~-···-,CHIUII A RECORDS. GOVERNMENT OF INDIA. TTAl\,f"D llVlllJ..'J POLITICAL-B. f 1J/ Proceedings, May, l-9l-8-, nos. 342-343. e India Office that information may be supplied in ftifore as to the result of important con• ;oiracy trials and the extent to which sentences in such cases are carried into effect. .idence and onki ni the LieutenanMfovernor of the Punjab in connection with the Lahore Second Supplementary Conspiracy Case. f 'Letters, etc., and subjects. 1-4 ~ to.Mr. Ginnd's Question in Parliament, no. 5, dated the 21st February 1917, regarding the ~:,E-rof Fersonscxecuted and sentenced to penal servitude, respectively, in connection with 11?-gcd political conspiracy aga.in.st British rule in India and how the tribunal which tried cases Was constituted 5 'e India Office, no. 1112, dated the 27th April 1917, forwarding a copy' of the judgment ~~ir.i ComT1i~:s:s10ners ~~. tihe Second Supplementary Lahore Conspiracy Case . and a · copy o; : the evidence recorded, together with a copy of the order passed by the LieutenaritGove:rnci.r of the Punjab in this connection .. 5-11 PRE VI0~3 REFERENCES. 'PoH; A., September 1916, nos. 403-410. Poll: A., May 1916, nos. 219- 221. Poll. A., March 1916, nos. 619-665. foll. A., October 1915, no. 91. JudL A., December 1915, nos. 101-149. ✓ Poll. Dep.,-February 1916, no. 27. it . , _,,,- ,I Poll-:---0~,' September 1915, no. 21. , Ju~l. f·, March 1917, nos. 315-330. LATER REFERENCES. , PolL Depi; July, 1~17, no. 32. Poll ..A., Septeru,por 1918, nos;· 5c:...-77, I CONFIDENTIAL. PCrLITICAL B-MAY 1917. Nos. 342_.:_343. REQUEST BY THE INDIA OFFICE THAT INFORMATION MAY BE SUPPLIED IN FUTURE AS 'TO 'THE RESULT OF IMPORTANT CONSI'IRACY TRIA.uD a1w Ui..1!.j EXTENT TO VflIICH SENTENCES IN SUCH CASES ARE CARRIED INTO EFFECT. JUDGMENT, EVIDENCE AND ORDRR OF THE LIEUTENANT-GOVERNOR OF THE PUNJAB IN CONl\ECTION "\VITH THE LAHORE SECOND STJPPT,RMRNTA RY CONSPIRACY CASE. Denii-c!fficial letter from M. rJ. Seton; Esq., Secretary; ~fodicial and A:bl-ic Department, India Office, Whitehall, Lond,an, S.W., · to the Hon'ble Sir Ja;;nes DuBoulay, K.C.I.E., Secretary to the Gm)e:rnment of India, Home Department, no. J. & P.-829-17, dated the 26th February 1917'. Pri'l,a'z. There are signs of a revival of Parliamentary questions on the internal conditions of India, and I think that it would be of material assistance to this Office if we eould have early reports . of the results of important conspiracy trials. 218t February. I enciose .a copy of a question and answ~r in the House of Commons on the Lahore conspiracy cases. When drafting an answer to this I found that we had no official information whatever on the second supplementary cases the judgment in which was reported in the" Pioneer Mail" of the 13th January. And recently we have not, I think, had any reports of the results on important conspiracy trials (at any rate outside Bengal) until the judgments were sent here. But this does not matter so much, as we have newspaper accounts. Still, it is not quite satisfactory to have. to rely on these in preparing Parliamentary answers. 2. V\7here our information is embarrassingly defective is that we never seem to hear from the Government of India how far sentunces in such., cases are carried into effect. I wrote to ..· D . F b l!HG Wheeler at the end of 1915 for' official informa27 Pohtical eposit, . e ruary .~ ' no, · tion as to the commutation' of sentences in the original Lahore conspiracy case= which he duly sent me. But we have ne'ver heard what w~s done on the sentences in the first supplementary case, except that we happened to notice from a reprint in a London paper of an American journalist's interview with Sir Michael O'Dwver that only five out of the six men sentenced to death were actually hanged. NP doubt th~se ()om.mutations are mentioned in Indian newspapers, but it is.very laborious to hunt for them. We are trying to cut down the number of reports which the Secretary of State asks for from the Government of India, e.g., we have agreed that we don't want the full ;series of police malpractice cases, and we ·are very relu~tant to press you for fresh reports. But it would really help us very much to get an official record of the sequels to important _po1iticalt.rials, and I do not think it would cause much trouble at your end to send them. I shall be greatly obliged if you will consider the matter. Extract from House of Commons DebateS, dated the 21st Februa't'y 1917. Conspiracy Trials (India). Mr. G,innell.-Asked the Secretary of State for India if he is now in a position to state the number of persons executed and sentenced to penal servitude, respectively, in connection with · the alleg~d political conspiracy against .British rule in India ; and how the special tribunal which tried those cases was constituted ~ Mr. Charnberlain.-There !S no doubt as to the reality of the conspiracy, which has been th~ subject of tbxee trials before special tribunals, each consisting of two Sessions judges an.Ii 2 an Indian pleader. I gave the Hon'ble Member on the 12th December particulars of the sentences in the first trial. In the second six men were sentenced t o death (five of \Vhom were executed) and forty-fivf to transportation for life; in the third six men were sentenced to death and five to trarn,porta.tion or imprisonment for life. I have not yet received an official report .of this last trial, which ,ms not concluded until last month, and I do not know whether any of the sentences were commuted. no. 342 . . QUESTION AND ANSWEi'.t IN COUNCIL, NO. 5, DATED THE 21ST FEBRUARY 1917. Judgment, e,vidence and order of the Lieittenant-Governar of the Punjab, in connect1:on with the Lahore ·8eeorul l3 ,1.ppl.ementary Conspiracy case. Pleasf: see the demi-official letter from Mr. Seton. We have now received without a covering letter the ·judgment, etc., in the Second Supplementary case ar.d may send on the papers to India Oifice by Secretary's letter. Draft submitted ,for approval. Briefly, 18 persons were accused of whom one _is absconding. a:·eait with as follows :_:. The remaining 17 were 0 Sentenced to death Sentenced to transportation for life Sentenced to 2 years' rigorous imprisonment Acquitted 6 5 I 5 Totai 17 Of the six ~entenced to death the local Government has commuted the sentence of one (Kartar Singh) to one of transportation for He. t - 2. It will he seen·from paragraph I ·of the order made by the Lieutenant-Governor that the reply given to. the·• question in Parliament, was ccriectly answered so far as the judgments in the First and Soco;nd Supplementary Lahore Conspiracy trials are concerned~ . The· order by the Lieutenant~Governor which we now propose to forwa.rd wiU show to, what extent the sentences in the last case have been carried into effect. . 3. We invariably send the India Offioo a. copf Of the jud~~nts in all conspiracy ·cases. What the India Office now ·ask for is infor:rnation &s to how far 'the sentences in these cases are • carried int~ effect. This is the fkst tim~. we have been asked. for this inforro:ation to be supplied as a general, 'Qlle. · · ~n. ·Mr. _Set-on's demi-offici~letter no. J. and P.-~271-15, dated the 30th Po1ltie4fDepo:3it, F~brna.ry l9.lG, no~ 27_ Dece10ber 1915, we wertf asked to furnish such inforn:iati~n in regard 'to · the origina.i La.h~re Conspira~y ·case and.· complit>d ·with the request.. '. · 4. A~ a. mt:iittcr of' fact we .do not' receivP- intJrmation as to the extent to whi~h sentence, in these oa.ses are carriod out. We may get some information indirectly in cases where the condemned. . persons petitic:m the Governor _.Genoral. ~n.:Cqun,~il •for .mercy, ·.e.g., as in the · original nd t 5uppl0mentary Laliore nd JudfciaLA .• Deoember 1_915, noa, 101-."49. an~ fi:ra a • .seco . . . .. . . • .·· ... . .· , ': : ·. < ,. , ,tri~.J~. Bllt ~4er,e _sue~ petition.s.·aire n1,raceived are not !!iWS.'l'e 0£ the extent to which the s<:mtcn,cc.,,,;lire,1~I10d., 1ow ef!e~·t .unless; tha 1-0ca.l ·, Govornm.ents concerned report -the ·matter to '~~:.;,. Jmpoi:tai;it. ~.nspiracy trials ·. have been held • in Bengal, the Un~t,ed Provinces, ,thp Pup.jab all.~ ~urlll~; - Jn tke .,case of Burma. the :Mandalay Conspira,cy d~~ is, now in progr~~s. After is1:n1e 'qf H;e qr,aJtjn the filef w~ ro:ay ask these Govern• ments kindlv t6 lot US 'know , in tbe' case of future conspiracy IJl' Important, trla\11 ·we , ,- • /. . ' . ·. · , ''{rHhe result of the' ~~land , . : • the ·Mandala)' con'spirac~ trial .' . I ·': {j) h6w·:mr theS(';nte~s are .:arried into efiec't: ~-. ' •·· In doing so we may stite th~ difficulties e~perienced by tho India Office in the a.bse'1ce :>f . e~dy information on these points. ·· A. L.,---23-4-17. 1. Burcly one conspiract case in Burma has been completed. 2. A draf(demi-official reply Mr. Seton's letter dated Febro:ary 26th 1917 shou)d be put up. to S. R. . HmNELL,~24+17. - . A draft demi-official reply to Mr,· Set<>n has been 'i,dded % th'.e file. Aletter to .. loo.a l _G overnments willbe put .up as soon as orders have issued.'~ · '.: , , · ·•· ' ·· · ; : _ -~- T~e oth~r ~asJ a,tJVlanda.lay whi~h Deputy ,Secretary l'eferg-toi has alrea:d:r been c6m. pleted The papers Wbl'8 sent to the India · Office Poli ."tieal A., September 1916, nos. 403...::'...410. ' ·. · · · · ,. · last, September. LJ ·( ~~ As tha India Office want information with regard. to· future trials it is proposed to ask Burma iu addition for particulars of the case now proceeding at Mandalay. A. L.,'"-25-4-17: ' I Put up a draft .to the local' Governments. S. R. liIGNEI,L,-26-4-17. LETTER TO INDIA OFFICE, No. 1112, DATED THE 27TH APRIL 1917. "f'- · - Pro. no. 343. Rooubmitted with a draft to the local Go~~~nments for approval. A. L.,-3-5-17. S. R. HrGNELL,______. . 4-5-17. Mr. ·Seton's letter is m·arked privato, so_I think we had better not send it out. If he was in difficulty about answering a question he might have telegraphed for the information : we cannot possibly fore3ee a,ll the questions that may be asked. Drafts may issue as modified. J. H. DuBouLAY,-5-5-17. I have made one small change in the !eply to Mr. Seton. W. JI.·. V[INCENT],-7-5-17. Demi-official letter from the Hon'ble Sir James DuBoulay, KO.I.E., Secretary_to the Government of India, Horne Department, to M. 0. Seton, Esq., 0.B., Secretary: Judicial and Public Department, India Office, no. 1217-Politic.J,l, da.ted Simla, the 10th 1.11.ay, 1917. WiHyou kindly refer to your private letter no. J. & P.-829-17, dated the 26th February, 1917, in which you asked for information to be supplied in future &.::i to the result of important conspiracy trials and the extent to which sentences in such cases are c~rr.ied into effect ( . . ' Hitherto we have not received any official information as to the results of such trials until local Governments had furnished us witli' cofies of the judgments. These are sent on to you as promptly as possible. We do ~ot usu.ally receive these p~pers till some_ ti~e after the conclusion of theJ trial - the delay bemg no doubt _due to get~mg the ~atenal mto proper form and having it printed;. Again, we have not hitherto received sper1al reports as to the extent to which sentences are remitted or commuted, and have only had ~official oognisanoe of these matte...s in so far .as petitions for mercy have come up to the Governor General in Council. To fill in these gaps, I am asking the local Governments concerned to let us know in fu~ure the results of all conspiracy or other important trials as soon as p_ossible after their completion (copies of the judgme!:lts, etc., being s1mt on in due course). and the extent to which sentences have been modified on appeal. I think this will meet our wishes without giving much trouble here. 2. By last maH I sent a copy of the judgment and evidence in the second conspiracy trial at Lahore, together :with a copy of the orders passed by the Lieutenart-Goyemor with regard to the sentences imposed. Demi-o.ffioial letter from the Hon'ble Sir James DuBoulay, K.C.l.E., Seereta ry to the Government , <'1 India, Home Departtnent, to the Hon'ble Mr. J. G. Cumming, C.S.I., ·-0.l.E., Addit ional.Secreta.r y to the Government of Bengal; the Hon'ble Mr . R. Burn, C.S.I .• ~ Chief Secretary to the Government of the United Provinces; the Hon'ble Mr ..]. P. TJwmpson: Chief Ser,rP-tnry to thP- Gorernment of the Punjab; the Hon'ble Mr. W'. F. Rice, O.S.I., Chief Secretary to the Government of Burma, no . 121.8 -Polif:ical, dated Simla, the)Otk 'M{i,y, 1917. 1 1 I have received a letter fro1n the India Office complaining of the delay in receipt of reports of the results of important conspiracy trials and of the lack of information as to the modifi.ca.tfon ·of sentences awarded. rrhey point out that. uniess sueh information is promptiy supplied, they find great difficulty ip answering questions in Parliament. 2. As you know, the Government of 1ndia do not usually get any inf~rmati,on in the matter of these trials until they receive from local Governments it copy of the judgments recorded. A copy of these papers is tra .s'n_itted forthwith to the India Office for -t~e information of tl,ie ,;fii 4 .J Secretary of State ; but some delay 'i ntervenes before the Government QI India receive the papers owing no doub_t• to their having to be put into proper fo~p.1 and pririted .. . Again, yve do4not :receive regular reports ·as to· the extent to which rnntences ia these cases are remitted or commuted, and generally ca.n only gather information on the point in cases in which the Governor General in Council is petitioned for mercy. To fill in these gaps, I am to request that.with His pe:.rmission arrangements may be 'mad~ ·to supply the Government of India in futwe with a brief statement of the result of all conspiracy or other important political trials ( ) to Burma,only. (including the case now p~·oc~eding at Mandalay) ·as soon as · possible after their completioncopies of the judgments, etc., being forwarded in due course as at present. A brief report showing the extent to which the sentences awarded have been modified should also be forwarded as soon as the materiai is available. !l~::~:~P- Exd: by-M.D. C653H.D 5 PROCEEDINGS OF THE HOME DEPARTMENT, MAY, 1917. Request by India Office for information re. Conspiracies, etc . [Pr o. nos. 342-43. REQUEST BY THE INDIA OFFICE THAT INFORMATION MAY BE SUPPL!ED IN FUTURE AS TO THE RESULT OF IMPORTANT CONSPIRACY TRIALS AND THE EXTENT TO WHICH SENTENCES IN SUCH CASES ARE CARRIED INTO EFFECT. JUDGMENT, EVIDENCE AND ORDER OF THE LIEUTENANT-GOVERNOR OF THE PUNJAB IN CONNECTION WITH THE LAHORE SECOND SUPPLEMENTARY CONSPIRACY CASE . Answer to Mr. Ginnell's Quest,io·n, No. 5, dated 21st February; 1917. There is no dou bt . as to the reality of the conspiracy, which has been the subject of three trials before Special Tribunals, each consisting of tvvo Sessions Judges and an Indian Pleader. I gave the Ifon'ble Member on the 12th December particulars of the sentences in the first trial. In the second six men wme sentenced to death (five of whom were executed) and 45 -to transportation for life; in the third 6 men were sentenced to death and 5 to transportation 'or imprisonment for life. I have not yet received an official report of this last trial, which was not concluded until fast month and I do not know whether any of the sentences were commuted. Conspiracy Trials (India). Mr. Ginnell.-Asked the Secretary of State for India if he is now in position to state the number of persons executed and sentenced to penal servitude, respectively, in connection with the alleged political conspiracy against British rule in India; and how the special tribunal which tried those cases was constituted ? lJ([r. Ohamberlriin.-There is no doubt as to the reglity of the conspiracy; which 'has been the subject of three trials before special tribunals, each consisting of two Sessions judges and an Indian pleader. I gave the Hon'ble Member on the 12th December particulars of the sentence~ in the first trial. In the second six men were sentenced to death (five of whom were executed) and forty-frve to transportation for life ; in the third six men were sentenced to death and five to transportation or imprisonment for life. I have not yet received an official report of this last trial, which was not concluded until last month, and I do not know whether any of the sentences were commuted. No. 1112, dated Simla, the 27th April 1917. ]'rom-The Hon'ble Sm JAMES DuBoULAY, K.C.I.E., ·c.S.I., Secretary to the Government of India, Home Department,· To-Srn T. W. lioLDERNESS, K.C.B., K.C.S.I., His Majesty's Under Secrefo,:::-y of State for In,p.ia. · \Vith reference to the Home Department ietter no. i503, <;lated the 4th Ivlay, 1916, I am directed to forward, for the information of the Secretary <;>f State, a copy of the judgment of the Special Commissioners in the Second Supplementary · Lahore Conspiracy case and a copy of the evidence recorded. forward a copy of the orders passed by His Honour the Lieutenant-Governor of the Punjab on petitions to him from. persons convicted in tk~ trial. 2. I am also Exd. by~M.D. C653HD Pro.no. 342 . . INDEX. PART !.-PRELIMINARY . (1) Introductory. (2) Jurisdiction in regard to Thaka,r Singh (15). (8) Police investigations. (4) Confessions a,nd approvers' testimony. (5) Accomplices. i l . I i ! 'i ! PART II.-HISTORY. i Ij A.-The Revolutionists abroad. (1) The revolutionary party in the United States, (2) Sedition in Penang; Singapore, Hong Kong and Shanghai. I I I (3) Manilla. (4) The revolutionary movement in Canada. (5) The Siamese plot. B.-The migration to India. C.-The Revolutionists in India. (l) The head-quarters at Amritsar and Lahore. (2) The meetings at Ladowal, Moga. and Badowal. (3J The !viian Ivlir and Ferozepore '>ttauks of November 1914 and the Jhar Sahib affair. (4) Seduction of students. (:o) Seduction of villagers. (6) Sedu'3tion of troop~. (7) Seditious literature. (8) Manufacture of 'bombs. (9) Collection of arms. {10) Dacoities. (11) Murders. (12-) AH.,,-.l,-e1 "" J..-,.i,lges. {13) The rising of the 19th February. (14) The Kapu.rthala raid and Walla bridge murden;. (15) The Mandi plot. D.-Tbe Revolutionists and Germany. E.--Final conclusions. PART III.-lNDIVIDUAL CASES. Gr.oup I.-The Canadia1i Group. \ Balwant Singh (3}, Rattan Singh (4), Bishan Singh t5), Dalip Singh (6), Dial Singh ,(7), Hari Singh (9), Jita Singh (10), Kartar Singh (11), Munsha Singh {13). , Gr.oup II.-T!te F:attegar!t~Mand, Grotp. Amar Singh (1), Babu Ram (2), Fazl Din (8) and Nama (14). Group · IJJ,-M,iaceltaneous. Kehr Singh (12), Thakur Singh (15), Hafiz Abdulla (17), Rur Singh (18). Schedule of ,convictions and acquit_tals. JU DG~lENT. PART I. 1.-lNTRODUCTORY. t The complaints in the case now before us affect 18 parsons, one of whom is absconding. The Court was constituted by Punjab Government notification no. 671Judl.-l, dated 4th November 19i6, under section 4 (1), Defence of India .Act, and as regard 16 of the 18 accused, orders under section 3 of the Defence Act and seetion 196, Code of Criminal ProcedurA, were issued bv the local Government on the 30th October, and as regards the remaining"' two 0::1 the 13th N ovembcr 1916. The Court commenced its sittings on the 8th November 1916, concluding the hearing on the 14th December, the total number of days employed in Court 1 _ • on oerng Zit1. · A total of 117 witnesses was examined for the prosecution and 101 for the defence. Of the accused accused no. (1) is a returned emigrant from the States, (12) and (15) from the Far East, accused (17) from Manilla, accused nos. (3). (4). (5), (6), (7), (9), (10), (11), (13) from Canada, and (2), (8), (14) and (18) do not app~ar ever to have left India. , The evidence before us hairnovered, though necessarily at much shorter length, the whole of the ground covered in the two previous conspiracy trials and the connected murder cases heard by the prior Tribunal, and in addition evidence has been given before us in regard to new matter, particularly the inception and growth of the . Ghadr movement in Canada aud Ma11illa, and activities in Siam and Mandi, and important evidence has been produced with reference to the connection of Germany with the Ghadr movement. We propose as far as possible to follow the same plan of judgment as that adopted by the previous Tribunals, dealing :first with certain preliminary points to ..-:,lear the ground, then with ihe history of the movement and finally with .i.udividu.ul uaac;o . . Wher~'the matter now beiore us has already been dealt with by our predecessors and does not directly affect the particular• acts of the aeoused before us, we do not propo~e. to do more than indicate, in the briefest- possible terms, what evidence on the same points has been placed before us and· to note our conclusions thereon. We prof0Se first to dispose of a few prelimi~ary matters. 1 2.-JURISDICTION OF COURT WITH REFERENCE TO ACCUSED (15). An objection was ta.k en on behalf of the accused (15), against 't he jurisdiction of this Court to try him for any offence, on the ground that he is a nonBritish subject resident of .Kapurthala territory, and he was not alleged to have committed any act in British territory. . , The objection was general in its terms, without speciiying and giving detailed reas01:,.s. It waE' withdrawn i. by his counsel with his concurrence; at a later stage 0£ the case ; but the learned Government .Advocate pressed for a decision on the point, and as it had been raised; and we could not assume jurisdiction merely on accuseifs consent, we have heard arguments and proceed to decide it. Unfortunately accused's counsel, on the instructions of his client, would not support the objection, and we have had only the Government Advocate's arguments on the point. The importance of the question, the finality of our order, the conflict of viewE amongst Indian authorities, the dive1JSity of opinion, even among English Judges, the disadvantage of hear~ng only one si_de's argument necessi~a~e our going minutely and thoroughly mto every rulm~, as to the am.enab1hfy _of foreigners to the British Courts, for offences committed beyond their territorial jurisdiction. The points with which we have to deal fall under the following h~~:- . (1) Whether a foreigner ·is triable by Indian British Courts for an offence committed within British India. (2) In what cases is he liable to be tried in India for offences com• mitted •outside British India, generally, or partieula:rly for .offence following under the head of waging, abetting or at• ·tern pting to wage war against the King. (3) Whether, at the time of the commisson, he should be bodily present in British India to make himself triable by the British Courts. · (4) Whether his act, actually committed outside British India, but taking effect _or producing criminal consequences in British India, can render him liable to Britsih Courts. (5) Whether an act of abetment committed through another at the foreigner's instigation, conspiracy or a.id, can make him liable. · (6) Wnether his presence in British India, subsequent to his committing the fvffence punishable under the Indian Penal 0Qde outside British India, can give jurisdiction to Indian Courts. N aturaily we have to look for the determination and ·solution of the above propositions, first, tJ Statutory Law. It is obvious that according to section 1 of the Indian Penal Cod~, the operation of the Code is limited to the territories which are or may be vested in His Majesty by the Statute 21 and 22, Victoria, Chapter 106. · Section 2 makes every person liable to punishment, for every act or 1 omission contrary to the provisions of the Indian Penal Code, of which he shall be guilty within the said territories. Prima facie both aliens and Brith;h subjects, irrespective of caste, creed, or nationality, are amenable to this law for acts or omissions contrary to the Code of which they shall be guilty in British India. In other words the section excludes from its operation acts or omissions of which they may be guilty outside Ruch territories . . Section 3 deals with cases in which by a special enactment, offences committed beyond J ndia are brought ,~ithin the cognizance of the Indian Courts. Section" 3 does not throw much light on the question before us. Section 4 is really explanatory, in part, of section 2, making a certain . class of people indictable to British Courts for offences committed beyond :British India. -Section 4 does not deal with the nature of the offences, but only with a class of people. We need not repeat the plain language of the sAction, but one thing is clear that no provision is made in this section regarding the amen• ability of a non-British subject, who may be a servant of the King, for acts done outside India, but for which he :tnay he guilty within British India. It hl\s been pressed upon us 'by the learned Government Advocate that in sect~on 2 the word " guilty )' occurs, not the word " committed,'' arid thereby he infers that the offender need not necessarily be, at the time of the coinmi~ion of the actj present in India. We leave this question open till we have reviewed all the authorities . .Our task is•rendered more diffl,@Ult when we have to consider the fact, 1 whether the . I( commission of an offence ' necessarily means an act done persona.Hy in British Indi~, or an act done constructively in the legal contempla.. . tion of law, and whether it has also the effect of rendering the offender ~uilty of the offence, although-he was not bodily present at the place where the effect independent of the cause takes .place. • f .,' 3 ..,._,,·-"I • r r In other words whether constructive presence in British India would be tantamount to· personal presence; whether, if the act be initiated beyond British India and completed ·within British territories, that is sufficient to create liability, and also whether a~ act of an agent is equivalent to one's own act so as to create ,..,riminal responsibility. Offences committed by a foreigner which fall within the purview of section 121-A require no special observation, as the section make~ everyone liable, whoever he may be, when he conspires in India or out of India to wage or to abet or to attempt to wage war against the King. He is guilty whether any act follows the conspiracy or not ; the mere act of conspiracy i~ punish~ ble under that section in contradistinction to the conspiracy mentioned in clause 2 of section 107 of the Indian Penal Code. J\fore conspiracy is a substantive offence, and it is only with regard to offences other than those which fall under section 121-A., and especially offences under section 121, that we ha-ve to eumine the authorities. We propose to deal first with the Chief Court decisions, for the reason tbat the p1·inciples enunciated therein are directly opposed to other High Court decisions, profm~&ing to be based on the latest exposition of · the law in England. 1 The first ruling which touches the point is Punjab Record 20 of 1878, ~o £ 878, Cri1 Criminal, which ruling :md the next following it, was delivered by three emi- tnina · nent Lawyer Judges of the Chief Court. This case deals with that part of the question which falls under clause 3 of our propositions. It was a case of an ordina,ry theft. The salient point niiised in it is contained in the following words. " If a subject of a Native State, by acts done in that SLate and not in British territory, abets thP, commission of an offence in British territm-y, and the offence is committed there in pursuance of the abetment, and the abettor is afterwards found in Eritis~ India, have our nwn Courts jurisdiction to try him for such abetment." The proposition could not be put in a clearer way. The answer was in the negative, based upon the well known judgment delivered bv Lord Chief J ustiee Cockburn in Rex ·ver-s·us Keyn, ·i.e., the F,·anconia c&se p;1blished in 2 Ex. l)ivision, :page 63. The judgment of the Chief-Court does not show under what clause of section 107 of the Indian Penal Code the acts charged against Dewa Singh and Ohattar Singh, abettor, _ fell, but it can safely be -presumed that the Judges did not draw any distinction between the 3 clauses. We will try and show, later on, that the case of abetment by conspiracy with an act followin~ thereon; a.s 1nentioned in clause 2 of section 107, stands on a different footing from ab.etment by instigation or by an act in aid. On the authority of the above r1+ling, Rex versus Keyn, it was held that in .. urt had jurfadiction to try the abductor. It was held that as the offence had become complete in fow,i~n territory; the offender conJ stances:-Schmidt, who was on the continent, corresponded with Bull, who · 'page · was in England, and asked the latter to get a plate engraved for the purpose of forgery. It was found on the facts that both of them were jointly engaged in planning the forgery; thP- order was ' given by Bull to an innocent agent for making the plate before Schmidt rf:'ached Englar.d, and on arrival in England both went to the house of the manufacturer and got the plate. They were tried for forgery. It was contended that Schimdt was, at the time when the order was given, on the continent, aud should not be indicted as a principal. Chief Justice Tendal held, that if an act in England had been done by an innocent person both would be liable, if both hltd been . abroad and, having planned forgery, one had given an order by letter, it. could not be doubted, therefore, that they were guilty as principals, and it could make no difference that iri that case one of them was in England and one outside. ;~:t: ~ot; fall ,,,. Mr. Justice Alderson concurred in this finding and remarked that " If a person does an act with a guilty fr.tent he is not the agent of any one, and if two have agreed to employ him he is the agent of both; it makes no difference whether both were in England or elsewhere; where they have once agreed to do the thine, the act of one is the act of all, although the rest be absent at th~ time.u ·we now come to a very important case, which was extensively referred to -in No; 20 -of 1878, 35 of 1880, and which formed the basis of thoi,e decisions, and from which quotations were freely made in both those rulings. This case , is Rex vereus K~yn 2, Ex. Div., page 63, lf)76~ of Both on account the ·elaborate nature of the judgment of Lord Chief Queen ver.sM• J us~ice Oock~u!n, and the _fact that a question 0~ juri.sdiction was . i:aised bt a -~r!~10! Ex. A 63 , foreigner cla1mmg exemption on the ground of his bemg a non-British subJect, 1876. 