as the second ethnicity involved, and the World did no better ( I. 5%, n = 11). So V1eak was press reported Canadian identity that virtually all the (racist) rationales of the eta for the exclusion of Asians and others as undesirable made reference to the rights of the- British or "whites" rather than to the riggts of Canadians. \ -ziz- _. , ·~ This relative weak press portrayal of Canadian ethnicity should not suggest that Canadian identity necessarily was similarly weak in the - 1 I population itself. The, press and the elites represented in it are only one aspect of the public, and their views and interests are hardly identical with individuals from other walks of life (Porter 1974:457-461; Clement 1975 :27 3--282). Similar misguided inferences from the historical utter- ance s of elites have led to a gathering consensus that the population of Canada was conservative, Anglophile, and perpetually in a state of anxiety over order and good government. '\ Certainly for the limited case under investigation here such an inference would seem to be unjustifiable. While elite British travellers wrote about the British feeling of Victoria, Canadian workers faced Canadian militia men in pitched battles over power in the workplace (McNaught 1970:67). News items claiming that Canadians and British were as one, and that the British were just as Canadian as 11 Canadians ( True Canadians, 11 Province, March 3, 1914, page 4) could find their way into print but a f~w months before the beginning of a war where an important segment of the Canadian population would steadfastly refuse to enlist to "save Britain" (Mcinnis 1958:412-414). Like Canadian ethnicity, that of French Canadians was virtually ignored, as indicated by Table LX. It is interesting to no~e that in what coverage they did receive, French Canadians were not portrayed in a particularly stigmatic fashio~. There appeared to be a slight tendency on the part of the Proy.ince to comment on (negative) ethnic relations and the "'.~ Vancouver Province number % Topics and Subtopics Education 1 11. 1 Ethnic Relations relations are gc;,od relations are bad 1 1 11. 1 11.-1 Immigration should stay in Canada 1 11. 1 Cultural Difference are loyal to home have different religion 2 22.2 Gelebritie s social notables historical notables 1 1 11. 1 11. 1 Sports Vancouver Daily World number °lo 1 1 12. 5 12. 5 1 1 12. 5 12. 5 1 12.5 1 12. 5 2 25.0 8 100. 0% / Ethnic Organizations organize in community Normal News human interest 1 11. 1 Total '9 100. 0% Table LX. French Canadian Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Daily World (1905-1914) - 214 - cultural differences of French Canadians more frequently than the World ) (at the level of themes), but for the most part French Canadians were rather consistently ignored. There was virtually no ethnic coverage at all. of French Canadians in British Columbia, whose numbers had increased from a few hundred to about two thousand in the decade after 1900. Even the attempts of lumber companies to introduce French Canadian labor 15 (Stewart 1956:39) at the expense of Asians met with press silence. Ethnicity and the Press (1905-1914) This chapter has outlined how the Vancouver press portrayed ethnicity and ethnic groups between 1905 and 1914. To this point, the concen- tration has been on how various ethnicities were dealt with by the newspapers on a group by group basis, and on the contextualization of these - . descriptions by comparison and through reference _to the social and political environment out of which these iplage s sprang. Having done so, in conclusion to the analysis of this era I would like to suggest a range of more general points which can be drawn from this data on ethnic portryal in Vancouver. The ress defined a consensus view of reali ethnics were deviants. 6 in relationshi to it, Implicitly, the Vancouver press subscribed to a definition of British Columbian society which emphasized consensus, stability, orderliness, homogeneity, and the lack of conflict; in fact, the world as ~onstructed by the press was like a parody of functionalist sociological models. "Real" - 215 - people obeyed the law, had identical interests (which were reflected in that law), a common culture (without alternative interpretations), and common origins. This consensus view of British Columbia mystified a wide range o_f relationships of struggle and attempted domination, one set of which were those relating to ethnicity, power, and privilege. The primary c_o ntent of the press was the unusual and th~ abnormal, rather than the mundane and everyday, , but more than that, press content was a selection of unusual cast in a very special way. Most importantly, the portrayal of ethnicity in the paper was primarily a portrayal of events which were unusual because they we re defined against this consensus view to be deviant; this deviance was frequently seen to be but a manifestation of a deeper deviation from normal society--ethnic difference. This characterization of the (non - British) ethnic as deviant in turn fundamentally affected how events portrayed in these news items were " explained" by the press. As illustrated many times in earlier parts ·of this chapter ethnicity in British Columbia was a factor in the primary definition of British Columbia socyty, both economically, politically, . and socially. Nevertheless, the press portrayal of events which wei:e in one way or the other the outcomes of the particular ways in which ethnicity and ethnic relations were organized ~ere alnlost never placed in that structural context. 1£, for instance, a Chinese individual were arrested f~r fighting -.J with a white British Colwnbian, the emphasis of the story would almost - 216 - inevitably be on that µidividual' s devi:att criminality- -the criminality of an outsider to society- -rather than upon the structural relationships between whites and Chinese which generated and were represented by that incident. To carry this example along f~ther, whereas the Chinese i n d i ~ l was as much a part. of the provincial economy and society as the white, he would never be portrayed as· such; moreover, the event itself would tend to be defined in individual terms (the deviant Chinese) rather than socio•logical ones (the oppressed Chinese). The accentuation of the abnormal tended on the whole to further stigmatize those of ethnic backgro~nds, for "ethnics" were rarely associated with. normal events ~ e pre~s conseq~ently turned them into faint images of real people. fo take the most extreme example of this practice, "press Italians" were individuals who spent their whole waking hours murdering, seduci.J:ig, and robbing normal hwnan beings. Even if it were not the o ~ t intent of the press to stigmatize or misrepresent minority ethnic groups (which it often was), press sensitivity to the unusual and nonBritish would have assured this result, 2. ~ The world created by the press was ethnically stratified: only a few ethnic groups were defined as being within the moral community , · The Vancouver press of thi~ era did not operate upon a premise of 17 ethnic equality. Rather, the conviction that ethnicity was and should be a direct determinant of the rights and privileges of individuals was overt and was not seen to be in need of any justifica-tlon. ----------I ( This stance has often - 217 - been shown in the preceding discussion. As 'paralleled the distribution of power and privilege in British Columbia, both papers created a hierarchy of ethnic castes composed of three basis "varnas." On top we,.-e the British and a few others whose racial, ethnic, class, or status position was reasonably close to them. They were portrayed as the paragons of virtue, industry, and morality. Second came those whites whose position was > ambiguous, who had some of the caste attributes of t h ~ more exalted than themselves but riot all of them. Third were the outcasts--those who were defined to be altogether out of the moral community--notably Asians, Native people, and Italians. The marked way in which the press differ- entially evaluated various ethnicities has a number of consequences. One of the mos_t important of these is that: 3. The consensus model of society defined by the press was an ethnicbased model: normal society was British society " The association of the normal universe with British individuals, their customs and beliefs, had an enormous iinpact on how ethnicity was presented by both papers, for it led to an identification ot deviance with ":seal" ethnics, such as the Chinese, Italians, and Native Indians. Con- versely, events of a similar nature involving those of~Canadian, American, or British origin rarely were presented within an ethnic relations framework. , Consequently, the press served to reinforce the ideal view of the orderliness, pro1;>riety, and industry of Anglo groups and individuals. ( As \ - 218 ~ in the ideal model, the press portrayal of these groups implied that individuals of those national and ethnic origins were never involved in class conflict, interpersonal violence, labor organization, immorality or other ways in which one might diverge from the norm. The press assumed that British values were fundamental and desired, and were for the most part , achieved. The general orientation of the press was class-biased as much as it was biased ethnically. For the most part, both the Province and the World presented the news from the point of view of the middle class. _/ For in- stance, though unsympathetic to Asians both papers consistently preached a policy of moderation in the advocation of Asian exclusion; immigration L was to be stopped through legislation and treaty, not in the streets. This middle class vie~/s also evident in the fact that even the supposed proworking class World consistently fawned over visiting Asian notables. In ter_ms of their general news reporting, neither paper tended to consistently express the concerns of working class people. In this regard, even the expressed advocation of British ethnicity in these n·ewspapers cannot be assumed to be representative of the feeling of the population at large. While it has been shown that a large number of Vancouver's population were either of British or Anglo-Canadian origin, many people were neither British, Anglo-Canadian, American, nor Asian, and these individuals tended to congregate in the·-working class. It would Jll-be difficult to argue that these individuals would have seen "British values" \ - 219 - in quite such a favorable light as did the newJ!>apers of that era. ( 4. rofaned the identities of minori ethnic Although it is now impossible to know what direct effects press por;. trayal had on those who were al!I portrayed, it is clear that the press· definition of the ethnic panorama profaned the social identities of a number of ethnic groups. In this, it performed a display ·function, bringing these individuals and the events and practices presumed to be associated with them onto the sacrificial altar of public.l-'scrutiny. In fact, considering the relative lack of other means of communicat_ion, the press must have been one of the mo st important if not the principal vehicle through which British Columbians received information about minorities. As such,, it must also have been a fundamental generator of consensus upon the ways in which minorities were seen to pose ~ctual or potential so~l problems. In this sense, the press acted as far more than a vehicle for the dissemination _ of information, for it provided the public forum in which minorities were , ~ judged, found unworthy• and sentenced. ' Far from being a passive channel for the transmission of societal happenings the newspapers actively participated in. the situations about which they reported. To take Asians as an example, the press defined their immigration as a threat and a fundamental social problem, demanded to know the opinions of politicians and other notal:ties on the subject, reported these, and editorialized when either the Asian situation or the / - 220 - inactivity of politicians worried them. They were not neutral. This process of profaning the identities of minorities was also contributed to by a less inteJ}tional but no le\;,important factor, {lotably, the_ format of the newspaper pr,ess itself. It was characteristic of the news- paper genre of that era to repbrt events via a formula which stressed the immediate context of the event and neglected the larger social context. A fight between two individuals would demand a surprisingly few additional pieces of itiformation to constitute a news story--the names of the individuals involved, a sequence of preliminary events and motives leading up to the fight, and the resolution of the conflict. This concentration on the imm_ediate at the expense of that which was an underlying factor or was once removed from the event has frequently been noted as leading to the inability of the press to accurately convey the meaning of events to its readership (Cohen and Young 1973:8). • In the case of ethnic minorities (at least, in this particular case) this tendency led f~rther, from the stigmatization of the individuals involved to an individualization of the ' problem and to a minimization of underlying social causes which might have precipitated the event. Thus, "Two Indians Fight" simultaneously make the.individuals involved responsible for the situation and stigmatizes them for breaking the moral order, while at the same tiftle neglecting the poverty, social disorganization, and discrimination which may have contributed to the event. t. Naturally, profaning the identities of minority indi~uals legitimated - 221 - ..,.. the rights and privileges of those who were not so stigmatized; l9 more accurately, the legitimations it created help to turn ethnic-based privileges into what appeared to b~ rights. In comparison with those who t_he press cast outside the moral community, virtually everyone else, be they oldtime residents 6r new immigrants, rich or poor, could find something .within their own condition which at least .appeared to be a sign of being superior. Because the press frequently shifted its oppesitional categories to include a,,greater or fewer number of individuals among the ethnic saved, ",', it must also have tended to push marginal groups such as Eastern • ' Europeans and Italians towards greater Anglo conformity; while they were categorized a~ white, they were not British, and, the plight of the Asians must have served as a warning to them of the results of transgressing themoral order. Asians in particular served to validate the status of normal non-British whit_e immigrants. Moses Rischen' s (1972:79) comments about early California also .hold for British Columbia: ~ From the beginning, Asian immigrants fulfilled a signµicant role, in California. Their presence conferred instant status on all European immigrants that was not their lot elsewhere except in the South, where slavery was endemic. This profane image had one other unfortunate aspect, in that there is . no doubt that the press portrayed most stigmatized minority groups as being polluting. Minorities were associated with eating polluted substances and with living in dirt and disease. They were immoral and sexually un- ~ 2 usual--and both:,qualities were contagious. 0 .,.., - 222 - 5. The press did not a.dvoca.te ethnic equality Opposing the presence or activitie-s of an ethnic group, the press had many alternatives available. It might have argued that individuals of that ethnicity should be curbed:because of economic ~ o n s - - a r g u i n g , say, that there was too much unemployment in the province to make further immigration desirable. Alternatively, it might have argued from a. humanistic viewpoint: these people will h a v ~ d time if they were to be allowed to come to Canada. To name but one other option, the press might have argued that their presence would lead to social disruption. \ In fa.ct, while the Province and the World were to use all of these arguments and more, the ultimate thesis was one of racial and cultural superiority. As far as both papers were concerned, all ethnicities were not equal; and arguments for the exclusion of individuals did not need to go beyond this "evident" point. Th~. racial and etlµtlc positiohs of both papers were overt, and neither paper saw any need to justify their position on this question. Neither did either paper take the slightest consigeration of how the various minority individuals so portrayed woµld interpret coverage ol themselves • . ' Both papers consistentl{used the derogatory terms for minority individuals which .were in common usage--John Chinamen, Jap, Hindoo, Celestial, and the like. Both papers ridiculed Asian and European minorities alike in cartoons and derided them in editorials. ' . . - 223 - 6. The press was not the champion of the downtrodden In sharp contrast to one of the most persistent mythologies of the press, neither the Province nor the World actively championed for the betterment of the position of any minority ethnic group. In those rare cases when either paper supported minority causes it was always from a· perspective of complete .paternalism. Far from advocates of minority rights, both papers were extremely conservative on this issue. 7. The press reflected the particular concerns of British Columbia With the exception of the stereotypic views of black American and Italians, most of the_p.re&-e-- generated imag~s of ethnicity were modified to fit local needs. The most obvious examples of this are the stereotypes of the Chinese, Japanese, and South Asians. In each c~se, virtually all Canadian immigration had been to Briti~p Columbia, which forced the press and public to generate their own BritisJI-:.Columbian ·social identities for these groups. While they we re definitely based upon prevailing stereotypes of China, Japan and India, the prirn.ary elements of these_ social identities w·ere framed in terms.'of local issues. One also sees this British Columbian perspective in the relative frequency with which the various groups were portrayed in the press. Most. people were not portrayed at all, while·those who were to be found in the press were of those few ethnic origins which the press saw as being tied up with the concerns of the day. , ( ' ~ 224 8. There wts little if any fundamental difference between the portrayal . of ethnicity in the Province a~d the World: different political affiliations led to only minor differences between the two. Although a range of small differences between the way the Province and the World presented ethnicity hav,e been pointed out in the previous discussion, nothing should obscure the more basic point that fundamentally there was almost no difference between the two paper~ow they portrayed ethnicity. In fact, the parallels are remarkafe in their consistency. Both paper·s presented almost the same proportion o their total space to ethnicity. The frequency with which various were almost identical. made the papers Most format variab es were virtually indisting- uishable. Those differences which were ost evident were comparatively minor. and Liberal parties, but in comparison with the general similarity between the Province and the World one can say that for the most part the papers were nqt politically divided in their evaluations of ethnicity. While the Province sought to associate the supposed problems stemming from immigration with the Federal Liberals in an outf ront and confrontational way, their solutions and their characterizations of the ethnically approved and disapprgved were al.Jnost identical to those of the World. In short, the intensely competitive economic and political relati%nship between the World and the Province did not lead either of them to try to generate differing versions of reality in the sphere of ethnicity, and it - C - - 225 - would be impossible to argue that the presence of competition in any way led either paper toward presenting a view of the world any closer to reality than had there been no competition. In terms of ethnicity, the portrayal of one paper simply confirmed that of the other. 9. The presentation of foreign news items on ethnicity was comparatively minor. Neither paper gave overseas ethnic happenings extensive coverage. Only 22% (n = 153) of the Province's coverage was of foreign ethnicity; this figure was identical for di'e World (n = 160). In general, the things in the rest of the world that interested the press were identical to domestic, concerns: ethnic relations, crime, violence, and cultural difference. As with the domestic coverage of ethnicity, foreign coverage uniformly tended to see political action and social problems in individualistic, devia'nt terms. As noted more generally by Habermas (1970:42): The gentle social control exercised by the mass media makes use of the spectacles of an undermined private sphere in order to make political processes unrecog-· nizable as such. The depoliticized public realm is dominated by the imposed privatism of mass culture. The personalization of what is public is thus the cement in the cracks of a relatively well-integrated society, which forces suspended conflicts into areas of social psychology. There they are absorbed in categories of deviant behaviour; as private conflicts, illness, and crime. This tendency was further augmented by the frequency .with which news items reported events in colonial situations, for these events were uniformly presented from the point.of view of the colonizer rather than the colonized. • - 226 Chapter Three: ) Notes 1. It should be recalled that actual measurements of article length were made on a microfilm reader, where the scale of r_eproduction is not identical with the original. The actual average lengths are given in the text. 2. These figures are census estimates of the ultimate paternal ethnic origins of British Columbia residents. Thus, people of United States birtn were classified in terms of their ultimate European origins, as were Canadians. This ta,ble only lists groups with substantial nwnbe rs. 3. Assigning a moral value to behavioral attributes without reference to the group with which those attributes are associated is subject to considerable error, and the subsequent moral community scores are therefore to be considered as approximate me~ures only; for instance, the attribute that a given type of per son saves money may have a positive connotation in one case (a Scot) and a negative one in another (a Chinese individual). Nevertheless, the resulting scores are well in accord with my more subjective sense of how the various groups were portrayed. 4. Canadians and French Canadians have been added to these tables because of their obvious relevance to the discussion of ethnicity in Canada, despite having frequencies of occurrence of less than ten. 5. As discussed here, "British" includes the English, Scots, and Welsh, in addition to direct references to British ethnicity specifically. Thus, tables referring to the British include items for all of these categories, unless otherwise specified. They do not include the Irish. 6. For instance, see the editorial in the Province (May 1, 1908, page 7) decrying the activities of the Salvation Army, which was involved in bringing the British urban poor to Canada. 7. The importance of those of British birth is indicated by their representation in the 1890 Biographical Dictionary of British Columbians. Of 178 individuals listed in this work who were resident in British Columbia in 1871, 94 were born in Britain, 45 in the Dominion of Canada, 7 in British Columbia, 12 in the United States, and 20 elsewhere (Sage 19'"7'b:61). 8. For another example, see "Labour Men Decry Salvation Army i - 227 - Schemes" in the Province (March 12, 1913, page 7) or the editorial in the same paper titled "Immigration Regulations" (June 16, 1910, page 6). 9. A similar, if even more gruesome example is "Ship Rats Feed on Corpse" (World, October 17, 1907, page 1), which vividly portrayed the drowning of a Chinese individual off of the docked immigrant ship 1 Tartar. The body was left in the water for the rats. 'Dead Man is 11 Held for Tax (World, October 17, 1907, page 10), followed up this story with a report that custom officials demanded that the $500 head tax on new immigrants be paid on the dead man before the body would be released to the coroner. - 10. Themes dealing with Japanese being loyal to their home government had frequencies of 6 and 2 for the Province and World, respectively. 11. In fact, W. J. Bowser, who 12. Gaultung (1965) has shown that this tendency to report more negatively upon more distant news is fairly general. The conflict level of news items also tends to increase with distance •. 13. Virtually all coverage of native people during this era was specifically about Indians. It should be noted that even at this early date Inuit were much tnore sympathetically' covered by the· press than 11 Indians. For this contrasting stereotype of the Inuit, see Spent Years Among the Eskimos 11 (Province, October 1, 1909, page 24). 14. 11 Have Suspicious Organizations is technically a theme .under Ethnic 11 Organizations and Events, but inasmuch as all themes under the latter were about suspicious organizations, I put this theme into Table LV. 15. French Canadians were hired primarily by the Fraser River Lumber Co., and the Canadian W~stern Lumber Co., around 1911-1912 (Stewart 1956:39). 16. See' Paul F. Lazarsfeld and Robert K. Merton (1948~9~-118); also 1 Murdock s (1973:156-175) study on the press presentation of political deviance and Paletz & Dunn (1967). 17. In this sense the press did no~ deviate from government policy. 11 11 uncovered the plot and who was McBride I s prospective Attorney-General, was active in Japanese 11 1 labor contracting when he made his 'discovery (Robin 1972: 101). 11 11 Until 1965 certain national groups had prefer red entrance status to Canada. - 228 - 18. See Garfinkel (1955:42-52). 19. For a discussion of this process see Braroe (1974). 20. Warren Breed has expressed the importance of the media in g1VU1g society an image of itself and for creating the agpearance of agreement to millions of individuals. This seems an apt comment on ethnicity (1964:187): By expressing, dramatizing, and repeating cultural patterns, both the traditional and the newly emerging, the media reinforces tradition and at the same time • explains news roles. Members of the society thus remain integrated within the sociocultural structure. As a form of adult socialization, the media are seen as guarantors that a body of common ulti~ate values remains visible as a _continuing source of consensus dee spite the inroads of change. i ' - 229 Chapter Four: Ethnicity in the Vancouver Press (1928-37) This chapter follows the. same organizational structure of the pre v1ous one. The fir st section sketches out the broad outline of ethnic P~ttrayal during this era in terms of format and basic issues. The following section focuses more closely upon the portrayal of ethnicity on a group by group basis, while the concluding part summarizes the coverage of ethnicity for this decade. The goals of this chapter are also the same as those of the previous era, modified by the ability to look backwards • from this era and compare newspaper coverage of ethnicity during I 9 2 8 - I 9 3 7 with that of I 9 0 5 - 19 14. I. "Format: The Quantity and Distribution of Ethnically Related Items The decade 1928-1937 saw a number of factors contribute toward a stabilization of Vancouver's ethnic panorama. While immigration to Canada resumed at high,levels after World War I, the Great Depression resulted in the establishment of severe curbs on immigration between 1·931 and the end of World War II. Immigration totaled over 160,000 for both 1928 and 1929, b\it fell to 27,530 in 1931, and 20,591 in 1932. Thereafter, immigration was not to reach the yearly figure of 15,000 until 1937 (Kalbach Mid Mc Vey 1971 :37). Moreover, several selective changes in the immigration regulations directly pertaining to British Columbia had been effected in the early 1920' sFir st of all, Japanese imm.igr_ation had been further restricted by treaty in . 1920. . Thereafter, no more than 150 male' Japanese workers per year were - - 230 - • allowed to come-to Canada (Corbett 1957:~ -As before, there were no re stric.tions placed- on the wives and dependents of legal Japanese residents of Canada (Kalbacn and McVey 1971:37). Secondly, the wiv!s-;nd dependent children of legal South Asian residents,of Canada were finally allowed to come to Canada in that_same year. Finally, in 1923 the Canadian govern- ment unilaterally banned the subsequent immig.ration of Chinese (Ng 1977:7.4) . .In essence, by the mid 1920' s ~ g r a t i o n restrictions on Chinese, Japanese, and South Asian immigrants had effectively 'solv~d' British Columbia's "Asian Menace • ." Moreover, the restrictions ·which the federal government placed on immigration in response to the depressed economic conditions of the 1930' s were also ethnically specific, for they gave preference to certain varieties of British subjects and to American citizens (Co r be tt 1 95 7 : 3 5 ) . So low were immigration figures during this era that Canada actually lost more population to out-mig.ration than it gained by immigration; Palmer (1975:12) estimates ·that between 1932 and 1941 140,000 people entered.Canada as immiyants, whereas about 240, poo people left the country. This demographic stabilization is reflected in the figures for ' Vancouver ks population for. this era. \ t - 231 - lfil .!.ll.!. illl. Total foreign born 83,300 118,197 108,259 Total Canadian born 79. 920 128. 396 167.094 Total population 163,220 246,593 275,353 'J'.able LXI. Vancouver's Pop~lation: Canadian and Foreign Born, 1921-1941. The population of Vancouver continued to increase dramatically during the 1920' s, after which it stabilized until well into World.War II. Most of the· meagre increase which was registered between 193 l and 1441 re s:wted from an increase in the number of Canadian born who became resident in Vancouver; their number rose from 129,000 to 167,000 during the d_ecade. Despite this demographic stabilization, ethnicity continued to be an important aspect of the Vancouver news: Dorpestic Foreign Spe'ci.fic Foreign Inferred , , · Vancouver Province 469 (540) 112 (117) 26 (36) 607 (693) Vancouver Sun 443 153 ll. 635 912 265 65 1242 Total Table LXII. Total Items The Number of Ethnically-Relevant Items in the Vancouver Province and the Vancouver Sun (1928-1937) 1 Found in a Sample of 230 Issues from Each Paper As can be seen, there was a slight decline in the Provi&:s domestic coverage of ethnicity, while its foreign coverage remained approximately ,.. identical. On the average, the Province printed 2. 3 items dealing with ,. ·-, 232 - " ethnicity in each of this era's issues, which was virtually identical to the • frequency with which· such items appeared in,£• 2J!l! (Z. 4 per da:)." These frequencies are down from those of the p r ~ s era's newspapers, both of which printed about 3 items per issue. In short, ethnicity became a bit less of a factor in press reporting during the 1930' s, even though it con2 tinued to b·e a vital par~ of the newspapers. The Distribution of Coverage: Sources and Localities II facility of communications alone were to be considered, one would . , 'have expected that the geographical scope of newspaper interest would have increased considerably by the 1930's. By that time teletype wire services were commonplace, and syndicated news services spanned the globe (Ke sterton 1967:45; Nichols 1948: 131). Nevertheless, on the question of ethnicity the Vancouver papers of the depression years tended to generate news items from almost identically the same places as before World War I. ' • • • - 233 - - ,, Vancouver Province number ~ Locality Vancouver~ number J!... British Columbia 249 41. 0 280 44.2 Canada 154 25.4 128 20.2 United States 66 10. 9 33 5. 2 61 10. 0 92 14.5 Asia 52 8. 6 80 12. 6 Africa 14 2. 3 16 2.5 Latin & Central America 6 - 1.0 3 0.5 Australia & New Zealand 5 o. 8 0 o. 0 Caribbean 0 0.0 2 0.3 Not Coded _[ o.o 1 o. 2 Total 607 100.0% Europe " Table LXIII. 635 100. 0% Geographical Location of Fo_reign and Domestic Ethnical~ ly-Relevant Events Occurring in Items from the Vancouver Province and the Vancouver Sun (1928-1937) · News items concerning British Columbia continued as before .to command the primary attention of the press, accounting for about 40-45% of all ethnic coverage. Items which portrayed events in th,J rest of Canada increased slightly, such that they represented 20-25% of all stories. \ Moreover, both papers grew slightly more i_nternational in outlook, especially in their coverage of Europe and Africa (particularly the Sun). 3 As before, the newspapers' dependence on foreign sources for information about happ~nings in the rest of the world was nearly compie'te, l · - 234 - as is indicated in Tables LXIV and LX:V. Even n~ws originating in the ..., United States was neither collected nor interpreted by Canadian news agencies; of the total sample of 99 news items portraying events occurring in the United States (both papers), only 8 either originated with or were reinterpreted by Canadians. In expressing their editorial opinion on over- seas matters the newspapers were thus relegated to the limited means of sele,cting which stories from off the wire services would go into print; this 4 had already become an established pattern in earlier times. \... - -------- - -------....--- - t Not Coded Locality News, Local News, Can. s. s. News, For. s. Editorial J:. .. _. Letter to Editor Cartoon _Xeatu]:"e Total B.C. 1 203 19 1 3 15 0 7 249 Canada 6 15 186 12 12 10 0 13 154 Europe 4 0 6 42 6 1 0 2 61 Africa 0 1 0 11 0 0 0 2 14 Latin Ii C. America 0 1 0 5 0 0 0 0 6 i' .I N u.> V, Auatralia & New Zealand Caribbean 1 1 3 0 0 0 0 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 z 59 2 0 0 1 66 0 .Q. 6 ....ll 0 0 0 2 ..1. 4 --1. ....ll _§_ 13 226 117 165 29 226 0 31 607 2. 1 37.2 19. 2 27.2 4.8 4.3 0 5. 1 100/0% \r U.S. A. . 0 r Aaia Tq.l Percent- &Je• Table LXIV. Type of Coverage by Locality: Vancouver Province (1928-1937) ~J ' I I \ I ( I '' \ -- r I ( Not l News, For. News, Can. News, Local ~. ~. Edi121:ial Lettet to Egit2[ l 11 16 s. l::dHi liilI ~~~si B.C. 0 238 Canada l 24 39 8 25 Europe 0 4 5 61 5 ,. 0 ~ 19 I 2 I 0 Africa 1 0 12 • 0 Cart2on Feature T2!al 1 13 280 0 12 128 0 15 92 2 16 1 3 1 1 0 ' I I . I (. Latin &c C. America Australia &c New Zealand 1 0 0 1 0 0 '- .l 0 N w er- 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .;' Caribbean 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 2 U.S. A. 0 0 0 31 1 o: 0 1 33 - ·__:l_ 1 - _]_ I 2! - 47 168 49 · 7. 4 26. 5) 7. 7 Asia 0 275 l Total Percentages ·- 0.2 43\ ~ ( ) Table LXV. • ~ ' \_~ 40 ..:.2_ .. - 1 53 634 0.2 8.4 100.0% 0 . \ 80 '~ ~ Q. 52 . ---:-,.._ . 6: 3 ·' ' ' Type of ; a g e by Locality: Vancouver~ (1928-1937) ~ · . ,. ' - .I - 237 - r Headlines, Photographs,~ Page Placement _ I!' Over ·the fir st thirty years of this century the format of the Vancouver new~papers changed significantly. In an overall sense, many of these modificatiori\Jwere made in the interest of increasing the visu~l aspect of press presentation. · "~ The papers of the turn of the century were in some ways representative of their age; news items were. printed in -small type and were accompa.nied by extended headlines with high content and little visual impact- -in short, the press was aimed at a population whi.ch would carefully search out what appeared to be interesting and who had the 5 leisw::e -tg read the more detailed a~ticles which were typical of the day. '- - -- . By the late 1920' s, one saw a trend toward increasing visual attractiveness and impact, which was accompanied by a parallel loss of content. For instance, he..adline length generally increased, while at the _same time the number of words contained in a givenHteadline decreased sharply. In the previous era the Province's average headline width was 1. 1 columns, but this increased to 1. 4 columns, as indicated in Table LXVI. The Sun was even more enthusiastic about latge headlines, which resulted in an average width of 1. 7 columns (see Table LXVII). t ' - 238 - Width in Columns · Absolute Frequency Relative F reguency (%) 1 489 80.6 80.8 2 77 12.7 93.6 3 16 2.6 96. 2 4 6 1.0 9-7. 2 5 3 o. 5 - 97.,7 , 6 2 o. 3 .~ 98.0 8 12 2.0 100.0 Not Coded 2 0.3 100. 0 Total 607 100. Oo/o 100.0% Cwnulative .F reguency (%) ~ Mode: 1,000 Mean: · 1. 385 ~ Table LXVI. Headline Widths in the Vancouver Pr.ovince (1928-1937) in Columns \ - 239 - Width in Columns Absolute Frequency Relative F reguency {o/o) Cumulative F reguency (%) l 464 7 3. 1 73. 3 2 85 13.4 86.7 3 30 4.7 91. 5 4 14 2.2 93.7 5 10 1. 6 95. 3 6 4 0.6 95.9 7 l 0.2 96. 1 .~\,. 23> 3. 6 99.7 o. 3 100. a~ · '• o. 3 100.0 100. 0% 100.0% "J ,' 8 '/ -,~f!t. 2 9 Not Coded 2 Total 635 Mode: 1. 000 . t ... .· ~ '- , I!, Mean: Table LXYll. 1. 679 Headline Widths in the Vancouver Sun fl928- l 937) in Columns - 240 - An increasing frequency of photographs also indicates the greater visual empha_s is of both newspapers. It should be recalled that in the earlier era photographs were extremely rare, occurring with no more than 2% of all ethnic news items. Between 19l9 and 1937 the Province increased · this percentage to 4. 9% (30 ,out of 607 news it.ems), while the more flamboyant Sun accompanied about 7. 6% of its ethnic news items with photographs (42 out of 635 news items). In contrast, page placement remained almost identical with that of twenty years earlier. As before, approximat~ly 40% of all ethnic news items were to be found on the first three pages of the paper: ./ Vancouver Province number -12... ~ Vancouver Sun number -12...· 1 152 25.0 177 27.9 2 50 8.2 47 7.4 3 46 7.6 34 5.4 4 27 4.4 39 6. 1 5 21 3.5 25 3. 9 6 46 7. 6 73 11. 5 7-10 67 11. 0 84 13. 2 11-20 115· 18. 9 103 16. 1 21-end 77 12.8 49 7.7 Not Coded _j_ 1. 0 _! o. 6 Total 607 100.0% 635 100. 0% l T~ble LXVIII. The ~age Distribution of Items in the V,tHrver Province and the Vancouver Sun (1928- - 241 - V Yearly Distribution of Ethnically-Related Items Taken together the combined influences of the depression, the immigration restrictions which resulted from it, and the containment of Asian immigration contributed to the Province and the Sun markedly re- stricting their coverage of ethnicity after 1931: Vancouver Province number .::/2__ Vancouver Sun number % 1928. 112 18. 5 79 12.4 1929 84 13. 8 94 14. 8 1930 65 10. 7 61 9. 6 1931 63 10.4 64 1 o. 1 1932 41 6.8 63 9. 9 ')933 54 8. 9 51 8. 0 1934 53 8. 7 56 8. 8 1935 30 4.9 54 8. 5 1936 66 1937 Total Table LXIX. 607 . • 10.9 60 9.4 6.4 53 8. 3 100.0% 635 100. 0% Yearly Distribution of News Items in the Vancouver Province and the Vancouver fu!a (1928-1937) The only deviation from this trend was seen in the Province's increased coverage of 1936, whfch reflected the renewed interest of this paper in 6 domestic happenings concerning the Chinese and Japanese. - 242 II. Content: Ethnic Portrayal in.!. Period of Demographic Stability (1928-1937) The P e o p l e ~ ~ Issues The depression of the 1930' s fundamentally stabilized the ethnic makeup of Vancouver. Immigration curbs resulted in the proportion of foreign-born individuals remc1.ining virtually the same throughout the ·era in question. Save for the migration of Canadian born into Vancouver, the population distribution of Vancouver in 1941 was almost a mirror image. of what it had been in 1931. membership. No ethnic group significantly increased its Some groups (notably the Chinese) even lost a considerable proportion of their number (MacDonald 1970:311). I / ill!. 7 lfil Country number i number England and Wales Scotland Ireland Norway Sweden Denmark Finland France Ger!?lany Poland Austria & Hungary Russia Italy Greece United States China Japan Other 46, 151 21,613 5,573 1, 723 2, 136 715 1,533 411 893 1,036 664 1,429 1,478 293 10,870 11,533 4, 133 5,983 39. 0 18. 3 4.9 1. 5 i 1.8 o. 6 1. 3 0.4 0.8 o. 9 o. 6 1.2 1. 3 0.2 9. 2 9. 7 3. 5 5.0 44,432 41. 0 20,080 18. 6 5, 166 4.8 1,783 1. 6 1,802 1.7 720 0.7 971 o. 9 416 0.4 956 o. 9 1,487 1. 4 1,022 0.9 2, 165 2.0 1,416 1.3 Not available 10,833 10. 0 5,427 -5.0 3,331 3. 1 6,252 5. 8 118, 197 246,593 100. Oo/o 108,259 275,353 Total Foreign born Total Population Table LXX. i 100. 0% Birthplace of Vancouver's Foreign Born Population in 1931 and 1941 (in numbers and percentagea) . • 243 Throughout the era, the ethnic makeup of Vancouver continued to be dominated by British immigrants and the Canadian born, who made up ·27. 5% and 52. 0% of the city's population, respectively. Along with the Chinese (4. 6%) and the Ame:cican born (4. 4%), four basic groups accounted for 88. 5% of the population of Vancouver in 1931. The distribution of news items in the Province and 'the ~ in part reflected the stabilization of ethnic relations which occurred during this period, as is indicated by Tables LXXI and LXXII. Relative to the past, coverage of Asians decreased substantially, even though it continued to account for approximately thirty percent of all domestic coverage; twenty years earlier such coverage represented nearly one-half of all domestic news items dealing with ethnicity. Coverage of Asians still continued to be far out of proportion to their numbers, for at no time during this decade did Asians constitute more than 1% of the total population of Vancouver and Asian immigration was insignificant. Changes in th~ ·frequencies of occurrence of other groups were rel latively minor. Both papers carried more news items dealing with British ethnicity than their predecessors did by a. factor of about 40%. Coverage of native people continued to command about 10% of the total, while coverage of Aznericans, Western, Northern and Eastern Europeans either remained . stable or increased. As before, the top seven groups in both papers comn1anded over 80% of all domestic coverage of ethnicity (see Table LXXll). Coverage of Canadians and French Canadians continued to be low. \ - 244 - Vancouver Province number i Group ., Colored 0 o. 0 0 o.o Black 18 3. 8 7 1. 6 Asian 146 31. 1 144 32. 5 · Native 55 11. 7 32 7. 2 Arab-Israeli 15 3. 2 9 2.0 Non-European 0 0.0 0 0.0 European 0 o.-o 1 o. 2 British 63 13.4 61 13. 8 Canadian 26 5. 5 31 7.0 French Canadian 17 3. 6 8 1.8 Eastern European 53 11. 3 46 10.4 Western&: Northern European 27 5. 8 35 7. 9 Southern European 13 2.8 19 4.3 !"fi~o-Portugese 1 o. 2 0 o.o American 21 4.5 36 8. 1 Immigrant 9 1.9 10 2.3 Australian &: New Zealand 5 1. 1 3 0.7 South African Ii Rhodesian White _Q, o. 0 - 1 o.z 469 100.0o/o 443 / Total Table LXXI. 100.0% Frequency of Ethnic Group Portrayal in Domestic News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouv·e r ~ (19Z8-1937) ( - 245 - yY909yer Province nwnber _!!_ · I Group Vancouver Sun number ..JL Asian 146 31. 1 144 32.5 British 63 13. 4 61 13. 8 Native 55 11. 7 32 7.2 Eastern European 53 11. 3 46 \.4 Western & Northern European 27 .J,, 5.8 35 •9 Canadian i 5. 5 31 ,. 0 ~ 36 ~ 83. 3% 385 7 9. 9"/o 26 ...1.!. American Total Table LXXll. " 391 I Seven Largest Domestic Ethnic Categories: Vancouver Province _.and Vancouver fu!!l (1928-1937) , The press also reflected the_ stabilization of the ethnic panorama in the topics which attracted newspaper attention during the late twenties and thirties, for while topics which :we~ primary ones before World War I continue to be important, several others rose to prominence. Reflecting the oppositional and polarized nature of ethnic relations in Vancouver, the newspapers of the previous era concentrated on topics which in one ;,,,ay or another reflected conflict: violence by ethnics, the question of ~mmigra- · tion restrictions, attempts by ethnics to gain redress in the courts, the prosecution of ethnics by the state, and ethnic t-elations. In the middle era these topics were moderated by the presence of others of a more normal, leas confrontational nature. Nevertheless, as can be seen in Table& LXXllllthroug@ •LXXIV, - violence by ethnics continued to be the most £re- .. - 246 - quent topic by far, thus continuing the tradition of the past; 17"/o of all domestic news items in either paper expr~ssed this topic. At the same time, both the Provine~ and the ·fu!a. diverged quite· sharply from past practice by sig:r;iificantly increasing their coverage of 8 normal news--things which reflected the everyday world of individuals. While at first consideration it~ay not seem that news items of this sort are of ~uch ~onsequence t<:> the pr-esentation of ethnicity and indeed might negatively reflect upon the ethnicity of the individuals concerned, I believe that the presentation of ethnicity within _the context of normal events has the important function of bringing ethnic groups into the moral community. In the early presentation of ethnicity by the Vancouver press, one frequently finds that stigmatized r'nino_rities were also stereotyped minorities, and that press stereotypes frequently were of the very few dimensions and were completely depersonalized: one found many "Chj.nese"_and "Hindoos" in the world of the press but found very few Chinese or South Asian individuals. The relative lack of individualized accounts of the activities of these minorities evidently made the application of stereotypical attributes to them far easier. Complementing this increased interest in normal news was a parallel increase of press interest in ethnic celebrities and ethnic org~zations; taken together, ·nonnal news, celebrities, attd ethnic organizations accounted for Z6. 5'9 of_ the Province's domestic coverage and 33. 4'9 of the~• s. ' outlined in the subsequent analysis of the ,specific ethnic groups, these As - 247 - topic areas also tended to be covered in more benign manner than previously, at least for most groups. Vancouver Province number _1L Topic Housing 0 0.0 0 o. 0 · Education 7 1.5 6 1. 4 o. 6 4 o. 9 24 5. 1 24 5.4 2 0.4 5 1. 1 Restriction Advocated 20 4.3 5 1. 1 Ethnics are Restricted 10 2. 1 6 1. 4 Restriction Charged 9 1.9 10 2.3 Health Employment & Economy Population 10.4 Ethnic Relations 8. 6 Immigration 52 11. 1 27 6. 1 Legal & Legislation 40 8.5 43 9. 7 Violence to Ethnics 15 3. 2 15 3.4 Violence by Ethnics 79 16. 8 73 16. 5 Culture DUferences 31 6. 6 36 8. 1 Celebrities 35 7.5 61 13. 8 Sports 4 o. 9 3 0.7 Ethnic Organization• 31 6. 6 51 11. 5 ---2.! 12.4 100.0,- ...li 8. 1 100.0,- Normal Newa Total Table LXXlll. \ Vancouver~ number _1L 469 443 Domeatic Material by Topic: Vancouver Province and Vancouver~ (1928-1937) - 248 - One of the most unexpected findings that derives from the frequency of occurrence of topics during this decade was that employment and econo~c activities were !!Q!. given particularly large amounts of coverage, despite the depression of the 1930's, which hit Vancouver with particular severity. The depression left many thousands of Vancouverites out of work and paralyzed whole aspects of British Columbia's resource-based economy (Robin 1972:255). One would have expected that the press would have' followed its traditional path and stigmatic ally associated the economic situation of the times with ethnicity. In fact, though both, papers did ex- press the feeling that the presence of Asians in Vancouver contributed to the unemployment rate.ft-bf white worker,-, in an overall sense coverage of relationships between the economy and ethnicity were minimal and were no more frequebt than in the previous era. Both the Province and the Sun devoted approximately 5o/o of their domestic coverage to this general area (see Tables LXXIV and LXXV). , •, '' - 249 - i nwnber Topic Violence by ethnics 79 16.8 Normal news 58 12. 4 Immigration 52 11. 1 Ethnic relations 49 10.4 Legal and legislation 40 8. 5 Celebrities 35 7. 5 Cultural dillerence 31 6.6 Ethnic organizations 31 ~ 375 7 9. '11/o Total Table LXXIV. Most Frequent Topics: Domestic Stories in the Vancouver Province (1928-1937) \... nwnber J!_ Violence by ethnics 73 16. 5 Celebrities 61 13. 8 Ethnic organizations 51 11. 5 Legal and legislation 43 9. 7 Ethnic relation• 38 8. 6 Cultural dilference 36 . Normal new• 36 Inuni1 ration -ll Total 365 Topic • Table LXXV. 8. I ► Moat Frequent Topic•: Domeatic Storie• in the V&DCOUYer ~ (1928-1937) 8. 1 1 . - 250 - - ~ Domestic Moral Community..Qf the Press Throughout this decade the Vancouver press continued to rnake strong evaluative distinctions between one ethnic group and another. While the range of moral community scores ·for this era is somewhat less than it was'in the past, the difference between the most and the least este~med groups was pQnetheless substantial.9 Tables LXXVI and LXXVII present the domestic moral community scores for those groups for which t~ore than ten news items were found during this period. ! ,· As i-s evident in these-~bles, those groups who had been highly :• evaluated during the previous era for the most part maintained their posi. / \ tion in the press moral community. Notably, the British, English, and ' : Scots continued to be treated well by the press; Canadians, too, received basically positive coverage. At the •me tune, some fundamental shifts occurred with respect to other groups. Germans. who the earlier press had treated with consider- able sympathy, fall sharply. es_pecially in the Province. The Japanese. moved even more in the opposite direction, towards a far more positive p~ess imag~·than before; Italians were also brought into the moral commUD:i,ty by the press, as were South Asians to a less significant degree. Only one new group made its appearance during this era--the .Dukhobors-- " who found themselves at the very bottom of the ethnic pyramid. ' ~ - 251 - Group Nwnber Moral ·community Score British 16 0.65 1 Jewish 13 0.54 2 Canadians 23 0,09 3 ! ·Italians 11 -0. 18 4 S!!!! . ;:, 21 -0.24 5 45 -0. 40 6 17 -0. 41 7 50 -0.56 8 South Asians 16 -0.63 9 Black Americans 16 -0~81 10 Germans 14 -1. 00 11 Chinese 69 -1. 10 12 Dukhobors 40 -1. 30 13 Asians 15 -2.07 14 Table LXXVI. The Domestic Moral Community: Vancouver Province (1928-1937) ------ r 252 - ....,. Group I Number · Moral Community Score Scottish 14 o. 30 1 Japanese 46 0.28 2 Russians 10 0.20 3 Canadians 30 o. 13 4 English 19 -0. 11 5 British 20 -0. 15 6 South Asians 16 -0. 43 7 Germans 22 -0.45 8 Italians 15 -0.53 9 Americans 36 -0.58 10 lnuni&ants 10 -0.70 11 Chinese 67 -1. 05 12 ~ ·/ Native Indians 29 -1. 