trhe Comr de. A \Vc>ekly ·Journal -·-~--~~ ...--·-' 21 Edited by· - Mohamed.· · ! ·! St.nd upright, speak thy thonght, declare The trnlli tlion l,a.,t, that all may ~ha.re. Be bold, proclaim it everywhere, The1 only li,e f!ho ~re I i -Mom,. Vot 7. i Siuile Copy No. 1, ~- Annu 4. A.nmaalJSub1eripti- -· Delhi: Saturday, January. IO, 1_9l4. lndlan Ra. 12. PoHip Ll ' • l onri,)f! D,...."'-"l'i>""" ·a...__ _ _.......,.. ·-· - .. A third nrticl() in th~ Time., pn the " Jndian ·Ped! " -cknl~ ll"_ith Page Na.( i".n11li,m crnpl1n~i:--i.ng tJ.,e P"ft !'.l11ycd ~_v '\,~.,,~tt:rn ell neut.ion ,liin Page . l Wl·J•:K Tnrr. SOUTI{ J\ l.'RIOAN CRISIS SUOII.T STORY- ... z ... l1 Syed Rahman · ·· 13 TErn .l. T1,;-r .;--+ ... 20 . lk,ul ur.iona Huunur: wlicic H onour is tlue ... f; Sir Hen ry ! Cotton's Apprc c \ation. Alignrb Affa!rs · .. . 6 -~ELEciTIONS-:-- Ci~is Britannicns-Ncw Style 'l'he :it nsleth Lc:igltc M eal The LMgo.e 11.nci . ite London. Branch ; 10 r,f . Nal 1on nli,-rn. I l liti .nrt1de udm 1,· , that amopg Cl\~l(j\r~ Uii'O,noo En!.:li ~li liter:!t1•s ill llnllia oremrn ?f wl,0111 m ig ht. be prou,I, 'l\ho ni Ut ) not _in('l:(:are and llrn1r ,rnfl i1ence_ l~ .d11111msh1r g in fo1-ts ,. ~re bf'111.~ m ri"rlo to ('llj'lnre Ppin ij>n fnr Ni1tionalist ·pn1'{Jnses. 'Ilhe . art i,J e deebres t hnt it i8 di nicnh. to fin tl s . trnceof the _real democi-at.ic ., ,;i ,ita11; nng tho" lilcrati, are n0t roprn,;e11l11tin, <>t lr~1~ia n-lii1ih l"t'ntai11s nn cs-cntinlly ur j_stl'OCl'atfc connn·.~ in I\ "".°."·C or ~.h~cb · Tirili,1, Prs lit home nrHI ir the r1n,11i11i,,111:1 l1ave ~•il'l,!;f -1 :'.~t ~no wl~tfie, S,-i11e uf 1111r mi~takrs in lii, pi<'Cl'S lrnti ,:v1 :1~nt~ erj r1 " princi pl,· cliori id1l'd by pi,lit ician. nt -l10111e wliv snppol't. d1i:a ~t>e_t1 ?ll. The artjeJe me~ti()ns 1'rif1C)li •~d th~ _DalkR01· wars · which ~t a.'!sisted ihe naHonal movement, rauung l\loslem Extmm111t1 to pow,.• r in the conn;;"Js of the cm~nmmity. South Africrtl} grienm!>-;- President's Address U11de1gra<)ualcs nnD1Citot1ot t , . day will l\rrire when the teeming ~ilJion~ of the nnPdncated wiU have to reftec, . on the tunrnltnoue forces latent .in r295 . milli"' .I: ,, beer, taught 1,neh hutrctl of the handful of Bri'tishers, and aueh 'disregard ol n11t!toiity, that they will offer i~luble · proulem in ;~~:at~~ .a.n~9i;l1e~~~ri~~sp::r . 'cb.:t.ro..~.~ :..e.gn'.·t•. ,~i. ·~.. ' ·· 'f . · . :·/.:./ if •. Governmen ,t. The vast mass of t i r e - ~ 1a totally aufit to a handful of literates mnet be the ftm of' the , . -~ ; · take part io self-government, lffit if . disaffected . it could make all ment. · If ·t he1 aucc_.ed in the aliea.tiW,i •,, .~ the: m...,._ l~Ja; Oovernme~t imposEible. 'lhe recent great change is due to the inwo11ld ,become nngo,e~~•ble, •~d.; it i1 . ett:t& ' ' ~bat &ll1/ -.,.,~le ' )'~f 1 . tervention · between Gov~f!ment and the ma88es ~1 a . ·small but weakenmg of the British G~~ernm.ot n_d. . . i-k.'!,fn": 11teadily growing di~a!Tect'M minority who ar;o devoting ·their slender . 1 • m.e nt mo~ ~op·c _wlmleflali! aliena. t ion.. . Q. . u rr .Ge1vm . · e ,r . n•• .•..- .1,,·J·,·· 1 • · · . · . • . · . • . · . · .. · . · .. · . · . · . , . -. ½ . .·:·.· :,.·:·.•.:. .L .·'i.fr, ednrational :equipment to misrepresenting the aims_ and results Qf (,~.:.politics• mnre witl~ ~nom~ )1111,t ~ .~ · .i' :••,::1~'.' Briti1-h rnl e 1111d sp,eading;, broadcast .the seeds of. d-is:iff,•clion. Tho and r . evcr11~ng the La. t in •. d Rge . ·:~rrlft ····: · ... go .· . ' ! . . . i tnt· . _ m . · . u~t . . · . . ". · •.· . ·. · ••. ,;. ' .. r·· . ' . ' ' ·' • , · . · ' . · · . • . · • · ~ . · , . i f1' " '' ' enc91fra1.;.~n,1cnt given to tha prnpn,oandists hy the i-naccnracies or enforce }aw and order, reah.-1p,I( tbar. ~•~p Qed ~e~.c ~?·. i.~ , :.:~:: wor,e of carefoss writers and spei1kers in BuglaiJu ·concludes the be crnel lfl the_long TIJD; . Thf'te; •re now N~tf .. Statfs Jli~flr ·.• ii •:< •rticl~, is incalculable, h.ight>r .stand•·a;.~ ·• ·. o.f eecurity t~an ·.aome :-13.. •· .t .... distnc,i_,.j,.; .• < hlgher branchd'. of dthamt.ion be' improffl), · :tecluliou ed1 -· · 1 : ,. . I• the de~~Mr ' an ::f rt·· ·.· ) ~ .n,::.r.6:~,. ·. '. ~oJ4L or •. -••~ i~nd,01101,,~ an? t . o ,-,i,.- • •a+r' b ·. ~· The. Comrade. 2 mu!lt be bni t. np, an(!. the prepo9terous mi,mse of English litera.tnre mm1I. be eli inatad. The ·jl1Jicid 11y,i,1.em nr ~entl,i.. needs overhauling .. The "rticle b,nph&si,i,es t.he loyehy engraim•d in the pt>11ples of India and. &dviseJ the G,iver.ornent frankly to explain ir.e objei:ts and firm,v to aJrni1frst-0r tht> Pres:t lain,' It 11.lso ad,·ise11 politidans and pnbll~ista a~ Home to t.be reasonable care t.o ascerL.Ain t.he truth. Tue great ~ueet.ion i,,. says tbe Ttwu,., . can . a democracy govern a vast E~,;ter 1 B ,npire 1 '£he rniu or progre~s of India depends on tl,e uns1t<'r, whid1 must be forthcoming in a fow yearli. Turkey. CoutantiMple, D«. 11. Geneu Li mat von S a n d ~ assumed the command of the First Tnrki~h Army Corps. \Vith ~fer,mce to the altitnde of the · Triple gnt.dnte, it is geueraily folt that the questiun has _ lost iti r.cutenes; a1~J that it i11 impr,,bable that. Ruil,,ia will insi,d... on fltrther a ltisf...:~illD,i It is thought. that the arraugeruent with Geueral Sanders m~y be moJ.ifitd in a manner which will completely close &he iocidt>nL Co111tant1naple, Dec. 28. The R~ssaiu and German Amblll.88adou jointly c11lh11.l upon the Gran-I V11/ r ye~terd&y to enquire rtt~1uJing t.htl progrt!SS of rtlforms in Ao1ia Minor. Turkish official circlt>e are optimi~tic, and hope tha.l the lU iter will ftl&l.lh & uti11(actory .,Htl<."ment iu & re" d11y~. 1t iiJ odi,~v,;1J liat the dtlllculty w,11 lw s,mu.,unteLi by tho Pune appoinii11g t1 -1 g 1r,1p,1:rn ln,1pti_~.t_n:11•Gu11er14\. for t)1e si~ Eastern Yila}til,~, th u ..1H'i11ltllg tho i"'s,nb1h~,,: uf cuntli-:t~ wh1d1 ~m6ht, r~1.rnlt !ro1n 1h,, tlj p ,ifllllHlllt of a aiu~lo .lain)pi:,rn auvist1r WLth OLtomaD in11pectol't4. R,ut,r. Pari,, Dtc. 28. 1 In a 11J1emeot before lhe Foreign Committee of the Chambers yttlertl•y, ~l. Dunmergue d"olL ou \111:1 i111pwui.uce of cotHiouity in fortigupsiliinJ, . . ~le •ffinn~ Ll1e ~om:1.rn11mt.'~ resol!e to fu~sue tL• line uf a.c,i 11n of 1h1 pre..i~dl,anrs 111 co-uperatrng with Unt1un and Ru~ilia. ije g~,e dt!t.a1l11 of t.he agreement which has just been conclndcJ ,•,rn l-'rance aud T11tk1:1y ns,mriug lit>cunty of F'reuch bd!' thtt 1 inl·tl··re:1t·.i,. i11. 1irtl d11J m ·,E,a.;.t. ,rnJ. rcCLHlUte,d ~ltl:I !ll,··i.l··S.dl'e:. tukeu.· co1Jtructvr1 tc, .Ue.•vclup Fn·nch en! Syria. He mt111t1uned tliat Freuoh bad 11 bt.iu .Sa prum11ot1 for the l.JL1i1Ji11g' of iml>Ortaut uilw•Jl! iu Ar111euia auJ Syria ovor 2,400 kilumdre& long; nlso fur the cun .. tn cti,,n and exploitation of ports Jatia, L'ni!fu, aod Trip,1li 111 ~yri111, anJ llt1r·a da:,, and lia1b,1li ou the . Ultt.l'k ~en. He poiutt•,l ouj ,1,.1t dtt: Frcach c.111irnl i11r,:st.¢,l iu Tnrkoy a :11,iun1cJ i.c, 3,00U 1f lli,,n fr1,us.:sj heuce tlaJ Frc11cl1 l.h,vcrnun·ul cuuhl llut ?'t"llrni11 iu,l!!Tur,mt to \he dt!~huu.mL vf 11c~~•r.J iUJp,,rtuut 1,ru1ri1,ceJ1 ftum th,; fi.11pirn.-Rtultr, Anat 1J li11. at Aegean Islands. I ThLl f1hile Alliance hi\., n,)t r1'lplied yet lo the British propos&li l't!guJ.in~ 11io .~1•1,;ean l~lia111.b1 antl Al\rl.'Offit'a New Urot,/s ceutn:,i d iuces,,~ut agit-.liull. Iu \lC~ of the di~ts:,iiQo proctttling ~tween tlw Po1ter11 . on the ,ub j,•ct ,,ii thi! pr"["h~~ r,,..;udla),( Lhe dh1t!i•111 of :ht! At•g.-11t1 J-\,.u,b, 11,,, P,)ne li.o,s tirc11l•ds,uJ th,1 l'D1Jt•n1, 11,ti l'unc."~ ,-1,u:1,lp•>i11!, irnd ,·mplu1,,1,i111~ 1ha~ a. s"l\\(lull 11i,.id1 JI,,~ Tt'lHPrr lti,) l,bmds J.,i:1ug Llie A~i .. titJ L.'uli.lit, wdl Li.J •l>~11lu,dy un1.~nT1"b\<> t,) Turk~y. ~ R/Jme, Du. 1 :i. lt i, •"'1,,,.,,,m,•r.111\· annnnnl'.t'd that tbt" lnt,' rnatio1rn! C(lmmi~l1d11111!,H1011 uf dtt\ t::,,utltc\rn Fr , 1,t,. r ni a\lc>i\111 .. lu.,; ,ion :, r C..mlluJ,,,i l:1lh1H' ~. ,u_lil,i ft>1S u1,11111i.u1,•t.'siy, '!~'''"_,',•.' to~,r,,1 .. ,,-eJ IU cv11fvnuity "ith the l'i}-wa c !L1.ty irnJ .A'\lotri•b,· lirdll liUIJl41HJ. 1 ' URJ101\, Dtt, :2J. R,,nt.:r tli!\t Gr~~ce is @,till· oflicially nna,ure of lhiti,h prop ,cc,l, , 1,~ .,,[tn:,.: Allkthili 11Ihl lite :\t•,;dUL h is pa,nted 011t 1(1 Gne,·k q "' i,· -,. tl1:.t tltd pr»;ld.Sd~l S,)dtln·ru li,_nwJctry g.1e,s .-\ ll•IA[Jl4 Hll,ll\Jl.l lt1:t·•t'k,; ,, 1it vf II t.Jtal uf 2:t0,UCO. . L Bagd.:id fa:.lway. 'I ,,t' I'iJ•,t: ', Lnrd,.rn c,:,rr~p-)ndent l'&iih•,; : 1rup.li'.i ii,, d :11 ~·.. 11 t1,p1•rhic-11~ 1l , ,1J .. ~.:-, r.J10~ tu L ,:., ..1,,;,- ;it ·' li lt' t!, !t"·: -· n1111>, _., ,,1 ·1!,u'i.:,n ,-;id1 r'<".:u·J l;,:,i,,S ", :,·, rl'f'''·"'l hy ti,., \;i.r ,stu1eu p,-,.,~""""' 1 i, •~Jl,c,i COlatr1t..'c. ••B d Li.,s•:·" m,!{iit have 11.e~irnt ,l 1 ax,; !Ulj -u rLl!i!IL J 1t! r rt' U\'t'.ili ,,I "l i,,i ,n1 o l• ' d ,e " \i,i;rli->t.tr •• :3dJia au.I thll di.cu»rnu on this 111•\ter wiU uu, L"<• rt: .ci:u.:'1 b-d!vN Ll.io un, J~•r. ·• Egypt. The first~tions. to the N w Legislative· sulted in a BWeeping victory of th!e Government. Opposition canditla.tes w,•re succesrfnl out or_. _•.... pltu members nominated by the f'overument. • T,heran, Dec. 2(1 Persia. 1 · It is nnder:.tood that Hnssia ibtends shortly to withdraw a con siuerable _uumber of troop~ from N°(irth Persia. Persia has agree~ to increase the Persian Cossack olrigade at Tabriz from sif hnudre4 w twelve hundred wi-th lour Russian r>fficers and eight 8-nssian noo.L commissioned officers. , . , .Allahabad, Dec. 2'i. I . . . · - . Imperial Delhi Committee. I I , I The report by lhe lmperial Uelhi Committee showing the proigress made io connection., with thb afbin1 relating to the new capital 1 has j111H be-en completed. ~The p oject estimated by the Enginee~ is also practically ready. Turkey and Greece. • Landon, Jan. ~. Reuter learoe lhat Greek offi ial circles are in no way perturbt>~ tn-er the purchase by Turkey of d eadnought which waa being built fdr " Brnz. I, as it will not b!' rt'ady for six. months 11ud Groece will ha~e pletH) of tinrn tn cnn,,ider lwr CO\ n,e ,.f 11c1inn. Conficlmice is exprni,~ed,_ lio,pivn, that the Grc\,k Go1·, rnme11t will not sliri11k frnrn any actmn necessary 10 rnsuie the f•1u11try's safoty, . The posi,illility i• l,iutetl at. of Gree-ce declaring "lllt; on Tnrkey in order to prevent the ves~l lea,ing England. Accord! ng to diplomatic upiuion, the iucide1iL ffil'IJ raii;e, in 11n acnle lurm 1 tl1e whole qurs1h,n, of the ciieposl'1 to other nation of the powerfol warships ornHer, llpe:i.kinl{ i'.1 Parli1unC>nt to-da~ cnnfi11111:d. tlte p11r-:lul•<;l ,,f the: dr,,ad1tn11ght by Turhy. Ho wi,; uuul,le. 10 rnf,1nn tire Hom1e u t,~ what st,•p.>! Uo,1emme1,t \fere tl\kidg or hi.J already tak, n to t>H;;t1re qr~lc ~up1e111a1:y in the Aegean. l~e could ouly a.i;,rnre tlie Chaml.J.er that Greec,• was dett•riuined t,1 rmtiO.tai11 ht•f i!t1premacy and that! the Gnek t1111Y11l authorities were alJg,.Jutely Cltllll, l•'i,111\'1.\ is Ml!ti",118 cn·i.>r the pnrdu,,:e of a dn•aclnnt1gl1t 'l\'hiGh Turkey lrns ltt>Cll ~n;1l,led to l1e,.111 1r1~; tha1ik~ t,, 11 L,uu ra,,,eJ iu Frt1111.::e. 'Il1ti "1\nups'' suy, that Turk,·y 'do,•~ not cnnt:rnl lirr intl'utinn tJf cl,dt1riug ,rnr on U ·,·ci.:,t in April nm! urge,; thtJ du.sing uf BriLi!lh aud French mnni•y nrnrkds to 'l\11 key. Hui du ,J,.111inu: A ~:m\ -,,lfo:i,il i:ommuniqur. atatc>1 t!rn~ Brniil WjlS _110 pal"I) li) tlie s11I,) 1>[ tlit, ·•Hiu (h• ,la1Mcr11'' tu Tnrkn, a11d 1 tlie liui! Ll,·ri.. 1He t,i snp!'IJ i11rnd it:r drn1dn, ,11ght to Br~zil. V1ubA,l 1ui ral HmiLt,at:ellar !I1ts Leeu 1ure,;ted fur 1.1 u11 ii shi11g a lt•tter critici ■iug G,nt•ri,rm·11t's 11ctio11 in part ing with the ·• [t.,j 1lc ,Janiero." l'on.stantiunph·: Tb 1ugh the '! urkish J){ll)ulation iH generally md1 tin• p11r1.:i,a,o ,,f the Brnz li»n Llr,.:ad1i11llght fill!lm·i1CI cireli>,1 are pertnrl>t~t The Ottoutan st.,,ck J.a:➔ . dr11pp1•d • p1,int. a~1d tltt! 1.111 1,.. i1,twt.'11t "' E11n•r lit-y a,1 .'llitL~ll'T uf \Vitr is llaruly 1,u11thing. Con:,tunrinnt,lt! : The Yuu p,B' t11rk, Enver B,!y, luls b~n •p1H,i11tt1d M111islt·r of W IH, ll)il Culu11rl l>jumal lfry, .'1li11i.;tur , f \\',.,t~. • L',,1,s•,111li1wf-l1,'. : I, i,, ,;i,d " i tlut tl 11; tlr,: Hlri o ll:{!l~ "ltoi !;lo ,Ji.11 .. ri >'' l\t.,.t t ,.., b,v:l,1,h,p •· H,,.,lt ,,d i, •li" ,~!- ,, b•~iug- l.iuilt at A11u1>tr1,1:g_'b 11i ,I be- 1n1, IJ fvr in bix ni1H1th,;, ha, 1 The South African Cris1s. rll'lvl i'll ( 1;,.,1,.,l1 ('o!tt,,,b 1ti)' .rfr. ~trnn~ ~~riLiei~fr1~ h&\'t~ l,t't" t, t~. ?·,J's,-.,·d uu f.t;,: l.h11ui i, i- •11 i,r-dcr 1 ~o- ,,i 1.rw;r.ln! 1tml Ld1, ,11n·r!! 11111H M1trcli 31st. lt 1-1,,k,., ,w,h,,!_:1>,l 1l111t tin, 1w·nsnn•.. _w1<,id,•s:l.{ticJ 1u prevPnt • gl111 i11tin· bhllll! 111:.rk.et and r,•iit'l·e ,1;-i;"1t"r;::r,1 jnimi41a.1i,.n ,.r.,{,1-tn. It .tl,e <'!ltfJ' 1,f w.,r~1n,•11 ))ni,n .-\11;;tr1.li.i1 a/id l11t' tll!ry Xi:,. lt1., ha.t,b u .,team~r, tH1ti:,r b1 I ,. J,.cm,i,m, D1.•e. li9, Thi' rdt,-.se of ~[essn. Jandh,i, Polak, and IC11,llenhd1 ,_ c.,.,.tir1u~f •f Ul klln,i,:·Q: tu p,,s,..,M no 1111!t•A~io.1tic Hajj , Unle,11 tli!' Gf,l'U!J[1 1l'IH aet't'died hr ;Lia, 11rup,.n,•l, it "u iutp(;,.~iu li!: to 1m.:tpl t~e C,,1nuii_,siun or iU> i ( The Comrade. 10th January· i i 'i .. ! A meeting of Indian women at Jo a~nesbnrg pa~ed a. . re11oliti<>9 , requesting Government to accede to he 1ndian..,qem1nds , and :u~ng the leaders to irersevere . tn the bi ~te~ end. In an interview 1'ith . Reuter's represenlfttirn reRarding tl1e iarticle in tl1e ~ ]Mr, Gandhi ~aid nothin~ was furll1N t'r<,nl liiH- wish .than to gh:e the letter:; the f?rm of an ultimntu•.111. He hnd 1 nt the slightust \.whih to emba~.•ras_s· -: the (,o-,,·emmeot. : . _: Nagpur, Dtar before the Co :mnission on their bdiali. lfo ~u\J,t f at '. )n:-r for Durban to :rrive in time for the next rnet'tiuc:: uf tlll· Cqmrmg~wn on January l.,th. h · will ht· r~c,,Jlt,eted that Sir B. Roherts~n. 1ield the post ,Jf ::3,,,.-r,·rnn, and offici:1frd as member of C11nnc1l rn,the C,immeree and [ndn,t~Y Lltlp1nt11rnnt fwm 1907 to 1911, and has, therefore, ~·illl ko•.•~\~lge Indian grie•an~ in -South Africa .. : Pi'ettnnarittburg, Dec. 22. Mr. G.andlii',, iwift> and three other women passi 1e resisters were wlt> ll:c-ed fr ,, 111 ga1,l this m,•rning. They were pulled through the iown in earri:i.g-es ;by entbnsi:istic Indians, :\lr. Giu:dlii, i on arriYing from Durban,. 'Vl'IIS garl11ndcd and rnn~ratnbted. J:n his rt'}'IJ·, he urged Indi11os to eschew l11x11ries as 3 ::-i~n ,,i m"urn 'l ng. A.Jdre.,lling a larger meeti11~ arte1w11rds, ho o:1&iJ that llurl•an ,ludians were more united thun eYer:~in their deterruim\ti"u t,, i11sih np,,n the ·1 emands formulated l\t the meeting on Sun,!,\y. Tlit> 11111eting endDrsed the ?.PS~lntions pa~sed at tl10 Durban meetin~. irnd tlt•ci ?ed to prosecute the pas.11ive ~esistance movement uule,-;; tht! G,,;-ern~lll'nt yielded. s\ tl'!t•gram from _ lJnrban stat.es that a cousin and son of Mr. G1rndhi auJ l'ight iothe't' p&s~iYe resisters, who "'ero Arrested for cro~eing the Tnrnsrnal liorJt'r on 8£>1 ,tember 16th, and iuititttiug tho present. c1u1q,ni~n, \H'rt' relt•!L~ed to-dlll'. Th;, l'up, 1'i11lt..~ says that the requ~ts of Mr. Gandhi and others fornrnbtt'tl at the !rueetiug at Durban, though rell8onsble, constitute a c, ,nrtt'l•llS ultiruatnm, and the journal ur~es Mr. Gandhi and his collt>~gue~ tu hesitate before committing tl1emsehe$ ·to acourae . which will :ilienate symijarhy in South Africa .anq orersea, and appears t-0 iWll lit ernbarra.s.si~g' the Gornroment. · · ! . Durban, Dec. 22, The ltllli:m· l!•aders hani written· a lotter t o the Go1·ernmcnt; fl:.'C.i.pimlatiu~ t\n•i,· dt•ffitllllls, Firstly, they ask for the 11ppnintflll'Dt of t he two Ut' W 111,:>n;\,hsoi tiw C L>lll1llissi o n preieral,ly Sir Jame,1 Ro1w Innei a.ud ~L'llit,,~ Sdm·ht'r, secondly, the immediate releast' of the imprisoned 11••~1,,• r,•,-1~!t'r~, , and thirdly, freedoi'tJ. for the }t,adt>rB to ,h1i~ tho ;'.1::,1r t',t,1t~,; irnd cnllit>r,ies for t1ie J.>Urpose of cnllec•iog nidence. lh t' letkr poi11t$ pnt tl ,iit. while the finding of 1},e Comrnis,,ion, if eolsr?,:t>d rt., ,n~~•'4(t>d, "ill b;, accepted &8 finally !H!ttling the diiatment of the 8triker'8, thu C ommis~'"1' ~ rc-t ,.' ll11m•r1-li}t1,,us r<"_1,;ardi11g the original griPntnce.s Wlll.. not. ~.._, l.'l c't:t'\'l<"-1 l,y thunudtiity in derngati~. it.q :.-demand, it:tt,·r ~,.n,·l\1,l,•,; l>y rt•it er~ting thl\t failing co plianct' with ll tt·: r :kma r1cL t1s :l,·,,d,•rs tliey will not eountt>nance ,: r even by · 11 ~ : ••! rt·tnb1t i- ,ni tl:e pa,-;,in, ~;;istanc-e morement will be resumed anJ _lud i,11;; wi:i 1)1t1rd1 acmts the Transrul border toward;i Pretoria Frt-1• ,. u, ly. It i~ ex pt>t·ted, bowenr, that the man hers ~ill b.i much ni-:r•_• nuc ,• r,-' u•. the leader-s -..~rtiog that from ter> tu t1'eh·e lhouaand .,. ,,l tak e' 1,:itt. : - t,f ~he ; LmtdO'ft, D« . .28, l l1:rl -n11 Ji. ftr- rnry ~•Y" that th~ Governm,nt 1rn11ld lose nothing . t·,lrn!l'.~"u by c,~uceding the dnuaud for the enlargl.'-. t!:t• L , -11;11, 1,.:,il) II 11s ~u gg.-stt'd by t}1e Iud:an1 aud for the L: ' r., i ::_ i, vf tl1t' p,\_•si; iv~ n•i;istns. But illwuld tl1" Gon•mment, r•fllM!., t b, l tiu ,,1u s ,., d,~ t.t' wi !!e t,, g in• their evidtoce bdure U1l' C1,n1mi&1 ' cf : th;; G t,~unumit of ludja ee1~diug Si.r Btnjatwa ~;·,.:·. . ::~·tt .\ _t " n1<, ,t io g l d thr Indians in London, pN'tided our b7 Sir nd ~" ,cr:cc 1:1.a ~n•gr~, a rt'sol•t.it1n --nrginfl t.he Imptrial •t•; er_tt,,~ 1H h 1 ~H·nrt' the appointment of n>pN"HntathH of JodiA ~ &etl ,r t b ;; llllf~ria.1 GHetlllll•a~ oa lM Cc,am~ in SoalJa Mrioa. Commiss . ner during. lus ab_s~.: nce is n['ow under consH·•D , u.•ler~:::: De~ .•..fl 3.~ In an interview with Reuter·s rep esentati\-e Mr, Gandhi totally. repudiated Urn allegation that tho agitation in Natal was largely fictitious, and had beeu engineered by disloyalists in India, who wanted a pretext to enlbarrnss the G ,•rrnmrnt of lndia. Hi11 best helpers, he said, were Em'op•:ians, mo ,tly British subjects, who knew the inwardness of the struggle as fully as himself. Ir the Commission of Enquiry found him guilty of com~licity in sneh criminal folly ¥ was alleged, he wonld undertake to r~tire not only from the movement, · but also from Sooth Africa. i • · i Durban, D,c. 24. It is reported from Vol1csrue~ that thirteen; male and three female Indians have been sentenced three months' hard labour for attempting to cross the Border. l . ' On the 23rd December, His E~dlleney the Viceroy, replying to the joint address of the Associatioos ;repre~enting the various IndiaD· communities of Calcutt;a, said : · : · As you knowAthere is at ·present one (tronbJeiiome problem) which· we all feel deeply, but for which I am still hopeful that aii equitable solution may be found, and I fed that I ought to take . this uppo"tunity of saying what great impprlanco I attach to the recognition by the leaders of the Indians South Africa ,of the Commi■~ · sion appointed by · the Government !· of the Union. The fact that. • · public and jndicial enquiry will be h ~ d by a Conu;uiesion of whoa tho President is a ,Judge of A Pileal and unh·er1:1ally esteemed and respected to iovestigate the allegatiotje that havo beeb made, to enquire into their causes, and to make recom,;nendatione, presents an oppor,;, tnuity that the Indians have not had l before to snhmit to the verdict. of the world the justice of their griev~nces. I cannot urge too strongly upon the leaders the urgency of atcepting the I CommiBSion and off setting to work at once to prepare1their case for 1ubmi88ion to it. ,, to open in 1 · AN AN:uous I PnoBLBM. · The Golfernment of India feel suob deep-interest in the reenlt of this Commission that we have appointea-a/ distiognished official, Sir Benjamin Robertson, whom I think tj>an,y of yon know. to . be preseilt before the Commi88ion as the representative of the Government of India. --4'his is one or thOtle anxioul!l problems to which I have jut -niferred, but .. all these difficulties ahd problems :m~n a• just . and right adjudication bet,,.een conflictiqg interests, in the decision el which, in the Tery nature of things, 11atisfaction : cannot be gi,ea to all. But as in tbe past 110 in the :fiitnre tL will : be my conet&ni · end\)avonr to bring to my task a spirit of fairnetl8 11nd jwit d84ling with a true sense of duty and re•po~aibility ; and if, when I come , .to · lay dd'wn the reio@, I ci.n feel \lbat·your stnt•menta oootinlile be such aa th088 you line expreesed ~o-day, I shall ~odeed be a happy •o man. ' , . I.Durban, Dec, .t4. Tho GoYernment ha.s rejected Mrl_ o_andhi'• dem~_inda for Lhe aiddi- or .- tion reprftenl~ti,es of Indian intett!81..& of tlte }fat.I Commiamob ,nd for the rele~ ol all the impri&-0~ed panire reei~«if'II. ., ' ~oria,.J),c. 24. Replying to the letter of the Indian - leaders to i the GoYeromel(i recapitulating their demands, General Smnta aaid hie waa unable to accept the conditions under which Mr. Gandhi •~ . bia colleagua propoeed lo _ give ev-idence before I the Commiasipn and ao,~Jid _ ! pagire ~i!!t~nce ~nding th~ c 1mmilll'ion'e fin~ing1 particol~l,y the ron,d1_uon. mY'oln~g the appomtmtnt. of addilioa~ meiaben of · the Comm181110D 10 the 1n_tereats of the ~nd1ao comD)no1ly. , The Commi&llioo waa intended to ihan arf · im~ial and jnd~ characlM, io constituting It, the Go,-ernmeot ~Dlll}ted oeiUwr lhe Indian co onity; the co.I dwoena. nor Uu~; 1ogv pla.ntcra lo Natal, nor could tli GoTunuatoi, fot a lD<)meat. CoUo" lbe eoarN propc~ which woul ,gi ,e colou.r to Qbltananted .Liou upon &wo /; of lhe ruemben of the Commil&ioo. : 'lhe cou.ne propoeed bJ the lettet, la -~ Hell\ ill the Oo1eralnflllfa aon~C>OmJJliance:, wu ~ l J ~ t e d , ~' t· 1-.d ila,,._! 7 io&en.t . • of · t .. he . _ Iodiao oommua . i&1_ •~ . eoold .. , .a _ .• • .. · '. · be _ p n,fc,aMI.: ... affedecl by· the Jul- , chanetft\ of . UM prooe4an_ ; tJiJ, (11:ratoitoaa Ioffid.ion of ..,..,. oa · · · I ·f'OPM. bit Wlii .... aod l ~ a.od &he OODNq~ll • ' ., , . . . . . . _ nff...,_ io . !· a·. ~ u > . UtuoD. . ·! • -. ,. · ~ ·, , ~ ;. .f" r-:·',· .•--•••:.;,:.• ;:1: r:-i';~},J:js: i . 1 1 ;·r. Mr. G ndhi and others telegraphed yesterdaJ to Lord- Am~thill declaring ~hat the people are so indignant that. an atWmpt .is made to advise the acceptance of the present commies i1)n , they w1U kill their I+aders . . "Unless there is very prompt a_g itat on i.o England.· to aupport. four deman(l.s," says the telegraw, "the Government . is not , likely to ~ede to them." lo an nterview with Reut.er's representativ_e regardin~ General SmulB'B r!eply to t.he letter of the Indian leaders, M.r. Gandhi s~id f rather farcia.l e. p·. e·io -.its us 1al _.·so.•1· emo . fn.· n.·•·e r·•l-lik.e to. ne,·•· .. h.e Right Hon'ble , gentleman nd . his faithfnl · oolleagnes li ve taken~thi!5 step, we are told, 11 in respi:H1se' to the telegrap appeals -and resolutions"' of_ the United .: Provinoes ., Leag e. the Punjab League, · the Mor dabad · League ; and other organ~sat tions in. lndi . ·a an.din, view of. the:_ delicate qn.·: es.'tioas that \.·•conf.r bnthe Mussalman Community." The average ;mind fails t ,o under.: stand the natu.re 9_f the ''. el. ioa , te qu~stion,.s _: that ·. c_onf.? ont /the he had p+at.ely com1nunic~ with the· Gov.ernment. and thought - Mnssalman Community," wh1c~ 'were evidently not m ex1sten~e a. t.aat a W'~J out of the deadl~as po:i8ible. The Gof)rnment m_o.ntb ago, when these gebtle.Iflen, in a body, :_severed their . con~.ec. ~_tion ffitb the Lpndon League. f It is now geuerally felt : that / t~e eould wit~ont loss of presti_ge respond to tho prllyer of ltidiani . for a somewhat undignified manner fo which C.he ~ight Hon'ble geritlerepresent.rLion oTiheir interBSta :on the CommiHion and. he would le&Te no ~tone nnturned to prevent reneffal of passive resistance. He man tendered his resignation /arid th_e equally unbecoming wat ia aaaerted ~is loyalty tot.he Imperial &.lld Union Government.a. He was which he has withdrawn it ba~e, on the ·whole~ produced a seen~ in deeply J>&ilDed to learn that employers on the- coast, for l\?me or whom this Comic opera, wh_ich· will c~r~nly riot enhance the ,P~s~ig' of lie entet"ned -a high regard, had suffered losses. . the London League 1n any degree. The -~ of all thmlung •/men · IL is nderat.ood that. Mr. Oaodbi has asked Mr. Smut.a for an are now naturally turned towairds the spproacbing All-India MoBlexa · ill\e"ie ,. League Council meeting at .Ngra and it is earnestly hoped, in / tbe It. is jalleged t.haithere ·are sign, that the mo-rement is w_eakening interest of the lndfail}f.ussal~an Community, that · a delioite / and a111ong tre rank and file. decisive liM of future action be then laid down. . i Dorf: ln a letter~ the Pr"68, M.r. Gandhi denies that the march Ta.s Jtt.uuc Soot UY. . , d to Pre ria baa been postponed because the masa of l9Cal Ia ians The Society owea no litt~ debt of gratitude to Mr. Zafa~ Ali cannot relied on to join in i 00 th e ·cuntrary, hi.says th e difficulty Khan, who has made himself/6nanci11lly res[>onsible for the· ~eekly , ia to del•J it and be has be,ia obliged to send special ·messengers to F • d . h 'S . , r d . . , 00 1 i•ae l9'6et.a in· order to adviee ludians that the march is postponed. , prayers n aye, anti t. e I oe1ety 8 nn s pennt\ th6 'r secµriog I · permanent rooms in London.: The attendi,nce is increasing /e very week and Indian .Moeleme, forks, · Egyptians, Persians and iEng. Ref,rriog to ~•olut.iona at the Indian Nat.ional O.o~gress, Mr. Oaadhi 1,..ya white the Congress is justified in a.1king and 1s boon~ to. lishmea are Rocking every Ffiday to Lindsey Ball in Kensitjgion, uk forl fall cit.iaea right.s Lbrou1ho~t t.b _e, E1npire, South_African · where the Jooma-Namaa is held. The 'Khwaja Kamal-n~-din'• ladiana/ have made it clear that ,n~y are boitn·i to re~o?ni!e local sermons are thoroughly app~iated and listened to most. atteotively : by all thme pl'eRent. • _l,ord Hei.dley generally recites the ~ubNprejndiqe and his •orbnl will JOt baa part.1 to an1 agi~tt0n _for t.lu, uote,tricted immigraLion of British Indians into the Union qaent Dua in English andf hia genuine ij:Ri- eot.hu•siastid ad~oeacy oli the •Uainm~nt of political frauchisft in ~e near. future . of Islam exercise a most. inv~gorating influence on tbe members of 1 fo ~o edirorial, I.be London "Times" that the ch"nge in the congregation. His Lprdsbip s four little aons were present Gaadhi/1 attitude ia weleo111e. Indian leaders have been clearly with him at this morning's Narnaz and, in spite or their tendet ag., i • p ~ DJ Lord lJ,.rJinJe's appeal in Oalcutta. "We fear, followed the proceedings wi~h real intere8t :. : , aoweni~, tbaL relaut.ion . of ih~ tell11ioo ia temporary. The sole The Khwaja Kamal-ad-di~ has is..~ned invitations to the m~mbera of a at.ble . eeLt.lemut. lies in • d.termined eltort by the of the Islamic Society for lbe M.ajlis-no-Nikah, -at the Mos,i ne ' ia laperi~ . Oo,eraraenL. The qneation inTolvea the claim of the Woking, on the 21st in1-.~t, when Princess Saliab of Egypt will .tf-~veroing Dominion to manage it& o"n affairs and alJ~ta. be married to Ata-or-~mao Shaikh : Jelal-od-di11 Mi~bamed TINee lA8tM8 AN -ri\al to the Bmpire and no Government, calling Jernnkevite, a Rnssiao nobleman, who has recently ernbr.acad I;"\am. ilaelf 1bpenal, oaa afford to adopt a 111erel1 negative attitude t.o"'ards The three vacancies on lthe Oommitte@ of the Islamic Society tbem, [ have been filled by Mr. Syed Abril Hasan Razavi, ! II.A., p~~ri•: The Labonr Party conference to-day, noanimonsl1 M.R.A.C. (Ciren), or I;Iyderabad, Deccan, Mr. Murtad~ B.A. ~ , . reeolalion prokllt.ieng ag.iast th.e system oi indentured . (Cantab) of Cairo and Hooeein Manzalanvi Bey of Oonstantin'ople. labou~ and oondemniag tlae ue o{ the police and military to compel · Indian Moalems. , .· . . ,_.., Iadiao• to •ork. Tt.. conference was oonrinced that the presence , et ,tb. bdiao popola~oa Sooth Africa would alwaye..lead to grave · · R.scoNBTJTUT10M or Tu ■ Lo1too• Luau•. / ' ~tli1'#'ies and orged Gorenn•eat. to_ take immediate steps to i1Uin01' ·The London All-Iodia !Moelem League hu bten reconstituted• .npa&riaiion with adeqaa'8 oompeneat1on. The resignations of tbe President, Mr. ·Ameer Ali, of M,T. 0. A. ~ telegram to the "Time•' frqm Durban uya th•~ coufidential --".. Latif. the Vice-President, iand of Mr. A, 8. M. Aaik, the lionorary ilego~auoa. be\'"9111 GandW... and Oo,erament c~ntrnoe on the U"eaalll'el', hue beeo withdrawn. At . a meeting of the ooim mittee poin~ of repreaenl&tioa OD the ~miwon of etrikera oa :augar est.Me held last evening the Aga iKbao WM eleotied to the bonorvr preaiud J. · ,__.. · denoy, iD pursuance of a tefegrafhic intimation from . lndi~ of bi, . ~~~Gokhale i;.. reoeiMCI the following ·cablegram from ~Utngn~ to aecept that. io#ice. The meeting paaaed a con:li&l vo\e . . / Gab i, d,a&ed Ule tad Juaar1 . . of thanks to Uie offieer1 ! for withdrawing tbeir resignatiqna, aocl • Tue Rn. K--. Andren and Per.non hue urind • .and_ also 1.o the Aga Jltian. · - ~ . I _ IOCGl'ded • molt :;:';~ reception b.1 tlM Indian oommonity. Tb~ satiefactory dev~lopments •re a :resalt of eager an~ anxious . ' Tbej bad a ftfJ• rollgb . . We are now · trying to aecn~ ~~e di~on among Indian ~ob.amedana si~ce we announced qn. Oclo-addi'-ion W the Commill8loa of at lea.st one European member 10 ber Slat lhat the London: All-India Motl.em League bad ~en spl~ .d~ impaM}ity we . ba,e contideoce, the plantel'8,. if neeeesary. by the attempta of the : advanood sootfoo of .. Yoong M!oslems" Ming all~~ to Maia~ one 011 i.beir Iii.de. I &1noerely ~oswi to impoee their will upon •the League. The hope we then t1xpreaed lncit• will iapport u in thtL Pray ask all not.~ be over aniuowi '8 baing ~ntertained by the Aga Kha.n-r-Uiat. the London Leap en Jur aeoonnl ~e dillOrdinaol 0:ur communiL7 · bad sbowa naex~powers of endarance of tion &l)d co--0peration with the L ~ d i a - h a a now: been ful.olf_•_:".·ng, an . d we were aat.on . _i11b&d at t.hf ~ looked f~>r lbilit.1 eho~n ft\led. ., : ·, b1 iiadeoinred l■diaoa., wiihont efftetl ~erahip, to aot. Wltb This happ:, outcome of the differen(:4'8, which were brought to a de~i0&tioo and in perfeat co-operation aad diacipline. We rehead by the demands made by Mr. M?J)amed Ali M.r. Wazir ~nii'e ·oheerful in oar calamit.7 preparing for and awaiting events.·• llaaa.n tlNl acceptance of an advanced''policy, ia . mainl,! aUri~ illr. Ghokale lau ,al.llO receiTed tbe following e&hlegrafQ. from able to the support given to ihe bit)i(rt.b recognized leade,~ by •tM K-.. Polak ud Kaleoh.cb:-" We moTe among Enrop,$an&, beat.and moet Nponaible Mni:r-lman~pinioo in_ India. / .A~on1 iadudiog reaP?n&ible Prasmea, wbo pri!&&.el1 or pnbliel7 reeogaiN many other mesaages reqoestrng Mr Amectr Ali to c<;>ptinoe 19 4 .&JM jmlttc'6 of the ladia:a demaoda i~ regard to the CommiMion ." gllide Ole League here were emphatic neolotiona from t~o of the JL _ m06t. active and important prorincial : leaguoa iii North~ India. .,. thoae (?f the U niud Prolincee and the •Pnajab. Before 3eeterday'1 meeting Mr. Ameer Ali, Mr. Latit tnd Mr. Aoik. iau~ .a jtJW !..A: let~r to the memben ol the commi~ announcing thei~ readio• ~,,,,,.,, 1,9111 D,e. . . ., 1918. to ~nun-. to giT& t.be ~ e i r 9!8fflce8 in the of l l • , -¥ <'U ha•e. bO "°°bt, bie&rd atl"Nid, b1 cable or' lbe Rigb\ Hon 'ble .Iman. dmlopment. ; i· ! / fl:,i"'4 AUNillr Ali'• •iu.4.-...i of : bis Nlrignatien of . ibe London The rall:, of mode. rate. Moslem R.PP~ nion '4, th.e _more ~x,.-i--' ~ ~ ~·lt1"idetllllllaip. , I'~ 11Dem:>eR of b_i• London ~m1-ere haa no dqobt. been ooalriba~ to bJ 'ibe , ref➔ of J,otd a\l\M " " dnly i111f&l'iD8d of due ~ takt-11 by &Juur lm Pftlllridt,t\ C.ni•e, and _af~ftl'ds bf ;a.fr. A!Mluit~,/ to grant in~ri, ws _~ : ..~ i1t. aa 6f6eial leUel\ ~geed bf Mr. A,oeer AH-~_im.eelt and the " ~~­ two "delega&.es.''. M,:. 'Maholl)ed Ah _ :Qd _ 11r. Wuu H~. J~ 11 ~belk, eiLriker-,, 31.,._ C. A.. Lelif A : . 8 . Ill. Aaik ; -~ the7 ,•~ ill th~ oonn•r:r-• fad known fo India./ ittoogla, ~ tl!ie outside Wurld ame about lL &IN! bu n:ot rude pnb)io Li1Mto in~ e<1Gntry,..;._TiNI~ i _.· sod io J_ will ·•1• prospeqt 1 in K;.; and for I . · Lon®lf--f _ t\ef. Our "° uo• •d. ,1.?'00p wort r, .. been ..._u The Comrade~ ·r ; easily like. .a copions stream, and has run a num,ber of ;ye;.._ i,ritll ·out leaving t ~ source _ dr,·, eserl"8dtr bec~!lles · a · Knight one wonders why the · Oovernm nt of India i is .. -so cbilfy of honouring Literat111·(l and Art., as t ci have negloote'1 tl,e T!t-gor~ to be obl{vions· of tlu, :very_ existenct of a : Hali and : an Iq,bat if f ia true that Art and Literatt1re do not hanker after tlitl,,e; Bat should titles always go to those that hankqr after th~m, alld do not Ad an · Literature decorate the decorotions themselves 7 Even if Ooverntnen1 are unfamiHar with the names 1lf me like H11li, 11 large portion of the world is all the better for their ~x.is nee and tbie is their b89t re"ard. -~~cl . ~ WB are snre Mesers."Wazir ,Hd n and Mohamed Ali wonld W amply gry.Hfied by the . following _jndgnu•t pat-eed o~ their work - bY: Sir Henry Cot.tea Sir Henry Cotton"• who is in, a better positi3'n--to jndge tl)e Appreciation. i../- r b ,ii ,eldom lthiit the Honours List. excites interest in the breast of aayhll'dy t>xoept the Jl>-Hookams or the GovI ernment which Jecori&t.es itFelf lavishly every Honour whcr~ halr-vtOtle invohed in one way or auother in the recent. happenmgs at · Cinrnpore and iLond,,n must. have felt.grateful to t~e PionNr for a_good many ihin~ itp1as blnrte..l out e~~ry no,:r a~d th6? m moments of irres- ponsible chagtin . . It has certiu'.1ly }uet1fied its name ~nd_ has _by its pioneer :work in this conn~t1t'.u spared others the 1nd1ecretion of e.xult&tion. i Th e la~t occasion 1s tbe comment of our contemporuy on tho i:ocognition of the services of Mr. ~yed Ali Imam to the Governi:hent of Lord Hardinge. His Excellency the Viceroy bu ne,er recbmmeuded any one more deaerving of aoob honour, 11or has His ~hjesty the King-Emveroroonferred a title in India which has been: bett~r recei,w ,.lij..tlte pt"Ople of this country. There ia no honour tQ which Sir Ali Ir.,.m cannot add lustre, nor 111 there an office of respo~sibility to which be cannot add digniLy. His position aB \he Indian ,\ : ember of the Government of India is one of great delicacy; bnt greater compliment can be paid to him than this, that no one oa* count. on the leaat faTonritiem in his discharge of dnty, while all feel C9n6deat of securing fati--play. Neither the bond of religion nor otper personal tiea give bis co-religioniata and • v•number of pe~na\ friends of all cll\.lieh~ w~tb t.h~ press org_ani&1L1i1111 in this oonn~. In a very short space of time yct,n aooomphshed ah nr11anal ~o-' of important work and have every teason to be aatie6ed with th.. gea~ ral effect it produced. It remainJ -~ prosecnte the! campaign in lnd~ and no doul:it ig eubseqnent 7ears ton 'frill be able ;to rene" .it , bere. 1 We hope it will be possible for th~~ .geotle~en to go to Engl&bd ~ _ fore long to renew their work. ~at England and India both neel is a hundred such missions in the n'.ed few-wears. · i . ~ I I i;ne Cpmrade. . Secretar ',, conce.ro with diEcipline wa1 t\,at c,f tht- t-:xecntiTe ~,fticer l•f the entire Board of Tru1-1e,,,.._ •n,., 11,iul uii' ti, d,s ... vssed ,rai' tliat tl1e dignity c,f the (lffiCt' ,,f ti r H, rr, ,,.. y S,, ,)i,11y !--lt(,u\d l )e rnaint ined, nnd it \\ill l.,e 1111,id,· " 1,rld to clrcid1J 111htlhtr · t ,rai; urnrr tragic or comic tl11t II t1111 j,,tilJ tl, 1·idrrl ll111t the di~n ty of the 1,ftic6 of Trni-! t>P ,nul G, .n, 1,or of tl;e Colli,ge ahould n • t lit' mllin\ ained. \Vt, k11H' it tn 1h 1 i,,r.ur Ir, knd tht> way inc mmenting ,,n.t\1is sdf-al•no1·11w111 111,d l,1!11 ilit) c.f tht Honrcl or Trn11t ·s. O1w thing m1~1.l,\Hn'r, Ii•· 11 nd1· ,·l1•11r lo, f,11 1· \\l' 1•roceed h11t wr. 'l'heTrustres weie n .,-11 · 11 1:x i,.1:.F- f,r }•111-,· 1l1a11 for 1 ju.11ti.ct' . , 1 • 11d . t..rn1111inic 11FlJ rf , nl tr_ , •.· ntn. i1,.h, 111,y far1 ·s · · 1•,d.d11n·d i ,r or ugai11 t tlie CP1Hl 11ct pf the lo »1)· S c1P l l\ 1 ~, tl ,1•. 'I ri:l'h·t·~ or the i;t nc! •Ito. Tht>refore _ nc, ue tl f 11 , l' 11-,,,h11i, 1>s 1.i . 1l1•·#1N·i11! "Mediug c11n line (ht> least practi('al !'i~1 .ili1·1tr~ 1111d it 1\ 11-t- •·XJ•Ta'. nPtl quitt· ea ly in the meeting that tli,•~ ,,,•fl• 11t•I 101t•., . i ,f 1onlid,·nce in the Hi•nNary Sc•cretary nor w1,11ltl . tl:~·'.r 1, j, 1•1 i II l·P e• 1,,id,·rNI a YOt~ of ltn1mrt' on that c•fficer. Mun~ I 11b11·t•~ tl, 1111,-: \.t. 11 ,111 rnch ttSOlnti9n1.1 flue ab!.iolnh'ly ,mnPn•, ~nry. l,11t all io~rto·d tL11t tlwir l'f'jedi1111 would pr..,b11bly b(i mi,1.111d1•r,trn,d, und 1,on· 1l,nt the l:lonor11~J Serrt't&rJ h11d sul,nii, tnl IIi, m for dis_.,,,1-in11, ,wd they forru~ ~ art ,,f tLe Agenda of the 11m·ti1 g, it 1n1s dJ.'si,al,lt- 1l1»t ti.e.1 abould ~ Jl&9i>t1d. !th?Moslem mischievous qtiarrel with tl1 l'hich Dr.-Z_i1uiddin was, lo· Ulimia and ,pnbli us a,sume, qwughtlessly l~adin ; • I ' hnuo of framing in tl1r J•rt· ·t1)\)1·d 1111nnPr ~ motion on tl~e sub ect; 1JH, ll • ]i(\llll'J l3 t·l·n•tary of the Alii11rh '.I' \18A Self-Denying t rci' i,11 mith-tl fo r th l'il· pro nounceuteut in the Ordina11CC• lu, t Ill Piing tli l:' (tlll'8tl() ll o[ the 'H ono ary . . , • ~ec1P 1_ 1~·y'i- 1ight~ 1iul; dulil'll ns n'~11rds ~lOlitr c~ «1 1<. t other" ~xler1111l nclr _n us. \\ e b1·he,•p WH are •flllly j~isti- fiecl iu ~aying th~t _tltci:1'.\}lt ' '! c,f ,:uch crn'.·~tirins in lb(• plnce of rt gu)ur ruotwu~ consist mg ol dt>hJH " 1•ror 1 •snls 1:s sal,Hrsivc or the rights of 1-11ch memh'.'rs _11s dD_ not attt:n ~l a ml:'d_ing lrnt nre entitled under i the rules to ~ubnut wntt en 0111111 , 1:s wli1d1 11re . counted 1s Yoles. -, Ve ~elicve that the:11ltenda n~e or ome 45 out of ·11 to\nl of 102 Trn4tees111 the last meetrng Clll1st1tut es 11 1t>c1·,y prn jcy. Dut tli'e dl'Ci:1io11 arrivEd at ·a . the last m~t_ing o.o the 9t1t:8tiun s,tlnuit.Lcu by the Honorn1·y Seorctar~ was the dC\:IBIOn .o! ll m,1i or1ty of oply thoi.e who l\thiucled the meeling nnd A.IIOTll ~ R J"tM>lntion reforre·d to tht' c1,nnrclion nf ~tnilt>nt- with of those who;.c 1iroxy v1~tes th~ hat.I. tak1•n go~d care to secure, fof the politi<•s, 1111d tlu• Trn~lr1·e w, re careful motion ()f Mr . •Tustice Shah Din W!lS tle\'Cf. circulated, and ther~for~ Underi~du.ata e1>011gh to ~11y that ,i, hat t l11·y w1,h,id nerer rnted 11pon el.'.cept by a !tittle mnre than II fourth of the elltire uid PolttJCt. l\tudt•tllll lo rdrRill rr,;rn ,t,u;. t11ki11K p11rt in bo~y of Trnstees wh o attend1d . in th o aherooon. Tho d ecisi• •n:. was prad ica l pnlitic!!. An undergraduart•". t'dueRti,,11 wn11Jd · lil· i11t·◄ 1111th is. The Honorary Secretarr JS no L t,) take any part in politics-f-and ph•1e if I u ,d1 . a . large snbjt-ct ai, Po ' itical .&•it•t,cl.', nr . l'..Jiril'al this without any qualification ~uch n., practical politics proscribe~ Eor l'hih>IKIJJhy-; a8 it j+1 nri<'>usly c.~l_led, ~1111 rigo r, ,ui.ly e.:c:el 11~ e,l fro n atL1dents--and he is to refrain ] rn,m such "exte1·111\l" acti1·ities a..'