'pa~ _ ' ' and the fact that the court was composed of 14 Judges who differed materially on the point of jurisdiction, we are ju~tified in ·r eferring to it and .discussing it at great length. The majority of Judges · took the view of the Lord Chief. Justice, and it was due to His Lordship's decision that the Act 41, 42 Viet., Cap. 73,. fixing the three miles limit from shore for the purposes of territorial 3urisdiction, was ·passed. The judgment extends over 48 pages. Briefly the facts were as follows:-One Young, was a passenger by the British Steamer Strath,. clyde, bound from London .to Bombay, and when off Dover this steamer :Wa& 8 run into by S S. Franconia, whilst she was under the command and immediate direction of Keyn, the accused, whereby the Sfrathclyde w=:ts su~k ~nd Young was drowned. rrhe accused was a German in a German ship, of which he was in command, with practically a German crew and a Fr~nch pil?t. The point at which the Strathclyde was run down by the Fmnconia, waA distant one and 9/l0ths mile from Do, er pier, and. "rithin 2-½· miies of Do·v-er Bcacl1. The question of jurisdiction was raised by the prisoners, and it w3:s overruled ~ncl he was found guilty in the original court. On appeal three important pomts ·· were argued1 (1). W~eth_~r ~n,der ~he la~ ,of Eng~a;1,~ th~ rule of a 3-mile belt of tcrr1tor1:11 water b.aa beer~ esta:111sneu. ·whether it was a case of wilful murder or man~slaughter by T\Agl-igAnnA, ~n.n whAthm• t.his font, m~.rlA fl,ny differRnce n.s regards tho trial. Whether the English Court could try the prisoner, who was .a foreigner, if it were held that the 3-mi.le limit was not in force, and also whether death having occurred on a British ship caused by arr act done by the prisoner on his-a foreign-ship could amount to an act committed in British territory-in other words, whether it was necessary to show that he was personaily present in - the British ship or could his presence be assumed, as a presence in legal contemplation of law, as continuous, the death having followed the act done by the accused as a consequence of or an effect of a cause. 1 We are not concerned with the first two propositions ; it is only with regard to the third that we have to look to this judgment, whfo1. throws a good deal cf light on the question before us. Pliillim01·e, J. referring to the contention on behalf of the Crown, which was in the following words:-" That as the person injured was on board an English ship at the ti111e when he received injury, which was the immediate and direct result of the collision, an offence was. committed on board an English ship" held that "the act by which the woman died was not accused's act nor was it a consequence immediate or.direct of his act; he never left the deck nor did he send any misile from it to the other ship, and he cannot be consid'ered ·by the intendment of law to have been on board the British vessel." · It a-ppears that if the ~act of killing had been wilful according to Phillmore, - J. there would have been jurisdiction vested in the Court to try the p1isoner. Justice Lindley left the question open. , Justice Denman held that the English Courts had. jurisdiction over Keyn. It seems that, in his opinion, he was influenced by the fact that the rule of 3 miles territorial waters was prevalent, and for the purpose of jurisdiction he drew no distinction between murder and nian-slaughter, and approving King uersu,8 Coom.bes he held, that the principle enunciated in that case thaf the "intention is presumed to accompany the aot and. so the shot, •which takes effect·on the high seas, must be presumed to be accompanied by the intention with which it is fired, and both then together operate," and observed that the principle laid down in Coombes' case is one of good sense and sound law. According to this view the act of the prisoner was on th~ same footing. as an act done on the British ship, as both were on the high seas within the criminal jurisdiction of England. · Justice Grove took the view that a foreigner is triable by British Courts if he does any ant, which is pµnishable by the laws of EngJand, if that act is done .within th~ British realm, and a foreigner in tiring from a ship in . Eritish 1 waters is for the purpose of crbinally within the British realm. 1.'he argument is simply .ab inexpediente. He did not decide the question whether the offence was an offences committed on bo::trd a British s.hip. Justice Amphlett gave as his opinion, that, according to the decision in ltex veraus Coombes, the crime must, for the purposes of determining , ' • I 9 A II I. ·r the venue, be held to h~we been committed on the English ship, where the death occurred, but that that doctrine, founded as it is upon a convenient fiction, and binding no doubt upon· ,a British subject, does not decide the question ~which is whether a foreigner who committed the offence, while he was defacto outside English territory, is amenable· tc Engfoih law. With some doubt he came to the conclmd.on he could not . The Judge could find no authority to punish a foreigner who, at the time of t):i,e commission of the ; offence, was not within the territory, and consequently not owing it any allegiance. Justice Bret, agreeing with the Lord Chief Justice, held that the act Page 148. was not committed on either shin. There was no iurisdiction in respect of a complete offence committed, loc~lly within a British ship; the only j1ir-isdiction in respect ofilocality arises from the fact of the foreign ship being within the territoq of Great :Britain and therefore the Central Criminal Court had jmis• diction to try the case. 150 Justice Bramwell held " that as regar~s an act which is wilful it is Page do:rie where the will intends it should take place, Aliter where it is negligent''. 15 Justice Kelly agreeing with the Lord Chief Justice obseTved '' that the Page 1. right to seize and try "in England an offence committed not in Britfoh territory connot exist any more than the right to seize and try in En~land any foreigner for an act done in his own country, a foreign territory, which act may happen to constitute a criminal offence by the Law of England. " 152 Lord Coleridge observed that; unless the place where the offence was Page · ~ommitt:~rl W!'.l\;l w:u•t "f t,hA l'PA,lm lo~i:ill v ; ff!' nnlAQQ t ,hP r.ffPnCP -W/:IQ r>nmmit,tpn on board a British ship, whether that "'ship was locally within or without the realm of England, the conviction cannot stand. He agreed with Justice Denman, quoting Rex vm·sus Armstrong, that whether the Act be wilful or n~gligent, the offence is committed where the effect and not the cause takes place. He felt the weight of the :reasoning given by t.he Lo!'d Chief .J ustfoe, Page 160. The points for determination are given by Lord Chief Justice Cockburn, on page 160 and he observed " that no proposition of law can be m01·e incontest... 'able or more universally admitted than · that, that according to the general law of nations, a foreigner, though criminally responsible for a law of a nation not his own, for acts done by him, while within the limhs of that territory, cannot be made responsible to its law for acts done beyond such limits". A.r:guments of inconvenience are disposed of on page 231. As regards the opinion expressed by Justice Deman and Justice Lindley that 1 where a death takes place on board a· :Hritish ship, the offence was com"' mitted there, he referred to two rulings Rex versue ,Coombes and United States ve1·sus Davis, wherein it was held that . where a person fires a gun from a ship and kills thA person on board another ship, the offence is in point of law committljd on board the latter. · On page 233 he writes '' that homicid,e, whether it takes · the form of murder or man-slaughter, n~cessarily involves two things essentially distinct; the act of the party killing as the cause of death, and the death of the party killed as the effect of such act. Both are necessary fo constitute the crime, one may take place in one jurisdiction, and the other in another. . . " A 11,erson may be wounded at sea and may die on shore, and vice versa or a blow may be struck in one . place and death occur in another. In such a case, where is the complete offence committed? He answered in neither because in neither had the entire offence been committed, so said the olcl authorities. '~ In Rex versus Coombes, he said, the act causing the death began in one · jurisdiction, and extendfld into another from which, as its effect, death ensued in a case whete a man strikes-a blow with a club or blows out another's brain by putting a pistol to his he.a d the act t.a kes effect immediately. It he hurlff 10 ·· 1 , ..•'.•:·.· ·' ·l·; Page 234. I 1 •,· ··.• a stone or discharges a bullet from a gun or a pistol to another person at a distance, the stone or bullet has to make its way throubgh a given space before it strikefl the blow it is intended to inflict, but the low is as much the act of him who casts the stone or fires a gun as though _it Las taken effect immed.iat1Jy, In such a case the act, in view of its taking effect imr~ediately, is a continuing act till the en,d has been effected. It may well be held that the <; ·:: : ~~k:s ~Jf!~t !he~t::uti:ti~::e:~: ~'t~i! ~~t;:~:tfi!ioi~' !~o1~~~~~~ b;;1~! :.~'..''. . \·V "' j enough to say that Rex versus Uoombes was _rightly decided, but t~e ques~i?n is not, ·whether the death of the deceased, whwh no doubt tock place m a British ship, '!as the act ?I defend~1;t i~ ~ su?h .ship, :Vh~th~r ~he defend~nt; at the time the act was done, was himself w1thm Br1t1sh Jl1r1sc.hction. In pomt of fact i .?~t ·- 1~1 '.f{i i: !Ji~ ii l :~gt · :~/ t {i.: :: }.-~ i'. >t ·~; ! ": trI ,L: · ;;!:lif\f~~\lr:~i:i:ti~fl~~:!~~~t~::F{~l~:!i~~~!~~~ttn!~~rea~: " One who, from the bank of a river dividing two territories, fires a rifle shot at a person on the opposite side cannflt be said to he within the territory where the Rhot strikes its object. But in order to render a foreigner liable to the local laws he must at the time the offence was committed have been within British territory, if on land, or in ·a British ship if at sea. No doubt in Adam versus The People, it was held that a criminal act done through the instrumentality of an innocent agent in law is t~e act of the principal, and will be triable at a JJlace · in which the act was done, · but said the Lord Chief Justice, the case is not at all satisfactory as the ~oreigner at the time w~,s really 81 0 .f:! t;h~ti:dt:~a: ~~:theJ:~:ic:a1,::\~:::r:t !fth itri:d tcit~ Justice . i , , R.e"f- ,.."!:.sua, Olip~- · C .)omi.nP' . t.o Rex versus Oliphant we find the facts of the case to be ·,w I am zi .r..mg s Bencn, • fl f oll A fi . b • • I d l d 1906. br,e. y·.as . o cws : . rm ~~ryi1:1g on .. us1ness 1n ,on on emp. oye. accused li} I I to manage the branch estabhsned m Paris. The agent had to recover money, i;[ I i . fi.11 ~p slips, a~d trans~it th~m to. London -t~ be posted _in t~e 9.ash B:ok. He .• .f~\ l l re~e1 ved c'ertarn sums m Paris, om1 tte_d to ~nter the rece1 pts m sn ps, . ~1sa ppro. /fi/l ! pr1ate,d the money, and fraudulently mtenaed that such amount reahsed should not appear in t~e ~ash bo?k in. London. He _wa~ t:ie~ in London? and it was ~ held that, the Cr1m1qal Courts m London had 3urisd1ction to try him. It was j : ur~ed that ther~ is a differenee between the · question of venue and }'wr-isdiction ; j !h!l~ t~e. authori!ies relatin~ to venue are no authorities on the questi_cn of ih1 ; I 3ur1sdwt10n, but it was admitted that an aot begun abroad and completed in the " '· county frying the offender, gave jurisdiction, though when the offence is wholly :~ committed abroad there is no jurisdiction; and as no part of this offence was com ~ .. mitted in England exemption . was claimed. ~rhe prosecution relied on Rex: ~,·. • I. vere!M Brisac and Rex versus Johnston, and contended that where an act was ~! committed outside jurisdiction, hut having,, an effect inside jurisdiction, it is triable in the place where it ~as effect. Lord Alverstone, 0. J., in delivering judgment; remarked that he w<:11:s -unable to draw any distinction between.sending information hv oost; or bTI' .... •~.~ ·.·.·l ·'•lt·:. L ···, ·:' ..·. .·.1 ··. ±.· I . ~.:·,. ·. :~ J: .---.r. IH ~t : f,~ 1:·! fl Ii I .,/-.i.~.l.·;.:I·:·•.·.·· . "· \, 2 ,I '~, telephone, and giving the same by direct personal communication, ..a.~d follow'ing Rex· versus Munton and Rex versus Brisao held, that where any act is done out of several acts, the vemle of any such act confers jurisdiction on the place where it is done. ·· Rex 11ersus Rodgers,. Re;x: ver~us RodgArs was a case of embezzlement hf a cle~rk whose duty Qneen'• :Senoh. 8, if was to remit from Europe all money collected by him to his employers in 1877 1878 • · lfiddle8ex. '· He realised a sum and never remitted it. He wrote a letter in which he did not mention the fact of the money collected, with the object that it should be believed he had not collected the money. It was decided that the receipt of the last letter in , Middlesex was sufficient to give jurisdiction. References were made to other · rulings in which it was held . that obt.aining money ·.by f~lse pretence in the country where the t'rial · takes p\a~e is enough to give jurisdiction., though the person who wrote and posted . 11 t it was in another county, and that a letter speaks continuously from the moment of its being posted until the receipt by the addressee, and gives jurisdiction, as a '' letter is intended to act on the mind of the recipient, its action upon his mind takes place when it is received. The same is the case of the firing of the slm~ from a place outside the boundary of the county into another county. The offence is committed in the county within which th~ blow is given. So with a letter ". The letter is a continuing act until the receipt. Huddleston J. took a contrary view quoting Rex -versus Murdock, Page 38. holding that the effect on the mind was complete when the letter was posted. He distinguished the case of false pretence, as in it the offence is not complete till the pretence is made to some one. In Rex vers·us Demarny the editor of a newspaper inserted an advertise- Rex ~ersus. Dem1 ment relating to the sale of obscene books and photographs. The Police, on n:1:f·~ • K. B~s°i the · basis of this advertisement, obtained from the advertiser, who was a 19;ton, page ' foreignerj obscene books and photographs. The defendant was tried on the charge of causing an-d. publishing obscene books and wss convicted. Lord Alverstone1 Okie/' Justice, held that it was a case of abetment, and foliowed Rex versus Oliphant, and upheld the conviction~ · In Rex versus ,Stoddard the accused had an office in London, and Rex versus Stodanother in Holland, and wai:i a proprietor of a newspaper called: the Football~~~• m,!~~hv-~~ .Reaord, which announced each week that a certain sum of money would be ~;:-'v'oi~;;" is.t'v. -= divided as prizes among those who gave correct forecasts of the result of football matches played on a particular day. Each competitor had to pay an entrance foe: and send it with a coupon to the ·accused.'e ~ffice in Rolland. The names of tho winners were sent from Holland to London, and the money was provided by . the accused in London, and was sent out from there. It was alleged that this appellant inserted the name of bogus winners. It was held that the London Court had jurisdiction. It appeared that up to 1907 the business was personally conducted by appellant in London, and it was contended that, inasmuch as the postal orders ,ind letters contain• ing money were received by the defendant's agent in Holland, the court had no jurisdiction, but it was held that when the postal order and letter containing m.ly on the ground that the facts of those case did not demand a 4i!fou•on of a foreigner's liabilities. We cannot hold · that even in the case of , . . . ~-~l)i? . .f ;. ... .,... • :~ .. 15 abetment and conspiracy in pursuance of which an act is done at a IJlace other than where it was conceived, there is no jurisdiction in the place where the act abetted has been committed. We admit that the question of personal presence and presence by intends ment of law is not free from difficulty, as remarked By Mr. Russei in his Law of Crimes, pag·e 56, wherein, after quoting all the authorities, he says that it cannot be said that any complete and effective consideration, has been judicially given to the questi_on. The author of that well-known book says that cases may fall under three heads- r (1) When the act is initiated in another part of the Btiti~h Empire and takes eff eet in :England. (2) When the act is by a British subject, and is initiated in a foreign country but takes effect in England. (3) When the act is initiated in a foreign country, and takes effect · in England, but is done by an alien. The first two propositions are easily met by the prov1s10ns of sections 2 and 4 of the Indian Penal Code. With regard to (3), besides the authorities which we have reviewed, two others are cited, namely, Bex versus Pelthier and Rex versus Taylor. The former case was of an alien who was convicted for sending a letter, containing menaces, without rersonable and probable cause. The letter was posted in Russia, and received in England, and the defendant was in Hungary, when he gave the letter to an agent to be posted. In Rex 1 versus 'l aylorit was held, th.at if a person, in a foreign country, sets another person in motion as his agent, by whom a forged cheque was presented, by his procurement in England, this would be . an uttering for w~ich he might he convicted in Engl1:1nd. There is an other casd Rex ver~us Menton bearing ontbe question in dispute, in which it was held that, when the criminal • matter arose wholly abroad, there is no jurisdiction, but when a false ' return ~~s ~eceived, a~d _fr~u~ completed, by their allowance in En-gland, the Engns.o \.,OUit had jU.nsdict10n. It was brought to our notice by the learned Government Advocate - that in section 2 the word!' guilty" appears, and not" committed;'' and thus an alien is amenable to the Indian British Courts for a_u act or omission contrary to the provisions of the Indian Pena} Coda, though he was not present therein, at the time when that act was done in British India. In other words., section 2 dispenses with bodily presence. Our view is that the me.re use of the word "guilty" in section 2, in appare;1t disfo1Ction .from the words "committed an offence" in sections 3 and 4, does not i11 itself give jurisdiction over foreigners, but its use in that section, as so distinguished, clearly docs not bar jurisdiction over foreigners. Now as we ha-ve reached a stage to give our final finding, with due deference to the opinion expressed by Lord Chief Justice Cockburn and Sir Meredyth Plowden, we am coustraincd to find that: on the latest author.ities-{a) In the case of conspiracy falling under section 121-.A: a foreigner is equally liable and triable by the British Courts, though the act of conspiracy ma_y have been committed outside British India, irrespective of any act following it. (b) That an alien·is punishable µnder the Indian Penal Code for acts done in British India. {c) That he is amenable to the Indian Courts for offences or· acts initiated by him beyond J.Ji•itisk lndiaJ and taking efject in British India, be it a continuing act or an act 01· acts separate from it ne~essary to complete the offence. · ( d) That in> cases of abetment, particularly of conspiracy falling under clause- 2 of section 107, he is indictable in Indian Cm.nts, if any act in pursuance of that conspiracy is do-rte by another for him as an agent, or co-conspirator, in British India. 16 (e) That offences, which are completed and perfected beyond British India, be they of the nature of substantive offence or of abetment, thought they may be contrary to the provisions of the Indian Penal Code, do not render him liable to be tried by the Indian British Courts. (f) That the provisions of section 181, Criminal Procedure Code, are not enactments, under section 3 of the Penal Code covering the cases of foreignerR beyond In,dia, but are only applic~ able to offences committed in British India, and deal with the question of venue o'1'i.d of jurisdiction within the Indian Btitish Empire. in\ That an alien who has been guilty of an offence through another \vi in British India, is, when found in British India, triable by the Indian British Courts. we·accordingly hold that we have jurisdiction to try accm1ed ('p) on the chargee on u:rh-ir>h hA lQ int11r>tl:lrl. 3.=POLICE INVESTWA.TIONS. The police investigations are fully dealt with in the general history sections or in the individual cases. For convenience, however, we insert here schedules showing the dates on which witnesses were examined by the police~ (a) The Canadian and connected witnesse.'J. Date of Lhe statement made +.n +.lu:::ai p·nl;na nTt.rli +'J...n. ,1.-.4-.,.,. of the confession. I I I I' .Raghunath Singh, P. W, '6 15th August l 916 Accused 8, 11. Bela Singh, P. W. 9 · 9th August 191n Accused 3, 9, 11, 4, 13, 5 6, 10, 7. Mangal SinghJ P. W. 11 9th An.gust 1916 Accused 3, 4, 11, 13, 5, 6, 10. :Amar Singh, P. W. 12 9th Augus_t 1916 Accused 3, 4J 13, 9, 5, Atta, P. W. 19 9th Angust 1916 Accused 3, 11, 4, 6, 7, 9, 13. Harcbaran Das, P, W. 13 First· to S. Sukha Singh and then to Ikram-ui-Haq on 26th Augu~t 1916. Acc~sed 3, 4, 6, ?, JO, 11, 13. Gopai Dal!!, P. W. 22 26th August 1916 Accused 3, 15. bth Septemhef 1916 Accused 3, 11, 4. Bawa Singh, P. W. 20 8th September 1916 Accused 3, 11, 4. Khazan Singh, P. :W• 21 8th Sept.ember 19 ~ 6 Accused 3., 11; 4. hder Sain, P. W. 14 16th Saptember 1916 Accused 13. Ralia Singh, P. W. 15 lBth September 1916 Accused 13. Dalip Chand, P. W. 10 1 t.... r ■ ■ 17 ■ (b) The Mandi and Faittehgarh witnesses. Date of the statement made to the police and the date of the confession. Name oi the accused or witness. r 23rd June 1916 yf Implicating what accused. Dalip Singh, approye:r, P.' W. 73. ) l ) _ __ . ~ .. f Amar ~mgb. 1, accut;eo (14} 27th and 28th September to \ and Fazal Din (8). 1,11\ Fairlie. .J \ 29th June 19i6 Arjan, P. W. 70 00 l Again 28th Septembf'r 1916 r 27th September 119l6 . lD F aza. m, accuse d (8) Nam a, accused (14) (state- ') l ment). !\. - . d (2)· l'"i-<-) •·• ·-. Confessed on 28th September \ .. ccus~ , -r • 1915. ./ ') L ,.. ,.,. 26th September 1916 A • ogth S _ t b ...-..gam { } n .. . ep em er 1., 16 and confessed on that d.Ly. ~ 30th September 1916 .Babu Ram, accused (2) •• Accused (2): (8) . . { Confessed on 1st October 1916 } Accused · (14). Na~ab Khau, P. W. 84 ••• . lSth October 1916 Accused (2), n4) , Kundan Lall, P. W. 64 .;. 1st November 1916 Accused (8). Lala, P. W. 60 ••• 2nd September 1916. Ladoo . .. 1st September 1916. 4.---CONFESSIONS AND THE STATEMENT OF APPROVER. There are only 4 confessions, namely :>f Babu Ram, accused (2), Fazal Din (8), Nama (14) aµd Rur Singh (18),_ and the statement of one approver Dalip Singh, P. W. 73. · · Accused (2), (8) and (14) have resiled from their confessions. As they do not affect the case as a whole we will reserve eonsideration of them until we come to the individual cases, merely noting here that we are at one with the Commissioners.in the first conspiracy case as to the law ~elating to retracted confessions. Accu~sed (18) -has made a confession, which implicates no other accused · before us, and he has not retracted it, and accordingly -no comment is neces• sary at this stage. ·· 18 For convenience of reference we append here the schedule belotYSohedule. ; ----~---------..------.---------;----------------. Name of the accused. Date of arrest. Date of confession whether retracted or not. Name of the place where arrested and where Magistrate took down the coo£ ession. i Name of tlie witnesses coroborating the statement. (1) n.,. the co11it;~i:;:o·· (H). n !" 1:: ............ .,..-·uBeU J .. (2) By Nawab Khan, P. W. 84. (4) Sher Singh, P. W. 55. (5) O-hui11.m Kadir, P. W. 53 . Babn Ram, accused 30th Septem- 1st October (2) her 1916. 1916. I (6) Kahn Singh, P. W. 54 ... --{ Ambala Lala:Sonj Narain, ,1 Magistrate, 1st cla1>a, A.mbala. ('l)•S11.rdar Singh, P. W. 65. (8) Pbangan, P. W. 56. Il (10) Amar Singh, P. W. 85. ( (1) By the confession of N11ma (14). (2) Arjsu, P. W. 70. I Fazal Din, sccuaed 27th Septem• 28th Septem- Hosbi&rpur ... --{ (8). her 1916. ber 1916. Mr. Fairlie, :Magis- I (3) Sarda Ram, P. W. 71. trate, 1st class, Hoshiarpur, l (4) Dalip Singh, P. W. 73. (2) Fazl Din, accused (8). (3) Dalip Singh, P. W. 73. (4) .Arjan, P. W. 70. (5) Sarda Ram, P. W. 71. (6) Nawab Khan, P. W. 84. Nam.a, e.oouscd {14) 29th Septem, 22th Sepkm• ber 1616. ber 1916. Ditto (7) Am:i.r Sing:h, P. W. 85. (8) Kahn Singh, P. W. 64. (9) Sardar Singh, P. W. 56. (10) Sher Singh, P. W. 65. {ll) Ghulam Kadir, P. W. 53. (12) Kahan Singh, P, W, 64. (13) Phangan, P, W. 66. (1) Foaja Singh, P. W. 93, (2) Ganda Singh, P. W. 92. (3) WRBBWa Singh, P. W. 91. (4) Inder Singh, P. W.14,- A!i Rnr Singh, accused 11th Novem•115th Novem- Arrested a.t Gopala (18). ber 1916. ber 1916. in district of Lu.dhiaM. Lsla Hari Chand, MBgistrate, , 1st class, Labore, took down confession. , (5) Ralia, P. W. 86. (6) BBdri Singh, P. W. 94. (7) .Amar Singh, P. W. 95. (8) Bhagw1m•Siugb, P. W. 10, (9~ f ula Singh, P. W. 89. (10) Harnam Singh, P. W. 90. )_ 19 In regard to the approvers we agree with the previous Tribunals as t o the law .relating to approvers' evidence in clause 14 of Part II of the judgme nt in the first case. We have nothing to add in regard to the old approvers. The only new approver we have is Dalip Singh in regard to whom · we will discuss his reliability in the individual Fattehgarh-Mandi cases. We append here, for convenience sake, the schedule below:Schedule. r Name uf the place Na.me of the witness. Date of Dalip Singh, ap• Dated 26th September prover, P . W. 73. 1916. "l"IT'h ~,..,a o.T'1 •AQ.t.P: f1 Dat,i:, of Statement. aud. wh'clre !Yfagistrate took down the statement. l-fn f!h;e'l,.nu,. ment on 3rd June J916, ~tith September 1916 and 28th September 1916. In~ i{e statement to Police to Mr. F airlie on :d7th September 1916 and 28th Sep· tember HJl.6. .Nam e of the witnesses corroborating t he statement. (l ) Ba.rkat Ram , P. W. 67. (2) Ga.ndu, P. W. 68. (3) Kundan Lal, P. W . 64 (4) Jowala Singh, P. W. 62. (5) Lalu, l'. W . tiO. 16) Amar Singh, P W. 42. (7) Arjan, P. W. 70. (8) Naw .. b Khan, t' . W. 84. (9) Mula Singh, P. W. 89. (10) Confession of Nama, aceused (14). (11) l'onfes1:1ion of Fazal Din. (12) Aru1· Singh. 5.-AOCOMPLICES. We have nothing to add to our predecessors' findings as to the law relating to accomplices. We consider the undermentioned witnesses, other than approvers, are _ accomplices, and in weighing their evidence will bear that fact in mind. Harcharan Das (~. W. 13), Gopal Das (P. W. 22), Abdul Alim (P. W. 36), Lala (t'. W. 60), J.. rjan (P. W. 70) , Sarda Ram (P. W, 71L Fauja Singh (J!. W. 93), Allah Dad (P. W. 96), Bhagwan Singh (P. W , 100) and Jodh Singh (P. W. 117). PART 11.-History. A.~THE REVOLUTIONISTS ABROAD. 1.-TBE REVOLUTIO:i.URY PARTY IN THE UNITED STATES. Tb.e activities of the Ghad'b• party in the United States, its operations Old evidence. in San Francisco and elsewhere, its resolve to return to India for Ghad1·, in fact the inception of the com1piracy and war have been a:lready fully desc:ribed in the judgments .of the two prior Tribunals. It is superfluous for us to do, more than to say we are in full agreement with the findings of the earlier Tribunals, and to indicate .very briefly the evidence we have on the matter in this case. We have, of cours,:,, that reliable source of information, the Ghadr file, and the following witnesses give in brief the evidence they gave before at length :-Nawab Khan (p. 85 et seq.), Umrao Singh (p. 50), Amar Singh (p. 89) and Mula Singh (p. 93). :But besides that evidence we have a little more. First of all is Harcharandas (p. 31) . He has given us reliable evidence New evidence. as to what occurred in Canada; he went to San Francisco in December 1914, and from ·him and another witness, with whom we will deal shortly, we get evidence, showing how, in continuation of the Ghad1· movement and migration, active revolutionary work went on, and is -probably still going- on in San Francisco, in conju~ction ~ith German agents, and -he show·s the connection bet7 een the various spheres of activity of the revolutionists. ,:~-~~~n•u1 ·~"";'.⇒, (t - ". • .. , .... 20 He tells us that when he went to 'Frisco, he visited the Yugantar Ashram, the 'Frisco headquarters of the revolutionists. There, among otherR~ he met the famous Ram Chand, Peshawria, now editor of the Ghadr, and the hardly less famous Mnnsha Ram. He agreed rca,dily enough to help them in their work, printing the Ghadr for them. 'l~he press wa3 then issuing not only the Ghadr and the Ghad,r-di-Gu,n:f, but a book by Hardial named the Nim Hakiu1, Khat?-a Jan, and another pamphlet called the G01·e Sha/ii Zulm. Moreover there were placards inscribed "Do not fight th~ Germans, they are our friends." a" Fatwa Jehad '' from Turkey i.n various languages, and Brayan's "British Rule in India" were all in stock and freely distributed to everybody. Under Ram Chand's directions witness printed some 5~000 r;opies of the Fatwa Jehad in different languages, of which many were sent to India, Afghanista~, Egypt and the Western front; the Gernrnn Consul in San Francisco coming to the press and removing the literature in bulk in his motor car to send to distribute among Indian troops. The headquarters in San Francisco, however, did not confine itself to litnrature. Bhagwan Singh, the Canadian deportee, had been despatched on revoluiionary work to Manilla, and we will see in the section dealing _with that place how he occupied himself there; :Barkat Ullah, a well known revolutionist, had gone to Turkey en ro·ute for Afghanistan to stir up trouble there ; one· Mangu Ram was sent to rfibet to collect arms ihere, and despatch them into the Punjab, and sev~ral were sent to Germany. The Germa·n Consul in San Francisco, he was told, was paying all expenses for emissaries, and those who were going to Germany interviewed the German Consul, who sent them on to New York, where t.he Gel'man Consul•General arranged for their despatch ·to Berlin through ·neutral countries; the main obj-e ct of their being sent on being to print and distribute seditious literature at the front, and to accompany relea~md Iµdian prisoners•of-war, seduced to the Ghadr movement, to the North-West Frontier to ·at,t~w}{ the British Government- from that side. Hence too help was sent to Siam, where as we know a plot was hatched tlo inv,::i~A Tntli~. IJ,,;,A Bnrnu:._ OnP R~ntn1- Rlngh, ho c.myo, hOrt· haen c:,on+ H-.ure, Siam being selected as an excellent place to collect arms in, and to serve as a jumping ground. He tells us too; and by this helps to link up the Canadian revolutionists. with the 'Frisco, ones, that when accused. (3) and (11) were leaving A.merica they came to San Francisco from Vancouver (a fac.t which is admitted), and were met and provided for by Ram. Chand and Tuiunsha Ram, and, after they had gone on, money, which had been sent. by Ram Chand ,to accused (3) ,in Japan, came back undelivered. He tells us too of a big meeting organised by Ram phand and one Gurdas Ram in Fresno on the 31st January 1915, where speeches were delivered,· and money collected for revolutionary purposes; also of monthly subscriptions pouring in from various places, from Panama, Manma, Siam, and elsewhere, and how Muhammadans, who were sympathizers of Turkey, were frequenters of the Ashram, and he further describes the rules of the Ashram; laid down by Hardial · He informs us also of schemes for despatching arms to India and -· of a mission of his own which we will deal with in the portion of the judgment concerned with arms. Bawa Singh (p. 37) testifies to the conneetion between Gurdas Ram of Fresno an_d Bhagwan Singh so long as 4 years ago. But the most irp.portant new witness is Jodh Singh alias Hassanzada. This extraordinarv man was sent from Germany to America, and we will describe elsewhere his -different activities. All we need here refer to is his visit t.o 'Frisco, where he arrived in the company of-two Germans en .route for Siam. He had been sent by Hatdial to help Ram Chand in 'Frisco, and he ·Jalled on r IJ ■ I I I I I. 21 him there was shown the literary activities of the press, and aiso visited the German Consul, where he learnt of an " Arms Scheme/' and got all bis expens~s for Siam paid by him. This evidence clearly establishes that the Ghadr movement in San Francisco is still being carried on vigorously, and is in close connection with German aaents there, where operations against the British Government in every part of th~ world are devised. ' ,v e are fully satisfie~ that the United States became the chief centre of t.lrn nhr,.rl ,1• moYement, that thHe the overthrow of the Ihitish Government in India was planned and discussed, and that, when the European war broke out, . many hundreds of Indians sailed to carry their plan into effect by war, murder and rapine. 