27 13 i \_ 29 Dukhobors Table LXXVII. -l~,31 The Domestic Moral Community: Vancouver Sun (1928-1937) 14 ' 253 ill British As previously indicated in Table LVXX, the British born population of Vancouver remained virt?ally stable tl:iroughout the decade in question. They made up approxima..t:tly 50% of the foreign born population of the city, as they had in the decade prior to World War I. The Order-in-Council of March 21, 1931 (P. C. 695) placed all immigration under severe restrictions a_nd essentially stopped immigration from Bxitain to Canada from 1931 until 1938; hence, the British-born population of Vancouver could be considered increasingly to be established, long term immigrants as the decade in question went along. ~ In the press the British were dealt with quite differently by the · Province and the Sun, as qm be seen in Tables LXXVIµ, LXXIX·, and LXXX. While both papers gave the British positive press, both the inten- sity of their support and the direction of it diverged significantly. The Province continued its conservative support of the Empire generally, and in particular very strongly advocated continued and increased British immigration iri the late 1920' s when such a policy was still economically rational. Over 50% of the Province's domestic news items on the British for the decade in question were to be found in either 1928 or 1929 (32 out ' 10 of 60 in the sample). The great majority of these news items advocated British immigration; immigration was the most common topic (37: 8% in the Province's British sample. and the moat common subtopic by far was that British immigration should be aided (n = 11). J - 254 - Topics and Subtopics -, Vancouver Province number % Education ,. need special education 1 1.7 Health & Welfare want services 2 3.4 Vancouver~ nwnber o/o ) V Employment & Economy are skilled are lazy are employed are cheap labor other /'Nwnbers there jl.re not enough here too many will lead to 't rouble 2 2 1 1 1 . Ethnic Relations try to better relations relations are good f.elations are bad unpose their ,ways pro-American investment ~ Immigration too much from inunigration is large arrive should be aided are deported are solicited by Canada make good citizens profit on immigration other 1 1 1. 7 1. 7 2 3.4 1.7 1 1 2 1.8 3 5.4 1 1 1.8 1.8 r 1.8 3.4 3.4 1. 7 Are Restricted Chafge Restriction · claim immigration bar other 1 1 1 1.8 1. 8 1 l-oi.• 8- 1 · 1. 8 3. 6 1. 7 3.4 2 3 3. 4 5-. 2 11 19. O 2 2 1 1 3.4 1. 7 1. 7 1 1 5.4 1. 8 1. 8 1 1 1.8 1. 8 3 ' ~ - 255 - . number % Legislative & Legal urge restriction laws limit laws protect 1 1 1 1.8 ' 1.8 1.8 Violence, Hostility Against are dealt with harshly 1 1.8 3 5.4 1 1.8 1 1. 8 nwnber I • Violence, Hostility By assault, harass others meet imposition Cultural Difference Canadianness urged be st cultural practices other Celebriti.e s entertainers . politicians social notables historical notables ~1 1 2 2 %- 1. 7 • 1.7 3.4 3.4 ._,, . 'I 1 1.8 1 1 1 1.8 1.8 1.8 1 1.8 6 4 10. 7 7. 1 " Ethnic Organizations . ethnic festivals organize in community celebrate holidays organize concerts Normal News human interest victim of accident make good other Total Table LXXVlll. 2 2 3.4 3. 4 1 1. 7 3 5.2 4 7, 1 -- 2 2 3. 6 3. 6 1 1 1.8 1.8 3 3 5. 2 '1 .. ...1. 58 100.0% 56 3. 6 100.0% British Domestic News Coverage by Topics and • Subtopifs: Vancouver Province and Vancouver~ (l.928•.J937) / - 256 Topic Vancouver Province number % Vancouver Sun munber % Im.migration 22 37. 8 10 18.0 Ethnic Organizations 8 13. 7 14 24.9 Employment & Economy 5 8.5 4 7.2 Ethnic Relations 4 6.8 3 5.4 Celebrities 4 6. 8 4 7.2 Normal News 3 5. 2 8 14.4 Violence, Hostility By 1 1. 7 4 7.2 ·-- -1 -2.:...i 79. 5% 50 89. 7% . Legislative & Legal Total Table LXXIX. 47 The Most Frequent Topics of British Domestic News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Sun (1928-1937) Theme Vancouver Province nUillber Vancouver Sun number Im.migration 22 4 Cultural Difference 17 15 Legislative & Legal 12 6 Celebrities 4 2 Numbers 3 2 Ethnic Relations 3 2 Normal News 3 3 Ethnic Organizations 1 8 Table LXXX. Most Common Themes in Domestic British News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver~ 0928-1937) - 257 - Nevertheless, the Province's strong stand on British im,.m.igration was not made without qualification. The Province continued to view with - suspicion British immigrants who were poor, unsltj.lled, or uneducated. / As before, there was a fear that this ty'\te of immigrant would compete ' with Canadians for the available jobs, reduce wages, and generate unemployment (Province, September 14~ 1928, page 8; May 2, 1.928, page 18) • ......,._ Pauperism and poverty continued to be viewed by the Province as a P_ar~ ticularly urban British blight, £or the newspaper saw Canada as a land of opportunity for "healthy old country youths" from the countryside (April 12, 1928, page 18)--individuals who were in actuality at least as poor, uneducated, and unskilled as the~r urban counterparts. The Sun was on the whole less unequivocal on the question of British immigration, and tended to view immigration generally with 'more of an economic eye and less of a cultural one than the Province. The Sun only rarely was moved to advocate British immigration~ se, and voiced considerably more objections to it than did thHr competitor. For example, - the Sun was to go on the editorial record very early in the depression to ':laim that assisted immigration schemes designed to bring• over British immigrants were then undesirable because "too great an influx of British lower class .labour is crowded into the cities" (March a·, 1930, page 4). Carrying this theme further, the editor of the Sun later argued that Canada had already taken more British iminigrants than all of the other Domini.ans combined, and therefore owed nothing to Britain in. this regard; again, the - 258 - Sun advocated that -British immigration schemes should be halted (February 16, 1931, page 18). A few months later, the Sun editor's stand was even Y' stronger, claiming that in :regard to immigration policy the fu!!!. was anxious to inform Britain that Canada was not "the colonies" and that Canadians were not to be thought of as colonials (October 13, 1931, page 6). In contrast, as late as 1937 the Province continued tC:, advocate that immigration should be selectively British in order . . to keep other types of immigrants from diluting the British tradition in Canada (August 30, 193 7, page 3); "if Britain is to keep Canada, it must populate her with the right (i. e., British) people- " This immigration is sue was clearly but one aspect of a continuing difference in political orientation between the two papers. The conservative influence persisted in the Province, and predictably~e Province could find much good and little wrong with the right sort of British individual. Perhaps more importantly, the Province also continued to use "British values and institutions" as the ideal by which Canada and Canadians were to be judged. In this, it could be argued that the Province persisted in main- taining a colonial mentality well into an era when politically, socially, and economically Canada wa• effectively independent-of Britain.. Already, the · Province was romanticizing a "Briti•h heritage" in British Columbia which in fact had never existed--& British heritage with which British Columbian society of that day was constantly and invidiously compared. On the other hand, the Sun was searching for a more specifically • ., ~ ·.t - 259 Canadian definition of Canadianness. As mentioned, it was suspicious of rel~nships with Britain which were maintained on the strength of arguments based on culture, support of the mother country, or the benefits of British rule, and tended to counter these arguments with economic ones and occasionally, with arguments based on alle~ance to a specifically Canadian nationalism. One of its most common complaints was that Britain and the British w,ere profoundly ignorant of Canada and Canadians. For l instanc,, in an extended editorial ("What Britons Should Learn About Canada~ember 12, 1931, page 6), the Sun outlined the following points: 1. Canada was the keystone in the arch of Empire trade. 2. It was the inte'rpretor of Britain to the United States. 3. It was the connecting link in Britain's trade with Asia. 4. It was the greatest undeveloped area within reach of British capital. The above points are indicative of two sometimes contradictory themes in • the Sun's worldview--allegiance to Britain in an equal association and the belief that Canadian prosperity would -come through increased international trade. The Sun in fact did support the British as inclividuals and as the country of Canada's origin, provided that neither impinged overly on Canadian sovereignty. It was not above claiming that the British personality had qualities not found elsewhere, such as good humor and honesty (July 17, 1935, page 1), as well as intellectual supremacy (Ma.y 15, 1937, ··page 6). - 260 In addition, the Sun gave far more extensive coverage to local British or- . ganizatio~s and normal news than did the Province, in this paralleling a major distinction between the Province and the World; in a comparative " sense, t h e ~ was far more interested in people as inditiduals, human interest, and "the· human condition" than was the Province, as will be 11 evident in the subsequent discussion of other groups. . In spite of these differences between the two papers, both papers were in very close accord in what they did not print about the British. Despite their qualifications about the British, neither the Province nor the Sun chose to associate deviant activity wit}:i the British. Local residents of British birth were indeed reported to have engaged in crime, drink, labor unrest, etc., but almost without exception these news items did !!.2!, contain references to~~ ethnicity of the individual; their q,~ancy was of a 'normal,' rather than an ethnic variety. ~,- \" ~ -Chine ae The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1923 had drastic implications for the organization and makeup of Vancouver's Chinese community. The Act was so severe and so strictly enforced that between 1923 and the end of World .,,,War ll only eight Chinese inslividuals were legally allowed to immigrate from China to 9anada (Buchignani 1977:46). This alone would have led ·to a general aging of the Chinese population and to an eventual decrease in their -.J numbers. In fact, several oth~r factors contributed to both tendencies. Firr,t of all, very few Chinese women had come to Canada prior to the ' - 261 - r-v Exclusion Act, which reflected the heavy expense ($500) which would have been incurred should one have brought his wife to this country and paid her immigration head tax. The consequence o'f tkis wa not biologically reproduce itself. that the demographic Secondly, many of the male Chinese then in British Columbia were already married, and when faced by the impos sibilit_y of bringing their family to Canada many of them returned to their families in China (MacDonald 1970:311) .. Thirdly, the depression of the 1930' s was to leave many Chinese without work (N~ 1977:74; Corbett 1957: 45); many of_ the unempl9yed returned to China as well. So great was the flow of individuals from British Columbia to China that the numb~of -J Chinese _in the province decreased from 11,533 in 1931 to 5,427 ten years ::later (Ma_cDonald 1978:311) •. Relegated to a caste-like status, cut off from '• both British Columbian society and China, those Chinese who remained· turned inwards towa~ds themselves and vr:aited for the end of the depression. Effe_ctively subordinated, the Chinese posecl neither an economic nor a political threat to other British Columbiana (Straaton 1974:38). Nevertheless, prejudicial .feelings against the Chinese continued unabated through the 192.0' s and 1930' s (Corbett 1957:34). All o.f the .formal restric_tions which were placed on the Chinese prior to World War I were to remain in effect throughout the decades between the wars. Labor remained antithetical to Asians, and British Columbia;n· politicians routinely continued 12. to run on anti-A1ian plat.form, (Roy 1972.:2.53). "' . The depre I lion 1eems to - 262 - have hit the ~ancouver .Chinese with particular Jensity (Ng 1977:74), Without citizenship rights, . many Chinese did not apply for social relief for fear that they would be deported as indigents. Instead, they relied on · whatever support they could derive from the range of voluntary associ- -, ations within the Chinese community itself. Despite their subordinate position and irrespective of the fact that their numbers had dramatically decreased, the Chinese remained central to the presentation of ethnicity in both the Province and the Sun. groups, the Chinese received more coverage than any other. Of all Tables LXXXI through LXXXIII outline the topics and themes associated with the coverag~ of the domestic Chinese . .______ Despite their heavy coverage, the Chinese were still associated with a very narrow range of attributes and situation,s, most of them stigmatic. Continuing the tradition of earlier times, bo~ papers were centrally concerned with perceived Chinese deviant behavior, notably crim.i.nal behavior. 40. So/o of the Province's domestic coverage of the Chinese falls under this categQry, as does 29. 9't of that of the~- Even these hi~h percentages do not reflect the totality of the newspapers' interests in Chinese criminality, . for rriany of the news items categorized under other topics also secondarily - involved Chinese criminality or its conseque~ces. For instance, most of the news item• dealing with the Chinese in court ·(13o/o of the Province' 11 ~ coverage and 11. 9'- of the World' a) were report• of the Chineae in court OJl criminal charge•, and many other item• Hated under ethnic relationa, _f 263 - Topics a~d Subtopi~s ,. Vancouver Sun number Vancouver Pr9vince ' %\-' number Education other · 1 1. 4 Health & Welfare health is poor Employment and Economy are employed drive people out of business are cheap labor other Advocation of Restriction should deny services · should deny ethnic ways advocate business restriction Charge Restriction claim job restriction other Ethnic Relations bad relations with police relations get worse relations are good unite with others have outside help do not get along lnunigration enter illegally are deported other 1 1 1 1 1 2 ·1 2 1 2 1 1.5 1 1 1.5 1. 5 1 1. 5 1. 4 1.4 _., - 1.4 1.4 1. 4 . ..:t 1 1 1 1.5 1 1. 5 2 1 1 1 1 3 3. 0 1.5 1.5 1. 5 1.5 4.5 1. 4 2. 9 · -. 1.4 2. 9 1. 4 2. 9 i. 4 1 3 . 1. 5 4.5 ~ · ~gialative Legal politicians urge restriction laws limit are in court laws protect 9 l 13. 0 1. 4 1 3 8 ·-{, 1. 5 4.5 11.'9 / .. 2 '6 4 ._ . ·; · number I % 2 2.9 Violence, Hostility Against are assaulted property is destroyed are victims o{ crime will use force against 3 2 4.3 2.9 Violence, Hostility By assault, harass people assault each other are accused of crime other 1 4 22 1 1. 4 S.8 3.1. 9 1. 4 Cultural Difference have different eating customs have different religion other Celebrities politicians in the news social notables celebrities 1 1 1 1.4 1. 4 1. 4 1 1 1. 4 1. 4 Ethnic Organizations celebrate ethnic festival organize Normal News accident victims make good suicide or die 2 1 Total 69 Table LXXXI. 2.9 1.4 100. 0% number o/o 1 2 l.S 3.0 1 13 1 1. S 7.S 19.4 l.S 1 1. S 1 3 1 1. S 4.S 1. 5 1 3 l.S 4.S s . ··• ·;.. ·2 3. 0 67 100. Oo/o Chinese Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Province and Vancouver~ (1928-1937) ( - 265 · - ... Topi-• ' Violence, Ho•tility By . . Vancouver Province number !! . . Le.gi sla ti ve &t Le gal Vancouver Sun number '.fo - 28 ' 40.5 20 29. 9 10 14.4 . 12 17. 9 7 10. 1 3 4.5 9 . 13. 5 # Violence, Hostility Agaipst Ethnic Relations 5 . 7. 2 lnunigration 4 5.7 4_ 6.0 Celebrities 2 2.8 5 7.5 4 ~ 57 85. 3% Ethnic Organizations Total 56 Table LXXXll. 80. 7% The Most Frequent Topics of Chinese Domestic News Items: Vancouver Pr~nce and Vancouver~ (19~8-1937) Themes Vancouver .Province number Vancouver~ number Violence, Hostility By 19 21 Culture Difference 12 9 Legislative &t Lega) 10 it' Violence, Hostility Against 7 2 Employment. &t Economy 6 4 Ethnic Relations 4 7 ~ . ' Table LXXXlll. Moat Common Themes in Domestic Chlneae News Items: Vanc.ouver Prod.nee and Vancouver Sun (1928-1-937) l 266 . - ' violence and hostility agail'!st; and immigration also had a criminal aspect to them. In fact, ~overage- of C.hine se criminality in the Province was rovoke ~conomic and political fears in the re st of. t9e population. . ,, . ~ ,The ~apanese had E1tr~ngthened· their economic bii..se in the first few· decades .,, ,. . .... ~ '·, .. of this,Hcentury, and by the.late l92l>'s.had se~ured a sub~tantial ~s~on ii b- --.. a number of oc ~upations i!1c~uding fis\ring, agriculture, s~building, the • 13 wood ind;stries, ~nd trade. Although the Japanese wer~ hit at least as severely as ev;e.ryone else by the depression, they were to be considered an economic threat throughout the decade in question. v' ,, . The continuing exploits of Japan on the international scene continued . -to fe,ed British ColumbiaJl fears that the growing power of that country , - ... might be connected in some ·importa~t way with the. Jap~ese population of the province (Roy 1972:242).. Japan had invaded China, which provoked worry that British Co.lumbia might be next. Japan was seen as an aggres- sive and successful ecqnomic competitor, which aroused both suspicion and admiration (Adachi 1971:222). Paradoxically, Japan hacf also become .:> one of British Columbia's major trading partner.a, especially in terms of 14 exports li:ke lµmber and fish. As is indicated in Tables LXXXIV through LXXXVI, Japanese coverage in the press of the period between the two World Wars remained high, accounting for about 9. 5~ of the Province's domestic coverage of ethnicity and 10. 4% of the Sun's. At the same time, in many respects the type of coverage received by the· Japanese changed significantly from the previous era. In an overall sense, the negative attitude toward the Japanese ... r._ .,.. . - 2·75 - _pr~aented by the Jpress in earlier times·wa_s muted, ,uth that~~ morat"'-- .. community scorea for the Japanese compare .favorably with many E~ropea~ . ·. . . , . ethnic groups. ~ . Even the Province accorded them a score of -0. 40, whic~ '· · was about the same as that f~ French Canadians. The~• s Japanese moral community_score (9~.S) WJLS ·unequalled by any other group save for .... tlte.~~ois\ .... 5 , Q .-' ' , " The fundamental·change in .ite topics of news items de:a ling with"the J ,a panese c"an be most r\adily s~en ,l>y comparing Table LXXXIV with Table XXXlll Qf the p:revious Chapter. • In the earlier decade, the coverage of the Japaries~ wa~ e~remely· confrontatio~al • . Violence by J3:panese, immi1 gration, (bad)· ethnic relations, t{gal an.d legislative happening;, and the , adwcation of further re·striction of the Japane.se were the predominant I 1 topics. In the 19·20 s and 1930's 1;1iese topic.a were less !requentlyfound, ---.:.--a.a1111;11uiie.n.Jth~e~ _were their intensity hact--l,een considerab~:ra~ed . ~ . . their place, news . items deali~g with celebr.ities . and normal news events . . increased dramatically, · such .that ta.k en together they acco1D1te~ for 38. ·ao;o · of the Province's dome1tic coverage_and 34. 8o/o of the §!!!!' s; similar figure~ for the Province and the World of 1905-1914 were 6. 4o/o and 7. 0%, respectively. In particular, the~• s fascination with Japanese social notablee was complete. - Characteristic of the way in which the Sun doted over the _; ~ Japanese elite wa~ the following item: - , 1 . .• .. ... _ _.... -~~#"'-+---·7 ~ ~ - ~ ~ ~-:. . ... -... ._~ •·. ' • 276 Topics and Subtopics ' Vancouver-·~ number. · ,- Vancouver P:covince munber % I Educationeducation costs too much Employment &t 1'tonomy ,.drive people· out of buaine-ss buy y,,r .own proper!Y oilier " ~ 1 1 -· z.z z. z Nun;i.be_r s . are increasing Advocation~of Restriction should-par fllOm jobs . should ,deny tights · . sbo~& ~a·r imtn.igration other Are Restricted are ,de'nied rights •. l z 1 1 3 2 4. 3 ·Z 4. 3 r1 z. z z. z 1 z. z ·z. z 1.,.,·• 4 t.·.z z.z ,_ ·, 6.7 Restriction Charged · z 4.3 1 · z. .3 . -z. z / Ethnic Relations try to better relations . relations are good· relations are bad threaten Western World. hnm.igration come illegally are deported· Legislative &l Legal laws protect are in the courts make good citizen• Violence, Ho•tility A1ain•t are aasaulted or hara••ed are victim• of crime 1 1 1 z 1 . 2~-2 .. z.z · z.z 4,4 2:z ' r 1 '\ 1 z 1 z 4.4 z.z -. 1 1 .z 4.4 1 z. z z. 2 • I > . ,-· ... ' ~ - 277 number o/o number o/o 5 11. 1 1· 2.2 3 1 1 1 6.5 2.2 2.2 2.2 Violence, Hostility By are accused of crime are executed assault each other are violent - Cultural Differences are learning English other 1 1 2.2 2.2 Celebrities politicians in the news social notables 1 1 4 2.2 2.2 8. 9 8 6 17.4 13. 0 3 6. 7 5 2 10.9 4. 3 2 1 1 4.4 2.2 6.7 2.2 1 1 2. Z 2.2 45 100. Oo/o 46 100.0% Ethnic Organiz•tions organize in the community other .. Normal News human interest ac ci.d~nt victim make good other 3 ' .Total '4 " Table LXXXIV.. Japanese Domesti5= News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouvij Province and Vancouver Sun (1928-1937) .... - ,. -~ - - 278 . ' Vancouver Province nwnber % Topic , Normal News 7 15.5 2 4.4 Celebrities 6 13. 3 14 30.4 Violence, Hostility By 6 13. 3 6 13. 1 Ethnic; Relations 5 11. 0 2 4.5 Ethnic Organizations 3 6.7 7 15. Z Employment & Economy 2 4.4 4 8. 7 Legislative & Legal 3 ..!2.:.1. 2 4.4 32 · 70.9% 37 80. 7% "· Total Table LXXXV. The Most Frequent Topics of Japanese Domestic N:ews Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Sun (1928193'7) Vancouver Province number Vancouver~ number Advocation of Restriction 8 2 Ethnic Relations 6 10 Legislative & I:-egal 5 5 Employment & Economy 5 4 Cultural Difference 4 8 Violence, Hostility By 2 6 Ethnic Organizations 2 7 Theme " Vancouver Sun number % Table LXXXVI. Most Common Themes in Domestic Japanese News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Sun (1928-1937) . .., ~ JAPAN'S ENVOY TO CANADA OF HIGH LINEAGE Jsmasa Tokugawa, Scion of Shoguns Who Rule for 300 Years " (October 9, 1929, page 6) In this feature story the Sun: argued that the appointment of such an important indi':idual to be an envoy was indicative of the regard wit,h which Japan held for Canada. The Sun covered Japanese community .events in a similar vein, . especially when important dignataries were involved in them: JAPANESE GlF T TREES CEREMONIALLY PLANTED Lasting.Peace Between Dominion and Land of Cherry Blossom Keynote of Function (May 10, 1932, page 2) Although less. frequently done than by the Sun, the Province also enthusiastically covered Japanese elites when it chose to cover them at all: VANCOUVER BIDS FARE U LEAVES F E CHEER. P Work AS 10,000 makes Contribution trymen Here (March 31, 1937, page 3) Nevertheless, the Province continued to be concerned about the possible negative effects of a Japanese presence in Canada, and it made that concern evident in a number of news items to do with the threat of Japanese tueover of the economy and polity. As before, the Province persisted in the position that the Japanese constituted a demographic threat to white society. Fof instance, in an eighty-eight column inch feature • / 280 story of September 1, 1934 the Provfnce claimed thai: • MORE THAN -A TENTH OF B: C. IS •ASIA TIC, AND THERE'S THE PROBLEM . Paradoxically, the article contended that because of the rapid -increase of . . the Japanese population they should be given all the rights of other . Canadians .. for some day their numbers would be comparable with those· of the white pop~ation. The Province's .concern with Japanes.e in the provincial economy centered principally on two issues--the supposed relationship between the number of Japanese in the province and white unemployment and the threat which the Japanese were presumed to be to the whites in the fishing industry. While the Sun had no news items in the sample advocating further Japanese restriction, the Province devoted approximately 9% of its domestic coverage of the Japanese to this toef Typical was: WHITE LABOUR SHOULD PRECEDE ORIENTAL: DENNIS Coast Industries Employ 6, 150, Minister Declares • (Octo~er 3, 1933, page 12) The Province's objections to~Japanese participation in the fishing industry was primarUy the same a·s its critique of Japanese labor in other areas of the 'economy- -that they caused unemployment. This was augmented by a fear that the Japanese government would interfere in the local industry on the side of resident fishermen: - 281 - HASTE URGED IN HALIBUT PACT Industry in Danger from -Invasion of Japanese Fishermen (August 20, 1930, page 3) FEAR JAPANESE WI~L PREY ON COAST SALMON Deep Sea Raids on·B. C. Industry Predicted (September 15, 1936, page 1) The Province's concern of possible political domination by the Japanese continued throughout the era. In the early 1930' s the Province often suggested that Japanese fishermen were serving as a cover for ' Japanese government spies (May 5, 1933, page 7). This later became part of a wider fear over Japanese imperialism (November 2, 1935, page 32; October 15, 1936, page 10). Occasionally, this fear reached levels which appear ridiculous today: NEILL FORESEES B. ·c~ AS JAPANESE STATE Comox M. P. Opposes Franchise Extension (March 16, 1937, page 1) On the other hand, the ~ continued the tradition of the 1 f Ws: in hoping that the benefits of increased trade with Japan woul before it outweigh the negative consequences of a local Japanese presence: CANADIAN JAPANESE TRADE MAKES RECORD Balance Favors Dominion.· Total Canadian Exports During 1929 Reach 69,000,000 Yen ~ (March ·24, 1930, page 4) In many re ■pech, the-~' a optimism about the poS11ibilities of trade with Japan closely followed the patt~rn which the same paper set in its \_ 282 , .. expectations of the Chinai:rade. There were, however, several important differences which made the Sun's presentation of trade with. the former distinct. The Sun was acutely conscious of the political and economic power of Japan, and consequently suggested caution in how Canadians· dealt with the Japanese government. For instance, in an extended editorial of February 15, 1935 (page 6), the Sun warned its readers against the . dangers of invidious racial classification, in that the Japanese who had for so long been despised in British Colwnbia, were modernizing rapidly in their home country. Two months later, another Sun editorial (April 2, 1935, page 4) titled "Pride, Race, and 'Face' 11 suggested that Canadian discrimination against the Japanese might lead to Japan taking direct economic action against British Columbia. The~' s optimism about Japanese trade continued unabated through the depression years, such that .even in 1937 the Sun thought the issue important eno:'lgh to devote 294 column inches and several photos to: • JAPAN'S TRADE WITH VANCOUVER What B. C. Sends Across the Pacific (April 30, 1937, pages 22-25) In other ways the ~ began to support increased rights for British Columbia's Japanese. It cautiously supported CCF proposals to extend the vote to Canadian born Asians in 1935 (March 2, 1935, page 10), noting that "the immigration of Japanese products made by cheap labor is a greater problem than the immigration of people." In a similar editorial in support - 283 - of Japanese fishermen (that would have been heretical twenty years previously), the Sun argued that the decreased ability of the British Columbia fishing industry to compete 0against Japan in the British market was a result of driving the Japanese out of the local industry (March 16, 1931, page 6). In a number of respects, the portrayal of the Japanese in the press of . this era stands in marked contrast to that of the Chinese, despite the great similarity of their places in British Columbia society. While the Chinese' continued to be vilified, the Japanese no longer were. Whereas the Chinese were routinely scapegoated as the cause of a whole range of societal evils, critiques of the Japanese were much more restricted and tended to involve economic rather than social ot cultural practices. Because their situations were objectively so similar, one must look elsewhere for an explanation as to why the i.inages of these two groups diverged so sharply. It would seem that the principal factor which accounts for this was the difference in respective images of China and Japan w~ch were held by the press in British Columbia. In short, the international · image of Japan did not make good material for a scapegoating ideology, especially if one considers it in the light of what were considered to be im- , portan\ values in British Columbian society. In relation to the majority, an ideal minority for scapegoating purposes must appear weak, and must be perceived ~ possess qualities which violate the naral order of majority society (Allport 1958:236). The Japanese did not appear to have these - 284 - characteristics. Although the local Japanese did not have sufficient poli- tical power to attain majority group rights and privileges this was somewhat compensated for by the economic and political muscle of Japan. Both papers were awar.e that Japan was concerned about its nationals overseas, and neither paper was willing to destroy British Columbia's export ·prospects by singling out the Japanese for viHfication. South Asians By 1921 the number of South Asians in Eritish Columbia had fallen from a peak of over five thousand in 1909 to 1,016 (Buchignani 1977:31). Faced with a total ban on immigration in 1908, many had returned to their families in India and the Far East. Others had moved on to California. In 1920, legal South Asian residents of Canada we re allowed to bring their wives and dependent children to this country, prompting a very small flow of immigrants over the subsequent two decades: Years Nu.robe r of South Asian Immigrants 1920-25 200 (est.)' 1925-29 • 1930-34 . ' 1935-39 Table LXXXVll. 289 262 78 South Asian Immigration to Canada, Fi ■ cal Years 19ZO to 1939 During the 1920' •• those South Asians who had remained in British Columbia slowly built up their economic position and developed a more - 285 - -5 ~ , coherent sense of co~unity than was possible pr/oito World War I. South Asian workers co~ntrated heav}iy in the woods industries, laboring primarily in the lurnber mills adjacent to Vancouver and on Vancouver Island (Buchignani l 977:40ti. Although no census figures exist for the South Asian population of Vancouver thro.ugh the 1920' s and 1930' s, there seemed to have been about 500 of them resident there. The total number of South Asians in the province was not to reach 2,000 again until aher World War II. In contrast to the Chinese and Japanese of this era, South Asians .did not constitute a social issue of much consequence. For one thing, immi- gration had been stopped before the South Asian population of British Columbia could reach a figure comparable with e"ither the Japanese or Chinese. Moreover, India was geographically too distant to excite the economic interests of local elites in the way that trade prospects with China and Japan had. South Asian reside~ts of British Columbia aided in the process of decrE:asing their liabilities as 'social problems' by turning inward on themselvea as best they could, considering that they were financially dependent on wage labor in uie larger society. Neither.actively despised nor praised, local South Asians were given considerable freedom to order their own· social live_s, given that they·acquiesced to ~r. economically and socially subordinate position in the larger society. After being allowed to bring their wives and dependent children to 286 - ' _canada, South Asians did not actively campaign for a mitigation of their political and economically subo:r;dinate position again until the late 1930' s (Buchignani 1977:54). This was to keep them largely out- of the public and press eye throughout th~ era. Nevertheless, their unequal position in British Columbian society was well known among Indian scholars and politicians across the world, and their plight was a frequent topic of discussion ill inter'national circles. This concern made itself felt in the viaits of important Indian civil rights advocates throughout the years between the Yorld Wars. Srinivasa Shastri made a supportive visit in 1922, as did Rabindranath Tagore and C. F. Andrews in 1929. Similar visits of Indian notables in the early 1940' s were to galvanize local South Asia~s in'to action on the question of the franchise and see the fight through to its conclusion. In the light of their small numbers and the far greater importance which was then placed upon resolving the place of the Chinese and Japanese ~ in British Columbia, it is understandable that local South Asian stories were less than one third as frequent in the Province and the Sun than they were in the two papers considered in the decade prior to World War~- ,.--- In the ten year sample of either paper only 16 news items dealing with ) domestic South Asian ethnicity were found. This accounted for only 3. 4o/e bf the Province's domestic coverage and 3. 6% of the Sun's. The distribution of topics, subtopics, and themes found in these news items are ·outlined in Tables LJQ(XVlll throuah XC. - 287 - Topics and Subtopics Vancouver Province number %· Ethnic Relations try to better relations relations mediated by others relations are good Legislative &c Legal laws limit behavior are in the courts laws protect 12. 5 1 6. 3 f 6. 3 6. 3 1 Violence, Hostility Against ,..;'\.,. are assaulted victims o~~ Viol~nce, Hostility By assault, harass others assault each other are accused of crime 2 1 1 2 2 Ethnic Organizations organize in the community Normal News victim of accident make good Total Table LXXXVW. l 1 12. 5 12. 5 6. 3 1 1 6. 3, 6.3 1 6. 3 4 25.0 1 6.3 1 6.3 1 6. 3 3 18. 8 6. 3 6. 3 6. 3 2 12. 5 - 16 1 6. 3 1 - .... 6. 3 Cultural Difference have different morals Celebrities politicians in news social notables, other Vancouver Sun number% 6. 3 6, 3 100.0o/o' 100.0% South Asian Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Province and Vancouver~ (Ut28l 937). - 288 - Vancouver Province number o/o Topic ,. Vane ouve r Sun number Violence, Hostility By 5 31. 3 5 31. 3 Ethnic Relations 3 18. 8 1 6. 3 Normal News 2 12.5 2 12. 5 Legislative & Legal 2 12.6 2 12.6 Celebrities 1 6. 3 4 25. 1 Total 13 81. 5% 14 87.8% Table LXXXIX. r The Most Frequent Topics of South Asian Dofnestic News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Sun (19281937) . - Theme . Vancouver Province number Vancouver~ nwnber Violence, Hostility By 9 4 Cultural Difference 7 9 Ethnic Relations 7 6 Legislative & Legal 3 3 Employment & Economy ~mal Ne""P Table XC. 3 1 2 Most Common Themes in Domestic South Asian News Items: Vancouver Province an.d Vancouver~ (1928-1937) \ 289 - The most common single theme by far wa~ that of South Asian violence. .. Approximately 30% of the domestic sa~ple of both the -Province and the fu!e_ directly dealt with this topic, and as secondary themes one third more of these news items also mentioned it. In particular, South Asians were portrayed as being a group who were very quick to resort to physical violence in order to settle their affairs. The type of violence that South Asians were reported to employ was an integral part of their earlier press ~tereotype. Their· violence was motivated by blind rage,. bloody vindictiveness, and clannish, long simmering hatred: TWO EAST INDIANS CHARGED WITH MASSACRE OF FAMILY OF SEVEN ' (VancouverProvinc.e, May 17, 1937, page 16) lilNDU MURDER RING AGAIN ACTIVE · California Jerchant Killed by Fusillade of Bullets (Vancouver Province, November 27, 1931, page 19) Often, South Asian violence was directly linked to cultural difference,· notably, to their exotic "Native Rites" or their unmanageable jealousies: GANG A TT ACK NATIVE RITE Wollyln Believed Cause of Hindu Beating in Victoria Three Arrested (Vancouver Province, April 20, 1935, ~page 9) HINDU MURDER CASE GOES TO ASSIZE JURY Shan Kaur Deniea ahe ever Plotted to Kill'-her Mate Con£easion at Temple (Vancouver Sun, May 25, 19:32, page 1) At the same time, the relatively coherent and totalistic stereotype I - 290 ' '!;.,, of the "Hindoo'T which had been generated in the earlier part of the century r becaine· fragmented. The sparcity of news items on South Asians made it impossible for the press to maintain a._coherent image of South Asians; - • "'!'16 - instead, the newspapers tencied to explain South.Asian happening by th~ less i~tegrative me~ of using single cultural attributes as the cause: two "Hindoos" fight because "Hindoos" are part of a' violent culture, etc. Despite this accent ori the unusual, both papers tended_ to more frequently place South Asians into a framework of normal ev-ents than did • newspapers in the previous era. Occasionally, there would be a pure human interest story on South Asians, which was very unlikely to be the case earlier: EAST INDIAN SUCCEEDS Poor ·Immigrant 23 Years Ago, He's Rich Now (Vancouver.Sun, December 23, 1929, page 24) At times South Asians would even be repoz:ted to have been acting~ w~tes against an external threat: CHINESE OPPOSED TO MARKET CONTROL ~ ~ Whites and Hindus Side with Board (Vancouver-Sun, October 3, 1935, page 10) There was very little difference between the two papers in their approaches to ~uth Asian. coverage during this decade, al~ugh the small samples involved make any differences of this sort difficult to dietinguis!J.. ) - . . Both ~pers were kee~y interested in South Asian violence, which be. cause of its relative inlportance would alone make the two·papers very . . ... ,, .. 291 similar. There did seem to be a slightly greater willingness on the part of the•~ to deal ~ith the human element of South Asian life, as in the coverage which the ~ gave to the visit of Rabindranath Tagore in 1929. The. only notice which the Province made to the visit of this Nobel Laureate to British Columbia was a four column inch story on page two (April 12, 1929), while the ~ covered the visit in depth, and even printed a detailed paraphrase of a speech made by Tagore's fellow visitor C. ·y. Andrews on the subject of racial unity (April 12, .page 12). "' In sharp contrast to the sparse coverage of local South Asians, coverage of overseas events dealing with South Asians was substantial. It accounted for 18. 8% of the Province's foreign coverage of ethnicity and ro. 4% of the ~ • s. By way of comparison, news items dealing with South Asians in' British Columbia constituted only 3. 5% of the domestic items on ethnicity found in either paper. Tables DCC and IIXC outline the distri- bution of foreign items on South Asians. r While the way in which local South Asians were covered by the Sun and Province were very similar, the images created by the two papers of overseas Indians were quite distinct. These differences for the most part reflected the differing political orientations of the Province and the Sun. The Province was strongly supportive of the Conservatives and hence, of the Empire. The P,rovince' s view of India was uniformly pro-British and was extremely unsympathe~c of Indians. To begin with, almost 40o/o of the Province's over seas news items on South Asians concerned riots or - .,,,,.,.-- -- 292 - Topics and Subtopics Vancouver Province number % Employment & Economy are in economic distress Are Restricted immigration barred Ethnic Relations relations mediated by others relations get worse relations are bad relations are good other 1 0 3 l l l 1 5.0 l 5.0 11. 5 1 5. 0 3. 8 l 5.0 l l 5.0 3. 8 3. 8 3. 8 Legislative & . Legal political restrictions laws protect Violence, Hostility By assault, harass each other demonstrations in British areas Cultural Difference ; have different morals have different religion a re loyal to home . other Celebrities politicians in news social notables other Normal News victim of natural disaster human interest Total Table D(C. Vancouver~ number % 5. 0 ' 2 7. 7 l . 5. 0 10 38. 5 7 35. 0 l 1 1 1 1 3. 8 3. 8 3. 8 3. 8 3. 8 1 3. 8 2 1 1 10.0 5. 0 5. 0 1 5. 0 20 100.0% 1 3. 8 26 100.0% South Asian Foreign News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Sun (1928-1937) I' - 293 - Vancouver Province nwnber % Topic Vancouver~ nwnber % Violence, Hostility By 12 46.2 8 40.0 Ethnic Relations 6 22. 9 3 15.0 Cultural Difference 5 19. O Celebrities l 3. 8 4 20.00 Total 24 91. 9% 15 7 5. 0% ' Table llXC. The Most Frequent Topics of South Asian Foreign News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Sun (19281937) - 294 - demonstrations in India. Most of the re~t involved closely related subjects, such as interpersonal violence, crime, or backwardness. These events were always covered from the point of view of India's colonial adm~nistration. Civil unrest of all varieties was consequently explained to be the work of thieves, sectarian fanatics, or bloodthirsty revolutionaries. Likewise, the Province subscribed completely to a paternalistic British stereotype of Indians. Indians were portrayed by the Province as childish, " sneaky, and hopelessly traditional (editorial, Vancouver Province, July 11, 1929, page 6). So uniformly negative was the Province's coverage of Indians overseas that at most only 10% of these news items dealt with events within which one would not immediately consider the role of Indians to be stigmatic. qualified. Even then, the Province's approval was tentative or The following headlines are representative of the Province: HINDUS FLEE FROM BOMBAY AS TOLL CLIMBS Killings Total 120, With 700 Wounded - Threat of Martial Law (Vancouver Province, February 11, 1929, page 1) RUTHLESS PLOT SWEEPS INDIA Secretly-formed Revolutionary Government Threatens Legislators VICEROY TAKES ACTION I (Vancouver Province, Aprii 12, 1929, page 1) While the Sun's foreign coverage of South Asians was of the same type of events as the Province. the paper was far more willing to question the place of the British in India than was its competitor (editorial, June 6, • 295 1930, page 6). It also g.ave far more extensive µcoverage to Ghandi and other opponents of colonial rule than did the Province. The 'sun even took an occasional interest in Indian philosophy: \ . , CHlCAGO AND CALCUTTA Swami Yogananda in an Article Said We can Learn from Each Other (Vancouver Sun, December 13, 192~, page 6) THE ORIENT AND ITS PlilLOSOPHY TO BE Sl:JBJECT OF LECTURE (Vancouver Sun, September 29, 1928, page 22) The P;s:ovince found it difficult to consider Indian culture altogether seriously, and often made fun of Indian religious practice, as in the 104 column inch piece "WAY DOWN UPON THE GANGES RIVER" (Vancouver Province, May 18, 1934, page 5) which paternalistically and sarcastically 1 reviewed the 'dirt, pove~ty and beauty of lndia, 11 - 296 - Americans Through this era, the number of Americans in Vancouver remained approximately constant. Both the 19_3 l Census and the subsequent one in 1941 showed that about 10,800 Vancouverites were born in the United States. Nevertheless, in proportional terms, Americans constituted a far smaller percentage of the foreign born (9-10%) than they had in the previous era (18%). Their share of the overall population likewise decreased, such that they made- up approximately 4% of the population at large. There was no significant immigration of AmericaQ.s to Vancouver during this era. Moreover, the 1930' s were also notable for the few conflicts of consequence which arose between British Columbia· or Vancouverftes and either Americans or the United States (Mclnnis 1958:474). In terms of the \. ·> major issues which involved the province, this era was primarily one of peaceful coexistence with the United States. One would expect that this relatively stable situation would have led to a severe reduction in the amount of cove rage which Americans received in the local press, but this was not the case. As can be seen in Tables VIIC through VC, the frequens::y with which Americans were portrayed by the Province£d the Sun was almost the same as it was in the Province and the World (respectively) of the decade before World War I. As in that earlier time, there was a marked difference in the intensity with which the two paper a covered Americans. The Sun continued in the tradition of the World, and gave Americans quite extensive coverage; - 2 97 ·- Topics and Subtopics ." . Vancouver Province number o/o Vancouver~ number o/o Education 1 2. 8 Employment and Economy cause unemployment own or buy property 1 2.8 Numbers are a given number other 1' 1 2.8 2. 8 Advocation of Restriction advocate job restriction advocate no ethnic ways advocate immigration barred 1 1 2. 8 2. 8 2 1 1 5. 6 2.8 2.8 1 1 2.8 2. 8 Charge Restriction claim ways barred Ethnic Relations relations get worse relations are good other Immigration immigration is large immigration is solicited arrive are deported should stay in Canada Legislative 8c Legal politicians urge restriction laws limit behavior Violence, Hostility Against are assaulted are dealt with bar shly Violence, Hostility By meet an impo•ition are accused of crime are violent 1 4.8 - 1 4.8 1 4.8 ·l 2 1 4.8 9.5 4.8· 1 3 4.8 14! 3 1 4.8 , \\ ... 1 2.8 1 2. 8 2 5. 6 2. 8 2. 8 1 1 298 - .... number Cultural Difference have bad language use have different morals have different ideas Qf law 1 % 1 4.8 Sports participate in sports, 1 1 4.8 4.8 1 4.8 Normal News human interest victim of accident tourist related suicide or die 1 1 1 4.8 4.8 4.8 Total 21 Table VIIC. % 1 2. 8 2 1 5. 8 2. 8 1 2. 8 11 1 30.6 2.8 36 100.0o/o 4.8 Celebrities entertainers Ethnic Organizations ·celebrate festivals celebrate holidays num~er 100. 0o/o American Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Sun (1928-1937) \.. , . - 299 - Vancouver Province nwnber % Topic Vancouver Sun nwnber % lmmig ration 4 19. 2 2 5.6 Legislative & Legal 4 19. 2 I 2,8 Normal News 3 14.4 12 33.6 Ethnic Relations 1 4.8 4 I 1. 2 Cultural Difference I 4.8 4 I I. 2 4 11. 2 27 75. 6% Violence, Hostility By Total 13 Table VIC. 62.4% The Most Frequent Topics of American Domestic News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver §E. (1928-1937) Theme Vancouver Province nwnber Vancouver Sun number Cultural Difference 4 7 Ethnic Organizations 3 2 Violence, ~stility By 2 5 lminigration I 6 Employment le Economy I 7 ~ Table VC. Most Conunon Themes in Domestic American News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Sun (1928-1937) - 300 - 8. 1% of its domestic coverage dealt with Americans. In contrast, news items about Americans accounted for only 4. 5% of the Province's domestic coverage. The way in which A11:ericans were portrayed by the Province and the Sun also differed, but in tb&s case·the major distinctions were not directly inferable from their respective political positions. If the coverage of ethnicity by the Province and the ~ were indeed directly derivative from their Conservative and Liberal political stances, one would minimally expect: 1. That the Province's coverage of Americans would have been more negative and cautious than the ~ • s. 2. That the Province would more frequently point to cultural differences between Canadians and Americans than would the ~3. That the Slm. would be more intensely concernedi-with the increasing trade with the United States than would the Province. 4. That the ~ would more likely advocate American immigration than would the Province. 5. • That the Province would more likely make invidious distinctions between the United States and Canadian "law and order." These predictions flow rather naturally from the political philosophies of the two main Canadian parties of the day. Nevertheless, in eac~ case these hypotheses either do not hold with I - 301 respect to the portrayal of Americans or else require significant qualification. Take for instance, the way in which the two papers evaluated American ethnicity. If the respective moral community codes of the Province and the §!m. are co-Jidered, one sees the first of the above hypotheses immediately invalidated; the Province's moral community score was -0. 24, as compared with -0. 58 in the Sun. Only three specifically named domestic ethnic groups did worse than Americans in the fu!a' s portrayal of ethnicity. The Sun's political orientation fil !. vis Americans seemed to mix ) \ • several considerations, only one of which was the continentalist trade and cultural orientation of the federal Liberal party. To be sure, the Sun~ keenly interested in promoting trade with the United States, especially tourism. Throughout the era the ~ continually editorialized that British Columbiana should treat American tourists well and that business and government should invest more money in tourist facilities, publicity, and better transportation. 16 Approximately 30% of the Sun's domestic cover- age of Americans dealt with American tourism. Almost one half of the ~ • s editorials on Americans dealt with the subject of tourism. This contrasts sharply with the Province, whose coverage of tourism was insignificant. T h e ~ often used the tourism issue to attack what it per- ceived to be the anti-Americu stance of Conservative politicians. Representative would be the editorial of December'30, 1930 (page 8) titled "Canada's New Inquisition, 11 where t h e ~ hit out at what it perceived to, be ~ - 302 - • the anti-AmericaR sentiments of R. B. Bennett. This worry that anij...-Afllericanism might hurt the tourist trade should not suggest that t h e ~ was necessarily pro-American, for it was not; the low Sun moral community score s~ould suggest this indirectly. t h e ~ was far from being unreservedly pro-American. Actually, More accurately (at least in respect to the United States), the Sun was pro-Canadian and nationalistic; in its coverage of Americans it was certainly more so than the Province. This pro-Canadian stance reflected more of a working class ,,, image of Canada; the fue!!, often compared Americans with it and found them to be wanting. The Sun's critique- of Americans centered around a small ..number. of topics. First among these was the assertion that (in contrast to Canadians who "loved law and order"), Americans Vl.'