! :may bl'. h~rmful to . the Co11ege. There was considerable differen~e of hi& st_ujiu., . or 1f c.nrrt'ot ~-pol11_1c." d1_d not i.1.11•1•ly. , cC'ns1:•nHlly a IMlhject for academical d1scW!810nt~ in lhe. ( 'olll'ge U,111,n. A _ op1mon among the Trustees, ~nd sr,me of the young repr<'scntativ~s of 1 careful ahld1 of the &object ah•n~ nith H islnrJ is tht> hrst "Old Mohamedaiµ&m.. '. ' of thq I'ionw· 8 CJC'!ltion rnted with the minorcorredi t> of •hat we are iudint·d to ,c11II "irtd.,)t·nt l'Atii,,tii-111" ity consisting of what that : ;, Grey- bParcl," 'the Hr,n. Cnptain Malik which im patient of the demand nf 1,11slR.im·d 1"ork 11bil'l1 n•al Umar Hayat Khan Tiwnna, fol\., wing tlm lead of eqm,lly "san~ nnd patriulii; n n ,tu!l al..,.ays make , and is tl t1 rtf,,re ug,·r to diacorer aober" Angl o-Indian jourol\l. , wc,uld c11ll "hol-headcd youngst~rs.' ' abort-cu 11 • • llation-bnilding is a Wf'uri,on1c tl'l~k, lint y1,1111gi11en,, 'Ihe V!!rJ first result of this decikion w1Juld be that tire II on r,rary St'c rbtflry eanrwt rraHi.e it ~nle~ they_l!tndy tl,r ~r•:"'·th of na1ii,11_~ _ an,I 11f the· would no longer be nllmrnd pkase l1is bemdicent and b{ini~n fr iend!:! principl '1!1 <'f oatiooaltsm with all the• p11tn·uctM111d h111111lity, f 1111' trne by organising abortin,hole-anU-corner ptJli t ical m1,eti11~s al Delhi of elso1"cdent-; i D('tlidt't!, too carefully Yt·r•J •piug np tht• u11drr,1,:ra.d11u1 c iu 11,here. Tho . next result 1rnul d be hilrdly less di sn!J t i,ms. lie ,vo1tld oott,m ~0<,l lul hil! luyalty catch ei1U i, in rN1lity Jitt>J•111i1,g ,111~1 for be unable to offer himself as ~ candicfotl; for Urn Legislati ve Council becm~iuf' a ieady victim fo th(' !ir~t win~l of politbil I usio'.i ~o of the Pro,·ince as he did a ye11r agn without success. \Ve wonder •hie_h_h . may get e:iq~•@ed on \eaY111g tJ.,. ~,,Jlr!{e q11adrn11g le. Tl111,, whether even the luxury of a : 1;crm o11 on loJnl ty would uow bo perlike thr 11tl1t-r reSgard (,f di!Orctary with Government a11d it11 officials Punuw 1tl1at the d1 ,,c11sa10n of th~ re!twttn tl1 e forces of wb_at may be . de,crih(,,d. u _new l\~ld S ec retary t o mix hi1m,el1 up '\\·ith any actiri til'S, whether" inte~naf·• old Molamed1 ui1m' ' aud, that thetr 1•11i:!'11~e w1t}l{)1tl a rl1sse11t11;111 v,,,co or "exte r~l ", 'l'lhich are "llllrmful" ' to the Coll~ge:, But the was a \~iumrb for the Picmur'" p,·otgii. 1'1ol111111ed11n i~m ill, at tl1e q11 estion is, 1s anybody in tl1e knst wi ser after the-adoption of- al~these ·lt,ut, coi-1,ptation, nHne than thittN.' 11 lw11d1Nl ytt111A old, urd tlie e:<(:dlcnt resolutions 1, No motic,n sugge!!live of a rnte o[ couficlonce aomenc1alnre of the Pi01tt~ •rwuld' U:.,t <'I\DIDlencl ih,.-lf to ar,~·h ody. in tho l lonorary Socrntary wais placed on the agenda of tho n1eeti1ig, and Bui ti!ti 1ugge11tion that, tw.camre th<' preteuee . of !llc.,.i;r!l. M1,l,11111ed no sueh resolution w1..-; ere r p~:_('d, all corre,; po11dt nts 11,nd eclito~ll and Ali au~" . ··. 1lr Hann 1'118 ~utiri}'ntetl, ll1e1 , 1\ul,k.l. i11tcrl't'11(' '• i11 · 1}1\] 1rnb-editor11 of all t.bopaptirs int.he wnrld nolwithsfa'n1'('11li,q-ly he had done in tho pABt was extolled, cond•Jned or censured. l But ... rped rjudg~t)Ut cbaiactNi&lic of 11 ... l'i'1>flttl... i;;e\1-tcatii,tll'll i l{ll• •r tH\ t,;t•, u,)thing wa.~ decisi vely s nggel!tc"a fCM his fntiuo guidance either, ~xcept ihe eatego rical prohibiti,,n of the Sec retary'~ taking any part !w hat• Jw t"OlliNtion with di~iplinar,-;;l'a~111rs dt>PrllPd nr-rl'~flrJ for keep-. ernr i,! polit.ics. If he thinks that this excused l1im for a.oy in~ction, real or. imagined, iu the Ca;1rni,ore 11ffair, ii, he not then Loqnd to . .! 'ing Ali~1nl1 undi-,~r1dt'1IPI! al o,,, r from tho resoluti:,n tu1 a teos ure 0 11 him for organising the aup rti\'O regard The ~oaatl ol the praetieal J-nlitici,., th1• 1,fhi .. ti111,t l'rinciJ'"'l mertiug 11t Delhi ? llu t in fact it did neitlwr; for the Truillct•sset thei r Ka'a~ and Aliaarh. " <'f"lhe C(,ltt•~t'"-'lllu, -.m11ld dn 11~11 tu ro 11fal·es from the Tery begining ag11·,ust t() lll',1iug the nns1nour)i mesa .: . fine him,-.-l i tt, thing~ or "'hid1 lw ha;, ~, ,urn ~lJlge and'· which f1'll within tin• !;(."Op-0 ,if l,is ~flit·ittl duti,·,-littd ~ d for their c onsumpti on : thrnn.l{h the ln t fltut e Gautte und ! other niilt'd ~be questic\O whtthrrtht• S i)C i~IJ t• f thl' Scro1tls of 1h .. K11'11ha • t F rdu papers. " rh1t. thl' rest,lu tio n has doue i~ to curtail foos t serionsly the freedom of tbe Honorary Senet1iry nnd. tu make the office consider,ras m~ttl, u-1igi ou~ or politital also. Wlt1·n tlit> n111ller ODH' \,.-,f.,re 11 lily less attr1UJtiveforthe alil~st men iu th e co\lllnnrnity. quclitipn the tlat- Tr11tt~t• at their ls.it m~ti11g it 1n1,- li,-hd 11·hdh1•r rl,e Collt·l.!e bindig force ot the deci~ ion, i?ecause it arn,,nn~l,t(I a restrict ion ~f the aotlwr)tit& liad any right to 1,it in .fud ~'li°1t•11t on ir, The .Honorary St>ert>tar,• iJ(•in a•d O!l t t l.at l,e l,a,I ll 0 f.,r whid1 a twv-Third s nrnjoritj' in the A nou1~l Meeting of the T~nsteee dt,tiirt' (n l'•llfl any judgment ou• thr d ian1cter of th1• :;.na11ts ..r tl.e j,; ti,x•essary. But £mm as . 11 " piuus lVisl~" the res()llltiou :111 not Ka'at.4 8,·('iety, aud 11,• ,us only concn.t,t>d •ith th.- i.tutli,·s " f the likely to last beyond a. ico npl e of J C:H>') and if! thi., sense cunsti't;nles 1 . •nd ,•rg ntl ■ ah•s on •hich tlieir attention should ~ ronr,•11 •1 a t,·1l censure on the present lfon orary · Sc<; retary ! which the Trust~!! had durin ~ d1tir C, ,llt'gt'! da,-~. T..- o mt>mL,u~ t lf the Sl...:i,•t! t·x,,J,. ,n,·,I n o right to p&ss. Whatenir Nawab lsba~ Khan Sal~ib did left Uiat i.1a1:I" nl'rt1, and i t- the •·V ,ti. ri1•!! of , 1,e K11'al a" h•tl t.n 1 thi! vuhli c, for he neve r pretended to act 1~itic11.lly a.,; the BotiorATJ pl.._. ,_, tlr rir llt'nicftl a.e "·ht>le--timt lll ('D tt tht Cie1J •ol N>91tttHe..i <"r org•ni!lled by the ('t,ll•g~. On tl ,is tl ..-re ' · wu d.il.,._.. of opinioR aad Alig:a.rh tru 1a,.d a 1lt1J-'id ~ul the q_lM9tioo for the deciaion of .hi• colleagtj-. .. ' ; i~$'. 1 1 I' 1 j il 1 tJ 1 ,ve or tir ~P The Comrade. 6a 1 )i' /' 1·: ' , : . ·' ''"' 1907, Mr. Ghulam HuMin, a senior uode~graduate of · that he does not accept this deci ion aa a peraooal triumph .. ~~• Ftbrnar ' Aligr.rb, was accused by a Police constable ill atlord to pick a needle88 qua rel 1'ith tbe (>1~ Boy■' A~'~ll ~~:::~t~! • of handling him roughly when on duty at the at a time when~"!,· need11 ~.·:.cea d ~s, t. ·.· ~-.··• •.· ..... •·.·. ·•· . ·.:._.'.-.·., · • ·.·.,:,·1 a~rthe local Exhibi.tiuu. Wit~1~-1~tl.dan)t. inquiry ltlhde· ___ , : . ,__..~ • . i ... ~•-, . T nuteea- I then Principal. Mr. Arcnw ' w IO -.qua.rrt- e bl spite of the deciiuo·n ot' the majority, t.be !Tr~s a p ~ .· ·, , ,,-ith tht Tnstt>es tbcmselre~ two years later a.nimd), in ~ondemning · wh•t · M•jC)f \ 1~ ,,ud resig11t-.4, expelled Mr. G-hulam Husain tr~m. ~b.e t~olle~e. ~Yiw~ it ·.The Policy ot Hasan. qgralu.•i descri~.ed ~~ ••. tth.e ... l·ic·7•·-1·.· 91: . .• l&i di:¾',.rrer!;d tha! this h:1d roused t~ete~lp;r ~; hi~ com! ~de.-,, Mi. ArchRevenge." . revenge" sometime& j punned "by OoU•a• :.O. ~ome tuue Riter peace tutors ~u _order to 1·ui11 the fntuce ~lli'Ja.ra 01 - . dt>d the sEnhmce into a. tine or 1~s. rd :·' 1~ ; t~1°u:~~tn patched ap, Mr. Arc,hbold u e.:.ed ~Ir. Glrulam' Husain to oi student8 whol))"". ·. they disl,kcd . in th_e,ir, •. Coli;ge dan.·,,,·._-.~. . •. 11 ,,.. 10 • th" College Hostels ,,n the ground of the alle.1-:ed U ur r-t'"'I e c, • referred tu the great ovation g;1v n by the entire ·oiversity ;OD ~•gi}@ ' ·1. -,ti. 0 g beruud the bonnds fixed for biu1 ~" a puuii,bment d d l l be t, d, •• f · · tbfnl v. fieuc·t> ?ho/ ti.u • •although · ~ 1 Ghularu rilu~aiu was 1oeeii wi1lking ~ions to un ergra uates w 10 ia en" sen own·· or some you . , '1long \'Ht Litle t:, · . ) [ . _ . . , peccad-Hloe but had subsequent 'I brought. honour to - their Alma M.~ter • • 1· f, ri:i the C,,llege iu C . any wit i t le A,:;~JS1.aut Tutor as well 88 to themselves. He cdptended that the, doctrine of" t st :.w, :1.ff ro bn this · tl1e uudergradua e1i held a demoo ntion. punishment" in snch ca.-IBs wa. alisurd.. Well, ~th,~ ease whicl_1 led the_ th 1 ::t~u · cllJsequence •> t thi;. seven uf em . were expe le_d froru Honorary Secretary to rnise this: qneslfou Lt :pai i ~ , nditicin,· :111d inaiSled ciu ue nppt •intnient vf a of 8uch literary work' u '&fr. ; luni Hmmin has dobt. He :is s1101ond 1 n t tlH'Et aL' 1"1!tnu, i:quin- ,;:',ich the TruS ee,, Jid U(•~ .. ppoiut iu a to 1.1006 I\S a jonrnalist, and _weil~i! P:n th,i,t is •. t,ho 1mvy of his fri,~nd-fl L\•I_l'.;,.lll~' .' ~\-;::, and th.ll p~rs,)11Uol ot' wliich did uul tiud favum· with aoJ comrade;i and the despair of his !,)cl~. Otir rel\dera hl\ve ohen th 11 \t1i. ~0r did thti report uf e Curumis~iuu comm ... nd .._tiered praise where praise was c~rtain 1y not dnP'·, ·. forgetting., that, I the tlit' :. s 1 p0 m~:;rni(Y 1'11i:1 t\'11.S uulr nitnn1.l it we rememh,\r th l\t Comrade hnd on its 1taff a wri~r as brilliant as Mr. Ghulam Htti,ain. ~-f,t u1 Mrlk.-'flliu.ol.l thts de~th ( ;' X ,HIUb ~Jnhsin-ul-lllulk llis stirring appeals for ,fund,iifri the column(, of the Comradd 'haye r th e 1same t•> ~ii,., <1tli~-e ,,f thti B'.,ncJrat} .:::-t l' ctary helped in a large measure to fill the coffers of the ill-fated Moslem P'ni~ th 11 lH>'L<' ~tr,m.~ 1uurntt- ot cli!j.~ent. lhe itri~e_rH n~re_ ,u _ e w«nmti~n~ Tersity. Yet after all this l&ps, of time, Mr. Towle is anxiott• to th political agitntinu, 11.a d wi th, _ rc\'iTe an all but forgotten incident from which ,the theu Statf ot the aernsed uf 1lnuuug tl,em"•hei, Uj• wi ,·,·,nsideral>l,f wisduiu dcni,•,t die (."?Mge arai ci!Je:·ed tu rd_urn t,, th ~ College did nut come out unsca~hed. Although our readers nre 1sure t h rd .. r or Cc,\lt'~e. ~Hr. Archlx:ld 1\'&:; ~rei·ai -d .llfh>!, wi lidnlW bi~ ,, to judge tht, matter on the liu~ iudicnted by ,Major Dilgrami, th t:cpui,it>[l tflt' pro~nlllt'Ut strikerl!, llllC u . L•illegti ,_e-npt:ned. add for Mr. Towle's informatio~ that Mr. Ghulam Husain WM! n~ver th fhis i~ ~11 tt:c_ient h,i1t, ,rx ll•Jff • but Ill [U([S(. e) ,irdy l~emner 0 ,1 th ., ., expelled from the College.". he College St~nt up hit1 name 11 11 ,beu t'. l\.-;.:\· ::::u,ff. ~fr. L,w!e._ :.e-etrll! lu Lai"' ''' ?g __tli,~ugh " 01m n-h11~ candidate fm the B. A. examin~t.ion afterthe fi':)al !lentence \l'll8 pa,Jed, 1 th 11 misle,hii1,.; jlllttuvry, lvr _h'-' nH', ·t..,_l e_ re~rett~l ~ incidents of 190: and lie appearetl in the examin~tion several months after as a· c~ndi10 ln,t ,,intt-r: wb,m. uu hi,_ ''"Y a,, fr!ellll-' pa;,:I'! _to r1:c1:up~ratt• 111 ~ clate ~ut up by the College, and s11bsc1piently took the B. A. degree 1 he:i'.t:1, ~ir Ghnhm Hu~alll br,)ki:: 1:, 1''.uruey l\t :\ !tgarh !or II ,t·_ouplr ,,f the/ Allahabad univer:;ity 88 K succe,;;ful cn.ndidate in every way of d.iy~ till::, llt (>:: I\ f~lrn~ ,,,t_ n,,;plm d }-)1\S~edsini·e sati:ify Cl"erybody aud the, matttjr will be dropped. If not, the Hqnorh tln' llf',dt' Ht ..t ti,,,; nil"i.:ni qlHll !Cl m l ~ t-i"lH·ruHm aud _.,1 r. 11ry Secretary l\llU bis athi.sers rill lie rnsponsible for the eom1equencee !l!Jli(t:' j ••IJ Lt,, ll!,1,)'.'~lld the buouua .. H.: lll\d smce of a i,l,ruggle bet.trneu tht, Trust~es a~ the Old Boy• which s~ould_ nut be entered upou with a light. heart. · entm:,l \it ,· i:-.n~ !t!\J "'_11rn~-,t ,y "" 1 '•1,. ,·d ,ur th e K')"d of 111 ~ A)n~ll )fatt>r. fit' a.,l· ,d h1,~ li1ng h1~ ,,!ie:.:ed 111u, w1rnld contl!lllP to l•i' v1~1ted upon , him . ~1r. !fowh, promi~ed to c1,n~ider the ,iuesti,,n llOLi lot him ha1·,... a Jennire :>11!isw,,r. :::lnb.,cqurut ly t ,> thil!I Mr. Ghnlrun Hurnin reminded ] v we he.d auy de@ire tu h~miliat,• the SecNtary we could ~note l1 r. T,,wl,,· tptll't' thirn d!lei• 1,tH. m,11 only informed [h!it ttw matter WM·the words ,,f tho,w '>f hia friend, and an,l.:>r c«u,i,lt·rati,HL c'lttur thi~ h"' atHni:led the A1rnu6I Hti-uuiu1 of tht' What of the Future? partisaiis who induced him to re~peot Ohl B,,y., at £11gttn· and lei! .·\lig:.irh aiter" fow bu11rs' !!tAJ 111 n l,nildthe ru.fet:1 . t1ud . procedu.re of the Tru~tee.s lll,:{ eet apnrt b)' th,· Colle~!' authorities for kdgir. 5 the 0-ld BoJ;;on the • i-.nd t~ -abide by the r~sult ,ii hii; . own errors. Bat "ceasiou. lt u,m !ippear~ thac e1·._.n to thi,; ~1:-. Towh• tonk objP1:tinn, under . the preseut ciroumsl'.apce we. heartil1 desire tl11_1t N,wab ,1ntl the ildµnrary S11cr.. tar,r of the Uollege ~omml"ll•~ed 11 ,:,,rn:sp0nlshal,; K.han 8aheb should he ghen an,,Lher ooportunity to win I the Jc•n,:e with Oit• Honorary S.-crecary of the d!d Boss' As~uciRti"ll coulldeuce not only of all hi;, c~Uea.g!les, but of. · the entire o~~ty . n the snbjtkt 'Jf tht> mills of the AMocia'.ion re_gardin..r Old B,m; by devoted, reii'rleJ:Js and unselfia,h d.ieoharge or his- overomt .autit!f u who lin,I bt'~'ll l'Xpdled· fr,im tiH~ CuUege, np;h,,t .-)f it was th~t lfononuy Secretary of the CoU~ge a.nd 1Jllcet'M9r of Syed Ahmed Khan tht• Hon,\r1-1py Set::rt!tHry ll(1l'i· ask!:!d th\\ Tr.11:;tee.!; t,) n·-ml 1·,, that no student !Ulrl Yiqar-nl-Mulk. We tru:1~ be would be '1ble to work II n~lhly el:f eHed ff(l(ll the Cnl:e~e ilhu~d be l:'nli11kd 1111 a w.-inLer ,,f the Old with the ~yndics in future, thait they would make this easillr fotjhim AsS<:J~iatiqu withutlt ,lie 11it'nctiqu ,)r himsel! antl the Princiby forgett'\ng the put, by refr11i:nt'i1,g fonu any undue criticism of d~t.ailR E,.id1Jnt1y it dL•t•11 uut niatter r,_, ~irn _in the lea~t that and by a.s.sistiug him in ~he ,inl\ition of the !n~io problems of Aliigarb ,Jl,i Hi'lJS, _\~,u.:i,,tio11 is au. indi·!Jt'lldent l,,,,ly with a me1'iiht·rwhi!.:h requir!l ·uu:ity of will, puryoise a11d aotrnu;, and that be, too would ~t111• ,,f ~om,1 ihirte<:-u hnndrt!d Old Boy,, and au 11emu~l incotue of nb,>nt torgd the past, let. byge1at1ou ou a 11imple majority of vot~. N.iit\wr complained th•~ they bad ~n r-,peatedly insulted by him, end o~ered ~-1',Yt>L :">l»h;1.1n-11l_-M'.1lk n,)r Sawab Vi ur-ul:..~lulk obj~ted to thrill, 1 ~ 1 a~oulJ timbri.ee one_ ap olher. . Tbi11 is oot ~e ftrat ~ion :, _ ,,u, M)Y ,:L•J~:twn raised b1 Mr. Archbold or Mf., 'fowlt>, A '..in w41c~. this p•n~a for. all ill~. w~. d,,,,:om~4 a~ A_hgarh .. Web•. H S:it• l\nnmittt•~· ,,t l)ld lh,ys, inelnding the Proctor of tlw- Ct,llaq Uiad touched feet ,,i two-tl11r~l' instead of a simp!i'.' majority o! the Honour, Secretary • in a public ~~ting in Uie .. _,oe, p11.radu.x1lial u it !Uf\_r ~m,. both th:e new apprn vtd , 11riental . fashion. • Like plague inocnlatioo. wbic~ i1 sud tht> PrincipA! uow find the 1:ew a preve11trv~ fur s1it ~onths, ()OIJ, the . effect of tbte ,_.edy TL t· P1oriu, rolel"l! t o the l1111t Seffiou of applied in April did .not 1~ tieyond 8ep~•rnoor. Let u hope .. p1'•::ketl with uurny ,,f tlie fonent friends lbat the more scieutJ6c w&11ttjm remedy or i shaking baada w~ndd W1uir Hasii.n and M11l1r1med _-\Ii, a.s i! the hare moie luting effect. If the ~i~greemttn~ i11 due to clilfen,~ m1rno'i!r,ruo i, nut ,1p<:>H t.. All litt1r11to 1nluits: and •tt the ,.i·f•· pri".uciple8, Ulen theac.• . wall:e;~•·•,It_ev·e·s are fu, ~.'·le.·•.od !001'1!1 .• wonl,, <>f ' in t1,,•,a.Heged . 11 p,nty "Pl;._~:i tn i:hildtt!D than of the biu1a1·9an-i-quwn. But. !if th-, diaagrwmut i• th,:, H,i.nl o: [ ru~t>.'ff 1;, tbP Bm,rd ,,f l'rn~t~ i, due UJ malice impla.nted in Lhe: heart of any ot t.b~. who t/llve ~.ilJ w:th tn!\ay ,,f thl'l fl'lrnrn! ,wd admirtn. "-,1f ,rnuugh shaken. haods t.o-da1, t~e · &etdem•n~', i . oot cbatacterini;Jr · of ,,HJ I tt ' ):/iii• the obri1,m; ~'.{>nsi !,;,la, m·., aa one gra,e, aod ·~.evereu~.. ••. g·. nor.. pro. ud• I. . •Wed..·. bat.•·. . of ~.afi • . · . • Trn,t"l'"S, •11d tl1,• allll "~~t unanid,.,..lit_y p. the. troee:.L 11enft ;. of th~ w,,1r.d. _Pi6si~.ly,. ~. . COrTif'IPO..•~l 'i 'l •$l!i,,n . thi li,,p wl1,, art! frn,1,h' ,1 '.' of Iii..- C,,Ue1:,,;, a majoor the Pl'~ »hare,; ~t f~,-. fot ~ih~ · .ti. •19 Chat j' all ., t,ht'. £ra~!tft.'S m:1inty COIUp!ut101c a.s 1rnbnmt.eJ by tbe li,,o,)rary SfCN1ur., . Let a. hope: acepUcitm ill• ,igaifloaot q~~doD: at for illit · · " ! 1 po.• I.H• eternal I J ~ r~gtl~r ~lttllj,t: t'\· l; ~f~~ ~tct,'.d ):ar. t,: "1 we~., lrll.!\. ,,n i ,a IT ! i I ? •' ! r•tug_ 1 ! ! n,e Io. ul u4 wu thel I dee.. i. of or tJ~· . 10th Janj. The Comrade. c~ .16' j beating " in at• iporting," •aalQUch to ez119t.frol0 ·uld w9rld ! procaduTe. The nrtu or We are anxiou to belie'fll that Lh• ..ttlement "oald lut at leut two Der i■ pe"t'hapt too 11••-fan yeara, buL the !'orortnation that we poHea on u imporlan~ U.)80t ·autooracy. of tb68e wret.cl ed. aqaaW>lee i, ~ omioou, lh.t we are a pre:r to ·1 greater doubts aud auxieLies than before. Could not Lord Hardinge ~ Cooataotinople letter :received · tlle last mail llaa the folio".. 0 .I earn aome mof'.Moelem ·gratitude by interesting ltimttlf J>!re<>Dilly .in i . ~ng abo1tt _ L he ~•ifi~iea ~f the Uilal-i-Abmai : tht aflai··rs o-f ligarh and giring 1ucb relief. to Aligarb and i11 r_rieud1 • I Turkiah Activitie■ u 1n the Kaditab Hospital a courae of inat'ruoas he brought tbe .Musu.lmaua of Cawnporyi and lhoee that befriend~d them ? The r t-tYil i1 in both cues the 1ame, and His EJieellent·y . . . lion. for ladi • ,who iutend act as ni1rtte 1D case of war. 1. ■ being.· g1 ren. In he nry near fit'11re • scb01'>l for , will not"6nd i au:r more difficult to discov~r 1he real friend, of ~ale our~ will also be sta.~tt>d by. tbe- ~ilal-i-Ahmar. A Hoflp;\al A.ligarh t.bau he fou.nd to diacoYer the r..J friend. •l Cawnpore ts also gou:.g. to be estalihshed edhvr 111 Fatib 'or Jirrah Piwha M.uualinao1. for_.-prt&Ctical in~~r~otion. On thJ first day of lbe . laiit Kurban ~a~r11_m 11mall _art1~,s,i!ll flowers wer4 ~i11trib~1eJ ill; the whole OltJ. · 1! lT i, 1urpri1i~g! an~nificani, that the PioftUr', l hie 1e the H1lal-1~lim11r D~y. ~ring to 111 beiog the first effort,, Aligarh cor~•pondent ur 011rre1pondenta, wuile and also because .~f _the fioa11..:1al or1~1:1 due ·to tJ1e w11r only £tq :660 A '"Stormy.. celiq. mentio~iug that "almost all the imP9rtant reaolut10911 put forward by the l1c,no1ary Sec~ere e~ll~d. ll111d~. no doubt. a/ 11mall 11nm. but if we ~m~mber t .1at tl111 amount_ wa~ oullected f_ro~ the B1'miu~I, and th" ~orer retary were p Md by large majoritiea," and adding tbat at timea the classea of the capital rn oue day, it ~iveagreat aa11araeLion and inspirt1 mt-eLiog wa.a "11tormy" and the Honorary Secretary's reaignation ,ra, the work~~• whh many hoi!~s !ur ~hr future. Thia:will be done ever)' imruiueot, do ot u.y auytbing about tbe resolutions that were not yea~ and 1n all parts 0 f thll Bmp1r,. If the eame t.biug is done in I pu»ed and th~• d11m,peti the triumph uithe Honorary Secreta,ry with 110 ~nd1a, a very great a~d u•:eiul i;ervif)6 will be done;'' · Other ite 1111, of I "almo5l-," no~ menuon who was the author of the "1turm." \Ve ha,o 1wp_o~t~ut news contained III the_ l11t~er are . th, foll~wing;-( 1) Euver 0 0 dttire I.O b~wiliate the Honorary Secretary., nor do we like to rub him BeJ Ii tn good. health. _lie w1H ~ leaving · nex~ we~k for llnlin I of any .. ti3fa.ctiun Uu1t he may hue found iu 1he· mteting 011 New Year·, to uudergo a Lh1rd operation fur apl}eudio1tie. (t) '.J he " R~haditb •• ! Day; But i~ is necc-l!4arJ that there should be no miiilake ab,,ut aud three Fjther uaral units of/ importance "ill i,. adJed to / facta. The I Honorary Seeretary pro1;osed that tbe 1hu11ld be the Beet ~y ' the end of F,M .ar,. l'he Admi;ralty baa made a : u-clfici'o mi:~l>cr 1) f the . Syndicate iu ch~~g• of t.be lloarJiog eonlr~ct With ~es•~· Ar111strong rand Vickers to eataulisb a 1hip• i liouse, and -4ught to aet uide the rl'ttlot decunon of the Sy11dic•te bu1lu1t1g ya~d, a fluat1~g dock. ,and ian aroenel in the gulf of lsiuid ! iu appoiutiog lto the racancy Mr. AbJnl Majid Kh"aj• B.A. (Cau\.llb.) aud Lu r.. pa1r and put 1u proper oruer tb, niating one iu the Goklea i Bar at-Law, I l11te La" Profc&Sur oi the, Uolle~e. .Mr. H,,rn. (8) The P?rte h&:11 uot •ir~u to appoiu~ Earopeau, to [ )lohau:ied Ali i asked for 1he ruling of the chair in farnur of lii11 concontrol the relorrua 10. A~~tol111 au4 the pre88Dt policy ie t.o oppoae i teotion7'tiit;-~ the motion iuvolrcd a elurnge i~ the rule which em~oy _such propoaal. (!) lho _stllte juf tl_1e. ll11lkao1 is· UDN\tled aud / powered the ~yn;,. Many l'iluri. were made l>y 1t.alwart _pa.rti• bo,i _c ottrng 1 u~key finano1aUJ, ~>UL 1Ru1:;111. • thrnata are ew1:1ty. liner- I nat10na1 relat11!na are ,ery cnt1c~I. (6) Kewal O,uer jj111 will be ! ~ani tu 111isiot~rpret the wor-as of Uu, Hununuy ~ecreLar/a re.;olu~ioo le1n•1ng for India, before the end oil tlie wooth, lie 1e late o•ing to i hut to no pt1rpose, Another res<.1luliou wu still wore iwp-0rlirnt. aod u:iav111d11ble re&afJDS._ . fbey had t i) &tik for the •permi11oioo of .:iir: still mur.i te-•o!i1>nuy a.s ~t a?uglr~ ~~ re,·in~ the uictatonship EIJ 'ffork&d! lo cootrtJl by iueaua o.f a Syu1..111.:atl LT u11k13 bun, the Bey baa already started or will Lie ~tartiu,; ,er, 11~n. _ , pret-tDt Houo1~ary Secretary h&s uut l>eeo alJill lo oarry hi1 00ll1:i1 8 uea of the Syodifate with hiw, and each recurring Syndicate tuet:Lilli hu prored a: " Crisis.'' A fow uurow-mrnded pllrU&a111 w1 1o w. ha·u rec•ived the follo"iug let~riro~ Kh,raj1 T:tamal-nd-din Saheh wi.oh to ruiiro t,he old Cab&l. of tba day& of Nano Mub:1in-ulfro1U Eugl•~µ, wuwb w11 Jeel wurtt would bl! re.4 . !tlulk whom ~ht-J alway;s wi,;hcd l.o "ruu," line beeu miaguiuiu~ th& I.lam ID Eniland, Wit~ 8re..t. iutcrel!L ID luulllf :-••roe fuUowiua pre,,;t>nt Hou•~rarJ ::;~retary, _u,,'i uue of them openly d6!1iteJ tlu~t the l•~ltl& auu go:iuth:uien have 4tolared to Dltl ~hi,tl' Svnuic1tt1 ,b qmld btl • 1.or~ vi L:ali1mit seltietele 1.. d r;tary from a/mt og his most ze11lullli pa1.rti!>llus, forgetttug that the Headley. T}ieir M11sl~1n 1u11ut1-t1 l_ gi_ve "o"ui,,t. t1N1r or1g1nat S,,,m.fuy outut nut to oo the lellut!r of ll pany but t!Je pos ie:i..or of ( l) Ht. Hno ble Li1ru .l:h:aJley-~llUur-~•llm,rn Shaikh Urih111 tuliab 11 the contiu1.1uce of all hi.i cylleaguee. Tile. advice of tl.Jt-te pltt"l.1t1i1ua Fiuuok: (2) V1scou1~~ Uu_K llci Pv1t1~ l a ,1r~ud1 nvl>llll~U j led the Secr~tary 10 threaten the SyuJic.. te with his reJjigDlltiua Zlfa"al11bnr-Raliman ~l11uk.h .:>•illl.i-uJ-u1.a A_bweJ. .PviLter. ~) u P~ ~hortl r ·1 1 . f t ~ t,keo OT Ill ch11rf e oi IJia uilice, it Mr . .Molu.weJ Ali t~in St~uley ~-Krade-:)lttikli ;AliJi1rr11lrniau . . { 4) .Mr. nhi:tt!111 \11'~ eiected t~ the office of the $Jndrn iu chu~H of ~eculu lostruat.ton: \1'lle ( I, Hus,lllll nvlilem•u) Ai1A-ur-H.h1uau Sh.1kh J»l•l-uJ-ui~ ~lr. MoluuneU Ali wu, however, e.k'C'l.ed, .liut reiiigued imrue..ii•te1y )lolta111eu . . (5) A l~Jy_ fn,w Lue; Un,~r p.1u ( iu LuulluD) (Nawe • ternr<)8cd the el~Liua seeu me yet anu ~) n11ine l1$,.,1 beciu gm,u lo Lill(, 1'l.Mln of erery one /who did noi cowe w~uo. the party urlm when ,ac 11 uoitt~ aloo fiome t,rclYll ~li1ldreu uf ,th~ aOvVt!-uu,uuv~a&1t1." We Tl'l'!fd oeiug fiHt1d last O.itob-ilr. Ji111 Opl,K>SHhJU, h01'6Ytr, pruvttd uuc:1n S!)talcfrotn firaL l1aud 1uturlll•llvu uvw i•buuL Lb "ork qf 111 arailiug, llll~ the tiy1\dice now ele-:wJ a~1unst htil w1,;IJ.e.li lllll nut fcul K h jl ll j a S~lteb, aud till:! h1ght21t~ COW!Jli1U1mL Lh11t 'H uan .,.., him inclintoJ to rr51gn 1uuuediately atuuwa.rdt1 uei¥renoe to lw, wii;bes, &ii 1s_ th1At he rem111d_s 111 01 9'1Jat w1:1 . hrue l ' ~ of \lie ear!1 u.1iutvua,itia that " imnrrent " 'AD~ .•• hot-beaded youugi;,te~ .. t Mr . ' Mot1111ued 01 l.sliuu who ldL heiwb anJ how11,. aulol !•Wll.Y •uu uvuutr1 au\:1 Ali, had doqe bdfort,. Ib1a led ti.le Huuur•(J :Secrn\.llry to llJOYe in "eihh aad comiort a~ the OHU oi :uuty, au~ u•u Jui, 11b1Qruiui ~ n the lut n,e,e.l.ing of the Tru.:1lte.8 tllat it the tiuuor11ry S~rt.ltary de.~ir,:1,j ~ _ el_y, the Ul,ilft! lo 011,rry this U l ~ l l ut O'un.r •ud .Suuw1wua t•J appul to/ lh" Tru,alk6 from t.be . d«.11uu11 uf _ ttrtl SyudJc&Le-, thti to evt!rJ lm11g sotu. H1:1 1u~1ve tiguri, auu iutJ6t1li aud uukempi 8rndi1.•at1.1's d~i1:1ioo ahould N-main 111op-dr11,tn·e 10 the !UH:irv.1, but that the lfo~ora.r)' :::it1cre~r,r sl10utd be l."'1! C ta1i.tl 1'li•t~s& 11etivn he ap1.1eullDCr' . wl.o:n t_he ff'urlu exti,t.,; ?DIJ _f .r 01J11 1.ht11Jt1 _p11r~~: .l::iis i.l uo onr.tur, ple.ued iu t~at m•t~r. lu other •1rnrd.:i, the .Sy udk:tH.i sli1.nthi m,m~ly but hll 1mpr~~.s yuu 1,ub 1l111 11~v1u.., ~1ui.ttn~1 ; (ais oo ur.wr cu d6. record the ..+ill of tile Honuruy :,e,::retary, auu uurnrngs.h ... ulJ. iuttH>llU\l !sl1111111c !TIIS.Sl~ll~rl\!.S lll:ll' t!r i > " ~ •u orguui--f10.U wurl.b •i-a1u1 between the. jomnii>'neoce of t.he ~,~rt1_t.r)1 1u . 1rnat h,, ~uu~ lv c~H 110 0i, bu t tl1e1r 111d1v1JuMl l'kal lillocdtiuc!J w1J11ri:, uicrt1 . 01gau1.. L1u1H1 ~l~ .• emer:gt.1ucr,·· au,.l lt.il 8Ubs<-'tprnut r-.Ull,li\lUl! tiy itb.i hu.it)' lht G!.llltrl.l..l.an, •Lv h,rtun.t,Jl , Mito., iou w.lifoh i11 eol1ihL~. .uwg i:::,_, ,uupe aoti U'in~u,J au ou we •llll_·~_,,., haiip,tieBeu more pNp,iek ll f ,1i lh 1 Disappointment~ s0 temble a cha~ilCLer tb:in usu~\ Y. J p~ovide us wit:1 more than . one obituary notice ,b,ntldn ·,~b:~~llc]lcutta, Lahore and All~l_mbad ior our agon} columns. fr,) m~.t~stio,;,_ s~\ch as· this, the. ~rad1t10~al de1w1rn1en: 1s . •· cleat~ In, · \ ,1 hcart-fi~i!ure ·• or ":;mc1de -wh1l?, tem~onmly rnsa?e. h ,,Wt! l'CT, we ~re cheated of ou r ., cupy, we may b~ con~tram~d tll• 8,.,.ne ab 5i>lute heartle ssness 1rnd permaTH'nt 111.samty 1_u th~ · ;.~,iphd,; ~llllt lmrn snn·i 1•ed cll·ar u _ proof of their f j :,nJ i:i!sl!h ~~,, J . We t\re u ,, t perm1tt,d t o say_ wh~ther there 1 ;r ws➔ nut j ,;,)me ptlle sh:et ligh.tuin~ or '' (>i:cas1,rnal l?cal ,\i,) l'IN ~" in the !S abjeet Com1mtlee. Bu~, m the League meetings \\n>m,di,•s thcr <.' j,,:1-; hsrJly eren a •· l!rt't'Zt.l. . .• l{ ,i w,,r ,) r. it j~ riri ioternsting qnest !on wl11l'!1 ut t)rn two tht: weather . ,,r,,•.h,:t~ h:\I'<' l" hn,mer for mMe, i-heir f, jlly or _th,iir falselwu(.L Had ~0/ .. An-.;l ,i-ln,li \1 " heen Rn i., land idm,i,,t entirely cut off fr,im. the urn:n h n,l .,i I n,I;~, we w,)11\d ha Ye hatl 11v ,lonbt whaten'r ,m the subject., f, 1r fn ,b kn ,,w:i only t'->•l wdl that the magnat_cs who used· to ~p,',lk f,ir_~~~-i:1 th,· Dtllll;l \)f the ~l'.1:bnlma_n" U!lll'. so r~ t.: cotlJ: as a ,:: .Jti· ,),· of ,,':irs Mi:·'· and ;y ere the :;lun111g st.a1,, o f th ,, ~o:.lem l:inuaUl l'~t. :,,,, •1.,_,fay -:pull,d up s!rn~p1y if they begin to _talk in rcpresenh t iH· t\•:,·,·nt.,. 1 i1n,1 ,h i1h1 mth no greater bnllm_ncy than the h,rnlk- , i n~,d ,)ti r,,rkeh. But ··Angl~-In.dia" still holds th" :rnd b'.ad,, ~nt!d stumps as 1f tney were torches tha'. ,: ,,1U L:ht 11;1 the path. o i prugress. () 11 r ,:, t,•l' mj, J c. ,nt etnp •H;rr_l", the kmar, publishes in its j,,._1p ,·f th ,• :!:d ln.,;L1 11 :. :1 J,..ttu 1u·tte1 y "1\ :\[,,lianrni.lan genlleruau "f 1i:.•h ~ .. ,• i,d ! pc•~ it id:1," whc,~e featnres we lravct· our equolly irr,'pr,•~,;j i, J,, ,· 1l'rc•,p,,nd,•nt. ·· lhmbooq nt'" to id.-i1tify. Hining writ\ ,, n t h,, l,·ita. :\S it is stated , .. on tho em of tho li <> l-iin~ ,. f 1'. 1-· .~!1 -J:d :a M,)~ls~iun at Agra", thi~ ~l ,h.i,;1 • h :. ,; ,· nd,· aHrn ,, i hi ,d1 :iill·ial po;;itil)n iudnlg-l•,l in ~o:mi r '',l : tr so . :I\} aLif, L·lurrdl and can _ genuinelJ e) : ll!P•~hii,e wit .h.is ._•_ · . eon _ ae_, .... _ • _ f.iitft. · -~. r . ' • · .. · _ · . , . · . • , l _ • . · . . · _ • , . : cannot agree with rt. Bnt we GUL'lt y we weNi :not. f in'l · · , ·ftttti · the zeal of the new eont'!rt with whic ont! or t,ro dttiet' geatl•~ ran down the views of Na•ab Fateh Ii Khan Saheb.(" Their aUil\'.lcl~ was too reminh1oeot of the Mu.allafat-1-Qultib who s~lled the raUlm of the Troe Believers after the taking of A i politlt'lian , . of necessity be an opportuniet; _bnt o po~nniam is by .no • same thing u absence of eonvictione. efttwe m~t :~ e what. ~ we can to ~he Hon. ~i•~ Moba Shafi who too~ •!1 early_ol>~ Mecca. months agobviomily and confess .· his de . fectio~-ar. f·.rfrom om. .l.ast S . . e•.·_s.any i·.on'sattempt _·po .. •.l.iti····e.· al ..·, creed had misjudged him. making at. hacksliding Mr. Shafi emphasised his rm adherence t;() the · ~eag~e•• creed, and although there were some ni mbers who . mi~ht have oppo'se4 · it-s adoption had they tnkeo the tronbl ·to attend the Lucknow SeMioU last Easter, there was not one except INawab F11teh All Khan Sabeb who showed the least desire to move f,\iat the l,eagn~'11 creed shoold be reconsidered. \V c, however, r£se~ve for another issne 'onr . o~rvation11 on Mr. Sh11ti's ourions mi~rea~ing-, of the Presidents t vit•• on the . s:1hject, wl'.ich ro~s hi:9 taJd1 rl-i-'1.1hcl (renewal of faith) of much of its grace, 1f - ,~ot eincenty. Another noticeable foatnre of discn<1.. sion the silen_ce of Messrs. \Vazir Hasan and _ Mo amecl Ali, who mnet have felt the needlessness of asserting ,hat Lord Crewe had doubted. narnely, the £~ct that. t_hey represetted the politi~al attitude_ •nd temper of lnd1an Mu~salmans _even 1_:more clearly · ~ban the L1beral Cabinet represented the p:ilitical attitpde and temper ;of Great Britain. ·• On the creed of the Le.a~ue the s~al WAS set. by the President, Sir Ibrahim Rtlhimtullai1, Kt.., than who-ta a better choi,::e could not hue been mnde for this occ11:.ion. Sir Ibr~hiin has the inestimable advantage. ~f the accumulated experience ofi twenty years M· pnblio life in perhaps the most. bnsin~s-like Pnh-ince or India. 'His sturdy common-sense and clear in~ig-ht give him \an ftlmost nn(janny shrewdness. an(l all clas,;es 0£ pJ:oplo in that m psaic of communities, Bom\ia7. recognise him ail an indit!pens:i.ble _ii.s-ure · "like in •__the Corporati.oo, and the Legislative Council. Nor d,ics Government.place less rnlianoe thl\n the people q£ hig Province in I the jud~mont. j of Sir Ibrahim ~·,_,1,'rt tht' lll'i ln•, i:\!L1 wr,•st Tr d lll the u,rn rp rm; tlrn pnw er and ~trc!1;gth ·,:·,: ,' : :':': "',::·:1i:ii:_:,::i:~;:;::~;~~t~,;:· ;;'\,:;~"; :;,~.:·~:::::; . 1 dt ::;;l;, OQ-~--~ mean~ •-- t.unity -t-o re-iterate the . faith he bad expre~ Ot\. !hte .Pres,denµ.J Address of Lhe last Session in .the idea of self-go•errimeot edi~d· .to India. Those who feared that he won d 11wallow th& 1rords of nine 5 11 1 1 ~\ 1~, ·::;;;;::::r~\t::JS'i'i.~ •s,11::.~1\~t,,,:,:~r L~l~1s:·~uti.ng. to_ ~1'.::v,~oi~~n:(~ ,rn I ,,:,,,,· ,· ';1, , " th,:i r own pnis, . m:r; that our "Mohnmednu ~eu tlein ·.1:1 ,,f i, i.;-h , , ·tril pr,>Yided him se li d fo 1• Daily ::iIHil'' with m · i·,, 1\i,in " " e of g,'nernns dimensions ii, iu the el'eut tlf the w\i,,,, i;; nn such oecasinns om1liemi,;tic:\ll\' · call-,d or-.i :>r ,,: the (hJ -w_a,; _.,t;!U'<' g,1i p/11.t. "It. t,n-~ d,)nbting pr,,rhet; " t.hat. at the coming !\t t' :Hly ·t:-Ui tLrnce and s 1ber ITisdom m,\y l>f irresp,,nsibte urd l.;it -hl,>;1,li~d v1111th 11\'.\S kc,•p its ~oun~ul and lit·tte r not sp,iak in th;; wi!l be rre:itd.'' How e.er. 8-3 things fin1lly ancl stoe r da.~-." did nnt sncceed in "r211tiug' _the p~wer nnd :;tn,n_gih tlwy htH tl appropri11ted to fr ·11 .. _,'1,: .. th "11,,•!v ,• ,. n . ,.Id the1~ niice" h!ep its coun;,el" and di!oy it,;clf th-~ :-1-.•:i,a r,• ,.j ~i• s."• c·h. There was no "p1111demonimr" exNpt snch 1 :1-: .. , 1,.• ,an,• :rn,I _ :.:,,h;-r ch,," th t•mseh f s created, for the y know as '11' ,_, 1) "' ~n~· ,' '. til' r ) ht' ;i wet''. u, ,,,: ,:;f ",;tirri11g up tho -m asses,"· Ii W:\ -: _f_' :11',' l '. !lt ,) th• ti m,, th!\t efforts w,l14J b~ 1~11de ti► go ba~k " :1 th ,, ,·:·• •.' l -i l ,:i at 1'll'e '! flt !,ar,•ly uine m,. )n!!is S~•) ,as regards the ideal ·•.•: nm1•11t ,rnit ?,l t ,) India, :rnd tha t- the b:g drnm of the · ' ;. '' , -;,, , ; ~ .i 1 h,:; :i t !! <1 11. ~\\'<'(~ _-\meer _-\.E \~O(tld be bt>aten with a veoiseance. A ,h)· '' : ti,_,i_ ag~1 t!i e C nit€d Pr,)vince;; League, after a tough 'fi~ht between t--. .:-hn ,,:,;\:'. 1b and:11. sense ,,f disc ipline', had de()idinl that t~hnicalitiee h:1d w, o t! :t' J,1:,, tl nd the id,.,al oi self-gr)\·ernment must wait for anolher 0 ! '1r ;ik,~a ~ unJ~11-trial criminal when ~the U .P. League would ._ p,_ ',:r,r~,p ,ucls!ut,~ .st, iu,1om .••ctand wbollJ mwlPad.ing~tof tha-. clian:, an,! "" ishall_ ~ failing in ou dut;, if we did not ~ noh --. : 'rrnt. We ~lie,e lhai tbia wu perhapt1. t~e 6.rtrt ~ oa ~,~;.:n :-ia"ab Fa~.ih Ali Khu Saheb atutnded a mH&i~ of ~ All-. .,tJ i • M,,,i;lc,m L~,gue, and we admire hi. COGr&(f11 ia faeiag ao ~ •uc-h _M thtl ooe f.iilil.t0tbl~ at Ag,a with a ~ wh~ if __,... 1'vu!J ha,e ma.ie:Uit, K ~ 1 ridieaao.. We ~~&ikh.-Ghnl~-Sadi,•~t;:' ; 1 jihe ',,"as. (bhirnt.nllah, whom tho Government io f Bombay &J'.e as anxious to make their IJWT1 llllll)inee ns the peo~>lo . make him their (')ooted rcpr('S(•utatiYfl. Hi:i Presidential Address is in 1Mny respechl nnique, and takes m, back to the famons A~nritsar Sessiot,t of ·mos wheo the lfon . Sir .Ali Imam lt'Apt : nt 0110 l101u1,l intfl la.~ting fam e. Wu ,i)mll uot snbj,'-Ot this add're8S to tho ' mutilation and dittmemh_ermcnt of extructs and qnotatio~.:i, and mnst reqnrst on·r r·eaderB tP rt>!i.-1 it in it ,; er1tirety. "\V,i refo r tl j~ni parlknlnrly '.to the Prn8identa• own pnlitical··fait,h, which Wll sli:ll'o in full, Md ,vhic[t ha.~ the sanction of ,no lc.ssa person th:rn His Mnjestiy the King-Emperor. With a _faith sn~·li a,; his, Sir lbmhim wrJllldihan:i been th~ la.st to quarrel 1 with the Lea.311e -s"\i1fo ill, nnd alth t:,ngh self-government suited to 'Incfo~ nppeMS l o him Yl.\~lle and iuaetinito, as compared with eelrgn, he frankly lackoowledge;i tl1at tlw League m •1st lrn1·e had go,)d rea.-;ons for 11do~ti"hg. it in the form in which it is mnlwdieJ in tfi,1 Lea~nu•~ Cuustitutioo. . ; . . Tho rnn.!l•)Ils t,.1 which Sir lbtiil) im a!lmltJ.'I will b~ apparent. if wo seek the :'-.~.,i,; tan cil .c ,1 co11w111p,)r.;ry lli-,-tory. \V!lurn the Con~reea adopted tho ideal oi siM-governmen~. it lul'l 11lrM1ly ~,en 11plit,_ op inh) two rirnl· t .t.iupi of MoJer:,t~~ - au,:i Ext.re111i~t.s at. Snrat., aod tho lattN wu,~ insi~tiog on the C~o:rrei!-il' declaring it&elf for an imme,liate progr11111me nf absolute iSwaraj without the •git of ~he tn British Crown_ The creed of the Copgre!III wa~ tbor,;fore U,e creed of the Moderates, IUli.l was in reali11 only • rie~ation i}£ the Extrenaieu' e r ~ League's. cre,ed i;i, on th~ eonl rary, the creed of it.a ~led Extrem~~ho •~ ho1'ev,er~ far m!)re nurnerorui tlhan the eeU◄yW moderates-and it, il'I a positive auert,ion of so!D4:1t,l~iog to wbiob ; ilae commnnit.y cou\d well a.spire at a um~ when it had ftll,J.y foaDd i'8 eelfconsciou.sn8$S but wu still uncopll(lio!nA of the object iof it.I upirallom. In the Congreu a group of men i were taking road tha, •wa dangerous, and the lead, rs of anothe~ aud • ranch l~llr group direci&ed il to • safer path. In the L ~ . on tho othelj haod, al) were uxiou1 l-0 go aomewhere, hat, DO ci;oe kne" wbitler to go. The well-known Y'f!nte of llf½i.1 exp~ ~he aitoation ~ +· --~J~£J~'--Jr~ .J.J.,1., .,,,.-&,, f .:.,-..,.al~~ ~I know baugbt. of the dei~ned g~l. All th.l l : koll1r ii i ~ & , r- --~- the llOund of the earavan bell i~ be-ar4,) . .·. Tbanb to R:. lJ'. the' Asa ;lC.._ _ ·!'hd ¥r. WJa!t t.011 in wbieh the CMaJln• 111.t' 111attfa ui ~• ho•• idMl MpltYM o~ fo11D of_._,,_ -go•+-_,~..,. _. '_- .... _ ! it uwrw aoother. n. ~•• i ~ t■JJ aep&f 1o,r(l•....... - ,............. H-... u.au-,. :11M · ~ .·_ ~ - - .. . ., the ~ •egali _..,.....,. _eci_~ _ibe 1el..v .._.'_ ·-_-._-_· ,,_ ~~- -'a..U -,· ~ -_'_· _ · lb,JIOIW _.-...,_. . ___,._j"'"' _·_•. _ - thi.tititou _.foe. oal7 11 . · ~ ~ - - ~ ·--lioaaol . ,..,.._ , • ·r ff{ ·:i>_ ·; : The··· -Comrade. __ 8: i ~not be c ~ io a rigi4, monld, and so iocommelisurable a thing as premptory demaod. :Mr. W azir H n;could well h~ve deferred r~plyin _ Life eannot measured by a foot-rule. _T he League's is a vo1,age to this ·letter; liut ~r. Ameer Ali anted that before _he left E~glan . he of diBCOver1• •H koo~B that it ca~oot rest wbere_it ie:-,._o1_it £0)1St. in three week~E! thfl Honorary Secretary of the All-India . Mosle .. eeek and di ver _nocharte4 lands I~ the same d1rect1on •.n wlnch League "will be good enongh to in orm \1S of the vJe•s of his Council/ the most pr gressi,e part of hnmamty .J1as sought 1tnd d1eco,~red And because he did so in the ost. nnexcepti9nable ,manli~r, them. Bu"t the very byp<)tlie-sis of · uncharted lands ~nggeste President of the Lo_ndon Branch de~n1ed it lit •._i to_ resign hi1:1.____ hig numerous ·1s oJ. the sea, and if success is to be attained caution . offi~. • , . : 111oat be com · ·with courage. _ , The London B~anch has neve ~en self-suppor~ing.' In additiol). as still donbt the wisdom of _ striving towards t? th~ All-I_n~ia ~ea~ue's syh'l'~n ion, H. H. the ,~ga Khan_ lu;ls bee* Of sue the only g)al consistent with seU-respect and national dignity hbera.ly a.<1s1st1ng 1t, and_ we tl11_n Mr. Am~er Al,1 has been m receip~ we shall nly a11k : Are you content with the life of Lotosof--fnnds from other lead10g fnd~& ~tnsl;almans also. We believe th~ eaters, and tisfied with t h e ~ )deal it can be called-conannual subscription of thci Lo don Branch i~ five shillings, an~ t&ioed in thitse drowsy verse8 : · . 11lthQ11gl1 tbt1tre are -sernrnl hundr .d ~iussalmans in Great Britairi : .. Let fa s swear an oath, and keep it with an equal mind. the total realised frorg..niembers· . ub;:criptione does not exceed £, · .. In 1e hollow Latos-land to live and lie reclined or a modest- sum of Rs. 10 a mon . This is becaQs~ most of the Mussal--.._ "On he hills like Gods together, cftrt>less of mankind . mine in Gre.at Britain resent the anner in which the Right HonouL -,, Or wonld y 11 rather drink lifo, like Uly~, lo the lees, and with able Syed Ameer Ali acts as the ictator of the-London~League · an1 - ~ restles.'!n ~s that leads to progress, " roam ~ith a ~11 ~1gry hellrt?" brings ont, aft.er the least differeope 1,f opinion, his threadbare resign~111 experienc~ to be anolht>r name for retrogression, or 1s it to betion. With re_ference to this, Drl. Aod-nl Majid, J,L. D., Lecturer. a, t I "An arch wherelhro' . the Colonial Institute, Dr. Ansar~ who le£t England only in 1911,. that untravelled world, whose ~1111rg10 fades • - _ _, and Major Syed Hasa·u Bil gram~ could unfold a ._:_t ale wh -ich wo_ nld e " For e,er and for ever when you move' ? far fr1,m edifying. A recent ins(once of such differences of opiniqn Will yon l!-t : . . __ ./ was the London League's action over the Cawnpore affair. Whi,l , "Sn ly, surely, slnmber is ~iore lllTeet ~han toil, the shore, r--....... --,.! Moslem India was seething wi b indignation the London Lea!lii, "Than laboar in the deep mid oce11n, wind and wave and oar : took no action . whatever. ll11t fhen Lord Hardinge announced i a " Oh jrest ye, brother mariners, we will not wander more" ' settlement of the question, the right honourable gentleman was amoJg 'Will yon nqt rather IIAJ: the 6r3t to come out. with a-resol~tion of thanks. . Having no share in I .. Come my friends, the grievance he must needs tfke the lion's : share in expressi ~1g "'Ti& not too late to seek a newer world, gratitude ! But that was not all , He pressed on the London League ~~~ off, an4_ 11itting well in order smite, a resolntion of thanks to-Si t Jame& l\Jeston ! Even the wo~m _ turns, and the Committee stoutlt opposed the resolution. The righ• · "Th11ionnding farrows i for my pnrp 088 ·hold,. "To ail beJond the snn~et., and the baths bononrable gentleman was outvoted and in this extremity he tnrned ... Of II the Wt"Stero f>tars, nntit I die, for support to-Mr. \Vazir Has~ ! He asked the Committee whetller Th~' mach ie taken, mnch abidt-s, and tho' _/_ · it would poss the resolution if tbe Honorary Secretary of the par~n, ,' -. · -,./"" Wei are not now the strength which in old. daya Leagne approved of it. We horlonr the Committee for their rt>ply. '-'- ', "l_Iored euth and heuen ; th.at which we are, we are : They said that they were prepar6d to hear anything thnt Mr. W azir , ·• Onf pqual ti>mp!