2.-SEDITION IN l'ENANG, SINGAPORE, HONG KONG AND SHANGHAI. I In regard to sedition in Penang we have nothing to add. to the ·evidence Penang. given in the last cases, and discussed in the previous judgments. Arjan Singh (p. 46), Umrao Singh (p. 50), Nawab Khan (p. 87) repeat before us in substance in evidence previously given, the first name~ detailing the arrival of Sohan Singh (L. C. C.) and of the Tosha .Maru,, and Nawab Khan that of the Tosha Mar·u, and the formation of committees there to Erocure arms, etc.. · Dalip Chand tells us of sedition in Shanghai and Jawala Singh (p. 58), Sh h . Sundar Singh, W. G. (p. 79) and Mula Singh repeat the story they gave before ang ai. of the movements there, and h~ is supported by Dalip Singh (p. 71). Sundar Singh (p. 80) tells us of revolutionary activities · in Singapore and Singapore and Tiong Kpng. So too do N awab Khan in regard to Hong Kong, where the Hong Kong. Central Committee was formed, and Amar Singh I (p. 90) also repeats his evidence on the same point. We are satisfied that the Ghadr movement spread there from Canada and t-9-e statP~ anrl. t.h:.:i,t mRn fl'Orn t.hngi:> lnna,l;t-ios p.)Qo preceeded to Tndia to ~c.!.liQt, in overthrowing the British Government. 3.-IN MANILLA. II -Among the centres of disaffection where Gkadr was preached and men • set out for India for revolution is :Manilla. Manilla as a. centre. Among thosa who returned from that place are Rahmat Ali Khan (the Ferozeshahr mm:derer), Jiwan · Singh (Ferozeshahr murderer), Surjan Singh (Ferozesh&hr murderer), Hazara Singh (L. C. C.) and Baj Singh (L. C. Q.), Kehr Singh (L. C. C.) and Baj Singh (L. C. C.), and in this case Hafiz Abdulla, accused {17)! was a resident in Manilla from lQOl to 19H. 'rhw evidence in regard to what took place in Manilla is mainly new. The two principal witnesses are Allah Dad (p. 98) and Parma Nand (p: 99). ·. . The former was in. Manilla from lfJOl to 1914. He tells us that up to Guru Datt Kumsr 1914 there was no revolutionary party in Manilla, but in that year one Guru an~ Bha~an Si~gh Dutt Kh~ar, ,":ho, we ?nderstand, .was an ~ctive se~itionist in ~Canada and the:~ States, arrived m Manilla and started holdmg a series of _meetmgs, which \\ere attended by accused (17)·, urging Indians to unite and kill the British-. .An association was formed in which Chanan Singh, a wealthy Indian in Manilla, and Hafiz Abdulla, were office-bearers, and meetings were held and speeches delivered, tli,e burden of which ~as that the ·Ro,.j in India should be wrested from the British. After the departure .of Guru Dutt Kumar, Manilla was visited by .the still more :nctcricm~ Bhagwan Singh, at one· time grantlii in Victoria, B. C., whom the Canadian Government was compelled to deport; This man, on arrival, is said by witness to have stayed with a friend of accused (17), and then w~th Chana~ ~ingh .. H~ bu_sied himself in lecturing_ every _Sunday and collectmg subscriptions, d1stnbutmg the Ghadr, and urgmg Indians to seiz.e the Baj. l~:o!i:;i~~~ion- The Korea in· Manilla. Witness·admits he subscribed to the funds of the revolutionists, and tells us that mans were compelled to do so by actual physical violence, gangs of grroters being formed to att.ack those who were disinclined to _do so. ·· The second witness Parma Nand Sharma (p. 99) was a detective acting under the British Consulate in Manilla, and appears to be an exceptionally able young man. Like the last witness he tells us that the revolutionary movement, in Manilla commenced with the arrival of Guru Dutt Kumar · in 1914. r he· latter formed an Indian . A.nti-British .Assocfation, a branch of the San Francisco one, and held a large meeting in an Opera House owned by a Turk, urging Indians to unite, and collecting subscriptions to be sent to HardiaL In the assooiation so · formed witnesR states Cha nan Singh ~nd accused (17) were the chief office-holders with Guru Dutt Kumar, and ihA members included Rahmat Ali Khan, the Ferozeshahr murderer, and Arjan Singh, the Anarkali murderer t whom he recognizes from a photo. only, and is probably inaccurate in this respect as A.rjan Singh was only in lfanilla for a short time. The witness states that later Bhagwan Singh visited Manilla, and became secretary of this association, urging Indians to go to India for revolution. Both these witnesses tell us that revolutionary agitation is still rife in Manilla, where the Ghad·r has been regularly" received, and Parma Nand also tells us the Jahan-ul-lslam came reg-ularly from Constantinople till war broke out, and that both Guru Datt Kumar and Bhagwan Singh knew how to make· explosives and bombs, and taught Indians in _Manilla how to manufacturethem. In the interval 'between the visits of Guru Datt Kumar and Bhagwan ~~ng~:. the~~~- f{-o,rea, carrying the_ San Franc!sco revol~tionists, stopped at iv1am11a. Tms ract was i-efe1·rsd to m the prev10us conspiracy cases by both Amar· Singh I and Nawab Khan. :Before us they give tho ~ame gtory as before= N awab Khan (p. 86) telis, us that on arrival in Manilla Jagat Ram (L. C. C.) disembarked; taking with him arms and copies of the Ghadr-di-Gunj, and the ship stayed for three days in hal'bour. The ship was visited by a party of Indians, including accused (17), who stated they were revolutionists, who were in the habit of holding revolutionary meetings every Sunday, and that the next day there would be a meeting inciting men in Manilla to get ready, Nawab Khan got permission to land, and on the Sunday there was a large m~eting, of w_hich accused (17) was president, and which witness and Jagat Ram (L: C. C.) addressed: . Witness himself recited a seditious poem, ~nd sp@ke against Government; Jagat Ram urg.ed the time to _strike J?.ad come, and all should go to India to . stal't mutiny and exp~l the British, in which object Germany and Turkey woohl~~ · The speeches concluded, volunteers for India were enrolled, _including Rahmat Ali Khan (F. M.), Jiwan Singh (F. M.) and Surjan Singh fF. M.), many others saying they would follow later.. Amar Singh (pp. 90 and 92) tel~ us also that 'on arrival in lvianilla, Jagat Ram · (L. C; 0.) landed, and' that H;;tfiz .Abdulla (17) and others visited the ship, gave speeches on '' unity " and sang Ghadr ' songs•. accused (17) himself reciting o-ne of these effusions. The party accompanying· Hafiz Abdulla. he says, inciuded three of the subsequent Ferozeshahr murderers. Amar Singh himself did not land, and so knows nothing of the meeting on shore, but we have further information in regard to it fro rn Per~anand and Allah Dad. · Fermanand (p. 99) remembers the arrival of the Korea, and Jagat Ram (L. C. C.) landing~ Accused (17)' and others got permission for Nawab Khan to Ian~, and a meeting was held in a large building in Manilla, the details of which were · reported to him by his assistant. -.. ._ r • Allah Dad (p. 98) also remembers the arrival of the Korea. The witness attended the meeting which was addressed by' accused (17) and others, including one of the Ferozeshahr murderers) Jagat Singh. Jagat Ram also spoke, urging the seizure of the ,raj in India, and the usual collection was made, the proceeds being sent to Bhagwan Singh. In regard to l\Ianilla we have also a reference in· the evidence of Har- Harcharandaa. charandas (p. 31), who tells us he heard from Ram Chand, Peshawaria, in San Francisco that Bhagwan Singh had been sent to Manilla to collect money and induce Indians to return home for rebellion. Jodh Singh (p. 183), also tell us that when in Manilla he heard of Jodh Singh. Bhagwan Singh having left, through the German Consul; but heard of no other revoiutionist-many of them had of course left long before he arrivedt1!oug'h he gathered Indians there were in favour of Ghadr. · Hafiz Abdulla, accused (17), denies (pp. 129, 179) all knowledge of the Denials. revolutionary movemont in Manilla; but we will deal with his defence in the individual cases. Witnesses have also been produced for his defence to _say there was no revolutionary movement in Manilla, but such assertions are obviously absurd. We are fully satisfied that M~nilla became, and is still a centre of Couclusion. revolutionary action, and has furnished some of the most dangerous tools of the movement, men of the most desperate character, who heralded their arfrral ~"'l India by a brutal and cold-blooded double murder. · ~. JL 4-THE REVOLUTION.A.RY MOVEMENT IN CAN.A.DA. In the judgment of the first conspiracy case the tribunal stated :" It is from the Pacific Coast of America that the present conspiracy The Lahore ~on8pi• _ derives its origin, and the two main centres were Vancouver and San "F-r11.n- racy ca.ea finding. ciso; Vancouver to start with, till its importance was finally eclipsed by San Francis~. The IJrosecution has not considered it necessary to place , before us much evidence in regard to Vancouver but we know . ~ that one Bhagwan Singh arrived there in 1912-13, and commenced a series of lectures against the British Government ... Bhagwan Singh was eventually deported, but not before the seeds of mischief had been sown among Indians in Vancouver.,, The tribunal also stated " W o may note . . . incidentally that the Komagatu Ma1·u had set sail from Vancvuver in July 1914, · and there is no doubt that this episode was seized upon to further inflame the excited feelings fanned by the Ghad1• newspaper. It is, we think, . . . probable that the intention of · Gurdit Singh in taking the Komagata Ma1·u to Vari;couver, with the full knowledge that admission to Canada would be refused, ~ was partly to create an e11isode, which would inflame Indians quite as much as any genuine desire to obtain ingress to Canada . · . . . " There is no doubt the incident led to the organization of part of the migration. That conclusion we fully ', agrae in, and ' we agree because we have in Our general conclu. this case a wealth of evidence, which shows how the revolutionary movement sion. commenced in Canada, how it was fanned into an important flame, . and how the Komagata Maru incident was used induce several Indians in Canada fo return to India for. murder and revolution. We have before us in this case several accused, who are alleged to have Indian eettleni taken part in the revolutionary mov~ment in Canada, and it ·is our duty now Cansda in 1906. to trace the origin and development of the agitation there. . Judging . from the evidenee before- us a nulliber of Indians went to , c---n~t1~ !l.hmit 1uo~.. ()'7 1n QA!l'lll\h nf! AmplnymAnt.. p,.nhJlhly thA!'e WAre numbers there before, but we gather from the dates given in the various _witnesses' and accuseds' statements that there was an increase in the number in those years. INe have no judicial knowledge of anything that took place in Cariada from ·1907 to 1910. Apparently there was no feeling of disaffection, at the'time. _ s 24 The Honduras The only incident which appears to have disturbed the outward serenity scheme, of life there was a project in 1908 to induce Indian labourers to go to British Honduras, where apparently labour was needed. According to Bela Singh (p. 24) the present accused (3)1 ('_t), (6), (7) a.nd (11) took an active part in opposing this proposal, and he adds that accused (3), (4) and (11) then first mooted the idea of expelling the British from India if the transfer was insisted upon. This incident no doubt did create some feeling, as we find that in the --.., memorial prepared at the Bradlaugh Hall meeting in HH3, to which we will have to refer later, this British Honduras scheme is referred to as '' a scb eme to effect the wholsale transporation of Indian settlers to British Honduras ..... by offering them plausible terms, which were not only to reduce them from free immigrants to the level of indentured coolies; but also to considerably reduce their earnings; Indians saw through the scheme ..... ", and in:tthe same memorial the scheme is described as " a measure adopted by the Canadian Government to make things as uncomfortable as possible for those already settled in the country." Now accused (3) W!ts one of the delegates who inspired this Bradlaugh Hall meeting, and though we are not, in the absence of further evidence, prepared to accept the statement that forcible ejection of the British from India was proposed in i908, it is clear, notwithstanding the present denials of accused (3) and (4), that the incident did give rise to some agitationJ agitation which may have been quite within constitutional limits, even if intemperate. :Both accused (3) and (4) in their written statements refe1:1 to the proposals and show that Indian feeling in Canada (pp. 231 and 211) was opposed to them, and would have nothing to do with the projected transfer. Canada. in 1908-12: From 1908 to 1910, at any rate, there appears to have been no trouble at all in Canada. In hHO we understand certain ordinances were passeJ in Canada, whfoh prevented_ immigrat.ion into the countrv of nersons of everv nationality except by a continuous journey ,. on through ti~kets from their country of origin, and :imposed on all Asiatics"7other than those who were admissible under treaty on _ other restrictive terms,-the necessity of being possessed.of 200 dollars before being allowed to land .. ~ · It is no place of ours to dfacuss the reasons which may have made these regulations ne~essary; all we are concerned with is that, though they do not appear on the face -of them to be dire~ted especially against Indian emigration they were regarded by Indians in Canada as directed against themselves. This conception appears to be based on the fact that, in common with a1Jpare.ntly nearly every part of the British Empire, through tickets from India to Vanoou ver, were not procurable, as no through services exist. At any rate in 1911 the wife of accused (3) and the .wife of Bhag Singh, granthi of Vintoria,-a person who became one of the most active revolutionist.It in Canarla, ·a nd was shot dead in his gurdwara later on by the witness Bela; Singh in self.. defenee,-came to Canada, and were admitted into the country by the Canadian Government, after, it would appear, some difficulty. , ~ Bela Singh (p.24), who, we may note, was employed in the Immigration Departrrien t in Vancouver, .states that it was at this time that Bhag Singh, one Schan Lal, accused (1:) and (11) and others started lecturing to Indians to the· effect that if the children of settlers in 0anada were not allowed to land, Indians should return to India and expel the British. Ata Singh ( p) 36 tells us that accused (3) was also agitating ·about that time in regard to the question of unrestricted immigration. , Wt\ have no evideIJ.ce before us of what took place in 1912 in Canada, beyond Nawab Khan tells ua (p. 85) he was ' about that time introduced to socalled ~olitics by Rahim. Affairs in 1913, In 1913, however, matters became critical. that year feeling ip. Canada was running high. There is no doubt that iQ ~. 25 r In June 1913. a newsnaner called the Sansar was started in Victoria, The. Sansm·. B. C. partly in English; pa{tly in Gurmukhi. The editor of it was one Sundar Singh, and Bela Singh (p. 24) states accused (4), (6), (7), (5) , (10), and (11) actively assisted or supported it, one of the men engaged on the press being Piara Singh (L. C. 0.). Ania! Singh of Barian (p. 29) rne~tions_a~cused (-1) and (11) only amon~ the accused as assisting in the publication of this paper. Accused (4) admits supporting and contributing to it, but the others mentioned deny all connection with it. This paper, so far as we can judge from the issues before us, viz., those of January 13th, July 20th, December 5th, December 20th_. 1913; January uth, 1914; April 18th, 1911; arul .A.pril 25th, 1914, is not a revolutionary or actively seditious production. It concerns itself principally with the question of immigration into Canada, itis sometimes intemperate in language, it excites racial hostility, publishes occasionally verses of a dangerous character; and. sometimes garbles and misinterprets factsj but we have not found any passage in it which incites either to forcible resistence to the law or to the encouragement of rebellion in India. It is a paper of quite a different character to the Gliadr, on the appearance of which it seems to have died out ; the vitriolic revolutionary propaganda of the latter being apparently mote to t~e taste of those for whom it was intended. Another paper also appeared somewhat later on. This paper _is a pro.: The Bindu,stani. duction in English, called the Hindustani, the editor of which, a Sikh, is commonly known as Rahim. We have only one number of it, dated the 1st June 19H. It was published in Vancouver and describes itself as the organ of the United India League. The number before us is coincident with the arrival of the E. omagatu Maru, and in some of its artfoles is virulent and inflammatory to a degree. One article entitled A Lesson from the Famine in the United ProvinceR" revels in abuse of the Indian Governmep.t, and deliberately incites to riots agaim,t Government, on~ inscribed " The future of India " is even more infl4mmatory, and ·it is interesting to note, in view of the evidence that follows, that there is an advertisement of the United India League to the effect that its hold '' propaganda meetings every Saturday at 7-30 p .M. (! In 191.3 Canada .received a visit from the notorious Bhag-wan Sin!!'h Bhasrwan Siny the evid.e nce of the Hindustani itself. We have· before us th~ issue of the 1st June (p, 5), and it contains an account of the meeting held in the Dominion Hall on the 31st May, the chail: being taken by Rahim, the editorof that paper, and accused (3) is reported as saying that if the ·Canadian Gove~_n ment .persisted in excluding Indians, the British Empir~ must collapse, as India would not tolerate -the position; an.d we find too that the audience was informed that all Britain gave to India, while drain• ing it, was famine, the drink habit, and insolence-an interesting echo of the ghad1· teaching. · ~t i ,I ti II I·. I . ~ ·,.: . ~=~~-UilJ!fllt~i-l"TTn11Jl .I l i!Ll ,L. , ii"} ! c.:;,(;fjJ.·. 30 Accused (3) (p. 134) first. denied attending any such meeting, but 0rr being confronted with the Hincliistani report said all he did was to collect subscriptfons and send telegrams to N abha and Patiala States, facts which at any rate show he was present, and he ascribes the articles to Rahim's imagination and dislike of himself. His own witnesses J a wand Singh (p 19G), Hardit Suwas. Singh (p. 201), Batan Singh (p. 201), Gharib Singh (p. 20.j), Sudh Singh (p. 206) 1 ~nd N aurang Singh (p. 228) bear the prosecution out so far that accused (3) and Rahim did address the meeting at the Dominion Hall; while another on~ J agat Singh (p. 199) mentions a lecture by him in tile gw·d,wara of an innocent purport. The Kom,c6.Qata 1.1/ar.'-u started on its return journey about the 22nd July with, as Rugnath Singh tells us; a resolve to rise in India: but we are told that, before its return, efforts were made to secure arms for them, Rugnath Singh (p. ~l) states accm;eu (3) and others were arrested at Sumas in an attempt to smuggle arms into Canada. One Mewa Singh, afterwards executed for the murder of a Canadian official, was caught with arms, and convicted, the others were discharged; but witness assures us that accused (3) told him he ha.d gone to the States for arms, and had hidden the weapons secured. Bela Singh (p. 25) tells us accused (3) went to the States for arms, with Ehag Singh (since killed in Vancouver), Harnam Singh (since executed in Burma) and Mewa Singh, and were arrested; Mewa Singh being convicted. Mangal Singh (p. 28) gives the same story. Moreover, after the Komagata Mcwu sailed ·right up to the outbreak of war the seditious propaganda was sedulously cultivated. :After July 22nd. Mangal Singh (p. 28) states that in the gurdwa1·a there were several meetings, accused (3) discussing revolu_tion there; at one meeting, two days after the Koma9a.ta Ma1··u sailed, accused (4) and (11) spoke, and at _others the return to India, the looting of treasuries and starting ghad1• was advised by accused (3), (4), (9), (11) and (13). Harcharan Das (p. 30) tells us meetings continuen in the Vanco1-:.ver gu,rdwa,rn everr1 Satutday evening, addressed by Rahim., accurnl (3) and. (11 \ and others, in which the same advice was given, ancl the ghadr received and GluuJA._,,,di.-G--UnJJ3ongs sung.__ . -·--The outbreak of On the outbreak of war, just as happened in the States, it was hailed as the opportunity for the awaited ghad1·, and men began to troop back for that purpose. Rugnath Singh (p. 21) was in Vancouver at the time. He tells us a United Indian League existed in the gurdwara, and there were weekly meetings there, one of which he attended and there saw. accused (3) and (11). The princiJJal speakers were Bhag Singh and Mewa Singh, and they enlarged on the theme that Government was oppressh;e and that, as their• ship had-been sent back, and the occasion of the war was favourable, it was the duty of Indians to return to India for mutiny. ~his ~as the advice_ given by accused (3) and {11), who had all _arra~gements m their ha~ds, ~nd w1tn~ss states many Indians proceeded to India with the express obJect of carr'yrng out the 'design of warring against povernment. Bela Singh tells the{same story. Manga.I Singh (p. 28) says several Indians retumed for ghadr at_ this time, and Harc~aran Dass (p. 30) say~ the same, and indicates that accused ( 3) (11), ,'13), Rahim and others urged this movem~nt; the same men and accused (4), (6), (7) and (10) specially pointing out the advisability of seducinO' troops and accused (9) assisting by composing a revoluti_o nary song, b~ofonin; 0 " Wake up, you sleeping lions." t, Ata Singh (p. 30) is to a similar effect. In the gurd1-0a1·a, he says, he heard accused (3), (9), (11), (13) and others lecture to the effect that the war y ! 31 should be seized as an opportunity to help Germany, expel the British, and commit dacoities, and several Indians left, in small parties, fo:r ghad'r, though how ghadr was to be effected was not clearly planned out, beyond that it drnnld i.it.!lrt. wit.h il::u~oities on treasuries. -·-~ No doubt some 37 witnesses for the defence say either that no seditious meP.ting was ever held in the gurdwara, or that particular accused never attended any meeting at _that place. Some few admit there were harmless statements on political matters, others that it was impossible for a sacred place to be the scene of political discussion, violent or otherwise. l Many of these witnesses are themselves suspect and interned, but apart from that fact we know well that it was in gurdwaras and so-called religious places that the reYolnt:ionists foregathered to perfeet their designs. We need only mention Sant Gulab Singh's rlhera, the Virpali Dharm~ala, .Kishen Das· dh,rJra: the Jhar Sahib, the Chobacha Sahib, Lohatbadi JJhatmsala and the Hong Kong gurdwm·a, and note that · it was at bhogs men were raked in for the Ferozepore raid. That the .prosecution story is not a fanciful one and that Indians, resident in Canada, did go back for revolution and murder is apparent when we turn and see what has happer.ed to so many of them. ( Isher Singh and Uttam Singh were convicted in the Lahore supplementary case, sentenced to death and executed for, amongst other things, participating iu the Kapurthala raid in the Fermmpore raid, and abetting the Walla Bridge murders; Pakhar Srngh was transported for life in .the sa::ne case for seditious pro1>aganda in India and abetting the Kapurthala raid; Mastan Singh was sentenced to transportation for life for taking a very active part in the Ferozepore raid ; Piara Singh, an active helper on the anscw, was sentenced in the first case to life imprisonment for abetting war in America and India, and when arrested did his best to murder the police officer arresting him; Harnam Singh [accused (23) in the L. S. -C. C.] received a · sentence of transportation for life for participating in the Ferozepore raid, and the Doraha Bridge attempt, and for c0mmitting dacoities in furtherance of the cause ; Harnam Singh II has been sentenced to death in the Burma case as a leader, he being the man alleged to have been one of accused (3)'s companions in the attempt to procure arm8 for the .Komagata. Ma1·u from the States; Hardit _ S_mg_l!__ ~_nd ~apur Singh, both sentenced to transportation for life in Burma for active revolutionary - work; -Sher- Singh --transpor.ted f01· -life- in- --tha Lahore conspiracy _case for bringing a body of armed revolutionists to India from Canada ; Gurm uk h Singh transpol'ted for life in the same case for seducing troops and students helping to make bombs and taking part in the Mansuran dacoity; Jawand . Singh, absconder, wanted as one of the most dangerfus revolutionists still at large, and alleged to be the actual murderer of S. Chahda Singh, and to have been one of the Walla Bridge murderers; Jagat Singh sentenced to death and executed in the first conspiracy case for dacoity with murder, for being present in the revolutionists' meetings in Moga and elsewhere, and seducing troop; in Sargodha and other places. ; ·Nand Singh sentenced to death in the Lahorelconspiracy case-a sentence subsequently commuted-a man engaged actively in dacoities, a particip~tor in the Doraha bridge affair and a manufacturer of bombs; Banta Singh, of the golden teeth, hanged for the W a1la l>ridge and Hoshiarpur murders ; Hari Singh sentenced to transportation for life in the· Lahore supplementary conspiracy case for active revolutionary propaganda in India ; '.Bu.ta Singh hanged for t):le Hoshiarpur murder; Gandha Singh executed for the Ferozeshahr murder; Bishen Singh and J a wand Singh both. transported for life for revolutionary acts in the Lahore conspiracy case ; Kala Singh, Mangal Singh ·and Indar Singh likewise disposed of for similar acts, and Bir Singh sentenced to death in the Lahore supplementary conspiracy case and hanged, a murderer and dacoit among other things. , To these we need only add Hardit' Singh, -wanted in the Padri murder case, Mewa Singh the murderer of Mr. Hopkinson,Bhagwan Singh u1·anthi, and The crimes of returned Canadian emigrants. 32 Guru Datt Kuma ... , +-..nly ~nnH,n .. .oi.-.q,.,,nTit" nnrnmpnfa,,.y (\TI Urn '1RQ~l'i~t.ion r. r Inditms in Canada aR "men of industrious, regular and steady habits, temporate and thriftv livinQ' and nleasant and straightforward manners." If these men ~re samnl~s of I'iidian ... settlers in Canada, it is hardly surprising that the Canadian Government was anxious for settlers of a less existing character. Canadian accused. Of the Canadian accused, numbers (3), (4,) and (11) left Canada together in December 1914, accused (15) on the Lai Sang on 6th Augustj accused (6) with Sher Singh, L. 0. C., on the Canada JJ!la1·u and Tm1ha Mlir·u, accused (7) in February 1915, accused (9) and (10) on the Skijoko Mai·u and Tosha Ma1•u. · · · · 1 We gather too from the defence evidence that several hundreds all left ' about the same time, and the conclusion is irresistable. · The death of Bha.g Before closing this section we have to refer to two Singh. after the outbreak of war, which illustrates the desperate matters in Canada nature of some of the Indian settlers in Canada. One relates to the end of Bhag Singh, Grrmtlii, one of the leaders in -Vancouver. · It appears that Bela Sing4, witness, was employed in the Immigration Department, and he kept his super1or officials informed of what was going on. He had certain men through whom he worked, and two of them, Harnam Singh and Arjan Singh, were mysteriously murdered. While attending to the latter's funeral in the gurdwara, he says Bhag Singh and one Battan Singh attacked him with a sword and fired at him, whereupon he shot the former dead, and inflieted wounds on the other from which he subsequently died. In the melee; which followed., accused (4) was also injured, and Bela Singh, who was tried for murder, was acquitted on the ground of self-defence. murder of The second incident was the murder of Mr. Hopkinson, who :Mr. Hopkinson. in the Immigration De_partment. The was engaged Harcharan Das (p. :s1) states that the murder of Mr. Hopkinson, Mr. Reid, another officer in the Immigration Department, and Bela Singh was open1y discussed in the gurdwara, and advocated by accused (3), (4), (6), (7), {10), (1 i) and (13) as a necessary step for the advancement of the cause in Canada. .. 1 Whether this evidence. Jts tq _a_ cor1spiracy be true or not, there is no question as to the fact that Mr. Hopkinson.