.'ere prone to crime and violence. This topic also was used by the Province but was given more prominence by the ~ • s .passion.for the unusual and its more flamboyant nature of pre- ... sentation. In ways that were reminiscent of the earlier Province editors, • the ~ often claimed that the Americans had not solved the problem of social justice, as had the British and Canadians (June 26, 1929, page 6). The ~ was also concerned ed~torially that American criminality might spread acroas the border to "law and order"_ Canada (June 29, 1929, page 6). Many news ite~s in the Sun originating in the United States which were !!.2!, coded as American ethnic stories must also have reinforced this image of Americans as being criminally inclined, for United States (. - 303 - newspapers in the 1920's and 1930's contributed much to the !).merican perception of violence in the United States. The §!!a. had_ a pa.rticular .fascination with spectacular stories aqout crime in ,the United States, as in th~ following 320 column_ inch piece with multiple photograp~s: . _... BABIES STOLEN FROM OTHERS Tragic Drama In "Kidnap Racket" U.S. Midwest Under Reign of Terror (March 26, 1932, page 4) This piece (and others which proliferated after the Lindbergh kidnapping case) dealt in detail with what it considered was the increaaing wa-ve of child kidnappings, suggesting that lax United States laws allowed such kidnappings to become big business. ~ news service items about crime in the_ United States by far outnumbered similar items about criminal activities in Canada. In addition, the fu!!!. was always on the lookoui._for ,xtraordinary American dev.i.ancy of other sorts: TWICE AS MANY U.S. CIIlLDREN SENT TO ASSYLUMS AS TO UNIVERSITIES· (August 23, 1932, page 1) __,,......._ The ~ • s Canadian nationalism was also expresse~ in news items about United States econo'mic and social domination of Canada. As in an editorial of May 27, 1929 (page 1), the Sun argued for retaliatory tariff, . against any attempt by Americans to limit Canadian exports to the United States. - The Sun also spoke out on occasion against American immigration .. ("Americans by Thousands Are E;migrating to Dominion" January 11, 1932. c- • 304 - page 4; '-'Americans are Being Given Favorable Rates in Settlers' Tickets," ~eptember 14 1 1928, page 6), and agaµist American workers taking . Canadian jobs (October 17, 1928, page 8). By comparison, the ·Province's position o~ Americans was relatively tame. Only very rarely was the Province provoked towards anti- Americanism and"there wete no specific issues which the Province consistently associated with Americans during this era. This lack of concern for ,. Americans was reflected in the fact that the Province" sample contained only three editoi::ials dealing with Americans in contrast. to the Sun's twelve. . . Moreover, virtually all of the Pra'vince news items dealing with Americ.i:ns involved events outside of British Columbia '18 out of 21); almost one _half of the~• s American coverage (16 out of 36) dealt with provincial issues. As might be expected. the coverage of Black America~s was quite different from th~t of other 'Americaxi·s. ' As iB. the previous era, there were very few Black Arne~can_s living i~ Vancouver and hence virtually all of the news items which dealt with them were about events~which occurred in the United States. Of the 16 news items on Black Americans found in the Province sample, 14 were of events in the United States; 13 of those were·. derived from the American news services. \ Relative to the Province, whose" rate of coverage of Blat:k.s was very close to what it had be·en bef.ore World Wai;_ 1, t h e ~ hardly covered :Slack Aznericans at all. In the ten year sample of the ~ there were only five news items which principally involved this grO¥p--far too few to say anything si~ificant about their coverage. ',, ', "- [ - 305 - Tables IVC and llIC outline the topics and themes associated with the coverage of Black Americans. In all fundamental respects the Province portrayed Black Americans as it did in the previous era. As before, Blacks only made the news if they were involved in violence or racial conflict. However, the tone of the Province's coverage seemed to have been moderated slightly, even though this did not reflect a change in the moral community score of Black Am.ericans. In particular, there tended to be·an increased likelihood that news items dealing with Black Americans would present them as the victims of violence than was the case previously, and normal news cover- age was somewhat more frequent than in the past. Nevertheless, Black Americans continued to be marginal to the press ethnic community during this period. - 306 - Topics and Subtopics Vancouver Province number % Advocation of Restriction advocate denial of services 1 6. 3 Are Restricted are denied rights 1 6. 3 Charge Restriction claim rights barred 1 6. 3 4 1 25.0 6. 3 Violence, Hostility By assault, harass others are accused of crime assault each oth~r Cultural Difference are unas similatible Celebrities entertainers social notables Normal News human interest victim of accident ethnic humor make good 6. 3 6. 3 3 18. 9 6. 3 6. 3 6. 3 I I I 16 Total Table IVC. 1 1 100. Oo/o Vancouver Sun number o/o 1 40.0 20.0 1 20.0 _l 20.0 5 100. Oo/o 2 Black American Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Sun (1988-1937) ,j - 307 - Theme Vancouver Province number Vancouver Sun number Violence, Hostility Against 5 1 Violence, Hostility By 3 3 Advocation of Restriction 2 Are Restricted Cultural Difference Table lllC. 1 1 l Most Common Themes in Dornestic Black American News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Sun (19281937) - f I qi - 308 - Native People For the most part, native people weathered the depression of the 1930' s in silence. Their participation in the cash sector of the provincial economy had been extensive during the 1920' s, and this had allowed a number of groups the resources to press the provincial and federal governments for greater native rights and more land (Drucker 1974: 152). Land claims were a particularly bitter issue. Because they were so dependent upon employment in the resource industries, the depression threw thousands of native people out of work. A great number of them ·had no choice hut to return to the near subsistence life of the reserves (LaVfolette 1961). Native economic resources were • severely reduced, and the disorganization resulting from the depression likewise weakened native political organization. The problems of native people were forgotten as the goverrunent attempted to de·al with a national ( economic paralysis. Native people nevertheless continued to rec~e~xtensive coverage in the press, as can be seen in Tables IIC through C. News items dealing with native people accounted for 11. 7% of the Province's domestic cover- ., age--more than any other group except the Chinese (14. 7%). The Province's coverage of native people actuall~ \ncreased substantially over the previous "-'' era. By way of comparison, the Sun was considerably\ess interested in r native people than the Province, devoting 7. 2% of its 1omestic coverage to them. , -- - - ·- - - - - - - - 309 - Topics and Subtopfcs Vancouver Province number % Education need ·special education Employment & Economy are skilled are employ~d 1 1 1 1.8 1 1 3. 1 3. 1 1 3. 1 1 3. 1 1 3. 1 1 3. 1 10. 9 3 9.4 1.8 1.8 2 6. 3 1 3. 1 4 4 12.5 12. 5 3 9. 4 ,' 1.8 1.8 Advocation of Restriction should deny ethnic ways Are Restricted are barred from jobs are denied ethnic ways 2 1.8 3. 6 Charge .Restriction claim they are not allowed w~ys claim th"e ir rights are barred 1 1.8 1 1.8 Ethnic Relations have bad police relations relat1ons get worse relations are good unite with others 2 3. 6 1.8 1.8 3. 6 1.8 Legislative le Legal laws protect are in court protest to government other Violence, Hostility Against are assaulted or harassed are victims of crime Violence, Hostility By assault, harass people are accused of crime assault each other are killed, executed 1 1 1 2 1 1 6 1 1 1.8 1 1.8 1 1. 8 9. 1 5 Vancouver Sun number o/o - 310 - ~ nwnber '.fa 1 2 1 1.8 3. 6 ,l . 8 number '.fo 1 1 1 1 3. 1 3. 1 3. 1 3. 1 ,I Cultural Diffei;ei;ice different morals different sanitation & health are assimilatible require special practices are unasaimilatible different ideas of law other 1 . 1.8 Celebrities 1 1. 8 ~thnic Organizations organize in 'the community celebrate festivals 1 2 1.8 3 •. 6 Normal News victim •of accident victim of natural disaster human interest make good other 1 5 1. 8 9. 1 6 1 10. 9 l. 8 3. 6 ...1. - ·, 1 1 3.'Ik 2 1 6. 3 3. 1 32 100.0o/o 3. 1 / Total Table IIC. 55 100·. Oo/o ( Native Domestic News Coverage by Topics . and Subtopics: Vancouver Province and Vancouver fu!!!. (1928-1937) ', - 311 ~ Vancouver Province nwnber o/o ~Opie • -. ,...__ Vancouver Sun number % Normal News 15 27.2 3 9. 4 Legislative & Legal :9 16. 3 5 15.7 Ethnic Relations 7 12. 6 I 3. I Violence, Hostility By 6 10.9 11 34. 4 · Cultural Difference 5 5.4 4 12.4 Are Restricted 3 5.4 Charge Restriction 2 3. 6 2 6.2 -1. ~ -1. ~ 49 85. 0% 2.8 87.4% ~ Employment & Economy Total ... Table IC. The Most Frequent Topics offia:tiv&,Domestic News Items-: . , ~ .. , ~' - Vancouver Province and Vancftiver Sun (192.8-1937) Theme L ' Vancouver Province number V 1ncouve r Sun nwnber Cultural Di.ff~rence 26 17 Ethnic Relations 15 3 Violence, Hostility By 14 19 Legislative Ir: Legal 9 4 Violence, Hostility Against 2. 6 Nortnal New ■ 3 2 Table C. Moat Common Themes in Domestic Native News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver~ N92.8- l 937) - 312 As in the previous era, the newspapers of the 1930' s continued to be • primarily concerned with native Indians, with only a small proportion of their coverage going to the Inuit. the total in both papers. Items on the Inuit made up about 100/o of The coverage accorded to these two types of native people -was very different one from the other, with Indians receiving much more negative coverage than their northern counterparts. This also followed earlier press practice. A glance at Table IIC will con.firm that the Sun and the Province portrayed native_ people in very different ways. The Province is of parti- cular interest because its treatment of native people changed fundamentally from what it was earlier. It should be recalled that in the· period prior to World War I the Province's treatment of native people was quite harsh, such that their coverage produced a moral community score of -1. 34; for the decade 1928-1937 the Native moral community score in the Province 17 was -0. 56. In contrast the~• s moral community score was .1 -1. 27, which made native people the most negatively covered group in that paper during the 1930' s with the exception of the Dukhobors (-1. 31). While the Sun was not directly connected with the earlier World, the-two papers shared a similar political and social philosophy. Nevertheless, the World's native moral community score was substantially less negative than the ~ • s in a time when the newspapers were far more harsh in their coverage of ethnicity. As can be seen in Tables llC and IC, the difference in the Province's • • - 313 - .. treatment of native people derived primarily from a dramatic shift in what \. topics were news when native people participated in them. As a compar- ison between Table IC and Table XXXXIX of the previous Chapter will verify, the moat frequently found topic-s of the past era were not the most common ones during the 1930' s, News items concerned with crime,· ~ violence, and cultural difference once made up fully one half of the . . Province's sample, yet in the era in question these topics accounted for only 16. 3% of the total.. In their place, normal news (27. 2%) and legal and legislative matters (16. 3%) became f~r more prominent. Moreover, the range of topics, subtopics, and themes found in news items on native people 1 increased considerably in scope. ~ No lo~ge;r were native people news only when they deviated from what was expected of them. One important aspect of this increased sensitivity to those areas of native life which were previously ignored was that the Province more frequently sought to portray native people. •• individuals. It should be recalled that- in earlier time·s native people, like other stigmatized and subordinate group•, were rarely dealt with in this fashion. News items either portrayed native people in the abstract or else failed to identify individuals by name when they were involved. Earlier on, the Province almost never sought to aak native people'• opinion_ on anythin1, even about those events in which they participated. To an increasing extent, the Province of the 1930' s showed native people'• concerns and a•pirati.ona, and occasionally would pre•ent the native point of view on ·nativ~ problems. Consequently, native {' - 314 - people were not so routinely characterized as being all the same as they were so often previously. Stereotypic words like "brave" and "warpath" also became less frequent. '\ Human interest stories were almost entirely absent from the Province's earlier coverage. They began to appear during this decade; INDIAN STUDENTS ENJOY C.ITY VISITS Girls of Alert Bay School are Pleasantly Entertained (Vancouver Province, May 31, 1931, page 2) Some of these human interest stories were used by the Province to support · more sympathetic treatment of Indians: ARE INDIANS HUMAN? Indian papooses Now Go to School (Vancouver Province, March 2, 1935, page 5) FATHER COCCOLA HAS AIDED B. C. INDIANS FOR OVER 45 YEARS Defended Indians Against Land Takeover (Vancouver Province, November 8, 1929, page 17) The Province ·also more often represented Indians as the active agents of their own fate than previously: INDIANS REFUSED TO DEAL WITH WHITES Preferred to Turn over Irrigation Areas to Chinese Farmers • (Va:ucouver Province, May 16, 1931, page 20) - 315 - TRAFFIC IN TOTEM POLES ENDED BY OTTAWA EDICT. Protest over Removal of Naas River Indian Relics to U.S. Museum Brings Action- from Government (Vancouver Provj.nce, February 1, 1931; page 3) This -relativ:ely b-enign coverage of Indians by the Province should not obscure the fact t}lat the Province continued to print a considerable number of stigmatic news items about nativ~s on the subjects of crime and cultural difference. Although the Province was far le~s interested in these things than was t h e ~ (see Table IC), when the Province chose to address Indian violence and cultural difference ,it pid so in the same harsh manner as did its competitor. In many respects, the~• s portrayal of native people in this era had many of the characteristics that were found earlier ~n the World. Like the World, the Sun tended toward the s e n s a t i o ~ un~sual in native behavior, even in comparison with much of its coverage of other groups. Like the World. this led the fu!a. towards a preoccupation with Indian violence, with i;:onfrontational legal and with cultural \ differences. At the same time, there were no indications that the stigmatic way in which the ~ portrayed native, people was the result of design. \ In f~ct, tl?,e ~ showed no evidence of havilg bothered to form a consiste♦t position on native people. Native people were rarely th~ topic of editorial comment, and the ~ seemed to have deta.ched native people from,. the Liberal !locial - 316 _; philosophy of support for the underdog to a far greater extent than had the World. Rather, it seemed that native people were the victims of the Sun's fascination with the unusual and the exotic--a fascination which must have been allowed to run free because of the obvious inability of native people to respond effectively to their press portrayal. For whatever reason, the ---,Sun clearly continued to perpetuate a stigmatic image of native people well into an era when even its more conservative competitor had made significant c}langes in its portrayal of this group. It should be noted in passing that Inuit people continued to be treated by the Vancouver press in a far more sympathetic way than W.fe Indians. Although the frequencies of occurrence of news items dealing--with Inuit were too small to engender an extensiv~ discussion, Inuit people were '-Yliformly described as friendly, enterprising, independent, helpful, and daring. The following item is representative: NORTHERN AVIATORS SHOULD TAKE ESKIMO Suggestion Made to Government that Precaution would overt Disaster (Vancouver Province, November 8, 1929, paie 15) The item goes on to claim that Eskimo had saved many white lives in the North, and that the E 'skimo were adapting well to whites; "Canada's Eskimo are Canadian citizens, not wards like the Indians. 11 j ' ~ - 317 - Eastern Europeans: Doukhobors; Russians,~ Others • '\ Between the turn of the century and 1931 an enormous 'number of East~rn European people came to~ada. The largest 'ethnic gl'-~up..' among them were the Ukrainians, followed by the Poles, German-spt?-ilkers ' . . from R~ssia (who were not themselves culturally· Slavic), and the Ru~sians. ' Smaller nwnbers were con,tributed by virtually every ethnic or national group in Eastern, Europe. Most of these new Canadians headed to the prairie provinces. Few of them went as far west as Vancouver, either in the pre-World Vfar 1 phase of~immigration or.in the decade thereafter. In 1931, Vancouver residents who were born in either Russia, Poland or the Ukraine, nwnbered only 2,465 or 1% of the total·po'J)ulation (see Table XVII). Neither did many :!!;astern Europeans establish themselvE:s in the interior of the province, with one very notable exception- -the Doukhobor s. • Doukhobors first came to Canada in 1899 as part of a group settlement scheme that was intended to provide mutual benefit to the Doukhobors and . , . . \ the Caµadian government. The Doukhobors wou,ld escape the persistent oppression of the Russian goverrunent, while Canadians would ben_efit from f . • their contribution to opening the Prairie West to settlement •. Organized. into intensely comm~listic and inward turning s~ttlement1J/' they initially • w prospered in Saskatchewan and in· Alberta, ..only to come into conflict with < • ' both the federal and provincial' governments. • In most reiipects the Doukhobors were politi..cal anarchists, and refused to have a n ~ g .whatever 0 II 318 - Unwilling to accept even ~ to do with government rules and regulations. minimal government interference, the Doukhobors .began moving to so·uth- - . .·; eastern,iBritish Cohnnbia around 1910, where they were able to purchase land communally and avoid the oath of allegiance required of homesteaders in the prairies (Davis & Krauter 1971:76). The Doukliobors came ·under intense criticism in British Columbia only after /he : close of the last era in this study. Violently anti-militaristic, the Doltkh~~rs refus~d milita_r y service during World War I as was their rightunder the Order-in-Council of December 6, 1898. Nevertheless, antipathy towards their refusal to serve and to the rise of sectarian • ... . • violence art"long Doukhobors led to their being denied the vote in British Columbia in 1919. It was no! until 1953 that these provincial voting re- stri~tion, were lifted (Da~s & Krauter _l971:7~). Duri~ the era under question the Doukhobors can,e under' intense • . pr~ss ~crutiny~ F.orty out of the fifty:..tnree news items dealing with . . . • Eastern Europeans during this era in t~e Province were on Doukhobof s as ~ w~re twenty-nine out of forty-six ne,ws items in the~- Mo st of. this coverage was extremely stigmbors received the lowest m~ral community scores of any group during this era; -1. 30 in the Province and -1. 31 in the Sun. Table Cl gives the distribution of topics and subtop~cs asaociated with these Doukhobor new• ne'11•· As----c.n be seen, the coverage of Doukhobors concentrated almost ....... .... . - . ,J - 319 - Topics and Subtopics • / Vancouver Province . number % Education need special education adjust to education •ystem other· 3. 8 '2 Health Ii Welfare are a·drain on services I 1.9 Employment & Economy are in economic distre as l 1.9 Advocation of Restriction should deny rights l 1.9 l 1.9 Are Restricted are denied rights other · Vancouver~ riwnber o/o l l 2.2 2.2 l 2.2 l 2.2 l 2.2 l 2.2 l l 1 2.2 2.2 2.2 2.2 2. 2 . · Charge Restriction c.laim they are barred from ethnic ways Ethnic Relations try to better relations relations are mediated relations get worse relations are bad are as siinilatible do not get along have bad police relation.have out•ide help other Immigration are deported law ■ limit (re inunigration) are in court (re immigration) ' 2 I I I 3. 8 3.8 1. 9 1.9 1. 9 l l 2 1.9 3. 8 l 1. 9 l l 3 5.7 1.9 2 l , Violence, Ho•tillty By are aa.aulted -. . property i • de ■troyed· are ·t hreatened with force a•aault; hara•• other ■ • L l 1 3 - ' 1. 9 1.9 1.9 5. 7 l 1 2.2 2.2 - 320 r_ ~ munber 4 Violence, Hostility By (Cont'd.) assault each other ·meet an imposition with force are accuse_d of crime other Cultural Differ-ence have different religion are unassimilatible • • • Celebrities entertainers ~liticians social notables historical notables Ethnic Organizations celebrate festivals J Total Table CI. l o/o l 1.9 9.4 1.9 2 3. 8 1 ·1.9 1 1 l. 9 5 1. 9 2 3. 8 40 100. 0%_ number o/o l l 6 2. 2 2.2 13.2 1 2.2 1 i 2. 2 4.3 2 4. 3 . - 2') 100. Oo/o Doukhobor Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Sun (1928-1937) ( ' 321 - exclusively upon the unusual. There were, for instance, no examples of normal news within either sample. Instead, virtually all of the items on Doukhobors had something directly to do with violence att'd ~rime. This coverage contin:ued throughou~ the era in question an_d largely concerned the activities of the Doukhobor sect, the.Sons of Freedom. Typical of the period would be the editorial "After Oakalla. What?'' (Vancouver Province, September 9, 1929, page 6), in which the Province claimed that although 103 Doukhobors had been jailed for six months in Oakalla prison it would not deter the burning .of schools _and oth~r social disruptions. In 1930, the provincial "Legislators Move to Pefranchise all Doukhobors in B. C." (Province. August 5, 1930, page l); the Doukhobors were actually disenfranchised in 1931. The Sun indignantly claimed that: . DOUKHOBORS ENDORSE VEREGIN Govermnent Thanked for Loss of Ci~zenship (Vancouver Sun. August 2, 1934, page 5) Both papers went further in arguing that the Doukhobors were unassimilatible and violent: they should be 11 01tracized for they were no good in principle" (Vancouver Province, editorial, May 18, 1934, page 6). Con1tant theme• in the coverage Qf Doukhobors were their reputed violence to each other, de 1truction of property, and public nudity: WOMAN DISROBES AT DOUKHOBOR PICNIC Exile Celebrated by Big Concourse Colorful Ceremonies Held at Brilliant (Vancouv,er Sun, June 30. 1931, page 24) C ... ..... -~ ·- __ - --·· _-- .-- - 322 - THE DOUKHOBORS AGAIN Old Vexacious Problem. Government Willing to Settle 200 Sons of Freedom on New Land (Vancouver Province, June 1, 1936, page~) With the exception of an odd paragraph he!e and there, both papers succumbed to a fascination with the moment and almost completely neglected the social, economic, and ideological context in which the Doukhobors lived. For instance, none of the approximately seventy news items in the sample (both papers) bothered to. inform the reader as to who -~ the Sons of Freedom were and what they stood for. The only background history provided on the group by the newspapers wa• an occasional reference to the Canadian government's generosity in letting them come to Canada. Hence, neither paper provided the reader with any sort of explan- atory information which would help to understand Doukhobor events .except in the most individualistic and non-systemic manner. During the period in question the only other ;Eastern European group to make the newspapers with any frequency were the Russians; Ukrainians 19 were virtually ignored. Even the Russians received so little coverage that the coverage of the Province must be combined (n = 7) with that of the ~ (n =, 10), in order to say anything substantive ab.out it. The coverage accorded to Russians clearly . reflected the middle class concern of the times about communism and the Soviet Union. Most of the news items on Russians in Canada had to do with events in Vancouver itself; these events c·oncerned the cultural distinctiveness of Russians, their _, • - 323 - involvement in suspicious organizations, violence, and bad ethnic relations. At the level of themes cultural difference was important, as it was in the coverage of the Doukhobors. / In overview, the coverage of Eastern Europeans in the press of this period serves to confirm several press tendencies which have been brought out earlier. In portraying Eastern Europeans, the Vancouver press chose to cover that which was µ1;1usual, especially those events which seemed to violat~ nQ,l"m&l canons of behavior. As in the case of many other peoples dealt with previously, neither paper provided any sort of explanatory context . with which the reader could really under stand the events about which he or she read. Moreover, n~ither paper devoted even the smallest measure of ' · its coverage to those many thousands of Eastern European immigrants whose role had been so fundamental in developing the Prairie provinces. Their activities, concerns, and contributions were simply not a part of the , ethnic mosaic of the Vancouver pres·s . i -'324 Other Europeans: Germans, Jews, Italians, Immigrants !.!l5!, Others As in the era before the' First World War, those few groups which have been dealt with to this point constituted virtually the to~l world of > · ethnicity as portrayed by the press. All other _ethnic and national groups received very sparse treatment by the Province ahd the Sun, as is indicated by Table .Cll: Ethnic Origin Vancouver Province Vancouver Sun Western & Northern European Dutch French German Scandinavian other 1 1 14 8 3 2 Southern European Italian Greek 11 15 2 2 Hispano-Portuguese Latin Americarl 22 8 1 1 European (unspecified) Jewish 13 9 Auitralian & New Zealand 5 3 Arab-Israeli 2 1 South .t\[rican & Rhbtie sian (White) hnmigrants Table Cll. 9 10 Frequency of Domestic Coverage of Other Groups. Vancouver Province and Vancouver§!!!! (1928-1937) In swn total. all of these groups together received only 14. 9o/. of the • -· ~ "' - · .. . - 325 - Prevince' s and 16. 4% _of the Sun's domestic coverage during this era. Sub- :'it tracting those news items on the groups to be discussed in this section (G~rm.ans, Italians, ,Jews, .::and Immigrants) leaves a remainder of 4. 9% and 3. 8% of the Province's and Sun's respective coverage which per~ains to the other gr-0ups in Table Cll. Germans Germans were on_e of the very few groups to fall from press grace during this era. It should be re called that in the previous de cad~ under scrutiny Germans were covered quite favorably (albeit rather infrequently). During this period the frequency of reporting upon Germans increased moderately while their press image deteriorated badly; the moral community scores for Germans were -1. 00 (Province), and -0. 45 (Sun). Although the small sample (14) in the Province does not allow one to generalize easily, it woul·d seem that the coverage of Germans suffered from a shift of emphasis from the good to the bad aspects of the German stereotype. Prior to the Great War, Germans in domestic stories in the Province and the World were praised by tJ:ie press as being hard working, law abiding, and resourcefu\. In the Province sample from the inter~ years, !!.2!, 2!!!. news item mentioned these qualities at the level of topics, subtopics, or themes. In their place we.re subtopic II and themes relating to violence, bad ethnic relations, subversion, and intransigence. The~ was less co~tent in its coverage of Germans, and continued to present a large minority (about 4°") of its news items on subjects that were primarily - 326 - favorable to Germans, mixing these items with others which were little different than those in the Province. It was still possible to find editorials in the ~ ("Germany and the Gerrrtans'' as late as September 30, 1936 (page 4) which claimed that Germans "are a wonderful people who mU;st be ,.,·. distinguished from their government." Moreover, the Sun editor could still assert the old adage that "they are our own kind, our racial cousins." Paradoxically, the Province editorial of the same day ("The Defence of • Canada," page 6), argued that Germany was such a threat to the world that it already had its eyes on Canada. / One must.presUITle that the difference in coverage which was received by Germans during these two periods resulted from a general change in societal attitudes towards Germans sterning from World War I; no change on the domestic scene can account for it. The place of Germans in Canadian society wa, not much different than it had been before the First World War. r At the sa~e time, it was surprising to find that neither paper covered Germans overseas to any significant extent. There were but 10 items in the overseas Province sample and 28 in the Sun's. Moreover, very few of these items gave any indication of the rising storm in Europe or the development of institutionalized anti-Semitism in Germany. Most of the items in both papers were paraphrase• of speeches on the future of Germana, German humor, and in the latter part of the era, reports of Germana doing violence to each other. -As an indication of the lack of press concern with German ethnic and political relations, there were no newa items during thia era .., - 327 - which were coded with "Nazi" as the primary ethnicity involved. As mentioned in Chapter One, Jews do not constitut;. an ethnic group in the normal sense of the term. Even if one restricts the field to those Canadian individuals who are religious Jews, few fundamental commonalities are readily evident. These individuals come h:om a very wide range of ethnic and national backgrounds, and even their religious practice is extremely variable. Nevertheless, the press considered Jews to b,e an ethnic and religious group, and they are considered as such here. Jews have played an important role in Canada from the ea::tliest times, but only became numerically significant alter 1900 (Sack 1965). From the turn of the century until the termination of large s·cale Canadian inunigration in 1931 their numbers increased dramatically. Most Jewish immigrants during this period came to Canada from Eastern Europe or from the German- speaking area of Central Europe. Jews were scarce\ymentioned in the Vancouver papers of the previous era. ' The Province domestic sample had only 8 items on Jews and the World hatt three. In the 1930' s, the frequency of news items dealing with _) Jews increased slightly to 13 in the Province and 9 in the Sun. On the whole, the domestic coverage of Jews was positive; Jews received a mora-1 community score of O. 54 in the Province and O. 22 in the~- Basically, iews were given coverage in accord with the positive aspects of the folk North American stereotype of th_em. Jews in the pres• helped each other, - 328 - especially with respect to social services, orglnized their comm.unities~ were active in community celebration, and got along with other Canadians. Negative elements of the folk stereotype such as unscrupulous Jewish . business practices were not given press coverage, and even the distinctively non-Christic\Jl nature of Jewish religion was reported without undue prejudice. Even though the era in question terminated at the end of 1937 it was disconcerting to discover that neithet- the Province nor the Sun carried extensive coverage of the situation of Jews in Germany or Zionism in Palestine. The total sample of foreign news items on Jews was 7 items from the Province and 10 from the Sun. Despite the fact that the decade did not include the last year leading up to World War 11, / ' the end of 1937 Hitler had been in power for five years and signif~nt restrictions against German Jews were already in place. Yet only one of the foreign items on .. Jews in the Province involved Germans as the second ethnic group involved and the Sun did little better (3 out of 10). 20 In fact, approximately one half of the foreign coverage of Jews during this period involved events in Palestine. While virtually all of ~e overseas news items dealing with Jews portrayed events in which Jews were one or another way the victims of their , ~- ethnicity, the Vancouver press systematically remained silent on a situation ~ • which led to over four nu.llion Jewish dead in the next few years. L - 329 - Italians After an initial influx between 1900 and 1910, the Italian population of Vancouver stabilized at around 1,500. ,This number remained constant throughout the 1920's and 1930's,largel}'.: due to there peing very little Italian immigration to, Canada in the 1920' s. Nei~er the Province rior the fu!!!. showed much interest in Italians during this era, as is indicated by Tables Clll and CIV. As was the case earlier, the newspapers were attracted to Italians when they were partici- ... ~ pants in crime or violence. Otherwise, Italians were rarely news. To a greater extent than previously, both papers tended to show a concern for local and Canadian events having to do with Italians. This was in marked contrast to the previous era when virtually all Italian news items were news 21 ·se\vice pieces des~ribing events in the United States~. To this extent, l t a l ~ n the press were no longer__, only~ scapegoat for urban crime. As with Germans, the local press more or less ignored Italians \ overseas. In the entire sample on~y two items of the sort were found in the Province, while another five came from the ~ - \¼' f - 330 - Topics and Subtopics Vancouver Province number % V anc ouve r Sun number % Charge Restriction other 1 9. 1 1 6. 7 Ethnic Relations try to better relations 1 9. 1 1 6. 7 3 1 20.0 2 2 13. 3 13. 4 1 1 6. 7 6. 7 1 6. 7 1 1 6. 7 6. 7 15 100. 0o/o Legislative & Legal are in court (re immigration) make bad citizens Violence, Hostility By assault, harass others assault, harass each other are accused of crime Cultural Di.He rence are loyal to home other 2 18. 2 2 18. 2 1 9. 1 Sports partici~ate in sports Ethnic Organizations celebrate festivals organize in community 1 9. 1 Normal News victim of accident make good other 1 1 1 9. 1 9. 1 9. 1 Total 11 100.0% Ta.ble CW. 6. 7 Italian Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Sun (1928-1937) \ \ - 331 - Theme Vancouver Province number Vancouver Sun number Violence, Hostility By 5 8 Celebrities 1 3 Cultural Difference Table CIV. 1 Most Common Themes in Domestic Italian News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Sun (1928-1937) • 332 ... Immigrants The abstract category "immigrants" was not much used during this period, despite a rather constant press ' concern· with immigration. For the most p~rt, both the Province and the Sun were not constrained by etiquette or the law to refrain from attacking ethnic or racial groups, and hence tended to use the specific national or ethnic label of the group that made the news rather .than "immigrants." Rarely did the press worry about immir grants in the abstract; rather it was concerned with more concrete things like Doukhobors, the lack of British immigrants or there being too many ' Eastern European immigrants. For neither paper were all immigrants the same. Both papers maintained the distinction between the British born and immigrants, as in the article "Should Alien Jobless be Deported?" (Sun editorial, January 11, 1932, page 6); while the Sun paternalistically "' argued that they should not, it was clear that the ~ was referring excluQ sively to non-British immigrants. Similarly, the author of a letter to the editor in the Sun "Would Halt All Immigration into Canada until Industries . . Develop" (January 18, 1928, page 8); this was because ~ g r a n t . Russians, Finns, and Slavs were ha·ving no trouble getting jobs, while British citizens were. As can be seen in Tables CV and CVI (particularly the 4,tter), the Province and t h e ~ were true to their political guns when discussing immigrants in the abstract. The Province continued in its earlier fascin- "' - 333 - · Topics a~d Subtopics Vancouver Province number %, . E;mployment II Economy are unemployed Vancouver Sun number % 1 10.0 Advocation of Restriction 1 11. 1 Immigration• too much should stay in Canada are deported immigration is solicited 1 11. 1 1 2 22. 2 2 10.0 20.0 1 11. 1 1 1 10.0 ' 10. 0 1 10.0 1 1 10.0 10. 0 1 10. 0 10 100.0o/o ' Legislative & Legal laws limit politicians urge restriction Cultural Dilierence are ·as similatible are unassimilatible Canadianne s s urged other 1 11. 1 2 . 22. 2 1 11. 1 Ethnic Organiza~ons celebrate festivals 9 Total Table CV. 100. Oo/o lmmi1rant Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Province and Vancouver~ (1928-1937) - - 334 Theme Vancouver Province nwnber Vancouve;r Sun number Cultural Difference 9 1 Numbers 5 1 Immigration 4 2 Legislative & Legal Employment & Economy Table CVI. \.r 5 4 Most Common Themes in Domestic Immigrant Ne)V's ·Items: Vancouver Pro¥ince and Vancouver Sun (1928-1937) ation with cultural difference, while the Sun tended to judge immigr•ation almost exclusively in economic -and legal terms . • ✓ - 335 - Canadians The booming British Columbian economy headed quickly towards collapse following the Wall Street Crash of 1929 and with that collapse came massive unemployment (Jackman 1969:213). By ~e winter of 1935 there were at least on·e hundred thousand unemployed looking for work in British Columbia (Robin 197 3: 17). While the federal government quickly shut down immigration, hostility among Canadians to immigrants definitely increased. Many of the Canadian born took the traditional option of economic hard times in Canada and emigrated to the United States; foreign · born Canadians were restricted from easy access to the United States by that country's quota system, which placed them on the quota lists of their home countries. During the 1930' s emigration of the Canadian born ex- ceeded immigration lty over one hundred thousand individuals (Corbett 1957: 148). Particularly in the West, the large number of Canadians who left for the United State a during the 1930' s led to the development of the "displacement theory" oi Canadian migration (Caves and Holton 1961:51-56). It . argued that becauae immigrants would accept lower w~ges than Canadian born individuals, Canadian■ were forced to move to the United States in the hope of achieving a higher standard of liviRg (Dale ■ 1966:173). Thia and similar ideas did little to endear immigrants to other Canadians dttring the depresaion years. The depression alao reaulted in dramatic population shifts within the - 336 - boundaries of Canada, and Vancouver figured heavily in these movements. The severity of the depression in the Prairie provinces led to widespread farm bankruptcies. the lucky <¥1-es. It also signified a return to subsistence farming for In either case, many people from the rural prairies went to Vanc~f·r _in search of work (Robin 1972:255). It is difficult to conceive _;;, ~f the sorrow and despair which stood behind these figures; the number of prairie born Ca.nadian residents in Vancouver increased from 2_2, 000 in 1931 to 40,000 in 1941 (Baker 1970:Jll). Similarly, the number of British Columbia born increased from 71, 000 to 93, 000. Those in similar rural circumstances in Ontario, Quebec, and the Maritimes drifted to the industrial cities of Ontario by the thousands, but they did not often come to Vancouver. As in the decade before the first World War., Canadians did not receive pai;:ticularly extensive coverage by the press. Only 4. 9% of the Province's domestic coverage and 6. '(f'/o of the Sun's was on Canadians, a~ -...__/ can be seen in Tables CVll and CVlll. Nevertheless, this rather meagr~ number constitutes a dramatic increase over the prior era, when the Province accorded Canadians 2. 2% of its coverage and the World managed an infinitesimal 1. Oo/o. With this increased press interest in Canadians came a more positive press image of Canadians. The moral community codes for Canadians were O. 09 in the Province and O. 13 in the Sun; the latter case is the first instance so far where a Canadian moral.community score equalled ~ t of the - 337 - Topics and Subtopics Employment &t Economy seek jobs cause unemployment are unemployed other Vancouver Province nwnber %' 2 8. 7 4.3 1. Vancouver~ number % "7 l 2 3.3 6.7 Are Restricted other l 3. 3 Claim Restriction claim job restrictions 2 6. 7 l 1 4. 3 4. 3 1 3. 3 2 6. 7 1 1 3. 3 3. 3 3 2 10.0 6. 7 6 zo. o_ 1 3. 3 z 6. 7 Ethnic Relations relations are good' try to better relations relations get worse hnmigration too much are deported should stay in Canada Legislative &t Legal laws protect politicians urge re atriction · other Violence, Hostility By are accused of criine aaaault ~ach other are violent Cultural Difference require special practice are loyal to home Canadianne ■■ uraed other l 4.3 1 4.3 l 2 4 4.3 8.7 17.4 1 1 4.3 4.3 1 4.3 1 4.3 8. 7 z c.1.tritie• politician• hhtorical notable• other 1 1 ~ I 4.3 4.3 ,1 ,. . - 338 - Sports ·participate in sports involved in sport controversy / number % number % 1 1 4.3 4.3 1 1 3. 3 3. 3 1 3. 3 30 100. 0% Normal News make good victim of accident 1 4.3 Total 2-3 100. 0o/o Table CVII. ., V Canadian mestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Pr ·nee and Vancouver~ (1928-lrovince editors, who still clung to the Conservative view that Canada was an integral part of the British world and that the British were -1le ideal by which Canadians should be compared. • Editorials which showed the Province supporting this posiiion were frequent. " Some of them we re so rapturous about the British that they seem a bit embarassing in today's context; an example would be the editorial of January 18, 1928 (page 6) about the arrival of Lord Byng. The Province editor gescribed him in glowing terms; he was an honored Canadian before he ever arrived in this country--as such, · he was just coming home. Another editorial (April 16, 1936, page 6) stated that British immigrants in Canada should have access to the same privileges as the Canadian born. Th~ Province's love affair with the British was reflected in the fact that the British moral community score (O. 65) was far above that of Canadians (O. 09). The Province did, however, support Canadianness in prideful association with the Br-itisl;l and in opposition to the Americans-: The Pro.vince joined the Sun in making a number of cultural distinctions between Canadians and America, (or more accurately, between Canada and the L/ - 341 United Statea) . . If anything, the Province was more active in this than the Sun, £or fully 4·3. 5% of all the news items on Canadians in the Province occurred in the United States. Canadian news items. This compares with only 3. 3% of the Sun's These news items often sug·gested that (due to their British origin) Canadians had a more profound respect for law and order and were more industrious than Americans, hence their leaving would seriously harm Canada. For its part, the Sun began to speak for a speci- fically Canadian nationalism based upon the unique qualities of Canadians. This theme far outnumbered' any other in the Sun (see Table CIX). ,To move to a more general level, a comparison of the way in which the Province and the Sun portrayed Canadianness belies the now fashionable argument that the Conservatives were the major reservoir of "tr.ue" 1 nationalism in Canada s past, or that Liberai trade internc!-tionalism made • them incapable of defending a specifically'Canadian identity. At least in these two inatances of Conservative and Liberal sentiment, the oppeaite . theaia could juet aa well lte argued--that the Province's Conservative brand of nationalism was the weaker of the two, in that.it looked towards Britain for ideal modele. Feeling llO auch allegiance, 3 an independent nationalism. 2 ' the !ml was free to develop - 342 - Theme Vancouver Province nwnber Vancouver~ nwnber 7 25 Cultural Difference • Employment & Economy 5 2 ~ Legislative & Legal 3 3 Normal News 2 \1 Immigration 2 Violence, Hostility By 1 Table CIX. • 3 2 Most Common Themes in Domestic Canadian News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver fu!!!. (1928-1937) -----... - 343 - French Canadians It would not be stretching the point to say that news coverage of. British was more a part of the Vancouver press world than we-re French Canadians. The local press of the 1930' s systematically ignored the French third of Canada, as they had before World War I. The Province devoted a meagre 3. 6% of its domestic ~overage of ethnicity to French Canadians, and the Sun could muster only 1. 8%. Tables CX and CXI swnmarize the distribution of topics, subtopics and themes found in these news items. AH of the events portrayed in this ' small sample occurred in Quebec ,save for one item in the Province and two in the Sun. Because the coverage of French Canadian ethnicity-was so sparse, it is difficult to say with any certainty whether the two papers had a sped-· The Province's news items seemed to fie position on French Canadians. \ characterize French Canadians primarily as a problem in Confederation-~ problem which French Canadians brought on themselves because of their ' . persistent commitment tp the French language (February 15, 1935, page 10) and the Church (June 5, 1933, page 5). Occasionally, the Province also mentioned French Canadians' place in history (Marc~ 3, 1934, page 6; November 16, 1934; page 8). French Canadians. The Sun was even less conce.rned with The total sample f>i news items was made up"of a handful of Quebec event ■ and two editorials--one which suggested that the French Canadian "is more akin to you than the immigrant from London, who is infested with Communism. 11 • - 344 - Topics and Subtopics Vancouver Province number o/o Education need special education 1 5. 9 Advocation of Restriction advocate no foreign language 1 5. 9 1 5. 9 2 Etjmic · Relations relations are bad unite with others impose their ways 2 11. 8 11. 8 Immigration arrive s~uld stay in Can~da 1 1 5. 9 5. 9 1 5. 9 Legislative & Legal make good citizens "' Culture Difference different religion require special practices have bad national language use Celebrities politicians in the news historical notables l· 1 ~. 1 5. 9 5. 9 1 5. 9 1 5. 9 17. 7 3 Ethnic Organizations celebrate festivals organize in the community Total Table CX. -, 17 100.0o/o Vancouver Sun number o/o 1 12.5 1 12.5 1 12.5 1 12.5 1 1 12.5 lZ.5 1 1 lZ.5 1z;5 8 100. 0% French Canadian Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vapcouver Province and Vt9c99Yer ~ (1928-1~~7) ' _J 345 Y-ancouver Province number Vancouver Sun number Cultural Difference 6 3 Ethnic Relations 4 l Theme . , ..... .... - · ■ '. w 2 Ethnic Organizations Legislative & Legal Table CXI. 1 1 Most Common Themes in Domestic French Canadian News Items: Vancouver Province and Vancouver Sun (1928-1937) This lack of coverage of French Canadians is significant, for it is an indication of the degree to which Vancouver (~ at least the Vancouver press} was only concerned with those national issues which had direct consequences for British Columbiana. During this era, the press did lire to explain French Canadians to its readers. This sparsity of coverage left Vancouverites without a social or political context into which to place growing French discontent with their situation in Canada. ' - 346 - Ethnicity and the Press (1928-1937) The material in this Chapter about the manner in, which the Vancouver· press portrayed ethnicity during 1928-1937 allows one to considerably expand the list of conclusions which were generated wi the previous Chapter. In addition to supplying additional insights into the general role of the press and ethnic portrayal, this data allows for comparisons to be made between these two periods and for the establishment of temporal trends. The following set of conclusions are of both these types. 1. The press continued to generate a consensus view of reality and in relationship to it, continued to ca~t ethnics as deviants. This is in reality a comment on the general nature of newspaper reporting, as it applies to,ethnicity. In all places and times the newspaper has been the vehicle for the transmission of societal happenings- in the h~re and now, happenings which are of an unusual nature (Epstein 1973:3-31; .- Cohen and Young 1973:1). In this _century, what constitutes new~ for the ). Vancouver newspapers (anci most c1thers in North Ainerica) has been restricted to schematically outJining events ofran absolutely current nature; , ~- yesterday's happenings are not today's news. There is little time for' backgrounding or an independent investi,tion of the facts, and a given news item can at best bope to accurately abstract a schematic sequence of events out of what are always •ery complex questions in the real world. The press does not have the reputation of achieving even·t:biia mjnimal objective with any frequency. _/ I - 347 - Moreover, of its nature, the press cannot refrain from moralizing. At the same time the press is extremely sensitive to events which have a moral aspect. This further distorts press portrayal into something difierent than the world so portrayed. portant criteria of newsworthiness. Great good and evil are both im- Of itself, this is not of much conse- quence, as both good and e _v il eJlist in the world, but both are portrayed in · a manner· which is unrepresentitive of the world. 1n essence, good events are def~d to be ia_ society, while bad ones are defined to be fil!1 of society · or dev}ations from it. l ~ both eras under consideratio~ ethnic groups have been the victims I i of the~ processes. Those groups which the press associated with ''bad" ' charadteristic s were simultaneously defined as deviating from consensus. i . . . • (LipprAan 1965:223; Rivers and Schram 1'969:99), and hence as being out of soci~ty. Those fortunate enoug_h to be portrayed in association with moral- ity ani.::I good were placed within aociety, and thus a_erved to confirm that aoci~ was indeed a place of general conaenaua and overall good (Boorstin . 2. ' The ah&rp etbuj<: atratification of the earlier period's preep moder. ated durin& tei• era, "but pre11 coveraae continued to define fOme grove• t• mqrtl outsaf1e•• Both the Pre-World War 1 ProYince a.nd. . .the World defined a number of ethnic groupacto. be altogether outside of the moral com,munity, notably B~ck, Americana, Chine-se, Japaneae, South Aaiana, Native Indians and JtaJiana ... The Britiah. Canadian•, Germana, and Americana conatituted the ,. I I I. \ .• ' - 348 - , ethnic elect of the era. During the second period none of· the latter groups did substantially better than previously, and some lost _ground. Almost every group among the f~rmer was portrayed in, a ·sub'stantially better way than before. Reasons for the rise and fall of the status of specific gro,ups have been presenter previously,- but what c\cc;ounted for ~e ov.erall moderation of both ends of the ethnic scale? I believe tha,t·several factors contributed to this situation. The most impor~nt fac~or would seem~to have been the demographic stabilization of the Vancouver population and the equilibration of the society and economy based upon that population. There was no substantial imntlgration after 1931, nor did a significant number of "ethnics" migrate to :British Columbia during this era. The exception w o ~ e ' Doukhobors, who received the most negative c::overage of any group during this period. Excepting the entrlnce of the Doukhobors, the depression froze the lines of ethnic conflict in British Columbia where they stood in 1929. Take the ca ■ e of Asians in Briti ■h Columbia ae an example. restriction ■ No new of ■ ignificance were placed on them during thie era, but at the same time they were unable to make any ■ ignificant economic, ■ ocial -or political g_ain• until after World War II. Secondly, both the Province and the §!m. seem to have changed their 'pre•• etiquette' with re•pect to the treatmeDt of ethnicity. The overt advocation of di ■ crirninat:ion on ethnic or racial ground• aL. .I!. wa• done . le ■■ frequently than before. \ The•~ type• of ■pecifically · rac~ critique ■ .., - 349 - were replaced by rationales for discrimination which attempted to justify the practice on economic, social, or cultural grounds. In addition, derogatory labels like Celestial, Brave, Jap, and Hindoo were less frequently used. Thirdly, minority group members were less frequently associated with stereotypical attributes and were more commonly portrayed as individuals than before. For example, Chinese news items remained an important element of press portrayal, but an increasing proportion of those items concerned events involving individual Chinese Pt;ople. Previously, there had been a tendency to portray the Chinese as a homogeneous group, and they were often collectively associated with a particular activity or characteristic by the press. In short, both the Province and the Sun gave less coverage to the group aspects of ethnicity than did the earlier press and this made their coverage less lunsh and more personal. Finally, what constituted ideal Canadian behavior was no longer entirely clear, a point which constitutes one aspect of the following statement . and one which will be further developed in the subsequent discussion. 