_'r of heroic heart!!, . . Hasan had to say on tho sn?ject, but they ; mnst hove an cpp~r, ~hde wuk by time 1mr\ fate,lrnt ~trong m will tunity of criticising his suggcsli? u if th ey felt disposed to do so, and _ ,.., "To !stri-re, to set>k, to find 1med hare so ignominiously failed, it is necesia~ry M:na~almans rf'sident in Great ; Britain nsi;embled at the Waldorr 1o truphlL'-ljH! cantion !'Vrn more than courage, and "e heartily Hotel, at tho invitation of Mr. Sadiq Has:in, the u11iversally honuured aapport SirJibrabim's advice in this connection. and admired son of Khan l}ahndur Sh11ikli Ghnlani Sndiq, ~Ld i ---aubst>qnently at Cn~t nn H111l, ,a t the invitRtiou or the Committee and its London formed at the pm·in11s met·ting, :ttrny w1•rc all cir one mind in con1lertrnl I _ing t,he mRnnt>r in wl1ich :'i1r. :\ 1~1e1? Ali rxercised his dir.tatorsl\ip, ---.Auuouou it · i~ undnnhtt"d that "An~ln-Tndia" wns extrc>mely th ongh they acknowledgrd snhmrs~rvely en ough that the office-bea1'er1 anX1.·0_11s thid' tl_H) A_ 11-lndi_a ~.(fo;;Je~n I~rl\gn e shonl1_ 1 gn o_nrk_ ll['ll'll the would hR\"e to act in R se mi didnlnrial manner jn II Le11gue most: of --' Ia-~t E as t er 11s regnr d s It s \C ] "n,e, a•~ d the mrmbers of which 1,ere onlv V/ith a vie,, not' to dec.r,;wn at Lwh11;lt 1t l!Rd arnn>u • students a bast•rd " isrlit" cnnceind hJ tho Jo -llool:ams of MMJ.. m Indra offend Mr. Anwer Ali's snsrrpt /bilities they did not pass a resol11ti on WM expt>cted to see the light Qf the d11:y in tli~ "sec~nd Snrnt" uftN_ n!ne oprnly complarning- of his manner of dictating to the meml>ns, ba1 11100ns' gtislation, no one can dt•ny tl!nt gcmpnc d,ft~n•nces of np1_11ion n11•rpJ )' dt.•i-irell that nndt• r thr ai1spiC('R or the L-owlon LHu.pie n meet· in,.,. ,,r" all ~1,,s!_(•m I11rlia11s rrside_n t in Great :Brit,1irt slwnld bo conn"ed eonld also IIexist on the 11nh1rct -•~d Ms 11n_1t• f~rmHl n11 • e pr 1'j'or.1• 11 Dul •~ dn not know lww an.J-. one c:rn cunnnc-e us tlu1t. .-cprnlly au(! steps slinnld be corr;;idne!I fnr inereui11g tl10 nnmber of i1a m~m~ rnt1ine di~t•rences ()r opinirin C ()llh\ uist on the l;Ubjt•cl of the ~i81it bHS. Hnd Mr. Amror Ali c11Hea !lllch a meeting, he lfould l~u 1Jonoun,li1tr Mr. Ame~r Ali'!!,-lCml\nd~, And h.1w they N11 ld c11lm1m,te learnt things that it is necesSMf he ,hould __l!!&rn. in,. "si,Ht !' in the Lea~Ui:'. No one can deny ~fr. Anwt'r ,\li'R' grcat · ~ 4.iL_ t\_;;·J ~i.)~,..,-j ~ ability i,.ttd !tl10 st>r,l"i~s lte liM rendrml_ to hhm. AS the antbnr ~f v• 8et' ~ra1 u ~u"bflt-1rorks on_ Mo~ lt•m fo11h Anti l11story. ~n fa('t at U-. JI._ 1JOUld be a~ impt•rtinenct'I for mo~~ o_r n~ Hen to bur te~hmnny. to Y tlie~ undt~nbted seni1·t>8. Nnr u~ 1t hkely thl\t any one ,.-1ll ques ► 1 o n But fe11ring a gener11l con1einnati,rn Mr. Ameer Ali ignc,red tl,i1 &he u~l "nll energy with whirh Mr. ,\ml'ilr Ali 1rnrkt•d in Engl"1HI for re~1,lntio11 of tho lll l'(•t in~, nod merely 11cknm, lcdgcd tltc rr11ulu !ioa 9'Curing fn~ M 1111.. ~lmans iwp,ua le eloctor"tes in Indian lq; i~L1tmt.s, aski 1,~ l•im tu witlitlruw Iii~ tl'~ ig nnti1in, 11l1l1c,11gh l,erc too Im iguqred Uionich h.-~ hnnonn wl'ro di\"i'.1t,,t, am\ snn1t' nf tho pr01 •Mals 11! ~ the qu11lific:11ti,:, 11s with which thn 1 n•q11csl wiu, qartfully heJger Me not in qnt>SI ion tmd th ose While on the snbjrct ur th ~ London LeRg:ue's financial position, who i11tr11de them in tht' PN"IWnt di,;;c_~l~,;i,,n pMve ei tltn llH•ir in,•apaeity it mny n,1t Le ont of J•lill'C to mention tliat, considering the amount oJ for clearlj' ijudRing J1<1lifo-&l i•$11esnr fl11·i1· de-ire to doud tlw~e rai~ llld l'ftr1' not ,rnnnd np ew•n nftll!r ll month and a h11lf~he l1aq t• l,e r.-gular,y aud pnnctcall.r r,,rt! tl"Ollli11 ,~ ," dt'sirrd ii to bt' ahs,.h,ttly l,11ik: out ror other r~~ources wherefrom to' J-IJ his ste.oograplier: accoolli1i4ual. litfore Mr. \\'azir Uasto het-tnio tl1e, H (• noruy Tht" Red C'rt'~ce nt .,·nrk WR.' L at a slandstilL But there wu iatiD 8'<-rdary 1,-.f the All-India Ltag-110 the annual sub,·~ntit,o wa., ,,nly tbe pr. pof al of• M,,~q11e in London, which ~ a:i so drar to l,im ~l1a~ R•. ';{;0; ibul ~ 'f,n afln l,it111n·1ti11tm1•nt ht i1H•rr,11i-t'\I it to r:~. 1,000, he '"·u t'rt'n prrpurd for its SAke to let th~ Woking Moeq~e b. ut.l --• Cflnltmplaring • futtl ,rr tnrru~t 0f R8. ~00, u .Mr. AnHtr \ )used _. ont to Christian lodgyll__ ,rather than be;handed over to Kb~ - ,ja Ali duirt>d, ,rl ,t'n lht latttr unl lii11 1•rt'TI1J•t11 ry drnumd . -His 1,ller Kamal-ud-din fur dirin . . .orship. for fear 1it may jeopardiMt: l1ia of th, t::? ~d O<-tN.itr wh id1 wt haH• alrt'ad)' Jl\\l•li~htd i.. , we Hf' t0ny own projPcl. He therefore tri'ed to plAN! atenogr.phtr'• .'ta., to hate t~ Ny,; c.bau<.-tni,tic of tl,o li'ttlJ!('r flf ita autl1or. Ne-edit~on the London lfo;;que Fund ; but. thank• kl the CommiU~ th• •lf-laudtiti1 n.-· ol'jullt df'prt ~iali t1n 1\f 11,fi muita 0r ntl ,tr • 01ki'111, attempt- Iailem fome Indian books of t e ed11gn n' ot ap~!\r on the credit side either, so that \qe M06leru donor oes r · f b· t· to Leiwnf's linmmittee ha,·e no opporhm1ty o o 1ec mg . • Londo_n ~ . '1 turn for pnl!s such as the T,mu, the Daily a subsidy ral id ~fn . Post and the Daily q,·aphic have recently Te.l1?'·aph , tie " or r rn.J' IV re ,, publ1!hed.M WazJ H:l.San·s reply to Mr. Ameer Ali's perempto~J :Now • r. 1 ara~1te1cd permanent snbrnntion was no more than tl11s: demand for :,111f '. t l 1 11 ,itlicient Lc8 guc c:m be maintaiuc..~ · here ouly _at l du n.-c0 !! "" ti,, a I n•t nud I ha'l'e- discussed this mntter with gflnt.._!o say · would bu prcpnr;,,'portiou to the support. which_th e London Brauch i,· c5 t~·, ,he ,n\rk ,,£ tbc pan•ut L~ague and Jts proJr·c ts. . . , iu tht· i '.".f;,, :i'~ \- 1 W; w,rnld wntlirc t u :\.Sk at tl11s stage what there was lD th1~ re l · l,) "distinctlyl ,,ff~n~ire communication tttw~~r. Am:er Ah c-0~fd fl,ue n~~aft ~r thrc>.:- dnys' ea.r nest search h1r sup~setl rnsults. .Now uole ~Ir Am d,·r a\li's reply: . · f ou a ' i;v ind i--,llc that the ~ub,·eutitm from (he Ccnttl\l League tothe L i I ... rnµ ..,. ,uh! l,c in 1,rupvrt io n to 1hc support the laltcr ~1ve11 d ' prvj<.>c ts"' c>f the Ccntr~l L!.'llgu?. far t.hc 1-?ndon Lc<1 "IC has cM,linlly suppork,i 11.ll pn."'JL'Ct!I which, _m 1t,i contide~ercd in~:tl'etii<'nt ill: 1 he be ~t i11tcn·sts . of the. c" 1nm11111ty. ~ i-.1111 th1a COUille it will uot ,kvi ~tc under my pre.i!Lk.J.J.tah1_p. . . The comliticm v.:hich yuu now wish to impose on the d1scret1on . and judgui~nt oi tlje Lu tHhin L~1guc I r~gr~t l ca_nnot accept. lt1! my aettk, \ cunv:ccion, r(' peatL-dly dee.Jared _111 public,_ that _t~e :\!u~lmana ef In dia, whil~t claiming a LI \l recngnit10n of th eir legn1~!\~e interesta .111rn! due c,rn,;ldc r-.1t io11. of the ir fl'clings and suscepu lnlit1~, aho~l_d eulc ini.u: a 5-<:!~SC uf ,,roportion annl w:t!j c'1c h olbi:: r :,,nd the Go,·erumeu~ . . lo lvngas I a,n ,::..,nn c'Ct.c, i with th is Le:1g11e l,w1ll sub~1t to no ontm.de d ii:ca1,,1u. n,>r I ai!ow it u adopt nny pn,g,nmme_ wllhou~ the fulleia «>n,;iJcrntivn ii.:! cun~.:11:en v• t(l our cowi:nu.n1ty. .,, t}~;,~'ll.. ,;:::~t ~1 So if This introdnt·e:1' tho second nnd more impo1Ttan~ demand of lfr. A11ll·er .\Ii . i ,\;; Mr . MohNll1t' d Ali !ind pointed out. at the nH•cl :ll ~ of tho 4,rnd thi~- m,)Jt•:;t nomendntnre and at0cd iLrth as." lhe All -lnJ ia. M,>;i,h·m League, L1>nd on. " Tliis, 1re 1-re,-u 111e, wa.;i or.Jc uf tl.i .. se imp ~1cC i•ti l,lo ~ilrnt •• :re.:nnstitutiuns ot tL~ L.. 11d, ,n Leag11f " II a bn~i:; ,.,f cu-urJi1rnti,m" or wliid1 Mr. ,\ met-r A Ii is i;,, f,l11d. . ll f is a l1,i,~riun of cun;-iut>rnLlc rt•pute and "e t.,:k l,1m wln·lht•r 1t ,j-ns ni1t 11reL' :Hly this prnce~s nr i,np<>rct>pti':>le sil+'nt fl'i." ,,11a,1i1u1i ., u· · of 13.:ugal, l>,•(can nrhl 011Jh "nu 1' ha..,;i,i of co -ordiuali uu" wl.id1 led t0 ~:w d i,-iu tL'gr11ti,,n ~nJ downf~!l or the o n ce mighty ll,,f;h"i Etui,in•. Tli,r..e....~as th is diffenm ce. h,)wt!,;er, bet1Teen the ~w ,1 !Jrul·e~ ,e,. Th t. Sl\t:rt1ps ,,f tl1t! .MoghRI Empire, although l'qoally llllfl'-\\ 1..; 1\ t ul ·• out~i,lo tlit·t11tiun" or discipline 7 as the i;anie;...thiug nay V<1r1 ;, usly Li~ ""fled-t, n,k ;;,wd C,He a:I th,.- ;am,.1 bJ obtain from a • _,.Ilk E:11p,•r<>r :i WMr.iut f,ir tlieir ,.nm intle pcnJ,rnce ard i_n:s_11bordi11~twu . H.. tit<'r th.~u b,1 snd1 11 wel\k Emper,>r, H. H . tl,e .-\ga l:Ui ::iu hH 1,rs· inrt!J ;t, r,·siKn his cwrn ot1ico, so that he lea~es ths A H-loJ i:\ .\1 slt' m I.;.,•agnt 111d its London Brnnch t.o settle the matter with .,u, u1a~iug hi1~ rt:$p,,·,n'silile for the con-t>qneoce&. But l!°P l1u sh,,wo .:le!uly eno1Jgh th11t di ctat orial and eTl'n @emi-dictatorial Ill<' :h.' ,~s src now ou t-of -da:e, autl hP, at any rat e, ij geouiue.17 glad that lt IS ~ ) . YI Ou tl.1~ :!7th 09-·oor-~lr Auu,er Ali un.-x~ttodly ft>lt, or declu.-J tlut lie> f<'lt~aitu foll three days· CO)(itallon iu the ciou,- of •liich 11 ~ ~1 1,.,.,nd hi:1; reAdiue.s.i,, tu give a coruplitnentary diuni>r to Yr. W u1r H_~ u, and ;subs~q llt'Utly applim:i t -,> the L ord Cb1ncel1,,r nen for P'rt.1,·tpati ,,n in II politiu..l Jinuer-lhat h~ had . l~n inJnlted by Mr . \\ It.Ir Has.au in the h.itler of the 2-ith le to the Comrade frn1* Marseil.e11 to the samt, effoot Fuur ctl\)'S after lliis Mei;ar11. Amulr Ali. I.ti£ a11d Anik wrote to t.be Lomlon League Commiltee withdrawing their resig-natio11s, and three tlay11 lat~r Reuter cabled the Timu • ven,ion of tl1e l~r'l;ccne in this opera-bou.ffll. wlaicb we publish elsewhere iu full. Now here is i a ctirioua •• rlt constitution." Mr. An1eer Ali resigneJ on the 29d1 Qdober am! M~rj, Latif and Auik, fulh,wiug the priueiples of Larki/1:,irn, Wt!pt on a •• aympatl1ctia ,trike:' But· Lho r,·si).{n11tiun11 coulJ ndt.,. tiike erfi!.ct, :for Mr. Anik was provinl{ hii, ab litieM a; an ex Jert :•coouotant_ by delayiol{ oyer ; acco1wts or ,rnme huudre_d odd l'ound!I fora month and a hall. Ererythin~, therefore., went on as a nsual a• ~f Mr, Wazir f:J ..un and hi1 . -◊-~lh~ insnlta and dictation bad neTer existed. N~ chaoge whate,er occurred in the rulei, or membenbi~ of the London League or the .AU-India Leag,oe, but leu than aix weelca later, Meara. Arueer Ali, Latif and Anik appe•r a.11 usual on the scene one ~ne morning ti> ann11unce the 11nns1111I fact that lhc entir~ universe had al~red oYernighl. "The L oudon All -Iudi11 Mo rn Leagt1eha.,i been reco11.titured", clucu the 1'imn a"I if ,wor a new· ,ti,J e that.1h11d been hatch~d int e Pria~ ing UciLMe Sq n:i. re im:ubatnr. But on. exl,.mination the &$3 appt,ara ~ b. the aociPnt prodnllt of Hl08, re-la~lled ° Frellh " I in 1911, awl "New-laid •• io 1913. or !v VIII ! 1f. lhi1 ~m•ke-belie,e pleues ¥r. Ameer ~If we haY11 no reaaoo...-,io obj~t. But le~al t fiction• have [ the ha~& ~f: OCCIL'liona1ly OY&r-riding the la,r !and ' from ~ing lwrfen&ed a.lj11Nt1di CGIIM b~ame innontfons uaed corri9trtdi ~_qua. . To Ul;. ..,. a.hall alway1 11trongly ol:>ject, .ad it. ~• with ~~ qbjfci tltat .,,. emphasize tho fM:'8 of tbe caee'. Wi~h rere~to !thi• qnea&ioo, Mr. Wr.zir Baun's opinion : contalned in bh . reply 1.o Ht. A~r Ali's la..,L leU«-r i1 well worih reprodoction.! He •role::; Yoca bAve. buwtn.r, intro.1!1-Cbd ia y,wr letter• matter of pri~cfplci wbJob 'ot the fflOltt far,.reachi.a r, imp,,rtaQ4,;!. ~el1. the ~ I p al ~ All.lo•I~ MQlllorn Leaflie-wbicb J i..-1 JOO l'ffi:r to oa (lltCI _ _ . . , • Ute Lacl111,- ~ &be Loodoa MoeHIID i-c-- Tim '- • •bjeoc; wb- 1- bappU7 wbalt7 l ~ t of ou- ~ ' " ~ • aallt-, ud l .b(lpe JOG. trill foirstN if I a,dd,- ~ - tie •bjeel wk.b .,_. ._pbMiL . I alao hope~ •iU 1IOi rep,d I •1 .. UIA.ll,...J•)' abo•l U.. wort et ~ l a l __ 1_liia..... ~ ·. a. , 1¥ ..._ i"'!rw-. ..... •~on,-,-,,; aar .,., .m,.,. ~~JtM• ...,..... ... o ... _ _ .. .... )low, 1 aainwia &JIM ,be polki7 ~ Ute ..... l-.- In Jndi-.aart.w,w .· ...,. _ ..._ . . i ~-~ . .. lald - - -"• .a. ad . · . 1, •. - .- ..; · . . . . . . . . . . .. i.id dowala -~ ~ U .I poaiblefot• .. •-" ..,...,. la "-I-of Ila aN ad,_-; ~t ;! I ' i '. '. . .I ~e Cbmtade. 10 !!n1i:1~iho~~1:a: fr!~!.hl! ~ca:e~Jbt~!:~f ":r~ • I arranged. to 0 Thli ia very dU!erent from •y dtetaUug a policy r~nd I need hardl7 usure J~hat 111Jcb an idea nevll{ cr089t\d my be ~ /!-- ! ,;::;t branch, tbe 111b,cnLion f~m t~e 111-lndia Moslem League to the .·. Lon?o" T do not~ what ob1cct10~ you have., or can ha•e, to ~y po1nt011t the very obvious fact tbat 1t would be, .... yoo say, "in proporlo the 111pport the latLer giYes to the .,.ork •nd project, of the Ce tral League." This is a matter or principle., and, as sncb, I believe, ~ wcon tat.able. What Is more, it ia a matter of fact and baa to 1,e pted. Whether the London League baa, as 7ou say:, "cordially 1 11 0 •=l11te11 '.' ,•l-e'' ' · (To send ns i wandering in. se•roh of t~e / fnneral proc~io~ falsely annonn<;i.~ g one's deat every dat !) ' ·r •. ' · ,. . : Mr. Ameer ,Ali bas to ta e orders ~eit~ei: fro~ the·; -~- ·. . _. I ~or hom Lucknow, He has o tak.e orde1:9 :from ·a pow~r:---a. d)~..) l& undoubtedly a greater powe~to;-d·ay than ,t was. ever b ~ ~ - i . whose dictation. no p11blic ma can pretend ~ . be free: i It ~ p<>~er of the pu,bli.c voice, a vo c~ ·. that may .a_t, ·· times be b.· ith exc1temeot, or unsteady ace ding to the mfluencee to ~bich it is ial uekyI •. ;!i~:~~ri:i::: ~!i!.~,ira ! :~:~e~j~~~~ii:1~11~ so~p.tible.• but"' .·. hich ia n~net~.elei!s, s~fticieot.ly· .~l~ . to-d .·· . ay.,: aod · bi."clt ' · with the growt~ of education 4nd enlightenment 18 bound to · row f~ mj.1to c.x press RD o p i n i ~ it may be that the " considered j udgmcn t" .... clearer and clearer every !ay. The LotJll!on Branch; fro ~ of .he London Le."Lgne may di~orn the" considered judgment" of the Yery nature cannot be treato · in the . san1e;-:manner as . ,Provi~ci!U Al -India Moslem l ~ e, and I pr~ume that in matters·iu which your Leagues. Its uneqnRI compo_ition makes it,fpoeition one of 11eeuLejlgue bas 11.:,t yet supported the All -In~ia Le.-.gue its " considered liar de-licacy. Financially Lotjdon cannot support the All-India.Mosju4gmenf' did differ from that of the All-lndta. Le.'\g-tic. Hl!re is. thercfor/e, an opportunity which you should welcome of a discus.iion between lem League and is it.self far fiom self-supporting. ' For the m'ost lpart. &w!:, resl'ting convened n~der the auspices of the Zia-ul~l~lam ~fr,rVaz:r Ha.s:i.n's,.,pioi1m W8,! not t~c e:cpressiou of his indi,iclual to wclcou11: Messrs. Wl\zir I~.1asan and M:.,!~i:l pnhlil'ly thnt the London League was not a wi!Jing to co-operate with lt hem, they will wurk at all timµs 88 braod1 bl1t nn a-~.;; ,,:i1ltion in,lepcndrnt nf the All- I n n prr>,st•J (o sn~mit this 111attt.>r modilit!!l li on bd,,r,' :111s 11 •;, •fi!I w,irk ,::i n h,! ague; !mt in~te t1(! uf doing 8tav of '.\f..•s-ir~. \V:L 1.i r ILl 111n 1111 l .\ h!i :i ,n -1tl Ali tl1 1? V 1nin~ not s,,, Ii,• t•,\ n111wnv,',l au intri,.;-,tt· wi1l1 the Prnvinl'i ·il LN\g111•s, 1Yith the t• 1· 1i11 0111w iuf,,rm ;•;} ,,f any m,[,,:i n•; "f th ,~ Lon,:lo!l_ L1J,\g11:,, anti ! were result ~hat wli ii, · tl1>1 ~LiJrn;; Ll•ng :te ,mnbbed ltim ir1 tht• 11111st subjPeted t•, ,:on~i,lcr.1 ;)!,• 11111 prnl ,,f rn lt!ll•.•s,: ,,n tho nnly •Jc~:isions e!T,•et:ve l :1nd di:.; nitit',l nrnn111•r · by d .. d,1rin!{ t.lr11t n dcei~i,,n .,f tliis IHI whieh thl\Y :1ttt11 ,lell: ~11 ·'.li IJl :•...till ); -l, ()11 the lfli t or qu,•,ti -rnl h_r ,rnt.si,l,· it, uw11 1,r,,vince l\lld only iu tho e, )g-ui,mnee th,He nl',::-~i -,n~ Mr. :\LJh,111ie I Ali w,1, ask ,id t,, !t•are tlw meotsnd juri .~,ltl't i,, n ,,f tlw p11rt•nt L1•:1gm', tl!i• p:H ,•nt Len,;1ll1 wn~ not iui; ; lmt n, :1lr. \V.11.ir H,l, :111',; 1,r,·, 'llL"L' 11'11., t11l,•rated and ; 1:Ii11 uppr,lael,\;•d ov,!n hJ' the ,,l,•d11n,d p,nti:;,uB ot ;\(r An1,1er Ali. The Hi;;hn e;;, tl 1<· .\g-,1 Khan w 1.; ;,r,•, .w J tc!arnt inn.:~ tln, j ,1,1n1>_•y. ff t!a• ::;,,..:r.:tnry, ,r 1\ C,·,uncil! or of the Ll·a;;nc to jik the~ trouL1e ,,f g-nit1'..4' t,, Li:,nJun tv i'th ,-,ut f<'lfllir il)g th e L,md,111 League t,l P"Y thi:it; t• X 1•<' rl~ b, c<,!Jl,l tlwy l'~J;11 ct t,, lie tnrneJ out overt 11 j1,11,, i· 1 hc'\l ,c,l. Ml t ! :!11\~t _w1Hk ()(1 t bl' f i llf' pnll c:,• lai ci , ,l<>wn .\ll fr, Hll it.-; ·1Jl 1•1.•:im::- :h UofH!l ~• mhr•r., ~ C \ ,, 1ru•rnti1,11 iu,oln' S ll bilti\1:\ . 11.d,~wn,,,., o! up1u1 ,m ma~t lK' wdco m,,d, hU'. th!T,,rc1 1t·,·~ latt:r.1! l'llllr wc1rdi;". wr it1•:, ,,ur l.' ,> nt111uthe full ~ign;t1 ..,trnci• ,1 / - o p1•rati .. n. purary, i·•thtl 1i.1liey 1lf th,, L,rn Ion Lt~aglltl is to bo s h11p1•d hJ th e r--....._ L,•!\,~\\t< i iu I tHli~. Mr. .Am~,•-•r A4 11\IISt n,:, l1~ gt' r l,,, al\•med to 'p11,Jdlll ihi, (1 1m canoo'; he m 11.sL- t:aku his urd,~rs -frnm the Comnrdr and L nrkn,, w. . . . Having resigned rather .tlJ(LII s11bn.it tn such 1 Is t:!1~~:~;d~i{~~; ~~,'\t;t'i:~)~l~lt~? . tt i ri 1 J' t1ir~J\:,:~1:lt{;~:?~:.'t,: ur:it ~d.~~i!~~·~;~~EI (fr;l~;t tl:\,~:r:::\t: ~\ li:X:!t:'~:~;: nf 1 :ff:f~~;(i::~f}~\J.\if;~:,;~':~;:·i~:,;;:~1i '.f~'.:1·.'.?r ·';,:::.::: 1 1 d i,tati ,)n, is he nuw iu humble 1\1\d i.:m1trite s pi rit g uin g tn Can"l'SII ?" X ,1, tli:l, I'i'tlnur eride-ntly cou"'iders itself cheated of its d11es because iu the GNt place, ooshoes were haded about at Agra wh ,ge tl "!'e,.•o nd Son,t" :had beenpredil'ted, and: out erena "split" ,:~curred ; and in the \__ ,ecvnd place be,canse, O\'en bdc)re the .\gra se,,sio_n comllH'?Ct'd, llr. Atw..'er [Ali tboughi better of tlw matte.r aud ,nt,hdrew hu; prtlte!ii;it,us ._ uie uwe ti1110 that he ~ithdr,..w his re,;i~111\tio n. N -.w if auything i~~rtaiu, it i• thi:& th•t. rt'>'igu•tivus n,1 l,i11~t!r ;:u11stitute uirlutl~ aud re•'•re prtlpared tv r...: ,1gnis1"l tt1~m c\'titl t.,1 &ttl!Ces.-1.ity. Ht> 111'h ,1 &""nders a tteiJatiou in thi! bdie-f U1at wilh it.,; ,.,..,:t>pt&1L1~>' th,?, 1Nrld 111' cn1ld ..iome 1o a'D epd i11 Tery 110<.10 likdy t ,> l..., taught tl,at tl\t' w ,1 1 Id i..~ al l~ul u pN!IIUll\l)tuutu u be, and thiu\.:~ n,)b..c1~y to l,.,, indi11~t1!!Abl,•. B-nt wbater~c U1.t g-oueral pr~Lil'\l, 111'l! fttil Sllhl th•t ~lr. Am1,~•r Al i • il l 11ot uk:~ hi,i: tip from thi'l l'i~11Mr 11nd sly i11 th •) i.piri.~ uf deti~Lh'\', " No• ~\1111.11U1J_.,uu." 'l'ht> j,,krr:l ha.;i brf...,n tried t.:><-1 ofl ·~i;i jJJ " ' J .j~ (,, Phantom Figures. VIII. THU the two D,ip,&rtme nt;; thst brio~ in•,sl money to the ntffDN. and "bich carrr Mi thl'ir wu rk with freedom from 1nittaA1H and w~bing of ot1icfa.l linen iu~mblic, shot1lrl ! !xi offieered eotir~ly bf mem~N 1)f tho D,)miciled cumrmrnity •aid lodian11, is a ~troag refutation oi the stain an;:ument about the ~1.ied for imp,lrting jcaodfJatts from Great Britain ti) fiU up vacant it:l in e,erJ branehj of U. pubUe i;t-n-it·e. The Enrop.,ao •ho (Tery i wisely) settles dawa i■ ,, Iodia tiuds him!lelf W(>rse trdated in the m~lter of employm~t fot bi1 sou~ than either ~loh1uuedan or Hi~da parenbl. Honi,-, by deidariog bit children t o "be " Statotor, ! Natlf'N ·· he •• 8 ' ~ 7 eennit&.c,,d to tiad oocup&tioa for them u . tro.Lal or Opiam ~ The ,Comrade. 10th Janu I , bribed 88 ref!li~g , QD ~ia} m _oi, One Cl!Illl•'I h Ip thinking_ t~at the Supreme Got"er~inent of that ~ay · out the monso_on h~ migl1t oa~. not hnvrng' mucli corresp den ~ynnd t!, fey, routrne pape:~ n•lied ,111 tl1P sepLime11tal d1sl1ke s0me Eu~oI ea?s ~tght -~gnmst • and Report~ to bop1er him. . en the r11ins a~proad1 tl1_ei~, e*-d dassifl'ing tlH•ir. offspring 111HJer_ the de~1g11atrnn JU:-t me?tione UH'ti, wlni dee i to> nbi,l e per_mn.n~ntly .111 India, 18 o•.~~ ~1!_ tlie fool!sh ,c,litil'al fads p, js.,essi n~ the mmd of yonr • ll\'t•rnge t:ml1~n. ~V11h intl!.IHling ·cultivat or;..•·• employing ~Iris. p. owers (:.'li·. ar.gumti..nt •. pe. r~l snnsiou tc> ket•p the opium area u l the expected standard. ln o.n ~he a boLtiMI tff the Opinm Departnw~it yet 111~oth~r op1.mrng w~ll l~e re:;pPct he is fortunate as compar kl with his fol(ows in the ~olice close 1r adopt1011. 'Ihrratene~d ,~en'. however, l1ye !t,ng ,,, ont' 11 ilY d,•seribe the afy11r1-wallali c,al11l> , ID the hupt>s is l!Dt called U(ic_m . o pl1•ase man . 1111,1:-ters_ If l. •e is a Snb-lJe.put~ his only "boss •· is the .:\gent,- CiYilian, of counse, of wltioh alas tl,a ; ' i,;,; dqrnr 1{ie n tal d ~mise _- lie post ponra yet awliilt>. ".hl'll bnt one now remnins since lht• cit ing down of t he Patna A~eno ; the P' 'CllY ('l'O:-e t o be grown 11ud the S ti'.1ally abandons ~ 1<0_nrce . Con,eqnently lie is deli\·ered fro111 those visits ,c,f ins1\fctior1, of .i.•.r."frt n:ider. he mi;;tak_e n.· not_. on of heue~t.mg the nrttwus. Chrnee, tl1e necessity for keeping a nun bers of big-wigs . of various degree ., ,kt• fl-h d tlie )pium ofl1cer, as he :irns _m tlw ~rsh, may _ hare a m·e:aucJ: .,], ;ut rl'st for stJt dents of" thing;; wh1eh ham l1een to infnrnietl as to his work, resemb ini:t a Frne Lauce rather than • official subordinate to a shoal of s 111eriors. Still an Opium Agent be!!:U 1;it b," tlie ray f,r the opium officer is h~rdl!" 8 living hns gn nt powers for good and ill where th81 officers under hi~ w:~,;e; rnppo.,;i ~g him to follow th~ customs ~ntl marntnm th_e same ~t, ·lt• nf l',,mfoj-t ns do otl1er S11b1bs. L11ck1ly the necesHty for c.harge are concerned. Probably given that liillet as a satis(actor;t ~ay of di »posi ng of his demaud for something in his own lin+ 8~;t'l!din~ 111:ltl) ! m,1~ 1hs fl tit iu CRlllp helps to ket p his_h end just nb nre ti"· Wtll'l'~ ,i i 111 t 1t'1 1d111g- d_eht, nnJ lw us_nall_y has a:qu1red th e u~ef nl of work, tho Agent-at all e,~eatf during his first yenr of office-+ kn:ic·k ,, f mnkiing bis te1ght annn:- g<, 'S'S la:,-or lurtl,~·-than mnst knows rPry little of tho intern~l .workin~ of the Department ot the .rier1.1li11rities of p.oppy cultivaLiqn, and nurnufa()ture or the existing_ ..•. other f.,}Jis' r11pti<'• ~~~ Regnlations. I ' Ill·_ Ti.it'rr art' nlleviRtic.ns for the somewhat minor 'P_()_sition occupied Ii he is a sensib~an he cotjtt-nts ltims,•lf :With quietlJ . goint ' bT da• i11111! Olfo;~r-wliether he be ft Suli-Deputy mert•ly an insigl1t into tlio m1rnner his offlcers are ,vorking, and in ' letting ,\,si,tnnt in 1h+ llt•pnr :1'.1t·nt. Mo~·ti tliau n11y ollit•r oflicinl,_ (sil\'e tl11·111 find in him n sympathetic ladviRer nnd friend, not a tyran~ ('i' l liiq s tl:c l 'julllll . Ulhet•r), lie JS br,,ugh~ 1n dose touch with the Eel'king whose prospec1s he cnn ,11\r or ulterly min. To the Ol'edi~ vnr it'l111g c1:i'tain tJpes nf the Indian sul·ordinr,te gentlemen-either E11ropeans or I11 ~ia ns-under his c,,utrol, and mnn1 olli,:i,.l, c•,.ul,i r,in,kr l't1.luai>le lit!!p to .\lagistrnte,; and Polire officers, are the stories rdatrd of ltis arbitrary acts ; his refnsal of leav$ "·,·ru 11,1 Hire itl i;1l sud1 assisla11ce \\\Jll lJ lie tliaukinlly recei,·ed . (justly dm•), on any frivolous reason!!, nnd-worst of 1\ll-a practic'~ 1-',rq11,•11 tly it., : l,,·i11g pr,•i~rrcJ i,; either re:;e nted, .!.Ir reg:,rs froml Indian s11liordirrnte~-g1Hn1:1shtasi 1n,ul• le; o11:c 11l,.- ,!J111 g by a per:l,lll Oqt clirect.y concern!!d with mohun·irs, et hoc ger;i,.s omne-agaihst the imm ediate a Rllpniors cx,•,·u.i,e iu11L'l ((ll1,;. Being tlrns thruwu for the major purtion of his his favoured spie&. It would hardly be possiule: for an European ti1u,· 1111"" '.,{ ,!ll' ~ltc·rs ,,11 ll,., lucii1m c,,uutrysidt>, n mnn in lhe Opium inn rrspnu~ible pm t to lower hijnself 111ore :n the estimation of i1ll loil:J;: >\ tlbte! kr ~ullle ,,ur,;uit (Ir ht>l•liy CUll!IC(;red witli the past, tlinsP nuder t!t1u1 ditl the iudiviclnhl in qnestion during ltis tenure ,,r }'rt'" ·11:, l:f,, ,~fdit' lndiuu ug1iculllll'III poplllution. He nrny take of all ,\gPrwy. Wl1l'11 rw more [ lields Lluom 1t ith white poppy ul' ti,,· ,u1,iy ( i i(1.k-l. ,r,· ; of t(llll'ding- at.tiq_uarinn ddnils; hunt s tl om•t'S Ritt.! a policy or Plrnrisaical ri/.::hteo11snes11 for suppressing :1! :, r 1111,·i,·lit ,•, -i;t1"; or r(',:,•nrche:; into tlie 11nturi~ liistory o[ nuimnls an i11rngina.ry ,\·ice-so lnng- us t his does not aff,•ct· thu pockets i.-1:n ,I witLiu ;1i:,; ii,.ii,;,:i,·tiun, ,\·e knew u1w ~lulrnuiedun Opium the Hriti:;} 1 t11x-p11yer-hns tiually tor111inat1•d a lJ1•pnrlment IHI vahmble Otri,·,•r 1\ii,, wa,; :skilleJ iu ln11.:ing tlie urigiD uf the rnd ti Lnllml,-, s1111g for Indian ren.rnqes, the last O j.ium Officer will be ahle in re7 :.t 1· il:,1,;,' gatl1tring~ by . the Hiudn peasuntry of the C.ornklipur tirrn1P11t on Ii.is l11m ble pension 1o ponn,,11:rn g co1np11n w11s, wh ose conrersatiou come~ 9..i a wekome d1uu~ <' 1 r'.,m th~ cust11mury gu,;sip lif a 1-m11ll station . Even in the m1H\t'r. u l_ d~pnltlme1,ta,t ~uil tlHl)' ~iffer from other " flies on tlie ,rh e,·l . ul l1ul' ~run~l'lnt. _ At Ct•_rt1Hn season;i nf tho ye:1r, they ha\'8 t<• Ut :tlt'.1?' tb 4 trml vt L1gh prcs:.llrt' condition;,, not having mure Uhun
  • itan~a Crom fallin~ into_ a 11tat~i of cv~a. .The7 i 111 m, .:· h·n(' h~·1:il •. ft>ntnre,; which im.i C()nwui~utly iguon,d py, faddi1ts pr1ded~ve;B, mthout r1ncour,i bnt ,nth a qoil) t CODIICIOU!l feeling : ell _1 11 ~ Ant1 -Up1um Party. As ,- splendid.'and 1mstainiog stimulant 11f merit, on tl,e fact that never had an Indian ~en poaled among, di~m" !'['' ,1"' 1.:,itl 11h)'sit-11l t•xertion ; a.s a prophyl•tic iu tracts inthem in any or the 90,-ernment , 3iices. ~nd that! th~r. •mall club ! f,d.-,l l•) ll!!ihirrn ; 1111,l as a help in some kind~ of fever, behouse sho111ed an n~mlt.'trrupttd row :of wh1!e faces.. ii.,,So 1t wu with ! "1,'1•'" .. " ·1 11 1':.:' a I tin,t rntc 11no{ly11t! in c11,.el! c>f RPY-ere bodily p:iin ; no l1ttl.e consternft11on _aud a huty eeek10g of ~eMon1 that they tLt> Ji,- r,::ht•,l pt•ppy :l!ll clai111 t o L,,e pr0n(•tmc~d a " b-oou and a beard their nrxt ASt!istant Magistrite waa a youot Mohamedu j~t i t " h ]d1an;;,-11 not to all men. This, howe-ver, is not the . appointed. Syed Rahman wu a bJ1, jnt~ a nice !frHh boy, a 1 p,a.:-,· . ~r~utpt>nts against the abolition of opium growing, but g ood spe,cime-n of English Public ,ahool and Varsi ~1 training. He I ~ {0'~.t, h tl_r,,;e en gaged in '9'1.\tching 011er itl!I cnhii'atioo. played most games wt1H, cricket an~ raequel.11 entha11iaatie.ll7, •rode ' ~,.:l:rne/,t,S : l'ullHUc>tilJ go at tlrn b1ttlt1.i,t tiUltl ur 1ltt1 JHr to lwnnd1, danced well, bridged be~tPr, sang coU,ge cho~ . io • 1 011 " • 6_tiay lvo .. i,; attftiuing full for:ce aud an April 11uu blaze« witb boJi~h baritone; and I don't belier~ had e,er P+•iaed ti> c,oa~der L,i'.tt'tl :s;u,:. gl,u1 for tl ,~ lw~t portion o! the. day . . 8urroandtn~ine:;..-. 1 ►f\•iicd,,iug t.l, e. aimonuts Lr\'.lugbt Ilia ('bnma had dttply bemoane4 the fad that l:&,npl wu to be l ,.i- ,t iwlu . 1,y . hn11d rt-d3 of eultiatol".il 111\) M!tling that the ~t>ne of' Iii~ official earttr, Thfi.1 AWlemol1 Jd,~ h.im to •ork IL ,.- 1. ' ,p :,.1 111. . I ~ duly. rcn,rdtid, and thr aceom)t l>t,tWHD. .... the po1'l'l''II lhat~be an.d get out of it i He heard ,~noaa ffJ>O'¥ of ' hideoua unh.-alth7 district• with bu~ ou or two: ~tched official, ,r: :,· l>_"i''-"rlmen t trn !J adj11Jte, 11J C.unpb,·ll sune ,.J his trap.i with apprornl. N t>:lt, to1,11 in E111;lanJ. U ,1t1l e.luc,1 10n !Hs them t,> take thtitr plaee and, use ful t~n1 k.~. b.~drnJ by i.;an c.~e~, uc case, b,lts, p,,lo . ;;lick~-. )!Olf Jwhl it I tliiuk tire p1,riJ.ih is as good a sph~re 'as any. The ~1u_l13... It pl,•ll-i••:l _I h,i ,11\l Ol l\11 lt} ;\('C that he t,i,) k1d after- his puui e;i break ing tlir,,n~h pw·-11:Jh sho,,,.., 110 r e1al aJnmcement · and d oes .. not, . '-.before c~• •t, ,·o-1,llrln~ w!i1clt ro,1 111 he wa~ to occupy, ':lll~ . th1lt ut s,1 fl\r i.s I ~•\11 ~ee, l.n·v~,leu . U~•ir ontlo,,k; . ' w· t, luve pl_enty I of diu ne r lie respcc t. f,t!ly, lrnt firmly, lcctnr~d his h os t o n the chan c,, ;; of Jndg ,ng ~pl c1iilly 111 ~ogal. It 1s wlieu eJucntton 1~nd cooditi ,i u ,f hi .~ st:1',\e ., ; j11,;t ,H his son had J.oue. lie spent his ~lie rig ht s,,r~ of upbri11git1 !{ is 11nj,,incd wilh the oomiu.~ _o ut, t j1at first. thre,• 1•1·,•11i11:,\', i11 p11tti11g them ri;;ltt l'l"ith hi s own han J;,. Ily we se.i a n·r.v fin e exiunp:e of 1••mauh 1>Ud." ," But surely if t~ey th is tim e (J.im p\Jd l re ,bse,l th t\t he liaJ J lme liitUS ld f a go uJ tnrn ; d n not start by bre,,kin;; ,l01n1 liis r i,licnlous • system there Ct\u) be R"hman ,l t lllll~, enth usiastic ~u";J 1un11siog, aoJ ~dJcd LO tiiese no nJnrnce. " " \Vti:\t make;; lyon think that ? A wo11J1111 brou,'rbt qnaliti~:. ~ trnly oriental tud wh1d1 m1dtJ lum 11 ,dch~htful c:,mpalip i11 p<.!rdali ifl not 'fiued her right plaec in the wnrkl, oioo. W111.,11 tl1r _strtJ:l1w1_1s sot_tlin;~i11_ wi!'-ti1~_1 l~ acc,H_11plishccl, he '':hy for,·,,_htir into I\ false p,istGlt>D , :~1~d crnate whole g~n(jrat>e.;-ar~ tn t11kc a11 111tl'rust Ill, :;oc rnl lit e, ~ ,1ire,l purt1.;ulurs l'--'i to t111n of be111g4 sneh as 1 ull:io.ieJ tJ ? But-out bn,~e Ill the 1 the Cl11h, •lt!., a rd ,,,..,11Jcr.:d l>ri., tly whelha there were any men of vo11n{{or nrnn . " L et me lbislf. " snid C1u11pbdt, " l co11:;;iJerll)1e bi!! own u e i11 th e pl.i..:e. IL W.\$ at thi,- juu1:t ire tlut . Camph!!ll i.tnlu~mctl,t.n com 1n1111ity in a \·e y strung p<>si t inn. They c:rn f~ee took np111 h:111.; -.1lf a f ,th<.' r',; ti .tty. lfo bt.l_;irn by taking Rah11u111 th e tirr,>r of both the pi~,-:_l:ih ~y tt.>m and tlk freedom -0£ - wo1uc~1 1p th to tho Cl, t, h ,,pin:; tlt:.1t tl1t! hoy's you tltfnl cl111rm m,11IJ. s11fte11 the ill-re,i;ul ... tell rn inJs. ll,1s uc1 1 __1{ Llie case the Jouu~er gc 1J t1 rnl1t1n of laJii>s an hi~ sp ,rti ,g in;tiuL,ts inL,Jrt.J :lt the men. In some measu re d,l1wliters 11111,;it ;urely score. '~' hey can from t;lieir yout.h s lie t.rai1ied he W.\S su •..:essfu l ·lfi tll thtl lat h' r, lmt the fornltlr wen, stuoily alL1of. propt>rly, g i\·en the wioy of race prewnman, [ ~peak of ·onr cla~s, h~-; hu1 ~he'.l all _lier d1>me>u~ other J.~lti:ale a coll',le of h,lllrs. Tnen, again; mn rnag" 1snol, a prules,;wu !'nd matt,•rs. 1\,lJ to this lud they see.111 eJ , ~ 1 n the o1J rnau" e,u, nerer' while it is ;.n lo,,ked 11p~n will it be a success. Yon n\usi ridiculu tl~ th•111g li 1n 11,y a Lim e tiitl b11111ptiuusu ,,ss of s01ue " Engharn heard in Er,g-Lrntl of the g rel\t denll\nu for n.hlde land rotu 11tiJ ·• ,;t11lte11t hnJ mad e the 11.rg11111euls seem suuuy,111 Wl\11 ~ your people to _go"7'tfrongh tl11s:. or Ca111pbell1s ri~hl _th ru'.1gb, s tirpri..eJ, hurt_, then a _l1Ltle s_iwage, Lill t,·1 avoiJ it wisclj' ? If y,)tH ~omen are domes tic d,,lls u"w, which Lhe old 11\1u1, ltJa11111:; tvrwarJ, 1,dJ out l11s lurn_J with a li1'.al \'l' •>r~; a;;~i>rtion [ ra ther doubt-, is it ;uetter to le1. t~1cm_ rt•nh,i11 suctlt in "To me 1· he s.11i ,l, " )'o U arc a,; lllY m,u sou, 1u uo "'"'Y 1.hlftren~. character ..xpccLing m •>nJ fr, .,m th_eru or. to wn1t tdl th ey c"J/. ~ake " Y vu arb rn ry g,1tHl. Sir, ·" Sl\id tTrn bl>)' " l~ealis11 110\Y hu1l up a nil d,nrn vernll(lah, 11111.l i11 the 1l11,-k it w,1s! noL ,uy;;, " Ht.iJtu. " Of Ctlll11iC, laJ, lllllll,Y, tinu frlluw::; t,,o_ t!U IUO pu-!:iblc fu r C 11mpbell to see I wlmt effec t liis w11rds w,:,ro li1w,i ng. of tlrnni ;!lrnt-n,,t cx ,1ctly lien, ; i,l1ll d1 \! re M e 1J1Hl _11r t,1·0 t t.lwre 11rc il)d iv idnal c11se;i und . of lat.lie-,., t~ u, ""ttl tl ~laJly 11 o i. hin-e l>tltiu 1r11m,.lly, but. _th t! L.J s pnJe c"n rse a !,)t w.,u lJ. depen ll on the so rt of soci ety tli&t tlio girl !had_. _;. ' !orli1tdt' i r, y iu!c rc,,11rsL1 drere. ThertJ ffO:I uo sport10,; g1 ,muJ . un arler her trni 11 i11g was n11i;;l1cd. H she is t_o be ~ss1Jci11t ed _ wi 1li--,.,a 'flliich th~y° wert< t•q11al, 1rni.l other terms he rejt',Led. . Hc _livcJ ou \ ' t• i· ,· odin~· circle of pet>[Jle, let us take tl11s stalrnn ti,,-· exlllllple, with Ca 1~1l't,tJll pl•rlc-:tly ha ppy, coyteut to_ ba,'t: spc11t life thu,;. I , iinn lJ thi;ik it l'ery probal,le th at her tive J C!lr's trni11 ing . wv uld This, ,1{ ic.. nrse, co ulJ out be. liclt'-'atcd IIIY!l-1tU,1lli ir,.'.m 111s J c11,d n11t ue e nough. H e r only c1 ,mp.1uions of her e,wn sex W<•~ld be father·-. ~teu ple n, .. Je.l1im journey ull II!) tJJ L11!1ure ~l'Sl _m ,•11ll1 8 IH1lU1'[\ wh,,,rn min ,l,i d o 1111t ri ee nl;o1•e the pet~• dorne15ti c ddili~s or let.,•;! hi! igul. \Vten till rntffrned, Cllmpl>d,l h i lL ILISUUC~l\·dy ,t,hat tl n•i r OWi\ n11 ,l lrnch ot hn's 1_1thi'l's, 811ciul, m,,rnl anJ pliysi1;ul. ' ~'heir all iir'ILS (iu t \'l'l!I L He sc•ttUJt•tl ·tu ham g rvwa ol,ler 1rnJ d,,. J,ill~e Tea.fin~ is li,11it ,•d s,.. n~att•Hlu l nnrcls . _au~ ftt .~hion ['il!'Cr~. ! 'l'he wond,m1U 1,) 11.\t li1ul tl" n" it . N ,,t U1t,-:11ll 11si_u111111:1,t, li e k,µ:w, i .. _r h,- i\{ l,t ,,f Ll1.- ir.a1 11li1 !10!J lS to t·O .I I\S ihc w,f_e DI I\ L 1e11~t•n1w~-Lio ~ ,r,nor. Rahnuul t .. ll l I speak 1n g c 11 ern l1t1 t·s 1111d tii,ke : my anrpri&..•il lw .IJ_ii..l tlw.-11 . Hi~ pc ,,p lo " e.r~ urlh ut..l,, x, UllL nJn11u:eJ. e:unq,l,•;i (r11:n the 11.-,.:i11 l li te iu l _u Ii" a:1 I }111 rn fo11ucl _it. Theo The me p wa,· ~p••rl sm~n ·1w,l ,,11.lnb, . ~-h<\)' _kq,1. . • uub ul· r_l' 1,awl.: thtHe i'..; i\t1 ud1t•r 1•-,i11t ,,f 1 :,·11·, .\11~hl ll l' l,dtt' S 111,;,, 111.l l11l\1tu t.:ln,ri11111g, 1h"11::,::li 11, g tw d J n il th,~ une i1 ,,liri1h1al ~h ,:,u l,l i,,r an mii:crt"in : ex 1,erii1t,·n t cltanc~ iumurc .. ~di,nl .. :t tlnrn t h\.' 111,· 11. li ,:, l't"j 1t',4l~•J tll 1.-i o;[.,1vl.v twit:,·, auJ l iitl · 11 ,, 11\!lll\' 11llit? r~ 'J S ,1y, th is \V t11lllloll l111 buy - t i.ci r )' t• sr l ••gt"t lit'r l1:1ci t: , 11 ~ilcut h· be inre hin), and th dl spo ke :\g>lill . " ~hrry her lfl_l' son in --.oiii.iat,iJ t ,,,• i r 1n,·11 .1sbif•· Une IU .J tluug 11;1l!U Li1e !'lie v i lc : Lc,,, vii t hL • \\-,{,li e r lll •f lh,·r w,,111.J lfi. ~ h ; train her yourself au:, 1111J (!IHt'tU!ly u di1,tiu,·dy 1,•rn i:.:Ut' l_1 [ ·•· 1111J ,uil Sll1t:11 111g u( ,Jl,u , l. ll ,;, lJ,,y t <..., k yunr s-,11 .;, " R ,h111 ,\n ~ pnuleJ t')'IJ$ rt•~ te.J ~II La,upbcll ttnJ :then it up fi t,-{ , lvukc-,1 ii ttrpri,nl, upi: 1,rJ iu1J l>d~iloU lu re~J it. L, t,., l:i. tic?"!i,•d: " I kn,•1T y.,11'd ~ue~~ . ~1r/ --i'I! ;th ink ,,1 ·,• r c i·e ry w~rd CampbHl 11,- -: vl ,ir,~ l1 .1t1 dt, -d} Ill s ,·yrs -n·,- rt> ~lw ll:,-, till 111'1.-x 1 11t1 \·,, n'l'e H iJ ." Tllo ontt:tJ lll tl ,_ , i tills C!; [Ht~l\ ll 'I [) WKS " hur ried aurpri,,f l.dcJ i1, t, , t. 1 d 1~1t 1n l r,-i ,s , t•r 1i..t 1,•u, 1,11 , l"li gMt.· 1':"•'tl tv ~-i, it t ,1 L,LhMe whi ch ob~·i1.ied llll clnrn1:I! 1,f! ao,)ther ,·1,i ~t. ,l ,u,: iop,1ri~t ;t,·n ,l,•nw.• • ; Intl ,1t t 11<' -,·l,"<' " r ll ,._. 1.-t \\•r lli c Lr -,,1., ,t' " ' 111~ 1 iu~h he w11,..,1 , ,1,1 y d is,.·r i.-ti o1 r1. Tti,, .. [,I 1111m g uei. .ded tl11.t, th ll ,ld:tl~at t,_,..:],;, J,lll1\,.c.1 t1 1nl 1•:1· 1,,1e :x, t.1 at""L11 ,· ,.l l •.> 1.,k ,, a ~f,:1rt•, \\' :, :,,,,,\ a1,_v th .- b, n·'i1 1, nd,•, 1.kli~litt>J, lfi4rl a.rra.11.; in:; I\ 01uriagu i11r !11111 ;"'1th rem;1rk ' H ., :1 111 ·. ,1 1 w,..-.1, 1l l e• ,. :h , r ; b, ,t ,l,11 t,, 5 l,1, "·h h .q,· l1·.o t,nni th ,, ,t.,; " iit,,r ,,f 11 111:i~ldJ,,llr wh ol!I o f c,rn, .. e ltalinuu l11ni. .. u!1 ;BUD 1 nu, c,,tjn t r:· !,,,.J . t,1 t hc:1 i,u t ~u u, "." 'I he '.u., n Jn1,.;: 11"t,•ac! ui !'Lit in ph ,,t.,~ ba t ,, f l'l'li ,, 1L1 In, hall lii:;a rJ much. _Ha lu n,111•~- iJ 1_11,11 l~ugb iu!( ra d i ,.1,·b 111 t l1:, t' H ' tl ; u~ . , , \\ !\~•11 -, ,•c,l u rd1, out• .,; til e L••· •)' . ~ rl'I •• ~ d ,,Ji -~ lth·, lly 0 11 L:e 1w, r,J tht u11:-;h lh ti n11) 11l::I a u J C ssinn 0f the :\tn,lem Lea~ue said:of i.ympathy and consid11ralion in pral'Lice, to win ore~· the heart~ of wi,-h to tender m)· gratrf1i! th:n)kS io ynn fnr tho • thr pe,,p!o of this cnuntry. May l nm uroto tdl them,huw ridioulou.dy c,,nfrrred •1pnn me in im·iting me to. presi,le ens_ic it is to succeed in this derection 1 Orw nf the pr,omin11nt chataon,.,, .... ,""'''"•' nt thi:- Annnal Srs~ion of the Mnsh'm ~t'azne. frrist ics of the Indian people is tl eir hil;hly developed sense: of it is the l1igliest lwnnnr in the gift of t1 ~ gratitude. In how ,nany plsces, in times of ~tress and strain, ha-.e npprecint t(>ll ~all.mt.he. greater b~canse it was not tlii; Indian penplP come to the res9ne of Englishinf'n in the past, .. ~ and in how m~ny c11ses ha\'e the~,t not gone tq. the lengthi of whcn,diffrrem~'h of orininn are !'twngly &aerilfoing th\!ir own lin•s t~ prole~t the lirns of Englishmen 7 If ni1d thNe is a !!l'nernl it•eling lhnt !lie Mu,~alan attt>mpt is seriously mad~ hy offii:i~l India, as a•· rnligions dnty, p,,liti'('ally ft>llcl1ed the .• rut int! of. t_lw way:<," to try anti ~ee Indian prohlt•ms from tHe lndbn pl)int of view, and ret·c,u.ist> l1nw diffi,·nlt 1s the pn,:1t1nn of _ronr if tl11• ollic:ial always kePp:, beforn l,is niind',:; eye lhaL he is tlie. Stirvant J ':V'l't'j'tPC] tlv' diffie11lt tn~k .· which ynn horn of the pPnp1e of Ind:a, he will cn1~ture the Indian ima.~iaatio11 as ,1, :i csll of dnty, and I havP dnnc i,,1, in the nothing else will rln. \Ve "ha 1l not th:cn hear tho lar11rntation"- which. "jl] :111 •·xlp1,d ·tn 1rn• yonr i>nrrwst help and nre being con,;tantly din11p1\ into nur c*rs, of the grnwing difficnltiee uf my dnltes and will will111gly :-l1are the.._ of the gorernance of tlii., col1ntry. It is his policy, whicl1 Lord n- ~l tr--nlmnns nttn1•l l', to i>uch ,,ne <.;I ns. The '"·· Ilnrdiq.\'t~ has !,\id before him anti ,vhich he is tryin,~ to Ol\rry ont c,f M us,nlu~;; ::::frSJHJ nil p11rts of in pnu:tic,•, that has so cmluarctl him ,,rl the Inrlinn people. Will the t,Hb_v, nt )!rt.•ai;-·-111•r,nnnl incnnrl'les:-011 be t11ke11 tll hea1t by the otUeiaCworld in India? Ir it is, they mind l•1•:,-,i11tl tlit' 1:-hndow d a do11l1t tl1e Rtrong will nnt only smn(>th tlwir nwn pnlh lH't the. pnth of, those amongst l'"litinil i'llld r,nl,lic lif1> pn,s('S•Pd by nnr the llllli1111 p11blic men whn ham !Jeen rtri1·ing in the face of ~rave ,·"1ifi,!t•r1t thnt J may ,nr,•ly n•ly npnn )"(lllr ~inrPre obstacle:- 1111d impc>,\inwnts to nrnke offidals realize how potent the 1111 e,m11 st pffc rt t,1 bridge nrcr the dit1knltil's effects of 1:'j'lllpathy und considero.li"n in 11 8( irit pf cnn,id,•rt·d 1·nmpromi~e. so that PLEA OF ,v&iAKNEBB.' ~h:1ll nil bt••·<·llll' s,.Jidly 11nitt>d again, and in Bnt there i:8 a class of croakers wh!> luwti sairl before and will May ,1nlY .lim• ,,f ndi1111 1d1id1 will eusnre the stt•ndy again, that it is all rery wdl to talk about wionin~ the hearts or the •;n• l;1n·,· nil at l1t•a1t. ln 1111 1,rga11izari11n~, snch people ; but whnt ab"11t British prfstige 7 If Gover nm,~nt are to ") ini,•rr--1m1,t prt·rniL It is ll1e npplil'ation of surrendn to erery agitation started B!!llinst offici1~l nwasuros, the pri I.J,•m,- and the f111l :rnd free disenssion ~ork ·or ad11Jin:st.rati11n will bec,,nrn imtios.•ible and tire ~ri; ish people ,.( i.:ivt·1i q1,t·stiun" wLirh lt>ml to thf' formation uuse circ11m,;tances 111ay as "!ell cle1\r out of th1 country. Ii and 11,Iianee pndic iutt>n'st. Holding these is this clas.~ of irre~pons,b!e people, tho:ugh they m!\y ht\l_ong to the t,1 wpJcnrnt' rPns,,ned di~(•nssion of ,11,ll Bri tit.h lll('e, which is largely rc,~ponsibJc fnr any HjsLinl{ esfr'r.qgement. 1,dl-!.ei11g-with tlris rt>;Prrntion, It i,.; people who imagine tl,at the '· m~ited li~t" iR I he bc!lt policy, r<"nd1t•d, we i-bould loynlly at·crpt it wlf., nre rt•ully rc',-ponsiule f1,r the i11cr1!11,-ingdifficulli11s wliicli c11nfront , n tl,t· lint•.,;_ so laid 1fown. 'l'his;,olic_r does not the ollieinl wo.r!d. Let 11,; calmly and! j11diehH1sly ('X1mline ,vhat this a deci,i1,n , nee taken 1>hm1lrl be irrerri('Rble. ;No cry logil'ally !ll(•au~. It can 011ly mean that onco 1\1\ offici:,l has taken lll.!"t' can [lt;j laid dcmn wlrich 1-h,,ul,I be regard. a dL•cision, in mosl cases 1''ith"nt 1011,adting the views of, re11ponsi~ law~ of d11> .:\lcd,•s and I'n,ian~-11nnltt•rnble ble 1,eople 11mongst those who may be .riff•·cte!l by ,rnch decision, aJl(l has Th,• d,cisin11 so taken ~h1111lt! lie Rl'Ct'pled as got ii. rntilied liy Go,•,·rnment on e~ J}{Jrte slaleurnnts, it shall be until ,1:eh tirnt> as the gt'rwral body of npi.niou i rrevoei,l,le. If th\l dt•cisi11n proves di!!lasteful to the pi,ople concerned, r i nlte1ed circ1111:sta11ees, gt·eatt.