· -was shot dead by Mewa Singh, the smuggler of arms from the Staites, in open court, and accused {3), '(4), (11) were arrested· on suspicion of · being concerned in it, but afterwards discharged. Conclusions. • We have no dou"bt that there was active sedition in Canada as there was in the States, that the incident of the Eomagata Maru inflamed stili -further those who were already ripe for mischief, and that the outbreak of war was seize~ upon as an opportunity for putting into operation the expected ghadr, and that many Indians left Canada arrayed for war, and prepared to carry their intentions of wagip.g war into effect by any and every" means, and that having arrived in India, many ot them put their intentions into active operation. -Reasons fo:r rely• . ' - It will be seen that we have relied largely on witnesses in_g on the Canadian Canada in 1913 and 1914, viz., Rugnath ~ingh, Bela Singh, Ata witne:!set. Singh, H archaran Das and Man gal Singh. who· were in Singh, Am:lr Wie have relied on them because their stories corroborate each other, and ate corroborated by other evidence as well, Arguments have, however; been addressed to us, and evidence tendered by ... --, 1.J made The only other evidence is in the cross-examina~ion of Hira Singh (P. W .. 114). 'l'his man is a self-c11nfessed mllrderer, the bl'other of Jaswaat Singh1 wr.o got a pardon in the Hoshiarpur murder case in return for giving King's evidence, and was p1·oduced before us simply to formally prove the· Hoshiarpur murder. He is heart and soul n Ghadrite. · He states that he knows accused (11) wired to the au.thorities and asked them to stop Bela Singh bringing in Bhagwan Singh. ~ow we do know that Bela Singh and Bhagwan Singh came 9n the same ship to Canada from Hong Kong, but there is nothing really to sub1;;t.antiate that Bela Singh brought him in. Not a single question was a~ked Bela Singh, and the allegation that any of thp accused, other than accusel (11), took any step to prevent his landing is u.nsupported by a scrap of evidence. As regards accused (11) his statement is supported by .a self-confessed Ghadrite and murderer only L 358 H. D. Is it at all likely eHher that meu wh() were most anxious to get ~be restrictions on immigration removed-men who :tad encouraged and sent a deputation to England and India on the matter, would make efforts to ~xclude ()tht:;1· Indians coming in, and that one man who would attempt to get one in was a paid band in the Immigvation Departmunt ? The idea is absurd, and this. allegation has no basis in fad. The next allegation against Bela Singh is one made by accused (5). Tds man 8ays that Bela Singh had a dispute with his cousin a~d in reven;:!'e became an enemy of accused. When accused opened a shop, he says Bela Singh got one Samand Singh to open an opposition one, also tried to get a contract of hig cancelled, and finaUy bad a series of fights, helped by others, wir.h accused and hb friends fr1 December .19~?, for which ~e Ujagar Singh, a friend of . ·· accu~ed's, got imprisoned. ·· Now, even if this story be true, it does not furnish any reason for Bela Singh implicating any other accused. But how far is it true? N(,t a single witness is produced in defence to prove anythi.ug except fights, and the only ·witness questioned at all 011 the subjeor. of the shop is the sam~ Hari Singh (P. W. 114), the Hoshiarpu!' murderer, who says there was a quarrel between accused and Bela Singh about the cpposition shop. It is no doubt t.rue that Ujagar Singh was imprisoned for some affray in which Bela Singh was a~sauited, possibly too Bela Singh was fined. D. W.'s 14, 22, 24, 25 and 41 say that the figlit was between partisans of Bishen Singh (5) and Bela Singh, and no doubt there was some ill-feeling betweP-n these two, as Bela Singh admits he accus2d Bishen Singh of insti~ating a series of assaults upon him, ,but oan it be saiu on that account that witness would falsely implicate the accused in the ~eriou:~ eharges now made? . Is it not possible that these disputes were really due to the fact that accused was taking a:c. active part in trying to injure a man, who was workin~ against the ,Ghadrite policy, _ and if that be the correct view, the evidence, far from helping accused, is detrimental to him. But, nevertheless, in so far as tbis accused is concerned we wiii bear in mind this matter in his individual case, and whenever Bela Singh i~ not supported, give due weight to the fact in favour of accused . The next matter i~ one alleged hy Munsha Singh (13) alone. He says that Bela Singh has deposed against him because he had disputes in Canada with sqme fellow-villagers, an allegation entirnly unsupported, vague in t1e extreme, and furnishing no possible reason for false evidence. The next matter is one the facts ·of which are more or less clear. It is undoubted that when Bela Singh was charged with murdering Bhag Singh, ~ charge on which he was acquitted, accused ( 3) and (4) ga ,, e -evidence for the prosecution. We do not know what evidence they did give. It iR also undoubted that in that affair MCuS'ed (4) was i_njured, and that Uttam Singh, who is alieged to have been; and prohably is, a relative of accused \ (3), was also injured. It is also fairly clear that aocused (3) and (11) 1 and perhaps ( 4), were a1Tested on suspicion of being implicated in a conspiracy to murder Mr. Hopkinson duriug tl.ie trial of the witness. I~ regard to the latter JlOint, it is impossible witness had anything to the alleged condo with it; as he was in custody, he could know nothing spiracy, and he has never, to our knowledge and most certainly not before us, said a word implicating anyone in any C'Jns,piracy to murder in Canada. In regard to the evidence given by accused '(3) and (4), if all thPy could aay was that witness shot Bhag Singh, that would raise no feeling in witness against then, :for he admit~~d the fact ; if they went fp.rther and said it was a deliberate murder w,itness should have been questioned on the point, a,nd be was not. · so or In any case the incident can have given rise to n6 hostility on the patt of witness to accused (11) ; and in regard to accused (3) and (4) there is no important inciient testifl.e~ t0 by this witn~~1;1 which ls 11:ot Qor,;ohor~t0d h~' \ - - ~7 ,L~~ : 35 perfectly independent testimony ; if in the individual cai:ieS we find tnere any, we will give due weight to the matter therein. That disposes of the allegations against Bela Singh. In regard to Amar Singh, the only objection direc tly taken to him is by four fellow-villagers of accused (3), who wen~ on the Komagata Maru, D. W.'s 83, 84, 8 and 9-1. They sa,y this witness' father-in-law has had dh,putes with Balwant Singh's family in 1910-one says it was a quarrel detween women in the families, one does not know why, the others that it had something to do with religion. . Evidence of this sort is useless ; it is vague, and so little is there in the allegation that a,1cused himself in his lengthy statements does not refer to it. As regards the other witnesses not a word is alleged to suggest direct enmity. Battan Singh (t) 8ays all he knows about Am:ir Singh is that he gave f:lvidence for . Bela Smgh in the charge of murdering- Bhag -Singh. D. W ~ 47 says Mangal Singh and Bela Singh are of the same village and are friends, that Amar Singh has relartives_in that village and that ho has seen Ats. Si!}gh there. Hira Singh (P. W. 114) in cross.examination says Am:ir Singh and Bela Singh are somehow related, which they deny. It is suggested, but no atte:::apt to prove it is made, that Mangal Singh and Bela Singh are related, they d_eny it, and so too does Inspector Ikram-ul~Haq. The only connection between the witnesses is that Amar Singh's brother was an employee in. the same department in Canada as Bela Singh, and that they carne from the same localit.y ; surely no reason for implicating innocent people in a serious charge. As there is nothing whatsoever to suggest hostility between Amar Siiigh, Ata Singh anrl Mangal Singh towards any of the accused, an attempt has been mad€ iii argument to sugg{~st th~se 3 men hav6 been influenced by Bela Singh to give evie1euce. Not a shred of evidence is produced to support the allegations and the argument is based on suppositions. To support these suppositions it is contended in effect that the police investigation show$ the likelihood thereof " re can only say the police fovestigation shows the exact contrary. The police investigation is deposed to by Inspector Ikram-ul-Haq. m~ knew of Amar Singh so long ago as March 1916, before any of the other witnesses had returned to India. · Jt was whe-n in July 1916 accused (3) a.nd Harcharan Das came under defention from Singapore, and Harcharan Das' statement was taken by Sardar 8ukha Singh that Ikram ..ul-Haq was deputed to make enquiries. He started hy questioning Rugnath -Singh at Shabkadr on 5th .August 1916, knowing no doubt from the K.omagq,ta .Maru Commission of him. Ha referred to Bela Singh as a man who had been in the Immigration Department; and knew something. Then witness proceeded to Hoshiarpur to enquire from :Bela Singh, a fact which shows' clearly Bela Sin~h was not pushing himself forward to implicate anyone. fie appears to have seen Bela Singh on 8th .August, and he mentioned :M:augal Singh, who wa.s at once sent for. Both of them fold ·him of Ata Singh, aud Mangal Singh and a constable were sent for Ata Singh. Mangal Singh returned before Ats Singh came, and, as it was rainfog, they were a.llowed to ~o home at 5 P,.M., with directions jO tum up next day, ~\ta Singh came . at 5·30, anrl he was let go also as it was raining. Next da.y witness went to Barian, and reduced to writing the statements of Amar Singh, Ata Singh, Bela Singh and J\fangal Singh in that order, separately from each 0ther, and he was fully satisfied they had had no opportunity of collaho:ration We, too, are .satisfied on that point, not only from the evidence of the Inspector, but from an . examination of the st.aternents themselves. They are in :co sense similar as collaborated statements would . be. They touch . each other at some points but they are not the same stories, and where~~f t,hey toµ.ch PT differ tliey aro supported by other ~vidtmpep · lQ J - . - I 86 I lJela Singh for instance speaks of the Honduras a.ffair in 1908; t11e agitation in 1911-11, of Bhagwan Si11gh's nctions and of some accu sed helping him in 1913, of the Sansar and compe:dtion of so11 gs by accused (4) and (.'.3), of tlie arrival of Balwant Singh and the Komagata JJfa,rn in Vaucouver, and the meetings held there, of the Smnas incideut, of the agib.tion when war broke out, of th9 murder of his two friends, and his own arrest on the chv,rge -of murdering Bhag Singh. Mangal Singh's story starts with Bhagw:rn Singh's aniY,il in Canada and his agitation; speaks of the Sansar, of Bahvaot S i1igh's anival and the Koma• gata Maru iu Vancouver and meetings, of the departure of the Kom,agafa ..., J11a1· ·u, and subsequent meP.tings; and of the Snmas incident, a11d ot t he ·~ agitation when war broke out. Ile re]ates these incidents in a different way to B ela Singh, and does not. mention the other matters spoken of by Relv, Singh. ...L\_mar Sing-h tells us nothir. Q' of Bha!.!'wan Sin~b: he sneaks onlv of the b;anso/r; meetin~gs in the . Victo~ia Gurcl~vora in 19L~-14 after Bhagv/~n Sin gh had been deported, of Balll'ant Si:ngh's return to Victoria; and. he te11s ne 1wthing of anything in Vancouver as the other two do, a nd only speaks by hearsay of Mr. Hopkinson's murder, and does not refer to Sumas Ata Singh speaks of mePtings in 1913, of Bhag;van Singh in Vancouver, his deportation and a scheme to rescue llim, of Balwant Singh's return to Vancouver; knows nothing of what happened while the Komagata .Mant was in Canadian !)OI'tP,. as he was away at the time, then speaks of lectures when war broke out, and knows nothing of the Sumas incident or anything afteli' 22nd August '\\·hen he left Vancouw:r.. It clear these statements are not collaborated. Morem er they are supported by evidence with which none of thesewitnesses could, under any circumst&nces, have had anything to do. · ·R ugnath Singh, fer instance, tells Us what happened in Vancouver when the Koma._qata j,l:fm"Ui arrived, of the Sumas incident, and the attitude of Indian3 in Vancouver when w~r broke out and of Mr. Hopkinson's murder. Harcharan Da~ speaks of Balwant Singh's return to Vancouver and what he said and did there ; of the arrival of the K omagata :JJ m·u,, of mertings on its. anival, and while it stayed there, of the state of. affairs when war· broke out,_ and of accused (G) and (13)' s compositions. The Hindustani paper corroborates part of what happened in Vancouver during the stay in that port, and the Givrdwa1·a meetings, and accused's own evidence and statements refer to the Honduras incident, the Sumas affair (which is not imaginary)., the murder of Mr. Hopkinson and the killing of Bhag Singh, of the meetings in bhe G111n?wmY1 and the Dominion Hall,, said, of course;; not to be seditious. · It is useless therefore to speak of co:ncoetion-of course we do .11ot accept any statement of any witness without careful examination of it side by side with other evidence, but we are quite. satisfied there is no question of collabora- ., I ■ is .I ~ ,,l .• ~ tion. , We have dealt with this matter at such length, because it is the main ~efence urged by the Canadi~,n, accused, and "'e can see very little iu ·it. ;;. I 5.-THE SIAMESE PLOT. ln p1 ior case; N othfog was known to the Commissioners who tried the :first conspira,cy case of the Siamese plot, some little was before them in the second conspiracy case, and some more has been revealed in the present case. ; But the main story of the actual Siamese })lot has been the subject of the trial of aertain persons in the Mandalay case. In the Mandalay c~.s~ it appears to have been established that certain revolutionists, including three from Canada, araong whom was Harnam Singh who was concerned in · the alleged smuggling of arms from,.Sumas, cpllected together in Bangkok, and there associattng ·with other revolutionists advocated Ghad1· and engaged in a plot to invade India via. Burma. I· J ___,._ A. 37 l In the present case we have clear evidence that this design did exist, anrl 1n Uie present that it was part and parcel of the Ghadr movement in which German agents case. were concerned. Harcharandas (µ. 31) tells us that he learnt from Ram Chand, Pesha- Harcharndas . waria, that one Santckh Singh had been sent from San Francisco to Siam to urge Indians there to return home for rebellion, and that ~iam had been selected as a place to collect arms, money av.d men in for an invasion of India, vide Burma, and he himself in course of time found his way to BangkoK, being placed under arrest within ~n hour of his arrival there. · Jodh Singh (p. 182 d seq) ,vhof as we know, w::i.s sent from Germany Jodh Singh, by Hardiai to assist the Gharlr movement in San Francisco, came across one Gupta, a well known revolu lionist, in New York, and he advised him to go on to Siam for imnorfant work on which a number of men bad already been sent, and more w~re going soon. Gupta introduced him to a German, • named Whede, an.d he obtained u passport through th~ Persian Consul in New Y 01k 1 who was a 'l urk by nationality, for Persia via Siam in the name of Eassanzada . He then proceeded to Chicago, where Whede introduced him to other Germans named Jacobsen and Boehm and the German Consul. Jacobsen informed him that ho was sending men to Siam to fight for Germany, and that Boehm, an ex-officer, was going to that country to give Indians there a military training in connection with the Siam expedition, and he was then introduced to another German named Sterneck, who was to accompany Boehm to Siam. 1'he following day Sterneck and witness; proceeded to San Francisco, where on 14th May he again met Boehm who was sailing on the Manahuriu. Boehm showed him arms and ammunition, and directed him to call on the German Consul. This he did and he received from the Cohsnl 880 doliars. Gupta haYing asked him to pay the arrount for his expenses, and he aiso learnt that arms had been despatched through a German agency to Siam. He also met one Chatterji- at the Ash1~am, and learnt he too was deputed for the Siamese expedition. The .Germans Whede; Boehm and Sternflck sailed for Manilla: on the Manchiwia, and a week later witness followed on the Teneyo Maru with a letter m his pocket from Ram Chand, Peshawaria! to Bhag'\Van Singh asking the latter to go on to Siam. On board the ship were Chatterji and Chanchiya. (now under restriction in Nellore Jail,_Madras), and at Honolulu two other Indians joined them. Arriving at Manilla they were met by Boehm and a Bengaii, and Boehm comp1aim~d that the details of the Sia.mese expedition had not been worked out, and · he had to do it himself. Boehm took him to the German Consul, and he heard from the Bengali th~t Boehm was to collect JOO Germans in Manilla for the Siamese affair. He also got orders from Boehm to go in advance of him to Siam, while he arranged to bring arms from Batavia on a specia1 boat for Siam, He left. Manilla on 26th June by the · Tai Sang with Chatterjf and Chanchiya, <,arrying letters of introduction to the German 0onstil in Amoy. Arrived at Amoy, they interviewe,i the ~erman Consul and then proc(ieded . to Swatow. At Swatow· they met acoused (3) and (15), who were reassured witness was not a Government Age1;xt' after conversation, and · afl'er· seeing the letters he had for Bbagwan Singh. .Leaving Chanchiya and Chatterji to follow, the witness proceeded with accused· (3) and (15) to Bangkok, whithei· they told him t.hey were ~lso bound. They reached Bangkok on the 17th · July and stayed in t.he gurdwara, and accused (15) advised going to his friends Shibdial Kapur and Atma Singh, trace of whom could be obtained through the German 0onsuL Eventually' they touk up their abode with Sh1bdial, and witness took his meals at the shop of Gopal Das. · The witness then described how he was sent for by the Germ·an Consul~ who enquired if he had found Atrna Singli and Shibdial, and promised to let him know was he to do in Siam. 530 II. 7). i • lie also asked Shibdial, who he knew was a Ghadrite, what he was to do_; and Santokh Singh, who . we have seen had been sent from America on the Siamese business, was wired for, aud lrn too told him he would get orders later. That was the last witness saw of him, for he was arrested on 1st August 1915 in Bangkok, along with a number of other Indiaus tI::ere. A.s regards accused (3) and (15) witness is clear that they described themselves as "patriotic;, and said they ,vere in the revolutionary movement, but did not hear what their purpose in Bangkok was. This witness' statement is a remarkable one. It is quite clear that some scheme for causing tro-uble to British Government, to be developed in 8iam. had been hatchedu by the leaders of the G h.ad1· movemen t in S~rn .lfran~isco in coni unetion ~vith Ger IBans. and tb,t Germa:vs with arms and ammunition were ~n -route for that oou11t:ri, and that Indians were assembiing there for some purpose: or other. The witness is not able to tell us much as to what took nlacA in Siam; he was arrested too soon to know much or what was taki;!:! nlace. and no Indian seemed to have trusted another over much there. u ... But as we are satisfied that there was some revolntionarv scheme afloat in Siam and as we know from tlie evidence above.mentioned and the Mandalay judgment that that scheme was concerned with an invasion of India, the very pe:tinent question arises as to what accused (3) and (15) were doing there, and it is necessary for them to give some satisfactory answer. This they attempt to do in their written statemAnts, and how far it is satisfactory or the l'everse we will consider in their individual cases. We have little direct evidence as to what they did do there. Gopal Da.s (p. 39) tells us he was a servant of Bu.dha Singh (a man convicted in the Mandal~!y case), and he saw th~ accnsed with Shibu.ial and J odh Singh in Bangkok, and they werA fed hy Bud ha Singh and Indar Singh ·(another man apparently charged but acquitted in the lVIandalay 'case). · He also tells us that at a gathering at Indar Singh's accused (3) addressed those present, advising them to wake up, go home, kill the British and seize the raj, and a collection was made for them. · Shol'tly after they we~e J;trrested. We will consider later how far we rely on this evidence of Goyal Das• It is sufficient here to say we are satisfied that there was a dangerous revolutionary scneme ailoat in Siam run by Ghad'l'ites in conjunction with German agents, and we can leave the question of individual responsibility to be considered in the individual cases. B.-THE MIGRATION TO INDIA. The sailing from America, and in part from Canada for ghadr have been described in full in the previous judgments. We agree with our predecessors, find.in$s as to the facts and as to the objects of the large majority then returnmg. · Umrao Singh (p. 50), Nawab Khan {p; 86), Pimar Singh (p. 90), Mula Singh (p. 93) describe to us the sailing of the Korea and the Tosha Maru as before. Umrao Singh (p. 50) and Mula Singh {page 93) tell us how the Siberia fo!lowed the Ko1·ea, and on this ship Dalip Singh (page 69), approver, also sailed. Umrao Singh (p. 30) details what happened on the Mashsma Maru,, so too does Jawal Singh (p. 58.) · ·_ On t.~e Ma!hima Mwru aiso Dalip Singh, the new approver (p. 70), and he gives evidence bearing out the old evidence as to seditious activities in Hong Kong an4 on board, but, as there is nothing in it implicating directly and accused before us now, it would be waste of time to detail the further corroboration. of well established facts. T ,-' 39 j' We need not trace all the vessels which brought back revolutionists ; we need only mention the vessels on which particular accused came. Hafiz Abdulla (17) returned on the Kut Sang, reaching Calcutta on 28th January 1915 with a party of a dozen Sikhs. Accused (12) returned on the Mam Sang arriving on the 13th October. Accused (l) came on the Lama arriving 12th November 19H,, in the company of Kashi Ram (F. M.) and Ram Rakha (absconder.) Accused (3); (4) and (11) journeyed together as far as Hong Kong on the Nippon Maru where (4) and (11) parted from (3) arriving in India 14th March 1915. . .Accuse~ (o) ~ailed on the same ship as Sher Singh tL, (1 C.) to Hong Kong and thence on the 1 o:sha Maru. Accused (9) oame on the Sijoko Mm·u changing on to the Tosha Maru, accused (13) on the Lai Sang arrivir.g 14th September 191-.L. C -THE REVOLUTIONISTS IN INDIA. We have sufficiently discussed above the migration to India and the object thereof, so far as the r.ew evidence in this case in concerned, and all we need say is that we fully agree with the findings of our predecessors, supported as it is by the new evidence. that the objeet of this migration was to wage war in India. In .regard to new matter in India the;e is not much, other than the :Mandi plot, and we propose to touch upon with the utmost brevity. 1 rflTl"-r.l .... ~ .._..u..&:.1 T..TT'l'I & 'T"-r'\..T"I" A ~m.T!'l'T9tr.1 ,L.LAllA.IJ~\J.11.0..l..rJ.D.0 & "" 4.1. A. -,r,.r"ftTmiN .t. 4n .c.L.!ll. L\,..L.1.0.11.Do & '-TT'lt. 4J.~ .1J T . A Tf" ,"\.TIT:'!. .LIAU.VL~.c.t, These incidents, which we need not further discuss, are deposed to before us as in the previous cases by Sucha S:ngh (p. 50), Anokh Singh (p. 75)! Sunder Singh W. 9 lP• 81), Nawab Khan (p. 88), Amat Singh (p. 90) and ?"1ula Singh (p, 93). , The successful raid is deposed to by Khan Sahib Ahmed Khan (p. ,·76,) and also by M. Amir Ali (p. l 05.) Our finding on the same matter corresponds with that of our predecessors. 2.-MEETINGS AT LADAOWAL, MoGA AND BADHOW AL. As in the earlier cases these meetings and their objects are proved by Umrao Singh (p. 50)s Jawala Singh (p. 59), Nawab Khan (p. 97) and Amar Singh (p. ~0), and we adopt to ours the conclusions arrived at by the previous tribunals. · d.-THE MAIN MIR AND FEROZEPORE ATTACKS OF NOVEMBER THE 19]4, AND JAHAR SAHIB AFFAIR. The jndgm.~nt~ cf onl9 predece~~cr~ i~ th~ fi.rst and tsti0011cl tti211ls have discussed the proposed attack on Main Mir arsenal on 25th November, the failure thereof, and the despatch of men to Ferozepore for an attack there orr the 30th November, and also the connected Jbar Sahib affair. We have the same evidence as they had, though not so full, and we .a re satisfied that one of the earliest schemes of the revolutionists was to collect men in Lahore on the 25th November, carry the Mian Mir arsenal ¥1 'conjunction with rebellious troops, then ride out'the ~foar Sahib and .raise uJf the whole of of the Manjha tract. The scheme fell through, the ~in Mir attark ended in smoke, the Jhar Sabib gathering frittered away into an aimless mob, and those who had collected in Mian Mir went down to Fel'ozepore to link up with _Nidhan Singh's party there, and assault the arsenal mr the 30th November, a scheme 40 which came to naught owing to the capture of several men ancl the dispersal of others in connection with the Ferozeshahar murder. The whole of this group of evidence can be very shortly dispornd of. 1 '1 he collection of men in Lahore for the Mian Mir attack, their abandonment •of the attack and their despatch to :Ferozepore is established by the e.Vidence of Jawla Singh (p. 59), Nawab Khan (p. 89) and Amar Singh (p. 90), but in addition we must rnfer to the confessions of accused (2), (14) and (8). AccusP-d (2) stafa=1d in his magisterial confession (p. 109) that Amar Sin?"h I and Jaga.t Sing-h got Surian Singh (P. M.) to collect some men in ]fattehgarh. Re, acct~sed: was o;e of them p.,nd so was accused (14). They came to Lahore for the revolt there, stopped at Mela Ram's seal'i, and the next day heard the scheme had been abandoned, and they were despatched via Ludhiana, where they met Nawab Khan, Ferozepore which they duiy reached. ' · Accused 14 (}J. 113) giYes an almost identical account, though naturally in different words as that given by accused (2); and Fazal Din (8) in his confession (p. 110) refers to Surjan Singh (F. M.), accused (2) and (14) setting off and on their re~nm hearing from S urjan Singh that they had gone down Lahore to see how cantonments could. be assaulted, and from there h~d · gone on to Fer0zepore to view the arsenal. The Jhar Sahib gathering is described by U dham Singh (p. 77) and Sunda:r Singh, W. G. (80), and the pl'Oposal in the 23rd Cavalry to ride out there by Sundar Singh, W. G. (p 80), Wasawa Singh· (p. 95) and Ganda Sjngh (p. 96). to 4.-SEDUCTION OF STUDENTS. The previous cases have dealt f-q.lly with the policy of seducing students. The evidence then given in regard to the seduction of ~tudents in Ludhiana is repeated before us by Abdul Alim (p. 41), who credits accused (12) with p1;1rt of this work~ Sucha Singh (p 48) who similarly implicates accused (12) and Anokh .Singh (p. 7.) . .Among new incidents is that of Durga Das (p. 42). He says he was visited by accused (l~),, an old friend of his, at a boarding h011Re in Lahore in the compauy of a man, named llunsha Singh, who'was described as a composer of songs for the Glrndr·di-Gimj, and is identified by the prosecution with accused (13), and while accused (12} went. o:ff to keep an appointment .with Bhai Parmanand, whom he had known in Japan, the other ,visitor spoke to him of revolution, with which he would have nothing to do. There is no doubt that this was part of the considered policy of the ~liadr- movement, and we know that it was highly successful in · too many mstances. 5.-~'HE SEDUCTION OF VILLAGERS. Old evidence. 011tside Honolulu, There :is considerable evidence . in the two prior conspiracy trials that the sedu~tion of villagers to the Glrnd1'' par;y was one of the means propagated by the Ghodr newspaper, and put into action in India, to- achieve the -revolution. We have in this case besides the Ghad1· incitements to that effect, whfoh it is uhnecessary for us to again reproduce, and evidence of inddents like the Jhar Sahib, some new. evidence. Bawa Singh (p; 38) amt Khazan Singh (p. 38) , who · travel:lE>d· on the same ship as accused (B), (4) and (11) from :San Francisco to Rong Kong both say that on board :accused (3), approached them, and urged ,them to assist the Ghadr movement by qollecting villagers together, advising them . not , to ·pay 1·evenue and to help in expellh1g the British, and aociJ.sed :(3) 's efforts were supported by the other two. There is no particular reason for supposirig th ese· men are inventing tht} other story~ ·· 1 f Perhaps one of the most. interesting mustrations of this policy, aDd what Fattelig;irh. it ultimately led to is to be found in the magisterial confessi0ns of accused (2), (8) and (14J, all residents of :Fattehgarh in Hoshiarpur District. Surjan Singh, one of the :Ferozeshahr murderers, was a resident of that village; who returned from the east when the general migration commenced. Babu Ram (p.109) in this confession describes how this man 8urjan Singh talked to him, telling him 2,000 or 3,010 men from America had turned rebels against the British Government; and were intent on expelling the British from India, to achieve which end they were in pcssession of ammunition and_ arms. The acc11sed jr;ined the mo:-e~ent r!1:d.er · tl1r-c:1,t r1f dJ~3.t11.} a,rtd ~short time after a man called by wJtness Jaggat Singh (L. C. C.), but -whom " I ,. \I -~ i \ : II 11 . "Jr-· I . ·1t _.h we have reason to believe was Jaggat Ram Singh (L. C. C. ), and Amar Singh (approver) came to Surjan to get him to send down men for the IVIian :Mir attack of the 25th N ovemher. Ferozeshahr The accused went and was ultimately involved in murder. N ama (p. 113) gives a similar story in his confession. He "ays that Surjan on his return home callAd him, along with Babu and Fazal Din, ·told them 1,700 or 1,800 men had returned from America intent on raising a rnbellion, and expelling the British, who were represented as loading Iniians ·with taxes'. Re induced them to join by promises of reward according to the services rendered to the cause. He also refers to the visit of Amar Singh, approver, and J,11gat S,ingh (L. C. 0.) to get men for the attack on Main Mir, and this accused a_lso went, 1 and was also involved in the :E erozeshahr murder. Fazal Din (p. 118) has a similar story to tell. He met ,Surjan 111 Fattehgarh, and was told he had come home for work which was superior to, money. Surjan proceeded to tell him there were 30,000 or 40,000 men in America who were taunted by Americans, that Gurdit Singh had taken a ship to Canada, and as the passengers had not b~en allPwed to laud societies had been formed and lectures delivered against Govern:nent, tthe lecturers including Ram Rakba (absconder L. C., 0.) and Nawab Khan {approver). Under the instigation of these lectures the Indians in America pad decided to return in Ir:dia, overthrow the British Government, and gcveru the land them@elves. 1\foney, he said, had -been sent to Japan to nrocurE.