3. No longer Wff the coneenpue model of society defined ay the press apeci(ically Britith baaed. Despite their .urface differences, the earlier Province'• and World's \ diN1reement OYer the ideal standard of fancouver society wae pz;imarily . rhetorical. . Both tended. to ideologi..ki;contra et aubc,,-c:linete groups with ideal Anglo-Britiah behavior. In the -,ubeequent era there arose a more I . \ - 350 - fundamental difference between the criteria for ideal ethnic behavior held by the, Province and that of the Sun. The latte'r was definitely groping • towards some •ort of specifically Canadian definition of an ideal Canadian, while even the conservative Province was having difficulty reconciling its British definition of Canadianness with the times. The consequence was that while both papers knew definitively what the ideal was not, they were somewhat unsure of what i t ~ • In turn, this uncertainty about Canadian identity resulted in a less enthusiastic portrayal of the British and a less • negative portrayal of traditionally stigmatized groups; the Sun significantly moderated both extremes of its portrayal. \ It should be noted that neither paper was prepared to accept ethnicity directly into their definition of Canadianness. There was nothing in the press of the 1930' s which was in any way comparable to pre sent day multiculturalism. The~ was the more flexible of the two papers, but at its most liberal moments it held the po•ition that assimilated ethnics should be treated in a manner si.nli.lar to the Canadian born. The Province was not even willing to go that far. 4. The pre,, neyerthele11 continued to profane the identitv of certain Pdmj,;: group• without concern over the effects of ite portrayal. The fact that both papers provided a more moderate view of e ~ than did the paper• of the earlier era •hould not maak the continuing sever- . ity of their. portrayal of certain group•. especially the Chine•e, Doukbobors. . and Native Indian•. Neither paper had the •lightest hesitation to "print the - 351 - facts" about these people- without regard to how members of the groups so portrayed would react to their presentation. In due regard for the lack of significant social or political power of these groups, neither paper ~ corrected its previous coverage or apologized for anything it said in pri.J?.t. This practice probably went unrecognized by those that produced the newspapers. Nevertheless, to the extent that today's explanations will serve for yesterday's situations the explanation given would no doubt have been one based on the objec~vity and freedom of the press: ."After all, i I ( isn't what we -print factually true?" I believe that this explanatio~ (which is extremely conunon today), is altogethe_r invalid, for it confuses an event being in reality with the reality which the portrayal of that event recreates in the press. These can be quite different, depending on those other selective aspects of the world wh~ch are or are not also portrayed. 5. Despite the fascination of the press with ethnic happening,. abno1t never were the event ■ portrayed ever given an hietorical or •ociological contezt with which the reader could under•t,ad what truly , happened and what cooeeguencee the event• bad for other tbiag•. PerhAps largely because of ~~hnical constraints cliscueeed previously., · the press dealt almost entirely with the here and now of ethnicity, as per "Doukhobor Burns School. 11 For the press, sufficient explanation of such an J. event constituted presenting the factual~uence which wae immediately causal to it (de Sola Pool 1963:30; Bagdiltian 1971:273); in this caee that might be no more than ''Four Sens of Freedom were arreeted yeeterday in - seen by Mr. Joe Brown setting fire to the local elei:nen- \ ,. - 352 - tary school." Occasionally, the press felt called upon to provide an explanatory resolution of the same order: "They will be arraigned in Nelson Superior Court on charges of arson Tuesday." It is evident that news items of this variety about a given group are not, explanatorily additive. To continue the example, no number of them will allpw the reader any understanding of who the Doukhobors or Sons of Freedom were or why some Doukhobors occasionally ran around without clothes while others did not. For the period in question there seemed to be little relationship between the number of stories that a given group received and the degree of under standing of that group which a typical reader might have had if the press were his or her only source of information. Funda- mentally, the Press~ !!Qi~ effective vehicle !2!:, informing people about the ethnicity .2!, others. 6. The press rarely supported minority ethnic groups; when it did so, the press was never able to maintain a con•i•tent position of support. At their best, the two papers under ,consideration would occasionally support a particular ethnic group against further subordination; even the Doukhobars received this sort of editorial consideration on a piecemeal basis. Even so, neither paper during this era consistently supported a ",·~ minority ~ c group, if by support is meant actively affirming that their place in Vancouver •ociety should be more than it was. Pe.rhaps the clearest ca•e where one of the papers seems to have had . a policy of support for a group ~uld be that of the Province's portrayal of - 353 - Native Indians. Province editorials were generally sympathetic to nati,res. At the same time, the types of news items found in the "factual" first few pages of the same paper which dealt with Indian people often associated Indians with extremely stigmatic events such as murder, drunkenness, and the like. The result was a fundamentally inconsistent stance on Indians. It should be noted that even this marginal advocate support of Indians constituted the (positive) exception to the rule. Most groups got no support whatever. 7. The Vancouver press maintained its geographically introspective view of the world in the face of the increasing impact of national affairs on British Columbia arid despite the incr~ayd ease with which information about events in the re at of Canada could be obtained. Although this study can lead to no firm conclusions about the degree to which the Vancouver newspapers dealt with social and political events in the rest of Canada, one generalization can be made on more narrow grounds; the local press was fundamentally unconcerned about ethnicity in the rest of Canada and gave almost no coverage to any of the Canadian ethnic groups who resided outside of the boundaries of British Columbia. Baaed on this study, one cannot say whether the local newspapers covered events in Quebec with f.DY detail. What i!. certain is that neither paper presented anything substantive about French Canadians. Likewise, events in the prairie province• might have been adequately reported; I cannot say. Nevertheless, none of the ethnic people who made up the population of the~ r i e a were. The Proyjec: and the~ were ahnoat exclusively concerned with ethnicity - 354 - / within Briti~h Columbi.a--,and within that context tended to concentrate on '- _ ...... '1 ethn~ in the urban area of Vancouver. 8. This concern with ethnicity in British Columbia to the exclusion of other places extended to coverage of ethnicity overseas. _ This _point is evident when one considers that foreign news items made, up only 22. 7% of the total found, in the Province for this era and 30. 2% oi the Sun's total. Even more than their dome,tic counterparts, foreign news items on ethnicity tended to disregard large scale societal happenings and instead conc,entrated upon foreign personalities, humorous ethnic events and ethnic violence. Those world situations of the day which were or were to be ones of fundamental ethnic or racial conflict were largely ignored by the press--Jews in_Germany, ethnic groups in the Soviet Union, the oppression of blacks and others by whites in Rhodesia and South Africa-none of these received even marginal coverage. Moreover, the types of ethnicity covered by the press in these overseas items were also extremely restricted. " pf the Province's foreign coverage. Similarly, coverage of the Chinese (21), lapaneae (23), South Aai&na ( 19), Arab and Israeli ( 14), British (29), and Germans (23) accounted for 66. S,. of the ~ ' • foreign coverage. 9. Ethnic individualf had little access to -the preps and bad no control -rovince staff· .. (who incidentaµy is a liaison between the Proce and various native groups) that the Province made a conscious change in their editorial eolicy towards native people around World War I. While I have not been able to substantiate tlus from other sources, the marked change in the "tenor of the Province's coverage supports this claim.· 18. ln the Province of the preyious era only five topiG areas accounted for I . more than So/. of the sample each, and two of them monopolized press interest. During this period the ~read of subtopics was also much wider than it was. . ' . 19. During the ten years in question, there were !!2_ news items on Ukrainians, and QnlY 3 items on Poles in the P;rovince and 2 in the Sun.' 20. Correspondingly, foreign news items with'Germans as the main ethilic group during this period rarely mentioned Jews as a second ethnicity involved (Province: 1 out of 10: Sun: 0 out of 28). ( 21. During this era o_nly two of the Sun items concerned events in the United States. There were four such items in the Province. 22. Letters to the editor and editorials in the•Sun about Canadians were far more commo~ than in the Province. 56. 6% of the Sun's coverage was of thi~ sort, in contrast to 2.6. 1% o'f the Province'•· 23. It should be noted that neither the ~ nor the Province cognatively included the non-British foreign born within the category "Canadian." To take the ·more expansiv:e and ).iberal definition of the Sun, to be Caoa.dian meant minimally that-one func.tioned as would one of the Canadian born. 24. The Chinese made up 9: 7 of the population in 1931. Considering that they were virtually all ldult males, they mu~t have made up considerably more o! the wor~ng population than that. - 362 Chapter Five: Ethnicity in the Vancouver Preas (1967-76) • , In contrast to the 1930' s, in the last decade there tve been f~da- mental changes in the ethnic composition of Vancouver and ~n the way11 in •.. which that ethnici~ has been cove.red by the press. During the ~960' ~ and . 1970's Vancouver experienced an influx of immigrants the likes of which had not been seen in the city since before World War I. By 1971 Vancouver's demographic makeup diverged fundamentally from the national norms. While only 15. _3% of the Canadian population in that year was born outside of the country, 22. 7% of the British Columbian population was foreign born. Approximately 147,000 of the 426,000 people in Vancouver city were foreign born - -a substantial 34. A% of the total population. While ~his proportion of foreign bo_rn actually decreased by about five percent since 1941, the ethnic makeup of that population change presented in the following table: -L. • I Ill 365 , Locality 1928-1937 nUIIlber 1967-'1976 i pumber i" British Columbia 280 44. ·2 296 20~0 Canada 128 20.2 491 33. 1 United States 33 5.2 160 10.8 .Europe 92 14. 5 204 13. 8 ' Asia 80 12. 6· 51 3.4 Africa 16 2.5 260 17. 5 Latin & Central America 3 0.5 11 o. 7 5 o. 3 Australia & New Zealand Caribbean 2 o. 3 5 o. 3 Not Coded 1 o. 2 _2 o. 1 Total 635 100.0% 1; 485 100'. 0% Table CXlll. - Geographical Location of Ethnic.ally-Relevant Events Occurring in Items from the Vancouver Sun (1928-1937 and ' 1967-1976) . Some important changes can be noted in Table CXlll. First of all, it shows a decided shift in interest away from events in British Columbia. While the present day Sun bas continued to publish news items on local events dealing with ethnicity with about the same daily frequency as before, in relative terms this coverage has decreased f:rom 44. 2o/o of the total to 20. 0%. The Sun's interest hf ethnicity in the rest of Canada has also become greater than it once was; as shall be shown, this was principally the result of ... -;,,,~ ( 366 -., increaaed coverage of French Canadians. In th_; r~st ~f th~ world, "'it is clear tliat cove~age- of Africa changed the m~st, -~ovi.pg fr~m an insignificant place in the 1930' s n~wspapers to being th~ most actively covered area outside of Canada. . This shift re- . fleeted increased interest in race relations in South Africa and Rhodesia and the ongoing Arab-Israeli crisis in the Middle East. ' , , - , - .... , Likewise, the £re- - quency of reporting on·eth_nic issues in the United States increased in ,jl. response to the urban riots of the late !960' s.. Similarly, the conflict in Northern Ireland accounted for most bf the European ethnic coverage during this decade. Ethnic relations in Asia, Latin America, the Caribbean, Australia and New Zealand received very little coveragt:, with the excep1:ion • 1 of the .Vietnam War, which was not coded in this study. The dependenc~ of t h e ~ on foreign sources for its overseas news decreased in comparison with the past. While the number of overseas news items originating from Canadian sources remained unimpressive, such stori~'s were more fr~quent than before. . ... For instance, whereas virtually all of the ~ • s news items of" 1928-1937 originating in the United State·s came from other than C~dian sources, in the present~ade 80. 6% of the United States sample came from foreign news services (12 out of 160 items). • ~s can be seen in Table C~V, 26. 0% of th~~' s ethnic cover~,e now comes from (non-local) Canadi~ ■ources,, in comparison to 7.. 4% ~ ~ 1930 s. 1 This shift away from local issues can also be_ seen in the .§!!!l's' editorial activities. Thirty-one editorials in the sample dealt with Canada ..,.} \ , " , r LocalJty B.C. Canada News, Local News, Can. s. S, 197 36 1 Europe 4 Africa 2.8 2.55 34 42. News, For. s. 0 2.0 142. 173 Edito rial Letter to Editor 5 '"43 31 9 14 \ • ' Cartoon Feature ' 0 • 1 59 1 . ,I 0 I · 24 ~- 2 2.96 . 0 491 j ' BB . • Ot 17 0 11 Mi~sing Value -,,, · Total 14 2.04 2.60 0 . .. Latin le C. America 0 3 5 0 0 0 0 3 p ' I (,,.I 0' Australia & New Zealand 1 0 4 0 0 0 ·o 0 5 · -.J I b, Caribbean 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 •5 (0 160· 0 51 0 . #- • 4 U.S. A. Asia - . ..,. Total Percentag,ea - 6 249 16. a· 129 0 2. 1 13 - ..ll 2 5 0 . 4 385 497 61 11 11 26.0 33. 5 ,, . -~ '\ ~ 4. 1 12. 1 8. 2. 2. o. 6 165 2. - 11. l 1, 485 , - 100. 0o/o !', Table CXIV. Type of Coverage by Locality: Vancouver Sun ( 1967-1976) . \ .. \ . . , .,. '":: .' ·. ~ "' /; ana e~hni.city,. in co~parison w F u t fi~e, .d eali~-g:- spe~ifiv~t!ly with .Br~tish Columbia. Nevertheless, only 41% of editorials were about Rlac~s other · , . . ~ At tlie same tim'e, pubd._ic interest (at-lea st40 the degree that ., than Caryada. . ., • .-1 it -.<:an be gauged by letters to the editor) also remained fixed on Canadian rather than foreign is.sues. Fort_y three letters to the e_ditor (35. 5%) dealt . •· ··· r . with British Columbia wnile another fifty nine (48; 8%) addressed ethnici~y .... in the re ,t o/ 2anada. Headlines, Photographs, and Page Placement The format of etpnic presentation in the Sun of the 1960 1 s and 1970' s cha'nged along with the format of the newspaper ge~erally. Reflect- ' ing trends which began aroWld the turn of the century, the Sun continued to mte towards the production of a more visual (and less developmental) . product. For instance, headline width increased more frmn the 1930 1 s to the pre sent (from a mean width of _1. 679 to 2. 495 columns in the Sun) than it had from the fir st era to the second. now the mode (38. 1% of the total). The two column wide headlin~ is The frequency 'of one column headlines have ·shrunk to 24. 4% - about equal in frequency to those of three columns (20. 7%). Head.line widths of more than two columns now account for 37. 5% of the total, whereas previously (1928-1937) they accounted for a meagre 13. 5%. One out of fifty (Z. Z·o/o) of ethnic stories merited a full page, eight column wide headlines. Likewise, _the· visual impact of the .newspapers was enhanced by a su,bstant~al increase in the nwnber of ethnic news items in the Sun which - ·. ..:.. .I I 369 . ,. . ... _, between do~e sti~ and foreign stories, ' Page· placement in the Sun'r~mained essentiapy the same,· with two ,.._. . . sign*capt _cfiffer_ences. Wh1le Table CXV _showf that tp~ J ir!ft page . of the ""· , ,·· Cl=: . . . . .. • paper .remains the most likely place to find ethnic news items, the relative . . ' .9"/o ., percentage of front page news items has gone do~n i?y a ' factor of two (from 27. , to 14. 3%). Concomitantly·, tlile frequency with wh~ch one finds ethnic 2 news items in the back pages of the pa'per l\as incr.eased considerably. • -- Nevertheless, the first five pages of. the Sun remain fundamental to that ... . _,,.,.,,, paper's presentation of ethnicity, for fully 41,..4% ~fall such news items_ occur there . ... ...,.. .., ,. r - 3r0 - ' , .• • .. , ·..... . . • 1 ~ .. ~ . _ ' . m:upb'e,J- . . ;_ 213 2. 6.4 95 ·116 117 193 ... • I • 6 4. 2 10. 6 11-20 263 18.7 21-end 220 14. 9 49< Special Features • Table CXV~. I l 3. 2 100.0o/o 1,485 Total 1i The Page Distribution of Items in the Vancouver ~ ( 1967-1 ?76) Yearly Distribution 2!. Ethnically-Related-Items The yearly distribution of etlmic news items over the past decade did • '· _j not follow a uniform pattern. "- The number of items found in the sample of - ._ a given year fluctuated by more than a . factor of two, ranging from 98 to 2.13: . . ) j C ~ I .- , ..... ' j ,. .. ' .. . 371 .... ~ ' Domestic Ne:,ys Items Year ,-1..·. nwnber· l4i 1967 , ., . . . i18 · 1968 ' nwnber. 15.0 . ' ~· 12.4 . 70 . JL npmber 13. l· 213 V ..... __ , •"" 11.0 ~ - .... 't'iJ69 106 _1 1. 1 53..,. 1970 88 9. 3 38 ~ ,;, -- 59 • ---~;i""' ii ...,, ... ,.,, Total · Foreign.News ltem_s ' 177 ~ 14.-3 . ., ... ·. 11. 9 9. 9 159 10/7 7. 1 126 . 8. 5 . .'. '1971 'l 8. 9 85 9,4 ~ 972 9. 9 • .•:/ . 42 7.9 127 8. 5 54 10.· 1 148 · 10. O 6. 9 106 7. 1 : ,;;' ., 1973 69 ·1. 3 · 37 . 1974 57' . l>. 0 41 7.7 98 6. 6 1975 99· 19. 4 52 9. 7 151 10. 2 1976 -21 9. 7 ~ 16.5 180 12. 1 951 · 100.0% 534 100.0% 1,485 100.0% .. Total Table CXVL . 'I' i ,:> Yearly Distribution of News Items .in the Vancouve~ Sun (1967-1976) •• As will become evident in the discuss~of individual_groups, this wide yearly variation was primarily the result of the Sun's er:r;atic, on again, off again c~verage of partiptlar groups. This was in turn largely dependent on 'big issues. ~ Unlike th~ previous two eras, no ethnic group or nationality during the present decade was to receive uniformly high ~ress coverage. Rather, •th• dominant pattern waa 11r a ;iven gro.,;, to move into and ~of the press eye very quickly., For example, taking all domestic newa items on Asians together (n = 101), the yearly distribution of_ their coverage in the . . . .. . \ ...: 372 ·- sample.ranged from 24 (1975) to none {1970>. Similar oscillati'ona are evident in the co~erage of all the inte~eiy covered g~oups of this era, such ◄ . . that the overall _yearly fluctuation of th..,..:pun' s portrayal of ethnifity was ...... - - . . 'primarilj the addi~e ·consequen~e of even ~der variations in the frequency . .' , . "'~ .· ~ \" . , of cove rage of ~dividuai grou~s. n. ~ 3 Content: The Persistence: of Ethnic Portrayal !!!!2 .tAe J're SE!nt ~ (196 7 -197 6) • ., The People and ~Issue~ • .. • ' The end ·of World War ·n m 9.rked th~ beginnings .of long term c~anges in the ethnic makeup Qf Canada .. At ·that time Canada ha'd one of: the ! ew ~ in~strial economies not disrupted by war. Its raw materials were in ·great demand on the world.market and·its expanded industrial plant was able to . gain entry into _export areas which overseas competition had earlier precluded. The result was a decade of large scale (though fluctuating) economic ~rowth, with a concomitant demand for industrial and a-gt"icultural labor. Following p~st practices, the Canadian government looked towards a renewed immigration program to supply a considerable portion of its labor needs. 4 ~ As those manpower requirements became more selective, so dt,d . inunigration sel~ction procedures; in essence the inunigration regulations ' moved through a series of changes which propelled immigration towards - further econoniic rationalization and away from selection on the be.sis of . ' ethnic, racial, or national criteria. By -way of example, the bans on the immigration of Cm.ne.,ee and South Asians were both lifted in 1947, and were • .• - 373 -# subsequently replaced by limited quotas. • • ~ ; In the 1950' s, British, American, and European immiy'ation pre~ . dominated. Immigration from other areas of the wprld was not encouraged, apd~n many countries information about Canadian immigration was entirely . lacking. It was only in the mid-1960' s that the Canadi~n government finally ,,, created an immigratioO" policy which claimed to be racially and ethnically unbiased. This policy culminated in the immigration act of 1967 which -' (t9g"e~er with its, attendant' regulations) created the point system for irtuni. grant selection which·essentj_~lly remains' ;.n effect today. At~:teast for- t . . • mally, the point system's operation was to be entirely f~ee~of etlµiic, · ·racial~: or national criteria. Rather, it was to be based.upon socioeconomic fac_tors w~ch were designed to match_ prospectiVe C.anadian economy. immig_;anr tlie de~d.· of the. It waa also aimed a! selecting immigrants who were mok:) likely to adjust easily to the Ca~dian social context. cfnno~ ~e claimed ~t i~grant flows J ~though it ~~w completely reflect the absence of national biases (Indta i 978), a fundamental shift in the pattern of · . Canadian immigration bas occurred. If ' the years 1964-1966 are compared· with immigrant flows ten years later (1973-1975); one finds tha;fin the _,,,, former instance approximately 85'. of all immigrants w~re either i>ro~ Europe, the Uiµted State ■, or from one of tne other (white, European) Dominions: in the latter caae the figur~ is approximately 50,. (Indra 1978). In contrast, Asian immigration baa increased over the same decade from. 7'o to at least 25'- of the total. .,. , .i - . 374 -: • This renewed immigration ha,s aJfected the demog:caphic makeup of Canada's large urban areas far more than it has fue p~pul.atio~ at large. , , Postwar immigrants· have come primarily to the cities, notably Vancouver, . . , Toronto, · and Montreal. · Table CXVIL pre sents · the eth~c mak~up of Vancouver's population and the metropolitati area around i~t the time of the 1971 census. Group or N ati.onality British Isles French Chinese German Hungarian Italian Jewish Native Dutch Polish Ru ■ •ian: . ~ ,, Vancouver City -- Scandinavian Ukranian . All A•ians Others .• Total Vancouver Metropolitan · Area number .!19_ nuniber ..1L 225, 995 14,330 30, 640 32,515 4,005 19,020 7,975 2,995 7,670 6, 315 3,085 15,465 12, 105 53.0 3.4 7.2 7. 61{ 633,825 42,870 58. 5 4.0 89,675 8.3 32. 150 o. 9 4.5 1. 9 0.7 1.8 1.5 0. 7 3. 6 2.8 - 426, 2_6S /· ,l- 30,050 10,815 2. 8 1.0 "' .! 2.. 2 31,965 14, 985 7,310 51,870 31~ 130 58,255 72.605 . 3. 0 1.4 0.4 4.8 2. 9 5.4 7.4 100. Oo/o 1,082,350 100. Oo/o "" Table CXVIL. The Ethnic Population of V~couver and the Metropolitan Area (1971) - The above table is both informative and potentially misleading. One of the niost important conclusions to be drawn from it .i's that the VancouveTr ~etropolitan area has grown over the past thirty year• to such an extent tbt it, ·r ather than the city of Vancouver must be conaiae"red to be the ,? . - 375 (' constituency of the newspapers. This.is actually the case, for ~he~ (and secondarily the Province) are the predominant newspapers throughout , the area and for quite a distance into the lnte,.rior of British Columbia. ~t the same time, it would be foolhardy to conclude that this tal!le actually represents the ethnic makeup of the population. For instance, conside_f the category "British Isles." First o_f all, it lumps together all individuals who we;e born anywhere in the Briti,sh Isles, including the· Republic of Ireland. Secondly, it does not differentiate fifth generation Anglo Canadians from recent British immigrants; in fact, as shown in Table CX'\lU,l only 19. 0% of these "British" in the metropolitan area were born in Britain. British origin. The most typicd Vancouverite is Canadian born of - 376 - ~ number Country United Kingdom Other British Irish Republic Germany Netherlands Other Western European countries Italy Other Southern European countries Poland Russia Other Eastern European countries China India Other Asians United States Africa Catibbean Other Total Foreign-born ) l 1.05, 270 15,265 3,465 19, 115 11, 110 7, 950 13, 750 11, 755 6,780 9,060 8,290 17, 040 6,530 6,525 25,685 2,680 4,835 11.380 .4t; l -, } ·, , 286,485 1. 2 6. 7 3. 9 2.7 4.9 4.1 2.4 3. 2 2. 9 5. 9 2. 3 2. 3 9. 0 · o. 9 1. 7 4.0 100. Oo/o 1,082,350 , Total Population Table CXVlll. Birthplace of Metropolitan Vancouver's Foreign Born Popu> lation in 1971 (in numbers and percentage 111) Postwar immigration has resulte,~ in significant changes in the size of Vancouver's minority populations. As a legacy of the 1950' s and early 1960' s the number of Germans, Italians, Greeks, and Dutch have incre-;,._sed substantially, as have people of various Scandinavian origins. Throughout the era immigration_ from the United States has held its own. After 1967, . many Asian immigran~s began comming to the Vanco\lver area; these individuals are only partially reflected in the 1971 census figures, f9r it was only in 1970 that Asian immigration was to reach a substantial size. Nevertheless, these figures show the marked increase in tlie number of ... - 377 - • . 6 individ~als born in "China" and India. . De.spite large number of British born who came to the Vancouver area in the postwa·r years, in relative - . ~ terms the number of British born reiiidents in_the metropolitan area has been going down steadily. The British born will nevertheless continue to be the numerically dominant immigrant group for the foreseeable future. The Sun's covera_ge of ethnic groups between 1967 and 1976 in no way reflected the population distribution of the Vancouver area. In rank order, Table CXIX give_s the frequency with which each of the general domestic ethnic categories were covered during the past ten ye,ars. ti J ' - 378 C Group number Native 192 20.2 French Canadian 189 19. 9 Black 106 11. 1 Asian 101 6. 9 Canadian American 64 Arab-Israeli 50 5. 3 Eastern European 47 4. 9 Western & Northern European 40 4. 2 Inuni.grant 32 3. 4 ttish 29 3. 0 Sou~rn European 12 1. 3 Hispano-Portuguese 8 o. 8 South African & Rhodesian White 8 o. 8 Colored 4 0.4 Australi,an & New Zealand 1 o. 1 Not Coded 2 Total · 951 Table CXIX. 100.0% Frequency of Ethnic Group Portrayal in Domestic News Items: Vancouver~ (1967-1976) Several important changes from past practice are readily evident. It should be r _e called that in the previous era Asians received the largest amount of cov~rage in both the Province and the Sun. . ~ . l- Collectively, they . have dropped to fourth.--p1ac.e. Coverage of native people has moved from being the sixth most frequently covered group in the Sun of the 1930' s to · the first; this ·shift is even more remarkable when one considers that the number of news items in the Sun samples of the two eras were 32 (in the 1930's) and 192 in the present--an increase of six times. The rise to - ,i;- ~rominence 01" French Canadians in the intervening ~orty years is even more startli_ng; previo\l,sly they received almost no coverage in the Sun whatsoever (8 items), while they now account for 20% of all domestic ethnic news items. The portrayal of British ethnicity correspondingly decreased (from 13. 8% to 3. 0% of the total items) as did that dealing with Eastern . Europeans (10. 4% down to 4. 9o/o). Southern European coverage also de- creased ("l. 3% previously to 1. 3% at present). Discussion of Canadian ethnicity has remained stable at around. 7. 0% of the domestic sample. The is sues involving ethnicity which intere ~ted the press continued to shift, as can be seen by comparing Tables CXX and CXXI with Tables· LXXlll through LXXV of the previous chapter. Even at this general level it is evident that the Sun has continued to moderate its position of ethnicity in two basic ways. On one hand, it has substantially increase·d its coverage of positive events involving ethnicity. for example, frequent coverage of ·; legal and legislative happening now more commonly involves ethnic groups agitating for their rights or the government moving to protect those rights. Like the category legal and legislative happening, items in the c'ategory .r \ - 380 ethnic relatiQns have also more than doubled in their 1:elative frequency of occurrence; while a ' considerable number of the news items classified under ·· ·-"- this broad topic continued to deal with inter-ethnic conflict, those which It p . . concerned more positive relations continued to increase. Likewise, topics which were usually stigmatic, such as "violence by ethnics" decreased sharply. As in both previous :. a number of the social and ecohomic concerns -~as of minority individuals and others continued _to receive scant coverage by the Sun. These include employment and economic activities, housing, education, health, and the provision of social services. The Sun nevertheless continued to concentrate its ethnic coverage in a few key areas. The eight most frequent topic areas accounted for 74. 4% of all the Sun's domestic coverage of ethnicity (see Table CXXI). News items coded with a topic of-either ethnic relations (n = 144) or legal and legislative affairs (n :;:: 222) together made up almost 40% of the sample. \\ I - 381 - Tot>ic number Housing 4 0.4 Education 15 1. 6 1. 1 Health and Welfare Employment and Econc;>my 22 2. 3 Population 4 0.4 Advocation of Restriction 22 2. 3 Ethnics are Restricted 13 1.4 Restrictions Charged 58 6. 1 Ethnic Relations 144 15. 1 Immigration 55 5.8 Legal and Legislative 222 23.3 Violence to Ethnics 27 2. 8 8. 3 Violence by Ethnics Cultural Differences 66 6. 9 Celebrities 9-1 9. 6 Sports 10 1. 1 Ethnic Organization 63 6. 6 Normal News .46 4.8 Total Table CXX. 951 • 100.0o/o Domestic Material by Topic: Vancouver Sun (1967-1976) - -- - 382 - Topic ( Legal and legislative nwnber _1L 222 23. 3 1 - 15. 1 Ethnic felations 144 Celebrities 91 Violence by ethnics 79 8. 3 Cultural differences T ~thnic organization 66 6. 9 '63 6.6 Restrictions charged 58 6. •l Immigration 55 ~ Total 708 74. 4% Table CXXI. Most Frequent Topics: Sun (1967-1976) ~ 9. 6 Domestic Stories in the Vancwuver The Domestic Moral Community of the Press {1967-1976) Two significant ob,servations can be made about the moral community generated by today's Sun. The first of these is that the Vancouver press-- at least to the extent tb..t the Sun is repre·sentative of it- -has continued to make strong evaluative distinctions between one ethnic and national group and another. This is evident in Table CXXll, which gives the moral com- munity scores for those domestic ethnic groups for which there were ten or . . more news items found. J 383 - Group Number Mora_l Community Score British 13 0.54 1 Chinese 29 o. 31 2 Jewish 29 0.28 3 Germa.,ns 13 d. 15 4 Native Indians 181 -0. 13 5 Russians 14 -0. 14 6 10 -0.20 7 24 -0. 21. 8 . Asians Anglo Canadians • Rank ., . South Asians 35 -0.40 9 Canadians 42 -0.52 10 I.nunigrants 32 -0.72 11 Doukhobors 15 -0.73 12 French 19 -0.89 13 French Canadians 189 -0. 97 14 . , Americans ')' • Black Americans 64 '-'0. 97 15 88 -1. 14 16 J i Table CXXII. -! ._. 7 The Domestic Moral Community: Vancouver~ (l967-1976) • Indeed, despite the frequent claim by member!! of Qle press that their r cov:erage of ethnic groups has become much less negative in recent year", these moral comznunity scores do not indicate that this is so. The measures used to create these scores .were no different than they ·were in ~ other ·-. . ... - 384 - eras whi_fh were considered, yet the scores themselve'S range across values which are very nearly the same as they were iJ:?- the 1930' s. To put it bluntly, the present day Sun is neither unbiased nor more kind in its coverage of ethnicity than it was previously. What has changed significantly has been the treatment of those ethnic groups which were heavily stigmatized by the Sun in th1 previous era. In , a' general sense the coverage of virtually all of these groups has become considerably better. This trend was most marked rt)" the case of the ' Chinese and native Indians, but was also significant for Germans and :All~aps. Even the portrayal of the Doukhobors was not as stigmatic as it was before. What runs counter to this p_ositive trend is that other groups have taken the place of those who were once so stigmatically portrayed. : . French Canadians, Americans, American Blacks, and the French, are the Asians of today's Sun. In addition, South Asians and Immigrants have maintainE!d their previous marginal statuses. .. The second observation about this ethnic hierarchy relates to the apparent randomness with whic:\l the groups are distributed throug,h it. Unlike previous e_ras, it should become· evident as the "'.'arious groups are discussed that th~ Sun has lost an overall philosophy of ethnicity that it once had. As will be seen, coverage of ethnicity itself has for the most part given way to the portrayal of events w.here ethnicity is of some consequence. The result has been that the moral worth of today's ethnic groups as evaluated by t h e ~ is primarily determined by the sort of event which that , - 385 ·.press chooses to associate with them. For some groups this has led to incorporation into th~ moral community. For others it has been their un- ..._ doing. The British ") With the termination of hostilities in Europe, immigration from Europe resumed _in earnest. preferred variety. As before, British im~rants were the From then . till now, the number of British immigrants to Canada has annually exceeded those of all other countries, with the exception of a brief period in the late 1950' s .. Approximately one million Britons came to Canada between 1946 and 19-66 and about 400,000 hav'e come subsequently (Kalbach 1974:7). While many of these new Canadians came to the Vancouver area, the growth of their numbers has not kept pace with other groups (particularly the Canadian born). Individuals born in the United Kingdom now make up about 9. 7% ef the po'p ulation of metropolitan Vancouver. While this percentage is considerably less than it was in •the . \ . past, the British continue to be the largest immigrant populati_o n in the area by far. In more visual terms, one out of every ten individuals in the Vancouver area was borl) in Britai'n• '-- ·. . ~... Considei:ing their nwnbers, Btitish immigrants were rarely seen in " the Sun. In the whole ten year sample only 25 news . items dealing with the ~ British in Canada were found--but 2. 6% of the total domestic sample. contrast, South Asians, who in 1971 constituted less than 1. 5% of the popu- ~ 8 lation of the metropolitan area, received 4. 2% of the total domestic coverage. • - ' _J - 386 - . I• . Tables CXXIII through CXV present the di~tribution of topics, subtopics, ~ and themes asao~iated with these news items. ~ nUlllber To2ics and Subto2ics • Health &: Welfare other 1 -., "'" 4. 0 Employment&: Economy are un~inployed , 2 8. 0 . Ethnic Relations relations are mediated relations are good 1 1 4.0 4.0 Immigration arrive • 1 1 4.0 4.0 Legislative &: Legal l~s limit laws protect l 1 4.0 4.0 Cultural Difference ha.ve different wor~ practices are loyal to home other 1 4 1 4.0 1,,.0'"\ 4.0 1 4.0 .4. 0 ,· -:-:.-, Celebrities entertainers politicians social notables - 1 8. 0 8. 0 2 z Sports 1 4.0 Ethnic Orfanizationa 1 . 4.0 1 1 4.0 ,.o 25 100. 0% b , Normal News victim of accident suicide or die Total ~ ... - Table CXXlll. -,. f ) ~ British Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver §.m!. (1967-1976) ~. ; '- "( . • - 387 ' munber • -1!... Cultural Difference 6 24.0 Celebrities 6 24.0 Normal News 2 28. 0 2 8. 0~ ; 2 8. 0 Topic Legislative & Legal l_mmigration - 2 • Ethnic Relations Employment & Economy Total Table CXXIV. J , -~a •.o 2 ~ 22 • 88. Oo/o I nwnber Cultural Difference 10. Celebrities 6 . Ethnic Relations 4 Victims of Crime Table CXXV. --<~. The Most Frequent Topics of British Domestic News Items: Vancouver Sun (1967-1976) l Theme - -- -----· 3 ·i M9st Common Themes in Domestic British Newe Items: Vancou-Yer Sun (i967-1976) In most respect ■ , the port-ryal oI the British by t h e ~ followed lines set down by the press far earlier. selective and very positive. As"before, this coverage was extr~ely .., Of all grou~, the Bri~sh garnered the highest ~ moral co~unity score (0. 54). Despite the many Br.itons who· came .:to ·1,.. 4 Canada during the past ten years. British immtgration was not new.s; only two news item~ in the sample dealt with this subject. · The first of these . ~ "t J was a letter to the editor ("Britons Aren't Favor~d. . -:... 11 August 8. 1974, page . .. ,,. 5) which asserted that the British we-re not getting any more benefits in Canada thaJ! were "their Commonwealth rights. 11 The other was an ex- ; tremely positive account of how British-miners had ben°efitted by immi- grating to the ~ast Kootenay region of.British Columbia. ~--- The British were not definitionally included by the press in the o:qgoin_g saga of immigration- . a saga about which the press had a great deal to say with respect to other groups. According to the Sun, there were no deportees and no illegal. British immigrants; as before, British imm~grants were an invisible press minority. T_his invisibility carried over into virtually all aspects of B .ritisb immigrant We. This can be no better illustrated than by noting that in the whole ten year sample the British were not onc1 associated_ with criminal activities, Qad cultural dilterence~ ~ poor e.thnic relations. Instead, the British were frequently associated with a narrow range of positively portrayed "British institutions;" this,. too, was nothing ·new in the Vancouver pres•, but it is of some interest that s_uch practices persisted into an era when most people in the V~ncouver era were no longer of that tradition. The. key institqtion·of this sort was the monarchy. Royal activities wer• continually in the news, especially when members of the royal family were in Canada ("A Visit by Their Queen," July 15, 1970, page 5). Moreover, the UJOnarch was frequently the topic of letters to ther . ' , -389 , editor ("M;onarchy Y___,ery Canadian," March 15, 1971, page 6; "Keep Queen," February 16, 1968, page 5; "Monarch Useful," May JO, 1970, page 5). CriticiAns of the Queen ("Her Majesty ·spoke with Forked Tongue", , September 7, 1974, page 5) or of ~e monarchy ("Queen Made a Pawn," February 20, 1976, page 5), were rather rare. Moreover, even the slight- est indication of press discourtesy or disrespect to the Queen was quickly noted ("Tasteless Story on Queen," May 27, 1972, page 5.) In certain respects what little coverage there was on the British indicated that the press continued _to maintain a double standard by which·the British and other immigrants were to be judged; what was 'bad' for other immigrants was often 'good' if done by the British. The most conspicuous exarnple of this was the ~ • s continual practice of associating the British (positively) with loyalty to their home country. The British continued to be portrayed as people who were pr,oud of their heritage and who actively tried 9 to keep that heritage alive in Canada. lf associated with other groups, I r • such a ~racteristic would very often be portraye~ as being traditionalistic and an impediment to assimilation. ,, As before, the Sun continued to maintain total silence on British i.nunigrant deviance. There were no stories portraying. British immigrants as criminals, and only one item referred to unemployment and British irrunigrants. As portrayed by the press, the British immigrant had no deviant practices and posed no consequential problems for Canadian society. They were not a burden on social services, they never imposed their ways - 390 - on others, and they never had trouble getting ·along. Instead, the 11 British Are Magnificent" (April 7, 1974, page 4),, for wherev«:r they go they bring with them "British Justice" (August 3, 1967, page 5) . . This _image of British justice, orderliness,. and fair play ·carried over - into the Sun's foreign coverage of the British. ""~ The great majority of the items in the sample were about events in Britain itself (23 out,of 27). While a nmnber of these items dealt with social problems, notably the state of the economy and the situation in Northern Ireland, throughout conviction was expressed that British perseverance would win out. In Northern Ireland the Sun portrayed the conflict primarily as one between order and anarchy, symbolized by the ~ritish troops and the Irish, respectively. Even Britain's E:COnomic woes were attributed primarily by the temporary triwnph of disorder and mismanagement over the natural state of things. The Chinese · In 194 7 the Oriental Exclusion Act was finally repealed, ending twenty five years during ~hich Chinese immigr~tion was completely banned. Nevertheless, Chinese immigration continued to be restricted throughout the 1 1950 s. Although the Chinese population of Vancouver doubled between 1951 and 1961, large scale Chinese immigration di? not resume once more until the racial and national restrictions were removed from the inunigration statutes in the mid-1960's. Between 1961 and 1971 the Chinese population of Vancouver doubled once more to 30,640. lO probably have doubled again. By 1981, the figure will - 391 - This renewed immigration has greatly increased the heterogeneity of the Chinese community. Most earlier Chinese immigrants were from the same part of China, were of the same class background, and experience.d similar socioeconomic conditions here. After 1960 Hong Kong, Singapore and Taiwan beca111e important sources of Chinese immigrants. The selection criteria for today's immigrants have also generated great heterogeneity in the educational and occu'pational experience of recent Chinese immigrants. ,, In addition, Chinese people are no longer constrained to live in the Chinatown area. They enjoy formal equality under the law, which they have translated into practical access to rights and privileges cumparable to many other Canadians. Con"sidering the great sensitivity which the Vancouver pr~ss has always shown to Chinese inunigration, one would have expected that renewed Chinese immigration in the 1960' s would have produced a simultaneous increase in press coverage of the Chinese. Actll:ally, the rate that the Sun published items dealing with local Chinese decreased by more than 50% compared w~th the period 1928-1937. There were only 29 domestic news items on Chinese found in the ten years sample of the Suri. This meagre total represented but 3. 0% of the local items on ethnicity found in the Sun. Tables CXXVI through CXXVlll summarize the coverage of Chinese during this era. Even a superficial comparison between Table CXXVI and Table LXXXI of the previous Chapter will show that Chinese newspaper coverage - 392 - Topics and Subtopics m.unber % Nwn.bers are a given number 1 3.4 Are Restricted are denied ethnic ways 1 Ethnic Relations relations get better do not get along 1 1 1 3.4 3.4 3.4 Immigration immigration is large enter illegally 1 2 3. 4 6. 9 Legislative & Legal laws limit prate st to gave rnment discuss restriction of 1 1 2 3.4 3.4 6. 9 Violence, Hostility Against are assaulted or harassed are victims of crime 1 1 3.4 3.4 Violence, Hostility By cause crime to increase are violent 1 1 3.4 Celebrities 2 6. 9 Sports participate in sports other 1 1 3.4 3. 4 / 3. 4 3.4 Ethnic Organizations organization takes role celebrate holidays 5 17. 2 2 6. 9 "Norm.al News makes good suicide or die 1 1 3. 4 3.4 29 100. 0o/o Total Table CXXVI. Chinese Domestic News Coverage- by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver §.ya_ (1967-1976) - 393 - Topic nwnber Ethni~ Organizations 7 24. 1 Legislative & Legal 4 13. 6 Immigration 3 10.2 Ethnic Relations 3 10.2 Total 17 58. 1% Table CXXVII. The Most Frequent Topics of Chinese Domestic News Items: Vancouver §.!al (1967-1976) Theme number Cultural Difference 15 Legislative · & Legal 9 Ethnic Organizations 5 Normal News 4 Yia:le.Dc:.v, Hostility By 4 Immigration · 4 Ethnic Relations 4 Celebrities 4 Table CXXVIIl. Most Common Themes in Domestic Chinese Vancouver~ (1967-1976) Na& Items: - 394 - has changed its character fundamentally fr<;>m the 1930' s. In both of the earlier periods considered in this study the Chinese were unambiguously defined as moral outcastes·. T~ey were constantly associated with crime and other evil activities to the virtual exclusion of all others an~ they were frequently the object of press attacks. These tendencies have ·greatly weakened in the past ten years. · Although an occasional a.rticle has appeared in the Sun on the Chinese and drug smuggling ("Heroin Trade Linked to Chinese Seamen," June 27, . 1972, page 8),. the Chinese are no longer associated with crime as fre- . quently as they once were. Interpersonal ~ioience between one Chinese and another has ceased to be a press issue save in a few articles on the sins of ' \ .. Chinatown: THE STRUGGLE FOR POWER IN CHINA TOWN Community Upset by Clash of Maoists and Nationalists (February 27, 1973, page 6) CHIN.A TOWN GANGS APPROACHING CRISIS (October 24, 1973, page 52) Despite the fact that Chinese inunigration was given far more attention by the Sun than was British immigration, the Sun of the last decade has d . . 11 not di rec tl y ta k en a s ta n against it. As will be discussed at further length in the subsequent section on South Asians, the Sun is presently far from sympathetic to Asian immigration, but it has contained its attacks to 'those of different cultures' and no longer frequently mentions Asian groups - 395 - by name. The ~ has also begun to give Chinese a small measure of social recognition. For example it has partially incorporated the Chinese into the natural and historical landscape of British Columbia by linking their past with that of another important element of British Columbia's history--the CPR. Although the Sun has much improved its historical view of the 1 Chinese over what it once was, to give the Chinese credit for builcµng th~ , 1 CPR is to grossly distort the relationl!lhip between the Chinese and others in British Columbia's past: REDRESS OF ANCIENT WRONGS IN PNE SALUTE TO CHINESE / (August 18, 1967; page 29) The Chinese did far more than help to build a railroad. Moreover, white British Columbians did more than watch them build it. Although the Sun has begun to incorporate the Chinese into the Vancouver moral community, the price seems to be the loss of any understanding of that group in the history of British \~lumbia. In other areas there have also been important changes, most of ~ch have also served to mitigate what wal!I once a very bad press image. ~ now gives The Chinese organizations, cultural events, and celebrities greater attention than pz-eviously, and has also begun to recognize Chinatown area residents as a significant political force. Although the Chinese remain one of the groups most frequently linked to cultural difference on the - 396 - .... local scene (see Table CXXVill), the tenor of the Sun items dealing with 19uch differences has changed; cultural difference was once used by the press to argue that Chinese themselves were the social problem, today the Chinese have problems stemming from culture difference which need corrective action. This is an important change. In the 1930' s the sort of action suggested was the subordination and exclusion of. the Chinese. Since today Chinese cultur«; difference rather than the Chinese are defined as the problem, the Sun's solutions to the "problems" are considerably less drastic. It is tempting to argue that at least part of this mitigation of Chinese press portrayal has been due to the much improved international image of China, but there is little in the coverage of either the local Chinese or of 12 Chinese in the Republic of China which directly supports such a position. Without a doubt, the Sun's coverage of China has also much improved over what it was before the War. In contrast to moat countries in Asia, t h e ~ has grudgingly granted China the fact that it has developed order in a 13 country once wracked by chaos, fed the people, and given them jobs. The J a.pane se The relative stability which Japanese Canadians in British Columbia had achieved by the end of the 1930' s waa completely disrupted by their forced relocation away from the coast during World War II. In essence, the total Japanese population of Vancouver, aliens and citizens alike, were removed and their property was sold. Many never returned. Even though - 397 - ' Japanese citizens were once more allowed to immigrate to Canada in the 1950' s, post-war Japan~se inunigration has never been extensive. In addition, most of these new immigrants have gone to Ontario rather than British Columbia. The 1971 census listed only 5,045 people of Japanese . . "d . V . ·ty 14 or1g1n res1 ent 1n ancouver c1 . This figure has not increased drama- tically in the intervening years. The Japanese were once one of the most prominently _port~ayed ethnic groups in Vancouver's newspapers. inconsequential. Today their coverage 'is absolutely The~ were only 8 items on local Japanese found in the ten year sample of the Sun. Such a small number does not allow them to be dealt with in any detail and it suffices to say that these news items all dealt with topics like cultural festivities, social'notables, and ethnic organizations. Similarly, there were ocly four foreign stories on the Japanese. It is not difficult to account for this lack of coverage. Since the · traumatic events of the Second World War the Japanese in Vancouver have, kept a very low profile. They have made virtually no attempts to assert their cultural identities except privately and in public ethnic celebrations. Without the racial caste line to constrain them as it did in the past, they have economically and to a large extent socially merged with the general population. Canada. Most Japanese Canadians of today have been born and raised in They are not immigrants, and as such are not open to critique in the ways which immigrants so often are. anyone as a social problem. In no r~spect are they defined by Having lost that problematic aspect they have 398 vanhhed from the newspaper~.:' , • a' South Asians Since 1947, the many legal restrictions which were earlier enacted against South Asi~I?,s have been eliminated. Legal South Asian residents of . Canada were formally granted t_he franchise in the late 1940' s, and in the . ~:"' ' 1950's and early 1960's, overseas South Asians were given greater access to the Canadian immigration system. As for, the Chinese, the culmination of these changes was the Immigration Act of 1967, which eliminated ethnicity, nationality, and race as criteria for immigrant selection. South Asian ,immigration subsequently increased with great rapidity, such that at present approximately 10% of each year's immigrants are of South Asian . origin. Many of these new immigrants have come to Vancouver, where they currently number about 50,000 in an urban population of over one million. South Asians who come to Canada today must pass through a set of fairly rigorous selection procedures which insure that most of them are skilled, educated and resourceful. 