>r t•x1wrieneP, tl11•y l111\'c co11stifotiou111ly two C1Hirsc1} open to them-(1) to petition dnrn be1cks 1,ot furP~i•en, and si rnilar c1rnses. Gow•r11111eut, liriu_i;ini; to their 110tice how hurtful 1mch decision is and l!H:n l,e TH~• -ll;.idned,. Rlld 111odifietl or alh•rt>d to requei:it. a rt'c,,nsiLlcration or the' qnestiun; ( 2) tu continne the e, ,1,diti, ,r ,s may r,•q11ire. ,\'hat· 11p1w11r:<. to me agitation by holili11g met>tings, by ~etting intnpellations put iu the l!l! t:,· i,- tl,nt all di,,·11,a,i,,n,; ~h qu\d he cnnd11cte:i Legii:ila.tiro Councils, au,.l by a>{ilating ,in the press. ' ll-}''''~"11a! p;n,u11d,:, an,1 pe,,ple tiuding tl11.•111selvrs Jr the pe11ple affected conlinr them~elre~ to tl.i-e ... firsf remedy, the L _1ally nL•('•'pt the elt"nrly ascertained ch•cisions deci ,iou iu rnost cases" is uclheretl to on Hutgro1md that there was no .-i!ICt.'rt'ly in(\ sririt of milfinry di:-:cil'line in ll nal feeLng\gains~ it arrwugst the people coucerned. so lnid dow11, U11le>'s ,rn are llii 11 If tlrn agi1ation is carried on on the: lines indicated in the secd. men, that they w;6le uunecessuily exdtiu,~ the to c,,1,fr,,ut 11s.-- May I al'p11al to yon· Gentleirtn, ·people who are al !Vil) s supposed t(J 'J)e qnite cnnllint t,, I\Ccept y«a to d :e .wlwle- of the M nsl,-m commnnitv in 11.,'.i:c, decisi1,ns ('Jllll,llllting I fonn VOl'ernment\onrces: When thh, pica CMllllH.>11 intPr,-sts in a i-1;irit M brr>ail-mi;,ll'd ~ t,1,·1,11 l1nwever, is found ·mllt•nable a11tl .thd · otlicinl.i! :are obliged to l'u-,_-i:a:.i_i, n ? 1f 11e dn so fr,•t· frnm 11II persrinal Hco~ui ,e thut the 11i;itation is • W\•ll-fo1111de;l •and calls for 111 11110.! n,,tliini; Lut wl111.t i,; lwst for the reJm·,lial nu•a,,url.!~; it is eren then strongly urg,ed tliat no change n .. t Dnly, be swe and cert11in, but 0, 11.ltcrati11r1 i,houlLI ho nrntle, ill t·iuw of the :ra..:t that s11cb Pl'l•n t,, tl 1e im1•11tit•llt :-pirits amongst us. actiuu would be reg:11.rJull'fjlH'IIC~ of ~11ch a p<•licr lwing that the- decisi,111 once : 1• r1e1:H 11ci 1,- 1,,,di with /,•,·ling- of r,·lid that Y i ~ t • d 1 1 tKk.-u mHst ho rigidly adh1m.•d tn May· I enq<1 lre under t!_teae ti ,,tit ' ' ti·' l,y th,, tar sii.:lrtt•d statt•SIJUUi!;li1p· of H. E. circumstances how ~hould ~opl.i act, wlio desire red,11Kidn11tion and L. cl lL-t, :, "'"· 1q· ,sr,,,nw !,and )'''Jllil11r \'ireruy, )lay f, at this aowudwent or lie orJer,. aml dtici11ione1 1rnno1111ccd l>y tp~ Aut-lrnrhie.• 7 th,, t1<•l•h• ,;<'ntimt'nt,i to which !Ji,; Exct·ll,•nt'lf gine P, lLi (>r_i /1,e "et·a,1,rn of his nt1i,,ixl eatry in\,; the Purtun11tcly them are. high officiala here do not l(l'flow ti.ii! plea, Ii,, !'It'~IL,ed at ti ne tlrst 111,•ctiu~ ,1,f .the r e,dy cn1Bbut deal with dillic11lt and del icate problem-1 in a •wiii~ and etat.eet!lt'E'li11~ for tlie tirst tiu1e in Dell,i ·? In the ma11likt• I!Llnner a.1111 thn~ ren,lcr lllUSL. ,·aluahle servic,j both to Oreal w:,:c•i1 he ueliwred 1)ll the UCL·a,iuo, His Ex.celleINJ Britain and l11tlia. I 1un 1n1re y11u wi11 Mill agree 1'itlf mti iu thinkiog that L Dni H1mlini.:e is the fort-me;;t am,~ug·sL such ◄lfficllll:.i •t pre8enL in l ndia, uni Iii~ action far from 1.i;iing vpen to critioililtn !in delk.lning . of nf thr crimr hwlt, I onl1 the higiwst curumeudati, ,n. ln1.!i& d1111t thi• im·iJ,·nt will ,_. u,·_,• my MtiiHdl'. I ,inll pnr:,ane witlwnt I wN1 1ler whl"th!'r lh,>f;fi crilic111 whn J"Jeriodically trot put the bugbt&r !' ,l 1.~ in tb• fllrme as dmiug tile p-.i;t two or weakr,e,..., n-aliz.e .. h•t th1.t mear111v 1'<, my minjd it can UlMD w,H,•r III h•ir's brt:a !th fr ,m1 thst cnnrHl." .-,nly 0 11t, thing, muuely, that the po11hion or the Drifb G,,.,ernmeo& 111 ludi .. i~ fo1111.J.-d 1111 r1111eh tlim•1 h•~-➔ tl.1at an •ct pf urdy jlliitloe d,·ny t\1At L ur,l H,rn.!in!{i' hu r11ithfoll1 1 the (~>pie or lntlia by the l1ig);1er a111horitiHi u d,111t-' t, the result !,!l gin·,, t" lh~ P~" pl1:1 .,f I thlis on t•f <1tn•n111Hl!I. tt'prt'11!l~•nt.nobin again~t ani exe<::rltiTe nrde~ nr dPd11inn, I() int..rr,-t h,• lu; 1>ii,,wu lo,ur,,h nur ~ui,,,11~1., Rh"kee tJ1e •tability of thl) · 11~ru::tn~-, that a f"• 1!lld1 1hoeb n,,a fur l11m tht• liruts of tht' p1>1)pi@. Thit would. rmlt,, the building t 1)tter aw:t f•IL C•n the fruth he fonher •~ an t>pi~r.dt' in tltt> hiiitory of thi• rerno red horn I hi11 olHion1 infeN!nee 1 :'J'be foundati◄r•h{ of Uri~efl rule • fubcy il!u.!it1at.,_,, ii ol Ufibliuu.Llein India ia. t~d o.n Lhe b«inm repn•;,;,•ut,1ti1·i• li.nl_ie:1 and . a ,snciatinns.· all o,·er lludia o n th e Vi ceroy's ann ·•uncemrnt at Cawnpore lrns ct~arly ahewn !1t•i~ far-rea ching in it,- effects His E:ccdlency's p..Jicy lrn $_ .. actually I pr(,~·et.l. _·No one~ \t1d11 that Gornnmeut should fnrtliwj_!.k yield td HerJ nt:itntion. :~ a t we ask for is that on r represeuta tio/ns alwnlJ lw t.'Xa_mirwd inn judicial spirit, 1rnd.tl111t wheri thrre is a g onr, case fnr th r anwndrnent alterati on or withdrn-wal ,,t spl'c:i>ic orders ,if the :rnthnrities, th ft1,t.'d out of defi>renc1> t<• tlmt l111glwar, Ins;:· of pn•,:.tig-t', any one renturc to contend that ou r demand is in nny ,rny 111rreasouabh•. ! " Put:sT1,a:." · tha~ _thi~ power shonld on y ht1 cxerci~c • on occ~~ioris wh~. . the pos1t1on~o gra~e as to lea e no other akeru"tive for 'coritr \ling a1_1d dispcn,iug _tl!e crowd. _ T_hc~e is bo11od to b<.1 qom1id rable d11l1)rt'11ce of ;np1I11io.ru_ ad. voc:ite ! 1at t'.!u, Govern.• met1.t ot lnt.lia sho 1~1_,d 11\y down as " standing nrder t.l.1. t 11r1 rndPpcnderH Commission of enA_nirr C( p1 m r to on 1~h.ich tl1_e I_11l.li1.\ll e~t'll •e.u t. s(ial_l l_·,_e n1.·11ply roprostmt. ed, si/a.· ll ·1;;_ \~1lh10 8 reason able tim~ after I tiriDg appomted lo tnslttl!t.e _an rnq hR_d tRken place. l lus Cot m11ssu:n should be authorised t~ , tak_e ; end~nce nnllle n•shniuing efred upon the. official cliRrg;;r; b_~· la1v "·i th tlw rei iu the intere.st,- 11i hr,th : ht• {, fficials 11nri the gerwral public that isuch ~ prr,eNlurn sh11uld bn bitl 1 u,,wn. 8uch an inquiry woult.1 s~·vc the ' 011i_c i11I frnm serinn;; _ndveriil' ,t·rit ici-lll to whi¢h i!1 the 1111ture of ]things he IS op•n when l:fe lS IICtiual!y tfikt•JI. fo Great Uritain, ivo11 seq1Il' Il\' O ol :he. gn•ater d t1nd?1m1e11t ,,! tlemocralill principle, h~rng is under serHH l!I contrul. D \mng the recent Dublin ri1,ts, surorul members of tlw police were ~eri,1usly i11jurcd to the ext,•nt or : bein" obli .~ed t o be take11 to li11{pital. Be it remembered that tl10 ~ritish peopl1.1 are not subject tn thQ sp1•ere re.,; trictions imposed und,l• r the l mlia n :\rnu; Act, an dt111l,t wli ,•11 it wns a m ost impurt.111t tllI1t·: i,,11 ,!,f thi 11 lL,11 ~t• tn st·t•-- th11t tl11, theory nt t, ,,1·1•r11a wut by j• H•,-tig,· " "' 1111!. c,uri ,• ,.l to t•xt•e;;~i l',• ll'1i1.;rhs in 111,ii_,,. In th e t+xtrcw,.• of c; ., ,·,•rnml•n t by pn•stigti tlwso who at!11nui , t,·r th e . q.. 1111tr_1· nr,' I take it 1111 -,m•rulilc 011 l,v t,) tl1t•ir nllicial Sll: •l'ri11r,; ·--- -- --- ~rd 11!'1 .,; it1i111 fu r r1' dn•1-.s by O iltl L>f the rult~d.at:ai11.;t oue ,_.f the min·,, (·an be (lllmittt>d us ti right. If f,,r i11,!a11ct~ a 11wnil.ier ,~f tlio rnli "~ rnee iati ict,, nn i11 j11ry up"u a 11w111 ',cr oi the t11n•rrwJ ra eL', n11 (jllt·sti()n will r.ri~l'. (1f put1i$hing t!w f.-,rmer ~<1 n•J rl'~, the wruug of the latter. The only c,111,;iJt•rnti,,n wit be \Y lictht> r pres!ig'e will l.,c morn impnircJ by p11nis!1i11g the t)!I~11 1!a 1111..l s,.1 11drnit it11jlt'rfcc ti n11 in llw g,n-ernini.,:- c:1Et ti or by Lonrlon , 31st Angust. 1~" L 1,lttli -h:il~ him. a11 ,l s I L'·•n,!•>11 i u:_;- the• lailur,• ,,•i .d_1_a_~ p1·11tec- . Two lnirnlrt•J nn rl thirty µolii.:,: were injuroJ j in I.1st ~ion<•! th<" ~ -,1·ern1•Ll whit!1 i, t'S~ruti ,d to ellicicut U 1, vem11H·nt. nig ht's ri otiu~. One has s 11ci.: 11 rubi:J i1; Hui;l'ital. · fiti,; J ln,-trnt••s 11, I un lerstnn 11<1~ say t:1at it was 'l'lI(' ri•>t.'l continnrd in ·l) ublin Jl'Sterday n11d twu hundred east•;: f' pr,,,;,.:; c•,.l 111 l11tli u, it ha,; nlway,.- :1eeu tl'lll[A'rl'J by Uriti ,; h in li <1spit11I fur iuj11ri1•.s n•b· ire,.l. l~ is sLnt,·d th 11 L d11ri11g tlitJ P" lic(l ¢.l1t1rildt-r, British oi'i11i, u anJ tho ll ,h · l'11rl1H111 ,· 11r. \\".liatchar~<' i .. ll<>wio~ 11p u 11 th 1, o.rru.,L <>i Lt1rki11 a u111nlwr ut old 111 eu and l•ver r_,. ]iK111·l' ti. e n; \Y R!! in ,iur G-11·,:, , ,1111PllL of 111d i11 i,:; now 1 H>11 1 • n and L"liildrt~ll wlin: 1n.•rc retnruiu ~ fr,1111 d111ri.:i1were s truck gi ,i m~ !'1'1-:,· t , r, ·linnc(• upnn ,•n•n l1:111de ,I j12 , 1icl1 lllllf 8tni11gt h, 1,· itli p,,l ,ct• lmt.,11 ,;. Th.J ;Jf,.1J or announ~·es fn,· lrit,·nlion l!J1 mori q 11 i)rd,·rl,· ~n,I <'tp1irn! lt• 11dmiuistmtio11 lnit 9real dr',c1l of' 1w113r11st tJwt ,111 rni111frp l,e he/,! wt,~ the cu11d11c t of lhr1 l'ulia. f.~ tu li-1:d ;t,l/, ;,;o it ,;um~ lu Ill(, about p ,·estige . . Cu ll it ii yun ~-i:t n u:;,·iul n~,,•t in ,111r relati"u" lwtw,•1•11 the Uriti ~h O,wernLowlon, 2:!nil Sr.ptcmber. ~er1,1ti,; ri ,ti1ig- t"ok l'lli!ce i11 ll,d1l in las t en·nin:.; i11 c,niurcti 11 n hh'nt an ,\ ti,e ,·,\i1n1t,·d I n,lit\n p,tl,lie. Du nut misund,•rsta!ld I, ilh • pr,)i.:c.,.,ions of strikt•r.-; The Cri)!{;l (l/t1ir ,' .·td and wredd /lit' l\lld d,is ! ""·" ,•,;p••~·icdly t,1 those who 111ay Jn 11w thP h,,aour trm11e irs and p ·1rlwl ·bc1t f/e.• with tl1 e police eHs11e·I m which' hato11,,, :,,( nitici:;in,~ 1,i1t,;:d,• tliii~c wull:1 what I a m 1, t,"' . ~&.) 111g. l stone.,; 1111(/ bottle, were ji·eely u:sd. .\. nnmber uf rioters wero taken illlt'llll \.y pasli~,!-the tlwo ry of Gorcrnm~nl tit ,, t J lia1e jn~t t,> h11;;pitnl :rnd ., er ;r. / pulic:t were ,-11.Jured . lde,eril>ed- tl w tht!urr that produces ine,pm1sibility mid :arro9 ,rnce. -I ti,, nnt 1;f cour se 111 1:'I\ U lhnt repntl\tion _f.,r firm ...~ ·-' .-\.11t.l still thern 1rns ~•) firiug upon tl.ie crowd. In In.lii1 t! 1e •nd dil(nitiell 1"-!mini~trati nn whi.ch no Guvemmeuc can utfor1t>rif,_n~l.r _dy1rg-,•1! 1_,_1· Hll lll' of . l!!i! 1)1•. n .~uu~try_,m,t1 1nth l11W11l3' which lead t11 tlw 111ki11~ ,,f lifn. l en11 app,,. il witli c11nfiJc ni:o to tlw gir .. 11 111 ~l'1i ,1u} l,},i,, t." th e •:!,lr"-~t'1l_1•rt'st1ge. Nu turtlit1r. ,:, '.rn ,uent llri~i,h pi•••pl,• 11,i.,-! tl11• llriti,lt U u1·rriir11.-11t to ~npport and: t,, gini on su~·h criti.~·ism uf the V1cerny 1s ,:ullcd for hey,,n,! p,nnt111~ out · l'll,!d t .. ti:,• :rn:-;~•·kti1111 wl,i ·11 J h!\l"t• ma~e in th1~ i11t,•rc,;ts or ererydull ~hi,- d"i-~ 11f nitir:-1 11r,• ~" kPr11ly s,:-licit .. 11 ~ ,,f t it,• "LdL•,sed <>llt' \•.-n,·t\rn,·,L 111 . d I Jo· .,., with ,:,;tdiJ,,uce , es1,c1;i,Lily lJcr1H1s1i th•.i prc~ti:~ti" that th t'J f,• ,·l it w,1uld he shaken by the pul,l ic daueioK ,,f wh -dc tr►.rn,l uf British f' r~1rni,.i11g lnr~•· ur11ps f,,r th•! n•l i,,f 1,r fa111i1J., ,,,_ rkken : IJCllpli:! r'.,, llo\lill){ th,, ,,is,• ~11,..:ge.,;ti,)n madd uy Irr E. tho \'ici•r,.iy w_irnn dnrin~ t inw oi fMnin,• 1'111•.I th1•rel1\' ~nvi/J~ thn11-,11nl,; .,f liveH wh id, he ,i ~it,•,l Gawnp,>r,, I\ Jitl l•r••l1gbt l\bI tbe quest111 11. w,,u!d othe rwi~e be l,ht, is :1~-•y,111d ali !•I.,i ~e. Tltt• i.:reat imp~tlli t ri l <.hi '. llclt 'll°isli tll tulJ unything more in ri,ga rd i,., this waq.,~r. rt1erc i~, h, fWt'VN, unP a~p,•c t nf tin:) q11tJ.,;ti,·,11 1,:hid...- call$ f.,r a f,,,1· !'lllllit,uy Il l\'l( .,ll r ••~ t hr,,u~hu llt t he 1.. r1:.:tl1 ll(y.,l hr,•adth of thi s ¢'ltlotry, in ~1 ,i te ,,t ·,ipfi"" rti,,11 io , : ,, me 'III!H lers, ltas bePn ~tudionsly a 11tTair c>uly, but 11.,; it ha,; a ,;nHe with th, • ,)hj,•.:: ,1f l' r<'~('n-io~ h,·Klth and ;life. N,,y, Gentlertien, the beari:nK un the iuture, l eaun,,t r,~strain fni rn ,;reakin i; at-,,ut it . I ft rndarn ,_- ntal prinL:i f.Jt•, .. o wh id1 Brit ish rnle in India is 011.~ed, wish i1,1 im·it,• )'c>llt .tt,•nti ,,u t,, tht• fo1·t tlu,t mnh-r ti t~• t•xi sti!l!!,; la¥!' nam,•!y, a !,, ,,Jat(• 11,,n,int ,·rf,•ren,.·e with relj;.: iou, rit,·., , pri1·ile1 5~ aod lih• rti,•,i ii i dw p,•,) p!P d l iidi1' Im~ been (!,.!ilH·1111tdy departed from the p, ,w,•r ,,1 tiriuK uiuu th,· l~ "l'lu u1.d a etrtitiu .:ir,·u:11 st t1tJrd ru_;; n ith ,1 ,·ip w t 11 ,,1ring- li ii,. I reft•r tn: tl 11• l.iw ll'li ich ha;; l>,.,en b"t"t.'llllr d,,lil.'O!r1.t,•l)' ~ifeit t u lic•n•rnllJt'lll _omcitds, ii!Ud tln·rn h zHt' bt,'ll ..,H'rl,.1 in.st1t.11,·,•~ d nri o~ tlt,• piB t ft' lf ) t·n1s whc• o tl is I Oifrr l1•.s bt"-'ll Cllil d•d pr,-htl ,itin~ th ;• im 1ll••!:tli"n of w,d,) wil ,,1, t hu fnn~•ra l }'F" r1f t'Xt't~ii;..•J, r,·~ll:t,u.: iu seri,:1u8 !,,.-.,; of !ii,•. T iu! tilt' ,.ii c,nthtir lrn, bnml,;. $1111rt',, wl1 ,;, under II liii::h iwn•u ,,f rd ig io ns i!en ti111ent trull lo~ .11n ,•x,:itt,,I 111,,b by tiri u~ up.;n t.l\t'lll 11nd c·r c·t rc:tm1sn,lunta.rily 1Jlitr to ,acritir11 th ~ir li1·~s by III hiJc"ns d1•11th are jnoh 1bit&lll'~lt- ,;h,, u!J rrm•i1t ...,i th t i"· ,.th,·i,\l,; in £li ,.• io h'r<.'~t.s " i f•'J. .'c ;;wJ tt•d tiy l"w fr11m J,, in.:.:- i;u. X,J am dttnt (Ji rel1 g-i1,w1 pn cti tJ nr\ltt m t,~t f.1<> r-.?-Adily 11.dm ilt t·J. .\t tl1c• ,1aI1 1c ti 11.1<1 ".! "··/U:.t ,• 11r,,ec·11it atta l•hin~ t, , th i,, prnctictJ hit, d0trrred t he British G ,. )'i\~rnuHmt frn m \i1>u ~ ,.rt t'"'"IIL :ally 11~<.'N$.uy l\·h,•I! tli,, ,1i:c .,lt. ·ll i, ,. ,1:,· ,,i h,kin,; LJ \' l,•;.:i,lt1,i ,,11 t'i a t ]ires ~h"uld DO~ be sa.c ri!ic.ed in this lite. : Nu i•r~!i11 a:r1 \' irc u111 ~tu 111·~•~ <'-llli d p,,,..,-ihl.r p ., ii(1e r/,., ll >< ' ,, [ ""Y · ls u;, , much ! ,) a, k: the same lfore r oment. t ,, pro, ide 11dequat~ fi.r,•-lun,~ 111,:aiu,t tli,• 1n•t•h•. \\',, k H ,•· t,, td u,rnt·,cr t li d 1•,L,,tt•rer lllld ~uit a ble ~aie -~1tard11 aga in st the ta king ()f th e lives of pedple wh1, rn :1y h:.r<• ,·, ,ngr~>("!.,•d t .. !:i wtlrnr nn,f e r svrqe e:-ccitir1; ei\nse, Holfe,.er, ~r,, "1d in .I ndi•. it i.11 l!!l .o r l!l : .J • !1-i ii~ f -i W!"r ,,i lll; ,:rin!,' t!i ,· v ,L.:a a.nd u,h.:r ~ ,.1 i,ie i• r1•ry ;im ik-tl iuJ .:'<'d. h w;:, m•-l i'.y h · ,:vo~~c-J~J tr·i \' ic.l, il>UU ha.J ,li,;,,h.iF"'l .rh,· ,:,,1111nll fl ~ t,> diap<'rs.i , in 11•lr:fl6 ca.ad 1 0 1 1 in 0 1 t I t i1 (1 b 1 1 i 10th Janual'Y• - _. ., tliev conld n t do so, bo-.reTer willing tbey ~ay bne been to, bt (,1r; ndy point ed out, 1t 1s ~rces,a~y JD the mtrr~st of the 1 A ~- in11c e d tli t' Bi iiish Gc•n ·rnmen! , _rn the mterest. of offi_c1~ls u11on 1 <-~n th i::nne rr f'._l•omibility of gnrn~ the orde_r to fire 1s imposed 'II. IF . · . tl , ili' 1 tNt'S( S n.1 • · tl ,e sneral .. pnbhc. that thi! safe . : 1 t,, J:iw. s1H. 111 n i . . . :l I ban i1afa·nti' d shoul.d be prov1 ~ . "'d.U< 1:snu' s t · 1nL SEnYANT • · · T he all th e rre of _..,, e1r entenng mto /he Cn:1 ,.;.-i,',' cf J r ,lia. th e inndttmenti1l truth tli~.t tl1e!-~~- ont to tl11s 8 ., llt in(l it .r:, ,t tn , de India but t n_ "so-r-e . India. 1lie thr~e let.ters ~,f th,• nlJ !Hi l•et I. ~.S., which ml~ r P~lRln attache? _t? the_1r ~amee dnrin l:' tht• ~h ole nf lwir lin•;:,and of which every cn1l111n 1s 3nstly ,n,nl stand f,,r I nd an Gin'/ ~ert,' '.11'. ts and ~o not represent Rny form ,·,dt . Ji tht' mPn h rs of tl~e (1\'ll Snv1ce would but constantly l){'llf in rniml tht' nn c mtn '.nrt1bl~ fact thRt they are the. Sert.•arita f I, ,di,1 . HIHl tliRt tho· will, dnrmg tl1 e "·hole~[ the ~emamder of their li,t,. ~lwtl1 (r t!it')' 11:rt' in 11ct-in• {'lllpl(•y or In retirement, eRt the _ lt .f tht> l"('['le (~f India , nnd thal as Mr. Montagn re<:ently stat('d :~ Parl iam r t.t d 1eyj nrn~t in_ co-0peration ~ith the Indian people fnr tlil' pr:m , ti, -u n~ tlie bt•st intHPst of this country, ·not me~ely tie \im ~ "hid1 i mi, y ll J pfar lo tlH'Dl best, but on t.he lines (~- ; ma'i l,r re~ an , ed 11 s blc';;t jointly by both, the work of edminis1 ~•r; ~g th; r c•nnir) ~ill bP g r<'1:1ly sin:1ili£ed, the progress of India will 1:-e tic th r111 id n~ d rn100th and the causes of eshangement and • · 1 FoitB.IG'N POLICY OF G11EA1 D111TAl:N AB • , ii <;:: T~g b1>uN: : llota•~·~•->'. n\a~e . Dnringtbe time 4---str~ss ~nd strain »rgtlS weJ . agai~at. the MnEsalmans of India ~hat they w ted to dictate:[ the : f"nign-) policy of Great Britain, that they de11ire tha~ England ehonld . go~.; :· war to prCltect the Moel('m States in Eur pe &lid .Asia. : Can any- : tl1ing be further r('moved frc,m thl\ truth 1 !'lhe Indian( Mllti~mans-i fully recognise the dan(!er: to Engjand, ilh all its int~r~sts 1:iprea( owr the face of the wl1ole world, to bin that !!he sl10~1ld tho,ig,ht~ : Jeto;:Jy imolve hen-elf in a bloody war. I is doing the: Moslem& of .' India a g_r.ave injustice to suggest that ti ey-had the re~otest notion : of dictating wh11t foreign J)olicy England! i-hould pars.u~. And u,. m 8 tter o f fact thry hne ne'fer dre11mt of ldoing so. A'.l} that they haYe urgrd-Rnd l tl1ink 1l1ey had amJ)l~ justification in• doing . s~ was thRt England as the sovl'rrign powl' irtor _millions MUB8alman : . subjects. sl1ould, ont of ngard. for tlieir 1- nti.me. nls, ende•.· vo. '.ir · to see- :. thal 'l'urkey obtained in !lie Councils or t110~, fair and juf.t treatment. I do not tl1ink any one cnuld J entme to a1,sert that the : request , nay even tlie ckmnnd, tl1at E11 end ,1t}1ould d~ its l:est in' the C'oum·ili, of Emq)e to,enrnre fair, jur t and ('(lllilable treatme.nt to Tmkry rtm f OE-sibly beregarded ns \ir ing in any "!'Y uurea~on-· able. It is her1H1 8e 1he ntterancee of r~sponsil,le Britji.,h Ministers an rtlred to tl11111 tc: ir:dic11te tliat ~r1glalnd's .,,J~,E!'tliic•11 wne agnin11t; the Tmks that ]r.d1an M(lshm fceh11g8 ~ ue nat.llv hurt end that they felt afrgrieved. Cnn any fault be f~und with ti1e~:n uuder thecircumstances 7 I At the lime of tlie declaration of wat between Tur}cey and theBalkan Allies, Sir Edward Grey said ii[I tbe Honse 'of Commons that "the great Powere are taking wha~ sleps they can to prevent, a breRch of the peace, definite prowsals were mij:de yel'lterda1 for collective steps to be taken by or on behalf of the great Powen to oYercome these difficnlt:ies by represedtations to the Balkan State• and at Constantinople and we agrud to t~m." 111e steps indicated by Sir Edward Grey were the declaratio~ thnt " if nevertheless ,var t,reak s out between the Balkan States ! and the Otl qman Empirethey will not admit as the resnlt of the qonflict any modificatious of the territorial status qtJ,D in Enropean 'furkE"y," 'lbiit wai, at the time of the commencement of ttle war. ! We may reasonably draw , di;;;;ati :-farti ,r '\\'ill l·e 11p-r<,01Nl. the inference from this dedaration tl,at ij Tmkey had been victodou1 llmin1; thr rn nn~ \"tnr s "hid1 I line Fpent in the service of the it wo11ld not ha'fe be<'n allo,.,ed to tetain[any portion of ~be conquered pu blic in 1lw B, ml ~)" ·Pn·~ider,cy I l1aw ~o~e intd' close and inti; territ')ry. .At the time war was deolare~ it was geneHlly felt in the ma tt> t't' llta l' t "ith 11 1l11rge nnmh,r c,f Cmhans and I have _made Chrncelleries or Enrope that the Tnrki11.1 soldiers \ll"Onld sweep over m 811 ~- intimal f frit·.nti s 11nw ugst them. As .a cl_a1:111 I ha,e th~ lngl~est the surrollndinF territory belonging t~ the Allies, and if theee dmirllt i111 k r 1hir! hr nt i ' o t)' ·d r-urpou•, their stubborn rntegnty, 11 e:xpectatin'1S J,ad littn realized the might. of EurPpe, including the tl1t•ir hi1.:h Nl •ilitJ r.9 u tl a·ir 1- ·_md,: dHoli nn to dnty. Would it :be power of En~land, would have been aR.srrted to depriye Turkey of t,•,) m11~h 1<, ll ~k tb rfl to cultiute a bettn regard for tlwse India~ any territorial e:ltpamion as the result of its ,ictories. :Jlnt the tide r ubl i,· mPn "ho de w,te a la, ge pr,rtion of their time in the 11ervice of 'fictory went tlie other way and the B~lkan Allies proved victoriot1t t,i tJlt, rou nt1y. wh olare t1rtna1td Dll t,y any rnrdid motives of perimmE>diately 'the -CoJlflict had begun iq earnest.. Tl~s completelJ i;,, nal gain hit by i:i~glPnei:s of pmpo~e in ~ning their countrymen, upset the preconceptions of the Chanceperie11 of Euro~ ,nd tbeJ t u ah~tain fr; 111 altr jbnting D!1,tiYE's 'l\htrl! none exist.., lo treat their felt tl1at the dec1aralicn or the maibt~nance of the ·1Jtat"' q,40 in opini ,·ns v.:.i1l1 r~ f arici C(,nsideraticn, ana to feel that perhaps the Ballan •· Allies. Mi;--, th t>r,' nay bf, ani tl1t1r aspect of quo:tions under di~cussion ,vhich may -- - European Tnrkey wonld be prejudicial Afqnitb, ~h~rime :Minist.er of Great fritain, took early opportnnity l req uire diffen•nt tre11,tme11 t? of then -declaring that whatever n,ay be itbe result of :the war the - I hue ;aid that [tl1e civilians are unanl8 of India, as their very Concert of Europe could not poegibly ~eprive the 'l'i~torions part.f dt-signBticn iudicate~,just 111, ruucb 88 we a.U" in .the i:enice of our from securing the fr'nits of their victorie,j. Are the Mneulmana of n r.1her- hrnd. hr aifference is that while tf-ie formtir are paid for th•ir , ,,nices. the l!ftter belong ·to the case not of the "unemployed" India to be blamed if tbey feel 1hat E~tland was ast1ociated with l nt , f the "1111 raid .' 1 H has always been a \\'ondtr to me that men the other Enro11ean Powers ro laying dorn and enforcing • policy t•i high intel lfctu,-111ttainnw11t;. and in active occnpation in their o,vn , that i( the Turks had proffd '\'ictorionsJ~ the com.htf; they would iPdn , tri:8• ('longibg to any of thf' Balkan AUieP, but that if the: Balk~n Allin pro•ed victorioua m 1twir ow.n p1.,·at e lr l•D. cNu., , c1me for-«ard in number&, .to , Pe.ne th e l' t ru l r) Ill grut reT1tona ucrifico and in the face of severe diathy wonld b,e ptrniitted' to annex impo~•nt. p-0rtiona (Jf itb.e European l" ,ura~rni eut. Cirn ,bt•tter J•roof be required of the sturdy patriotism Domit>ione of Tnrliey ? la it nn~aaouble that the M~lmao11 of 1,f >1:ch men. wh o re/u ;ilv make Ft-rions nerifices 'of uluable time and India shc-old fttl lhat fair and equitah~ treatment not being n,cI1t'Y in au rndt•av~mr "to rrnder all the help that liu in their rower mrtrd ont. to their eo-ttligionists beyond the seas and ibaL England t, l-n, urt' g, ,·d Gl•Htrnmt' nt in India : This c)ug •of men are in wu taking a promi11ent ptri in ruch b~~tment ? ! ,•~-'.;:tin;c, n tl1t> nw~~ raluable ln!puial asset in India and ~ne Ma. A11Qu1Ts .urD ras Pale■ o, L011noi . :1 tL t , Ill' ( lllll~H!l~ lll pof..~ihlt> in their self-imp<>1;ed tuk. Any Well, 18 yon ar& •••~. after the Pe,ce of Londo~ waa ligoed fn•\ 1ug d rnoJ•il·i l•ll ~nd d istrn,t towards tl11t mn1t r~~nlt in enhanc10.d the Balkan Alli~• fell olJt amonpti tbemselne, · r~ting in ·• iu~ tl.e difli rnlti es l•l th e si tuation.• · re-diahibntion ol the conq_aettd terrilorj', '.{t1rkey, a1'aiJJ'ng iteelf of R~LtU.!11 w AR. 11>& opporh1oity which ~NIH ao proTid~ntially ua.ilab~, ftt"aptund _ It ru u~t b" ,r ith • fe<:'l ing of l"l'lief that yon will have aeeo the eod 1he town of Adriaoop)e aod the lllTl'OOn~Ung counu1 ~th wbieb a lO: tL t' Balh n war, Tnrkey has 'Dim llo rld. Mnuahnanw in different pa1ria of . tb6 "", :\,l li •'_ t' • H p \ ,·t'1:\ tbt> ir rudineM to com-e fo"'a.rd in a ,pirii of · 1piMt il and wu «-&o~ntiDf with ~tlw, EmopND I Po"" who t'are the dfoelaml fDflDMa of the .T mk• Eaapjr.. all .,, , : ' l' ~1tie t nd deV1c- ti1•u to i;hnd by their: c-c-ttligicnict.a · ia U..r !).11 e r · t 1m l • o d tt \~uh\ ". h i, the li,ing n iir~lt bla8- ti.at:tJ,e fJ'M°'9U<,9, Uff the ........... ,.,.. ~Jtlmtl' ..... ,..W ;- -: HJ blame to Uwm t B ..e ·i• t)»e .U . . . .. 19 ...tll : t1 k t1h d ltla mi~, l, rollmb('◄,d ut1 euted dftp do,m in h8rl• 11t· !, \ju•er~ d 1tir renmi Pror,het and that ti,. lapte of tattW, tHlmg ·or ainttn . . lo7.llky ~ .. .. Brita . f Ben,-] t ur,t , ba.s 10 no waf blunftd tli• e-fftcnrade. : I ,t i oell ntNI and ,..,nint and lh,i, ,mndaot far fro'!' b,ing bi.m.. ,co..,;.i... thot retoliaijoa • oold be appli . : in the •~i~io~f ·,~ wort y deaerves highegt commendation. · prohibition to all the S?nt Africans fr?~ any employpient . Sooru A!'a10,ur Qua1T10M. -~ the Government of India ~d the restr1ction against t\le p rchaae am ap~aling t.o yon to exercise ~Lienee and resLraint in critiof Son~h African coal by e railways in India. I am afraf that. •i•m fo doibg__ so I have not failel to realize hotJ edr,muly retaliatory measnres, confin to these two '. ~hings would ha dly ~ diffi ulL it is at tim1-i to t-X:ercis~ Lh,He virtue~. The f1:1elicg of ancoessful in att.ainin~ th ol>ject we have ·at heart in enforci g the indi nation anil b,irror which has s1>re:,d tluo11~ho1tt. thi~ country recognition of our rights f British citizenship by the , Colo ies of gard to the tre•tment meted out t.o our fellow-countrymen and Orea~ Brit.ain. \Ve will I aY'e to consider anll device whic~ wo n in South Africa laas led to the nse of langaage which under while living perfectly c nstitution_al,_ Jnty prove really e,iective. the iroamstances could hardly be contr,,lled. But. in the face of the The intelltiat11al c,pacity o the fodinns is not so meagr~ 88 to gra e.pl,'Ov~atian to I_ffiian feelio~s 11.~d I~dian sentimeota [ c11nnot despair. offi.,n.diog sn. ch an leffti.ctive remedy·. • •lmt · tl.1a U: ma f~:r. ~uc. he11expl'W!ing my sense &:P grat1ficatl?n at the masterly promeaaares bas yet to come. We have th11nk£nlly to ramem r. · t~ t~e Indi~o Officials •~e s11porting 011~ 011pse and that man. ; Eo~000 cement which H. E. the 1oeroy made 1n M11dl'as, I know thai t.he xpressioo of hin,incere feeling of sympathy witl_1 the. peopie of hsbmoo 1n South Africa a pear t.o be Ill o,ur f11vom·. A 1uajbrity ~f this onntry has laid him open t,l severe criticism in 11ome qul\rters. the powerful E11.l{lish pr ss .is sufficieuily outspoken. v{e 'have It curious anannly tha~ the,ie very critics, who never forget to therefore, to wait for the ~0111 result of the present contretem~ pre. ch to us, [n11a:1s, t.he J ,)-1t~in,1 of 14\IJ1°:itt.in~ to i_he views ?~ .the beforfl, concert.in~ auj pr ss1ng effoct.iY'e . ineasures in this i behalf. w~ ,111 h 11 ~p ,1~, wh,1 ne,er fail tl.l res,mt iuterpallat1ons and cnt1c1sm Th~re is no [nJ.ian who do~s. not r~gret the necessity ~f being iu t 16 H 1 use of 0<11u ruon!! 11.a th wos THK BogR WAR. : th th th0 nd i■ ti!> keep ltiiu~elf in ,:\,i~I) t,)alic,i or whether: it · was · th th N II, gentlemen, in ,ipi«. of is c~itteism e Boer Go~·er_nment hu tbe Boers who succe.,sfnlly do;1feated Gre,,t Britaia. If Great Britain bee obli.:r&d t-0 au110unco thd appointment, of a com11l1ssi;1n of _ en. 0 • d h' 0 was in reality the victl)rioJ\:1 party, it, sh,rnlJ uot be powerless to quitJ. You 11ll k~o.,.. th~ ~,mst~t11tioo of t 18 ,>mrnis~1~n an t(rn . h r , ;3,>u~h ..\iric,rn [uh:1n ,l~H 111 nn ot the m111 cho'len to . sit upon it enforce its w1s e:1 up•JD t 1,e 8 oers. 8 nt . r,>m recent prononilceme11ts On ~ dems,ml was th , t the Com nission ebonld be so cnnsLtnted as t.n it seems obvions tfnt th~ Briti,;h Cabinet i:i in re:1lity absolnteh I ! · s th \ f · b helples:i in the tu 11twr. T,he pie:. ptlt t,,rward i:. tlut in :iell-g,,vcrn-I 11 1 1 1 1 th - ~n:i,rc? n,)t lrnly :i.t till LUJ!l c i-; ,rn Ill ' HI : ric ,\ s l\lll ' e sue ing Ooloaie;i, the British ;G,wemm,rnt Cl\n merely u~o snasiun and th 1 th th O th •• i 0u\ ,l \l->m·n \ll l e n!i;},,n .:rt~J lnth by thnl11tion. Woll th~ Uuirm lt>w -rn,1nLry1ut1n are n•c,•i\·ing at tho cell abo t () dedar~ the.t it is puwerlo;.s to intorfere with the : dome8tic uadd! ol the Sooth African Go\' efllnl60\., It, cauoot bd uarrowad legislation of a !i(.IH-gove:C, ning C,ilony. All I\ result oi 1rnch legisla,.. du.yu t;J th.i prtJ~nt ro;ii.l.i,nt..i in ll\D South _Afric:l.n Union. Tl~&t tion the English p.iupfo in Natal ma,r uo lio1111c.led outj of that qlt~,;tion i~ 11 uJo11bt0i.lly etUergl)nL l\lld ro l.ia dealt w1tb. Colony, and still the British Cabinet I supp,1,;e wo11ld sit w(th folded forthwith but the wiJer que..,tion can no 1on~r l>e postponed but arms and declare to the world its mt~r holple.~,mess to t;ecure ,ulJ~t 00 ~ ht! f11eed •nd that qne;,tioo i11 "\I/hat is t~e position--'\ just.ic.e to their own pe,1ple. If this i.t a. fit.ct then it clearly foll<►w&. of I the p<-"-lple of lndiai!.} tuo Bri~is~1 E1Dpire." . Au;;t~alia _ is that though no1Ui11ally Bria in won the B,1cr \Var it wiB the lloem pr~~tic~lly bamiJ ag ,in~t UJ!. C,rni.J11 1s e,,ntemp~tiog legtslat,_on who were re:11ly vict.ori,) ~>l, Rod a;; a re,mlt oi such victocy : annexei to i prohibit Asiatic immigration. The. attitude of South Africa the British Culonv of Natal t,'J the Republics of the Tmnsvaal and i,s ·pa~nt. to yuu. '£11~ time i~ therefore ripo t •<> a.sk whether we Orange Fr~ St~te. ()!\n anyt ,ing be more absunl?: Wonld common subj~t.,i of His lmpQrial ~hjest..:; the ~iog, cx:cu,i~Great Brita.in remllin 1-1, i'. indilTerl.'nt if : the Boer majority to,)lc it \ iuJ idirntic.&lh· the Name po!!itiou M the ot.her SllU}eCU! of li111 iot-0 thei.r head,, to a.!t io the ma.nu~ i11di !,1ted ? Genderucn, it }ljijecty, oi; _~rn Wt! 110 in the_ ory only? C mfor the graci,ml! prodadoee1 ant rt•qnire any prr~•iei t•111!e t,) KrltiW that the whvle of Gri!at tu~tion 0 ( ~ue~n Vil'tori-., c1rnfinm,d by thu · U,:>y,ll pwnouu~u1no11ta Ilrit.aiu wonld be eJCcitiJd fl',,111 one cud to the othn and tlw migbt uf i Que.:m, Vi..:t,,rit\',, two s111..-ct),;.:1on1, pll'tirii and th~ w.:1 i jn au uu••quil',~•,lblo m11uner lha\ 1,e ,1tni _th \ cll1zt1U:l . of tl~e might or England would prernil. [t ii only w!um th,i per:4o~fi affected £1,~.ipir~. lu pr-adiC,'. howeTIJr, 1'e tiud th~t 1u S,Juth Afri~.a, 1_0 are the ~ iople of Inditi p1,\t thi;-1 lrnlple-i~n!l;;,i i,; mrnii1Hting itself. C'~u .. da aud iu Aust rah• - 'tl!?, U 6 reKuded. 111 a wanner which it A c11rinus sidt!light ~-; tbrnwn ,rn tho i,i,;,trn I have rai,e~ by the ia ! diftknlt tu ,rxprNS in ,uoinot~---\.Qfl~\lgli,.~ 1•~ ::;,,,-cret&rJ , Df 8 tate, 1n the !lpeech wh ioh he deli\:o red ou . tho :.l-lth ~fo1·eruber )1e i8 tt.11 fot • J,idarat.iou wlwtber tht')' Wtll mam,i;t• t.i ~~tire t,,i " Lim port,!d tu hav1, 1111.id that. "Thu~1 cmrntry WM part ui the British ri~hts ,rnd privilege!! of Uriti 11 h_l·iti ~.- u~liip'. . . , Entpirt!, !Jtl tlid!I 11Jtn c1~frtt u · they tf ert cm i11dep~11clenl : Slat, . li ihe au:.·iH•r t,, the qt1e.it1uu 11> 111 1 he t1rlirm11tll'u, l::n: land 11 j"o,1till') ol eqimli lJJ with t!ir -;,:,. tr: ~1,,tu!,iiHl thtJ were a . , (·~1u date h~ ~ ;ot to exen:i&t1 tlul 1wwel":I which lt'.,:All)' \\i.s t I Q lltlr Id f.l/ E11y h111.'/. Our lir,,t iintJ iu t I) intt-;r~t oi the Uuinn i~8eli ill in il U,,y,.1 plt' J,; e:' · tu re,L·ei_vo t ~1e with0t1t in any way Ui!partin~ f n 11 0 th~ t.~...;t of 0 11r prini:ipl~. " right.ii of .llriti,.h cit i:t:t O"-h1p . ti 'ft't' AN . p rn h tb, t (•J _l r.J m ,-e ltll!l l{ t u I s b;) nld lik:e to ku1v,. " lmt t he BriLi,~ .\linistcr!i ha,'e to say im tl~,3 llriti,.h C,)l 0 n(ee ,rn r, p111\ t<'rnH with th,, wl11t<" u ,,:~,1, \t i! • ·r'-1 Tl';;u.rJ t .. thts d•im. Ir tltt!y 11Jmit it, c,,ulJ they st ill c~aim that o1;citldd t.o a d"ar 1rnJ ,iditi it~• ll,,--=l,i.r .. ti•,u .. 11 th,, p,,: tlt . lt_ is tl1ey 'fl' uu the Il,,1J,r \V"r' 1 ; , u,c~uirJ that lhl :1\1-)ul ,! d ,• ~rly '. \ld,•L' -l (" u .J . w /1;\ (. .~ .xlr..:•ady rdt>rr,..,l t, ,, t,, q q,\l n ;ht., " t Bt;lt.,;lt c1t1z,HJ.t,i p, if iha\ ri,( ht ,Hl th~, d,..: l:u-.,.l l\n d1,,r t1 ~· ,,{ th d Br1t i,; \1 C a. ha1 i; t iu tr1'•1,, l\11'1 l' " m 1111:rc-•J . I'll <} ,J. ,,;t rin u ,H th >.1 .st1r v1v ul " ( ~hu :i,k,t ;~ tu b-c- d t'Di ...,l t > u,. thrill l'l't' ,h.\\1 1.> · fr,·,· (,, 11 r .: •11 1t ,~~ II H ~U ::1 •ud d ~~ u,,, p n>:;UtU~bly np jily 1•.l :; n1th ,i{ ric11. \Vti ,i, n thr lnJiaU,i u4,ocl!!l\ r<'e. t ·> 11~,,t~t ,> tir·&dnH a,;, t11 ,t :hi , ,ttk;u it.)' . ~{d s1 t: :.ti,m is deLU!lld legi ~l.iiv,• 11n,i' tJ XJ ,·Hit."ll thl! li0 u ' b!"' Mr. G ,.J k:h.alt', pri nciple of thii "t111rvinl 1) i thtJ ti~k.s t.' ' ! T :1 ,~y wca t t, , h,-\"d i~ l.1< Jth " hv bu ma -1 uth Africa hili (HUl, .. a,j. May I t.eU tl.H!W ,rn!h a l"' ii,; J leaJ tu no g vuJ r lllldet ,nean~ h. 1 ·1 • .,. t, 1 : 1 J 1 1 "'- uJ 1 1 °" 1 1n ctu . ' ThdComrade. · 10th January. I" ,. JuoicuL AND Exscur1v~ ~uNCTIONs. ------ • SsP.rn.u10Y :St ion of the sepuation of tl,.e jnd1mal and execnt1v~. 1:he _que, been well threshed out thronghout the country functwns hi~" . 0.t ha~e referred to it here, but for the (act . of the th at I ~i':u,,~:m in· the Imperial Legislative, Council on . the sn~'.e,cent 1 do wish ent.er into the history or ·the qnest1on,. as 1t ~:i t Ito !ect. ll-known to you!. There i,, howe~er, one aspect the di~u~1~ wein the Imperial rl)Ullcil whieh reqmr11s_ to be bronght out prom~11on When the resolnti ,)n on the subject was put lo -the v~te, tt nenti~~md tlrnt l'\"•'ry Indian member, whethe~ e~ooted _or nom,~a'.ted ,us . in fiwnur of it. It i8 a me1~e incident 1_n t~e poht:cal 0100 ' _ 0 f 1 d. th t. all the acluns\' 1mportanc11. 01 C11u~E!'rs hiwe bt•en 11,llbi1rnled b_1· H1 .. ElC•'.ellenlly the Viceroy _h:~1self. All lu,lilln "di,h,'ll n•p1·es(•ntntivt•s or tho pcllple _o~ India h~ve unauim,iit,d)· R,-.k,·d qiat a be~innin~ should be forthwith madt:1 with thi~ rt'f,)r!ll. TlF•Llc.(h t he re.,,il1rno11 W!lS _ lost hy the_ vote or the ,fficial nrnjnrit,\" we a,h·,~nce _on prev10~1s e?ndttwns. _We hut' st>e11ted m ,r,, ,,,,fit~ ,,n tht• L,,~islt\tt\·e 011uuct!s, we have obtained th.si verl' va.lu,·d,le l]til'il e:.;e oi msting in the;-;e bodies arc of a fat-· r,,4,•ltin1,; clta~at'ler. :A Legi latin~ Conncil can not. only pRss or r1'ject It lr,·,h l~·~i~l!\li,,n, h11~ ean rqieal and amend existin,g lawB. i:-, th,•r¢(,1n•, ri;zht that the p0w.•r of tht> majority should remain in the hands oi Grl\'t'rlltrl'i nt, Bnt it is absolutely nt!p •)Siti,m" in Parliament, I do not mMn that--· they ,,lw1y~ nppot'r or the l!u.lian memb.er;;uf the Legislath1e Conncils in,.foputably pnwesjthat they h1He'been actuated by a high sense of duty trnd p,1tri1 m, 11.s~\res intrnduced b,· GuYernnwnt. They WDrk prl'.di~,1lly nu o>Hllt\ ba.,i~ akin t.r) ;ll "''P(h)Sitiun." It ·is nnw ;''c,,gni,;c•d a;. 1111 ax ipiiatie trnll1 that the elncienc.~· of Government i~rs;dy d,'}h'll,l, a i-ll'lltlg oppostttou. Any meuures which 1 " u!J impc1ir tli,, of the upp~)sitiou \Tould unqllC,$tionl\bly r,•-:.,'t ,<11 tin, acltninistratioll. 8'.1ch an oppo8rfiun is !iy tlit• nwmh tl'> in the Ll'gi~Iatin) Couneils. i,_. lt .. w,·v,·r, n uu,LL1<11JnHl\1 difference f.,,etwet;;l the " opp'!.lt!itiun" 1 :t1. l\ rl1,11t\\•nt and iu India, and I am sorry ti, find re-Alized by Gurernment officials. In to-day may well hope to sit on tn-murr.,w. The whole 11.tt~nt.ion of the party hwards winning the :rnffrages of t,he people nf may ;; ucceed in st>Curing a ma jority at tlw occupy the Gon•rnmtJut benches. As l P'-'rt_1· iu tlrn 11p1:,,.isitinn to-day may be the .\H the p,(>wer tmd patronagt'-:u1d th-, En.(!ilrd-whid t lllll)' VMt in the party l,y tht~ opp,osit i,,n t,>-111<.,rrow. Tht- pol!i,!J" 1n ln,lio1 is quitt1 diffrire11t. Th" l"'iwu it most e.u,rnsive, e\ie,n in ludis --« hkh mu~t Chn·,-ru :n,•ut in ollil't r111uain,1 alwau in th<'l T h+.i O,,nirnm,mt bend1is mu.~t alwa·n re1naln l'li,, "opp,,sitiu~>'' UHlit alway, o,,,- .:opy:t~, ume i ii, .. to c•X ~ f'Cl11<1 unJf.lr pr~':,,,:Hlt . : ••J odith>O•- tbit, ;.;d th ,, \'estiug in Govtrurueut aod d1• t•ll.iug i « 0 0 it1tluence whfoh directl7 resnlts the from. Io serious disability, men-are found ready a d willin,r to , 1 sacrifices in the public caose. Ther -~ d1_ to accept rOo~rQ~ displenure in the honest and coosc1ent.iou d1~huge of.their _do~ · 1 Scrutinize the clR&~ of men who 00011 .Y s641ts on th~ Leguslati,e i CouncilK in India I\Dd yon will observe w t . cl~. the1, are clra,,. , from. Yon will find amongst them men ~gaged to ~m~rtaot and industries, in 11~riculture on an exten~ve• sc11le, 10 profess1one which they cnin money. These men wh:>.,e ti.me is of f t~e utm~ i ,·alue reasp,a1sihle Indian pre;is_ thaL !Govern~1e11 L sl~•n.l. to obta1a direct informntion a,; regard$ the feelings and sent1meut::i <)f the people. Just ·a,, full enconra~ernent is nooded to s~11re the best men to sene on the Legislati1•0 Councils, adequate lib~rty of expression is necessary for the I nJian press _I have no sy1npathr with those new!papen .. which regar1l lice,'!e as liberty and are ~ab1tnally transgressmg the bounds of lih,~ral .ju11:rn:1lism. At the Safl'.le timo it is neces~arr that. no nndue restrict i,ms should either be i-qiposed or by any act.ion er Government officials, should be felt to st~nd in the way of a full and free discussion of pnblic mt.tterR. The oj~1y independent: source fro• which Government can keep itseH in daily touch with ;the feelings and sentiments prel'ailing it the different; parts of Indi.a is throngla the Indian pr 1,;s, Ir the actual effect of lany measure of Govern~e•t leads to a con lition under which Oovernn\ent are them!Kllves deprlVN of this direct. k-w1wledgt>, it is hamlfnl anjl miBChionms in its reswl&a. I ha\·e been c,rn,-t.rnined t,, make these rornark11 bt>c1111se J am penio■ally aware of the fact that the Pre&! Act, with th~ wide powel'8 il confer:~, is nµerntinl{ in directly discouraging even well-established••• long-Rtanding I 111l ian nl.'w1:1papers from freely expressing t eir vieWII. I think that timo has come when the qn11Sti,m regarding- · the op,,.tion of the Press Act should be carefully :and judicially uamined AN tho necessary measure;; 11pplied in order to remove the disabilitie!I existing. or n•• Mosu.:M Io1u.u AND Pouov. Having touched thus briefly oo c11rrent events I should like le uy a few words in regard to the question, of our policy and our ideals., I do so with --(\orisiderable hesitation ; ~ut. I am obliged to deal with it in view of t1,e fact that dnring recent times mnch diff'erence el opinion has manifosted itself among the I Mobamedans of India, aatl statements han, appeared in the pl'OOI to; the effect that the League. has been cAptu1·ed liy the young hot. h ~ of the commnnity, that it i;; tottering and i~ ou · the verge o~ collapse, .that loading IMll .among~t ns are abandoning the League either op!!Jllif or qaietl1. J t will strik11 a1n 01.10 that there mnst. b(j· Mmothing ra:dicaUy wrong ,.,-ith the mach:n~ry by which the Muua.lm11n11 have ora-ani!led themsehes to pronwto their comrnunal in\el'('11t4, it these 11t.ternent.8 were true, MY PoLt'fJ04L F.l1TH. Bef.,ini I deal wi th this queatinn, I ~:hould like to . place bet.NI you my n lfn faith a11d 1.ieliel in regard t..> ltha political fu~11re of Iodia. I do ,-o with a ,,iew to remo,ing Lhe elilJhUAt chance oC my aUitude ooin~ r11isunden1tnod or mi11eonatr™ld. ;Looking to tl1e growth Gt ~:ilitical li!e in India during so ehon a ptriod io the lir~U)f a Nation &.'I the la-.t [)() yt!ar~, it IUUllt strike e,en! a ca~mal obseriver that the progre.ss made hy the country i11 phebiJmeoaJ. W'id1 the liberal edncat1nnal policy adopted by the Britieh G inerument, we have "' l~n enahle to come in close cont.ct with Western thought. li!Hi cnlture and with the hie1t.ory of the ri1.1e and prngr$iil of demooratil' i11,;tit-uti ,)ns in th11 West and their pr:Meot ucondeoc1 , and it i11 b11t- n11.t11r-a.l that nnr h1niz•ln should be wiidened and th~t we •honld l.~•1me kNmlr anxi,·rns t1') more At.eadi!J for•ard on Himil•r :inea. I think w.-, sho;,l,l not be true to mn \lolhe,. land H we di-J! not .!drire &4• aUaiu • high i.tandar,I of pmgNM on det"pooratfo Iiu~. I •m ooe or th,~~ drn'lltnt!'nl wlt n firmly beline tt..l gl,oo a a11ffide11ll1 foog llf)ell ,,f Bdti~h n1l11 in fnJi~ we ai:-e boQod to ber:omo noi~ u a na\i,, 11 in th,:1 real ,,,e,ni;e of the term.. When \hat ,mv-. (• it (1 ttlril to do), we sball hue qialHled ·&o: mJe the couaLtY ?1Jraely-. aud ~lf-gonrnn~~ot will be abaoJ11tely to 1u: I~ mU .U.. proude,d (~1 iu . the hi-1l,,ry tlf Ell!g~D~ , wheo, ha nag f _ , . ~ ~ giardia.tuibtpp( • J.~>ple o•er 800. m1lUo• in DUJJtbtr, ,~loa,iag le •• a.uu r~ di,-idi,d int.:> ion......W. _ . aad c ~ it bu 1 i "m. .,..rm,d I be 1 ,'7 .