· arms and ammunition, and it would be a very short time before the independent Hindustani R~j woulJ be established. He was .told the Indhn Army had been seduced and it was intended to attack canton:c.:..ents and plunder the treasuries and magazine1-, and, under a promise of al'eward whPn the Hindustani K_ing was duly placed upon the throne, the arcused promi~ed to hAlp. The aecused al~o ~tates be w~s tben introduced to A.mar Singh (1), who , corroborated Surjan Singh' s accouflts, and as he had Pathans wnrkrng under , him, he was asked to induce them to join too, a course they agreed to Lllow. He was then, he states, visited by- one Tara Srngh, and later by Ram Rakh&, :who boasted of the success the revolutionan agents were having amon~ the troops, and how they proposed to ,cut the telegraph wires. , This comp~ehensive programme wa~ sufficient to make accused certain cf .:;~ccc::;:;; he d.eolincd, h0·•~6v1::,c, to join in a projected dacoity, and he rem.em .. be,rs Babu and Nama, some time after these event~, going 0:ff for the Miau l{ir expedition. The p~u-t played by this accused will be cliscussed in hi., individual case; here it suffices to say t};ta.t it is incredible that he could have invented or was tutoted into describing his e]aborate prograro:pie uf what w~ know was the real pro6 r9m.me of the Ghadr pa:rty. · · We may note too that . Amar Singh. approver (p, 186), corroborates the story of his going to Fattehgarh to inµµce Surjan Singh to get men for the proposed Mian Mir ~ttt:tck. We have also an interesting account from anot.hf.'r accused, Rur Singh SagW&I. (18), of what took _place in Sagwal. This man's confession is unretracted, and he has admitted befo1·e us his confes~ion on·this matter is corrrnt {p. 121.) 758 H, D. 42 The man who 11.rst mooted Ghacfr to him was Banta. Singh '' c~f the • golden teeth," famous as a participator in at least two mnrclers fo L· which h e 'r h&-s been executed. l!ahran&. Banta SinO'h was a · resident of Sagwal, and on his return from America beO'an accordh~O' to his confession, to lecture in the village dharanisala. He ·w:S j~ined by Harnam Singh Tunda (L. 0. 0.), and t~e two lectured in Sagwal and neighbouring villages, Buttar~ Lakhanrnke, Dhanwal, etc. '.Phe bmden of the lectures<:was that paople Rhould form their own panchaytas and decide their own cases and that the British ~.oyernment, bei~~ oppressi~'e, should be overthrown. They spoke of daco1trns as a means ur raisinr.i' money for a press to print seditious· leaflet~, and urged that revenue was b~ing i~creased. 'lhis man, as hiR individual case will show; he~arne a very formidable recruit to ~be Ghadr party, a.nd, par-ti0ularl~ .as h~ rn~inb ins before us the accuracy of his statement, there 1s no rP-ason to cn~beheve 1t. But in addition to his account as to what occmred in Sagwal we ha·ve other e~idencc, viz., that of Indar Sain. (pp . 3-t, 9 2), Rc1lla Singlt (1>. 34) and Ralla (p. 92). Indar Sain {pp 34, 92) depose to accused (18) being in the village with Rarnam Singh (L: C 0.), and Banta. Singh giving seditious lectures, reading out the Ghadr and inciting the people to mutiny. He adds that accused (13) was an active associate of theirs, and had a long seditious talk with him. Ralia (p. 92) gives evidence to the same effect, but does not mention accused {13). Ralla Singh (p. 34) gives evidence also as to accused (13~, (18), Banta Singh, Harnam Singh and others associating and lecturing to the same seditious . effect.· · '\iYhether or not we are sflitisfied that Mnn~ha Singh nm did a.~sneiat.Awitµ the others find lectme we will discuss in his indi~id~al' case, but it i~ quite clear that there were seditious lectures in the village of Sagwal by men of leading in t he Gkadr movement. Another village in regard to which· we have evidence is Marhana. Surain Singh (p. 35) and Bhola Si.ngh (p. 35) depose to accused (5 ), a returned emigrant, lecturing in the village, advising everyone to refuse service and to de_cline to pay revenue, as the British Government would soon be driven out of India. , · In regard to this incident, however, there is a considerab1e Lody of defenceevidence directed to show the witnesses are· inimical to accused, and we will discuss in the individual cases as to how far it is safe to accept the evidence. We have also the evidence of Udhain Singh (p. 77) as in the previous casEs,. and that too cf Bhagat Singh {p. 77) relating to Gujarwal, and Lohatbadi and his own Feditious t0urs, Amar Si!:!gh oi Usmanpur (p. 97), of 8undar Sfogh A. M. (p. 100) with reforence to Lohatbadi and neighb:mrhood and of Arjau Singh (p. 47}, Bhagat Singh (p. 78) and Baehan Singh (p. P6), relative to Dlmclike and neighoourhood, and ·of Harnama (p. 94). regardiug efforts in the Padd as in the Padri murder case. Sufficient has been said to further establish that the seduction of villagers was an integ~al part of the revolutionai·y campaign. r 6 -THE SEDUCTION OF TROOPS. :No fres~ trddence is produced before ua a~ to the seduction of troops. It is µ.nnecessary to again r~fer to incitements to tamper wit.h troops. _That is estab li~hed by Lhasa me evidence •as in tho previous cases. All we need do is to ·.iudicateth'! direct evidence given of actualtampcring with success in this case. ., Suohai Singh (p. 49) duscribes his iong tour with Kartar Sinbh (L. C. C.) and Pingley · (L. Q. C.), anu his sub~equent efforts in Meerut, Fyzabad and Ambala. Anokh Singh (p. 76) and Mula Singh, . (p. 93) describe the seduction of-troops in Ferozepore; Sunder Singh, W. G. (p. 80) and Amar Singh j 13 tr_. 90,91) the tamnering with troops in :Hong Kong, and in Mian Mir, Nawab Khan (p, E7) the preparing of troops for Ghadr in Hong Kong; (p. 91). Mula Singh Wasawa Singh (p. 95), Ganda Singh (p. 96) th(dealings with the 23rd Cavalry in Lahore. J We must note that Wasawa Singh and Ganda Singh say accused (18) was one of Prem Singh's companions in the 23rd Lines, and the former identifies accused (18) as the man who taught the sowars how to make explosives, but this accused (18), while prepared to admit many thrngs, denies. We also have the same evidence as before of Nawab Khan; Amar Sin()'h· ,.a,n d lt>..1.Uta 7\,,f" l ..:,' 1 _,;_ .. , • l ,. " ' '1-' , ,. • '::, a::,mg,1 as LO Llle rnocu1at1on or troops Wilin rcvo1ut1onary 1cteas throughout tbe Prrnjah. , We are fully satisfied that this too formed pa1·t of the gramme. ghadr pro- 7.--SEDITIOUS LITERA'l URE. _.. Before touching on any new matter we have briefly to indicate the evidence given in the former conspiracy trials and repeated before us in reg9.rd to the use and discovery of seditious literature, and the for.nal evidence of production. S. Sukba Singh (p. 23) deposes to.the discovery of seditious literature on the Komogata Mar·u on 27th September 191-4 in Caicutta, and pwduces a c 011y (p, 5) of the Hindustani, as well as an incomplete file of the Sansar (p. 6). He also produces a copy of Bhai Parmanand's bookTa1·ikh-i-Hind (p. 7). l I ft.Bhagwangir (p. 44) proves ihe d.i:soovery of du.plkate Chad;- Sa,ndes~s in Ludhiana, Inspector Niaz Ahmad tp. 74) that of the duplicators, Su.cha Singh (p. 48) tells us of its duplication and the production of the Nadir Maqua in Ludhiana, ascribing a share to accusei (12) in the ,dissemination of•. the Gh.adr-di-GunJ; Anokh Singh of its being prevalent in Ludhiana. The appearance of the G hadr in Shanghai is deposed to as before by Jawala Singh (p. 58), Dalip Chand, and Sundar Singh W. G. (p. 79). The discoveries of seditious literature in Lahore are related by Khan Sahib Ahmad Khan (p. 76), and Amar Singh (p. 91) gives an account of its production in Lahore. In Manilla: also, according to Allabdad (p. 98), and Parmanand (p. 100), the 1 Ghadr was freely distributed and ·the latter describes to us a paper, which came from Constantinople, edited by a Punjabee ~nd called the Jahan-.ul-Islam to which one Zafar Ali, apparently the editor of a defunct sheet in the Punjab, contributed inflammatory articles and, if the witness is correct, indecent and disgusting illustrations. Connected with individuals (p. 11), is identified by Bela Singh (p. 26), as signed by accused (4)/and he tells us that it was returned by the D. L. O. to another Batten Singh, who handed it over to witness. Th,ere are two letters included in (p. 11), one imploring the addressee to help Balwant Singh (3), who wa~ then under arrest in Vancquver,. apparently in connection with the m urde~: of Mr. Ho1Jkinson ; and the other to other addressees much to the same effect, with the addition of a reference to stirring articles having appeared in the papers about the Komagata .Maru, and some news from India of German roroplanes having been dropping l~tters there, and ca.using great unrest. The letters are really of little importance. Inspector Aziz-ud-din (p. 40) deposes to dis~overing P. 12, in the hou11e of accused (7) on 11th August 1915. · ,· This document contains a particularly virulent Gurmukhi poem, in which supposed oppressions upon zamindars are violently described, the King is described as a tyrant, and the people are adyised to form their own panchayats 44 and spread their own flag. The distant mythical past is decribed as a golden era, and Government, with whom bankers and pleaders are associated, is described ~s ruining the land. The production of the Sonsar and the Hinduf:J'foni in Vancouver we nave _discussed in the section dealing with the revolutionary movement in Canada, and the dissemination.of the Ghadr in Vancouver and Victoria in the samesection. "\\-~ e have evidence also as to its dissAmination in Shanghai and N ankin. Dulip Chand (p. 27) tells us that accused (15) was in the habit of distributing it to passengers in the train between those stations, but beyond proving what is proved from other Rources, viz., that the Ghadr found its way to Shanghai, we are not prepared to place much reliance on thi~ unsupported testimony as 13.gainst Thakur Singh. f Its appearance in Penang is evidenced as before by Arjan Singh (p. 46). ' Mr. Isemonger (r. 103) tells us that amongst the luggage of accused (17), which he had brought back from Amritsar to Ludhiana, he found P. 60, which accused at the time admitted ,vas in his own or his wife's hand, prooably the latter's. 1 · P. 60 is a short song, virulent intone with the refrain "'1 he tyrannical Faringhi are drinking our blood,'' hardly the sort of production to be possessed by a law abiding citizen, as accused represents himself to be. Lachman Singh., lambardar, who arrested n.ccused (18) tells u~, (p, 105} that he ~ound P. 64 on accused. He is supported by Head Constable Dil Muhammad (p. 106), and accu_sed himself (p. 122) admits the fact . i This document is a particularlv Ion!? noem and starts with an invocation tci" the "brave brothers the Gliadr pa;ty" and extols the work of those who belong to it, is very virulent against the Br:itish and the police, who " are to. be burnt with dried bushes and their children murdered." , "Those who are loyal to Government," it says ' ' are to be butchered," and a very unkindly :fate is promised S. Sukha Sing-h, who has done so much to brin!? these desuerados to ·book. ~ . ~ of V Anothor document is P .. 65. This is a pocket book found in the k ggageof accused (4), but which is admittedly a diary of accused (3)'s. The diary con• tains the dates of departure and arrival at _various plares between Vancouver and Marseilles, which accused visited in 1913, but in addition there is a Persian couplet on the front page, rendered also ·i nto Gurmukhi on another page, the translation of which is '' when other plans do not succeed, it is right to take up the sword." It is a si.gnificant passage, but accused denies it is in his _hand. 8.-THE :MANUFACTURE OF Boirns. · The two previous judgments of the former triburl'al have given at length the story of the manufacture of bombs. We have the same evidence before us in this c.ase, though not in the same detail, and it will suffice for us to mention with the greatest brevity what that evidencA is, and to say that we agree with the previous tribunals that the msnufacture and use of bombs by the revolut~on~ts to c~rry their designs -into eirect, -is amply proved. The discussion or bombs in America is fully proved by the Ghadr file. The experimenal bomb in A~rit8ar is proved . by Amar Singh (p. 90), Mula Singh (p. 93) an,d M. Amir Ali, District Superintendent of Police (p, 105J. The pur~hase of materials _in t ·u dhiana is eviden~ad by Wilayati Ram (p. 42), Dial Singh (p. 43) and Sucha Singh (p. '48), and Jhabewal as a centre -of collection of materials is established by Sucba Singh ·(p. 48), U mrao Singh . ·• y-· .~ I I -~ 45 (p. 50), Suh-Inspector of Police, Mohamad Akbar (p. 41) and Mula Singh (p, 9o). I The transfer of the materials to and manufacture in Lohatbadi is established bv Sucha 8in(J'h (p. 49), Narain Singh (p. 7-1), and Sundar Singh (p. 101) fa Dhudike and 7ieighbourhood by Arjan Singh (p. 4';'), Bhagat Singh (p. 78), at Doraha by Anokh Singh (p. 76), Bhagat Singh (p. 78), and Inspector Fazl Imam (p. 7tJ); the preparations for making bombs in ~ahore and the di"coveries in Lahore and Amritsar are proved by Khan Sahib Ahmad Khan (p. 77), Amar Smgh (p. 90), Mula Singh (p. 94) a.nd M. Amir Ali, Deputy Superinten .. dent of Police (p. 105). Their manufacture in the lines of the 23rd Cavalry is deposed to by Wasawa Sing b {p, 95). We wiil discuss the propos~.l to make bombs in Mandi in the section deaiing wi.th the .Mandi plot, and the connection of the particular accused (12) wit,h the purchase of materials iu Ludhiana, and accused (18) with the manufacture iii the lines of the 23rd Cavahy will be discussed in the individual case. 9.-THE COLLECTION OF ARMS. In the two judgments of the prior tribunals much was discussed as to the Old eviden;;e. provision of arms for the revolutionists. We have much. of that evidence recorded in this case, but it iR unnecessary to refer to it f4rther. ... We need only consider the new evidence there is . "\Ve have dealt in detail with ihe alleged attempt to procure arms for the Komctgata Ma1·u in Sumas, and we will be compelled to refer to it again in connection with tho individual case of accused (o ), and we need not enter into it again here. We will also refer to the discovery of arms i~ Mandi in the section dealing with the :Mandi plot, and to the Kapurthala, Walla bridge and Doraha affair, and we need not refer tc them agairi. All the sources of arms W;.t;.tdo not and cannot know, but it seems to us Tbearms schemeimd that it is well established that a number of arms were arranged for in America the s. s. Maver•c1'. by German agents. Jodh Singh (pp. 182-83), himseif at ooe time a German agent, tells us that when he was' in San Jfrancisco in May 1915, one of his German companions Boehm told him the German Consul had despatched a quantity of arms either to Sia.m or India, and asked him if he knew anything of the "A1·ms Scheme.'' .: the Consul, that. official also a.sked him if he knew of this scheme, and the Consul consulted a report, which witness noticed referred to a quantity of arms havicg been despatched from Me~ioo, and the• Consul told him that the arms would reach their destination before witness reached Siam. · Y hen he himself -called on When he reached Manila, he saw the German Consul there, who informed him that arms had been despatched, according to a code telegram received from San Francisco, to some place· on the Indian coast, whose name witness cannot now recollect, and the Consul feared the cargo had been intercepted. · We have no further direct evidence on this point, but there 'is an interesting statement by Harcharan Das (pp. 31 et seq) which we think is probably connected with this Arms Scheme. · · This man, as we h~ve already seen, had left Canada in December HH4, and became a willing worker in the Yugantar Ashram under Ram Chand Peshawaria. From him, besides hearing that the Komagata Maru men had been armed in Japan through K~shi Ram (F. M:.), and of -proposals and , schemes to get arms into India via Siam a:nd Tibet, he heard of other methods of supply~ including direct shipping to India. 758 H. D, 4(3 A.bout April 19:,5 he was induced by Ram Ch~n~ t~ consent to. g~ on :,, particular ship, called the jJfaverick, with one Han Smgh, on revo1ut10nary work, which w::i,s not disclosed to him. They boarded the Maverick at San Pedro under assumed names. The ship wa; an · oil ship with one tank empty, was sailing under the American flag, officered b~~ Americans and sailored by :Marshall Islanders, formerly German subj.ects, with Mexican fireman. They put in at a Mexican port, and thencp, sailed to Ci~a_ro, an u11~n.• habited isle, where they waited for a month, and ~ere _v1s1ted b;r some Americans and Mexic::tns. Here time was spent mamly m watchmg for something to turn up, and they receivecl surprise search visits from H . 1\!L A. S. Ghent, and H. :M::. C. S. Ra-iriboro and an American .man•of-,.,·ar, which all searched the vessels. From _Cigaro they cruised, apparently aim1essiy, about · the Pacific, calling at various islands, and on to Helo, Johnson Island and Java, which they reached on 22nd July 1915; where a Dutch torpedo boat seized the vessel, and it was apparently interned. Witness cannot tell us what the ship was doing, but ht) says those who were not in the know thought they were either hanging about with oil for G:erman ships, which is hardly likely with an · empty tank, or were waiting to. pick up a cargo of arms for India. · When we think of the apparently aimless wanderings of the boat, and connect it with what the ltermau Consuls in -:; an lfrancisco and Manila told Jodh Singh, we think it is not improbable I that this v~s~el was employed for the purpose of running arms for the revolutionists. f · ,. i0.-DACOITIES. The judgments in the two -previous conspfracy trials deal fully with the evidence relating to the various dacoities committed in the course of the war waged .by the revolutionists, and it is not necess&.ry for us to go over the ground again. We have before us the Ghaclr file with its incitements to dacoities, and the same evidence in regal'd to decoi.ties being considertd and advised by the revolutionists in America, Penang and elsewhere. 1Ve have also the snecific evidence of witnesses in regard to particular dacoities. ' ·. . . The dacoity at Sahnewal and the murder of Khushi ; Ram is proved as before by Sub-Inspector of Police Muhammad Akbar (p. 40}, M ussar:nmat Sobhi (p. 41), Ama,r Chand (p. 41), Umre Khan (p. 41), Sub-Inspector of Police :Faiz-ul-Hassan (p. 42), Durga Das (p. 43), Siri Ram (p. 43), ParmPshri Das (p. 43), Bisher. Singh (p. 43), Abdul Alim (p. 44), Sucha Singh (p. 49), Umrao Singh ,(p. 51), An·o kh Singh (p. 75), Mula Singh (p. 9-:b), and Amar _ Siugh (p. 91)~ . Ke~r Singh1 accused (12), is implicate,d before us as being concerned in { this affair, but we can rAserYe_the question as to whether his partfoipation in it is established or not till we come to deal with the individual case. A.s regards the Mnnsuran dacoity, we have the evidence, as before given, of Anokh Singh (p. 75 ), Abdul Alim (p. 44), Sucha Singh (p. 49), Umrao Singh (p. 51), Hamir Chand (p. 53), Mula Singh (p. 94), and Amar Singh (p. 91). The Jhaner dacoity is proved as before by Waziri Mal (p. 53), Narain Singh (p. 74) and Sundar Singh (p. 101). , _._ The Rabbon dacoity is established by the evidence of Mussammat Sardi (p. 53), Narain Singh (p. 74), and Sundar Singh (p. 101) as in the previous c~ses, while ~he Chabba dacoity is proved by Kundan Lal (p. 61), Udham Smgh (p. 77), M. Amir .Ali (p. 106), Mula Singh (p. 94), and Amar Singh (p. 91), and the disposal of the proceeds of these dacoities for the benefit of the Ghadr- party is deposed to by the same witnesses as in the previous cases. ~ r- -,( 47 We have a]so the evidence of Jawala Singh (p. 59) as to the marauding gang he joined; and Dalip Singh, the new approver (p. 71), who was a member of this gang, gives evidence hearing him out. Nawab Khan also g'ives evidence as before (pp. 88 and 89) in regard to the clacoit gang with which he asso~iated and worked. The dacoity activities of the GhadrittJs is further evidenced before us by fresh witnesses. We have a number of accused before us who have returned from Canada, and Ata Singh (p 36) tells us that, when accmed (3) returned from India, in Ivfay 1914J 1 he too advocated the commission of dacoities, and Mangal Singh (n. 28) deposes to the looting of treasuries being proposed when L1.;_e Kurnu.ga,ta Ma.,!"UJ had returned, and we see no reason to doubt them. Two of the accused in their confessions break fresh ground. Fazal Din ( p. 1.19) has stated that, some time in t~ovember, one Tara Singh and Surjan Singh (F, l\iI.) told him that Piara Singh (L: C. 0.), Jawand Singh (L. 0. C.) 3 Amar Singh, accused (1) and Ram Rakha (absconder) had foregathered to commit a dacoity at Panchnangal and his heip was invokPd. He did not, however, go but he heard afterwards from Surjan Singh it had been committed, and a chaukidar kiiled. We have no further knowledge of this affair, and possibly it has been enquired into and disposed of by other courts; Rur Singh, in his unretracted ·confession (p. 124), gives a long account of a dacoity at Alawalpur, engineered from Sagwal, in which amongst others the famous Banta Singh participated, the whole gang being armed. Ile details the loot, and describes the use of firearms, and the disposal of the loot, but, as in reganl to the affair 5,t .Pauuhn.wngal, ";VB have no furthe!' e~riderrne in re(!ard to the Alawalpur d.acoity. ' ..., All we need say is we are satisfied dacoities were co:nmitted as a part of the considered programme of the G hiJdr party. 11.-THE MURDERS. The Anarkali murder and its connection with the revoh1tionists is proved before us by Sub-Inspector of Police Muhammad Musa (p. 78) and Khan Sahib Ahmad Kh·:m (p. 76), and the PaJdri murder is proved by Amar Singh (p. 97), Khushi Ram (p. 104) and Harnama (r· 94) ; the latter proves that that murder was also the work of the rernlutfonists, •· and he . asserts that accmsP,d (18) was 'o ne of the party, though accused (p. 122) denies this strongly. The projected murder of Kirpal Singh (sepoy) by Prem Singh~ his cGmpn.nian, an.d men in the 23rd Cavalry is deposed to as in the l4econd conspiracy trial by Wasawa Singh (p.- 95), Ganda Singh (p. 93) and Fauja Singh (p. 96), and they all implicate accnsed (18) . as one of th~ men despatched for the murder, but this accused denies, though he is · prepared to aclmit many thln~ · The Hoshiarpur murder is proved . by Hira Singh (p. 106), who was in. the affair. He does not identify Rur Singh, who,. however, has confessed he was in the murder, and has told us that he joined the gang wit;h the intenti9n of murdering Chanda Singh, but stayed outside the village while others went in to commit it, and in his confession (p. 127) he gives a detaiied account of the murder and his share in it, :an~ makes it quite clear it was the wo1!k of revolutionists. The deplorable affair of the Ferozeshahr murder has already been describ~ ed in various judgments, including two of the Chief Court, tiro of the Sessi':)ns Judge, Ferozepo·re, the two prior judgments in the Lahore · conspiracy cases and the judgment of the same tribunal in the case against Ganda Singh. l I I f f 48 It is not necessary for us to describe the murder further, we are in accord with all these previous judgments as to the facts . . As, however, there are two of ihe accused before ;s, accused (2) and (14), who are alleged to have been implicated in it, it will b_e necessary _for _us in their individual cases to describe the new evidence connectrng them with 1t. This evidence consists of the magi8terial confessions of these two accused. '1 hese confessions which have been retracted disclose an intimate knowledge of the murder. 1 r Formal proof in regard to the murders and post mortem i~ given by Assistant Sur~eon Jai Gopal Sethi (p. 53), Inspector Ghulam Muhammad (p. 53), Ida (p. 54), :P. C. Fauci.an (p. ;;ct) , M:nh~1m:11a d Sitliq (p. 57) , !i!!.d the following witnesses who were present at the time of the murder, Qesides describing the events, identifv both these accuserl as in the affair :---Karim Bakhsh (p. 54), Sher Singh, Sufedposh (p. 55), Glrnlam Kadir, Zaildar (p. 55), Khan Singh (p. 55), Sardal't'i. Singh (p. 56), Phangan (p. u6) and Nawab (p. 56). The other old witnesses are sufficiently dealt with in the individual cases. 12,-ATTACKS ON BRIDGES. ( As in the prior cases Anokh Singh (p. 76) and Bhagat Sfogh '(p. 78) describe the projected attackon the Doraha bridge, while Nawab Khan · (p . 88) refers to the plan to carry the Safid Bain bridge and Kupp Station, and we have nothing to add to our predecessors' findings, with which we agree. Jr 13 -THE RISING dF THE 19TH FEBRUARY. This also is one of the matters already fully discussed liy our predecessors. No useful purpose can be served ?Y again going through the evidence. The fixing of the 21st for the rising, its sudden change to the 19th, its discovery and its collapse and the abortive "Feroz'3pore raid timed to occur with the rising in Lahore, are proved · before us by Sucha Sin~h (p. 49), U mrao Singh (p. 51), Anokh ~ingh (p. 75), K. S. Ahmad Khan {n. 76), Bhagat Singh (p. 78), Amar Singh (p. 91), Mula Singh (p. 91) and Sundar Singh, .A..M. (p. 101), and we adopt the conclusions of our predecessors on the subject. 14.-THE KAPURTHA.LA RAID AND THE WALLA BRIDGE MURDERS. In the previous cases ..it was established that several of the Canadian emigrants made Dhudike their centre ofoperations and that revolutionists there conceived a scheme in June 19lo for raiding Kapurthala to get arms there. A gathering took place · on the 5th June at Kapurthala, and, though the assault was postponed until the 12th, a party set off for the Walla bridge and there on ~he 11th June aUacked the guard, killing two soldiers, and in their flight murdered two other men. The actual murders at thC" Walla bridge, a:nd- afterwards j'n the pursuit, are proved before us by -Inspector Aziz-ud-din {'p. 40), Bachan 'Singh (p. 96) and S. I: P. Shib Sarall' Sini:i;h ( p 177). Though none of the ·a ccused before us is directly implicatei in the Walla bridge i;nurders, one, accused (18), admits being concerned in the Kapurthala raid: and a' little .new light :is thrown on that ma~ter. · -, The actual plot in Dhudike is again described to us by Arjan Singh (p. 47), Amar Singh (p. 97) and ·Bachan Singh (p. ,96), thew.atter two cescrihfog the meeting oft.he 5th, where they say ~ccused (18) was present, and the Walla bridge attack was pl_anned. -t ., I )r ~ AO :rv Mula Singh (p, 94) tells us be heard from Banta Singh (lloshiarpur murderer), that there was a havildow- in Kapurthala ready to job the move• .ment, and accused (18), Jaswant Singh (absconder) and Banta ;Singh had been sent to interview him sometime in February. · This so-called havildar, Bhagwan Singh, now we are informed a life• convict, bas been produc8cl as a witness before us. He gives a statement naturally exculpatory of himself, but he deseribe~ several ·visits of accused (18) to him, when accused asked him if it was difficult to steal arms fr<>m the m_agazine, remarking he wanted them for dacoities. -, The end of i!i was that there was a gathering of some 18 men, including accused, who said they wanted to steal guns to fight -Government withi but the attflck on the magazine was postponed for a week. The next week fewer still ..it.ti, cd, :t:1d the ~·itnP~s WH~ given. clothes to keep. which eventuallv turned out to be c0nnected with the ~Walla Bridge murder~ · " Rur Singh, accused (18) has admitted to us paying a visit to Kapurthala ftt M uh,, Singh's suggestion. He admits also trying to win over the havilclar; and to going to Kapurthala both on the 5th and hth ,June, to raid the magazine, but _denies that any attack on the Walla Bridge was discussed then. In his confession (pp. 126, 7) he has given a long and detailed account of the Kapurthala episode. He says he first went to see the liavildar with J awand Singh, absconder, and the hai,ildar told them that they could easily raid the magazine if they had 100 men, and advised an attack on a Saturday. It was after Nidhan Singh's arrest, he says, that they arranged at Dhudike to a8sault the Kapurthala magazine. Banta Singh went first to view the grou.nd; ~,nd then a party of 20 was got together, but the numbers were considered insufficient and when they went again, i.e., on the 12th June, only four turned up, and they then heard of the Walla Bridge exploit. This additional evidence on]y confirms the findings of our predect1ssors that the Kapurthala raicl and the connected Walla Bridge murders were the work of the revolutionists. 15.-THE MANDI PLOT. The Mandi plot is an incident, which has been brought out fo-r. the first Th fir 8t. t· t·100 time in the prest3nt case. A slight reference appears to have been n ade to it in ° rn ima • the second conspiracy case, when Bachan Singh (approver) stated that he had heard that there was a Rani in some State who had promised to assist the Ghadr movement, a subject which he a~ain deposes to before us on p. 97, where he says he heard from accused (18) there was a Rani of a hill State prepared to · give R2,0OO for arms. But otherwise the mattC:Jr has been elucidated only recently and is, we understand, still under investigation, so far as regards the connection therewith of residents in Mandi. The ·discovery of this plot is due to the fact that Surian Singh, one of Ane::t of l5urjan the Ferozeshahr ·murderers, now lying under sentence of. death, was arrested on oinah._ the 2nd M.ay 1916 in Suket. · -. .. ... Das (p: 57) and Sardar Sukha Singh (p. 2:1), and an investig-ation made by Inspector Bhag Singh (p. 82). -~ We are, of coursE,?, not competent to consider the statements so made, and what we know of this incident is based exclusively on evidence before u·s which is possih ly in com pletA. •· ' I )r It was in consequence of statements made by him to the police that .the jncident was opened out,-vide statement of Sub-Inspector of Police Gopal ~ '\,Ve havA a. considerable amount of eyidPnce, however, and reference is made to the affafr in the confessions of accused (8) a,nd (14).. 