0 At the same time t};tey come from a very wide range of national, ethnic, and religious backgrounds. Whereas most earller immigrants were Sikhs, many East African (Gujarati) Hindus and lsmailli Moslems, Pakistanis, Fijians, Punjabi Hindus, and Sri Lankans have also come to Vancouver in the last ten years, as have" fewer individuals of many other backgrounds. This new wave of South Asian immigratio:Q. has not gone unnoticed by :I - 399 tJie Vancouver press. During the past ten years an article dealing with local South A!~ns has appeared on the averA-ge in one out of every six issues of the Sun. On the domestic scene o~Y French Canadians, native Indians, Blac}s Americans, Americans, and Canadians now receive more frequent coverage than do South Asians. Inasmuch as the coding rules of this study did not consider items where ethnicity could be inferred from the name of individuals, the frequency of South Asian news items was actually quite a bit more than this. • Tab'les ,CXXIX, CXXX, azta'Ups far better treatment. The press moral community continµes to be a stratified one, where South Asians (with a ~ moral community score of -0. 40) do considerably worse than the British (0. 54), the Chinese (O. 31), or Native Indians (-0. 13). worse than any other immigrant group. Their coverage was Table CXXXll shows that the differences between attributes found in South Asian news items and British ones is still very substantial: - 407 - South◄-~• British Ethnic rela\ions .r;· 6 E:hnic orga~izations 15 3 Cultural difference 14 16 Legislative & ·1egal 13 4 Immigration 9 3 Crime, violence to 9 4 Normal news 9 4 Claim restriction 8 1 Celebrities 7 12 Crime, violence by 6 1l Advocation of restriction 4 1 Numbers 4 Employment & economy 4 Housing 4 Health & welfare 3 Education 1 Are restricted 1 Sports 0 Attributes 1 1 ., Table CXXll. Major Attributes of South Asians and British in the Vancouver 16 ~ (1967-1976) - 408 - 17 Americans· Even though liberalization of the immigration regulations in the 1960' s allowed people of many developing countries access to Canadian immigration, the primary beneficiaries of this process continue to be the British, Western Europeans, and Atnericans. American immigration has been very strong since World War II, even though it has in no way compensated for Canada's enormous loss of people to the United States. The 1971 census listed 25, 685 American born as living in the Vancouver . ~etropolitan a::-~hey made u~ about 8. 9% of the region's foreign born population- -within one percentage point of what it has been since 1931. There have been several_ir:nportant issue-s which involved A~icans --- -- in Canada during the last ten years. ' In certain sectors of the economy there were loud objections voiced to American immigration. This was most marked in reference to academic employment and the hiring of Americans for top mari,a.gement positions in Canadian corporations. While this debate often was placed into a framework of the threat of '½.mericanization" of Canadian institutions, the primary problems seemed to be personal and economic; Cana7"in these occupations have been restricted from emi- gration to the Ul)ited States by the latter country's present immigration laws. At the same time they have had to compete with Americans who have access to both job markets. The other primary issue was very closely related--that of the takeover of Canadian businesses by American corporations. This concern was • - 409 - factually justified, for during the 1960' s and early 1970' s an enormous amount of American ca.pita! flowed into Canada, with the consequence that a substantial majority of Canadian businesses are now directly under the control of American parent corporations (Clement 1975:101). This worry over the Americanization of the economy merged imperceptibly into that of cultural and social Americanization, a~d together they generated a renewed "search for a Canadian identity" and a degree of antipathy to certain things associated with Americans. As can be .seen in Tables CXXXIII, CXXXIV, and CXXXV, coverage of Americans in the Sun was quite extensive. It accounted for 6. 7% of the domestic items collected during this ten year period. In many respects, the way in which the Sun portrayed Americans reflected the issues of the day. By far, the most frequent issue associated with Americans in the Sun was that of American involvement in the economy. A minimum of 35. 4% of the sample brought up this question, either as a subtopic or a theme. This figure is very conservative, for it does not include those items on Canadian-American relations or legislative and legal topics which stemmed from this question but did not mention it prominently enough to warrant being coded under the topic of empl9yment and the economy. Through accident or de sign, the Sun was far from neutral in its coverage of American investment in Canada. It was not that the Sun attacked American participation in the economy editorially; there were only two editorials found which touched upon American ~conomic involvement, and - - 410 - number % Education other 1 1. 6 Health & Welfare cost services 1 1. 6 Employment-& Economy seek jobs cause unemployment are unemployed buy or own property 1 2 1 1 1. 6 3. 1 1.6 1. 6 Numbers are increasing 1 1. 6 Advocation of Restriction should deny services 1 1 1.6 1. 6 Are Restricted are denied rights 1 1. 6 Restriction Charged 1 1. 6 Ethnic Relations relations mediated by others relations get better relations get worse have outside support impose their ways anti-American investment 1 1 1 2 1 10 1. 6 1. 6 1. 6 3. 1 1. 6 3. 1 15. 6 Immigration too much immigration is large are deported 2 3 2 4.7 3 4.7 1 1. 6 3 4.7 1 1. 6 1. 6 Topics and Subtopics Legislative & Legal politicians urge restriction laws limit laws protect Violence, Hostility Against are dealt with harshly 2 i 3. 1 3. 1 . - '111 - number Violence, Hostility By assault, harass others meet imposition with force a:r;e accused of crime other Cultural Difference have different morals Canadianne s s urged l Celebrities politicians Sports sports controversy other . Normal News victim of accident makes good Total Table CXXIII. 1 1 1. 6 1. 6 3 4.7 1 1. 6 1 2 1. 6 3. 1 3 4.7 1 1 1. 6 1. 6 3 1 4.7 1. 6 64 100.0% American Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Sun (1967-1976) • 19- ' _, nwnber % Ethnic llelations 18 28. 8 Immigration 7 11. 2 Legislative & Legal 6 9. 6 Violence, Hostility By 6 9. 6 Employment & E ~onomy 5 8. 0 Human lntere st 4 ~ Total 46 73~6% Topic Table CXXXIV. • The Most Frequent Topics of American Domestic News Items: Vancouver Sun (1967-1976) Theme number Ethnic Relations 43 Legislative & Legal 14 Cultural Difference 9 Employment·& Economy 7 Immigration 7 Violence, Hostility By 7 Table CXXXV. Most Common Themes in Dome,stic American News Items: Vancouver~ (1967-1976) \ \ - 413 - they did so secondarily ("Americans and Trudeau, page 4; "Time and Reader's Digest Issue, 11 11 December 22, 1975, February 5, 1976, page 4). Likewise, only two letters to the editor attacked American control over_ the Canadian economy. Still, the Sun consistently printed far more news items critical of American business activity in Canada than those giving opposing views. About 15% of the \merican sa~p~e ~ere items decrying the American takeover of the economy at the level of subtopics, and it figured as a theme ,in 11% more. By way of contrast, !!.2. items primarily supportive of American investment were found, although this sentiment was expressed as a theme in 9. 4% of the sample. . It should be noted that mo st of the items on this subject did not actually de scribe the takeover of specific Canadian businesses by American interests. This type of article w~s surprisingly rare except in the business section of the Sun, where it i s inevitably framed in economic terms rather . than in socio-political ones. . Items in the first pages of the newspapers almost inevitably were seconda_ry com'mentaries which dealt with the pron:~~cements of governm~nt, academics, and influential citizen/'Thus~ the intensity with which the subject was covered was largely a function of the · 'availability of "prepackaged" opinion about it, and as such it bore little relationship to the aatual takeover ~ocesi; or the structure of American economic control over Canada. Important documents like the Watkins Report got extensive coverage, even long after its publication; yet newspaper cover- age of the process of economic takeover was insufficient to give a reader the - 414 - ~~- 18 material with which to un<;Ier stand the' debate. · The Sun portrayed American corporations .and the United States (Y' government aSj the main problems in this dispute. Nevertheless, it was • l equally evident that the Sun did not completely disassociate this discussion ' l.rom other ways which it saw in Americans ~the United States constituting ~ • a problem for Canada. . . . h. h ( 1·nk d One of the most frequently found of these topics w 1c were 1 e to American control over Canadian business was that of A_m~rican immigration. Items ~oded under subtopics relating to American immigration accounted for about 20% of the sample. American immigrants to Canada we.~e par- trayed as generating two somewhat different proble'his. 'I.he mo st saliep.t one was the claim that Americans were taking jo~:s a~a:y fro{rl qualified , , Canadians, thereby-e:using unemploymertt and further subjecting Canada to American culturat domination. ' The predominant concern of the p".ress was with rather elite positions, notably those in_ Canadian ~iversities: AMERICANIZATION AT WATERLOO HIT (Aug-ust 1, 1969, page 1) TORONTO'S A HAVEN FOR ELITE FROM U.S. (Dece~ber 14, 1970, page 29) ,~ NO A~RICANs· AT SIMON FRASER UNIVER~TY . (May 1, .. 1969, page 4)· .... AMERICANS GET UBC POSTS (September 28, 1971, page 13) • . f j. 415 - Items such as these stressed both the economic and the cultural conse- .. quences:of' _this "Ame~ican takeofer o~ the universities." There were far fewer items in the Sun about Americ~ inun,igrants taking -jobs in those secto•s of the economy where Canadian workers had I..,. . fewer ways of ma:king themselves heard. \ '-..._ this phenomenon as if it were only✓ 9perat,ing at elite le~els. ~~.. "Now U. S~ 'Ill Pilots Th~eaten U~" (April 10, 1973, page 5) with unemployment in the - ' • s ,- airline industry, yet si.znilar threats in' 'bth~r ~ccupations went unvoiced. There_ was also considerable worry that .American i.Jnmigraqts· (legal . ' ' or otherwise}"were unjustly exploiting social services in Canada .. This is· obviously a new press attribute for the American who was for so lqng . . . .,, considered to be the imn;-iig.rant • ¥!- excellence. In:actuality, the press did not make the polar switch in opinion .tbout American immigrants that might be suggested-by the preyalence of such iterh-s. press image. of 11 . _In an overall se~se, the 11 nor:inal Americ.an immigrants r-emained good, to the extent that they were covered at all; like the British, American immigrants had considerable i~munity ag.ain3t press coverage. 1,9 , • I Instead, the principal focus of press concern over Ame-ri.can immi- gration was on the immigration of young people, espec:ially draft dodgers, . . ~~.. ~ . , deserters, and hippie~. 'I; - Even though there was. considerable sympathy . . shown to those who left'°"the United State.s for_ Canada because of 'the Vietnam • War, this press sympathy. did not always extend to.~ndividual Americans once they were here. Paradoxically, Canad.a• s acceptance (?f the~ pe·ople • ' .. . , ....,_ - 416 - was portrayed in a fashion which reflected negatively on the United States . \ government's harsh treatment of them) yet those who c:ame ..often got as b_ad press as did hippies: • r BORDER JUMPERS GET COMMUNE GRANTS (June 29, 1971 , page 1) 0 U.S. F REELOADERS IN OUR HOSPITALS (October· 13, 1971,· page 16) .: CAR DRIVEN BY AMERICANS 1WAR ARSENAL' ---.: · (April ?, 1968, page 7) POLICE ON U. S. DESERTERS TIT FOR '.I' AT, SAYS SHARPE (December 1; 1970, page 7) The Sun also ambiguously trec1;ted the otjler prunary i_~_sue· surround- ' ing Americans in the press--the relationship be~een Canadian nationalism, Canadian identity, Americans, and the Unite~ States. On one hand, the press reported (though it did not editorially support) the rise of a <;anadian reaction to American culture which occurred in the later 1960' s: CANADA SOL Y,ING GREATEST PROB LEM U.S. Influence Being Shaken, Pe.arson Say a in Interview · (May 2, 1968, page 1) ... > At the same time the ~ itself gave no evidence, that it ~a• making -attempt• to be aiaything but a fu.P participant in exten4ing the Ameri_c_a"'n worldview into Can:ada. Perhaps to ,a gr~ater extent than ever before, the .,. • • - 417 . . ' §un depended on A:merican sources. for its news of ~oreign affairs.. The Sun's. heavy use of UPI, AP, 'and copy received from American newspapers . . ;.',1 I and "White House _s:orrespondents," made the pap~r dependent on those _ source,s for making decisions about what constituted news and what was not. -· Ms:>i:eover, these news collection agencies tend~d to select and edit news in . relationsliip _to its principal consumers--the United States media. Conse- _ . ' ' quently; most .of the ~ P Y printed in the Sun came with a prepackaged worldview--a worldview which at bet1t reflected the concerns and interests of media personnel in th~ United States. Similarly, the Sun continued in its tradition of not making a distinc\ "' tion between the United States and Canada when covering American in• dividuais. ' For instance, Jimmy Carter was always labelled "President Jimmy Carter" rather than "U.S. President Jimmy Carter." The Sun likewise failed to portray the United States c'ongress, politicians, and celebrities as b~ing in a different co.untry. Most news items on No_r th American events found-in 'the Sun could just as easily have been in any of the larger American dailies~ In a similar fashion,· events occurring in the . United StatJes w~re very _rarely portrayed as if they were happening in a . . f~~gn country. . ' While this FY seem like a smallish point, it becomes m&ir'e significant when o~.cbnsiders that what was news in the United States ")~ .) _._ . : wa;;,.t~o Jargely det~:~d by United States inter~_fts and not by the Sun. This dependency which t h e ~ allowed itself to have on United States source~ of news largely explains th~ extensive coverage which the Sun gave to Black - 418 - Americans over the past ten years. Black Americans The decade 1967-1976 will assuTed.ly stand as one of the most important in the history of Black Americans. The civil rights pr~ests of the previous ten years led to a fundamental change in the attitude of the United States Federal Government towards its Black citizens. Earlier it had . found it politically expedient to allow the question of Black econoz:nic, social, and political equality to be decided by the various states--and the state governments were entirely controlled by white males. Only in the later 1950' s did the combined forces of Black revolt and the Federal government· begin to break down the racial barriers which Black people had endured for ' generations. , The 1960' s was the decade of the urban riot. They were not race riots in the classical sense of the term, for they were not primarily battles between Whites and Blacks. Nevertheless, they were riots about race. Most of the large scale 'civil disturbances' of this period were ignited because of reports of racial injustice, and they wer.e certainly fueled by similar feelings (Report of the National Adriaory Commission on Civil Disorders 1968). By 1970 Black people in the United States were beginning to make tangible political and economic .gains. • ~. ~-.,,;.. While the relative standard of living of Blacks in 1970 was still far lower than that of Whites, an increasing number of Blacke were able to rise to social or political prominence. Blacks appeared on the national political scene, in the entertainment media, and in - 419 - the arts. Considering that Blacks constitute sometlibrg--on the order of 12% of the United States popula_tion, ~tis not hard to understand why the United State.s newspapers co've.red them extensively, especially in the light of how important the successful resolution of their subordinate position was to the • future of the United States. What is more difficult to explain is the fas- cination which the ~ had for these people, 'particularly in the light:ol ·the ... ~. kind and quality of the coV'erage associated with them. Of the entire domestic sample of news items in this period, 8. 2% was devoted td news written on Black Americans. Only native Indians (n = 192) and French Canadians (n = 189) were more extensively covered. / As can be seen in Tables CXXXVI, CXXXVII and CXXXVlll, the Sun's interest in Black Americans was extremely selective. When they were vfo1ent, criminally inclined, or otherwise deviant they were far more likely to appear in the Sun than when they were not. _So one sided was this por- tra:yal that of all ethnic and national groups who received an appreciable amount of coverage during the last decade, Black Americans received the worst coverage; their moral community score (-1. 14) was the lowest of any. Both the score and the type of coverage which it represented were more representative of the past practices of Vancouver newspapers than they were of the 1960's and 1970's. . . The fu!a. focused in particular upon the violent and the confrontational. About 30% of the Black American sample was coded with a subtopic of this - 420 - number % Health & Welfare are on welfare 1 1. 1 Charge Restriction clairri job restriction claim rights barred 3 1 1 3.4 1. 1 1. 1 2 2. 3 1. 1 1. 1 3.4 1. 1 1. 1 2.2 Topics and Subtopics Ethnic Relations relations are mediated relatiom! get bette :c relation"i, get worse relations are goo~ relations are- bad do not get along Legislative & Legal politician urge restriction laws limit laws protect are in court other ·. ' 1 1 3 1 1 2 1 3 5 1 1. 1 3.4 4.5 5. 5 · 1. 1 . Violence, Hostility Against are assaulted 5 5. 5 Violence, Hostility By violence by assault, harass others assault each other demonstrations, riots meet imposition with force are accused of crime 1 4 2 17 1 3 1. 1 4.4 2.2 18. 7 1. 1 3. 3 Celebrities epfertainers politiciahs !Je:tia.l notables historical notables 3 1 5 1 2 3.4 1. 1 5.7 1. 1 • 2. 3 · Ethnic Organizations organizations are sinister 4 • 3 3.4 • ! ... - 421 number Normal News victim of accident make good suicide or die Total Table CXXXVI. % . 1 1. 1 ·s s. 7 2 2. 2· 88 100.0% Black .American Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Sun ( 196 7 -197 6) number % Violence, Hostility By 28 30.8 Legislative & Legal 15 16. 5 Celebrities 12 14.4 Ethnic Relations .11 12. 1 8 ~ 76 92.6% Topic Normal News Total Table, CXXXVII. The Most Frequent Tppics of Black American Domestic News Items: Vancouver~ (1967-1976) - 422 , Ii Theme number V~olence, Hostility By 57 Violence, Hostility Again st 22 Ethnic Relations 22 Charge Restriction 18 Legislative &: Legal 12 Cultural Difference 6 _Normal News 6 ~~ Table CXXXVlll. Most Common Themes in Domestic Black American News Items: Vancouver Sun (1967-1976) \ - 423 - sort, and as Table CXXXVlll indicates, themes of violence and confrontation by far outnumbered all others. 18. 7% of all news items on Black Americans in the Sun portrayed their participation in riots or demonstrations. Blacks. This subtopic was by far the one most frequently associated with The ~ 1 s coverage of these events had two basic themes. The first of these concerned the role which Blacks were shown to be playing in these riots and demonstrations. Were the}' victims or victimizers, rioters or revolutionaries? For the mo st part, the Sun portrayed Black Americans • as the instigators of violence and disorder, thus indirectly making them responsible,for the situation and its consequences. Blacks rioted and the police restored order; Blacks conspired while Whites planned. Bl~t:k Americans were five times more frequently portrayed as the instigators of violence than as its victims. Black Americans in the Sun were disorderly, dangerous, and impatient to achieve equality with others: TOLL OF VIOLENCE FILLS FBI REPORT (January 2, 1970, page 8) NEGRO CONSPIRACY CHARGED (May 17, 1968, page 29) RACIAL TENSION CLOSES SCHOOL (April 2, 1968, page 20) THE PANTHERS Black Cats are Reaching for their Guns Because Whitey's Driving Them to It. (November 15, 1969, page 6) ,,.., . - 424 - rn·a general sense, Black Americans were blamed for the situation in which they were in. To be certain, the ~ never suggested that Blacks were directly responsible' for their disadvantaged socioeconomic status. But at the same time, in those articles having to do with civil disturbance-s consideration of the root causes of Black p~>Verty, political impotence, and I' frustration fell before the immediacy of the event. As always, the Sun~~ " a strong stand against any sort of violent action perpetrated by this mino-t7 group, and its disapproval of the event in hand consistently removed from discussion the u.nde r"iying causes of it. In this way the coverage of Black American violence and confrontation in the past decade closely resembles that accorded to Asian crime and violence at the tu:rn of the century. Black Americans in the press functioned to 'explain' much of the disorder and conflict in United States society. 1 Th~ second use 1 to which Blacks were put by the Sun was more specifically Canadian. Only about 8% of the news items on Black Americans were derived from Canadian sources (see Table CXXXIX). Neverthel1', these items typically argued that Black-White relations in the U.S. ufus~ trated the difference between the U.S. and Canada; such things as racial confrontatj.on could never happen in such an enlightened country as this. For instance, in the previously mentioned editorial 'The Panthers," the Sun editor's enthusiasm to tar the United States with the brush of racism forced him into the position of supporting part of what the Black Panthers stood fo'r-- something the paper never did on the front pages. Similarly, in "Cause of l- - 425 - Disorders in U.S., Living Conditions Partially Responsible" (August 3, 1967, page 19), the Sun directly compared the standard of living of Blacks in the United States with that of Canadians, and in the difference found the "cause" of the U.S.' s racial problems. In "Pinning the Rap for Riots Popular American Pastime'' (August 3, 1967, page 8), the Sun's Washington D. C. correspondent pontificated in a similar fashion. - In making such a distinction between ethnic and race relations in Canada and the, United States the Sun thus gave support to a Canadian belief that is as widespread as it is unsupportable--that ethnic and racial discord in the United States was a particularly American disease that was never prevalent in Canada. Insights to the contrary could have been easily collected from the Sun's own behavior in past decades. As in most other issues the Sun's perspective on ethnic relations has no past. It is only a thing of the pre sent. Why was the Sun's coverage as negativ~. as it was? Clearly part of this bad press can be accdunted for k?y the utter dependency which the Sun had on American news agencies to provide ihformation about Black Americans: .. • -· 426 - Source Number Percentage Local 4 4.5 Canadian 3 3.4 American 79 89.8 British (Cartwm) l 1. l Other l 1. l 88 100.0% Total Table CXXXIX. The Source of News lte..ms on Black American9': Vancouver Sun (1967-1976) Nevertheless, this information dependency ~lone was insufficient to have determined that thl Sun's portrayal of Black Americans wcruid be so stigmatic. While it is true that the overwhelming proportion of the news items which the ~ printed about these peopi.e came directly from American news services, the Sun nevertheless had to select these items out of the far greater number that were available. The volume of information which is generated by these news services is so gr~at tha.t the n~wspaper s must still ; make continual choices about what to print. Moreover, a quick perusal of one of the large American dailies who are similarly. dependent on the news . service I for information will confirm that the ~ was actively selecting out " f ~ items on crime, protest, and violence to the excl~sion of more normal affairs. There is empirical support for this comparison. In the wake of the massive urban riots of the 1960's the United States government struck a National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders to look into the causes of .- '\.... - 427 - the riots and ·to suggest ways in which they might be avoi~d. One aspect o{ their inquiry was to look into the role of the media in covering these I ' Jiots. , Their content analysis of the subject (1968: 364) found that the m<;>st . . frequent topic of news items was !!£1. the riots themselves, but discussion 1 of legislative anti other means by which riots could be prevented. This ,;as definitely not the case for the Smi, where legal and legislative matters were only seconparily presented. So also were news items which dealt with Blacks successfully 9vercoming the barriers of racial segregation. In order for Black American achievements to make the Sun they had to either be about a Black celebrity or deal with some important event like a court judgment or governmental policy statement. By far, items on celebrities were the most common; such stories make up 13. 6% of the sample. By in large, these stories were all of the same form--"Black Gets High Position": U.S. NEGRO WINS GENERAL'S STAR (September 16, 1968, page 1) BLACK OFFICER NAMED POLICE HEAD (September 9, 1972, page 10) NEGRO GETS HIGH ATTICA PRISON JOB · (Octc;,ber 28, 1971: page 53) The~• s coverage of Black Americans illustrates the degree to • which what j.s news in the Vancouver newspapers has been disassociated from the immediate concerns of local readers. Black America~s are quite • - 428 - ' irrelevant to the everyday world of most readers of today's ~ - There are very few Black Americans in Vancouver, and• ,few Vancouverites have much to do with places where Black Americans live. I am not suggesting that because these events .occur on the other side of the border that they should not be newsworthy in Canada. Nevertheless, Black Am,ericans were more frequently f~und i~}he pages of the Sun than were any Canadian group, save for French Canadians and native Indians. Moreover, this biased and extensive coverage of Bl~ck-White confrontation . in the United States must nave some important consequences ~r how Canadians view ethnic relatiops. ~ . Black Americans were so constantly 1 ' associated with social problems that this must have placed psychological and social liabilities on Black individuals in Canada. It must also have affected Canadians' views about the desirability of non- White iminigration. ( Native People i The 1960 ' s marked a significant change in the relationship between native people and the Canadian government. At be st, the government's prior • rble had been one of a paternalistic caretaker of native people who had been deprived of most of their land and who did not have the r~sources what little of it remained. to utilize On the whole, native people had very little power to affect their own festinies, yet the government which controlled so much bf their lives assigned a low priority to its stewardship. Native people in British Columbia only succumbed to this system in the 1930' s. The earlier history of government-Indian relations in British j " ' • - 429 - J Columbia was distinct from that .in the rest of the Canadian provinces in several important ways. ?".lative demands for land rights in British ... ..,--:. Columbia developed well before Confederation, and led to conflicts betwe~n native pepple, the provin~ial government, and the federal government •. These conflicts lasted well into the 1930' s and are still not resolved i>(' . (Drucker 19-74). Likewise, native people in British Columbia were par..: '. tially protected from the excesses of re serve life by the ongoing and shifting dispute ~ ·the province and the federal government over who had responsibility for what in. the Indian administration. • Moreover, native ... people in British ~olumbia were afforded some protection against white ,· domination by geographical isolation and by their early entry into the cash economy. Still, the depression fo·rced a great many native people out of the cf_Jh economy, and they correspondingly became more dependent on the '\ g6vernment. They were unable to regain their place in the economy after the war. Two factors were to lead to a reyolution in the government-Indian • relations in the 1960' s. one hand, native groups generated a number of effective spokespersons for the1 and they developed the in2'ti- tutional means to make their complaints more widely known. The public_ relatiol\s sophistication of British Columbia native groups presently far exceeds that of most immigrapt groups. Using the media as their public platform, these leaders put increasing pressure on government to address the sorry state of Indian affairs. J J \. ,;·.l t 'r - 430 - On,the other hand. government policy and practice were changing, partially in reaction to native criticism and partially as a reflection of internal bureaucratic •djustments to the postwar welfare state philosophy. Although the most evident changes were to come in the 1960' s, this process was well along somewhat earlier. For example,- between 1951 and 1961 federal funds designated for Indian education grew from 7. 4 million dopars annually to 27. 7 million (Dc>Sman 1972:26). As early as l 960 mast bands had elected councils, who had an increasing input ·into Indian Affairs pro-· grams. During Lester Pearson's government and Pierre Trude3i9'-s first term . the philosophy of government's role in native affairs was signifi~antly altered. Se_veral widely-publicize4 reports on the living conditio~s of , Canaqa's native people had severAy criticized the government's handling of . , the matter (Hawthorn 1966), such that a major revamping of the bureaucracy was necessary. Henceforth, the government began to recognize the validity of allowing native people to control more aspects of the Tarious assistance program ■ aimed at native people. For the first time, ~overnment .began to ac_cept the principle tlat th~se programs were compensatory 'rights rather than welfare. In the practical sense, the economic boom of the 1960' s and early 1970' • allowed an the ■ e program ■ • d.mou■ growth in the .~ange and availability of De ■pite ongoing miamamgement, some of the money and service ■ which the government has m.ade gotten to Dative people. a:Jahle to the ■ e prograina has • ,. - 431 - In spite of a growing s_ense of legitimacy, native ·people in British Colwnbia remain se'l/erely disadvantaged with respect to the rest' of the population. Th~y are economically w9rse off than any, other segment of the population. _- "-·· Although the restrictive 'provincial ·1aws are now gone, British .Columbia native ~ople still must contend with prpfound prejudice and discrin:unation. No other group, inside or outside of Canada~ received more extensive - coverage in the Vancouver Sun during the past ten years than did native people. There were 192 iteins on na~e people in the Sun sample, which I - represented 20. 2% of all domestic items. -:Th~se figures are sharply up from the 1930' s both absolutely and relatively. De.spite the identical sample size used in the period 1928-19 37, only 32 items on ~ative people were foundl,./ in th~ Sun; these 32 items constituted only 7. 2% of the domestic news items collected during that ten year period. ( 1 As can be seen in Tables CXXXX through CXXXXI4 the Sun covers native affairs in a far different fashion than it did in the 1930' s. Previously: the Sun's portrayal of native ·people had been quite harsh, such that its (1928-1937) moral community score for native Indians of -1. 34 was worse . than any other groups except-.for the Doukhobors. community score for native Indians is -0. 13. 2~ Presently, the moral Native people have been brought into the moral community of the press. Considering ~at native people in the United States were continually in die public eye during the 1960 s and 1970's, it is somewhat surprising the 1 " , 432 - number % Housing. cause n~ighborhoods to go ethnic are denied housing other ~ 1 1 1 0.5 0.5 0.5 Education need special education are educationally disadvantaged other 1 1 1 0.5 o. 5 0.5 3 1. ~ 0.5 Topics and Subtopics ' \, __ Health & Welfare health is poor want health & welfare services ~ 1 Employment & Economy are unskilled are unemployed own or buy property 1 1 1 0.5 0.5 Advocation of Restriction . .1 o. 5 Are Restricted 1 o. 5 Charge Restriction · claim job restriction claim bar reg. from social services claim institutional barrier claim barred from rights claim no ethnic ways barred other 6 3. 1 1. 6 ' o. 5 3 1 o. 5 2 3 2 1. '0 1. 6 1.0 0.5 1 ~ .' ., > Ethnic Relations try to better relations relations mediated have bad police relations relations get better relations get worse relations are good are· assimilatible have outside help do not get along ~ 3 1 1.6 0.5 1.6 0;5 0.5 0~5 1.0 3 1 1 1 2 o.s 1 1 0.5 - C ... - 433 number o/o 1 0.5 5 5 2. 6 2. 6 4.2 14. 6 4.7 6. 3 7. 3 Immigration arrive Legislative & Legal politicians urge restriction laws limit behavior laws protect behavior are in court go to government to prate st J other 8 28 9 12 14 Violenc-e, Hostility Aga"inst are assaulted, harassed are dealt with harshly are dealt with leniently 2 5 2 1 1 Violence, Hostility By assault each other demonstrations are accused of crime 2 1 1 Cultural Difference require special practice are unas similatible are ~s similatible other· 0.5 1.0 0.5 o. 5 o. 5 8 1 1 4. 2 · o. 5 o. 5 10 1 5.2 o. 5 1 2 1 0.5 1.0 1. 6 o. 5 o. 5 192 ·100. 0o/o 1 Celebrities politicians social notables historical notables T~ble CXXXX~ 1.. 0 2. 6 1. 0 0.5 1 2 3 - Total ~ 10 3 Normal News victim of accident make good suicide or die other ~_, i, 1. 0 1. 6 1. 0 o. 5 5.2 2 Ethnic Organizations , organize in the· community organize concerts, etc. ( l Native Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Sun (1967-1976) . -. ' ;; ~ r ' . - 434 - number ' ·o/o 81 42.3 18 9. 3 Charge Restriction 18 q9_ 3 Ethnic Relations 14 7. 2 Celebrities 11 s. 7 Ethnic Organizations 11 ...2..:..1.. 153 70. 2% Topic Legislative & Legal Cultural Difference Total Table CXXXXL - The Most Frequent Topics of Native Domestic News It¢m~: Vancouver Sun (1967-1976) Theme number Legislative & Legal 126 Ethnic Relations 47 - Cultural Difference 39 - Charge ,Re strictiori 36 Violence, Hostility Against 23 Violence, Hostility By 23 Employment & Economy 16 .., Table CXXXXIL I Moat Common Themes in Domestic Native News Items: Vancouver~ (1967-1976) - 435 - great majority of events concerning native people which t h e ~ carried occurred in Canada: Number Percentage British Columbia 94 49. 0 Canada 79 41. 1 United States _ll :,. 9 Total 192 100.0 Table CXXXXIll. The Geographical Locality of Events Occurring in Items on N_ative People: V..ancouver ~ ( 19671976) Locality -:--- Moreover, only 9. 4% of the items in the sample derived from foreign sources. In short, the Sun was primarily concerne'd with Canadian native people, and the above moral community code is therefore a reflection of changes in the Canadian press image of Ca:Qadian native people. Coverage of native Indians has changed in several ways. '"' Perhaps the most important of these has been a decided shift in what topics t h e ~ considers to be newsworthy when they involve native people. The earlier stereotypic associations of native people in the §.Y!!. were that they were culturally different, violent. criminal, and drunk. They also had poor re- _ lat:ions with others and they were portrayed to be primarily victims of their ... own inability to assimilate with the larger society. Today, the ~ • s prim.ary focus is upon a range of legal and legislative happenings concerning native rights and privile.ge.•~ These presently acqount. for 42. 30/o of the sample of the level of subtopic·a; and themes in this area - 436 outnumber~those under any other topic area by at least three to one. These news ~terns concerned topics which were quite different in emphasis than those of the past. For one thing, in the past ten years native people have been portrayed as active participants in trying to get native living conditions changed. 6. 9% of the items showed native people charging that they were in - one way or another discriminated against. Another 7. 3% were of native people going to the government to protest. In addition, many of the items which involved discussion of laws and regulations pertaining to native peopl~ (18. 8%) also portrayed native individuals as acting on their own behalf. 5. 2% more portrayed native people organizing in their various cqmmunities. This activist aspect of native people's coverage was alto- gether absent earlier. It is equally important to note that the way that the Sun portrayed native people and the law gave far more legitimacy to their cause than was the case of earlier newspapers. In both of the eras which have been pre- viously considered native people were more frequently portrayed as being • subject to the law; they were before the court on criminal charges or else the means were being discussed Et_ others about how laws regarding native I people might be changed. Today's Sun allows for the possibility that some of the laws and regulations pertaining to nati'Ye people may well be wrong, and does not automatically stigniatize native people for protesting against the law or attempting to get the laws changed. Nevertheless, t h e ~ is not always consistent in th.is, for it still continues to print articles about some . - 437 - native protests which characterize the participants as being obstinate, stubborn, and irrational. 21 In this, the Sun seems to reflect the more general difficulty which many people have about deciding what rights are legitimately the heritage. of native people and which are not. Such decisions are not made solely on the bases of fact, for they involve very primary definition·s of society. Issues like land claims call attention to the fact that native people are autocthonous; they spring from .the land, while all o • r people in Canada do not. Hence, native people's very existence draws attention to the creation of this country by conquest and colonization. To say tha~ native people have rights which are different than those of other people is to acknowledge that otl,ier native rights were taken away previously, and it questions the privileges held by others. The Sun's somewhat inconsistent portrayal of native people, mostly sympathetic but sometimes unconscionably harsh, is a common response to this dilemma. Certain key topic areas common in the past continue to be extensively covered by the Sun, but the manner in which they are developed is quite different than it was earlier. For ins~nce, while cultural difference con- tinues to be a salient feature of the Sun's coverage of native people, the moral framework surroun~g these reported differences has changed substantially. Before, cultural difference was almost always portrayed in negative terms and it was often presented as a reason for native backwardness. Today, the Sun concentrates more on the positive, "multicultural" - 438 - aspects of native behavior and belief. To a certain extent the Sun has in- corporated the native people of British Columbia into the natural landscape, along with .the mountains and the sea. Native culture, particularly as it is represented by art and crafts, has become associated with the distinctiveness of British Columbia, and the Sun has given considerable support to this 22 perspective. Likewise, the proportion of news coverage which shows native people as. violent and criminal has gone sharply down relative to other types of coverage. At present these topics account for a very small pr<:>portion of all items, and the portrayal of native people as the victims of crime and violence is at least as frequent. Ethnic relations continues to b'e a principal aspect of the portrayal of native people, but the problem of native-white r~lations is no ~onger defined as· lying only on the Indian side; ·these problems are portrayed as mutual concerns to be resolved only by joint action. In a sinu.lar fashion, very little coverage is now given of immediate native social problems such as housing, education, social services, and employment; the primary 'problem orientation' of the Sun is now more abstract. - - In overview, the past seventy years of newspaper reporting on native peoples shows a n\Dllber of ways in which the press goes about incorporating a stigmatized group into the moral community. While these will be' dealt with more generally at the end of this chapter, it is useful to outline them here, insofar as they pertain to native people. Like other groups, the stigma which native people once had was com- --- •. 1. - 439 - posed of a rather coherent set of attributes. Native people were (1) crimina~ . . and violent, (2) more frequently the perpetrators of social deviancy and disorder than its victims and (3) were culturally different in ways which • were presumed to account for their position in society. MoreQver, (4) . ... J ,- their ~overage ~as largely such _that it isolated the situation of native people from larger social forces and (5) it rarely gave them the chancr to be por·trayed as acting in their own behalf. Similarly, (6) very little of their _· · normal everyday lives or their significant successes made the news. These ~ttributes seem to have changed together, which is reasonable in that they reflect a structured, constellation of meaning surrounding the term "native." Incorporation into the moral community for native people • and .others would seem to involve two phases. In the first of these the group is po_rtrayed as distinct from normal society, but these distinctiona are not bad; this is where native people now .sta_n d. As "good but different" people, the coverage of many of the deviant practices once associated with nati~e people in the newspapers have been severely restrictedi. They are 1,0 longer violent and contentious, save in the (orderly) defense of their rights. often they are portr"!-yed as victims rather than victimizers. they prey on each other. More No longer do As indicative of their good but different staµis, their relations with others has become more si_g nificant to the newspapers than it was earlier. Their extensive coverage is representative of the pro- . blematic nature of their transitional status from that of a stigmatized out group to being fully incorporated, into normal society. - 440 - It would seem that the final stage would be reached when the once stigmatized and subordinate group achieves both ide'ological acceptance and access to resources which are somewhat commensurate with those of others; for native people this phase is likely to be far in the future. Should they achueve this state they would cease to be a societal problem (at least in the narrow fashion which the press defines problems) and they will then vanish from the world of the newspapers as have the Japanese. Eastern Europeans: Doukhobors and Russians The establishment of a communist government in the Soviet Union eventually fed to the end of extensive outmigrat;i.on from Eastern Europe • • From the first, the Soviet government considered its people to be a national resource and saw emigration as a cowardly and treasonable act; emigration ' signified an abandonment of social responsibilities by those who left. The postwar governments of Poland, Czechoslovakia, Bulgaria and Romc!,nia, I developed similar policies with resp~ct to emigration. After World War II only Yugoslavia allowed a significant number Qf people to leave. The ex- ceptions to this rule occ,urred during civil unrest in Hunary and Czechoslovakia and resulted i~ a sudden outflow of individna.ls, a considerable ; · number of whom came to 'Caaada. While many Eastern Europeans came to Canada after World War n. most. of them did not g 23 were once more totally neglebted by the fu!!!,. In actuality, the ~ • s cove rage of Eastern Eur~peana wa a even more restricted thu that indicated by Table CXXXXIV for Doukhobors continued ,.. "- 442 - to be news only to the degi:-.~.~- Jhat they participated in unusual and specta- .. ' . '. .,. cular events. '~ Typical would be the ite~s "After Prison-Rampage Doukhobor Women to be Moved" (November 16, 1972, page 17) .and "Douk Leader Expected" (December 3i, 1968, page 2). · This sort of coverage was ,. nothing new, as was shown in the previous chapter. Nevertheless, one found an occasional defence of Doukhobors on the letters to the editor page that was not common earlier:. DOUKHOBORS MALIGNED (August 13, 1971, .. page 5) 1 DOUK 1 HEADLINE WAS REDNECK (November 24, . 1972, page 5) \. The former letter complained about the way that Doukhobors were portrayed -4. in a book of ethnic groups which was assembled to celebrate British Colurpbia' s centennial (Norris 1967). The latter complained about the un- fair manner in which the Sun portrayed Doukhobors. As Table CXXXXV indicates" the .§lm.' s coverage of R~ssians in Canada was very ~stinct from·that accorded to Doukhobors. less extremely restrictive in its own way. It was nonethe,- Russian Canadians were almost never mentioned in the Sun; instead,· most of the news items involved the.activities of Soviet citizens or their government in Canada. This coverage could be further divided into three types: items about political refugees from the Soviet Union, items on the travels Q.f illustrious Russians, and • those c·oncerned with Canadf.-Russia political relationa. , •. - 443 - (, Doukhobor · number o/o Topics and Subtopics ~ Russians number Education other 2 13. 3 Health&: Welfare ia poori· ' l 6.7 o/o C Employment &: -Economy are unemployed l 7 •. l Advocation of Restriction l 7. l Charge Restriction clai.In they are barred from other l 7. l Ethnic Relations relations get worse impose their ways r-.J ' l l 6. 7 6.7 ' I I l ) 6.7 / Legislative &· Legal laws protect are in court go to government to protest 2 l 13. 3 6.7 Violence,. Hostility By are accused of crime 2 13. 3 l 7. l l 3 7. l 21. 4 •· . - ,,,. - .. . Celebrities ! ; entertainers politicians social notables hi storical~ ,- notable a r,;;. . J 1 - ~ ) Ethnic Organizations organize 1 mmunity Total Table CXXXXV. ~ 1 J\ l Doukhot:. an.a Topics SI;. z 15 7. l -~ 4 7. 4 l ~• ~ 1 - '. • ., . "".,... Sports . -- ---sports controver ~y Normal News victim of acs,_cident 6.7 l 2 1 7. l 1 7. l 14 JOO. 0,, - 3 6. 7 . 100. Oo/w Russian Domesti~ News Coverage by Subtopics: Vancouver ·§!!!!. (1967-1976) • . · :. • . By far, ·the greatest number of r~fuge~s stories involved the place Because Jews were frequently the primary ethnicity inv ved these items ~.,were coded under Jews rathe~ t~~ Russians, but they"""\ explicitly co~tained opinions abQut Russians and the Soviet g o v e r ~ that it is justi- fiable to treat them here. Sto»ies dealing with Jews in th: t i e t Uni~n co~sistently pre sebted Rus'sians and the S9viet government in a v~_ry ·bad ,. Articles like "Religion. in . Russia" (November f'5, 1969, page 5) . . light. ~ claimed th.at the his~rical a~itude which_ Christianity in .Rus~i~ had towards~ Jews continued to the present; it w~s asserted that Jews were systematically· { I , • discriminated against by other Ru~sians in the search for jobs, education, poluical office, and social honor. The decision- of the Soviet government to _not allow the free ernigl'ation of Jews ~as portrayed as being anti-semetic ' 25 and indicative offoe totalita-rian nature of that government. Invidious . / . - . .: _____-/ d i a t i n c ~ e e n the restrictive emigration policy of ~e Soviet Union '-- and the West were continual; pre<:Uctably, "tae;Sun never sought to explain ~ \ w~y-the Sovi~t Unio_n · waa unwilling to ·let Jewa emigrate. , Neither did it give ~re than the ftiptest idea that in -this ,regar,d the. Sovi_et Um.€•~• no{ . - singling out .J ewa. - . 1 . -. '. ' """'-... . In actuality, whe_n the Soviet Union even~y -illowed a • .. \ i. nmnber of Jew• to emiarate they made a m.aaaive exception to ~ more 1eneral r u l e ~ baa not been accorded to ,any other group, but~• was Iii, . • • . ·· 0 , never rqoiied '1,y the -~ '. . . .:- . . . . ,,,,, . ~ Neither did- .tile !!!, comment on the fact that tho•e people who eventu. . '\ • ally left the Soviet Union were exactly those people whose class status would be the most improved by emigration--professionals, artists, musicians, and writers.• "Polish Atom Experts Defect in Purge Wake" (~pril 17·, 1968, page 1), and "Soviet Ballet Star, Wife get Exit Ok.ay" ....