· .· . r .> l ··.:· ·. i.•.:·. ;.: ·'·.·...' :. .• :.· ' ' ,~iJ~.1 1_8 gnid their eTolntion and bu succesafully carried out a far-sighted ·community w;ould not have ade ~hat pro . ,. in ed~~tiin ~llij:h we- . policr enabling them to reach a pitch of oon101idation and solidarity, see all around us to-day. I vqbmg the Jdaesalmans oommuiity fo maki g them perfectly · qualified to gonrn themsebq_. 1'he debt. of politicaDtrif.e at tbat: . s~g~-.·~. ou•.·ld not h.ay•e :· be.en. tp th~,ir in.·. r. es. t. gratit de lndia owes to the. Crown of England . for the , :~ce and .They had lagged far behmd m ,the race of ~acation. C()ncent. · tion order prevailing throughout 01e length and breadth ot tlus Ya~t on "education.,_was·ei,;se11ti~lJ 11eeessary. . If the Moslen:a · miqd had : been iliverted into ~itleren . channels, it. ~01.ud have pr:oved pighly Continentt the safety ~of life and property, the earnest and linmanitarla~ policy for our wdfare and. adtancement, the ~fodi~us eff~rts detrimental t.o our (\ause . ...' he. commnnity as a whole, followi~g the hdrajin and ,nceive that the poitcy of enlled mvl't'lf n -drt'11n:er aud y(lu arc 'l'leln,me lo reg1trd me ns suchabstaining From 1)(\litieal· 1fas nie11nt t(l be pem111n1mt . . ~t wai,! if yprese~ta.tive that tnlr rnnT h>, 1111d tl1 <.•1:gh llnt ~h 111le lR undr,nlitfdly h11~rd c1 n gatli~ring t•S I ~ncl HSH'llrU1ed l1ere t<: tw,, br1 ,tl1~ t:~ ::,z.~\-''t :Mother Hind _ _and ic n 11·l1ell1er thu, t•xrc11cr,ce d ivr tlii" ~unrtlit1hi-l.i\1 1111d it_ WM, grnlftrd to Eng_lftnd . How to umte yotnHe!Hs ma Cl*m,pn bo,,nl pt't•t•lt' b!ls<'d as it is in Jndi11 on a firm conridion c,f self-interest, you to all the people oI ln~ia to work for your Mothr.r-lnnd ion the. is bJ11 11d to he det>\HCIUt<,d 11ud gC'nniue. .l\ ny 1rns1 1icion of the deeplines indicated, 11nd thus contribute to the ultimate fnlfilrne1~t of the l'(,ot~d loyalty of l ndia is nnju~t and groundlrss. Constitutional agiproud destiny which ine\·iti~bly awaits you. t&tio ? again;;t Governmrnt mt>asnrrs there 11·ill ho nod there n:ust be. ! 1 We qaniH) t eon\·inee nnr g-mmlinus without constitutional agitotion and , PKAI,S. . ' commnn foilin_g nf n11 gnar d'uths a 11 t h e wor ld . over, tn11t t Having explained at co,; nsiderahle lrng-1.h mvJ political faith. for tb.e it is pie t lrny are d'lffitt1lt to bt' enr1nnced of 1hr 1Jte11dy growth o~ thfm wards. SlYi::h future of India you will e~11ily undf.'fstn1Hl:th11t I c1111not objedt to the gro,v/th i;, l11rg.'ly inip,•n eJ •t ilile ,' 0 them, _taking plar_c 88 it ~oes nndor ideals "hich ha\·e been ad qpted by tho two leading p11litical <1tganizatht>ir iHiJ e~·es. .:\~ 1 lia1·e t-a1d, the mrnors are Ill rC'ality steadly tious of tbi11 country. The Congress. ideal of self-governu1ent on grcw~r-~ up 11 nd tll(•ir ueed~ nllll riq uirt' llH'lll!i are multiplying. The wards Colonial lines has the advantage of being clear and definite. The wonlo t,i fal,e to tfie training: "Aliid1 the gnardiru1 in the noble discharge League ideal of self-gMe~nmt'nt suital11H to lnclitt appear~ to me of his duties hai; h:m,elf gi, 1 u ii tltt>y did not rei;PfClfully ask, nay vague and indefinite. Yon must ha,·e ha.d good reasons fc,r adopting it but I c.noot help rerua~king that I wo11ld ha1•e penwrmlly preferred clam l, nr, fnr l11rgrr 1ill,,w ,.1Jl'H ~11it11,l,1,· to the re!tfl<'Cth·e ages to wliich thrJ jma)· lune n·~dwd ,u,d t I.., h~t rolicy to be adoplcd towards th!'!m something which wa,; mor~ definite 1111d distinct. ,vhatevn the ideal is to !rrc-1,gnii-e th e fad lr1>111 time to time aud malrn furtber grantR in a 'I should like to appeal to you to ~ar con ~tantl~ in rni11d tl_11,t nothing l't'nernm, spirit. . . . !hould 00 allowed to create I\ feeling_or 1mp11l1encc-, II dc~1re ,to reach i BHnti;u CoN,;i,:c·rto~ IsmsPE~SADLK• _ . it by _shor~ cuts, or a t~ndency to excite the }lRl'>'ions vf tlie people. . h , d d . I • -j I Nothmg 1s more detrimental to advance the cause cf India than lt w,1 1 h-' ~• 1· 1t us. to Y<•tt 1 ~t it ep~n 8 en~ire "! upon yoarse v~s ~ impatience and disaffection. Far from/'ac el fn .. ti it d b(IW ~adv\( ti 1'ill 1ullze yr,ur prond destrny. lt will c1dl for the best m th It' t tt . t r h' I . IJ O b Jedrc1: OWI\Tl I 1 yomlnat~1r"e, y(•U ~ ill }1a1·f• t{) I e: 111l it:~t and presen_ing, you have to efJ::~ ~fs:t~ina :~~n~fc~ck\ ~ : gao' it .W . Im ou te Y_ ;ave tie tl(' p~t>Fl~Hl for_ all calls (,f sd_r::.~ arntice a nd deT~trnn:o your Mot berWe have grecent\. lieard a ' reat d 0al \ 01it d' ·'d f r · a landl \ ( 1t1 w1lf line Hi me ahne fl<'lty ie-alomn,s· and personal , h g . !\ m e • ee ing st <.•tu:;\lm1Li cn,-, H•ll ?.ill l'!!HC Iii unite in 8 bvnd of Indian btotherl1ood llffiO~g t , e memberll '.)f pl'lr. c'.,mnH\lllty, I~ 8 PP 1'fl~S to llltl :wholly 1 to n\h \' Alikati on 11f ,, ,ur 1i!1{n ,11lt• lmJ•H, and l\q.,ir•ti()IIB, dcpeuds wliolly ll!IQII till after ~e\'t'~al dt·en?t'S t-rf !!lrenll?n& . an(l \~Utl~Ll dlurrs. ?lhether ., . . i l d l I t' . t l f th . Crow l r E l d the final consummatiou ,){ our l11ghcst nsp1rnt1onil t•~sm·eral der~'\111,u,u~ lll i lt' .tn,· t Jl'_ •l ' II<" 1('\\'D ru tj O e ' .. L O. !l!il ~u.. cades or several ~COT!' ,;f . t . ,. 1. ' . ' b I>11rlng 1l1t· Hllll~llH' ll J t'lll'd tlH• pn'$0Jee of the Bnt1sh Ill India 18 f .. J j ,· .s ', JCars or sorue. cen tlrit.S _s Ill , . .'WOQI al ,:,.;, llt(>h' iu,li•!'dlsitle. }' ( u IITC O(•lllld to grow to adult manlio-:>lntcd _qut, ~poo iu ti~1a~ i.·u~I l'('ll'L' intn \'1 ,ur inl1eri1atH'~, but you runst iu nu way oo onn-t- ,_t.s. . 1Y thrn 'ft"lll:ile onr rn~r!{trs lll fr111tl ~ss d1~11ssion11 iu,1,11ti.-nt of yuur ~mudi .. n. ln tr)illg to acceleral!J tlil.l p&l'.tl do uot atll'l, di;isentio~s upun n,e form of 0 1irern1_n~nt wl,1 '.:h ' we should ~trile to .attam at the • cud of tlrat_ i_ndcfw1te pern,dl ~":ben _a rt'la :d \ (1 1:r i:n,~n•~s. We l,R1e ti, remembe r alfo tbat we shall not T\'ll.t 1!,r K<'lll bv lht• l!~C (\ [ I h)'sical forct'. ~\nard1i8n1 and l,;nubs stur~y . ' ~nt i• ngst ~l~ the eontl,chtrg elements pre1•a1ling Ill 01.'\'(ir ]qn~ iu th~• hi~l l• ry l'i llll)" n•ti on ('1)$rtrt'd progres.s or helped in India ltHlay ,_s I\ . eond1110_n preceden_t tu an,;· l!O llUd _irnd steady attaining tl,t•ir eud. Ih1lin-e me, gentlemen, that wbi'n the time progNilll , 1' Duld it DLi t 00,. w111e_ _to d~n ~e ~Mans by 1tl11ch!we may . arri1·eM thu force t,f uwr11! pn•:;;urn will b-e irre~istable and it will tl1! able to conL~ntr~te out t~ndmded at~JJlJOD on 1Jn~blems of th ab «"lutdr t•u,ur;;• 1l1e rt'ali1.1ti r> n d l'\1t prnud deslinr. e iby and bJ 1m1ted 1~:urilom, eo1rnre stt>ady and solid J•rqgre887 -1 • GRAClOt:S MEsHtH~ M' TUB Knw.· . ~Te~Jone ~inst recogn ise tlia~ n_o form of Re~i-goverome_m . is : .. . . . .· . J)('Sstble 1n Ind '. a unlessJhc lwt) pnnc1pal: comm1m1t1e:,, the : Hmdoo iThis 1~ fully b<1tlll' 1-J _1 lir u'.,bl1: mr~:i;,~~ 111 h1 rb ~is Imperial and the Moslem, a.re <:Iosely and conscieifffon;,ly 1w1ted; What, M a;j(';:ty ■ l·hmg_ s,~nthcance .' is no force in the wurld which can k1wp us fn,rn onr beritage; Cab l>{'C!n 'llrPrds t't' h uno 111 th t' Eng h.-.h l•riguige l o iodieatc to you without saeh nnion the fot.lians Ifill hawo to wa it ir~ddiriitely for in ~hat din'~liPn ) t lll !ulnrt· l it' ~ '. th_c1 'lfnrc ".Edlll'(lfl :· i!i ,tbe Tf'llization of their fondest hopes. l~i,tead of !JniUI{ d1ffereoce. mc~ut not uwr 1•,l ~: tht' I 111 ~~ ,1, !< '' 1· : ·x•~~inat n~ns. It I!! u st:•li m • anil dL....:•n,ion,i am ong .. t • our.reh·eg at the present time matter1 1 11 11 hr~~--r Hll..., anc1 _t· !1s tt J•Ml )_ " ''' tJlHihty .! ~nr~d,ej fo r 1h1! . Dl'hle of reroute realiuti,rn, I "loulcl urne11llJ :app<>•l to all true: son• of d~hny 1ht na1t~ J' _u. \ Put lt·~tl,·r• dumig tbe p•s! gt'ni,;rnioo lridi1 to conl·eotrate all their eoergiN,1, all the ir ti.Jen~ cl tbt ful jy r.. th• i-tt,:i.i_tit-aii .:-i> i-( !hi ~ ~,, r(', h ut t .. r tbat t'nr~utrau ,,n th~ Mu,llai<111ri and t.'1:lncentrata their eff()rtil on tbe rtjl,liutfon c,f such .., ideal. 1 wJy. : life ls ,"m· , 1 \trn wiU d J •· cw9 the union 'of t'': M\l c'4 , i ' -· .·..1:,..·.·•1.·.·•.. ' ! , n,. •hi,,J ,·,,m tdrri\twg on aD4 U ~ , I I I The Comrade~ 10th January. in :\ ,-pint ,,f rc:.,n ed e?mpromist~. ~11 our ditncalties will or~m1ble sl"l"ny an,! I ndi:i l"I" 11 rise phoenix-like ..fro~l1 the ashes_ of d1_se?rd :rnd ,-trnc::~k t•' a frt>:;;h_ and wbn,;t lite t,,ll of promise and ,-!ull of hope. Tlw 0 ,, :,..t , nt'Stit,;l',wliid1 I mu,t J,,al with nnw is what shonhl 1 ,,, the ,,.\it'Y ,,f the-'_Lt•i1g1w a, rt:pre~,•nling tlH' ~luc,;si~!m:rn_s nf 1 1 lu,E:l. Tli<' an,,n',r wh1,·h l w,,ultl _gin• t,, tht> qncstwn 1., hrn•tly thi,. t lnr p,i]i,·y !tow:mh th,, Briti:'h Goy_ernmt•nt slw 1~ld hf' <1llL' uf un:-iwninc:: !uya~ty :rnd t,,wnnb the H111dn,1~ one ot brotherly l""" :w,I rc!!ard. l h"ld that tlll~~l'Y whieh ~hould guid,, us slwuhl 1.,. tli:H ,,i tjw y,mng'-'r l,r,,th,·r iu iarnilr toward" his gnardian and ., 1,,mi- hi, eh!t:r brnther .. \\'hilP fully_ rnaintniuing _' his 1 imli,i,ln, ;lit::, an,l I re111ai11i11!:.!" kePnly alirn ! 11 h1,- ,,wn ncNI,; and n'quirem,·nb. he should extend to hi,- guardian hi>< re;;ped.ful ho;n,,c:e :rn,I t11 hi~ elde r lm 1 ther hi;; brntherly affediun am! sincert> re!!arcl ~h mhil', hl y,,n ki ofkr unswNring lrPliy make your full conuibuti,,n t,,wiu~:, the better administration uf this country. When I i,1n acli· ising ym to extend brotherly affection and ~nct•re rd.uml t11w~rds the Plder brother, I am not fon,etting- that yon are eutitl,·d ti, :ret·ipr,,city at hi,, hand~. The union of the two brntha~ canw•t l.;tanntatirc dqHtt~tion lnili11, !i(•thle.l li~• our ackno11·k•1laed !t•nder 1-;:1 ..rn. ll!Lltl'.l • np,,n 11. E. L~rcr Minto: ,,f wh,Lt I will ennlinup to ,·,Lil tlw i.-11:Lnlian, _ _ br"t1 ,,•r t,l ,-,hare din•ctly by .,\p,~ti"n _ iri rn,t :tnti"n" in the c,, trntrv. Thi,; was the c:r,,wd1 ,,f th,• yonnger bn,tl ;cr had n•,1d1ed a ,1n ,i requin·ment,; \'l'ere keenlv fc•lt that the l!llllrdian had prol"id,1d 1, ,r the chil~h(•n \;a;; ba;:+t1g th,, y,,nnger di_ild ·as 1t had had ni»,n thetl,,• tlt1n1t' , ,,f pMrioti~m hrhl \,,,,,u \;indl°ed t,, lni .,,..,,,,,,., ,, _,._.,, th,•n•ait e r), i, ,r the ~ervil't! ! i to ! 1 l,;srielit inq ,t>r Bnt takiug and tbe f,,r a J'!lrl nf t" tht.' hr, •tli"r.r 1 wil ::n~•1:·;::i,i;::' -l~:_1\ }t\;1·,,,, h,;!:m,1te I . t l! · I 11,,w stu ' ,\, rn:v th e .,f uur j n,t ri;;lit .-, i:; ~ow l\ 1kt', for forward. the largeriasi-ociation of the people of India with the 1 admioistratio~ of the country, the inter 1 st of minoritie"li shall' '.be d~l7 i • i-af,,gnarded.' - May I ~nq-nire. ~hat idifterence tbereiis' in ,principle ;, l)Btwren dnlz safeguard,mg t!1e mtenj;it of the min:orities (and the ?t·l• n""_ 1iln.mn.,; fo_. n.11 · ri.• H>st_. nnpo.rh_ of.. s.:1·1-ch_he m··.in··•.pr.ities )•·._· in.·. _ ~--' politienl rights .irndt..he privih•ges wliirhnJ't should demanded in th···· the £ut11n, and thPH' which hnYP 11.lrend · bet'n obtained 7 I cannot: ·, cun'.·•:in• _that tho derna~1d ot the 1\111. snlmiu1s for adequate oppdr~nn1t1es tor rPprpsentat10n on the pnblit\ lrndies in the country was Ill any 1rny nnreasnnablP or 1111just or ir any way militated agai~st tht> nltini.att· n·aliz.a tion ,>I' the brilliant destiny which awaits tho peopl_r ,)i 'this land.. Wise statesm~hship and sympathetic con1,1ider~t10n "t ,,ac_h nther s nPP?~ and n'qm~,~ments are essentially necessary dnrrng- ~he penn~ of ~rans1_t10u throu~h which every country must pass bt>lore reM:hmg it~ lnghest desti)1y. ~lay I et1q11ire whether tht• Moslem rPpresentattYe nu the Legi~latirn (fonncil have bt1en in any way w.anting in pnhlic spirit. nr indppral r olitical questions :affecting the whole of India are concerned. I for one am ntt:erly at a loss to underst11,nd why M nssalmans i,hould n<)t work shoulder tn i:!ho uldcr wi~h thi:ir fellow-countrymen of ,,ther races ,rnd crc,ids •(l)r the com1non- bencfit of all." ; in ~lay I _inquire ~hethcr we ha~e. not. worked tho League on the broad pr1nuples laid down by a d1t1 b ngmshed co-religionist of onr:e from the PresidPnli11\ chair o: the :National. CungrCijS 7 Examine tho resolutions wliieh the LPagun lws pas~ed from year to. year and cnmp1m1 them with those pa:-1sed by t:ie Congress , and yon will clearly observe thut nn ill! qne,-;tions u:ffectiug the common inter1i11ts of t l'.e _1w_,,ple of _India we liarn rt'OLlily and i;ince1't•ly co-operated. lth-l1h:-lt8 liLLl'\l l,11.11·e1·er to n!mcrnb..r ,tlnLt the M11s:, 11Jmnns of India h'.w.', tl'.(•ir 01nt ''1 1'Clt~'.ar, SO('!Ul, ntornl, Ct!ucat ion:111 and political d1!11cnlt1cs to <'lll'lllunnt, aud that th ey have tli(•reforn t.o 11miull~in tht·ir orgnni,.1'd a~:--ociatir,n~ nnd in:;ti l utiuns. R,•111ai11ing k<>enly 1dive t,, ,,ur oinl\.needs and r, quin•mPnts w~ luH,.' thr11nglio ut the existence oi the ~,,·ag111' t•xt en'.!1'.d a l',,rdial hand of fol!11w,;hip trnd co-operntion to t ht- s1,tt·r 1·omm11111t11 s, n!l,l f eunn, ,t ~i1•e better advice tlia11 to a.sk. you t•> c:ontitnie thi~ lim1 ,,f P"l_icy ns t\1!: Ill llHt foresighted 1uid wise. 1 Mosl,EM AT1·1Tu1ni:. Twn yrnrs ngu, finding that. lli1)doo irnd Moslem senliment waa bt:•c/,rni 11g 1•st, an~e11' And redi.ng tit at i, uch !\ cnIHlition wu1 detrimental to the 'l'lt·~l-_l,'.•i1~g ,,f th .. ct,untry, it Wll!H the Mo1ilm11 oomm11uity which tn uk th,• __i_n1t 1att\'~• •• and under _tlie gui1!1111ce uf tht•ir 11ecngniscd le11der, II. II. b11; ,\ga h.han, wi:nt rn tin· fo rm of a 1-pecial d1'pntati on from Na.:'pnn>, the ;;Pat of tltc A nnul\l S1'Hl' i1111 of tlrn Miislcru LrA1.p1e, to i~ llal1al,11d, the ,,.,at of 11:rrnnl rn,•Ni11g ,,i d1,.1 l r,diao Nu!'i nual C 11~11.: t t•,~, t,, 11wi:1 Tt']'T'•'.nt,1t 1" : nn,! tW k,•t'll run.I: IJn~ 11nxiouH ho waa 11ri ,1t•,·~tH,nd,,,,,, Ld1f,..ie,11 the two. Y1ou are all aware 11 n~presenta~e Committee . of butl~ the Cl,HJ!munit i e,➔ was app·Jinhid for thP pnrp-,~P of d,,rn,Slflg' the pomtg or. disa~reerneut and 1mggestinJ mean,_ llll\~ . W:hieh. in a 8pirit of rUSOll·f'd compromise, nwrt' t'. Pnl1111,I rd&t1t1nil 1111ght h..1 ht,)u~ht about. T•o vearll hare P"_,.~,·,l ,i.11H:e th., datu thi~ C,nnmilil'•! !'ii~ 11,ppoint<1d, an1.i i.t is t,> oo r,•K r1,tte..! that 11<,t a. ,i.ngli:! uu•.itiui.r I.as yet lH'Pll l1elc~ \\"1,&tenir may l,.1 th,i ,:uH.e for t!11.i Inn~ ,tlt,J.lV in mei;lin~ for:~ndt a laud.able ,>l,~,,d , it <•e.n not (..,. Hai n~aid that ..;,o }111n1 J,.•e n 1Lh~·1yil 1rnxinui1 to o:h~,-hi.1r ,:: ,i •>H r .,1:11~,._1 ,,qis l•••nrds tlw ti! ,h•r brod1 cr in !hi:! ri ~ht iipirit. 111 t~••.r n! r,•~n•t that 'e\ IHH::h II,. 11ple11did c1ppo'rlunil1 l1u not Jf)t t, 1-•UfJ:H '•~e. I w.i.ko., ddi1 rngg.6'tioh beeau;;:e 1 :;tr,,nd 1 lhi.t in t he .i·nlerei!tH of ,ludia u .11 ·wljw le and tlu,e.e o( ea-ch of tfa, 1ll., to appornt a representative Committee, s~ould bo a.:leJ uprn, amt tlrnt it should meet periodically and Ji:1c~!i all the points alTccting the inten·st a9,I rt' latinu,i of each with ttie·!other. It is becau,e I feel thl\t for-reaohia; r,·s:ilt i, >r good will accnltl from irnch a Nurse that I - Tu:i~";-referred. to th<) matter ! I ! I QIJCi The All-lndi Mosle~ League. -----,, ;·· ·,. PRoPouofN.nro.KAL Fo~o;: . . · The first resolution "~ the moved hJ. His Highness the ~ge. Khan to the effect that in ,iew of the growing politic&l ueedii ot ;he Mohaml'd1m community, it " s neces~1uy to: take step, tci esta~lish a permanent u11oti.onal fnnd. ~is Highness in a. 11hort speech stroQgly appealed for funds, the wan~ of which ronsiderably hampered! the work of the League. Everyl politic11.l organisation &nd part/ i11 --Europe and America ha.d i~mense funds at its b.aek and the absence of funds iu the League_lwu a t;iationaI disgrace .. If the L~guc was to do any good work, . ljt must be selfc-supportlOg; otb.jr'w•iile it could not command self-re/Sp!!ct. The fund urnst come from the called ~ natio[·l·al fund.. His. Hig.·l ne11i n~tion .• o~herwi!se it _could DL~t u1d that the c0mm1ttee whrnh was to be forml'd to collect the 'und would be announced later. The resolution ffas daly ,;e~onded by the Raja of Mahmudab . and passed. SobTH ArnlcA. ag~iD. THU: LKAOO& A.NO LONDO~. I I a.m!irnre you "ill all apprndate the r,?i~so!H! whi ch hare inclnced me tu kdep to the c'"uclu,lin~ part nf my adJre:is, any refc•rL'!l~,i t,, the recent l~app,mings in L"nd11n. You r0~,J.c;11i,m lww cl,di,:,1t.i uiattcr ~-a..➔ • Thu M11,snl11mus of India lrnYc n high rt'garll for S,eli Ai~llll'T Ali wh ,1 h:1.,➔ Llitring th(' period uf rwarly h:ilf a century r~ndcrcdi ,evmcu· ii<'nic.:: t,., t!Hi cau,;,i ,)f blam. Ili,; ,i.;r,•at. aciiit•remeut.:; ii~ ttl\3 J'idd uf litc-ra t nr-.-, his masterly expusitiun of the lnith of Isl ,rn, b(,; active cu-ll; ,crntiou with our disting-uished leader II. U. Sir .'u,s 'r~lrnn .ill pr,i111 0tiug Llllr. political adnincro meut are iew of the di~t'cti,,1l" m whid1 he ha.~ e,111ierr,!d lastiug ouliL('11ti,1u,1 u11uu the l:1t1:i::i-!\laia11s. 011 the uth,' r lrnnd wo h:,\·e Sy,·d \Vazir Ha~an aud ~ir. '.l, ih:rn1t~d Ali, t\\'u uf t)llr i,Jrem,>.,t workers in the ittl L' l't',l,; 0 [ ls\iml. Pl1rlllf, tht11\•:lfc1ti,ely 8hur~ ptri t,,1 "f th,,ir career, tlt,·y lrnru pr,i,·,:,1 b, ,.,u,I the\ ~h:,cl ,1, ,;f ~ c i r . - Sterlin~ ll!lcl t-lw:r •,, \1,,l,,-h,.!i\rk.l ,l, 1',, ti,n :efthe ~l.,ihlem ea11~c. Ti:~ ,.,ill 1 ~; t::~,i:J::r ,~:~·:1,:l;~t;i:::l ~\\\'.'u,/lt.'/i !~~;'.,1'.ilt/t~;:·I l'CS W(l l: w,,,1:.I li,1r.: l,,•,·11 1111 ,C:rcr!l1htan ,•,.>~ tusi~t Ji :T,: r, 11 ,-;,,, ,,f ,,piHi,, 11 ·,,l,i·l: 11,,1t.:f, ., t,,,J th!'!n.,uh·,·~ i11 L,n,!1111 ,,liuuld h:H,1 lia.l :1nJ l "·:nn .111,·:11. cff,,,·t. .\!. .1 t:i11,• liL• tl1 1• w,, ,·,,ulll ill .d. ,rci t l,h,' 1Ih ,_;; i'r ,·,,: 11 .' •1 of th ,· t ;:,i:. 1:r 1,:1\ k11·,, . :..;h' !J,,, k:1 ,-;::,: ii I ,\111\'L'r Ali, i11 1\i,• Ct'lllre !i,• 11tl1·m,·u, th:n ~ir ,\,;a Kl1au, 1 ,•,;_••.::11,·.l l ';d ,·r, !L ::::/:::J/r .,. ,. . . ::'i;;·::is, :~.::;:::r:,, ·:::,k,i. .. Tii,.-:r,· di,·11~-i In th e ''"l'T n,i•n~ ,n ·11d ;;·; 1:~t w.irli 01l di.1 line uf p ,11 ,·y in i II Ii~. lli :'i,·r,·1, ,·., :,r , 1•i1i;1rn llill.,t bi~ wd1.·,nn,·d, hnt of 1.1rl11 ) pl1 ( '.~ H:1 ·ii ~i;~,,~, 1. ' \ (~ .. n~tiu1ti1.\rud e!\:i1 l\r;.,u ,:'1 • L, :1.~u -• t , mi~,, u.,;-• dio>: r,•,rti r~ l ]•fdc·,·.l nr,· ma, t l.>,) 1; 0 :1ti,•:1t· 'I\· ! l\l rn'lst luH' b·! t'l\ am,1wJ at th,· critici,rn wit;_.11 h.:1, t,,•, 11 r.j.:,•u:l, t,,,,,il,,._i ,1.c;ain,t wli:ll t,n' INlll t' l th,· }l11,,c.:::1un:1 ·,,f lu,L11. ::-i11 Jit 1,,n 111d Lh,·,;: ,·:";;. io tr& le ,,i ,;.,me ,:riLi,·~. x,, ,.,\ I trll 1 1 I br i I . , · I Tho second resolution wj1ich was moved by Nawnb Znllik~r Ali Khan express8d the indi!.;natioin of Indians l\t the ill-treatment of !their countrymen in. South Africa!1u.. tendered respectfnl l.h.ankl! to , ... ord Hardinge for hi:; pr,>nounceiheDt in M,1drns. The i,,peaker iq the conrse of hi:; sptlech n>iternted lthe demaml for the repeal of the t)lreepc,unds-lt-.x and the rcmo1·al :of other disabilitie:1 under which lu~ians arc suffering, He &aid the ptr$onnel of the Commission appo:inted by the S,rnth A rrican G,,,·nhrnent had gi1·cn satisfaction to nolne in India as it lrnLnial gt>\'t\rlllll'illt,, \fml evil.lent. frvm th,: fo,:t th tlt afl.,,r the ,,t,,rm nr iudignaLi,,n r:1i~,,._1 in lt:,lii1 and th,· Uni,,11 U ,"·l, n 1m·•11t [,,,t 11u ti111-' in app,i11ti1q:; the II,· !(• all sedi1)n, ,l,·m:11!,l jL1:; tic\l; until jm,iiee w,1,; 1lDn ,·. in ,, ,!1 ,.:lt1 ~i11n i>1q,r1,,_; (,d th,: ,il.,!igiition ,,fall ln -li:1 t, L ,,,l f,,r hi~ 1,1 ,.,t 1,r .. 11 ,,n11c~\111cnt iu ~b lr,1~ :rn,l tlmnk,,,t him Sir · !{,,bert,mn to lay tli,· l 11lr. :\l.,iui,111,J .\Ii t1utl tur :\lr. Zafar ,\Ii Kli:i.n who b1,l, huw..,1,~r. t1c,t y,·t r<:t,,n1t:d•: The l'n:,i,kn,. "n ,,r th 1• Nawab thnn ~arhnd,·d tilr. Ylazir lb.,,rn an 1·:'llr. \\.,h:1'H>' l ami.J ,d1,•,·r,, fr.,m the au,litorium. Th~, r,•c.,luti •, :: rc,;M,lin~: :-;,, 11 t!1 wa, lh"n d1ily p,1ijrillU, 'J'11r: Fx1.: .;·1;r1vg ASP ,J1.,u1c 1 \Hr. Th (' s :o:t'l lU ,1· ,,J ti 11: tl,i nl n•·• ,rilutioD [ !,.ri. ~li l!l 1 \l ,,l,·in Le:1;,ue! urge• t li -i ard u:: pbciul{ C ,ar~ iLI 1HMY '» ,,,l)' 11111oii or to , ,)i ~~pe,ra~iuu t!t ,· ur.;-e11c1 M that t,, fulfil the •pledge1,Li,:e iu !lie Iinperial tlmt a :eolem• eo11ld ~nhan~ i n t,, th c'i r cunfiJ,rnee. had p11.l-l,ed thia r,,iii1irn a.111 forUu!r h,ue bc,:, ,m,, p,,\ i1.i,·al!y tht•m~,·11·,,~ f, )r the purp,J,;<' ,,f their t: l) lll!ll\tll1IJ'. Th,'! ar,• a>0 a:[ i 1;;;: ,,i the ,, u,tirnt: ,,,a .. l m~irn'i. ,,111:u t.,, ,•1·ery Sl'l'ti o a t>f t l1t• Irlf c 11-rituti,i nal : S,,, l1u~ ,re O•J~ ,,,·er-st,•p p<:'d it,; ln .:1,.;r1at,1 . . but I l'lill , 111 ;,,,ltllt in~ly ,h•,du,• ,,n y,, ur bdrnlf t ll !\t nn, h 1n.; i:. iunli,•r rt''i!l'l"1.•._l rr. 1111 ,iur m 11lil~ thzrn t o ,·n:.:" w1 11.1 111ny llHt,•m,·nt 1, t a,~ti ,,n 1'flti,:h li11,s in ,\ th" h 1a~~ tin~c• ,,f di, k1y~'ty ,.- :L ti ,:1. It l'f1Y1lJ b,., tbl" .J,·.n i .,.~.~ ,,I ;,r,•ry ,.Ille• 1[ pt•,•pl,• "''llU tall.. II litt l,· )~"!-~ or hnli .. 11 ,\i ~l <> ralt, an ,I ~,,,]iti ,JU, l, j ,• , ,11d;1,1, ,n, l t,.•;: l.i h•n,lu t41 ]'Ill my , :\:: n 1•ltdg11:1~u,~ f.,r Y'"tr in,i11lh,, nce. iri h,•&n ,1g • 1th m,• rn·td 1 tim,. I •rn ,lt•<"pl1 t,1 ud1<"d b.' J <> t!r k ,u !n,:1,.➔ arl'i G ,1H dNa' i., a u1,l !•:-$. He , ai,1 h-, d:1 !l;: I }!emb~r. The u,,)ln:i,)n w~,; put t,1 the meeting ~ad c_arr1ed. i . . , <)n :llst l) .. ,,,, 111 11,'r the usual re_51?lutwn rn farnur c)f commn~al rer,r,,,,•n\iiti,,n m;>t _rith SOl~C op_prig1t1on. ?Y ~foslems . W~I• desire au nr:d,•r"t:.n.:ling ,rnithc snb3ect with the Hindu ~ommu~1ty . .>-,__ r~:wlini«n wttSim<1H'd oy Hou. 111_·. Hati~u (Bombay), 'llhic!i ran 3,, f,,Jl,iw"l-" That t'.1e_ All-Ind1~ 1fosle:n League once ,.. ;,1 r,,,:s,r,l~ iB ddibcr:1te op1111uu that 111 the rnten•sts of the 1 1 1Li~,"1\:i:an ,•Jl!llllll!ljity it is absol11tely neces,;ary that the principle of ,,.,m:iii:n:ll r,•pr<',1 ndt.•d by :'11r. Zahoor Ahmad (Allahabnd), :"ilr. :'>l 1·': •:r lhlnran tlwn rn°Yc, t" b.,, tri,,,l, why nnt t:'y the lllt'llioJ,; ,,i h· t•) th,· ultimate intL,rci.-;t t,_, w,,rk t,,,:, ther_ Hr ,aid the Hindus in the Cnngresi!, bnt thi1' th,•y ha,l nut pa,sod the n•s,Jluwere c,Hi1ir1eed of the nt>t:esL',,:1~,.. 11t. H" w,,nt~,J thl)",t\Vo c,,m1m!l1fties to f,11· ~!u,,alnrnos tu 11h.\rn fvtW.\rd i11 the '" th«'. rh,,_1' Wicr,,. t<:, tneet the· Hindns Ht' uri;P,l l>€c.~u,;e the Bindns l,1r that his. views on tlitYSubjcct of c~immunal •r 1 1:11s.!'"r"',,ne n,, ,·htlng-e 1;1xc-ept th11t t.he operation , , l!l !~:•tlilpr.\cticr 1:<>ntir111t'd huu in the belief that the 11 n·-,. I]''' '. '' ,l:'.rt,~tilti~s ,.( :1t,tion-bnildiug- iu India ffunld be lbl!I ,,, :, ,,: '.I:~ ,,r _c-,,mmnn~l r~•pr-~s.:'nt.at.ion. Vnit;, would th1; llJ•par,n1t i;epuat.ic>U. India would be ,,{ F.iths. Hut that W"&.1 n..:,t the 1]U81(t1,,o ,\ ti th~\ ht: a;ke:d fot IUc◄ · d1e {JQ!ltf"l)lll'J· on lHi- ~IWJ,'t't u1 ,irder t.o ewpb.a.iite, the wa,; _c-.impldt1 •~rl!,l:•ment boetw""'n tl1, Bnrri.9ter-at-)aw (Bankipnr) said that he was nl"rH' whPll he nrnd11 simihr prllpornl,i at. Lnuknow last year, but. nc•w o:nme Jc,nrlin'.~ ~fohnnwd11n~ lwld ;;imi!ar \'i,.•ws to thm,e he h('ld. Th,•ir antPndm(•nt mig-ht li,• Ins~ hut tl1t> di!l•'.l1Rkton Hhowcid wit .. was t·tc:bt nna whn wu~ wr<•ng. , The <,liject of Mn!lsalm&ns shonl,l be t .. b•('!' pace wtth ,,ther domn.nniti,.•s. Tim yrnlfare of lrnli,, 1[pp,.n.!P({ on tl1e uninn of Hindn,i nnd Mnssalrnam;, Ho all al,lln{ hd.l tlrnt \ntreaied hi,; co-rdigiooiRt,s not to pre,:,;, ti,,, r,.s,,lntion tlii,; year-s. Nawah Z11lfikar Ali an.\ ~('.Vt>ral other s1wakH;; fol19wed, They unanimously c·,,nt,•n,fr,l t!iat n,,thing Vft~11ld b,: 1.,.,t by 11otttpooing ihe rp;.olntiun (pr a Yrar. The H,,n. \lr. ,\l"111r Hani i Allalrnhat!) ,mid the original resolution ' mnst 'l,p 1,res,t'd nnd h·e 'W!lil s11 1,portt•ll by the Hun. Mir A1mrie ah,•rna•ir,~ h·ft irn,l t!rnt w11i to decide the adoption of tlw i,riginal n•s,i\iiti ,11 or th0 t11w•mli1H·llt bv vot.is. Aitt'r a pr,,lnngetl tli.~c111;si11n it wa!l :decide\ l,y a foling from the chair it1 fo111ur of Mr. !iluh11rncd Ali'~ c,:,ntentinn, that the YOtiog wonLl be in aet·,mlR:1ce i,·ith rnl,~ :l:! which laid down th'at. voteil 11bould be rec•lrdt!d accimli ng to tbe 1\lli)tment t>f tlrn numlwir; of members &o the ('.rnncil ,.1f the Leag1w by prnvinas, A iter t h,1 Yotes had been recorded the result declared u folluws:-Por the amendment for rmstponement llllOVed b1 Mr. Mohamed Ali, 40 votes. Ag11io,~t. 8H ,otes. Mr. )injibnr H11hmin',; amendment was witbcfirawn and U.. original resolution wa_., declared pa,SM!d. "'-s ~Pli!AL or TUR P1uu111 .AcT. Ou the motion of Mr. Abnl Kuim, Si! TtO: Aun. Mr. Abdul Walt Khan (Pt1:1Jbnar) lll<>Yed tbal. &be lime W an1,e,d "ben tbe Go,ernmeot ,hould ~in, lndi1ur1. • sluu-e. ia t.be deJenc,; of \beir eoanlrJ by appoint.iag qoaUfied fo~ao• _lo higuc po,1t" and couuniuiont in the Ann,1 for whi.cb E11r1)P:t'&na alone ar. now eligible. He s.aid il ..., uou~,.,, to TIC<)UD~ the_ feat& or nlourperformtd by natin. troov- in r11rklU. eam.p.aiffM, Oa lliUaJ a batlltfitld it h&d been ,IND how mu.ct.I the Iadiu1 ~Dld b e ~ ill rnilitar, aft.int. The r-.olulion• being duly 1up~~ WM eanW. ~:~:~:!':.' The ?t- Posm C•••• Coo or, ~ < o g i v e eff,cl '"th '"'OloUon Ibo Land The ext resolution was moved by Mr. Gul Mohamed (Ferozepur) should b&-.amended. ' :• and was 'i t.) the· etTect that the All-India Moslem League-is of opinion ExTE.NSION OF TH PER:nA.NBNT SETTLEMENT . that t~ sta tus of tho Punjnb Chief Cour t should be raised . to that The next resolution urge~ h e extension of the permanent settle eut of a chartered High Court. 'l'he n1 over 1:1 ai Dded . i lxnt.\S8 ASD llRITISII Cor.osn:s. the agrarian trouble of India would he settled once for i all j th~ ~bjor S yed lb.au Bi _ uni. l.M.S . ( ret irt'd). mnvecl th e fc,l! .-, wpermanent settlement were ex ended all over the co untry. ing l"t.'s11j ntit1n;; :- •· That the , ndia ~loslem Leagt.1e re-:ords it ;; 'l'here WL•re some di ssent ent rnices against the first. part f,the delibera~e opiui on that the present status oi 1/,anzibar ,; lwuld nof be resolutioJ1 and Mr. Mohamed Ali wa.-, among , the opposers. . · c::hsoged.f and that the pre:-t'nt. rig-ht.s, pri \·ilege:; and stat.us -· ,, i Indians The resolution ·was, howt1 er, carried by a majority. in Briti. h East Africa and Ugunda slionld remain · int.ad. " The TuE sou s CouNc 1L, O)(wer " · id the whole world was watchin g what was happening iu 11,t. ,J~nnah m_or ed a j resolut~on urging the_ reconsti 1tion of the India Council. The re~olution was passed ou the same South Ai frica and he had uo doubt that the people of India were anxious lhat their iellow-c1,untry meu :-:honld n Jt suffer in anyway in any part line s as that adopted by ~1e Congress. :Mr. ,Jinnah ·urged! that of the ~orld . This resolution. as well as the uext. resolution which th~ sn.lary of the :Se<:retary of St-at.e shoul~ be. placed ?n t.he ~ ritish cst1ma~ . . H e. also urged t~at the C" nnc1l should be advisorj and protesteµ against. the l'.(>ntiml(lll S jonrn t.>y dau sr in Pri ,·y Council Order, o. !1 20, whil:)1 had the e~ect pre,·en.t-111g lndi1u1s from going not admm1stratne. rho. s. ecreta. ry of State at prnEent was playing to Can~a. were 1mammously carried:- "'--~";-··' the Great Moghal more than Jany Moghal ruler of India. ~ n .cu T1vi,; Cous c n.s F' OR TEn: l ' . P. A SP TU B P U 'iJAI: . The Hon. Mr. Abdur R9!uf1lid that if the salary of the Secretar.1 Mr.IMolamt.-eked ·or rectifi ed by oth (•rs. tion was carried nnanimouslyl Io India, however, th e una ided judgment of one administrator Tm,: CAW:}(PORK MosQUR: CABE. , •as relled upon for the good go,ernment of · half a hundred millionThe last re.solution of this year's sitting's was moved by H. H. souls. i Wi th the greatest goodwill he co uld not attend to all the work the Aga Khan and ran as fo~lows : -" The All-India Moslem tleague that l'.'a~e t-0 him, And in e ffect ht1 had 1111 Executive Council the begs to place on record its w~rm appreci:!tion of the wise aod couraSocretar ie.s and U udl• r Secre taries on wh om the work actually dcvr,lgeous statesmanship with wljich H is Excellency the Viceroy I deal~ ..ed. ~ u_t _thcy had all a .I.e mber of Co unc il's powers without his with theC.awnpor~ mosque case, and expresses it& deep senst' of lgratirespon~tlnh ty and the re.rnlt of th e di rnrce of responsibili ty from ~ude for his lmn_g ,ng peace t~ Ca"npor~ and the Mm;lem communit1 power as u~nt1l depl or11 ble. Tl1e iweaker referre d to Sir ,J11 hn rn a manner 1'h1ch hn~ 1:nhl\t)ced the faith of the people 0£ I ddia in llewetfs stand iu~ in th e way of thi ~ reform, sud tho, lt o pes enterBritii;h j11stice." : . t&ini'd uf it ,rn Sir ,l11 111 es ~I e.w ,11·!:, appoi1.trucnt. Thu re,rn lt uf 1hc His Highnes8, "ho spo ke in Pon!inn, said th e truth Wail with the deb-ate jill tho t'. . l'. c .. uneil \l'fJS not com:l usire as Si r Jomri! Mcs ton Mussalman CO IDtllllllity nud it \HS uphold Ly H is E xrcllenl:J the Vicchimt.elfi had ;; t'1 tey and he ai-k ed Moli n1~cdan8 to 1\nss the pressio ~ this rt·fon u in th e Punjab slso he n-ns not any rn rm· "dis\,)yit l" r esolution unan1111n11sly. Althuug h o n.st11no ocrnsio118 iodi vidual c,fficers than ~l,o,;,, 1- t3 lw1u t " loya li~ ts" uf the Pu njab wh,1 l\:,Surcd him that they were 11\st a.~ a. 11 x 1u us iis 1,e fu r pli1crn g- th 1;i nece!;S ary ch~c k un the wero too t hroreti cal, jn~t ice ~ould alwaJ s be conn ted upoo in 1}10 end. autotr~.: y (,f L i,•.nt ,•fl l\ llt -\;,,..e m ,,r,;. 8 11 d 1 q1w:;ti ous a,; this irnJ tlui" · The H il jll of ~l t1h mrnl11Gad, ti t1ppnrtiog iu Urdu, rel ut~d the ~p~r.i\~i" 11 nf th,· j l11! i,· i,11y _1\ 111!_ th" ,·xec 11tin', tlw placin.~ 0 [ t he hi story of th o mo ;ri11e nlill ir. He ~aiJ th at th ,i., e en~u~t!d !ill tho jlldl<'laty 1111,l,•r tl w L1.: h,,,- t p:,h:i,11 t ri li illH\l nn ,l not. under t.he exec uCawnpnro affa ir had to be1R g reat sufferin gs. E n •ry kind of ~appeal iiv e, a lll'. tlw rni sillg- ,, i _( 'hi,i;' ( :,. ll r ls of n l,ich th e jud~~s were app11inttha t -w·n.s made ha~ be,• n_ rd 11:;ed. After nil jns ti,.'C had bee n: stio'ns, :;;id releJ.l~l'd !lllll Hi, E xe,•lle11(·r bat! ll••t ,,nl y ft!Stored the na liono1l l1on';;ur the ~P'iak \!r, were ~he tru ,~st tt-:;t.;,r so-ca lle~ _lny~lty a_:!_J l)i~loy,ill!, of M, ,~!cms lmt aif,) tli t' [' ~C; t ige of British ,Justi ce. . i &lld 1t l,~ e111,-d h ) l1IJll thl\t titer,) w..ir1; m,ne d1 :,t1 nc l HJUS titan dilt ,· rt'll t;•:C.'> . Mr. ';\b ul Knlatn ..\ ;,;id ; edi tor .,f ~1l-llila ', said justice was not Th,~ r11$uluti ,,n was ·5_fi}•pi,rted \.,y the H,rn. Mr . F\ 12.l~t,1-lhq · ohtnirie1.I irnm th e L1Jcul G n'111rn me 11t from which tho people expected justice., lrn t frnm t he h ei~ ht s ~f S111! L1 • _ _ Though ho know H1at : ju.-.tice (Bcug~I ) 11.!i,l IY :\ s l~a,ri,•Ll. · I ~l ,>11.Hllc:J> ,\ S Es t>1) W!O:h' T t!. co11ld IH1 t _n lway:s e:tp,•ctet! t r~ m rn11 , wh il'l1 prn~·,·d (;,,\'t•rn 1mn t t .. insist L) II !I ll he kn ew fo r cc rtrtl!l !li,,t J llrl llC C wou ld ulti111"tely CO illll fr om the r enqniri)· i11 \,, tlu, ~,· 11,· 11d jll lrpn,,;~ an d 111 1111 1H• r ,,f 11,lm in istrnti ,,n uf IJr itish C " \¥ tl . · t>: ont~ wns more g rnt~fnl t o ,us m (1 YL'd l,1· .\lr. F,1,. I,· l l u~ni u 11n,I c11 rr i,·d.. t.he Vll'er"y th Lit h 1111 ~eli N, , better !H.it tl emcmt co nld ha w, beon I · Cn w S\ ,,HI H ,: ~:,i . arrin:d 11t and lie L: 111' '.' 11 li rid nc e;J11 11 t of wh iit hllpp .. ,wJ ut C~ wnpnre an d )i ., w 11111 .-li n ·11m h.: umv tt·l t. Li e .1. h,11,k eJ ~l ,,h 1111etfom1 for Tl1,• l.li,n. \Ir. F ,u.1-u:- ll aq lll <1 \' t• Li-l\ re,rnl ntiou tu t he t'ff t'd t ha t t li ,·i r lib,•rn l ~ll !•l'"n. 1n ,i1111clu~i11 n l11: ,iuid lw kiw w 1;;,w 1,1-11J h Lord 'tl'hil,1 tw,1:; ni,iu;-: t h,, 11 ,·,·1•,;;i1y ui 1,•,pt!di11g tliL• l,•~it inrntt' , 'wai!· carri,d throu~li . .Mr. ,vz~z1 r 11a-~.a u ar1~1 1>1111n• ,J tha t H ii! H i~line,;~ t he Aga Kl lan had etk.>t'.• lt~' ~",-l) t:1 ,· \'\l lll l\lU(~iti e.- ~t ll t i:11e .:,f a r,•:igiuu,; _rc,r i,-,. : ;.h ,·ni J be :,d l«" i ,- ~· d ,.-, , -,. 11111ltlll( l lt· :- tl1,·111,,·11·e., ,,n.! tht• 1rnt1 ,-•rr ,:,·, ,lwu lJ n1.,1,!n ,·J _t h>" Pr,•~1th-nt.,;l ,1~ uf tl1 t1 ,\ 11- l wii:, ~1 ,.- lem L1>a ::p) e. He D•' l t--1·:,l!l •\I t·:! \ " int\:1f,·r<'. :\l r. l~,\,1\ ~,k,,J. d w rrq :t·\·ti , 1'. l' " lllUlll!iit huu~ht .I t Wc,u!J b~ U. cah111 ity f .. r .\l ll.hor~,i• l1LH~ wl,,.,n Hi~ High t ~~3 rl.!~l t! Oed. · , : t i,•,-; tf ,ll'l·:"· :<',:t t':n·li ,_,thn ' ,; f,·di 11~ "· Th,• Btiti ;h <_; ,, .,. "' rn nwri; 'l{t"ft !,n' t'd - Th~, ' Pr<"s id,•nt ~-aid t h11t, h,:•IVHt: r 1·~ irif11l t it ,, d.-,'.i , io n .,[ ~he Ag • Ll><'<.'Hl ~•,' .. r lh,1i r pn •111 1c;,1 oi n,,11-in tt·d,•r,• n~... wit h tin• rd1 :;.: ic, 1l} i,I t he ld lll ll , !t Wa,-~ lt ri,l' "<:,l,! ,,, i. oJ tl ,,•y h,i,J l ·) 111\:c,q,t it Hi•, l)11wH ~r, 11 1·p,· 11h•cl t n u,._. A ~:is l\ l,,. 11 11 nt t , i.,lan, hi$ rc, .iKn llotinn j(J thei r hand.I ~'' '" !'1_~ a11 1I ",n t lmt i\l 'l',>l1Ht tl 11·y w •llhi p N t<'c,t ag 1:1 iu~ t. iitJ)" otlic(!l1 llli t•rt i• r t: UL't' 111 d1 ,'t r rt·l ~1 ,.11~ ,1t· r,•rn ,, n11•;. fo -,l ll)' ,mJ t, , ,,,1uu uu 11., £>resiJe ut till th~ ru le:i 1,f tbe Leag uil 1t'l'te yme. ·f of j in ,Li! 1 be 0 jl 0 : 1' 1tWo! .: 1t\·.~ t1, 1S l• •· ll!J thfl 1lh >t i1H1 .,f tit,, ll ,• tl S ," "H l:t, l ' I. Al ' ~ I, . x ~w a !, ;·.1 1•,! N1h,11 t, c\ li Clu !!,lhr i (l.\,• 11 ~1 I) lh(' f,,!l, ·, ww ~ h ', " lnti,, 11 w :b 111:, :rnr t11 ,,,-!_. eur ie.J : ·-· ·· l !.,H thur~ t'i:\ ll j'' ll 1J,.,vt•rt1m,, ot th,• irni ,: r.i.t ii ,. u, •,:_•.-.;eny 1a kn1g • II h·~:isl ,~l lHl 1 11J ,-1! ,•r ->l<'!' S n,-e>c· ., •:l.r,1 i,, , !li~.:u•d dn: -..nt:tH ~ a ud Hiot<'c c.i .or_, and c_u k.,t','P iot al't, all pul,lic 1,!s, '<'~ ,,i .,., .,r:;h ,p a11d 1Hh~ r ...acrt.-d plact-t 10 l oJa. 1n a ,·11ry brid !!ip~:,:-;;h , il,t• ~pc• ku ~U t'} alt.,• rni. · j H i:1 H i)l. hll t'.'8 >i.&icl he woul d remain P resident fo r t bo time 1 tt 1.;,: ~ -ilt"1 . Ht' s.a id th.tt i~ nu ca~ wou ld be se Ter Lis cohn ectioa Yi t a the League 11.,; \' ice - Prei,.. di•nt. : ! ,. . , .. · T 11A !t Kil ·rn TtH: P u £ f 1L> JOI T. · I . l l,1.e h 1&Jil ,J f \l l\li 11 ,u,l1"l1.L •.l•f_H"J'•"Wd a ~lit~ a i than l.: s to th~ ~ h11r. \\ 1t h cl,i•,'t>< for lJ,.. l're:.i11.. '. \+s nd our The 'Jlberal side of onr educational prolilt-m is .cof cerned wit.h . quite diO'eren\ · kinds of pl1enomena wliich exhibit them eh:es, in cl0tie \ affinity the higher and more refined aspects of individual an~ oa1iooal life, in 1111 i.n\·igorating almospl1ere of ,cult.or ar'ldeolighten;n1eot in which alnnc can flourish the ~ost fruitful iirtues of civilized man. ~ shall explain my meaning by a simple i lu~ation, • · ; In your <>xperience of .the concreter eull of modern education most of yon must have co~e acrou lwo types of edm:att>d men i~ this country. One is that of a young an who has a1)plied himself assid11011sly to liis tcxkbociks; who Ly passing aucce&1i\·e examfoa:. tions lia11 risen laboric,uslj from the low~st · rung of tl,e educational ladder to tl1c hig het.t; and who, after a brilliant acadetjiic career, b~ canied off a great many of the prizes o~n lo men or ·hia time. In the student world he has the rcpulati~n of l>t'ing a walking.. ency~ clopietlia of knowledge, and his College rellows look np him with . nerrnus respect as a m1rn of great condition. But scrutch ltim and Jou wil! and a barbarit.o, ,without a vest~ge of rnal culture in him, and he is none the less a 1,arbarian beca11~e he carries ai 1uoontainooa load of books on his back; As &di says: ! , as perba'pat f,,ll,;wing ~re extracts from the Presidential addre~ delivered 8 ~1;' ,JnsliCl' M. Shah L>in at the twenty,-seventh SC3Ston of the 1u~Indill ~!"ham dan Euucalional Conference held at Agra on he 2lilh, :2,Lll and 28th o~_ember : > • . • t ,\fterrdt?rring to the Ah~arh College, tho l resident sa1d::C-_Gen,t ·,n <·!l<' l•i tlte mos~ pleas111g results of the spread of tl1e "'l1garh 1110 t{ ' . Ind a uas the organ~ e_lf?~-t,. recently made by our 11 ;, 1 col tct funds for the ~isbmeo~ of a Mos_lem l r n:i'Nsit;. flt .\!ig,,rh. Tue wne ~r enthusiasm "l11ch . passed O\"er j elas:-£·5 "f ~lu\salm11ns thro1~ghont the length and breadth o~ the 3 1 lflud nnd the !'triki~g snccess ach 1cred b?' the p:-~ruotc_rs of the Un1rnr~it,· idea undtr tlic brilliant leadersl11p of His. H1gh~ess the Aga · · nitir~nt., proof of the great aw:ikenmg ~vh1eh has taken K h,in im' 11 -~•g 0 , 1r I pebplt' : and- this is mainly due to the grndual 111 1 !1rn ~;''' n. " -~ 1·,1~,rl 1 'ideas first promulgflted at A ligarh. These 1 ri11ni1 1, ,11 o, ,,,. • . . - r id,--,-· nn ,1 :1 1~ ;irin ~ipl· s 11uderly10g them, must lie de ~gt'nt1y sprea_d !\Ill:_~;:! \t u,-calu;Rn,sJuiJ 11p~•lied to tho new order of t~mgs wluch _B i:,,n,ii;c: i:itn existelc; nnd you nmy _tlicn _b?,,sure that rn the_doma~n ,,f ,•,hv:lt i,,y, a,; als, in other field,; o~ aeLm_t~, our comnrnmty w1!l ,..., .1,. 1_, nccupr a p )~i 1io11 worthy of HS tradtllon~ an~ of 1Ls numenc:\i· .:1 r,' r,~tli ir; tlll' •vuntry. Wi:h y(,11 education 1s the _supreme n,'l"LI ,,f 11,l" 1t,,ur, i, r re1m•mbcr th11t. u110~ the ~xlent to which JOur c,, 11 ,1111111 i1y will be du,critcu on modern ltne_s mil depend ~our pro,,,,,,, r,·1 _.tir,-ly to otbcr cn1111n11nilics, IU nit the more 1111por1ant " 11·\.~ -· .· , >1·_ 1·11·•, ...\ c~:1:-;n•••nrd of this trnth will nssnredly endanger wn · ::, vour r, ,,iti ·n in Llii country; . . · Tit ,' ~1 ,1,.- ,:. U iti,·,•ra!,ity qu:stt on_ has been d1scus~cd for the past thrL's' war,; in maurl uf i1,- beanngs Ill all parts of tho c:onutry; 1rnd b,i, :n ~ r,•c.;,'1· .! 1 , tl~1;: ia~ t tbt it is under the conside~ati~n ()f certain Tt.' f! H'~·. 'l;l a,i ·;,• l'.- ,11111iltt'('S clt1\y empowered to deal with 1t, f d1) not f,,cl ,· ,i'i n l ui ,,:1 t , s,iy anything special ali,Jut it on tho present 1 1 I . . L , . . ,,·.:a, i, . l 111aY, I uw,•1·rr, be pcrniitted t<> remark that, after ha,·iug 11 1 . . ~ ~\!) 'J! ~'P':" . . sh,, wn una,ualh_.kt' n intert:5t in it the c'onnunnity seems to hnrn The other type is that of the slndcn~ who, in going! throngh hit r,+p,,·J i1 ,t,, s:,n,et _,ing like iudi!Terencc towards 2-!'.:.. I know that t! ,:, i, ,·b!! 1· du •.\ t ~> 1he foct thl\t 11111mento11s 9c1Hs----nf n most •---~ehnol and his _College cnrriculnm, 111\j J!1'id more ~ttJ ntion to the s1iirit Qf-i,h.e· books he hns rend lhnn to tbe1r \'erl>al fra1~e work; who s,•1 j ,, 1: , L'l1111',;d,·r i11,h• bpp1>11ed in t!tc .Moslem world which hare hns uot disling11i,hcd hinrneH i1f the exn~1i11ation h11II won lnurnla t'll ~ ,· , ,._, \ :I«· ;, tl t'rf" n of tlie lndinn ~j olrn'.11ed1111s ni,d 11am placed th, ·:r ,-·:t 11 t , r,·,,,11rl·tts under a sc,cre strain, Bu~ now that tlte at tho Unlversily CMn'<1cation, \mt who i lt11s asl!imilate4 the know~ ,· l,,1;, l- L.l,;. r,-:l~d a{rny 11nl we art' in sight of clearer" skiei,, 1 t•arlcd•"e l'laeed nt. hi::1 disposal by hi:1 lcl\ch~n1;, who lrns tt icd to apply 11,, ,,_ 1y t,_,,,·s:,· h )·,,n tnrn )'1)llf at_tention once more to the Uuirer• it t7, tlte at:tnul fac!s of life; who has ~cq11ired a wi~t•r and more sity ,1,:,·- ;.. 11 \\l1id1 )1as l;,,•cvmt• for ns n qncstiou of sovereign- imp,11clic,1l outloo.k npnn the world anU hus thu11 bci.:orne a truly l'" rLct :<·,·. s\ ml iu 'liis eon nee Lion may I re11t11re npuu. a word ·or cnlt1m•d nwml>er of socirty. His inn<'Jsell is in per,ect harmony l\ .ll i"· : L j,; <'~S t 'I Lin I tn tlte ri~ ht re,wlnl ion of tlii,i question tl1at with hi~ enli='htened exterior, and he is la moral force: of no meao }' ,nir lt•,1.li n~ mens!: rnld uring to bear upon it their best qualitic;i of pokncy in his own social circle. ht'a ,I :,:id h,·21rt, nn,l it is eqnally necessary U111t tlte rank and file Wl111.t is lroe of , individuals i.e al11q true of com~oniti~, and oi t~-:- n11 11 m l1 1oitv ,-] u1 ,hl iol1111-,- their le1Hl in t11is n1aller with cvnfidamong tho l11tler yon will tind th~ same I ,ypes of tt-m~rament and ill / i,,,::1 1~:·- I ;.ery 11111cli u,1ubt whether our leaders folly reiilhl the behill'iour which I hare del!Cribed above. Now-, altbo~1gh the pre--uat u!