758 H. D. surjan Singh'11 first visit to I!l.twdi. the The beginning of the Mandi plot, eo far as we know, was subsequent to l!,erozeshahr murd·er. Surjan Singh, an ahsconder in that murder retmned, according to accused (2) and (14), to Fattehgarh after the murder. Nama, accused {14), in his confession (p. 114) states that fro"m Fattehgarh Surjan Singh went off to Suket Mandi, and he himself followed some days after, fearing arrest for his complicity in the Ferozeshahr murder, taking stockings he had made with him for sale. .He savs he went off to Bhoj pur ; this was some ti~~~i~~~c~~~~~r,_~1;,~ ~here,..met S~rjan Singh, ":ho took· him to ~,h : ~ous! ~f f s~rua, .L11aw ~ 'n' iulle~/:':i 4 .l.i, wh,., promised to show him the road to :1-"'Iu,nch. .1h1s he did, accompanying him as far as Nagchela, and Ba-rsu where he introduced him and Surjan Singh to one Sidhu, of whom apparently Surjan Singh had previously.heard. In the course of conversation Surjan Singh stated he liad come from America with others to turn the British out of India, and as ther~ were no restrictions as to arms in Mandi, he had comA there for help. Sidhu agreed to· help, and Surjan Singh replied could make bombs, and asked for guns, swords and men. Sidhu then toid them he would interview one Mian Jawahar Singh, who, we are told, is an e1:-Thanadar, who was not long ago a candidate for the Mandi gaddi, he They returned to Suket, and again visited Nagchela a few days later, i.e., accused himself, Surjan Singh and Sarda Ram. There they met two men named Siddu, who took them on to Barsu, -where they were taken to a cattleshed, and introduced to Mian J awahar Singh and one J awahar. They then proceeded to a baoli,' where lhe revolutionary ruovement was discussed, until Surjan-Singh informed Mian Jawahar Singh he could make bombs, and on the Jatter's requ.e~t to ~ee him make one: Surjan Singh detailed the 4igredients Ilouc~a,.1:.Y fv~ ai bvlllb. l,.. ''I Followin.g upon this Jawahar Singh and Sidhu asked Surjan Singh to bring men from the Doaha, on Reeing whom he, Jawahar Singh, would raise a rebellion in Mandi. Surjan promised to do so, and it was then agreed that a., rebellion shoe.Id be started iu Mandi, the W azir and the British Officer resident there-murdered, the magazine and treasury seized, Mandi and Suket occupied, and a descent made on to the Punjab with ,arms and men to link up with the revolutionists there. Upon this the party dispersed, the accused going to Fattehgarh with _d irections from Surjan Singh to arrange for men with Faza.l Din, ·a ccused ( 8). Fazal Din, accused (8) also stated (p. 119) that after the Ferozeshahr murder, he met Surjan Singh in Fattehgarh, and Surjan told him he was off to ;Mandi to find a refuge there and, stir t1p · residents in the State. He arranged t(? correspond with him and indicate what success he had had. One letter came· showing he ~ad been successfu], and some time after a month or so, Surjan returned , to Fattehgarh, and told him Mian Jawahar Singh and Sidhu Kanait had agreed to supply men, guns and swords, and he, Surjan, was to make three bombs, one to blow a bridge, one tq kill the Wazir_and the British resicen·t, and one-ta lootthe treasury, and also told him that Jawahar Singh had agreed that, -after seizing the State gadd-i, he would descend with his men on the Draba, and help in expelling the British. Surjan al~o asked him' to help and supply men which he declined to do until the rebellion was properly started .in Mandi. · T~e_se pro,cocdings which occupied the. m~nths of December and January are evidence Mt only by the confessions, but by independent evidence. · The principal witness is Sarda Ram, himself no doubt ~n accomplice. , He tells us · (p. 68) that he lives in Bbojpur, though formetly of FattehgMh, and that Nam!'- (14) and Surjan visited him in December 1914 or January 1915. They went aw~y, and on return Surjan told him le had come from America to fight the British, and had been to Mandi and seen Sidhu, as~ing ~im for swords and men, an1 that Sidhu had arrangea for a meeting with M1an Jawahar Singh. , up ..,,. 51 On the following Sunday the witness ac~ompanied Surjan and Nama as far as Nagchela, where they met the two Siddus, who took them to a cattleshed and introduced-him to Mian Jawahar Singh and Jawahar Kanait. They were taken to a more secret spot and there, on Mian Jawahar Singh's enquiries; Surjan asked for arms and men to help the returned emigrants to _expel the :British. ,Tawahar Singh demanded to see ~ome of the returned emigrants and Surjan promised to bring some. Then Surjan described how bombs were made, and asked for ingredients' and it was· finally decided to make bombs, kill the W azir and the British Resident, seize Mandi and Suket and descend on the Punjab . and expel the British. The party then broke up. · Dalip Singh (approver) (p. 71), tells us that in February be heard Surjan Singh tell Amar Singh (1) ~,t the Fattehgarh kilns that bombs were beirig· m·acl~ in , !i!e.udi, tJie \\" a~ir ancl the English Resicle11t th~l~6 w€re to ba killed, the treasury and magazine looted, the place conquered, and men and. arms brought into the PunJab to help the revolutionists. Kundan Lal (p. 61) also tells us he saw Surjan Singh in Bhojpur. about two years ago-that would be December i914. Surjan Singh told him _he had returned from America with 2,000 or 3,000 others to turn the British out of India and seize their country. He gave him a Ghadr-di-Gimj, and asked him to buy arm~, which he refused to do. The next step in the plot is more fully evidenced. We have seen that Surjan Singh had returned to FattehE;arh at the end of January 1915 to arrange for bombs, etc. There is a horse fair held in Hoshiarpur apparently at the end of Febru- The Hoshiarpt) ary. lo 1915 it was held on 19th to 27th. horse fair; :ma:1gin for Nidhan Singh. Fazal Din, ac•;used · (8), ill his oonfossion. stated (p. 120), that, after seeing hirn at Fattehgarh, Surjan Singh vmnt off to Kotla to see .A.mar Singh• .. accused (1), then returned and told him, Fazal Din, to go to the fair and bring .Amar"Singh to him at the kilns where lfazal Din was working, and concealing Surjan Singh ~n a hut near by. Re did so, met Amar Singh (1) and Dalip Singh, approver, and brought,, them both to the kiln. Surjan asked both of them to accompany him to Mandi as bomb-makers were needed, but both declined to go. Surjan asked. Amar Singh to go and fetch Bidhe Singh, w-hnm Amar Singh said he did not know. Faz al Din himself also refused ~o go, and then Amar Singh ~uggested the. famous Nidhan Singh of Chuga (L. C C.), and A.mar Singh and Daiip Singh went off to get hold of N idhan Singh, Surjan going off .to lviandi. , That Fazal Din was working on some kilns at Fattehgarh at this time is corrohorated by .·the evidence of Roda (p. 62) and Ganga Ram (p. 62), and in fact before us 'accused admits th~t fact (p. 116). Arjan, who i~ a broiher of Surjan Singh (F. M.), supports this incident. He tells us (p. 67) he was at the, fair with Jfazal Diµ (8) and Nama (14), wher~ they met Am·ar Singh (1) and Dalip Singh. Accused (8) spoke to them for some 15 minutes hut he did not hear what was said, but accused l8) told him accused (1) had come to see Surjan Singh. ' · ' he Dali p Singh, a pp rover (p. 71) also states that met Amar Singh (1) at the fair, and later came across accused (8), (14) and Arjan there. Arpar Singh and Fa~al Din had a conversation, . and then witness and they w~nt t? th~ kil.n an~ f.~~n~ S~rjan Singh: Surj~n sai~ he had vrepared · a rebelhon m Mandi, and hact d1str1buted the Ghadr-di GunJ . there, and after describin_p' the plot. said .a bomb-mtt.ker was require4 in M ao~i. Amar Singh · suggested Fazal Dm who, however, was ruled out. Amar Smgh himself declihed to go; Surjan Singh suggested· Bidhe Siugh, whom Amar Singh did not know, and eventually Amar Singh said he would ~end for Nidban Singh (L. • C. C.) to arrange. Therc1tpon the party broke up. 0 52 It is to be notecl that Nama (14) does not mention being at the fair in his confession, and before us denies 1-::.wing gone there at all. A.mar Sin(J'h has admitted bein()" there ancl has pro.lucecl several witnesses to prove all was doing there trying to seli a horse, and his defence will be considered in its proper place. 8 Singh' s The next inrnortant step is the actual coming of Nidhan Singh and hi proceeding to :Mandi. ?fama, accused (lt), (p. 115) stated in his magisterial confe~sio!1 that Dalip Singh came with Nidhan Singh--this is probably in the begmrnng of 1 March 1915-to Fattehgarh, and :Eazal Din (8) asked h im t o n.ccompa1:y thP-m to point out the road to Mandi. He declinetl to go and eventually Ar3an was sent. he "v~s I Fazal Bin {p. 120) }11 h~6 w~J:s~~:~.:.~: 5!9.~~!TI'!;-~ t;_ .~tR.t.Pt1 th~1t ·som~ 10 d.ay~ after Amur Singh and Dalip Singh had gone off to find Nidhan Singh, Nidhan Singh turned up in Fattehgarh with Dalip Singh, and asked him to write to Surjan, who was in Mandi with the addrnss of Piara Lal~ son of Kundan Lal, Suket, to return. T iiis he did, but a reply came to the effl::'ct that he could not return, and asking himj Fazal Din, to bring the two men to Mandi. He, however, asirnd Nama to do ~o, aud Nama declined, and eventually Arjan was despa.tcheq. with them, Nidhan Singh giving him R2. Arjan, he stated, retiirned after five or six days, saying he had failed to find Sprjan, and had left Nidhan Singh and Dalip Singh in Maudi. · Dalip Singh (p. 71) states that while at Anandpur he met Nirlhan Singh, who told him he had hea ed all about the Mandi plot from Amar Singh, and asked him to ta,ke him fa Surjan. 'fhey journeyed. together to Fattehgarh du Tiua. and Q..,..,nn,:,,mol Qnrl "t.VPnt. to "F;:i1,al Din's kiln where thev found Sur~~.n had gone r~que~ Faza•l Din wro.,te asking to return, but a reply camt, that he would not do so, and asking Fazal Din to 1 take, witness and Nidhan Singh to Mandi. } azal Din and then N ama declined to accompany them. and then Arjan was induced to join them at Malahat to take them on. They proceeded •via Laltani, Sir Khad and Gh~tapatri where they tell,lporarily separated. t;S,.;l;~t·.'~~At-Nidh;~~s{~gh;~ ~urncy to ·hi~ ' A ,-4-' They met again at Nag • .Arjan· re r orthg be had failed to find Surjan, but promised to go to Suket. Thjs he djd. Nidhan Singh and witness going to ¥andi. Eventua1ly they got to Suket~ where they found Surjan in th,e µouse of one Landhu, but tliey do not appear to have come acroi:,s Arjan again. It is necessary, before proceeding further and showing what took place thereafter, to refer to Arjan Singh's statement conoborating this journey, and the oth~r corroborative evidence. Arjan (p. 67) teHs us Dalip Singh and Nidhan Singh came together to the Fattehgarh · ~il:µ, ~nd Fazal Din took him and Nama to meet them in a Choh. ' , • Nama. Wj:lS af3ked to tal<~ the v~sitors to Mandi but he refused, and h~, ~rjan, con~ented to do /,O. ou hf:d:og pa~d R2 by l\ idhan Singh. He describP.s meeting them at lfalahat, proceeding via Laltani, Sirkhad aµd Ghatapatri where th~y separated: ,He himself went to Suket and Bhojpur, and eventm,Jly found Su,rjad at M~la Ram's in Suket, and told him two men .were looking tor him. He in the meantime had lost trace of them and. so returned to Hoshfar .. Jmr~· Kundan Lal (p. 61) state$ that, when Surjan returned to Mandi, h~ ~sked him take in Jetters for him addresstd to Piara Ram. Two postcards came ·from one Fazal Din of Hoshiarpur. to Sometimes after Dalip Singh and an elderly Sikh came and asked wh~re S"q.rjau wa~ :i\nd ·h~ •told them he had g9ne to Daher'. J I II~ l We came next to what this party did in Mandi. Nidhan Singh Our principal witness is Dn,lip Singh (p . 72). At Landbu's house, where Mau5), found ultimately with accused .<(4), giving certain dates .which in. part supports his statement, and the CrQwn / ,, P!OEl~~utiol} wit_n~sse~ Bela·Singh {p. _24) ·~nd,; At~ Singh (p. 36) also tell us tlutt ,_: accusedleft ·Canada m 1913 .on a deput,at1011 . . .. . .· Arrived in - lndia, we h&venvevidence 'for the CJ;"OWn .as to what .accused -'.- qid ~utsid~ Lahore. · '·:; : A ,~d· t~µs, -,~hjt he ..~~ certain; gentlemen in '.Bombayt whieh is p1;9~,~]Y·-~~f!',, ~ ;~u~~~e p~hor~ :h~.~W ijarda,r S.und_~ Singh, .Majithia, in. ,_a I • r: I :us ) I i' meeting convened at Amritsar to hear the 3 Canadian delegates. Sardar Bun• ~iar Singh (p. 206) states that at that mee~ing accused did not speak, and there was nothing objActionable in anything saiu. by his fellow-delegates. Everyone is agreed that accused was in Lab.ore in August 1914, and that a big meeting was held in the Bradlaugh Hall on the ·18th August. We have discussed that meeting- in the section dealing with Canada in detail, and it is hardly necessary to discuss it further. The meeting, we consider, became .excitable and some unwise things 'l. were said which had better have been left unsaid, and the_atmosphere created -0ould only result in - making people believe that there· was a good deal of , ·hostility 'towards Government on the subjecL The meeting was not unconstitutional or illegitimate, hut its tone in part was regrettable; and it accepted blindJy as foot.8 whateyer the delegates said. However. what we have to· consider here is accu11ed's part. He admittedlv Q'ave a sneech. That s.peech is not reported in the Tribune, which we been asked by accuse·d to peruse. - ha;e We have, however, ~ summary repor.t made by Lala Chmii Lal (p. 20). That report (p. 3) contains among other things & parable, which ,states that the. .way to deal with a snake coiled r01md you is to rub its head against thorns . .The metaphor in its context is clear in its application. It can only show, if true, that the idea of forcible resistance and retalia,tion is present in the mind of the speaker. ' The question is, did the accused use that parable ?-he denies he did; an4, two gentlemen, S. Sewa Ram Singh (p. 189)- and S. Mehr Singh, Chaw\a (p~ 188), who were present at the meeting and are witnesses for the defence~ have no recollection of it. .On the other hand, Mr. Jalal-ud-din, also a witness for the defence (p. 22;>), recollects that in th-e !§peech of' one of the ·d~legat~ who spoke i.n ·Punjabi (and accused did speak in Punjabi) there was something ,disa,gree~,b,le by way of : a story, ·the purport of ·which he cannot remember~ Lah;\ Chuni LaJ, who ia _the Senior Reader, Government Press, swea.rs to- the ,accuracy of his report. He.sent in . a prcliminary r,eport (p., 9) on the 19th August to Mr. Gray, Inspeetor, which dismisses Balwant Singh's- speech :in 3 lines and d,oes net mention the snake story, Qut promises a more detailed account later. Thie mor,e detailed 'report {p. 3), which gives a lengthy sum;. mary of accused's speech, cont~ining the snake story, was received .b y Inspector -Gray (p. 19) on 2bt August 1915,. and hllS been in pouession Qf the police ever since. · ' t " "· ' '.i '~ - ' ,l___ l .I It is n.o t suggested that Chuni Lal is or ever was liostile to acc11sed:, and .the report was not furnished with any view to a proseoutfon, _b-qt simply to kee2 the Police informed of wha.t w~ going on, -~nd · we cap: see nQ ~ n t9 _ believe it is a fabrication; . · . .' There is another incident 'in regard to the accused's stay i~ '1'ahore/of which evidence is given by Jogindra Singh (p. 19). , He staies he met accused iµ Lahore in 1913 · and aQlet, translated also intQ ,G urmukh1, mserted 1n: 1t, whwh :runs" When all other plans fail, it is right to have recourse to the sword.;' . Accused dP.nies that is in his handwriting ; but it is his book, and we are satisfied that that is a corr~ct epitome of accused's attitude. , We entertain no doubt that accused has associated himself with the G~ad1• .~arty, and t4at he has ac~i vely al>etted the . wag~ng of war . by ad vising and urgmg :µien to l'eturn to India for Ghadt, and that m consequence thereof J}len have returned for, that purpose. It is not necessary to record any further .finding. We have in aocµsed one of the ·rin.gleadors of mutiny in Canada, a · man. who ~y his position there has drawn others to crime, to tnutinfand ·murder. He.is one of tl):e chief instigators, aILd he deserves; noJess a punishment · tlup:i thos~ ,who have obeye4 his behests~ , ,· 1 . __, ,;,~ We find accused guilty-under sections 121, 12h.A., Indian· Penal Cod~; a,nd sentpnc~ him to~b.e hanged by:- the 'nee~ until' he is dead, ,an4· we further . direct that alt bis property, liable to COJ:!.Q.scatioI!-;he forfeit~d to .the Orown. · -' 68 Battan Singh, accused (4). This accused is also a Canadian returned emigrant . The allegations against him in the complaint will be found on pp. 9 to 13 of the re~ord; and the charges on pp. 148-49. He ·is charged with having wa~ed war, or al')etted or attempted th0 waging of war in Victoria in ~913-14, in Vancouver in 1911 and 19h and in Honolulu in January 1915, and also as a conspirntor with responsibility foe acts committed by other conspirators in pursuance of such conspiracy. The· :-teoused has plea~ed "Not Guilty'' to the charges. , .Accused appears .· to have gone to Canada in 1006, ar.d to have le.ft that c?untry in the conipanyJf . of accused (3) and (11) in December 1914 on the Nippon Maru as far as Shanghai, and to have a:rrived in Colombo qn a 1\!Iessageries boat on . 14th March U,15·, being al'rested in Ludhian~ on 25th March 1915, and interned at once. l;[e was identified on ji1il parade on 26th Octcjber 1913 hy name by ''.Beia., . Singh, 'Mangal Singh and Amar Singh, and pointed cut, though net named, hy A fo. ~ingh ~nil -;::r !'l't'~lrnl'~Tl n~Q. The identifications arA not objected to except in the case of Harcharan Das, who, it is alleged, knew accused by reason of having been intnned. with him for sometime in Campbellpur Jail. It is true thrv were both interned there1 and· quite pos~ible that ·witness saw him there, but that does not necesssrily establish that witness is falsely accusing him. The first matter allegey Bhagwan Singh, and along with others spoke, urging it was useless . to stay· in Canada, and they should return to India for mutiny. also says he ~ . 'was active in distributing the Ghadr. He also alleges accused was the composer oft~e Ko'lra Ohhand, a very virulent song .which appeared in the Ghadr-di- He Gunj_~. . . · _; Mangat , Singh (p. 27) also connects him witJi Bhagwan Singh, and ~~atel:l ·_that· ~ccused, among others, undertook to do :what Bhagwan Singh· wanted: viz., go to India to close that country to the British, and also that he busied him,self in distributing the Ghadr . .A.mar Singh (p. 29) also alleges that accused t ook part in distributing the Ghad1·, and gave seditious lectures in the gurdwa1·a, saying Government was oppressive and should be put down. Harcharn Das does not mention him at this period, and Ata Singh does not refer to him throughout his statement-sure]y a mal'ked proof that there has been no collusion of witnesses. --~ , From the return of Balwant Singh .to Canada the activities of accused increase. Rugnath Singh does not. mention , him, the only accu~d he speaks of at all are accused (3) or (11.). · Bela Singh states accused became a member of the Shore Committee, and, though he is the witness who is alleged to have engineered,. -the case against accused, does not attempt to implicate him further. Accused was in the gurdwara when Bhag Singh was shot and was injured: probably by Bela Singh in the fracas, and he was arrested on st1spicion but released in connection with the murder of Mr. Hopkmson. l I Amar Singh (p. 29) says that when accused (3) arrived, this accused met him at Victoria with others and was present at the inflammatory meeting in the gurdwara, but he doesn't accuse him of lecturing, and he is? he admits, a friend of the accused's. It is iirMangal Singh's and Harcharn Das' evidence we get serious alle~ gations again~t him and these men certainly have had no chance of collusion. ) - ~,. Mango.I Singh states he spoke in the Vancouver Hall meeting of 31st May, and when war broke out he was one of those who advised returning to India to loot treasuries and start a rAvolutfon ; accused, he says, took him to that meeting and he l'eported his attendance ·and speaking to the immigration authorities. Harcharn Das (p. 30) includes him in the .members of the Shore Committee, and as one of the speakers in the Dominion ·Hall meeting, as one ofthe persons who, on the outbreak of war, stirred up India.ns to return to India to seduce troops and start a rebellion; and as one of those who openly advocated the murder of Mr. Reid, Mrs Hopkinson and Bela Singh. • . ;, Before to aching on the defence evidence as to · this period we may note that, already stated, beine a member-of t4e Shore Committee is not, on the evidence before us, a fact to use against any accused, and an arrest on suspicion· . of murdering }Ir. Hopkinsop., followed ·by discharge, goes no further than · to establish that the Canadian authorities iooked . upon hirri as one of the dangerous men in the place. As regard.s the Kolra Ohhand being · composed by him we are not prepared to hold that that is established. · . ·. .· as It rests on Bela · Singh's testimony only, and though · we, do . not say that ..Bela Singh is not to be b(3lieved on this point, w~ think, \ll view of the possibility of hostility arising out of the gurdwa1!afracas; that we should not rely exclusive]y on his testjmo1,J.y, against the accused. . In regard to the other matters, 'Viz., a general seditious . ~ctivity, distribution of the Gh.adr, lecturing in the Dominion Hall, and urging, a return to , India. for re~ellion.\ when war ..broke· out, accused in his written Md oral state• ments (pp . . 2~}- and .;]1) denies, ..all the allegations. His wri~ten stateniaht confa.in~ iong ttrelevant account . of his wor}c in connectio.n with 8'·-school in Capa.da, and the agitation in 1911 to get won;ien and children admitted Canada, and a matter we have already dealt with, vi:., ·that accused opposed B~l:;t .Singh in an alleged •·attempt-of. the latter t:O land,,.undeeirablefindians in Yancouver, and an account of the gurdwara fracas. His witnesses 26, ·27, 36, 30, 45, 4,7, 50, ~t, 52, 81,·86, .9 1, all say he took no part in se.di.tiouM activities ip. -Oan~da, but then they say there were no such.activities by any one; P . .W.114, the to 70 Roshiarpur murderer, i!il cross-examined to say that accused opposed Bela. . Singh in trying to land Bhagwan Singh. 36 says tia~se two were ene:mies. 4 7 · does not know whether they were or not, and witness 32 only saw him in the streets. In pt•oducing witness 63, accused produced one too many. He says he saw him in the Dominion Hall meeting;-and thereby corroborates the prosecution evidence,-but he did not speak seditiously. 'I'his evidence does not destroy the evidence for the Crown, and it is a very strong point that it is not the evidence, which acc.used's counsel asks us to consider tainted, which is th~ strongest against the accused, but evidence against which nothing valid can be alleged. · · The case again.st accused does not rest here. · He admittedly left Vancouver on the Bame shir, as and. in the compant of accuseu. (3) anti (11) going via Trisce to Shanghai,-in hjs written statement accused gives an irrelevant account of the steamers he went on. Going on .ihe same ship is of course nothing, but both Bawa -Singh and Khazan Singh (p. 38) allege he backed accused · (3) up when th6 latter at tempted to seduce them outside Honolulu to Ghadr, though we must point out the8e witnesses have not identified him. That he was a close intimate of the accused (3) is proved by two further facts. x ,,,. P. 11, the authorship of , which accused admits, consists of two letters: in which accused appeals to other Indians for funds to help Balwant Singh and his family during the farmer's detention in connection with Mr. Hopkinson's murder. · 'fhey are not seditious, but they sho\V a close connection between the two accused . . The other fact is, that accu~ed bronght Ralwant Singh's wife end family to India ,from Shanghai, and when arrested was in possession _of 'P . 65-accused (3)'s pocket book with the sedttious couplet in. 0 What was accused's purpose in coming home ?-he says work was getting.sJack, that he had become ill owing to -his injury in the melee at the gurdwara, and because his parents would not send his wife and children to Canada, and he got letters to go ho~e. No supporting evid.ence has 'been produced; the different reasons are somewhat at variance with eac~ other, and the fapt remains that there is no explanation as to the company he was keeping, and Jiis close association with accused (8). \ On. a consideration of the evidence we are of opinion that it is es• t~blished that a9oused did •take part in urging and organizing a return to India for mutiny, in co~~equence of which: peop}e did return, and that he himself probably returned for the same purpose, but was- interned in India before he could do a.ny damage. · · 0 1 ., n'I TIT fi a· h" ' · a·. . t'. ., " T , • . ,,, • ,. .. ~ 1t . ne n _·. 1m. gu.11 y uner see .wns .1."', .1.~.1-11., .rnman . rena1 uooe; and !lentep.ce him to transportation •for lifo, and direct that his property, liable to confiscation, be forfeited to the . Crown. · · F.indings on the other charges are ~nnecessary. Bishan Singh, ~ccused (s)~ · . . . I , This aocuse4 is also a returned Canadian emigrant. The allegation• ~gainst him in tpe complaint wi11 be found on pp. 9 and 18, a·nd the charge on 'V· 150 ·of the record. He is charged with .waging war or abetment of or attempt to wage):v.ar i:n Vancouver hi 1913-14, and · in M~rhana i'.n 1914, and as conspirator wit:q. respon:ibility for acts of other CO!•conspitators. . a to. • .•_·.· ·-A:cc.used ·has ·. :Plead~.d ' ·Not Gu~lty.' the charges. ·He was .identified on ·1ail po.rade qn 8th November 1916 ·by Bela. Singh and Amar Singh, and Mangal Sin.gh..pointed oµt accused (15) ·as Bishan Singh. , _J 71 There is no clear evidence as to when this accused left Canada. Mr. Siattery informs us that t.he police · do not know. His arriva.1 in his village was reported on 26th September 1914, and he was restricted in October 1915. 'l'he compl_aint states he was interne_d in October 1914. He was in Canada from 1906, and he states he left there on 7th ,July 1914, coming home i,ia Quebec, London and Bombay, was arrested in November 1914, and interned in Campbellpur, was released in August 1916 and re-arrested in October 1916. T As regards his return to India, D. W. 41 says he left before the Koma{iflta JJfar u; D. W. 21 of his village says he was said to have come on the X Komagata Maru, but his name does not appear in the Koraagata Maru list of pass,engers~ and Amar Singh says he returned about a week before war broke out. W e are not, therefore, in a position to say positively when or how he returned . ~, .As regards his alleged activities in Canada there are two w'itnesse~ only. \ -~ __l . Beia Singh (p. 24) says he was a supporter of the San.sar, that he attended some of Bhagwan Singh's meetings in Hf13, and spoke a urging·return to India for mutiny, distributed the Ghadr, and spoke in the Dominion Hall on 31st May 1914, 'urging a l'eturn for rebellion. · Amar-Singh {p: 29) says he was one of t~~se who mat , Balwant Singh at Victoria, that he distributed Ghadrs in 1913, and spoke seditiously about the same time in the gurdwara.; presiding at one meeting. There is no further evidence against him in Canada. He denies all these allegations, and in his written statement (p. 213 J gives a long account of enmity with Bela, Singh about a shop in Victoria and frequent fights between him and th~ witness. . D. Ws. 14, 22, 24, .25 and 41 support hi@ in his alle5 ~d. disputes with Bt:la Singh and assert he never spo_k e seditiously. · _ We have already dealt" with his quarrels with Bela Singh; in our section dealing with Canada. Bela Si:r;igh has .admitted before us that he reported this accused was the instigator of assaults upon him, and though we are not prepared to say that Bela Singh 'has in consequence falsely implicated this accused, we must see that Bela Singh is corroborated before acting on his evidence. . That he is not-Arna~ Singh speaks to quite different matte~ and the only thing· they support. each other in is in the distribution of Gk~dr • . 'where · the sole evidence, therefore, consists of witness testifying to different actions and · there is a possibility of one of them -being influenced by -prior disputes, it would be unsafe to convict thereon. . The only other ,evidence against accused (8) is that he spoke seditiously in )Iarhana on his return. _ Sur3:in Singh and Bhola Singh (p. 35) both say so~ -~oth of these witnesses, however, belong to an op.posite factio~ in the village, ·and that there are -factions, in which bitterness: runs high, and .that there is enmity between · the witnesRes ana accused's family is proved beyond qc.es• t.ion by witnesses D. 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 21, · 2'3 and 25. Wa need not give the details of this ~:nmity, for we are satisfied that it is sufficient to discredit the two witnesses. ' · As to why accused came home we have · nothing from )Vhioh we can draw an adverse in~erence. · Accused says he : ran away from Canada, as he owed a lot of money~ and in this he is supported by -D • .Ws. 14, 22 and 41. We d~111egatitot1t1r1g~1J:t~t hirti i_n the ,cotn,plai_n t :will_be found :,On pp_ . 9~13~ , .,_, ua .un-- T ' __. . ---- He is chargeJ with offences under sections 121, 121 A~ by virtue of· acts OQJJUnitted • in. Vfotor~ in. 1'9l3: a.n.d "Vancouver in 1914:J and also· with responsibility; as a conspirator fvr acts. of his co-conspirators. The accused baa pleaded' '": Not ·GuiUt ,,, to the charges framed. ']I( I I I Mr. Slattery tells ua th~re is no clear evidence as to when this accused returned. .A.ccusedsays he returned. home by an unknown ship in January 1915, was direoted to· go home, and was arrested in August 1915. Inspector !kram""ul-Haqq tells us his house was searched on certain, information given .by Bachan Singh (approver), and iq. consequence of discoveries then ·made w,as.interned. _ He wasjdentifi.ed' on Jail parade on 26th Octobep 1916 by Bela Singh alone~ Th~t witness atates:{p., 2~); that ag,cused was an opfonent of the Honduras transfer proposals in 1908; and a supporter of the-Sa-near in 1913'; facts which, if true, were not necessarily criminal, as we have already held in other ca,$es. . .Ele,also-;!St.a~,he!waitone of· the speakers in the Dominion Hall on 31st Ma,1914. . · 1 The only othei witness against· him:ia Harcharan Das,1 who .has not iden• . tif!ed' him. He states (p.p. 30.-31)' that .accusedlwas .one ,of' those actively, engaged on the outbraak ot w.a-c · in~stirring · people up to go to·India for revolution and seduction ()f. troops,, and furthen -that ha was one .of ·.those who-openl1· advooat• ' ed the murder of Mr. Reid, Mr. Hopkinson and Bela Singh. · · 1 In.speotor Ikram-11l-&4.q, filll~>us1_ the,; first : description h43 had of .h.im was as Diyal Singh, .Chikka, from -Bela Singh, Atta Singh,_Mangal Singh and &?ohaia.ndas.. ••·Ohikka1" is.