-<,.,;;.::;_ (June 8, 1974, page 7), but few less illustrious people left. In many respects the image of Russians which came out of these i items on Russian Jews expressed a particular view of a more general image of Russians which was inextricably tied up to the press' ideas about Communism. The Sun rarely made a distinction between Russians, Com- munists, Marxists, and the government of the Soviet Union, ~nd it was . suspicious of all of them. It had no sympathy whatever for the Soviet Union as a governmental entity. The "Soviets were (November 26, 1976, page 46). seen as 'New Nazis'" The Russians were porkayed as an ongoing -.:.t_hreat to the "free world" ("Russia's Pincer Movement," September 18, 1967, page 4). The Sun's coverage of this particular aspect of world events was extremely political. Individual Russia.us might be quite nic-.; person' ally, but ultimately they were the enemy, citizens of a country bent on the destruction of our way of life. This theme permeated virtually all the Sun's coverage of Ruaaians. Paradoxically, the~•• portrayal of the activities of Ruasian social . . and political notable• in Canada and the United States did not seem to be prejudiced by the extremely negative coverage accorded to Russians on the 8Ubjecta of Jewish emigration, i.Jnperialism, and the lack of freedom of - 446 dissent in the Soviet Union. The Sun rarely chose to attack visiting Soviet '> politicians, and adopted a practice of staying strictly away .from political questions when dealing with visiting performers and other celebrities. Germans'- Nazis, Jews, and Arabs . ; Bet)veen 1939 and 1945 Canadians and Germans fought on opposing sides in a major war. The Germans lost, il,Ild have continued to pay the ideological price of defeat up to the pre s~nt. Although both the domestic and foreign samples of German news items were small {13 and 16 respectively) concerns, stereotypes, and accusations stemming from World War II • was a fundamental aspect of them. The (dentification of Germans with Nazis continues to be pervasive and ongoing, despite the fact that the War is now thirty years past. 38 % of the domestic sample and 75% of the foreign news items on Germans specifically mentioned Nazis. On the domestic front this association of Germans with Nazis was less frequent than it was overseas, but it nevertheless was col'I}ffion. One of the many uses of Nazi ■ by the press was to m.ake an analogy between a present social or political practice and the stereotype of the National Socialist regime· in Germany~ For instance, the Sun editor claimed that "Alberta'• Sterilization Program was 'Like Nazi Germany'" {October 31, 1967, page 4). In this way "Nazi" was used by the press as a synonym for ~ b ~ , unfeeling, totalitarian, or racist, depending on the specific requirements ~f the tim~..,.. Other co1n1I10n items were rememerances of the War (from the.Allied perspective), none of which were particularly flattering to - 447 - · Germans'. For instance a tlDeutchland Tour" (April 19," 1967, page 5) had as an .objective _a_n under standing of the way that Nazis had dealt with Jewsduring the War •. Rarely did domestic press coverage make any attempt to ., separate out Ge.rman people. from Nazis.· >. • • Peopie of German ancestry in <;anada are now the largest "ethnic group 11 in Canada after the British and the French. The German origin population of Canadians always has been large, but it was significantly . raised by extensive German immigration between 1948 and 1968. The 1971 census listed 1,317,200 Canadians as being of German origin. Virtually none of these people made the pages of the Sun in any way in which their ethnicity was identified. Although the "P. M. Lauds 'Enrichment by Germans"(April 18, 1967, page 14), German Canadians rarely were as sociated with positive events or attributes. minority. They were another invisible The prime difference between the Germans and other groups who were systematically ignored by the press was that the ideological connection between Germans and Nazis must have reflected badly upon German Canadians even though they were not mentioned. Moreover, it has been my personal experience that German Canadians are extremely sensitive to these Nazi items; they see s\X:h stories as an indication that they are not fully accepted as Canadians. Coverage by the~ of Germans outsid~ of North America could not help but give further support to this conviction, for the great majority of it • concerned Nazis. Many were straight descriptive pieces about the activities - 448 - ' of Nazis during World War Two or thereafter: NAZIS GOT VATICAN AID FOR FLIGHT (May 30, 1970, page 14) GERMANS CJ.,EARED OF WAR CRIMES (June 27, 1972, page 1) GERMAN VOTERS UNHORSE THE BROw?-l SPOOK LEADER (May 30, 1971, page 4) N~~NAZI RISE DUE TO OTHER PARTIES' APATHY (May 2, 1968, page 6) ,. . GERMAN Cl-llEF CALLED NAZI (April 2, 1968, page 3) BUCHENWALD'S ILSE KOCH HANGS SELF (September 2, 1967, page 1) There were many more. There were several reason•· why the number of items on Jews in' creased dr~~tically.,aince the last period under consideration. The first ..... of these was"'\he -.etematic ge??,ocide of European Jews during World War II. r .. . 1nexthcably linked to. the Nazis, the Holocaust has not been forgotten by the Sun, and a n\Dllber of domestic items on Jews involve the topic in one way or another. larael. The aecond waa the eat.abliahment and expanaioa of the atate of Two full acale Arab-laraeli Wars occurred during the last ten years, \ ,; 449 - ,. ,. and together with reports of reciprocal terrorism between Israel apd the adjacent Arab states and coverage of the various "peace missions" this was one of the ~of h~~y covered issues of recent times . The third issue was that of Jews in the Soviet Union, as di!fcussed earlier. In addition, Jews in Canada and the United States Vl(ere rather frequently given press · coverage when involved in public celebrations, demonstrations, or performances. Despite these rather different types of issues, the coverage of Jews ~I' by the Sun was consGtently sympathetic to them. This can be seen in the typea of attributes and events _a ssociated with Jews outlined in Tables CXXXX\j1 to CXXXXVlll. The~ moral community score for Jews was 0. 28--one of the very highest of the last ten years. One oi the prim&ry roles of Jews i n ~ domestic stories was that of people protesting prejudice or restriction being placed upon them. 23. 8% of the domestic and 31. 6% of the foreign sample involved a topic which charged restriction. and it figured heavily at the level of the~es as well. For instance: JEWISH GROUPS SEEK TV SERIES BAN (re: the suggested assirnOation of Jews) (February 8. 1973. page 42) JEWS PROTEST IN CITY VIGIL (re: Vancouver mayor'• alleged slur on Jews) (December 29. 1970. page 12),.... "' · - 450 - • number % 3 1 1 10. 3 3. 4 3. 4 2 ~8 1 1 1 1 3.4 3.4 3.4 3.4 lrnmi.g ration , other l 3.4 Violence,. Hostility By assault, harass people l 3.4 l 3.4 3. 4 3.4 Topics and Subtopics Charge Restriction claim rights are barred claim they are not allowed ways other Ethnic Relations try to better relations relations are mediated unite with others impose their ways .• Cultural Difference different religion are loyal to home· other Celebrities politicians 3.4 3. 4 l 1 Ethnic Organizations celebrate festivals organize in the conununity organizations are sinister organize concert• other Normal News auicide or die 1 1 , • 2 3 1 1 1 6. 8 10. 2 3.4 3. 4 3. 4 1 - 3. 4 Total 29 100.0-,. Table CXXXXVL Jewish Domeatic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vagcouver ~ (1967-1976) ~ • • - 451 • nwnber Topic Ethnic Organizations 8 27.2 Charge Restriction 7. 23. 9 Ethnic Relations -4 13. 6 Cultural Difference 3 10.3 Celebrities 2 Total Table CXXXXVll. ~ • SL 8% . 24 The Most Frequent Topics of Jewish Domestic News• - ' Items: Vancouver Sun (1967-1976) f Theme • number ' Ethnic Relations 14 Cultural Difference 9 Charge Restriction 8 Violence, Hostility To 2 Violence, Hostility By 2 Legislative • Legal 2 Table CXXXXVlll. Mdat Common Theme• in Jewi ■ a~Dcaw.-b News Items: Vancouver §2 (1967-1976) - 452 - ~BS? OH, NO! -(re: · allowing Arabs to immigrate to Canada) (June 19, 1967, page 5) SNEER AIMED AT 'CHOSEN PEOPLE' (re: alleged prejudicial statements) $ (January 8, 1974, page 5) Over the past decade, Jews have been able to employ the newspapers as an effective vehicle to advance their interests. They have been able to. respond quickly and forcefully to a wide range of perceived restrictions and prejudicial statements about themselves in ways in which the press listens. The Sun itself has not beer:rrmmune to these charges, and has frequently printe_d objections to the way in which Jews have been portrayed by the S_un: RABBI DEPLORES RALLY COVERAGE (October 28, 1971, page 5) FURORE FOLLOWS ~mTORS' PRO-ARAB STAND (May 31, 1969, page 15) SATIRE FILTHY (in a previous Sun article) (March 1, 1969, page- 5) It is difficult to say with any certainty why Jews have been able to use the press in this way while other groups have not. Part of this ability must derive from the ■uperior organizational characteristics of Jewish copimunity infra ■ tructure. _Jewi ■h group ■ in Vancouver are organizationally structured to quickly re ■pond ~ prejudice and discrimination. Jews have al ■o be•n able to uae the attocitiea done againat others of their faith during ... - 453 W<1rld War II as a powerful legitimation for their present activities. The ~ frequently covers Jewish memorials and commentaries about the Holocaust, as in: . JEWS SAVED IN NAZI PURGE HONOR DANISH BENEFACTORS ~· (Octobe~ 1, 1968, p~ge 9) 1 I J~WS MOURN 14 HANGINGS (January 30, 1969, page 2) The Holocaust has been used to remind potential discriminators a! the consequences of their acts. It has also been used to argue for the continued Canadian and American support of the state of Israel: JUIXiE URGES SUPPORT OF PEOPLE OF ISRAEL (April lt:\, 1969, page 29) POLITICAL LEADER SAYS: ISRAEL NATION MUST FIGHT TO SUR VIVE (October 10, 1972, page 16) In addition, Jews wefe accorded more news items descriptive ol their culture and history than most other groups~ In this., people of Jewish faith made frequent use of the letters to the editor page to explain ffieinselve s to .,. others: JUDAISM: PAST SURVIVAL AND FtlTUIU: HOPES (December 9, 1972, page 52) . WHAT IT MEAN;i TO BE A JEW (December 29, 1970, page 6) - 454 - A TRADITION THAT ISN'T THERE (January 3, 1967, page 5) Jews were also given extensive coverage in their attempts to support Israel f1nancially: U.S. JEWS SEEK $100 MILLION (for Israel) (October 9, 1973, page 53) ' TORONTO FLOOR CLEANER GIVES LIFE SAVINGS TO AID ISRAEL (October 9, 1973, page 5) Arabs Arab ethnicity was almost never covered by the papers of the first two e~as considered in this study. With the rise of the state of Israel and the increasing importance of Arab oil to the western world, Arab coverage has increased dramatically, as Table CXXXXlX indicates: Number Domestic Items Foreign Items Newspaper Vancouver World 1905-1914 V.apcouver Province 1905-1914 3 Vancouver~ 1928-1937 4 Vancouver Province 1128-1937 2 4 Vpcouver ~ 1967-1976 9 59 Table CXXXXIX. ' The Fz:equency of Arab Coverage: All Eras This increaae baa actually been far greater than tl:a.at abown above, for there were technical coding difficulties which made it impossible to collect a representative sample of Arab stories. \ These problems centered around the difficulty in clistinguishing ethnicity from nationality in foreign news items. . There j:lre many international situations where the ev~nt turns upon the relationship between two countries; a war would be representative. In these cases (as for instance in the various Arab-Israeli wars), press coverage is totally inconsistent in its use of labels assigned to the disputants. In different items describing the same event the participants might be desc 'r ibed as Israel and Egypt, Israelis and Egyptians, or Jews and Arabs. Similar difficulties required that coverage of the fir st era terminate at the beginning of World War I and dictated that the Vietnam War _.,, be excluded from considerations. With respect to Arab -tove'rage, I believe '\ it to be a significant enough problem that no quantitative~ssessment of the attributes of Arab ethnicity is attempted here. Nevertheless, over a hundred news items relating to Arabs over the past ten years were collected during this study (counting those primarily involving Israelis), and they allow an impressionistic assessment of their structure to be made. By in large, Arabs have been badly treated by the Sun. ally, Ara~ have played the villain to Israel's hero. Internation- The coverage of events concerning both Arabs .uid Israelis has mutually defined each of their press identities. In this, their coverage reflects the same relationship as Asians and whites once did and which Anglo Canadians and the French have at, / present. The Israeli ■ have been con ■ i ■ tently portrayed by t h e ~ a-s· the . - 456 righteous defenders .of their native soil. ·, Arabs have .not. Rather, they ✓-~ have been continual_ly pictured as being sneaky and devious. · Word use in news items often gives' greater legitimacy to the Israelis than the! Ar~bs. • . F~r instance, the Israelis have an arrriy, while Arabs . have terroritt:s. · Items such as the following consistently placed right, • orde-r and morality on the aide of the Israelis: ARAB HATCHET MEN KILL 3 IN TERROR RAID Religious Settlehient in Israel Attacked (November 21, 1975, page 1) • . ISRAEL JETS BOMB ARAB GUERILLAS . (December 1, 1967, page 8) BERUIT RAIDERS RIDE IN RENTED CARS -.J " (April 10, 1973, page l) Similarly, Israelis were "competent" while Arabs were not. Arabs co\Jld not stabiJize their governments and nej.ther could they organize an efiective military. Israelis "made the desert bloom 11 while Arabs were "unable to feed the~r people. 11 Israelis were "democratic," while Arabs wer~ ''tyranical1' and "exploitive" of their own kind. ful" while Arabs were ''warlike" and ofienrive; 30. Israelis were "peace- 5" of the topics coded for the 59 foreian Arab items involved violence and conflict. .. . Similar attributes -.rose from coverage of Arabs which was not directly concerned with Israel. There were several nouveau riche items about the spendth~t and dec_adent habits of oil rich Arab leaders. which portrayed f . • ' , - 457 . these people ao if ~ey lacked concern with the futur~ of their countri~d peoples. This lack of concern over other people's welfare extended . W world, for the Sun was extremely critical of Arab manipulation <;>f the ' . international price· for oil, claiming that it was selfish, ··trrational, and short sighted. Just aij the portrayal of the Arab-Israel confli.c:t. was utterly . . !~eking historical and sociological background, so also was that of the ' . relationship between Arabs and oil. ln contrast to the extensive coverage of Arabs over seas, Canadians of Arab etlinic or national origins, were scarcely covered at all. Of the ni.al!l aomestic items coded under Arabs only two involved Arab Canadians. hnm.igrants Canada is an immigration country, in the sense that it is one of the few nations. which still accepts large nwnbers of imntlgTants. Immigration has been extensive since World War Il. · and its impact upon V~ncouver has \ been considerlable. ,. Nevertheleu, despite the frequently heard claim that -- '· "we are all irrun.igranta" moat Canadians have been born here. In Vancouver and the rest of Canada the Canadian born monopolize positions o! economic and political control. , Canadian ■ have always held a grudge against the im.m,igrant. lmm.i- gration policy has historically been decided upon from the top down, and common citizen■_ rarely have had a hand.ill its creation. today. This continues lmm.i_gration policy ia an inlposed policy,· one which has been pri- marily d•termined by criteria which are not identic·a1 with the i.ntere sh of -- 'l , - 458 all Canadians. • - - ~ It is not a policy which has been well explained' {o Canadians, and consequently both the policy and immigrants frequently provoke hostility and suspicion. This suspicion has tended to focus on cultural or racial minorities, b'1t all immigrants partake of it to some degree. We have seen that the Vancouver press has historically attacked and defamed immigrants.who it saw as culturally and racially different. For 0 the mo1t part it dld this in an_ overt mann~r, mentioning the "p roblematic" group- by name and directly associating it with a_ particular social problem. , This tendency ha-s been slo...-ly weakened, as a comparis.on of the coverage ~ A • ., '<:>! an:y ore gr~u~ tl(r"b~gh the three ~ras ~}early shows. Nevertheless, the Sun still .disapproves of cultural and racial diife renc~. In certain respects the abstract category "immigrants'' fulfills the sai\'ie function today that ' • specifically named groups did earlier. Tables CL ·through CLII outline the topics, subtopics and themes associated with domestic items on immigrants. ~Immigrants do net fare very well in today's fu!!!. '#b For one thing, imm1grants are portrayed almost exclusively in terms of one or another social problem. . Tney of course we re the representations of the "problem of ' immigration," and h~nce contributed directly to unemployment~ They ... created a burden on the educational system. Discussion of the law or of legal and legislative matters concerning imn:iigrants. was in.clu~ed in over . half the sample. < ~ Many of the Sun's news items on immigrants wire directly critical of them, especially in a collecti~e sense. T h e ~ was strongly . against the continuance of the high rate of i1;1-migration that continued . J • - 459 - number Topics and Subtopics % Education need special ·education are,_ educationally disadvantaged adjus't to -educational well other 1 1 1 1 3. 2 3. 1 3. 1 3. 1 Employment &c Economy cause unemployment own or buy property l 1 3. 1 · 3. 1 Advocation of Restriction advocate immigration be barred 2 6. 2 Immigration ·) too much immigrati9n s large discussion of laws protecting behavior discussion of laws limiting behavior protest to government discuss reports re immigration other 2 5 3 1 3 l 3 1 6. 3 15. 6 9. 4 3. 1 9. 3 3. l 9. 3 3. 1 Cultural Difference multiculturalism · ·2 Celebri tie<; politicians social notables 1 l 3 •. 1 3. l Ethnic Organizations organize in the community 1 3. 1 32 .,100. 0% ~ Total Table CL. • ., .r. Immigrant Domestic News Coveragt( by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Sun (1967-1976) ' I e--. '- .. . - -460 -... I Topic Immigration \ I I / ntnnber o/o 11 34. 1 24~8 Legislative & Legal , Education Tptal Table CLI. . 4 12.4 23 71. 3% The Most Frequent Topics of Domestic Immigrant News Items: Vancouver Sun (1967-1976) Theme number Legislative &: Legal l7 Economy &: Employment 10 Immigration 10 Cultural · Difference 7 . f Table CLII. Most Common Themes in Domestic Immigrant News Items: Vancouver~ (1967-1976) - throughout the era: ' 'STUPIDIST' GOVERNMENT URGED TO END IMMIGRATION (August 21, 1976, page P) NEW BILL TO CLAMP QUOTA LID ON IMMIGRATION QU0TAS (November 20, 1976, page 1) HIGH PRICE FOR IMMIGRATION (October 7, 1975, page 1) IMMIGRATION ASSAILED (October 7, 1975, page 2) RESTRICT IM MIGRATION (January 18, 1968, page 35) As least 31~ 1% of the news items on immigrants indicated that there were too many of them. No item claimed that there were too few. As was historically the case, the Sun continued to present a very narrow picture of the immigrant. -., ,, , • Stories ab\ut illegal _immigration were i frequent and were very harsh: ~ How Officers Use Power to Bar Entry or Okay It WHEN IMMIGRA:t-:lTS CONFRONT THE ENFORCERS (March 8, 1975, page 6) The above item spread its headline_ across a whole page, und~r which there was a page wide pen drawing of a sar ca~tically grinning policeman with his broken billy club in hand. The feature story itself took up the whole page ( l , .. 462 and dealt with the rc>le of immigration officers at the Vancouver International Airport anq at the White Rock b_skder t:!rossing. ' . ImmigTants were also frequently portrayed as subversives or frauds: Some Abuse Our Hospitality, Says St. Pierre TIGHTEN IMMIGRATION LAWS, GOV'T TOLD (February 26, 1972, page 3) INSTANT COMPUTER CONTROL OF "UNDESIRABLES" (March 8, 1975, page 6) IMMIGRANTS 'TARGET OF WELFARE INVESTIGATION (September 21, 1976, page 1) Although it was nowhere stated specifically, it was clear from the things that the Sun associated with immigrants that they were referring primarily to a rather small class of immigrants: those who were from places other than Europe or the United States. Many examples of this selective use of the word immigrant can be found. For instance, the letter to the editor "Only Russia -will be more Polyglot than C~nada" (August '1, · I 974, page 5) claimed that the liberalization of the immigratiqn laws in 196} had le-d to the immigration of many foreign cultures, whose presence would eventually ''change the face of Canada'i for the wo~se. It was clear that Asians were the intended referent, even though they were .not mentioned by · name. "Immigration Policy Blasted by Tory 11 (June 27, 19y2, page .J.f) attacke~e immigrati~n policy of the -~iberal government on the grounds that it was altering the British character of Canada. 'Some of the Sun's news items on im'migrants were overtly racist. ,,. ' , - 463 - .. Many of these in turn stemmed from a continuing series of c"lurpns by Sun writer Doug Collins, some of which have been-referred to in Appendix Ill. ,. 0 Commentary on Collins' articles was extensive on the 'letters to the editor £ ~ · page, and much of it was favbrable to hifll: -<:. WHY BE AFRAID TO BE LABELLED RACIST (June 23, 1975, page 5) ~ ~ COLLINS' VIEW .FULLY SUPPORTED ,. Collins' basic argument was base_d on the proposition ~ t rslda.l m~ing . , . inevitably l~ads to conflict, hence, colored immigration to Canada should be severely restricted. He also advanced supporting propositions that must have had wide appeal in British Columbiafthat the present national mix of the immigrant flow was destroying the British character of G:anc\-da and that . immigrants wit~arkeqly different c~ltural backgrounds (the ~ifference s were never specified) were an economic drain on Canada. I:Iis impact on ' immigrant groups has been substantial, for they have taken his sta:ements to be indicative of the Sun's . convictions; iI: some respect his statements also stand for what other Canadians think of immigrants. Collins' support among some elements in the population are such that I know of an instance where a person who wrote a letter to the editor opposing Collins re~ed hate 'mail,,,.from angry .reader's fs:,r weeks thereafter. To _,?e fair, it must be ~aid that not all of the Sun'. s coverage of immigrants was bad. On occasion tJhe Sun noted the particular successes · of • • • • . •. 464 - inµnigrants and there was art odd art(cle supportive qf the . principal of· .... . . . ' .~ /. 4P .. '··_ , ;. •_ multiculturalism. •, Nevertheless, the s,e items in no way compen~at_~dJor ,,, what wa~. gen·erally a stigmatic image of the -im:rn'igrant. · Black Africans . ) , .. With ,.r_egard t_o ·the news, dev,e loping .natiQPS. suffer two fundamental lia:bilities. For both e c onomic aud po1itical reasons they. are often unable to insure that their own news m~di~ accurately reflec~ national co~c'ern~: 27 At the same time, developing nations have Iittle · control over how they are· portrayed in the· _r'est of the· ...;orJ.~ . In an age of increasing .economic ancl . social interdependency this latter problem has become a very ,S'e_ri01.is one, . for the international ·image of a particular country is largely a - function of '\.,__.. . . . . . its media portrayaL Quite aside from c oncerns which the national govern- ment s of developing nations may have over the truth· value of their coverage, it is obvious that such portrayal can have immediate economic and political consequences. _A bad international image can lead to a·loss of foreign investment an4 de'{~lopment assistance , •a deter_ioratiot\ of tourism, and a weakening of intellectual and political ties with other countries. 28 .• In the postwar era, Airican countries have beep among the first to 29 1 . b . . t· realize the scope of t h is problem, for t h ey h ave f requent y ee_n _its v1c 1_ms. ' Nevertheless, they have been hampered in their attempts to deal with this issue because they are on the periphe~y of power. This has been com- pounded by a la.ck of con~r~e information about the press portrayal of Africa over seas. ., ;, .,.. - ) ' - 465· . / / / The worldview of Africa and its_'people·gep.era_ted by the m ·edia in the developed·world has .b _e ~n ,a pri1;1e concern. ,. ' • . ,. "r, - - .- - - What image of the Afri~an-• • ~ > '--(' • I ' ., nations :has be-en created? · What events and attributes have ·been associat'ed ' . . with itsp~~ple? · Wbat•irnpiicati:ons does this cov~rage hav.e,iio-r Africa? r " ' ' ~ . - • ~ . • ~ . , ' 11. ~ • e African people were not a significant element- of the news in the forty~... . J ,-.,.. years prior to World War II • . ·Between 1905 .and 1914, the two major dailies .•-.. . ~,,. of Vanc p _uvet were primarily concerhe<;i with eth_!licity and ethni~ rela_tiorf's , . ., . . in Canada,,.. the United States~ 'Europe;' and Asia. ' . on Afri ca found in the Province sample and 17 in the World. Most o{ t\o se f- . very few news items about Africa concerned events in th~ Near East, and a~ ,, s u ch are Afri c an only as· an· artifact of the coding process. Only three items 1n the Province sample and four in the World _had to do with Sub-Saharan It 'is Fir st of all , t,d.ifficult to account for this lack of interest in,African affair~. frica was simply not defined as a "problem, " as were other . 1 pos es s1ons . c o 1orua sue h •as I n di a. Africa was ,,, . 3o In 'Contrast to China and J ~pan , ot seen to have significant trade P?tential for Canadians, and . d · t 31 t hi s a 1so restricte 1 s coverage. Moreover, during this era the local press was primarily involved with ethnic relations in British Columbia• especially with respect to Chinese, Japanese , and ln_diafimmigration. If one considers the world distribut{on of news items in the Vancouver press during the p·eriod 1928-1937, Afritan items continue to be relatively, rare (Province, n = 14; Sun, n = 16). . The re were only_ 1-2 items Once· more, events in the Near East ,. - 4 66 ., ..,i • . _ • · .... . • . - ... - ' made up the bulk of the " ~frit::_ai;i ' ' items • .~ - . - : . , , 1£ 0 · , . . .' . . .._ 1'.here were but five items fo the , .,. _ .""' . Province dealing with black Africans and they all dectlt with violence by one., There we.r.~. no articles on black Africans in the . or .another "native " group. !; in' South Af:i~a, garnered two4rti~ie s i_n~-th~ Js~. one 'On sports 4 Sun. · ~hi~e ' and ~~other to do ~;th . a c.eleb,r,it. · .. . . -. '· ; . =. - ◄ 0 I Since the Second Worl<;l Wa.r, the people of Afi:,ica -h.ave bf€ome ·an- ,. " , ' . f Q, • • • ' importa'nt element of Vancouver' press portrayal. . Cover.a·ge of r _a ce 1 • . ethnicity, apd nationality in Afri c a now exteeds' tha,t of any other ·geo,. . . '~ .,, ~raphical area~outside of Canada. · Th~re were .~ 60 items in the Sun sample • Q.11 ~v ~ nts Q.·cc \i;rring in· Africa. ·;.. ., ., • Thi's a; c counted·Jo:r 17. 5% of the Sun's ~ove"rage o/. ethnicity. ,.. - The coverage of African people during this era has several important {--f characteristics. The most consistent theme throughout has been . one of ::: onfli c t. . Tfti s was usually expressed in -the context of violent ethnic or racial confronta~ion. Predictably, R~e.sia and South Afri c a figured pro- minently in the news of Afri c a: " Pr£rpary Group Involved number Bla c k Rhodesians or South Africans 33.6 28.8 White Rhodesians or South Afri c ans 34 Other' Afri c ans/ 57 • 137 100.0% Total Items on Sub-Saharan Africa Table CLlll. 41.6 The Primary Group mentioned in News Items Dealing with 3 Sub-Saharan Africa from ilie Vancouver Sun ( 1967-1976) ~ . ,, • - . . 467 - - ~ -., . ..... -•The way ir).wbi:ch z:ec'"ent ev~nts h~ve ·bee'n portray~d }~ Rb6tesia _a~d·litical control so 0 in either c~untry, J:1.o.r were the ,re· many_ news_ items which diJ'.'ectly \egitimated • . : . ' • either situatio~; the only exceptions ~ere a fll.w articles giving the opinions .!- C . ' ,I r . . 33 of visiting South African w}ij_te s on the roatter. The Sun's headline·s often . . . . . • presented white rule in So'u th Afric; and Rhodesia as oppressive, arbitrary.,_ ' and brutal: SOUTH AFRICA ACCUSED OF SEIZING 5,200 (September 21, 1976, page 3) PICTU~E STILL SORDID IN SOUTH AFRICA (January 21, 1976, page 5) SOUTH AF RICAN POLICE FACE TORTURE CHARGE ' (October 28, 1971, page 3) SLAVE-LIKE CONDITIONS CLAIMED (September 3, 1968, page 6) At the satne time, the Sun credited foreign news sources in aboµt 75% of its articles on Africa, and it tended to uncritically accept the pre.: packaged worldview which went with these sources. Leaving aside the degree to which they reflect reality, the international news collection services make available a torrent of information about certain types of African J r ,. affairs. -._ 468 .. Neverthele-ss,.,-Sun articles on race relations iri South Africa and Rhoc,lesia_ did 'not us,e this information to provide any so rt of e·conomi~, historical, so'Cio,logical, or politica~ persp·ective through.. whic;h the im- · ' ,aspect of each event bicame central,--athies_ of the press and public in Canada and the United States. Once more, the Sun relied extensively upon foreign news service copy and abstracted out of it the events and not th_e context. It thus tended to trivialize 36 the causes of the war as ,well as the motives of those engaged in it. 0 In order to express its support of Biafra the Sun used one of the oldest press interest-grabbers: ''Big Bad Bully Beats Brilliant Boy.·· In or_der to makf this th~-s-is a bit more plausible, the Sun portrayed the Ibo as identical with ' the Biafran revolutionaries, and·made them ·out to be the oppressed Puritans ,i ~, of ~Ve st Africa . . In one important respect it did not matter' that the Sun supported one side of this dispute~her than the-other. Regardless, the Nigerian civil · war served to give credence to a general image of Africans as people who were not yet capable of managing their own affairs. 1n the Nigerian case, they fought in a "Useless War" (editorial, October 1, 1969, page 7), which .was the result of the inability of both sides to transcend narrow tribal and . ,.. 471 - ,.., ethnic affiliations towards the greater good. Africans in the 'press were 'generally portrayed as being"incapable of follo~ng the rules of "civilii;d conduct" in situ:ations"of st-~ess, as if their• civ~ity was only a thin veneer covering brutal, uncontrolled instincts. To once more take the Nigerian civil war as an example, the fedel"al kovernment force<; '.were continually shown to be inhumane and insensitive to the plight of the Biafraos: ., NIGERIA REJECTS t:ALL FOR CEASEFIRE (August 16, 1968, page 1) , MALNUTRITION RIFE SAYS NIGERIA TEAM Ibo Being Wiped out (October 16, 1968, page 16) RELIEF PLANES RUN GAUNTLET TO BIAFRA Canadian Crew Makes Two Flights (October 31, 1968, page 1) BIAF RAN MOTHERS SO DAZED Children's Names Forgotten (February 14, 1969, page 6) This theme was brought to the fore in the Sun's very heavy handed . ::overage of 1di Amin. Of Amin,. the Sun created the ideal stereotype of the igr,orant ex- colonial who· does n~t know his place. . Canada a:::cepted several thousand South Asian refugees from Uganda ' in 1972 and 1973, which required that t h e ~ formulate its own position on' Amin before the world press was mu'iP interested in him. What was • j \ · generated was a picture of an arbitrary, racist, irra'tional leader who did not know what wa,s in the economic interest of his country and what was not. Neither the degree of popular support which he had in expelling South As.ians • nor any of the negative aspects of ~uth Asians in the Ugandan economy were ·considered. • ---.., From 1974 on, the Sun's coverage of Idi Amin has succumbed entirely to the image of him generatt!!d by the foreign news services. As such, , Amin was portrayed as being viciously mad, pure and simple. he be came a clown: In 'the Sun I 37 ID! AMIN EXECUTES REBELS (March 25, 1974, page 1) AMIN CLAIMS TO HAVE PLANS FOR ATTACK ON SOUTH AF RICA (July 27, 1975, page 37) AMIN SAYS HE'S FOND OF HITLER (April 23, 1975, page 40) . HEY IDl-BABY, WANNA BE A MOV~E STAR? (November 20, 1976, page 42) Amin' s coverage could not but reflect badly upon other African people. Amin' s excesses served as the perfect ·legitimation for the perpetuation of 4 I minority rule in Southern Africa--"look what happens when they take control too quickly." It abo provided an~ p9st facto rationale for colonializati~n, while at the same time it s~pported the thesis that the underdevelopment of ' - 473 Africa was its own fault; African p~ople did not know how to govern._themselves, hence, they were poor. I If anything, this was the essence ~f the press image of Africa and Africans. Africa was the continent of wild animals anl people: As a re - ?resentative of an African country one put it to me, the Canadian press 11 made Africans part of the "Wild K~ngdom, more part of nature than culture. The dramatic an·d violent aspects so routinely associated with African people in the press contributed to an image of a continezj)t ifl a constant I state of crisis; there was no peace~ .stability, or o r f in_ the Wild Kingdom. This view was made more believaple by the pr.eg;s ,~cination with the meetings and pronouncements of elites.. T h e ~ continually followed the • travels of Washington an'd London diplomats in Africa to.the exclusion of their African equivalents, to the extent tbat it appeared that these white 38 elites were responsible for what little order there was there. This same view of African people was given further support by what the Sun did not print about Africa. Items which dealt directly with the economies of African nations were virtually non-existent, leaving the readers without an insight into one of the most basic areas ne_cessary to an under3 standing of African affairs. 9 Neither was there m\J,.ch information about 1140 Africa which dealt with "normal events. Descriptive articles about African countries were notable in their absence. Indeed, most of the ' countries of Sub-Saharan Africa received absolutely no coverage whatsoever. Only those which were the scene of violent, la.rge scale conflict-- • ,. - 4 74 South Africa, Rhodesia, Nigeria, Uganda, Namibia and Angola--were ''news", and they we~e so only insofar as these types of violent events were noted by the press. Thus, even in a context as dens~ly covered as South Africa, the readers of the Sun would be ignorant of the low grade, oppressive violence of the· pass laws, and other racial restrictions, to say nothing ,/ (· of the more "normal" aspects of the everyday lives of the people, This sensitivity to the confrontational also made the Sun' incapable of reporting the sue ce s se s of African individuals or countries. .E::nsconced in the metropoles, such things were not sufficient to attract the collectors of . 41 news to Af r1ca. · A coun_try where people got along was not ne'ks, wnereas one whose people did not was, A high sustained economic growth rate simply did not have the newsworthiness of a famine or drought, Likewise the §El did not provide its public with positive imagel'of black leaders. With the exception of Idi Amin, the spokespersons of the liberation groups in Rhodesia, and an occasional mention of Joma Kenyatta, no other black leaders received significant attention by the Sun. In an overall sense, the Sun was primarily a vehicle for bad news about Africc:t', even when this was not its intention.· Like most large North American dailies, the Sun does not collect its own information about Africa . • f) -- Only large o;cale, confrontational issues in Africa attracted the attention of the metropole centered "international" news agen~ies, and up.on these the ~ was ultimately dependent for its definition of what was news. Moreover, format considerations, especially the length' of a "readable" article and the ,l ,. - 4 75 - demand for impossible. 11 1 today s news today 11 seemed to make developmental arguments Readers were rarely given more than a superficial account of who the players were,.and what the score was at presertt. It would not be over stating the ca.se to say that cove rage of African news events in the Sun and other North American newspapers ultimately has - - J nothing whatever to do with accurately portraying reality. Certainly, the· newspapers rarely achieve this objective, but that is not my-p~int. Instead, I would suggest that African affairs are so far from the concerns of local_ press personnel who know virtually nothing about Africa that what appears in print has been selected 'largely in terms of dramatic considerations rather than informational ones. I believe that the l, is broadly represefitative of the way in which most other North Ameri an newspapers cover Africa. Considering that these newspapers all ultimately depdnd upon the same sources, have similar financial and format constraints, are often part of the same larger media conglomerates, address the same type of audience, and have the same business goals this is not an unreasonable proposition. If this is so, it f wou1d have several important consequences for African countries and North American readers. It would mean that the newspapers serve to confirm stereotypical views of Africa which make it difficult for North Americans to be anything but indifferent to A_frican problems. At best, the press might ;.. elicit sympathy for Africans in certain situations of oppression, but only at the expense of forcing the event into an unrealistic paradigm of racial or - 4 76 ethnic rela:tions, with the consequent mystific.ation of historical, econ~mic,. social, and political factors underlying it. Canadifn,r As has been the case throughout the,twentieth century, most of the 1 potentiai readers 'of tod~y s Vancouver ne~spapers have been born in Canada. 42 Canadian. A great many of these people know no other affiliation but If anyone is representative of the normative resident of Vancouver it is they. Nevertheless, thfy are not alone in wishing to be considered Canadian. This label, which for so-long was restricted to people who were white, Protestant, and British, ) s no~ undergoing considerable modification in order to reflect Canada's changing ethnic and racial makeup. The tradi- tional definition of Canadian was one which considered both birth and right . ' action; it was not a status that was easily achievable by those people who were not of British birth. In this sense, being counted as a Canadian was an !.' ideological asset to those who had access to it. For British Canadians it rationalized their access to privileges which hyphenated Canadians could a spire to only with difficulty. Thus, the question of what constitutes a Canadian today is of considerably more significance than whether there is a "Canadian identity" or not. It is also a question of power and privilege, for the term will inevitably confer legitimacy upon those who are included under it at the expense of those who are not. - 477 - If hi story is the judge, the media will continue to play an important role in determfning the form which this definition of Canadian will take. Moreover, if the Sun is representative, the media will not be in the van- h guard ,of change on this issue. The Sun's use of the term Canadian during the past years is largely repr~sentative of an earlier time, even to the extent that its primary definitional attributes remain what it is presumably not- - ' • it is someone who is not American. There were only 42 items collected h)Om the Sun sample which primarily involved Cana·dians. This modest number represented 4. 4% of all domestic news items--about the same as were devoted to local South Asians. Tables CLIV through CLVI outline the topics, s~topics and themes associated with these news items. As can be seen, Canadians made the news largely in reaction to . Americans. Fully one-third (33. 3%) of the sample actually mentioned Americans and their relationship to Canadians; no other groups were associated with Canadians with any frequency. 43 No other group in the whole study had a higher proportion of its items involve another group. Having once said that Americans were so heavily involved in items on Canadians the topics d.ealt with are fairly predictable. Ethnic relations, which is to say Canadian-American relations. made up 24% of the sample. One-third of the sample dealt with the subject of American investment in the Canadian economy; following the same patterns t~at were found about how this topic was covered in the American samp{e, most (64. 2%) items were -....:. - 478 number Topics and Subtopics Education other 1 2.4 Employment & Economy 1 2.4 Advocation of Restriction advocate job re stri:ction jl.re denied ethnic ways 1 1 2.4 2.4 ..Are Restricted are barred from jobs 2 4. 8 . 1 2.4 1 1 1 2.4 4. 8 2. 4 2.4 4. 8 2.4 2.4 2.4 1 2.4 1 2.4 3 7. 2 2 1 4.8 2.4 1 2.4 I'·• ' Claim Restriction claim they are not allowed ways Ethnic Relations relations get better relations get worse relations are good relations are bad impose their ways : pro-American investment anti-American investment 2 1 1 2 1 Immigration should stay in Canada Legislative & Legal _ politicians urge restriction laws limit laws protect other Violence, Hostility Against other Cultural Difference different morals are unas•imilatible are loyal to home Canadianne s s urged 1 1 2 . 5 • 2.4 2.4 4.8 12. 0 - 479 - , number Celebrities politicians . social notables 4 11. 2 l 2.4 Sports 2 4.8 42 100.0% Total Table CLIV. Canadian Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: Vancouver Sun (1967-1976) Topic number % 10 24.0 9 2 iii. 6 Legislative & Legal 7 16. 8 Celebrities 5 12. 0 Total 31 74. 4% Ethnic Relations Cultural Difference Table~CLV. I The Most Frequent Topics of Ca~ian Domestic News Items: Vancouver Sun (1967-1976} nwnber Theme Ethnic Relations 21 Employment & Economy 9 Legislative & Legal 6 Violence, Hostility Against 4 Table CLVI. Most Common Themes in Domestic Canadian News Items: Vancouver Sun (1967-1976) ( - 480 - against increasing American involvement-in the economy. --.As it did in the 1930' s, the Sun continued to strongly support a Canadian nationalism, albeit of a fairly narrow variety. The Sun had earlier attempted to define Canadianness as separate from British. For the most part, the Sun p-re:sent]y attempts to distinguish Canadians from . Americans. For instance, the Sun frequently (19% of the sample) urged Canadians to greater nationalism, in each case to the end of " protecting them" from be.ing culturally or economically submerged by the United States . • Because of its fascination with the topic of Canada and the ,United - States, the S:in tended to severely neglect the q;-1estion of what it meant to be.._,. Canadian within Canada. In its concern to differentiate Canadians from Americans it tended to use those elements of the traditional view which for > so long were the opes in which only some Canadians participated--the British heritage in Canada. ' Almost never did items in the Sun discuss Canadianne s s and ethnicity, save for an occasional worry about- extensive 44 non-British immigration upsetting British traditions. ·Similarly, the.Sun gave its readers very little indication of the heterogeneity of the Canadian populati~n in those .items dealing with Canadians. French Canadians were almost never included under the definition without being further distinguished as being French. Whenever- the Sun presented instances of Canadian traditions, these were uhi~ormly British ones; they were rarely· French and never 'ethnic. I In many practical respects the Sun ... cur·rently uaes the terms Canadian as synqnymous with the cqmmon meaning . - 481 - of "Anglo Canadian. " It should be added that the Sun of today has given somewhat more extensive coverage to Canadians overseas than the Vancouver newspapers did in earlier times. At present about 3. 7% of the overseas sample directly . involved Canadians (n = 20). m one of two ways. Basically, Canadians overseas made the news A number of these items involved Canadians who were acting as political or military intermediaries in international conflict situations such as South Africa or Cyprus. These sort of positively por- . trayed role" for Canadians over shadowed all o::_rpects of Canada's . foreign policy. l The other way Canadians overseas were news is when some tragedy befell them, such as being accused of crime, being assaulted, or being in an accident. ·There was virtually no coverage at all of Canadian business activities overseas. • French Canadians, the French, and Anglo Canadians Th.e two labels "French Canadian" and "Anglo Canadian" are intimate ly intertwined with each other, and to treat them as entirely separate categories would inevitably distort their meaning. _,,.,,,.,, This is particularly so with respect to their portrayal in the Vancouver press, where one was usu1 ally found in association with the other. be addressed together here. As such, the two categories will For the same reason, domestic coverage of the continental French is also included in this section. French-English relations have always been one of the most important . factors on the Canadian political scene. Nevertheless, the recognition of _ • 482 • their importance in English speaking Canada through time has been extremely variable, For thE: most part, French-English relations have become relevant t~ anglophone C~nada ~ly when those relations have been problematic to anglophones. They have always been problematic for French , Canadians. J, This on-again, off-again a:r:iglophone concern with F rench-E'nglish relations has been very evident in British Columbia. British Columbia is geographically far remo'oJ~.d from the center of the controversy, and it has traditionally been little concerned with the ·matter. British Columbia has never had a large francophone population, and inevitably Quebec was of relevance to British Columbians only to the extent that Quebec determined the balance of power in Ottawa. ' This historical British Columbian lack of concern with French . Canadians has already been indicated by the near total absence of press coverage on them which characterized the first half of this century. Simi- larly, the term Anglo Canadian was scar·cely use.cl int~ two .er _a s considered . previously. 45 ' "Canadian" was the more relevant term, and it was defined in terms of British ancestry and against Americans and (non-British) immigrants. When one turns to the press oj the past ten years, the difference from the pasUs ·d r ~ c . French Canadians now share the dubious privilege with native people o"f being the most cover,ed domestic group in the sample. 189 items were found on French Canadians, which accounted for 19. 9% of - 483 - " the Sun'~ domestic coverage of ethnicity. ""I Tables CLVII through CLIX -- outline the topics, subtopics, and themes associated with these items. The number of items on Anglo Canadians have also risen substan- • tially, although not to anything near the degree of French Canadian cover- • ag~. For comparative purposes the attributes found in these news items on Anglo Canaqians hav~ also been placed in Tables CLVII through CLIX. , ♦, What accounted for this sudden rise in press cover:age? The answer 1s very clear: activities among Quebec francophones which threatened anglophone rights and privileges. British Columbia papers like the Sun now participate in a "debate" which was traditionally restricted to Eastern Canada. It is unrealfstic to attempt to infer what now motivates the Sun's personnel to cover what they did not cover ~arlier. Nevertheless, as will be outlined shortly, · the topics associated with French Canadian news items '6 concentrate so heavily upon conflict, violence, and threats of francophone domination of anglophones that interest in this subject may well simply reflect the press's long term interests in the spectacular and the unusual. . I will return to this point at the end of this discussion. The coverage of French and Anglo Canadians was dominated by dis::ussion of the relationship between them. • As can be seen in Table CLVIII, subtopics in ethnic relations accounted for 26. 0% of the items on Fr~nch Canadians and 25. 0% of that on Anglo Canadians. The mo st frequent topic I category for both groups was legal and legislative business, and most of these items dealt with legislative or legal action in defense of one group or " -. '. I I - 484 - ' Topics and Subtopics French Canadians number % Education are under educated need special educ-~tion other 1 1 o. 5 o. 5 Health & Welfare cost services 1 1). 5 Employment & Economy lower standard of li virtg are employed,,, are cheap labor 1 1 1 o. 5 o. 5 0. 5 Number are a given number 1 o. 5 Advocation of Restriction should deny ethnic ways advocate no foreign language Z. 1 o. 5 Are Restricted denied ethnic ways I j 4 1 -.J Charge Restriction claim job restriction claim institutional barriers claim thfir rights are barred claim they are not allowed ways Ethnic Relations try to better relations relations are mediated relations get better relations get worse relations are good relations are bad a re as similati ble have outside help unite with others impose their ways do not get along threaten world 1. 1 1 1 o. 5 o. 5 z 1. 1 1 o. 5 3 1. 6 z z z % 1 4.2 1 4. Z· 1 4.Z z 8. 3 1 4.Z 1 4.Z 2. 1 1. 1 1. 1 1. 1 z 3. 7 1. 1 1. 1 1 0.5 8 4.2 1 o. 5 ,4 Z. 1 7 2 number 0. 5 z 4 Anglo Canadians ... - 485 French Canadians nwnber % Anglo Canadians nwnber % 1 Ethnic Rela-tions (Cont d.) pro-American investment bilinguali~m advocated .l 0. 5 10 5. 3 2 Legislation & Legal politicians urge restriction laws limit laws protect are in court · prate st to gave rnment im.migration language . bill 7 3 11 27 7 l 3~7 1. 6 5. 8 14. 3 .: 2 t\ 3. 2 Violence, Hostility Again st are assaulted or harassed l l o. 5 o. 5 Violence, Hostility By assault, harass others demonstrations •in P. 0. meet imposition with _f or c e hostile to Canadians ·are ac ::used of crime other l 2 2 l 4 l o. 5 ·Cele bri ties politicians ~ocial notables historical notables Ethnic Organizatfa.ns ethnic festivals organize in com.munity have ~inister organizations . l 5 l l l 6 l 25.0 4.2 l 4. 2 ' 3. 7 0.5 1. l Cultural Difference require special prac.tice bad national language u,se diiie rent ideas oi law a re loyal -to home be st cultural practice other 8. 3 ,, 4.2 1. 1 1. l o. 5 2. 1 o. 5 o. 5 2. 6 0.5 0. 5 2 1. l 2 14 3 1 1. l ·7. 4 1. 6 o. 5 1 .. 1 0.5 0.5 6 l. 2 1 l 4.? ,. 4.t ,. 2 8. 3 1 1 4.2 4.2 - 486 - French Canadians number % '--' Normal News make good humor - other } ~. Total Table CLVII. Anglo Canadians number % 1 1 0.5 o. 5 0.5 189 100. 0% 24 100.0% French Canadian and Anglo Canadian Domestic News Coverage by Topics and Subtopics: VancouverSun .(1967-1976) Topic French Canadians number % Anglo Cenadians number % '- Legislative & Legal 66 35.0 9 ' 37.5 Ethnic Relations 49 26.0 6 25.0 Celebrities 20 1 o. 6 2 · 8. 3 Violence, Hostility By 11 5. 8 0 0.0 Cultural Difference 10 5. 2 2 8. 3 Ethnic Organiz~tions 8 --1.J.. 2 _hl 164 86.8% 21 87.5% . r Total Table CLVI.µ. The Most Frequent Topics of French Canadian and Anglo· Canadian Domestic News Items: Vancouver Sun (i967197 6) - 487 - Theme French Canadians number Ethnic Relations .... 