·,· nn l! cxtt•11t l1f · the respo11sibilities which rest. . upon their aent nee'ds of the country are snch that we mnat continue to pay ,-!_111_1:: ,l,1°: ,: ih t'_I' lta~· e lilllnched UJ>On 8.n experiuwo~ of enormous attention the u-c '.111ical side of onr [educational. prpblem, or, i~d1t! ;.·n ,:y mth i.•rtJ qabltJ CL111seque11ces or a:1ar-reaclung cl11iracter.;:.. otl.1t.>r words, _m _ ust try .to prod_uce from a,m on_g. us as m~ny_ •_•ed11cate~1\11t1 :11 timb it ~e,•mk a~ ii th,,y wern driring.the chario~ or the Sun barbari11n!! ''. 88 we can, wo mu11t not losl!_Jigbt of what \ [ 'have called ~i'c\1 br11!;; llDt'qnal lo thtJ ta~k. ' 'JiiiS 'is-· hurue out~l,y the discusthe liberal side of that problem, tha~ is to say, "e m~t,: endeavoW' si ,,n,; wh ielt ham. ta~en place orer the · uoirnrsity q\icstion both in to under11tand and as~iruilate and exhibit in oar dailfi actions the th,, '.l \ ,,,;-s an~i at the meeting~ of the C om111ilttts that are ; mosL endoring_ principlts of modern civiF, lire so . ..._tp '. beco_m _ e in ,·l_;:1:-~ , d witl1 it,- _dt?t+ilt'd c,, nsideratiun, and thoughtful men hue . course of tim~ a commnnity of cnlt.ured Jnd enlighten~ Qlen. . " 'Ct-11 ~l 111k~11 their ht 1nl~ oYcr t'1c resul !s t.hns far achie,·eJ. The '!'lie _,_narch of ~ftnt11 io India haa'."°"'t.touKliL u1 to. ,_•lag_e of pro,.;_ ;ru1,.- ,l,•i,·,·: i11 the g~) nernl attitude ut tlrn Mohamed1rns lowuds this gre~s a( ."_hich ' h e_hould _bi! im~ . . itf~ fQr an1one _ijat t_he ·moet• •[i:c.,t :., n i~ tk it 1 -1l1u1·,_·t.cH~ty. o_ne w_l_w has sul~cril1t1<.I, or creu. pr_obigoted Mullah not to recogni'f t!•e utgenL- need of aln organiaed 1_ 1_:, ' · ~1:1 ,,n. h\ t ,. the t lllrNs1ty funds claun;, the right to give and sustained ache-me for promoting abur,d edu«lioul •mong onr . ''l i :,i.. n rt, ID th ClJn s tiru1io11 of the proposed Unire~ity and tJ 1e won1e11. In the West '!OIJl~n ha, pl•1iug, for ·~ , long '-illle' :i:: :, :1/11 ,1;.:,·1!wu t (f its i~tl&irs without i;t?pping t'? ~onsiling it.a atren1lh and •riooe~ meaos lo · •t~p- o~t . o_f ii ':, :,, ,,1, th~ .\! .. slem U ,.i\'ersity 8<:heme which lu,ve staggered men accustomed sednaion t() ~ke an buQoara le · aud iocreding iot8'"t ;-:, · bl\:'.· rt",'c'1 ,ni e /,irn,ity edul·ntion themsd-res and who therein the cuore practical eonce'ro,a of-the oa id• world. impoaible :· t ,, I •. .. ,! >'!~, t -1 _ ,: ,,rnr t>Xlt>.llt , the complicated natnre of the great now_ to s,em tl,e tide "_- h ch. ia fto•_•_n_ g inti•. dlrecuon .e ea •. if , IOllle :_ : .. _. . :_:t·:' :nv~,:...-ed rn til~! si t u.:ttion. I wonld e..arnestlJ advise tJ 1e, comofJott, wi th• 1npreme coiiteolp&- for th, Deeda of the limea. were ic :;.; :) t,, ,~:. v~ th ,.• Jc,nsideration and de.:isiQn of the · who~ UoiY~ri~ think or duiQg ao, and you wo1ald be eU ad,ieed lk> to :ngulau :i in !t:rnds 0~ edncati ooal experb_;ltien it iulo .ex.i11_eo_y_·e' ; and mJ fear ia Lh_at m,Tf•.• ._ or _UJe _ t,ro_D.JCen . •_ · ot 1 1-~ •: ,lt:c•M1 ,,~ :i11d e~1--en cnc~ to t1peak on thi~ qoNtjon with the echerqe •NI ghiog \bc-1Uaeln1 ibe P.,.._rJ lraininf ' o eopct with ,' l "' ·Jld iu1pk,re th, ,se up,:,rhi to d o their work with tuk th•~ .... b.f.,re ~IDTbe ~(ical uaiDlD' . in ed ..... j th~ 1 ; ., r , __ _ _~·:• ur~~e u1d di:1cr.imioatio'n, 'Ihe 1'hol., qnelidioa tion l wm·k wbich tbt Trust.... of -~ AHtf · li ·College · ~ nt'ei,i. . 1 · · · •'· ' w,\h ,.l :t llL' 1:l d <'s; tltt~y UllHt. l>alised and facl!d, anJ Fairu _c . le __·.r pre - ~nL _con_diti.ont ia .-n_ol u._ : • _ _ kin _ _ o_,__ -trainia. 1_· _. _ aired lot i :: : .: ,:,. :.,-r.i ,i-~ti ,iri, or ha;ny c uclu.'.1-ion~ must be aYoid!Ni. · M.7 tra~ 8"f1:'flllhg bodiee of the fropoaed ni,enit1, "h · • lib · ;- :, · : , t, ' · : 1:?:-i,:,l t!p n • brief experitnee o! th& ~lual working S,ndica.l• and Senalee ohbe uiaiog 1.. • _·. Unim:ei • , will t.. 1 ·1.•: •:,'. ~-:/':_- · \ .' · is ~h at ('m'~ditl\cnhieii will \kgia aflt>f ihe iu_iGd_.•ptndt1n_\. eh.,.,. of ~-8 'Wholei.· 1'0rk. IO of b .. i . gber · . . •,·· · _ . :_ eoa! 1 l ' , ··:• ·'~ ' t,,,,·n ~f • 11 ttd and L,11~ l.l o,lt!ut Uni.-e~t1 • - ~ ~~ witb the· nriot11t faa11ldee of I &Del o.-..•M..,.01, : 1 <'. 1f national ed 1ca,l ion will .~ . complete . a~n _• · th; . ident, the Govern- - Indian Mohamed.ans which~oes n.ot make :ample provision fo ths doubtful boon~ Gent.leme~~ti~u.ed tbe pres ment of ndia have recently_ l~own an extensive programme of education of ,~omen on m ern . linee, with ~pecial referepce to .the 4Klnc•tio 1al expansion, and the Mohamedans must be: prepared to peculiar n~d of a progressive . slami~ commu~ity. This does no~ -by take fnll ad,aotage of the facilities thus afforded for the__ spread of ao.y means imply. the wholesal . ad. opt1on of. th~ n•rnthods or i.n·strn. Ci.:tion educal.iof among the upper classes and the masse!' of - tlie country. and of t.he standards of c : tnre which hare rome to be associ~ted The Go~ernment of India resolution, dated the 21st February 1913, w. ith Western ·.•civilizatio.n ; e in the E~~J1ave our own distin¢tive sketch~ . i t~ broad onllines o( the policy which the Department of traditions and . predomiliantieodericies of thought, - and we iust Educatitn iJ)teods to pursue in the matter of promoting both eleevolve a new type .· of culture the result of i "'. :holesome combin~tion of the Asiatic and Euro_pean systems of training. One thing is, mentary/an.d higher education, and that resolution marks a moat impo~ . · F,'_tage in the educat~onal development of this country. boweve;, clear, .an~.t~a~ 1s tha±i th.e p_urely·~.W!•.tern. modes o~•.· edu~ .. tion would be &1:1 stale, ms1p1d and mprotiLable lD the case of our wdmen Soon~• on the Srd of April 1918, the Government of India addreueid a circular letter to all .the Local GMernments and Adas they have prov_ed t.o -~ in t e case of our men, and_~he commJnity ~nietrat.iooa on the subject of Mohamedan education, calling altenmast make up its mmd o ce..Jlld lor alLto allow its girls .tQ be t.ion t-0 ~he aneatisfactory condition of that education, except ih the instructed in the elements of k+o~ge accordlng to the more ecid1ti6c primary /et.age, in all the provinces, and inviting suggestions and methods of th~ . modern age. I The Lime _has long since gone by ~hen eveo our leadtng men favoured the idea of concentrating all our recommiodations as to the beet means of improvigg it. ln that letter e Government nf India expressed their anxious desire thu.t energies upon pe .· rfecting the 1. ucatfo,n .>f boys•; before takin. g . u~ the qnestion of educating our girls ; we have advaoced far beyon~ the all re&11 nable f•cilitiee should be provided for the education of Hoham ana and indicated generall.r the direction in w}iich enquiry stage at which such a ,1iew cupid be held and acted upor. without endangering our national ~:iitioo iu India. In these days! the and sJ>e4ial act.ion will, in their opinion, be useful. The Government of Iodi~ letter is still, I uoderstand, under the consideration of most education of girls must pr~d par-i passu vrith that of boys, a6d I of the ~oc&l Governments and the latter have asked for the opinions am certain that a disregard of this principle will result in serious of lire. / of the blamia Anjumans and the leading Mohamedan gentlemen in _ difficulties and greatly bandic~p us in the their resjpectiTe proviJ:1Cff on l~ poiots raised in the letter in ques'l'here is urgent need of e~pbasising this /principle in our na~ional system of education, and ~he . public mind must be traine~- ,to tion an4 geoerally on the subject of advancio~ Mohamed.an education. ~ e;&1n~tly hope tbat the various Anjumn.os addressed by the recognise it.a importance. U~forttinately the ; Indian Musalman:s ){88 Local qovernmenl.8 will 1:onsider the whole subject thoroughly in all still very primiUve ideas o.o tqi.i subject ; and, this was made pai~fully it.s beatjngs, with special reference to their local requiremeot and t,le~r only re<:ently in the P~ujab in the -~u~ of a contro ve 1·sy will aubtnit practical and use£ul suggesli6ns--fe-t__ improving the edu~ wh1cb waa waged there over[ a proposal to mtr;oduce the teaching of eation dt MllllAlmans in all stages of inalruction, more eapeciaUy in English into the curricnlum qf a new Girls' .School which has ! beeo the sec of life ~~uld often both misleading and u1>true. broad-fnded statesman who is prepared to weigh sympathetically But at the same time we CAil, l tbfok disco~er at any pnrticula~ stage the sp81'=ial claims of backward corumunit.iea to considerate t,tntment of the moral . a~d materia} progress . of 1' community some iof th• ' in t.he ~t interests of the geoeral progreea of t.lie country; and they predominant traits of its :character which maoifest themselve~ with AN dei .rmi.ned . • on- their. owo part, to. do all that l'.1ei1 iu their power more. or le~ pers ii;teuce in ;its thought an~ acti on, and which for the to bel themsel ,eti. . time being, sen o t o diffe:r;!ntiate it from other communities. 1t A ut16t gratifyiog instance of self-help on the part of our co-nligionis . ·aod o! sympathetic encouragement oy a Local Oo,ernment &eems . to me _th~t _wo Mohamodans_ suffer, in a peculiar d~gre~, from a lack of d1sc1plrnary seU-restrarnt, aud eveo our virtu,eti are in Le fatter of our edu~at.ion is afforded by the re-cent establiahat timea made to appear as i.erious i faults. because of this ment qf an Islami11. College at PNhawar. We are all dteply gr-atefnl gniat. defect in our national character) lllustrationa of thi1 to Sir/ G&0rge R 00se- Keppel for the great inured which he bu taken _[rom the TM)' b.-gioning in tfie hlamia CoTiege as to be able to can be eABily furn iahed trom the reli~ionll and seeular life or diT\'!rt ~t into pr,.,1r.er channel.a. The eoormoua ._iutluence or woweu oo o~r ~ple. An e_x(!_e~ of zeal in_ t~e obset vaoce of religious rem,!-' the ~nti•tlr human side of the chaneter of mankind must. be nul 18 the most gtnlung cl1aracteru11lo. of e Mosalmans, an thetr' eb,iod, to th~ nwst supttticial obeener ; and our tir:aL duly at the piety often wanif~~ itse.,I in extraraga·~ forms L<, the ut r dispre&e~t mo~nt is t~> re.fine and pnr-ir! tba&, ioft~en:1; in onr count.r.1 regard of ~h.e t. pi_rit .n~derl.J··ing ~. heir religi9·a·.a precept&. Thettforge\•, and t4 bri&g it to bear u~n tbe totali.ty of °.nr mdn-_idual and corpothat Is.law 10 all 1ts iniunctlons msistJJ upon a re&11onable ad· ~meat rate lif11 in order to make 1t more frmtlul 10 relahoo t,, the gre.t of the reli!Jioua and the secular dntie., diacourages ascelici . with mort1thent.1 of the world. its exeeeaive ln th~ affain ,,r the ne.x t ~orld, and t>nforcea tib, role Ftom Lh"- time when the tint atirrioga ol new life 11end a thrill of the golden me&n betwM~ two exlremee i in all human ~atioo11, of jo~h1'}ugh a.n ~xp,e,t11&nt famil1 circle to the 1upreruelr critical Our pre:acheril 1.lwa,-s adwi,-:ii:..ter an over-df)M or theological -1moni~ momot "'bes:i th• lul. ray of hope it ut ioguished and the dark ti on to their cooirregations~ a.nd the latter la.re thereh1 led to tie o.er, 1 ahado;tn of ~th eloee in upon an ema¢iat.t!J tigutt., the pt'N()DalitJ ae.IoW!i in their per.formt.r1.,c-e ul lLe chief l'. raett.·ca.1 du.tiflil enjoin.d b1_. of " ~ st.and out ae being in dOtM •iLa.l tonch with so1ne or the Islam, regarole6il oi lhe liru,i~lions im~ in eonnexiot1 wit the111 moeL ~•erful aprin.gt «) f human thou~ht ~ti_o n; ~ad !l,i) uu part bJ lbe gn.-at Law-g.iver. Aluch of ow enetg,7 thll.8 run.s to •• ; • i.n ~1ng t.b. dHhoy of ruac hu ~n ~ --ign1k'd tn the U.()dera 1pirit of iodiffttrtnce tow~d• eome of ~he chief conc-erns o,f life ~ -«-· .,. l)Oe -tif "rfo41ot !ll(IUfe po•~. You will all l't!JQf'lbbt>r tngeodereJ ; and lit-tle activity is aho•u bJi our people ia on~ming _ \be jltt!(ll&Dt N}'ing that U1" hand th.at r•ic~il the ~r•dl~ ru:l" the difficuhiet that lie in! the path of aechlar advance. Tbi1tk for , I.be ,-,, rld, and l ma.1 add that th<> d'-'h .::,te fingel"i that 1n .ick ruomeot of the way in. whioq our moat wieruUnatitation of al~. giTIDI c:hau1 ber elt•. with u ioUpn'#iblj •tft'('tio ute tooeh, &.h.e eye-s of is ahnRd by the gMerall/t1 of tbe pioa iM.ualmam. En 1M •xptri.og DWI hue ner IJotG. bWIJ ~n 1u>ranllin.g the ~glN aku) them coui~.r• hilDRlr tree· t.o 0 dole oa& b~ charity .. ~ . ; b . od :!::n:!~.::~!e,e.!wbi::, ~:.:_::: :.~.·.;~• · .' ;i.~:~. l.::.• .a- race 1 i 1 tl'. , 1 1 and ;:.ol ; 1 i 1 ' U w 0 0 i A f 1 8 q V d a e S ' t "t 0 a "a • C ! i I0th JADualY• the objects of chari ble relief are not :carefully selected; no method · . obserred at all n the:disLribution of such relief; all advice and :rectioos for the organisation and systematic ccntrol of Zakat ~ resented : and the result is an appalling waste of sobstance and strength wbicli. if t. Musalmans o_n~y submitted tbe~seh-es to a little judicious discip_line_. could be ut1hsed to great nat1~nal ends. Ou~ educational iust1tut1 08 would uot then be starved, &8 18 the Cll&e 'JOWj throu(Th 'llant of 6nancial aid, and the Jlroblem of Moh&medan back:ardn€s.S wonl4 be partly solved. Consider, 11gain the serious difficulties which ha~e to be faced both in India and in Arabia itself, because Mohamedatjs who ate too )oor to pay the expenses of a pilgrimage tn Mr_cc? and_ who are the~e . . rohibited by Islam from unJertaking it , ins1st on going to the HtJa.z rn a e nnmbers every year, with th~ r~snlt that h•any of them are either left to perish in ,\ rabia M pr,wl' a heaYy bt~ ~den to their ricl'.er folio~ pi'.grims. ~'he cr~io· i> U the re;,;nt ces ol ~ he. !\I n~alt_nnns mvoh·ed Ill this_ proceeding wh1_ch is r,'peated year 11f~er year, 1s econuou_s ; and 1t ~onl~ be easily an ,ided if they wqre to ltarn how to strictly regulate their exberant rl'ligiou;; fen-vur ncfordinj to the very sound rules laid down by Islam. The ,,ne grrat f~nlt in the Moslem character is want of. sol,ri,,ty, llll'daatior[, ~straint and self-denial, and yet these are the qulllil~i.'li to which ··~li:uu assigns a high place in the list of human Yirttl t?•. A man c!l'n be as selfish, wasteful and immoderate in dl)Y,ltionnl exercises in his worldly relations with his fellow► beings, and th e incukatiot~ of this truth shonld be the aim of all religioUB edu;:atit•n. , Ii ir,' turn to lthe secular side of our lifa. we find that want of ~wli-disciplirH' is a t reat impediment in the path of Moslem progress. Tlw t~d \' ll C)' obsen~ble in lhe younger generation towards deetruc:. tirn rritfri~m witlio,it a cor~espon,liug anxiety to show constructive work i~ au illustratiqn of tbili f~iliug, and one result of this unhappy tendt!ncy has been I a treakening of lhe i-ense of responsibility in our c0mrnunity which niay do a great deal more harm.than it has alrt'ad.1· done. Ag~in, consider the utterly unmethodical way . in wh ich the n:ry luge funds collected from the Indian Musalmans in aid oi Yarious motement.s ha\'tl. been administered in this country aud :mu will find jthat you haYe a great deal to learn from other cowmuuities as_ to ! how. yo~ should regulate your patriotic action by rderl'Dce to business!maxims 1n order both to preveut your resources heing fritt:r:ed. ai.,- ~y and also to_ apply your full'ds to their proper ob)eds_. . '!his :don~ way(,! edncaltng y'.1ur community to 11, right ~ppr~C ~l\tl OU ol sonte of the factors which m•ke for tuoral progress 1u lud1a. ; Another deputipent of human acLiYity in which we !uoham~ dtrn? suffer frum lapk oi discipline iiJ m1r literature, nnd in this con_.. llt' x1on I s!111ll c~ll jYOlll' attention lo one phase of our amqrous ~~elry .. 1he LH',o':~d. of the Mu_ham~dan Urdu poet of the old -dWlll, ~n '\lwm 1:1 murnalt' ~ h.,s highest conception of human l •eillll)' , .ls a lr~ak ~f ORlll~tl w1t_h a mouth littlo bigger than the g:tlllJet_neal purnt anp a wais t thmner that a -hair. As an example 0_1 IOr~er, we ha~· e lbc c~uplet ?f ~ Persian ~ t whose· style and l.l.'.>tt l,ur l ·rJn 1•ul'lf have tried to umtatc and -.2cquire. 1 t8 _tl:e j.)~ "~."~ JJ~L.-\ r-t~tJ And as a3 JU5l a 1ice of the latter. Yen;e ~)r an l I Ju j)iJ)}t• 1..,-..,. '1w .;,.;j fl ~fwo- I may :.quote the well-kno • < e"' ,I L <'. • ~ ~ . t / / ' r ' ~ V'!·--',r -' vbT v ,.,--~4-jj ~.Jr~ /JJ . /JJ ..It }" 11 tl11~k f~_r a moment, you will perceire that in Lhe domain _tlus kjrnd of poolry, illustrating u it does t>-ie fs pa:t~tu~ !_or 1_m1.1JoS t tradi~wns (if Moslem progresa and culture: '. and j&, is in the d . th rngs ~ha~ you i;bould draw your inapiratioo f~m U.-::;.c_,n~ and ~ight& tbaL &llfTOnnd you. The •er, gronnd oa 1 m; ~, \ 1~:u../' e tre~rng must recall to your, ~in~ the llirring aJ ; , . ; :" h• 11c age, when Jour c-0-rthg1on1•~ bore with :it ·.t.'" lt> ~v_rt~tt:d" ~lie but_ an.d bu~en of the day, ud with patienl. tues~ wl,:~"ti: . ut1tlit,, rng! re-&ol11hon and 1ndomitahle oounp de•eloped the : •-', ,,_I lllld i--e•re and maint.aioed for • long ti~ a bigb 8'aDda,d IHti. a1 ti~e when the tide of Mugbal IUfNrDae)' . , . hrc,,::,c at ll& lc,wr!it iebLJ, the rooatrocth·e ~niu■ of AkMI' the 81'8& ai,J.. ~nlttlfl th,nMtot ■ tog.lher, ••ol"'4! order oat 1 tL ~ :·<.: 11<:Ifion · statesmanship to .«)O()mpl~~- A , little J~: cam~ ii6 ;~ 1' throne Shah Jehao the M~gniftce:n t who ga~!Iodiil :a: k ,;- ,.: ~nce--peace th~t bath its:•iotories t~ao war--~lo(~ . ~n · ' p_1ety and . learmng and 1exalted · ment . •bote aocieQli )pi~ nches, who made art t~e study of p aod plac;t i, 1 people the best specime~ or aesthtitfo c 1.ttJre who im1qottal~' . . f moet. abi.ding. phase of . ~nman affectio by building t~e! T,i~rlta~ :. JMO!n~ or no le.M a ~on "tha11 Marquis of Lansdowne who wu Mituster for War 1when f.he ~n~cl- ·began and , was well-qn■Jified to . make a pronouncement on ·~he :eit.uliQn · by reaaoo of hi• having been th4l Vicetoy of India p~riootly, Lord Lansdowne apealring at Sheffield in l 899 uid :-" OQDtidenble num~r of the Qdeeo'a hdian nbjeota ~re,to be foo~d iii, ij}e Trau•-1, aud among Uut manJ misdeeds of: the 8{,oth African • ~public. l U ,im,gine w aid be the eff-,it, •.plodaced ,so I i wu tor the• iA: oa ,n ~•®'" Iidi~n \bae poor people ~rn . t.be.i r $o ttport to their frie&d1 Lbat t.!1e GontnDMDt of . : .E mp..-, • ~o . m~jb~J . • ~nesielible io India, with it, popnlatio~ . o( tbne .hu,dred milliOQe, ia powerleaa i4> eecore nclreee , . at. ha,d.e .o f,. ,mall !LnU. . .• Afrio6D , 8Ple 1" , . . : " We Qllnot be too tbukful ~ J4rd : AmpUilll ; ho u, taba Up OQT C&Wle iD SooUi Africa in ri~t, ~ . al -,mpMbJ f~ '118 .peopt. of thia ooootry whi4h be , ~ dllrifNr hie t.rm of Oo~ip;iq ~ tO, uJ: of ._, ;1'17uo$forml11 · lbdta,leQCI..,_ I.·. .be ~ .u~&.:i.~~.~~. ·.·.f .~.•.~ ' ~·a ·. ·.. . ;... wi .· .T.:I ·~ .· of... ...:• ....... :'...... a.ad ilia OQlJ alLer ,&he .... pndaoed ia I.Adia'.!' 2'liia .... ~ :. :~ ,1 8tt,. .···:·.. . w h o ~ ~ .;:;.::: ··· : , ,, ao•-.pha&io ~ .~ ··• ol': Lml ~ ,f •~ . rl :~ apoq:fl• ......... ~ - - • -'! ·: ~ : :... : r.- ,•~-..:'J' i· i I . ,, ':, ~../ I Lord Sel e, .. '. our d~ty to aee Lba~ °!11'. d01Jk7' fellow-sob~ in . ' ° ~(), 11boold be treated they be.treated' If die 'Trans,~, •he,e Lher had. a perf~ t1ghL in :e, , ~ eh ••1 , > .· · .·••· •··•···' < J... . <· :>o :I> : 1 ~::r1:::~i~::•u= tt~-~l~f~~ R•roax DQo;NOl~r -1-( .·.·• )i .• · · 4-u.••. ii I: · lbe Q our name bad proruiaed ahoold agreed ith him and admit.led lbM LhNIE!. •ere qoeJtions and oppression. '· . fl had to a.n wer u trualeee before Olli' fellow,-<,ouot17flN'n. befo,e 0 Oom .. iug. 1.(1 thel·•·qneslio1 . •.s. c".o c . . •.c::1~1l•.·.•· ··.W1 . •. .••.,tl·~.•! ·].•le ··. '.. .•'orme•·•, , · ·d ····•·.·..Oo. ! , · , ~. · . . •. . i~ )Ulftory. then thej would aicree with b(,n ~•~ •tb~t the path tif duly I need nut refer tets, h,•1~1g p_owerle~s to rc~tnu~ _an 1rre,:po11s'.ltle tho first. started with nn elee!od tjon-nfficinl nrnjiirit,y in itg Legishtil"e Ool,rn}' is nM only unedifying' m the extremo but 1s rncomprolicm,tule Council. and in tho redistribntio1~ of territories n111Lle in 1912, bdth and c~u -es t;lismay to tlw luffi-.:t. In th_o days of tl~e Doer Gonirnment the with a non-official majority cc► n1~osed of n<)minated and elected memIndinn settl:ers had the rt•elrn.:;- that thmr ,nong11 were due to an .oors b.aroly .sufficient to satisfy tl lo regulations, unjust and! 1rnsympt\tlietic foreign Stat8 which only needt>d to be brought tn }he notice oF tln•ir o\Y.11 G,,vernrnent to bo re,medi1•d. But By far the.most seriom.1 of tl~e drawbacks in fl1e regulations, wli~ch to-day th,,_v find the I mp':riul Gover. n···n·1e. nt stau,ling by. while blow have heen allnwed to exist in th~ re,·i.,ed re_i,nlati,ms, nre tho11e relatingaft"r blnw it d,•li\..,,rl\tdy l'imed llt du:_iµ_ witl1 t('rrible pre1.:i,.ioo an(l to the disqualifications for memljership, the arbitrary nm! nnreasonabl& elft>eL This inddf..ren ;(' has ag~r•v&ted 11ituation and has ronsed -'"\manner in which restrictions are imposed on candidates t>eeking el1JcbittH i,>elin~s bctw~n twn conn tries of t~e Empire and is c\'rtaiuly detion to the Councils, and the general disparageioent of the edl'lcated rogatory t(i the bigh chara.cl~r . o! Briti~t~ . et~tesmansh~p. Not. classes that it in\'oh·es. Proper~y qu:1li6cations, have been ·prescri9ed only tl1at, th,\t it le.ad,; one to tl11nk that th,a rnd1fference -·-in ('ffc\ll in various di\gteea and in variou$ methods in the different Frovinc¢s, ~nc•H1rages ithe Sonth .;\!rican ·Uuion 1n the belief that. their mi-s.lak~n and the deci&iou of questions cam1~ted wit.Ii eledoral mies is commit~ policy ha.'l ~lie fUpport of thp Ootetnment. at H<>1ne. · to the t.bse1lkiug ~le<:ti,,n. ' we s.ltould 1ll-Ok up io thew and n1ue an earnast appeal to u,.-m. It In' 8pi te of tho repeat.ed and innanimous reqnestK of the poople! of, is a pit v th~t. the Parli11me11t liad no baud in tbe ruaUer : othenri~ the United Pro,inces for the establishment of a:n Executive . Contjcil I am .,,;re ~ur lriends in Parliamen~ 'trnuld have raised their mice in thert\ the question is hung without .the! nuthutitiee 11,99i1Jnif8' support of i)Ur righta. I. hne rn(>re faith, 1 eonf~, in ~etaliatMy co~net n-asonil. Sir ,John Hew, tt'11 o ~ 'o the pro1)(1s11l is ,0-0 l:IH!unrea t1l1d1 H the placmg of an embargo on the unportion of cnitl well-known to ynu, lint with tlie ! change oi tt e [,ieutenant-Oo,ern(1rfrorn Natali into this co11atry, and the clOiBing of the d~ni of comp,•tisliip in the UnitB1:l Provinces, itiwu hnped tha ~ it will reoeiti1 eym~aLion for lh~ Cilfil ~enillll agaiuet. tho Svut.h Alric&n Wiiih•s. It seems thetic cnnsi6t c111 the m,•111l ...ir11,, I am hopt>fol that it ~ill receive due con&ideraliou a£ ~ Union Gu~l!rllnll'lll. 81 huing nicour-..e to these retali.tor1 mtaband,11 of the ' ~o,'Nlituent of luqi1.1 and the S«:r brJ of State. •nrH oar fioyerm:m.•nt would bl.t liliowing before 1l,1e wh,,le w, rld that thev are in,, t>Arne11t and WtH1IJ. nol lvlor:ate tho ill trealuwnt l>i Indian As re~n,et• ntllH,,MajeitlJ of the £_m,1itt•. Wt1t hine lo repres-o11latio11 o{ some of the Pr:,ninces is Jeft)c ive •.nd for &hi, ~011 a.d,,,._._le ~tali11torJ measnrt'll l-ecauMJ we h::m:t lie.-n ddv.,n tn Jo ao I • onld su~gl'l.lt an incrt>&M of faL · ltu~ hit dozen. seat.a: no ~ much ·a.gai4tt. our own wilt . W i, lrnweTtr hop..i that !110 resout1.'0 ot (.J"m1til. and d11m1 bciog 1.hrown :(•.~11. for popo ar el\"Ction. ;. ,We 1-:ll ttpN'k'nlallott not yet 01:hauiltt'd aud that th!'I lm.1..;rial Q4 ,.\",ak1•1Hr that at prt1Rlnt we huo ai1'liJ,,J1ead of th. Gonramtoha l~lia lM'l'll hue !not don~ their tlllll01$t"1to ik't'UI~ jtl!Hi,:0 f,,r ,,-ur c,~i,,~ a s.agM:fou,i: s\a!e,;m11n wh~ ra:r-sigbted and "mpathetic p>lie1 ·~ Dk'n. Wl~1!0 rt,,,,goi,-in!f lhat. tl11eirp,»1id uu ,inc d ~rc<1t diffo:ult.y eude•~~I him t•i the people_ of U1i, cotu1try,, 1u,di I fe":endy .~L• •~ ia ri0• td Cofo11i11l aut<1nmuy. I 1hmld tli!'I l!~m" ti111e Ji< ,iol out His F~1:Ci.-lfonc1 Lord Ha dmge ;uefon, layrng owo ibe mp of ihaJ d,e p~n\ Li~ral Oo,et11iu1.•ta !um, el•imt-·..I gr.., .. ~ t'r.idit ( . .~_,i.:_. .~__:·•.•· ·.--:.·- ,1'•.;·-, I want t-0 emphas.ise ere is what Lord .Morley himself mentioned, prosperity has coµie to be :fully recognie by the Go~~t'i~ that ths t ~clJ,,me of ~eform "is not, and hardly pretends to be, a com'!'e grater~lly acknowledge, the}r ear~es! effort to -.f~t in~'tp~, . plete representation ~1f the entire _body of changes and improvements 1t fonuro. But at. .t~>e saµle time . we f l that they d? :not igo in tlw ,,:,:.isling systetfl that are evident resent to the minds of some enough. The political :fears tliat t e Government.l en~~ • of tlw;;e ""hom your qo-rernment }ias c?nsn!te d t~at •~ the best of ;PY ~ega~ds t.he adoption of tile p~nciple o compulsion :-~ al~6thef judgment nre now dlJI!1rnded by the s,tullhon _described rn the opemng 1ma~nary, and if the scheme wluch h~ put forwar~ • is :catemllJ! : words of the 9,espatcl)." Lord Morley proceeded to point out that it , conindered and · followed ! by Governm[t, • the administrative aQ4 i,.S ., e,idently de~ir~ble to present our refo:m o! the I~dian_. consti..;. financial difficulties with which · the ove.rnment belie'fe the:,: •~ tutii,nal system as a whole and that from thu pornt of new, 1t seems ~oRf_rnn~d, will ':'°on ~sappear in J)r~ tice. So long ae the locaJ nece~sary t (• ~!tempt lwitl10~,t delay 11n effectual advance. in the direction rnst1tut1ons. ~etam the1r • st~ong offic1a com _ plexion, ~ . pie : woul(\ of Local Selr-Goven~meot. ! • naturally hesitate to confide m them. ut before these •institution$ I I j ,; ll()W five ye~rs since these words were written and the Govern~re entrusted with the initiation and cotjtrol :of Primafy _:E:ducatio~, · ment ,,f InJia are ·yet rlllt.(uring proposals for makiug an advance in if they are made more pop~lar and repre\l8.nt.alive, the •.,people wou14 this dirt•c!ic•n "witbfittt delay." The reluctauce to reYive the old be glad to co-operate with them anq. . would eveu to willing to village (,r_g~~is11tion 11nd t:) establi~h village paucha!at,s i~ parti_cul~rly bear the impositi~n of a !!pecial ~~ w1ichill be _ e• . • r..;.marked for prononnrll m sume fronnces, while a degree of tardrness Ill considering the pnrpose of being devoted to Prima Education. :I may point propl•!'als f()r the ef pnnsion of local and municipal administration o~t that when, i~ the famoua D8'patch . f 1864, Sir - $hades W 00(}• coupkd with the oft-teputed desire to hedge further advance with laid the foundation of the system or pu~lic education,! a memonblit orer-rautious restrict jons, is noticeable among all grades of adminisadva?ce was ~ade. And ~- the aut,orities with ·~enuine atates-r trati,,~ antlwrities in llodia, Lord Morley quoted the memorable words manlike : fore81ght, recognised that l England's prime function of Lord Rip0n that is primarily with a view to improvement in India was to superintend the tranti,uil elevaticn iof the · moralin admini str11tion th ~t this roe~ure is put forward an~ started ; it is and intell~tual standard ·of life .amont the people; 1 ·fail to see' chiefi)- desinble as aq instrument of political and popular education," any plausible ~ n t_ha~ could I adduced agai11st m~king a and that there is littl~ chance of affording any effective training to the mo_dest and cautfous. beginmng to . in1!1'oduce compul~ory and free pt'Ople in the mana.gement of local affairs or of the .non-official Pnmary Education JD selected areas tha~ may be conaid,,red to be ripe members thereof taki~g any real interest in local business, unless ~~ i ' "they are led to feel!that real power is placed in their hands and that i. thr)· hare real respo~sibilities to discharge." Tn:1 PUBLIC 8Bav1cB iC01uuse1011. The Royal Commission on Decentralisation which submitted it.s The ques~ion of th_e_en1pl~yment of [ ~ndians in' th,~ higher and repflrt shortly after !this, fnJly endorsed Lord Morley's views and ~ore respone1_ble pos1t1ons . 1n . ~e Pu~hc Service o~ this country ~si~ted t~at the !i)lage should be made the starting point of publio 1~ not a ques~101;t . of merely 1ndmdual ~~eers, but ia lone of much life rn India, th_at Til~~ge panchayats should be revifed all over . th~ higher and wider importance, Not to I speak of the : material and conntry as the first uµ1t of Loe&! Government, and that the constitn~onomic d~in tb~t the ex~lw,ion of I JQdiana from f higher tiJu and functions o~ other local bodies should be broadened and 10 the publ!c aemce of their own co~otry involves, iJ is repugnant liberalised in ,arious l "'~ys. The I_mperial and Provincial Govern1 ~ t~e nat,on s sense ~f ,self-res~t. With th~ growth of ments have been cogitatmg over this part of the recommendations ~ntelhg!nce •~d s~lf-oo_n~1ousness &mfDg the peoP,le, their ~ now [or_ orer fou_r y~~rs, and repeated inquiries ·in the Imperial a.nd 1s ~~ 10cr~10g-d1spoait1on on their tpart to compare t.beir own Provmc1al. Leg1slat1re Councils have not. BO far elicited · any that of the other natitjns of the world and to position with llJmpatbetlc assurance aa to the recommeDdation11 being likely regard their_ prese~~ political status• incompatible ;rith,the rigb._ ~o be c&rried out i~ the near future. The latest annonnefment of freedom and equality conferred on the!m by .the Britill)i Constitution l8 tb!t the Governm~nt of India have suQmitted their propo1als to ~nd guaranteed to them by British ~radilione. In ithe worda the tSt>eretuy of . St.a te a.nu obtained his approYal, and that they Sir Thomas Monro "the aim of1 the British ~ini•tratiop would ,,bvr .ly . rntr9duce the neceesary legialaUon for carryinr of _ ~q6ia . wu to be . to raiae t.h~ _minds of i the natiT., them out. It 1s not! easy to anticipate what - these propC1Ml1 are to raise 'their character and to render th~m worthy of rfillliig higher hut the Cong_ress h~s a rigM to demand that the Oommi.Nion'~ 11it~tione in _the management of the fOOntry, so ~i: falla-, recommendations shc)uld_he fully carried ovt, aod \he propoeal. of of time I nd1an1 would be able •to . f~me a nguh.~ GoTeroment fnd1a should be placed: before the . ublic u a the Go,e,nment for themaelvea and to condud and p~e it." We ) f~l that W:• whule and n~t P1~f meal. We mu.&t -.impreaa n on t.£e OoTernruent that thl _ s quest~on should be '-awd .... pa_. pf _ • · are not in this respect tteated . ill ae,cordanee with i the • tpirit of · 7 Y" · · n o a progreuive ]"", l 1· ; t.he proo~amatiooa an~ pro~ises •~e ! b; the Briti,p : SoTereig.._, po ltl(a po icy &nd as one of more admini.etratiTe . exigency. &he ~arbament and reepoDB1ble M.1nme11. Jt. ia, theref on, . • matter PR111f,tRY A.SD TzceN1C.AL EDUCATION of 11~~ p1-aure and great aaUafaetion to ue tu,a& • a Ro,-! Tl'.t> uur~st the a~ept' over the ccuntr:, from on~ end- to the CopJmuunon nnder lhe able Ohai~ahip or Uiati eminebt aa<·-··vot~ier ~s a. thrng o_f t~e pad: at a.ny rale1 we are no Ion r f&CG to 11m~the.tic , •tateemao,. Lord lalio~n, bu been I •p~inted to fate with 1t_s turgid iwatera and dangerous and iosiclio:: cnmnta., enq_utre .•~to the .q\\e8t100 _ of Pn~lio i Wi~oat in u1 but l•nly With se>me cir-the evils that have lain beneath the 1urfaee way ant101patiog ~ recom~Ddabon• it may makt. I cu •'i ~f 1he ucm-H and a!re now discemible. Now that' the storm hu th•~ the manner in which ~ Commmion began -to !tue mdnee ~tp'.ly pamd aw_. Y, let ns addreae ourselves -_ to th . of dunng t.he oo1d ~~ amf11 j~ifta the ho_,. that it will th uud~rly~bg evils in the ,ray theJ oagbtc t.o do jDlltic:e to IDCJ1u1 whd U OOlllfl to f~allte ita 8,iull •ooDO!aaoae. a - _l't'eu a i;tt>addy ipcrt>asing feeling on the t .f h b of ._i. la wbioh bel1 ....... .i. i)f d1_,;,,atisJactiuu 1'it~ their slmoundi~gs and • t pBQ_ple, )urrng for a bettt>r l aod more bearable existence E;en ~ 1a1d: C~mmiaaion_ " are on con&dent the .8. th- o.,_r&.hat _- Jan.-, -., ..· i. •· •reoein .•• Mwu. . llllch _ -.· . -, _-. ·.•-· -·.•· Lordlhfp and_· vb~e~';f lll~Bt oo str~:ck by the desire manifested .Oll n . aide for co-opention tbai nbetc}a.11411 ~ fruit.I of. · •JahQan art mc:rc l1ght Ill tl1e shape of education both Prim•PT ' oder,T-L-:_,_ publiahed it maJ be food that 1"I ha-, ~ a · ' buia Pnmuy Ed r · 1 ' -,1 - • - · 111ill h•lp th uca ion, : need not say, is the remedy of nmediea that and l;tha - : muses at preeent steeped in igno~, •..,...ution tberu - lf rg_ ' t o get ;O?t of t~e. slough of despond • .ud •will teach , L- s.: -h1: !p by pl11c1ng wuhin their ttacli, through the IIMCtilllll o1 ltcrature, tl1e ~etita that would attrtHI from ado . lllrtbod ~ •Iid prinfiples ·· fo their hueditar · ~ ~g moden ii, t'\:~l>at 1l> D vf_agricul~ure and other ama.ll i11lnstr.• = o = • otud rn the~ • frame of mind that would -,.:.___,,. wit.b lf.:ff ; :>·>·, )£ ~~~~~7..-~~:i=-~7a~~·~jil~!tft~;r'.a· 118 al present. A1: die oriai1 in Soatb •~rioa hM tbe-willl ofj~ lritiala 081 . .· , ~& "°ahl :Mli'.' ~~ O: ~ i=j ~tt~afJE~1i:r~~1 EF::.SL~£:t~I~:&~ bjec~ of &he King will aot ~" a • ~ in dle . ~mi~igratioa wiU :; In; and oancliclalee from •ViGh Ooloniu be ~barred from ~ng par' in aoy oom~Ye u::amia~tion. •or en~og : into any-· of oo7nt&q. Ia making ao ~ t _appeal 18ma. of tbia to Lo lslington ~d memben of \be Ro,ral · :Comm1~on ·t o ioclod lbic~on in their reoomaaeodatioos, I 'ff,oulcl : hke _to therefore fra~ed " BChem ·for ,, UM ~ of :'• regi•1!:t.o ·•~ · 1 otlloerM b7 ~ected Indi ~nUemen ..,~~ 1'0hld .gea ~ ; ha~ ~ilitarJ edu('ati . , in . the Q"4el Oorps~ ~ar/ · ~ ~ 1'11tlw.the ~men~ ahoul :.~ ra ,ri,b aakelekJII : of a J; few, Britiati ieoeiffd • ollioera . . to gi..·ve it a at.a ·. ;·,' ..».d .y·o,n.g !·;· l.·nd. i.an · ..· • · ·. ·· ..oe .:. ".·.•·•.· ~ ldd •.· .•· grafted to it in the o inalJ way, .wi,tl) 60114 )id4Jr ~m· '$Siona a:: ~~~:~~!~:. ~in~ !':J~:al~rile~:~1 ::~;.r::r~:n; 1:::~ ~~~!ri!1 :::t~:~a:~i~:~n ~~:b:ot will M ,~ as a winning to the Colonies •nd prevent. them from fnllow ng\ the e:umple of the Union Gllver~meol h will al_so i;treoglth tbtt hands o( the Government of India and the Im~er1al ~ .: t i n mJ action which they may oontemplate to take 10 an J• b1>uJJ.• DT TH■ AlUlY, . 057 I . allied, to the qaee&.ion that I have now dealt with, is the q ·oo of higher career .for Indiana in the Army. Meeting th 01 at Ka hi 10 cloee to placea diatioguiehed as e home warlike ~ / from whom the Indian ae~~ ia largely drawn, we oan approeriatelJ - go int.o it at eome lengtti. From its . earlieat years die oongre11 bu iooloded : in ita 1'$80lationa • demand for th e 81tab¥-11manl , of military colleges in India in which natives of Jodi~ u ddoed bJ ".tat.ate, m.•'. be ed . . _aoa . an. d train•.d for •Ppoin~t. u commiaioned or non-commissioned officers aocording to ~ capacit.J and qaali.&oationa..· in .the Indian Army. _That demand aw-reoUy remai~ unheeded till the advent ·of Lord/ Canon wboee Vicaro1alty was a soooession of promi868 o.r only .. partially redeemed. You may tither broken reme~ber, Gentlemen, that · soon after his arrival he formed • "Ca«lei ~" oouiat.ing of Indian Prinoes and. .Noblemen with I b.d qllllrien at Dehn Dap. The Oongreu of 1901 held / at CalcuUa welcomed it .u the fi..,t instalment of a policy wbic~ will eolrnioate iii UH, establishment of military colleges th IUI r '1'<1nlmended by Hia Royal Hiihnea e Duke of Conrt!\a~ht, at which natives of India may be edocated aod trained th 111 for pl 0J ml!ut •• offioel'8 of • army. The · expectation wu uu, ,realited ud the Madras Oongl'888 in 1908 Niiereted it, dem~ cl, io Tie• 8 .-.iallJ of the hi.gh · reoogoi~on of the valour .... · K ing ud lit, of India.---troops · b7 Bia ·Late I mpen'al m.a)eety Edward VII, in hi.B meaap to the Prinoee and the people of • b"':L Lord Minto, true to the spirit of policy · of bia Go,emment, p~uor- on the anthorit.iee- a\ Home a aobeme fram~ by ·h~• L ip in this matter which, .~ the full 111~port ?f _hle Conocil aadf f the Commander-in· Chief. The worda 1n which he ·referred to t .e scheme, in tbeoonne of a speech he delivered aa. chairman ~ 1 912 of a meeting in London 011 A. p ril · • 2-., . , d~ • repeti't•lOD here '!;hat. speech 111Mm11 to me ~ be a remarbble illustration of b{s policy, hit bro&d. eyini-,&hiee and of hie graep of Indian . 1m1. diati -:.i.-1 h'19' · I di · 10 poi~t.& of new "' · ,. i,&.._...... career n a. ·· nd ~is Lordship said:-" l mo,& take frie iy uoeptioo to wbat Sir W. C. Plowden bu said u to my not tfa,ing ·faced t.he iq~tioo of Commieaiona in th~ Army for fodiao gentlemeo. I uanre yon that I not only faced iL, b?l that I f?nght. ~t. I 11-.-t>{.Y da'I". It wu m.r hobby the whole time waa in India &o ~t'-. ind obt.in such oommi~ona for Indian gentlemen and th l h~•)6(f tbaL I bad . ~.. It. ;ia curioll8. aL British opinion ,if !t ~ay as regards the pouibilllJ of granting commisaions is 1~ "dvane«l than it .waa • g.nen.tion ~ e .vie,n of many ~plt1 to-day are much behind the til1\fll8 in ~rn_parison wilh thoee 0 { /di11t.iriguiabl'd offl~n . even befo~ , the Muu~y. As long ago as ~SH, Sir Hen.ry Lawrence dealt. wt~ the qneatton. Snbeeqne~tJJ Lord Napier wrote • memorandum 10 188.:'> on the same snb1ect, ~ ~ ng that. tbt, G \)Hr1UDent of India bad .thn th,, matter under OOl)aiderati,Jo. Sir George ObeltMy, Sir Donald Stewart and ~ a\l lH!ld the aame news. All th@ee distinguished officers adplitted that_a greel injaat~ ~ .. being perpetrated _in wi.thboldi11g ,u.bh oommiaon• ; they n,a.in\aiood. lhat yoo.ng loduns gentl8.ak9n +1d bant gtmt.er oppc>1;tu11itHla ,ror military distioctio. n ; bnl at ~ _. wae tbeJ all laid dowo that the;y DlWlt. bot eo11:una.nd Br tieb i.roopa and that the eolotioe of the diflicuh y ftB the nwng ot: -,-c'-1 lodiao ~DMoLI in which Iudiau ge.nt.lemen ehou.ld rebeiu commiaiooe. I am afraid tblli, r-.cial antipeth~ howetf!t ~ - mu:, of I» may lhiok ~ - &N ll\ilieh "'°n~, i11 India 1 ~ . the1 ar. at Hosoe. 1 do D;Ol knl " wb.J . Bnt at an:, l"ak, 11 -.. u,1 ot do aw-a:, wilb ~ nc1al aoliJMlllii.,. ti, word of comnaaod; ~ o._ly to i...,,_ &Me ui bJ l':tamplund by con,t.ni •J'ID~J. 1>Ur lodi.n feHow,..bjeda.. ~ ., fo,~ l'll_ eu.mplt1 ud bJ eou&.ani ~•paU;y, lei* hope &hat rat'.'ial Pr-fJOOI~ may gtaduailJ ~ l .'. e d 1 1 Jo If ••1 eveaioall1 obtain command of ;t he .. regime~t. ; whiob - would •· bei .in th~ ooane of 20:years or ao. be 1ebeme ""8 ,aent. Ho~ and I it •• my earnest;; hope that i 1foold .recei,~ official san~tion .~fore J left India. ;I am BOrry to ~1 I do . not ~now what. Jias b~ppeoed. to it aiooe ibeo: I_ feel, ~owe,er, t~at i~ wool~ be unf~r/ to the Governmen•.··of India not tp . ..k.e th18 OR., port.110·1.ty of :.aay10.1 t. ha4 u far u they wer, coo,sraed, the oeqeeeiLy . for tb.e oo~mi88io~ was recognieed and the di~c~lt;, was d.~t . -.rith. TJ}e o·,··8'1positior11 to oor propoeal wu a~ Home t'' T~ · laat sentence . illnstra~ the 1pirit in. which the In~• Coonoil deaij .. _:. with India,o as~iration.•·~ ..Fortuna'811 howner, a ~oning baa ~n made by Hia I Majea*:, nominating two or t ~ Indian noblemen 0011 receotl71 and :i t nmaioa for the Indian N•~onal Congreaai to bring to : bear . ion Bia · Hajeaty'a Government. tf1;.11e · weight of th., e uoaoimooa. and.I earnest wish ?f the Indian people tor a aatiafactor,11 soh1tioo of this i1;Dportant eatio , qu n. i : i 1 Resolutions. I : The Congress met akain at 12-15' on December 2f7 , th, the attendance :being the nrqe as· yeaterdai. : The President moved I a reaolat.ioo U1at the Oongc:ess d~ired to record its sense or the great. loss ~119tained by the I conntry b7 the deaLh of Mr. Ji. Ghoaal, who / w"a a staunch ~ orker :i• tlle Oongreu cause and I the death of 1Mr. Jnatice P.R./ Snndara Ai7er. The reaolotion "" c-.rried, the -.sembly standing. : 860Qnd . Diwan Bahadur Gori~d Raghava A7er (Madras) moyed i reeotu,ion- ~ihe ! . 1 ... That .this Oon~nters an empba .tic prof.est against ihe pro,i0 ·- r 1 sions of the Immigration fAot in that they violate the promises mada , bj Ministers of lhe Sou-.h; Af.rican Uoioo: and respectfully ~rgee the T Orown to Teto thll Act requeata the Imperial and India~ Go•nme~~ ~ IMlopt such m~oree 118 wonld ! eosnr~ to Indiana / in Sontb Arn~ Just and hooontable treatment. This Oongresa : expreeaeil ita abborrenee of the croeJI treatment to wµiob !Jidians were / e11bjected in Natal in the reoent •t~k:91 ud entirely disapproves ,of th~ perso11nel , of the Committee appointed. by the Soolh African Union to enquire into maUera, aa • I two of ita members. are alread1 kno!wn to : be bi&a&ed against ndiana, and aa it doee nqt include persons !who commud · the confidence o~ Indians in ~11th Africa aod·.re. TJm ~ngrea tende_ra ita m~ _respectful ~•nb to his . Exc~Uencr , die Viceroy for his •tee~aulib pronoutk)8ment of the polioy ot ibe Gover~ment of India on /~ South A:frician question. Th~ Cong,_ reqneate the Imperial ~d Indian ~ovemmente to kak the ~ needed to redreea the grijenaeee relating;to the qnestiooa ~f the U tu:, indent.ored J.~ ,: domicile, the f)dncatfonal te.sl, th~ ..,alidi~y of Indian marriages and ol.ber qoeationa ~riog on the atatusi o'f'-IndiaM in 8011th Africa. , Tb.t. th.is Coagrejia expreues ita /warm ' and grat.eCll1. appl'(!Ciauon of *be heroic struggle carried on by ¥r. Gt.andi and bia co-workers. and calla opoo the people of this oouin ltJ of all claeeee and ereeda to cof tinae t.o 11uppl,1f.them with fuoda." 1 1 In moving t.he resolution Mr. G~vind Ragbava Ai1~ said,' 1W the 1"8801ntion related !to what might be called ~e qu~on of tlMi day and with. ouL reforriu.' g t.-0 the oondi ~~98 of Ind.ians in 84uth. Ar.rica, ihe speaker turned toiLhe quest.ion ,f principle, a n' ~who did noLsympathise with tbep) urged ihat ~ lmPtrial 00'8 • , . . coold not inte.fere with ee.lf-g<1,' Ntning oolo. m.·t!f It wu no . .. .., . ht all .. Indian.a we,e strinng , to get Nlf-gorernQ18JlL within E➔~ But before UM righla i of aelf-go,eratq" coloniee lhere fwu jo,l&iel, Indians were ouly q08il~oraiog the act, of ~ Coloaiee io i reepeet.. ri not al.lowing Judiaaa .~ - lin there: An• ..~.a&ing .~ . · ot.her argumenta. ol "°88 who wed t • ! I D ~ Uleco. .• speaker refemld to the :11ix point, mea · • .. io e&.&emeot. Mr. Gokbale. Tbe1 '!'an&ed that .~ racial bar ahoald !be ..-o South AfriCllQ Incii:arul ;IIJhoold ha.'. e &bejrigb, &o enw .. 7 ·;·· the.righc. of dom~ile sb:•. oold be f'fllBto . red . ; the. abolitfo•.'u of~. ." .·. td . ..:; lae , · ncogt1ition of In