& term applied: to,a man' with- a twisted beard, . and thi~ acouse()ssiblv on this evidence dou.bfinspector Aziz-ud-din and we are fully satisfied p. i2 w~,s found among accused's papers. This is a Gu:rmu'khi ;erse of a seditious nature. It complains of increased revenue, and of- the King being a tyrant, urges tho establishment of · separate.panalwyats ,to boycott the courts, arid the prepa.ring of a flag of tb.:eir own : speaks of ditihm lty 111 ~etUn~ . foo1 + a!!.tl ieys -tho ·f.k,,~Tuwe.u~ has suoked all the biood out of India, an interestin.?e feat in which bankers and pieaders are also said to, be indulging. .., This document shows clearly the state of accused's mind and strengthens th.e Canadian evidence as to his revolutionary . work \there,-but inasmuch as we have not relied ·o n this ~n1idence against acc-tu:ed Dali_p Singh, we can• not consistently rely on it against this accused~ This leaves on the posses"' sion of seditious literature clearly proved against him, but the possession of seditious literature is not . in itself a criminal offence, thought we consider the Legislature would be well advised to make such possession an offence, just as possession of -counterfeit coin i~. We think acoused is probably a dangerous man, but there is insufficient to convict him on and we accorciingl"t acquit him. ., 'Hari Singh, accused (9). This a~used is,also-a Canadian returned emigrant, who was admittedly, for some time Granthi, of the Victoria Gurdu,ara in April and Ma'y 1914. · The allegations in'the complaint aga\nst him will be found ,on pp. 9: 41 of the record, the charges on pp~154 et Beq. lie is charged }Vi.th offences under sections 121, 121 AJ with respect to his acts in Victoria inl914 and-Vancouver in 1913-14, and with responsibility f~r acts committed by his co-conspirators. _ O Accused pleads " Not guilty to the charges. He was identified on jail paiade by Bela Singh, Mangal Singh, Am...t Singh and Har Oharan Das ~by name., and by Ata Singh by sight. , Accused appears to have 'gone to Canada in 1907, and to have left tha.t country by the Sangoko Maru, staying a short time en route at Shanghai, reaching C8Jcu.tta on the the %Bhr; Mw·nleseeond voyage on 17th January 1915, being restricted to his village ~n. arrival, and arrested in August 1916. · . There is a considerable amount of evidence in .regard to . his activities in Oanada, but none with regard to him in India, and consequently we need not - consider D. Ws. 68, 69, and 73, who say he was quite quiet at home: The first evidence we have in regard to him relates to 1913. · Amar Singh (p. 29), says he was busy at that time distributing the Gkadr, speaking at meetjngs also, advising the suppression of the British · f,overnment and presiding at lea~t at one of them. - Ma:ngal Singh .(p. 27) says he was supporter of Baghwan Singh, Grantki, a and promised to act as. he desired, vii., return to India to drive the British out. .·· 1 · In 1914, Amar Singh (p. 2~) says he was one of those who met Balwant Singh on his return, when ther~ was the. big,meeting in Victoria Gurdwara, of which ~ccus,ed w~ then Grantki, and in .which Balwant Singh made a violent , revolutionary speech. · ·· I · · ,/ - · · "' I ; y ) '75 !,fangal Singh (p. 28) states he attended the meeting held by Ba.lwant Singh in Vancouver on -his _arrival, when a similar violent speech was delivered, and that, on the return of the Komagata Maru, accused wa~ active in advising a return to India to loot treasuries and start a :revolution. Bela Singh (n. 25) asserts h.e s.ddr0g~ed the Domin~ion Hall meeting cf 31st May-the nature' of which we have already seen, and with reference to this meeting Harcharan Das (p. 30) states he recited a seditious poem entitled " Wake up. vou sleenin!:!' lions," which is the burden of more than one of the Ghadr·-di-£Guni song~. u Ata Singh (p. 36) alleges that on the outbreak of war he was one of those who' advocated a return to India to help the Germans, start war, commit dacoities, and expel the British. Accused denies these 8!11egations, and says in his oral statement he returned to India soleiy because his brother and wiie had died of plague; and he got letters recaliing him. In his written statements he adds another reason, viz., th:lt the y·w,-d·~v:•A/i-Ui w~ ~:..;. Jttt. , He ·makes no allegation against any witness. D. Ws. 27, 29, 32, 64 .A, and 72 say he _was not seditious in Canada; no one is produced to prove his supposed reason for returning; but one of his own witnesseo, D. W. 63~ asserts he was in the Dominion Hall meeting, though he did not speak. Bia written statement contains nothing in addition to what has been mentioned abovereltiYant to tho case. _ We have digcussed elsewhere tha reasons we have for generally believing .the Canadian witnesses ; in this particular case no hint of enmity is given, and accused, as a granthi, must have been known· to most of the witnesses. This evidence conclusively proves accuse«: took part in seditious pro,. pa.g~nda in Canada, was present at the Dominion Hall meeting and· ad voeated , rebellion i~ India. , -. No adequate reason is proved why ac-eused should return when war had broken out. - We find acuused guilty under section 121, 121 =4., but in view' of the fact that he was quiet on his return, we do not think .the supreme penalty ii called for. We sentence accused to trans-porta~ion fof life, and direct that his _pro• perty, Hable to co:n.fi:;cation, be fm-feiteil to Gove:r:ume:nt. Jita Singh, accused (rn)!' y The allegations in the complaint against him will be found .on pages 9, 14 of the record, and the charges on pages 156-157. Ile is charged with offences under _section 121, 121-A., in respect to his acts in Victoria in 1913-14, and also in Vancouver in the same yea...-ns. and further with: respo·nsibiiiiy for acts committed by co-conspirators in the course of the conspiracy. Accused pleads" Not Gui]ty "to the charges. ·The accused was identified .on jail p~rade on 26th October 1916, by Amar Singh I, Bela Singh, Amar Singh of Barian aind Harchn.rn Das, against the latter of whom it is contended that ha was interned with him in Campbellpur jaH and hP,nce knows him. The accused appears to have gone to Canada in i906-07, ana to have . , sailed on the Canada Maru, ~hat is the same ship as Sher Singh (L. C. 0.) trans-shipping to the Tosha Maru at Hong-Kong, arriving in India on 29th October 19141 and being immediat~ly interned. . / Amar. Singh· I merely ide~tities him f.\S a passenger on the foaha 1Jlq,ri1. Bela Singh {p. 24) says he was a. 6uppo:rwr of the StJ/ii,Bwr; tA, fact fa itself not oritni.nal, and that he attended some of Bhagwan Si:n.gh's revolutionary Il;leetings, speaking and urging a -return for mutiny and distributing the Ghadr. AmaT Singh (p. 29) only says that accused was one of those who met Bal.want Singh at Victoria on his rntum from India in May 191'.i,. Harch~ran Das (p. 30) say, that on the outbreak of Yvar accu~ed occupied himself with others in stirring up people to return to India for rebellion, and ad-vised onenly the murder of l\li r. Reid. lvlr. Hopkinson and Bela Singh the latter being an unprobable story, as Mr. Hopkinson was not murdered till s9me, time after accused had left for .India. Accused denieg all these allegations and says he was not in Vancouver in.1918, and further. states he returned to India as his family had. written asking him to return~ His,writteri' statement (p. 218) adds nothing of importance to his oral statement. His witnesses D. Ws. 26 and 32 are of no assistance; D. Ws. 27, 29, 36, ,3:i''~ 48, 49, 53, 54, 69 ancl 60 say he was not seditious, and. many assert he was never- in Vancouver at the .time he is.alleged to have been there. In regard to· his .I'.eason for return D. W. 48 asserts letters were rooei'y-ed ftom India, and D. Ws. 46 and 55, father of accm:ed and lmnbardar, respec .. tively, testify to letters being sent. Lett-ers D. 1, 2, wrltten by aocused iu October mu and February 1912, are produced which show acoused is replpJ>g 1:4) 1,etter~ .asking to CQlll~ home and ~romi&ing to .do:so shortly. hjr.n N'o reason, is .assigned by ·the accused. why any•of the . prosecution evidence shouhl ·btt-disbeiieved ; but it is clear that · Haroharn Das · has made a , mistake iitone particu}ii,r ~nd, _thJt 3· witnes~ . whQ depose , against him refer to"widelv ~ ~ra~d inc~deJ1ta,. e~chi deposing tp that. one ihci~~nt alone. • We are pot prepared to say. this evidence is untrue,- but we feel that ther~ iac a, da:qger, i.p actj;ng on witn~sse$-. ~pt dir,e otly supporting ®.ch otl:ier1 especially as there is a ,corisiderable amount of evidence to the affect q.0c~ w~ elsewhere than aUhe plaoes he is alleged to ,have •been. W:e; give him th,thenefit.- ofth(tdoubtand.acq:u.it. him. "' Kartar. Singh, a~cused (11). to This accused is one ()f the Canadian accused, who is alleged have taken a fairly prominent part in the revolutionary .moveJllent there~ · The allegations against him in the complaint will be found on pages 9, 14 of the record: and the charges on p~ges 158-159. He is · ohar,ged with havill:g w~~~d war, and &betting and attempting to wage war m Jan.couver i:n hnl, 1913 and 1914; at San Francisco in Dooe~ber:_1914 ~nd Ho~ol?lu . in 1915s a~~ ~s, a o~~spirator '!ith bei_ng responMble· for,a s~nes: of cr1mmal acts comm11iLeu oy otner conspirators in the pm.-g~ft,cf- eu.ch: corepiracy. The ~cused pleads " Not Guilty " to -all charges. , Tl:J~:aqe~~d,appeardo have,gone to Canada . in 1907, and to have left V~couy,e~J,u, ,t~t:t cornpa.ny· of accu,sed (8) , ~nd .(~) in J?eo~mb~r 1914, arrivh1g at .Ita~9~Jt~ocli; on.th~ •l ,8 th ~arch 1916, bemg 1~eas who, acc .. · um.:•· ~us~" i!r·ai.b,le." , t!>... icle.ntify ~ inasmuch ashe wa.~ intern.ed in Camp- · bellpuf ~lF\vith"l;lim~ T 77 That they were internerl together is undoubtedly a fact, and it is not improbable that witness saw him there, but this would not necessru-ily make his evidence unworthy of credit. The general grounds on which we believe the Canadian witnesses are reliable and the contentions urged ag-ainst thern have already been considered by us in the section dealing with the revolutionists in Canada, and there is no necessity for us to repeat that matter again. The first point in evid ence ~g•ajmt accused relates to the proposed ~ Honduras transfer in 1908. Bela Sirgh (p. 24) aE-serfa that accused opposed it, and was one of those who urged a return to India then for m o.tiny; if the transfer was tt:ffected by forca. We have already dealt with this episod_e in the individual case of Balwant Singh (J), and mutatis rmutandis our remarks in regard to it apply in this case also. We are not prepared to hold that the opposition to this transfer developed then into anything criminBJ: or that it it.clearly proved th._;,t accuse(l ihen advocated mutiny. \ We have seeu that eariy in 191~f Bal want Singh (3) and Bagh Singh, Granthi, made an effort to get their families into Canada and that they were allowed to do so after some difficulty. _We also have heid in Bal want Singh's ~asc that this probably led to considerable soreness, .hut we ' were not prepared to hold that that soreness had developed then into anything criminal. Bela Singh (p. 24) asserts 'that at · that time accused (11) and others urged that if children in India were not allowed to land they should return to their own country and expel the British . 1 )L. ... ~ .. f .,..~_ .Amar Singh (p. 29) a5serts that about this. time accused was actjvely engaged jn this work, i.e., in revolutionary work. Accused denies doing so, and hi~ witnesss Bhola Singh _(p. 230), who says he lived with him in 1912, denies he was engaged in sedition. ~ Fo~ the reasons we have given in Balwant Singhrs case, though we think it probable that all Indians were very excited and sore on the question of exclusion, we are not prepare~ on the evidence before us, to hold -it is proved that any ciear policy of criminal force or mutiny had yet been adopted by accused. We have already seen that in 1912·13· a news pa per ca.lled the Sansar. was published in Vancouver ; its general character we have discussed else- where. "Bela Singh (p. 24) states that one of its active supporters was this accused, and Amar Singh (p. 29) supports him, stating accused was engaged in collecting subsctip_tions for it. T Accused on p .. 144 _of his oral statement denies assisting in the production of the paper; and produces D. Ws. 36, 89, 96, 98 and 100 "to support this denial in a general way.. . He may possibly have been a supporter and a subscriber to the paper, but it is not asserted he was a contrib11tQr or worker c_::1 the ptesss and even ii it be accepted that he did encourage the paper, that can hardly be held a criminal act. The articles in that paper are not themselves criminal; they are sometimes objectionable in tone, bu.t crime is nowhere advocated and by merely subscribing to such a paper, or supporting it, cannot make accused criminally responsible. ,. · ' The real ·case aga,inst acm1sed begins in 1913.·, In tpat year, as we have already seen, Baagwan Singh, Granthi,. arrived in Canada, and began a most virulent anti.•British campaign, advocating mutiny in unmistakeable terms, and the Ghadr newspaper began to flow into Canada.; · ..,. ·Bela Singh (p. 25) asserts that accused (11) and others used _to attend these me~tings of, Bhagwan Singh's and speak in· them, ·urging that it wa~ us~ less to stay in Canada longer, and thaflt was time to go to Indfa for lllUtiny~ lie also asserts that the accused was active in distributing the· Ghadr. •18 MEtngal Singh (p. 27) gives similar evidence. He states that a,ccused adopted Bhagwan Singh'~ attitude _a~ his own.; ~nd defi.ni~ely undertook to go to India, to help in expellmg the Br1t1sh and seizmg the raJ there. Ata Singh (p. 36) statBs that at this period a?cused was engag~d _in sedi: tious propaganda, with others in the gu,,·dwcira, u~gm7 a return to [ndrn to ~xpel the British; and that, whi.le Bha~wan Singh was u1 Ganacla; _acc~lsed _ass?ma~ed with him :in leoturing. He alsD states that accused was active m chstnbutrng the Ghadr, and he also asserts that, on Bbagwan Singh's deportation, accused ~dvocated in a meAtinfl' · the forcible rnscue of the deportee; ~,nd Har~haran Das. (p 37) reme7nbers him in particular as one of the active speakers~ on sedition at this stage. . This C,\:ideiI<.::e, ,v-;t.k,h ~"' J,rc; net pl'E:,P.;?~:d tc dfa~eEe~s fo~ :reasons alreE.Ll Din was not present at the time of the murders; and was only repeating from memory what Babu Ram :wd Nama h3,d told hi.::rL 'rl1e1'G is therefore ampie evidence to show that both the accused took . part in the murders at :Misriwala, which were, 11s was held bv the Commissioners in the Lahore supplementary conspiracy case, committed in pursuance of rev-oln• tionary designs. How they were induced to identify themselves with the revohi.tionary progra.mmA ;p, t.olrt 111. in thP.h ~onfAssionR. They are both natives of l\tfauza Fattehgarh in the Hoshianmr District. whence Suri an also hailed . The latter returned to hi.s village from~ America about 3.½ years ago, and Babu Ram,. hearing of his return, hastened from the brick kiln of Ganga Ram (66), where he was working, to meet him. Smjan in the course of conversation told him that some 2,000 or 3,000 men including himself ·had rebeHed against the British Government, and bad determined to expel the British from India, having sufficient arms to effect their pu:rpose, and eventually :induced him and N ama to join the movement. They agreed to do so, and with Surjan were ..J!_ ,_ _.J,. __, uu:t,ui.,tiu uy a.msr cmgn anu '1agat omgn tor Jagat namJ, wno nau iate1y come to his village to enlist recruits for the m-mse, to proceed to Lahore where a number of Indian soldiers were said to be ready prepared to raise a rebellion. __.. On arrivai at Lahore they were informed by these two men that this plot had. miscarried, and were told to proceed to Ludhiana, where they were met by Nn,w~.h Khfi11, to whom thev had been ordered to renort themselves. The latterwas ,:i,t first inclined to mistrust Babu Ram and· N;ma, but on being assured by Surjan that they . were fellow-conspirators , and to be trusted, told him to, take them to Ferozepore, saying he himself would follow later with arms and ammunition. At Ferozepore Cantonment Railway Station they were met by about 25 men, described by Nama as American emigrants Jagat Singh (Ja.gat Ram) then arrived and told them to· disp~·,•sa as there was no hope of the 13lot ·succeedi11g. Some of them aceordingly ...did so,. but 15 of them remained behind with the intention of proceeding to Juliundur by rail, and had bought ticketsfor that purpose, but missed the train. They were then told to get into 3 t·wii, ·titmu a.i..i.d j.i.i.c'-Jccd (/:r.2 ~-,Ci.LVL.,Co~a~ ~v ~~uoa, nhu1c; ~~ \'VU·O _piv_pv~cJ. lvvt the treasury and obtain arms and money, and it was while they were on their way there that they were intercepted by Sub-Inspector Bisharat Ali and the I Zaildar Jawala Singh, Babu Ram and Nama tell us in their confessions how they, in company with Surjan, managed to escape from the cordon, which the· uolice had drawn round thA rPAns. in wllioh t.hA V':rnO' took l'f~fnITA a.ftAr mnrdn--· ing the Sub-In'~pe~t~r and Zaild~r, and got b~crtoc:,F~tehgarh i~- s~foty •. On arrival there tuey all recounted what had happened to Fazal Din, accused (8),, who had been previously seduced by Surjan t0 join in the revolutionary movement, but had hithedo taken no active part. Babu Ram here dropped out, and took no further share in the movement, and we now have to deal with the· further charge against ~ama and those against Fazal Din, accused (8). The· latter is also a native of Fattehgarh, and the charges again~t him are set out_l, on pages 165, 166 of the record. It is alleged that he harboured. Surjan" who is a proclaimed offender, and took an active part in arranging plans for waging· war and the collection of men, arms and bombs, par·ticularly in the Mandi State~He also tells us in his confession (page 118) how he was induced by Surjan to join in the revolutionary.movement, and promised to obtain from one Shamsher Khan, who agreed to provide them, the services of 20, or 25 Pathans from the 1_ •,I, t""1• , , ,- • ....... 'I I ,- _, ~ "Ill ' , 1 1 .J JY y '1 \)\_.I 0 I"',..;,.,.,- J 87 kiln at which he was working He was also asked to join the d.acoity at Panch Nangal, but declined O? the ground that he ·was . unable to leave his kiln. He then describes the departure from. rrnd theh· return ta the vil1age of Surjan, Babu Ram and Nama, and the accounts they g-ave him on thei'r return of the failures of the conspiracy at Lahore and Ferozepore, and of the murders of the Sub-Inspector and Zaildar. 0n their return Babu Ram, as bas been said, took no farther part, but Surjan went off to Suket Mandi, followed on bis advice a few days afterwards by Nama, who feared arrest for his complicity in the murders. Nama tells us in his confession how he met Surjan at Bhojpur in Suket Mandi, and. was taken to the house of Sarda Ram (71), also a native of ~Fa.ttehgarh, and from there to N agchala on :he way to Mandi antl then to ~Ba.rsc. At the l:1tter place they mi=:,t one Sindu, of wbom Surjan ap1 arf'1it1y bad previomly heard. In the course of a conversation, Surjan said he had . come from America, with others, to expel the British from India, and asked Sidhu;g heip with men and arms, as there wern :no 1°estrictions &.s to arms in .:Mandi 3 representing that he himself could make bombs and others of his party airships. Sidhu replied that he would first interview one Mian ,Jawahar Singh an ex-T'hanadar, and let him know the next day. Surjan and Nama t,ben returned to Suket, where they related what had happened to Sarda Ram, who himself accompanied them a few davs later as far a-.i NaQ'chala. 'l'hnP. they met Sidhu and ~another m~m of the same JJame, Sidhu II, ar,d the fi~~ of them then proceeded to Barso on the road to Mandi, where they were met by Mian Jawahar Singh, ex-Thanadar, and Jawahar Singh Kanait and taken first to a cattie shed, and then to a . baoli close to the formcr's house .. Here revolutjonary plans were discussed, and Surjan explained to Mian J a'Yahar Singh the compos\tion of a bomb. It was then ~greed that Surjan should bring men from the Doaba and. on their arrival a rebellion should be 8tal'ted in }Iandi, the BrUish Officer Yesident there and foe W8;i'..ir murdered, Mandi and Suket occupied and a descent made on the Punjab to expel the British from India. The party then dispersed and Na.ma, subsequently returned to Fattehgarh with directions from Surjan to arrange for men with }"azal Din to be sent to Mandi. 1 lt y ( .. ~~-- ~ This brings us to the share of F!l.zal Din, aecused (8), in the conspiracyHe tells us in his confession on page 119 that Surjan, after describing to him the share he, Nama and Babu Ram had taken in theFerozeshahr murder, told him he was off to S uket Mandi to seek refuge and i;;tir up the people there, many of whom he knew. About 15 days after his deparhu-e Surjan, in compliance with the promise he had made, sent a letter to say he had been successful, ~nd, about a month after that, retur1;1ed in person and~ telling him of the plans for the revolution tbat had been arranged with ~Han Jawahar Singh, ex-Thanadar, and Sidhu Kanait, asked bi~ to help and 8upply the men be had previously J)romised. Th1s Fazal ])in declined to do until the rebellion had been properly started in Mandi. T Surjan then °"'ent off to Kotla to see Amar . Singh, accused (1), to whom 7 Fa~St.1 Tiin hnn hP.P.n il1t:ron11~P.(1 wl1P.n hP, 11 ~'7,'-'!1 Din, b~,1 -A».:-f n{Vv!g!'.'~tc~ to join the movement, and on_ his return told him to bring Amar Singh, accused (1), from the• horse fair at Hoshiarpur to the kiln, where :Pazal Din was working, and had concealed him, Surjan, in a hut near, by. Fazal Din then went to the fair, and r-eturned with Amar Singh, acc;msed (1), and Dalip Singh, informer, both of whom Surjan asked to accompany him to Mandi as bomb-makers were needed there. r.rhis they declined to dq, but eventually Dalip Singh went off to· fetch the famous Nidhan Singh of Chuga (L. C. C.) for that purpose~ while Surjan him~elf rel.urned to Mandi. A bout 10 days afterwards Dalip Singh and Nadhan Singh arriv,ed, and, finding that Surjan had gone, asked Fazal Din to write. to him, B_urjan having, before he left, given his ad.dress as Piara 'Lal care of Kundan Lal, shop-keeper, Suket, a,nd aske~ him to return. Fazal Din did so, but,. Surj,an replied that he could not come, and that Fazal Din was· to . bring Nidban Singh and Dali~ 88 Singh to Mandi. Fazal Din could not go himself and asked N ama:, bu~ tho latter declined, and Arjan; the brother of Surjan, eventually consented to take them, returning 5 o.r 6 days later with the information that he: httd failed to find Smian. but had left Nidhan SinP-"h and Dalip Singh at. Mandi. 15 or 20 days afterwards Surjan himself returned to FattehgaJh. with two swords, which he and Fazal Din buried. One of these was, ~ome. days later, carried off by Dalip Singh, and the other Surjan himself took away in consequence of a quarrel he had with Fazal Din, owing to the· •latter's failure to giYe any effective help and made it over to Arjan. The latter told Fazal Din that he had buried it, and that 8urjan had returned to M&ndi. 4 V AM regards Babu Ram's and N ama's share in the movements at Lahore anc~ Ferozepore, there fa th_e evide?c~ of Nawa~ Khan (841, _i!~wal~ Sin?h (~\2) ~ their own separate confe$g1ons anu the confession of Fazal .Vm. Nawan Knan tells us tha( after the attack OL1 Lahore Cantonment hacl been decided on, he ordered bis party to assemble at I,qdhiana on the 25th .November, and that on_ the 26th these two 3,ccused, whom he identified in uourt, arrived thei·e accom-, panied by Ralia Singh and Surjan, and said that Bhai Parma Nand had advised,, through Karter Singh, that the attack should be made on Ferozepore instead. He accordingly paid their fares an.d .. seut them off to Ferozepore, though he. did not follow himself. Fazal Din, in his confession teiis us that S.urj_an a,nd these two accused. who lrnd gone off together from the -village, 1·etu.1·ned: a_ week 3ifter, and descrit,..,d to him their visit to Lahore, where they ha_d been to see how they could best plunder it, and get we{lpons from the troops st$l_tione~ there. From Lahore they said they went to Fero~epore to see the arsenai, and get weapon~ from some Americans, but not fi,nding thelll had started off in" t·um tutiiS. 'fhey then described the murder of the Zaildar and Sub-Inspector a,nd the:i:r ow:µ escape, ~~ama mentioning to him how he iost his chutai or ke:Ji· (shoulder cloth) ~ '.fhis is also referred to by N ~m~ in his confession. We. have also the pvidence;.of Jawala Singh, approver {62). '.Re tells \JS that, after the attack on Lahore Cantonment had been abandoned, he went to Ferozepor~ Canton-p.1ent Station_, a11d there met Rahmat Ali, Feroicpore tnurderer, Surj;,inl Arjan Singh, Anar-kali murderer, and some friend~ of Rahmat A.li, tha,,t it was decided to make the attack on the 30th, and in orderto fill iu the time mean=. w hila to go by the 12 noon train to lioga, attack the treasur-y there and get arms. This witness was ~arrested ori 20th November and made a statement before a Magistrate in Ferozepoi·e. In the course of this statement he described how he niet Qne Wari8im Singh, from whotn he heard an account of the murder of the Zµ,ildar and Sub-Inspector of .rolice. In thi~ account mention Wijs jmide of Surjan. his :\\{uhammH~hm companion, and another. Tiabu Ram and N ama are of course both Hindus, and. C";pital is made of this statement of J awala Sin~h, but the mista~e is capable of explanation. J awala Singh re" ferred to them as }Iuh3:mmadans~ beca.u se he thought Surjan was a Muham., 1 madan. He had s~en two youths at ] erozepore station with Surjan. and as they were youths only them is nothing surprfoing in his calling them Muham-: madans. 'fhe murder. of the Sub-Inspector of Police and the Zaildar is further corroborated by the evidence of Arjan (70), who tells us that these two accused desQrih~d to him the murders and their qwD; e~cape, and there is ~lso the evi~ dence of .Amar Sin~h (1), apnrover (85), w~o tellij us he metS-µrjan at Jullun~ dur~ and he~rd fr9~ b,im qf the murders. We have now to deal with the evidence as to the share taken and Fazal D,in, respectively, in the Mandi plot. by ~ama Sarda R~m l 71), who is hi.mself no doubt an aiccomplice, descr~bes the , _visits paid to him in D~cember 1914 or Janu~ry 1916 by Surjan ~nd Nama at 13hojp1.1,:r, where he kept a school, the meeti:o.g at l3µ,rso, wh~re revolutionary plans were dhmussed ,with the two Jawahar Sing4s and tlie two Sidhus. Dalip Singh, informer (7:3), tells us how hem.et Amar Singh, accused (1), l3abu }tam~ Nama and Fazal Din at the Hoshiarpur Fair, and then accompanied Amar ~ingh, accused (1), to Fazal Din's hut near the brick kiln. ~l1he door of the hut was unlocked by Fazal Din, whom they met at the kiln, and inside th~ hu,t th~y fo~~d. Sµr,js.:µ in 9 Pathans ready,- whenever they were required, i:md neither Dalip Singh nor Amar Singh knew how to make bombs. One Bidhi Singh wa~ then suggested as a bomb-maker, but Amar Singh did not know him, and eventually Dalip Singh went off to fetch Nidhan Singh. ,,. Dalip Singh then describes how he met N:idhan Singh at .A.nandpur, dressed as a NiLang, and told him what Surjan had said about Mandi. Nidhan Singh said he had already heard of it from Amar Singh, accused (1), and was read v to comt,; and asked to be introd:uced to Surjan. They ,s..ccordin~ly went off t~ 1 } azal Din's hut, on itrri~val tf1e.rf~\ forr11d ih.at S t1rjan haci alread:r gOne t o Mandi. Nidhall Singh said be had come to see Surjrm, as he understood that the latter wanted a bomb-maker, and he himself couid make bombs, and asked ]fazal Din to write to Surjan. Fazal Din, who hs.d made arrangf>,ments' with Surjall about correspondence, wrote to him a.c cordingly, and a f'ew days afterwards informed them that 8urjan had tolgauon, anu we are satisfied that it was voluntarily macfo. Fazal Din, Babu Ram and Nama all --pleaded not guilty to the charges brought against them. Babu Ram, while denying the allegations made against him, admits his acquaintance with Surjan, but denies that the latter sed-qced him, to sedition. He reiterates his accusation against the police hoth as to the cunfossi0n having been extorted from him aud as to the unfairne.ss. o.f thtJ. identification. N ama also repeats these accusations, hut admits hiEJ visit with Su1'jan to the house of SLtrda Ham (71) at Hhojpu,r. He says that he went to Suket State to sell socks, and there met Surjan, who asked him to take him to Sarda Ram's }10use. Fazai Din denies that he knovrs Smjan, and a,l~o alleges that he was tortured by the police into making a confession. _,' All three accij.sed called a numbet nf witnesses as to their good character,. but made no attempt to refute in auy other way the specific charges made against them, or to substantiate the allegations, in the case of Babu Ram and :t~ama, as to the unfairness of the identification by the prosecution witnesees. The question &.s to this identification has almady been dealt with by us, and there is in our opinion no reason for holding that the confessions are not genuine. They have all been corroborated by a large number of witn(Jsses, and corroborate each. other in close detail. The only discrepancy of any importance lo be noted is that in connection with tlw visit to the Hoshiarpur Fair. Dalip Singh has told us that he met Babu Ram. N ama. Faz al Din and Amar Ri n O'h Tt is true that Fazal Din admits his own presence, but Babu E,a,m and N;~;in t-heir confesAion.s m~ke no mention of their having gone to the fair, and Nama emphatically denies th::i.t he was there. However, nothing is alleged against them at the time of the meeting, and the discrepancy is not; we consider, of such importance as to throw doubt on, the truth of Dalip Singh's evidence. The same remark applies to the other iliscrepancies and variations that have already befJn referred to, though it should also he noted that Arjan picked out Kehr Singh, accused (12), as the man he reforred to as Amttr Singh, accused (1). This matter has been dealt with in Amar Singh's case, and there is ~o need to refer to it further, byond saying that this does not in our opinion in any way di~credit Arjan's evidence. The confessions, it is true, of all three accused have been retracted, and there 1s the qijestio~ whether they ca11 be used both as against the persons wh;o T 9] made them and the pereons impiicatcd. therein. These confessions have, in rnH opinion, been voluntarily made, and the plea made by Babu Ram in his con ~ fession that, he only joined the conspiracy under fear of death, does not vitiate the confession as a- confession. rrhe plea, if proved, could only be urged as an ·extenuating circumstance, hut there is no proof of it, as Babu Ram now denies any share whl;litsoever in the conspiracy, and there is no reason for thiking that there is any truth in it. It bas been held in Punjab Record 30 of 1914, that when it is a question of using a confession against a co-accusP,d, and the court is not prepared to accept the confession pe1· se as sufficient, the corroboration ought tu Le of the kind that not only confirms