123 Anglo Canadians number 16 ~- 12 •.' Legislative &: Legai 99 Violence, Hostility By 93 Cultural Difference 66 9 Celebrities 27 1 Charge Restriction 13 1 Advocation of R~ striction 12 3 Table CLIX. 1",_ 2 Most Common Themes in Domestic French Canadian and Anglo Canadian News Items: Vancouver Sun (1967-1976) . _, \ " - 488 - at the expense of the other. Moreover, Anglo Canadians were e~plicitly 46 mentioned in 27. Oo/o ,of the items on French Canadi~ns. One third of the items on Anglo Canadians mentioned French Canadians. Over the past ten years the Sun has portrayed Anglo-French relati~ns r· in a fashion which has been extremely unflattering to French Canadians .. The ·sun' s moral community score for French Canadians was -0. 97, one of the worst of any group in recent times. Canadians was fcl\rly good (-0. 21). In comparison, that of Anglo This wide difference between the ways in which French and Anglo Canadians were portrayed is the result of two basic press tendencies. First of all, virtually every piec~ on French Canadians in the sample of 189 had something to do with Anglo-French conflict. 85. 7% of this coverage was either about conflict in Quebec or governmental activities in Ottawa related to such conflict. Separation and the deterioration of anglo- phone rights dominated the news of French Canadians. Normal news about French Canadians accounted for only 1. 5% of the sample and only one out of 189 items dealt with French Canadian cultural festivities. With the excep- tion of French Canadian politicians, French social, intellectual, and business elites were rarely covered, and events participated in by typical fran~ophone s were not reported at all. \. \ e condly, the Sun consistently used anglophone standards to judge francophone behavior. This being the case, it is not difficult to see why French Canadians fared so badly in the press. The Sun tended to follow _J - 489 - I cJassical anglophone thought by consistently reducing anglophone.\ , francophone conflict to a problem of different culture or of language. Some ' of th~ major separatist objections to things as they are were therefore , automatically removed from consideration. For instance, the structure of the present day Quebec economy and the historical relationship between English and French in Quebec were given almost no attention at all. There were only 3 (1. 5%) items in the sample directly dealing with French Canadians and the economy. Neither was the Sun an effective vehicle for airing French Canadian ,: grievances. Although it was necessary for the Sun to deal with some of the points raised by French Canadians if it was to deal with the question of Anglo-French relations at all, very few articles which found their way into the Sun provided a platform for French Canadians to outline the liabilities 47 which they claimed spring from their prese11t place in Canada. Press interest in French Canadians has fluctuated widely, even~during the last ten years, as the following table indicates: ,, ( 490 ~ Number 1967 24 12. 7 1968 25 13.. 2 1969 17 9.0 1970 42 22.2 1971 22 11. 6 1972 14 7.4 1973 9 4.8 1974 5 1975 14 7.4 1976 17 9.0 189 100.0% Total Percentage • 2. 6 Table CLX •• French Canadian Domestic News Items by Year: Vancouver Sun (1967-1976) This variation was primarily the result of a rise of a few key events in particular years. These events were so extensively covered that they must be considered directly 1n order to illustrate how the Sun portrayed French Canadians. The key story of 1967 was President Charles de Gaulle's visit to Canada. De Gau1-Te overtly supported separation for Quebec and took no special pains to hide this sentiment during his stay in Canada. The French protocol used during the trip dealt with Quebec as a sovereign entity. Most g of his energies were directed towards francophones. For the Sun, the focal 491 point of de Gaulle's visit was a single line in one of his numerous public appearances m~e by the French President; his toast "Vive de Quebec Libre" resounded across the land. Sun editorials immediately attacked de Gaulle Is comment as inappropriate meddling in Canadian affairs; "No Thanks Mr. de Gaulle" (October 18, 196 7, page 5) 1 we Canadians have things nicely in hand without your ' interference. Commentary on this speech was continuous, and two months . later one still found the issue on the editorial page of the Sltn: WITH HIS FRENCH CANADIAN ROCKETS De Gaulle 4ims a Satellite at Uncle Sam '\ (December 2, 1967, page 5) The above item contained virtual.l.y all the charges aimed at de Gaulle by the press. He was attempting to disrupt life in Quebec for imperialistic ',. , purposes. Quebec was a province, and not a sovereign nation and de Gaulle had no business sugg/sting otherwise. The editorial went so far as to suggest that French Canadians were entirely against de Gaulle's separatist policy--an assertion which would have be.en difficult to support if the Sun were even slightly aware of French Canadi~t thought on the matter. De Gaulle's statement generated a number of articles which were not directly related to the event itself. These all centered on the question of separatism- -a question for which the Sun had already formulated a very clear answer. From the point of view of the Sun, separation was imprac - tical, immoral, and illegal. ,. 'Slra~ion was the Road to Ruin" (October 3, - 492 - 1967, page 4) for Quebec, becaus·e Quebec got far mo:e out of Confederation than it contributed to it. There was alrea?y an "Exodus from Separation: Business Runs out on Quebec" (October 18, 1967, page 4). Those who agitated for separation were portrayed as a small group of anarchists, who' di.cl not represent Quebecois feeling ("Separatist Stays in Jail," October 3, 1967, page 2). As a cartoon suggested on October 18 (page 5), people in Quebec _preferred "Kicking Levesque out of Confederation" to doing the same , to Quebec. In many respects press coverage of de Gaulle 1 s visit paralleled that accorded to the French throughout the era. In the two periods covered previously there were almost no news items on the activities of continental French in Canada. During the past ten years the number of French stories have increased to about 2. 0% of the domestic coverage. News items on the French .were concentrated heavily into the area of ethnic relations (57. 9% ' of the total). In addition, 57. 9% of the items involved either Canadians or French Canadians. Most of these items concerned Fr,~ch involvement with affairs in French speaking Canada. Like the reaction to de Gaulle's visit, the Sun took a very dim view to these activities, considering them to be·interference in Canadian affairs. F ranee was seen to be supporting separatists in Quebec ~ 48 for its own purposes: • - 493 - QUEBEC FIND RUMORED De Gaulle,.Ga~ble·s on Uranium (December 18, · 1967, 'page 28) The Sun took an extremely hypocritical stand on the relationship between Quebec and F ranee. It was unable to s~e the relationship as being in any .,.. . way similar to that between anglophone Canada and Britain. The Sun rather enthusiastically supported the monarchy as a cultural and histor~cal link between Canada and England, but was intolerant of French suggestions of a similar link between French spea~ing people in North America and those in France. 1£ visiting French dignitarie·s did not remain silent o:r:i Canadian internal matters, the Sun editors thought that they should not be allowed to come at all ("On Inviting Offensive Guests," October 16, 1969, page 4). "We Briti~h , Who Founded Canada" (editorial, December 16, 1968, page 5) could do very well without the likes of Mr. de Gaulle. French foreign coverage was also up considerably over that of previous eras (n = 15). Essentially, domestic.and foreign French coverage were reflections of each other. Most of the domestic coverage dealt with French interference, stubbornness, and lack of civility, and the overseas portrayal of French showed them acting likewise ~n Europe. The Sun took a very dim view of France's unwillingness to allow Britain into the common market (February 17, 1967, page 20) and it explained this reluctance on purely cultural grounds; the French hated the British, and hence, were unwilling to allow Britain any advantage. . --. ~- 494 The bump~r year for French Canadian coYferage in. the Sun was 1970. ... . ... . · Far more items on F re.q_ch .Ca11:~di•a1:. appeared in that year than in any other .-' during the past ten, de spite a three month strike which sh~ the Sun down "' .. . ,... from Fe bi:-uary I 'st to May 11,th. · 1970 was ·the· yea; w~en anglophone Canada first began to -sense the d,egree to which . {r·ancophones were fundamentally · Q dissatisfied with their status ih Confederation. _ It was the ye·ar -!hat Rene . Levesque's Parti Quebecois .von 24% of the popular vote in the Quebec • . provincial e-lection . • This alohe would have _produced con·si:d,erable press . response.· • Nevertheless, the growing strength of the Parti Queb~cois paled in' . . •. compa.ri.son w~th coverage of the F.LQ ki-dnapping of James Cross and Pierre Laporte. Sun coverage -of the October Crisis was heavier than that accorded to any other event involvi!\g ethn~city in this study. • I_ The six issues > • of ·the Sun -s~pled between Octa.be r 14th and..the end of 1970 produced 33 I • items on the F LQ; •! ' 'Phis meant that for that period there were about five .... items on the ¥ LQ irr• ever,/ is sue of ' the Sun. . The Sun's cdverage of the F LQ was remarkably consistent. • Fir st of all, it was consistent in the perspective which it used to relate FLQ events to other things. Whatever"the particular happening, it w.as placed into a context of what implications it had for Canada, not for Quebec or for French . 49 C ana d 1ans. Would the F LQ spell the end of Canada as we knew it? Would Canada have sufficient resources to deal with the threat? These were ,. questions which were typical of the Sun's pe"rspective. f 495 - By far, the primary concern of the Sun was the threat which the FLQ posed to "law and order." The political impli5=ations of their activities were for the most part ignored. This concern for law a~d or~er completely J._ .• ,:,. ,J C, ; negated the political.anc\pistorical .aspects of the situation. T-he FLQ members were routinely reduced to "terrorists" or a:t best, to "kidnappers." . As far as the Sun and other anglophone pap€rs were"-e,oncerned, the ¥LO' s activities were criminal, not political. As such, they were to be dealt with by the police, the military, and other means which were available to deal with th9se who broke the law. The Sun gave continual support for the War Measures Act and other moves on the part of the gover~ment to strike back against the FLQ. It generated a great number of news stories which covered government spokespersons and others justifying such measures: WEAK-KNEED BLEEDING HEARTS' FLAYED PM Vows No Limit in Terrorist Fight (October 14, 1970, page 1) TRUDEAU TAKES A HARD LINE (October 14, 1970, page 1) IN THEJ¥ OWN WORDS, WHY THEY SUSPENDED LIBERTY (October 27, 1970, page 4) Protests against the imposition of the War Measures Act (on October 19, 1970) were rarely found in the Sun, and they were inevitably restricted to Quebec opponents of the Act: J - 496 - QUEBEC CRITICS SPEAJ:< UP IN OPPOSING INVOCA ~ION AND USE OF WAR MEASURES (October 29, 1970,.page 2) QUEBEC OPPQSITION MOUNTS AGAINST EMERGENCY LAWS (October 29, 1970, page 1) As one might expect, the Sun developed very iittle backgr·ound material on the FLO. There were a few 11 human interest" items on indivi- dual FLQ members, but there was almost nothing on the history of the The Sun left the reader without any insight' into the organization itself. political philosophy of the F LQ or the depth of its popular support. Instead,, . ·. the Sun linked the FLQ to large scale international forces which were acting to de stabilize the gave rnments of the western world: LINKS KIDNAPPING TO MASTER PLAN Drapeau Is sues Revolution Warning . (October 14, 1970, page 2) FLO BASES NEW THREAT IN EUROPE (October 14, 1970, page 14) Although of a less spectacular nature than the FLO Crisis, several other events and processes involving French and· Anglo Canadians received extensive coverage in the Sun. language rights. One of the most salient was the conflict over ~ The passage of federal statut¼ decreeing French and English to both be nati6nal languages has generated press response since its inception. For the most part the Sun has been extremely unsympathetic ,. ,. -· 497 to the idea of a·bilingual Canada. " Pay for a Dying Language 11 It thought the legislation a ,·,High Price to (editorial, May 8, 1975, page 6) and it . ridiculed the use of French where there were few francophones ("City Depot: CN Plans Bilingual Signs_ Soon," January 18, 1967, page 2). The Sun subscribed to the stafldard anglophone thesis: English is the dominant language of the country; it is a world langua-ge, while French is not; it is undemocratic to impose a minority language on the majority; federal legislation which protects French language rights are a politic al concession to a strident minority. -- Also in keeping with more general anglophone thought, the Sun had no -- particular trouble reversing this argument in defense of the minority language rights of anglophones and others in Quebec. Quebec provincial government language bills were unfair because they forced minority language users in Quebec to conform to the language of the majority. As in the editorial "Come Out in the Open" (January 28, 1971, page 4), the Sun portrayed the language question as if it were simply a cover for francophones discriminating against anglophones. Similarly, the Sun co.uld see no reason why non-anglophone immigrants who settled in Ouebec,:Bhould be ,( required to send their children to francophone schools; it 'Mias a gross violation of the right of free choice. In the Sun the question of language rights was intimately connected with the "threat of Quebec separation. 11 In almost all re3pects the ~ was unsympathetic to separatist sentiment, and it tended to go so far in the de- ... - 498 - fense of national unity as to p.rgue that the social and econom~ inequities claimed to exist by francophone Quebecers were themselves invalid. ,. . As - far as the Surt was concerned, Quebec had gott'en a good deal out of con~ federation, and was using the spectre of separation.to exact further special privileges out of the federal government. The Sun was convinced that Quebec was unlikely to separate because French Canadian sentiment was against it; besides, argued the Sun ("The Price of S e p a ~ April 17, 1968, page 4), separation would lead to the economic demise of Quebec. In its stand against separation the Sun exhibited the fundamental weakness of other media representatives of anglophone Canada who dealt • • with this issue: although the ....-Sun was ''for national ·~~ity, '' its. coverage did nothing to foster it. Its pro-unity stand was one that was based upon the ✓ s .1bordinanc:e of Quebec to the nation. 1 It was not a stand of reconciliation o.r \ ~{ . resolution. ,' The Sun's coverage of the Parti Quebecois and others in Qqebec contributed next to nothing to a British Columbian anglophone's knowledge of the situation. For the Sun, the Parti Quebecois was synonym? with Rene Levesque. There was essentially no coverage of the p?sophy of the Parti Quebecois, its history, or the size of its political support. Likewise, the Sun virtually ignored those activities of the Parti Quebecois government which did not bear on the confrontational aspects of the separatist issue. ,I Moreover, the~• s coverage of Anglo and French Canadians legi- '/ timated the rigpt; and privileges of the former at the expense of the latter. Anglo Canadians in Quebec were portrayf:;d as being sober, industrious and 7 - 499 - non-political. French Canadial'ls were argumentative, confrontational,· ( I I.... irrational, impractical, and self-centered. :This pair of stereotypes has \ - been historically pre sent in Canada since the time of the Conquest. They are the classic top-down stereotypes of the conqueror and the c o n q u e r e ~ Their currency in anglophone newspapers of the last quarter of the twen- •. tieth century is illustrative of how little the perspective of Anglo Canadians '- has changed in the intervening centuries; • Conchisions The intervening years between the last decade and that considered in the previous chapter saw remarkable changes occur in Canadian orientations towards ethnicity. Tolerance for those of different backgrounds increased, both officially and in the public, and ethnicity became less significant.as a .£actor in social and economic mobility than it once was. During the· same period changes in- immigration policy led to a postwar diversification -of the • ethnic and national backgrounds of Canadians UBexceeded by ·any other era in history. Economic necessity brought many of these new Canadians in.to :::ontact with others all across the country. The past twenty years in particular have been ones of extensive adiustment of old and new Canadians to each other. \ They ha.ve been times when the definition of what it means 1:o be a Canadian has undergone considerable modification in order to reflect the new demographic and cultural makeup of Canadian society. Clear4,y, these are important changes, for they directly affect the life chances of individuals.. Foreign born Canaqtans _./ .. - 500 - are significantly affected by the entry status of people of the~r particular ethnic or national background, if not economically then certainly in terms '\ of self identity and feeling of east:\,and ~curity. some consequence for the.Canadian born. Similarly, ethnicity is of-, For some, ethnicity remains an important aspect of self identity and is a frequently activated basis for \ interpersonal relations. For others, interaction with those of different ethnicity either challenges or confirms notions oi self and society. In short, ethnicity remains an extremely fundamental aspect of Canadian society. Ii is also an extretnely visible one .to many Canadians, and whatever their position on the subject they realize its· importance in everyday life; ethnicity • in Canada is a social as well as a sociological issue. .. In this chapter it has been shown that the Vancouver press has far ' fronyignored ethnicity in the pa~t ten years~ Rather, it has dealt with the "---- • subject in very complex ways, depending much on whose ethnicity was being portrayed and the issue involved, among many other factors. Following the format of the concluding sections of the two previous eras, the following set of points. are of a more general nature than those raised during the case-by._. case discussion of the various groups which made the press between 1961 and 1976. 1. Ethnicity continues to be an important aspect of the news. In fact, the amount of coverage devoted to ethnically related issues has increased. Ethnic and race relations in British Columbia have changed funda- mentally since the 1930's. In certain respects .they have gotten better, but t 501 - it is equally significant that they have changed structurally. Earlier ethnic relations were frequently characterized by direct, group against group conflict and competition, at least in the minds of majority group individuals. For example, the Chinese {as a group) were seen as a threat to white jobs. Ethnic groups and ethnicity~~ were extremely ·vocal issues of the day. Presently ethnic relations have be come much more individualized and are more dependent on the individuals involved and the circumstances surrounding them. None of the large scale issues of the past era are salient now, with the exception of immigration. At the same time, it has become in- appropriate to voice specifically prejudicial statements about ethnicity and race in mo st social contexts, regardless of personal convictions to the contrary. Explanations of the cause of social problems by reference to race and ethnicity are pass~, at least in the form that they were frequently aired in the pa st. Nevertheless, analysis of the Sun shows that ethnicity remains a very important element in the world of the newapaper s. As we have seen, a typical issue of the Sun now contains about six items with ethnic content. News items are on average longer than they were in the 1930' s, such that the number of column inches in each day's Sun dealing' with ethnic issues has \ increased some 300% in the intervening years. Consequently the Sun must be considered an important input to people's ideas about ethnicity, especially to the degree that individuals do not have access to alternative information sources. Moreover, ethnicity forms an ..,, • . - 502 - integral part of the Sun's worldview, regardless of the degree to which its presentation affects the views of its readership. Decreases in, the degree ·- to which local ethnic relations are characterized by conflict and competitian have not led to consequent decreases in the level of press concern with ethnicity. Several factors seem to have insured that ethnicity continues to be important in news presentation, as outlined in the subse quent discussion. 2. The press is no longer a spokesman for majority views of local ethnic issues in the same way as it was in the past. In the past two eras it has been shown that the Vancouver press supported the sentiments of the majority in many overt ways. It editorially attacked Asians and the Federal government which it held responsible for their presence in British Columbia. It morally degraded Asians and others, in striking contrast to its coverage of ethnically acceptable individuals. Its interests were speci'fical_ly British Columbian, and Canadian national issues were rarely its concern; international questions were virtually beyond the f pale. l For the most part the press (at least to the degree that the Sun is ' representative of it) has lost much of its role as spokesman for local majority group interests. Its advocacy of dominant group interests has been made difficult by a number of factors. f . For one thing, it is far more diffi- cult to discern exactly who is the majority group than it was in the past. In ,. additit>n, the Sun is far more constrained in its advocacy role by the threat • J - 503 - of public outcry and govel'nment displeasure at the appearance of specifically racist,or ethnically-exclusive.news items. Consequently, the Sun has restricted its advocacy to 'motherhood' issues such as immigration and . urban social problems and has delegated the more sensitive aspects of its support of the majority in particular to 'independent' columnists. The Sun is also less of a spokesman for, local majority interests as an indirect consequence of a shift in what S(?rt of people and events make the news in relation to ethnicity. Over the past thirty years the press has become much more geographically_ expansive in its ethnic coverage. Quebec, the United States, Africa, and the. Middle East have received extensive coverage over the past ten years, such th~t items dealing with ethnicity in British Columbia are relatively fewer than they were in the past. 3. The criteria for what people and events are news when they :involve ethnicity have chard significantly. a. The nature o(events primarily determine what is news. The ethnicity of the people involved does not alone determine that events and is sues concerning them will be newsworthy. Wh~he Vancouver press was more concerned with local issues than . \ . ' it is at present, ethnicity alone was often sufficient to make a particular eve_nt newsworthy even when it would not be news if done by individuals of a different ethnic background. This tendency persists in terms of local is sues, as has been pointed out several times in pre vio u~ discussions. ~ r example, Asian immigration is news while British immigration is not. At\ "'\ the same time'it never was the case that the ethnicity of an individual was I' ' · - 504 - sufficient to guarantee that events concerning that individual made the newspapers. The press has always been sensitive to, certain ·ty;es of e v e ~ and issue~ to the virtual exclusion of others. In the past these issues ~nd events seem to be divisible into two varieties: issues of high local interest and events that were unusual, especially g they were of a violent and confrontational sort. Today, criteria of newsworthiness have shifted. No longer is ethni- city alone nearly as important a criterion as it was in the past, and issues and events are now the principle con side rations which now make a thing news, such that the various ethnic groups are now only covered when they are associated with particular types of events. This h~s led to an enormous yearly variation in the number _of items dealing with any one group •. b~ The specific factual content of events is not as important a selection, factor as is the degree to which the event involves confrontation, violence, crime, or discord between individuals or groups. The manner in which the Sun covered ethnicity over the past ten years shows a virtually complete victory for .:he tendency to allow the violent and unusual to dictate what is news and what is not. This was especially so of ethnicity involved in events which occurred outside of British Columbia. French Canadians were only news in relationship to anglophone -francophone conflict or to crime. Similarly, Bla½k Americans were newsworthy when engaged in civil strife or crime. Coverage of Sub-Saharan Africa was almost exclusively that of conflict. This tendency is now so strong that it ., 505 - is almost inevitable that if the press accords a substantial amount of coverage to an ethnic or national group outside of British Columbia that coverage will be negative. i -( Because the press seeks· out the violent and confronta- tional as being especially newsworthy, this constantly leads to what might \.~ be ~ermed the:incidental stigmatization of the people so portrayed. Conflict I - situations are typically presented in such a way that ethnicity is associated ✓ primarily with minority individuals; as in the case of French Canadians or Blacks in Southern Africa the press frequently portrays conflicts as being ' between an_ ( e t h ~ r i t y group and society. Consequently, minority groµp members are commonly portrayed to be the perpetrators of violence-they are always the deviants. This is but one aspect of a more general press tendency . . 4. The Vancouver press continues to hold to an extremely narrow anglophone North American view of British Columbia, Canada, and the Worl,d. Rs a consequence the press continues to generate a ' stratified ethnic: moral commW1ity in spite of the changing nature of its outg roups. The press .only rarely expresses H,pelf directly in support of parti- ... cular ethnicities or in opposition to others: In certain respects this has meant that some groups who were heavily stigmatized by the press in earlier times now receive more favorable coverage. Nevertheless, the press continues to employ a perspective on the news which indirectly leads to some ethnic groups getting unfavorable treatment. This perspective can be characterized as being white, middle-class, middle of the road North American. It is one that approves of representative democracy, order, - 506 stability, and the peaceful amelioration of social problems through gradual change. It is not a particularly philosophical outlook and it is an extremely ethnocentric one. It is intolerant of minority group protest, especially if it is done through extralegal means and it is strongly assimilationist vis ~vis Canadian ethnic groups. While the Sun no longer overtly derogates ethnicity or ethnic groups simply because of racial or cultural origin alone, the narrowness and in1 flexibility of the Sun s worldview inevitably disapproved of things which diverged from its ideas of normal behavior. ... Consequently, violence and protest by French Canadians, Black Americans, Doukhobors, Arabs, Black Africans, and others was portrayed in a stigmatic·fashion not only because it was sensationalistic and normally considered to be bad; it was also stigmatic because of the explanatory framework into which that violence was placed. The press was sensitive only to violence and conflict which contra- dicted its view of the normal. As such, the organized, rationalized use of violence and other means of subordination by governments and their military and police usually did not convey the same s,ense of disapproval when such actions made the newspapers. > The terminology with which the Sun described the activities of various groups vari_e.d in accord with this general perspective on the world. As has been shown with respect to the portrayal of Arabs, Black Americans, Black Africans, and Fre1;ch Canadians, deviant and disapproved acts on the part of minorities merited labels which u _n ders cored the, impropriety of the acts - 507 - themselves. " . Terms such a ■~rrorist, guerilla,' militant, and kidnapper denied legitimacy to those so '½&eled. For instance, in the Near East, conflict was often portrayed as being between a collecti;>n of ragtag - guerillas and a national army. Similarly, ethnicity was far more frequently associated with minority causes than with those who held positions.of power. Hence, Arab guerillas would come into conflict with the Israeli army. 5. Press coverage of ethnicity 1s non-reflective, non-integrative, ' and non-developmental. As the Vancouver press' horizons have expandetl to consider events and issues in the rest of Canada and the World much of the earlier phirosophy of ethnic'ity which the press used in its portrayal of local ethnic matters has been lost. Many local items dealing with ethnicity no longer are directly relatable to social concerns about ethnicity in the way that things like Asian immigration once were. Likewise, most Canadian and overseas items are portrayed in such a way that they are for the most part detached fro·m local concerns. This has further contributed to what has always been a weakness in the way in which the press has portrayed ethnicity; items with ethnic content only rarely seek to explain what occurs in the particular event portrayed except through the simple chronological outlining of events leading up to the immediate present, The _press almost never provides an economic, political, or social context for events, with the consequence that a great many happenings are dealt with in extre'mely individual terms, despite the fact that the events involved could far better be explained as manifestations of far larger forces. - 508 The press does no better in dealing with long term historically developing situations. Even situations like the F LQ Crisis of 1970 which received an extremely large amount of press coverage failed to elicit evert the barest press discussion of past Quebecois grievances. Neither did the press outline the history of the FLQ itself or its past relationship with ·\ other groups. The time depth of the news is often so shallow that the be- ginning of eve.nts which took over a month to resolve themselves were lost from press discussion before the event had come to its final resolution. Coverage of long term issues and events were developmental only insofar as today's coverage tended to link itself to yesterday's events. The Sun was also completely wireflective about its own role in the . portrayal of ethnicity. Followin~ general press practice, virtually all news items in the Swi were written in the strict third person without any discussion of the newspaper's role in the colle~tion and interpretation of the events portra)'ed in them. Items rarely contained any ind_ication of the processes which come together to generate a news item; it was as if the news was generated unproblematically from the facts at hand and that the medium itself had no impact on the final product. The Sun never commented on its own presentation of ethnicity and only allowed pc.1bli c input about its coverage on the carefully controlled letters to the editor page. Neither did it ever comment in print about its own his_torical practices, even to the extent of commenting that its practices had changed. ,, - 509 - 6. The press' perspectives on ethnicity have become increasingly dominated by its extralocal sources of information, United States news services in particular. Somewhere between 60 and 70% of the news items coded over the past ten years of the Sun derived from other than the Sun's own collection of information. This increasing informational dependence on non-local sources 1s mor~ than a simple dependence on fact-gathering. As has been shown at several points in this chapter; information derived from the international news services carries with it the heavy imprint of its creators. While the production of news service copy is subject to the same limitations as news items which the newspaper generates itse.lf, it has several others, .some of which significantly ajfect the way in which ethnicity is presented in the newspapers. These all center around the fact that (with the exception of CP). the news services which the Sun has available are all primarily oriented towards major markets outside of Canada. UPI and AP are American owned services, and their major market is the United States. Reuters is primar- 1 ily a British news agency which provides much of CP s foreign cover~ge. As such, what appears of does not appear i~ the copy of these agencies is ft. selected in the light of their primary audiences, not Canada. Consequently, -{' ,.d"omestic American affairs make up a large proportion of the news items ' available through UPI and AP- -a fact reflected in the high propoi;tion of news ~ • items in the Sun which portray events in the United States. These items are \ naturally frarped in terms of their consequen.ces for American,' not Canadian affairs_. Reuters' news is similarly biased towards events 1n • - 5 10 - Britain. The coverage of international events by UPI and AP also reflect American interests. ·• American politicians overseas and current crises in America'.n foreign policy attract heavy and disproportionate attention by \ \ both of these news services. . \I Conversely, when relations between· t~e United States and a given foreign power are non-problematical, activities • in that country frequently drop out of the news despite_ the consequenc;es which internal ·affairs there might have had for other foreign countries. The most blatant current examplE; of this would be news service coverage of the demise of the Shah of Iran, where brutal repression on the part of the Shah's military and police and the vigorous reactions to it were not 11 news 11 until the Shah's position was so unstable that United_States interests were directly threatened. Similarly, both UPI, ~P, and Reuters have distributed their personnel worldwide in a fashion which reflects the interests of their home market, •he volume of information available from particular parts of the world, and the traditional spheres of influence of their metropoles. Hence, UPI, AP, and Reuters all have a high proportion of their personnel in Europe and the United States, w'ith UPI and AP-prevailing in the latter.· All three have a number of people in the Near East and South Africa, while the rest of the world is only sparsely covered; Reuters prevails in those areas of the world where British influence once was felt, while AP and 1 UPI s proportion of "personnel in Latin America is somewh~t-greater. News - 5 11 ~ I • flow from the various ,parts of the world approximate this distribution of personnel. •In no ·case could one argue that this distribution of personnel reflects Canadian interest; neither does the perspective on foreign aff°airs presented in their c·opy. One consequence is that it is not difficult'to support the thesis that the SWl has grown co:isiderably less Canadian over the p~fifty years. ' Th~ ,,, predominant pla-ce of local issues has diminished, and the void has only partially been filled by increased coverage of the rest of Canada,. With I respect to ethnicity• 'the re st of Canada mea~~ only anglophone -francophone relations in Quebec and their expression in federal political debate. At the same time, international coverage of ethnicity has greatly expanded, and Canadian input to it has correspondingly decreased. For the most,pc1.rt, control over the content, philosophy, political orientation, and possible relevance of stories abo_..t international eventi has been ceded to others. 7. The ethnicity portrayed in the press is and always has been the ethnicity of adult males. Coverage of women and ethnicity has historically been insignificant, and shows no signs of increasing . . To this point, I have not discussed the fashion in which the pres~ articulated the sex of individuals portrayed wi~h their e t ~ t y , save fo'r f mentioning in Chapter One that I coded sex as a variable. This decision stemmed from the dramati.c disparity in the frequency with which males and 0 iemale's are assoc.iated with ethnicity througb--the years. The frequency of news items dealing with women was so low in toto that discussion of males and females in the context of distinct ethnic groups would have been virtually , I . - 512 - me~ningle s s. Here, the statement that ethnicity as it is portrayed in the _:ne_wspc1-pers con:::erns what the papers have defined t~ be the activities of It means that in retrospect what I have males has far greater saliency. been dealing with in this thesis has been a· representative sample of ethnicity 1 :.. ' in the press, but it has been a sample that has virtually excluded the lives and interests of one haif 6-_,f the r~levant population. Indeed, it means quite a bit more, -for it 1s a direct commentary on .r ~ • what are and are not markers of ethnicity for the public at large. . As in so many other areas of life what has attracted the attention of the press and - public has been almost e\cclusively the public activities of males. I do not mean to say that the papers have been concerned with malespecific ethnic attributes to the -detriment of the attributes of ethnic women. More careful analysis shows that this is not entirely true. To be sure, when they have been portrayed at all in ethnic content~ ~omen have been more commonly characterized as the passive recipients of actions begl.lll by others than are males. For .i.nstance, Canadian women were more likely to • . be in need of "protection" than men and men were more lik~_ly to ''attack· . others" than women. Still, the portrayal of men and women in the Vancouver newspapers has been characterized by very ·similar topics. \ This is demonst,rated· by the fact that if all papers and eras are consider~,d 'together the linear :::orrelation coefficient between the frequency of male and female subtopics io~nd in ethnic news items was . 908. In fact, it would be more accurate to l . .. I - 513 - say that women made the news .only in a few of the instances when they did things normally associated with men. There are a few more points to be mad~ about the disparity between male and female presentation for which table CLXI provides fome sup.port .• First of all, it is clear that the proportion of news· items given over to the portrayal of women and ethnicity has not incnased appreciably over the 71 years considered in this study. Women figured prominently in 5. 1% of the sample from the Province ( 1905-1914) and 4. 4% of the sample from the Sun (1967-1976). Ap?roximateJy speaking, there were six items dealing with men ror every one on women. Se conqly, although Table CLXI might suggest that relative to males the prop~rtion of co\·erage accorded to females has gone up over the past seventy years, but this is not entirely true. To be sure, the proportion of I news ite.;:ns involvihg men has slipped steadily over the era in question; '\ . from 46. 5% of the early Province sample ( 1905-1904) to 24. 4% of the late Sun sample (1967-1976)--a proportional loss of almost 50%. Those lost per~entage points have been picked' up by the 'unspecified' category. Never- theless, one should not infer from this that the portrayal of ethnicity pas become more balanced with re~pect to sex over the years, for when oi:i.e considers the nature of items in this 'unspecified' category more closely such a conclusion dpe s.. not see·m justified. As Table CLXIl indicates, the topics coded on items wl!icb were also coded as of unspecified sex are considerably different than those associated ..- - ,. 514 ' • Female Unspecified Newspaper ' Province (1905-1914) 233 279 28 103 43 7 domestic 182 349 '23 foreign 100 52 8 domestic 193 241- 35 foreign 85 47 6 215 200 28 domestic ' foreign 1. World (190521¼ Province (1928-1937) ~ Sun (1928-1937) · domestic • foreign Sun 13 139 (1967-1976) domestic 658 248 foreign 399 115 1,481 1, 3 1 7 159 826 . 297 54 2,307 1, 614 213 39. 0% 5. 2% Total Domestic T . Total Foreign l'otal Percentage • Table CLXL The Sex of Individuals Involved in News Items by Newspaper, Era, and Locality 515 - Unspecified Topic Male ~male Housing and Settlement 15 5 Education 33 7 Health and Welfare 25 13 Employment and Economy 10 56 Number 32 3 Advocation of Restriction 78 44 2 Are Restricted 45 25 3 Charge Restrictions 83 26 7 Ethnic R.elati.ons 528 145 12 Immigration 216 95 13 Legislative and Legal 304 ' 17 3 24 Violezrre; Hostility Against 84 10 l 8 Violence, Hostility By 238 377 42 Cultural Difference 197 72 15 Celebrities 68 226 35 Sports 15 30 3 Ethnic Organizations 165 51 5 165 -1.§. 1,614 213 6 , Normal News 2,307 Total Table CLXll. ... Topics by Sex: All Papers and Eras - 516 - with items on males or females. - At·the more finely discriminating level of subtopics the linear correlation coefficient between the frequency of subtopics of unspecified and male sex w~s only. 488; between unspecified and fe'male it was even lower (. 342). When one looks at the range o~ subtopics associated with unspecified sex it is evident that they tend very strongly to express the common characteristics of abstractness and generality. Alternatively, subtopics associated with males and females are more·'·concrete and tend to express more individual activities. - This can be seen even at the level of topics.· _,..,. The number of items of unspecified sex is disproportionately higher than • those of male or female sex in the a .reas of ethnic relations, legal and legislative concerns, cultural difference, housing, education, health, population, a:id ethnic restrictions. ,items involving males or females had sub~tantially higher than average frequencits only in the ~reas of crime and '\ violence, celebrities,· and normal news. significant at the level of subtopics. These differences are much more F£instance·, 4. 9% (114) of the un- specified category were found with the subtopic I relations get worse , as 1 compared with I. lo/o (17.) of those coded as male and 1. 4% (3) of those coded • as female. Similarly, the percentage of male items devoted to 11 action" subtopics was much greater than unspecified items; for example are 1 assaulted' (2. 5% male; 1. 7% unspecified); 'victims of c~ime 1 (2 .. 2%, O. 3%); 1 1 are 1n court' (5. 3%, O. 9%); 'assault and harass others (4. 2%, 2. 3%); . 1 assault each other' (5. 3%, 1. 6%); and 1 ac,cused of crime 1 (10. 2%, I. 6%). - 517 - In essence, whenever a particular story dealt with general conditions it was likely that it would not involve individuals and hence did not designate Having said as much, one is left with three conclusions .of relevance , to the coverage of ethnicity. First, foreign items tend to less frequently exhibit the sex of actors than domestic ones; Table CLXI shows that this trend has been consistent across seventy years of Vancouver newspapers. 'Second, the overall proportion of items of a general (and hence, 'sexless') nature has steadily increased over time. t Surprisingly, despite ethnicity being one of the most personal of subjects, indivi:duals are slowly being removed from its portrayal in the press. The third point is more difficult to support on the basis of the data from this study alone: that in essence 'unspecified' items are actually male items. In the case of certain groups at particular points in time this has certainly been the case; for a long time groups like the Chinese were almost exclusivefy male, but I mean this more generally. Almost exclu- sively, 'unspecified' ite~s describe the events in the public arena--an arena which until recently has been virtually the exclusive preserve of men. I do not mean to parody the processes of news gathering and editing which are involved in the generation of daily newspapers, but they nevertheless --- frequently haye the appearai:ice of being mechanisms through which men can -~ comment on the male-relevant activities of other males. " Consider as support for this proposition the way the press has dealt with more important historical issues involving ethnicity. " For example, - 518 - 1n the first era considered here one of the principle fears of the press was that Asians (and others) would take away jobs from white Canadians; Asian immigration was seen as an attack on white privileges. .. The whites who were having their privileges attacked were clearly not the whole European p::>pulation--they were white males. I never came across a single news item that was concerned about the possible effects of immigration on the \ employment of women. Similarly, sexual biases were involved in the way the press dealt with virtually all other questions like those of ethnic violence, cultural difference, and ethnic restrictions. -. 5 19 - 1. The enormity of·the· coverage on the Vietnam War was one factor in not coding it for its ethnic content. In that war of Americans against Vietn~mese it was. nearly impossible to separate out ethnic from military, sociopolitical, and other sorts of relations. Similar problems .earlie'r l~d to my decision not to code the first months of Wo'rld War I (late 1914). 2. For instance, the percentage of news items in the Sun found from page 11 to the end of the paper increased from 26% (1928-1937) to 34. 2% at pre sent. 3. This fluctuation is but one indicator of a rather fundamental shift in the way that the press covered ethnicity during this era. In short, the Sun had shifted from covering events because they were ethnically . based (as per "the Chinese take away Canadian jobs") to a fascination with spectacular events--events which were unusual in part because of ,their racial or ethnic component. This is not as subtle a point as it may seem as presented here. See the more extended discussion of it in the concluding part of this chapter. 11 11 4. For detailed (albeit ti,uasi- official ) views of postwar immigration see Hawkins (1972~ Department of Manpower & Immigration (1975), and Richmond (1967). Corbett (1957) presents the most objective outline of the fir st ten years of po stw~r immigration presently available. S. 1t goes without saying that the categories listed in this Table mix a wide range of ethnic, racial, national, and religious criteria, and do not directly indicate the presence of ethnicity or ethnic groups. Nevertheless, they are the best figures available.~ and do indicate the range of ethnic variety of the Vancouver population (Statistics Canada ·1972: table 7-20). 6, Most "Chinese'' immigrants during the past decade have been from Hong Kong rather than from mainland China. 7, Here, "South Asian'' refers only to those news items which mentioned "Ea.st Indians,~. ''Indians" or the like:\nd as such does not include news items referr~ng to more specific groups such as the Sikhs. Likewise, "British" does not include the English, Scots, or Welsh if one of the latter groups was- referred to specifically. 8, Because figures for th~ ethnic origins of immigrants are· not officially - 5 20 kept, it is nearly impossible to accurately assess the populations of most immigrant communities through governmental statistics. The figure of 1. 5% for the South Asian population of the Vancouver area is therefore only a crude estimate. 9. Of the six items dealing directly with cultural difference, four of them were about British loyalty to their home c·ountry. 10. See Table CXVlll of this chapter.. 11. About 20% of the domestic items dealing~ith Chinese were on subjects relating directly to immigration. 12. The Sun only infrequently covered events dealing with Chinese overseas. There were only 14 items of this sort in the sample. Naturally, the number of items on China (as opposed to Chinese) was very high. 13. This view of China has no doubt also been supported by China's extensive trade with Canada, most of which flows through the port of Vancouver. Laurier' swish to establish a market in China and Japan · has been realized. 14. Statistics Canada (1972:table 5-22). 15. See Appendix Ill. 16. The ' 'attributes" in this table are a summation of the subtopics and themes found in each sample, arranged under basic topic headings. 17. As noted previously, the Vietnam War was not coded in this study. 18. "Peter Newn1an on Watkins Report " (February 16, 1968, page 15; "Report Studies American Pawns," February 16, 1968, page 14; 1 1 ' Watkins Carries Message to U.S.," July 30, 1970; ' Thoughts on 11 Owning Canada, August 29, 1970, page 5). 19. "Americans Welcomed in Canada," April 16, 1969, page 5; "Brain Drain Helps Us, Yet We're Grumbling," May 31, ~969, page 5. 20. Recall that Indians were separated out from other native people when the moral community scores were generated. 21. \ 11 "Indians Protest Fee at Kamloops Meet, • May 16, 1969, page 2; " All B.,C. Ours, Indians Declare," April 1, 1969, page 2; "Time to Bury the Hatchet,'' September 26, 1972, page 4; "Indians Picket F~deral - 521 Building," March 1, 1969, page 10. 22. See "The Potlatch in Perspective," February,20, 1975, page 6: 11 Carvers Face a Bright Future," May 9, 1974, page 55: "Haida Artist Will Try Restoration," May 29, 1974, page 10. 23. This figure was given in the 1971 census (Statistics Canada 1972: table 1). · 24. See "Eastern European Jews in 'Precarious Peril'" (November 15, 1969, page 7). 25. There were also e. few items on the defection of Russian seamen at ,. Canadian ports. See "Russian Seamen moved to Quebec" (September 13, 1971, page 1). 26. The moral community code for immigrants in the Sun was -0. 72. 27. The impediments to the evolution of the press in the developing world a re both economic and political. For African countries the e stabli shment of a secure economic base for newspapers has been a severe obstacle (Sommerlad 1966:53). Once such a foundation has been built, another difficulty arises--striking a balance between "freedom of the press'' and press responsibility. A major difficulty has been that developing countries in Africa and elsewhere are almost completely dependent on the international news services for their foreign news (MacB ride 197 8), with the consequence-- that newspapers often reflect metropolitan rather than local interests. This has even been the case with the Canadian print media (Litvak & Maule 1974; Davis 1970; Butler 1976a). 