  • D bad been gi~n by th~ . All-Iodi.·a ~~e.m ,· • Lea . Pl •· . :.~ . . it.· w.· o.•-al11 . .·.·. @-OpenM! ,nth the ma&ier oommun1ii fo-r the ad'hDOellleot .· --4 regeneration or the country. He reg fCI tlaia d e ~ u a ~ mark in the history of the oount.ryj Some W ~ ..~ . thM!b would be impossible for HindWI and M<>11atnedau to uite &Dd ~k to th That redi • · had · ge er. P otion been P Ted fa1ee. l' : Mr. Sheugiri1 AiJ81', in anpporti g,: •id that del~ had objected that the reaolation waa ha iliatiog to the ~ j ngreea. lie failed to see h.ow it wu bomili.'atiog io ·lhe .• . Con~ .• BGt M,a.it the Congrea were hmniUated by the on on of the two ~ collllllWliitiee of -India, :that bumili•tion 'ft8 c1eai le. · i Mr. Khare. in aopporting, • uid, ~e wu glacl toi• a obanp;ia attitnde of the M:Ollem Leagae. Fqm .etleUI bad · beae1M frienda, and b7 tb~r _onit1 they . wool in the D~ t~ww ao'hltM'· aelf-goYernmeat ,ntbin the EmpiN. [ · · . !· 1 Mr. ;;waou, . in 1op.porting• • .nd~•• .i it.hat I in hiaopin_: io·•.D• .· .tb• India National Congnaa wu entering ~ 1 into a Delf i Dativ1'J. '1"6e Io:li&a National Ooogrea is bound Ito aobie-Ye a oew aaUritJ, Ile ·..«.• w before a tribunal ~fore whic!J they all ha_d to stand one day. T... ooly way in whil'h tb~t trust_could be exero1i,ed ~as the wa! _tu~ by Lord Hardioge. IThe Viceroy hacf-felL the weight of the 10Jusl.u,_ .sod had thrown o~ i:ese"e and risen equal to ~he ocouion! aa the responsible bead of I ~dia. The speaker asked Indians to shield the Vioo-oy against the ,itoperatiooa of opponents. After briefly referring to the disabilities l~ns in South Africa, Lala Lajpatrai made a i!irriag appeal for fdnda. ~~/ Mr. Choudhari i~ tmpportiog the n,solotion said that they formed ode • •1 • b t b aelf . a component part of m rn cm zation, t a t ~ . -eonc1ouso888 that pervaded the !world also foood a place in their hearts, and tha~ being as they weJ'1l · they legitimately uked for the ~me position 1 as other colooista iot "ithont effort. Indians had aaorificed tbeir life-blood for the ~;mpire, _and what bad the Boers done? YeHhe Boors had been giren privileges of self-governing colonies while Iodi&ns bad ·been J ompletel.7 denied cit.izenabip. In concltl8ion be uid that their derband wu for jusl.iee and their firm determination ,,,,._ to get jttst.ice f_njm the Imperial Government. · 9f °~ . Oo~ · · J • ,· :• laome lhb·: i nwel8wTbe~~NllOl-D' ..·•!°reU:,ean _wuanoarned . te·.• nd, b1t.;t M hbbped . .to aee th.• •, f,.rai.. ti~n of Up .. -"' J' for the goo~ of the . I,alacommon Goverdha~daa of country ibe Punjab and Mr. Sahai of Bilhar, 1111pp0tted tb o reio)ution. -- ,f 1 0 00 0 _ Kr. Bh_anADdra Nat.h Bua moTecl ollowina, &be ~Q&ioa: &fore the reimltttion wu adopted, the P;_dent anooonoed that be had received a I m ~ from Japan wb·ich said that the Indian N mmunity in tha~ country had . contribol.ed Ra. 5,000 and they -o r-- . ' i&a nnaj ~ O D: 'ot. • ~ t .. lhia Oongrtm · pa.. OD 11 ,t;~ · :e:omplet,e .o~ . ad!:.t '°. :JI~~ , -~~.the;· · !· . · . ~ . ·L..·.Bmpin eap . ·.•.° ' = .•.·- ....... w..t •·.· · °' o1 ..u; .* . . aceonl tfith·the belief lhal League ·hat IO empbatiolllJ 1;,1:i:::: r::::t ;;:r: S~~thp:CS~~~t ~e an'°no~o~::e i~ _&id of South ffrican Indiaos woaj__d be collected after Ute day's s1tt10g was over. Mr. Bbupendra! N,at.b Baen, in monng • resolution oa Hindu and Mohamedan un1Ly. &&id Uiat it waa no eaay t.bing for the Koelem Leag ut> to ha~e _pobliel1 d~lared the adoption of• the _jdeal of aelfg,n ernmeat wlthm j he E UJptre. In the put ibat ideal fo,med . the subje<.:t .of stro. ng. riticisqi, not on.I.y from. timid ...Incli&Di .. .· bal. from hig h otnci.Is iu t ho l,nd, When such was the at.Lit.ode of offlcula, 01turally s0me .of t.he Iet18 advauoed, \imid and bNitaLing Hoalema we~ _mor-e caution , and took time to cooeider wb.t wonld. be Uu,ir P'1j lt w n ~ . regard' the Congress. The: speaker congra~ the 11.,,.,_l~m Lt>11.gne for ~oolaring publicly Uiit Iudia '"\loold not riei if they ._·,rntrn ed thtims.lresi to a separatist policy. Last ,ear . the Moelem Lt'ague _adopted "'iholeheartedly the position of the If t\wy ,_ Hmdu~ and I Mohamedans. 00 ,, a&ood faee to flOO there WM rfitlnn~ t;:i st,1 p t~e Congrese from ,tretcbing baild of fello-.hip to tht' :!lfo~liltu League. Appealing to lliodaa, be _ . . . tolen&ion. • Oo•sn-. .-\ pp,!ahog to. Mo;ilelna, ~ au . ed. tbitm lo regard en,u •..• .· . • • . : " · • aaJ. a., p?\>a.:hed ~by M~hamed. In conolmion, lh. Baao ..W: ., Now, br't'tb r~n, H1nd11S ~d KohuH!d&o-. io oar- huada U. • deian '.of our 1.' vmruon coantg. Wbe&her we belong to the · noe OI' ~ '"° hc ther "" belie,, in dM rHelatiooa of lbeOi .. oroftbeQ.,,u. "~ hr.ve tt&;; •n to ~ pund of onr put~ia India. ·~ • ucl •~ Shahjahu en namkwhielurill , _ . die._ t~rn,ium of •ny ~ and ·1841d laatre OD UM, rono.... oC ..., ·..... 1 h" M_,igb.ul Emperoruall the rilioa of a aaiMlcl I~.._ Ul141t th~. 1eg11 of B.rit·i•h,., rule., 1-&, u realiN .· tJl-1. Titaoo .· . · •.1 vur ,•,_,u ™• il lt:. !l .a ud MIi dilloeJ&. _. illt iW i.lr.gupta, Akbar ~d r declared ai ite lut 1N1Uion1 that -poli~ical f ~ or the• ooulrJ depends on lhe barmoaiont workio~-~...,.U~ !of Uaei varic)• coun:pnnit.i.·ee . in ·t!M · ~a~'."• whiah ..· ~ .· lhe aherilW . . .· .•i tbl .• . or.., Congrea _ Jbill _0c)agrela moA b · · ~ weloome1 · ~ •\ope upNMll!N b7 the Leigae ·, Iha& the .1-kn, of I the dilereot cpo•mGDtllea ..II make eY«J eodea:roar .. .t() &nd ..~.,,....,di for MN•~,ud oonoeriei action on all ·. 4...-.0• of Ddioul ~ aed to lall ll«'Uona of Uie.people to be.IP tlMl ob~ ft .U baYe at~•• · . J . 11:r. O. A. E·. Bam-.nm1 Ai,- ~lladru m~ • mgiag the ~ of ,&be jadioial fl'Obl ~ e ·,. faoo&i~• and the pleoiDJ oUhe jadioiuy aader aoo&tol of bigheai oocnt in 8ffrJ p,oti,ac,e. Aa i\ 1'U a11 old ~Moa the • er O()ll8oe4 hi....U &o poiq&iag 0G &he erila of the oombiu&ioa lW'O fueuo-. aod UM urpec7 of their aeparauon. '. .• , t,,.llr. Oh~ of Beapl ·• speaken ~ - ..~ · . ,,.. ~ ! ....-,:appMII rm+ K._... •·Gdt=t· 1 · : : · · ~Lni10• u ~•• 8ac~urua · • 81'4'9 ; Kr. Jiuah IDOwd •:.-.Illtiha Dg th . · • .•• . . . ..... . . · . .. ➔• .;..i-. • of ... ~ Gt; SW.<.... , ..-, · .·' , . , .4Y'id big •. . . . . . . . . ...·.•.·.·. ,. :• tlue:: (•·.· . .....· : , mast ....._, GI ..... ':for i.la . . N .<•·•.l ..... ...·. _..,•··•·• ..·.·,.•· . . · ta .· . ..... .'. ~... ··. · .,._II * ' ' . al,.. . .•·, .' ·· GO tilt ._,._,, ..r.,,~ - ,, • .. apa.t;'W 'JI-..... .. .,..., . . . . . • ~ (,)i ... die w.1 ..... of!> . ' ,o,· ~ _.. ,_ •.._,: .,....iia t ~ sf; ~ -,... .... Ii" ~ ... . •..~_· .·.-.·•· .·.·. ·.1.~..:·[ ].··•~ .·'. :~.·.•.. ,• .I.:,···· ., .. ,_,.• · If'. ·,,.. ' iLIIIIIJl.-11,p._!l I ' :a--: ,. ~.:: =·~ ::::.•:; ,:..z:.::-=.~ Oae-. O . · , •i.i.•.a e ~j~~;:~~ -~!~~\~~~~:: ..!.";:':!t ... i· · i tlli•tvnlfotru~ntt~aotpeclel&al.eoowt.iol • • a,lal reoognia • ed_ Mr. M. T. Kape~bhoy of Bombay, in supportiog, said .that so long as the idea:rem!l.inedlwith the White racr,s that; they were aopei-ior to Indians, so loog w~ the trooble1botind to continue, and lbey could only get rid of it by !bringing about a complete regeneration in India in 1( --~ lt ·l I ·,i ~ ~ ~.:• i • . .•• ,: ;,1;~~~;:t::) 1 abonld co ·at ;of public mu of merit and abilit1, nncoaneeted ,nth tbe Jodi admimration ; U) that the' remaining portion of the MD1ioat CoUDeil ehonld . ooosist of o~ciala who )um, se.n:ed in Jodi• tor ot tesa·that 101eare. and, have not been away fro.... India for .1DOre than twojeara; (g) that the ·character of the Council tshoold be adTiao and not administ1atin; (h) that lhe term .of office of ach mem r -1)oold be the years:• Mr. J 11 nab, in moving the resolution. described how the Council wu coos ti -cted. There wu no place in the Council for the advocation of tlie , 8 of non-dficials, because the Council _11'&& cum posed e»tirely f officials. a~d it ought__ tb~relore to be abolis_Led. The Council as -formed m l~and 1t should have been refom1ed long ago. --- ~ _ ., ~ 1 Qf ~e .Oote_.•_r_n_me;n. t of In_.di . _·•._ an ___ _ ,_ :h_,t.i.~_-_ J t_d__ n._ · _-_-•,a_d_•_ _ '_>_ ,et-.·_ -:._'1_----~•_la_.__-_:_•-•_Jld'. at ie__ w~u-·_h•__ppe ·- ned i_P: 1~_10. - -·-: ~ - - ~--• Indi_.~ i •.- _ -_i_ • _aa _ -__ .' li _ _ ·_ b·e:-~ai_'e· _-.· r_; . Yl _· \_ ·_. .·_:._ 1827 am1deW:m!~tan~ ~f . :t ~lem~tt, ~th :a deol.~ tjtin; : f boldl_r l_?O_~ed -th~ fntnre__ 10_ the f•.-. ce" _} T_h_e_ '3&1' _ . If _ !_-, nlfml ____ :_ of, ,J n__ ilia___· :·_- tre' · not_ bDl14 µi.en, lJ'e~ not ;fnght n~~.f shado~ not imen lf~o. e : itcf · \heu bearta on thei.r sleeves, n ,me~. who ' tropbled themselves-' iitb Continent11l ano~ogies, not me w~o:, ran ,to ~-11Stria or ~nesiatfor models of Goiernment. _ T e! : r~scued , lnji1!1 from . mi~rule : nd anarchy, they w~sted th_e dom 010n of India f~om the French -• ._ ey wanted to give r_ ndia the bene ts 9_ B __ritish ad~ , in_ str~tion_i they w_r~nt-_ .- ed to infnse the ,country with t e Spirit of BJ±i.tish rule. T~ose ,l,ere ?1en ''.110 wielde .•~ alike the sw rd- a. nd_ the_~en, .:an_d we.re at_h_ome- j _ lik-~10 ~h~ busy ha~nts of men and. n the .eec~u8lon ff the CouncH Oba ber. _ ° .,_-" __ t ___h ~ 1 1_· r_ - Mr. Samaith, in sec'cnding, thought that they -we!e righ1, in This is what Sir•. Charles .·r .of -th--e Ind-•ian -_ -~~e_s_' . th - Metc~Ife· • t_ h_e libe_ra.to_ eaJing ():at it wot Id be a retrogade step to d1ange , the present said to a depotation that waitea~ on him in 18~7~ Referring to t ose" th ad,·irnry Council into adminidrafrre bo_ dy. One oI the n.·tal proposals who ~ere oppoSed ~o e remo al of e licens~ng laws for the P ss, L t f tl C h ]d be be wd: "If ~heir argumen be true that th~ -spread _of knowl ge iD this eso 1ution '\lRS t at a por ion ie' o~nci 1 ' ou may be ultima~ly fatal to our rule in India, ![close with the_m on hat nominate and tht'n duh elected. All that be ,mhed to say was 1echon. that a fnflhn adnnce 1,}wuld be mad e 10 representation Y e our duty communicate the bate ne6te If India . . b one poin-t to and m•-ainta-in- -that, _ v-_ ,_ofm-knowledge. ay be•:·_t -h•·- e -conseque_ n-ce, I. itI uldis • . llr. frish~ Ram, wbc, supported, said there -was absolutely no only be preserved as a part of the British Emp~b!. keeping the notif.cat~n ll'hic~tta"Iudia to bear any po.rtion of tho expendiinhabit.ant in & state of .ignor nee, our dominion wottkl., be a _ nrse we andl the s~retary of State's _Council was in no way helpful for t-0 the country and 011ght cea,s e." These: are memorable wtrds · the admibisb .. ,ion of the c.ount.ry in its best interests. · and their grave significance slould nenr be los~ eight of. _ Unf rtu' \lr. qr,paldas ,Jhamalmal Bupported. · nately they were lost sight of n 1910, and th•~ - _Government _of. _ ndi _·a Babul Surendranalh Mullick said that Europeans were indifferent took a haa'rand hurried ste -tow~rds what _S ir Charles .Me alf& in mat!4ra which did not tonch tlieir pockets. He insisted upon the eougbt to avoid. Diel Lbey t ink what they 1rere doing by the J law -. total •t>tlition of the r.ouncil _and on its being placed under the they were yassing7 Killing edition 7 Did·[ they beli_eve that 1they direct "iaion of Puliament. If they relied wholly ar,d solely were choking off the subterra ean channels torough moisture br9'ught the nseien~ of the British people, they might then perhaps \ to t~at plant of noisesome 1 growlh 7 They must have. Bn~ the : 00 expect r )I ju.sti~ to be done to Oiem. ) question may be asked. H,ve they suc~ed T Their sucee~s is · lution 'ff&S carried. ,/ writ in large characters for th~ man who runl:l to read. And so it was The r anticipated by those whom panic and passion. bad not ,blinde~ to The ICongre&s-mel at l p. m. on December 28th. The proceed- , re.a.eon. And sedition drivenL un-dergroond i•. s _more dangerous !tb_an wgs cc,tjlmenc(d 'ffith the singing of the well-known Punjabi National sedition whose roots you can j_each with one's eyes open. We b~rred Bong. I our way to the sources of danger and, gentlemen, it was not ~8 if Sar4ar Nand Singh mo-red • rei;olution protesting against the there was no law dealing witli sedition. It ~as not as if we ha~ not prohibil ton of Indian immigrati?D to Conada resultin~ f1om (be ctinsucceeded in suppreli8ing bewsp&pel'.S which were offending/ fa tinnons oouroey clame and urgmg upon the Imperial Government Bengal, the "Sandhya" had Igone, the "Y~gantar" had gone thethe neceissity (If securing the repeal of that regulation. The speaker "Bandemat.aram" had gone. f S~r.Her~rt. R,sley declared in a s~ch ,aid t instead of bringing glad tidings, Christmas week had that out of 47 oases for bed1t10n instituted under the law• then IJr-ought, a deplorable tale from Canada and other Colonies. In this existing, the Government ha~ secured 1' con ~iotion in every o~e ot matter SikM--.llUe feeling tha, injoslice bas bten done to India and them. What more could bei wanted 7 The!answer was given i that that thel tr-eatroent accorded to Indians by the colonia~s waa unjuat the prosecutions involved treat labour and much consideration. and crutl, a.nd lhey were condemning with one voice tbe colonial Consequently the Government wanted a sweeping m~~ej not atrociti~s. After citing instances of tLe tioublea t(! which Indians causing BO much trouble. Alias I the blindness of rnlers and bf :men t were su~~jeeted in Canada, the speaker prayed for the intenention of How hnman foresight is apt ,to be v.ain, bow ; human 11cbemes the Ooverntj.,ent. wrong way ! Gentlemen, ,ou will allow : me to pass to aj otber ·: btanch_of the eubj~t. The ovemment of I_· ndia bad t-0 pnt a salve : Mr.! Krishnt. E.mua.r Mitter, in seconding, uid the world waa th T'l-i b d tO ·11 0 th ' e British public on err own conselence. r_ey a reco_ _nc 's li!nd all men had the right of free ecce88 to all parts of it. This &nd a Liberal administration They bad to 're-enact what Gla4stone God ek-men ~ary truth had ~en forgotten- by many races and · countries, had helped in removing, ~ndj who could find for them more pl~usible and thif was the root cau~ of the -troubles of Indiana in the coloni~ reaaons than that keen, gift~ and astute scholar and politicia~, Sir That in~incere and co"!rdly _law, of the -eon_tinuo~ journey regulaHerbe.rt Risley? .1:Je broug~~ into ~uisiti~n the laws prevailirg in Lion, passed because Indians,::-were aober, tDdll.Stnous -~d ,frugal. Aus~rta, the condit.1ons of wl1ch he md we~ similar to Indi~ forM.i~ .Ayub Khan., a proajnent lead~r o.f the :Mahomedan Commngetting that Austria-Hungar, had _their D;iets and th•t Mi?isters : nity, sqpp<,rttd the reaolutW)~ in a fo~i~le _Urdn speech. The Mir could be removed. But lhek-sligbt CODBide~tions do not aff~t our. had hit~uto attended Congre&& aa a 1'18llor bot wu eo moved by the rulers when they ~ra" •u~ogi - • _ fro _ m ~~e C.•-ontinent of _Euro~for lut i,,? daJs' procefdings that this morning he had bjmllelf iegisthe enactment or 1ntroducho'1 of a retrogade or reactiona,-y ni re. tered ajde!tga1e, and took part in the proeffWD,P, He ea.id that hia But, sa.id Sir Herbert, we ini]ndia shall be better off than in A Im. ' aJmpalbies had alway, been with the CongNM, The.re bad alll'a:,11 T~e Bill doe11 not propoee tq confer any po91'.er on the police. ! They bffQ ~ ruetbing against Mahomedalll. but since t.he Coogreas · bad w~ll ~ absol~rt~Iy o~taide it ~d will hne [nothing whatenr doutend~d its band to Mabomedns, the latte.r were willing to join the "'1th its adnnmstration. I lhink there is i difference between the , Co 11gnju. The 1'elfare of the . nation co_ :o1d not be attained without polict1 and the C. I. D. T~e one is open ipublic, the other ~ the Mnt labours of the two great ·communitiea in India. Be aub.t erraoea~. And Sir Ht ~bert was onlj thinking of the lpublio : appealid to tl1e people to contribole to the South Atrican and polic., keepi~ the C. I. D.i lD reea _ ne. _Ho~ i1 the_law_ admini,teredt ; Canadi•n Fundll. --,, Aa BO-On a& an application i6 made for re~stration the ma~te · P~ndit Rambhnj DuU al.IQ supperted lhe l'fl()lulion which waa re.fers it to lbe C, I. D. an~ upon its repofti depend~ the fate .newspaper or the pr8'8, Tije.re are many _Bffll&meo in tbi1 _,_'1bl1, c,uriedi The1 wil.l cornet meif I am wrong. But f Sir Herbert had ' :11hu~ndra Nath ~a.su movtd a ffllOlution protesting against .noL only to throw dust in ttie eyes of the i'British public. 8 bad ! the to!'.ltmuaoce of the ~ndi~ P~eea Ad on t.he ~~tute .Book ~d also to reintroduce on a I m11Ch larger ~e whai G _ _ bad., urging i~ ttp«I, u~1ally in ."1ew of a recent decwon of the High repeated. namely, the Vernaicnln Preea .Acti of 1878 and be • &ed : Coorl jof Calcutta wbKlh h~ ditdoeed -f:be fact that ~e &&feguar~ out, the differe~. It wu ilot like he PNfi Act of' 18781 a purely ! pror.d;ed bJ the Ad ~el'e- 1ll~~y and •i.n_cap.bl~ ~f ~lD8. enf~.\ exec _ utire measure. The i~t.iatiYe indeed '_ reeta with tJ)e ex aUff ' He said: "I am dMl1ng now w,1th '!'hat wa,e • pie« of p&nlC leg1.1!aGcm•.rnmllnl bnt ample aecg:jitJ againat bu~ or arbitf'U'J · 'oo • · tion. ~ The Oournmrnl ?' I ndi.a ~1th all oth~r G1:1nrl)~_11u, w1lh proTided in the form of :wba, ia rirtoally an appeal &o a _ highly : not. a~w•y• tM1 co~Jeo~. 1• liab!e.·to ~tc , but, unlike ol.h er 0011,pdent. judicial anthorit~. Thia noi all. _ Thia doe, , .-& : ~OTfll!~n~•• tbe ~onrnmeut !'! B_ntit1h India motit not fo~ that on the elwin~ U8orance of an aaiute etateai;nan. The Law .Wi at the time, ,rbou hone.i., ~d candour an,! abote all o.uo~aaicl. 1u ~ t i ~ ~'. peculiar ~d nvthing -~- mort cakulaW to do l8 harm ~ ° 1 • to 'f ie l so 1 tbt' gp 1 ·_••' i/ ~ :~ ; G~~ C9ur · .~di ·A cti t11e 81 the tby _tl the o nigar uig t come .reg that say t becat it wi: grav1 lie OJ forci U1 a Briti 11ati1 cons that appE CO\tr Part and para a do diad tei-t thot it c, l111v, iu I l,-1\ll b ,u 111 -li IC:tl tlw lil c to, ! , J 1 • "f Ito Pul iuc1 1ml C(1l 8 t't lin1 jud l'C81 tl,11 be I Inc dee _e~~ Rwe, Mt. •µ w• ! ~ ta 1~ _ b1 ht1 to ~~and no. _ lh1og _ m~. du -geroQI th-anbaat7 _,.o~ a~ri-U:•n in ftar or an~ . ., Sed.iUOD JDa)' ~ like th.a- u .a _·n linat~ of tht ••od. aa&tth,1 may raa• lit D.la&W locb 1n dark and ~ol~. wrnu,, but lliat ma, alAJO gt,, but .•hat it ~ • ~ _DM go ~ tM! 11111,>ttta.ioD that• ll~ful of boyt Wtila •_1ploai,ee 1.n ~ taD-~la and • · firw hy.,tt.ric&l tw••paP41" cu cliat,ub tM tqllih'bria:m in _ worda of g r eat e mpbui ·a.i that be had _ p~ Tided _ ., _ i g•· u u-d 8 _~ -- - _-_ would make a Local 0o ..~IDetlt beaitaie bieron it rDMM u. al' fodeitare. because thff9 -. ' a -.ribaul .,1.;..\. wooJd ·t ' ·- t could re-...ne i~ deeiaiouJ Then ,,..~ther - ~ Uadlti ' toction • of the Act, the O~,ennnat woal4 have &o l&a&o mi word&. ai&'D& or · n.f>neeD · · n,.. _were _ · .... ! , riabW ..a: u.· .! : lh1 Ill• 001 WIii Mc, A &II ... it-r The Comrade. 10th janual'Y· guards. · The Local Governments. wonldr have to· particularize the offence and 1her._, would be tl~e right oi appeal. . ,vell, no L~cal G) eruttl<'Ct did set out particulars. In a recent .case the· High c:i~rt ,,f Beog11l hel that the declaration of forfoitu~ was inYalhl a~i.d ill.,•gal. . But. tip i.11~11tlidity was proh,-c.ted by Sectwn 22 ot th.e A.. nd tlw High ljonrt had no power to mterfere. Thei. as regards 11:: ~:frgmirJ of ap1*11l, this is "·.hat, th? Chief ,Ji]stice has said: • •·Of 1 tl 'two t:!1e<•t·d checks Oil execut1n~ action supposed to be forn1shed b. ll·.t' • \. ,t ~rne lhetlinterventiou of the conr.ls,. is ineffectnal, while tte r:,r this rn y reuson cnn b,·, _and in t.his case h~. been. disn-gardeJ. 1\S the GO\·ernment of India is, ;'.~1i:/ t fun•.•ig.n i.11 itol,t'Ml.1pn·iti,,1.l'c\ .• ,nd"n lo ,of·i,n !ts ch~racter,' thnt·· . . ··th.at .. law. u; I!, ",nrcv ,,i ,_:;rl'i\t >rido (.~iit,.,f{ 1s agarnst the sptrJt of the Bri:i,h Com;titutiu11 that it is derognt<,ry to the self-respect of a usii,,ll, a peorle f you will', which !s fast de\'el~pinQ." its, self~ Cllll,,i,,t:~nt·,,, a11,l \lie Fay, fill the uulhority the. luglwst tr1bnual that the su ft'i.::u1uds 111rposcd to be pnn-inl_ (1f Lord Hnrdin.gc, who _hils ~hown 8 collnll.::,· iu Iii,, l1t•n1111e11L nl gnat and bnr111ng quost1011s hke~ the Psrtiiivu 1 ,f Bt<11gal l11nd thc·griern11ct!S of lmlinns in S, )uth A£rict1 1 an,l " ju,t indi:,.;1;ati,\n ,,rer tl:e Most~ll: bungfo in Ca:Ynpore, oom- of of paw. \.;,. •.,uly ''. ith _t·l!t th·•·\ .'.:nrly u.J.m1~rn,tr.at,,)r,:;. I.·ntlm, to r.. emorn 11 durk 1u,cl in:.:\: 1?:1 s s!lut 111 .~,!mt 1s 1ustly regardt',l us the brightest ditl,,, llL rn tl1t' l,r1ll:, l nrnu. ~!r. l'. G. h,h of B(,mla_y, in ;-econuing the res,;lution prouL:ain,-t the cunt in atil,n of tlie lndian Prtcss Act, said that tL. Ii,, l:nd ng1 rJcl " ith tl,e g(•11ernl pl'iuciples of this Bill when it cc 1u· <>ll iu tht· ~jntt;t,: 11,.1 k~, l ,~ was of ,>piniuu that it shf)u1d b: 11,'tnll rqt'uh·d!:.fter f,,m J?a1s. He said the Press.Act was i11 wt.it,, ,ti 11h 11 tlaj1e wm, :-(•,Etin1 in the country. N ow that the 1 pu,:r 1 \ t I, 1I \' lL.1, :--Ii, 1:\ I l t' l (! eale(l. s..: .•n( Ll anarchy und Lu: l•.hi l\,, d 1i11g ,,, ,1,, with the Pr,•~s in !;t'ni•ml. Tlro I' '" I!,, ,,i·J ,,111;t,! , 11 in a haphazard 11,.: :,, ,. 1, .. , ,, t•t,t u! tie i.,,1,,•r 1- 111,nld he nnder 1!.,, ,.Lei 1 1::, , t t 1• 1 i,~h C, ,a t . [ n d ii111,; lii,;hly ch,•ii:,hod tho lil ,1 1.1 , l titt· 1·1, as it" whid1 tLe .\ct g:1ne cherk. ! Ja!'. , Other resolution, we~ adoptediprayi ,g (ol{~• peffi1aoeot land ... settleme ·. t • in ·• rtotwa,. • ~ higher ranks in t.be ,Arm)j to Iattians, (o, in compulsory education~ for *he e&tablishm nt ~f: ~~\i supplementary to the existing ani.• ersiti •• Jot makµia }pro~,.rout .· foi ~ , frlle ~:.~~};(;.~~:~.~;ti~,~,\·: !' The 11ext resolution gare cordial suprlort to the 8Jrad~hi mci~~~ 'and another resolution nrg:ed the total ptobibition of th~ i of lebonr under in~enture whether for Indi11 or Resolutiop praying for an increase I of the powera bodi-., the re,·bion of the Conncil Regulations, the establishme~t of Et.eoll~ live Councils in tl1e United Provincels and the Pnnj11~ were moved from the chair. I · · ·1 The Pm:!ident moved another rer:mlnt,on anthorisin~ the All-Indi• Congress C(,mmiLtoo to arrange for a deputation to Englnnd to rep.ntr sent Indian views on tbe South Africi qneAlion, the Pl,"e&'l Ao~, the reform of .the India Conno,,il and tbe sep~ration of jndicl,al an.d ex. eotl~,:.· tive functions. , I : Tho Congress next recorded its ,ense of appr~inlion of the senices of Sir William Wedderburn an other members.• of the British•. Committee. A resolution was mo\'ed by the tlmt the follgwiug message be sent t1l Mr. Gandhi and was carritid ufnanimonsly : , "Thll 28th IndianPNational C,m,~r.j~s, K11rachi, ~xpres8es deep indignation at the ill/treatment of India11 strikers in.Natal and accords its cordial support· to your request for th~ extension of t~10 composition of the Enquiry Commission by thH addi~ion of two gentlemen enjoying the confidence of Indians in Sonilh Africa, and fervently trnsta that your demand will be satisfied so I\:! ~o seJ · ~flocal 1 • Cl;alir I : Rai Baiknnt. N:Lth Sen, in moving , resolution ex~ressing regr~t at the retirement of Mr. D. E. ,vaehn 11md ?!Ir. D. A:. Khare frotn the ollice oi Gei'1ernl St.>eretaries, paid nl mmn trilmto to the signal seniccs renuered by them. ! Mr. W11d1a, on behRlf of hinH,t•lf l\bd Mr. Khar~, thnnked tl:&6 nndienro for 111•~ kind words ot f•\'aise s1loke11 in appreciation of tlieir scnic,•,i aml sai\l that they had only Wll)' due ,to & want · of interest. On the contrary their rntore~t wol\ld la..~t ns lontr as health permitted. As ll of Mhiceto th ~ ymmger met~ or tho Congrt•;;,, ~lt·. '\V 11eha.snid that. tho Conznl:.s had now been . 23 years in existence, tlu\t it had, passed through I many a phas, , . through · the phnses of ridicule, c<;rnt~mpt and ob\oquey, bnt th!lt it WM no" entetinr; oR a new era when it was 11ha~ing hand!! witij their MOl!lem bretlITT~. A new star bad arisen for t~1e Congrese an(} the conne of "t11is star would sha~ its ,future destiny ) l>uring its o:nwatd progreas its course would be sometimes oue of"'s~orm and strees~ Bot remember this: 11Toil 011, toil on; bnt go onifard in your :progrffl. We oan only reReh our goa! &tep by step, tlj&\. goal ~hich will crown with sncces.s. L@L it be. self-govern~~illt." , i )l t' ,1. Chn11,ih11ri, in snpportin!-(, citt>d spc1ci!ic O:\$C:'1 of hRrdships tv 1>l1i, l: l'r, ,,rnt n jrnd t. Pl'Il put unt!Pr the .\ct. ,,,ti,,n :w,1,; forth,·r ,-np; 01t,,,l by two Sindhi spenker.4, 11(1, 1 "[,,,·Ii it 1,t.s c4rried. _ U:.: 1:, :kt;i:t tath S,·n m,tH'•l 11 r,·$ ohniou with n•sped, 10 tho l't;: ,· ~en:,,,, C\,11:1rni,-,:;:i, n, 1•r111c,ting ag-,:in;.;t·· 111e diargt'.'> general it;~, 1q, t< L<1', lm·k uf initintirc nnd lm·k (If dwracter whiclt :'Ollle llllL,ns Lad 1t,wll11d against In,Unns. lL prnyed tlmt tho Royal CL u,mi.,~iun ,n,uld ret·1. mn:,·ntl an increase. of India in the higbor ai•ri.,inlrnrnt~. a sim)1H11neom f'i·Yil Srn-i.fe examinntion, t.bat. the age· limit for Ci, i\ ~ t1niee camiidatrs iebonld not be lowered that the jndie.i11l_ irnd ex~eutiie se~,·ke.s a.nd fn~clions should be 8t'~ted, tha, m,nnrtwns ugnrnst ~,p,powtmt>nts to lngher offices should be removed, ' Nawab Syed Mabammnd Bahadnr and Mr. Subba .Rao were tlrnt tl1,• di, isiP11 of pie Sen-ires into Imperial and Pr,.wtncial should appointed General Secrelariea for the 1fex:t year. MrJ Subba Rao in ki rt'uHnrd 11ml tha~ the people ot those dominion::i of the Crown whore n,ply iu¥ited tba next. Congfflll to )b~taa. fot'.1anl! _.,,,..r~. uot accord+;<:l the rights uC llritish eitiz.enit should be Mr. Ool.m Chagla. ~retary iof the Rec•J)U".pa.•·• ·•. 0.ommi~ d,·c,artd rnel1g1bh1 f?r. app01nhi1ents in India. proposed a ,ote of lhanka to the l'fflti~n, and Mid ® &be Naflb"t l n speakiug to the resoh1tit,n, Rai Baik~n t Nath Sen Mid that it preeence b• l been prodllclhe oUrnitf!ll realll&a. h ~-- doe to ~ a1igbt Dt.• asked tliat, while t.he Commiesion was going o,;-w.i.th i_ta pnu1eo~ that the., Hindu,-Moh•eda, • ~u ..-olotioo had .beieo work, wliy _should the Cnngres.i pass.· HICh a rtf.olntion 1 '1).ee ·N'DIN'p y Mlopted whose el~t. would be t.r-reaotµn, .. · I was tl 111tsenou,i .e11arg~s h~d been le,elled against Indiana and, if th. Mr. &411 IICIClOndtMI and N,oral ~~ 1up~. , Cnng rt'SS k,•pt s1len~, ll might be (.'ODStroed &8 & !partial Mbniaeion. The pneid•ot made tta. follo~ug fa>11 : - · • I and tht>ref.ore, ~hey •ere going to emj>h&iictally refote ~ · ~ T~ .. ~ be ttlt't_t 1nsl1'j1Cl'S of ~me Bengali Cililiana who hMI proYed more 0 0enLl.-n. from .~ bottom o' m7·1Nud I • ~ yoa for~ efhw,nt dun.cg th~ re.t'.'eot nnrt'8t Bengal tl1an Enr9peao .Qlagia'~•l<'$. I~ n~w of Hie progress mRde by Indians in malten of ednoa~ j:' . ·o.• ~.•· . . :. ; . t : 'i . o u . ..:,·.to . uoo, aud rn ~iew of the present policy of tbe Oonrnment. the 1peaker JOU bate dolltl me bf ei.,tiag o,_ the . ;of Uwu~bt the ~1me_ h'd come when there ahould ~ • simu1-eooa CMl o.ar Natio·nal .. ~... bl7 . ··.• ·I.~.·• 1~ · . .U, ·.forU...·~. ' . · 1,· • · . , • · · . •~-1DiM . . , . ' · &rm·t examrnatwn both in London .nd io India. ~ y o a h a.. react.edtomei•--•dilehatge•~m1_....a ,rortl or 1 i I ua i l AU 1 1 i, In Dr. Nilratan .El-car, in aecondfog, aid that UM, &rd prineipt. th•t ~b, ,u\d le rrco~oill("(} wu that India ,ru go....-oed (Qr ladiaaa 111 d tl11,t her childrtn 1hould tint be admiUtd into lff, Serrieee of the wuimy and that! non-Indiana abould ~ •J>J>Ointecl ooly •hen U..,. ".u ou com1 etent ~ndian .. od lbat only for a li nited time. The diri•m ti tb., ~mic~~ into Imperial 1nd .Protibt'i1l • • IDQP. ~ ' A .: , rm.ull·d lnuia with. a ,e,,iN ftller4 by , her OH ---•.,.. • • ~ ~;: t,.l'·' England t~an u imt~~ lndiuht>M .(W.. Pd . . . . . • ,c t' ~ 11 thl UIO~,,ix,U-1 1>7 DOtl-fo~u-~.. The, re:l())ldioo ...., ~ip,. ,r~J 1u Si~ b7 \wo K.anchi ~ ,,.,. ~ ,A 1 :.;•.;:o~o:•.·:,.·.of·.: . ·; :,.·.·.•·h.a1~.~. .· ·~.'~.·• •~~ lor ·the i..,...J01l._".,_n _.,:nNnJm,, •· . ~· I&•• •to .... ~j -.... s "i!~..::...,r..:.1:...-:.:; .,,.. :=,; ___,, fot ....... Dp .... ,,,. ~ - . . . •. . . . . . . . oely •~•·•ut•1 t,;;.;...;..~~ J..W•~ ._,._ I will 1W the, . . . ~· ... ~ .. b,, ~ ..... I ' ::-:.-:.~·_i,:.:.: .. ,~_r •.. •,,~ wmkof--,..--~,_..,..._ ...... .. . ,~ .: . uy - - t of ....... ab;.. ' i It,..... .,......... . i' - 1,-) .~ ' ) : :'.' ::> :i_ ·;u->_ > M 0,- ·if f'I;~;~p:rr' The~~;: ' towarda DAD~OU8 progress, iacladi11g =•• peace and plenty, eelf-impro.-e- The Indian National Congteas is no~ an a_ n'!aal bnt ,a an orpoiaat.ioo d ~ to atfonilat,e a~d : guide eeno'!8 Da&ional work . -in which all who h&Ye coolideoce ~ ooqotry a 1 adY&Dpe'1'tion Hd in the exe ise of the public virtu• specially demanded by ~be exoeptiooal 00 dition• of the coont.ry. · As a visible .repreaenta~ion of onr naiioorJ pintiona, ~e Oongress ••Hl attract .•od ra\ly together the best· mind among na, and eve11 ~ooal f~lnre will impel! them to ,trive 00 ard · further in ~beliefthat, for committaea as for men, &be tet\t .0 real greato688 is the , . ity for &elf-denial and disinterested devoti n to the public good. T zeal, earneatne88 · :9nd rout~ -eonfiden minifest among all that worked for the An~, of.th1s llfl88io.o • ong the delegate,, the members of the reception committee aod th; v~rnoteers,. .re nndonbted in?icalioiuf of our_ de!erminat.100 to be a u~ited nation. Let ne not l1es1tate, falter nr despair. Let us march fo~ard, on and on .. Let us be up aud down, and not rest until the oal is reached. . . Yon aTe'711e_ ~ very,£r~ recept.ion on my arrival here, and during u y 8 ta~--r6foired ~e•~ kindness rrom yon for eaonot tm[fficiently ex·pret-~ my obhgat1ons._to yon. I 8hRll-carry w.1tn rue rery happy . recollections. of yout ~1t,y Rnd 0£ yonr excell~nt, quali.tiee. , jwhioh I. a!M'. ure yon will endure till the last hour of my life. Om~ agafn I expre,.s m1 grateful thAnlts for all y~n have done to make mJ ,stay among ynu comfort&ble and pleasant. On t rn conclusion of. the President's speech the Congress was diMoln>d. t and Iidarity. m · popalal' ~ , i ~~~: ; . i ,·~•: j ~ a-:-~- I,t holds /~e co _ ~ .·•··~ w! . . :t..:~:; rivt.J.i, ft. ·tiaa cooq~md the co~otr,: ~~11888- _,•~ g~t ~o~l,- ! teas and sappers. ! _M1hner1 an d~aJc1ng ; reepoPte C()DCei -of confirmed io86mnia." The veo nutnbera retort that -grim ·• po 8 j. bilities lnrk for the too vigoro e Tango· d•u,oorboardiac trouble, • nd' muscular atrain and liability to · islocation of th~ tibia. ·•· The•~ too, 111ill soon, r,o doubt, analJs the atmosphe~ of a Tango dinc~ c room and p.·rov·e, that it• yiel s ·a.• nd almo.st :._.in_ eredihle nu_ mber l ot ' bacteria to the sqnare ~llimetr . · The iestbetics are $ally d!i~·ided. M. Ric~epiq gives the Tango a distinguished ancestry and a ood character. : H is the incarnation of the spirit of !he dance, and it comes to ps: fr-om Pallas Atb~oe, though it has bad wanderings ince it satisfied_! the Hellenic ios~i oct for grace. Other .voices sea. rc➔y l_ess distingur_sh.ed are re.ise.d ag·",_inn the innate savagery of a danoo~said to betray .in every gesture ite fitness for the cowboys and gauchos wh1>. ;.evolved it. .l ndia.q or negroid-.Spanh.1h dec&dence g fte . don to pri:•mitive . . aoimaliem7. thit ie the degraded ance!!try of thq thing European .d egenerates are l not asl1amed to ombra.ct\ Broaclli, speaking, the _voting follows st1jtoU1 party lines. The . AcAdemiciap condemns ; -the Jl'uturist • appl~nds. The school of art thl\t i:1till d~lllres gnss to l>e green is hostile to .JL the Tango. Those who belier~ gras!! to be pnrple, with blotchJs or -,. blne and yellow are warm rrieqds of the Tang?· . I ~ The argument, presi1mabl~ will go on un~I th(' Tango-dahced, photographed, " filmed," bles1ed and banned-;-has reached the ttage · · .. · • of a ge.nernlly recognised bore; Then, H it bas real merits, i..h.JilI quietly take its place in fall oaonr of respectability in the repettory of established dances. Such tfas the fate of the Polka, the Lancel'lt I the Scbottiscbe, and the resti For the Polk.a, whieh so preoccµpied ritain is now dirided irito three parts. There are those Paris that in 18-!0 the Ti,11u complained i that its correspon~eoce who rave in praise of the Tango. There Rre those who ram /gainst. was interrupted, was cr.,nµcmned, by Mrs. Grundy (not :then And the e are those--a q11iet majority--:ho know little about it and ennobled) ns a thing of lico~se and contagious immodesty. tveu cal't'I~. , tho decorous wahx, tho blamo1ess mainstay 0£1 lhe m1>lforn p1ogr~mmo True it is nvt eRS)" to presor'i'e a virginal ignoranci', since lbe met a st-Orm of opposition whJn it rcacuod thq3C sh1m;i " c•.mtnry ! ago. nrw~1u11)( rs a.nd the tl.1ealrt'S have ml\de the . Tango _their. own. ~ut The 1'ango may prom to hn~ no moro~liLy than the Amdricao manr 11- cellont pt'nple are really clovrr 10 dodging tncr,nvenient ccoentricit.ies which ham had their l.ittlo day Tu, Lond,m, but li~s au kno;ledge. A fow J('ll?"S ago a plily cRlled " Ihm !for " enjoyed itll interest for the moment as tho exprcssio~ ot the spirit of the I age. day of tlfeting popnluity in Londnn. A certam ~reat,, mn.n •~s It rc1?rcsents a rernlt f~om thJ tyranny o! t,ri~dilion, together wjth • as.ko>d if )1(' had Set'n it. · " or course. on the hoardtngR, was h11, bU the futorc. Jt says in : effect, "Give 11S ~om~ reply. 13nt l me.a hne you St.>f'll the play 1" "-~ pl~:· is it ? thing now-or at least noi-el+ugly or beRutiful matters not. iAnyRt>ally, l thought it w1,s some n£>w brand of wlnsky. People tliiug rat.her than dnll poriectjon on tho ofd l~nos." of thi,- kind onte tho constant references to " Tango Tel\S" and It ~xpres:1es, too, the tiiodern pMo1irrn ' . for yo1ttHf-4_lbess. ! The 11 T1H1gn iS_npp1.m;, " h~t prob~bl)' connect. the word wil-h the hlca of child wm, curious to know! wh"t became of the old ~onJ ~ • @omt cmpungly athcrt1sed dnuk r1r ~f essence. great.er puzzle ii'I whnL hec:unes of the ohl men, aud women. ~ . Tlwsb wh~ are nt all intereiitt'id in tho Tango, ltow~we,;r, are intcrest------- refuse t-0 grmv old ; perhaps : because they -ine afraid to. They ,re ' cd wr,! mm:h. Th~ quMti~n-is the Taugo a sluimeful like thi• wunderfnl one-h ~r:,e shay, proof against the or1inary and rididul -nts {ltrnce or a thing:_ 11£ rarn grac.e and be~ty 7-rnts· process of gr"d11,1l nt Ra(lic~Is who condt~-m 1~. Ser1011~ yout:l1 ; ts Old age is ~mfo~hinn11hh1, 1u1 ~l'~ g~avity pardfnable , only in thej very , 11pp11Ht•d I cht~•rJ sen:iity 'deli.ghted. It lu~.-.; 1ls frwnds ancl i_t.,;. cne_m,eii yonng. lt i::, s,lHI thllt \.he n1~1 •m~y of .Tango stnd,mt,"I are wel\ over in May ~air and Whitcehapel alike. To nptt:,s ~n opin.wn e1the,r fifty. A &oy. nu,y delight in :hluelmokl¼, a Grenzelike young gir' may way in 11nblic j;, hi imite the most dcadl.Ji af\d._w1thotrng_retorts from addict lwr~cli to the study of;" Enieoics ; but th•t way fbgeyisnl ancl · frnmpishne:111 lio for the n~ an or worna11 i over forty:" Uentje Ole otTeud. t!,ll 1,art . isan. s •. . The. pr->-T•··,n·g. o·.party ·• . d~~w all llt~ . ,r . · . ,arg1.rn1t11~: . ,; from tlH, ball-roonH o! London ; the" antis rely on lernl>le elortt.i! ex,c1:Iss1rn catering for the yo1_1th£ul in all rdeparlmcnte .. The~nenof the l ,Hi~ c-.barets. They ma1 be loft to tight the matter out pa11er readt!r uho c_rued , for " ,wmetbiug about snnspots ' ~ bchtt'l'll tiiems~h-es. The unbi~ iuve!ligator it oul,1 concerned disappt'Med, His sncce.'!1sor Is assumetl to Le interested • almo!t eltwith thtll actual facts. ; · - dnsively iu tho actiY-ities of those mysterio~ clas:'les diacuasedi in a I .• . . , seientific: spirilit by Mr. GMfge GroS!lmith--i-the "hloods" a~d the It a yea~ince t;ie . Tango rt>,1cl1ed .• th1i conn try from S; uth Amt>ri..:• oy way of l •r1B. , IL was,, at hr1,t. no morn ,, nuts,, au_d their female eq11in:leotA. : . . I 1 And Jl~t tht, 11ihmt maj,jrity reaHy c11r1is &$ little al>i·mt. th• thau I\ ·.1 '.\l~ it•..- -.1 . .•ll• fl"t . ale.. . But B .o.me of . · ti_. io~e m.y.shiri.11n~.. [· .Ml·· npl·e. wl_ rn _ . inspire \\1W ~ial ruhion!I wen, att~too by_ it.; sino~ts movem~n:a things ,_.g the ht)nest J+~o man 1u11det Chari~~ !, [[, troubli,q aboitl ~ and thi: strau~t! b..ckward kick, and this year 1t made its way mto freaks of S ealey and ll od1i!:i!ler. Modern lperiehnetie prhate hnuMt: u well u 1:ublfo ~I-rooms .. Eoterpri.i iog bost"11!ee enons;-1_, in the u!w:;ip•J~rS, ~ d,mbt. But ~ost men who haH f~J smiled a wek-omt'I to the lDnoutioo. ,Daocrng, once . reg-1nded by exte1ls1"e a..--qnatntant~e: will ! agree that oq the whole the nt.a yoong imen u the out.aide edge ,of . borrdom, became sod.Jeoly pnl&! bea,ts as he-<hflll m11sip a;s bereti.>foN!. ! John Bull ia Job ~al popula~. The hrngnishing i~dW1try o! !tlr. Tur~eydrup revived into stlll, thou~h he 11010-,tim~ trie.s in bis awlr:w~rd way to cul a P ritaaa Tig>.>ro~~ li{e. 1'~ver.1bodJ, 10 · the hml™1 eoc1al M?ns-e, beg.n to eaper.-The Sahm-lay Ruier· " I I acqni.r,j.the knack of .••ying and kicliing on the appror~ Taog-o lin•. Tfhe ~ulting 1pe1.1tacle wu Loo mui:h for Uepaioah Coun'-8 of Oru~y. That l.dy-eHrjoody-nimembers her h1Hbend'1 elt1,aI tioo. 1~ in VieM>ria'• Nign--aboNI the ~gnature "A Peenaa.