the general story of the crime, but aiso unmistakeably connects the said co-accused with the crime. It is true that in the absence of corrohora.fa111 in mntcrfal pa.rtieu1~Y''\ it iP -rH,t ~~fo tr; convict on a confession which has been resiled from, unless there remains a high deg-ree of certainty that the confession though retracted is gRnuine. Bnt it was ais~ held that. it was not illegal to base a conviction upon the the uncorroborated confesRion of an accused person, provided that the court is satisfied that the cor..fession was voluntary and true in fact. The amount of corroboration required is for the court to decide, and no hard and fast rule can be laid down- as to what particular points the corrobora- tion is necessarv on. and as we have noi:nted out the confessions of the three ~ccused, beside; cor~oborating each other not only in main particulars but in -close detail, are themselves corroborated by a large number of witnesses. It is true that many of these witnesse~ are approvers, and one of them Sa,rda Ram (71) is no doubt an accomplice, but tbe evidence of these approvers, with the exception of Dalip Singh;; who is the only new approver in this case, has been believed by the Commissioners i.n the two previous oases, and we can see no reason for disbelieving the evidence in this case as abainst accused, bearing in mind, as we have done, the fact that. the evidence is tainted, and having scrutinised it with the utmost care, both in the light of the circumstances in which it was given as well as in the light of all the other circumstances of the case. We are fully satisfied as to the correctness of the evidence for the prosecution aad the guilt of all three accused. In considering the legal liability of accused ( 2) and (14), Babu Ram and Nama in the Feroze8hahr murders we must refer to t~e Chief Court judgment in tbe first Ferozeshahr mmder trial. In that case 7 men were sentenced to death for their share in the mm·der ; it was held by the Ohi,f Court on appeal that, though there was evidence wanting to prove that any of them except J agat Singh took the prima:ty part in the murders, yet they, and all other members of the whole party of 15 were banded together with a common object, well knowing that any form of desperate violence would be freely used in order to achieve it, and to. escape capture in .case of resistance. Though there is no evidence that either Babu Ram or Nama were armed, there were, as was held by the Chief Court, enough dangerous weapons, consisting as they did of automatic pistols, revolverst an axe and five chhavi heads to go round nearly the whole party of 15, and, even if they themselves were not armed, they were membns of a gang banded together with .a common object, and though the murders of the Zaildar and Sub-Inspector of .t'olice was an unpremeditated incident it was an incident for which they were prepared. It wa8 held by the Chief Court that the appellants were liable equally with others, who escaped_ for both the murders which occurred, as being a contingency for which they were prepared and which they knew to be ......, likely to occur. We ai·e of opinion therefore that both Babu Ram and Nama are guilty under sections 302, 149, Indian Penal Code. J_ T --,- f Ther are both further guilty under section 121, Indian Penal Code,. for a direct act of war in collecting at Lahore for the attack on Lahore Uantonments and proceeding to Lahore for tt.a attack there. Nam~. is further gµilty under s'ections ~21-A and 121, Indian Penal Code, for _,conspiring to wage war and abetting the waging of war in Fattehgarh and Mandi. We are satisfied also that Fazl Din is guilty under sections 121 ~nd 121-A, Iudiai+ l?en;1l Code, for conspiring to wage war an:1"01\ ~nrl in p~.rtin11hn~ t.o h~.vP. P:Orn;ip1rArl with ot,hAr~ ln t.hP. Mandi State. He has been charged under section 121, Indian Penal Code,. with having, in the course of a. war waged against the King-Emperor, waged war, attempted the waging of war, and abetted the waging of war at the Hoshiarpur Cattle Fs~r and lfattehgarh in February 1915, snd at Fatteugarh in November 1914 as well. Th€ reason why he is not charged with the resporn,ibilitv of the-acts of co-conspirators is that he was so charg-ed in the Lahore ·supplementary conspiracy case, but was discharged on the ground that no witness was able to identify him as the person against whom they were testifying. We are told by }fr. Slattery, Superintendent, of Police in the Criminal Investigation Department (P. W. 115), that accused returned to India on the Calcutta-Ra:ngoou S.S. Luiii,w Cu the 12th N ovewber l!J: 4 in company with Kashi R3m, who has been hanged, and Ram Rakh·1, absco::1der, and accused ·himself admits his return to India on this boat. The principal evidence against him is that of the approver Dalip Singh (7o) and the confession of Fazai Din, accused (8), the latter of whom has told us how,. after his seduction by Surja.n, the Ferozeshahr murderer, he was introduced to accused, who repeated all that Surjan had previously said about ths 1:'f:Jvolutionary movement; and asked him, Fazal Din, for help. Fazal Din promised to help him with 20 or 25 l'athans, which Shamsher Khan agreed to provide. He then tells us how after the Ferozeshahr murders, and after he bad declined to accompny Su-rjan to Mandi, he was sent by the latter to the Hoshiarpur fair to fetch accused and his merr and to bring them to the hut where he was concealing Surjan who was wanted for the Fe1·ozoshahr murders. He did so,. and Surjan asked accused and Dalip Singh, who also cam.a at the i.:idme time~ to come with him to Mandi as bomb-makers were needed there. Accused declined to go, and after Surjan had related his doings in Mandi the two of them went off. Dalip Singh: approver (7 3), who was at one time in the same regiment, the 35th Sikhs, with accused, tells how he met the latter at the Hoshiarpur fair in comp.any with Shiv Singh (L. C. C.), and then with accused met Fazal Din accused (8), Nama accused (14), and Arjan ; accused had a private talk with Fazal Din, and mentioned his name to witness, and giving him news of -Surjan, who had committed a dacoity, and had returned from Suket Mandi, a~ked him to accompany him. vv'itness went with him to a kiln and they were taken by lfazal Din, whom they met there, to a .hut in which Sm-jau was t,oncealed. Witness was introduced by the accused to Surjan, who told accused that he had prepared men for rebellion in Mandi Suket, and had there read out the book which accused had given him, but that the men there, though ready to join, would not do so until the services of a .bomb-maker were obtained. Accused said he too would be ready when the time came, and that thou~h he himself could not make bombs and could not therefore accompany Surjan to 1\'faniH, ·he wouid send for Nidhan Singh and get him to arrange. Witness then went to look for Nidhan Singh; whom he found at ,4.nandRur, dressed as a Naha,ng. ;Nidban Singh asked him if he knew Surjan. Witness replied that he had met him at the kiln at Fattebgarb, and told . Nidhan Singh all that he had heard from Surjan about Maudi State. Nidhan Singh said he had aheady heard about it ;, r 93 from Amar Singh, and that was why he had come to A:nandpur. lie asked witness to introduce him to Surjan and the two of them according1y went to Fazal Din's kiln to find from Fazal Din that Surjan h~d gone off t o :l'.tfandi. Witness tben started to look for Surjan under the guidance of Arjan (70). This is corroborated by ·F azal Din's confession, and the statements of Arjan himself, which have already been dealt with in the cases of the other 3 accused in this group. ,, Accused bas been identified by Dalip Singh afone, Arjan failing to identify him in court and picking out Kehr Singh, accused (12) im;tead as the man referred to in bis statement. But that accused is the man in question is clear not only from Fazal Din's confession, but from the sfaJement of Narindra Singh (72), Lambardar of Kotla Nod Singh. This witness tells us that though there are three men of the name of Amar Singh in Kotla, Nod -Singh, accused, i3 the only enc -;vho is a returned emigrant, that he was an associate of Shiv Singh (L. C. C. ), and to his knowledge went to the cattle fair at Hoshiar:pur and that when he returned from America his hair was cut and he had no beard as he has now. Though there is no re~emblance between accmed Amar Singh and Kehr Singh, accused (12), this latter fact is in our opinion sufficient to explain witness's failure to identity Amar Singh. he Accused admits having gone to the Hoshiarpur cattle fair; but contends that it was for au innocent object, viz., to sell a horse and not for the purpose of meeting Surjan, that he went ther0. He denies having met Arjan, Fazal Din,, Babu R.am and N ama, and that he had any conversation with Fazal Din about getting in.to touch with Surian. He alg1) denies that he subsequently met Surjan a kiln at Fattehgal'h, or had anything to do with fetching l{idhan Singh to Fattehgarh in urder to go to Mandi. He alleges that a false case has been brought against him by Dalip Singh from enmity. He says that while he was in Portland, United States of America, working at a rope factory, he lived in the same house with Dalip Singh and had a quarrel with him .. . They separated Rnd he then lived with Shiv Singh and Harnam Singh, a friend of Dalip Singh, with whom he also quarrelled. He himself returned to India for domestic 1·easons, vowing vengeance on Dalip Singh at the time of his departure, and it was in revenge for this, he says, that the false case has been brought against him. On his return to bis village he was restricted, and, with the exception of his visit to Hoshiarpur to sell a horse, when he returned to his village at 4 P.M. the same d.ay and of a visit .of condolence to his nephew at Mau.za Ramtoba, he never absented himself from his village. He called one Jamnl Singh, D. W. 95, a returned emigrant, to prove the quarrels referred to at Portland, but the evidence of this witness, even if believed, is not sufficient in itself to throw any doubt on the truth of Dalip Singh's statement against accused, and it is uncouoborated. He also produced a number of other witnesses both as to character, and to prove that it was to sell a horse he went to Hoshiarpur, and that, he returned to his village the same day. One witness, D W. 11, also stated that, with the excepti· I Though ~e i~ technically guilty of rm offence u?-cle: sect~on \ ~l,..., I1]di ~T'. Penal Code ' m view of the fact that he took a very mrnor part m Inu1:1, Ll,n d "a§ . -1 - ] .. <- 1 . ~ .• little n1ore than JJ messeno-er actin~ probably u nder tue oruers 01 ms co~v111ager 0 ' t, • 1 '11 A T . 1 " .· ~ Shih Singh, we prefer to deal with him under sect10n . .1. ~ •1.\ .._, 1.nn1:1n renal Code, as was done, in similar circumstances in some cases m the Lr~hore supplementary conspiracy case and sentence him to 2 year's rigorous imprisonment. 1 -, T1' GROUP 3.-MISCELLAN:E0US .A CCUSED. This group contains 4 accused, vi.z., Kehr Sin_gh (12) of ~ahnew~l, _ ~tn absconder in the first case, Thakar Singh (15), who 1s charged w1~h act,1vit1es in Sha.nghai and Si:1m, Hafiz Abdulla (17), who is a returned. mrngrn_ut froi11 Manilla, and Rur Singh (18) an absconder in the second conspiracy tnal. To take first the case of Kehr Singh, accused 12. This man is said to have been one~ of the conspirators in the :Par East? and to have arrived at Calcutta on the 13th Oetouer 1914 by the ss. Nam, Sang, one Sarwan Singh (o7) being a feliow-passenger o~ uoard a ~hip wh~eh he says arrived in Calcutta two years ago, and accused himself admits havmg returned by that ship. He ig a resident of M:r.,nza Sahuewal, and is al1eged to have taken part in the dacoity which was committed there, having previously in th~ monthl'i December 19H and fanuary 1915 attended meetings of the conspirators at Ludhiana, and he is also said to have purchased nitric acid for the ma-:J.afacture of bombs for the purposes of the conspiracy. He was arrested, but escaped from police custody at Ludhiana on the 8th April 1915, wa!-l an absconder in the Lahore conspiracy case, and was eventually re-arrested on the 29th May 1916 at Raipur, Central Provinces, where he bore an assumed name (-vide the statementB of Sub-Inspector Kadir Bakhsh (27), Head Constable Raghunath Das and Inspector Niaz A.hmad. Sucha Singh {41), formerly a student in the Khalsa and Islamia Schools at Ludhiana and a pardoned approver in the Lahore conspiracy case, tells us how he became disaffected to Government on reading the Ghadr-di-Gunj which he got from one Kahn Singh, an accused in the Lahore supplementary con .. spiracy case. With the help of a fellow-student, Kirpal Singh (L. S. C. C.) he duplicated it in Urdu, and about Christmas 1914 gave a copy of it to Kher Singh, accused, who visited him at school in company with Dewa Singh, (L. C. C.) and said he wanted it to publish. Subsequently accused was deputed by Dewa, Singh to show witness the road to Jhabewal where a born b factorv had been started. He did so and the witness then gave him 2 rupees where;ith to buy alcohol and nitric acid for bombs to take to Jhabewal. Accused brought the stuff and told witness he had got it from the shop of Chandra Bhan, but excused himv~lf from accompanying w_itness t? Jhabewal on the 1:lea ?f ~usiness. S~bse,que~~ly ~ccused. visited him on his return from Ludhiana m hu~ :rooms at me ooa,rcnng house m company with Arjan Singh, the A.narkali murderer, Kartar Singh (L. C. C.) and Gurmukh Singh lL. C. 0.) and witness then describes how, - after a secret meeting in his room one Friday, attended by Jagat Singh (L. C. C.), Jaswant Singh (absconder), Ram Rak.ha (absconder), Bir Singh (L. C. C.)t K::i,rt8sr Singh, Dewa, Singh and others, accu8e the party went off to commit another, and the next morning Kartar Singh told him they had committed a dacoity at Sahnewal, and gave him as a memento a kalma rupee, which witness showed to Abdul Alim {W. 36). in corroboration of the story there is, as regards {l) the inciclent of the purchase of nitric acid, the evidence of Walaiti Ram (31) and Dial Singh t32); (2)j the seditious meetings in Sucha Elingh's room at the boarding house, that of Abdul Alim (36) a student at the Islamia School at Ludhiana and (3), the dacoity at Sahnewal and the part accused took in it, the statements of Umra Kba.n (28), Muhammad Akbar (2-Ji), Mussammat Sobhi (25), Amar Chand (i6), Durga Das (30), Sri Ram (33), Permeshri Das (34), Bisha.n Singh (35), and Umrao 1 95 Sin~h, approver (4i2), As to (l) Walaiti Ram, an employee in the shop of Chanrfar Bhan at Ludhian[ti tells us hml\i· on the 9th January 19l;j 011e Dial Siriu-h a student whom he knew, came to his shop with accused and bought a noubnd of nitric acid. Dial Singh;s name was entered in the register as the pur~haser, hut on his representing that the accused was responsible for it, and accused 1 paying for the stuff, Dial Singb. s name was erased from the register and accused's entered instead. This story is supported by Dial Singh hhmelf, who described his visit to Chandar Bhan's shop with accused, whom he had known for a long time, tbe purchase of the nitric acid by Mcused and the substitution of the latter's name in the register for his own; which hatl been entered wrong·1y. :r rrhe only evidenre as to (2) consists of the statement of Sucha Singh, and of the student Abdul Alim. rrlrn latter describes how on a visit to Sucha Singh's rooms he was present at a seditious meeting attended by accused, and some 8 or 10 men, including Kartar Singh (L. C. C.) and Arjah Singh (A. :M.), and he tells us of a subsequent ·visit by these same rnen, armed with lathis and chhavi blades, which he -affixed for them, prier to their departing for the dacoity. IIe was also present when Kartar Singh returned the nex't day, and. Sucha Singh showed him a kalma rupee, wihch, he said, formed part of the proceeds of tb.e dacoity. As to the dacoity itself, in the course of which one Khushi Ram was murdered, this is testified to by the evidence of Musrtammat Sobhi (25) and Umra Khan (28), and as i• has been fully dealt with by the Commissioners in the two previous cases it is unnecessary to refer to it further, beyond saying that the loss of the kalm(1, rupee which was given to Sucha Si~gh is proved by the statement of Mussummat Sobhi, the widow of the mmdered man Khushi Ram . Sub-Inspector :Faiz-ul-Hasan (29) tells us Low it was recovered from the possession of Sucha Singh on the 23rd February 1915. As to the part which accused took in this dacoity, it is not alleged before us thai he was one of the persons who actually committed it. He is a local man and well-known and the risk of being recognised would have been too great for him to have been present at the time it was committed. But the services of a local man, who would know the names of the persons best worth looting an,d the situation of their houses, were required, and that is why they were utiiized. Bishen Singh (35), also a resident of Sahnewai, teiis us how Dewa Singh (L. C. C.) and Dalip Singh, deceased, came one day to Sahnewal, mounted on cameis, and accompanied by two other men and asked for Kehr Singh, accused. Amar Chand (26), a former school-fellow of Kehr Singh, describes how, when he was talking to the latter at Sahnewal on the day of the dacoity; two men came up and interrupted them. One of these men in accosting them reminded witness that his name was Dalip Singh; accused went off with them and witness then saw him drawing a sketch on the ground and explaining it to them. It is a.lleged that this sketch was probably a plan of the villaJge; sho·wing the situation of the house to be attacked and looted, and the various lanes affording the safest means for access and exit. Witness was not himself positively certain that his meeting with accused was on the actual day of the dacoity, but he remembered that accused, on his return from speaking to the two men asked him for the loan of a hi~yde from Sri Ram; the master of the village school, and Sri Ram himself (33), corroborating the incident of the bicycle, is certain that accused asked him for it on the actual day of the dacoity. Durga Das (30), who as well as Amar Chand (26) was a nephew of Khushi Ram, who was murdered in the dacoity, tells us that accused, v;hcn speaking of the daeoity afterwards, said it was not political, but merely the work of local badmashes, and tha,t the loss was small. Amar Chand said that he used to be a friend of the accused, and it might be argued that, knowing as he does now! that accmmd had a hand in his uncle's death~ witness)s friendship would be turnecl to P-nmity :md his e-v1dcnce therefore not be trusted. But in the case of Durga Das no. such argument can be adduced. He declines even now to believe that accused, who is an old acquaintance, was one of the dacoits who murdered his uncle, and his e7idence in view. of this is valuable. He describes how accused on his return to India came to see him accompanied by a man who he said was Munsha Singh, and famous 96 as a composer of vcrsrs for the Olwclr-cli- Gunj, and on the same evening · told him he had made an appointment with the notorious Bha,i Panrn.t llanu , w hum he had m('t in ,J a.pan. Accused was identified at a number of parades hy Sri Ram, Dia,l Singh, Bishen Singh, Abdul Alim, Wilaiti Ram, and by Sawan S~ngh as t.he man who travelled with him on the same ship. Am : r Chand an d Durga Das identified bjm in Court. They both knew him intimately and their identitica-tion was not challrngC'll. Parmeshri Dai;: (24), who kcPps a wine shop at Sahuewal, testified to having seen accused in the shop iu the company of ])alip Singh a day or two before or after the uac..;oity; anu tbh, meetiug :tceuSl'll hirnself admits. He denied, however, having had anything to do with the Sahnewal dacoity or with the seditious meetings in Ludhiana, his meetings with Sucha Singh, be contended, were quite innocent, and he stated that be escaped from poiice custody after his arrest merely to escape further torture. He i,roduced no evidence in bis defence, and. his counsel confined him~elf. to ~n '-lHPn1!,t. t.n lmpe:u~h that for the prosecution. As regards the substitut10n of accused's name for that of Dial Singh in the rngister kept by Chandar Bhfm; he alleged that this had been done by the police, and pointed to the fact that the alteration had been made in a different ink from that of the previ0us entry. But Wi1aiti Rttm tells us that the inkstand, which h e 1.rncd at the time contained three ink~pots, and this fact would alone satisfactorily account for any difference in the iuk. ,iV e can see ,po reason for disbelieving either bis evidence or that of Dial Singh as to the circumstances in which the alteration was made, and we hold that the purchase by accused of the nitric acid hns been clearly proved. It is true that Sucha Singh could not remember whether he told accused the purpose for which it was required, bui that accused himself knew the purpose there can be no doubt if the evidence of 1 ~ .whfl, Singh hP lwliPvPrl· APfl1H1Pc1'.-: !:l ..-:.1 ;:nn-iaf.inn 11 urith n1Pn li1.-n ~,rnh" Ringh, Kartar SinQ'h. and others. and the fact that he had an appointment to mrnt such a notorious man as Bhai Parmanand, whom he admits~ having previously met in Japan, would show that he was not merely an innoceut tool, bu,t ai conspirator himself. There is no reason that we can see for disbelieving Sucha. Singh's evidence. His statements in the two previous cases were believed by the Commissioners and no arguments have been ady a quanel which had tak~~ place between them at N ankin. He admits that he went to Bangkok with Balwant Sic~h from Swatow, expla;ning r,hat he had to do so as he had lost his passport, and was tLerdore Hot allon·ed to land. at Hm1~ Kong, where he had to proceeJ en roitte for India to fetch his fa mily. As to Bal want Singh's presence on board the sa,me ship, he explain~d that he \\:as not aware of it until he l>oarded) and he a(lmitted living for a Rhort time n1 the same house with him and J odh Singh on arrival at ··Bangkok. But he disciaimed all knowlR1lan ~-" t.o }hlwHnt, SinQ'h'~ movements 1 here. a,rnl denied that be ga~e · hiru ~~~ist~nc~- i~ t.he. r~~-olutionary movement as he had be~n ill on the voyage, and was iii dul'ing his sta.y o,t Bangkok lHlving to be adrrntted to hospital. ~~y_, In his defence he prorlnced ~ne Karam Cha1~cl Koh1_i, D ~~- 3--~' ,~n jnterned emigrant, who 2::1.ve pv1rlPnce ae to h::.s nJat10ilS \\ Hu .vanp Chandi P . ,v. 10. But ·~s reg·arrls the part accused is said to ha~-e taken in the revolutionary movement at N aukin, we are not prepared to hold that he took the part ascribed to him on the evidence of a single witness, vi-z., Daiiµ Chan~, a witness, whose evidence 1~as not l1elieve d bi t~e ~o~illissionei:s. in the Lahore suuplementary cousn1raey ca.se auu wno 1s not aoovc suspicion himseif. Ther: IS also the ~alleQ'ation tirnt this witness is actuated by e~nnity against the accused, and tho(tgh there is no evidence ns to this b·eyoncl the vague stateru.ent of Karam Chanel K.ohli, who is himself an interned en:i.igrant, it would be; we consider, unsafe to rely on Dalip Chand's statement, ".rhieh is uncorroborated by any other evidence, an:! is in itself perhaps somewhat improbable. It would hafe br~en an expe nsive m ,tter to send a man the 2:W miles separating l\ankin from Sh::i.nzhai once a \\.'P.flk to cEs trihnte t,h,J Gliatli· paper, when if might have beeu cl~livered throu~h the post without auy great risk of detection. Moreover, Mula Sin g'., , approver P. \V. 80, tells ns that. accused was a Government Inteqn·eter in Shanghai, aDd that he himself had no oommunication with accu~ed because the latter was in a GoYernment o!lice, and Karam Chand Kohli also giv3s eYide;ice as tu accus~d being a Goverme:.1t Interpreter, 1 As regards the witness Gopal Dass (22), though his statement is to some extent corroborated by that of J odh Singh, a \Yitness whom we see no reason to disbelieve, it is to be remembered that Gopal Das was himself at one timt: suspect, having been _detained in Bangkok Jail and subsequently deported to India, and moreover ~e are not impressed by bis evidenee. There remains, therefore, only the evidence of Jodh Singh. As has been said there is no re'1son to disbelieve it, but it does not amount to verv much as against accused. It is true that both the aocused and Balwant Singh were described as being evilly disposed towards the British Government) but witness admits that neither of them gave him any details of their concern in the revolutionary movement, or of their purpose in staying at Bangkok and he also admits that accused was ill, both during the voyage to th:=it place and for _two days after his arrival there, after which he, witness did not see ac ~f Ghadr. C~unsel for def~nce presses the point th~t--;it~~ss -~~ly-h;;d~f J3hagwan Singh, but we fail to see how that helps him, for his client had left Manilla 5 or 6 months before. The two principal witnesseR, however, are Allahdad and Parmanand. l Allahdad (p. 98) has been a resident in Manilla · from 19')3 to 1916. Until 1914 there were no revolutionists, he says, in Manilla. In that year Gurudatt Kumar, a well-known seditionist came to Manilla and called on all Indians to unite, holding a mPP.ti:ng for that purpose in whinh accused (17) participated. He says there were regular meetings on Sundays, a house wa;· hired, the Ghadr paper distributed and a committee formed. The officeholders in tlmt committee were Chanan Singh, a very wealthy Sikh and Hafiz .A.bdulJa, and they held a series of meetings attacking the English and urging the seizure of the Indian 1·aj for themselves. J " f . 1{)0 Gurudatt Kumar left, and was succeeded in 1915 by Bhag wan Sin gh , who stayed with a fritmd of ac(jused (17 J, aud theu with Cha,na,n Sin gh. Hl:, was in Manilia. for 3 months lecturing and collecting, urging tlw s(•iinre of the raj and distributing tne Ghadr. Subscriptions were extorted by force and threats, and a very active propagandist was Abdulla/s wife. Parmanand Sharma (p. 99), who was a detective under the British Consulate was in Manilla from 1911 to 1916. vVhen he arrived there, was no G hadr party-it was set on foot by Gurudatt Kumhar. about J unf' 1914. He founded an ::i,1;1-.nci"!,tlnn, l..-now11 to fh," Tnrlinn n. ,n fi- R;-1t·.i;;.h A ,;;i~oni~1t1on holding a meeting in an Opera House owned by a 'rurk. }l.Q 'fhis meeting- witness attended and Gurudatt spoke on unity and the~ improvement of f'ndians. ~ 'fhe association wa:s a brtrnch ot the Sa,n FmncL~co one-a house wa.s hirPrl. and collections made for remittance to Hal·dial and 81-1n Francisco; an.d the local office-bearers were Uhanan Singh and Hafiz Abdulla, among the members being RahmaJt Ati Khan (Ferozeshahr murderer). Gurudatt was later succeeded by Bhagwan Singh, who urged Indians to .return to India for revolution, and both he and Gurudatt before him taught Indians how to make bombs. Hafiz Abdulla was wellmknown to witness, and he says he was a strong advocate of revolution, and constantly urging a return to India for mutiny. Witness also desoribes the reception of the Ghadr newspapers, and the Jahan-ul-lslam which we have already described. These two witnesses prove very clearly the existence of a strong revolutionary association in Manilla; of which accused was one of the leaders~ ABa.hdad may be an accomplice, but his evidence is amply corroborated by Parmanand, \\ ho is not. But over and above this, what we may call general enncnce, we have convin•-~ing testimony as to Hafiz Abdullah'Sl ar.tivit.ies ::i,t the tirnr th e fL .-:;_ Korea stopped of Manilla en 1·0-ute for Hong Kong, with revolutionist~ on board. Allahdad (p. 98) tells us that, when the Korea arrived, Jagat Ram (L. C. C.) came on shore, and held a big meeting, which was addressed by several men, including accused. The speeches were against the British Government, and foe seizure of the r,11J in India was advocated by fighting. Parmanand (p 99) remembers the same incident: On the 3rri-val of th( Korea Jagat Ram disembarked, and through the help of accused (17) and others N awab Khan was allowed to land. A big meeting was held, which witness himself did not attend" as he wai- known to be a detective: but he got full information from his assistants. 1 Nawab Khan states (p. 86, 87, 89) that when the Korea reached .Manila 1 J'agat Ram went on shore with arms and G!z.adr-di-Gunjes '1 he finit day i~ port the ship was visited by several Indians, including (accused 17), and thev sn.id they bekmgad tu the Ghadr party and held meetings every Sundav, and that there would be a meeting next day to incite Indians to get ready" J'ermission was obtained for him to land, and on the Sunday he and J agat Ram addressed the meeting. Abdulla was chairman, witness recited an inflamatory so:cg. Jagat Ram urged they had been ready for a year and the time had ~ow come to s~r~ke and to go to India for mutiny and expel the British. A hst of those w1llmg to start at once was compiled, and Rahmat Ali, Jiwan Singh and Surjan Singh, :E\~rozeshahr murderers, were enrolled and others pl'()nµ.sed to follow. When ths K01·ea sailed a large crowd came to see them off. Now the value of his statement lies in the fact that it was made in s1+,bstance not merely before us, but in the very first conspiracy casP. when Hatiz Abdulla was not even in the do~k, and witness can have had no possible reason for implicating hi:m, particularly as he was a co-religionist, l I 101 Doubt is ca.st i~ cross-examination as _to the fair~ess of tho identity, but we can see nothmg irregular, and there 1s no q_uest10n that accused is Hafiz 6 1. , __ 11 _ _ f' 1111"" --- :11 _ .ti.UO.UUi:L Ul ..i.ll.i:U!UJ.l:I,. Amar Singh (pp. 90-92), who was also on the Korea, bears out part of Nawn.b Khan's story, but as he himseif was not aliowed to land, he knows nothine- of what took place on shore; Re sniys J agc1J. Ram g·ot off at Manilla, and H~fiz Abdulla came on board with other Indians, ~tnd discoursed on "unity," Ghad1· songs being sung-one by accused--and he says that in the party accompanying Hafiz Ab~al;~-i~' ;~~p~n-y with Pingley, that 13::tnta Singh ·whom he knew as a fdlow member of the revolutionary party had to his knowledge a printing. press at Sagwal and had told him that there was a havildar at Kapurthala ready to join the party, and that accused and Jaswant Singh, absconuer, had been sent to Kapurtbala to see him. Bachan Singh 1 approver (94), tells us that at a meeting of the revolutionaries at Dhudhike it was decided to assemble men and go to Kapurthala and there loot t.he arsenal and the magazine, that at this meeting which was attended, amongst othern, by accused and himself; and the Havildar Bhsgwan Singh, it was decided, owir:g to insufficient numbers, to postp