28. Examples from recent years could be put forward endl~ssly. Bad press has seriously hurt the Jamaican tourist industry and has destroyed Uganda's international credibility. · For years, negative press images have hurt China's foreign relations (Myrdal and Ke s sle 1972). 29. For a recent exampfe, see "The Press on Mozambique" (Africa 1977). 30. From the point of view of the early Vancouver press, the Empire scarcely included Africa, Australia, New Zealand, or Britain's Caribbean colonies. Concern over social and political disruption in India overshadowed all of these other areas (Buchignani 1977:1-76). 31. It should be recalled that during the first ten years of the twentieth century, Vancouver businessmen had high hopes of dominating the J • - 522 - Etropean trade with Japan. By the 1930' s this focus .had shifted to China. By comparison, Africa had little to offer; it was too far away, it was a small market, and it was too much under British economic co'ntrol. 32. 260 items dealing with Africa were found in the Sun, but only 137 of these involved Sub-Saharan Africa, with the majority of the rest having to do with the Arab-Israeli conflict. 33. Examples were ''This Was the Speech They Wouldn't Let yo·u Hear" (October 21, 1976, page 6); "Racial Mix 'Bad Error'" (August_!, 1968, page 6). , 34. This sort of differential labelling,_ where Africans are associated with disordef-, rioting, and unorganized protest while whites are · associated with order, stability, and the state, follows the same pattern as the portrayal of black-white relations in the United States. The relation~hip between reader's views of Africans and American blacks is unknown, butitis reasonable that the similarity of their respecti've press images must lead to! an identification of one with the other. 35. Only 6. 8% of _the items on blacks in Sou.thern Africa showed them to be the victims of violence. This contrasts with a figure of 26. 9% of the items about whites. 3 6. April 2, 1968, page 15; September 3, 1968, page l; January 15, 1969, page l; April 16, 1969, page 7; _July 2, 1969, page l; October 16, 1969, page 37. 37. On the coverage of Amin in the world press see La Rose ( 1974) a11.d Nazareth (1977). Coren' s (1974) "Collected Bulletins of Idi Amin" is a fictitious satirical account of Amin, but it clos-ely follows the press stereotype of him. 38. September 7, 1976~ page l; October 7, 1975, page 10; November 5, 1976, page 1. 39. Only four onfi.e items in the sample dealt directly with economk issues. 40. In the ~ sample all of the items on Blacks in Southern Africa were to do with race relations. None could be called normal news. Only three items on Black Africans in other geographical areas were normal news. ? l - 523 41. Correspondents for the five dominant international news agencies are distributed in the following way: 34% in North America; 28% in Europe; 17% in Asia and Oceania; 11% in Latin America; 6% in the Middle East; and 4% in Africa (MacBride 1978). 42. The 1971 Census (Statistics c;anada 1972:table 1) gives 73.8% of the populf1-tion of rpetropolitan Vancouver as having been born in Canada. 43. Two items were coded with immigrants as the secondary ethnicity. British, Chinese, South -Asians, and South African whites each were ,found in one item dealing primarily with Canadians. It should be noted that this is indicative of the degree to which press concern with the relationship between Canadianne s s and Britain has de creased over the years. 44. One should not neglect the fact that in differentially characterizing and 11 11 evaluating all types of non-Canadian ethni_cities, a late_nt definition of what constitutes Canadianness is always being formed. I will return to this point in the conclusion of this work. 45. In all, there were two such items in the Province (1905-1914), none in World of the same period, three in the Province (1928-1937) and one in the Sun (1928-1937). 46oc By way of comparison, "Canadians" were mentioned only once 1n French Canadian items. 47. 3. 7% had a subtopic dealing with French Canadians claiming that they were restricted in some way. Only one item had a subtopic which directly stated that the French were restricted. This does not include items- coded under legal and legislative business .. 48. The Sun moral community code for the French was -0. 87 . 49. This tendency was also found in Siegel's (1974:65) analysis of the national press during the F LQ crisis. . 50. ... "Mother Backs Rose Brothers. My Children, Regardless" (Decembef' 29, 1970, page 2); "Behind the Unrest: Life of Poverty" (October 29,1 ° 1970, page 50). "Reb~l. from a Rtspected Family: A Nice Girl Like 11 Lise in the FLQ (November 13, 1970, page 15). - 524 Conclusion This thesis has 'sought to characterize how ethnicity ha1'; been partrayed in the Vancouver press. 1£ nothing else, the foregoing chapters !· have demonstrated how ::,_9P1plex that portrayal has been. At a concrete level I have· shown that the newspapers have always differentiated one f ethnicity from another and have generated reasonably consistent images of many bf them. Moreover, these various press stereotypes have been in- timately interconnected, such that at any one point in time they can be merged together to form a more general worldviev/ of ethnicity in the press. As such, as the portrayal of one ethnic group has changed, so have all the others, for to a certain extent they have been mutually defining. At a more abstract level, I have shown that ethnic portrayal 1n the Vancouver newspapers has derived from a complicated interplay of causes and constraints which have also changed through time. At no time has press coverage of ethnicity accurately reflected societal happenings, yet it has never been disassociated from them. Criteria for what is news, constraints of time and format, political con.side rations, and~ priori . notions of what constitutes normalcy and deviancy have all heavily influ. enced ethnic portrayal. • 'In retrospect, ~ e l th.at what I have done here may well have exceeded the normal expectations of a work of this sort in scope and detail, but it is my expectation that it will be those two qualities which will allow this thesis to contribute to subsequent research in the areas of ethnic relations and i.:/s 25 c.ommunications. To be sure, ·one could argue to the conttary. that the scope of this work is rather small--ethnic portrayal in one city in one country_in the world. 1£ understanding only that were its objective I wottld readily agree, but neither in its formulation nor realization' have _J had that .. as my only goal. Instead, I have sought to characterize ethnicity a~ but one element of the news. .,,_. As such, much of what I have said here to do specifically with ethnic portrayal applies directly to the more general problem of how the daily papers generate the news. 0 Similarly, I belie ve that in dealing with a • well~defined social context my analysi~ was able _more easily to move be·/ tween ethnic portrayal and current social issues than "would have been the • case if I had drawn my geog1-aphical sample more widely. As it is, to the degree to which press organization, context, or ethnic group elsewhere parallel those found he re this_ study' s findings should be extendible to other places. 1t I believe the specificity with which I approached ethnic portrayal in this thesis also has the potential to make a contribution to subsequent work, particularly on the relationship between the media and ethnicity in Canada. ' 1£ nothing else, no other study is comparable with it in either detail or the volume of data upon which it was constructed. What I believe to be of greater importance is the fact that because of its specificity it has outlined a representative, relative picture of how one group has been portrayed by the press in comparison with others at the same point in time. I believe - 520 - • also that these various analyses of group portrayal will augment both historical and sociological work done on Canadian ethnic reJ.g.tions. Finally, I think that it contributes· something to a greater understanding of the role of the press in shaping social strahfication in Canada. In this thesis I have dealt primarily with the newspapers themselves, as if they really were the final output of the newspaper industry. As I have mentioned in Appendix Ill, I realize that they are not the ultimate product at all - the ultimate and most consequential output of the press is to be found in the meanings which people attach to those prihted words and the actions they take based up~n them. ' Save for the limited instance of Sikh reactions to their press portrayal found in Appendix ill I have defined the analysis of the effects of ethnic portrayal on belief and behavior to_ be outside the bounds of this thesis. \ Still, I beli~ve that it is ultimately the most important question--one which is far from resolution. Despi}e the paucity of Canadian research in.this area, common sense alone suggests that ethnic press portrayal must act as ...- an unequally distributed resource it1 personal quei;1s for power, privile~e. and prestige. It is only reasonable that a stigmatic press identity is a much a · liability to aspiring individuals of that background as being portrayed as ethnically normal and non-problematical is to others. Moreover, I have ~ shown that in Vancouver (and presumably, elsewhere in Canada) this --- resource ha's never been disn-ibuted rand_s,mi'Y. Anglo Canadians, the - 527 - ( British in Canada, and a few others have rather consistently been dealt a ~ better hand than most, both in the positiveness of their own covezs.age and in the -selective silence with which the' press has responded to their deviant acts. Of course, this long term ~nequality in ethnic portrayal corresponds to patterns of ethnic stratification in Canadian society more generally. It is within this framework that ethnicity in the press becomes a social and moral question rather than ~nly a sociological one. In these relatively enlightened times I believe that very few Canadians think that it is right that an indi_vidual's access to the things he or she want should be determined even in part by that person's ethnicity. In any case, such a premise 1s antithetical to government policy and the law (at least in the negative case").:::·; Framed differently, whereas both Canadian mores and Canadian law stand mute to inequality based on class, to an increasing extent inequality based on ethnicity is being defined as immorai, unacceptable, and in certain cases, "7 '- -J illegal. The portrayal of ethnicity rn the Vancouver press poses a clear challenge to this ideal. More generally, the portrayal of ethnicity by the press would seem to be antithetical to Canadian unity; it c~rtainly does little to foster it. One need not be either 'for' or 'against' the persistence of ethnicity and ethnic identity in Canada to rec_ognize that the presence ~such a major social institution which makes invidious distinctions based upon ethnic or national origin is disfunctional to national cohesion and to a specifically pan- Canadian national identity . • .J - 528 - ( Appendix I: General Rules for Coding Topics and Subtopics As noted in Chaper 1, the potential problem of topic and subtopic overlap was eliminated by developing rules to arbitrarily assign events and attributes to one rather than another possible category. The following sections detail these guidelines in terms of the appropriate topics and subtopics. Each section also includes a headline from a news item re pre - sentative of that topic. 100. Housing and Settlement This category in':luded virtually everything about the housing of ethnic people that was distinctly an 'ethni.c ' story. include stories on discrimination in housing. it did not, however, These were classified under the topics " ethnics charge restriction, ' ' "ethnics are restricted," or "advoccttion of ethnic restriction." Neither did it include items on differ- ent housing customs, whi~h were classified under the topic II cultural differenc;es. 11 For example: BOARDING HOUSE FOR THE I-llNDUS: Building a't Corner of Granville Street and Beach Avenue rented from C. P.R. (Vancouver Province, November 1, 1906.) Subtopics:. ,. ( ~\. 101. 102. 103. 104. 105. 106. .•• are overcrowded ~ • .. cause high rents or house prices to rise ..• cause neighborhoods to go ethnic ••• housing is restricted or are denied housing . •. provide their own housing • .• cannot find housing _J - 529 - 100. Housing and Settlement (Cont'd.) 107. 108. 109. 200. • .. do not keep up their houses • .. cause overcrowding • .• other Education ( This category included news items relating. to the education and training of ethnics as well as to their impact on the educational system. Discri.rn}.oation in education, however, was included under the topics "advocation of ethnic restriction, charge restriction, 11 11 "ethnics are restricted, 11 or ."ethnics as the case might be. Lack of occupational skill items fell under the topic "empl~yment and economic activities. 11 For example: , CANNOT SEPARATE ORIENTAL PUPILS: City Solicitor reports against proposed move to City Council. Re solution proposed to request Act to be changecfin that respect. (Vancouver Province, April 9, 1914.) Subtopics:( 201. 202. 203. 204. 205. 206. 207. 208. 209. 210. •.• cause schools to be overcrowded Canadian children are held back by .•. children Special educational provisions are required or have been established for ... · ... in the educational system are costing too much money to the taxpayer .•. are educationally disadvantaged compared to Canadians< . •• make bad adjustment to Canadian schools •.• make good ~djustment to C"tnadian sc.hools • •• are under-educated and lac~western cultural knowledge (except regarding work) Suppor~ of foreign students other ' ,. "' - 5 30 - 300. H_e Jlth and Welfare . This catego~y includfnews items to do with the impact of ethnic - ' ,. ,- peoples on health services as well as articles relating to their own health and welfare. Discrimination was once again coded under the topics "advocation of ethnic restriction," ."ethnics charge restriction, " .• or "ethnics are restricted. 11 / .I For example: SLOWLY KILLING INDIAN PUPILS: 25% DEA TH RA TE AT GOVERNMENT INSTITUTIONS IN MANITOBA - TB VICTIMS (Vancouver Province, November 21, 1907.) \ Subtopics: 301. 302. 303. 3Q4. 305. 306. 307. 308. 309. 310, 400. • •• are a ha~ard to health • •• health is poor • •. health is good . •• are a drain on social services • .• are not a drain on social services • •. are on welfare • •• want health or welfare services . •• do not pay their shar~ of social services other ••. provide their own social services Employment and Economic Activities This category included news items about employment in relation to the labor market except those that could be classified as discrimination. Included in this category also were stories dealing with expenditure of funds and entrepreneur ship. For example: CI-Il.NESE TO BUILD SAW.MILL AT CANTON (Vancouver Province, January 18, 1905.) _J - 5 31 - 400. E;mployment and Economic Activities (Cont'd.) or: HANDSOME PROFIT ON REAL ESTATE - CHINESE MERCHANT SOLD HOLDINGS ON CARROLL STREET AND PURCHASED HASTINGS ST FRONTAGE (Vancouver Province, March 4, 1905.) Subtopics: I"' • 401. 402 . . 403~ '\__ 404. 405. 406. 407. 408. 409. 410. 411. 412. . . . seek jbbs . •. cause unemployment or take jobs cause lower standard of living for Canadian workers (re: work) . .. are needed for the labor supply .• .. work hard or are good workers • •. are poor workers or lazy ones; do not work hard or do not follow orders . .• are skilled workers • •. are unskilled workers other: (mostly trade soliciting - tariffs and markets) • •• are unemployed ... are employed • •• are or will be driving Canadian establishments out of bus ine s s \ ••• send their fuoney out of the country . •• are frugal and do not spend much ..• own or are buying up property or businesses • •• patronize only their own bu sines se s . .. employ each other ••• are a source of cheap labor (positive) • •. are in economic distress ( • 413. 414. 415. 416. 417. 418. 419. 500. Nwnbers ... This category included news items about the size of ethnic popu- ..__,,,-- lations, census figures, etc. All stories were included. except .those where m;mbers were subsidiary to other topics (as for instance, immigration, ' which would have been classified into the topic "immigration"). For example: .J - 532 - 500. Numbers (Cont'd.) JAPANESE !MMIGRA TION INTO BRITISH COLUMBIA--7, 589 Japanese ••• (Vancouver Province, October 15, 1910.) ____;f --,----- / Subtopics: 501. 502. 503. 504. 505. 506. 509. 600. •.. are of a certain population .•• are increasing in number • the re are not enough ... here • •. birth rates are higher than general population • •• cause overpopulation in Canada too many •.• will lead to trouble other Advocation o~Ethnic Restriction This category included news items in which ethnic restriction was specifically advocated. No other topic dealing with spe~xamples of the advocation of restriction overrode it. For e~ample: JAPANESE EXCLUSION LEAGUE WILL BE FORMED· (Vancouver Province, August 2, 1907.) Subtopics: 601. 602. 603. 604. ._ 605. 606. 60?. 608. 609. - ... should be barred from certain jobs or get less wages . .. should be denied social services . ••. should be denied rights of citizenship (votes, etc.) . •. should not be allowed to use conveniences, busi~. nesses, etc. . .. should not be allowed to do things in ethnic ways . .• should not be allowed to compete with either businesses ••• should be barred from immigrating • .• should not be allowed to speak lo reign languages Keep Canada White .._ .J - 5 33 - 700. Ethnics Are Restricted This category included news items that related to actual restrictions upon ethnics. . Discussions of legislative restrictions were classified under , ,_, . r, - the topic _"legislation, citizenship and"-legal business. 11 Those claiming that ethnicity restricted school performance were coded under the topic "education. 11 For example: WHITES AND BLAc;:KS NOT TO INTERMARRY. Order Goes Forth in Samoan Isla~ds Belonging to Germany (Vancouver Province, February 20, 1912.) Subtopics: 701. 702. 703. 704. 705. 706. 707. 709. 800. ... are barred from certain jobs or get less wages . .• are denied social services · . .. are denied rights of citizenship • •• are not allowed to use white conveniences . •• are not allowed ethnic ways • •• cannot immigrate lack of information or knowledge restricts .•• other Ethnics Charge Restriction This ,category included any news item in which ethn':ics charged that • they were restricted in t_heir access to rights, institutions, places or services. For example: .,. WOULD SUE TORONTO PAPER FOR LIBEL: DR. SUNDER SINGH OBJECTS TO STATEMENT .THA T HINDUS ARE SEDITIONISTS (Vancouver Province, January 29, 1912.) j ,_ 5 34 800. Ethnics Charge Restriction (Cont'd.) .. ... Subtopics: 801, 802. 803. 804. 805. 806. 809. 900. ••• claim that they are bar red from jobs, housing, or get less wages • •• claim that they are barred from social services • •. claim that they are barred from Canadian social . institutions . .• claim that they are barred from dghts of citizenship • •• claim t,hat they are not allowed ethnic ways • •• claim that they cannot immigrate other Ethnic Relations This category was very broad, and included material that could not be specifically classified into other categories dealing with ethnic :z.selations. Included were items on ethnic relations, relations with the p~lice, articles on assimilation, and the like. For example: LAW-BREAKERS ARE FOREIGNERS: Only FourNahve-born Canadians Prosecuted in Strike Zone. Whitehead, Secretary of the IWW at Lytton, Got Six Months \.,__ (Vancouver Province, May 29, 1912) Subtopics: 901. 902. 903. 904. 905. 906. 907. 908. 909. ••. organizations try to better ethnic relations . •• relations are being mediated by an external force • •• have good relations with the police • .• have bad relations with the police relations between and the larger society are getting better relations between and the larger society are getting worse relations between larger society and ••• are good relations between larger society and .•. are bad (French Canadian separatism in this, category, too) other .J - 5 35 - 900. Ethic R.elations (Cont'd.) · 910. 911. 912.. 913. 914: 915. 916. 917. 918. 1000. ••• are as stmilating • •• have outside support ••. and another group unite in action or concern • •• try to impose their ways on other part·s of society (includes Canadian language conflicts) .•• do not get along and. exploit each other • •• are a threat to the Western World pro-American investment of pro-Americans in Canada anti-American investment · or anti-Americans in Canada ••• bilingualism advocated ~ lm;nigration This category included all news items relating to the entry of ethnic peoples. Exceptions included the advocation of their restriction which was classified under "advocation of ethnic restriction" or discussion of ·immigration legislation which was classified under the topic "legisla,,tion, I dtizenship and legal business. " housing. 11 Settlement of immigrants was coded under 11 For example: RUSH OF ENGLISH SETTLERS TO CANADA.· ln·c rea sing Tide to Dominion Fallows lndu st rial Troubles in British Isles. Canadian Chamber of Commerce will adopt energetic policy of publicity (Vancouve.r Province, April 13, 1912..) Subtopics: 1001. 1002. 1003. 1004. 1005. 1006. 1007. 1008. there "I.s too much i.punigration from • •. are coming to the country in large numbers • •• are entering illegally ,, • •• arrive or will arrive • •• should be aided in immigration or are aided • •• bring over their relations or would like to a ••• is being deported . •• are refused entry _j __J 536 1000. Immigration (Cont'd. ) 1009. 1010. 1012. 1013. 1100. other Canada goes to or should go to ••. to solicit the 'right kind' of immigrant ... should stay in Canada rather than emigrate to U.S. A. make money on incoming immigrants Legislation, Citizenship, and Legal Business This category included all news items dealing with the discussion of acts oJ legislation concerning immigration or dtizenship. . It also <'. :-,., included evaluat,ive stories on ethnics I potentials as citizens and events concerning ethnics involved in litigation. For exampl e : INDIANS TRACKED WEARY MILE ON MILE. Graphic Description of Chase Given At Paul Spintlum' s Trial. Chief-Fernj.e tells of Trailing Fugitives through Wild Country. One Indian Witness arrested today to be charged with perju:r:y. Defense has only a few ~tnesses to call, it is said .•• (Vancouver Province, June 26, 1913.) Subtopics: ' . 1101. 1102. 110 3. 1104. 1105. 1106. 1107. 1108. 1109. 1110. politicians are· acting or urge the restriction of discussion of laws limiting .•. _behavior discussion of laws protecting ..• behavior . .. are in the courts . .. go to · the government to protest . •. make good citizens or contribute to the general good ••. make bad citizens or do not contribute to the general good discussion on parliamentary debates or government reports concerning immigration of ••• to Canada other (including Native land claims) discussions of language bilis in Canada _J - 5 37 1200. Violence, Hostility, or Crime Against Ethnics This category included news items about assaults, harassment, and derogatory statements against ethnics and their property. For example: T'WAS OTHER MAN WHO BROKE SWEDE'S NOSE. William Pierce, however, was fined by Judge Mclnnes £dr Assault (Vancouver Province, July 26, 1913.) Subtopics: 1201. ..• are assaulted or harassed in an ethnic-related incident .•• property is destroyed or vandalized in an ethnicrelated incident ..• property or per son is the victim of crime . .. should not do something or they will be met with force ... feel that they are isolated from others . .. are dealt with harshly by government and police . .. are dealt with leniently by government and police other 1202. 1203. 1204. 1205. 1206. 1207. 1209. 1300. ·Violence, Hostility, or Crime by Ethnics This category included ne_ws items about assaults, harassment and "" derogatory statements by ethnics against members of the majority population or against each other. '. ' ;For ~xample: AUSTRIAN SENT TO JAfL. Eighteen Months for man.who stabbed woman at Greenwood ... (Vancouver Province, June 26, 1913.) .eubtopi c s: · 1301. ••• as~ault, harass or destroy persons or property (except for 1303 and 1304 below) 538 - 1 J0.0. . Violence, H1stility, ,or Crim~ by Ethni-~s (Corit'd.) 1302. 1303. 1304. 1305. 1306. 1307. 1308. 130,9. 1310. 1311. 1400. .L,ssault,_ harass or fight\each other (or property) (except for 914) riots in the U.S.A. in'{olving demonstrations -involying ... in Britain or in the British Dominions ••• will meet (or meet) an imposition with force • •• are ho stile to other Canadians . •• are 'accused or suspected of crime • •• cause crime to increase other· • .• are violent ••. is being given capital punishment Cultural Differences This c;:ategory included all news items where cultural differences were central. For example: STORY HOW PETER DUNLEVY BRAVED THE INDIANS AND WHAT LUCK IT LED IBM TO. Johnny Walker of Nana.imo continues his story to Dr. Walkem. Trip to Cariboo in· Earliest Days of the Gold Rush. ~ (Vancouver Province, July 6, 1912.) Subtopics: 1401. 1402. 1403. 1404. 1405. 1406. 1407. 1408. 1409. 1410. 1411.· ... have different housing customsr . .•. have different eating customsfor food . .• have different morals • •• have different religious beliefs or practices • •• have different dress customs • •• have different working practices . •• differ in sanitation stan,dards or health, different medical practic-e_,s • • •• require special cultural provisions or are provided with them other ••• are unas,similati.ble •.• stick together - 539 - • 1400. Cultural Differences (Cont'd.) 1412. 1413. 1414. 1415. 1416. 1417. 1418. 1419. 1.420. 1500. I •. : do not learn English or speak it badly' . .. humor . .. have different concept of law . .. are learning English . .. are assimilatible •.. have home country loyalties Canadianne s s urged • ..• have be.st cultural practices • .. and multiculturalism Celebi-itie s Thls category 1ncluded all news items on ethnics who got into the news because of their status as celebrities. Such stories must have . contained reference to ethnicity. For t;xample: RUSSIAN. PIANIST AT THE IMPERIAL: Versatile Artist "t,o give Grand Concert on Thursday Evening (Vancouver Province, March 12, 1913.) Subtopics: 1501. 1502. 1503. ,.; - 15 04. 1509. 1600. .•• entertainer in the news .•. politician in the news . .. social notable in the news . .. historical notable in the news other Sports This categor·y included all news items in which sports were men- tioned in relation _to ethnicity. For example: BRITISH SOCC,ER SEASON WANES: Results Today in the Football_Games Played in the Motherland.· Many Draws and Postponements in Big League Matches (Vancouver Province, April 26, 1913.) .c: .J ) 1600. - 540 - ~ports (Cont'd.) Subtopics: Ol. 02. 03. 04. 1609. 1610. rl 1700. keep ethnic politics out of sports •.. . • • participate in sports . .• and ethnic-related sports controversy a Canadian wins over or loses to ••• 0th.e r boycott because of ... participation J Ethnic Organizations, Celebrations, and Events This category included news items on ethnic events, celebrations and ethnic organizations except those emphasiz~ng cultural difference, which were placed under the topicl'cultural differences;" For example: • CHINESE WOUL,.,STOP COMPATRIOTS COMING: Local Colony take.s Steps to Discourage other Celestials Flocking Here (Vancouver Province, May 13, 1908) 0-J Subtopics: 1701. 1702. 1703. 1704. 1705. 1706. 1709. 1800. .•. celebrate ethnic festivals . .. organizations ·take a role in the community ••. celebrate national holidays . •• organizations have sinister, suspicious activity • •. organize concerts, plays religious organizations help other Normal News This category included news material in which ethnics were featured .. prominently because of their involvement in otherwise newsworthy events. For example: J - 541'- ' 1800. Normal News (Cont'd.) • CHINESE TO BUILD FREAK STRUCTURE. Permit lssued Today for Thinnest Building on the Continent. Will be Six Feet Wide and Four Stories in Height (Vancouver Province, March 27, 1913.) Subtopics:· • 180 1. human interest story on • • • ~ 1802. • •• victim of eidents 1803 . . ••• ethnic ~akes good 1804.' ••• commits suicide or dies 1809. other 1810. tourism aid ..• ac I \ ) • . . • ... 542 J' / Appendix ll. I Values Assigned to Subtopics in Generating a Moral Community Score Subtopic Value 100. Housing 0 101. ••. are overcrowded -1 102. • •. cause high rents 0 103. • •• cause ethnic neighbor-1 hoods 104. . .• a:re denied housing Subtopic 206. Value • •. make bad adjustment to Canadian schoohl -1 • •• make good adjustment to Canadian schools +l 208. • •• are undereducated -1 209: support of foreign students 0 other 0 207. 0 105. . •. provide own housing 0 lil6. . .. cannot find housing 0 107. . •• do not keep up their homes -1 300. • •. cause overcrowding -1 301 •••• are a hazard to ,._ •. health -1 302. • •• health is poor -1 303. • •• health is good +l 304. . •• are a drain on serv1ce s ·- 1 • •. are not a drain on services +l are on welfare -1 307.' ..• want health or welfare services 0 108. 109. othe.r 2-00. Education 2-01. ••. cause schools to be overcrowded 202. 203. 204. Canadian children held back by ... children . .. need special education • .. education costs too much 210. • • •• are educationally disadvantaged 0 0 0 -1 305. -1 306. -1 -1 308. 205. Health & Welfare 0 • •• do not pay their share of social services -1 543 - 309. 310. 0 other • .• provide their own social services / +1 416. . .. patronize only their own business 0 417. . .·...,. employ each other -1 418. . .• are a :wurce of cheap labor -1 / 400. E~pl'?yme,nt & Economy 0 401. ... seek jobs 0 402. . .. ca.use unemployment 403. . .. cause lower standard .of liv~ng 404. · ... are needed. for the labor supply 419. . .. are in economic distress -1 500. Numbers 0 501. . .• are of a certain. population 0 . •• are increasing in number 0 . -1 -1 0 502. 405. 406. 407. 408. • •. work hard or are good workers +l . .• are poor workers or lazy • .. are skilled workers . .. are unskilled workers 50.3. there are not enough ••• here +l 504. • •• birth rates higher than general population -1 • •• cause overpopulation in Canada -1 -1 +l -1 505. 409. other (mostly trade soliciting) 0 ~ 506. too many . . . will lead to trouble -1 0 41 O. • •• are unemployed -1 411. .• .. are employed +l 509. other 412. . .. are or will drive · Canadian business out -1 600 . Advocation of Ethnic Re stri c tion -1 . .. send money out of fountry -1 ~O 1. . .. are -frugal 0 ••• should be barred from jobs or get less wages -1 . .• should be denied social services -1 413. 414. .. , • 415. . .. own or buy up property 602. 0 .......' - 544 - 603. 604. 605. 606. • •• should be denied citizenship . •• should not be allowed conveniences· • •• should not be allowed .ethnic ways . •• should not be allowed to compete in business 1t,709. 800. -1 80 l. -1 608. . .. should not be allowed to speak foreign languages -1 keep Canada white -1 Ethnics are Restricted 702. 703. 704. 705. 706. 707. 0 ... claim they are bar red 0 802. • .. claim they are barre«t. ..~ . 0 from social services 803. • •• claim they are barred from -Canadian social 0 institutions 804. • .. claim they are barred from rights of citizenship O 805. . •. claim they are not allowed to vote 0 • .. claim they cannot . . /! 1 mm.g #ate 0 0 806. 701. Ethnics Charge Restriction from jobs, hou-sing -1 . •. should be bar red from imm,igrating -1 700. 0 -1 607. 6~9. other ... are barred from certain jobs or get less wages 0 809. other 0 • .. are denied social services 0 900. Ethnic Relations 0 901. . •• organizations try to better relations tl . •• relations are mediated by external force 0 • •• have good relations ~th police +1 • •• have bad relations with police -1 • .. are denied rights of ~itizenship . .• are not allowed to use white conveniences 0 902. 0 • •• are not allowed ethnic ways 0 • .. cannot immigrate -1 lack of information or knowledge restricts. . . 903. -1 904. ' - 545 - 905. ~06. 907. 908. relations between ... & larger society are better relations between ... & larger society are worse relations between larger society & ••• are good relations between larger society and .•• are bad +l +1 910. • •• are assimilating ~ __;.., .. +1 913. 914. 915. 916. 917. 918. 1001. there is too much immigration from • • • -1 · 1002. • • _ are coming to the country in large numbers ' . .. and another group united in action and concern • .. try to impose ways 0 1003. • .• are entering illegally -1 100.4. • .• arrive or will arrive 1005. . •• should be aided in immig~ation or are aided + 1 1006. . .. bring over their relations -1 1007. • •. ~s being deported -1 1008. • .'. are refused entry -1 1009. other 0 101 0. Canada goes to or should go to .•. to solicit 'right kind' of immigrant +l 1012. . •. should stay in Canada + 1 1013. make money on immigranu 0 • .. have outside support 0 0 -1 other 912. Immigration -1 909. 911. 1000. 0 0 -1 . •. do not get along and exploit each other -1 . .. are a threat to the Western world -1 pro-American investment in Canada +l anti-American investment in Canada -1 1100. Legislation, Citizenship, and Legal Business 0 • •• bilingualism advocated 0 1101. politicians acting or urge restriction of • • • 0 1102. discussion of laws limiting .•• behavior -1 0 \. 546 1103. 1300. discussion of laws protecting ••. behavior 0 1104. ... are in the. courts 0 1105. . .. go to the government to protest 'I,. ► • , :I +l 1107. . . . make bad citizens -1 1108. discussion on government reports re irrunigration of •.• 1201. 1202. ... are assaulted in an ethnic -related accident • •. property is destroyed -1 •.. assault, harss each other -1 1303 • riots in the. U. S. A. -1 1304. demonstrations involving . • . in Britain or in -1 British Dominions 1305. ••• will meet an impo si-1 tion with fore~ 1306. . .• are hostile to other Canadians 0 discussion on language bills Violence, Hostility, or Crime Against Ethnics ••• assault, harass or destroy persons or property 1301. 1302. ... make good c1tizent 1200. -1 •· 0 1106. 1110. Violence, Hostility, or Crime 'by Ethnics " 0 0 1307. • •• are accused of crime -1 1308. • •. cause crime to increase -1 other -1 1310 • • . • areviolent -1 0 1309. 1203. 1204. • .. p r o ~ or person is the victim of crime . .. should not do something or they will be met with force -1 0 1311. ••• is being given capital punishment -1 1400. Cultural Difference 0 1401. •.• have different housing customs -1 . .• have different eating or food customs 0 0 \ 1205. 1206. . .. feel they are isolated from ·others 0 . .. are dealt with harshly by government and police 0 1402. 1207. 1209. . .• are dealt with leniently by government and police 0 other --- 1403. 0 . •. have different morals -1 - 547 - 1404. 1405. 1406. 1407. 1408. 1409. • •• have different reli-; gious practices . .• have different dress cpstoms . .• have different work practices -1 +l 1502. • .. politicians +l 1503. • .. social notables +l 1504. • .. historical notables +l 1509. other 0 . .. require special cultural provisions 0 1600. Sports 0 other 0 1601. keep ethnic politics out of spa rts ... 0 1602. . .• participate m sports +1 1603. . •• and ethnic-related sports controversy 0 a Canadian wins or loses to •.. 0 . .. stick together -1 -1 1413. . •• humor 0 1604. . .• have different concept of law -1 1609. other 0 . .• are learning English tl 1610. boycott because of ••• participation 0 1416. . .. are assimilatible 1417. . .. have home country loyalties 0 Canadianness urged 1419 . . . . have 'best cultural practices 1420. .•• entertainers -1 -1 1418. 1501. 0 . .• do not learn English · 1415. +l -1 1412. 1414. Celebrities . .. differ in sanitation or health standards 1410 . . . . are unassimilatible 1411. 1500. . .. and multiculturalism +l 1700. Ethnic Organizations, Celebrations, and Events 0 0 1701. ••. celebrate ethnic fes+l tivals +l 1702. . .• organizations take a role in the community +1 • .. celebrate national holidays +1 0 1703. I - 548 1704. 1705. • .. organizations have ..... sinister, suspicious activity _ -1 • •. organize concerts, plays +l religious organizations help +l 1709. other 0 1800. Normal News 0 180 l. human interest story on ••• 0 1802. .•. victim of accident 0 1803. ... ethni~ makes good +l 1804-, ... commits suicide or dies 0 1809. other 0 181 o. tourism and 0 1706. - 549 - Appendix Ill. 1 South Asians and their Coverage in the Press: A Case Study One of the principal difficulties which limits any analysis o_f newspaper content is that the ultimate output of the press is not the.printed . word. Rather, it is to be found in the meanings which readers attach to those words. In the realm of ethnic presentation this problem is further r compounded by the polyethnic makeup of the reading public. It is a virtual certainty that in such situations the same printed words will not meap the same thing to those whose ethnicity is portrayed as it will to those whose ethnicity is not. In this Appendix I would like to complement my content analysis of ethnic portrayal in the Vancou've r press by briefly outlining how members of Vancouver's Sikh community reacted to their press coverage in the first haU of 1975. I will then conclude with some findings on how these people presently view the press and their place in Canadian society. / . In January of 1975, press coverage of South Asians ros~arply above previous levels. suddenness. Some four months later it declined with equal Table CLXIII. shows the number and type of news items re- lating to South Asians which were found in a daily search of the Vancouver - 5 50 - January February March April May June July Total Topic Crime 0 1 3 2 0 0 0 6 Cultural Events 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 Disc riminat~on, Victimization 1 2 2 1 1 0 0 7 Colored Immigration 5 4 , 10 7 2 0 1 29-. Other Immigration 3 1 6 1 1 2 1 15 1 1 lL 3 3 77 Supportive Letters and Articles l l .!.Q. 4 , 1 Total 10 9 32 15 5 Table CLXlll. South Asian News Items in the Vancouver Sun (Ja_hu"':ry 1 to July 3 1 , , 1 9 7 5) This sequence b e ~ i t h a spate of articles on the theme that Asian immigration was the root cause of several social problems in the VaI1couver area. \ . Although South k~ns were rarely mentioned specifically, such transparent euphemisms l~'"the immigration of those of different cultures" "-or of those with "diffic.!1lties in adjusting to Canada 11 left little to the imagination as to who was the intended referent. This theme was expressed in several ways. Vandalism and minor , ~ ci:imes agains't South Asians were uniformly presented by the Sun as racial incidents. In virtually all of these ca~es of individual vandalism, name calling, and assault, the Sun tended to suggest that such acts were the inevitable outcome of the interaction of two fundamentally different cultures, / - 551 thus reviving a hoary theme in the portrayal of South Asians in Vancouver. As will be shown shortly, both the editor's of the Sun and the mayor of Vancouver w~re to use this s~me theme to explain what they saw to be the dangers faced by the city through continuing immigration. Provoked in part by the Federal Government's public review of immigration policy and .practice which culminated in the Green Paper£!!_ . Immigration (Department of Manpower &: Immigration l 975a-d), the Sun's direct coverage of this subject increased enormously. In keeping with its past practice, the Sun linked immigration to several current social pro- • blems, notably the soaring price of housing, unemployment, and the high· - cos't of government. During January and the first hall of February many Vancouver Sikhs were well aware that the Sun's interest in them had increased. Already considerable concern had been generated that the press was misrepresenting South Asians and was using Asian inun.igration as a scapegoat for soc_ial ' ills that were not of ,their making. Sikhs were not prepare<;! to agree that they were any so"rt of social problem whatsoever. Nevertheless, the- relatively low key way in which these topics had been approached by the Sun did not prov~ke any active response by Sikhs or for that matter, by other South Asians. A story carried by the Sun on February 20 (page 2) began a sequenco/ f or interaction between the press and local Sikhs which eventually resulted in national media cove rage. Capped by a large picture of a Sikhfamily . • . 5 52 - looking out through the bro! ...: 555 - • headline 'City.~grants Not Conc;erne·d by Racial Tension." On 1 .. February 6 (page 5)~ ~ Sun Pr:_inted an editorial on the .Oreen Pa~:r;- wJJich . justified the ','racist~! tone of· the C::-r~en J:>aper by reference ~ ~anada' s rac!ally biased past. -,Tlf9. was fcfllowed two ~ays later (page 5) ·by _another · editorial whicb was captioned. "Violence is a>ini.ng to our land ••• a Pe,r. . . . . . vasive, Individual Violence." The headline was taken from a speech by the -~ Prime, Minister wpich attacked racial violence. senfence o~t of context to legitimate racism. However, the ~ us.ed the Selective editing made "it .seem that the Prime ."Minister was making a prediction that fu~re racial V\9lente was a certainty. Many other news item.,...~ppeared which reiij!orced the belief that - ~ i g r a t i o n brought trouble with it. . -- On January 22~ the Sun's front . . . page ·headline shouted "East Indian 'Slave' .Racket Broken Here.-•·•- It was ·an.· accoun~ of an alleged scheme to bring immigrants illegally i•to the country.. In another full page i~em of February 18 (page 6), the Sun claimed that· there was a "Crisis in the ~ity School& Thousands Know Little ·or No Engli_sh. 11 ~gration continued to be news in March. of Vancouver On March 5, the mayor made a speech o~the aubje..ct in Winnipeg. The next day South Asian~ ~-s:Ubjecte~'t~ a page one headline which directly questioned their p l a ~ British Columbia:"~ . •• DRAW RACIAL LINE ON IMMIGRATION, MAYOR URGES (Vancouver Province, March 6, .page 1) ,. • . r J " I 556 . The only parts of the mayor's hour long speee:h which were pre,sented in the ' accompanying article were overtly .A;cist. Tlie mayor sug·gested that while "It is lau~able to have non-discriminatory poUci5s •.• it is a mistake if 4 . • . . • .. ., : . . ~ • . they lead to racial violence." Rather, "the cause of toler_AP<=:~ and br:otherhood can be better served by policies which recognize the realities ·of human _nature ..• [which are that] ••• tensions are increased if the rate 0£ immiroblems. ·• . • . ....-• . ., ,.,, Sikhs nevertheless had a ve'ry pessi~stic view of how other . '· Canadians viewed them. Whe~ asked whether other Canadians liked a r~nge of ethnic and national group..-,· ~ t themselves at the very bottom.of the list: ' GrouE ) ' . Score . \ British Americans Germans Italians French Eastern Europeans Portuguese Chinese Filipino West Indian Indigenous. People Sikhs Table Cl4{VC.t.. Table,. CLXVI 1. 11 1. 28 I. 40 1. 58 L64 1. 69 1. 85 2. 18 2. 19 2. 3 2.70 2.74 • Rank 1 2 •c 3 4 5 --. 6 ·7 8 8 9 10 11 Sikh Perceptions ' of the Attitudes of Other ' Canadians to various Ethnic and National 5 Groups . ' ~ , shows that Si~s were using a very consiste,:it "ideal ., • ( . '. . .-' :_.. , .' . . : . . : ; .· .. - :· · ;_ .. . ,type" .of ·a Caruldian: .yi _i_d eal ~c;lian is culturally Britis~ and.biologi.;. ~ ~ ...- ~ -- cally white-.. p .; . . : .. ~ - " •' · . In their view ~nyone diverging from ei~er of. thE!~e two· ; .. e.riteria merited less e~teem. Si~ perceptions that other Can~dians disliked therri was also affirmed . . . - by .their estimationl!I of hQw fre•q uently they had been the vic~iml! of dis,-' ..: crimination: _\' Experience Discrimination ~ - Rrequently. · Occasionally Rarely or never Total number ~ 45 34 ll 45.4 35. 1 18. S 97 100.0o/o Table CLXVil. Sikh Perceptions of Discrimination J • They were convinced t~t others believed very stigmatic things about them: -. , ~ Object to different Sikh behavior Hard working Ignorant, stupid Good people, like them Object to use of different language Cause unetnployment Object to .Sikhs on racial grounds Total ·, ' number .., JL 30 19 16 . ·13 30. 9 19.6 16. 5 13. 4 ""'·' a·· -a.z 6 6.Z 5 s. z 97 100.0o/o. Table CLXVlII..' 'Slkh Perceptions of what Other Canadians Think of Them What was tell'ing was where tjley believed that othe_r Canadians got this atigmatic view of Sikhs: .. .. I i' - 562 - ~ The Mo st lmportan1, Sour-~e ' of· Information About Sikhs ._- · •. / number . • 1 Newspapers " Ca?).adian friends . Dir~c~ ~gn~ct with other S i ~ 4, Television · Sikh ·friends Otlier • • I 41 -41-. 8 24 _ 24.-5 . _ 15. 3 -8. 2 7. 1 3. 1 " I's· 0 , . 8 7 • ~ ...l. Total Ta.ble CLX~. ' Sikh Perceptions. of the Most Important Source ·of Information....About Themselves ' ) . The newspapers were _by far the most frequent~y given response. · _Whether true or . not, -it is clear that even at this time •en pres~ coverage of SO\fth . ~ ~ Asiaps was relatively low, Sikhs saw the newspapers as directly cintributing to their stigmatic social identity. sitive to their press portrayal. They were manifestly not insen- This was no doubt partially so because a substantive nwnber of. them were active newspaper readers: Do you Frequently Read the Province or the Sun? Yes, t h e ~ Yes, the Province Yes, -both Occasional t-eader of one or the other No, neither Total Table CLXL. nwnber JL 35 35.4 20 19 12 1.1 20.2 19. 2 12. 1 13. 1 99 100.0% Sikh Newspaper Reading Habits The sections that they most frequently read were (in order)r the international and national news, sports, local news, the entertainment section, .t · 563 . -- ~ . ... . . edltor;fats, _lette.i,-s to ~e . _,.,. \"". , , . ,e~to!, ads, and feabl.r~ storie•s. -· . . ,, ~ -~"' . There was no do~t that ~ikl?-s·thought that of all the ~dia the riews~ .. •~- papers did the wql'st job of provir was present at this meeting~ This concentration was much greater among olde:r_: uidividual~. Dividing the sample in two at the median age-of 29, 68. 1% (32) of · the older sample were blue collar workers; 42. 6% (20) were u.i- . skihed. ' · · · I A 5. Respgndents were allow.ed to pick from these possibilities; Yes, Neutral, No, Don't Know. In order to create the scores in this tabl&1_a ",ve_s." re,po;nse was ~S'Signed a value of 1, a "neutral" a value o'f ' 2, and a "no•·, a value of 3-. "Don't Know" responses were excluded from the calculations. The score~ are the mean responses · - from the resulting sample • 0 • • • . ·. / ' . " • • ",-•- • • ,,,.__~ ... rI :. • \ . 566 ' " /;' ·11 . r- List of References , ' , I , • ·• Newspapers ◄ •. ~- -, ~ Vancouver Daily Worlci (l.':l05-t914) ~ . •. ~ .. ~ . .~ - ' . The Vancopve:i; Prgvince (1_90~--1914, 19~8-1937)- - . t . . ~;•""· ·-" · - "' .' . • ~, - The Vanco.uver.Sun. (19i8-193'7, l96T-l-9'7b) ..... , ' Articles, Books, . ~ ·: .. r ~ . . Die~rt=~o:s, and y~publi~~e~~ Pape~s - . Adachi, K. 1971 ~ r ,.. The Jap_ane~~- : In Strangefs ~ntertained: .A ~~tory of the . .Ethnic Groups in British Columbi~a JQhn Norris, ed., pp. 220-22~, V~nc~uver:- f British Columbia: A Marxist Pers,PFctive. In Essays in B. C. Political Economy. P. K ~ n d P. Resnick, eds., pp. 3-13. Vanc,ouver: New Star Books. ..,,,-- Riclunond, A. . ' 1967 Post-war Immigrants in Canada. Toronto Press. " Rischin, ·M. 1972 Toronto: University of - Immigration, Migration and Minorities in California: A Reassessment. Pacific Historical R_eview XLl:71-90. Rivers, W. L. and W. Schram " 1969 Responsibility in Mass Communications. New York: Harper & Row. ) ' Robin, M. 1968 Radical Politics and Canadian Labour 1880-1930. Kingston, Ontario: Queen's University Industrial Relations Centre. ~ 1972 . The Rush for Spoils: The Company Province 1871-1933. , Toronto: McClelland and Stewart Limit~. Pillars of Profit: The Company Province 1934-1972. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart Limited. ) - 579 - Rock, P. 1973 ~oy, P. E. 1972' / News as Eternal Recurrence. In The Manufacture of News. S. Cohen and J. Young,· eds., pp. 73-81. Triptree, Essex: The Anchor Press Ltd. ·, .· ~. The Oriental "Menace" In British Colbmbia. lJt The Twenties in Western Canada. S. M. Trofimenkoff, ed., pp. 243-255. Ottawa: History Di.vision, Natural Museum of Man. Rutherford, P. ~ 1971 The Western Press and Regfonalism 1870-96. The Canadian Historical Review LII (3):297-305. 1. _ · 1978 The ?14aking of the Canadian Media. Toronto: McGraw Hill Ryerson. Sack, B. G. 1965 W. N. 1976 History of the Jews in Canada. British Columbia Becomes Canadian, 1971-1901. In Hi,storical Essays on British Columbia. J. Friesen and · H. K. Ralston, eds., pp. 57-69. Toronto: Carleton Library. ~ 1, A. 1974 Montreal: Harvest House. . Canadian Newspaper Coverage of the F. L. Q. Crisis: A Study on the I~pact of the Press on Politics. Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of Political Science, McGill University. Silverman, P. 1970 Military Aid to Civil Power in British Columbia. Northwest Quarterly• 6(3):156-161. Pacific .. Skelton, O. C. ·1911 Reciprocity: The .Canadian Attitude. Economy ~:77. ~. Journal of Political Sommerlad, E. L. · 1966 The Press in Developing Countries. sity Pr.es s • Sydney: Sydney Univer- ... .. ,,... . _.., - 580 - . Stewart, J. R. 1956 French Canadian Settlements in British Columbia. M.A. Dissertation, Department of History, University qi British Columbia. Str,aaton, K. 1974 v. The Political System· of the. Vancouver 'Chinese Community: Associations -a.nd Leadership in the Early 1960's. M.A. Dissertation, University of British Columbia. Sugimoto, H. l;l. . _ 1966 Japanese Immigration, the Vancouver Riots, and Canadian Diplomacy. ~- A. Di9se·rtation, Department of Histor-y, University of Washington. Swnida, R. 1935 The Japanese in British Columbia. M.A. Dissertation, Department of History, Univers~ty of British Columbia. Tannenbaum, P. H. 1953 ·The Effect of Hea-dlines on the Interpretation of News Stories. Journalism Quarterly 30:189-197. Underhill, F. H. 1960 In Search of Canadian Liberalism. Toronto: MacMillan. / Vallee, F. and M. Schwartz Report on C:r:iminality among the Foreign-~orn in Canada. 1961 ~ Canadian Society: Socfological Perspectives. B. R. Blishen, et al. eds. , pp. 560-566. Toronto: The Macmillan Company of Canada Limit~ ( Ward, W. P. 1973 Warnock, J. 1970 White Canada Forever: British Columbia's Response to brientals, 1_858-1914. Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of History, Queen's University. • l All the News It Pays to Print. la, Close the 49th Parallel: The Americanization of Capada. I. Lumsden ed. , pp. 117134. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. ii ' . - 581 - Wild, R. 1958 Wilson, R. 1932 Amour de Cosmos. • Toronto: Ryerson Pre~s, _,. .... Migration Movements in Canada, ·1868-1925";- Canadian Historical ·Review Xlll:106-175: Woodcock, G. 1975 Amour de C98f'nOs. / Toronto: ,Oxford University Press. .......... Woodsworth, J. S. 1909 Strangers Within Our G.ttes. Toronto: ~esionary ~ciety of the Methodist Church, Canada. ) . . . . \ .. J. .