·•• brtlke <,-ol into aeareely co--he~nt. pro~ ag•inill the •· Jisgraoefnl Tn1 ,trike of the Jntliane in Natal lilt11&\rat. belier t.hjlll ..,, t.n.,-•~ ot daoeing " t.o be NH in. London b&ll-room.s. She had ot~"~ in.tan~ \ht, uoreal~L! iof moc:h \alk I a.bo1;1L ~ 'QllitJ · ~ • : • debll~to of ..gbteeo_. lli• Podi1uiape,-to pro~t. and &.bat Bnl,ah Empire. A duef :C.oll· n·t. 10 ou:r cue agaanet , . &M . ~~ . ·, : . ~~)u JCH&ag pt'NIOQ'• ~~ . •u ..._w..i t.> he ~a,let; otttt (be 0,>T.emm . ent wa11 tbitir noju_ .. t. and oppnlllll!lH. ~. .'. " ' .-. . •.··.I, abockia>!t otoli&\.iou ol UM Tu:go. I ndiant. We claimed from !chem roll prini,,g. of eu&ry and . ~y Onuu.l,'• p ~ of N)Or"M,; oolJ a,.hertiied the . ~ · f-or bdian11 in aooord&oce wiUI · . the LoucL . •• ,eolioo. ud t.ht Taa!') baa au• ,-...d · ,luougb ma.DJ of the pbu«t of a when e-OUDt.rJ waa nnder oa.r- co~I, we did ·rtu111 aodt.iaa w, 111111! : ! after believ -t;..rre,~•• oft.Ill the pl ·of thE after He 1 refori licene meot whi~ wear• and; j i two has been -ac, mine priso Pris, gazefor C .i · I t• Se ec Ions tho term and The Tango. brut1 whic ALL!' Nati colm CoJI on t pop1 pani stor mo, rcbc ·r collt atla, ll h11 with Zul j tl1si~ · li,·c, Znl· i il himlly ! is impO" Civis Brita~nicus-New Style,. brio rati on i 1 i ¥1-' • . '. : . f· .· · ... : •. . I I •i. •·. &a "tfTI •,i ~ .. . . if~·. : ;-: ; 10th Jaauary. The~. 'lhe!Comrade. onr ook the circum11tance that in the . Hapsburg Monarchy most "'" 'thin , have another than tbeif surface meuing. · fulfil another than \h~ ostensible function!'· The strength of the Thr~ne 111as · proved _ with o ver;r recent "history when one of tbe long · sciies : of Magyar atte pts to 888ert the 11eparale natnre of the Hungarian tt:rtnY failed lib U tl1e others. At the eame time,• Mr. Steed: does oQ, deny i.bat the undermining tende~iea of the Magyars are ~ne ,()f the moat 11eri ua menaces · to the Throne. The . method& of the Magyars. ind , are one or the great ironies which have to be • remembered in stAimg general rnle as to the certainty of sweetenh~g ~ people by a g< nt <>[ .autonomy. Engli&hmen who are still alive can. remem~ U.e rapttUff of euth~ with which ·Kossnth ~as received in Enfand when he plead~d cause of' bis oonritrymeu. But. uh r since the day when the Mag1ars got what tbey wa_nted have the shown any sign of according ,to their own_ atibotdinates the aym thy. which they themt1elves once craved a_ nd won~ .' T.he meanae ia the, greater because they attain~ more than they had deserved or ~ en expe-0ted, .thanks to the i,agacity of Deak. When Austria ,ru.lhard pttssed by oth1•r troubles and the Hungarian question waa atil an ~n and dangerous sore, the Enlperor Francis Joseph asked k 011 lt~~!~ie would settle the dispute. D~llk, with an out ard i!h!~hivalry, answered that the , Hnugarian:il desired to t.ak po unfair advantftge aud would require no better terms now tha 1 befof('. lt was an answer worth1 of that clever leader, for what bet,. otiHttlll' m,H,! tlurn . tla•ir llll'11grt1 pay. They sttrnd nearer '11 n I be UemH\11 (•,ftic~•r11 to the ('OllllllOII 1-oldier. Cnses of ill-treat.m nt uf nwn by n!ficn11 !Ht! r11rt>. The snlmltern -who should restrict.· Iii~ inh•fl::1,nr,1· with J.i .. f11~n_ to tin} i,lwuting pf I\ few Wt•nls ur com• 11;1rnd "\'uhl H)vl\ l><.! fo~111d \\'11.Htiug;: Th~. b_ulk t!f Anslro-Bnnganfll n:gnneul~ nN n,c1l'IH;f:~"'111i:ios1h•. Ilw1r ofiH't'l"S mJl!lt speak e11011gl1 d tlw lin1gu11ges ii the lU('O to l-Rtill} to sup11h>men.t, the G~rm11n ""''!::- nf tvmmand with detaHctl•instructions 11tal explana• tipnj in. the moth,•r tongu~ or -the' rank a~d Hie. There results a ~r"Sonal tth,ti..rnship tbt zenden• the army in 'Au1-1tro-Hungary a it~ort> lmnuui -.ml l.ut~iniiing orgat1iulion than Gerniaoy)' O~l the Church Mr. Steed dtU-Yera a l>iUe,r 1a11d d,uin1ing judg. l11ud-ln·tng ! -i-nt :- _ • . "n ha11 grt-11 p11wer, ,ut we.lth, 'Ynd liHlt> li,ing faith. . H ie •~ iustilnti11n, 1wt an euJJgelizing nc,r_ ,lwa,)ll a 1nuifyin~ agen('y. •!In tutt,a Vienna non ho \ro.-tA., uu. i!Ola .nima,' wu, the ead ,erdict ~t, 1mJfo11ndly rt>li~fons fonign .friar alter con11iderable HJ)(!fieuce qf tbt Austrian N:tltei~I world. The nligio111 mon~nt, nick~ • Modt>r~' that afffe~ 80tne oI tht11 best minda in l11e ftt\Mlt, Italian, Offman. and English bu11clwe of tl1e Roman ~burel1, ldt Auetria•Hungnt prKlically "gntA>nehed. Austria hu pH'>du1.~l a single• Modernistr or note. Oue si:.lilary JHiest. who pleaded for g. realer 1piritualh7 ill,, ,• book ealled No.rlra .Ila. .rima p.lpa wu t1fHdil1 eiJeoctd ud ia DOW forgotten. One Hungarian op ren..led tpbihaal \en&nei~ in a lleries of boob and pastoral ett, ba\ foatH! him-1f condenioed a.nd obliged to retract. These . tbe only aigoa or loftier upi~ion in the Cborch of Austria and ~uagu-7. The tea& ie ·-dominufon, ial.rigoe, enjo,Dlt'nl of fat. n,. and mainltDUC-e of contrtil onr a people ttr1 ob.M,uant of a.ligio• f~• 118d ,e,y ,ciid of ttligioua fNling. In 1ueb cooditfooa ! oot e raan•. lc1-rkal•' to•ri•..__.. : ·, i , ,r\1,~;i ' ; •' : i ~ :r~:~t! e:::~1:ii·~· "'l fi'f0''7; i!fti•! 'ilX oi,o bf A.\.triao +Libe 1ij•• i•J tk6r,,: 0 We hare .n~t space to men~on' -1l ' th~ i ~dQlirable j pQj,i ,' 'in book, but "e must ll~d th ·~~r8. is a, bri~f :hut ~asterl1, ,s~ ),,ar ·•• ~ the South lav q~es•.· hon.. ·.A. _;Pa.,.'• t f!o: m.•. tb.r, ·..,s,·0. u,.th,.,-• s·.l!\V.,·:··,l.•.que . • · ·,· . ~ .l~ . '. II German~ BeeDll! un ike]yfa, consent to any essential d~smemb~r~ ment_ of Anstna~H?ngar as. l?ng llB the: qerman Empire isl able, iby· a P_Ohcr of economic a,nd ~lttlC~ penetr~tt?D, to ·use the \Mo11areb1 as its :nstrument. A am ob1ect of i t~IS penetration ~8' to gi•e Oenuany .command of the route to :1·rieste and~. thr~ug h the Atlriatic, ·•to _the. .Me.di rra.nean. 'fh1 Ha. psb. ur.g ,'Mo·n. rc. hy ··w,m_ probably be exposed to n~ mortal peri~ as long as it refr ins from serious_ insub-Ordina!ion t~ Germanyi an d should a Eurofean cpn• flagratlon ever · ange mlt ~f. t.he num~rous unsoh-ed international-' i86nes in E. nrop_e or the _Eas.t~ tl·m,: l\. fonarchy n•1ig·h.tj.' .bo.J)e, in th_c eyent of . victor~, toi obtain with German help •a c nsidenlhle shce of Russian temtoryl In. the event of defeat ite exist~nce ,ike that of the Ger~uan Emt~ire in its prese1~t form, might be e)ldan~e~ed, Bnt catast,rophtc hypoth1fles are best ~!eft •out of account in tbeseda) S of interwined inler(fsta and of arapies so coloasal t~1at defe~t conld har~l! fail t~ oo attended by re'¥o\utions, {atal to tqrones and to_ the ex1st1ng so_c1al or~er ; and caln;i consideration 9£ I the cpm. phcatcd factors mvolve~ leads rather : to ~he conclusio~ that the· ~ap~burg Monarchy ha~ but one snre 1'RY of escape from its difficult~es mto a more pro~pertus. and tranquil future-the wny of ev;pltttlon, gradual or r11p1dj ·1 c1rcumstauces may permit, towai!ds a form of internal organizatiou helter adavted than the Dual System to tho permanent needs of its peopl"- ·· • , Spufoto,·. 1 1 ! i 1 1 l~e.lr .! i 1 -· ritish Indians. Tlle Mnrqni;; d rtewe, Secretary' of St1-4le for IncH11, recE•iy,,•d on t\1,1 ~$t l!ece1n\t,r,. tt, the lndia ~)fliel' a dtTntntiot~ frurn, tlie . A l1-luda111 South Afncrn L(•ngt11', wlw conveyed Lo hin~ the ,itws of the Lc-ngnc on the p~,.;ition of lndinds in South Afiiea. _ 'flit! memla·r:i o! 1he depnlntinu wern Sir M. l\L m ,,w1,i•"gM.• 1 MaJor N. l'. Sidlm, ',linnj N. ~.h-htn, 11 l'iiSl'8, B,i vuC~, .,: M. P11rib, C. A. Latjf, S. ,\. Hhiscy, N. M, .M11zum, he said, not persdn of lndran forth 10 tins cuµntry or elsewhore who was nut" in absolute UlUl~imit~ wit~I theohj~Ql.s of'tl~e depu;•atiou. As to U1J pnm•iling fe• l111~:--1t be c~Hc~ exc1temenr:--arroused anmngl the people of 1_1:)UIII, ~,y recent ts l(l .South Arrica, tliere "'88 powerful 'of Lord Jhrdt_nge . . ~~ll words of the Viceroy Lad eened to 11ome rxtent rte, Jiac1f y tl1e 111tem,e indignntion with which · tho 1~< {Jfo uf. fodia_ viewed the t~enp , of things in So~tb Alric-. The. dep_ntatwn w1!l1rd. to • a~O()lftit! 1taelf with Lord Hardi11ge'• ~eniand IM ll ~eareluuJ uiqm~y ,11t.o ~lle grie,,ancei or 1the Indio• m Soutlt Afr1c• ,rnd [ the d11m1al eventa which had rajnlted th• fron_1. The tale of the: ilufferingi+ an~ indignities to which Britiah I.nd1.an1 had ~n t-ub.~eded .in Soutl.,1 Af.rica for. y~ pa11t nt l1)ng a~d 11quabd. It: had been bad enough in t~e µIQe of the BOtl~fi 1t l,ad bN-n t~n times •or~ since. Old J.111~ io • tMir dt'innient bad ~n •~rengtl1tned, Dew onee had been ,oacted, -' all or them enforced ,ritb a rigour ~known before lUe •'-b)idl. m. e,..nt of. B. ritish. domin:_:.•l•i(.)b th.ere. T~e effect of_ l th~•. bad.i •. •~ _haraMi the Indian settlers· thert>, ~d to lower the 1hole of d» Kmg-Rmpe-ror'a Indian 11ubji!Cta in! the eyea of the world' • •• fow _o~er o! h~man t;,,eingat unfit t~ enjo1 the Qrdinaty pri~ of c1hi_en_,h1p rn any lf'&rt of tbe globf.• for 1.bi.• brand lor on...... •· •u.. !ng. pnt upon th'·!iem i.o oUi. tr. .~tiab _coloni• an·p ·•. f~.. .... · ,· . co~n.tnes. Uow the all-prolecupt ·and merciful • of •• i 1 ltr, ! 4 might ~t.inwnJ esef t¥~ I 1 I a .· l I l-..·_ 1 »•. ".· t.Ulh11n1fer CrownSOO . , u. m1ll:ion11 ndet,·•. w.hkh wei,e.; conten_t·. and. ~· ·.•. . .· . C?uld' of the'. i1e 1nb~t• to be tho• ;j,8Ii."' ..a:1gbt of nations naiurally pUl!IW their comprehe • a, • ,... \ht.rt .,.. juatifitation for ~h ..ui-atDMat ... •ri~n, · - ..., fad that: fffllponeiL~ ltinit.ttrw of Uie Crown of • both ~tedly admitted tl~ ,i.,j~tiee and ~neu of : the ~ against tbem, and ljad gnen repetµed promilff and pW..- . ,,. redt-. Their pledgr81l bad remai ufulfilled. ·: • r . ··._·· ~.•··· .• no I•• 1 ~ . ~ . The-~ 10th January• } E n snch pa ial settlement oF the most intoleraNe burdens/ tr.ch,:~ pdl-tax and:· tho unnecessarily •drastic provisi.ons .~f the Jmmigr1ttion Bill which was lut ye,ar dangled . before _their ~es had so far been ~nded: That settlement w~ understood to. aff~td t porary · relie~ from .somo or the moiK irksome. ~urdcu which :ei:.Jrfllking th1 Ye-ty e:1:islenco · of the. euff:ere~. impowbl~, ·Fiif. were a long waJ off from any appreciahle .solution • of lbeu numerous wrong!l for RO long as the •pee pie •of• lnd1~ were l 1·d under any dEhilities on account of race or eolour 10. a-.y ; 0. rt.in_n.. of tl1e Bi1ish.·domi.nion11. EO long mnst.tbe.y fet-1 . . aorel•y ~g1?rit'ved. Thal r sir:is~r must be removed at all eot1ts. ll n 1 ~ld lumll.r be c ntested that mos~t at~ o! the bard me~urea kvdlrd agninst U1em were_ due t-0. rae_e-i,re1ud1ce, and were u~ v-iew Ito · their exhrpabon from the colomee. 11 1•11 8. . 4. .The instit J: ....· . . ,·.·• · ..· ::~~~t:iJ°~:'i~~~!~, Ii. . The ..o~n .-l"~a'4d7:: sball •111011re .to}lritlah Ilfi1U11 .• which have been 11.....t~ .to •~ 1 ; Cron. · ·· 1 · • !atatemen Mr. B. l)oJ,. quoted Crown.-tncludi~g L.ordSaliebory ;a the rights of cili~•hip ab~ of the Crown .wbereJ'et U.~y, migl.t recent times. be .re.called. ~h• word~ ,hich admitted ·ioto1Jrh,iilb col~niea th~y or ' not. at all • seems to ~e the so pire." 'fhere cool~~ np queatio Indians in South Afnca ~1onged,t by virtue oH11eir birth ~~der t:h" 1 .r ~.r yeiirs of ~.tient suffering, and find. iug th. a,•t·· eve.?. .the. }ittl···e relief they bad tn led _to ex~t Cr~m • the more 1mmed1ate]y pres,ini; burdens &'- bt-rng fioa ly_ w1thhe!d, _son~~ of them h_ad pro!estid in the Iiast few days agamst their s1t11at1on by p888ne r.:.',i,-tsnc,', 1\lld cetta.in num. hers of. the indentured l.•.~urers had gone on strike. [l'hey knew the penalty of _the ~hnical offence thry we.re commi:~in.g,~~-d.."-~lli~ly took the~r pu_n•~hme~t, B~t th,, iigonr and, 1b tnany~s,- the _brutality _with which their ·pnnishment h11d Uee~ . and w~s now bemg . earned ont ,:ras the mi.in gronnd <•f t~ea· • complamt.. The horrible, tale of their m~tn,atnit·nt in varil'1s shapelj came from quarters JlD Whl'se vernc1~y foll rdia1,ce cot.il l,c. placc·d. H hnrl been refuted by the local nutL.,ritit'i<, but pas, ex1•erieuce of tho nttitude of tl1e officials there 1,,i·ard s British lndiam jns~ified belief in the ~omplai~ts.. Even th,:, a!nwst one-sde~ reports that had appeared m pubhc JOUrnals ,h,,1wd that the indentured Jndians had been sent back to the rni1 t , n1:J fi, lds fO \fotk · under t~e. lnsh of the ejn,mbok f~e)y w:,·hh,l by 1heir-1.>njployer.~, aud that 1t was ouly when thus drt_ven tu d,•,-petatioo thtt they adopted measures of •self•preserrnhon. Tht' t alt.> of so man! deaths of Indians by the free use of ·fire-arms (Ill th(• pmt. of tLe lucal police, on the one hand. and, on the other a fow s{'ratches or wounds suffered by the latter in the scuffles pro,ed conclusirely t.bat the reports of violence by Indians were C'Xn:Z,~PrnlC'd. ~\t all ercnt!I, there WM a strong case made out fr,r ~::1 in,h penden inquiry on this point Whatever the result of ,;l1di iun,:; tig,1ti,J 1 mighL be, it would befonnd t~at the wholesale .,x,•rci,,, f, •1· the first time in the bist.ory of the British Empife of the rr,wi~inn of iaw which A11tborised the conversion of compounds iut1.1 could nolt hant failed to res11h in a form of t'lrtnre ..which th" oi th~ la\t could have scarcely contemplatetl., . It w11, 1,,t dt:>nied that ihe sjambok and other weapons bad been irrel,r u, ,,J to com1~l men to do the very work which · in their la.st 1.k,rm1ti,-n they l1ad refused to perform. This htcident, this t1;,w,ty d law, miJbt be pnssihle in a savage cou~itry, but it W&!3 :1 nw:l 11 d of vindi!clite barb1uism ought to be impossible in a1,y sc1uaro ioot fr soil orer which the British flag flew. • :,,, .· ;; ., ., • <:righ~ t,!0..."1tisltcltf • ·•·, . \:rt D oU~~ 8tjii~-- Eaip~ c'.'.W :. Be did not ignore the dd1io0Jt1e4 the I~ptritl ffi>Yetllment in South Africa. It was · . leadet of ) he Indiana ln Sooth Africa, Mr, Ghaodl. folly .. diftlculd411 thaUhere,.,.. '. no demand at present ;for the : ~al . riJhtef ~f · cl~noh!ip under the Union. Those rights, ,oped, ~o~lcl · co~ la,r. ' : Jaem•• •·• l>nbe· poibt,11 without any demand hav~ng to be out bow tl1e SouthAfridn Union ~at, in~:pr leaaeni,1 the rigottr af. the laws and regnlatio ere t.o}n~i&o,had materially increased and intensi He M a-·•peoial griennce the fact that tlie wire of • . ian who ~ entitled · ~ reside within the Union could not joi.n, her huaband \a,id: wUh him simply because ehe wa.s married. ~ccording to tlie : ritee of q.e •t- h~miU~~,g mea,aa~ Un ::Jt!/:~'f~!~ ·!:!~~~~t:i ~;t£ !!~~l=~!;i~~o:~tl' attack upon their religion. . It had pro'1need an •unp~enled ato,at of indignation in every f~mily in India.I • f . Loao Ouws•a 1aarLY, .l The Marquis of Crewe said :.,-I hare listened withf close attention to the observations made by tho ~wo s~eakers on beh11r: of this repteset,tnt ive deputation. l need no~ aasu~ yo!J that the 1erente of whioli yon l1ave 11poken-evet ts which ~ver a fong period• e,,nte wht~h prove a condit.ion . or gen. oral d.i. soontept ·,.•m • opg...Ul. e fa".~jeo. ta. ·o.f B.: ii Majesty in South Africa. and which ha.ye now culmioa~dn. resiatanoe to thcJaw. in tomult. and in actual Io• o[ life-:-~~ 'events ar~ a subject of deep concern :to all His . Mtjefity'a Ooverq~en~ · and, · of conrse. in particular t-0 111yself, who, 118!. 8ec.1'8tarr of S~te for I.bdl-. am finally responsible to Parliament a~d to the . Empi"' for the weU• 0 1 1 ! whfob I .The. al»~\i A,'.·•."• being of India an·d•,·lnd. ians·• evert•. where\ · • · aU Jc·~• . , o. •,,"•. : . I.· n. dia. •~. been deeply stirred. bJ the reporte whicli .have reacW ~er, and tho-1sh we need not adopt u pn)ved !acta ever, •~nt,whi.,~ has appeared in the pre38, yet it ia nident tbal gronpda exiat for ntO¥ terioaa • . •\ ll tliis hnd lbttn dr ne in the sacred--- name of law, But 1 t)ic ln;3 of_ St nt lh Africa, ~P~(allJ devised for the exlertnioaquiei,.ndtbere•·.·ala.o eXJ. ·•.ta. • m.at. · ~.rialS:· f ... . , • el~ . . i ·aq. ,.· 0t . . ··r·1·{ ·.~...,. · . •,.h·· • .. ·.ioto···•·Oi . . · . • · .•. ·occurrences t.beDl8ehea and w tbe · which baY:e '4,d lip to hon o, l nd,an se1ttlers and mnmgrants, were not soch laws aa a free nntion rn~ted for the preservatiop of · li(e, property, and ( Hear, b•e .. ar.) 1 it h: appena .. I ha, en . .1 . ~.· op•. · . n n· . , · J • . . u···• · .. o.'. ".··•·Q······d ...Aa •.' :. -.. ing this questi.on, whieh. I think', mat be ,eprled N. unique. . PTJn It w11s to: the enach).ie11t of Jawa or thi& kind . that 1be pt>rp\e of India ~trnngly objeeted, ·and· they soµght the inte:nen&eretuy of State fol' the Colooiec for~• Jeart •· ; . lbq ~ 0 8 t_i,,n. of tlie_ lmpt>firasurM wl:ieh ftftl !aajuet M ~ Sooth AfrNMi~< I . b et 1 ~ "~' tmnnls its 1Indian subjeds. That •ckarJ1 ebolttd U.,1 the ~ " 8 . . . . . . .,. . ..:. . . . . Afriea; aaclto ..........i... : ~·1:-~o,·ernment ct1nferted WU li1nited. witb the ~thoril7 of the OOUIHI.to •1 Cn,w,u remred. !He contended th.ii~ waa the lmpcrial Omerament " duty to me~ate at. this eri~ •IQOIDeDC.. 011jJI. it Arriea of a~~. .._.: alone, rested th~ responsibilitJ l;o aafeguard the int.- of·ladla 11 th;? gliont the E~pire. The Jmperial had . IMUJ ··eo , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ,/ ~ l l, ur:1~r-att, o~ tl1~e-ra,-e dilereoc;,ee Nt_.,.a IJae ho . . _ , c,f ltWakw, 1 .WMaW.lo Bnt,sh bl!b~ts. •.o. ·.· tbai •114.U.e fol .. lowing ha. .·.· .. ·. . . .,,., ·.·. . .. •.·• ~1:~ drpu~ah0n rt'AroUwly nbtniUe4. ..... 1 th• t•.<,~ ::.r;::~ i ~~e":U!:!~/~'\~i.,~~f •-~ ~:j~ Jo•· A·•• .# p.••. o · . ... f:•., i. •~: a~:~: ~b::~~leacl;r~~,t. ~..•·.· ':d ha"' o, ....,.....~,.. b• 1 ._.,.._,_.~I ! :-4 i Go...,.• be~:-·.~.· .·.) ~ i l • ~ l ~ •,d. L lhe relea.ae of the i,ri•on. : i ne Lu. ! .t .-~---: ....... ..:.,.~•l ~i-~•·I1·--"-. ~. .... .., • .,....or··.w palaft rNiden aac11 ........ •.·· ' . · . ' . a.. · · ! • : , - amend~t~ tM JlhJ.,--~ let t o ~ ._;.,....li,e n-foJal o~ dom.oUia,y Jis)t-.f;;r ... ~ " and.•••- ~~·;::;;: :,•11•f>dt .... 11,o ............ r- . . . w ... ~ -_ ,:, •· · · ··· 1 ...•. 1 ..... ..-al1:m:~•,,1 .. •.•.•· i•• ' . ,; ~ 1 ,,.,,·· c;. ;· ... ··, .,·.. ·. . . . )! . ,r I ;j,:r~'.;1>'.:~'·!>. .!'• • · ·••i ::1 1 p 1 ,, ~ 1~, , ;' ''(16! l'mtlm u~tobelil'in~~ ...~ o l ~ • ~ . b y . tlleee ,_.. or ~ < ~ ~ ~ t i l e i~S.lto ~ w ~ I ua alrai ·we ;caanot np-4~. 11&~.· ~ ·•; ~ J ; .•~ ==~-=~¥at~ dilfflm*'r'~ ·~'lhe aotml· ~ t ~ th~ law, or b f ~ . , . :r:· t;r\~:~::~~~ ,rO:.-tJ:O~~':n,:e: been ~ : - ·. ' ' ' ::_: ' ' . ·-:,:· ':-,.;: -,.'. i: -/i,:_-:·:·,_. :i;~-: _);;~).:::i~.::\-,/ ? ::o....ue. t\lie·•you. •~"·rm.. .CQriol~~· .. ... U'tff~~: >~ .•~.rt 0 •llajeaty•s Govero~t ~ t,~o\. J attention to:thls ~ht, I : •. , > :, . . ,. oollitagoe )Ir; Ba~ort ~.ff>··...~;:s, .• ·. :: , . : . ':' .. / •. · . t~ ~~ , to .•.. ··. '.•.·.1.!¥1 .. ·.~·. •.. ·:•.·;, l+'8 ,. , anxio ··. usin th.•' . ·comp•l:~fri~ ·ete· ·.. Jast.:.•roe. ·'. old .oirou.:matan~ ·.. •. d··.o. P. .9:. J•h•v.e ' .'.·• '·,·.•e·ee .·•.·.·..... ·:·I··..~..~ . .·•. •· .·u~der ··.··.·.·•. ·• ~ll♦ ' grants South whom. pli\ced. ID)' conrict.i9n ..tljat.. though •.h .. · "'ditlbey ;ma,i ,.< ,• .· , .... · . :~~ : we do in the ac~ual J.n~ poi} of:rewfyet.~,:,.~ no,e.~flff ) 1 :b ·•· ,•· e ..•. ·. . a · ·· . . ·b •• special care of their Depaft~ent , . !r~~t, 1 t,htn~, :'1s ld.}Jba~e t~ &lay , lo you this afte~ooo. I ~eed ~nly as3ure yqt1 i o~oe lfl011. t~~tjI, fnlly ·. recognise ~th the , 1mpo . } q~~\er ~, Jo,~r dep~~f~oil ,~~i .' the supreme imp9rtance of the a bJ~t. npon.whijili yoa have 9ome ·: speak · , .: . ·. ,. : i · i : . r ~ Sir M. M. Bhownaggree t nked. Lord. C~~e for hi~ st.atem~nt; . and for. its sy~patbetio . tone. fn ord~r th~t there. migbt be ~o misunderstanding on the BUbJ t, he W1Bbed ~(l· refer to the iuqui~y that. waa suggested. W Quld th!interests of ln)lia be duly recog11-i&e4 by an adequate• Indiar. . NJ? ntati?n 1 l'h~'re, w~ one pll.8"11\ge liq Lord Crewe's reply to ; wb1c attention ehou\d be directed,! .. h ~as be unduly. .ha horde • dMduals, can it.t. ion be..~d that_ 1ush baa the statemtmt th~t it. was: simpl becawie ludians had gone jti la~ge ta·e·mae·f~. .. '.·•.•·. ~ea.·ired .., . t.·b•t. the. -.• .·•minist';& o.! tl•e .. lawt?lS ~. h.(i\l .•l·d n. ot alnya n carrie out 1 The law, aro neeetl8ar1ly admm1sterod hJ a numbers to South ArriCl', '>efo all these questions arose origiu~ly, number O different official.a of all grades. Some of tbeae officials . and be(:anse they bad been the · ~ne ol buildiqg up the prosperit <>f ma:, be st pid, and bound up wilh red-tllpe · and the litera! interrre~som.e of the, South Africa. n colo ies., that th. eir.· ~.esidenoo there,. co.ul~be .. ilon of th~·)aw. Others. again, may be so effected by TIM:ud preJudice tolerated, and tha.·t. if !.he lndiaTg had not gone ,.to South Africa when ~ they on't wish that the burd~n of the law may be hgM~y borne. they did it would have beeu ¢omp.itent for Spnth Africa to proh\bi& So that 8 ly it ia a daogeroos ibtn~ to ~epend,.":' 3ou_U1 Africa seems the i.mmigralion'. Totl11.1t .vieJ th.e Indian po~.ul.ation wou.ld. cer. tali'nly. to ha,e d ne, on "'tional and sympelbehc .admm1strat1on 4:>f t~1e law demur, because as citizens of t1!e British Empire, &!I loyal subjec of lo proi«tl individuals from tbe ~p(bLion.t of se,~re enac~rnenls an such tbe Crown, they claimed the right of entry Into all p~rts of · ia circum.sta as acloaU7 exilt .Ul the South Afncan U moo, Majesty's dominions. If the ~ep~tation did oot make that clt!&r t ey would be ace\ll!ed by the peopJe of India geperally · of not hav~ng Now ali:e some of the quite familiar an.d spe<:ial instances which represe.. nted . ,· their. view po. the s nbjec . .t.. The dep .• utatio.n could go. ar,.•~1 ha'f8 been to0¢hed upon in the t!o speeche~ w,?icb we have ..beard. with some satisfaction in the kpowledge \bat at all events an inq1lll1 Now it is not claimed by the Indian population m Soul.Ii Africa that was promis-ed, .an inquiry in I which he a.ss{lmed Indian . i11l~,.te, South Af ic• ongbtio legaHae polygamy, but, on the other ban~, would be duly · represented. ! Something had been said about! an commuuil es that. pnctiae polygaqiJ surely demand reasonable cons1inquiry by Genera\ Smuts. i If. recent telf:grams ht\d been i!ead dentioo. And can it be fairly that in indl'id~l ~es this conrightly General Smuts haj ceased to i!lqnire, and Wl!Ji 110w sideration hu al ways boon aQOOrded ? Well, t!1en, 1~ ., 1s apparently refll8ing to interfere · at ~ll. . The deputation entreat(>(\ It~ rooogni by lndiADa in 8(,'Qth Africa-and tlna, again, we hue had Secretary of State for In4ia to use his greal influence ,ith Dlfntion in Mr. Dube', spe.-ch-~1a► they · cannot enjoy . trnreshie colleagues fo the lmper~al Governmen~ in supprirt of ~ord tricted I nvemeol from province --to province. Again, we ask llardinge•; demand. for wi iu11~artlal inquiry, io wb;ch all, n<>l i,,oly if the lregulatfooa which restrict that mo,·emcnl hue been Brit.ish aubjoots, but the wo~ld at IRrge, ll)light harn confidencl' ,modified aa far u poaaible, and baa care been taken to (Hear, be.ar.) the wilb~rawal of powers wbi_ch have t-xiated in the past for Jl:<>Or membera iof the l ndian corumu01,y? when we come to the moet noticeLord Crewe, in reply, ~id:-1 mnst tl~al at onct~, and ■ho Jl1, able inatjl.nces of any, •~d to the ~•nee of the recenL. events of whi~h with the two points which ha~e been mentim1ed. In the 6rsL p aoo, we ha,~~n reading. What haa been the history of the £3 tax 1n witb ,egard to the general """'8 of lhe .,,bj.!'9ts. of His Maj.estJ . all parts of the Empire. WhaL said with regard to the part playe bJ Natal. a d the nrions queation·s· of domicile wl.1ich ha., e been attached to th&'t . ? W 11ll, ibere ill a regreLtable obscurity as to what rully the Intlia u!'l or South Arric~ in building : up the imlm,tritu I 11nd occiu-Nld ~beo t.he matter wu lliJit before. the Union Parliament. Wu acfoitiee of South Africa id the past was simply observ~d witlj th, it the r,ct .that the Union Oovern~ent were willing to drop the tax purvuse o[ emplia.;,isiog the claim which they thereby posse~soo upon bat tharrit" was maintained in -deTerence t~) the ~iewa or th!! Natal tl1e Brith1h and Dutch inhabit~nta of the U nic;m. I liad certain}~ no members 11 That, I understand, is di$pnted. How· far was~ the--"\ de,;ire to engage i.n any argum~nt on the absLract queBt.ion · of tbl abolition of the ta.x even actually foretold or promised? There again access of all the King's 11nbje<¥s to eYery parti of the Empire. :CerIM!mtl tol be a diff erenct of opioton as to what ~ctuall1- ~n~. tainly I, for ()UO, should neYeri quarrel with aµy India~ who clatm~ I ean onl, u.y that it·muat b@__a g:n,:at miafon1;1ne Jf the Ind1ans_m that right, or who considered pl,llt he or she 011ght to be freely admit-South A (rfoa cont1ider tbe111&e1,_1:9 to have been .1~ &DJ W~J pla:,td. tntb ted ~.1 aU parts of the Empir~. ···Dut. as you gentlemen, wJ10 arel well ill a mt.ttle.r of such weighl and 1mponance aa t.b11. Thus lQlJ)O&f. does iostrncted both in l1i11tory i,:nd politics, aro · a1var1:1, variom, ~omnot bring in a large revenue j it dooe not, 80 fa.r u_we c~n.11c,e,.seen1 to munitiea within the Eropirel_hold ·11troug vie~n1 which tend. to wr1ily eene -.n~ useht\ purpote,{ and a larg. bodt of pubhc Clfl?to•~ Ul. South lha~ right of free acces.... ! On the secon~ and more . impo~t Urie• ,Jfm& to regard it !D a.m~ner •lueh I ha,e JUllt •?'~•c•w,d; quet1tio.n, o[ a.u inquiry int.•~ South Afric•i:i e,euts and of &.be rona and yeti~ hu ht,"fome lMi 1na1n •eoun,e t:>f, th~ rttent ~1fficult1tis. fthich it onght to b.ke, I oug~t to stale that 1 ham not yet bad1 U. Rioting fnd h'IAfl of life hate f~llowe. gal.. or 1th. a& one. _.1 .rihet u •••n . legal--,iuhmce that pinticulu inquiry ooghl. Indians o.·rnialthe inquiry .•.nom·.. in~·!.•:e I b.J. the In~. •n. Ooveromoat. ·.• .··· ..· . ..rr\~ ... .•·.·•·•·•.•. lbe lmpe. Government. \o be e. H ia alto«ttht,r 111ong and pu,rp,)l!el~ of a.nybodJ to adopl • tQM of 11'1f'a&8 to-.uda South Arrira. U11t l t"'liue cbat, the Lord C~•e :' As l 11&id,_t:he ,o~jt~t ~ -tl1a ~ al~ tl1e fact• ·~ .~· ~Nnl~ni. tlwN will agree th•t if ' &rnU1 Afrksn. repute •nd tbe bro~ght onl lD a ma11ner wlrn;h utu1hed the 1jnbhc, both h-.: ~• :~tolidari~v of t~ Empir• ""' to be 1111lla\n, d by institut,ing a form d< ,ae, th~ ma,elu~ry la..:tmcely 16" •. 11pport.a1lce tua el.!kl".hi!.rtl .• t~:•t.th~.J • r.e•U.y ol have·bet> ·.~. bro.oghLo. utJ . . · . t:.~ ...•. . ' ..•.·.·.·.•·: •· lndu., an.d •etual i.oqwj.'r;, •l1~h WU lh.·1t &.)lel1 nfticial n~ .~•1i:lhneut @Illtt'r 1...r n•. tin.ad or of Jtrt0o.al ,....,, ,..,.. ought 10. atatHJ in the ,·.f 1111:b •n tliat. t.he hntl1 l$ clearly bronght • oal. Th.all was 01e onl1 · . , '-:~t. iaN.tig•\ion , Aad I Mid that 111-tll an! inm1igatii.,n, t,J L. fruicfnl. which l had to make a .guu1ll rorreetion. · I. \~ank .r;m ,,.~ • ·•·· ~. oog\t ,.ii l.e diri'C:ted la()l oat, into the partienliir cire11~la1:et·~ eif ttn• la.st th(' kind wurf{ard t •my recapu.>n ' ... bu\ ialo &he 1 0 ~ ol ~ complll:nu ,.bicb arc tbe cal.IN dep0tation.-T/u J/Q/ICAt,ltr: Gwudia•. ~ n t Jw!hich baa ~ptlied oa by $ooLh. A,fraoa1~ t~l'Ongh the whole hij d diffionlty. , That •rgament ~• ~t al~b the ••.·,ra ate in t.ffld , .trictive use &.u~ ~.fncan opinion on having them SO.: their operation~ .~ so.euily eondocted no ~wai' •·~ exist. ·That.If!. the .~rg:ntn8Dt wbieh baa •used: . On ~ U ~ Bret to be remi\l'ked ~•t. beaides prac:t cal grlevaoeea, there ~ such things as moral gnevaneea which eannot ~ left altogether out! of sight , Eno taking the ~t of p ~ gm,uices. and ·regar4i~ that as the reaso_nable ~11;b1eet of oomplai~t, though lam quite cenain that South Afncan Munsters 1~ oonttoten1•3 ·• i$.1ead· ~r : bec:a. . • 1 •4 i i · 1 t I I i* i "~ij··. l:u it:£' t. ! • · ~ . I °'. ,._ da,h ••y l·. • f···.·· •. ·i : ,; next w, of goo Atheial reason, enemi.e the hol in fav this tn At Euglis Medsrs has ubi and in for ll tho so Introd Intern The f Proµh unirer next f to the the ea phet, of the 1 etc. praye, deal ii portio !{iven liCCOtll tho R, insigh tho al esi{WS being learned trnd in:;tmctne 1,i ,·eryl mtert>strng readmg For a Moslem, and more so, i1Jr a 1wn-~hslem inl' i;ca.rch for truth aboui L!lam. · · The book for th,· ".'ak,) oi 1:.•ouv,mi, nee is di\'itfoJ into LhnJ:? chapte.rs, and has an lntM.indiou ,irhich de ls with know1eJge gained by External Senses~ Internal Seuse;;, by U~vclations and by means of Signs iand Emblems. The tirllt d1apter de~ls with tho last 1tnd the greatest of all the Pr,i;)lids uf God, lloh1:\U1•d, lhe attri[mte~ of God-the crel\ter or Lbe unirer;e, S11:11:tifictiot,, A 1ig-th, G~•nii, Sonl Res:mnection, and the next worhl, "'i~h 1,bjc~1.i"u" ruis,~ J by opponents of li!la:rn aud answer& ti) tl11.'in. The sec,m4 chapter i~ the 1nost important ~ ii deal& with tb,, l'tuly hi»t,,ry ,>f hram, gin·s a hrieF sketch the Hre of th1 Prophd, and dis :n~.~.-s fol1ly all about crnsados' pnligainy and inspiration uf the lfoly Qnrnn. ,Jnd:1ism, Chri8tianity, Ved:J.S, Budhism, Jainism; etc. It ,•xplnin:1 tb(l Dil"ine Science i,n tbe Qnran,. ~xplaioiog the Z,1L1t, Fiutir{g, Haj au.I Jeha,l. In th.e IMt chapter, a great i$ exph.1ine1l abou~ the Old and the. New ·Te3tament.R and the P?rti,•n~ th•ircul whi~h have beeil lost. _-Very usefulioformatfon i8 -.:1,tu a\i,mt the Chris~i.in 1m,.\ the Hin'dn sects. and olOlel with an "~c,,uut oi Z orustria~s. H is R bnok which will be "108t useful for ~he_ Eng'.ish educ~ted .~.91lems, as it woold give tberu a nry el• rnstght rnto their fa1t.h, a.od prepare them to defend it easily apioat thr:: attacks of the ChrlisUa:o and other Miulonariee. Boob like tbu rn fi*ed tlrn 1!;/n:tnre angeh,,·j I or UCAling with the ru~ern r~' 1- wen badly ~~ .ud we it ca~f,!l)ly.'' FATEHPU~.2J&d S~•l>w. 19U. Tue Engli;ih tr~nalalion of "Al-Bay~," '·the• fMQo• "'book "'i~te~ by ll,rnl11;ua A;bdnl Haq had h~n g1Yen t-0 me (or ,.Jing and r~n;~ 1ng by .11•ie.e Alubammad hliaq. , . , lhe bo~,k _1• so we~l tr.,nslaled tb•t tbe be&oliee of th~ a11t.hor'e "J 1e an,I d,ctwn liu":boon amply pl'91!1ened •. , 'Thia ~se woold be • w..iat. ,aluable .•dd,ttion. to tbe Isla,mic liu-ntun, . •!in the tog.•~ 1 trongl1 r'cl\!vmmend a.\l lo purchJ:e and study I liusl'.&Jol'll. It 1u:.p,)u~ds. in a most lucid and logieal 11\S:OQet; lhe tc~luc_g oI the Gresti Prophet. and gi-ree • nlioiw &1¥lc lop,a1 r\!,ut~t~on or all the •l!t.ack11 on Islam. . ! • •· . • ,... 1 lHs bv0k w,)ttld Qt usefo.l :>lb to .'b. o 11. o,hamc-du ,__... .• ·•~ . !!,~ Eurup,e.ani1 who "ant, to learn the troth abooi 1.i.., (SJ.) !ANSARI. B•••, ..... w.o.•• J,LCL1',: Thi• ~.'lOk "ill bftl a host eornp.ofoa to the M«.em, and • · ~o,,limu l~. India ~d Fontig11 Coeu1triea ai.d Ule - - - - .,,,... ~ll'All-ludt 4 Y,,ha11~e,.l;u1 Roligiont .\e•ocirdion e!ria, hu ..... r, !ru-u lh. 15 to lb. 10/6 IO Iha& lu.rt111 may ~l,r purthut ii. · ; ,. b.:. w.. A· J~' lk~ 1 -· D U · 'I. al·"·•.·.· .........., ! ' . : ' Afl'Lt 'N-T~E M.ANAOER, 1 ' ' f:I, H.-· J t ~ ,! TA.. Gftlfr'Gl N ~ ~ Gad]. . . . . . . . 1¥,JWW. !I--,. M,rdal. .&Mitlr .._,., .p.lW. , I 0 2. 8 ... l 8 0 t ·o i 0 0 AIDA . & , KHURSHED, i . COMM~CIALISTS. : BADAUN, and l I 0 Persian-Engli~b- U rdn Dictio ar.y ... 3 o· Roman-English Ditto l English-Ro1nnn · Ditto . 1 8· . Other u;;eful uotei!, &e.' of Matriculation ~re available ~t Red~ced a: Pr!oos. APPLY (5) (6) -:--: SMOKE ONLY -:- NVER BEY CIGARETTES Man fucturcd in honour- of· our HERO whose name iB re1Vered in every . Muslim Household. Unrivalled for -reshness, purity and delicacy of .~ma: ~Fresh TUI KiSH TOBACCO ,i iseit : Made daily a~ The·Upper-India Cigarette Co., No- '19. AMINA8.«\D; LUCKNOW. / ~ F. A. ~ 4: ' 2 8. CIID081'& . · 8 2 1 Wallted. - ! Mo~~edan ~ i o g good kn+wledgc ~ English• and .¥athematics. Thirty or toryy ymrs_ old. ~ n and ·some religious knfwled~ 1.1 neceaaary,,ealar;rR~. ,tO/- (forty only) per m9nt.h, with food an~ free lodgmg, to tEach two boys Good of i Matriculation Class, with future prospects on ~tw~ .Appl1 to. Mir Aalam :Khan, ee....r.l Contractor. BraW Loclp Ci.U u.... Nqpur. w The;Comrade. EXTRACT FRO~ A LETTER RECEIVED PRQ~ T$ BOMBAY MUNICIPALITY PUBLIC HEALTH DEPARTMENT. NOFELE and MALA ES .. .. !. 1, - .. : Treatment with ESANOFELE contnHed with ql1inine in most cues was reoeoUy . ·yen• fair vi.;l.: ~ · ~ on~ed to the P11re~ Orphan\~"'· where M \L -\ R{\. OF A PARflCULARLY SE:VERE TYPB ;ngect cs.see- of Malaria were treated of which FIVE WERE CH RON IC. ,rith considerable eolargeme · t of epleen the ~$;S 1 0 f ~t;:;. 43 1 ; aqd\Oeoera! ~, .J~a Cachexia.''- R ult : · ' REDUCTlON IN THE SIZE OF THE SPLEEN ♦ ♦ DISAPPEARANCE OF PARASlTES ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ INCREASE IN THE HAEMOGLOBIN VALUE ♦ ♦ ~ GENERAL CONDITION OF PATlENTS VERY SA.TISFAOTORY. I ~./ .. I \V riting on th re,mlJ ,1f ch~rmic . c~'!es. the report ~tate : - " Q•1inine wo'.tld __not have worked eq~lly well in tbeae cuee iand. one e~p,,,..;~!h· emb ,1,lene . to girn tlus np•n1on from the CA'1e oC a S,ld111r!\m .J1v1\]I, who wae a chrome sofferer od ALWAYS TOOK A "Oo the whole, ESANOFELE appeari! to have VERY GOOD EFFECT ON CHRONIC O i8BS. LirnrsE on QUI~INE AN'D A. RS~~N'IO mx rURE:3 w1 rnou r MUCH n1rnEFCT. . .· · SANOFEL~ is obi,h»l,I, froru .U Cb,mi,t, aod Deale,s >hrooghout BR!T[S!l INDIA, BURMA ANf CliiYLOli, m,al Agmt,o- Me~srs.3. Wallace B. G. GORIO & Co., Street, BOMBAY. . ffla Dr7AJIT8 "E8.UtOIPBLllll'J.,'' APTD IIAL.&.RI~. fta&O OBDIAWDIL i I ! FELICE ~ISLERI & Co., MILA~. ITALY. IWANTED. A trained B. Sc., salary Rs. 70 rising: to l 00 per mensem, and ~ trained B.A. with Mathematical qllalifications, P4Y Rs. 50 rising to '80 per mensem. ~xperienced ~nenl those who have special qunlificntions , m MaLhenmtK-s If1ay also apply. _ Manager, The 1 1 FAIZ-1-AM HIGH SCHOOL, Meerut. H. M. Ahmad · Beg, . Indian Rub~r Stamp }laker, !Die Sinker,! Copper, Zmk Plate nnd Stone Engraver. liionogramist.• Manufacturer of Dross Badges and Seal~ etc. D~er of all Strunping Requisites @d Rubber ijand Presaet. I • ' Chandni Chowk. DELHI. i i a1.10.u""' - -- '.t ~or Stationery write-,~ EVERY KIND OF r-.....__ PRINTING •I· ;The Comt'ade ~d the Hamdrrd Pfess , DONE ··- • ·r .,J.-!,_. 1:.:.i;.,. tJt-l~ · 1 IN THE ''COMRADE" -./.Ji J,b, .;1t ~~,.:e,1,..__.:,1 PRESS, DELHI. ' ~ \ ; , ,J.;. ..t j '~,~ ,,. • . ,,,,.. I . ~~ ' ~ ~· ···-- ~......- ',.,j,J J•r' .:,,,.f ' "J~#r, J\J-J'1., :J~•"'., ..;\. s~\J .~\,: r.,, ~,•~ ~ • -J..u .r~'r,z;.r.~,.1:.c1J> fa~f•- '=t J J--!l\l~.~•J"N-...·, r\ ; •. - .,.:AJ.Jt.,a.,a I i1!1~ :i f· t.~;1.··. , . t. 1 1 il1l·~::;1;J:r~}'.:;i,'.•,·" .·:1? fl ; , l.- l i • , )••· .. {.. ' \;o"' · · · ·~ t,ei ..•· .iTiDP:• ~':f'll tloabt/:,, ,~i· i"';, :Wi~g ,~ .i~ion ~the cele~1-a,t~ ,: ' :> :vfuiiii'esperierice not necessafy ··. • . ,',' '' •. .l . '"' . l ,., .. ./ Work, ~ ~~:' -. ,·. '/f~:t::, . - ·, 5 I / ·+' (t)ur PrOt>OsltiOn, UrieflY' 1 ,, 1 .t.. ~·_ : , . , .;.-.i ' l~RMOIM' mo11.;Atuto• ·. I ~l l' • • •. • . ' , the +SP, }~eit ·~,-L~Mt~$(f ,-,■->e'·UUffrliHltce: thereafter to 'puiimnse i , ,~!1 :?out·, :bY:. ybu ·with of th$1na('bUiee, but · through -. . . · . , .. w0,~~1.~.ort: :.•:~;ottrijig Bot8$ .II whieti'lt •~'1i! Bonds l t £ 10,0{ aoms. tome Pi JI YOUC growing Uemnnd: ;·w:ei mo1·e ' eo.im~t wotkers-~ parti~•.~ . ·' Wkeele, r . 'it{l: c : ' ~ eompare Auto-Knittrr.''' We , ~ : j. tf>. . keep pnce w~th i·. you. · :Wiiite us now succc•f of tJ:ie . l)peiators. Bonds/1 ~~ry ;~ t4'1( th~ c' CC ID , 1 ~i:.._,.... ,'fbi :marijets ,~ ~ 1 ,.______ , , 1 · 1r" , i -.,.,,,_.. . ._. , / ' JolJ,off rdrne th'ro11~l! ' the The, ~'~ ' " I~ 1\e,: . iSBUedl ••~-- us. , Our T-•;"" {l(f;f ' ~ - · -~- f /H ',,Jl .q;llt:'r'~il !'J 1 :.·e1tz .·· i/1 : ; ·, l~fll7 day . · is received~ IJ1llllD11U.,rs:~or: 1~ . your •·'Bn,rAol'lnLf' . whb aN ' ambition$ to stl,plied,/,·': by i" [ :.:· ·:· );~{ >',~e that the-fih~li:~ . ~ -1;~-::accord ttJ the 1.a ' . ~ ~ • ·•J,· .'.: ~ ReJni~ .:are . f o ~ ·· ·'" "'"""-.-..-::• :or • .. , : .......- - - . . . . . . ; ·•···Tlte ,- ~ #,,~• c~~~~ ~!)\bet R?fo,; ~ i ti! .,,:~ '/ii ' . ? , J . • · • ·· • · , · . fj ,i7Je;, - ,Q. ft. ··. '• r [y sol,1 G,n,ma1 pttrp08E Notes, Ibis oot &hat wl o_f1ean Woe,·th • 'certai whole l w~ Tl confom of Lott u:cept to Prm Bondll at thei1 eotirel1 Those; agrtt I iDleft',;1 to hau io11e11 0 '!-~)~~-~*: ::~~: D~~=::::F:r:h~~ ~l I '\ ~ I ,.. THIS CO.UPON l:NTITLES YOU TO FULL PETAILS. ; ;,,..1( ,.·J .._~. J,•1· - ~ ~ f i n d 4mia Stamp to help t.o pay posbl,,«ea~ · · . ,\· T~;}' NMM -" ·-;. ,., ·i · . : · · ._. -.. . "l.!.,t-~,;;..- ,__ ,c, -.; ' 1'! NdemJ •priu feetly ;,.,,, I ! ' ....' .t...,. ,... ----:..-------•---,---\-· .. ~ co., De,t.136, 11-2,U.-.1! s~ai ' . ;:c-~:- ·:;:~,, i~in- l~~: l; _ ., ._:, J, f.•.,{J.;:,.~:., .•·. , ,. .: .. ' lat.ion, . -~~ ;- T· r-··- .. -- . . .,, . ;r, , , . . 0 '· ,,, ~, · ,:, ··• :'.\-'~ ....,., --- they cc , , ·; · ~ - ~ - · - .U.f kus •' ~ . : · -.t. ~- _,1- ...,,: i' ,-,.... TnOowu,Daa:TDIJl-.,e.,...,S __ .t-QII...._ , ·. , I -- of for w hle , .and 11 .Fi: Ia n 8{,01 Octol Roya l)ra11 Hall, Jan I Jul, Apl Oct p and J. A . ~._ .. . - 1~ ·~. ~. .-- .-.:~ .. -, \ or• .~-; . _ . :· -/;.(~.-~~}'.< ~-~- ;. Ir : i:"+· ~ i. . . . ffo~. 1he ~c»l~r 5826 oh. . . to r1'ln ;• ~ r Fr. 6(H),000 to Fr; ·100. ii., ,'., >, •.•, ' , : i' ! : ~· ii''.,..\l'~-'1 ••. ! :i : ' -~::::·:·::·P4» .m.,).2rf ~ u<;'.. )rJ}·,•. ·•mebt& oUh., ~~- ~IL ·, ,i• , · i .. _;1.· ;.~~fi:: ,) ,·,T8.:n,:.:..:..r~ , ~ ~=· t 'Js. : i, o , ~ ::'''p'J):1,\,,.:,.:t.:::, •,:;t•,t:~.,', ' ';,\;, '/:1, !Congo 1 1 · f ' Ottd11➔i',';:.,,;./•· l ', 1 . . I CQ~• $1~ :1: f1- 8 !;~{~!·~of1.Fr; ~• · City.ofP P.~ich>aijn(t;~111 2, draw:i~ the,hol~er 8760 :cijia','~ ,t.o r~v! ,~ 600.000 to Fr. JOO.: ,,. : 0 ·~=~ J.,.. : 'd nlrii"p :. i• · ~~: r.t~~:;:ez,.i (:~g,a~rr,/~ti . , : 1 - f, !I O"i ; ~ )~~.... , ~~ ;'; 'i 1' p ~ r . , of I B~lla City or Paris J aN ' . . l90&. ' ' • Oiq of. ~ 1899 City df Li.-e 1905. ,, . ~ C()ogo ~ 't 1 I ~ ~I M' ! ~I driwioga,eaeh ~- ~ 811~ IJClll9· to, .. ,·.... ~' . r IL s--:ie. ) ;111araa , Iii• ~.. '°·'· 8 o ~ - ~ wiu • I ) .,,~ w~,:~,.wl'rtl&&. , ' ! l , .L:, ,., , ·, ' ,,cf;' ,,;,,,h " ' ' ·•:'·.~•,,: ,·•••,: : c:.;.,· , \, • ,,, 7 E: 0 1;· · , ,' :.1 _!', , ·., 11. ,''·, :·.,, ,,. !' t. a 'J . . ! p. ~, . ·. Fi-. I ):i~g i~ :;~ j it"o'l~~D~ '~ ' 1•fand 1:15P,~ ~;:;:t'f:0 : ' ' ! <;;,: , • :!P,ai ,., ! !plJ.' :~ •1.-.i •witha ?·'.' . •!' . :·•'•:..:,.. . : .,r, :.,.,' } : : ·.'.·.r•.',·, · ··'••.·,·,·•' ~, .' ,. .'·,n ·• .· .' ·.,•....:: .·,, ...... : the ', ·-, •_1. , ·. ~ - i • · · ,:.r, 1 :~~ ,,•' ~--.., I '' : · . pri"" , • ,.., ·,• , . · -,~ .·.·.i,,>.• ii• ~ ·._~,c ~ Jf*/ \ : ' · ' ; • :l; ., .. '·{ 1 , ' ' I ,., , hj' ' · · '' ' 1 H ,I 1 ,, l;~: ,. I 1 " _; J.,,,:,:i::, ~,,:~ ' '" ;·_ )\ I ' ' ° 1'1.) .. ftF~J®n ' .· f 'l•il ' . ' ' ' ! ' ~pMe >iallM, ··IIP~Df !U ,weO; :;I · ~!~-tif~-- {!~ . ho·~ . . r 97,Q~i.,.:~ .'', :, 1:-' ~ :t , . · ~ , ."~:..-=~,.~~-""f~ .~, ~_i~.:(~··•~ ,,, n. 1an, :Red 0l"OIIS. ! ., . 1 :. : • ' ,. ~❖-- . ' ' d!. ,' _ .;.1.4··i,i _. ·....•,~ . •,.,:···. 1 I ~ )~!\ . '. . . . •· ·• "~ . ~ . _ : .f . ~ . : ~ . , ,•'. ;',', .:, •.11H8'9,-:: ~ . . : : -... •11- , I ' ll, ))eti}aquJa · :' .' .1 , ,0 . ong. o • free ' , , . 8 , te, . , :._1,. C , . ity, of, MM!. ,." · • ·d., S.nlii i' ; •. . . . .•...:•,•.·.. •·., Ow■ l 'Pu, a, <>r Ra. ;;..;lff,•.•;·•·iL:'·, ·,•,:.I,l,:.,.:•~· :! . . , , ,, -r..., :~ ~ . D,E LIJ1. •·· ,' 1 , mi, of ~:ntwe~ · 1 .' Bl.:. U081' . . '· h1n .Cft1 of ~ :' ·\~~i ,1) 3: '•~ ,, :f''; ' :t;J';\, '1'11■ Oommut.i · ,_ ., ' : · I ~-;J~:~ ·t . :~ · ~J. ,.;----:- ~;..ni • r ~ce . ... ~r Ila. ,-J ,., :~ _:.:~ ,-~.,..·• ,,,•, • ••.~:l:._;,:c•, .:,., ·, I],,·, ~ - - - JDUOW•- "I' , , }llt1i~~rtf4'S1T~:--7 · ,. ,, : 1 i.P~ma N ~ ft~icli'ario , .~ °F~ :uo. . ,. : :t ~-, r._o ,wit~_: ~r·•n,·~. ·~ 'i,&?~~1-"in,~: • V .p,·· :~;• 'i • , ) /1: ", :·:~!1 :fl ' : ' ', i-., p·, ," ' . · ] ,.,. 1 ~ ~ :. • h,.·, lJ}. ,', ) ,; i , Tt